Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A FRAMEWORK FOR
PRE-QUALIFYING NURSES TO
BUILD LEADERSHIP SKILLS
Karen Buckwell-Nutt and colleagues describe the development
of an innovative module to help students become better leaders
Correspondence
karen.buckwell-nutt@bucks.ac.uk
Abstract
Nursing students are our future leaders in the importance of continued practice support in developing
Karen Buckwell-Nutt is
head of academic department, healthcare sector. It is proposed that, for students to leadership skills and confidence. The educational
pre-qualifying nursing understand and demonstrate leadership knowledge, approaches, including lectures, the use of problem-
skills and attributes effectively, they need to: learn based scenarios and enquiry-based learning, are
Jayne Francis-Shama is a senior
lecturer, pre-qualifying nursing concepts, experience leadership roles, analyse their explored and the inclusion of e-learning methods is
capabilities and develop these with the support discussed. Students are made aware that placement
Pollyanna Kellett is a senior
of practitioners. The drive to improve nursing expectations are different from those in previous years.
lecturer, pre-qualifying nursing
leadership does not come from within academia but Recommendations include strategies to strengthen
All at the faculty of society and from practitioners and other stakeholders, such as practice support for students who need to develop
health, Buckinghamshire New
patients, the Nursing and Midwifery Council and leadership skills.
University
Health Education England, and this need is reflected
Date of submission in the university curriculum. This article reviews Keywords
July 1 2014
a final-year module on personal development for Leadership, pre-registration nurse education, academia,
Date of acceptance leadership and management and highlights the shared leadership, distributed leadership, quality
August 26 2014
Peer review Contemporary leadership in the NHS promotion of a transformational leadership style,
This article has been subject INEFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP has become the focus the rigid hierarchical structure of the NHS has
to double-blind review and
has been checked using
of blame for some failings in the NHS (Francis prohibited an effective approach to leadership
antiplagiarism software 2013). This has been accentuated by the challenge (Roebuck 2011). This problem has not been
of delivering consistently high quality patient care overcome, but the model proposed here aids
Author guidelines in today’s demanding and complex healthcare students to challenge more.
rcnpublishing.com/r/
nm-author-guidelines landscape (Nagel and Andenoro 2012). Nurse leadership is going through
Leadership style has influenced the development unprecedented change, heightened by a view
of leadership in nursing for decades. For example, that a shared model of leadership should be
transformational and transactional leadership integrated into the profession (Fulop and Day 2010,
emerged in the 1990s as the dominant framework MacPhee et al 2011).
(Rogers 2012) following Burn’s (1978) seminal Shared, or distributed, leadership is an
work. This emphasised the individualist role and emerging role that views leadership in terms
heroic view of leaders as nurturing, motivated of collaboration and collective activity that no
individuals who can encourage innovation and longer embraces the heroic individual leader.
creativity in teams. However, despite the It is this view that is being promoted as the
Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jul 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Art & science | education
In nurse education, recognition of the implement leadership at each level of the course
to embed in students a growing interest in and
importance of leadership is not addressed realistic perspective of the demands of leadership
(Hendricks et al 2010).
until students are within months of qualifying
Pedagogical considerations
future leadership model in health care (Block and There are varying components that universities
Manning 2007). have recognised as essential to the development
The concept of shared leadership is reflected of leadership awareness and adult learning
in the current NHS leadership framework (NHS principles, including communication skills and
Leadership Academy 2014), which provides a conflict (Hsiu-Yueh et al 2011). However, a clear
consistent approach to leadership development Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) (2010)
for all staff in health care irrespective of directive about the leadership qualities of nurses
discipline, role or seniority. The NHS leadership calls for fundamental elements to be in place.
framework, titled the Healthcare Leadership Model, Universities and clinical areas that support
represents the standard for leadership behaviours undergraduate nursing students must collaborate
to which all staff should aspire. Fundamental to as each setting can offer students differing
the development of the Healthcare Leadership perspectives on leadership (Allan 2010). First,
Model is a desire to create a single, overarching universities need to meet the pedagogic needs of
framework for all health and care staff, building on students, ensuring that differing learning styles
best-practice standards for leadership development are addressed and innovative teaching is provided.
(NHS Leadership Academy 2014). Second, clinical areas need to ensure that students
The shared leadership model is different from are exposed to examples of high functioning nurse
the traditional individualistic models of leadership leaders who demonstrate the qualities of a leader.
