Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Received 15 February 1999; received in revised form 8 July 1999; accepted 25 February 2002
Abstract
In tide-dominated sedimentary systems, close relationships exist between tidal hydrodynamics, sediment transport and
geomorphology. Tropical coastlines contain many tide-dominated mangrove creeks, yet few studies to date have examined the detail
of such relationships for these environments. Time-series observations of tidal height, currents and suspended sediment
concentrations were taken between 1992 and 1996 in Cocoa Creek, a mangrove creek system near Townsville, NE Australia. The
creek and surrounding mangrove swamps and salt ats were surveyed with an echo-sounder and total survey station, respectively.
For within-channel tides, the ood tide is always the fastest, at up to 0.5 m s1. In contrast, for overbank tides (i.e. tidal height
> 1.5 m Australian Height Datum, AHD) ebb currents are fastest in July, December and January, but ood currents are fastest in
August and September, at up to 1 m s1 in both cases. The tidal asymmetry of overbank tides in Cocoa Creek is controlled by the
interaction between offshore tidal forcing and the intertidal storage effect of the mangrove swamps and salt ats, with the result
being that during certain periods of the year there tends to be a predominance of either faster ood or ebb velocities on overbank
tides. Signicant tidal suspended sediment transport in the channel is only initiated at overbank height. On overbank tides,
measured net suspended sediment uxes in the channel are mostly seaward-directed (up to 180 t per tidal cycle). However, the net
ux measured over a neapspring period may be either landwards or seawards (up to 465 and 60 t, respectively). Furthermore, on
the larger overbank tides (where the maximum tidal height > 1.85 m AHD) net sediment uxes may be reduced because of a
limited supply of available material. Thus hydrodynamic and sediment sampling durations of up to a month may not be
representative of long-term trends. Given that our large dataset has not identied a clear long-term net transport direction within the
creek system, we conclude tentatively that the geomorphology of Cocoa Creek may be near a long-term equilibrium.
2003 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: tidal creek; mangroves; sediment transport; Australia
1. Introduction
Studies of hydrodynamics and sediment transport in
mostly temperate salt marsh systems (Bayliss-Smith,
Healy, Lailey, Spencer, & Stoddart, 1979; Boon, 1975;
Boon & Byrne, 1981; Friedrichs & Aubrey, 1988;
Pethick, 1980) have provided the initial understanding of hydrodynamic and geomorphological controls
on sediment transport for tide-dominated creeks and
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: sonya.bryce@jcu.edu.au (S. Bryce).
0272-7714/03/$ - see front matter 2003 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0272-7714(02)00192-0
416
417
Fig. 1. Locality map and geomorphology of Cocoa Creek and the adjacent coastal plain.
Table 1
Major geomorphological features within the intertidal area of Cocoa
Creek catchment and the corresponding tidal elevation range at which
they occur
Geomorphology
Chenier/beach ridges
Salt water couch
meadow
Salt at
Mangrove swamp
Low-intertidal mudats
Substrate
lithology
Elevation range
(m AHD)
+3.65 to +2.00
+2.00 to +1.85
+1.85 to 1.40
+1.40 to +1.10
+0.50 to 0.40
418
3. Results
3.1. Tidal asymmetry in Cocoa Creek
Some mangrove creek systems, including Cocoa
Creek, have a characteristic double peak in ow speed
during an overbank ood tide (Fig. 3). The tidal
asymmetry is therefore slightly different to that described
for most shallow estuaries in previous studies (e.g. Boon
& Byrne, 1981; Friedrichs & Aubrey, 1988; Speer &
Aubrey, 1985). Past usage of the terms ood and ebb
dominance in reference to estuarine tidal asymmetry has
usually implied that the ood (or ebb) tide is shorter in
duration and faster, with a single peak in speed. This
inference would be inapplicable here, and so the terms
will not be used. A closer examination of the nature of
tidal asymmetry of overbank tides in Cocoa Creek,
reveals the signicantly different consequences for sediment transport in this system. For example, in reference
to Fig. 3a and tides of the 24 February 1994, the
overbank ood tide has two peaks at around 0.68 m s1
and corresponds to a tidal range of 2.85 m. The subsequent ebb tide has a single peak of 0.71 m s1, (i.e.
slightly larger than the ood peaks), but this peak is
very short in duration. In addition, the ebb tide range is
2.60 m, slightly smaller than the ood tide. So, although
the ebb tide has a higher peak current speed, it is unlikely
to be as signicant as the ood tide in terms of sediment
transport because the ood tide has persistently higher
current speeds due to the larger tidal range.
