Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
org
Published in IET Electric Power Applications
Received on 21st September 2010
Revised on 15th August 2011
doi: 10.1049/iet-epa.2010.0226
ISSN 1751-8660
LUT-Energy, Lappeenranta University of Technology, P.O. Box 20, Lappeenranta 53851, Finland
Department of Electrical Machines, Saint-Petersburg State Polytechnic University, St. Petersburg, Russia
3
Department of Power Electrical Systems, University of Zilina, Zilina, Slovakia
E-mail: janne.nerg@lut.fi
2
Abstract: Hybrid excitation synchronous machines (HESMs), which combine the best features of traditional electrically excited
synchronous machines (SMs) and permanent magnet synchronous machines (PMSMs), are investigated. Such machines provide
energy efciency benets over traditional eld-winding-excited machines, especially in the lower power region upto a few
megawatts. This paper studies the applicability of a hybrid excitation synchronous generator (HESG) to a marine diesel
genset. Three HESG structures are proposed, and their performance in island operation are studied by the two-dimensional
(2D) nite-element analysis. Comparison of the proposed constructions is performed.
Introduction
www.ietdl.org
frequency as the stator reacts only to the correct rotorcaused harmonic. The excitation sources are connected in
parallel. The PM has two different ux paths so that one
passes the adjacent PM and the other passes through the
other adjacent, electrically excited pole. The ux of the
electrical excitation is circulated between two eld windings
in the case where the pole pair number p is odd. The uxes
produced by PMs and DC eld windings are radial uxes.
Another possible construction termed a consequent pole
PM hybrid excitation machine is studied in [8]. The
machine consists of a rotor divided into two sections. One
section has rotor surface PMs that are radially excited, and
the other has a laminated iron pole. The stator is composed
of a laminated core, solid iron yoke and a conventional AC
three-phase winding located in the slots. A circumferential
eld winding is placed in the middle of the stator that is
excited by a DC current. The magnetic paths of the two
excitation sources are relatively independent. The two
excitation sources are in parallel.
Because of their special conguration and operation
principle, HESMs have potential to be used in such
applications where conventional SMs or PMSMs do not
satisfy all the desired requirements (efciency, machine size
limitations, etc.). In this paper, a hybrid excitation
synchronous generator (HESG) is studied with respect to its
applicability to a marine diesel genset. The contribution of
this paper is to propose a solution where an HESM replaces
an SM in ship electrical power generation and meets all the
requirements set by the classication societies, particularly
in island operation. Three different 8-pole HESG topologies
that full all the requirements in island operation are
IET Electr. Power Appl., 2012, Vol. 6, Iss. 1, pp. 1 11
doi: 10.1049/iet-epa.2010.0226
www.ietdl.org
introduced and their performances are compared applying 2D
nite-element analysis (FEA).
The paper is organised as follows: The problems faced by
traditional solutions (PMSGs and conventional SGs) in island
operation are discussed in Section 2. The structures and
operation principle of the proposed generators are presented
in Section 3. The performance of the proposed generators in
island operation is studied by the 2D-FEA, see Section 4
and their comparison is performed in Section 5.
This paper is an extension of [9]. Two more HESM
topologies meeting the boundary conditions set by marine
classication societies are proposed, and their performance
is studied in detail. The paper does not present detailed
experimental results as we have not yet had an opportunity
to build a 500 kW machine prototype. The authors,
however, have a lot of experience in the design and testing
of machines of different sizes upto several MW in power
[10 17]. In these designs, the calculation methods used
have proven to demonstrate satisfactory conformity with
practical results.
(p.u.)
(1)
Lm = m0
m 2 tp
l (kw1 Ns )2
p2 p deff
(2)
Em = vkw1 Ns F
h
2
(3)
tp l
0
(B d ) dx dy
(4)
Isc =
Em 2
Em 2
=
Ns =
vkw1 ai B d tp l
vkw F
h
(5)
2
m2 1
Em 2
k
w1
p2 p deff tp l
vkw1 ai B d
(6)
tp =
pD
2p
(7)
(8)
www.ietdl.org
Fig. 3 Phasor diagrams of two PMSGs meeting the boundary conditions at the rated operating point
a Non-salient pole PMSG
b Salient pole PMSG
The non-salient pole PMSG is larger than normal ones. The generator no-load voltage is EPM 1.1 p.u., the power factor is cos w 0.8ind and the generator rated
voltage Us and the current Is are equal to 1 p.u. According to the phasor diagram, the synchronous inductance Ls is equal to 0.15 p.u. and the load angle is d 6.68.
