Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Johan Richter
Pioneer in Continuous Pulping Technology
Born in Lier, Norway, in 1901
12 Lectures
By Sven Rydholm
Director of Research
Billeruds AB
STAP N O . 7
Gardens Point
A22810250B
Continuous pulping
processes : 12 lectures
A22810250B
Copyright 1970 by
Technical Association of the Pulp and Paper Industry
360 Lexington Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10017
Preface
This book is a compilation of lectures given at the TAPPI Pacific Section
Meeting in Seattle, Wash., in September 1968. They dealt with experiences
in continuous pulping obtained over more than one decade at Billeruds AB
in collaboration with AB Kamyr.
One reason for my choice of topic was that Kamyr digesters have dominated the most vital operation in our industry for more than ten years and
still do, although some signs of healthy competition have appeared. A
second reason was that the Kamyr digesters are now becoming quite diversified, and thus the lectures would have to cover all pulping processes
needing a pressure vessel. A third reason was that I have been involved in
developing many of these process variants during my past sixteen years in
Billerud research. A final reason was that it was then 30 years since Johan
Richter started the development of a continuous digester. Someone,
perhaps outside his company, should tell the story of the devoted efforts
from him and his associates to realize an idea, in which he firmly believed,
in spite of innumerable troubles and a general disbelief from most people
in this industry for a good many years. I am not able to do that initial
story justice, but shall instead cover some experiences of continuous
cooking gained during the last decade. In preparing the lectures, I have
endeavored to give a brief background of wood chemistry and pulping
chemistry, which simplifies the understanding of what goes on in the
digester and what comes out of it. The theory is treated more extensively
in my book "Pulping Processes" (Wiley, New York, 1965). The treatment
of the continuous cooking itself includes the results of work undertaken
by my company. I think I may make clear that continuous cooking is
now ready for all pulping processes and offers possibilities for carrying out
process modifications which only with difficulty are feasible in batch
cooking. It gives a system available for the largest mill units conceivable,
lends itself well to control and automation, offers advantages in combination with other mill operations, and yields pulps which meet the highest
quality standards. It is one. of the weapons needed in this industry to
meet the competition from other materials in serving the markets of today
and tomorrow.
vii
viii
Thanks are due to Billerud and Kamyr for allowing the comprehensive
publication of all results which were previously unpublished or published
only in scattered presentations at Scandinavian and American meetings
and magazines. Actively involved in the administration of the Jossefors
experimental pulp mill were G. Ojermark, S. Haglund, and W. Ameen of
Billerud, and in the administration of the research program T. Bergek, L.
JQrgensen, and myself from Billerud, K. Dahl, J. Richter, and T. Christenson from Kamyr. Actively involved in carrying out the experimental
work during different periods over the 16 years were, from Billerud, myself, G. Arnborger, S. Boren, T. Krantz, J. Grundstrom, U. Mohlin, E.
Nilsson, G. Annergren, A. Haglund, K. Mattsson, S. Lokrantz, S. Wenneras,
B. Dillner, and an experienced crew of 10-20 men. From Kamyr, particularly, the following were involved in the experiments at varying periods: H.
Ortqvist, L. Jansson, A. Backlund, S. Jungeblad, and L. Westerlurtd. The
sparks necessary to carry the work over the critical periods and to yield
the successful redesigns of the machinery were supplied by Johan Richter. With Knut Dahl, the managing director of Kamyr, and Ake Pihlgren
and Gunnar Hindemark, former and present managing directors of Billerud, the financing of the program has rested. This has required from
them substantial courage and belief in the soundness of research and development efforts in machine and process design, perhaps rewarded in the
continued success of digester sales of Kamyr and in the successful operation of continuous pulping processes at Billerud. Part of the work has
also received substantial financial support from the Swedish development
fund Malmfonden.
Sven Rydholm
Billeruds AB
Saffie, Sweden
Lectures
1 Historical Development of Continuous Kraft Cooking...
2 Sulfite Cooking Process Theory
1
11
33
51
63
75
97
105
121
159
173
179
193
Lecture
Historical Development of
Continuous Kraft Cooking
The detailed story of the development of the continuous kraft digester
began with a 5 ton/day pilot plant at Karlsborg in northernmost Sweden in
1938 and continued, (after an interlude during the war) in 1948 at
Fengersfors, a small kraft mill in Central Sweden. During the period
1948-52, Fengersfors took the brave stride to continuous cooking from its
19th-century technique of stationary batch digesters, which opened at side
lids near the bottom and were emptied manually into wheelbarrows to
carry the pulp to the washing and screening departments.
In this mill, the Kamyr enthusiasts introduced their first commercial
unit, for 50 tons/day. The basic principle of a downflow digester with a
balanced high-pressure pocket feeder (Fig. 1.1) was already established,
but they had a long way to go.
The high-pressure feeder is still the key feature of the Kamyr system. It
solves the problem of introducing the wood chips into the high-pressure
system without mechanical compression damage, without excessive wear
on the feeder, and without losses of steam from the pressure room. The
chips fall from the steaming vessel into the pocket of the feeder when the
pocket is in vertical position, and are packed by a liquor circulation. The
revolving plug of the feeder contains 2-4 such pockets at varying angles, so
that always at least one pocket will receive chips. The plug, which is
slightly conical, is a precision work of stainless steel in an iron housing
with a monel sleeve. In turning, the plug delivers the pockets successively
into a horizontal position, in contact with the high-pressure feeding
line. By a circulation pump, the chips are then conveyed into the digester. The pocket is thus emptied of chips but full of liquor when it arrives
again at a vertical position. A liquor volume corresponding to the volume
of the new chip charge must thus leave the system at an overflow in the
chip chute and has to be pumped into the system again by a high-pressure
pump, together with the small leakage volume from between plug and
housing, and with the cooking liquor charge.
The first commercial continuous kraft digester is outlined in Fig.
1.2. Its basic design is similar to that of the present digesters, but many
improvements have been made. The chips are charged from a hopper
1
Lecture 1
Mill
Country
Capacity,
tons/day
Sweden
50
Process:
Kraft
Wood
Softwood
Italy
90
Kraft
Softwood
Italy
France
25
40
NSSC
Kraft
Straw
Chestnut
Japan
Australia
90
60
Kraft
Soda
Softwood
Eucalypt
Sweden
100
Kraft
Softwood
Finland
120
Kraft
Softwood
Finland
120
Kraft
Softwood
France
60
Soda
Esparto
60
Kraft
Softwood
Sweden
Sweden
Sweden
Sweden
New Zealand
60
150
10
150
NSSC
Kraft
Pilot
Kraft
Hardwood
Softwood
Softwood
Canada
250
Kraft
Softwood
Canada
250
Kraft
Softwood
USA
150
Kraft
Softwood
Finland
200
Kraft
Softwood
England
60
NSSC
Hardwood
France
150
Kraft
Softwood
Japan
90
Kraft
USA
350
Kraft
Softwood,
hardwood
Softwood
USA
150
Kraft
Softwood
Country
Japan
tons/day
120
Process
Wood
Kraft
Softwood
Japan
120
Kraft
Softwood
Japan
120
Kraft
Softwood
USA
Sweden
150
120
Kraft
Kraft
Hardwood
Softwood
Sweden
120
Kraft
Softwood
Japan
150
Kraft
Japan
150
Kraft
Softwood,
hardwood
Softwood
France
150
Kraft
Softwood
France
150
Kraft
Softwood
USA
350
Kraft
Softwood
Argentina
100
Eucalypt
Yugoslavia
Canada
Canada
USA
50
250
250
250
Cold
Caustic
NSSC
Kraft
Kraft
Kraft
Hardwood
Softwood
Softwood
Softwood
USA
225
Kraft
Softwood
Australia
100
Soda
Eucalypt
Swaziland
Sweden
300
150
Kraft
Kraft
Softwood
Softwood
Sweden
300
Kraft
Softwood
Japan
150
Kraft
Hardwood
USSR
USSR
USA
420
420
300
Kraft
Kraft
Kraft
Softwood
Softwood
Softwood
Canada
300
Kraft
Softwood
Lecture 1
Lecture 1
1950
1955
I960
YEAR
1965
1970
Fig. 1.5. Kamyr continuous kraft cooking system with digester washing
followed by filter washing. (1) Chip measuring wheel; (2) steaming vessel;
(3) high-pressure feeder; (4) white liquor pump; (5) impregnation zone; (6)
heating circulation; (7) cooking zone; (8) black liquor withdrawal; (9)
flashing system; (10) "Hi-heat" washing zone; (11) washing liquor circulation; (12) blow tank; (13) knotter; (14) washing filter.
10
Lecture 1
currently, succeeded, and has done so ever since. There may still be different opinions about the virtue of cooking countercurrently, but the mere
proof that it was possible to let the liquor flow upwards and the pulp
downwards gave rise to the second breakthrough, the high-heat countercurrent wash in the lower part of the digester (Fig. 1.5). This eliminated
quite a few problems in the filter wash after the digester, where Kamyr
had been temporarily less successful with its constructions, and which at
one period had caused more production disturbances than the digester
itself.
With both those features, the cold blow and the digester wash, the
system was quite competitive, technically and economically, and thereafter increasingly dominated the new capacity of the kraft pulp industry,
in increasingly large units. The largest one on order at the moment
is for 1150 metric tons/day, and this feature alone, the size, is
proof enough of the foresight and soundness of Johan Richter's basic idea.
Other advantages, such as heat economy and labor economy through facilitated combination of cooking with subsequent operations, will be further
discussed in the last lecture. It is no overstatement to say that the
continuous digester introduced on a massive scale the concepts of instrumentation and automatic control to the pulp industry, now being completed by digital control from computers.
The happy situation of Kamyr, with a practical monopoly in the field of
continuous kraft cooking, would have made many firms self-assured and
lazy. It is commendable that the company continued the development
efforts and extended them to adjacent fields, mainly sulfite pulping in
1957-64, prehydrolysis-kraft pulping in 1964-65, neutral sulfite pulping in
1965-66 and modified kraft pulping in 1965-68. Since that development
has been performed mainly in collaboration with Billerud, at times even by
Billerud alone or in collaboration with Swedish Cellulose Co., it is on this
topic that I should be able to speak with some experience. However, I
felt it was only fair to enlarge somewhat on the development of the kraft
digester, thus paying my respects not only to the Kamyr men but to all
pioneers of continuous cooking working in the industry, who have carried
the double burden of technical difficulties of development and the responsibility of the current production.
Lecture 2
12
Lecture 2
Fig. 2.2.
Ka
pKa
25
70
100
110
120
130
140
150
0.0172
0.0046
0.0024
0.0016
0.0011
0.0008
0.0005
0.0003
1.8
2.3
2.6
2.8
3.0
3.1
3.3
3.5
13
[H + ] [HSOj ] =
[H + ] [HSO3 ]
[H 2 S0 3 ] + [S0 2 ] [total S0 2 ] - [HSO3 1
14
Lecture 2
15
16
Lecture 2
The reactions forming thiosulfate during the cook are not only the previously mentioned inorganic reaction, but also reactions of bisulfite with
sugars, as well as with terpenes, etc. (Fig. 2.7). In a normal acid sulfite
cook, these amounts of thiosulfate are consumed in a reaction with lignin
(Fig. 2.8), and the detrimental cooking acid decomposition is thus
checked. When cooking at a higher pH, such as in the bisulfite cook, it
appears that this reaction between lignin and thiosulfate does not occur to
any extent. Then the sensitivity to thiosulfate contamination becomes
accentuated, especially since the higher content of bisulfite ions tends to
give increasing amounts of thiosulfate in reaction with the carbohy-
17
18
Lecture 2
drates. This prevents the cooking down to pulps with lignin contents
below 4% with the bisulfite process, as compared to less than 1% as the
minimum in the acid sulfite cook. It also became evident in our trials
with continuous bisulfite cooking that the decomposition reactions can
create real technical problems, which I shall refer to later. On the alkaline
side there is no similar spontaneous decomposition, and considerable
amounts of thiosulfate can be tolerated in the neutral sulfite cook, for
example.
The lignin reactions of the sulfite cook, disregarding that often neglected
one with thiosulfate, are predominantly sulfonation, hydrolysis, and
condensation (Fig. 2.9). In all cases, the initial reaction is probably a
protolysis of the dialkyl ether bonds of lignin, or protolysis at the benzyl
alcohol groups. Various model reactions have illustrated the various
reactivities of the possible configurations. Here it is sufficient to state
that, in the course of delignification, lignin is at first sulfonated to an
extent corresponding to one sulfonate group for every three monomers
without dissolving. Continued acidic treatment without bisulfite ions
will remove some of the lignin so sulfonated, but a continued sulfonation
will introduce more sulfonate groups, to at least one on every two
monomers, and results in a more complete delignification.
If the sulfonation is interrupted at too early a stage, e.g., by the decomposition of bisulfite ions to sulfate and thiosulfate, the reactive groups of
the lignin not only can be hydrolyzed, but to a considerable extent, also
condense with other reactive centers in the lignin molecule, particularly in
the 5-position of the aromatic ring. This is called the self-condensation of
lignin and leads to discoloration, screenings, and in bad cases to "burnt
cooks." A similar cause of the same phenomena is where the heating of
the cook has proceeded too rapidly in relation to the penetration of the
cooking liquor. Then condensation can occur within the lignin before
sulfonation has a chance to take place, and the end result will be nonuniform cooks, with "burnt centers" of the chips, where impregnation has
been incomplete. A large amount of research work has been devoted to
these phenomena, such as pretreatment in various buffer solutions. Part
of the problems has also been ascribed to physical phenomena, such as
"coalescence" of the lignin during the pretreatment, which should have
the same consequences as condensation. There is also direct chemical
evidence of condensation during such pretreatment, and it is likely that
both condensation and coalescence play a role in the deactivation of the
lignin.
Another condensation of a similar type occurs betwen lignin and
phenolic extractives, such as the pinosylvin compounds of pine heartwood,
19
Fig. 2.9. Mechanism of lignin sulfonation, etc., assuming proton activation: (1) hydrolysis (R' ,alkyl) or status quo (R'H); (2) sulfitolysis
(R alkyl) or sulfonation (R H); (3) condensation.
or the tannins of bark-damaged spruce surface wood (Fig. 2.10). This
prevents the cooking of such wood by the original acid sulfite process and
has led to the development of two-stage processes, such as the Stora process for pine or the Kramfors process for tannin-damaged spruce (Fig.
