Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
because food supplements alone are not enough to keep the person in good
condition.
The dilemma that the researchers have found is on the safety of the
consumers who have lack of knowledge with the No Approved Therapeutic
Claim products that most people disregard yet still continue to take those
for their own satisfaction. They could have been using these products for
decades, their medical supplements could contain varieties of these kinds of
drugs and they might not know that these could harm or could not even
affect them at all, thus this prompted the researchers to conduct this study
aptly entitled: The Lived Experience of the Users of the No Approved
Therapeutic Claim Products.
Non-prescription drugs are now present in the market these are drugs
that can be bought over-the-counter, which means these are sold even
without a doctors prescription.
Herbal dietary or food supplements are some examples of nonprescription drugs. These products become popular alternative for the health
needs of many people, mainly because these products are widely advertised
in the market, and are proliferates the pharmaceutical market. Some
manufacturer showsadvertisements of confirmations from people who
become healthy and cured after taking heir products for their. Consumers
engage with these products due to their claimed quick results and for their
low price.
The following are some claims of manufacturer of food supplements;
Akita Herbal Products, they claim that their medicines provide premium
quality of natural and herbal supplements; Atienza Naturale, claims that they
provide a high-quality and affordable dietary supplements and skincare
products for us Filipinos; and Daila Herbal, claim that they provide health
friendly organic and all natural supplements.
Usually these products bearing a disclaimer No Approved Therapeutic
Claim --- this label means that these products didnt undergo a rigid testing
to prove its efficacy because Food and Drug Administration or FDA (formerly
known as BFAD) just examines its safety.
Few examples of supplements bearing No Approved Therapeutic
Claim label:
Fitrum
My Marvel Taheebo
ABS Bitter Herbs Capsule
Memo Plus Gold
Atienza Natural
Sante Barley
MX3 Natural Xanthone Capsules
4
why some of the manufacturers claimed that their products can cure
diseases which is deceiving.
The label No Approved Therapeutic Claim tends to misinterpret and
didnt mind by many Filipinos, because somehow the terms used is not
familiar to them.
And because of this issue, the researchers pursue this study to know
the experiences of the consumers and what are the factors that influence
them to buy these kinds of products. This study also wants to inform other
people about this label.
Theoretical Framework
The researchers used three theories to explain the factors that affect
the consumers buying decision. The first theory used was the Theory of
Planned Behavior (TPB). It started as the Theory of Reasoned Action that
predicts an individuals intention to engage in a behavior at a specific time
and place. TPB was proposed by Iceck Ajzen in 1985 through his article From
intentions and action; A theory of Planned Behavior. The Theory was
developed from the Theory of Reasoned Action, which was proposed by
Martin Fishbein together with Iceck Ajzen 1975. The Theory was intended to
explain all behaviors over which people have the ability to exert self-control.
The key component to this model is behavioral intention; behavioral
intentions are influenced by the attitude about the likelihood that the
behavior will have the expected outcome and the subjective of the risks and
persuasive influence; central and peripheral source. The ELM accounts for
the differences in persuasive impact produced by arguments that contain
ample information and cogent reasons as compared to messages that rely on
simplistic associations of positive and negative attributes in some object,
action or situation. The key variable in this process is involvement, the
extent to which an individual is willing and able to think about the position
advocated and its supporting materials. When people are motivated and able
to think about the content of the message, elaboration is high. Elaboration
involves cognitive processes such as evaluation, recall, critical judgment, and
inferential judgment. When elaboration is high, the central persuasive route
is likely to occur; conversely, the peripheral route is the likely result of low
elaboration. The receiver is not guided by his or her assessment of the
message, as in the case of the central route, but the receiver decides to
follow a principle or a decision-rule which is derived from the persuasion
situation.
The Health Belief Model (HMB) mainly concerned in explaining health
behaviors. It is a psychological model that attempts to explain and predict
health behaviors. The Health Belief Model was developed in 1950s y social
psychologists Irwin M. Rosenstock, Godfrey H. Hochbaum, S. Stephen
Kegeles, and Howard Leventhal at the U.S. Public Health Service to better
understandand beliefs of individuals.
The HBM is based on the understanding that a person will take a
health-related action (i.e. take food supplements) if that person:
1. Feels that a negative condition (i.e. diabetes) can be avoided,
2. Has a positive expectation that by taking recommended action he/she
will avoid a negative health condition (i.e. taking food supplements will
be effective in preventing diabetes), and
3. Believes that he/she can successfully take a recommend health action
(i.e. he/she can take food supplements ease and without hesitation).
The HBM was spelled out in terms of four constructs representing the
perceived threat and net benefits: perceived susceptibility, perceived
severity, perceived benefits, and perceived barriers. These concepts were
proposed as accounting for peoples readiness to act. An added concept,
cues to action, would activated that readiness and stimulate overt behavior.
A recent addition to the HBM is the concept of self-efficacy, or ones
confidence in the ability to the successfully perform an action. An added
concept, cues to action, would activate that readiness and stimulate overt
behavior.
As what the theories stated above, attitudes and behavior of a person
really affect his/her buying decision. It also said above that even the
constant usage of this person can affect his way of buying, people and the
environment where the person belongs can also be a factor of dealing with
those products in the market. The Theories will support and corroborate the
study entitles: The Lived Experiences of the users of the No Approved
Conceptual Framework
Attitude
towards
behavior
Health
beliefs
Subjecti
ve
norms
Buying
Decision
towards
No
approved
therapeu
tic claim
Effects
products
Perceive
d
Behavior
al
10
11
This paper will help them to the improvement of their study. it will also
give additional knowledge regarding the topic.
13
Definition of Terms
Terms
here
are
conceptually
and
operationally
defined
for
better
Consumers
-
Cure
-
Drug
-
Effect
-
Efficacy
-
Medicines
-
Misleading
-
The product that has not been tested or proven for therapeutic benefit.
Over-the-counter
-
Prescription Drug
-
Risk
-
Safety
-
Supplements
-
Taking
-
Therapeutic
-
Users
-
16
CHAPTER II
RELATED LITERATURES
LOCAL LITERATURE
Nowadays, many Filipinos are taking alternative medicines, over the
counter drugs or supplements rather than drugs prescribed by their
physicians and one of the reasons why they prefer those products is because
of its cheaper price. According to the most recent information that Food and
Drugs conducted, there are 2588 registered food supplements in the
Philippines most of them promises that youll have a healthier body or claims
that it can treat conditions such as diabetes and arthritis. Another thing is it
also claims that it will helps to improve your metabolism in helping a person
to lose weight or anti-aging by using it regularly. Yet in each carton, bottled
and advertisements often ignored the statement, No Approved Therapeutic
Claim this basically means that food supplements are not yet proven to be
as effective as what they claim or promise to address. In this case, it is
obviously that advertisement is one of the factors that affect the buying
decision of the consumers disregarding the disclaimer means that they still
consider and patronize those products.
The major key players in an advertisement are the product advertisers,
endorsers and owner. These key players are requested by the FDA to seek its
approval to ensure that they provide true and correct information. FDA also
noted that food supplements were granted only as food products and not as
a drug product. All food supplements are required to carry the No Approved
Therapeutic Claim phrase to their label. This label meant that it cant cure
nor intended to treat diseases; drug products that are authorized by the FDA
17
are the only one who can made all those therapeutic claims. Endorsers
whose tries to persuade people to believe to their products claim through
testimonials or even false claims were associated with the FDA logo and the
Certificate of Product Registration (CPR). It means that it should have enough
information or knowledge about the product or about the advertisement
towards those products.
Self-medication is one of the Filipinos do to treat their illness but
according to the FDA it is not advisable because according to them it might
lead to a serious damage such as permanent mental or physical disability.
FDA encourages the public to be more conscious about our health yet be
wiser in choosing a product to buy. FDA said that patients should consult to
their doctor for proper treatment of their diseases and to know more about
the benefits or risks in taking food supplements.
Purchasing a product is not only a decision of yourself but can also be
an influence of your physical surroundings. Perez, et.al (2004). Individuals
decisions are influenced not only by advertising but also by an individuals
level of education, family beliefs, religion, socio-economic status,
community, personal goals, and other factors.
With all these influences, it might seem that a person can hardly be
blamed for making choices about consumer health products. But this would
deny self-responsibility. Consumers can make informed choices if they desire
to do so. By accepting self-responsibility, consumers can then seek out
information about the product, analyze each in its own merits, and make
wise decisions accordingly.
