Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract
Historic Landscape Characterization (HLC) is a methodology for historic landscape studies pioneered in
Britain. Using satellite imagery and RAF archival air photographs, Naxos provides an excellent pilot study to
explore the application of this technique to the historic landscapes of the eastern Mediterranean. Our research
identifies a number of discrete HLC types and considers their developmentfrom the Byzantine period to modern times. In addition it has been possible to tise these data to set Naxos' rich corpus of Byzantine churches in
their landscape context, providing amove textured account of rural life in medieval and post-medieval times.
Keywords: Historic Landscape Characterization (HLC), GIS, Aegean, Naxos, Byzantine, field systems,
terraces
Introduction
D
>
r i ' T i
c r^
' - L -
toric landscapes.'
^
^^^ research we report here was designed to
^'^P^^'^ent with a relatively new kind of land''^^P^ archaeology applied for the first time in
'^^ ^^'^''' Mediterranean. Historic Landscape
Characterization (HLC) is a method for mapP'"g ^^^ ^""re landscape with reference to its
historic development. Using Geographical Information Systems (GIS), we attempt to present
our interpretations of the historic landscape
based on spatial datasets (principally satellite
imagery, historic air photos and maps), and to
integrate these with data from historical and
archaeological studies.
doi: 1 0 . 1 5 5 8 / j m e a . v 2 4 i L l 11
112
Crow et al.
113
The same geographical area can be characterized in different ways by different users. For
example, two simple characterizations of parts
of Cornwall (UK) used rather diflferent HLC
types (Table 1). The first characterization was
designed to be used by archaeologists in largescale planning and landscape management work.
It defined 18 HLC types that were mapped
at a scale of 1:50,000 using modern maps as
the principal source (Herring 1998). A second
project using HLC produced an outline map of
medieval land-use in order to help understand
the location of medieval landscapes and setdements. It used just four HLC types to map parts
of the same area, but characterized them at a scale
of 1:10,000 based on historic estate maps. Tithe
Award maps and Ordnance Survey maps (Turner
2006b). It is important to remember that HLCs
are designed in relation to specific projects as well
as specific places. Existing HLCs may not necessarily be suitable for addressing the questions or
applications pursued by later researcbers.
In practice, this means that the present-day landscape is examined and characterized into 'HLC
types'. These types are classified in advance of
mapping by the researcher and tailored to the
region and specific project. HLC is a flexible
method: in different regions, different types are
appropriate because of differing landscape histories (see e.g. Dingwall and Caffney 2007 for
a typical example). Different types might also
be defined by the researcher if the characterization has been designed to be used at a larger or
smaller scale. HLC 'types' commonly relate to
the form of features, like field boundaries and
the historic processes that created them.
The exact nature of the HLC types defined
for any given project will vary depending on the
goals of the project in question. For example,
a project particularly interested in analysing
agricultural practices in a particular landscape
might choose to define several different types
relating to fields: arable fields, pasture, meadow.
The Fund for Mediterranean Archaeology/Equinox Ptiblishing Ltd., 2011
114
Crow et al.
Table 1.
Retrogressive analysis is a technique for unravelling the physical and chronological relationships between different elements in the historic
landscape (e.g. roads, field boundaries). Historic
landscapes and the physical features in them are
continually subject to forces of change, whether
natural or man-made. Change is therefore
widely recognized as a key characteristic of landscape (CoE 2000; Turner and Fairclough 2007:
121-2). Most landscapes contain features from
many different periods, and the relationships
between these features can be analysed to cast
light on the changes and processes that created
them. Sometimes these changes can be dated
absolutely, most often where there is independent archaeological or documentary evidence
(e.g. a sequence of maps or air photographs).
Otherwise it is often possible only to establish
a relative chronology. A classic example of this
method is Williamson's (1987; 1998) study
of the 'Scole-Dickleburgh' field system on the
boundary of Norfolk and Suffolk in England.
He argued that the basic framework of the field
system was created in the late Iron Age or earlier
since it appears to be cut through and overlain
by a Roman road.