2.11). If namely the initial treatment is carried out in a less acid medium,
pH 4-10, sulfonation is favored and condensation suppressed sufficiently
to allow complete delignification.
In the neutral sulfite cook, carried out at higher temperatures than the
acid sulfite and bisulfite versions, the predominant sulfonation reaction
20
Lecture 2
21
22
Lecture 2
23
24
Lecture 2
Fig. 2.18. Pulp yield, mannose content and acetyl content of two-stage
sulfite pulps, cooked to constant ligniri content at varying pH and temperature conditions of stage I.
25
27
PULP LIGNIN.% of
28
Lecture 2
conditions of the two-stage cook that gives the yield effects with softwoods.
Another carbohydrate reaction in the sulfite cook is that of oxidation by
bisulfite ions under formation of aldonic acids and thiosulfate (Fig.
2.24). Its importance for the cooking acid stability has been commented
on already. It is also responsible for a yield decrease in the bisulfite
cook, to an extent which offsets the advantage of a lower hydrolytic
degrading action in that less acidic process variant. Bisulfite pulps are
therefore obtained in about the same yields as are acid sulfite pulps at
equivalent lignin content. Not only aldonic acids, but also sugarsulfonic
acids are formed, and this appears to be the case also with neutral sulfite
pulping, where, however, both hydrolytic and oxidative degradation are
quite limited (Fig. 2.25).
It is not necessary here to enlarge on the pulp properties obtained from
the various types of sulfite cooks. It suffices to say that the sulfite process generally gives a higher yield but a weaker paper pulp than the kraft
process, and that its sensitivity to the type of wood, to the state of wood
seasoning, to the extent of mechanical chip damageas well as the less
29
30
Lecture 2
STEAMING, min
Fig. 2.26. Degree of penetration vs. time of steaming for spruce chips
treated at 75C with an acid containing 5% total S0 2 and applying a
pressure of 0.8, 5, and 9 atm (0.8 atm corresponding to the vapor pressure
of the acid). Penetration after 2 min , 5 min X, 10 min A, 15 min O, 30
min D, 45 min .
kept at about 20 mm, shorter chips leading to more mechanical damage
than can be usually tolerated.
A factor which complicates penetration is the air in the chips, which
becomes trapped in the capillaries and prevents complete penetration. In
the practical range of pulpwood moisture content, 30-50%, a combination
of air and water pockets fill the capillaries, the most difficult situation
from the standpoint of impregnation. Therefore, several methods of air
removal have been devised, the most efficient of which is steaming. Steaming causes the air pockets to expand thermally, and when
steaming to 100C at atmospheric pressure, the increased vapor pressure of
water will force the air to leave the system. Steam shooks have been
applied to increase this effect but have in general been found not to
31
Lecture 3
34
Lecture 3
Fig. 3.1. First Kamyr pilot plant system for continuous sulfite cooking.
These experiences indicated a 10 ton/day pilot unit, a soluble base, and a
two-stage cook with no excess S0 2 in the initial stage. When the experimental pulp mill was created at Jossefors in 1956, it contained a digester
designed accordingly (Fig. 3.2). In order to separate the two stages completely, the digester consisted of two bodies, one upflow and one downflow. There were the usual arrangements for charging and steaming the
chips, the standard feeding circulation, and then the upflow digester,
equipped with two chip-lifting circulations, a top scraper for transferring
the chips to the second stage, with a transfer circulation as an additional
acid. The second body was equipped with a heating circulation and the
usual discharging system, with bottom scraper, discharge sluice, and bottom circulation. A blow tank with subsequent filter received the pulp for
further operations.
The machinery development work continued in that equipment for two
years, until it had been made to work properly, and then process studies
continued for some years. During this period, we had considerable mechanical experience, e.g., with the material of the high-pressure feeder,
corrosion in the digester top and behind blind strainer plates, where cooking acid decomposition took place and sulfuric acid corrosion was severe. We learned how to get the chip column moving upward in the first
stage, and how to discharge through a small blow valve instead of the
Fig. 3.2.
35
36
Lecture 3
37
VISCOSITY, cp(TAPPI)
38
Lecture 3
39
Table 3.1. Pulp Quality Obtained from Spru e, Birch, and Eucalypt Rayon Pulps by the Sulfite Process, Using Batch
and Continuous Cooking
the chips, which required a minimum length of the lifting zone and a
certain minimum temperature to make the chips soft enough to exert a
low friction against the digester walls. The final solution also here proved
to be the Mumin digester. Table 3.1 shows the results obtained by the
two-stage and the one-stage digester, as compared to batch mill scale and
laboratory scale cooks to the same viscosity, using spruce, birch, beech,
and eucalypt. It is quite evident that the final one-stage continuous cooking gave completely satisfactory results with all wood species, at least as
good as with batch cooking. It is also clearly demonstrated that experimenting with digester machinery often leads to theoretically unexpected
results because of deviations from batch cooking conditions. This, of
course, not only indicates troubles, but also possibilities.
Table 3.2 shows the cooking conditions. The most striking feature of
the successful one-stage cooking is the low liquor ratio, 2.2-2.5 (tons
liquor/tons o.d. wood). This includes chip moisture, steam condensate,
and seal water, as well as actual cooking liquor. Since the latter was only
about 1 ton/ton o.d. wood, and the charge of combined S0 2 about 40
kg/ton o.d. wood (or 4%), the concentration of the cooking liquor had to
be about 4% combined S0 2 . In a larger digester, the influence of seal
water from circulation pumps and other water-sealed shafts is less pronounced, and a somewhat larger volume of cooking liquor can be tolerated
yet to achieve such low liquor ratios. However, much higher concentrations of cooking liquor must be realized than the normal 1.2-1.3% combined S0 2 in batch cooking, where a large liquor volume is needed to
cover the chips. Soluble base is a prerequisite for a high concentration,
but then the concentration as such is no problem for either sodium or
magnesium base, as seen from the table. The design of the recovery system will, however, have to allow for this demand in order to realize the
possibilities of a better steam economy offered by continuous cooking.
42
Lecture 3
43
44
Lecture 3
but with proper control of chip, steam, and chemicals flows, the frequency
of the viscosity variations was not higher than could be controlled by
direct viscosity analysis on the pulp. This is demonstrated in Fig. 3.8,
showing viscosity variations when cooking spruce, birch, and beech acid
sulfite rayon pulp in the Mumin digester system.
Of other quality data of Table 3.1, the favorably low contents of lignin
and extractives should be pointed out. Compared to the corresponding
batch pulps this means a decided saving in bleaching chemicals.
The efforts on the continuous cooking of acid sulfite paper pulp were
mainly concerned with the paper strength properties, after the initial cooking acid decomposition problems had been solved and the delignification
controlled by the same means as described for rayon pulp. The initial
trials showed a paper strength which was only half that of batch
pulps. This was a much more severe degradation than that experienced
for kraft pulp during the hot blow period. Considerable efforts were
made to locate the source of the damage by sampling from various levels
of the two-body digester and continuing the cook- on the laboratory scale,
followed by paper testing. This showed several degrading influences, commencing at the bottom screw of the upflow digester, when that ran heavily
loaded, continuing with a slight influence of the top scraper, and finally
severe,degradation by the discharge devices. Table 3.3 shows the paper
properties of pulps cooked to Roe No. 5 (lignin content 4-5%), using
bisulfite precook at 130C, followed by acid sulfite cooking at 135-140C
in the downflow digester body. The charge of combined S0 2 was 40-50
kg/ton o.d. wood (4-5%) and the excess S0 2 concentration in the cooking
liquor of the second stage 2.5-3.0%. It can be seen that by unloading the
bottom screw in the upflow digester through better lifting circulation and
introducing the cold blow (this was done at the same time as in the kraft
45
Table 3.3. Paper Properties of Spruce Acid Sulfite Pulp, Two-body Pilot Digester
Process: Bisulfite-acid sulfite, combined SO 2 charge 4.5%
of o.d. wood, pulp Roe No. 5.0.
Fig. 3.9.
Fig. 3.10. Kamyr digester with inclined top separator used for two-stage
alkali - acid sulfite cooking.
Lecture 3
Table. 3.4. Two-stage Neutral Sulfite-Acid Sulfite Pulping
of Spruce and Pine in Mumin Pilot Digester
Digester Pressure: 10 atm.
Table 3.5. Two-stage Alkali-Acid Sulfite Pulping of Spruce in Mumin Pilot Digester
Digester Pressure: 9 atm. Estimated yield improvement
over acid sulfite 4%, wood basis.
ing. It is seen that also in this case the screenings were very low and the
major part of the glucomannan stabilization obtained. This elegant process requires a recovery system that yields carbonate with some sulfite, but
simplifies the cooking liquor preparation very much.
From an operational point of view, both these two-stage cooks were thus
successful. The quality obtained was also entirely satisfactory, equal to
that of laboratory pulps, as shown in Table 3.6. There is every reason to
believe that a straight acid sulfite cooking without glucomannan stabilization would lead to laboratory quality also, although this was not
tried. Thus, the Mumin version of the continuous digester appears to have
eliminated the remaining slight disadvantages of the two-body digester as
regards acid sulfite paper pulp quality, which rounds off our development
work on continuous acid sulfite pulping very nicely. The system is good
for both rayon and paper grades, for both straight one-stage and two-stage
pulping.
Lecture 4
52
Lecture 4
Lecture 4
54
125
50
10
22
10.1
64
25
8.8
62
11
24
10.4
65
7
28
9.0
73
55
Fig. 4.3.
58
Lecture 4
10
15
ROE NUMBER
20
25
60
Lecture 4
Table 4.5. Bisulfite Pulping in the Mumin Pilot Digester
Paper properties at three yield levels as compared to laboratory pulps.
Pulp
yield,
%
53
58
75
Scale
Beating
time,
min
Lab.
Pilot
Lab.
Pilot
Lab.
Pilot
13
14
15
16
33
19
Lab.
Pilot
Lab.
Pilot
Lab.
Pilot
26
27
27
29
49
28
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
Paper properties at 25 SR
8.7
109
8.5
100
9.8
100
8.9
103
8.8
80
8.8
73
Sheet
density
0.67
0.68
0.66
0.66
0.64
0.61
Paper properties at 45 SR
53
58
75
9.8
9.4
10.5
9.8
10.0
9.9
98
88
86
85
66
62
0.74
0.76
0.75
0.74
0.64
0.68
sulfite was also tried at the intermediate yield level and found to perform
equally good as sodium bisulfite.
The one-body downflow digester allowed countercurrent cooking operation. However, with bisulfite it is not surprising to find that countercurrent operation resulted in rapid cooking liquor decomposition. More
interesting results with countercurrent operation were obtained with
prehydrolysis-kraft and kraft pulping, which will be described later on.
In order to achieve additional brightness with a chemical bisulfite pulp
of 70% brightness, dithionite was added to the washing zone and the pulp
thus subjected to a brightening action at 130C. The result was disappointing, since the brightness improvement was less than with dithionite
at a subsequent conventional brightening stage. The idea of using the
washing zone for brightening is, however, tempting, and might work out
better after a more systematic effort made on a laboratory scale prior to
mill scale trials.
One remaining doubt regarding the sufficiency of the short impregnation
period, when using sprucewood with excessive heartwood content, initiated further trials. It was found that such wood from northern Sweden
gave on cooking somewhat discolored centers in about 2% of the chips, as
compared to none with spruce from central Sweden. The brightness of
61
Table 4.6. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data and Paper Properties of Spruce
Bisulfite Semichemical Pulps for Newsprint, Produced in the Mumin Pilot
Digester, Without and With Pressure Preimpregnation at HO^C. Sodium Base
Mumin system
High-pressure
preimpr.
Mumin system
Mumin impregnation
Retention time, hr
Impregnation
Cooking
Temperature, C
Pressure, atm
Liquor ratio, m /ton
o.d.wood
Total S 0 2 , % on wood
Combined S0 2 ,% on wood
Initial pH
Roe chlorine No.
Brightness, % SCAN'
Resin content, %
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Galactose
Glucose
Mannose
Arabinose
Xylose
Cellulose content, % on
carbohydr.
Estimated pulp yield,
% on wood
Paper properties at 25 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm3
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm3
0.02
0.83
169
9.2
0.02
2.00
160
9.2
0.02
3.50
152
7.4
0.02
4.85
145
8.0
1.40
2.00
156
8.9
3.0
17.0
8.5
4.4
24.2
64.4
1.1
3.0
16.6
8.3
4.4
23.6
62.4
1.0
3.5
16.4
8.2
4.5
24.3
60.9
...
3.4
17.0
8.5
4.6
23.5
62.1
...
3.0
16.0
8.0
4.3
22.7
65.7
1.2
1.4
76.2
14.8
...
7.6
1.2
77.6
14.0
...
7.2
1.1
81.0
11.9
...
6.2
1.0
79.0
12.7
...
7.4
1.0
78.4
13.2
...
7.4
71
73
77
74
72
77
75
72
74
76
24
8.6
73
0.57
16
8.6
76
0.59
21
8.9
74
0.63
21
8.3
72
0.56
32 1
9.1
70
0.63
35
9.5
62
0.66
23
9.4
64
0.68
30
9.7
67
0.70
33
9.4
60
0.65
47 1
10.2
59
0.74
62
Lecture 4
the refined pulp was virtually unaffected by this phenomenon, and the
only conceivable disadvantage would show up in a slightly higher shive
content. Some trials with a preimpregnation vessel for high-pressure
impregnation {cf. Lecture 9) prior to cooking (Table 4.6), indicated
possibly an improvement, although the differences were fairly hard to
detect, and a comparison with batch pulp of the same type gave better
brightness and uniformity for the continuously cooked pulp. The table is
of interest mainly to show that the cooking time and temperature can be
varied considerably without quality problems. This indicates the
flexibility in capacity of a system chosen initially for a retention time, for
example, of 2 hi.
To sum up the development efforts on continuous bisulfite pulping, it
might be said that the Mumin digester system appears to allow bisulfite
pulping at all yield levels with satisfactory result from both an operational
and a quality standpoint.