The variety of food and drugs available means that you must be critical
when buying a product. Some criteria for selecting health products may help
you obtain quality goods. Before buying any health products, ask the
following: does the product protect your health pocket? Who are the
manufacturers of the product? What is the reputation of manufacturing
18
company? What is the brand size and weight of the product? Has the product
even been tried or tested? Does it bear a seal of acceptance and high quality
standard set by the Philippine Medical Association and Bureau of Food and
Drugs (FDA)? Has the product been recommended or prescribed by the
physician? Knowing all the information before buying a health product should
be practice by the consumers.
LOCAL STUDIES
Supplement which has been labeled with No Approved Therapeutic
Claim offers wide range of varieties that most consumers buy without being
notice. It includes Food and dietary supplements with vitamins and mineral,
amino acids, proteins and other like Herbal supplements which contains
ampalaya, banaba and many more.
According to the study of Ortiz (2006), given the variety of dietary
supplements available in the market, information on the most common used
supplements, the widespread use of vitamins and minerals preparation is
probably due to the fact that these contain the most commonly known
nutrients and people believe nutrients such as vitamins are essentials to
their health. Additionally, taking one pill which contains all or most nutrients
is appealing for most people.
Differences in the study population, a lower income group, less
educated, and prominently non-users and the timing of the study could
account for the difference. This also showed that the type of supplements
used varies according to the population group studied. Differences in the
19
FOREIGN LITERATURE
Health is known to be the state of humans free form illness, injury or
pain. Health is a condition of complete physical, mental, and social well20
being and the absence of disease. This is the definition of World Health
Organization (WHO). Health is very important to every person because a
healthy person can engage in daily activities normally and helps achieve
ones goal.
In general, for an individual to have a healthy lifestyle you must have a
balanced diet with enough fruits and vegetables. Plus the fact that you get
enough sleep, water, exercise and avoidance of vices such as smoking and
drinking alcoholic beverages.
Another way to get a healthy lifestyle is through taking multivitamins.
People take multivitamins because they lack in nutrients or they wanted to
stay ahead and make sure that their body is getting the essential vitamins
that they needed.
However, according to Roize (2006), people nowadays have busier
lives and hectic schedules. Thus, getting a healthy lifestyle is not easy.
According to Cutler (2013), Medical advancements have helped people
to stay healthy and live longer.
Based on World Health Organization, people nowadays are living longer
and having healthier lives than before. Although in the past few years life
expectancy in the United States increased because health hasnt improved
and people are still suffering in chronic diseases due to poor lifestyle. In the
United States healthy life expectancy is currently 79 years. Also in the same
country, healthy life expectancy declined between 1990 and 2012 (it
declined in this index from 4th position to 26th position) despite of having a
big spending in healthcare.
People of today are more educated and more motivated to stay healthy
for a long period of time yet people cant hide the fact that there is
unfathomable and ampant dispersion of diseases that come from individuals
21
Drugs with the main purpose to treat diseases or symptoms are called
medical drugs. On the other hand, drugs or medicines that are available or
can be bought without the doctors prescription are called Non-prescriptiondrugs.
A simple way is to think of medical, non-medical and illegal of
restricted drugs. Most of you have probably used medical drugs at some time
for the treatment of an illness or to relieve pain. While drugs that work on the
central nervous system and produce a marked changes in peoples feelings
and behavior are called illegal and restricted drugs.
To produce safe and effective drugs there is a due process that the
drug must undergo for it to be approved and this is called the FDA Approval
process.
First in the approval process is the pre-clinical or drug discovery phase
which means they are looking for a possible new components to target a
specific illness. The main purpose of this stage is to identify the correct
dosage level, how frequent it should be taken, and the best way of
administering (oral, topical, intravenous, etc.) this product. Toxicology of the
product is also tested in animals and other living tissues during this phase.
This process took three and a half years.
The company who has completed the pre-technical test the y can now
file an Investigational New Drug Application IND with Food and Drugs
Administration. Expedited reviews of a drug which is called Fast Track
Designation that is given to a company whose drug or biologic makes both a
product and marketing claim that addresses an unmet medical need. It can
be granted at any point after the FDA approves an IND.
If everIND was approved by FDA the experimental drugs will then
moves to Phase I which is the Human Testing .and this process takes a year.
24
The experimental drug was tested in a small number (under 100) of healthy
participants. The purpose of this stage is to see if what will be the effect of
the drug to the human body, and for the curacy dosing.
Testing the effectiveness of the drugs for a targeted disease and
determining its short-term effects is the objective of the phase II. In this
phase the experimental drug will be administered to 100-300 people; this
process takes about two years.
A large- scale study will be conducted which will test the drugs to
1000-3000 patients to know the effectiveness and the possible side effects of
the drug. The result of the phase III will be submitted to the FDA for the drug
to be approved. Aside from the testing the viability of the drug, the producer
of the drugs identify the amount includes in creating a large supplies of
treatment. This process takes about three years.
The company then files a NDA (New Drugs Application) or BLA
(Biologist License Application) with the FDA which are usually 100,000 pages
which includes the result of human and animal tests together with the
informationsin manufacturing drugs. FDA normally took 1-2 years in
reviewing the process before it will be completed before the drugs to be
approved.
Once the drug receives the approval of FDA it can now be marketed to
the people. However, FDA still monitioring short-and long-term side effects
and should submit results to the FDA. The company must receive approval
from the FDA that the drugs can approved it as a new indication.
The effectiveness of a certain drugs or medicine depends on the
identifiable benefits get by the public which means that without large
population health figures it will be very hard and impossible to prove its
efficiency of some preventive interventions. As the case of diseases got by
the people gets high, as the price of the medicines gets costly, and due to
being practical of the public, they come up with patronizing various food and
25
dietary supplements and those products which has not yet been approved as
being drugs.
A large number of questions arose about whether such a new product
is needed to be reviewed for safety before it will be marketed and if whether
some of their beneficial claims that it was made by the seller constituted
mislabeling. And those issues are cleared by Dietary Supplement Health
Education Act of 1994. Its definition of dietary supplement was broadened
which include not only vitamins, minerals and proteins but also herbs and
herbs extracts. (Drugs, Society and Human Behavior)
In recent years, many people have become interested in herbal
products. Research shows that most people try an herbal product at some
time in their lives. Health food stores, grocery stores, and pharmacies all
carry some of these products. Some people take these drugs instead of their
prescription drugs, and some use them along with their prescription drugs.
Although research may someday find that these products are safe and
effective, at present these herbal products are not regulated, standardized,
or tested for safety and effectiveness. Government consider herbal products
to be nutritional supplements rather than drugs, there are no regulations to
control how they are made. There is no way to know if one leaf that is ground
up and made up into a pill will work the same as another leaf that is ground
up. Also, you cannot easily tell how much of the herbal product is in each pill,
or even if in each pill in a bottle contains the same amount of the product.
People in the United States are now using these same herbal remedies
in growing numbers, because they wish to prevent disease, treat illness, and
improve health. Because herbal therapies have such a long history in
different cultures, this may have created the impression in the minds of
some consumers that they are safe and natural and lead to a false sense of
safety and effectiveness. The fact that a product is natural does not mean
it is either effective or safe. With the growing scientific research of many
herbal products, there is growing belief on the health care community that if
26
herbs are effective, then they should be used under the direction of a health
care professional (Edmunds, 2009).
Believing that these products could heal them or even lower the risk of
having some kind of diseases, their beliefs created strong urge to take those
medicinal herbs and supplements. Belief constitutes as one of the
determinants why people tend to patronize a product. It is something that
one holds to be true. Our beliefs continue to be powerful and relevant drives
of human behavior and constitute a central component of the
biopsychosocial approach to explaining illness behavior (White 2005).Belief
must be some sort of association held in the mind and gained through
experience of some internal and external stimuli which predicts a particular
outcome or response. Presumably, then, the acquisition of beliefs comes
about by accumulation of those associations with the usual outcomes or
outcomes overtime (Halligan, 2006).
