Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CME
For reprint orders, please contact reprints@expert-reviews.com
Mohammad Yawar
Yakoob, Yasir Pervez
Khan and Zulfiqar
Ahmed Bhutta
Author for correspondence
Division of Women and Child
Health, The Aga Khan
University, Stadium Road,
POBox3500, Karachi-74800,
Pakistan
Tel.: +92 213 486 4782
Fax: +92 213 493 4294
zulfiqar.bhutta@aku.edu
Deficiency of vitamins and minerals, collectively known as micronutrients, during pregnancy can
have important adverse effects on maternal and birth outcomes. Evidence-based nutrition
interventions can make a difference and potentially avert these outcomes. Iron supplementation
has been shown to improve maternal mean hemoglobin concentration at term and reduce the risk
of anemia. Zinc supplementation has been shown to result in a small but significant reduction in
preterm births. A cluster-randomized study in Nepal showed a 40% reduction in maternal mortality
up to 12weeks postpartum with weekly vitaminA and 49% biweekly b-carotene supplementation
but subsequent large studies in Bangladesh and Ghana have failed to demonstrate any impact on
mortality. Maternal vitaminA supplementation has no role in preventing mother-to-child transmission
of HIV in HIV-infected pregnant women. Periconceptional folic acid supplementation reduces the
risk of neural tube defects, while supplementation with vitaminD reduces the incidence of
neonatal hypocalcemia with no impact on craniotabes. Iodine supplementation during pregnancy
has also been suggested to reduce the risk of perinatal and infant mortality, and the risk of
endemic cretinism at 4years of age. Calcium supplementation reduced the risk of preeclampsia
in women with low baseline calcium dietary intake, while magnesium supplementation has been
associated with a lower frequency of preterm births and adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes
in childhood. Other vitamins and minerals, such as vitaminsB, C and E, copper and selenium, have
been associated with fetal development, but their impact on pregnancy outcomes is not clear.
Given such widespread maternal vitamin and mineral deficiencies, it is logical to consider
supplementation with multiple micronutrient preparations in pregnancy. The clinical benefits of
such an approach over single-nutrient supplements are unclear, and this article explores the current
concepts, evidence and limitations of maternal multiple-micronutrient supplementation.
Keywords : folate iodine iron micronutrient supplementation pregnancy vitaminA zinc
10.1586/EOG.10.8
ISSN 1747-4108
241
Review
CME
Editor
Elisa Manzotti, Editorial Director, Future Science Group, London, UK.
Disclosure: Elisa Manzotti has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
CME Author
Dsire Lie, MD, MSEd
Clinical Professor, Family Medicine, University of California, Irvine, Orange, California; Director of Research and Patient Development, Family Medicine,
University of California, Irvine, Medical Center, Rossmoor, CA, USA.
Disclosure: Dsire Lie, MD, MSEd, has disclosed the following relevant financial relationship: she served as a nonproduct speaker for: Topics in Health for
Merck Speaker Services.
Authors and Credentials
Mohammad Yawar Yakoob, MBBS
Research Fellow, Division of Women and Child Health, The Aga Khan University, Stadium Road, PO Box 3500, Karachi-74800, Pakistan.
Disclosure: Mohammad Yawar Yakoob has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
Yasir Pervez Khan, MBBS
Research Fellow, Division of Women and Child Health, The Aga Khan University, Stadium Road, PO Box 3500, Karachi-74800, Pakistan.
Disclosure: Yasir Pervez Khan has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
Zulfiqar Ahmed Bhutta, MB,BS, FRCP, FRCPCH, FCPS, FAAP, PhD
Professor and Head, Division of Women and Child Health, The Aga Khan University, Stadium Road, PO Box3500, Karachi-74800, Pakistan.
Disclosure: Zulfiqar Ahmed Bhutta has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
Nutritional deficiencies are widely prevalent globally and contribute significantly to high rates of morbidity and mortality among
mothers and their infants and children in developing countries.
The nutritional status of a woman before and during pregnancy
is important for a healthy pregnancy outcome. The prevalence of
maternal undernutrition that is, a BMI of less than 18.5kg/m2
ranges from 10 to 19% in most countries [6] . More than 20%
of women in sub-Saharan Africa, Southcentral and Southeastern
Asia, and Yemen have a BMI of less then 18.5kg/m2 [6] . In India,
Bangladesh and Eritrea, 40% of women have a low BMI, which
has adverse effects on pregnancy outcomes and increases the risk
of infant mortality [6] . Malnutrition among women manifests
itself at the macronutrient and/or the micronutrient level. More
than 40% of pregnant women around the world are anemic,
most of which is due to iron deficiency [103] . Iron, therefore, contributes to the largest prevalence of micronutrient deficiencies.
