Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Ruth Fischer
Volume 33 Number 1
The contents of Foreign Affairs are copyrighted.1954 Council on Foreign Relations, Inc.
All rights reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this material is permitted only with the express
written consent of Foreign Affairs. Visit www.foreignaffairs.com/permissions for more information.
HO CHI MINH:
COMMUNIST
DISCIPLINED
By Ruth Fischer
MONG the present generation of Communist leaders, so
decimated by the Stalinist purge, Ho Chi Minh is one
of the rare survivors of the Leninist International which
he joined as an ardent nationalistic revolutionary. In our time,
many Communist leaders are progressing in the other direction,
going from doctrinaire Communism to their kind of National
Communism, a process of which, for the time being, Tito is still
the most striking example. I met Ho Chi Minh, then called
Nguyen Ai-Quoc, quite often inMoscow in the early twenties.
He became popular quickly in Comintern circles with his pleas
ant, almost timid manners. But it was Ho Chi Minh's nation
alism which impressed us European Communists born and bred
in a rather gray kind of abstract internationalism.
Ho Chi Minh was born on July I5, I892 (there is still some
discussion about the exact date of his birth), in the village of
Kimlien in Annam. His father, Nguyen-Sinh-Huy, was a poor
gentleman well-versed in the four books of Confucius, a studious,
pious man, but an implacable enemy of French colonial rule and
an active participant in the Resistance of Annam, a country
riddledwith secret societies all plotting, preparing and attempt
ing an uprising against the French. Nguyen-Sinh-Huy named his
third child, a son, born in these years of distress, Nguyen Ta't
Thanh. Nguyen, the family name, means "one who lives in the
plains" or simply, a peasant; the given name, Ta't-Thanh, can be
translated as "aman who will be victorious."
Young Ho received the best education available at that time
and in that place, but he left his native Annam and its schools
early; his impressive personal culture was enriched later by self
education. In leaving Annam, he was driven by an obsession
current among Asian revolutionaries of this period: to seek help
abroad among the young anti-colonial nations against the old
colonial Powers. M. N. Roy, for instance, a foundermember of
the Indian Communist Party who later turned against the Stal
inist regime, tells us in his autobiography how he left his native
Calcutta during the FirstWorld War in the hope of getting arms
for the Indian revolution fromGermany. Roy never got the arms,
A
www.jstor.org
HO CHI MINH
87
88
FOREIGNAFFAIRS
HO CHI MINH
89
go
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
HO CHI MINH
gI
92
FOREIGNAFFAIRS
HO CHI MINH
93
94
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
Ho Chi Minh had suffered a terrible blow: from being the rec
ognized chief of a state, he became again the underground leader
of a largebut dispersed guerrilla armywhich was driven from the
industrial strongpoints into the jungle.General Vo Nguyen Giap,
aman who combined brilliant military talents with long experi
ence in party politics, came to the fore; he was surrounded by a
team of able and dedicated young men who were convinced that
Vietnam could win its freedom only by proclaiming totalmobili
zation of the Indo-Chinese after the pattern of the Chinese revo
lution. Ho could not but accept that policy, although he might
have known better than anyone in his entourage that "total
mobilization" and "democracy" are incompatible forms of social
organization.
The Viet Minh's policy of total mobilization met with consid
erable success inmany parts of Indo-China.Many nationalists
who had wavered during the intermediate years now chose the
Viet Minh as the only effective representation of the national
movement for independence.The Viet Minh organized a network
of branches and sub-branches cutting horizontally and vertically
through the Indo-Chinese body politic, on lines of the party, the
popular front and themilitary. A good deal of voluntary coop
eration on the part of the native population was found by the
Viet Minh, but there was also considerable coercion in case of
opposition.
Paris
to end the
HO CHI MINH
95
96
FOREIGNAFFAIRS
HO CHI MINH
97