(Turnball James 2011). According to the Healthcare Traditional pedagogy has centred on
Leadership Model, rather than focus on a set of teacher-dominated perspectives, with the transfer
personal attributes, leaders are to be supported of information to students in a pre-determined
by a network of people engaging in leadership manner (Horsfall et al 2012, Tedesco-Schneck 2012).
practices throughout the organisation (Elliott and This style of pedagogy, which relies on recall and
Stead 2008, Gronn 2008, Turnball James 2011). factual forms of knowledge, has attracted criticism
The new shared leadership role is embedded in around its inability to reduce the gap between
a culture of collaboration, partnership working what is taught in classrooms and the realities of
and reduced hierarchy, with individuals displaying clinical practice (Leigh et al 2012). Traditionally the
effective interpersonal skills and an ability to ‘talk and chalk’ lecture method (Young et al 2009)
deal with conflict (Crevani et al 2007, Fulop and presents to students a passive form of learning
Day 2010). that achieves engagement for a minimum amount
Leadership in pre-registration nurse education of time and fails to promote deep learning
therefore faces immense challenges to develop (Toynton 2005, Machemer and Crawford 2007,
undergraduate nurses with the ability and drive Cherney 2008).
to promote a shared leadership culture in the The constructivist view of learning suggests
profession. The preparation of leaders who will that a teacher lecturing to a class may not always
make the types of decisions needed in today’s be the most effective way for adult students to
complex healthcare environment requires learn (Kapp and Fergason 2002). Contemporary
innovative approaches to learning (Wilson et al pedagogical theory, therefore, aims to promote
2010). With the focus on patient outcomes and leadership development through the incorporation
safety, it is imperative that preceptee nurses enter of a unifying theoretical framework that links to
practice settings with leadership capabilities nursing practice and research and that provides
(Hendricks et al 2010). the basis for decision making with regard to
In nurse education in the UK, recognition of content (MacPhee et al 2011).
the importance of leadership is not addressed When considering the complex nature of
until students are within months of qualifying. leadership, an experiential learning approach
This results in undergraduate nurses entering to encourage students to critically evaluate
clinical environments unprepared to take on concepts, think laterally and apply theoretical
leadership demands. In light of this, there is a call positions during problem-solving exercises is
for undergraduate nurse training programmes to more productive (Banning 2005). The experiential
Innovative design framework The Learn, learning so they can meet the challenges of
Experience, Analyse, Develop (LEAD) framework constantly changing healthcare environments.
was created to design the module flow and the
presentation of content. See Box 1 for examples of Nursing innovations The NMC (2010) requires
activities and content. graduate nurses to act as change agents and
The module delivery consisted of seminars, provide leadership through good quality systems.
lead lectures, e-learning activities and an To consider innovation and implementation of
employability day. The small group seminars change in practice, students were guided through
enabled discussions of key themes and exploration an enquiry-based learning (EBL) method (Khan and
of a three-stage field-specific, problem-based O’Rourke 2005) to explore important innovative
clinical leadership scenario. Through the use of practices appropriate to their fields of nursing;
problem-based scenario activities, students were these might include use of the safety thermometer
encouraged to explore concepts, think creatively (NHS Quality Observatory 2012), red-tray system
and apply solutions during problem-solving (Royal College of Nursing (RCN) 2014) or the
exercises (Banning 2005). During lead lectures, Productive Ward initiative (NHS Institute for
new concepts, including theories of leadership and Innovation and Improvement 2007). Through this
conflict management, were introduced. Students process, students seek evidence to support ideas
had the opportunity to explore and test the triggered by a topic and take responsibility for
new concepts further during the problem-based analysing and presenting this evidence to peers in
seminars and preceptorship. their seminar group.
While the traditional teacher-centred lecture NHS Improving Quality (2013) advocates staff
method could be criticised for its transmission empowerment and proposes innovative ways of
of information to the passive student, this delivering good quality services. The RCN supports
opportunity for large group teaching is the definition of innovation offered by West and
economically justified. By adopting an interactive Farr (1990) as ‘the intentional introduction and
style in the one-hour lectures, students had the application within a role, group or organization
opportunity to be less passive. As well as using a of ideas, processes, products or procedures, new
question-and-answer technique, the inclusion of to the relevant unit of adoption, designed to
popular culture, for example reference to common significantly benefit the individual, the group, the
activities such as the use of mobile telephones or organization or wider society’. The transferable
social media networks, and artefacts from mass skills required to source, analyse and present
media, such as current soap opera storylines or evidence are fundamental to developing confidence
recent news headlines, enabled the lecturer to to challenge and change practice.