Other important deficiencies include iodine, zinc, vitaminA,
folic acid and vitaminB complex, including thiamine, riboflavin
and B12 [7] .
There is a critical window of opportunity during the early prenatal period while the fetus is still growing to prevent undernutrition during pregnancy and its effects on maternal and child
health. Evidence-based nutrition interventions can make a difference to short-term outcomes, and also offer the best opportunity for long-term growth and development. These interventions
include strategies to improve maternal nutrition before and during pregnancy, with appropriate micronutrient interventions.
Although iron-deficiency anemia is recognized as an important
risk factor for maternal and perinatal mortality globally, the contribution of other micronutrient deficiencies to adverse outcomes
Expert Rev. Obstet. Gynecol. 5(2), (2010)
CME
Study or subgroup
(year)
Batu (1976)
Butler (1968)
Buytaert (1983)
Cantlie (1971)
Chanarin (1971)
Cogswell (2003)
De Benaze (1989)
Eskeland (1997)
Makrides (2003)
Milman (1991)
Puolakka (1980)
Romslo (1983)
Tura (1989)
Van Eijk (1978)
Wallenburg (1983)
Ziaei (2007)
Ziaei (2008)
Total (95% CI)
Treatment (daily)
Mean
SD Total
113.00
136.00
127.29
124.00
124.00
121.40
130.00
125.70
127.00
128.90
132.00
126.00
121.00
132.13
128.90
139.00
138.80
10.00
9.87
12.80
6.00
9.80
10.39
10.00
7.80
13.00
8.00
12.00
8.00
8.00
11.27
11.30
12.50
4.50
30
97.00 11.00
27 135.00 7.10
24 124.07 8.05
15 11.0.00 9.00
49 114.00 9.50
90 121.70 10.48
44 122.00 10.00
24 112.80 6.50
200 120.00 12.00
99 118.90 10.00
16 111.00 9.00
22 113.00 10.00
129 119.00 10.00
15 112.79 16.11
18 125.60 11.30
370 131.80 13.60
114 127.80 4.70
22
6
21
12
46
62
25
21
193
107
15
23
112
15
20
357
120
Review
Several UN agencies recommend the universal distribution of ironfolic acid supplements to pregnant women in the
developing world. The evidence base for the effectiveness of
iron supplementation in pregnancy is strong. A review by PenaRosas and Viteri on preventive iron or iron and folic acid supplementation during pregnancy included 49 trials involving
23,200women [14] . Daily oral iron supplementation resulted
in a significantly higher maternal mean hemoglobin (Hb) concentration (mean difference [MD]: 8.83; 95%CI: 6.5511.11)
(Figure1) and a reduced risk of anemia in mothers at term (relative
risk [RR]: 0.27; 95%CI:0.170.42), compared with no intervention or placebo administration. There was also reduced risk
of iron-deficiency anemia, a significantly higher risk of hemoconcentration at term and also a higher mean Hb concentration
within 1month postpartum. The benefits to the infant included
a significant increase in birth length (MD: 0.38cm; 95%CI:
0.100.65) and higher mean ferritin concentrations at 3 and
6months of age. However, there was no significant direct evidence of benefits on maternal outcomes such as maternal mortality, severe anemia at term, preeclampsia, antepartum hemorrhage
and postpartum hemorrhage, but few studies were powered for
these effects. Similarly, infant outcomes such as perinatal death,
low birthweight, small-for-gestational age, premature delivery
and Hb concentrations at 3 and 6months were not statistically
different. Similar results were achieved for iron plus folic acid
supplementation versus no intervention or placebo. There was
a significantly higher mean Hb maternal concentration and a
Weight
Mean difference
IV, random (95% CI)
5.2%
4.7%
5.0%
5.2%
6.5%
6.8%
5.8%
6.3%
7.3%
7.3%
4.3%
5.6%
7.3%
3.2%
4.4%
7.5%
7.8%
16.00 (10.1721.83)
1.00 (-5.797.79)
3.22 (-2.959.39)
14.00 (8.0719.93)
10.00 (6.1213.88)
-0.30 (-3.683.08)
8.00 (3.0912.91)
12.90 (8.7217.08)
7.00 (4.539.47)
10.00 (7.5412.46)
21.00 (13.5628.44)
13.00 (7.7218.28)
2.00 (-0.314.31)
19.34 (9.3929.29)
3.30 (-3.9010.50)
7.20 (5.309.10)
11.00 (9.8212.18)
1286
1177 100.0%
Heterogeneity: Tau2 = 17.08; 2 = 120.52; df = 16 (p < 0.00001); I2 = 87%
Test for overall effect: Z = 7.59 (p < 0.00001)
Mean difference
IV, random (95% CI)
8.83 (6.5511.11)
-100
-50
0
50
100
Favors experimental Favors control
Figure1. Forest plot of the effect of daily iron alone versus no intervention/placebo on maternal hemoglobin concentration
at term.
