Date of Request: June 30, 2011

Due Date: July 22, 2011

Request No. DPS-15

NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION d/b/a National Grid

Case 11-T-0068 - Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation d/b/a National Grid
Mohican to Battenkill Article VII Application
Request for Information
FROM: Edward Schrom and Vijay Puran
TO:
Request
Subject: Transmission Line
Reference:
1. If Niagara Mohawk were to install the new towers next to the existing towers: please
state how close the new towers could be constructed if one side of the existing tower
arms was removed (assuming one new circuit is installed on the new tower first). Please
explain your answer and include any explanatory supporting drawings or documentation.

Response:
1. Assuming the replacement structure types are the same as those proposed in the
Application, the closest the new structures could be constructed to the existing ones is
five feet, measured from structure centerline to structure centerline.
Because the existing A Flex Towers and A+10 Flex Towers have continuous arm
members supporting the circuits on both sides of the towers, five feet is the minimum
distance whether or not the existing arms are removed on one side. Removal of one side
of the arm from the insulator attachment point on the tower body connection will create
excessive loads on the opposite side of the arm (the side with the conductor still
attached). It is possible to alleviate this condition, but that necessitates either use of an
intermediate structure or a temporary structure to support the conductor on the side being
replaced, or reinforcement of the flex tower prior to its retirement. Attachment A, A
Flex Tower Analysis, which includes a tower loading drawing and element usage report
for an A Flex Tower, further illustrates this loading case. (The attachment is illustrative
for the A+10 Flex Tower as well, since that type is identical to the A Flex Tower except
for a ten foot tower extension at its base.)
National Grid notes that placing the new structures five feet from the centerline of the
existing structures would not materially change the amount of additional vegetation

management rights area required. This spacing would necessitate approximately 37.5
acres of additional vegetation management rights area, only slightly less than the
approximately 39.4 acres required for the Project as proposed in the Application.
Finally, placement of the new structures five feet from the centerline of the existing
structures would increase the Project cost by approximately $1,750,000 because it would
necessitate multiple trips to each structure work site to construct one circuit on the first
side of the double circuit structure under one outage, then the opposite circuit under a
different line outage.
Date of Reply: July 22, 2011
Name of Respondent: Jessica Farrell
Title of Respondent: Senior Engineer (National Grid)

Commonwealth Associates, Inc., Project: "temp construction-a-flex tower"

Tower Version 11.00, 12:43:09 PM Thursday, July 07, 2011
Undeformed geometry displayed
Attachment
115kV MOHICAN BATTENKILL REBUILD
TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION A-FLEX
TOWER ANALYSIS
RESPONSE TO DPS-15

Z
X

A to DPS-15

% Usage Legend
0 <= % < 25
25 <= % < 50
50 <= % < 75
75 <= % < 100
100 <= %

Analysis Results:
Maximum element usage is 443.89% for Angle "XARMMIDP" in load case "4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA-,I NA-"
NG
Maximum insulator usage is 29.59% for Suspen "MNTBTM" in load case "INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I NA-"
Summary of Joint Support Reactions For All Load Cases:
Load Case Joint
Label

Long. Tran. Vert. Shear Tran. Long. Vert. Bending Found.