115
116
Crow et al.
117
118
Crow et al.
interpretation of earlier phases of landscape character was made using all the available sources.
This means that for much of our study area we
can model earlier patterns of land-use and (at a
fairly simple level) try to trace which landscapes
have remained most stable and which have
changed fastest. We can also see how earlier uses
of the land have affected later patterns.
Naxos HLC Types
Our starting point for this study is the 'historic
landscape'. Archaeologists' definition of this
term is deliberately broad. We include not only
all the physical components of today's landscapefor example, walls, lanes, trees, hedges,
ruins, houses and other buildingsbut also the
earthworks or field remains of long-deserted
sites. Using a range of archaeological techniques,
we include barely visible or even wholly buried
features into our analyses, like the soil-marks or
crop-marks left by ancient setdements, or earlier
landscapes concealed beneath recent alluvial
deposits. Historical and ethnographic records
also allow the cultural perceptions and associations of places to be valued as part of the historic
landscape: battlefields or sacred sites may leave
few physical traces but an awareness of them
may further influence the way we understand
and value the historic landscape.
Although historical archaeology has begun to
emerge as a distinct field of study in the Aegean
only in the last couple of decades, it is clear
that historic landscapes are rich and varied here
(Vionis 2011a). Throughout the region, postmedieval settlements and medieval churches nestle amongst fields and terraces of largely uncertain
antiquity. Networks of kalderimia (footpaths or
tracks) snake amongst the ancient olives, lending
a timeless atmosphere to the region's small-scale
agricultural scene. In pursuit of these landscapes'
ancient forerunners, pioneering archaeological
fieldwork has included the development of surface survey methods, which have revolutionized
how we understand the prehistoric and classical
worlds (Renfrew and Wagstaflf 1982; Cherry et
119
Table 2.
Enclosures
Enclosures (modern)
Enclosures (post-medieval)
Enclosures (post-medieval) based on Fields (medieval)
Enclosures (post-medieval) based on Braided terraces
(medieval)
Enclosures (post-medieval) based on Step terraces straight/contour (post-medieval)
Olives (modern)
Olives (post-medieval)
Horticulture (modern/post-medieval)
Terraces
120
Crow et al.
Figure 2.
A traditional diystone wall topped with thorns at Agios Mamas at Driti (J. Crow, August 2007).
121
10 km
.T
Apollo nas
NAXOS
Apano Kastro
Chora ^ , , v
Agia Kyriaki
irea of Fig. 7
Apeiranthos
I
Rachi
~area of Fig. 3
plain of Drymalia/Tragea
area of Fig. 4
Ano Sangi
Aria
Apalirou Kastro
Rough ground
I Braided terraces
I Enclosures (post-medievat)
I Terraced fields
I Olives
I Check-dams
Wtoodland
I Horticulture
I Villas (modern)
I Orchard
I Settlement (histohc)
Sand
I Settlement (modern)
I Quarry
Recreation
Figure 1.
I Industrial
The island of Naxos, showing the area of sites, case studies mentioned in the text and the pilot HLC study
area.
122
Crow et al.
HLC
Figure 3.
Rough ground
Features
Stream bed
c[3
Olives - post-medieval
4"
Settlement - modern
Field boundary
Settlement - historic
Ten-ace
Historic landscape characterization (HLG) and retrogressive analysis of the area around Ghalki in the Drymalia/Tragea plain, Naxos. (Includes IKONOS material 2006, Space Imaging LLG. All rights reserved).
Figure 4.
100
200
300
123
400 m
HLC and retrogressive analysis of the Ana area, Naxos. (Includes I K O N l J i marerial 2006, Space Imaging
LLC. All righrs reserved).
- 1
Remains of
post-medieval buildings
Figure 6.
Straighr step terraces within surveyed fields associated with deserted post-medieval farmsteads below Apano
Kastro, Naxos (J. Crow, October 2006).
124
Crow et al.