Lecture 5
Fig. 5.1. Schematic diagram of the first NSSC continuous cooking system
at Billerud: (1) digester; (2) discharge pipe; (3) Asplund Defibrator; (3a)
blow valve; (4) blow tank; (5) Davenport press; (6) Sprout-Waldron refiner; (7) to screening.
the lignin. The buffer, 25-33% of the original carbonate, has mainly to
take care of the uronic acid and acetyl groups of the xylan to give uronic
acid sodium salt and sodium acetate, under formation of carbon dioxide. The total quantity of sodium carbonate charged is about 160 kg/ton
o.d. wood (16%) when cooking to bleachable grades of 70-75% yield, and
110 kg/ton (11%) when cooking to corrugating medium grade of 77-83%
yield. The cooking temperatures used vary between 160 and 190C and
the cooking time is adjusted according to the temperature used and the
yield desired. It thus varies between 15 min and several hours.
Our reason for choosing the Kamyr system for Saffle was that we desired
maximum uniformity of cooking for the bleachable pulp grade. We did
not feel convinced that the other systems would give an acceptable impregnation because of short heating periods to maximum temperature and
sometimes rather primitive methods of adding the liquor to the chips. Today, we know we were wrong about the heating period required for uniform cooking, but we might still have made the best choice from an
impregnation point of view.
The system chosen was the standard kraft digester, although with a shell
lined with stainless steel and some auxiliary machinery attached (Fig.
5.1). Thus, before the blow valve and the disk strainer of the bottom
circulation, a Defibrator was inserted, to fiberize the semicooked chips
65
Fig._5.2. The effect of temperature on the tensile strength of (7) waterswollen sprucewood, (2) birchwood, and (.?) neutralisulfite-cooked birchwood, 75% yield.
before blowing. The blow tank did not contain the conventional impeller
at the bottom, but instead a low-pressure feeder to handle even very coarse
material. The pulp was then to be discharged to a Davenport press prior
to refining in a Sprout-Waldron 36-2 precision refiner. The intention with
the Defibrator was partly to facilitate the blowing and subsequent handling of the semicooked material, partly to save refining energy, and possibly to improve quality. Refining at high temperature of uncooked
chips, as practiced in the Defibrator process, gives a less damaged fiber
than groundwood and at a much lower power consumption, since the
fiberizing is done above 170C, in the temperature of plastic flow of the
lignin (Fig. 5.2).
One immediate experience with the system was that the bicarbonate
buffer had to be abandoned and substituted with the more expensive
66
Lecture 5
Beating
time,
mm
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
Sheet
density
Slowness,
SR
0.3
2.0
5.0
Batch cooked and
refined at low
temperature
19
21
15
7.9
8.2
8.2
48
46
48
0.98
0.98
0.99
73
69
74
15
10.0
60
62
C
162
130
120
110
Batch cooked and
refined at low
temperature
Beating
time,
mm
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
15
15
23
13
8.2
8.8
9.2
10.0
48
51
55
61
15
10.0
60
Sheet
Slowdensity ness, SR
0.99
0.99
0.97
74
68
61
61
62
Table 5.3 also contains information on the CMT value of the unbleached
pulps. This value indicates the corrugating medium properties. The results are somewhat bewildering, since they indicate more damage at 110C
than at 160C. The average indicates some 10% quality decrease from the
fiberizing and discharge equipment, as compared to fiberizing at low temperature in the laboratory of samples removed from the digester bottom.
After these experiences it could be concluded that continuous cooking
of bleachable neutral sulfite pulp from birch is feasible in the normal
Kamyr kraft system, and that a good quality can be obtained if the discharge is made at 110C or lower. The Defibrator was removed from the
pressure system and the fiberizing done entirely with the Sprout-Waldron
refiner at 60-80C. Following this experience the British digester was
68
Lecture 5
VALLEY BEATING TO
45 SR SLOWNESS
10 cm 3 /sec POROSITY
69
Table 5.3. Effect of Refining Temperature and Plate Setting on Quality of Neutral
Sulfite Semichemical Pulp from the Saffle Digester
Paper properties at
"greaseproof density," bl.
Refining
temp.,
C
110
Refiner
plate setting, mm
0.3
5.0
130
160
5.0
5.0
0.3
SamCMT of Beating
pling at unbl. pulp, time,
discharge
lb
min
Before
After
Before
After
Before
After
Before
After
After
65
60
63
(54)
68
64
59
58
...
9
9
11
12
9
9
9
10
19
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
9.5
9.7
9.7
9.7
9.2
9.3
9.3
8.6
7.9
62
60
60
62
64
58
59
53
48
Table 5.4. Analytical Composition of Neutral Sulfite Semichemical Pulp from the Saffle Digester;
Varied Refining Temperature and Plate Setting
Refining
temp.,
C
130
160
Refiner Sampling
plate setat disting, mm charge
Before
After
Before
After
Before
After
Before
After
%
85.4
82.5
85.8
85.9
84.8
85.2
84.7
85.7
79.2
74.4
80.6
79.7
79.4
79.2
78.2
80.5
24.4
23.6
23.1
24.8
23.8
24.4
23.4
22.6
Glucose
68.5
66.4
71.0
69.8
70.8
69.9
69.2
69.4
Mannose Xylose
28.0
30.3
27.5
28.4
25.7
27.5
28.4
28.0
Analytical composition
of fraction soluble
in 10% NaOH, %
Glucose
Mannose Xylose
90.6
89.0
71
Table 5.5. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data and Paper Properties of NSSC Birch
Pulps for Corrugating Medium Board, Produced in the Mumin Pilot Digester and in
the Laboratory
Laboratory pulps
Yield level, % on wood
Retention time, hr
Impregnation
Cooking
Temperature, C
Liquor ratio, m /ton wood
Cooking chemicals charged
Na 2 C0 3 , % on wood
S02,%onwood
Final pH
Roe chlorine No.
Brightness, % SCAN
Resin content, %
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Galactose
Glucose
Mannose
Arabinose
Xylose
Paper properties at 25 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm3
CMT at 127 g/m 2 , lb
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm3
CMT at 127 g/m 2 , lb
82
78
72
2.0
1.5
153
4
2.0
3.7
153
4
2.0
4.0
160
4
120
48
6.5
19.3
48.1
0.64
120
48
6.1
18.9
47.1
0.81
120
48
6.4
16.9
46.4
0.94
67.8
2.2
68.7
3.2
71.1
1.9
30.1
28.1
27.1
0.6
69.4 69.2 68.8 70.3
3.6 5.2 2.2
3.2
0.4
27.5 27.3 25.4 27.5
15
4.4
61
0.51
37
8
4.9
65
0.56
38
12
6.2
70
0.63
39
6
1
4
7
4.9
5.4 5.3 6.0
73
77
80
70
0.52. 0.58 0.54 0.61
38
36
40
42
27
6.0
54
0.62
47
14
6.4
57
0.65
48
20
7.8
62
0.73
49
12
6
9
12
6.9
7.4 7.3 7.6
60
66
71
69
0.62 0.66 0.64 0.70
48
46
48 48
82
80
76
Fig. 5.4.
Table 5.6. Corrugating Medium Board, Produced out of NSSC Birch Pulp from the
Mumin Pilot Digester, as Well as from a Full-Scale Mumin Digester and from a
Conventional Multiscrew NSSC Digester.
Pine Kraft Addition to the Furnish 15% or Less
Pilot
Mumin
Pulp yield level, %
Slowness of furnish at
headbox, SR
Basis weight, g/m2
Sheet density, g/cm3
Tensile strength, km
MD
CD
Elongation to break, %
MD
CD
CMT, kp
MD
CD
82
Commercial
Mumin
84
Commercial
multiscrew
83
38
126
0.69
35
127
0.59
127
0.57
7.7
4.2
8.8
3.8
7.9
4.0
1.8
4.6
2.1
2.6
2.2
2.7
28
17
31
15
25
73
KMW, where it was run at the maximal speed of 600 m/min without
wet-web breaks, with 15% pine kraft, and at 550 m/min with no addition
of long-fibered pulp. The other trial was at the experimental paper machine of PCL (Central Laboratory of the Swedish Paper Industry) at
Stockholm, where the pulp was run at moderate speed, but instead a
finished corrugating medium was produced. The test results of this board
are shown in Table 5.6 together with an average of mill-scale produced
Scandinavian corrugating medium boards. The board was further run on
the experimental corrugator of CL (Central Laboratory of the Finnish
Pulp and Paper Industry) at Helsinki. There it showed no breaks up to
the maximal speed of the corrugator, 300 m/min, and goQd glueability
over the entire practical speed range.
To judge from the experimental pulping, papermaking, and converting
data, the Mumin digester system produced an excellent corrugating medium board grade. This, together with the satisfactory washing results, contributed to our decision to order a digester for Gruvon, for a corrugating
medium board line which is the largest in the world so far. The design of
the system, which will have an ultimate capacity of about 600 tons/day, is
shown in Fig. 5.4. The Mumin digester is attached to a blow tank in the
form of a live-bottom bin to allow a reliable feeding of the refiners and
some drainage after the digester washing. This will, so far, at 300-400
tons/day, be the entire washing system, with high-density pumps after the
refiners directly feeding the thick stock buffer tower with no intermediate
washing or screening. Ultimately, with the increased cooking capacity, a
pressing stage can be included prior to the refiners to complete the washing. We also considered omitting the live-bottom bin and feeding the
refiners directly from the digester blow cyclones, then passing the stock
through a continuous diffuser prior to the buffer storage towers. This
may be the most elegant solution but it was not sufficiently developed at
the stage of decision for us. As shown by Table 5.6, the quality experience of the pilot digester and experimental paper machine has been verified on the large scale.
It remains to be added that an equally large digester has been ordered for
Japan for the same purpose, and a smaller one for Sweden. It should also
be added, that there is now also one large Defibrator digester unit coming
into operation in Finland for the production of 300-400 tons/day which
was considered by us but finally decided against because of limitations of
expansion and absence of digester washing. Another NSSC digester of
similar capacity, Esco, has been recently installed in North America.
Lecture 6
76
Lecture 6
Fig. 6 . 1 .
the vanillyl alcohol groups of lignin to form mercapto groups, which then
give episulfide under splitting of the bond between two monomers (Fig.
6.2). The episulfide is subsequently hydrolyzed to alcohol groups in the
lignin under reformation of hydrosulfide, whereas the sodium hydroxide is
consumed by the lignin in the principal splitting reaction of the alkyl-aryl
ether bond. That reaction not only decreases the molecular size of the
lignin but also makes it water-soluble as a phenolate and thus brings it into
solution. Only 0.1 -0.2 S/monomer remains in that lignin.
Unfortunately, there are also other lignin reactions. There is condensation to larger molecules, which partly counteracts the degradation just
mentioned. To some extent the condensation is favored by the formaldeh y d e formation occurring from the aliphatic part of t h e lignin monomer in
the absence of sulfide (see Fig. 6.1). In the kraft cook, lignin condensation is not a factor to watch out for as in sulfite cooking, in the sense that
it should prevent delignification if conditions are not chosen correctly. There is merely one phenomenon of importance, which is likely to
OCH3
Fig. 6.2. Sulfide-induced alkaline hydrolysis of lignin.
have connection with condensation, and that is color formation of the
pulp lignin. It has had to be accepted that kraft pulp and papers are
brown, but there are different shades, brighter or darker, reddish, yellowish, or blueish. In the first approximation, a kraft pulp can be said to
be the darker the more lignin it contains, as illustrated by Fig. 6.3. Then
there is an influence from other colored compounds present, such as
extractives, or the blue color from iron and bark tannins when pulping
spruce containing substantial amounts of bark. Such influences may
necessitate a more complete color measurement than brightness, such as
with the tristimulus filters of the Elrepho meter.
Unbleached kraft pulp brightness and color shades are of increasing
importance, not only for kraft paper to envelopes, etc., but also to sacks
and for liner board to boxes, which are increasingly being printed. The
increase in pulp color with an increase in yield is therefore a serious
limiting factor in our efforts to save wood. The cause of the discoloration
of lignin in kraft pulping is therefore an urgent subject of research, since
we know too little today to describe the reaction and define its variables. We can only suspect that it has to do with the formation of
quinoid or semiquinoid structures. Demethylation of guaiacyl propane
monomers leads to pyrocatechol structures, which in order to yield
o-quinone structures must find a ready hydrogen acceptor. This may be
dioxocyclohexene, likewise formed from pyrocatechol structures, which
after hydrogenation and rearrangement ends up as hydroxycyclopentanecarboxylate, a proved reaction.
This demethylation has been studied quite closely for a different
reason: odor abatement. Softwood lignin contains a methoxyl group on
almost every monomer, and hardwood lignin in addition has a second
40
50
60
70
80
YIELD, %
90
79
100
81
tion. The splitting of the alkyl-aryl ether bond of lignin has its counterpart in the scission of the glycosidic bonds of the carbohydrate chains,
which appears to proceed over an epoxide (Fig. 6.8). It is thus understandable that the conditions of the delignification in the soda cook had to
cause carbohydrate degradation, until a reaction was found to speed up
the lignin degradation. As far as is known, it is not possible to accelerate
the carbohydrate degradation with hydrolsulfide, and thus episulfide formation is not an intermediate reaction in this case.
The chain splitting reaction of the carbohydrates proceeds mainly at
maximum temperature of the kraft cook, 160-180C. At lower temperature, 60-160C, an important carbohydrate reaction takes place, called the
peeling reaction (Fig. 6.9). This starts at the aldehyde end groups of the
chains, and after certain internal rearrangement reactions leads to the removal of the terminating monomer in the form of the sodium salt of a
saccharinic acid. The nature of this acid varies with the carbohydrate
attacked, but it is usually a C6- or C5-isosaccharinic acid. In addition,
some fragmentation of the end monomer occurs, to give acids of lower
molecular weight, formic and lactic acid, also consuming alkali. After
peeling of the end monomer, a new terminating unit appears, likewise
H OH
Fig. 6.7. Demethylation of glucuronoxylan in .the kraft cook.
ending with an aldehyde group and capable of the same reaction. In this
way, monomer after monomer is peeled off under consumption of alkali,
and the entire carbohydrate wouid be destroyed if there were not a
stopping mechanism. There are several types, having in common the elimination of the aldehyde group, which is the weak point of the molecule
(Fig. 6.10).
