World Research Journal of Agricultural Sciences

Vol. 3(1), pp. 069-079, August, 2016. www.premierpublishers.org. ISSN: 2326-7266x

WRJAS

Research Article

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and

sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation
in Mysore, Karnataka, India
Mohammed Abdullah Alghobar1 and Sidduraiah Suresha2*
1,2*

Department of Environmental Science, Yuvaraja's College, University of Mysore, Mysore 570005, Karnataka, India.
The effect of wastewater irrigation on plant growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and
sugarcane crops was compared with that of ground water irrigation. Treatments included
untreated wastewater (UWW) treated wastewater (TWW) and ground water (GW) as control. The
results obtained, plant height, number of fruits/plant, dry biomass g/plant and number of
branches/plant of tomato (78.46 cm, 45.88, 15.49 and 11.41) and (75.13 cm, 41.48, 14.42 and
10.28) were significantly higher in the UWW and TWW compared to GW. The UWW and TWW
irrigated Napier grass gave the highest growth and yield, compared to that of GW irrigation.
Plant height, number of leaves/plant, leaf length, leaf width and number of tiller were 188.46 cm,
83.62, 93.62 cm, 2.52 and 13.2 in UWW and 182.68 cm, 69.75, 88.67cm, 2.29 and 10.39 in TWW
and these are significantly higher as compared to that of GW irrigation. Wastewater irrigation of
sugarcane increased cane length, number of nodes/cane, number of leaves, cane diameter and
cane weight significantly as compared to control GW are 191.86 cm, 22.48, 39.3 and 2.30 cm in
UWW and 149.4 cm, 20.54, 27.53 and 2.22 cm in TWW and compared to that of GW irrigation.

Keywords: Wastewater, groundwater, nutrient, heavy metal, cation exchange capacity, soil bulk density.

INTRODUCTION
The term wastewater agriculture refers to crop production
under wastewater irrigation. This practice is widely seen
in many cities of developing countries where urban
wastewater becomes the irrigation source for farmers in
urban and semi-urban areas (Raschid-Sally and
Jayakody, 2008). Wastewater use for agriculture is an
important management strategy in areas with limited
freshwater resources, yielding potential economic and
environmental benefits. The practice has manifold
benefits in the form of water conservation, nutrient
recycling and prevention of surface and ground water
pollution (Farahat and Linderholm, 2015). Irrigation of
olive trees with treated wastewaters in arid and semi-arid
regions is becoming a necessary alternative to
addressing issues of water shortages. The irrigation
requires a careful monitoring of soil and plants for a

range of parameters including salts, nutrients, microelements, heavy metals, toxic pollutants (Petousi et al.,
2015). In agricultural soils, the presence of metals is of
increasing concern because they have the potential to
get accumulated in less soluble forms, get transferred
into soil solution, and subsequently deteriorate the
groundwater and crop quality (Kelepertzis, 2014).

*Corresponding author: Dr. Sidduraiah Suresha,

Department of Environmental Science, Yuvaraja's
College, University of Mysore, Mysore 570005,
Karnataka, India. Tel.: +91 9448755001, E-mail address:
sureshakumar12@yahoo.com

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al. 069

Irrigation of rose flowers plants by raw wastewater

(RWW) every three days showed higher flower yields per
plant and improved flower quality parameters. RWW
frequencies imposed higher macro and micro nutrient
levels in leaves of rose plants (Rusan et al., 2008). The
results of Aghtape et al. (2011) and Tavassoli et al.
(2010) experiments showed that irrigation with
wastewater significantly increased the fresh and dry
forage yield of corn than that of irrigation with well water.
Abu Nada (2009) undertook study to assess the long
term impacts of wastewater irrigation on different
parameters of soil and crop. Long term wastewater
irrigation increased salt, organic matter and plant
nutrients in both soil layers. Alfalfa yield increased as
long as the period of wastewater irrigation continued.
Alfalfa yield from wastewater irrigation was 240% higher
than that from groundwater irrigation in the first year.
Nadav et al. (2013) indicated that the physico-chemical
properties of soils were altered by wastewater irrigation,
as a result of long-term accumulation of organic matter in
the soil profiles. High level of organic matter in
wastewater acts as cement for the building up of soil
aggregates. Therefore, lower bulk density and higher
infiltration and water retention are the main features
under wastewater irrigation. However, suspended solids
in wastewater negatively affect the soil porosity. Khurana
and Singh (2012) summarized the available data on
chemical composition of different wastewaters and their
effects on soil fertility, soil heavy-metal content, crop yield
and quality. Field application of all types of wastewaters
significantly increased soil OC percentage and cation
exchange capacity (CEC).
Biswas et al. (2015) assessed the feasibility of using lowcost filtered municipal wastewater for irrigation of red
amaranth (Amaranthus tricolor L cv. Surma). The
average plant height for T5 (8.097 in.) irrigated with
municipal wastewater was statistically identical to the
control (water from ponds and rivers). Gatta et al. (2015)
observed that the source of irrigation water did not affect
significantly tomato yield traits except tomato quality. Also
marketable fruit yield was higher with wastewater
compared to that from groundwater. According to Jou et
al. (2015) a 3-year monitoring of some parameters of
plant and leaves of olive trees in Crete, Greece was
conducted using trees being irrigated with both sewage
water and tape water. Plant growth was similar
irrespective of irrigation sources as indicated by
measured trunk diameter and plant height. In addition, no
significant differences in leaf mineral contents were
observed. Mahesh et al. (2015) reported that in many
urban and peri-urban areas of India, wastewater is less
considered as a major water resource for agricultural
purpose. The integrated approach showed that the
change in the total irrigated area was marginal over the
decade, whereas there was a distinct shift in cropping
patterns from paddy rice to paragrass and leafy
vegetables.