‘connect with the adult learner’ (Wright and
Sandlin 2009). Increasing awareness Initially, students were
The virtual learning environment (VLE) required to revisit their understanding of
was carefully structured to make explicit the healthcare assistant (HCA), nursing student and
prerequisites for classroom-based sessions registered nurse roles and responsibilities,
and suggested additional independent learning and the concept of accountability and delegation.
activities with which students could chose to Through the use of self-evaluative tools, strengths,
engage. The e-learning activities were congruent weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT)
with the themes addressed each week in the analysis and Johari windows (Self Awareness
classroom sessions. Sharpe et al (2006) suggest LLP 2013), they were expected to identify
that students need to understand the use of their developmental needs in meeting the role
technology in their learning and that educators and responsibilities of a registered nurse. To
need to be consistent and transparent in contemplate skills and attributes associated with
communicating their expectations to students. leadership specifically, students completed the NHS
The expectation that students engage with the leadership framework self-assessment tool (NHS
VLE materials was made clear at the beginning Leadership Academy 2012) with initial emphasis on
of the module and reinforced throughout by the the domains of demonstrating personal qualities
seminar lecturer. and working with others.
For the VLE and seminars to be effective, To capture their development needs, they
students are required to self-regulate their learning. formulated individual learning plans, which they
O’Shea (2003) suggests that nurse educators must were encouraged to revise throughout the module
help nurses develop the skill of self-regulated and incorporate academic developmental needs
educationalists. Shared, or distributed, leadership the LEAD framework. Students have understood
is an emerging role that views leadership in terms leadership through the innovative approach of the
of collaboration and collective activity, and one that module, and demonstrated leadership in practice.
is being promoted as the future leadership model We conclude with a plea: let us feel excited about Online archive
in health care (Block and Manning 2007). It is also our students, brimming with enthusiasm about
For related information, visit
reflected in the NHS leadership framework (NHS taking charge of their professional development
our online archive and search
Leadership Academy 2014). and wanting to join our profession, and role model using the keywords
In recognition of these drivers, an innovative and reflect to them the knowledge, skills and
framework for pre-qualifying nurses to develop practices that will help develop and shape our NHS Conflict of interest
leadership knowledge and skills was developed: into a healthier place. None declared
References
Allan H (2010) The perils facing nurse Hendricks JM, Cope VC, Harris M (2010) Nagel C, Andenoro A (2012) Healing Sharpe R, Benfield G, Roberts G et al (2006)
education: a call for leadership for learning. A leadership program in an undergraduate leadership: the serving leader’s impact on The Undergraduate Experience of Blended
Nurse Education Today. 30, 209-211. nursing course in Western Australia: building patient outcomes in a clinical environment. E-learning: A Review of UK Literature and
leaders in our midst. Nurse Education Today. Journal of Healthcare Leadership. 4, 25-31. Practice. Higher Education Academy, York.
Banning M (2005) Approaches to teaching:
30, 252-257.
current opinions and related research. NHS Improving Quality (2013) Our Strategic Slavich GM, Zimbardo PG (2012)
Nurse Education Today. 25, 7, 502-508. Honey P, Mumford A (2006) The Learning Intent. NHS Improving Quality, London. Transformational teaching: theoretical
Styles Questionnaire, 80-item Version. Peter underpinnings, basic principles, and core
Berwick D (2013) A Promise to Learn – A NHS Institute for Innovation and
Honey Publications, Maidenhead, Berkshire. methods. Educational Psychology Review.
Commitment to Act. Improving the Safety of Improvement (2007) Releasing Time to Care.
24, 4, 569-608.
Patients in England. tinyurl.com/ot53wmh Horsfall J, Clearly M, Hunt GE (2012) NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement,
[Last accessed: September 2 2014.] Developing a pedagogy for nursing teaching- Coventry. Tedesco-Schneck M (2012) Active learning as
learning. Nurse Education Today. 32, 930-933. a path to critical thinking: are competencies
Block LAM, Manning LJ (2007) A systematic NHS Leadership Academy (2012) Leadership
a roadblock? Nurse Education in Practice.
approach to developing frontline leaders Hsiu-Yueh Hsu, Lai-Liang Lee, Chia-Yun Framework: Self-assessment Tool. tinyurl.com/
dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2012.07.007
in healthcare. Leadership in Healthcare. Fu et al (2011) Evaluation of a leadership self-assess-tool [Last accessed: August 29
20, 2, 85-96. orientation program in Taiwan: preceptorship 2014.] Toynton R (2005) Degrees of disciplinarity in
and leader competencies of the new nurse equipping mature students in higher education
Bruner JS (2009) The Process of Education: NHS Leadership Academy (2014) Healthcare
manager. Nurse Education Today. 31, 809-814. for engagement and success in lifelong
Revised Edition USA. Harvard University Press, Leadership Model: The Nine Leadership
learning. Active Learning in Higher Education.