This machine meets the requirements given above but the machine is large and expensive. The parameters for the salient pole PMSG are: the power factor
cos w 0.8ind , the generator rated voltage Us and the current Is are equal to 1 p.u, the d-axis magnetising inductance is 0.27 p.u, the q-axis magnetising
inductance equals 0.51 p.u., and the stator leakage inductance is equal to 0.1 p.u. According to the phasor diagram, the generator no-load voltage should be
EPM 1.26 p.u. and the load angle is d 208. This generator does not meet the voltage range condition as the no-load voltage is higher than 1.1 p.u
www.ietdl.org
Next, three different structures of the HESG are proposed
and their performances are studied by a 2D FEA.
Parameter
phase number, m
nominal power, Pn
nominal voltage, Un
nominal current, In
power factor, cos w
rotation speed, n
frequency, f
number of pole pairs, p
Value
Unit
3
520 000
450/260
833
0.8ind
900
60
4
W
V
A
rpm
Hz
6 2 HESG
4 4 HESG
8 8 HESG
Magnetic paths of the uxes produced by PMs (solid lines) and excitation coils (dotted lines) for the 4 4 HESG
www.ietdl.org
Table 2
Parameter
6 2
4 4
88
760
370
5
48
2
16
2
500
760
385
5
48
2
16
2
500
760
422
5
48
2
16
1
280
(9)
Synchronous inductances
Cd,q
is
(10)
No-load test
Finite-element analysis
www.ietdl.org
6 2 HESG
PM poles
electrically excited pole
4 4 HESG
PM pole
electrically excited pole
B1d , T at
Qf 40 kA
B1d , T at
Qf 0 A
B1d , T at
Qf 25 kA
1.25/1.19
1.14
1.16/1.24
0.6
1.11/1.26
0.33
1.24
1.03
1.16
0.81
1.13
0.73
www.ietdl.org
are close to the common values compared with the 6 2
HESG and 4 4 HESG. Table 3 and Fig. 7 demonstrate the
operation principle of the proposed HESGs: the PM source
provides the air gap with a constant ux, and the excitation
winding acts as the ux regulator to adjust the air gap ux
distribution and the total amount of ux.
Fig. 8 presents a no-load generator voltage as a function of
electrical excitation. When there is a positive DC current in
the excitation winding, it increases the rotor excitation, and
the RMS value of the induced phase voltage increases
compared with the induced phase voltage corresponding to
a zero excitation current. According to Fig. 8, the variation
ranges (with respect to the rated 260 V or 1 p.u.) of the
induced phase voltages at the total current linkage of 40 kA
reach +28, +26 and +24.5% for the 6 2, 4 4 and 8 8
HESGs, respectively. When the DC excitation current is
negative, it weakens the excitation and the RMS value of
the induced phase voltage decreases with respect to the case
of no electric excitation current. Effective variation in the
magnitude of the induced EMF results in effective control
of the output voltage. As it can be seen in Fig. 8, at the
zero excitation current linkage, the induced voltages of the
Fig. 9 Results of the rated operation test; the HESGs supply inductive loads with a load power factor cos w 0.8ind producing rated
operation at U 1 p.u
a Generator voltage as a function of electrical excitation
b Power as a function of electrical excitation
8
www.ietdl.org
operating point, the 6 2 and 8 8 HESGs need almost an
equal total current linkage (SQf 40 kA) and the 4 4
HESG needs 30 kA.
The efciencies and loss divisions as well as the power
density of different machine types at the rated operation are
given in Table 4.
The 6 2 HESG suffers from the limited wound space in
the rotor, and therefore the excitation losses are higher than
in the 4 4 and 8 8 HESGs. However, the machine has the
highest power density.
4.4
Table 5
Parameter
6 2
44
8 8
E0 , V
Isc , A
Qf , A/pole
xd , V
334
2873
21000
0.12
329
2551
10625
0.13
296.7
2692
1400
0.11
Short-circuit test
The short-circuit test is carried out to check whether the shortcircuit requirement mentioned in the boundary conditions is
met: the sustained short-circuit current must be 300% of the
rated current for at least 2 s. This condition is one of
the most challenging requirements for pure PMSGs. During
the test, the generator is rotated at the nominal speed, and
all three output phases are short-circuited through switches.
At the beginning, the switches are turned off and the
generator is running at no load. After 0.0333 s (two
periods), the switches are turned on. The objective of the
test is to observe the sustained short-circuit current.
