Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Bhutan lies in the Himalayas which were formed by collision between the Indian plate and Eurasian
Plate that started about 50 million years ago. Each year, the Indian Plate advances relentlessly
about 20mm towards the Asian plate resulting in the stress built up in the Himalayan region.
The two earthquakes of 2009 and 2011 which affected mainly the eastern, western and southern
Bhutan have re-confirmed the active seismicity in the region. These two earthquakes caused severe
damages to properties in Bhutan.
The earthquakes can neither be predicted nor be prevented but proactive precaution can be taken to
reduce the risk by building safer homes. It is said Earthquakes do not kill but bad buildings do.
This Earthquake Resistant Construction Training Manual- 2013 is an updated and improved
version of the previous Good Construction Practices Manual 2011.
The Manual provides various measures to be considered in proper planning, design and
construction of the houses to achieve good seismic resistance.
The Ministry of Works and Human Settlement is pleased to bring forth this Earthquake Resistant
Construction Training Manual - 2013 and anticipate all the users and the home owners to take
full advantage more so , this should serve as a good guideline to all artisans, engineers, architects
and builders in rendering their services.
The Manual will be reviewed and updated periodically as and when better methods are available to
suit our context. We would also, appreciate valuable comments and suggestions on this Manual for
consideration in its next edition.
Acknowledgement
This Earthquake Resistant Construction Training Manual- 2013 is prepared with the financial
assistance from the UNDP Bhutan office and USAID. The Ministry of Works and Human
Settlement would like to thank the UNDP and USAID for their support.
The Ministry would also like to thank the members of the Technical Core Group for their valuable
inputs in developing and fine tuning the Manual. The Members are:
1) Mr Karma Jamtsho, Thimphu Dzongkhag
2) Mr Jigme Dorji, Thimphu Thromde
3) Mr Karma Sonam, SPBD, MoE
4) Mr Sonam Norbu, SPBD, MoE
5) Mr Tshering Dupchu, HIDD, MoH
6) Mr Pema, DCHS, MoHCA
7) Mr Yeshey Lotay, DDM, MoHCA
8) Mr Karma Drupchu, Gelephu Thromde
ii
iii
Epicentre: It is the point on the surface, vertically above the place of origin (hypocenter) of
the earthquake.
Magnitude: It is the quantity to measure the size of an earthquake and is independent of the
place of observation.
Wythe: is a continuous vertical section of masonry one unit thickness. A wythe maybe independent of, or interlocked with, the adjoining wythes.
Delamination : is a failure mode where by a splitting apart of layers takes place, or division
into separate layers.
In-Plane Failure of Wall: The failure that takes place due to the forces parallel to the axis of
the wall.
Out - of-Plane Failure of Wall : the failure that takes place due to the forces perpendicular to
the axis of the wall.
iv
Preface
Scope of the Manual
Contents
1
1
3
4
7
7
7
9
11
12
15
16
18
21
22
22
23
25
27
28
31
31
33
34
35
37
38
7. References
44
Each
year,
the
Indian
Plate
advances
earthquakes
signify
accumulation
of
the
region
great
surrounding
stress
future
in
continued
rupture;
the
the
The list of Historical earthquakes that affected Bhutan in the past are given in the Table 1.
Table 1: List of Historical Earthquakes that affected Bhutan
Sl No.
1
Magnitude
(Richter)
7.0
Date
Location (Epicenter)
1713
7.6
11 June 1806
Eastern Bhutan
8.0
12 June 1897
6.5
12 May 1906
5.7
13 August 1910
8.0
15 January 1934
6.7
21 January 1941
7.3
29 July 1947
8.7
15 August 1950
10
6.4
23 February 1954
11
6.6
29 July 1960
Southern Bhutan
12
6.4
19 November 1980
13
6.8
20 August 1988
Nepal
14
5.5
26 March 2003
Paro
15
5.0
11 February 2006
16
5.7
14 February 2006
Sikkim
17
5.8, 5.5
24 February 2006
Dewathang
18
6.1
21 September 2009
Narang, Mongar
19
6.9
18 September 2011
Sikkim, India
2
Houses Damaged
Beyond
Repair
Major
Repair
Dead
Trashiyantse
21
70
Partial
Repair
400
Zhemgang
Trashigang
147
445
439
572
18
Pemagatshel
25
24
24
187
Lhuentse
24
87
Mongar
260
331
413
1253
18
Samdrupjongkhar
10
11
Gasa
23
Punakha
10
Chukha
22
11
Sarpang
12
Tsirang
28
Total
462
884
1335
2269
12
39
Minor
Repair
106
Injured
Note: Cat III: Total Collapsed , Cat II: Substantial to Heavy Damage, Cat I: Minor Damage
Dzongkhag
Houses Damaged
Cat I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
356
15
383
21
22
15
58
Wangdueg
145
47
193
Zhemgang
48
50
5568
1008
401
6977
14
62
Chhukha
Dagana
551
101
18
670
367
70
12
449
Gasa
209
15
229
Haa
515
319
200
1034
Lhuentse
61
63
Mongar
439
35
478
Paro
837
129
54
1020
27
32
868
39
910
18
19
645
189
81
915
46
50
336
16
367
Trongsa
Tsirang
Pemagatshel
Punakha
S/jongkhar
Samtse
15
Trashigang
18
19
20
Injured
Total
62
14
17
Cat III
Bumthang
Sarpang
Thimphu
16
Cat II
Dead
Trashiyangtse
TOTAL
Stone masonry walls constructed of two wythes are susceptible to delamination. The space between
the wythes is usually filled with small stones and mortar. Delamination takes place when the
vertical wall wythes bulge and collapse outward due to earthquake shaking.
