Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
6) When the offender knows that he is afflicted with the Human Immuno-Deficiency Virus
(HIV)/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) or any other sexually transmissible disease
and the virus or disease is transmitted to the victim;
7) When committed by any member of the Armed Forces of the Philippines or paramilitary units thereof or the Philippine National Police or any law enforcement agency or penal
institution, when the offender took advantage of his position to facilitate the commission of the
crime;
8) When by reason or on the occasion of the rape, the victim has suffered permanent
physical mutilation or disability;
9) When the offender knew of the pregnancy of the offended party at the time of the
commission of the crime; and
10) When the offender knew of the mental disability, emotional disorder and/or physical
handicap of the offended party at the time of the commission of the crime.
Rape under paragraph 2 of the next preceding article shall be punished by prision mayor.
Whenever the rape is committed with the use of a deadly weapon or by two or more
persons, the penalty shall be prision mayor to reclusion temporal.
When by reason or on the occasion of the rape, the victim has become insane, the
penalty shall be reclusion temporal.
When the rape is attempted and a homicide is committed by reason or on the occasion
thereof, the penalty shall be reclusion temporal to reclusion perpetua.
When by reason or on the occasion ofthe rape, homicide is committed, the penalty shall
be reclusion perpetua.
Reclusion temporal shall be imposed if the rape is committed with any of the ten
aggravating/ qualifying circumstances mentioned in this article.
Article 266-C. Effect of Pardon. - The subsequent valid marriage between the
offended party shall extinguish the criminal action or the penalty imposed.
In case it is the legal husband who is the offender, the subsequent forgiveness by the
wife as the offended party shall extinguish the criminal action or the penalty: Provided, That the
crime shall not be extinguished or the penalty shall not be abated if the marriage is void ab
initio.
Article 266-D. Presumptions. - Any physical overt act manifesting resistance against
the act of rape in any degree from the offended party, or where the offended party is so
situated as to render her/him incapable of giving valid consent, may be accepted as evidence
in the prosecution of the acts punished under Article 266-A.
SECTION 3. Separability Clause. - If any part, section, or provision of this Act is
declared invalid or unconstitutional, the other parts thereof not affected thereby shall remain
valid.
SECTION 4. Repealing Clause. - Article 336 of Act No. 3815, as amended, and all laws,
acts, presidential decrees, executive orders, administrative orders, rules and regulations
inconsistent with or contrary to the provisions of this Act are deemed amended, modified or
repealed accordingly.
SECTION 5. Effectivity. - This Act shall take effect fifteen (15) days after completion of
its publication in two (2) newspapers of general circulation.
Approved:
(SGD.) JOSE DE VENECIA, JR.
Speaker of the House of Representatives
(SGD.) ERNESTO M. MACEDA
President of the Senate
This Act, which is a consolidation of Senate Bill No. 950 and House Bill No. 6265, was
finally passed by the Senate and the House of Representatives on June 5, 1997 and September
3, 1997, respectively.
(SGD.) ROBERTO P. NAZARENO
Secretary General
House of Representatives
(SGD.) LORENZO E. LEYNES, JR.
Secretary of the Senate
Approved: September 30, 1997
(SGD.) FIDEL V. RAMOS
President of the Philippines
common offenders are fathers resulting to 14 first-degree incest rapes, including that of
stepfathers and adopting father. In short, more than fifty percent of the cases were perpetrated
by fathers or those considered as fathers by the victims.
Not only are the cases mostly incest but they also fall under statutory rape where the victim
is below 12 years old. Fifty percent of the incestuous rape or eight of the cases, in fact are
statutory rape. Seven of the victims were 12 years old when they were raped. Three of them
were 7 years old. Two were 11 years old. One was 10. Another was 9, and another was 6 years
old. Only one was above 12 years old (14 years old) when she was raped. This fact will show
that the children are in their most vulnerable ages, and are therefore, so dependent for
material and emotional support from their parents or parental symbols, so to speak.
Among the peculiarities worth mentioning in each of the cases are the following:
In one case, 3 brothers and the father started raping the victim from age 12. In another case, a
brother and father raped 4 daughters and sisters. In another, a father of 2 daughters raped
them both starting age 7 to 15, without these victims knowing the rape of the other.