Agios Isidoros
fllC
Rough ground
Rough ground with enclosures
Rough ground wrth enclosed braided terraces
Olives - post-medval
Settlement - modem
Settlement - historic
Stream
Track
Field boundary
Terrace
Early Byzantine church
Middle Byzantine church
Taxiarchis Rachis
"
.:
Rachi
Figure 7.
HLC and retrogressive analysis of the area around Rachi at the northern end of the Drymalia/Tragea plain,
Naxos. (Includes IKONOS material 2006, Space Imaging LLC. All rights reserved).
Figure 8.
1 he middle Byzantine church of Agios Mamas. Braided terraces overlain by later post-medieval enclosure walls
are visible on the hillsides beyond. The peak on the horizon behind is site of the fortress of Apano Kastro
(J. Crow, October 2006).
125
126
Crow et al.
Based on what is known from the Naxiot documentary sources, and by analogy with other parts
of Europe and the Mediterranean, it seems likely
that these post-medieval field boundaries could
perpetuate the layout of individual parcels or
strips in earlier open fields. On Kythera, archaeologists have tentatively suggested that similar
semi-regular field patterns may have Byzantine
or Medieval origins (Bevan et al 2003: 220).
Particularly around Chalki, but also around the
village of Ano Sangri, the subdividing boundaries are slightly curved in form. Elsewhere in
Europe, this morphology could be interpreted as
perpetuating the form of divisions in earlier open
arable fields. The Chalki examples are very similar to those identified in Crete's Mesara plain by
Rackham and Moody (1996: 147-49, fig. 12.6;
for other European examples see e.g. Chouquer
1993: 102France; Herring 2006England).
It seems highly likely that around Chalki, this
prime agricultural land would have formed the
core of the medieval topoi. In the HLC, such
areas have been mapped as 'Enclosures (postmedieval) based on Fields (medieval)'.
Indeed, our retrogressive analysis suggests the
post-medieval period was the time when most
existing field walls on Naxos were constructed.
Although some enclosures are recorded in medieval documents (Kasdagli 1987; 1999), it seems
likely that the period of their creation and the
enclosure of Naxos was probably after the abolition of feudal lordship in 1721 and during the
economic fluctuations of the mid-late 18th and
early 19th centuries (Kasdagli 1999: 167; Vionis
2011a). Where the earlier histories of these
fields can be discerned with a reasonable level
of confidence, the likely earlier HLC types are
included in the databasee.g. 'Field (medieval)'
or 'Braided terraces (medieval)'. In many cases,
however, it has not been possible to suggest what
the earlier landscape character might have been
with any degree of confidence, so the character
type has been described simply as 'Enclosures
(post-medieval)' in the database. This is an oversimplification that inevitably conceals richer his The Fund for Mediterranean Archaeology/Eqtiinox Publishing Ltd., 2011
127
Byzantine (Brunet 1999; Harfouehe 2007: 1566). High-resolution imagery available through
Google Earth (January 2008) certainly shows
that the form of the drystone enelosure boundaries of Delos are morphologieally different to
the post-medieval enclosure walls of Naxos,
or indeed those on the neighbouring island of
Rhenea. Instead, they appear to be associated
with the 20th-century farms noted by Harfouche (2007: 154-55). Beneath these boundaries lie abandoned terraces. Although some of
these terraces are rather regular in form (hinting
at a more recent date), many have a slightly
sinuous morphology and braiding that suggests
more than a single phase of development.
The available evidenee suggests that eultivation terraees are likely to have existed in many
Aegean (espeeially insular) landscapes during
elassieal antiquity. Terraees were also built, reused, repaired and developed during the Middle
128
Crow et al.
Ages. In other places, however, it seems terracing was largely absent until tbe 19th century.
Such differences must have contributed significantly to differences in the economic, social
and cultural landscapes of each area. Similarly,
archaeological and historical evidence suggests
that diflferent regions and islands witnessed significant variations in patterns of landholding,
agricultural practice, distribution of settlement
and establishment of religious sites in the medieval and post-medieval periods. By mapping,
understanding and analysing these regional variations we should gain a richer and more textured
awareness of how local societies functioned and
tiltimately of how today's Aegean landscapes
came to be created.
