Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
CHAPTER I
SACRED SCRIPTURE AND THE SPIRITUAL LIFE
"Sacred theology relies on the written Word of God, taken together with sacred Tradition, as on a
permanent foundation .... Therefore, the 'study of the sacred page' should be the very soul of
theology .... In the sacred books the Father who is in heaven comes lovingly to meet his children,
and talks with them. And such is the force and power of the Word of God that it can serve the
Church as her support and vigor, and the children of the Church-as strength for their faith, food
for the soul, and a pure and lasting fount of spiritual life."(1)
The Fathers of Vatican Council II have officially recommended a return to Sacred Scripture and
Tradition. Yet, it is not without its difficulties, both for Scripture scholars and for theologians, as
is pointed out by Yves Congar, a highly respected leader of the movement back to the biblical
sources.
There is bound to be at times an alarming confusion among theologians in possession of a
centuries-old heritage. The unfortunate consequence is not that they are upset; it is the resulting
divorce that might be established between the research of biblical scholars and the conclusions of
theologians. An unhealthy situation of "double truth" might ensue, which must be avoided at all
costs. One group must pay close attention to the work of the other in a common fidelity to the
tradition of the Church ....
But the problems created for classical theology by exegetes returning to biblical sources must be
recognized and faced. For centuries past, especially since the great Scholastics who proposed
such a seemingly definitive and perfect elaboration of sacred doctrine, theology has been
formulated satisfactorily in ontological terms. Its work was to contemplate and define by means
of revelation the en-soi of God and of Christ, that is, what they are in themselves. And now
biblical scholars agree more and more in affirming that revelation comes to us essentially in the
framework of history and that it is essentially "economic" or "functional": there is no revelation
of the mystery of God and Christ except in the testimony handed on about what they did and are
doing for us, that is, except in relation to our salvation.(2)
The primary witness of Scripture, therefore, is that God has acted in the life of man, so that the
Bible is not so much a code of laws or a book of questions and answers as it is "a history of what
God has done in the lives of men, for humanity as a whole, in order to fulfill in them the design
of grace."(3) One does not go to the Bible to get ideas about God and to talk about God
(although it does reveal God to us as he is in himself, e.g., Ex. 3:14.), but to understand what
God is to us and to respond to his presence. "Man wants to experience God's presence somehow,
through signs that manifest it unambiguously; and he wants to live in communion with God on a
quasi-experiential level."(4) The Fathers of Vatican II expressed the same sentiments:
It pleased God, in his goodness and wisdom, to reveal himself and to make known the mystery of
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 2
SPIRITUALITY OF THE EARLY CHURCH
In his sermons and parables Christ frequently stated that the kingdom of God would be rejected
by the Jews and accepted by the Gentiles, although the Jews remained the Chosen People.
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 3
MONASTICISM IN THE EAST
Monasticism began toward the end of the third century as the result of the efforts of ascetical
Christians to live a more perfect life. Although it would eventually constitute a distinct state of
life in the Church, at the beginning it was a manner of life available to any Christian who wanted
to give an authentic witness to the teaching of Christ. The monastic movement began so quietly
that historians are unable to describe its origin with exactitude and it was not until the I93o's that
there was any serious investigation into the matter.(1) However, there seems to be some
connection between the end of the persecution of the Church and the flourishing of asceticism
that was a prelude to the monastic movement. Thus, according to Fnelon: "The persecution
made less solitaries than did the peace and triumph of the Church. The Christians, simple and
opposed to any softness, were more fearful of a peace that might be gratifying to the senses than
they had been of the cruelty of the tyrants."(2)
CHRISTIAN VIRGINS AND ASCETICS
In the earliest days of the Church the supreme witness to Christ was martyrdom, although even
in those times there were ascetics and also men and women who vowed to live a celibate life.
When the persecutions ended, the ascetics and the celibates were placed in a difficult situation; in
a world that was tolerant of Christians it was almost inevitable that relaxation should set in and
that some Christians should become worldly.(3) As long as they were considered enemies of the
State, it was relatively easy to avoid contact with pagan society and to practice their religion
within the confines of the small Christian communities; and if they were arrested, they could
hope for the coveted crown of martyrdom. But once Christians obtained their freedom and
Christianity became the official religion, "it is no longer the pagan world that fights and
eliminates the martyr; it is the hermit that takes up the attack and eliminates the world from his
being."(4)
From the beginning of the second century there are references to ascetics who lived a life of
continence and it seems that the state of virginity was approved by the Church and held in
reverence by the faithful. Both St. Clement of Rome and St. Ignatius of Antioch speak of
Christian men and women who had embraced a celibate life, and for both of these authors the
primary purpose of the celibate life is to imitate Christ in that respect.(5) There are numerous
texts from the third century that describe the role of virgins and other celibates in the life of the
Church; the treatises by Tertullian and St. Cyprian are especially noteworthy.(6) Finally, in the
fourth century the authors who praised virginity were even more numerous: St. Athanasius, St.