The power of belief in the medicine is no better illustrated than when
the doctors belief in his treatment and the patients faith (belief) in his
physician, produce a tangible therapeutic effect. (Alyward, 2006)
So with the manifestation of the dietary supplements in the market
where customers have strong faith with those products because of various
influences; because of this alarming situation, an act was passed by the
United States government which requires that the label of a dietary/ food
supplement identify it as such. The said label should state that the claims for
these supplements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA). The list of each ingredient by name, quantity, and total
weight and must identify the parts of the plants from which each ingredients
is derived. (Beers, et.al, 2003)
The outcome of this 1994 law was that the dietary/ food supplement
manufacturers were now free to market a wide variety of products without
fear that the FDA would consider them to be drugs, requiring evidence of
solid premarketing of both effectiveness and safety (Ksir, et.al,2006).
27
28
uncommon.
Patients have different response to a medicine than others.
label on it.
If the medicines expired already throw it.
Patients should not use a medicine that does not belong to
them.
Patients should buy only products that will treat their
symptoms
Buy generic products and check the prices of OTC medicines.
If the user is a child the parents should know the right
30
FOREIGN STUDIES
Medications before uses different parts of plants or herbs without any
chemicals included. As technology develops, forms of our medicines
transformed and develops with the additions of chemicals that are usually
made in laboratories and needs to be approved by Food and Drugs
Administration before releasing in the market.
Those FDA approved drugs can claim or state that the products can
cure, or prevent disease. For the product to be approved, the manufacturer
need to show or prove that the product is safe and effective for the
consumers health condition. Also, in approving these products, wide-range
of preliminary research and the progressively clinical trials with the humans
participation to a three phase series is necessary. (Alzheimers Association,
2004)
Herbal Remedies and botanicals are parts of the Complemantary and
Alternative Medicine (CAM) including ayurvedic medicine. Firenzou (2007)
said that Nutritional supplement is the most commonly used among CAM
approaches.
Nowadays, these herbal medicines and supplements become available
in the market. According to Suleiman (2014), the use of Herbal Medicines
and Dietary Supplements in the world was substantially increasing; and
according to Samoljik et.al, as retrieved by Suleiman (2014). People uses
herbal medicines and dietary supplements for health maintenance, for
preventing and treatment of some chronic diseases or even minor ailments,
and sometimes they often used as a partner of a prescribed drugs while
some uses those products as an alternative to the prescribed medicine for
diseases which considered to be chronic.
When people heard that the product is made from organic ingredients
like supplements, they perceived that the product is safe. People are
31
SYNTHESIS
With the reference and sources the researchers had gathered, from
books, internet, newspapers, magazines and journal, we consider that the
literature and study presented strongly supports and are connected and
related to our proposed study which is entitled: The Lived Experiences of the
Users of the No Approved Therapeutic Claims Products. Health is defined
as the state of complete physical wellness in all aspects by the World Health
Organization where Roizen supported that by (Reviewed) being aware of the
amount of foods we eat plus exercise. That showed people in America tend
32
to be more aware of their health status that made them considered in taking
supplements to stay healthy and made people have recorded longer life span
from around 64 years to 70. But the fact that diseases are just around us and
are easy to disperse, we can prevent from having complicated health status.
Daniel by his Health annual auditions shared the list of top 10 leading killer
diseases including Heart disease, Cancer, Stroke and Chronic Obstructive
Lung Disease.
After listing the top diseases, bacteria are defines as one of the agents
that brings diseases. This brings further information to the people and this
adds to what the medicines includes showing figures of the benefits that
drugs provided.
According to Creighton, the term health products refers to different
types and according to Craig and Stitzel, people tend to accord herbal
products with its ability to remove pain and diseases that are readily
available in the market which can project differently through the eyes of the
consumers and disregard the thought that using those products could be
risky and dangerous especially when frequently used with a large dosage.
Drug is then defines by Allen by basically a help to treat a range
of common and rare condition from four sources: plants, animals, and
minerals as well as chemicals said Gauwitz. Drugs are also classified stately
medical drugs, non-prescription drugs, illegal or restricted drugs.
Drugs may be available in large amount in the market but if so people
little did know that these undergoes rigid testing and other processes before
labeling a product as a drug which is called the FDA Approval Process. The
non-clinical or drug discovery phase, approval of the contents of the drug
takes 3 years in the making. Dosage level and the best delivery system is
evaluated then they do a filing of an Investigational New Drug application
with FDA and when approved this goes through the Phase 1 or the human
testing from at least to greatest number of people they can test the
33
effectiveness of the drug. On the third phase, side effects of the drugs are
determined and come along with 100,000 pages long information on how
drug is manufactured.
Aside from drugs, supplements are used to substitute the health
effects that drugs offer. Because it is cheaper than drugs, supplements
demand is higher disregarding the thought that these said supplements are
not yet proven to be approved as drugs.
But as Act 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act clarified
that supplement doesnt need to be approved because they only contain
vitamins and does not directly claims curable though they are permitted t
make general statements about the overall health and well-being and also
the use of claims such as high in calcium, good source of fiber, may
reduce risk of heart disease, supports the immune system, or helps
maintain mental health said Hamilton.
Because people tend to associate medicinal herbs and supplements as
to healing and lowering risks having some kind of diseases, the level of these
products demands to get higher said Halligan. Dietary supplements Health
Education Act (DSHEA) cleared out that these products must be properly
indicated with labels that these are not evaluated by the FDA, list of
ingredients by name, quantity and total weight according to Deers, Hetcher,
Jones, and Porter, which must be observed especially nowadays that dietary
supplements are free to market. It is also stated that most of the reason that
adds
to
the
consumer
patronize
such
products
is
because
of
its
2014).
Consumers
of
these
products
treat
it
as
health
36
GUIDE QUESTIONNAIRE:
1. What is the demographic profile of the respondents in terms of the
following: (Ano ang mga demograpikong impormasyon ng mga taga
tugon sa mga sumusunod)
1.1 Age (Edad)
1.2 Gender (Kasarian)
1.3 Civil Status (Estadong Sibil)
1.4 Employment Status (Trabaho)
2. Are you familiar with the No Approved Therapeutic Claim label?
(Pamilyar ka ba sa label na No Approved Therapeutic Claim?)
3. Where have you encountered these kinds of products? (Saan niyo
madalas makita ang mga produktong ito?
4. What is your idea/perception about the products with No Approved
Therapeutic Claim label? (Ano ang iyong ideya o pananaw tungkol sa
mga produkto na may No Approved Therapeutic Claim na label?
5. Does your current condition require you to purchase and use these
kinds of products? (Sa kalagayan ng kalusugan mo ngayon,
nangangailangan ka pa bang bumili at gumamit ng mga ganitong
produkto?)
6. What influences you to purchase these products with No Approved
Therapeutic Claim label? (Ano ang mga nakaimpluwensiya sa iyo na
bumili ng mga produkto na may No Approved Therapeutic Claim na
label?)
7. What can you say about the advertisement of products with No
Approved Therapeutic Claim label? (Ano ang iyong masasabi sa mga
patalastas ng mga produktong may No Approved Therspeutic Claim
na label?)
37
38
CHAPTER III:
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Method and Design
1.1
Qualitative Approach
Phenomenology, as defined by Creswell (2009), is a research strategy
Research Population
2.1 Description of the Respondents
The study is consisting of forty-five (45) participants residing at Quezon
City that are users of products that have No Approved Therapeutic Claim
label.
2.2 Method of Data Collection and Instrumentation
residence.
2.2.2 Instrumentation
39
will
be conducted based
Claim products. If the result of the pilot test is vigorous then thats the only
time the researcher can conduct an actual interview.
2.2.3 Procedure
Semi-structured interviews were used to collect accounts from
and
write
the
information
gathered.
Each
interview
lasted
Data Analysis
3.1 Narrative Analysis
A narrative approach presents a storied account of experience and
recognizes the value of stories in the construction of meaning (Labov, 1972;
Mcleod, 1997; Sarbin and Kitsuse, 1994). Narrative analysis is concerned
with probing the means by which experience is represented and interpreted.
Experience is represented in the form of the written and spoken word. A
41
1998). In adopting this approach to data analysis in this study, analysis initial
phase was focused on written interview like summarized stories from a raw
data. The results will be supported by the remaining data from participants
own words.
The steps for making inferences and analysis as discussed by Van
Manen (1990) have been applied to this study. Firstly transcriptions were
read through several times, until a strong sense of each participants storied
account was grasped. This was followed by going through the text again,
underlining and highlighting words, phrases or sentences in relevance to the
research questions. Individual stories were then rewritten in terms of these
thematic headings and illustrated by reference to participants own words.
This was followed by rewriting a combined account based on individual
stories. As co-narrator, the researchers attempted to retell participants
stories through thematic discussion of the research questions.