In another case, the rape was accompanied by maltreatment. A victim was raped from age 7 to
9 by her stepfather. Another victim was subjected to acts of lasciviousness when she was 8 and
eventually raped at age 9. In one case, a stepfather raped her two stepdaughters. A
stepdaughter was raped at age 6 and age 8 by another stepfather. In another case, both her
grandfather and uncle raped the victim.
Out of these 24 rape cases of minor children, eleven offenders are still at large.
Respondents Data
Given these data, several respondents comprising of judges, lawyers, prosecutors and public
attorneys were asked to answer a standard questionnaire to determine various concerns. Four
stages involved with incestuous rape cases were identified as follows: Discovery of the Crime,
Investigation, Prosecution and Resolution of the Case.
Majority of the respondents were involved in the investigation and prosecution of the cases.
Only two were part of the discovery of the crime and about forty percent, most composed of
judges, were involved in the resolution of cases.
Majority of the respondents says that the most difficult stage for the child or victim is the filing
of the case in court. This is the first statement or the revelation that she has been abused by a
person she trusted. The respondents believe that the relationship between parties makes it
hard for the victim to seek justice.
At this stage, the traumatic experience of the child is characterized by fear to divulge the crime
as a result of the threats and confusion coupled with uncertainties as to what lies ahead after
the discovery of the crime. Oftentimes, this part is attended by social inhibitions, shame and
the guilt that somehow she contributed or was instrumental in the commission of the offense.
Other respondents believe it is the investigation that is difficult for the child because she will be
made to reveal and recall and recall the sordid circumstances surrounding her dishonor to the
investigator. It is very difficult for the child to testify against a relative. It is the time when the
child has to open up and expose her unfortunate experience to people she doesnt know or
trust.
Just like investigation, several respondents said the prosecution stage would also be difficult
also because the child will be subjected to grueling cross-examination.
On the query as to which stage is the most crucial to the success of the case, majority of the
respondents believe it is the prosecution. Here, the testimony of the child is needed for the
resolution of the case. Hence, the desire of the child to testify or not is important.
Even if one has a case, if the child refuses to testify, it will be difficult to difficult to prosecute
without her testimony, because in almost all instances, there are no other witnesses. The
success or failure of the prosecutor depends on the kind of evidence he or she has.
The competence of the prosecutor is vital to the success of the case because inaccuracies in
the preparation of the information and presentation of the evidence may set at naught all the
efforts exerted by the investigators and resulting either to the acquittal of the malefactor or the
downgrading of the crime.
For some respondents, the investigation of the case is crucial to its success because at this
stage a lot of preparation is required and a good preparation is the be all end all of rape
prosecution. This includes the early report of the incident and gathering of evidence.
Several respondents consider all three stages as important: discovery, investigation and
prosecution because the fruits of said stages determine the success and failure of the case.
As to the query of which stage is the most difficult for the lawyer, all respondents agreed that it
is the prosecution stage. This stage is characterized by the fear that the complainant may or
may not pursue the case after all. They believe that prior to the presentation of the victim in
court, she might change her mind or not cooperate.
It is also in this stage when the factor of gender bias sets and the lack of the minor childs
ability to articulate salient legal points needed to pin down the accused.
The prosecution is the most difficult stage because the lawyer has to exert utmost effort of
convincing the child to do away with her fears, fully cooperate in the prosecution by being open
or candid to the lawyer without any reservation and encourage her to gain strength in order to
overcome the rigors of the trial and above all the concomitant public humiliation or ridicule.
Some respondents consider the investigation stage as hard for the lawyer since here the lawyer
will have to seek for witnesses and evidence to support uncorroborated allegations of the child.
In addition to these questions, the respondents were made to rank the following factors:
Relationship between Offender and Victim--Culture of Filipinos--Age of the Victim--Lack of agencies to support victims--Fear--Ignorant mother--Lack of authorities to aid the victim---
10 respondents
8 respondents
6 respondents
2 respondents
2 respondents
1 respondent
1 respondent
10 respondents
7 respondents
5 respondents
4 respondents
4 respondents
1 respondent
5
5
4
4
4
4
2
2
1
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondents
respondent
Among the other factors cited was poverty of the victim and all the relatives supporting her,
thus resulting in the loss of interest in the successful prosecution of the case, which oftentimes
takes a long period due to several factors, inadequate number of judges, prosecutors, public
attorneys (oftentimes defending the accused), lack of transport facilities to bring the accused
to Court, congested court dockets and dilatory tactics by such counsels.
