Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
doi:10.14355/ijes.2013.0306.03
www.ijesci.org
ACriticalReviewonEnhancementinSystem
PerformanceofFlatPlateHybridPV/TSolar
CollectorSystem
V.N.Palaskar1,S.P.Deshmukh2
DepartmentofMechanicalEngineering,VeermataJijabaiTechnologicalInstitute,Mumbai,India
DepartmentofGeneralEngineering,InstituteofChemicalTechnology(DeemedUniversity),Mumbai,India
1
2
Abstract
The combined efficiency i.e. electrical and thermal of a
simpleflatplatesolarhybridPV/Twater/aircollectorsystem
islow.Thereforeabovesystemsarecommerciallynotviable
till date. To make these systems commercially viable,
development in the system configurations can be done by
modifyingPVabsorbershape,size&materials,andalsoby
attaching various types of diffuse reflectors or flat
concentrators to the sides of commercial PV module. PV
absorbersurfacedesignwithvariousconfigurationssuchas
simpleopenairchannel,singlepasswithrectangulartunnel,
spiralflowabsorbercollector,thinmetallicsheetsuspended
at the middle of air channel, fins at the back wall of an air
duct etc., are used in a simple flat plate solar hybrid PV/T
water/air collector systems to enhance its system
performanceatonesunconcentrationandabove.
ThisarticlereviewsasimpleflatplatehybridPV/Twater/air
collector systems with and without PV absorber surface
design with various configurations as discussed above.
Finally effect of attaching a flat concentrators or diffuse
reflectorswithunglazedandglazedsurfaceonperformance
ofthesesystemsisalsodiscussedandanalyzed.
Keywords
Hybrid Solar System; Photovoltaic/ Thermal Collector; Flat
Concentrators;DiffusesReflectors
Introduction
An absorbed solar radiation by PV module results in
generationofelectricityanditsheating.CoolingofPV
modules improves its electrical efficiency at a
reasonable level. The natural or forced air circulation
isasimpleandlowcostmethodtoremovewasteheat
from back side of commercial PV module. But this
method is less effective if ambient air temperature is
over 20 0C. The water heat extraction is more
expensivethanairheatextraction,butitisusedforthe
above application, as the water temperature from
mains is normally under 20 0C throughout the year.
The usual mode of PV cooling is by circulation of
water through a heat exchanger or PV absorber
surfaceattatchinthermalcontactwithPVmoduleon
rear surface. In a simple flat plate solar hybrid PV/T
water/aircollectorsystems,thePVpanelsandthermal
units are mounted together and the systems can
simultaneouslyconvertsolarradiationintoelectricity
andthermalenergy.ThehybridPV/Tsystemsprovide
a higher energy output than standard PV panels and
could be the cost effective in near future if the
additionalcostofthethermalcomponentislow.
An extension of the HottelWhiller model had been
usedfortheanalysisofhybridPV/Tcollectorsystems
for both thermal and electrical performance of a
combined collector systems as a function of collector
design parameters (Florschuetz LW 1979). A hybrid
PV/T collector system consists of a PV panel which
wasplacedonathermalcollectorwithagapbetween
themhadbeenusedtoachieveaneffectivePVcooling
with increament in electrical efficiency (T. Takashima
etal.1994).AhybridPV/Tcollectorsystemwithlow,
mediumorhighconcentrationreflectorswasattached
with the above modified system (AlBaali 1986).
Becauseofthismodification,theelectricalandthermal
output of a hybrid PV/T collector system was found
increasedsignificantly.
The effect ofplane booster reflector had been studied
forsolarairheaterswithsolarcellswereusedforsolar
drying applications (H.P. Garg 1991). A new type of
PV/T collector system with dual heat extraction
operationeitherwateroraircirculationwasstudied(Y.
Tripanagnostopoulosetal.2001).TheabovedualPV/T
collector system had been combined with booster
diffuse reflectors, achieving a significant increase in
outputofelectricalandthermalenergy.