Summary
Chapter 3 discussed the research methodology that will be applied in
the qualitative study, which is a phenomenological research design. Also
included in Chapter 3 was information on the data collection process as well
as data analyses, which include the narrative of individuals experiences and
identifying themes from the answers of participating consumers taking No
Approved Therapeutic Claim products to their respective interviews. The
following chapter presents the results for this study, where they will be
examined and assessed.
43
CHAPTER IV:
RESULTS, DISCUSSION, and ANALYSIS
DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE
The researchers from the time span of 3 months specifically from the
start of the (December) to (February) gathered data for the research entitled
" The Lived Experience of the Users of the No Approved Therapeutic Claim
Products around the barangays in Quezon City.
Having the total of forty-five (45) participants who are subject to one
on one interview which are all users of No Approved Therapeutic Claim
44
45
46
The participants were asked if they use the products regularly, most of
the participants answered yes. There are about 38 participants in total
while the rest of the 7 respondents arent taking it regularly for the reason
that its either expensive or they just consume it only if they have illness.
47
There are both six (6) respondents from the span of 3 years to 4 years
and 11 months, three (3) users from 9 years to 10 years and 11 months and
both a user from 7 years to 8 years and 11 months and 11 years and above.
These span of time are the standard limit of years using the products
for qualification to interview. If a user spent 5 years and above using the
NATC products, they are qualified to be the key informant.
MEDICAL CONDITIONS
HIGH BLOOD- 11
DIABETESE- 7
UTI- 4
PROSTATE- 2
HIGH CHOLESTEROL- 2
HYPERTENSION- 2
FREQUENT COUGHING-1
ULCER- 1
GALL STONE- 1
LOSE WEIGHT- 1
CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE- 1
COMMATOSE- 1
ALLERGY- 1
ANEMIC- 1
STROKE- 1
ASTHMA- 1
JOINT AND BONE PROBLEMS- 1
STOMACHACHE- 1
PNEUMONIA-1
ARTHRITIS- 1
STRESS- 1
CONSTIPATION- 1
WEAK BODY- 1
BRONCHECTASIS- 1
BACKPAIN- 1
As the results of the one on one interviewed came out, we have noticed that
most of the interviewees health problem is having high blood pressure next
is diabetes, Urinary Tract Infection and problem with their prostate.
48
MITOGEN- 1
ISPERULINA- 1
MORINGA- 1
PRIMERA- 1
USANA- 1
UNO- 1
BITTER- 1
C 24/7- 1
HERBAL- 1
SERPENTINA- 1
JINGA JUICE- 1
ACYBERRY- 1
HERBAL LIFE- 1
MITO MALUNGGAY -1
AIM GLOBAL- 1
EDMARK GINSENG COFFEE- 1
This is the list of the products that are used by the interviewees and based
on the information that the researchers have gathered, the top 3 used
products are MX3 which has the greatest number, garnering a total of 8
same us with the users of the product Vita Plus. Next are the products
namely Taheebo, Green Barley, Ampalaya Plus which has 5 users each
products and 3 users each for Malunggay and DXN products. The researchers
observed that these products that gathered the most number of the users
has advertisements and are also display to public through the television.
49
OO.
yun
yung
mga
gamot
na
hindi
pa
naaapprove
d ng FDA
kasi di pa
napapatuna
yan
na
nakakagalin
g
(Yes. Those
are
the
drugs thats
not
yet
approved by
FDA because
its not yet
proven that
it can cure.)
Oo
naman.
(Yes
of
course )
OO
(Yes)
50
sometim
es it was
offered
by
many.)
Usually sa
mga
herbal
products,
tsaka
yung mga
hindi
BFAD
approved.
(Usually
on herbal
products,
and those
that is not
approved
by BFAD.)
Sa
mga
gamot na
binibili, sa
karton
tawag
dyan, sa
lagayan.
(On
the
drugs that
can
be
bought,
on
the
box,
on
the
package.)
Wala
na uhm uhm.
dito
e. (iling)
(dealer)
No idea
hindi
na
dito
nakatira,
sa
sta.
Lucia
(Not here
anymore.
He/She
doesnt
live here,
in
sta.
Lucia.)
sa
mga
box
for
example
Vita plus.
No. 1 kasi
nandon
na yan sa
vita plus.
(on
the
boxes, for
example,
vita plus.
No. 1 its
already
on
the
vita plus.)
Table 2 shows that the Key Informant, and 4( Four) out of 5 (Five)
FGD participants have encountered this label through the herbal
products that they take or through the dealers.
3 What is your idea/perception about the label No Approved
Therapeutic Claims? (Ano ang iyong ideya o pananaw tungkol
sa label naNo Approved Therapeutic Claim na label?)
K. I
Participa Particip Particip Particip Participa
nt 1
ant 2
ant 3
ant 4
nt 5
Parang ano Ibig
Hindi pa Wala,
Ibig
Maganda
51
lang,
Supplement
s
lang,
pampa
parang
vitamin
lang.
Hindi
nakakagalin
g
talaga.
Oo.pampaka
lma
Pampaano
pampalakas
lang, yung
sa akin sakit
nadun
pa
rin.
Hindi
nga
gamot siya,
ano
para
nga
lang
siya
supplement.
(Its just like
a
supplement,
just
like
vitamins.
It
cant
actually
cure.
Yes,
it
tranquilizes
and
can
only
strengthen,
but
my
decease are
still there.
Its
not
actually
a
sabihin
hindi
siguradon
g
makakaga
ling di ba,
Or
effective
di ba
Sa herbal,
no
problem
(It means
it
cant
surely
cure or it
isnt
effective
right?
No
problem in
herbal)
siya.
Hindi
pa,ibig
sabihin
hindi pa,
ano yon
100%na..
aynako
hindi ko
alam!
Hindi pa
siya ano
( approv
ed)
sa
BFAD na
nilalabas
sa
merkado.
(Its not
yet,
meaning
its
not
yet
100%
that... I
dont
know!Its
not
yet
(approve
d)
in
BFAD
that
is
proliferat
ing in the
market.)
maganda
siya
(Nothing.
Its
good.).
sabihin
hindi
naapprov
ed
sa
ano
(BFAD).
(It
means it
is
not
approved
in BFAD.)
kasi
hindi
para sakin
mas okay
yan
kasi
nga
nakakatul
ong
kasi
imbes na
katulad ng
ibang
gamot na
talagang
ano
masisira
yung
kidney
mo. Mga
ganyan
tinutulung
an nilang
lumakas.
(For
me
its
good
because it
could
help,
unlike
other
drugs that
badly
affect
your
kidney.
This could
give
strength.)
52
(Right
now,
thats
were i am
most
comfortabl
e,
so
i
continued.
)
iniinom
pero hindi
gumagalin
g
(Yes,
actually
there
is
no choice
because
our
patient
have
taken a lot
of
medicines
but is not
yet cured.)
lang yung
mga dugo
namen
dati.
(No. That
is
what
prescribed
to
me,
because
were low
bloods
before.)
sa
min
kase hindi
ko na ano
kase
syempre
naranasan
mo
eh.
Syempre
ayaw mo
rin
na
pero
di
kame
nagsalita
na ganun
ganun.
Hindi.
Basta
tinigil
lang.
basta
tinigil na
lang
namin.
(Yes.
supposedl
y?
Because
there were
still many
who sells.
Claims, and all of them are influenced by mere people. The Key
Informat was influenced by her wife and son or family member. Four
(4) of the FGD Participants are influenced by a family member,
relatives, and product dealers. It also shows that even the place
where the products can be purchase influence the buying decision of
the participants.
6 What can you say about the advertisement of products with
No Approved Therapeutic Claim label? (Ano ang iyong
masasabi sa mga patalastas ng mga produkto na may No
Approved Therapeutic Claim na label?)
K. I
Participant Partici
Partici
Participan Particip
1
pant 2
pant 3
t4
ant 5
Oo,ano
Merong dati Wala
Mas
meron dati Magand
yong
nag ano sila, Alam
magand ah.