Basil, St. Gregory Nazianzen, St. Gregory of Nyssa, St. John Chrysostom, St. Ambrose, St.
Augustine and Cassian.(7)
At the start, the ascetics, virgins and other celibates remained in their own homes, living with
their families and sharing in the common life of the local church. Sometimes they organized
themselves into groups, similar to confraternities or chapters of a Third Order. Eventually a rule
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
CHAPTER 4
MONASTICISM IN THE WEST
There is little documentary evidence of monasticism in the West before the middle of the fourth
century, at which time it was already flourishing in the East.(1) However, since there was
constant communication between Rome and the centers of monasticism in Egypt, Palestine and
Alexandria, it is probable that Christians in Rome knew about the monastic movement. What is
certain is that St. Athanasius visited Trier during the time of his first exile between 336 and 338,
and he was in Rome in 340. His Life of Antony, which had such a great role in the popularization
of the monastic life, was quickly translated into Latin for Christians in the West.
On the other hand, it is possible that monastic life in the West could have developed without any
direct influence from the East. The ascetics, virgins and widows were already observing some of
the practices proper to a monastic life style. Eusebius even speaks of an ascetic living in solitude
as early as the middle of the third century.(2) But one of the distinguishing elements of monastic
life was absent in the first few centuries of the Church in the West, namely, separation from the
world. The early ascetics preferred life in community to a solitary life separated from the world.
Consequently, although we cannot say with certainty that monastic life in the West was strictly
an importation from the East, during the fourth and fifth centuries eastern monasticism was a
dominant influence on the development of monastic communities in the West.
ORIGINS OF WESTERN MONASTICISM
Writing in the 380's, St. Jerome states that the name "monk" was held in contempt, probably
because of certain male and female ascetics who were excessively charismatic and lacking in
discipline.(3) At the same time he spoke favorably of the monastic life of certain noble Roman
ladies for whom he served as spiritual director. In spite of some opposition to the ascetical
movement, St. Jerome fostered this type of life during his three years in Rome.
Another promoter of the ascetical life was St. Ambrose (+ 397) whose own sister Marcellina
began to live the ascetical life in Rome in 353 and later moved to Milan.(4) As bishop of Milan,
he was the patron of a community of men near Milan, and it was here that St. Augustine first
encountered anything resembling the monastic life.
It has been said that Eusebius, Bishop of Vercelli from 344 to his death in 371, founded the first
monastic community in the Latin Church. However, since he was exiled to the East in 355 for
refusing to sign the condemnation of St. Athanasius at the synod at Milan, it is likely that he
established the community after his return from the East in 363.
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 5
BENEDICTINE SPIRITUALITY
In the seventh and eighth centuries the Church was still carried along by the momentum received
from the fruitful pontificate of St. Gregory the Great. The Council of Orange (529) had given the
Holy See great prestige and had confirmed the doctrinal authority of St. Augustine. Prior to this,
the writings of Boethius (+ 524) had also helped to propagate Augustinian doctrine. However,
the predominant influence and unifying force was monasticism, and especially Benedictine
monasticism.(1)
At Toledo in Spain the entire Visigoth nation had embraced Christianity, and St. Isidore of
Seville (+636) emerged as an influential theologian and a promoter of monasticism.(2) In Italy
the Lombards, tainted with Arianism, were gradually assimilated into orthodox Christianity.
Meanwhile, the Anglosaxons, who had arrived in England as pagans, were now sending forth
missionary monks to the continent. Willibrord evangelized the Low Countries and St. Boniface,
assisted by monks, nuns and clerics from England, labored from 718 until his martyrdom in 754
to establish the Church in Germany and to reform the Church in the Frankish empire. The
successors of St. Boniface also preached the Gospel in Hungary and in Scandinavia. Back in
England, Bede the Venerable (+735) dedicated himself to a life study and literary productions
based on the teaching of St. Augustine, St. Gregory the Great and Cassiodorus.(3)
When Charlemagne (Carolus Magnus) came to the throne in 768 he achieved by peaceful means
what the Visigoths, the Vandals and the Lombards had failed to do by warfare and pillaging: a
unified Europe. It was not, to be sure, a reincarnation of the ancient Roman Empire, but
Charlemagne did succeed in bringing the Roman and Germanic peoples together under one
emperor and the universal authority of the Holy See. During his long reign (768-814) the liturgy
was stabilized, the biblical text was unified, the Gelasian Sacramentary was revised, Gregorian
chant was promoted and new hymns and prayers were introduced. The monasteries played a
significant role in all of this renewal and reform; in fact, Charlemagne had desired to see all
monasteries under one rule but the first move in that direction was made only after his death.(4)
BENEDICT OF ANIANE
The first representative writer on the theology of the monastic life, according to Leclercq,(5) was
Ambrose Autpert, who died in 784 as abbot of a monastery in southern Italy.(6) His doctrine was
fully in accord with that of St. Augustine and St. Gregory the Great, since he saw the monastic
life as a distinctive form of ascetical combat in which the monk seeks personal sanctification by
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER SIX
SPIRITUALITY OF THE MIDDLE AGES
The twelfth century was a period of political and ecclesiastical turmoil, intellectual stimulation
and challenging adjustment to the changing times. The merchants and artisans of the towns and
cities were confronting the ancient feudal system and demanding greater freedom and autonomy
as individuals and as members of the guilds. The romance languages were slowly but surely
replacing Latin, with the result that people in a given locality were becoming more isolated
culturally and somewhat alienated from the Latin liturgy. The masters in cathedral schools and in
monasteries, previously immersed in patristic sources and tradition, were reaching out to new
methods of scholarship and thus preparing the way for the rise of the universities. Finally, the
laity, individually or in groups, began to take a more prominent place in the life of the Church,
even in areas that were formerly considered the exclusive domain of monks and the clergy.
