Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/255906980
READS
224
2 authors:
Alfred E. Hartemink
James Bockheim
University of WisconsinMadison
University of WisconsinMadison
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Catena
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/catena
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 19 June 2012
Received in revised form 16 October 2012
Accepted 4 December 2012
Keywords:
Pedology
Soil genesis
Soil history
Soil taxonomy
Soil science in the USA
a b s t r a c t
The formation and classication of soils have been a key area of research in the soil science discipline. Major
breakthroughs have been brought about since the mid 1800s and it has evolved from conceptual frameworks,
to descriptive studies to more quantitative approaches. Some 50 years ago the American soil scientists Stan Buol
and Francis Hole hatched idea for the book Soil Genesis and Classication. Now six editions of the book have been
published and it has become a standard text book in teaching soil science and pedology in the USA. Over 50,000
copies have been sold and this paper reviews how the book evolved over time, and relates the text to trends and
developments in soil formation and soil classication.
Published by Elsevier B.V.
1. Introduction
The formation and classication of soils have been a key area of research since the soil science discipline emerged in the 19th century.
Most things beneath the feet of scientists in that time were largely
unknown and there were wild speculations on the origin of many
soil features. For example, there were theories that stones developed
in soils by chemical precipitation and that peat was formed by algae.
Initial soil studies in the 19th century focused on geology and parent
material on one hand, and agricultural chemistry on the other hand.
The chemical school of thought had several followers (Baxter, 1832;
Lawes et al., 1883; Rufn, 1832) but was led by J. von Liebig who
was one of the most inuential scientists of his time (Blume, 2002;
Brock, 1997). An early example that viewed soils from a geological
point of view was by J. Morton (1843). Morton discusses alluvial
and diluvial soils a distinction made between ne sediments deposited by water (alluvium), and coarse sediments deposited by oods
(diluvium). That geological distinction had a religious origin, and for
Morton soils and geology were one. Also Fallou (1862) distinguished
between soils formed in-situ and washed-in or alluvial soils and as
he was trained as a mineralogist he attributed variations in soils primarily to differences in soil forming rocks. Senft (1857) and Fallou
(1862) prepared the way for V.V. Dokuchaev (Blume, 2002) who
brought the study of soils out of the chaos and confusion of the geologic, chemical, and agronomic points of view and established it as independent science (Marbut, 1936).
Whereas soil science in the beginning was driven by the idea that
geology and parent material are the main forming factors, the Russian
school emphasized the effects of climate and introduced the zonal
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 608 263 4947.
E-mail address: hartemink@wisc.edu (A.E. Hartemink).
0341-8162/$ see front matter. Published by Elsevier B.V.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2012.12.001
252
Plate 1. The founding authors of Soil Genesis and Classication, L to R: Stan Buol, Francis Hole, and Ralph McCracken.
In 1973 the text Soil Genesis and Classication was published (Buol
et al., 1973) with the intention to summarize the body of knowledge
called pedology, to encourage students to learn directly from the soil
in its natural setting, and to serve as stepping stones across the
seeming morass of terminology and information. Recently, the
sixth edition of this standard text was published. Here we review
how that book has changed and how that changes reect developments in the subdiscipline of soil formation and soil classication.
The book is widely used and represents the synthesis of a substantial
period of almost 40 years. This sort of analysis has been done for
other soil science books like Russell's Soil Condition and Plant Growth
(Greenland, 1997), general soil science books (McDonald, 1994a) and
the seven soil encyclopedia and reference books that have been published in the past between 2000 and 2012 (Hartemink, 2012).
Although there are several other excellent soil science text books
(e.g. Fanning and Fanning, 1989; Singer and Munns, 1987; Wilding
et al., 1983) none of these textbooks have 6 editions that cover almost
40 years and could be used to investigate trends in the subdiscipline
of soil formation and classication. The aim of this paper is to contribute to the limited number of historical and interpretative studies of
the soil science discipline.