Pero a.
binibigay, pero
hindi mo
a siya
ngayon, di (Good)
pag bumili naman
pagdati (Its
ko
na
ka
niyan masasabi na ng
sa really
napapansin
bibigyan
tv ads yun ads, ano good)
ka ng DVD kasi sa ano din ako
hindi ko rin
yung
eh alam mo e,
ano
papapaliw yung
mga minsan
(pansin)
anag yung salamat dok, hindi
kase
tutok
ng mga
ako
syempre,
ano
program.
naniniw
ano(comme
(herbal
Still,
ala kase
rcial)
lang
suppleme sinasabi nila, base sa
naman nila
nts)
what you call experie
yon
(Yes, the it,
nce
(There were
give
a advertiseme namen,
before. But
ways,
nt,ano lang (None,
know
i
when you siguro
because
didnt
bought it sponsor kasi. when it
noticed.
you will be
comes
I
wasnt
given
a Siguro
to ads,
aware
DVD that nakakatulon im like,
because of
explains
g.
someti
course
its
the
(There were mes
i
just
their
focused of before , but dont
commercial.
herbal
you
cant believe
)
suppleme actually say because
nts)
that its a TV it
was
ads like you still
know
the base on
Salamat
our
56
Participa
nt 4
nong una
syempre
di mo rin
masasabi
dahil
Participa
nt 5
di na kasi
ako
gumagam
it ng mga
medisina
57
eh
product
industry
nakakano
yung
Pinipilit
na "Hoy
bumili
kayo
magaling
to." kahit
hindi
di
ba.
(Theres a
big
difference
. Its like
the
product
industry,
its
like
when you
are
forced
that
Hey, you
should
buy,
its
good
even its
not,
right?)
mga
nakapag
aral
naman,
tanung
tanong
din muna
tungkol sa
produkto.
Pero kung
may mga
kemikal
nay
an,
hindi ako
basta
basta
iinom.
(Yes,
because it
was
endorsed.
To those
educated,
you
should
ask
first
about the
product.
But
if
theres
some
chemicals
on
it
i
wont
easily
intake
that.)
ko nakita
yung
palabas
dyan sa tv
(No.
Im
actually
using
it
before
i
saw it on
TV.)
gusto mo
eh diba?
nong
natake
mo
na,
parang
ano na, di
ko
na
lang, wag
ko na lang
kumibo,
kase
alangan
naman
sabihin
mo
naninira
ka pa.
(At
first,
of course
you cant
actually
say that
you like it
right?
When
youve
take it, its
like,
i
shouldn't,
ill just not
react,
because
you might
say
somethin
g
against...)
ang
ginagamit
ko
puro
vita plus..
(I actually
dont use
the
medicine
now, i use
the
vita
plus
more.)
of the FGD Particiants stated that their buying decision was not
affected by the advertisements.
sa ano 7,700
isang
bag
eh.
nakakasamp
ung
bag.
(Also on, my
wife, its also
in
ortigas
and all the..
Like
the
main
in..
7,700
for
each bag, i
used almost
10 bags.)
mga
booths
doon.
Then sa
mga drug
stores
wala.
Actually
may mga
ano
na,
mga
dealer.
Pero
sakin
kasi,
meron sa
japan,
pinapabili
ko
sa
brother
ko.
(Here,
also
in
the
market,
on
SM
malls.
They
have
booths
there.
Theres
none
in
the drug
stores.
Actually
there are
dealers
already.
But mine,
can
be
bought in
japan,
i
asked it
for
my
brother
e
ng
kapatid
ko
(Mercury.
The
green
barley is
from the
office
mate of
my
sibling.)
FEU.
(When
we
run
out
off
supply,
we
bought it
on
the
drug
stores.)
nag
attend ng
seminar.
Tapos
dun kase
di
ako
member
nun eh.
(Someon
e
bring
us there.
There is a
networki
ng, then
we
attended
a
seminar.
That
is
then,
because
im not a
member
of it.)
seminar
(In
our
office. It
was
referred
to
us
when
there was
a
seminar.)
60
to buy.
Table 9 shows where the participants buy these products with
No approved Therapeutic Claims, the Key Informant said that the
supplement was provided by his wife. While the FGD participants
answered that they usually bought this in SM, through colleagues,
near the university and through networking seminars.
10 How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas mong
ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
K. I
Participant
Participa Participa Participa Participa
1
nt 2
nt 3
nt 4
nt 5
Minsa Dati
high thrice
a Minsan sa isang
pag
n
dosage
ako, week.
isang
beses
masaman
tatlo,
pero
Ganyan
linggo,
lang
sa g
umag supposedly
every
dalawang isang
pakiramda
a,
ang
other day beses
araw.
m
ko
tangh recommendat (Thrice a
(once
a halos
ali
ion nyan 1 week.
Pero yung day.)
maubos
tsaka
sachet a day, Thats it, vitamins
ko
ng
hapon sakin
every
namen na
isang box
.
nagagawa
other
malungga
(When
i
(Some kong 3 times day.)
y,
araw
dont feel
times, a day. High
araw yon
well,
i
thrice. dosage para
a
almost
In the ano
ang
(Sometim
emptied 1
Morin
immune
es, twice
box.)
g,
system
ko
in
a
aftern mag boost.
week.
oon
(Before i was
But
our
and in in
high
malungga
the
dosage,
but
y
evenin supposedly
vitamins,
g.)
the
we take it
recommendat
everyday.
ion is 1 sachet
)
a day. But for
me I've take it
3 times a day.
Its
high
dosage
to
boost
my
immune
system.
61
Table 10 shows how often the participants use the products ,the
Key Informat and one of the FGD use it 3(Three) times a day while the
other are either once or thrice a week or if ever shes not feeling well.
11 What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet etc.) aside
from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim products to
improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong mga paraan o
gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga produktong may No
Approved Therapeutic Claims label para mapabuti ang iyong
kalusugan?)
K. I
Participan Participa Participa Participa Participa
t1
nt 2
nt 3
nt 4
nt 5
Iba-iba
Actually,
Diet.
Wala.
wala
umiinom
(products) matigas
Hindi
naman
ako
ng
din, Ano din ang ulo
naman na (Nothing) guyabano
ba
yung ko
yung
kami
leaves
isang,
mga
nagtetake
lahat
nakalimut pinagbaba
ng kung
herbal
an ko na wal
na
ano ano
lang ang
yung
pagkain,
pa.
ginagamit
pangalan
maaalat,
(No more,
namin.
ng doctor, fats
we
(I
also
puro juice
doesnt
drink
din.
Ang pwede
take
guyabano
(There are lang sakin
anything
leaves,
different
nilagang
else.)
we
only
(product)
isda
na
take
there
is may
herbals.)
this one, i konting
forgot the sibuyas
name of and
asin
the
wala talaga
doctor,
as in tubig
its
also lang talaga
juices.)
atsaka
konting
sibuyas
wala na.
(Actually,
im
also
stubborn,
the
prohibited
foods, salty
and
fats.
62
Those that
are
only
allowed for
me,
are
stewed fish
with onion
and salt, as
in theres
no
more,
only water
and onion.)
Table 11 shows the answers of the Participants if what are their other
practices aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim products that
helps improve their health, FGD Participant 2 said Diet, while Participant 5
stated umiinom ako ng guyabano leaves (I take guyabano
leaves.)However some of the participants didnt have any other practices
aside from taking those products.
12 What are the effects of these products to you and what are
your experiences while using this products (Ano ang nagging
epekto ng produktong ito sayo at ano ano ang iyong nagging
karanasan sa paggamit ng ganitong produkto?)
K. I
Participa Participa Participa Participa Participa
nt 1
nt 2
nt 3
nt 4
nt 5
malakas
Ayun,
Sabi nga
parang
oo
kasi
yung
nakatayo
Pinahinto
wala nga lumalakas
nila
katawan
ako from parang
na talaga eh.
kami eh.
mo
paralyzed
ko
ng
iniinom
parang
doctor
iyon nga Yun
ang
mo
yan
maganda Imagine
dahil
tumigil
kaibahan
na yung mo
yun mind over umabot
kami ,
ng
matter
blood
payat ko
ako
ng Parang
medisina
circulatio talaga
umabot
wala
rin na
tawag ko
n
mo tapos
ako
ng kase
inaano(pr
dyan
tapos
continuou kase, sabi 140
masyadon ocess)
medyo
s
yan,
Highblood g
kesa
sa
nga ng
yung ano unti-unti
na yon
matamis
mga
parang
hanggang anak ko
eh.