MEDIEVAL PIETY
The prologue to the Rule of Grandmont, founded by St. Stephen of Muret (+ 1124), stated that
there is only one rule of faith and salvation, namely, the Gospel. All other rules, such as that of
St. Benedict or St. Augustine, are simply applications of the Gospel teaching.(1) The reading and
knowledge of the New Testament was not, however, the exclusive prerogative of monks; there
was an intense interest in Scripture on the part of the laity of the twelfth century. In fact, a group
of the laity at Metz translated into the vernacular the four gospels, the letters of St. Paul and the
Psalms. Then, in private meetings they discussed and interpreted the various passages, but they
excluded from their gatherings all priests and any laymen who disagreed with their exegesis of
Scripture. As a result, in 1199 Pope Innocent III issued a letter in which he praised their devotion
to Scripture but condemned their secret, exclusive meetings and their anti-clerical attitude. Later,
the synods of Toulouse (1229) and Tarragona 0234) forbade the laity to possess or read
translations of the Bible in the vernacular. (2)
Interest in the reading and discussion of the Gospel and the preaching of the Crusades for the
liberation of the holy places naturally contributed a great deal to another dominant characteristic
of medieval piety: devotion to the sacred humanity of Christ. Some historians have asserted that
this devotion was introduced by St. Bernard and popularized by St. Francis of Assisi, but the
truth of the matter is that this devotion has existed in the Church from earliest times.(3) It did
develop in the twelfth century, however, and because of the worldwide interest in the Crusades
and the Holy Land, the devotion of the faithful began to focus more and more on various scenes
or "mysteries" of the life of Christ or on the instruments of the passion and death of Christ.
The attention of the faithful was especially fixed on the intensity of Christ's sufferings and,
indeed, was preoccupied with that aspect. In succeeding centuries mystics such as St. Brigid
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 7
DIONYSIAN SPIRITUALITY AND DEVOTIO MODERNA
Following Cayr,(1) we have decided to designate this chapter as "Dionysian spirituality" but the
title requires explanation. First of all, it refers to a revival of neo-Platonic, Augustinian
spirituality by the German Dominicans, who then influenced the Christian life in the
Netherlands. Secondly, while dependent on the Dominican intellectual tradition, it swings away
from that tradition toward the mystical and contemplative spirituality of pseudo-Dionysius, who
lived around the year 500. Thirdly, it resulted in the expansion of spiritual influence from the
Latin countries to the Germanic and Anglo-Saxon countries, introducing at the same time a
classification of schools of spirituality according to national cultures and temperaments.
The leader of this new school was Meister Eckhart, a German Dominican who was later accused
of pantheistic tendencies. His disciples included John Tauler and Henry Suso, both German
Dominicans, and John Ruysbroeck of the Netherlands. In England a more moderate form of
Dionysian spirituality was taught by Richard Rolle, Walter Hilton and the author of The Cloud of
Unknowing.(2) Mention should also be made of the Carthusian, Denis Rijkel, who is in the same
school of spirituality and brings the Middle Ages to a close as far as spiritual theology is
concerned.
Before noting the contributions of each of the outstanding figures in Dionysian spirituality, we
should investigate the circumstances that led to the emergence and success of this spiritual
movement. Although theologians of the stature of St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Bonaventure had
written about mystical contemplation, it was not until the fourteenth century that this subject
became the object of intense and specialized study. One of the principal situations that favoured
this theological development was the increasing number of fervent and educated women who
were claiming various types of mystical experience and seeking spiritual direction as a result of
it.