The absence of the through-stones is the primary cause of delamination. The process of
delamination and a picture of delaminated wall are shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4.
Poor quality of construction and use of low quality of building materials are the cause of significant
earthquake damage and destruction in the stone masonry.
Type:
Natural building stones such as granite,
limestone, sandstone etc. are to be used.
Durability:
Stones should be hard, tough, compact
grained, uniform in texture and color and
crack-free.
Size:
Stones small enough to be lifted and placed by
hands can be used. The length of the stone
shall not be more than 3 times the height and
shall not be less than 200mm.
b) The house should not be constructed near or on top of the edge of slopes as it might
collapse due to earth avalanches.
e) Houses should be
built above the
possible flood line
and with adequate
distance from the
river banks. Buffer
zone of 30m from the
river bank should be
maintained as per the
NEC Act.
Square
Rectangle
Narrow Rectangle
L Shape
U Shape
Building should be as regular as possible along its height. Vertical irregularities are not recommended, but if they cannot be avoided, a load-bearing wall should be provided below each wall in
the upper story.
The pictorial representation of the above mentioned is shown in the Figure 9.
DO
DO NOT
DO NOT
Figure 9: Regular buildings are recommended, Building irregularity in vertical direction: and buildings
with setbacks or overhangs are not recommended.
Stone masonry buildings with cement mortar should be limited to two stories in high seismic zones.
2.4 Foundation
Foundation of a building is the
part of the building below the
ground level. The purpose of the
foundations is to transfer the load
of the superstructure to the
ground. The weight of the structure must be suited to the load
capacity of the ground which in
turn shall be stable. An adequate
depth of the foundation should be
provided and it should reach the
stable ground with adequate bearing capacity.
11
2.5 Wall
i) Slenderness Ratio:
v) Course Work
Through-stones are the long stones placed through the wall to tie the wall together and prevent
delamination which is one of the main causes of collapse of stone masonry wall during earthquake.
Through-stones make the wall perform like hands with interlaced fingers as shown below.
When through-stones are unavailable, precast concrete members (1:2:4) of 150mm (6) by 150mm
(6) cross-section, or 8mm / 10mm diameter rod in S-shaped or hooked link with a cover of
25mm (1) from each face of the wall may be used. Through-stones should be placed every
600mm (2feet) along the wall height and every 1200mm (4feet) along the wall in plan as shown in
Figure 18.
15
Diameter of Rod
6m or 19.7 feet
12
12
18
In particular, the rocking behavior of slender masonry behavior is modified into bending due to the
presence of vertical reinforcement wherein the tensile strength is provided by the vertical
reinforcement. The vertical reinforcement in walls also increases the shearing strength at the
reduced wall sections and this prevents the sliding of wall piers at opening along sill, lintel and
below the roof. These effects are depicted in Figures 31 32.
In wider walls, the placement of vertical reinforcement enhances the capacity of wall sections to
resist lateral earthquake loads. Due to this enhanced capacity, the process of development of
X-crack is substantially delayed. The vertical reinforcement along with RCC bands strengthens the
opening to prevent formation of opening cracks at the corners. These effects are shown in Figures
33-34.
larger
diameter
Type:
Natural building stones such as granite,
limestone, sandstone etc are to be used. Round
stones and river stones shall not be used.
Durability:
Stones should be hard, tough, compact
grained, uniform in texture and color and
crack-free.
