Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
v
i
t
a
r
Nar
A compilation of Sustainability stories
This past Monday, I presented my Master of Sustainable Solutions applied project to policymakers, planners,
business leaders, and environmental activists in Indianapolis. I took my audience on a rapid journey through
the images and visualizations of the citys energy and transportation system, stopping periodically to recap
how the information connected with the values and goals of Indianapolis stakeholders.
After the presentation, I opened the floor to questions and called on a hand raised to my right. The
owner of the hand talked briskly, keeping his eyes peeled to the 20-page report that summarized my research,
while slowly turning each page to ensure he did not miss a detail.
While you provide a lot of good information, I think this report misses the opportunity to frame how
your research fits in the larger picture of the city-wide carbon reductions and community benefits that will result from implementing your policy solutions.
For me, capturing the larger picture of my research is a major challenge. As sustainability scientists,
we seek to achieve solutions based in academic rigor. All the time, we discuss studies that use faulty methodologies or insufficient amount of data to make illegitimate claims. But, rarely do we debate articles that
overload the content with methods, data, and jargon to the point that the larger picture or the so what moment is lost.
At the Sustainability Review (tSR), we believe that academic articles need to strike an appropriate balance between applying academic rigor and identifying the larger picture. While the public, decision-makers
and leaders want to gather information from credible sources, at the end of the day they want to use that information to better their communities. They cannot use the information if they do not understand it or cannot relate its findings to their work.
With our first annual Narrative, the tSR editorial staff challenged five sustainability scientists and
scholars to capture the larger picture of their research. After reading this publication, we hope you understand
the important role fossil fuel divestment plays in the fight against climate change through a personal investigation into the expenditures of the Arizona State University Foundation. We explore the tireless work required
to protect the endangered loggerhead sea turtles by following a day-in-the-life of a turtle girl. We expose
you to a first-hand account of the different cultural perceptions that nuclear weapons elicit across the globe and
explain the need for nuclear disarmament. We describe the complexities faced by Arizona farmers and the innovations they employ to overcome them to deliver food to your table. Finally, we introduce you to the deeprooted planting method that could potentially reduce erosion and bring life back to the desolate urban desert
landscape in Central Arizona, if it was only given it a chance.
We want to hear your reactions and thoughts after reading this Narrative, as sustainability science and
research can only progress with an open conversation. Please share with us through social media, in face-toface conversations, and, maybe, even add your voice in next years Narrative. At tSR, we are all ears.
Sincerely,
Ryan Anderson
tSR editor-in-chief
gime.
climate change.
While this campaign did not single handedly end Apartheid, South African Archbishop
fossil fuels.
climate crisis
The first number comes from the 2009 CopenOne would expect that a leader in sustainability hagen Conference, where 167 countries recognized
and multiple conversations with the ASU Foundation perature should be below two degrees Celsius. To
the organization that handles ASUs endowmentI
found that to not be the case and took it upon myself to bon emissions cannot exceed the second number, 565
understand and unwind the complexities that prevent
companies.
extraction or use.
University to pursue.
for donors. Ginny noted that large oil and gas com-
investment projects.
investment strategies.
U.S.
meeting.
ment. In Shangraws opinion, the endowment represented only one of the Universitys and the Founda-
gies.
Conclusion
stitutions have already divested or partially divested from fossil fuels. Last, ASU and the Foundation can work
together with their current investment managers, or seek out new ones, to develop a low carbon investing strategy that does not jeopardize the Universitys fiduciary obligations. For instance, Morgan Stanley Capital and
other investment firms offer sustainable or low carbon investment strategies. Fossil fuel companies comprise
only 11 percent of the S&P 500 so divestment hardly restricts investment strategies.
The Universitys endowment is one quiver in the arrow, but when our society is dealing with a challenge as pervasive as climate change, it needs all the arrows available. When considering divestment, University and Foundation officials should reflect not on my words, but ASU President and Foundation board member Michael Crows: Do you replicate what exists, or do you design what you really need? ASU has already
changed the university model through its interdisciplinary approach and it is time that kind of reevaluation take
place concerning the Universitys endowment, to create what Mr. Crow calls the maximum societal impact.
End Notes
What is Fossil Fuel Divestment, Fossil Free, http://
gofossilfree.org/what-is-fossil-fuel-divestment/
(accessed February 1 2015). For a full list of commitments, see ibid, Divestment Commitments. For Tutu
quote, see Divesting From Injustice, Guardian 13
June 2010. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/desmondtutu/divesting-from-injustice_b_534994.html
(accessed April 1 2015).