One stopping reaction would be a fragmentation of the end monomer,
yielding a terminating unit of 3-5 carbon atoms and ending with an acidic
or alcoholic group. This type has not been definitely proved but is rather
likely. Another stopping reaction is an intermolecular rearrangement of
CH2OH
H^ ^CHOH OH
c
\ ~ / \ O H ACOOH
H H
Fig. 6.11. End group stabilization by redox reactions.
In connection with the methods of increasing the carbohydrate yield
should also be mentioned the method for diminishing it by prehydrolysis. By subjecting the wood to an acid hydrolysis, either with mineral
acids at moderate temperature or with a steam or water treatment at
160-180C, the carbohydrates are degraded to shorter molecules, which to
a certain extent dissolve during the prehydrolysis but predominantly remain in the chips. Because of their shorter chains, they contain more
aldehyde groups and therefore degrade more easily by alkaline peeling. Since the cellulose is more protected against the prehydrolysis than
are the hemicelluloses, because of its more well-ordered superstructure, the
prehydrolysis-kraft cook yields a rather pure cellulose, suitable for the
viscose process (Fig. 6.15). In order to illustrate how the main part of the
fiber wall is influenced by these process modifications, Figs. 6.16-6.18
show the schematical carbohydrate distribution around the secondary wall
elementary fibril, analogous to Figs. 2.20-2.21 for wood and sulfite pulps.
Changes not only in the chemical reactivity but also in physical accessibility to peeling may influence the carbohydrate yield of kraft pulping. The reprecipitatfon of xylan onto the fiber has been indicated to be
of this kind. Anyway, it has been proved that some carbohydrates dissolve in the beginning of the kraft cook, reach a maximum concentration
at the end of the impregnation period, and then eventually disappear again
from the solution (Fig. 6.19). Some of them probably degrade in solu-
2.0
2.5
SULFUR, % on wood
Fig. 6.12. Increase in unbleached kraft pulp yield, given in percent based
on the wood, in relation to the amount of sodium borohydride (above),
and polysulfide sulfur (below) added to the cooking liquor, given in percent based on the wood.
tion, but it has also been demonstrated that part is capable of becoming
adsorbed to cellulose. This phenomenon is dependent on the alkali concentration of the liquor (Fig. 6.20), and therefore on the alkali charge. It
is mainly xylan that is capable of readsorption, probably because it is more
easily stabilized chemically than the glucomannan, which degrades rather
quickly in solution. When the alkali charge of the cook is increased, the
xylan content in the pulp decreases, the glucomannan content increases,
and the pulp yield goes down for a constant degree of delignification. For
the same reason, a decrease in pulp yield and xylan content must be
expected of a countercurrent kraft cook, since that will leave the highest
alkali concentration to the end of the cook.
There are two more carbohydrate reactions of importance to the alkali
consumption, namely, the direct neutralization of the glucuronic acid
POLYSULFIDE SULFUR, %
Fig. 6.17.
Schematic representation of cross section of cellulose elementary fibril surrounded by hemicelluloses, in main secondary wall of j>olysulfide or borohydride kraft pulp.
CH3COONa
Fig. 6.21. Instantaneous carbohydrate reactions of the kraft cook.
produced per hexose unit. This is what is found by direct reaction of
carbohydrates with alkali.
Thus the predominant part of the alkali is consumed by carbohydrates. The amount consumed at immediate contact between wood and
cooking liquor at 100-110C is about 70 kg NaOH/ton o.d. wood, 7 or 8%
92
Lecture 6
NaOH
76
lg5
)
|
Na 2 C0 3 19
)
M28
[13()
Na 2 S
33
J
Na 2 S0 4
2
'
Concepts, g/liter Na 2 0: Total alkali NaOH + Na 2 C0 3 + Na2S + Na 2 S0 4
Total titrable alkali NaOH + Na 2 C0 3 + Na2 S
Total active alkali NaOH + Na2 S
Total effective alkali NaOH + Vi Na2 S
%:
Sulfldity Na 2 S/(Na 2 S + NaOH)
Causticity NaOH/(NaOH + Na 2 C0 3 + Na2S)
Causticizing efficiency NaOH/(NaOH + Na 2 C0 3 )
Fig. 6.22.
Fig. 6.23.
130
128
109
93
30
60
80'
93
which really becomes fixed to the lignin, the amounts of organically combined lignin toward the end of the cook is only 5-10 kg S/ton o.d. wood
(0.5-1%). With an effective alkali charge of 170 kg NaOH/ton o.d. wood,
10 kg S only means 25 kg Na2S, or a sulfidity of about 13%. The normal
sulfidity of 30% means 24 kg S, which thus leaves a considerable surplus
above the sulfur consumed in side reactions. Extensive investigations on
the role of the sulfidity in kraft pulping indicate a critical level of 15-20%
and no major improvement in the rate of pulping above 25%.
Although the above considerations are principally correctthat alkali
concentration, temperature, and time are the major variables controlling
the rate of pulping, provided that the sulfidity is high enoughit would be
wrong to treat the kraft pulping as a homogeneous-phase system. Since a
large part of the alkali is consumed immediately or almost immediately, it
is an obvious possibility that some of the alkali has been consumed before
impregnation is complete and that there exists an alkali concentration
gradient in the chips. This means a danger of non-uniform cooking from
different parts of the chips and different chip thicknesses. A dependence
of the rate of cooking from the chip thickness has been well established
(Fig. 6.24). Assuming that the chips can absorb 2 m3 of liquor per ton
o.d. wood and have a moisture content of 50%, this means that 1 m3 of
chip moisture and 1 m3 of white liquor can be absorbed, disregarding
steaming condensate. That volume of white liquor of normal strength will
contain 110-120 kg active alkali, of which about 80 kg will be consumed
directly and 40 kg will be left over for the genuine cooking. Another
60-80 kg active alkali/ton o.d. wood will have to diffuse into the chips,
and run the risk of being consumed on the way in, thus overcooking the
exterior and undercooking the interior of the chips. Since the diffusion
paths are normally only 1-2 mm to the interior from the outside, the
effects are not catastrophic at normal chip thickness and normal chemical
pulp grades. With nonuniform chips or with semichemical kraft pulp for
liner board, the heterogeneity becomes quite noticeable and may limit the
maximum yield level. This makes various systems for impregnation
pretreatment of interest, in addition to the steaming and pressure-impregnation treatments already described in connection with the sulfite process. The figures quoted are valid for Scandinavian softwoods. The
heavier southern pines absorb less liquor, and the diffusion of alkali into
the wood becomes more important, whereas some of the lightweight soft.woods of Canada may be able to absorb the entire alkali demand by good
impregnation with white liquor of normal concentration.
The properties of spruce kraft pulps at varying yield and process modifications are shown in Fig. 6.25, together with the properties of sulfite
94
Lecture 6
100
120
140
160
180
TEAR FACTOR
Fig. 6.25. Tensile-tear strength relation in the 25-45SR region for spruce
pulps of various degrees of delignification from various processes. Numbers
indicate pulp yield.
hydrate yield of the kraft process by polysulfide or borohydride additions
keeps up the tensile fairly well, but at the expense of tear strength.
All those changes reflect the influence of the hemicelluloses to improve
the paper bonding characteristics, at the same time tending to make the
paper more sensitive to locally applied stresses, such as in the tear
test. The figure also illustrates the strength advantage of kraft pulps as
compared to acid sulfite, and the insufficiency of the sulfite process
modifications to meet the strength demands that the market is used to put
up because of kraft pulp.
This picture would not be complete without showing the influence of
wood species on kraft paper pulp strength (Fig. 6.26). Two main conclusions can be drawn from that figure and comparisons with the previous
one. One is that hardwood kraft represents a widely varying quality concept, with the poor members being filler pulps of little strength and the
better ones approaching or surpassing spruce sulfite in strength. The same
picture is obtained when bleached grades are compared and also when
opacity is introduced as one of the quality criteria. The other main conclusion from the figure is the influence of softwood density, i.e., fiber wall
thickness or summerwood content, on kraft pulp strength. A lightweight
softwood, as grown in Scandinavia or Canada, gives a better paper bond-
96
Lecture 6
Fig. 6.26. Tensile-tear strength relation in the 25-45SR region for kraft
pulps of various wood species. Numbers at each curve indicate basic density/average fiber length for the respective wood species.
ing, with a higher tensile and lower tear, than a heavier softwood such as
slash pine. In general, these differences move along the general beating
curve for softwood kraft, meaning that a southern pine kraft, beaten to
the extreme, reaches similar paper characteristics, aside from porosity, as a
light-beaten Scandinavian or Canadian softwood kraft.
This terminates the process background for kraft pulping. As in the
case of sulfite, it has had to be a rather sketchy one, serving as an introduction to the presentation of efforts on continuous cooking rather than to
give a complete coverage of what is known today on the subject.
Lecture 7
99
1957
Batch
Speed of bottom scraper, rpm
Discharge temperature, C
Screw pressing
Number of tests per average
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Cont.
Cont.
1959
Batch
Cont.
2
145
20
20
59
59
33
1.6
145
+
33
59
10.3
114
62
9.9
101
60
10.5
114
60
10.4
102
55
10.1
111
58
9.9
97
3
170
1960-61
Batch Cont.
Speed of bottom scraper, rpm
Discharge temperature, C
Screw pressing
Number of tests per average
Paper properties at 45SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Batch
1967
Batch Cont.
34
1.6
100
+
34
40
1.6
100
+
39
61
10.5
112
66
10.6
113
57
10.0
124
69
10.0
122
1968
Batch Cont.
. 18
48
10.2
121
1.6
100
+
19
57
10.2
125
100
Sampling
station
Beating
time,
mm
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
Sheet
density,
g/cm3
Above scraper
After discharge
Batch pulp
Above scraper
After discharge
Batch pulp
39
39
39
42
47
39
9.5
9.4
9.5
10.2
9.6
9.6
131
114
125
144
134
132
0.67
0.65
0.67
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating
time,
min
Above scraper
After discharge
Batch pulp
Above scraper
After discharge
Batch pulp
Tensile
strength,
km
Tear
factor
Sheet
density,
g/cm
10.4
10.2
10.3
11.3
10.8
10.6
119
102
113
129
119
119
0.71
0.70
0.73
101
Table. 7.3. Kraft Pulp Quality at Various Stages of Processing; Extended Testing
Discharge Temperature, 100C
Paper properties at 25 SR
Sampling
station
Beating
time,
nun
Tensile
strength,
km
Stretch
at break,
Above scraper
After discharge
After screw press
Batch pulp
Laboratory pulp
38
41
42
35
31
9.9
9.9
9.5
9.5
9.6
4.7
4.7
4.9
4.8
4.5
Tear
factor
Sheet
density,
g/cm3
Air
resist.,
sec/100 ml
139
136
134
138
146
0.67
0.67
0.65
0.66
0.67
29
31
26
34
31
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating
time,
min
Above sciaper
After discharge
After screw press
Batch pulp
Laboratory pulp
58
64
65
58
54
Tensile
Sheet
Stretch
strength, at break, Tear density,
factor g/cm3
km
11.3
11.1
10.8
11.0
10.9
4.9
5.0
5.1
5.1
4.9
124
123
119
121
130
0.72
0.72
0.71
0.72
0.73
Air
resist.,
sec/100 ml
335
300
270
390
400
These trials clearly demonstrated the necessity of the cold blow and
showed that the continuously cooked pulp was up to mill batch pulp
standard. They also indicated the possibility of surpassing it and reaching
the laboratory pulp standard, and this has been realized elsewhere in connection with the countercurrent washing, where the cooling of the pulp to
blow temperature is more uniform than it can be in the rather primitive
cooling system of Gruvon.
We also sought to find out the reasons why the hot blow gave an inferior
pulp quality. Table 7.4 shows the results of paper testing, fiber length
measurements, chemical analysis, and DP determination of pulp and
hemicellulose fractions, of the samples taken before discharge, after hot
and semi-hot blows, and from batch cooking. No evidence whatsoever
can be seen on any measurable property of those usually having an influence
on paper strength. It is therefore concluded that the damage done by the
hot blow is restricted to very limited regions of the fibers, such as the
so-called slip planes of the fiber wall in the superstructure of cellulose. The agreement with the previously reported experience on the hot
blow of other pulp types is striking, as compiled in Table 7.5.
DP of fro
DPof710
Pulp composition, %
Cellulose
Glucomannan
Glucuronoarabinoxylan
0io composition, %
Cellulose
Glucomannan
Glucuronoarabinoxylan
7i o composition, %
Cellulose
Galactoglucomannan
Glucuronoarabinoxylan
20
57
10.5
117
1.8
77
87.3
87.1
5.7
8.6
182
145
60
10.2
170
Batch
2.0
54
9.8
91
1.9
61
10.3
119
1-9
83
86.8
86.6
2.7
10.2
141
115
75
86.7
86.3
3.8
9.9
180
108
81
86.7
86.5
2.7
10.0
142
113
103
78
7
15
78
8
14
78
8
14
4
9
81
4
7
79
4
7
81
0
30
70
0
31
69
0
31
69
103
Pulping process
Digester
Cont., 1-body
Cont., 1-body
Cont., 1-body
Batch, mill
Cont., 1-body
Cont., 1-body
Cont., 1-body
Batch, mill
Cont., 2-body
Cont., 2-body
Batch, mill
Batch, lab.
Cont., 2-body
Cont., 2-body
Cont., Mumin
Batch, mill
Batch, lab,
Cont., 2-body
Cont, 2-body
Cont., Mumin
Batch, mill
Batch, lab.
