enacted the National Engineering University Act, 2007 (hereinafter NEU Act) to establish the National Engineering University (hereinafter NEU). NEU received substantive funding from the State along with resources such as land, infrastructure etc. NEU is run by a Governing Council which frames policies and makes decisions regarding its administration. The members of the Council includes the Chief Minister of Ankistan (Chancellor), a Director, four state government officials and nine other members selected by the process mandated in the NEU Act. NEU is on the outskirts of a small town Garvapur where the local residents resented the party culture and dressing habits of the students and have continuously protested against it, Sometimes even forcibly shutting down student parties outside university premises. In lieu of these events the Council implemented an exit-pass system wherein a student had to submit an exit pass to leave the University premises and permission was required for recreational activities happening outside the campus. At the time of admission Batch of 2021 was informed about the policy and was required to sign a consent form wherein they agree to obey all the rules laid down by the University. The students after some time protested against the exitpass system and led by Ms. Rajsa Prasad made petitions stating that the rule was a violation of their right for free movement. The Council replied by stating that the University is not a state under Article 12 and when the students gave their written consent to abide by the rules and regulations of the university they voluntarily surrendered their rights. Unable to reach a solution Ms. Rajsa Prasad filed a writ petition {W.P. (C) No. 1094/2016} before the Supreme Court of Shivistan. Simultaneously Mr. Depi Prasad (Managing Director) of Zukhil Mediaids & Co. a company engaged in manufacturing and supplying medical equipment received a large tender from Krisha Hospital in Priyabad. To supply the equipment Ms. Aargas, Chief of Krisha Hospital suggests the services of Mansinghkart & Co. who were a delivery service establishment. Mr.Prasad wrote an email on June 1st, 2015 signifying his offer which was accepted by Ms. Kuku Sharma, Director of Mansinghkart and a contract was entered by the two parties The consignment was picked up and delivered to Krisha Hospital on July 7th, 2015. However the consignment was damaged during the journey as it was in good condition when dispatched. A suit was filed by Krisha Hospital in the district court where it was in their favour. Later Mansinghkart files an appeal in High Court of Priyabad bearing Civil appeal No. 1053/2016. The Supreme Court transferred the civil appeal and clubbed both matters together.