Nissim et al. (2015) showed that municipal wastewater

could be a valuable source of nutrients (especially N and
P) and water for plant growth. Wastewater Irrigation had
a positive effect on willow growth and biomass yield.
Gupta et al. (2015) evaluated the effect of irrigation
schedules of domestic wastewater on growth and yield of
fodder sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) in Karnal
(Haryana). Irrigation with wastewater resulted in
significant (P<0.05) increase in plant height, number of
leaves per plant, leaf area index, leaf to stem (green and
dry) biomass and green fodder yield. A significant
(P<0.05) decrease in dry matter content was observed in
wastewater fed plots as compared to that of tube well
water. Bedbabis et al.(2015) studied the long-term effects
of irrigation with treated municipal wastewater on soil,
yield and olive oil quality in Tunisia. Treated wastewater
irrigation of Chemlali olive trees result in significant yield
increase when compared to yields from plot irrigated with
water.
The purpose of the present work was to study the status
of plant growth with wastewater irrigation in
Vidyaranyapuram area of Mysore city, Karnataka, India,
with respect to growth and yield as compared to that of
ground water irrigated crops.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study area is located in the suburban area in the
south western part of Mysore city, Karnataka, India, near
Vidyaranyapuram sewage treatment plant (latitude
12.273681 to 12.270031 N and longitude 76.650737 to
76.655947 E) where the facility was constructed in 2002
with an area of 27.21 sq. km and a sewer length of 7000
m. Locations were selected to get information on the
effect of wastewater on soil and tomato (Lycopersicon
esculentum L.), Napier grass (P. purpureum) and
sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) crops in Mysore
city. The study also covered the physico-chemical
characteristics of water samples collected from
Vidyaranyapuram sewage treatment plant station. More
than fifty percent of the wastewater handled by Mysore
city is received by Vidyaranyapuram Sewage Treatment
Plant. The total sewage generation of sewage treatment
plant is 67.75 million liters per day. It is a biological
treatment plant situated next to the solid waste disposal
area at the foot of Chamundi Hills; the treated wastewater
of Vidyaranyapuram sewage treatment plant directly
reaches the Kabini River. The treated sewage water is
pumped out after sewage treatment to field channels for
direct use as irrigation water; also the farmers use this
untreated wastewater for irrigating various crops.
Field surveys were carried out in and around Mysore city,
to collect water and plant samples. Water samples
collected from different sources included untreated
wastewater, treated wastewater and ground water. On
the whole the samples were collected from untreated

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

World Res. J. Agric. Sci.

070

Table 1. Analyzed parameters for soil physical properties and methods were used for study of soil

Parameter
Soil Texture %
Soil Color
Determination of Cation Exchange
Capacity (CEC) Meq/100g
Measurement of bulk density (Pb) of soil
g/cc
Calculation of porosity

Test method
Mechanical analysis of soil by sieve method
Munsell Soil Color Charts, 1954 edition
Determination of CEC by Ammonium Acetate method
Determined using a clod by mercury displacement
method (Blake, 1985)
Calculation

wastewater, treated wastewater and ground water, along

with soil and crops samples from the fields irrigated with
these water sources.
The wastewater and ground water were analysed for
various, parameters of agricultural importance such as
pH, EC, nutrients and heavy metals as per standard
methods of APHA (2005). According to Soil and Plant
Analysis Laboratory Manual of International Center for
Agriculture Research in Dry Areas (ICARDA, 2001),
common soil physical measurements were conducted,
including particle size distribution, texture, porosity, bulk
density and infiltration rate as mentioned at Table 1.
Measuring plant growth and yield
Measurement of plant growth and yield of tomato, fodder
grass and sugarcane, grown on these fields and irrigated
with different water sources were done. The parameters
studied included plant height, number of leaves per plant,
stem diameter, tillers, primary branches, secondary
branches, flowers number/plant, number of fruits/plant,
total weight of fruit/plant, biomass, etc. Three replicates
were used for each treatment. Crop growth rate was
worked out as proposed by Hunt (1978).

washed to remove the soil particles. The samples were

kept in the air for drying, when the weight become stable,
the mean dry weight of the plants was calculated and
expressed as gram per plant.
Napier grass crop growth and yield measurement
All the measurements were recorded at harvest date
(eight weeks of re-growth), the recommended period for
feeding the Napier grass for animals. For collecting data
five plants were randomly and were uprooted from each
plot before harvesting for recording data. The total plant
height of Napier grass was determined basal by
recording circumference at 10 cm above ground level to
the top leaf by using measuring tape in cm. Total number
of leaves/plant was estimated from the tiller number/plant
and leaf number/tiller. The leaf length and width were
measured from five representative plants in each plot and
numbers of tillers per plant were calculated. Napier
fodder was harvested above the ground level (3-4 cm)
sample was taken for dry weight. Air dry weight dried
when was measured stability of weight was achieved and
recorded as gram per plant.
Sugarcane plant growth and yield measurement