Size:
Stones small enough to be lifted and placed by
hands can be used. The length of the stone
shall not be 3 times the height and shall not be
less than 200mm.
2. Ribbon test. *
Roll a handful of moist soil into a cigarette
shape and squeeze it between your thumb and
forefinger to form the longest and thinnest
ribbon possible. Soil with high silt content will
form flakes or peel instead of forming a
ribbon. The longer and thinner the ribbon, the
higher the percentage of clay.
ii) Mortar
* For these tests, the soil specimen should be gradually moistened and thoroughly reshaped and
squeezed to bring it to its maximum "plasticity" and to remove dry lumps. Do not add too much
water, as the sample will lose its cohesion.
22
b) The house should not be constructed near or on top of the edge of slopes as it might
collapse due to earth avalanches.
23
e) The house should not be constructed on the unstable slopes as it might slide down. The
slopes where the trees are bent as shown in the picture are not stable.
24
Square
Rectangle
Narrow Rectangle
L Shape
U Shape
Stone masonry buildings with mud mortar should be limited to one storey.
3.4 Foundation
The foundation detail is shown in Figure 45.
Foundation of a building is
the part of the building below
the ground level. The purpose
of the foundations is to
transfer the load of the
construction to the ground.
The weight of the structure
must be suited to the load
capacity of the ground which
in turn shall be stable. An
adequate depth of the
foundation
should
be
provided and it should reach
the stable ground with
adequate bearing capacity.
The minimum width of the
foundation should be at least
1.5 times the wall thickness
and the minimum depth
should be 750mm or 2.5 feet.
The thickness of footing
should be 450mm.
3.5 Wall
i) Layout of Walls
v) Use of Through-Stones
Through-stones are the long stones placed through the wall to tie the wall together and prevent delamination which is one of the main causes of collapse of stone masonry wall during earthquake.
Through-stones make the wall perform like hands with interlaced fingers as shown in Figure 48.
When the through-stones are unavailable, wooden bars of 50mm (2) by 50mm (2) cross-section,
8mm/10mm diameter rod in S-shaped or hooked link with a cover of 25mm (1) from the each face
of the wall may be used. A pair of overlapping stones can also be used, each extending at least three
-quarters of the wall thickness. Through-stones extending over the full wall thickness must be used
every 600mm in the height and at 1.2m maximum spacing along the length as shown in Figure 50.
Figure 49 shows a picture of wall failure due to delamination.
28
29
Timber bands are used in stone masonry with mud mortar. Timber bands are made using a pair of
parallel planks or runners nailed together with small cross members. The corners of the timber
bands should be strengthened by diagonal knee-braces. The required size and number of timber
elements depends on the distance between the cross-walls, type of timber and importance of the
building. But for a wall span up to 5 m, generally long parallel timber runners with dimensions of
50mm by 100mm and cross members with dimensions of 50 mm by 50 mm placed at the spacing of
half a meter along the runner is enough. This type is usually used as Plinth Band and it is shown in
Figure 54. For a roof band timber plank band of usually 300mm by 35mm thick is used as shown in
the Figure 55.
a) Plinth Band
b) Roof Band
Timber plank 300 mm x 35 mm thick (1 by 1.4 thick) to be provided on top of wall at roof level.
Adequate length sill and lintels are also necessary for seismic protection as shown in the Figure 57.
Min250mm(10)
33
34
4. Appendix A:
Building Typology in Bhutan
The most common type of buildings found in the different regions around Bhutan as summarized
1. Reinforced Concrete
Buildings- mostly in
Urban areas
3. Brick Houses
35
6. Timber Houses
7. Eckra Houses
8. Bamboo Houses
36
37
Gewog:
Village:
Name of Owner:
House No:
Thram No:
Year of construction:
No. of Storey:
Different types of building respond and fail in different ways during ground shaking. Three Categories of damages have been assigned for Rammed Earth Structures for post earthquake damage assessment purpose. During earthquakes buildings may undergo both structural and non-structural
damages. Damage location and patterns may also be different for engineered and non-engineered
structures.
Categorization of Damage for Rammed Earth Buildings
Category I: Moderate Damage
Tick
Final Categorization:
Category I :
Category II :
Category III:
Additional Informations
Foundation &Plinth
Roofing Materials
CGI Sheet
Shinglap
Others
Remarks:
39
Date of Inspection:
Gewog:
Village:
Name of Owner:
House No:
Thram No:
Year of Construction:
Number of Storey:
Different types of building respond and fail in different ways during ground shaking. Four categories of damages
have been assigned for Stone masonry structures for post earthquake damage assessment purpose. During earthquakes buildings may undergo both structural and non-structural damages. Damage location and patterns may also
be different for engineered and non-engineered structures.