Force Force Force Force Moment Moment Moment Moment Usage
(kips) (kips) (kips) (kips) (ft-k) (ft-k) (ft-k) (ft-k)
%
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1-NESC H INTACT NA+,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -3.82 56.79
3.82
3.03
0.27 -0.08
3.04
0.00
1-NESC H INTACT NA+,I NA+ 200X
0.00 -3.01 -40.40
3.01
2.80
0.27
0.02
2.82
0.00
1-NESC H INTACT NA-,I NA- 200P
0.00
2.95 -17.96
2.95 -4.18
0.27 -0.08
4.19
0.00
1-NESC H INTACT NA-,I NA- 200X
0.00
3.88 34.35
3.88 -4.52
0.27
0.02
4.53
0.00
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA+,I NA+ 200P
0.01 -2.06 31.38
2.06
1.60
0.57 -0.18
1.70
0.00
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA+,I NA+ 200X
0.01 -1.65 -23.62
1.65
1.46
0.55
0.02
1.56
0.00
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA-,I NA- 200P
0.01
1.65 -13.77
1.65 -2.09
0.57 -0.18
2.17
0.00
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA-,I NA- 200X
0.01
2.06 21.53
2.06 -2.23
0.55
0.02
2.30
0.00
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA+,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.07
1.60
0.07
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.01
0.00
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA+,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.07
1.21
0.07 -0.04
0.00
0.00
0.04
0.00
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA-,I NA- 200P
0.00 -0.07
1.60
0.07
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.01
0.00
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA-,I NA- 200X
0.00
0.07
1.21
0.07 -0.04
0.00
0.00
0.04
0.00
4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA+,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -2.09 49.58
2.09
0.35
0.04 -0.01
0.35
0.00
4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA+,I NA+ 200X
0.00 -0.64 -22.14
0.64 -0.11
0.03
0.00
0.12
0.00
4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA-,I NA- 200P
0.00
0.63 17.51
0.63 -2.41
0.04 -0.01
2.41
0.00
4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA-,I NA- 200X
0.00
2.10
9.93
2.10 -2.90
0.03
0.00
2.90
0.00
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA+,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -2.00 35.04
2.00
1.21
0.15 -0.04
1.22
0.00
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA+,I NA+ 200X
0.00 -1.29 -21.28
1.29
0.99
0.15
0.01
1.00
0.00
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA-,I NA- 200P
0.00
1.27 -1.93
1.27 -2.21
0.15 -0.04
2.21
0.00
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA-,I NA- 200X
0.00
2.02 15.69
2.02 -2.47
0.15
0.01
2.47
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 11 AHEAD,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 11 AHEAD,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 1 BACK,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 1 BACK,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 12 AHEAD,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 12 AHEAD,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 2 BACK,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 2 BACK,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 13 AHEAD,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 13 AHEAD,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 3 BACK,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 3 BACK,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 14 AHEAD,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 14 AHEAD,I NA+ 200X
0.00
0.32 -1.28
0.32 -0.57
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 4 BACK,I NA+ 200P
2.47 -0.29 11.73
2.49 -0.31 157.18 -53.60 157.18
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 4 BACK,I NA+ 200X
2.42
0.29 -0.75
2.44 -0.49 153.68
6.04 153.69
0.00
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 15 AHEAD,I NA+ 200P
0.00 -0.32 13.30
0.32 -0.36
0.00
0.00
0.36
0.00
Commonwealth Associates, Inc. - temp construction-a-flex tower

Page 1/5

7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 15 AHEAD,I

7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 5 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 5 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 16 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 16 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 6 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 6 BACK,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA+,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA+,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA-,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA-,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA+,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA+,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
60 Deg F,I
60 Deg F,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA+,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA+,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA-,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA-,I

NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NANANA+
NA+
NANANA+
NA+
NANANA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NANA-

200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X
200P
200X

0.00
2.52
2.48
0.00
0.00
2.67
2.55
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.32
-0.29
0.29
-0.32
0.32
-0.29
0.29
-1.64
-1.09
1.06
1.67
-1.90
-0.58
0.57
1.91
-0.66
-0.23
0.22
0.67
-0.19
0.19
-3.41
-2.59
2.54
3.46

-1.28
11.38
-0.40
13.30
-1.28
11.71
-0.74
27.89
-16.97
-2.01
12.93
45.08
-20.13
15.92
9.03
13.77
-5.36
5.10
3.30
7.83
-0.71
52.30
-35.92
-13.48
29.86