Cambridge MA. Kapp S, Fergason J (2002) Contemporary Dimensions. tinyurl.com/pescfa2
6, 2, 106-117.
students: learning styles and teaching
Burns JM (1978) Leadership. Harper and Row, NHS Quality Observatory (2012) NHS Safety
strategies. American Academy of Orthotists Turnbull James K (2011) Leadership in Context.
New York NY. Thermometer. tinyurl.com/leco9ag [Last
and Prosthetists. 14, 2, 71-74. Lessons from New Leadership Theory and
accessed: September 2 2014.]
Carmen L, Rodeiro V, Nádas R (2011) Effects Current Leadership Development Practice.
Khan P, O’Rourke K (2005) Understanding
of Modularisation. Cambridge Assessment, Nursing and Midwifery Council (2010) King’s Fund, London.
enquiry-based learning. In Barrett T,
Cambridge. Standards for Pre-registration Nursing
MacLabhrainn I, Fallon H (Eds) Handbook of West M, Farr JL (1990) Innovation at work. In
Education. NMC, London.
Cherney ID (2008) The effects of active Enquiry and Problem Based Learning. MA West, JL Farr (Eds) Innovation and Creativity
learning on students’ memories for course www.aishe.org/readings/2005-2/contents.html Omoike O, Stratton KM, Brookes BA et al at Work: Psychological and Organizational
content. Active Learning in Higher Education. [Last accessed: August 29 2014.] (2011) Advancing nurse leadership. A model Strategies. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.
9, 2, 152-171. for program implementation and measurement.
Leigh JA, Rutherford J, Wild J et al (2012) Willis Commission (2012) Quality with
Nurse Admin Quarterly. 35, 4, 323-332.
Crevani L, Lindgren M, Packendorff J (2007) Using patchwork text assessment as a vehicle Compassion: The Future of Nursing Education.
Shared leadership: a post-heroic perspective for evaluating students’ perceptions of their O’Shea A (2003) Self-directed learning in nurse Report of the Willis Commission on Nursing
on leadership as a collective construction. clinical leadership development. education: a review of the literature. Journal of Education. Royal College of Nursing, London.
International Journal of Leadership. 3, 1, 40-67. Nurse Education in Practice. 12, 46-51. Advanced Nursing. 43, 1, 62-70.
Wilson DS, Redman RW, Potempa KM (2010)
Elliott C, Stead V (2008) Learning from leading Machemer PL, Crawford P (2007) Student Roebuck C (2011) Developing Effective A vision and compass for health care
women’s experience: towards a sociological perceptions of active learning in a large Leadership in the NHS to Maximise the Quality leadership: lessons from the migrant nurse
understanding. Leadership. 4, 2, 159-180. cross-disciplinary classroom. Active Learning of Patient Care. The Need for Urgent Action. resolution for recurrent nursing shortages.
in Higher Education. 8, 1, 9-30. King’s Fund, London. Journal of Healthcare Leadership. 2, 91-96.
Francis R (2013) Report of the Mid Staffordshire
NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. www. MacPhee M, Skelton-Green J, Rogers R (2012) Leadership communication Wright RR, Sandlin JA (2009) Cult TV, hip hop,
midstaffspublicinquiry.com/report [Last Bouthillette F et al (2011) An empowering styles: a descriptive analysis of health shape-shifters, and vampire slayers: a review
accessed: August 29 2014.] framework for nurse leadership development: care professionals. Journal of Health Care of the literature at the intersection of adult
supporting evidence. Journal of Advanced Leadership. 4, 47-57. education and popular culture. Adult Education
Fulop L, Day GE (2010) From leader to
Nursing. 68, 1, 159-169. Quarterly. 59, 2, 118-141.
leadership: clinician managers and where next? Royal College of Nursing (2014) Supporting
Australian Health Review. 34, 344-351. Meyer J, Land R, Baille C (2010) Threshold and Assisting People. tinyurl.com/p356tjj Young MS, Robinson S, Alberts P (2009)
Concepts and Transformational Learning. [Last accessed: September 2 2014.] Students pay attention! Combating the
Gronn P (2008) The future of distributed
Sense Publication, Rotterdam, Netherlands. vigilance decrement to improve learning during
leadership. Journal of Educational Self Awareness LLP (2013) Understanding the
lecturers. Active Learning in Higher Education.
Administration. 46, 2, 141-158. Johari Window Model. tinyurl.com/klnahzt
10, 1, 41-55.
[Last accessed: August 29 2014.]