Tomato crop growth and yield measurement

Five plants were selected at random from each replicate
treatment. The observations were recorded and the mean
values were statistically analyzed and expressed in
respective units. Height of plant was recorded from base
of the plant (fixed point) to the growing tip of the main
stem; the observations were recorded on five labeled
plants and are measured in centimeter. Fruits were
harvested at each picking and number of fruits obtained
from five plants was summed up. The average was
calculated and expressed as number of fruits per plant.
The average number of branches was counted at the end
of harvest stage and the observations were recorded
using five labeled plants and the average was worked out
and expressed in number. The mean fruit weight of five
fruits from each randomly selected observational plant
was during harvest period and the weight of fruit was
recorded by using electric balance and expressed as
gram/fruit. Five randomly selected plants were removed
from each treatment plot without damaging the roots and

For data collection five sugarcane plants from each

treatment were randomly selected for different
parameters, like cane length (cm), number of
nodes/cane, number of leaves, cane diameter (cm) and
cane weight (g). These were recorded according to the
procedure given by (Beadle, 1987). Millable cane height
of sugarcane plant was measured from the ground level
(base of plant) up to the highest visible transverse mark
below the green tops. The millable cane height was
measured by using a measuring and recorded tape in
cm. The numbers of visible nodes on five sample
sugarcane plants were counted by visual counting
method; the mean values obtained were recorded. The
average number of leaves was counted for five
sugarcane plants by visual counting method, the mean
values obtained were recorded and expressed in number.
The diameter of centrally located inter nodes was
measured by simple scale measuring method in
centimeter. The mean values obtained were calculated.
After harvesting millable cane green top was separated

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al.

071

Table 2. Parameters of physicochemical properties of waters used in the experiments

Parameter
pH
EC S/cm
DO mg/l
COD mg/l
BOD mg/l
TDS mg/l
Ca mg/l
Mg mg/l
Na mg/l
K mg/l
CO3 mg/l
HCO3 mg/l
Cl mg/l
TN mg/l
TP mg/l
SO4 mg/l
Fe mg/l
Mn mg/l
Cu mg/l
Zn mg/l
Cd mg/l
Ni mg/l
Pb mg/l
Co mg/l
Cr mg/l

UWW
7.50
1032
Nil
964
650
560
43.37
27.01
48
24
Nil
296
93
78.4
4.55
24
2.93
0.157
<0.05
0.133
0.047
0.040
0.053
0.055
0.032

TWW
8.13
1225
2.3
145
30
624
62.64
28.89
60
20
Nil
392
115
61.6
2.40
20
2.48
0.041
<0.05
0.278
0.047
0.036
0.053
0.054
0.031

GW
8.30
1099
6.9
16
2
696
56.22
68.50
56
20
40
544
17
0.56
0.053
52
0.075
0.043
<0.05
0.363
0.047
0.034
0.051
0.054
0.032

from each other. The wet weight of millable cane per

plant was determined by electronic balance.

content of UWW, TWW and GW were very low when

compared to the FAO values (1992).

Statistical analysis

The pH of UWW, TWW and GW were 7.50, 8.13 and

8.30 respectively. According to the FAO (1992) the
tolerance limit of pH of water samples for irrigation should
be 6.50 to 8.40. The EC values were 1032, 1225 and
1099 S/cm, the range based on salinity classes of
irrigation waters (Environment Protection Authority 1991),
is 780-2340 S/cm of irrigation water. It is not advisable
to use more saline water on soils with restricted drainage,
even with adequate drainage, best management practice
for salinity controls may be required, and the salt
tolerance of the plants to be irrigated must also to be
considered. The sewage water is an important source of
nutrients and can be used for irrigation under controlled
condition (Angin et al., 2005). Wastewater contains
considerable amounts of N (78.4 mg/l), P (4.55 mg/l), and
K (24 mg/l) which are considered as essential nutrients
for maintaining productivity levels (crops growth) and soil
fertility. All heavy metals analysed in irrigation water were
not at elevated levels except Cd, which was elevated in
wastewater and ground water (Table 2). In comparison
with the standard guideline for irrigation water
(FAO1992), it was found that the mean concentrations of
Fe, Mn, Cu, Zn, Ni, Pb, Co, and Cr were within the safe
limits. The level of Cd is more than 4 times in the
irrigation water than the recommended level of 0.1 mg/l
as prescribed by FAO (1992).

The recorded data were subjected to an analysis of

variance (ANOVA) as described by Steel et al. (1997).
Least significance difference test was applied to assess
significant differences between the means at 5% level of
probability. All statistical analyses were carried out using
the SAS program, Version 9.1 (SAS System, 2004).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Water quality parameters
Data presented in Table 2 show physico-chemical
properties of untreated wastewater (UWW), treated
wastewater (TWW) and ground water (GW), which were
used for irrigating of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane
crops. The chemical parameters measured were
temperature, pH, EC, DO, COD, BOD, TDS, Ca, Mg, Na,
K, CO3, HCO3, Cl, N, P, S, Fe, Mn, Cu, Zn, Cd, Ni, Pb,
Co and Cr. There were obvious differences in several
measured parameters when the results were compared
from between sites. The BOD and COD presented in
Table 2 show that UWW the values were very high when
compared to the FAO values (1992). The DO and TDS

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

World Res. J. Agric. Sci.