0.32
2.54
2.49
0.32
0.32
2.69
2.56
1.64
1.09
1.06
1.67
1.90
0.58
0.57
1.91
0.66
0.23
0.22
0.67
0.19
0.19
3.41
2.59
2.54
3.46

-0.57
-0.28
-0.47
-0.36
-0.57
-0.31
-0.49
1.06
0.89
-1.83
-2.04
0.32
-0.10
-2.19
-2.64
0.24
0.11
-0.76
-0.92
-0.21
-0.33
2.59
2.36
-3.75
-4.08

0.00
0.00
134.78 -57.44
130.34 -6.45
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
118.75 -43.34
113.83 -5.39
0.17 -0.05
0.16
0.01
0.17 -0.05
0.16
0.01
0.03 -0.01
0.03
0.00
0.03 -0.01
0.03
0.00
0.03 -0.01
0.03
0.00
0.03 -0.01
0.03
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.22 -0.06
0.21
0.02
0.22 -0.06
0.21
0.02

0.57
134.78
130.35
0.36
0.57
118.75
113.83
1.07
0.91
1.83
2.04
0.32
0.11
2.19
2.64
0.24
0.11
0.76
0.92
0.21
0.33
2.60
2.37
3.75
4.09

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Note: Summary of Joint Support Reactions For All Load Cases in Direction of Leg not printed
because none of the angle members attached to foundation joints have a group type of 'Leg'.
Sections Information:
Section
Label

Top Bottom Joint Member Tran. Face Tran. Face Tran. Face Long. Face Long. Face Long. Face
Z
Z Count Count Top Width Bot Width Gross Area Top Width Bot Width Gross Area
(ft)
(ft)
(ft)
(ft)
(ft^2)
(ft)
(ft)
(ft^2)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Section1 65.450 45.000
17
34
0.00
0.00
0.000
2.66
0.00
113.861 Section
"Section1" has a transverse face gross area of 0.0, wind loads will not be calculated correctly for this section
Section2 45.000 7.002
14
24
0.00
0.00
0.000
4.64
8.32
246.277 Section
"Section2" has a transverse face gross area of 0.0, wind loads will not be calculated correctly for this section
Section3 7.002 0.000
6
6
0.00
0.00
0.000
8.32
9.00
60.644 Section
"Section3" has a transverse face gross area of 0.0, wind loads will not be calculated correctly for this section
*** Overall summary for all
Printed capacities do not
The Group Summary reports
which may not necessarily

??
??
??

load cases - Usage = Maximum Stress / Allowable Stress

include the strength factor entered for each load case.
on the member and load case that resulted in maximum usage
be the same as that which produces maximum force.

Commonwealth Associates, Inc. - temp construction-a-flex tower

Page 2/5

Group Summary (Compression Portion):

Group
Comp.
RLX
Label
Connect.

Group
RLY

RLZ

L/R
Desc.

Bearing

Angle
Angle
Steel
Max
KL/R Length Curve
No.
Type
Size Strength Usage
Comp.
No.
Of
Member

Max

Comp.

Use

Control

In

Member

Comp.

L/R

Comp.

Force Control Capacity Connect.

Load

Shear

Case

Capacity

Bolts
Comp.

Capacity

Comp.

Comp.
(ksi)

