Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The fourth part, the results, provides the findings which is the product of manipulation of
data collected suitable for this research. The dissemination of the results have been used in
determining various relationships. The relationship between different variables has been
determined in the study. The testing of the hypotheses form the basis of discussion in the
fifth section. The fifth part is the discussion which provides an analysis of the results
depicted in section four. The discussion renders the efforts in the interpretation of the
results. The last part is the conclusion and recommendations which sum up the details of the
findings and the study.
Research (Study) Objectives
This study has the following objectives:- First, the study aims at determining the extent of
security improvement at IDM and finding out the causes of poor security practices as
revealed by the security guards working at the institute. Secondly, the study focuses on the
analysis of the effects of laxity on the side of the administration of the security authority at
IDM in respect of the security improvement efforts in the IDM community. Thirdly, the
study aims at finding out the reasons and causes of theft (at least the reported incidents)
which takes place despite the fact that there are security guards at IDM. In other words, the
author wishes to prove whether the IDM's security guards contribute to the theft events
taking place now and then at the institute.
The fourth objective centres on the finding out why some IDM residents fail to be positively
security conscious in security affairs of the institute; and fifthly, to see and evaluate the steps
and measures being taken by IDM's management in combating the problems mentioned
above. After the investigations, to recommend on the measures to be taken by different
parties involved in the improvement of IDM's security thus enabling the residents in the
community enjoy the operations of the IDM's security guard system. Above all, the study
would benefit other institutions for the findings are going to be disseminated in diverse ways
and techniques. The `bandwagon effect' is assumed to take place after the output of this
research has been disseminated.
Research Hypotheses
The researcher has attempted to use inferential statistics to make decisions about the value
of each parameter. One of the most commonly used procedures for making such decisions
is to perform an hypothesis testing. Hypothesis testing is the procedure whereby theory and
reality are brought face to face with each other. A hypothesis in this study is simply refers to
a statement that something is true. In this study the two types of hypotheses will be
examined in detail. One type of hypothesis is called a null hypothesis [H O] and the other is
called the alternative hypothesis [HA].
The researcher had conceived the four sets of hypotheses for an effective decision making
rule in the variables selected. A test of hypothesis H is a rule that specifies for each possible
set of values of the observations whether to accept or reject the hypothesis, should these
particular values be observed. The major aims of hypothesis are: to test theories, to suggest
theories and to describe social phenomena. Above all hypotheses try to promote change.
The researcher tested the following hypotheses in the study for that sake:
SET I:
H1O = IDM's Security Guards Contribute to the Security Problems at the Institute.
H1A = IDM's Security Guards do not Contribute to the Security Problems at the
Institute
SET II:
H2O = Provision of Security Gears Influences the Effectiveness of the Security
system at the Institute.
H2A = Provision of Security Gears does not Influence the Effectiveness of the
Security system at the Institute.
SET III:
H3O = Senior Security Guards are more keen to their jobs.
H3A = Senior security Guards are not more keen to their jobs.
SET IV:
H4O = IDM's Management is involved in Security issues in keeping the community
security conscious.
H4A = IDM's Management is not involved in Security issues in keeping the
community security conscious.
Data was collected from interviews, observation, self administered questionnaires and the
utilization of the secondary data sources available at the Institute of Development
Management (IDM)'s libraries and offices. The sampling frame constitutes the population
of security guards employed at the Institute of Development Management, Mzumbe from
July 1971 to December 1993. Nineteen questionnaires (19) were prepared and distributed to
two pairs of sample [Sample A and sample B]. Thirty eight point seven eight percent of the
population were included in the sample by being given a self administered questionnaire
(Table I).
Table I Percentage of the Sample from the Population
S/No
Method
Sampling
Frame
Selected Sample
Percentage of the
sample from the total
Population
Questionnaire
49
10
38.78
Interviews
49
12.24
Observation
49
11
19
61.22
Secondary Data
Reasonable
Used
The sample selected was a non-probability sample from the sampling frame of the IDM's
security guards. The chance of each respondent to fall in the sample carries a characteristic
of being accidental; hence a non-probability sample. The interviews both structured and
unstructured ones have also been conducted to collect additional information in the topic
under discussion. Two major interviews were conducted with three respondents in each
sample who were conversant with the security system at the institute. The interviewees
represented 12.24 percent of the sampling frame of 49 security guards.