3.1.1. Velocity asymmetry over an annual timescale
At the mouth, lower creek and upper creek sites
during neap and intermediate tides, maximum tidal
current speeds are usually fastest on the larger ood
tide of the day. Flood and ebb speeds generally increase
with the onset of a spring tide period (Fig. 3). In the
lower creek, maximum speeds recorded in the channel on
overbank tides tend to be faster on the ood tide during
419
Fig. 2. (a) Locality map of the main instrument sites and surveyed transects at Cocoa Creek. (b) Channel cross-sections at the three main instrument
sites. L and R stands for true left and true right (i.e. looking seawards). (c) Topographic proles of two salt at areas in the Cocoa Creek catchment.
Table 2
Geomorphological description of the main instrument sites at Cocoa Creek
Site
Thalweg distance
upstream (km)
Width at
MSL (m)
Maximum depth
(m AHD)
Channel cross-section
(bankfull m2)
Channel shape
(in prole)
Bed sediment
Upper creek
Mid-creek
Lower creek
Salt at
Mouth
Low-intertidal mudat
7.5
6.2
1.5
1.5
0.05
0.3
15
21
27
30
2.0
1.5
5.5
1.5
4.0
0.4
40
45
95
110
Symmetrical
Asymmetrical
Slightly asymmetrical
Slightly asymmetrical
Muddy gravel
Sand
Coarse sand
Silt and clay
Shelly sandy mud
Muddy sand
420
Fig. 3. (a) Current speed, direction and tidal elevation (all measured at 1 m above the bed) at the lower creek site for days 1826 February 1994 (neap
to spring tide). Note that tidal speeds on the overbank ood tide are slightly faster. F, larger ood tide of the day; E, larger ebb tide of the day. (b)
Current speed (measured at 1 m above the bed) at the lower creek site and current speed) and tidal elevation (both measured at 1 m above the bed) at
the upper creek site for days 1014 December 1993. Note that at the lower creek site, tidal speeds on the overbank ebb tide are fastest. F, larger ood
tide of the day; E, larger ebb tide of the day.
421
Fig. 4. Velocity-stage diagrams at three channel sites (during three spring tide periods where ebb speeds were fastest). The mouth proles are part of a small spring tide period where the maximum
tidal height reached is 1.56 m AHD. In contrast, the lower creek and upper creek proles are parts of larger spring tide periods, reaching maximum tidal heights of 1.85 m AHD and 1.92 m
AHD, respectively. Abbreviations of velocity peaks: F1, initial ood peak; FMIN, bankfull minimum speed; F2, second ood peak; EMAX, within-channel maximum ebb speed. The jagged nature of
the proles at the lower creek locality reects a higher sampling frequency than used at the upper creek and mouth localities.
422
S. Bryce et al. / Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 56 (2003) 415431
423
Fig. 5. Tidal discharge curves for within-channel and overbank tidal cycles at the upper creek, lower creek and mouth localities. Water uxes were
estimated using the depth-averaged velocity multiplied by the cross-sectional area of the channel for a given stage when overbank speeds were faster
on the ebb tide. Maximum tidal elevations in AHD are shown for each tidal cycle. F, ood tide; E, ebb tide and OB, overbank tide.
present in the main channel of Cocoa Creek. The greatest discharges are in the lower creek and on the ebb
tide, and the duration of the ebb tide is longer than the
ood at the mouth and lower creek. Using the same
datasets water budgets have also been calculated where
the total discharge over a tide was determined by
summing estimates of discharge for 10-min periods
(upper creek and mouth) and 2-min periods (lower
creek). At the upper creek, results lie between an export
of 3.9 104 m3 and import of 6.8 104 m3, and generally
show a slight export, on average 3% of the total
combined ood and ebb ux. At the lower creek, results
lie between an export of 1.7 105 to 2.9 105 m3, and
generally show an average export of 30% of the total
combined ood and ebb ux. At the mouth, results lie
between an export of 2.4 104 to 1.5 105 m3, and also
show an average export of 20% of the total combined
ood and ebb ux. Some differences in volume can be
424
Fig. 6. (a) Plot showing the variation in SSCs (at 0.2 m above the bed) over a neap to spring tide period in January 1996 at the mouth, lower creek,
mid-creek and upper creek localities. Numbers in brackets denote distance landwards of the mouth. Note the difference in scale on the upper creek
dataset as compared with the other three sites. (b) Expanded view of four tides. Note the phase lag between the mouth and upper creek site.