Early in the fourteenth century there was an amazing number of religious women who composed
spiritual treatises in which they described their mystical experiences, many of them being
accounts of the mystical espousal or mystical marriage. Eventually this Brautmystik (mysticism
of spiritual marriage) became one of the chief characteristics of Eckhart's "mysticism of the
essence".(3) That this movement had its excesses, there is no doubt, for Sitwell observes that "in
the fourteenth century the whole of the Rhine valley was seething with religious enthusiasts,
Bguines and Beghards, and Brethren of the Free Spirit, some of them controlled and
respectable, some of them not."(4)
As early as 1292 the Council of Aschaffenburg initiated a repression of the Beghards and the
Bguines; in 1306 the Council of Cologne accused them of infamy and heresy and blamed them
for instigating attacks on the Franciscans and Dominicans. Finally, the Council of Vienne (1311)
condemned eight of their doctrinal propositions and denounced their pseudomysticism. Yet, not
all the Beghards and Bguines were deserving of condemnation. Mechtild of Magdeburg is an
outstanding example of a Bguine who rose to the heights of the mystical life and, together with
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 8
POST-TRIDENTINE SPIRITUALITY
The period covered by the title of this chapter corresponds to the third volume of Pourrat's
Christian Spirituality,(1) that is, from the middle of the fifteenth to the middle of the seventeenth
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 9
MODERN SPIRITUALITY
The period covered under the heading "modern spirituality" extends from the seventeenth to the
nineteenth century and the focal point is France. While it is true that modern spirituality retains
something of the affective flavor of the teaching of St. Francis de Sales, except for Italy, the
Salesian influence has not been predominant. Rather, the spirituality fashioned by the French
school was eminently Christocentric, firmly rooted in the Christology of St. Paul and the
theology of St. Augustine.
"We would have expected that period to produce some masterpieces in theology," says Florand,
"but when we list Chardon's Cross of Jesus, the Sermons of Bossuet, the Meditations of
Malebranche, we have practically named them all. The Penses of Pascal are but 'a woodpile in
disorder'.(1) Nevertheless, the Christocentric spirituality of the French school was diffused so
widely that for all practical purposes Catholic spirituality in modern times could be characterized
as French spirituality. This is especially evident when we consider the vast influence of French
culture and religion on countries throughout the world, particularly during the eighteenth and
nineteenth centuries.
In order to evaluate the strength and the weakness, the orthodoxy and the distortions of the
French school of spirituality, it will be necessary to retrace our steps somewhat in order to
investigate its origins and trace its development.
SOURCES OF FRENCH SPIRITUALITY
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHAPTER 10
THE TWENTIETH CENTURY
If Christian spirituality in the twentieth century is indebted to any nation more than others, that
nation is France. Indeed it would be safe to say that until Vatican Council II, practically all the
aspects of the life of the Church - liturgy, exegesis, theology, philosophy, mission work and
spirituality -- received their most powerful impetus and orientation from French experts and
leaders. Even officials of the Roman Curia were sometimes prodded into renewal and adaptation
by French theologians and ecclesiastics.
Yves Congar has aptly stated that "the beacons which the hand of God has set aflame on the
threshold of the atomic century are called Thrse of Lisieux and Charles de Foucauld." There
are other lights as well, not only as examples of Christian holiness but as experts in various fields
that relate to the spiritual life, but it is worth noting that in an age of intense activism and
flourishing technology, the Holy Spirit has raised up those two great witnesses to the power and
efficacy of the contemplative life.
ST. THRSE OF LISIEUX
After St. Teresa of Avila and St. John of the Cross, St. Thrse of Lisieux is the third great
luminary of Carmelite spirituality. Although she lived in the nineteenth century (1873-1897), her
impact on the twentieth century is nothing short of remarkable. This is all the more true when we
consider that she spent her youth in the closed circle of the Martin family, tenderly protected by a
loving father and older sisters, and the remainder of her short life was hidden in the cloister of
the Carmel of Lisieux.
Thrse was the last of the nine children born into the Martin family, of which four children died
in their infancy. Four of the girls became Carmelite nuns at Lisieux and the fifth became a
Visitandine. From her earliest days, Thrse felt the call to the cloister, but when she made the
formal request for admittance to Carmel, the superiors refused her because of her youth. Thrse
even travelled to Rome with her father and Celine, to seek a dispensation from Pope Leo XI1I.
Finally, on April 9, 1888, she was admitted to Carmel and made her religious profession on
September 8, I89o.
In 1894 the prioress, Mother Agnes, a blood sister of Thrse, asked her to write the memories of
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html
[Amber demo]
CHRISTIAN
SPIRITUALITY
IN THE
CATHOLIC
TRADITION
Jordan Aumann, O. P.
CONTENTS
Trial version of ABC Amber CHM Converter
http://www.processtext.com/abcchm.html