Away from the plains, much of the land
mapped for the HLC is terraced. Rackham and
his collaborators have identified six principal terrace types widespread in the Cyclades: braided
terraces, contour terraces, straight step terraces,
check-dams, terraced fields and modern false
terraces (Rackham and Moody 1996: 140-45;
Crove and Rackham 2001: 108). We have used
this existing classification as tbe basis for our historic landscape character types. Here we discuss
the first three of them as they pertain to Naxos.
As on other Cycladic islands, there are many
areas where field boundaries, usually drystone walls, cut across earlier terraces (e.g. Kea:
Whitelaw 1991). As we have observed earlier,
virtually all examples of braided terraces on
Naxos are overlain stratigraphically by enclosure
boundaries that divide the terrace systems into
discrete blocks (Figure 4). It is not uncommon
for individual terraces within such systems to
abut dividing walls, although invariably other
terraces within the same system will underlie
them. This shows that, in these terrace systems,
there have been long (possibly discontinuous)
periods of use with several phases of terrace development. The underlying terraces must antedate
the walls, which themselves are no later than
the 18th or 19th centuries in the vast majority
of cases (Figure 5). Our analysis of the RAF air
The Fund for Mediterranean Archaeoiog}^/quinQx Publishing Ltd., 2011
Figure 5.
129
The terraced landscape of Naxos: view towards Apano Kastro from the southwest showing a typical Naxiot
landscape of braided terraces enclosed and overlain by later drystone walls (J. Crow, August 2007).
130
Crow et al.
131
Conclusion
The study of Byzantine archaeology has ofi:en concentrated on monuments (especially churches)
and most frequently the specific study of their
132
Crow et al.
133
References
Alcock, S.
1993
134
Crow et al.
Gerstal, S.
2005
1998
Herring, P.
2006
Kalas, V.
2009 Sacred boundaries and protective borders: outlying chapels of Middle Byzantine settlements
in Gappadocia. In G. Gates, J. Morin and T.
Zimmermann (eds.). Sacred Landscapes in Anatolia and Neighboring Regions. British Archaeological Reports International Series 2034: 78-91.
Oxford: Archaeopress.
Kasdagli, A.
1987
1999
2001
2007
The middle Byzantine economy: growth or stagnation? Byzantine and Modem Greek Studies 19:
243-61.
Herring, P.
1996
2007
135
Lee, W.
2001
136
Crow et al.
Change and the human landscape in a modern
Greek village in Messenia. Hesperia 70: 49-98.
doi: 10.2307/2668487
Poupet, P
2000 Science du sol et archologie: propos d un
exemple dlien. tudes Rurales 153-54: 91-114.
Lefort, J.
Price, S., and L. Nixon
1985 Radolibos: population et paysage. Travaux et
2005 Ancient Creek agricultural terraces: evidence
Mmoires'): 195-234.
from texts and archaeological survey. American
foumal of Archaeology 109: 665-94. doi: 10.3764/
2002 The Rural Economy, Seventh-Twelfth centuaja. 109.4.665
ries. In A.E. Laiou (ed.), The Economie History
of Byzantium: ftom the Seventh through the Fif- Pryor, J.H., and Jeffreys, E.M.
teenth Centuries. Dumbarton Oaks Studies 39:
2006 The Age of the Dromon: The Byzantine Navy ca.
231-310. Washington DC: Dumbarton Oaks.
500-1204. Leiden: Brill.
Lehmann, R.
Rackham, O., and J. Moody
1993 Terrace degradation and soil erosion on Naxos
1996 The Making of the Cretan Landscape. ManchesIsland, Greece. In S. Wicherek (ed.). Farm Land
ter: Manchester University Press.