425
Fig. 7. Current speed (measured at 1 m above the bed) at the lower creek site and near-bed SSCs (at 0.2 m above the bed) on the low-intertidal
mudat, lower creek and salt at sites during a spring tide period where ebb tide speeds were fastest (1016 December 1993). Numbers on current
speed gure are the maximum high water elevations reached in m AHD. F, larger ood tide of the day; E, larger ebb tide of the day. Note the
signicantly smaller SSC scale used for the salt at data in comparison to the other two sites.
426
Fig. 8. Measured net suspended sediment ux per tidal cycle at the lower creek locality (February 1994).
4. Discussion
4.1. Factors driving tidal asymmetry
Tidal asymmetry in shallow estuaries takes the form
of unequal durations and/or unequal magnitudes in the
ood and ebb tide. It mostly results from the frictional
interaction of the tide with the channel and intertidal
areas (Friedrichs & Aubrey, 1988; Speer & Aubrey,
1985). In the literature, the type of tidal asymmetry
present in a channel has been expressed using the
following parameters: (1) the relative tidal amplitude
(ratio of offshore M2 tidal amplitude (a) to channel
depth at MSL (h) = a/h) and (2) the relative estuarine
intertidal storage (ratio of volume of intertidal storage
(Vs) to the channel volume at MSL (Vc) Vs/Vc). In
estuaries where the fastest speeds are during the ood
tide, tidal asymmetry is thought to be controlled by the
a/h ratio, whereas ow in those estuaries with fastest
speeds on the ebb are thought to be controlled by a large
relative estuarine intertidal storage. For a/h < 0.2, an
estuary would tend to have a fast and short ebb tide, and
for a/h > 0.3, it would tend to have a fast and short
ood tide (Friedrichs & Aubrey, 1988; Table 3). Ratios
of the total tidal amplitude to channel depth at MSL
were calculated for the lower creek site at Cocoa Creek
over four spring tide periods (Table 3). The total tidal
amplitude near the creek mouth was used instead of the
M2 amplitude because the tidal wave may have already
undergone some distortion on passing across Cleveland
Bay (i.e. before it reaches Cocoa Creek).
Most values of a/h at lower Cocoa Creek fall into
the transitional to ood range of Friedrichs and
Aubrey (1988) rather than consistently reecting the measured tidal asymmetry, indicating that the relative tidal
427
Table 3
Comparison of the Friedrichs and Aubrey (1988) ratio of relative tidal
amplitude (a/h) ndings (see text) to calculated a/h values for overbank
tides at Cocoa Creek
<0.2
0.210.23
>0.3
0.180.47
428
Table 4
Measured substrate slopes and calculated estuarine intertidal storage
ratios (Vs : Vc) at signicant tidal elevations, Cocoa Creek
Tidal elevation
(m AHD)
Substrate
slope
Intertidal storage
volume : channel
storage volume (Vs : Vc)
4.3 104
8.6
12 103
3.8
2 1041 103 2.6
1101
1.7
429
Fig. 10. Plan view of the turbidity distribution (expressed as SSCs) in Cocoa Creek at various stages of an overbank tide on 18 January 1996,
together with the main controlling factors. The tidal elevations expressed in AHD at the mouth and upper creek sites are taken from real depth
values. The distribution pattern of SSCs is also based on turbidity data measured during a deployment of four nephelometers along the main channel
(locations shown in Fig. 2a), each placed at approximately 0.2 m above the bed.
Hooper, 1993). Geologically, the creek system is therefore not limited by sediment supply, and we conclude
tentatively that the geomorphology of Cocoa Creek may
be near a long-term equilibrium.