When asked as to the factors that sets the crime apart from other crimes, majority of the
respondents believe it is the relationship between the parties involved. The love of the father
and the hatred brought about by the incident usually puts complainant into a dilemna whether
or not to pursue or dismiss the case, resulting from acts which are considered as bestial and
repulsive. A lot of emotions are involved for both the sides of the victim and the accused. These
emotions stem from intricacy of the relationship between the offender and the offended party.
One has to consider the family as a whole, the implications vis--vis the other family members
and their welfare.
Some respondents also consider this kind of crime as sensational where the element of trial by
publicity is usually present. There is concomitant public humiliation that the victim has to
undergo and the consequent ostracism for being a rape victim. Thus, more often than not, the
successful prosecution of the offender becomes difficult due to the lack of cooperation on the
part of the victim not to mention the difficulty of discovering the crime unless accidentally
discovered. This being another characteristic of incestuous rape cases: the difficulty in its
discovery.
In incestuous rape, the one who investigates, oftentimes also find it difficult to separate their
biases and prejudices in resolving the case.
Another important aspect is the need to rehabilitate not only of the victim but the accused
especially if he is also minor.
Jurisprudence
To test the data accumulated, jurisprudence will be used. What is the highest Court of the
land has to say in their decisions involving incest prepares a child and her lawyer for the basic
realities of a courtroom battle. Some of these pronouncements are, to wit:
Nature of the Crime:
In Wilkinson vs. People, 282 Pac. 257, the crime was considered an outrage upon nature in its
dearest and tenderest relations as well as a crime against humanity itself.
Weight of Victims Testimony:
In considering the weight of he victims testimony, jurisprudence said that unless she was
telling the truth, the rape victim would not deliberately identify herself as such and expose
herself to public disgrace and the embarrassment of having testify on the sordid details of her
violation. This would be especially true if the ravisher was her own father as the humiliation
would be compounded by the stigma of incest and there would be the natural reluctance, born
of an underlying filial loyalty, to denounce her own kin. But it does not necessarily mean that
once the charge is made, the conviction of the accused would follow as a matter of course.
(FIRST DIVISION, PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES vs. PORFERIO IGNACIO, G.R. No. 990318. July 24,
1992.)
Degree of Resistance on the Part of the Victim:
In cases of rape, the manner, form and tenacity of resistance of the victim therein are
dependent on a number of factors, among which are the age and size of the victim, as well as
of the aggressor himself; the degree of actual force and intimidation employed; and, of utmost
importance, the relationship between the rapist and his prey.
The absence of violence or offer of resistance would not be significant because of the
overpowering and overbearing moral influence of the father over the daughter which takes
place of violence and offer of resistance required in rape cases committed by an accused
having no blood relationship with the victim. (SECOND DIVISION, PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
vs. HONORIO G. MABUNGA, G.R. No. 96441. November 13, 1992.)
Indeed, the kind of force or violence, threat or intimidation as between father and daughter
need not be of such nature and degree as would be required in other cases, for the father in
this particular instance exercises strong, moral, and physical influence and control over his
daughter (People vs. Rinion, C.A., 61 O.G. 4422; 2 Reyes, Revised Penal Code, First ed., 1977,
p.827; People vs. Carino, Sr., 167 SCRA 285 [1988]; People vs. Hortillano, 177 SCRA 729
[ 1989]).