SD: Standard deviation.
Data from [14] .
www.expert-reviews.com
243
Review
reduced risk of anemia at term. Hb levels within 1month postpartum were also greater in the intervention group. There was
also a reduced risk of small-for-gestational age babies, and a
significantly greater birth length and mean birthweight in the
ironfolate group. There was no difference in maternal iron
deficiency at term or adverse maternal and infant outcomes
between the two groups. Iron and folic acid supplementation
during pregnancy also resulted in a significant 31% decreased risk
of death in children occurring from birth to 7years of age compared
with controls receiving vitaminA only (hazard ratio [HR]:0.69;
95%CI:0.490.99)[15] .
Zinc
CME
VitaminA
CME
Review
Zinc
Events Total
34
14
33
5
127
22
29
7
5
50
30
194
249
585
92
628
121
521
109
87
268
294
3148
Control
Events Total
34
30
49
6
137
10
30
5
4
68
38
216
258
621
87
593
121
495
113
90
288
286
3168
Weight
Risk ratio
M-H, Fixed (95% CI)
7.5%
6.9%
11.1%
1.4%
32.9%
2.3%
7.2%
1.1%
0.9%
15.3%
9.0%
95.8%
1.11 (0.721.72)
0.48 (0.260.89)
0.71 (0.471.10)
0.79 (0.252.49)
0.88 (0.711.08)
2.22 (1.094.45)
0.92 (0.561.51)
1.45 (0.474.44)
1.29 (0.364.66)
0.79 (0.571.09)
0.77 (0.491.20)
0.87 (0.760.99)
Total events
356
411
Heterogeneity: = 14.17; df = 10 (p = 0.17); I2 = 29%
Test for overall effect: Z = 2.11 (p = 0.03)
Risk ratio
M-H, Fixed (95% CI)
0.01
0.1
1
Favors experimental
10
100
Favors control
Zinc
Events Total
10
2
243
30
Control
Events Total
Weight
Risk ratio
M-H, Fixed (95% CI)
17
1
243
22
4.0%
0.3%
0.59 (0.271.26)
1.47 (0.1415.17)
265
4.2%
0.64 (0.311.32)
3433
100.0%
0.86 (0.760.98)
3421
Total events
368
429
Heterogeneity: 2 = 15.36; df = 12 (p = 0.22); I2 = 22%
Test for overall effect: Z = 2.32 (p = 0.02)
Test for subgroup differences: not applicable
Risk ratio
M-H, Fixed (95% CI)
0.01
0.1
1
Favors experimental
10
100
Favors control
Figure2. Forest plot of the effect of zinc versus no zinc on preterm birth.
Data from [18] .
VitaminD
Review
CME
Vitamin A
Events Total
Study or subgroup
(year)
Coutsoudis (1999)
Fawzi (2002)
Semba (2002)
70
155
67
319
453
242
Placebo
Events Total
70
113
82
313
445
250
Weight
Risk ratio
M-H, random (95% CI)
30.9%
36.7%
32.4%
0.98 (0.731.31)
1.35 (1.101.65)
0.84 (0.641.11)
1.05 (0.781.41)
Risk ratio
M-H, random (95% CI)
0.01
0.1
Favors experimental
10
100
Favors control
Figure3. Forest plot of the impact of antenatal vitaminA supplementation in HIV-infected pregnant women on
mother-to-child transmission of HIV.
Data from [26] .
pregnancy has important consequences for the newborn, including fetal hypovitaminosis D, neonatal rickets and tetany, and
infantile rickets [3840] .
VitaminD status at birth is closely related to that of the mother.
The fetus at birth (cord blood) will contain approximately
5060% of the maternal circulating concentrations of 25(OH)D
[41] . VitaminD supplementation during pregnancy may therefore help to improve the fetal and newborn vitaminD status
and reduce the risk of vitaminD deficiency in the early months
of life. The review by Mahomed et al. on vitamin D supple
mentation during pregnancy [42] reports data from two trials
that had clinical outcomes [4346] . In the London (UK) trial, the
mothers had higher mean daily weight gain and a lower number
of low-birthweight infants [4446] . In the French trial, however,
the supplemented group had lower birthweights [43] . There was an
87% reduction in the incidence of neonatal hypocalcemia (odds
ratio [OR]: 0.13; 95%CI: 0.020.65), while no impact on cranio
tabes (softening of the skull) with supplementation (OR:0.40;
95%CI: 0.091.65) was seen.