%
%
(kips)
(kips)
(kips)
(kips)
(ft)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEG10
10IN CHANNEL
CHN
10X15.3
30.0 92.64 92.64
LEG1P -56.8821-NESC H 130.816
61.400
216.000 1.000 1.000 1.000
33.74
33.74 2.004
1
10 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following
members (make sure your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): LEG1P LEG1X LEG2P LEG2X LEG3P LEG3X LEG4P
LEG4X LEG5P LEG5X LEG6P LEG6X ??
LEG9
9IN CHANNEL
CHN
9X13.4
30.0 65.29 65.29
LEG8P -54.4794-NATGRI
83.439
0.000
0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 107.75 107.75 6.007
1
0 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following members
(make sure your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): LEG7P LEG7X LEG8P LEG8X LEG9P LEG9X LEG10P LEG10X ??
XBRS
X-BRACING
SAU 2X1.5X0.25
30.0 90.10 72.76
XBR1X -8.9354-NATGRI
17.851
12.280
22.500 0.526 0.763 0.526
84.72 102.36 3.997
3
2
XBRMED
X-BRACING
SAE
2X2X0.25
30.0 29.94 29.45
XBR11P -3.0941-NESC H
10.506
12.280
22.500 0.524 0.762 0.524 162.76 162.76 10.117
4
2
XBRLG
X-BRACING
SAU 2.5X2X0.25
30.0 24.65 24.65
XBR12P -2.8831-NESC H
11.695
12.280
22.500 0.522 0.761 0.522 163.82 163.82 10.617
4
2
TPCHN
6IN CHANNEL
CHN
6X8.2
30.0 64.16
0.00
TPCHNP
0.000
65.556
12.280
36.000 1.000 1.000 1.000
59.44
59.44 2.660
1
2
HANGERS
HANGERS Bar2x.25 Bar 2x.25
30.0 335.72
0.00 HNGRBTMP
0.000
0.085
6.140
22.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 1322.50 1322.50 7.954
4
1 NG
XARMSHT TOP AND BOTTOM XARM
SAU 2.5X2X0.25
30.0 233.48 233.48 XARMTPP -16.1274-NATGRI
6.907
12.280
22.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 213.16 213.16 7.532
4
2 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following
members (make sure your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): XARMTPP XARMBTMP HBRTPP HBRBTMP ??
NG
XARMLNG
MIDDLE XARM
SAU
3X2X0.25
30.0 443.89 443.89 XARMMIDP -20.2794-NATGRI
4.568
12.280
22.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 277.71 277.71 10.067
4
2 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following
members (make sure your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): XARMMIDP HBRMIDP ??
NG
Group Summary (Tension Portion):
Group
Group
Tension Tension Length
No.
Label
Desc.
Connect. Connect. Tens.
Of

Angle
Angle
Steel
No.
Hole
Type
Size Strength
Of Diameter

Max

Max

Tension Tension Tension

Usage

Use

Control

In

Member

Commonwealth Associates, Inc. - temp construction-a-flex tower

Force Control

Net

Tension

Section Connect.

Load Capacity

Shear
Page 3/5

Bearing

Rupture Member Bolts Holes

Tens.

Capacity Capacity

Case

Capacity

Tens.

(ksi)
%
%
(kips)
(kips)
(kips)
(kips)
(kips)
(ft)
(in)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEG10
10IN CHANNEL
CHN
10X15.3
30.0 92.64 66.00
LEG1X 40.5261-NESC H 112.319
61.400
216.000
0.000 2.004
10 2.000
0.6875 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following members (make sure
your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): LEG1P LEG1X LEG2P LEG2X LEG3P LEG3X LEG4P LEG4X LEG5P LEG5X LEG6P
LEG6X ??
LEG9
9IN CHANNEL
CHN
9X13.4
30.0 65.29 37.01
LEG7X 31.8141-NESC H
97.729
85.960
293.580
0.000 6.007
14 2.000
0.6875 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following members (make sure
your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): LEG7P LEG7X LEG8P LEG8X LEG9P LEG9X LEG10P LEG10X ??
XBRS
X-BRACING
SAU 2X1.5X0.25
30.0 90.10 90.10
XBR4P 11.0644-NATGRI
13.854
12.280
22.500
0.000 4.779
2 1.000
0.6875
XBRMED
X-BRACING
SAE
2X2X0.25
30.0 29.94 29.94
XBR9X
3.6771-NESC H
20.739
12.280
22.500
0.000 8.552
2 1.000
0.6875
XBRLG
X-BRACING
SAU 2.5X2X0.25
30.0 24.65 24.40
XBR12X
2.9961-NESC H
20.604
12.280
22.500
0.000 10.617
2 1.000
0.6875
TPCHN
6IN CHANNEL
CHN
6X8.2
30.0 64.16 64.16
TPCHNP
7.8794-NATGRI
57.375
12.280
36.000
0.000 2.660
2 2.000
0.6875
HANGERS
HANGERS Bar2x.25 Bar 2x.25
30.0 335.72 335.72 HNGRMIDP 20.6134-NATGRI
8.859
6.140
22.500
0.000 10.645
1 1.000
0.6875 NG
XARMSHT TOP AND BOTTOM XARM
SAU 2.5X2X0.25
30.0 233.48
0.00 HBRBTMP
0.000
23.979
12.280
22.500
0.000 4.641
2 1.000
0.6875 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following members (make sure
your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): XARMTPP XARMBTMP HBRTPP HBRBTMP ??
NG
XARMLNG
MIDDLE XARM
SAU
3X2X0.25
30.0 443.89
0.00 HBRMIDP
0.000
27.489
12.280
22.500
0.000 3.866
2 1.000
0.6875 A potentially damaging moment exists in the following members (make sure
your system is well triangulated to minimize moments): XARMMIDP HBRMIDP ??
NG