Ibig produkton
tingin mo sa.. kung its only in Umabot
sabihin
g herbal.
the
mind
medyo
minsan
na ko unti hindi
ka Mabisa
maayos
kasi ayaw mama
unti
rin
talaga
63
na yung ng doctor
sakit mo. talaga
haha!
ipainom
sakin yan
Kaya lang eh, inano
ano
ko
lang
parang
dinisobey
palagi
ko
lang
kang
talaga
naguguto yung
m, gusto doctor ko.
mo kain Kasi dyan
ng kain.
ako
(You will lumakas
have
eh,
so
strong
ganun din
body, like naman
you have wala
a
good naman,
blood
may
circulatio dosage
n and you naman
think that yan
eh.
your
Hindi
illness
naman
had
inasabing
recovered masama,
.
hindi
But, you naman
always
sinasabin
feel
g mabuti
hungry,
pero ayaw
you keep ipainom
on
ng doctor
eating.)
bastabasta. Eh
ako
sinikreto
ko
ang
pag inom
ko.
Still
continuou
s
parin
naman
yung
gamut ko
ganyan
ganyan.
Kaya
iniimom
ko baka
sakaling
makatulo
ng
Hindi
naman
nawala
yung
aking ano
(sakit),
kase
diabetic
ako wala
din Wala.
Ay ewan ko
lang din,
kase paano
ko
malalaman
na may
epekto e
kagaya ko
may sakit
hindi naman
ano yung
sakit ko,
siguro sa
ibang banda,
in some
other way
nakakatulon
g din hindi
ko lang
napapansin.
Kagaya ng
naabot na
ko ng 90,
tapos 120
ganon.
Yung ano
na,
umabot
na ko nag
140 tsaka
naglalock
na
yung
ano
ko
(yung jaw
ko)
huminto
na ko ng
vitamins,
bawal na
saken
yung mga
vitamins.
(I
was
actually
forced to
stopped
by
the
doctor
because i
reached
140
(blood
pressure)
it
was
already a
High
blood.
I
slowly
reached
90, then
120 until
it reached
140 and
then i had
a
jaw
lock.
Thats
pwedeng
ano, baka
magkaron
ka
pa
tuloy ano
diabetes.
(Like
nothing.
Thats
why
we
stopped,
like
its
nothing,
too
sweet(pro
duct).
It
just mean
you cant,
you might
end
up
having a
diabetes.)
kasi
gumagali
ng
na
pinapalak
as pa ang
immune
system
mo.
unang
una wala
kang
nadidigha
y
na
medisina.
Natural
lang.
(Yes,
because it
strengthe
n us.
That
is
the
difference
of
medicine
that
is
being(pro
cess) than
herbal
products.
Its
very
effective
aside
from
it
cures
it
also
strengthe
n
your
immune
system.
First of all
you dont
belch
medicine,
only
the
64
na
binibigay
ng doctor
ko.
(I
recovered
from
being
paralyzed.
Imagine i
was really
thin then
its
continuou
s,
gradually
until.. But
sometime
s
the
doctors
prohibited
me
to
take
those, but
i disobey
the doctor
because it
strengthe
n me. So
its
just
the same,
theres
nothing,
beside it
has
its
dosage.
when
i
stopped
the
vitamins,
It
was
prohibited
(I wasnt on me.)
actually
cured,
because
im
diabetic,
its
nothing.)
vitamin c o
diba
nakakatulon
g din
natural.)
They
dont say
its bad or
good, but
the doctor
prohibit
me
to
take
it.
Anyway, i
65
intake
that
secretly.
But
my
medicines
that was
given by
the doctor
are
still
continuou
s.)
Table 12 shows the experiences of the users of the No Approved
Therapeutic Claim Produts and the effects of these products to their health:
Some of the participants answered positively to the query. According to the
Key Informant maganda na yung blood circulation mo,Kaya lang ano
parang palagi kang nagugutom, gusto mo kain ng kain.(Youll had
good blood circulation, but you often feels hungry, you always want to
eat.) ; FGD Participant 1 said Ayun, nakatayo ako from paralyzed (I
recovered from being paralyzed) ; participant 5 answered lumalakas kami
eh.(We become strong)However FGD participant 2 said Hindi naman
nawala yung aking ano (sakit), kase diabetic ako wala din. Sabi nga
nila parang iniinom mo yan mind over matter tawag ko dyan
kase, sabi nga ng anak ko its only in the mind mama ganyan
ganyan. Kaya iniimom ko baka sakaling makatulong(My illness are
still there, because im diabetic, its nothing. Like what they have said you
intake it Mind over matter thats what ive called it. Like what my child said
its only in the mind mom thats it. Thats why i intake it, hopefully it could
help.) FGD Participant 3 answered Yung ano na, umabot na ko nag 140
tsaka naglalock na yung ano ko (yung jaw ko) huminto na ko ng
vitamins,(When, i reached 140 (blood pressure) im having a jaw lock, that
when i stopped taking vitamins. )and FGD Participant 4 said parang wala
nga eh.Iyon nga tumigil kami ,Parang wala rin kase masyadong
matamis eh. Ibig sabihin hindi ka rin pwedeng ano, baka magkaron
ka pa tuloy ano diabetes.(Its like nothing. Thats why we stopped. It
seems nothing because its too sweet. It means you cant actually, you might
get diabetes instead.)
iyong pamumuhay?)
K. I
Participa Participan
nt 1
t2
Oo,
With the Sabihin
Medyo help
ng nalang
siguro
ganyan,
naten
na
kung
ng herbal ano,positiv
hindi
suppleme e
naman
pa ako nt na yan, ako
ah,
guma
lumakas
nakakatulo
mit
ako ulit, ng din.
niyan
back
to (Lets just
baka
normal na say,
im
nakalib naman
also
ing na ako.
positive, it
ako.
can
also
(Yes.
Mas enjoy help.)
Maybe ang
someh buhay ko
ow if i (With the
haven' help
of
t used that
that I herbal
might
suppleme
be
nt
I
dead
became
right
strong
now)
again.
Back
to
normal
again.)
Participa
nt 3
Wala.
Okay
naman
siya e
Ganon pa
rin naman.
Wala
namang
nagbago.
Yung
palitan ko
ganito
ganyan
kase
iba
pakiramda
m, wala.
(Nothing,
its actually
ok.
Its just the
same.
There is no
change.
Thats
what
i
feel.)
Participa
nt 4
parang
wala
naman.
Di
ko
naman
nasabi na
nakasira
sa min di
rin
nakabuti
parang
ano
lang
kase
normal
lang kase
nalaman
mo na nga
eh.
Nandun ka
na eh.
Participa
nt 5
maganda
kasi unang
una
napakama
hal
ng
gamot.
Samantala
ng yun ay
napakamu
ra.
(Its
good
because
first of all,
medicines
are
expensive
unlike that
which
is
affordable.
)
Di mo na
pinagpatul
oy
syempre
wala lang
ganun
talaga.
Parang
wala ding
epekto
may
epekto
yong
parang
ganun.
Huminto
lang.
hininto na
nga
naming
kase wala
67
parang
ano
eh.
Tsaka
mahal eh.
Haha
(Like
its
nothing.
I cant say
that
it
damages
us nor it
helped, its
just
a
normal
that
you
knew.
You were
there.
You
had
stopped
for
nothing.
Like
it
doesnt
have
an
effect.
We
already
stopped,
because,
like
its
nothing
and it is
expensive.
)
Table 13 shows the answer of the respondents if in what way does the
products affect their lifestyle, majority of the FGD participants including the
Key informant answered positively with the question: according to the FGD
Participant 5 maganda kasi unang una napakamahal ng
gamot.Samantalang yun ay napakamura.(Its good, because first of all
drugs are very expensive unlike those which is very affordable.)which is
somehow similar to the answer of the Key Informant; while participant 1 said
68
its synthetic the doctor will claim that it can really cure while on
herbal its like an alternative medicine and they shouldnt depend on
it)
Participant E: Umano tayo dun sa karapat-dapat na gamot na may
permit ba, ng ano, permit ng.. tawag dun? Bureau of Drugs bay un?
( We should believe on the medicines that have permit.. what do you
call it? Bureau of drugs?)
Participant F: ibig sabihin hindi sila approved diba. (It means they are
not approved)
Participant G: Wala. (Nothing)
Participant H: Wala lang, basta uminom lang ako, tapos, kung
mayroon sa aking umeepekto na ano, ayon sasabihin ko na umeepekto
pala ito (Nothing. I just take it. If there are some good effects on me
then I would say that its effective)
Participant I: diba kaya nakalagay yan kasi di pa sila anon a talagang
nakakagamot. Parang supplement lang sila.. pantulong lang sila, pero
hindi sila talagang gamut na yung kagaya ng nireresita ng doctor okay
rin pwede na rin( They include it because they cannot really cure any
disease yet. Its like supplements only. It can help but they are not like
those medicine which are prescribed by the doctors, but its ok.)