072

Table 3. Physical parameters of soil samples of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane

Crops

Treatment

Tomato

Napier
grass

Sugarcane

UWW

Particle
distribution, %
Sand
Silt
77.91
11.15

Size
Clay
10.94

TWW

84.03

9.89

6.08

GW
UWW

88.46
76.48

10.63
19.63

0.91
3.89

TWW

90.00

6.61

2.71

GW
UWW

89.34
87.01

7.29
6

3.37
6.99

TWW
GW

88.61
89.97

10.78
7.91

0.61
2.13

Texture
class

Colour

Bulk density
(g/cm)

Calculation
porosity %

Sandy
Loam
Loamy
sand
Sandy
Loamy
Sand
Sandy

Light
grey
Light
grey
Red
Black

1.57

41

16.27

1.67

37

13.76

1.54
1.49

42
44

5.12
12.49

Light
grey
Red
grey

1.58

40

11.33

1.64
1.65

38
38

8.22
13.93

grey
Red

1.57
1.55

41
42

10.51
6.53

Sandy
Loamy
sand
Sandy
Sandy

Physical parameter of soil

Trace metal mobility depends on soil characteristics
including soil pH and texture. Soil texture affects how well
nutrients and water are retained in the soil (Marcussen et
al., 2009). Hardy et al. (2013) reported that, sandy soils,
by nature, have low CEC, and little can be done to
change it. The CEC will vary with changes in soil pH,
organic matter and clay contents. The data on colour and
soil texture of soils are presented in (Table 3), the soils of
the sites are classified as red sandy soil in GW irrigated
soils used for tomato, fodder grass and sugarcane crops
while UWW and TWW irrigated soils were light gray
loamy sand and sandy loam, respectively, except UWW
irrigated soil used for fodder grass which is black loamy
sand. The colour of soils may be due to the organic
matter content in UWW and TWW.
The bulk density and porosity of soil samples were 1.54 1.67 g/cm for tomato soil (1.49 - 1.64 g/cm) for fodder
grass and (1.55 - 1.65 g/cm) for sugarcane. Porosity of
soils samples for tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane
were 37-42%, 38 - 44% and 38 - 42% respectively.
These results are in conformity with the findings of Tunc
and Sahin (2015), who through their study on soil
physical properties like (bulk density, particle density,
total porosity) observed that these are affected
significantly from wastewater irrigation to cauliflower and
red cabbage planting. Mollahoseini (2013) observed that
use of untreated wastewater increased bulk density of top
soil significantly (p<0.05). Several studies have shown
that wastewater irrigated soils have higher aggregate
stability and porosity and lower bulk density compared to
freshwater irrigated soils (Mojiri, 2011; Mojid and
Wyseure 2013; Vogeler, 2009). Nadav et al. (2013)
indicated that lower bulk density was obtained under
wastewater irrigation conditions. The suspended solids in
wastewater negatively affect soil porosity. Kumar and

of

CEC
Meq/100g

Chopra (2013), revealed that, insignificant changes in

bulk density of the soil were observed after irrigation with
paper mill effluent. Kumar and Chopra (2011) found that
the effluent of the Doon distillery Dehradun (Uttarakhand)
increased bulk density of soil.
Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) was higher with UWW
and TWW as compared to control GW in soils of tomato,
Napier grass and sugarcane. The values of CEC for
UWW, TWW and GW irrigated soils were16.27, 13.76
and 5.12 Meq/100g for tomato, 12.49, 11.33 and 8.22
Meq/100g for Napier grass and13.93, 10.51 and 6.53
Meq/100g for sugarcane, respectively. From the data in
Table 4.2 it is clear that, the CEC concentration in soils
irrigated with wastewater was more as compared with
ground water. The sandy soil has a good permeability
and a low CEC (few exchange sites), retains less water
and naturally loses water as well as soluble salts from the
root zone (Kallel et al. 2012). A low CEC means the soil
has a low resistance to changes in soil chemistry that are
caused by land use (Hazelton and Murphy, 2007).
Khurana and Singh (2012) reported that, field application
of all types of wastewaters significantly increased soil
cation exchange capacity (CEC). Astera (2014) reveled
that; no clear effect could be established about
wastewater irrigation on CEC.
Effect of wastewater irrigation on growth and yield
characters of tomato
The effect of wastewater irrigation on growth and yield
parameters of tomato has been given in Figures 1 and 2
which include plant height, number of fruits/plant, dry
biomass (g)/plant, fruit mean weight and number of
branches/plant. From the Figure 1 it is evident that the
plant height, number of fruits/plant and dry biomass
g/plant were 78.46 cm, 45.88 and 15.49 g/plant in UWW
and 75.13 cm, 41.48 and 14.42 g/plant in TWW sites.
Whereas in control ground water GW the corresponding

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al.

073

Figure 1. Plant height, number of fruits/plant and dry biomass g/plant of tomato irrigated
with untreated, treated wastewater and groundwater .

Figure 2. Fruit mean weight and number of branches/plant of tomato irrigated with untreated,
treated wastewater and groundwater.

figures were 61.83 cm, 36.67 and 10.61 g/plant. The

increase in UWW and TWW may be due to nutrient
enrichment in the irrigated wastewater. Fruit mean weight
and number of branches/plant of tomato are presented in
Figures 2 Fruit mean weight of tomato was not
significantly influenced by irrigation with wastewater. But
number of branches/plant increased significantly with
wastewater irrigation and they were 11.41, 10.28 and
8.66 for UWW, TWW and GW, respectively.
Results revealed that UWW and TWW irrigation always
gave the highest growth and yield, compared to ground

water (GW). Similar effects on growth and yield

parameters by wastewater irrigation were observed in
tomato crop by Gatta et al. (2015). Christou et al. (2014)
revealed that the wastewater irrigation did not
significantly affect mean fruit weight and fruit diameter of
tomato, as compared to control fresh water irrigation.
Bedbabis et al. (2015) found that wastewater irrigation of
olive trees resulted in significant yield increase when
compared to yields from plot using well water. Qaryouti et
al. (2015) concluded that, raw wastewater irrigation
increased significantly tomato crop parameters,

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

World Res. J. Agric. Sci.