Erosion: In Temperate Plains Environment and Renfrew, C , and M. WagstafF
Hills, 429-43. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
1982 An Island Polity: The Archaeology of Exploitation
1994 Landschaftdegradierung, Bodenerosion und
in Melos. Cambridge: Cambridge University
-konservierung auf der Kykladeninsel Naxos,
Press.
Griechenland. Physiogeographica 21. Basel:
Rippon, S.
Geographisches Institut der Universitt Basel.
2004 Historic Landscape Analysis: Deciphering the CounLock, P
tryside. York: Council for British Archaeology.
1995 The Franks in the Aegean 1204-1500. London: Roymans, N.
Longman.
1995 The cultural biography of urnfields and the
Mastoropoulos, G.S.
long-term history of a mythical landscape.
n.d. (ca.2006) Na^oTO U o KOkXoq. Naxos: ByzArchaeological Dialogues 2: 2-24. doi: 10.1017/
antine Monuments. Athens: EUinikes OmoioS138020380000026X
graphikes Ekdoseis.
Ruiz del rbol, M.
Mee, C , and H. Forbes
2005 La Arqueologa de los Espacios Cultivados: Terrazas y Explotacin Agraria Romana en un Area
1997 A Rough and Rocky Place: The Landscape and Setde
Montara: La Sierra de Francia (Salamanca).
tlement History of the Methana Peninsula, Greece.
Anejos
de Archivo Espaol de Arqueologa 36.
Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.
Madrid:
CSIC.
Nixon, L.
2006 Making a Landscape Sacred: Outlying Churches Schaus, G., and N. Spencer
and Icon Stands in Sphakia, Southwestern Crete. 1994 Notes on the topography of Eresos. AmeriOxford: Oxbow Books.
can foumal of Archaeology 98: 411-30.
'Carragin, T.
doi: 10.2307/506437
2003 A landscape converted: archaeology and early
Slot, B.
Church organisation on Iveragh and Dingle. In
1982 Archipelagus turbatus: Les Cyclades entre colonisiaM. Carver (ed.). The Cross Goes North: Processes
tion latine et occupation ottomane c. 1500-1718.
of Conversion in Northern Europe, AD 300Publications de l'institut historique-archolo1300, 127-52. Woodbridge: Boydell.
gique nerlandais de Stamboul 51. Leiden:
Nederlands Instituut voor het Nabijen Oosten.
Oosthuizen, S.
2006 Landscapes Decoded: The Origins and Develop- 1991 The Frankish archipelago. Byzantinische Forschungen 16: 195-205.
ment of Cambridgeshire's Medieval Fields. HatTalbot A.-M., and Sullivan, D.
field: Hertfordshire University Press.
Peatfield, A.
2005 The History of Leo the Deacon: Byzantine Mili1992 Rural ritual in Bronze Age Crete. Cambridge
tary Expansion in the Tenth Century. Dumbarton
Archaeological foumal 2: 59-87. doi: 10.1017/
Oaks Studies 41. Washington DC: Dumbarton
S0959774300000482
Oaks Research Library and Collection.
The Fund for Mediterranean Archaeology/Equinox Publishing Ltd., 2011
Terrenato, N.
2007 The essential countryside: the Roman world.
In S. Alcock and R. Osborne (eds.). Classical
Archaeology, 139-61. Oxford: Blackwell.
Turner, S.
2006a Historic Landscape Gharacterisation: a landscape archaeology for research, management and
planning. Landscape Research 31: 385-98. doi:
10.1080/01426390601004376
2005
1991
2007
Whitelaw, T.
2009
137
Widgren, M.
2004 Gan landscapes be read? In H. Palang, H.
Soovli, M. Antrop and G. Setten (eds.), European Rural Landscapes: Persistence and Change in
a Globalising Environment, 455-65. Dordrecht:
Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Williamson, T.
1987 Early co-axial field systems on the East Anglian
boulder clays. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 53: 4\9-3\.
1998 The 'Scole-Dickleburgh field system' revisited.
Landscape History 20: 19-28.
2007
Copyright of Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology is the property of Equinox Publishing Group and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.