Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
quantum or subquantum level. Eccles says that his theory can account for ordinary
voluntary actions, but that 'more direct actions of the will are precluded by the
conservation laws' [8]. This is significant, for even if there is no measurable violation of
energy conservation in ordinary mental phenomena, this may not be the case with
certain paranormal phenomena, especially psychokinesis and materializations. Eccles,
however, does not take paranormal phenomena seriously [9].
Eccles is in basic agreement with the neo-Darwinian theory that evolution is driven by
random genetic mutations followed by the weeding out of unfavorable variations by
natural selection, but he also believes that 'there is a Divine Providence operating over
and above the materialist happenings of biological evolution' [10]. He accepts that
mammals (such as dogs, cats, horses, and monkeys) and possibly birds are conscious
beings, which experience feelings and pain, but denies conscious experiences to
invertebrates and lower vertebrates such as fish and even amphibians and reptiles
which, he says, have instinctual and learned responses, but no awareness or sensation.
He maintains that the mental (or psychon) world, and therefore conscious experiences,
came into existence with the development of the complex neocortex of the mammalian
brain, and that the neocortex evolved by natural selection because it enabled the
increased complexity of sensory inputs to be integrated, and therefore offered survival
advantages. Then,
with hominid evolution there eventually came higher levels of conscious
experiences, and ultimately in Homo sapiens sapiens -- self-consciousness - which is the unique life-long experience of each human SELF, and which
we must regard as a miracle beyond Darwinian evolution. [11]
In theosophy, rather than the physical world giving rise to the mental world, lower
realms are said to unfold from higher, more spiritual realms through a process of
emanation, differentiation, and concretion, and all the various planes, and the classes of
entities composing and inhabiting them, are manifestations of consciousness -- the
ultimate reality. In the words of H.P. Blavatsky:
Nature taken in its abstract sense, cannot be 'unconscious,' as it is the
emanation from, and thus an aspect (on the manifested plane) of the
ABSOLUTE consciousness. Where is that daring man who would presume to
deny to vegetation and even to minerals a consciousness of their own. All he
can say is, that this consciousness is beyond his comprehension. [12]
Thus not only are all animals conscious; plants too have a primitive form of sentient,
conscious existence, as various researchers have established [13]. As for the mineral
kingdom, 'panpsychists' such as B. Rensch and C. Birch believe that all physical matter,
including atoms and subatomic particles, possesses a protoconsciousness. Eccles
rejects panpsychism on the grounds that modern physics does not admit memory or
identity for elementary particles. However, physicist David Bohm believed not only that
all forms of matter were alive and conscious to some extent, but also that, at deeper
levels, every particle of a particular species is distinguishable and unique, rather than
being completely identical as is assumed in orthodox physics [14]. Furthermore, newly
synthesized chemical compounds have been found to crystallize more readily all over
the world the more often they are made -- implying the existence of some sort of
memory [15].
today.
Eccles at least recognizes that Darwinian evolution cannot account for our
selfconscious mind:
Since materialist solutions fail to account for our experienced uniqueness, I
am constrained to attribute the uniqueness of the Self or Soul to a
supernatural spiritual creation. To give the explanation in theological terms:
each Soul is a new Divine creation which is implanted into the growing
foetus at some time between conception and birth. [19]
Theosophy, too, assigns human beings a spiritual ancestry, but rejects the belief that
they were created by a supernatural, extracosmic, anthropomorphic God. If nature is
infinite, divinity cannot be outside nature but must be coeval with it and pervade every
atom of life. At the heart of every entity is a spiritual monad -- a deathless spark of
divinity, or center of life-consciousness -- which imbodies in an endless variety of forms
in an endless variety of worlds in the course of its eternal evolutionary development.
The earth is merely the latest station on the evolutionary journey of our spiritual
monads. The first protohuman forms on earth were huge, ethereal, nonselfconscious
beings which slowly materialized, declined in size, and assumed the present human
shape. When these physical forms had attained the necessary degree of complexity, the
gradual awakening and unfoldment of our latent intellectual and spiritual powers could
begin. [20]
As for what happens after death, Eccles says:
we can regard the death of the body and brain as dissolution of our dualist
existence. Hopefully, the liberated soul will find another future of even
deeper meaning and more entrancing experiences, perhaps in some
renewed embodied existence . . . in accord with traditional Christian
teaching. [21]
Given his belief that a new human soul is created for every newborn child, Eccles is
probably not referring here to reincarnation on earth. But if our souls are to learn from
the past and evolve, it would seem logical that they must not only reap what they have
sown (in accordance with the law of karma), but must also reap where they have sown,
and must continue to incarnate on earth until they have learned all the lessons the earth
can teach.
Thus, although Eccles recognizes that the mind is relatively independent of the brain
and works through it rather than being identical with it, his views still remain limited by
several materialistic and theological dogmas. Nevertheless, his attempt to reach out
beyond scientific materialism and develop a more spiritual vision is refreshing. Towards
the end of his latest book, he writes:
I here express my efforts to understand with deep humility a self, myself, as
an experiencing being. I offer it in the hope that we human selves may
discover a transforming faith in the meaning and significance of this
wonderful adventure that each of us is given on this salubrious Earth of ours,
each with our wonderful brain, which is ours to control and use for our
memory and enjoyment and creativity and with love for other human selves.
[22]
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.