Folate
supplements
Study or subgroup
(year)
Events
Total
Control
Events Total
Weight
2391
88
51
602
6.7%
5.4%
20.1%
67.9%
0.07 (0.001.32)
0.17 (0.014.24)
0.42 (0.082.23)
0.29 (0.120.71)
0.28 (0.130.58)
Czeizel (1994)
Kirke (1992)
Laurence (1981)
MRC (1991)
0
0
2
6
2471
169
60
593
6
1
4
21
Risk ratio
M-H, random (95% CI)
Risk ratio
M-H, random (95% CI)
0.01
0.1
1
10
100
Favors experimental Favors control
Figure4. Forest plot of the impact of the use of periconceptional folate and/or multivitamins on neural tube defects.
Data from [32] .
246
CME
Iodine
Iodine
Events Total
Control
Events Total
Weight
Review
Pharoah (1987)
66
498
97
534
69.3%
0.73 (0.550.97)
Thilly (1978)
27
197
42
202
30.7%
0.66 (0.421.03)
0.71 (0.560.90)
Risk ratio
M-H, random (95% CI)
0.01
0.1
1
Favors experimental
10
100
Favors control
Figure5. Forest plot of the impact of iodine supplementation versus no iodine in pregnancy on infant and early
childhoodmortality.
Data from [53] .
www.expert-reviews.com
247
Review
CME
CME
Maternal nutrition interventions to improve maternal and neonatal health include supplementation with micronutrients such
as iron, folate and calcium, and also macronutrients such as
balanced energy and protein diets. The review by Bhutta etal.
on interventions to address maternal and child undernutrition
derived the data of over 388studies from 139countries to find
preventive and therapeutic strategies to address undernutrition
deficiencies [53] . These interventions include disease-control
measures, as well as dietary diversification, supplementation
and food-fortification strategies. Maternal nutrition interventions are not only entirely feasible, but also affordable and cost
effective. Nutrition interventions are among the best investments in development that countries can undertake, provided
that these can be implemented at scale with community participation. Large-scale programs, including the provision of
www.expert-reviews.com
Review
Review
CME
The total cost of the final product must not significantly increase
with fortification. Besides, it is necessary to have a monitoring
and control system that guarantees both adequate nutrient concentration and program compliance. In case of potentially toxic
nutrients, excessive concentrations should not be added that could
put a population at risk. Legal issues include the facts of whether
the program should be compulsory or voluntary, and whether it
should be financed by the government or the private sector, or
both. Even if food fortification programs are mandatory, they
may fail to secure compliance; therefore, different approaches
for adequate implementation may be adopted, possibly including
fiscal and tariff incentives [107] . It is also important to demonstrate and document the costbenefit ratio of the intervention in
order to gain objective evidence to support the continuance of
these programs [85] . Besides, in areas where subsistence farming
is practiced, fortification is not likely to be a practicable solution
to nutrient deficiencies.
Technologically, it would be necessary to maintain the overall
quality of the product in terms of the bioavailability of the fortifying agent. Despite an increase in bioavailability, the products
quality may be at risk, especially its stability. Iron, for example,
may react with fatty acids in the fortified food, forming free radicals that induce oxidation. Any alterations that affect consumer
acceptability of the product should be avoided. Some options
for the future include microencapsulation of nutrients, the use
of nutrient-bioavailability stimulants (the addition of ascorbic
or other organic acids to promote iron absorption) and the
elimination of inhibitors of mineral absorption in the intestine
(e.g.,phytates) [107] . Fortification is certainly an effective micronutrient deficiency control strategy whose coverage needs to be
expanded. It should, however, be viewed as a complementary
strategy, and it will not be able to replace interventions such
as iron supplementation during pregnancy (and other micro
nutrient control strategies among other population groups), at
least in the short term.
Dosage & potential interactions
shows the recommended daily micronutrient intake during pregnancy and lactation based on recommendations provided by the American Academy of Pediatrics and American
College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists [57] . The current
recommendation for pregnant women is to provide a standard
daily dose of 60mg iron and 400g folic acid for 6months, or
if this duration of treatment cannot be achieved during pregnancy, then either to continue supplementation during the postpartum period or to increase the dose of iron to 120mg daily
during pregnancy [86] . In those areas where iron is fortified in
foods, the recommended daily dose of iron during pregnancy
is 30mg. Given that multiple deficiencies can coexist, we need
to determine the efficacy of multiple micronutrients to replace
ironfolate for pregnant women in developing countries, even
though their use has become common practice in developed
countries [87] .