2. The beginning
The ideas and start of the text book Soil Genesis and Classication
were summarized by Stan Buol of NC State University in the USA
(2010). It began one summer afternoon in 1963 or 1964 when Stan
Buol met again with his major professor Francis Hole in Madison,
USA. Both used Hans Jenny's book (1941) but several new developments urged for a new textbook. These included the ideas laid out
in Outline of a Generalized Theory of Soil Genesis (Simonson,
1959), several papers translated from Russian relating in the several
elds of soil science, the adoption of the 7th Approximation (Soil
Survey Staff, 1960), and the fact that soil survey had greatly increased
the interpretation for land use and productivity studies, especially for
nonfarm land use problems. An emphasis was put on classifying soils
on the basis of soil properties that could be measured within the soil
body. Existing concepts of soil genesis and classication related to external factors of soil formation were replaced by discussions of specific soil properties, such as mollic epipedons, argillic horizons, or aquic
conditions. Terms related to climatic conditions such as warm, cold,
arid, and humid conditions were replaced by more quantitative
terms of soil temperature and moisture regimes. According to Buol
(2010), it was becoming apparent that the system of soil classication
presented in the 7th Approximation was to become the ofcial soil
classication system in the United States and that there was a need
to teach the system to soil science students. Both Hole and Buol lamented that teaching the 7th Approximation was cumbersome
when the complete text was used, and there was no available text
that presented the processes of soil formation. Buol, Hole and
McCracken got together in the summer of 1972 at the University of
Wisconsin and prepared the rst draft. Both Hole and McCracken
came from Earlham College in Richmond, Indiana, USA, whereas
Buol was a graduate student of Hole (Brevik, 2010).
Table 1
Summary of six editions of Soil Genesis and Classication.
1st edition
2nd edition
3rd edition
4th edition
5th edition
6th edition
Year
Authors
1973
S.W. Buol
F.D. Hole
R.J. McCracken
1980
S.W. Buol
F.D. Hole
R.J. McCracken
1989
S.W. Buol
F.D. Hole
R.J. McCracken
No. of pages
No. of chapters
360
26
406
26
446
24
1997
S.W. Buol
F.D. Hole
R.J. McCraken
R.J. Southard
528
23
2003
S.W. Buol
R.J. Southard
R.C. Graham
P.A. McDaniel
494
21
2011
S.W. Buol
R.J. Southard
R.C. Graham
P.A. McDaniel
543
21
Table 2
Chapters in six editions of Soil Genesis and Classication.
First edition
Second edition
Third edition
Fourth edition
Fifth edition
Sixth edition
Introduction
Introduction
Introduction
Introduction
Introduction
Introduction
Morphology of Soils
Morphology of Soils
Morphology of Soils
Soil Micromorphology
Soil Micromorphology
Biogeochemical Processes in
Soil Formation
Soil as a Component of the Ecosystem
Biogeochemical Processes in
Soil Formation
Soil as a Component of the
Ecosystem
Space and Time in Soil Formation
Soil Systems
Andisols
Soil-forming Processes
253
254
Index
Bibliography
Index
Author Index
Subject Index
Index
Index
Bibliography
Fifth edition
Index
Third edition
Second edition
Fourth edition
The book Soil Genesis and Classication has run through six editions. The rst three were authored by the founding authors
(Plate 1) and the last three editions have been authored by four
authors all from the USA. The rst edition was reprinted seven
times and translated into Russian, Japanese, and Spanish.
The book increased in size from 360 to 543 pages between 1973
and 2011 whereas the number of chapters slightly decreased
(Table 1). The second edition underwent four printings and a translation into Chinese (Buol, 2010). After three printings of the third edition the fourth edition was published in 1997. At that time both
Francis Hole and Ralph McCracken were retired and Randall Southard
was recruited. For the fth edition Robert Graham and Paul McDaniel
joined as authors.
In the rst three editions the ve soil forming factors each had a
separate chapter but from the fourth edition these chapters were
merged (Table 2). In the rst two editions there were chapters entitled "Contributions of climate to the total soil environment", whereas
some years later the rst books appeared on the soil contributions to
the climate (Bouwman, 1990; Scharpenseel et al., 1990). Soil micromorphology was treated separately in the rst two editions and
then merged with the morphology chapter. Except from adding two
extra soil orders and some relabeling, the book chapters and its
main focus changed little over time.
Fig. 1 shows how the number of pages per topic changed over the
six editions. Although the size of the book changed a bit over the
years so these gures the graph shows that the number of pages devoted to the Soil Taxonomy soil orders almost doubled between 1973
and 2011. This obviously reects the additions of the two extra orders
(Andisols, Gelisols) and an increased amount of new information on
all soil orders. As the number of pages also increased (Table 1) the relative portion that deals with the soil orders only increased from 25%
to 30%. The number of pages dealing with soil formation dropped
over time and so did the section on soil survey interpretations.
About 40 to 50 pages dealt with soil classication in each edition of
which about half was devoted to the US Soil Taxonomy. The last edition has 94 pages bibliography (17% of the book) and 13-page index.