*** Maximum Stress Summary for Each Load Case

Summary of Maximum Usages by Load Case:
Load Case Maximum Element Element
Usage %
Label
Type
----------------------------------------------------------------1-NESC H INTACT NA+,I NA+ 219.29 XARMMIDP
Angle
1-NESC H INTACT NA-,I NA- 270.54 XARMMIDP
Angle
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA+,I NA+
85.37 XARMMIDP
Angle
2-NESC EXTREME WIND NA-,I NA- 129.37 XARMMIDP
Angle
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA+,I NA+
4.18 XARMMIDP
Angle
3-NESC EXTREME WIND w/o wires NA-,I NA4.18 XARMMIDP
Angle
Commonwealth Associates, Inc. - temp construction-a-flex tower

NG
NG
NG

Page 4/5

4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA+,I

4-NATGRID HEAVY ICE NA-,I
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA+,I
NESC Wind & Ice 07 NA-,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 11 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 1 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 12 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 2 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 13 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 3 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 14 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 4 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 15 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 5 BACK,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 16 AHEAD,I
7S-STRINGING COND SUSP 6 BACK,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA+,I
INSULATOR NESC H NA-,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA+,I
INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
-20 with 1psf Wind,I
60 Deg F,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA+,I
1-NESC H INTACT GRADE C NA-,I

NA+
NANA+
NANA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NA+
NANA+
NANA+
NANA+
NA+
NA-

421.88
443.89
198.50
223.86
159.05
159.05
159.05
159.05
159.05
159.05
159.05
159.06
159.05
99.20
159.05
159.06
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
111.07
117.00
93.24
222.37
267.47

XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
HNGRTPP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
LEG1P
LEG1P
LEG1P
LEG1P
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP
XARMMIDP

Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle

NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG
NG

NG
NG
NG
NG

Summary of Insulator Usages:

Insulator Insulator Maximum
Load Case Weight
Label
Type Usage %
(lbs)
-------------------------------------------------------------------MBSW
Clamp
17.65 INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA+,I NA+
0.0
MNTSW
Clamp
17.68 INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I NA0.0
MNTTP Suspension
29.54 INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I NA- 150.0
MNTMID Suspension
29.54 INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I NA- 150.0
MNTBTM Suspension
29.59 INSUL-NATGRID HVY ICE NA-,I NA- 150.0
*** Weight of structure (lbs):
Weight of Angles*Section DLF:
Weight of Suspensions:
Total:

2810.2
450.0
3260.2

*** End of Report

Commonwealth Associates, Inc. - temp construction-a-flex tower

Page 5/5