Effect of Delay in Reporting the Case:
In a long a line of cases, delay in reporting rape incidents, in the face of threats of physical
violence, cannot be taken against the victim. A rape victims actions are oftentimes
overwhelmed by fear rather than by reason. It is this fear, springing from the initial rape, that
the perpetrator hopes to build a climate of extreme psychological terror, which would, he
hopes, numb his victim into silence and submissiveness. Incestuous rape magnifies this terror,
because the perpetrator is a person normally expected to give solace and protection to the
victim. Furthermore, in incest, access to the victim is guaranteed by the blood relationship,
proximity magnifying the sense of helplessness and the degree of fear. No matter how
courageous the act of filing a complainant might appear to be, rape exacts a heavy
psychological and social toll on the victim who is usually twice victimized: by the rapist during
the act of rape and by a society which devalues the victims worth by characterizing the crime
principally as an insult to the victims chastity. With all the attendant social consequences such
as classification brings, many cases of rape go naturally unreported, and those cases which
manage to reach the authorities are routinely treated in a manner so demeaning to the victims
dignity that the psychological ordeal and injury is repeated again and again in the hands of
inexperienced, untrained and oftentimes callous investigators and courtroom participants. If a
woman would have second thoughts about filing an ordinary rape case, all the more would it be
difficult and painful for the child to complain against her own father.
Conclusion
Incestuous rape cases are a genre of their own. The data above clearly show that these cases
must be set apart from other crimes and treated as a distinct offense. Among the things we can
do to address the issues raised in these studies are the following:
1. Our penal laws should provide for sanctions to address and deter the proliferation of these
cases. While we protect our children from bodily harm and other injuries that may befall upon
their persons, who is to protect them from those are tasked to protect them, but violate their
trust instead?
2. Our remedial and criminal laws must provide for ways to lessen the stigma of the victims of
incestuous rape cases while still successfully prosecuting them. Sensitive modes of presenting
evidence may be conceptualizes to minimize the impact and trauma of investigation and court
litigation.
3. Authorities tasked to investigate and prosecute cases of incestuous rape must undergo rigid
and intensive training to become sensitive and equipped with the necessary skills to undertake
and handle these cases.
4. More agencies must be established to aid and support the victims of these cases, who are
usually displaced from their own homes, and are left at the custody of their investigators, who
do not usually have the resources to house and provide these children.
5. Educational support and rehabilitation measures must be available for the victims of
incestuous rape so that they will eventually be reintegrated into society as physically
productive and mentally healthy individuals.
6. Counseling and constant psychological examination must be conducted over the victims to
ensure their successful and complete rehabilitation.
7. A holistic approach must be observed by including the family of the victim in the
rehabilitation process, taking into careful consideration the feelings and welfare of the other
members of the family, including the offender himself.
8. Massive information campaign on the rights of the children must be given to parents as well
as community lecturers on responsible parenthood.
9. Educational curriculum must include sex and gender education for young children to teach
them of their rights towards their own physicality and to equip them with the awareness and
mechanism to determine any violation against their persons at an early stage, be it perpetrated
by strangers or kin.
10. The right to privacy of the victim and even the accused and confidentiality of the
proceedings must always be enforced.
Incest
Submitted by jessicab on Mon, 2006-02-27 18:28.
Introduction:
Incest is often included as a subset of Sexual Assault of Children. While there is a substantial
amount of overlap in the two types of assault, for the purposes of this website we have
separated them in recognition of the different needs that victims of each type of assault may
have.
Definition:
Sexual contact between persons who are so closely related that their marriage is illegal (e.g.,
parents and children, uncles/aunts and nieces/nephews, etc.). This usually takes the form of an
older family member sexually abusing a child or adolescent.
Incest is considered by many experts to be a particularly damaging form of sexual abuse
because it is perpetrated by indivuals whom the victim trusts and depends upon. In addition,
support can also be lacking and pressure to keep silent powerful as fear of the family breaking
up can be overwhelming to other family members.
CULTURAL NOTE: There are, however, different cultural expectations and rules about incest.
For instance, in some areas of the Arab world and southern India it is estimated that as many
as 50% of marriages occur between first cousins. In addition, in southern India it is still
common to see a maternal uncle (the mother's brother) marry the first daughter.
Incest can include such sexual acts as:
Noncontact acts- sexual comments, exposure, voyeurism, showing pornographic
materials, etc.