As an example of the short-circuit test results, Fig. 10
presents the short-circuit current of the 6 2 HESG as a
function of time. With 6 2 and 4 4 HESGs, the shortcircuit requirement is met when the excitation current
linkages are equal to 21 000 A/pole and 10 625 A/pole,
which corresponds to 42 and 21.25 A eld winding
currents, respectively. The corresponding current densities
in the excitation windings are 5.6 and 2.83 A/mm2. The
Table 4
6 2 HESG
4 4 HESG
8 8 HESG
5144
2500
3496
7000
2600
20 740
96.16
1995
5284
2360
3568
2014
2600
15 827
97.05
1904
5631
2532
3749
3197
2600
17 709
96.71
1802
Masses, kg
62
44
8 8
PM
rotor iron
stator iron
rotor copper
stator copper
total
108
734
976
84
283
2185
87
748
1021
172
287
2314
128
681
1101
204
297
2411
www.ietdl.org
excited poles. After 550 kW the 4 4 HESG has the highest
power density.
Considering manufacturing of the proposed constructions,
the stators of the proposed machines are the same except
the length of the machines, the only difference lying in the
rotor fabrication, in particular in the installation of poles. In
the case of the 6 2 HESG and 4 4 HESG, the installation
of poles should not pose any major problems; the poles can
be mounted on the rotor yoke with bolts going through the
holes between two adjacent PMs.
Based on the above comparisons, the 4 4 and 8 8 HESGs
look more attractive from the design, manufacturing and
economic points of view. Of course, the 6 2 HESG has
only two wound poles, which is also a favourable factor.
6
Fig. 11 Comparison of efciencies of the proposed HESGs
Conclusions
Acknowledgment
References
1 Shushu, Z., Chuang, L., Yihao, X., Xiang, Z.: Characteristics and
experimental study on a novel tangential/radial hybrid excitation
synchronous machine. IEEE Int. Symp. Power Electronics for
Distributed Generation Systems (PEDG), 2010, pp. 883 886
2 Amara, Y., Vido, L., Gabsi, M., Hoang, E., Hamid Ben Ahmed, A.,
Lecrivain, M.: Hybrid excitation synchronous machines: energyefcient solution for vehicles propulsion, IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol.,
2009, 58, (5), pp. 2137 2149
3 Zhao, C.: The research of radial structure HESM of magnetic shunting
type. IEEE Int. Symp. Industrial Electronics (ISIE), 2009,
pp. 2103 2108
4 Bali, H., Amara, Y., Barakat, G., Ibtiouen, R., Gabsi, M.: Analytical
modeling of open circuit magnetic eld in wound eld and series
double excitation synchronous machines, IEEE Trans. Magn., 2010,
PP, (99), pp. 1 14
5 Fodorean, D., Djerdir, A., Viorel, I.-A., Miraoui, A.: A double excited
synchronous machine for direct drive application-design and prototype
tests, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., 2007, 22, (3), pp. 656 665
6 But, D.A.: Brushless electrical machines (Vysshaya shkola, 1990),
pp. 166181 (in Russian)
7 Luo, X., Lipo, T.A.: A synchronous/permanent magnet hybrid AC
machine, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., 2000, 15, (2), pp. 203 210
IET Electr. Power Appl., 2012, Vol. 6, Iss. 1, pp. 1 11
doi: 10.1049/iet-epa.2010.0226
www.ietdl.org
8 Naoe, N., Fukami, T.: Trial production of a hybrid excitation type
synchronous machine. IEEE Int. Electric Machines and Drives Conf.
(IEMDC), 1720 June 2001, pp. 545547
9 Tapia, J.A., Leonardi, F., Lipo, T.A.: Consequent pole
permanent magnet machine with eld weakening capability.
IEEE Int. Electric Machines and Drives Conf. (IEMDC), 2001,
pp. 126131
10 Kosaka, T., Matsui, N.: Hybrid excitation machines with powdered iron
core for electrical traction drive applications. IEEE Int. Conf.
Electrical Machines and Systems (ICEMS), 1720 October 2008,
pp. 2974 2979
11 Wei Hua, M.C., Zhang, G.: A novel hybrid excitation ux-switching
motor for hybrid vehicles, IEEE Trans. Magn., 2009, 45, (10),
pp. 4728 4731
12 Kamiev, K., Nerg, J., Pyrhonen, J., Zaboin, V.: Hybrid excitation
synchronous generator for island operation. IEEE Int. Conf. Electrical
Machines (ICEM), Italy, 2010, CD
13 Pyrhonen, J., Kurronen, P., Parviainen, A.: Permanent magnet 3 MW
low-speed generator development. IEEE Int. Conf. Electrical
Machines (ICEM), Greece, 2006, CD
14 Pyrhonen, J., Ruuskanen, V., Nerg, J., Puranen, J., Jussila, H.:
Permanent magnet length effects in AC-machines, IEEE Trans.
Magn., 2010, 46, (10), pp. 3783 3789
11