074

Figure 3. Plant height, Number of leaves/plant and Leaf length of Napier grass irrigated with
untreated, treated wastewater and groundwater.

Figure 4. Leaf width, Number of tiller/plant and dry weight of Napier grass irrigated with untreated,
treated wastewater and groundwater.

cucumber plant height and fruit yield and average fruit

weight, and tomato leaf area and plant dry weight. Jiusheng et al. (2012) evaluated and found that, chlorine
injection intervals and concentrations, and their
interactions, had no significant difference on tomato plant
height and leaf area of tomato when irrigated by
wastewater effluent is applied through drip irrigation
system.
Abdoulkader et al. (2015) determined the use of
untreated wastewater and treated wastewater in irrigation
which significantly increased stem height and dry matter
of Panicum maximum compared to other treatments,
whereas irrigation with saline well water and well gave
lowest measured values. Osman et al. (2006) showed
that, irrigation of plants by untreated or treated
wastewater caused stimulation in the measured growth

parameters of Zea mays and Phaseolus vulgaris. On the

other side, there was a slight inhibitory effect of
wastewater on some measured growth parameters of
plants. Bourazanisa et al. (2015) observed that
application of treated wastewater slightly increased fruit
production during the year of high tree yield and
increased the oil content, during the year of low yield
under fresh water irrigation.
Effect of wastewater on growth and yield characters
of Napier grass
The effect of wastewater irrigation on growth and yield
parameters of Napier grass has been presented in
Figures 3 and 4, which include plant height, number of
leaves/plant, leaf length, leaf width, number of tiller/plant

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al.

075

Figure 5. Cane length, Number of nodes/cane and Number of leaves of sugarcane irrigated with
untreated, treated wastewater and groundwater

and dry weight. From the (Figure 3) it is revealed that the

plant height, number of leaves/plant and leaf length were
188.46 cm, 83.62 and 93.62 cm in UWW and 182.68 cm,
69.75 and 88.67cm in TWW and these are significantly
higher as compared to control ground water which has
reached the values as 173.69 cm, 52.50 and 81.78 cm.
This may be due to nutrient enrichment in the irrigated
wastewater. Leaf width, number of tiller/plant and dry
weight of Napier grass are shown in (Figure 4) Leaf width
of Napier grass were significantly influenced by irrigation
with wastewater which were 2.52, 2.29 and 1.91 cm for
UWW, TWW and GW respectively. Number of tiller/plant
for UWW, TWW and GW were 13.2, 10.39 and 7.99
respectively. Whereas, dry weight of Napier grass
increased significantly with wastewater irrigation which
was 186.76 and 163.3 g/plant, for UWW and TWW, as
compared to control treatment (GW) (142.6 g/plant).
Results revealed that UWW and TWW irrigation of Napier
grass always gave higher growth and yield, as compared
to ground water (GW).
The values for growth and yield parameters of Napier
grass irrigated with wastewater reported in this study
were higher than those reported by Munir et al. (2005)
who obtained high yields of forage crops such as corn
and vetch by wastewater irrigation and recommended for
successful use to irrigate and enhance growth of forage
crops. Nissim et al. (2015), showed that, irrigation with
wastewater had a positive effect on willow growth and
biomass yield. Jimnez et al. (1999) concluded that,
reuse wastewater increased significantly crop productivity
to five crops/year of alfalfa, fodder oats, tomato, barley
and maize and the yield was higher than those obtained

with rain. According to El Youssfi et al. (2012) studied the

effect of wastewater irrigation on three varieties of
quinoa. The salinity caused the depression of plant's
height, and reduced fresh and dry weights of different
parts of three varieties of plants tested. Golchin et al.
(2013) indicated that use of wastewater could improve
morphological characters, yield and yield components of
alfalfa as compared to control treatment. Increasing
wastewater concentration more than 45 % caused
poisoning effects on plants which decreased biological
yield. Gupta et al. (2015) irrigated with wastewater which
resulted in significant increase in plant height, number of
leaves per plant, leaf area index, leaf to stem (green and
dry) biomass and green fodder yield of fodder sorghum
and significant decrease in dry matter content as
compared to well water. Zema et al. (2012) investigated
the biomass yield of T. latifolia which increased by
irrigation with wastewater, while A. donax showed
greatest capacity to survive after transplanting.
Herbaceous crops irrigated with wastewater can produce
appreciable biomass and energy yields.
Effect of wastewater on growth and yield characters
of sugarcane
The effect of wastewater irrigation on growth and yield
parameters of sugarcane are given in Figures 5 and 6,
which include cane length, number of nodes/cane,
number of leaves, cane diameter and cane weight. From
Figure 5 it is revealed that the cane length, number of
nodes/cane and number of leaves are 191.86 cm, 22.48
and 39.3 in UWW and 149.4 cm, 20.54 and 27.53 in

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

World Res. J. Agric. Sci.

076

Figure 6. Cane diameter and cane weight of sugarcane irrigated with untreated, treated wastewater
and groundwater.