Kraft, pine
Bisulfite-acid sulfite,
spruce
Neutral sulfite-acid
sulfite, spruce
Bisulfite, spruce
Discharge
temp., C
160
130
110
170
145
100
120
50
120
50
50
120
50
50
8.0
8.6
9.6
9.4
9.9
10.4
10.9
10.5
7.5
9.0
8.7
9.5
8.1
8.3
8.4
9.3
8.6
8.8
10.4
9.8
10.3
10.5
57
62
68
70
101
102
117
114
59
68
66
75
49
55
66
53
64
62
65
85
75
86
their digester, as well as their paper machines. Many problems have also
come up because the continuous one-line production requires a different
approach to maintenance than a batch system with several digesters and
chests. Systematic preventive maintenance is vital to the success of a
continuous digester. By experience and skill, several mills have achieved
a digester performance of 99%. In Gruvon, with the pulp mill attached
to a paper mill, the average downtime of the continuous kraft digester
during recent years has been about 5%, of which 3% occurred because of
the paper mill, power failures, or steam shortage, 0.5-1% because of miscellaneous disturbances, and 1-1.5% because of actual digester
troubles. No major changes have been made in the machine parts. Lowpressure and high-pressure feeders are worn out in about two years, which
appears to be general experience.
Table 7.6. Kraft Pulp Quality from Pine, Birch, and Eucalypt in the Jossefors Pilot Digester, as Compared to Laboratory Pulping
Wood species
Pine
Pinus silvestris
Pulping operation
Roe chlorine No.
Brightness, % SCAN
Resin content, %
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Glucose
Mannose
Xylose
Paper properties at 25 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Birch
Betula verrucosa
Laboratory
Pilot
hydraulic
Pilot
Mumin
Laboratory
5.2
24.3
0.34
5.4
27.1
0.18
5.1
30.6
0.19
3.0
32
0.9
84.4
6.2
8.7
84.2
7.5
8.3
82.9
9.1
7.6
41
9.5
156
53
9.9
143
66
10.8
130
82
11.0
129
Pilot
hydraulic
Eucalypt
Eucalyptus globulus
Pilot
Mumin
Laboratory
Pilot
hydraulic
2.2
35.9
0.51
3.0
34.8
0.51
2.2
35.3
0.27
2.2
42.3
0.40
2.6
37.8
0.25
73.7
0.5
25.8
73.1
0.0
26.9
73.2
1.7
25.2
81.2
18.8
80.1
0.3
19.6
80.9
0.3
18.8
43
9.4
149
16
7.0
88
14
6.6
90
17
7.1
103
18
5.7
95
14
5.5
93
17
5.4
100
67
10.8
128
25
8.6
73
26
8.9
81
31
9.5
87
37
8.6
105
28
8.1
106
33
7.9
103
Pilot
Mumin
Lecture 8
106
Lecture 8
107
H.P. STEAM
108
Lecture 8
109
110
Lecture 8
111
112
Lecture 8
113
114
Lecture 8
115
Prehydrolysis
Kraft cooking
Washing
Prehydrolysis
Kraft cooking
Washing
To transition circulation
To cooking circulation
Total
White liquor sulfidity, %
Roe No.
Screenings, % on pulp
Viscosity, cp TAPPI
Rl8.%
R10,%
R, % (= alpha-cellulose)
Brightness, unbleached, % SCAN
Retention time, hr
2.5
1.5
3.0
2.0
2.5 '
15
Temperature, C
166
170
155
158
135
135
Active alkali charge,
% Na2O on wood
8.6
8.5
9.4
9.8
18.0
18.3
30
0.7
0.9
65
97.8
96.4
97.2
48
30
0.6
0.9
56
97.5
96.4
97.0
49
drolysis. This was achieved by feeding the first chips into the empty
digester at full vapor-phase prehydrolysis conditions. After reaching a
certain chip level, white liquor which was preheated to cooking temperature was introduced to the digester bottom and the liquor level successively raised. The discharge was started at the moment the chip level
reached the digester top. This startup method gave a rayon grade pulp
from the very beginning, and any contamination by paper grade kraft pulp
was avoided.
After the initial adjustments in equipment and operation, and a limited
trial period with three wood species, a reUability test was performed to
investigate the operation efficiency. During a test period of one month,
the digester was in operation more than 99% of the time, disregarding a
short stop because of a pipe welding failure. The remaining 0.8% downtime was caused by tramp iron. Considering that this reliability test was
carried out with a new system, the results must be regarded as quite
satisfactory. Subsequent operation of the pilot digester for over half a
year to produce trial quantities for customers fully confirmed these conclusions, and this can also on the whole be said about the commercial
operation of the 300 ton/day digester in Portugal, after some necessary
116
Lecture 8
Table 8.2. Cooking Conditions and Quality Data for Prehydrolysis-kraft
Pulps from Pine, Birch, and Eucalypt, Mumin Pilot Digester and Laboratory
Cooking. Retention Times Not Identical
adjustments caused by scaling-up factors. Digesters have also been ordered for USA and Russia with identical design but twice the size.
Table 8.1 shows digester conditions and quality data for eucalypt prehydrolysis-kraft pulp produced at two different rates of production. The
retention times were fairly long, though not excessive. The comparatively
low temperatures in the kraft cooking stage indicate that the volume of
this zone can be reduced. The necessary charge of active alkali, 230
kg/ton o.d. wood, as NaOH (18% Na 2 0), is rather high owing to the fact
that the prehydrolyzate is not extracted separately. In many cases, however, it is an advantage to include the solids dissolved by the prehydrolysis
stage in the black liquor. This will give more heat from the recovery
furnace and also minimize the water pollution problem.
The pulp quality was uniform and on a high level. The high alpha-cellulose content of 97% obtained was partly due to severe hydrolysis conditions and partly to the fact that eucalyptus is a wood species well suited
for high-grade rayon pulp. The effect of different wood species on final
pulp quality is illustrated in Table 8.2, which shows the result of similar
trials on pine, birch, and eucalyptus. The quality data obtained are
satisfactory and quite comparable to those of laboratory-cooked batch
pulp. Possibly the countercurrent principle in the kraft cook gave a shade
higher purity than the corresponding batch cook, though the main reason
for maintaining it is the greater uniformity obtained from the kraft cook.
One can therefore conclude that the new continuous cooking system
119
cook. That white water has to be cooled before the introduction to the
digester base, to ensure proper cold alkali purification temperature, and
then subsequently heated in the digester as usual between the washing and
cooking zones. Likewise the fresh white liquor should be cooled to
ensure 30C in the purification. A less good heat economy and a slightly
reduced pulp yield are the limited disadvantages to obtain the increased
cellulose purity shown in Table 8.3. The system has thus been tested on
the pilot scale and will soon be tried on the large scale. It constitutes an
elegant example of how the continuous cooking system can be advantageously utilized in combination with a subsequent operation.
I have described the development of prehydrolysis-kraft cooking fairly
elaborately, in spite of its specificity, partly because that was the process
which initiated the development of the flexible Mumin digester system,
and partly because several of its elements may become useful in other
process applications. The reliable performance of the system further
shows that once a continuous system has been worked out, one should not
fear to run a series of seemingly complicated operations, such as steaming,
liquor impregnation, vapor-phase cooking, countercurrent liquor-phase
cooking, and countercurrent washing, or even cold alkali purification.
Complexity is not a virtue in itself, but in order to achieve the goals of
quality and economy it may sometimes be necessary to accept it, and to
make it work.
Lecture 9
122
Lecture 9
123
Table 9.1. Cooking Conditions and Analytical Data for Chemical Kraft Pulps
Produced with the Normal Hydraulic System and the System with Instant
Heating (Mumin). Pine, Birch, Eucalypt
Hydraulic system
Pine
Birch
Eucalypt
Mumin system
Pine
Birch
Eucalypt
The results of the kraft paper pulp cooking in the Mumin digester system
with instant heating are shown in Tables 9.1 and 9.2 ( cf. also Table 9.4),
in comparison with normal hydraulic cooking with a heating period. In
the case of eucalypt and birch, only chemical kraft pulps were produced,
and the composition, strength, and screen rejects with the Mumin system
were found to be entirely equivalent to normal hydraulic cooking. This
conclusion has been further corraborated by the preparation of several
hundred tons of trial quantities of bleached eucalypt paper pulp in
sefors and by the 500 ton/day operation at Leirosa, Portugal.
In the case of pine, some differences could be detected, seemingly insignificant, perhaps, but important enough in view of the size of the pine
kraft pulping of the world. The carbohydrate composition of the pulps
from the cooking with instant heating appears to be slightly different, with
somewhat less xylan and somewhat more glucomannan, indicating about
124
Lecture 9
Table 9.2. Paper Properties of Chemical Kraft Pulps Produced with Normal Hydraulic System and System with Instant Heating (Mumin). Pine, Birch, Eucalypt
Hydraulic system
Pine
Birch
Eucalypt
Mumin system
Pine
Birch
Eucalypt
125
126
Lecture 9
127
Table 9.3. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties for Pine
Chemical Kraft Pulps, Produced Concurrently and Countercurrently. In all cases
instant heating in the Mumin system.
128
Lecture 9
Table 9.4. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data and Paper Properties of Semichemical Kraft Pulps, Produced Concurrently and Countercurrently. Hydraulic
cooking as well as Mumin cooking
Hydraulic cooking
Concurrent
Partial
countercurrent
Countercurrent
Mumin cooking
Concurrent
Partial
countercurrent
Retention time, hr
129
Table 9.5. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties of Chemical and Semichemical Kraft and
Polysulfide Pulps, Produced by the Hydraulic or Mumin Systems
Mumin cooking
Hydraulic cooking
Chemical
Retention time, hr
Impregnation
Cooking
Temperature, C
Impregnation
Cooking
Pressure, atm
Active alkali charge, %Na 2 0 on wood
Sulfur charge, % S on wood
Roe chlorine No.
Screenings, % on pulp
Brightness, % SCAN
Resin content, %
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Galactose
Glucose
Mannose
Arabinose
Xylose
Chemical
Semichemical
Kraft
Polysulfide
Kraft
Polysulfide
2.5
2.0
2.5
2.0
2.5
2.0
125
168
10
14.5
0
5.4
2
27.1
0.18
125
171
10
18.0
4.4
5.2
4
21.9
0.18
...
84.2
7.5
...
8.3
...
83.2
8.7
0.9
7.2
Polysulfide
Semichemical
Kraft
1-stage
1-stage
2-stage
Kraft
Polysulfide
2.5
2.0
0.02
2.2
0.02
2.2
0.02
2.2
2.0
2.4
0.02
2.0'
0.02
2.0
125
155
10
13.5
0
14.5
125
150
10
15.0
3.8
14.5
105
156
9
18.5
4.3
5.2
4
26.7
0.20
122
151
9
18.5
4.0
5.5
1
26.5
0.27
105
147
9
14.0
3.2
14.5
15.7
0.38
105
158
9
17.0
1.0
4.4
4
29.6
0.15
105
152
9
14.0
0
14.5
17.9
0.38
105
165
9
16.0
0
5.1
3
30.6
0.19
19.2
0.37
18.0
0.35
1.1
79.9
8.5
1.7
8.8
1.2
78.1
11.0
1.7
8.0
0.2
82.9
9.1
0.2
7.6
0.6
83.1
10.3
0.6
5.4
0.6
"81.3
11.4
1.0
5.7
0.8
79.9
12.7
0.7
5.9
1.2
79.4
10.5
1.5
7.4
1.6
76.0
13.7
1.7
7.0
Table 9.5 Cont'd. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties of Chemical and Semichemical Kraft and
Polysulfide Pulps, Produced by the Hydraulic or Mumin Systems
Mumin cooking
Hydraulic cooking
Chemical
Kraft
Polysulfide
81.7
47.3
Chemical
Semichemical
Polysulfide
Semichemical
Kraft
Polysulfide
Kraft
1-stage
1-stage
2-stage
Kraft
Polysulfide
80.3
48.1
77.1
55.0
74.4
57.5
79.9
48.5
79.7
49.0
77.5
51.5
75.7
53.5
75.9
56.0
71.4
61.2
53
9.9
143
0.70
39
9.6
146
0.67
37
7.6
148
0.57
35
7.6
129
0.56
43
9.4
149
0.68
42
9.2
129
0.66
35
9.0
131
0.65
44
8.8
124
0.66
34
7.4
135
0.55
34
7.2
116
0.55
82
11.0
129
0.76
65
11.2
126
0.75
58
9.0
130
0.63
51
9.0
113
0.64
67
10.8
134
0.74
62
10.4
116
0.72
53
10.4
116
0.72
63
10.1
110
0.69
51
8.7
117
0.64
48
8.4
100
0.62
132
Lecture 9
133
134
Lecture 9
135
Table 9.6. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data and Paper Properties of One-stage
and Two-stage Kiaft and Polysulfide Pulps, Mumin System
Kraft
1-stage
2-stage1
Polysulfide
1-stage 2-stage2 2-stage1
136
Lecture 9
tried in the two-body digester and found to work well. In the two-stage
polysulfide cookings, both 130 and 170C were tried for the initial cooking stage, the latter temperature being equal to that of the subsequent
kraft cook. The results are shown in Table 9.6, indicating that the yield
improvement of polysulfide cooking disappeared with two-stage cooking
using two white liquor charge points. This rather astonishing result indicates that the polysulfide oxidation of carbohydrate end groups requires a
fairly high-alkalinity. As shown in the table, a straight polysulfide cook in
the Mumin system, with all white liquor charged to the feeding circulation
but a lower temperature, 122C, kept in the upper part of the digester for
the polysulfide reaction, gave an unusually high yield. The system must
be arranged for vapor phase in the polysulfide reaction zone to prevent or
limit thermal flow from the kraft cooking zone. The combined high alkalinity and polysulfide concentration of the Mumin feeding system and the
favorable temperature conditions of the vapor-liquor phase cooking explain the good polysulfide efficiency. This is in accordance with laboratory results. It should therefore be possible to limit the sulfur addition to
reasonable amounts, 2% or less, to achieve a desired yield improvement of
4%, but regrettably, lower sulfur additions were not tried with the vaporliquor phase system. Another favorable observation with the vapor-liquor
phase system is the low screenings obtained with both kraft and polysulfide cooking.
The trials with polysulfide cooking have thus shown that continuous
cooking systems can be designed to fit advanced process requirements for
optimal economy and quality.
Before continuing with the presentation of additional process variants, I
should like to sum up the experience on carbohydrate composition of pine
pulps, cooked by the normal kraft process and the variants of instant
heating, countercurrent cooking, and polysulfide cooking, for both chemical and semichemical pulps (Tables 9.3-9.5). The sugar analyses have
been recalculated to cellulose, galactoglucomannan, and glucuronoarabinoxylan (Fig. 9.7). Countercurrent cooking decreases primarily the xylan
yield, whereas instant heating, as well as polysulfide, increases the glucomannan yield and causes a certain loss in xylan. Limiting the degree of
cooking causes a gain not only in lignin yield, but also in xylan and
particularly in glucomannan yield.
