Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
b.
2.
3.
3.
Article 196.
Importation, sale
possession
of
lottery
tickets
advertisements
Acts punishable:
1.
2.
3.
Elements:
4.
1.
2.
and
or
b.
c.
2.
knowledge or view.
When the acts were performed
in a private house and seen by one person,
the crime was not committed.
Bar Questions
Grave Scandal (1996)
Pia, a bold actress living on top floor of a plush
condominium in Makati City sunbathed naked at its
penthouse every Sunday morning. She was unaware
that the business executives holding office at the
adjoining tall buildings reported to office every
Sunday morning and, with the use of powerful
binoculars, kept on gazing at her while she
sunbathed. Eventually, her sunbathing became the
talk of the town. 1) What crime, if any, did Pia
commit? Explain, 2) What crime, if any, did the
business executives commit? Explain.
SUGGESTED ANSWER:
1) Pia did not commit a crime, the felony closest to
making Pia criminally liable is Grave Scandal, but
then such act is not to be considered as highly
scandalous and offensive against decency and good
customs. In the first place, it was not done in a public
place and within public knowledge or view. As a
matter of fact it was discovered by the executives
accidentally and they have to use binoculars to have
public and full view of Pia sunbathing in the nude.
2) The business executives did not commit any
crime. Their acts could not be acts of lasciviousness
[as there was no overt lustful act), or slander, as the
eventual talk of the town, resulting from her
sunbathing, is not directly imputed to the business
executives, and besides such topic is not intended to
defame or put Pia to ridicule.
2.
Person
aggrieved
may appeal the forfeiture action to the
Secretary of National Defense for
review.
In case the offender is a
government official or employee who
allows the violations, the penalty is
imposed in the maximum period and the
accessory penalties shall likewise be
imposed.
Obscene
publications
and
indecent shows under RA 7610 (please
refer to exploitation of minors, Title Nine)
o
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1.
2.
3.
4.
P.D. 1563
Mendicancy Law of 1978
What is a mendicant?
A mendicant refers to any person (except
those enumerated in section 4 of the law) who has
no visible and legal means of support, or lawful
employment and who is physically able to work but
neglects to apply himself to some lawful calling and
instead uses begging as a means of living.
Those enumerated in section 4, who
considered mendicants, are the following:
1.
2.
3.
are
not