The different experiments had been performed on
hybrid PV/T water collector system by attaching flat
AluminumconcentratorswithcommercialPVmodule
(Lj. Kostic et al. 2009). The final results showed that
electrical and thermal energy generated by hybrid
395
www.ijesci.orgInternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
ThreePV/Twatercollectorsystemshadbeendesigned
and their thermal performances had been compared
suchasdirectflowPV/T,ParallelflowPV/TandSplit
flowPV/Tsystems(KamaruzzamanSopianetal.).Out
ofthesethreePV/Tsystems,thesplitflowPV/Tdesign
had showed better thermal performance compared to
other two PV/T systems such as direct flow and
parallelflow.
FIGURE1:SOLARPHOTOVOLTAICTHERMALAIR
COLLECTOR
396
FIGURE2:SINGLEPASSSOLARCOLLECTORSYSTEM
InternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
www.ijesci.org
FIGURE3:COMPARISONOFPANELSTEMPERATURE
FIGURE6:CROSSSECTIONALVIEWOFPV/TAIRCOLLECTOR
MODELS
Duringtheexperiments,combinationssuchasnatural
andforceairflowcirculationforREF,TFMSandFIN
models had been used at a time. For forced air flow
circulation experiments, the air circulation was
maintained by using air pump. For natural air flow
circulation experiments, the inlet and outlet vents
were left open to atmosphere for freeair flow
circulation.
Under forced flow air circulation the results showed
that, the Fin system yields high thermal efficiency of
30%; followed by TFMS with 28% and lastly the
typical with 25% for REF model respectively. Under
natural air flow circulation the final results obtained
that the Fin system yields high thermal efficiency of
20%; followed by TFMS with 18% and lastly 16% for
REFmodelrespectivelyatnoonday.
FIGURE4:ELECTRICALEFFICIENCYOFBOTHCOLLECTORS
FIGURE5:THERMALEFFICIENCYOFBOTHCOLLECTORS
397
www.ijesci.orgInternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
FIGURE7:THEDESIGNOFSPIRALFLOWABSORBER
COLLECTOR
Thethermalandelectricalefficienciesofthesesystems
hadbeenusedtocalculatemonthlyandannualenergy
output by using experimental calculation. These
resultswerecomparedwiththeelectricalperformance
of the PV/T water collector systems and that of
standard PV modules of the same type in a typical
installationandwithdiffusereflectors.
TABLE1ANNUALSYSTEMENERGYOUTPUTINkWh/m2Y
FIGURE8:CROSSSECTIONOFTHEPV/TEXPERIMENTAL
MODELS.
SYSTEM
Annul
Electrical
Energy
KWh/m2y
%Of
nput
energy
Annul
Thermal
Energy
KWh/m2y
%Of
input
energy
PV
MOUDLES
182.84
11.12
PV+REF
MOUDLES
217.53
13.23
PVT/UNGL
250C
178.43
10.85
537.87
32.70
PVT/UNGL
350C
166.17
10.10
217.13
13.20
PVT/UNGL
450C
161.19
9.80
35.79
2.18
PVT/UNGL
+REF250C
198.62
12.08
619.77
37.68
PVT/UNGL
+REF350C
186.02
11.31
275.53
16.75
PVT/UNGL
+REF450C
143.57
8.73
263.96
16.05
PVT/GL
250C
149.33
9.08
776.30
47.20
PVT/GL
350C
137.55
8.36
467.98
28.45
PVT/GL
450C
125.25
7.62
220.39
13.40
PVT/GL
+REF250C
167.98
10.21
831.75
50.57
PVT/GL
+REF350C
155.77
9.47
519.15
31.56
PVT/GL
+REF450C
143.57
8.73
263.96
16.05
TableIshowsfinalvaluesofannualenergyoutputfor
allsystemsoftheannualsolarinputonthePVplane.
FIGURE9:APV/TSYSTEMSWITHDIFFUSEREFLECTORS
398
InternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
www.ijesci.org
Alsothesolarradiationintensityhadaugmentedupto
65.6% byattachingAluminum foil concentrators with
PV/T collector system, in relation to without
concentrators. Because of this increment in solar
radiation intensity, the thermal and electrical energy
produce by PV/T water collector system had been
improvedby55%and17.10%respectively.
FIGURE10,MEASUREMENTSOFCONCENTRATEDSOLAR
RADIATIONBYMINIKLADEVICE.