Thirty respondents were observed by the researcher in the course of their work. They
represented 61.22 percent of the target population. The researcher observed the selected
security guards in order to measure attitudes of the respondents in respect of the theft at the
institute. The knowledge, feeling and action components of the respondents were observed
by the researcher at different time intervals.
Techniques Employed
The following methods were employed in this study: The goodness-of-fit-test or Chi-square,
the hypotheses testing, the sign-test, Wilcoxon-Signed rank test, Mann-Whitney test and the
rank correlation. None of the efforts were made to incorporate any test which needed some
obvious parameters.
Data Analysis and Interpretation
The data analysis and interpretation employed in the study took the advantage of the
statistical packages at the IDM's computer centre. The Minitab application programme,
Wordperfect and Lotus 1-2-3 were used to process, analyze, interpret data and finally
preparation of this report ready for dissemination.
There were twenty two variables in total which were then developed into six sets of code
categories. The code categories were designed in such a way that they match with the
research objectives. The coding scheme outlines twenty nine coding parts or responses.
Table II illustrates the choice of the coding categories based on the questionnaire designed
by the researcher.
Code Categories
POSITION
EMPLOYMENT
Coding Scheme
Number of Variables
II
THEFT
III
GEARS
IV
11
11
ASSISTANCE
CAUSE
VI
Results
This study in the first set of hypotheses asserts that: The respondents wondered to hear from
members of the community that they have made an insignificant contribution to the security
problems at the institute. Seventy five percent of the interviewed respondents believed that
they are not the contributory agents to the theft and other related problems at the campus.
SET I:
H1O = IDM's Security Guards Contribute to the Security Problems at the Institute.
H1A = IDM's Security Guards do not Contribute to the Security Problems at the
Institute
The researcher considered at the H1O and H1A in terms of the extent or the degree to which
the institute's security guards assist or not assist in maintaining the security system in the
campus.
involvement, non-involvement, and neutral (Table III). Thus the null hypothesis in this set
is rejected.
Year
Rank
Year
Rank
D2
d=u-v
1989
1993
10
-6
36
1975
1990
-5
25
1978
1990
-5
25
1992
1986
1993
1982
36
1982
1991
-5
25
1988
1975
25
1983
1989
1993
1991
1986
-3
10
Total 190
Source: Milanzi, M.C. (1994) Questionnaire: Utafiti Juu ya Hali ya Ulinzi Hapa Chuoni,
March.
The Rank Correlation: rs = 1 - [6Sd2]/[n(n2-1)]
where,
n = the sample (n=19)
rs = rank correlation
d = the difference between ranks of Sample A and Sample B
Computation:
Rank correlation,
rs,0.05 = 1 - [6Sd2]/[n(n2-1)]
= 1 - [1140/6840]
= 1 - [0.166]
rs,0.05 = 0.60 (from the rank correlation table)
rs,0.05 = 0.833 Reject the Null Hypothesis, H1O, because rs,0.05 = 0.833 falls in the rejection
region.
The second set of hypothesis focuses on the provision of work gears for security guards
working at the institute. The questionnaire and the interviews conducted revealed that the
provision of security gears needs a lot to be desired. The security guards fall short of the
necessary working tools and implements. The interviews conducted show that over 60
percent of the respondents complained over the inadequacy of the gears. The questionnaire
results reveal that 74 percent of the respondents had received no gears to enable them work
comfortably in the last six months (the study was conducted in March 1994).
One respondent was reported that "I have decided to buy some boots for self protection.
The Institute has failed to provide us with such good item." Another respondent was heard
saying:
"Kila vazi lina mwendo wake. Mwanamke aliyevaa vizuri huringa. Vile vile
kwa askari anayepata vifaa vyote vya kazi ataipenda kazi yake."
Literary translation: "Every garment put on by someone has its own walking style. A
woman who has put on a nice clothes is proud of herself. Similarly, a security guard who
has all necessary gears will be proud of his/her work."
SET II: Hypotheses
H2O = Provision of Security Gears Influences the Effectiveness of the Security
system at the Institute.
H2A = Provision of Security Gears does not Influence the Effectiveness of the
Security system at the Institute.
Uniform
The multiple regression in the provision of these gears seem to be not possible. It suggests
that management attention is obviously required.
The Chi-Square test (X2) has been attempted to determine the goodness of fit in the 19
respondents administered through the questionnaire.
