Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract
Introduction
Page 1 of 9
Mark of Schlumberger
Page 2 of 9
Impact on logs
Poor contact by pad tools
on the wellbore wall.
Calipers & bow springs
unable to push pads against
borehole wall.
Excessive borehole signals
Excessive mud cake signal on
pad tools, especially density.
Deep invasion by mud filtrate
reducing quality of resistivity
Page 3 of 9
The well-known high thermal neutron capture crosssection of chlorine necessitates an accurate
assessment of the mud filtrate salinity. For oilbase
muds porosity corrections are strongly dependent on
pressure and can be as high as 5 porosity units. Gas
filled holes cannot be logged with thermal neutron
tools, but epithermal tools usually give good results
after borehole fluidcompensation. The epithermal
capture cross-section measured with the APS tool is
relatively insensitive for salinity and can be used to
estimate the residual gas-saturation in the invaded
zone (Scott et al, 1994), when oil base mud prohibits
the use of micro-resistivity logs.
Pulsed neutron tools require large corrections for low
salinity muds, but can give reliable results in gas filled
holes up to capture cross sections of 40 c.u. Carbon
oxygen (C/O) tools do not suffer from these salinity
restrictions, but are sensitive to the carbon and
oxygen content of the borehole fluid. The standard
C/O ration vs. porosity plots give the impression that
the dynamic range is larger for holes filled with oil
instead of water. This is caused by the lack of oxygen
rather than a higher sensitivity to formation oil
(Jacobson et al, 1993). One of the few disadvantages
of silicate muds is that corrections for the Ca/Si ratio
can be required.
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR)
Unless the hole is severely washed out NMR tools are
virtually insensitive to most borehole fluids. However
when the mud is very conductive the depth of
investigation of mandrel style NMR tools is reduced, in
some cases dropping below the borehole diameter. In
addition under these circumstances long polarization
times may be required, and logs can underestimate
porosities if logging speeds are too high. Oil base mud
can change wettability of the formation, which reduces
the "irreducible" water saturation, and thus invalidates
the relation between the relaxation time spectrum and
permeability. It also can affect the remaining oil
saturation evaluation (Flaum et al, 1998). NMRs like all
tools based on induction principles work well in gas
filled holes. It is noteworthy that even traces of
magnetic materials in the mud filtrate will produce much
shorter relaxation times and lead to an underestimation
of porosity, and erroneous permeability predictions.
Acoustic tools
The path of the acoustic wave from source to
receiver depends strongly on the mechanical
properties of the first few inches around the
borehole. The drilling and invasion process might
have weakened this zone which leads to the familiar
increase in travel time. When long spaced sonic tools
or the modern multi-spacing tools are used these
effects can usually be recognized and compensated
for. High density muds can decrease the dynamic
range due to the reduction of the compressional
velocity.
Oil base muds sometimes dehydrate shale layers,
which can increase the velocity and give erroneous
velocities and impedances (Boonen, et al, 1998). This
hampers comparisons with seismic velocities.
Acoustic measurements are as a rule not possible in
gas filled holes. Acoustic borehole imaging tools are
less reliable in heavy muds (>14 lb/gl), and lower
operating frequencies and focussing techniques
have not fully resolved this problem.
Gamma-Ray tools
Correction algorithms for high mud densities and the
presence of potassium are available. The K40
radiation of KCl muds can drown the radiation from
the formation and limit mineral identification by
means of the potassium over thorium ratio.
Field examples
Norway
In figure 4 the original and a repeat run of a MWD
resistivity log are depicted for a well drilled with oil
base mud. The runs were taken several days apart.
The deep resistivity measurements (heavy) overlay
and seem to be hardly affected by invasion. However
the shallow resistivity measurements (dashed) are
affected, and the comparison clearly shows that oil
based mud invasion in the water zone increased the
shallow resistivity curves in time.
In the hydrocarbon bearing zone the lack of
resistivity contrast between the filtrate and the
indigenous oil masks this invasion. This example
warns us that calibrating wireline resistivity logs in
Page 4 of 9
Discussion
Conclusions
In the section on borehole and mud-filtrate effects the
conditions were identified under which tool readings
are less reliable. If these conditions are recognized it
is often possible to compensate the readings using
existing environmental correction algorithms.
However there are important exceptions. Combining
the density and neutron tool readings can usually
compensate for the invasion effect in a gas zone, but
in shaly gas bearing zones the situation is more
complicated due to the opposite directions of shale
and gas effects. Freedman (1998) introduced an
evaluation method that uses the nuclear magnetic
resonance porosity and the density porosity to
eliminate the masking of the gas by bound water.
1.
2.
3.
4.
For oil base muds it is difficult to determine the
resistivity of the first few inches even when the most
advanced induction logs (HDIL*), AIT#) with a
minimum coil spacing of 10 are available (La Vigne,
1997). It is recommended to run a dielectric tool
[D200*), or EPT#)], because their very shallow depth
of investigation (2-4) ensures that they can measure
the water saturation Sxo of the flushed zone. Sxo can be
important for the correction of the induction log
readings if deep oil base mud invasion occurs. This is
fortunately not often the case. Sxo can however be
vital for porosity log corrections e.g. to unmask false
gas indications (Chardac 1985, Peeters 1986, Solomon
5.
6.
7.
8.
Page 5 of 9
Chardac, J.M.L.
EPT applications in the Middle East
Society of Petroleum engineers, Middle East Oil
Technical Conference. Bahrain, March 1985.
Chemali, R., Su, S.M., Goetz, J.F.
Measuring Rxo and dip in oil based mud with the six
arm dipmeter. SPWLA 30th Annual logging
symposium. June 1989.
Classification of fluid systems (no author)
World Oil, June 1997
Flaum, C., Kleinberg, R.L.
Bound water volume, permeability, and residual oil
saturation from incomplete magnetic resonance logs.
SPWLA 39th logging symposium. May 1998.
References
Allen, D. et al
Invasion revisited.
Oilfield Review July 1991
Allen, D., Anderson, B., Barber, T., Liu, Q.,
Luling. M., Supporting Interpretation of Complex,
Axisymetric Invasion by Modeling Wireline
Induction and 2 MHz LWD Resistivity Tools
SPWLA 34th logging symposium. June 1993.
Freedman, R. et al
Combining NMR and density logs for petrophysical
analysis in gas-bearing formations
SPWLA 39th logging symposium. May 1998
Baker Hughes
Fluid Facts
Engineering Handbook, March 1998
Fordham, EJ et al.
Dynamic Filtration of Bentonite Muds Under Different
Flow Conditions
SPE 18038 Society of Petroleum Engineers 63rd Annual
Tech. Conference, Houston, October 1988
Gomes, R. M. R.
Time-lapse resistivity log responses in horizontal wells,
Namorado reservoir, Albacora field, Brazil. AAPG
bulletin, v. 82, 11, November 1998
Page 6 of 9
Page 7 of 9
Figure 1
CNL departure curves
Page 8 of 9
Figure 3
Two front model of fluid displacement
during invasion after Allen et al. 1991
OIL ZONE
0.2--------------Ohmm-------------20
x
XX50
WATER
ZONE
X120
x
0.2----------CDR shallow (Ohmm)--------20
0.2
CDR deep(Ohmm)
20
x
Figure 4
Page 9 of 9
Figure 5 a, b, c, d
Page 10 of 9