Sexual contact- touching, rubbing
Digital or object penetration- both of the victim and of the perpetrator
Oral sex- both of the victim and of the perpetrator
Penile penetration- vaginal, anal, animals
Circumstances of the sexual acts can also be diverse including:
Dyadic sexual abuse- involving two people (victim and perpetrator)
Group sex
Sex rings
Sexual exploitation
Child pornography
Child prostitution
Common Reactions:
Reactions in Children:
Withdrawal
Depression
Sleeping & eating disorders
Self-mutilation
Phobias
For reactions in adult survivors of incest please see Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse
The following reactions are seen in child, adolescent and adult survivors of incest.
Traumatic Sexualization:
Aversive feelings about sex
Overvaluing sex
Sexual identity problems
Hypersexual or sexual avoidance
Stigmatization:
Feelings of guilt/responsibility for the abuse
Self-destructive behavior
o Substance abuse
o self-harm
o suicidal ideation
o risk-taking acts
o provocative behavior in order to encite punishment
Betrayal:
Lack of trust, especially of those who were supposed to be protective and nurturing
Avoidance of investment in others
Manipulative behaviors
Anger, acting-out and borderline behaviors
Re-enacting the trauma through involvement in additional abusive or dangerous
relationships
Powerlessness:
Perception of vulnerability, victimization
Desire to control and prevail- often exhibited as identification with the aggressor
Avoidance- including dissociation, running away
Anxiety- including phobias, sleep problems, eating problems, elimination problems,
revictimization
NOTE: It is important to note that there is no standard or typical symptom that can identify an
individual as having survived incest. Much of the reactions and symptoms will depend on age
at time of abuse, age at time of disclosure, support (or lack of support) from other caregivers,
length of abuse, sex of the victim and perpetrator, etc.
This section was adapted from materials provided by the Texas Association Against Sexual
Assault. Additional information for this section comes from Valente, S.M., Sexual Abuse of Boys
in Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nurses, 18:1, p. 10-18 and Child Sexual Abuse:
Intervention and Treatment Issues, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (1999).
Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse
Submitted by jessicab on Tue, 2006-02-28 12:24.
CAVEAT: The following descriptions are meant to serve as a general guideline for how a victim
of sexual assault might react in a time of pain or crisis. It is important to recognize, however,
that each victim of sexual assault will have his or her own life experiences and personality that
will influence how he or she react to the assault.
Reactions:
There are many reactions that survivors of rape and sexual assault can have. But for adult
survivors of childhood abuse there are reactions that may either be different or stronger than
for other survivors. These include:
Setting Limits/Boundaries
Because your personal boundaries were invaded when you were young by someone you
trusted and depended on, you may have trouble understanding that you have the right
to control what happens to you.
Memories/Flashbacks
Like many survivors, you may experience flashbacks.
Anger
This is often the most difficult emotion for an adult survivor of childhood sexual abuse to
get in touch with.
As a child your anger was powerless and had little to no effect on the actions of your
abuser. For this reason you may not feel confident that you anger will be useful or
helpful.
Grieving/Mourning
Being abused as a child means the loss of many things- childhood experiences, trust,
innocence, normal relationship with family members (especially if the abuser was a
family member).
o You must be allowed to name those losses, grieve them, and then bury them.
Guilt, Shame, and Blame
You may carry a lot of guilt because you may have experienced pleasure or because you
did not try to stop the abuse.
There may have been silence surrounding the abuse that led to feelings of shame.
It is important for you to understand that it was the adult who abused his/her position of
authority and should be held accountable, not you.
Trust
Coping Skills
You have undoubtedly developed skills in order to cope with the trauma.
o Some of these are healthy (possibly separating yourself from family members,
seeking out counseling, etc.)
o Some are not (drinking or drug abuse, promiscuous sexual activity, etc.)
Self-esteem/Isolation
Low self-esteem is a result of all of the negative messages you received and internalized
from your abusers.
Intimacy
Because entering into an intimate relationship involves trust, respect, love, and the
ability to share, you may flee from intimacy or hold on too tightly for fear of losing the
relationship.
Sexuality
You likely have to deal with the fact that your first initiation into sex came as a result of
sexual abuse.
You may experience the return of body memories while engaging in a sexual activity
with another person. Such memories may interfere in your ability to engage in sexual
relationships which may leave you feeling frightened, frustrated, or ashamed.
This section was adapted from materials provided by the Texas Association Against Sexual
Assault.