Participant J: Wala. (Nothing)
Participant K: uhhmmm ano under ano palang siya under..parang
test pa lang siya hindi pa siya ano napapatunayang ano (nakakagaling)
(It is still under testing. Its not yet proven that it can cure diseases)
Participant E: Aah.. Dun lang sa mga kaibigan ko. Dahil nga nagging
salesman ako ng mga ganyan. At Yun napatunayan ko naman.
Meron, meron talaga Meron talaga. (On my friends, because I
became a salesman of these kind of products. Then I agreed to them
that its effective)
Participant F: kasi diba, diba asthmatic ako.tas meron naman sya
dito na anti asthmatic (Because I am asthmatic, then the product says
that its anti asthmatic)
Participant G: Nakita ko lang sa TV, patalastas (I saw it on the TV
commercials)
Participant H:. Dito nga sa stroke ko yung mga nag dedemo, yung
mga nag aalok alok sinubukan ko lang din naman yan. Lalo na yung
nagpunta dito na channel two, na puro herbal ang ano doon, hindi ko
na binilhan ( Because of my stroke. They offer me and I tried it)
Participant I: yung ano, di tsaka nag aalok kasi, parang syempre
bukod dun sa nag aalok, nag tetes,.. may mga nagtetestimony
(Because of the salesman and testimonies)
Participant J: Wala, basta nabasa ko lang, narinig ko pati sa radio
(Nothing. I just read and heard it on the radio)
Participant K: ahh kasi nakakapanuod ako minsan ng mga shows sa
t.v. ayun (I saw on TV shows)
good and effective of course you will definitely try it. Especially when
youre sick you will try everything thats in there and see if it is ok)
Participant D:
Participant E:
Participant F: minsan nakakatulong diba yung sa patalastas, minsan
nakakatulong sya minsan naman hindi kasi baka hindi yan sa iyo. Hindi
yan natutugma dun sa gusto mo. (Sometimes TV commercials can
help, but sometimes its not because it all depends on what the
consumer wants)
Participant G: Maganda sa katawan. Makagamot, vitamins. (Its good
for the body. It can cure)
Participant H:
Participant I: oo naman number one yun.kasi kung walang
commercial, paano mo siyamagugustuhan? ( Of course because
without it how can the consumers know the product?)
Participant J:
Participant K:ahh. Sinusubukan ko lahat. Minsan Kung anong
ma.aano. kung maganda bas akin o di maganda di ititigil ko kung
maganda itutuloy ko ( I try all of it. If its good for me then Ill continue
using it. If not then Ill stop)
10.
How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas
mong ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
Participant A: Ayan. Ano yan. Mx3? Pwedeng once a day, pwedeng
twice a day. Pero ako twice a day ginagamit nyan. (You can take it
either once or twice a day. But I usually take it twice a day)
Participant B: ang ginagawa ko nyan pag bangong ano ko yung
gamit araw-araw. oo inaaraw araw ko ( I use it everyday)
Participant C: Araw-araw (Everyday)
Participant D: talagang gabi-gabi, pati mga anak ko( Every night
even my children)
Participant E: Pagka ano talagang.. daily puro ano may.. diba may
ano? May dosage? Iinumin mo nang every 3 hours. Aah.. 3 times a
day. Ganun. Ginagamit ko talaga. ( Usually daily. But I think it has
some dosage. But I use it 3 times a day)
Participant F: everyday minsan twice a day. (Everyday, sometimes
twice a day)
Participant G: regular
Participant H: Hinde, yung vita plus araw araw yon, iniinom ko
ngayon (I take vitaplus everyday)
Participant I: araw-araw (Everyday)
Participant J: Ah dalawang beses sa isang araw ko iniinom (I take it
twice a day)
Participant K: regular.oo (Yes. Regular)
11.
What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet
etc.) aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim
products to improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong
mga paraan o gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga
produktong may No Approved Therapeutic Claims label
para mapabuti ang iyong kalusugan?)
Participant A: Una, diet. Ang almusal ko is oatmeal after two hours,
kakain ako ng isang saging kung wala naman kung anong prutas na
77
13.
In what way does the product/s affect your lifestyle?
(Sa paanong paraan naapektuhan ng mga produktong ito
ang iyong pamumuhay?)
Participant A: Mula ng uminom ako ng mx3 na yon, naging flowing,
ano yung pag wiwi ba ano na yon, dati every hour mag wiwiwi ka,
ngayon nabibilang mo na parang back to normal na ako kase dati
parang dati apektado na yung wiwi ko kase matagal na kong diabetic
(Ever since I take MX3, I can urinate regularly, unlike before that Im
having some hardships on urinating because of my diabetese)
Participant B: okay naman na ano na nakakapasok naman arawaraw.ganyan, pero dati dinnagtetake din ako nyan yung mga tanglad,
79
80
A:
B:Sa tv( On the TV)
C:Sa tv meron nyan eh (On the TV)
D: Sa TV (On the TV)
E: Sa lahat ng mga herbal medicines (In all herbal
F: Ayy wala akong alam, hindi ko napapansin, hindi ko
dont know about it, I dont see it neither read it)
82
83
Participant F: Wala naman kasing patalastas ang ganon, hindi nagaano(nag.a.advertise) ang Vita Plus ( Vitaplus doesnt have any
commercials. They dont advertise it)
10.
How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas
mong ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
Participant A:Gaano kadalas, pag inaatake lang ako ng sakit ko dun
ko lang sila ginagamit (When Im sick. Thats the only time I use it)
Participant B:Once a day
Participant C:minsan tatlong beses sa isang lingo (Sometimes 3
times a week)
Participant D:Isang beses maghapon isang beses ah. Once a day
lang. tapos minsan pag may ano pa kami. Meron pa akong tea iniinom
ko rin yun. Maganda rin yung tea ng ano. (Once a day. We also take
the tea because its also good)
Participant E:madalas kapag may nararamdaman akong kakaiba sa
katawan ko. Tapos magtetake ako nun kesa drugs synthetic drugs.
Syempre mas gusto ko na rin sya. Yan. Yang herbal. (When we feel
85
11.
What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet
etc.) aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim
products to improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong
mga paraan o gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga
produktong may No Approved Therapeutic Claims label
para mapabuti ang iyong kalusugan?)
Participant A:Exercise every morning, jumping rope.
Participant B:Exercise
Participant C:wala na (Nothing)
Participant D:ano kumakain ako ng maraming prutas tapos tubig (I
eat plenty of vegetables and plenty of water)
Participant E:May sabon naman ako dito na nabili ko rin na herbal
kasi meron akong allergic sa skin dati yung ginamit ko yung soap na
yan kahit may ano sya may herbal soap sya ngayon gumaling yung
mga skin disease ko.( I have a soap that is also herbal and I used it for
my skin allergy so far it got better now)
Participant F:Mga gamot ganun (Medicines)
12.
What are the effects of these products to you and what
are your experiences while using this products (Ano ang
nagging epekto ng produktong ito sayo at ano ano ang iyong
nagging karanasan sa paggamit ng ganitong produkto?)
Participant A:Mga naramdaman ko, gumaan ang pakiramdam ko
tsaka mas mura kesa sa gamot. Yun ang karanasan ko yung mga
herbal, oo, sa tingin ko oo naman.meron naman. Anu umayos yung
kalusugan ko, naging magaan tapos naging normal yung BP (blood
pressure) ko. Yun ang tingin ko (I feel light and at the same time its
cheaper than the medicines. For me, my health got better and my
Blood pressure gets normalize)
Participant B: Okay naman. Maganda. Nawawala ang pamamanhid
ng kamay ko tska paa (Its ok. The numbness of my hands amd feet
are gone)
Participant C: eh kase parang gumagaan yung katawan ko, kase pag
nakatake ka nyan para kang dumi ng dumi, ganon (I feels very light.
As well as you release your wastes regulary)
86
13.
In what way does the product/s affect your lifestyle?
(Sa paanong paraan naapektuhan ng mga produktong ito
ang iyong pamumuhay?)