A process variant of kraft which has attracted considerable attention
recently is the so-called "Alkafide" process, which is essentially a hydrosulfide-sulfide cook. It is unique so far as it has been developed directly
for continuous cooking by the M & D "piggyback" system, that is, a
two-body digester for a two-stage cook. The essential virtue of the pro-
138
Lecture 9
cess is that it can utilize uncausticized liquor and that therefore the calcium cycle of the recovery system can be eliminated. The snag isso far
-that the recovery furnace cannot be run to give 100% sulfidity in the
green liquor, but that the carbonate must be separated from the sulfide, a
process which has always been within reach of the kraft industry but not
been regarded as a very attractive unit operation. Leaving the recovery
aspects aside, the cooking process consists of a pretreatment at a somewhat lower temperature, where a limited amount of sodium sulfide is
allowed to react with the wood chips to form at steady state a mixture of
hydrosulfide and sulfide. In the second digester body, run at a higher
temperature, the semicooked chips are allowed to react with more sulfide
to give a pulp of essentially kraft pulp yield and strength.
In order to run this process in a really large-scale new mill, or in those
mills already having a Kamyr digester, it could be of interest to apply the
Kamyr system to the Alkafide process. This could be accomplished in a
similar manner as the two-stage polysulfide cooking just described, i.e.,
with a limited charge of sodium sulfide to the feeding circulation, to an
extent corresponding to the first stage of the Alkafide cook. The alkali
consumption in the feeding circulation will convert most of the sulfide to
hydrosulfide and the chips will become impregnated with hydrosulfide,
which may then react with the chips in the precook in the vapor phase,
down to the liquor level, where more sulfide is added. There is also the
obvious possibility of adding sulfur to the feeding liquor for polysulfide
effect.
In the first approximation it was tried to run a straight sodium sulfide
cook, with all cooking liquor added to the chips, and in the second approximation, liquor from the middle of the digester was recycled back to
the top, which also ought to give the desired hydrosulfide cooking medium. The cooking temperature was in both cases constant throughout the
digester, 168 resp. 174C, and the sulfide charged 260 kg/ton o.d. wood,
26%, expressed as NaOH or Na2S. The liquor ratio was kept as low as
possible, about 2.5, which gave a reasonably fast reaction. The chemical
pulp obtained contained more screenings than previous pulps, but was in
most other respects equivalent to kraft pulp (Table 9.7). The carbohydrate composition indicates a fairly normal yield, the strength was on the
kraft pulp level, the brightness somewhat lower, and resin content somewhat higher, without extremes. Considering these trials to have been
rather short and exploratory, the process can be said to have definite
possibilities without having shown any advantages over kraft pulp, as also
indicated by laboratory trials. The interest in the process thus appears to
lie mainly on the recovery side. If the advantages there are found large
139
Table 9.7. Cooking Conditions, Anayltical Data, and Paper Properties of Chemical
Sodium Sulfide, Hydrosulfide, and Polysulfide Pulps (Mumin System)
Retention time, hr
Impregnation
Cooking
Temperature, C
Impregnation
Cooking
Pressure, atm
Active alkali charge,
%Na20 on wood
Sulfidity,
% on total alkali
Sulfur charge,
% S on wood
Roe chlorine No.
Screenings,
% on pulp
Brightness, % SCAN
Resin content, %
1-stage
polysulfide
Normal
High
sulfidity
sulfidity
2-stage
polysulfide
Normal
High
sulfidity
sulfidity
Kraft
Sodium
sulfide
0.02
2.2
0.02
2.2
0.02
4.2
0.02
4.4
2.0
2.4
2.0
2.4
105
165
9
105
172
8
105
156
9
105
177
9
122
151
9
130
168
8
16.0
20.0
18.5
5.5/15.51
18.5
5.0/17.01
30
90
30
100
30
125
0
5.1
0
5.3
4.3
5.2
4.0
5.8
4.0
5.5
4.0
5.0
3
30.6
0.19
8
23.2
0.35
4
26.7
0.20
2
20
...
0.7
26.5
0.27
5
22
Table 9.7 Cont'd. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties of Chemical
Sodium Sulfide, Hydrosulfide, and Polysulfide Pulps (Mumin System)
1-stage
polysulfide
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Galactose
Glucose
Mannose
Arabinose
Xylose
Cellulose content,
% on carbohydrate
Estimated pulp yield,
% on wood
Paper properties at 25 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density,
g/cm3
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength,
km
Tear factor
Sheet density,
g/cm3
1
Kraft
Sodium
sulfide
Normal
sulfidity
0.2
89.9
9.1
0.2
7.6
...
85.4
6.9
1.6
6.1
0.6
81.3
11.4
1.0
5.7
2-stage
polysulfide
High
sulfidity
...
83.4
8.6
0.9
7.2
Normal
sulfidity
High
suffidity
0.8
79.9
12.7
0.7
5.9
83.5
7.3
1.0
8.2
79.9
83.1
77.5
80.6
75.7
81.1
48.5
46.5
51.5
48.0
53.5
47.5
43
9.4
149
41
9.5
145
35
9.0
131
39
10.0
155
44
8.8
124
41
10.1
152
0.68
0.66
0.65
0.70
0.66
0.68
67
66
53
65
63
64
10.8
134
10.9
129
10.4
116
11.0
136
10d
110
11.2
137
0.74
0.73
0.72
0.77
0.69
0.74
Table 9.8. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties of Semichemical Kraft and
Alkaline Sulfite Pulps (Mumin System)
Kraft
Mumin
only
Retention time, hr
Impregnation
Cooking
Temperature, C
Impregnation
Cooking
Pressure, atm
Active alkali charge,
% Na20 on wood
Roe chlorine No.
Brightness, % SCAN
Resin content, %
Carbohydrate analysis, %
Galactose
Glucose
Mannose
Arabinose
Xylose
Cellulose content,
% on carbohydrate
0.02
2.0
Mumin with
no extra preimpr.
0.02
2.0
0.02
2.0
Alkaline sulfite
Mumin with
pressure preimpr.
1.25
2.0
Laboratory
1.25
2.0
0.2
2.0
0.2
2.0
105
152
9
14.0
105
170
9
29.0
105
175
9
19.8
105
170
9
27.0
105
175
9
19.8
105
170
9
27.0
105
175
9
19.8
14.5
19.2
0.4
14.5
20.0
0.5
18.0
14.5
1.2
14.5
18.9
0.9
18.0
14.9
1.2
14.5
17.0
0.5
18.0
14.0
0.6
0.92
82.8
8.0
1.4
7.0
1.2
84.2
6.9
1.3
6.4
1.3
83.5
7.5
1.3
6.4
1.0
85.2
5.5
1.3
6.9
1.0
84.6
5.8
1.3
7.3
80.1
81.9
81.0
83.4
82.7
1.2
79.4
10.5
1.5
7.4
75.9
0.8
83.2
7.6
1.4
7.3
80.7
Table 9.8 Cont'd. Cooking Conditions, Analytical Data, and Paper Properties of Semichemical Kraft and
Alkaline Sulfite Pulps (Mumin System)
Kraft
Mumin
only
Estimated pulp yield,
% on wood
Paper properties at 25 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm
Paper properties at 45 SR
Beating time, min
Tensile strength, km
Tear factor
Sheet density, g/cm3
preimpr. = preimpregnation.
Alkaline sulfite
Mumin with
Mumin with
no extra preimpr.
pressure preimpr.
56.0
58.5
61.5
57.5
61.0
34
7.4
135
0.55
42
8.5
132
0.60
33
7.5
121
0.58
33
8.1
140
0.56
35
7.7
140
0.56
51
8.7
117
0.64
59
9.5
116
0.67
45
8.5
109
0.64
47
9.6
123
0.64
48
9.0
124
0.63
Laboratory
60.5
57
45
8.6
150
0.61
67
10.0
135
0.67
39
7.6
142
0.57
57
9.2
125
0.63
144
Lecture 9
145
146
Lecture 9
147
148
Lecture 9
149
chips to prevail at 120-130C for an hour in the vapor phase in the digester
top before increasing the temperature to cooking in the liquor phase.
Analogous results were obtained on polysulfide cooking with these various
systems, i.e., less screenings through preimpregnation or prevailing in vapor
phase at lower temperature before cooking. The results are summarized
in Table 9.10, together with those of other modifications of chemical kraft
cooking. Similarly, preimpregnation treatment prior to Mumin cooking
of semichemical kraft pulp variants appeared to decrease the fiberizing
energy, indicating better homogeneity of cooking (Table 9.11).
Obviously, differences in the penetrability of the wood may influence
the choice of the kraft pulping system (see experience on semichemical
bisulfite pulping quoted in Lecture 4). For chemical kraft pulps from
hardwoods, such as eucalypt and birch, there appears to be no reason for
choosing elaborate impregnation equipment, and indeed the Mumin digester system is the simplest, fully adequate equipment to choose. For
chemical kraft pulps from pine, the choice is more open to question. The
ordinary hydraulic system appears to come fairly close to ideal uniformity,
and gives somewhat better uniformity than instant heating. If the instant
heating system is preferred for other reasons, and yet absolute unchanged
uniformity desired, the steaming vessel should preferably be designed as
the vertical impregnation chamber. With demands on improved uniformity, the pressure impregnation vessel could be chosen. This is possibly
the case with chemical pulping to higher lignin content than normal. A
possible alternative is the simple Mumin system for vapor-liquor phase
cooking. For semichemical pulping, the impregnation effects should be
reflected in the fiberizing energy consumption and in the paper properties. As indicated in the previous tables, this is the case to only a very
limited extent as far as paper properties are concerned, and the measurement of fiberizing energy did not allow any fine gradation, although preimpregnation did seem to decrease the energy demand. The impregnation
in the simple Mumin system with a white liquor of high concentration may
in many cases yield equivalent results, and could motivate the choice of a
simple digester system. However, the first steaming-impregnation vessels
for the large-scale production of kraft pulps have already been delivered,
to Italy, Japan, and Sweden, and further experience may bring out their
possible advantages more clearly.
The uniformity of impregnation and cooking of semichemical kraft must
be important not only for the energy consumption of the fiberizing, but
also for the shiviness and runnability of the stock on the paper machine. Particularly at the highest yields, this influence of pulp uniformity
ought to be pronounced and a limiting factor in the efforts to decrease
150
Lecture 9
151
152
Lecture 9
153
154
Lecture 9
155
156
Lecture 9
Fig. 9.13. Paper strength between 25 and 45SR for pulps cooked continuously in the experimental pulp plant, as compared to kraft pulps cooked
by the batch and continuous systems on the full mill scale.
wood consumption and cost. A new technique for study of the uniformity of semicooked kraft chips has been applied on four pulps from the
trials with low-pressure and high-pressure preimpregnation. Step-wise
laboratory turrnix treatment of the chips followed by lignin content determinations on the pulp fractions liberated indicated (Figs. 9.11 and 9.12),
considerably better uniformity by the high-pressure preimpregnation. Further studies along these lines appear motivated, and the results
suggest that a perfect impregnation prior to cooking may make higher
yields possible. Several large-scale installations are under way.
To sum up the results of the kraft pulping development work, it is fair to
say that both the process and the machinery may deserve to be less standardized than they used to be. Systems have been designed for simpler
operation, for higher process flexibility, and for improved uniformity. The
process modifications indicated so far by research have all been realized
with fair success in continuous cooking. Their large-scale realization will
now depend on how the recovery problems can be solved, and whether the
quality of the process variants can be accepted. My personal opinion is
that the conventional kraft process will remain dominant for considerable
time, and that the inroads of the process modifications will first come on
special applications. The urge for less wood costs will, however, move the
yields upward by limiting the delignification and by stabilizing the
157
Fig. 9.14. Tear factor at equal tensile strength vs. pulp yield
for the pulps produced in the experimental pulp plant by
various processes and process variants.
carbohydrates. Yields of 60% and above will then be realized. Figure 9.13
compiles the paper strength of the pulps produced in the experimental
pulp plant by various processes and process variants in a diagram plotting
tensile strength against tear strength. The large variety in strength
properties makes those pulps useful in different areas. As shown in Fig.
9.14, the strength variation is largely a function of pulp yield, with the
exception of acid sulfite pulping, where the acidity combined with the
mechanical chip damage results in lower strength at equal yield. It is not
irrelevant, however, how a certain pulp yield was obtained, since the
drainage properties at a certain tensile strength will be quite different for
example, for a semichemical kraft pulp and a chemical polysulfide pulp of
equal yield. A combination of less delignification and less carbohydrate
degradation may therefore prove to be the best alternative in some cases.
Since it is now fairly well known how the process conditions should be
chosen to obtain a certain yield and a certain combination of properties, I
am personally convinced that the most important task for future research
is not to improve the pulping processes as such (aside of their recovery
systems), but to find out what properties are important for each essential
application and then to apply existing knowledge to select the process and
its conditions.
Lecture 10
160
Lecture 10
because these allowed air to mix with liquor and to cause immense foaming problems. These were only eventually solved by improving the filter
design, adding large seal tanks with foam tanks and foam
breakers. Thereby filter washing became an efficient operation but also
required expensive equipment. With the increasing capacities of the kraft
mills, the filter sizes have grown immensely (now approaching 15 m in
width), until it has become evident that a different design principle is
needed.
The filter washing has contributed to the pulp washing technique in
many ways. It introduced continuous operation and instrumentation to
pulp washing, with an easy control and adjustment of the dilution water. However, its design principle has many fundamental drawbacks. It
involves too much of a complicated pulp transport and web-forming operation before it arrives at the proper washing phase; it allows fairly little
time for diffusion during that phase; it introduces the entrainment of air
to the pulp and liquor; it leaves to the atmosphere malodor and steam,
necessitating ventilation hoods and odor abatement systems, it introduces
an operation which requires attention by the operator to prevent overflowing of pulp slurry; and it requires indoor operation.