Table IV Chi Square Test for Security Gears
d2
(O-E)2
d
(O-E)
D2/E
Item/Gear
Observed
Frequency
(O)
Expected
Frequency
(E)
Whistle
-1
0.50
Uniform
-3
2.25
Boots
-4
16
4.00
Pullover
-2
2.00
Rain coat
-2
2.00
Torch
-1
0.50
d2
(O-E)2
d
(O-E)
D2/E
Item/Gear
Observed
Frequency
(O)
Expected
Frequency
(E)
Gun/Other
-1
0.50
Telephone
-1
1.00
Wall clock
-1
1.00
Handcuffs
-2
2.00
T - statistic 15.75
The t-statistic is 15.75; the critical values X2a where the degree of freedom (df) is k - 1;
where k is a number of categories in the sample. The significance level a is 0.05 and the df
= k - 1 = 10 - 1 = 9. The chi-square (X 20.05) = 16.919 (You can get this figure from the
Chi-Square distribution table).
Thus do not reject the null hypothesis because the t-statistic, 15.75, does not lie in the
rejection region. It is clear that the provision of security gears has a direct influence in the
security of the institute.
The distribution of these (gears) work tools and implements to the security guards at the
institute seem to be doubtful. It is shown in figure 3 which the percentage distribution of
eleven security guards gears.
Analysis of hypothesis under set III:
The third set of hypothesis reveals that there are complaints which exist betwixt security
guards working at the institute. There are cultural and symbolic behaviours which appear to
be true amongst the security guards at the institute. It is obviously clear that the seniority list
amongst the security guards at the Institute of Development Management is not followed or
observed at all.
The Mann-Whitney test was applied in order to describe a non-parametric procedure for
comparing two populations. The assumption is that there is a random sample from each
population and the samples were taken independently of each other; and thirdly the
population of 19 has approximately the same shape (Refer to Table I). That is variances
between sample A and sample B are approximately equal. The n1=4.5 represents the median
of the first population and n2=5 is the median of the second population.
SET III:
H3O = Senior Security Guards are more keen to their jobs.
H3A = Senior security Guards are not more keen to their jobs.
Table V Mann-Whitney Test on Attitudes to Security Based on Seniority
S/No
YEAR
RANK A
YEAR
RANK B
D2
D=A - B
1989
10
1993
19
-9
81
1975
1990
13
-12
144
1978
1990
12
-9
81
1992
16
1986
64
1993
17
1982
12
144
1982
1991
14
-10
100
1988
1975
49
1983
1989
11
-5
25
1993
18
1991
15
1986
-7
49
10
Total 746
The sum of the ranks W in the Mann-Whitney test = 3 + 7 + 12 + 8 = 30. Reject the null
hypothesis.
Analysis of Set IV of hypothesis:
SET IV:
H4O = IDM's Management is involved in Security issues in keeping the community
security conscious.
Selected Sample
Sample
AE
BE
10
19
11
11
19
19
30
12
17
22
25
30
4
where,
EXPECTED
FREQUENC
Y [E]
[O - E]2
[O - E]
[O - E]2/E
1.50
??
11
11
0.00
Total 1.50
[O - E]
[O - E]2/E
OBSERVED
FREQUENC
Y
[O]
EXPECTED
FREQUENC
Y [E]
10
16
??
19
19
0.00
2.67
Total 2.67
Thus the Chi-Square for Sample B is (X 2) = S[O - E]2/E, df = (r - 1) (c - 1) = (2.67 - 1)
(32 - 1) = 1.67 x 31 = 5.177
That is X20.95 = 1.145
The null hypothesis in sample B is not rejected.
Discussion
In brief there are different conclusions derived from the testing of the four sets of
hypotheses. It is therefore obvious that the theft and other related incidents at the
institute are not contributed by the security guards alone. This contention proves us that
it is the task of every one of us who are staying at this institute to be security conscious.
The letter written to the Institute's community by Mr Habi in March 1979 highlights the
need to have a security conscious community at the Institute of Development
Management, Mzumbe. Such incidents which took place in December 1987 show that to
become a security guard is not a good job.
It is therefore interpreted here that security guards at the Institute of Development
Management have a partial contribution to the security problems. There was a time
during the interview when one anonymous security guard told the researcher that, "we are
blamed so much as if we are planning together with the thieves to come and steal some
properties." The OCD once was heard saying "Chuo kinashindwa kuwatumia maaskari
wake vizuri."