Categorization of Damage for Stone Masonry Buildings
Category I: Negligible to Slight Damage
Tick
40
Final Categorisation
Category I :
Category II :
Category III:
Category IV:
Additional Informations
Foundation &Plinth
Roofing Materials
CGI Sheet
Others
Shinglap
Remarks:
41
Date of Inspection:
Dzongkhag:
Gewog:
Village:
Name of Owner
House No:
Thram No:
Year of Construction:
Number of Storey:
Different types of building respond and fail in different ways during ground shaking. Two Categories of damages
have been assigned for Ekra type structures for post earthquake damage assessment purpose. During earthquakes buildings may undergo both structural and non-structural damages. Damage location and patterns may
also be different for engineered and non-engineered structures.
Categorization of Damage for Ekra Type Buildings
Category I: Substantial to Heavy Damage
Tick
- Damages in most Ekra walls
- Dislocation of timber joints / doors and windows
- Cracks in foundation and plinth
Category II: Total or, Near Collapse
- Serious failure of both structural and non-structural
components, collapse of ekra walls, timber posts, joists,
roof & floors.
- Total or, near total collapse of the building
Final Categorisation
Category I :
Category II :
Additional Informations
Foundation &Plinth
Roofing Materials
CGI Sheet
Others
Shinglap
Remarks:
42
Date of Inspection:
Gewog:
Village:
Name of Owner
House No:
Thram No:
Year of Construction:
Number of Storey:
Different types of building respond and fail in different ways during ground shaking. Two Categories of damages
have been assigned for wooden structures for post earthquake damage assessment purpose. During earthquakes
buildings may undergo both structural and non-structural damages. Damage location and patterns may also be
different for engineered and non-engineered structures.
Categorization of Damage for Wooden Buildings
Category I: Substantial to Heavy Damage
Tick
- Dislocation of joineries, posts and joists
- Dislocation of frames, floors and roof
- Cracks in foundation and plinth
Category II: Total or, Near Collapse
- Serious failure of both structural and non-structural
components, collapse of ekra walls, timber posts, joists,
roof & floors.
- Total or, near total collapse of the building
Final Categorisation
Category I :
Category II :
Additional Information
Foundation &Plinth
Roofing Materials
CGI Sheet
Others
Shinglap
Remarks:
43
Date of Inspection:
5. References
1. Bilham, R., Gaur, V.K., and Molnar, P.: Himalayan Seismic Hazard, 293, 1442-4, Science,
2001.
2. Bothara. J, Brzev.S, 2011. A TUTORIAL: Improving the Seismic Performance of StoneMasonry Buildings, Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, USA.
3. Boen. T, Earthquake Resistant Design of Non-Engineered Buildings in Indonesia, 2001.
EQTAP Workshop IV. Kamakura.
4. Brzev.S 2007. Earthquake-Resistant Confined Masonry Construction, Department of Civil
Engineering, British Columbia Institute of Technology, Burnaby, BC, Canada.
5. Guidelines for EQ Resistant Construction of Non-Engineered Rural and Suburban Masonry
Houses in C/S mortar in Earthquake Affected Areas, 2006. Earthquake Reconstruction and
Rehabilitation Authority (ERRA).
6. Guidelines for Earthquake Resistant Non-Engineering Construction, 2004. National Information
Center of Earthquake Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, India.
7. Guideline on Proper Construction Practices for Non-Engineered Buildings (Stone Masonry)2010, Standards and Quality Control Authority, Ministry of Works and Human Settlement,
Thimphu, Bhutan
8. IS 1597 (part 1): 1992 (reaffirmed 2002) Construction of Stone masonry code of practice.
9. IS 13828: 1993 (reaffirmed edition 2003) Improving Earthquake resistance of low strength
masonry buildings Guidelines
10. IS 43261993 Earthquake resistant design and construction of buildings Code of practice.
11. Papanikolaou .A, Taucer. F, 2004. Review of Non-Engineered Houses in Latin America with
Reference to Building Practices and Self-Construction Projects, Institute For Protection and
Security of the Citizen, European Laboratory for Structural Assessment (ELSA) I-21020 Ispra
(VA) Italy.
12. Murty.C.V.R, Earthquake Tip, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, India.
13. Zangmo.D, Retrofitting of Rammed Earth Walls with Prestressing, A Dissertation, 2008.
Department of Civil Engineering, Yokohama National University, Japan.
44