Presses were more lately introduced to the washing operation. They do
not allow diffusion nor displacement, but are quite efficient by also
squeezing out liquor from the fiber lumen. In combination with filters or
with several presses in series and intermediate dilution, satisfactory washing is obtained. However, a press stage does not give better results than a
filter stage, requires a similar high investment, introduces air, and has
similar operation problems. With the ever-increasing capacities of the
pulp lines, press constructions have had still more difficulties than have
filters in keeping pace with the development.
The diffuser really represented a much sounder approach to washing
than the filter or the press, because it involved fewer moving parts, gave a
closed operation without air entrainment and ventilation, and allowed
both liquor displacement and time for diffusion. Its essential drawback
was the batch operation.
For that reason, the continuous diffuser has been subject of many efforts. However, it was only recently that a successful construction could
be presented. The principal difficulty has been to ensure that the necessary strainer is kept clean of the pulp mat which tends to form at the
withdrawal of liquor from a pulp slurry. At fairly high consistency, this is
not a problem, but then the resistance to liquor flow within the pulp is
excessive instead. A fairly dilute pulp suspension, 5-10% consistency,
must be used, and the strainers must be kept clean by movement. One
161
162
Lecture 10
163
164
Lecture 10
165
quired. Of the sodium loss, about 2-5 kg salt cake per ton of pulp is
chemically combined with the pulp and cannot be recovered by washing
unless the pulp is acidulated.
Filter washing is often visualized as predominantly a displacement operation, since the retention timesonly a few secondsare considered too
short to allow much diffusion.* In countercurrent continuous digester
washing, on the other hand, with 1-4 hr, considerable diffusion must be
expected, despite the considerable diffusion distances from the chip centers. Also, the slower the flow rates, the more efficient must the displacement process be, and hence the less the turbulence and mixing between waste liquor and washing liquor. In crude terms, old-fashioned
batch diffuser wash involved linear flow rates of about 1 m/hr, continuous
*Assuming accessibility of the individual fibers, however, diffusion will take place
because of the short diffusion distances.
166
Lecture 10
digester wash a relative linear flow rate of about 10 m/hr, and filter wash
about 100 m/hr through the pulp pad. In all cases, channeling is obviously detrimental to the result.
A concept widely used in filter washing is the displacement ratio, DR,
which is defined as the ratio between the recovered solids in a volume
corresponding to the liquor volume of the pulp leaving the washing operation, and the solids in a corresponding volume of liquor entering the
washing stage. Assuming the same pulp consistency in and out of the
washing, the DR becomes equal to U, the substance yield factor, but if
there is an increase in consistency, the substance yield factor will be higher
than the DR as a result of a thickening preceding the displacement. The
DR is simply measured by the ratio of concentrations as follows:
where Cin and c o u t are the concentration of solubles in the liquor of the
pulp entering and leaving the washing, and c w a s h , the solubles concentration of the wash liquor. This is a convenient way of measuring the washing result but tells nothing about the quality of the operation unless related to the dilution factor, since the DR must necessarily increase by an
increasing volume of wash liquor. A related concept to the displacement
ratio is the entrainment, E, or the amount of solids entrained by the pulp
leaving the washing stage with a weight of W ton of liquor per ton of
pulp. Obviously, E = W( 1 - DR).
The continuous digester washing must obviously involve some diffusion
from the interior of the chips to their surface, as long as the chip structure
is preserved. There will always be a larger resistance to flow within the
wood structure than between the chips, until complete fiber liberation has
taken place. It can be assumed that all solutes are in equilibrium between
the liquors inside and outside the chips, when these enter into the coun
tercurrent washing zone, and that the solutes in the outside liquor are
withdrawn by displacement in the very beginning. The solutes in the
interior of the chips, on the other hand, diffuse to the chip surface and
into the outside liquor during the further course of the washing in the
lower part of the digester, where a liquor of increasingly lower solute
concentration passes the chips on the way upward through the washing
zone.
The diffusion of solutes through the chips occurs at a rate varying with
the nature of the solute. The inorganics and low-molecular organics diffuse faster than the carbohydrate and lignin polymers. The diffusion is
slower in wood than in water, and slower in tangential-radial direction
than in longitudinal direction of the wood. Particularly in the former
Fig. 1 0 . 5 .
Table 10.1.
167
directions, the diffusion rate is also dependent on the pH of the liquor and
the yield of cooking. One way of expressing the diffusion rate in wood
relative to water is the so-called effective capillary cross-sectional area,
ECCSA, which is the fractional area of the wood considered open for
diffusion at the rate of diffusion in water. As shown in Figs. 10.5-10.7,
this is about 50% in longitudinal direction and 5-10% in the tangential-radial direction for uncooked wood at all but alkaline solutions, where the
diffusion in the latter two directions increases to 20 (pine)-40 (aspen)
%. At a pH slightly higher than that of black liquor, the tangential-radial
diffusion in pine increases from about 20% to 30-40% as the pulp yield
drops from 100 to 65%, whereas the longitudinal diffusion remains at
50-60%.
168
Lecture 10
169
Fig. 10.7. ECCSA vs. pulp yield for blocks of partially digested softwood
at a pH of 13.2.
A mathematical model has been developed by McKibbins et al* to
describe the diffusion subprocess in the countercurrent diffusion washing
in the digester, based on the following simplifying assumptions:
Subsequent to an initial displacement of the external black liquor, it is
considered that the washing mechanism consists of diffusion from the chip
interior to the chip surface, followed by local mixing with the outside
liquor. The chips have all the same thickness, sufficiently low as compared to the length to consider the diffusion as occurring exclusively across
the thickness. The degree of packing is assumed to be no greater than
that all chip surfaces are available to the wash liquor. The diffusion is
slow compared to the local mixing of liquor outside the chips. The wash
water-chip flow is countercurrent and uniform over the digester cross section.
Applying Fick's second law of diffusion,
where c(x,t) is solute concentration in chip liquor at the time t after the
start of washing and at distance x from the midplane of the chip in the
direction of diffusion, an equation is finally derived for the system, which
*McKibbins, S. W., Tappi 43: 801 (1960); Williams, D. A., McKibbins, S. W.,and
Riese, J. W., Tappi 48: 481 (1965).
170
Lecture 10
171
doubles the diffusion constant, should reduce the required retention time
by half. A flow ratio F much lower than 1 will cause the washing efficiency to level off at a value corresponding to F even at rather long
retention times, whereas a ratio much above 2 will not appreciably improve the result, unless the retention times are very short. In the units of
the figure, 1 hr retention at 130C and a chip thickness of 3 mm should
correspond to a reduced time of about 1.0. The least defined function is
that of F. The upward flow of wash liquor ought to equal the dilution
factor times the pulp capacity, but the downward flow of liquor inside the
chips should be dependent on the extent of fiber swelling and chip swelling, and thus to the species and to the degree of cooking, but possibly also
to the degree of packing of the soft chips. It can be anything from 1 to 4
ton/ton of pulp and F thus anything from 0.2 to 2, as indicated in the
figure, with a normal value of about 1.0. With both F and "reduced
time" being about unity, the expected digester washing efficiencies ought
to be considerable, about 90%, or even above, particularly if a prolonged
washing zone of 3-4 hr is used. Lecture 11 will present some evidence
from mill scale and the Jossefors pilot digester experience.
Comparisons between the various types of washing equipment is desired
for obvious reasons. A recent attempt has been made by Kommonen,
based upon theoretical work by Norden. The latter introduced the concept of efficiency factor, defined as the number of ideal mixing stages
required to get the washing effect of the washing equipment in question. Kommonens data indicate an efficiency factor of about 2.5 for a
kraft brown stock filter washer and 7-9 for a complete multistage kraft
filter washing station. The continuous diffuser has an efficiency factor of
about 5, and the continuous high-heat diffusion wash in the digester gives
an efficiency factor of 5-10, depending on washing zone retention time,
1-3 hr. A comparison has to take also into consideration the pulp consistency from the washing stage, and ends with the result that the continuous
diffuser is worth about 1.5 filters, continuous digester wash 2-3 filters,
depending on retention time, 1.5 resp. 3 hr. The results are in agreement
with the general opinion, that a 3 hr digester wash needs no additional
filter, but that 1 hr digester wash will require at least one filter washer.
Lecture 11
174
Lecture 11
175
176
Lecture 11
DILUTION FACTOR, / 9 0 p u l p
Fig. 11.2.
4
4
4
3
3-4
1.7
2.6
3.0
3.0
2.0
47
47
54
2
2
1.5
2.5
1.8
2
54
1.5
24
30
17
14
11
15
14
17
25
Digester plus onefilter stage
11 (69 1 )
13
30
5 (62 1 )
8
20
96.9
98.6
98.8
98.4
97
96.1
97.5
97.8
97.4
99.5
98.8
96.8
99.0
98
95.9
97.9
97.2
17
Neutral
sulfite
(birch)
Bisulfite
(spruce)
Kraft
(pine)
Poly sulfide
(pine)
80
80
80
75
58
55
47
59
51
1.8
1.8
1.8
5.0
5.0
2.8
2.8
2.8
2.8
0.45
0.82
1.50
3.0
3.0
2.7
2.7
2.7
2.7
177
70
84
91
87
87
88
88
87
87
70
75
83
79
86
86
86
82
83
178
Lecture 11
neutral sulfite pulps. This may reflect both the diffusion hindrance of the
chip structure and the fairly high-molecular structure of the organic
solutes of those processes as compared to kraft.
The conclusions of those trials are mainly that the continuous digester
washing is called for at all yield levels and pulping processes, and since
then commercial digesters with a countercurrent washing zone have started
operation at all yield levels between 40 and 85%, including kraft, prehydrolysis-kraft, acid sulfite, bisulfite, and neutral sulfite pulping. The following design philosophy appears to be gaining ground: The digester volume is dimensioned according to a future capacity demand, with a large
washing zone and no subsequent filter. When the mill is expanded, a filter
or a continuous diffuser is added, and if necessary the cooking zone of
the digester is extended downward at the expense of the washing
zone. Thereby, the one-line operation economy can be maintained with
only marginal investments.
One advantage with digester washing is the minimization of foaming
troubles. With a complete digester wash, no foaming is experienced,
since there is no introduction of air to the system. Even with a combined
system of digester and filter, the foaming troubles around the filter are
considerably decreased because the dominant part of the tall soaps have
been removed in the high-temperature digester wash. Particularly for the
introduction of open precision refiners for semichemicaJ pulps, it is vital to
have removed the waste liquor.
Lecture 12
180
Lecture 12
of batch cooking? To some extent, the choice between batch and continuous remains a matter of philosophy. Yet, there are some good reasons
why those in the pulping industry with few exceptions now choose continuous cooking.
1. Large one-line units have been made possible.
2. Improved heat economy.
3. Ease of instrumentation, automation, and coordination with paper
mill.
4. Ease of attaching subsequent operations, such as washing, refining,
evaporation, odor abatement, etc.
5. Improved quality.
I shall comment on each of these items and also point out what remains
to be done to improve the systems.
Large One-line Units
One of the most spectacular trends of the pulp and paper industry in
recent years is the increased size of the mills. This increase has been
stimulated by the severe competition in most sectors of the industry, and
particularly those of market pulp, newsprint, liner board, corrugating
medium board, and other packaging grades. Not long ago, 50,000 tons/
year was the output of a sizable mill, and 100,000 tons/year a large
one. The units now constructed are for 200,000-500,000 tons/year. It is
also important to observe that good economy demands few lines, preferably one, in those units to achieve maximum benefit from the large size.
Machinery development in all sections of the pulp and paper mill has
been required to meet the demands of the large one-lined mill. The most
spectacular ones have been the digester, the recovery boiler, and the paper
machine, where now 1000 ton/day units are available. The largest digesters in operation or on order are as shown in Table 12.1.
No doubt there are mills of similar sizes in all those categories equipped
with batch digesters, but they tend to get fairly complicated and not very
labor-saving. That is particularly true for two-stage processes, semichemical pulping, and acid sulfite pulping. That the present size of digester varies
considerably with the process is more nearly ascribable to historical development than to real technical limitations. If somebody for some less
understandable reason would like to build an 800 ton/day acid sulfite
dissolving pulp mill today, it would be technically quite feasible, although
both seller and buyer of the digester would probably sleep better after
having seen not only the present 275 ton/day unit in operation but also
one or two of intermediate size. Kraft digesters have been through that
181
850
1150
620
600
400
200
275
phase, and since the development work for the other processes has endeavored to make as much use as possible of the kraft digester details, it is
likely that these processes will catch up in size quite rapidly. In fact, it
took kraft 17 years and 17 units before reaching 300 tons/day, but prehydrolysis-kraft and neutral sulfite less than one year and one unit before
reaching the same size.
It may be fascinating but fairly useless to speculate on the ultimate
digester size. The present units are far from ultimate size, since the largest
chip feeder in operation is capable of feeding chips for 1150 tons/day of
liner board pulp and there is always the possibility of two feeding lines to
one digester if necessary. The ultimate digester size is therefore likely to
be decided by external factors, such as wood transportation costs or
economical size of other machinery used. It is a good testimonial to the
digester machinery development that it can be said that the pressure operation of pulp production will not become the bottleneck of the large mill
for the foreseeable future.
On the other hand, it must be admitted, that the large-capacity digesters
have become rather monstrous, and that efforts should be made to decrease their size and costs. It is debatable though, whether a temperature
increase alone will bring about an improvement, since the decrease in size
will be accompanied by an increase in shell thickness due to the increased
pressure. The elimination of the excess hydraulic pressure achieved
through, the inverted external top separator is one of the better means of
reducing shell costs and some circulations.
It is also conceivable that the really large digesters of the future may
have to minimize the volume spent on countercurrent washing. That a
considerable part should be devoted to the task is an obvious advantage
when considering the subsequent unit operations of liquor recovery and
182
Lecture 12
Fig. 12.1. Mass and heat balance for continuous cooking and washing plant.
odor abatement. The development of the continuous diffuser is likely to
offer an alternative to the extreme digester wash in cases where filters
should be few or entirely avoided.