See the School of Sustainability website at https://
schoolofsustainability.asu.edu/about/school-ofsustainability/
The numbers come from Carbon Tracker Initiative, a
project of the non-profit Investor Watch. Its report
has been utilized by several large investment firms and
banks, including Standard & Poor and HSBC, to calculate risk to carbon exposure. The total reserves do
not include shale gas. See, Bill McKibben, Global
Warmings Terrifying New Math, Rolling Stone August 2 2012. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/
news/global-warmings-terrifying-new-math20120719?page=2 (accessed March 3 2015).
The S & P study was commissioned by the Associated Press. See Tom Zeller Jr., Fossil Fuel Divestment: Smart Bet or Losing Strategy, Forbes
February 10 2015. (accessed March 24, 2015).
Sheila M Olmstead, Applying Market Principles, 220-221 and Henrik Selin and Stacey D.
VanDeveer, Global Climate Change: Beyond
Kyoto, in Kraft and Vig, Environmental Policy,
287-292. As of 2013, there are three regional cap
and trade programs. For example, ten Northeastern
states created the Regional Green House Gas Initiative and in 2009, and California launched a capand-trade program. See, Barry Rabe, Racing to
the Top, the Bottom, or the Middle of the Pack?
The Evolving State Government Role in Environmental Protection, in Kraft and Vig, 32-49 and
Ken Portney, Sustainability in American Cities:
A comprehensive look at what cities are doing and
why, in Daniel Mazmanian and Michael Kraft,
Toward Sustainable Communities, 232-236. For
carbon pricing scheme statistic, see Fabian,
Support low-carbon investment, 28.
For other examples, see MSCI ESG Research
Team, Responding to the Call for Fossil-fuel Free
Portfolios, December 2013 and IMPAX Asset
Management, Beyond Fossil Fuels: The Investment Case for Fossil Fuel Divestment, 2013. See
Carbon Trackers website for a multitude of reports on the matter of unburnable carbon.
T U R T L E TA L E S !
H O W S U S TA I N A B I L I T Y P R I N C I P L E S C A N T R A N S L AT E T O
B I O D I V E R S I T Y C O N S E R VAT I O N
HALEY RANDELL
Stressed and devastated, we sprinted through shallow cold
waves that soaked our pants. Seagulls picked off silver-dollar
sized sea turtles for morning snacks. A late-hatch led these
little ones to face their attackers in the
daylight.
We sprang into action, divvying up the
rescue efforts for the turtles by
screaming and yelling to each other
and at the murderous birds. Frantically, we ran around collecting turtles
and swatting gulls, Ill go after the
birds, you get the turtles!! Those vulture-esque seagulls always seemed to
emerge out of the sand scavenging for
easy pickings, especially unattended
turtles and Sun chips. Ash! Can you
tell how many have been taken?? Not
the best day of turtling on Cumberland Island.
Cumberland Island hides off the southern coast of Georgia,
only accessible to man by boat and intends to stay that way.
madness.
island would sniff out the nest and dig up the eggs
..we found
indications of a
new nest upon
arrival a good
sign for the turtles!
ocean.
nests?
species.
nest and with the help of the team dug all the eggs
genes than
mom in-
tended? The
priority on
Cumberland
is hatchling
success and
relocation is
an impor-
tant aspect.
but dont tell the bossman about it. Its even more
paid off!
government.
Nuclear Options
Do nuclear weapons threaten the human species?
Does anyone at ASU care?
Siddhanth Paralkar
As a child, I was in awe of nuclear weapons.
spite the cold wind, saluting the flag and singing the
jpayee, gave the nation hope for the future of the coun- The society taught me about the agony of nuclear war
try.
home in Mumbai.
After the speech, the televised parade began. The mili- ers who survived the Japan bombings gave birth to
tary marched to a brass band. Then the crowd ap-
plauded with great pride as the Indian army began pa- vors still suffer from radiation sickness.
rading the nuclear Agni missiles past them.
Although I had no clue what those long colossal cylin- A nuclear war would prevent a sustainable future,
who are not yet here to speak and act for them-
ies.
told me.
Uncertain outcomes
devices in 1998.
of nuclear weapons.
weapons is possible.
Unending tensions
term drought.
Tollefsons family hails from the Midwest,
thorny vegetation.
He eventually
Years of farming
have left a
permanent mark on
Tollefson
to water crops.
in Coolidge, Arizona.
valve and let the water out. The pipes were laid
zona.
disappeared, their
canals remained as
reminders of their
presence.
conflicts.
The first half of the century saw explosive
water savings.
climate.
Before Tollefson came to the Harquahala Valley, the regions aquifer was nearly depleted from
plants.
The desert farmer smiled and said, With the drip, its
coming back.
depleted.
Wayne Warrington
Im drawn to the call of frogs congregating on a
root structures.
role
one.
https://twitter.com/TSRJournal
https://www.youtube.com/channel
/Ci7sr8jkygvOme_W4NpNK8Q
thesustainabilityreview.org