The test to the second set of hypothesis is quite discouraging. The null hypothesis has
been upheld because it has some kind influence to the performance and motivation of the
security guards. It is sometimes very difficult for someone to distinguish between a
security guards and a common person. They have no uniforms at all and if there are any
the security guards put on them at their own convenience. The security guards at the
Institute of Development Management, Mzumbe may come to work with the clothes
which does not allow him/her to run or chase a thief.
of drills which any military person is required to perform seems to have no roots at the
Institute of Development Management, Mzumbe. The seniority list in the security unit is
not observed to the positive. The seniority culture which is to be followed as in the army
does not exist altogether. It is in this spirit the Mann-Whitney test of the third set of
hypothesis suggests that the null hypothesis be rejected. This set of hypothesis stultifies
the first set of hypothesis in that the burden of most of the incidents taking place at the
institute are to be born by them. In fact the security guards have to be responsible any
way! But such responsibility should be within the limits of the law. The security guards
at the institute have never been given a sufficient responsibility to enable them to perform
the utmost and appreciable work. A reasonable number of the security guards know the
environment of the institute since they are the long timers.
The controversy in the two type sample when testing the fourth set of hypothesis reveal
that there is a piece of truth that IDM's management needs to change her orientation
towards this unit. The scheme of service for security guards is very crude: "Standard VII,
experience or passed in the National Service and willing and to do the security guards
job." Training should be seen as necessary if the prevailing situation is like this.
The organisational structure needs to be revisited because the head of the security section
is answerable to the chief executive of the institute.
overloaded with a lot of strategic issues than security affairs which are mostly
administrative in nature.
Conclusions and Recommendations
The research study unveils that there are a number of inconsistencies within the security
office at the Institute of Development Management, Mzumbe.
structural; while others are administrative; some are strategic while others are
operational. It is in line of this spirit the author calls for the pulling together of our
energies in order to find out the long standing solution to these problems.
The
documentary sources show that the security incidents started to escalate from October
1975 when the watchmen meeting was held (23/10/1975) to discuss about the crucial
issues such as gears, provision of the security office at the institute.
The author recommends the following measures in order to rectify the situation:
1.
Immediate Recommendations
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
2.
Intermediate Recommendations
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
The code of ethic for security guards need to be designed. Smoking and
being drunk during working hours is unethical and it is subject to
summary dismissal and other possible permissible penalties as stipulated
in the Security of Employment Act of 1964.
v)
Only the guard commander should have been given a gun and all others
must have the weapons inferior to the gun. There is a danger of the
security guards shooting to anyone who is seen passing during the small
hours of the nights.
3.
Ultimate Recommendations
i)
ii)
The road and some lights to be constructed along the borders of IDM and
the surrounding area. This road will enable the security guards to patrol.
This idea contradicts with the current exercise that the security guards are
not aware about the area designated as IDM.
iii)
iv)
i) Build the security guard's main office at the main entrance of the institute in order
to be more functional than it is the case now.
ii) Privatise or outsource the security function.
Notes and References
Letter with Ref No MGR/AD.41/93 of 26/11/91: Chijumba's minute to the Director of
Studies. He calls the guns as scarce items simply because they are new to IDM's security
system.
Dr Habi's Letter of 27/03/79 `Matatizo ya Ulinzi Chuoni.'
IDM, (1975) Mkutano wa Maaskari 23/10/1975
Ingram, J.A. and Monks, J.G. (1990) Statistics for Business and Economics, Philadelphia:
The Dryden Press.
Institute of Development Management, Mgambo, IDM.OF/N.2/3
Institute of Development Management, Watchmen, IDM.OF/R.1/9
Institute of Development Management, Walinzi (Security Guards), IDM.OF/S.1/13.
Building and Estates Manager, (1987) Martel Kuletea Vurugu Walinzi Getini 4/12/87 Ref
BEM/PD/192.
Milanzi, M.C. (1994) Interview Notes, Ofisi ya Ulinzi IDM, March, 1994.
Ryan, B.F., Joiner, B.L., and Ryan, T.A.Jr. (1985) Minitab, Boston: Duxbury Press.
Weiss, N.A. and Hassett, M.J. (1987) Introductory Statistics, Reading: Addison-Wesley
Publishing Company.
APPENDIX A (QUESTIONNAIRE)
CHUO CHA UONGOZI WA MAENDELEO
MZUMBE
UTAFITI JUU YA HALI YA ULINZI HAPA CHUONI
MAELEKEZO: Tafadhali sana jaribu kujibu maswali yaliyoko katika fomu hii. Jibu
lako uliweke katika nafasi zilizoachwa wazi ili kuweza kufanikisha utafiti huu.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
TANBIHI:
KWA
APPENDIX B
INTERVIEW GUIDE
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.