Some reference statistics was performed for the rst and sixth editions. The rst edition had 772 references and the sixth edition included 1581 references. About 80% of the references in the rst
edition were from the previous two decades (e.g. 1950s and 1960s)
whereas only 27% of the references in the sixth edition were from
the 1990s and 2000s (Fig. 2). The sixth edition kept about 35% of
the references listed in the rst edition and appears to have a reference distribution pattern with peak references from the 1960s and
from the 1980s. The number of references to Soil Science Society of
America Proceedings/Journals was 140 (19% of all references) in
1973 and 272 (17% of all references) in 2011.
First edition
Table 2 (continued)
Pedotechnology
Sixth edition
4. Discussion
The literature of soil science is rich and diverse. It consists of half a
million articles published in peer reviewed journals, and thousands of
books, monographs, and reports (Hartemink, 2012). Initially, most of
the exchange of ndings took place through letters followed by books
and reports. In the beginning of the twentieth century the journals
that solely devoted to soil research were started (Hartemink, 2009).
Various books in the nineteenth century focused on the origin and
formation of soils. With increasing knowledge and over time soil science books were published that digested and synthesized large
amounts of information. These books served as reference works but
also had an important role in teaching and education.
Here we have analyzed how the text book Soil Genesis and Classication evolved over time. Although the amount of statistics is limited
from these types of analyses, the book covers almost 40 years and
255
Fig. 1. Changes in subject treatment in six editions of Soil Genesis and Classication (19732011).
No. of references
450
400
First edition
350
Sixth edition
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Fig. 2. References per decade in the rst edition (1973) and sixth edition (2011) of Soil
Genesis and Classication.
256
interpretations and distil some solid soil knowledge out of that new
information is highly essential. The new data can greatly help us in
better understanding how soils are formed, how they differ across
the landscape and how they can be classied. With time the urge
for new standard text books on these subdisciplines becomes
imperative.
References
Basher, R., 1997. Is pedology dead and buried? Australian Journal of Soil Research 35,
979994.
Baveye, P., Jacobson, A.R., Allaire, S.E., Tandarich, J.P., Bryant, R.B., 2006. Whither goes
soil science in the United States and Canada? Soil Science 171, 501518.
Baxter, J., 1832. The Library of Agricultural and Horticultural Knowledge; with Appendix
Containing and Abridgement of the Principal Laws Relating to Farming and Rural
Affairs. G. Baxter, London.
Blume, H.P., 2002. Some aspects of the history of German soil science. Journal of Plant
Nutrition & Soil Science-Zeitschrift fur Panzenernahrung und Bodenkunde 165,
377381.
Bockheim, J.G., Gennadiyev, A.N., 2000. The role of soil-forming processes in the denition
of taxa in soil taxonomy and the World Soil Reference Base. Geoderma 95, 5372.
Bouwman, A.F. (Ed.), 1990. Soils and the Greenhouse Effect. John Wiley, Chichester.
Brevik, E.C., 2010. Hole: Geologic mentors to early soil scientists. Physics and Chemistry
of the Earth 35, 887894.
Brock, W.H., 1997. Justus von Liebig. The Chemical Gatekeeper. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge.
Buol, S.W., 2010. Evolution of the text Soil Genesis and Classication. Soil Survey
Horizons 51, 116117.
Buol, S.W., Hole, F.D., McCracken, R.J., 1973. Soil Genesis and Classication. The Iowa
State University Press, Ames, Iowa.
Duchaufour, P., 1977. Pdologie. Masson, Paris.
Fallou, F.A., 1862. Pedologie oder Allgemeine und Besondere Bodenkunde. Schnfeld
Buchhandlung, Dresden.
Fanning, D.S., Fanning, M.C.B., 1989. Soil Morphology, Genesis, and Classication. John
Wiley & Sons, New York.
Gillot, J.E., 1981. Book review of: Soil Genesis and Classication, 2nd edition. Canadian
Geotechnical Journal 18, 609.
Glinka, K., 1914. Die Typen der Bodenbildung Ihre Klassication und Geographsiche
Verbreitung. Verlag von Gebrder Borntraeger, Berlin.
Greenland, D.J., 1997. Inaugural Russell-Memorial-lecture soil conditions and plant
growth. Soil Use and Management 13, 169177.
Hartemink, A.E., 2009. Publications for evaluations: the impact of soil science and soil
scientists. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 64, 18a19a.
Hartemink, A.E., 2012. Soil science reference books. Catena 95, 142144.
Hartemink, A.E., McBratney, A., 2008. A soil science renaissance. Geoderma 148, 123129.