5. Conclusions
The tidal asymmetry of Cocoa Creek is controlled by
the interaction between oshore tidal forcing and the
intertidal storage eect of the mangrove swamps and
salt ats. The result is that there tends to be a predominance of either faster ood or ebb current speeds
430
Fig. 11. Measured net suspended sediment ux per tidal cycle at the lower creek site of Cocoa Creek versus measured high-water elevation at
Townsville Port (the closest port datum). Note that most seaward-directed suspended sediment uxes occur on overbank tides. We have illustrated
uxes calculated for successive overbank tides of late February 1994 (spring period commencing in Fig. 3a). The data describe an open loop whereby
tides of equivalent elevation (most notably where HW > 1.85 m AHD) produce high net seaward suspended sediment uxes early in the spring tide
period, but up to 100 t less only a few tides later. m July 1993; } September 1993; d February 1994.
Acknowledgements
Many thanks go to Ross Hyne for assistance with
eldwork, and loan of a boat, vehicles and other eld
References
Aucan, J. (1998). Hydrodynamic model of the circulation in a mangrove
fringed tidal creek (50 pp.). Unpublished postgraduate diploma
thesis, James Cook University, Townsville.
Australian Land Information Group-AUSLIG (1994). 1 : 1500 Topographic map Cocoa Creek Townsville, NI5-359 (B1).
Australian Land Information Group-AUSLIG (1994). 1 : 2500 Topographic map Cocoa Creek Townsville, NI5-358 (B1).
Bayliss-Smith, T. P., Healy, R., Lailey, R., Spencer, T., & Stoddart, D.
R. (1979). Tidal ows in salt marsh creeks. Estuarine and Coastal
Marine Science 9, 235255.
Boon, J. D. (1975). Tidal discharge asymmetry in a salt marsh drainage
system. Limnology and Oceanography 20, 7180.
Boon, J. D. (1978). Suspended-solids transport in a saltmarsh creekan
analysis of errors. In B. Kjerfve (Ed.), Estuarine transport processes
(pp. 147159). Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
Boon, J. D., & Byrne, R. J. (1981). On basin hypsometry and the
morphodynamic response of coastal inlet systems. Marine Geology
40, 2748.
Bryce, S. (2001). Controlling factors on sediment transport in mangrove
creek systems of North-East Queensland (156 pp.). Unpublished PhD
thesis, James Cook University, Townsville.
431
Lettau, H. (1969). Note on aerodynamic roughness-parameter estimation on the basis of roughness-element descriptions. Journal of
Applied Meteorology 8, 828832.
Pethick, J. S. (1980). Velocity surges and asymmetry in tidal channels.
Estuarine and Coastal Marine Science 11, 331345.
Queensland Department of Transport (19931996). Queensland tide
tables. Brisbane: Queensland Government.
Ridd, P. V., & Larcombe, P. (1994). Biofouling controls and optical
backscatter suspended sediment sensors. Marine Geology 116,
255258.
Ridd, P., Renagi, S., Hollins, S., & Brunskill, G. (1997). Water, salt
and nutrient uxes of tropical tidal salt ats. Mangroves and Salt
Marshes 1, 229238.
Speer, P. E., & Aubrey, D. G. (1985). A study of non-linear tidal
propagation in shallow inlet/estuarine systems. Part II: Theory.
Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 21, 207224.
Wolanski, E., Gibbs, R. J., Mazda, Y., Mehta, A., & King, B. (1992).
The role of turbulence in the settling of mud ocs. Journal of
Coastal Research 8, 3546.
Wolanski, E., Jones, M., & Bunt, J. S. (1980). Hydrodynamics of a
tidal creek mangrove swamp system. Australian Journal of Marine
and Freshwater Research 31, 431450.
Wolanski, E., Mazda, Y., & Ridd, P. (1992). Mangrove Hydrodynamics. In A. I. Robertson, & D. M. Alongi (Eds.), Tropical
mangrove ecosystems (pp. 4362). Washington, DC: American
Geophysical Union.
Woodroffe, C. D. (1985). Studies of a mangrove basin, Tuff
Crater, New Zealand: III. The ux of organic and inorganic
particulate matter. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 20, 447461.
Woodroffe, C. D. (1985). Studies of a mangrove basin, Tuff Crater,
New Zealand: II. Comparison of volumetric and velocity-area
methods of estimating tidal ux. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf
Science 20, 431445.