TWW and with respect to control ground water (GW) it is

168.42 cm, 18.7 and 22.64 this may be due to nutrient
enrichment in the irrigated wastewater. Cane diameter
and cane weight of Cane diameter (Figures 6) was
significantly influenced by irrigation with wastewater and
the values were 2.30, 2.22 and 2.01 cm for UWW, TWW
and GW respectively. Also cane weight showed highly
significant difference for UWW, TWW and GW the values
were 884.2, 723.34 and 654.78g respectively.
Results also revealed that UWW and TWW irrigated
sugarcane gave highest growth and yield for UWW and
TWW parameters, as compared to ground water (GW).
The results of growth and yield parameter values for
sugarcane crop irrigated with wastewater are closely in
accordance with the findings of by Biswas et al. (2015)
who assessed the average plant height and average
number of leaves of red amaranth (Amaranthus tricolor L
cv. Surma) cultivated by irrigation with wastewater which
were statistically identical to the control fresh water.
Ahmed et al. (2011) noted that, use of wastewater in
sugar beet irrigation led to increase in dry matter content.
Jun et al., (2015), irrigated olive trees with treated
wastewater and tap water. Plant growth was similar
irrespective of irrigation source as indicated by trunk
diameter and plant height. Ghorab and Safaa (2011)
investigated the effect of different irrigation by treatments
by wastewater which gave high growth parameter and
total dry weight in three shrubs and seven timber tree
seedlings. According to Paliwal et al. (1998), wastewater
irrigation significantly influenced growth performance of
Hardwickia binata. Shoot length, root length and root
collar diameter of H. binata seedlings increased by 25, 50
and 75% as the result of use of wastewater in different

treatments. The fresh weight of stem, root and leaves

increased with increase in the sewage water
concentration. The dry weight of plant components
increased in lower concentrations of wastewater (25 and
50%) but decreased in 100% of wastewater
concentration. Ntzala et al. (2015) found that the treated
wastewater affected significantly the dry matter yield and
non-significantly the plant height on Lactuca sativa L.
crop.

CONCLUSION
The results of this study showed the effects of irrigation
with wastewater on growth and yield of tomato, Napier
grass and sugarcane crops as compared to control grown
crops. From the above mentioned results, it can be seen
that, the effect of wastewater irrigation on growth and
yield parameters of tomato, it is observed that the plant
height, number of fruits/plant and dry biomass g/plant this
may be due to nutrient enrichment in wastewater
irrigation. Mean fruit weight of tomato was not
significantly influenced by wastewater irrigation. While
number of branches/plant increased significantly with
wastewater irrigation. From growth and yield parameters
of Napier grass it revealed that UWW and TWW irrigation
of Napier grass gave higher growth and yield, compared
to groundwater irrigation. In Napier grass plant height,
number of leaves/plant, leaf length, leaf width, number of
tillers/plant and dry weight, were significantly higher with
UWW and TWW irrigation as compared to that of
groundwater. Results from sugarcane crops showed that
UWW and TWW irrigated sugarcane gave higher growth

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al.

077

and yield or yield traits as compared to that of

groundwater irrigation. It could be suggested that usage
of wastewater could affect positively on growth and yield,
these effects could be attributed to increase of nutrients
like N, and P in wastewater, so that as a function could
improve plant growth and yield of Napier grass and
sugarcane crops could be improve with UWW and TWW
compared to that of groundwater irrigation.

REFERENCES
Abdoulkader BA, Bourioug Mohamed B, Nabil M, AlaouiSoss B, Erice E, Aleya L (2015). Wastewater use in
agriculture in Djibouti: Effectiveness of sand filtration
treatments and impact of wastewater irrigation on
growthand yield of Panicum maximum. Ecological
Engineering 84, 607614.
Abu Nada Ziyad (2009). Long term impact of wastewater
irrigation on soil and crop quality parameters in Gaza
strip. Master Thesis, Islamic University of Gaza.
Aghtape A, Ghanbari A, Sirousmehr A, Siahsar B,
Asgharipour M, Tavssol A (2011). Effect of irrigation
with wastewater and foliar fertilizer application on some
forage characteristics of foxtail millet (Setaria italica),
International Journal of Plant Physiology and
Biochemistry, 3(3), pp. 34-42.
Ahmed A, Afifi Kh M, Abd El-Rheem, Refat A, Youssef
(2011). Influence of Sewage Water Reuse Application
on Soil and the Distribution of Heavy Metals. Nature
Sci. 9(4):82-88.
Angin I, Yaganoglu AV, Turan M (2005). Effect of long
term waste water irrigation on soil properties. J. Agric.
26: 31-42.
APHA (2005). Standard methods for examination of
water and wastewater. 21th ed. American Public Health
Association, Washington, DC, USA.
Astera M (2014). The Ideal Soil: A Handbook for the New
Agriculture,
Available
from:
http://www.soilminerals.com.
Beadle CL (1987). Plant growth analysis. In: Techniques
nd
in bioproductivity and photosynthesis. 2 Coombs,
(Eds.): J.D.O. Hall. S.P. Long and J.M.O. Scurlok. Per
Raoman Press, Oxford New York, pp. 21-23.
Bedbabis S, Trigui D, Ahmed CB, Clodoveo ML,
Camposeo S, Vivaldi GA, Rouina BB (2015). Longterms
effects
of irrigation with
treated
municipal wastewater on soil, yield and olive oil quality.
Agricultural Water Management, Vol: 160, 14-21.
Biswas GC, Sarkar A, Rashid MH, Shohan MH, Islam M,
Wang Q (2015). Assessment of the irrigation feasibility
of low-cost filtered municipal wastewater for red
amaranth
(Amaranthus
tricolor L
cv.
Surma).
International
Soil
and
Water
Conservation
Research, Vol: 3, Issue 3, 239-252.
Blake GR, Hartge KH (1985). Bulk Density. Methods of
Soil Analysis, Part 1, Soil Sci. Soc. Am., Madison, WI,
USA, 363-376.

