CT (QM) FE 06D (i)

FACULTY OF ENGINEERING
KNJ3373 Finite Element Analysis
Group Project Report Rubrics

Report Writing (20 %)

Group No.

Project

Criteria/Level
Introduction /
Project
description

Design
Specification

Justification

Manufacturing
process and
material
selection

Result and
Discussion

Programme

n=4.0

n=3.0

n=2.0

n=1.0

Introduction is
complete and
well-written;
provides all
necessary
background
principles for the
experiment.

Introduction is
nearly complete,
missing some
minor points.

Some
introductory
information, but
still missing
some major
points.

Very little
background
information
provided or
information is
incorrect.

All design
process is well
presented and
have proper
work flow ,
equation
involved.

All design
process is
presented in
proper work flow
and have little
research
including
equation
involved.

Design process is
not presented in
well flow and
have little
research
including
equation
involved.

Design process
is not presented
in well flow and
have very little
no research/
equation been
done.

All assumption,
selection and
improvement
were made
based on
supported
reliable sources.

All assumption,
selection and
improvement
were made
based on
unreliable
sources.

All assumption,
selection and
improvement
were made
without any
source.

Little
assumption,
selection and
improvement
were made.

Construction
procedures and
process is well
presented and
explained
including related
figure during
construction
progress.

The process is
written in proper
but little
information
given. Related
figures are
presented.

Process details is
missing, and
little information
regarding
manufacturing
process as well
as related
figures.

Missing
important
information and
work flow
process.

Discussion is well
explained
including the
comparison
between the FEA

Discussion stated
have some minor
problems, little
information
regarding FEA

Little discussion
presented and
FEA part and
experimental
part are not well

Little and no
discussion
regarding FEA
as well as
experimental

Weightage,
w

Marks,
n

Total Marks
(n*w)

CT (QM) FE 06D (i)

Conclusions

Appearance and
formatting

result and
experimental
part.

result but could

still be improved.

presented.

part.

All important
conclusions have
been clearly
made, student
shows good
understanding.

All important
conclusions have
been drawn,
could be better
stated.

Conclusions
regarding major
points are
drawn, but many
are misstated,
indicating a lack
of
understanding.

Conclusions
missing or
missing the
important
points.

All sections are

in order, wellformatted and
readable.

All sections in
order, formatting
are generally
well but can be
improved.

Sections in order,
formatting are
rough but
readable.

Sections out of
order, sloppy
formatting.

Others (please
specify)

n * w

TOTAL

n w

TOTAL MARKS

5 w

x100%

(A)

(A-)

(B+)

(B)

(B-)

(C+)

(C)

(C-)

(D)

(F)

80-100

75-79

70-74

65-69

60-64

55-59

50-54

45-49

40-44

0-39