Table1
Constipation is a common side effect of high-dose iron supplements, with other gastrointestinal effects
being nausea, vomiting and diarrhea [14] .
Table1. Recommended daily micronutrient intake during pregnancy
The frequency and severity of these side
and lactation.
effects varies according to the amount of
Micronutrient
Nonpregnant
Pregnancy
Lactation
elemental iron released in the stomach, and
women
is one of the main reasons for poor compliIron
15mg
30mg
15mg
ance with iron preparations in pregnancy.
Besides this, there is growing evidence of
Zinc
8mg
11mg
12mg
the existence of metabolic interactions
Calcium
1000mg
1000mg
1000mg
between micronutrients such as copper,
Iodine
150 g
220 g
290 g
zinc and iron. Excess iron can lower zinc
Selenium
55 g
60 g
70 g
nutritional status and vice versa [88,89] ; similarly, copper and zinc compete with each
VitaminA
700 g
770 g
1300 g
other[90,91] . VitaminA deficiency contribVitamin B:
utes to anemia by interfering with iron utili Thiamin (B1)
1.1mg
1.4mg
1.4mg
zation [87] . Besides vitaminA, other micro Riboflavin (B2)
1.1mg
1.4mg
1.6mg
nutrients can also enhance the absorption
of other micronutrients, such as vitaminC,
Niacin
14mg
18mg
17mg
increasing iron bioavailability [92] . As can
Vitamin B6
1.21.5mg
1.9mg
2.0mg
be seen, these interactions may be positive
Vitamin B12
2.4 g
2.6 g
2.8 g
or negative, and we do not have significant
Folate
0.4mg
0.6mg
0.5mg
scientific data on this aspect. The issues
related to the interactions between microVitaminC
75mg
85mg
120mg
nutrients and the coexistence of micro- and
VitaminD
5 g
5 g
5 g
macro-nutrient deficiencies require serious
Vitamin E
15mg
15mg
19mg
considerations before MMSs are given to
Data from [57].
pregnant women.
250
CME
Conclusion
Existing and emerging research linking micronutrient deficiencies during pregnancy with adverse birth outcomes is an exciting
development. Supplementation of micronutrients; for example,
ironfolate, has been the decades-old way of preventing and treating iron-deficiency anemia during pregnancy. In those areas where
the prevalence of anemia is high and mass fortification of iron
is unlikely to meet the needs of the population, weekly rather
than daily iron supplementation is recommended for women
of the reproductive age group. Folic acid supplementation has a
definite role to play in reducing both occurrent (first time) and
recurrent NTDs. Micronutrient supplementation can also have
a positive impact on other birth outcomes: zinc and magnesium
supplementation reduces preterm births, the effects being small
www.expert-reviews.com
Review
observational studies.
251
Review
CME
Key issues
Nutritional deficiencies are widely prevalent globally and contribute significantly to maternal and child morbidity and mortality.
Micronutrient deficiencies are associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes such as low birthweight and preterm birth.
Iron supplementation reduces the risk of anemia in mothers at term.
Folic acid supplementation reduces the incidence of neural tube defects.
Zinc supplementation has a small but significant impact on preterm births; however, its recommendation is weak.
VitaminA may reduce maternal mortality, but results of ongoing studies are awaited.
Other minerals and vitamins, such as iodine, calcium, magnesium, vitaminD, selenium, and vitaminsB6, B12, C and E, may also be
important for maternal, infant and child outcomes.
References
10
252
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
CME
27
28
39
40
29
30
41
31
42
43
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
www.expert-reviews.com
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
Review
52
53
55
56
57
58
59
253
Review
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
254
CME
72
73
74
UNICEF/WHO/UNU. Composition of a
multi-micronutrient supplement to be used in
pilot programmes among pregnant women in
developing countries. UNICEF, NY, USA
(1999).
75
77
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
78
91
79
92
CME
Websites
101
102
www.expert-reviews.com
103
104
105
Review
106
107
108
255
Review
CME
1.
Activity Evaluation
Where 1 is strongly disagree and 5 is strongly agree
1 2 3 4 5
1. The activity supported the learning objectives.
2. The material was organized clearly for learning
to occur.
3. The content learned from this activity will
impact my practice.
4. The activity was presented objectively and
free of commercial bias.
256
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.