Bourazanisa G, Roussosb PA, Argyrokastritisc I,

Kosmasd C, Kerkides P (2015). Evaluation of the use
of treated municipal waste water on the yield,oil quality,
free fatty acids profile and nutrient levels in olive trees
cvKoroneiki,
in
Greece.
Agricultural
Water
Management, 163, 18.
Christou A, Maratheftis G, Eliadou E, Michael C, Hapeshi
E, Fatta-Kassinos D (2014). Impact assessment of the
reuse of two discrete treated wastewaters for
the irrigation of tomato crop on the soil geochemical
properties, fruit safety and crop productivity.
Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol: 192, 105114.
El Youssfi L, Choukr-Allah R, Zaafrani M, Mediouni T, Ba
Samba M, Hirich A (2012). Effect of Domestic Treated
Wastewater use on Three Varieties of Quinoa
(Chenopodium quinoa) under Semi Arid Conditions.
International Science Index Vol:6, No:8, 116-119.
waset.org/Publication/8903.
Environment Protection Authority (1991). Guidelines for
wastewater irrigation. Publication 168, Environment
Protection Authority, Melbourne.
FAO (1992). Wastewater treatment and use in
agriculture. Pescod M.B. Irrigation and Drainage.
Paper 47. FAO, Rome.
Farahat E, Linderholm HW (2015). The effect of longterm wastewater irrigation on accumulation and transfer
of heavy metals in Cupressus sempervirens leaves and
adjacent soils. Science of the Total Environment, Vol:
512513, 1-7.
Gatta G, Libutti A, Gagliardi A, Beneduce L, Brusetti L,
Borruso L, Disciglio G, Tarantino E (2015). Treated
agro-industrial wastewater irrigation of tomato crop:
Effects on qualitative/quantitative characteristics of
production and microbiological properties of the soil.
Agricultural Water Management, Vol: 149, 33-43.
Ghorab SAS (2011). Recycling of biotreated tannery
wastewater in planting of some hyeperaccumulation
shrubs and timber trees species . J. Plant Production,
Mansoura Univ., Vol. 2 (6): 797 809.
Golchin L, salmasi SZ, Shafagh-kolvanagh J, Shahin
oustan, Shokati B, Hashemi-Amidi N, Haghverdi H
(2013). Effects of irrigation times and wastewater
concentration of a leaven producing factory (Iran
Mayeh) on some morphological characters of alfalfa.
Intl J Agri Crop Sci. Vol., 5 (23), 2831-2836.
Gupta SP, Gajender, Yadav RK, Magan S, Koushik P
(2015). Effect of irrigation schedules of domestic waste
water on growth and yield of fodder sorghum. Indian
Journal of Small Ruminants. Vol.: 21:2, 257-263. Article
DOI : 10.5958/0973-9718.2015.00073.2.
Hardy DH, Tucker MR, Stokes C (2013). Understanding
the
soil
test
report.
Retrieved
from:
http://www.ncagr.gov/agronomi/pdffiles/ustr.pdf
Hazelton P, Murphy B (2007). Interpreting soil test
results. What do all the numbers mean? CSIRO
Publishing,
Victoria,
160pp.
http//:
http://www.publish.csiro.au/

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

World Res. J. Agric. Sci.

Hunt R (1978) Plant Growth Analysis. Edward Arnold,

U.K: 26-38.
ICARDA (2001). Soil and Plant Analysis Laboratory
Manual, International Center for Agricultural Research
in the Dry Areas, Ryan, J.; Estefan, G.; Rashid, A.,pp
172.
Jimnez B, Chvez A, Hernndez C (1999). Alternative
Wastewater Treatment Intended for Agricultural Use.
Water Science and Technology.; 40(4-5) 355-362.
Jiu-sheng LI, LI Yan-feng L.I, Hang Z (2012). Tomato
Yield and Quality and Emitter Clogging as Affected by
Chlorination Schemes of Drip Irrigation Systems
Applying Sewage Effluent. Journal of Integrative
Agriculture, 11(10): 1744-1754.
Jou PH, Mohammadi E, Mohammadi M (2015). The
effect of quality and different levels of irrigation on the
growth and yield of maize seeds in Kerman, Iran.
International Journal of Biosciences (IJB). Vol. 6 No. 4,
64-71.
Kallel M, Belaid N, Ayoub T, Ayadi A, Mohamed Ksibi M
(2012). Effects of Treated Wastewater Irrigation on
Soil Salinity and Sodicity at El Hajeb Region (SfaxTunisia). Journal of Arid Land Studies. 22-1, 65 -68.
Kelepertzis E (2014). Accumulation of heavy metals in
agricultural soils of Mediterranean: insights from
Argolida basin, Peloponnese, Greece. Geoderma 221
222: 8290.
Khurana MPS, Singh P (2012). Waste Water Use in Crop
Production: A Review. Resources and Environment,
2(4): 116-131.
Kumar V, Chopra AK (2013). Distribution, Enrichment
and Accumulation of Heavy Metals in Soil
and Trigonella foenum-graecum L. (Fenugreek) after
Fertigation with Paper Mill Effluent. Open Journal of
Metal, 3, 8-20
Kumar V, Chopra AK (2011). Impact on physico-chemical
characteristics of soil after irrigation with distillery
effluent. Arch. Appl. Sci. Res.: 3 (4)63-77.
Mahesh J,
Amerasinghe P, Pavelic P (2015). An
integrated approach to assess the dynamics of a periurban watershed influenced by wastewater irrigation.
Journal of Hydrology, Vol: 523, 427-440.
Marcussen H, Holm PE, Strobel BW, Hansen HCB
(2009). Nickel sorption to goethite and montmorillonite
in presence of citrate. Environmental Science and
Technology, 43: 11221127.
Mojid MA, Wyseure GCL (2013). Implications of
municipal wastewater irrigation on soil health from a
study in Bangladesh. Soil Use Manage. 29, 384396.
Mojiri A (2011). Effects of municipal wastewater on
physical and chemical properties of saline soil. J. Biol.
Environ. Sci. 5, 7176.
Mollahoseini H (2013). Long term effects of municipal
wastewater irrigation on some properties of a semiarid
region soil of Iran. International journal of Agronomy
and Plant Production. 4(5), 1023-1028.