Thesolarradiationintensityhadbeenincreasedupto
43.6 % by attaching Aluminum sheet concentrators
with PV/T collector system, in relation to without
concentrators. Because of this increment in solar
radiation intensity, the thermal and electrical energy
produce by PV/T water collector system had
augmentedby39%and8.60%respectively.
FIGURE11:SOLARPVPANELEQUIPPEDWITHWATERFILM
PRODUCER
Afilmofwaterhadbeenproducedoverthepanelbya
tubewithaslitalongthetopendofthePVpanel(Fig.
11).Awaterpumpwasusedtofedwatertothetube,
399
www.ijesci.orgInternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
FIGURE14:DIRECTPV/TWATERCOLLECTORSYSTEM
FIGURE12:COMPARISONOFCONVENTIONALPVPANEL
TEMPERATUREWITHTHETEMPERATUREOFTHEPANELIN
THECOMBINEDPV/TSYSTEM.
FIGURE15:PARALLELFLOWPV/TCOLLECTORSYSTEM
FIGURE13:COMPARISONOFCONVENTIONALPVPANEL
OVERALLEFFICIENCYWITHTHEOVERALLEFFICIENCYOF
THECOMBINEDPV/TSYSTEM
ThreePV/Twatercollectorsystemshadbeendesigned,
tested and their thermal performances had been
compared (Kamaruzzaman Sopian et al.), shown in
Fig.14to16.
400
FIGURE16:SPLITFLOWPV/TWATERCOLLECTORSYSTEM.
InternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
www.ijesci.org
Conclusions
After applying above system configurations
techniques to simple flat plate hybrid PV/T water/air
collector systems, an improvement in combined
system performance took place. So single pass with
rectangular tunnel collector, spiral flow absorber
collector, thin metallic sheet suspended at the middle
of air channel, fins at the back wall of an air duct etc
has been used to cool under side of PV module to
maintainconstantopencircuitvoltage(VOC)ofthePV
module. Attaching flat concentrators or diffuse
reflectors to PV module, the short circuit current (ISC)
of the PV modules has been augmented. So the
combined effects of above configurations have
enhanced electrical performance of the hybrid PV/T
water/air collector system compared to simple flat
platehybridPV/Twater/airsystems.Whentheabove
systemconfigurationstechniqueshavebeenappliedto
these systems, enhancement in thermal performance
took place too. Hence the combined system
performancei.e.electricalandthermalperformanceof
thesesystemstookplace.
FIGURE17:THERMALEFFICIENCYOFPV/TSYSTEMSWHEN
WATERINPUTTEMPERATURE260CANDAMBIENT
TEMPERATURE250C.
Adnan
Ibrahim,
Mohd.
HafidzRuslan,Sohif
Yusof
Mat ,
Othman,
Azami
Zaharim
Mohd
and
UniversityKebangsaanMalaysia.
FIGURE18:THERMALEFFICIENCYOFPV/TSYSTEMSWHEN
WATERINPUTTEMPERATURE310CANDAMBIENT
TEMPERATURE250C
401
www.ijesci.orgInternationalJournalofEnergyScience(IJES)Volume3Issue6,December2013
heatextractionoperation.InProc.17thPVSolarEnergy
collectors.SolEnergy6(1979);22:361.Adelman,Rachel.
ConferenceMunich,2226Octpp25152518.
Gohlijin,AdnanIbrahim,YeeKimChean,RoonakDaghigh,
Patra26504,Greece,RenewableEnergy32(2007)623637.
Kamaruzzaman Sopian, Goh Li Jin, Mohd. Yusof Othman,
Saleem H. Zaidi, Mohd Hafidz Ruslan: Advanced
Absorber Design for Photovoltaic Thermal (PV/T)
Collectors, Recent Researches in Energy, Environment
andLandscapeArchitecture,ISBN:9781618040527.
Lj.Kostic,T.PavlovicandZ.PavlovicInfluenceofPhysical
Characteristics of Flat Aluminum Concentrators on
Emailaddress:vnpalskar@vjti.org.in
UniversityofRomeLaSapienza,Rome.
Y. Tripanagnostopoulos Y., Tzavellas D., Zoulia I. And
Emailaddress:sp.deshmukh@ictmumbai.edu.in
402