Heat Economy of Cooking and Subsequent Operations
One of the original arguments in favor of continuous cooking, the superior heat economy, still holds and has become accentuated through
some refinements of the system. Figure 12.1 shows the heat flow to and
around the digester system. The blow steam used to be passed to the
steaming vessel for preheating the chips, which is a major improvement in
heat economy as compared to batch cooking. With the introduction of
the cold blow and countercurrent washing, an increased digester steam
consumption was experienced, since the wash liquor is heated to about
130C. A further increase in steam demand is experienced when cooking
countercurrently, since all liquor, including the wash liquor, is then heated
to cooking temperature, about 170C.
On the other hand, improvements in the liquor balance have contributed
to reduce the digester steam demand. In the original system, considerable
quantities of black liquor were added to the chip feeding system as socalled "compensating liquor." This served to keep up the hydraulic
pressure of the digester, compensating for the drainage of liquor from the
183
184
Lecture 12
Pulp type
NSSC, hardwood (Mumin)
Kraft
Liner base, softwood
Chemical pulp, softwood
Chemical pulp, softwood1
Chemical pulp, hardwood (Mumin)
Prehydr.-kraft, hardwood (Mumin)
Black liquor to evaporation 128 C.
Demand
LPHPsteam, ton steam, ton
Production
secondary
steam, ton
Total
heat
demand,
Meal
Secondary
heat
produced,
Meal
0.14
0.48
0.25
395 x 1 0 6
155 x 10 6
0.06
0.01
0.36
0.09
0.00
0.79
0.90
0.91
0.60
1.33
0.36
0.38
0.22
0.31
0.73
485
465
755
365
755
230
240
140
200
460
Fig. 12.3.
187
188
Lecture 12
tion of batch digester rooms have also been seen, with remotely controlled
valves and automatic charging and discharging. For some processes, instrumentation of the end point control of the cook has been attempted.
In general, however, it can be said that batch cooking requires a more
elaborate instrumentation and control to be fully automated, and
particularly so with two-stage processes and other deviations from the
simple kraft process. The large number of digesters in the batch system
naturally increases the points of measurement, and the discontinuous operation complicates the control of the system to give a uniform quality.
The final stage of automation is to put the continuous digester on a
computer control. This has already been done at some places, but the
main development remains to be seen. For the running of a constant pulp
grade, the general instrumentation already in use today allows the continuous digester to be put on digital control, although the system analysis to
give the process equations will have to be done specifically for each process and digester type. We now attempt to do so for the simple case of
neutral sulfite semichemical pulping. The principles for digital control of
the digester switching from one grade to another have also been worked
out jointly by Kamyr, International Business Machines and International
Paper. It is to be expected that during the years to come, most new mills
will run their digesters on a computer basis, but with the same computer as
controls the other activities of the pulp and paper mill. We make efforts
in this direction with our NSSC digester, which is directed from the same
computer that controls the corrugating medium board machine and intermediate operations. This will also eliminate the traditional borderlines
between the pulp and the paper mill as far as supervision and personnel
organization is concerned. The continuous cooking principle has then
made pulping an operation too simple to validate its own organization, and
it will also have eliminated the pulp equalizing chests and minimized
buffer storage facilities. This development, of course, owes much to the
corresponding simplifications of the intermediate operations as well, but it
should be stressed that their progress could not be fully utilized without
the development of the continuous digester, as will be discussed now.
Combination of Continuous Cooking With
Subsequent Operations
The development of continuous pulp washing on filters preceded the
development of continuous cooking. Considerable problems were encountered, particularly with foaming, which made the filter constructions
sophisticated, instrumentation elaborate, and the liquor tanks voluminous. The expenses were multiplied through the considerable number of
189
190
Lecture 12
kraft pulps and not just high-yield chemical kraft for liner board and
similar purposes.
The combination of cooking with evaporation was touched upon earlier. Batch cooking delivers the black liquor to evaporation at a temperature of only 70-80C, which means that the enthalpy drop from cooking
temperature can be used only for hot water production. With continuous
cooking, including digester washing, the black liquor is delivered at almost
full cooking temperature, and the flash can be used in pressure evaporation
in a suitable countercurrent system. We shall see more developments in
that field. Closely connected with this train of thought is our idea of
treating the black liquor at high temperature for odor abatement. Batch
cooking delivers malodorous compounds in two ways: partly in the blow
gases, partly in the black liquor. The collection of the blow gases causes a
special problem, which has been solved at considerable expense in the
so-called "Vaporspheres," gas buffers to receive the batch flow of gases
and deliver a continuous flow of gases for treatment. Furthermore, the
blow gases unavoidably become admixed with the air of the blow system,
which also complicates their treatment. Here the first and fundamental
virtue of continuous cooking is obvious. The second source of malodorous compounds is the black liquor during evaporation, which delivers these
compounds to the condensates of all stages. It is not impossible that a
prolonged treatment of the black liquor at or above cooking temperature,
will create all obnoxious volatiles at once and eliminate their successive
formation during evaporation and combustion. Such a heat treatment,
possibly combined with a suitable stripping arrangement, might therefore
concentrate the odor problem to one convenient spot, where suitable
means of destruction or by-product recovery could be arranged. Continuous cooking is a prerequisite for doing this at a reasonable steam comsumption.
Quality Aspects of Batch and Continuous Cooking
The quality aspects have been commented on in connection with each
process. Therefore I just need to summarize that laboratory pulp quality
has been achieved when pulping continuously, with the possible exception
of acid sulfite paper pulp, where also batch pulping on the mill scale gives
a somewhat lower quality than in the laboratory. Whether with this general statement it can be maintained that continuous pulping yields a superior quality as compared to batch is thus mainly a question of batch
pulping standard. At some instances, mill scale batch pulping yields a
quality close to that of laboratory pulping, but in many cases, perhaps
normally, some quality is sacrificed to gain production or production
191
economy. This need more seldom be the case with continuous cooking,
which thus normally yields a somewhat better quality than batch cooking,
provided the modern modifications of cold blow and countercurrent washing are installed. The advanced process control likewise has generally resulted in a superior uniformity of the pulp as compared to batch.
Index
AB Statens Skogsindustrier 5
Accessibility 23, 39, 82, 85
Acetic acid 105
Acetyl groups 23-25, 28, 48, 64,
87-88, 92, 105
Acid sulfite cook 15-16, 33-50
second-stage 45-47,49,103,157
Acid sulfite pulp washing 178
Active alkali 87, 109-110, 116,123,
127, 130, 132-135, 140, 142
Air compressor 122
Air in chips 29-31
Aldehyde end groups 81-82, 85
Aldonic acids 28-29
Alkafide process 136,138
Alkali consumption 77, 80, 87-88,
91-92, 109,117,122,132, 138
Alkali lignin 108-109,113
Alkaline hydrolysis 77, 82-83
Alkaline peeling reaction 81, 88, 92,
105
Alkaline sulfite cook 15-16,139,
142-143, 152-153
acid sulfite second-stage 45, 47, 49
Alkalinity 109, 125, 136
Alkalirresistant cellulose 36, 40, 54,
70,102
Alpha-cellulose 36-40,61,102,
115-117,123-124,127-128,131,
135, 141-142, 147, 150
Ammonium bisulfite 11
Ammonium sulfite 69
Arabinose 22,61,71,82,123,
127-128, 130, 135, 141-142, 147
Arabinoxylan 22
Arabitol 84
Aspen 167
Asplund Defibrator 64-67
Asplund sluice 7
Associated Pulp & Paper Mills Ltd.
4-5,8
Automatic control 10, 180, 184,
187-188
Backhammars Bruk AB 4
Back-water pockets 35
Bark extractives 19,78
Batch cooking 40,99,187-188,
190-191
Batch diffuser 165
Batch digester wash 159
Beating time, see Paper pulp quality
Beech 43-44
Belisce Kombinat 5
Benzyl alcohol 18
Bergvik mill 11
Beta-cellulose 102
BillerudsAB 4,7,10-11,64,113
Birch 7,38,40-41,44,55,59,65,
67, 69, 71, 72-73, 87, 89-90,
194
Index
Fengersfors Bruks AB 1,3,4
Fiber length 101-102
Fiber wall, see Cell wall
Fiberizing (see also Refining) 64-66,
127-128, 149, 189
Fibreboard Paper Products Inc. 5
Fick's diffusion law 169
Filter washing 117,159-160,165,
175,188
Fine papers 75
Flash steam 113,183-184
Flash tank 99
Flow ratio 42,171
Flow resistance 166
Foam problems 160,178,188
Formaldehyde 77
Formic acid 17, 81, 84
Free sulfur dioxide 11-12
Friction 41-42
Galactan 91
Galactoglucomannan 22, 102,131,
136-137
Galactoglucomannan acetate 27
Galactose 22, 61, 71, 123, 127-128,
130, 135,141-142, 147
Gamma-cellulose 102
Gas bubbles 66,110
Glassine/greaseproof pulp 7, 63, 67,
69
Gluability 73
Glucan 91
Glucomannan 22-23, 26, 36, 38, 45,
48, 50, 82-84, 86-89, 102, 123, 132
Glucometasaccharinic acid 84
Glucosaccharinic acid 83
Glucose 40-49,59,61,70-71,73
104, 123, 127-128, 130, 135,
141-142, 147, 150
Glucuronic acid 22, 25, 28, 86
Glucuronoarabinoxylan 27, 82, 88,
102,131, 136-137
Glucuronoxylan 26, 81, 87, 89
Glycolic acid 84
Glycoside hydrolysis 22-23, 81-92
Green liquor 138
Gross washing efficiency 170
Groundwood 31
Guaiacylpropane 78
Gulf States Paper Co. 4
Hardwood pulping 15, 25, 28-29,
63-73, 95-96,109
Heat balance 182,186
Heat economy 10, 43, 113, 119,
182-184
Heat exchangers 108
Heat recovery 116
Heat transfer 108
Heat-up time 18,37-38,51, 55, 64
107-108,112,121,132,135,148
Hemicellulose (see also Xylan, etc.)
22-29,70, 87, 89-90, 94-95, 101,
195
105,126,128
High-heat washing 10,108, 168, 171,
178
High-yield pulping 15, 25, 53
History of
acid sulfite cook 33
bisulfite cook 51
cold blow 7
countercurrent digester 8,10
Hi-Heat washing 10
Keebra process 139
kraft continuous cook 1-10
kraft process 75
multistage bleach 75
Mumin digester 37-38
neutral sulfite cook 10
prehydrolysis kraft cook 10
pulp washing 159
sulfite continuous cook 7, 10
sulfite process 11
Holocellulose 26
Hot blow 66,97-99, 101-102
Hydraulic pressure 31, 52, 144,148,
181
Hydrazine 82
Hydrogen sulfide 82
Hydrosulfide ion 76-77, 79
Hydrosulfide-sulfide cook 134, 136,
140-141
Hydroxycyclopentane carboxylate 78
Hydroxylamine 82
Hydroxypyruvic acid 84
IMPCO digester 63
Instrumentation 10, 43, 180, 184-186,
187-188
International Business Machines [IBM]
International Paper Co. 4, 7, 188
Iron in pulp 78,115
Iso-hemi lines 27
Isosaccharinic acid 81,83
Jansson, Hannes 7
Jansson, Lennart 7
Jonsson, Ragnar 3
Jossefors mill 7,34, 123, 173
Joutseno Pulp Oy. 4, 6, 7
Jujyo Seshi KK. 5
KamyrAB 3,97,188
Kamyr digester 1-10,46-47,63,67,
105-108,138,161,163,174,
180-181,184-188
Kamyr impregnating vessel 144
Kamyr washing system 161,163
Karlsborg pilot plant 1
Keebra process 139
KMW machine 73
Knots 33
Kokusaku Pulp KK. 5
Kommonen efficiency factor 171
Kraft cooking
continuous 97-104
196
87,95,103,156-157,177
Stainless steel 1, 33, 64
Startup 114-115
Steam economy 41, 111, 114,182-183,
188
Steam flow 112
Steam hammering 33, 66
Steam hydrolysis 105
Steam shock 30-31
Steaming 30-31,119
Steaming vessel 33, 144
Stiffness 63
Stockman, Lennart 7
Stora process 19
Strainers 52, 99, 106-109, 113, 144,
160, 162,173
Styrene sulfonate 21
Substance yield factor 163-165, 175
Sudbrook Pulp Mill Ltd. 4
Sugars, see Carbohydrates
Sulfate formation 16-17
Sulfidation of lignin 13 9
Sulfide cook 15,75,134
Sulfidity 87,93,115,133,138,
140-141
Sulfite-bisulfite mixed cook 15
Sulfite cook 7,10-31
Sulfite cooking acid 11-17, 33,41, 48,
63-65, 68, 69
Sulfite pulp 26, 164
Sulfitolysis 12, 19, 21, 29
Sulfonation 11-12,15, 18-19, 21,
28-29, 63-64, 139
Sulfur charge 129-130,135-136,
138-140, 146
Sulfur dioxide 11-31,51
Sulfuric acid 34
Sulfurous acid 11,14, 16
Summerwood (latewood) 95
Swedish Cellulose Co. 10
Swelling degree 171
Tall oil soap 178,189
Tannins 19,78
Techmashimport 5
Temperature schedules 11-12, 20, 43,
64, 66-69, 81, 91, 98-100, 108-109,
132, 134,136, 140, 142, 146,168,
171, 173-174
Terpenes 16
Thermometry 43
Thiosulfate 16-17, 28, 52, 139
Tilghman, Benjamin 11
Tokai Pulp KK. 5
Top scraper 2-3, 35, 106
Tramp iron 115
Two-body digester 34, 37-38, 43, 45,
51-52,105-107,110,125,136
Two-stage polysulfide 129,134-136,
138
Two-stage sulfite cook 15, 19-20, 23-24,
44-50, 103
198
Tyloses 29
Upflow digester 36, 39,44, 105-107
Uronic acids 64,88,92
Usutu Pulp Co. Ltd. 5
Vanillyl alcohol 77
Vapor-phase cooks 55, 110, 112, 119,
135-136,138, 144,146-149
Vapor pressure 31
Vaporspheres 190
Viscose pulp, see Dissolving pulp
Viscosity 40, 43-45, 54, 59, 102,
115-117
Wall effect 178
Washing 159-178,188-189
Wash liquor 117, 122,173, 175
Wash zone bleaching 60
Water hydrolysis 105
Water pollution 70, 116, 159
Watt-Burgess process 75
Weyerhaeuser Timber Co. 4