078

Munir JM, Ayadi M (2004). Forage yield and nutrient

uptake as influenced by secondary treated
wastewater. Journal of Plant Nutrition 27: 351-365,
Nadav I, Tarchitzky J, Chen Y, (2013). Water repellency
induced by organic matter (OM) in treated wastewater
(TWW) infiltration ponds and irrigation. In: Jianming, X.,
Jianjun, W., Yan, H. (Eds.), Functions of Natural
Organic Matter in Changing Environment. Springer,
Netherlands, pp. 883887.
Nissim WG, Jerbi A, Lafleur B, Fluet R, Labrecque M
(20150.
Willows
for
the
treatment
of
municipal wastewater:
Performance
under
different irrigation rates. Ecological Engineering, Vol:
81, 395-404.
Ntzala G, Kalavrouziotis IK, Koukoulakis PH,
Papadopoulos AH (20150. Impact of sludge and
wastewater on Lactuca sativa L. Growth and on soil
pollution. Global Nest Journal,17 (1):148-161.
Osman MEH, EI-Shouny WA,
EI-Sheekh MM, EIGammal EWE (2006). Effect of Sewage Wastewater
Treated by Nostoc muscorum and Anabaena
subcylindrica on the Growth of Zea mays and
Phaseolus vulgaris. Journal of Plant Biology, 49(5):398402.
Paliwal K, Karunaichamy KSTK, Ananthavalli M (1998).
Effect of sewage water irrigation on growth
performance, biomass and nutrient accumulation in
Hardwickia
binata
under
nursery
conditions.
Bioresource Technology, 66, 105-111.
Petousi I, Fountoulakis MS, Saru ML, Nikolaidis N,
Fletcher L, Stentiford EI, Manios T (2015). Effects of
reclaimed wastewater irrigation on
olive
(Olea
europaea L. cv. Koroneiki) trees. Agricultural Water
Management, Vol: 160, 33-40.
Qaryouti M, Bani-Hani N, Abu-Sharar TM, Shnikat I,
Hiari M, Radiadeh M (2015). Effect of using raw waste
water from food industry on soil fertility, cucumber and
tomato growth, yield and fruit quality. Scientia
Horticulturae. 193, 99104.
Raschid-Sally L, Jayakody P (2008). Drivers and
characteristics of wastewater agriculture in developing
countries: Results from a global assessment, Colombo,
Sri Lanka, IWMI Research Report 127, International
Water Management Institute, Colombo
Rusan M, Bashabsheh I, Safi M (2008). Reuse of
Treated Wastewater for Cut Flowers Production and
Impact on Soil and Plant Quality Parameters, ICCBT
2008 - D - (06) - pp63-78.
SAS (2004). Statistical Analysis System, SAS Institute,
Inc. Cary., N. C. USA.
Steel RGD, Torrie J, Dickey DA (1997). Principles and
Procedures of Statistics: A Biometrical Approach, 3rd
edition. McGraw Hill Book Co., New York.
Tavassoli A, Ghanbari A, Amiri E, Paygozar Y (2010).
Effect of municipal wastewater with manure and
fertilizer on yield and quality characteristics of forage in

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India

Alghobar et al.

079

corn, African Journal of Biotechnology, 9(17), pp 25152520.

Tunc T, Sahin U (2015). The changes in the physical and
hydraulic properties of a loamy soil under irrigation with
simpler-reclaimed wastewaters. Agricultural Water
Management, Vol: 158, 213-224
Vogeler I (20090. Effect of long-term wastewater
application on physical soil properties. Water Air Soil
Pollut. 196, 385392.
Zema DA, Bombino G, Andiloro S, Zimbone SM (2012).
Irrigation of energy crops with urban wastewater:
Effects on biomass yields, soils and heating values.
Agricultural Water Management, 115, 55-65.
Accepted 28 June, 2016.

Citation: Alghobar MA, Suresha S (2016). Growth and

yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as
influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka,
India. World Research Journal of Agricultural Sciences,
3(1): 069-079.

Copyright: 2016 Alghobar and Suresha. This is an

open-access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original author and source are
cited.

Growth and yield of tomato, Napier grass and sugarcane crops as influenced by wastewater irrigation in Mysore, Karnataka, India