Helms, D., Efand, A.B.W., Durana, P.J. (Eds.), 2002. Proles in the History of the U.S.
Soil Survey. Iowa State Press, Ames.
Hilgard, E.W., 1906. Soils, their Formation, Properties, Composition, and Relation to
Climate, and Plant Growth. The Macmillan Company, New York.
Jenny, H., 1941. Factors of Soil Formation. A System of Quantitative Pedology.
McGraw-Hill, New York.
Joffe, J.S., 1936. Pedology. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick.
Krasilnikov, P.V., Ibanez, J.J., Arnold, R.W., Shoba, S. (Eds.), 2009. Soil Terminology,
Correlation and Classication. Earthscan, London.
Lawes, J.B., Morton, J.C., Morton, J., Scott, J., Thurber, G., 1883. The Soil of the Farm.
Orange Judd, Washington.
Lyon, T.L., Buckman, H.O., 1948. The Nature and Properties of Soils. A College Text of
Edaphology. The MacMillan Company, New York.
Marbut, C.F., 1936. Introduction. In: Joffe, J.S. (Ed.), Pedology. Rutgers University Press,
New Brunswick, pp. viixiii.
McDonald, P., 1994a. Core monographs in soil science. In: McDonald, P. (Ed.), The
Literature of Soil Science. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp. 161256.
McDonald, P. (Ed.), 1994b. The Literature of Soil Science. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
Merrill, G.P., 1906. A Treatise on Rocks, Rock-Weathering and Soils. The MacMillan
Company, New York.
Morton, J., 1843. The Nature and Property of Soils; their Connexion with the Geological
Formation on which They Rest. James Ridgway, London.
Ramann, E., 1911. Bodenkunde (Dritte Auage). Verlag von Julius Springer, Berlin.
Rice, T.J., 2003. Book review of: Soil Genesis and Classication, 5th edition. Vadose Zone
Journal 2, 767.
Robinson, G.W., 1932. Soils Their Origin, Constitution and Classication. An Introduction to Pedology. Thomas Murby & Co, London.
Rode, A.A., 1962. Soil Science (Translated from Russian). Israel Program fo Scientic
Translations, Jerusalem.
Ruellan, A., 1997. Some reections on the scientic basis of soil science. Eurasian Soil
Science (Pochvovedenie) 30, 347349.
Rufn, E., 1832. An Essay on Calcareous Manures. J.W. Campbell, Petersburg Va.
Scharpenseel, H.W., Ayoub, A., Schomaker, M., 1990. Soils on a Warmer Earth: Effects
of Expected Climate Change on Soil Processes, with EMPhasis on the Tropics and
Sub-tropics. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Senft, F., 1857. Lehrbuch der forstlichen Geognosie, Bodenkunde und Chemie. Manke, Jena.
Sibirtsev, N.M., 1900. Pochvovedenie. Y.N. Skorokhodov, St. Petersburg.
Simonson, R., 1959. Outline of a generalized theory of soil genesis. Soil Science of Society
of America Proceedings 23, 152156.
Singer, M.J., Munns, D.N., 1987. Soils: An Introduction. MacMillan, USA.
Soil Survey Staff, 1960. Soil classifciation. A comprehensive system, 7th Approximation.
Soil Conservation Service. United States Department of Agriculture, Washington
D.C.
Soil Survey Staff, 2010. Soil Taxonomy, 11th edition. USDA National Resources Conservation Services, Washington DC.
Stockmann, U., Minasny, B., McBratney, A.B., 2011. Quantifying processes of pedogenesis.
Advances in Agronomy 113 (113), 171.
van Baren, J., 1920. De Bodem van Nederland. S.L. van Looy, Amsterdam.
Vilenskii, D.G., 1963. Soil Science, Third Enlarged Edition (Translated from Russian).
Israel Program for Scientic Translation, Jerusalem.
Viscarra Rossel, R., Adamchuk, V.I., Sudduth, K.A., McKenzie, N.J., Lobsey, C., 2011. Proximal
soil sensing: an effective approach for soil measurements in space and time. Advances
in Agronomy 113, 237282.
Weir, W.W., 1949. Soil Science. Its Principles and Practice. J.B. Lipincott Company,
Chicago.
Wilde, S.A., 1953. Soil science and semantics. Journal of Soil Science 4, 14.
Wilding, L.P., Smeck, N.E., Hall, G.F. (Eds.), 1983. Pedogenisis and Soil Taxonomy
(2 Volumes). Elsevier, Amsterdam.