Participant A:ayun nga, mas mura sya, mas nakakatipid ako, mas
abot sa budget ko(Its cheaper, I can afford it)
Participant B:Napakagaan sa pamumuhay kasi mura lang (Its cheap)
Participant C:wala naman (Nothing)
Participant D:affordable ang price pwede mo syang bilhin kahit
sampu-sampu hindi kagaya ng meron silang side effects sa katawan.
Pwede bang mag banggit ng ano diba uminom ako nung propan
good alloy. Kaso minsan ano namamaga parang ano parang
tumataba pero maga na pala yun. Parang maga na manas. Hindi mo
mararamdaman na ano. Lumulobo ka lang pero ano wala kanga no
pero yung mga herbal talagang ramdam mo yan kasi kahit na payat ka
87
A: Oo (Yes)
B: Oo(Yes)
C: Oo(Yes)
D: Oo naman( Of course)
88
89
Participant D: wala lang kasi talagang may ideya na ako kung ano
(Nothing, because I have an idea ever since)
10.
How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas
mong ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
Participant A:depende kasi kapag ano, kapag parati akong
sinisikmura
mga
tatlong
beses,
dalawa
syang
tabletas.
depende naman, kahit, wala naman kasing overdose yun eh, mas
marami daw mas mabisa (It depends, when I have stomach cramps I
take two tablets. It doesnt have overdosage anyway so its ok, they
say that the more take it the more it is effective)
Participant B: ah, once a day ko syang ginagamit. oo regular talaga.
(I use it once a day regularly)
Participant C: once a day. kasi lima silang iniinom ko sabay-sabay
after lunch. Every meal. After meal.( Once a day since I take 5
different tablets all at once after lunch. Every meal. After meal)
Participant D: Halos everyday yun pagginagamit namin.( We use
almost everyday)
92
11.
What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet
etc.) aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim
products to improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong
mga paraan o gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga
produktong may No Approved Therapeutic Claims label
para mapabuti ang iyong kalusugan?)
Participant A:ang, kasi iniinom ko madalas herbal talaga ... talagang
naghahanap ako ng herbal. (I often take herbal. I always find herbals)
Participant B: wala, kasi sa totoo lang ,busy ako sapag ano dito sa
mga anak ko, pito sila, ako lang naghahanap-buhay. (Nothing, honestly
Im busy on my kids since there are seven of them and Im the only
one whos working)
Participant C: ang pagkain ko healthy, vegetables,paminsan minsan
lang ang meat. Usually fish. (Eat healthy food, vegetables, sometimes
meat or usually fish)
Participant D: Wala naman basta itinake lang namin yun. Eh syempre
pagnagkasakit kami gagamutin namin ng talagang advisable ng
Doktor nagpapadoktor kami pero yun nga yung naengganyo kami dun
sa mga Vita Plus na yan so ok naman daw. (Nothing we just take it. Of
course when we got sick we would find ways to cure it. It is more
advisable to go to the doctor. Then we got engaged on vita plus and
found out that its ok)
12.
What are the effects of these products to you and what
are your experiences while using this products (Ano ang
nagging epekto ng produktong ito sayo at ano ano ang iyong
nagging karanasan sa paggamit ng ganitong produkto?)
Participant A:oo, yung sakit ng sikmura ko talaga ano kasi, minsan
naexperience ko na parang dito, yung sobrang sakit, tapos may
nagrecommend sakin na ano, na uminom daw ako ng Ispirulina. tapos
nagtake ako siguro mga 3 weeks, ang naging ano naman sakin nun,
edi pagtapos ko uminom nun ng 3 weeks, sumuka ako ng mga kristal
na galing sa loob ng tiyan.yung parang hindi naman, parang plema na
ang kulay nya transparent? oo, yung parang plema nga na isinuka ko
yun tapos ang sabi ng nagbibigay sakin, yun daw ang epeko ng ano na
parang nililinis yung loob ng katawan ko.hindi naman, parang basta
isinuka ko yun nga yung mga kristal na transparent sabi nung
nagbigay sakin, yun daw ang parang asin ng katawan natin sa loob ng
93
13.
In what way does the product/s affect your lifestyle?
(Sa paanong paraan naapektuhan ng mga produktong ito
ang iyong pamumuhay?)
Participant A:
Participant B: Ang laki ng naiitulong kasi syempre isa pa hindi ka na
nagkakasakit, kesa isaalang alang mo yung kalusugan mo (It helps me
a lot, I dont get sick easily anymore)
Participant C: naging active ako. Naging productive (I became active
and productive)
Participant D: Wala naman kasi matagal na na panahon yun eh
(Nothing, it been a long time)
94
95
oo,
kasi
constipated
ako
eh(Yes
because
Im
96
97
Participant C: yon nga High Blood ako tapos yong Cholesterol kasi
matakaw ako (Because I have High blood and High Cholesterol)
Participant D:
Participant E: syempre nakikita mo naman yong mga kasamang
advertismong kung talaga yong maganda eh. Pero nag-ano, nag-ano
pa nga ko sa hedi high-desert eh, nag ahente pa ko sa high-desert
nun. High desert, high desert na ano mga herbal. Pati sa ano.. sa
marami akong Naging ano sa herbal kase makaktulong talaga.( You
can see it through the advertisements if its good or not. I even
became an agent on Hedi High Desert because I know that herbals can
really help)
Participant F: Wala lang, kasi ako through recommendation lang
kami tulad ng nakikinig lang kami na ito maganda to napapanood sa
t.v ganito to maganda to approve nga food and drugs ano to (Through
recommendation, through some hearsay or via TV. They say that this
approved food and drugs)
98
10.
How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas
mong ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
Participant A: everyday
Participant B: pag nakabili ako tuloy-tuloy pag naubos na at wala ng
pera kape-kape naman yun madalas diyan. ( When I buy it I use it
everyday,when I ran out of stock I just use coffee)
Participant C:
Participant D: May ano siya.. May once a day, may 2x a day, may 3x
a day. yong start ko para maramdaman ko, nagtake ako ng isa sa
umaga, isa sa tanghali, isa sa gabi. Yon para maramdaman ko daw
yong effect.( Usually once a day, twice or thrice, it depends if I feel
strange)
Participant E: ay yong sa kin maintenance. Araw-araw talaga yon.
Kase pag maintenance araw-araw eh. Kaya nga maintenance eh. ( I
use it as maintenance. I use it everyday)
Participant F: Daily.
11.
What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet
etc.) aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim
products to improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong
mga paraan o gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga
produktong may No Approved Therapeutic Claims label
para mapabuti ang iyong kalusugan?)
Participant A: marami akong iniinom na vitamins. para sa stress tska
yan marami silang tinda na vitamins ( I take a lot of vitamins for stress
since a lot of it are being sold everywhere)
Participant B: kakain lang ng mga nirecommend na mga pagkaing
rootcrop ganun (I just eat the recommeneded rootcrops)
Participant C: Eh di sabi ng asawa ko, yong mga bawal, yong mga
matataba ayaw niya akong pakainin. Hindi na ano.. yung dati hindi ko
alam na High Blood ako, suka ako ng suka, nahihilo ako, umiikot yung
paningin ko, yon pala mataas ang cholesterol saka High Blood suka ng
suka buti pala nagpatingin ako yon pala High Blood na. yon nakainom
ako ng ano, gumanda na yong pakiramdam ko. Pero ngayon di ako
masyadong umiinom ng ano para sa Cholesterol, ang ginagawa ko na
lang, nagkakakain palagi ng prutas (My husband told me that I shouldt
eat this and that. Before I dont know that I have a high blood, I
continuously vomit, and feel nauseus, then I found out that I also have
101
12.
What are the effects of these products to you and what
are your experiences while using this products (Ano ang
nagging epekto ng produktong ito sayo at ano ano ang iyong
nagging karanasan sa paggamit ng ganitong produkto?)
Participant A: oo, umaano ako medyo nabawasan timbang ko yung
timbang , kasi maano ako eh, masyado akong mabigat noon eh.
Constipated (Yes. I lose weight, because I was overweight)
Participant B: oo naman nagging masigla yung katawan ko tapos
nawala yung pagkakamakalimutin ko. ( Yes. I became active then I am
not that forgetful anymore)
Participant C: Kaya nga di ba ngayon umiinom pala ako ngayon ng
ano ng Pharex yong B1 B2, yong ano ba yon, ah pang ano ba yon
Vitamins, Vitamins yon di ba, para sa ano, yong mga napapanood ko
sa TV pag ano, yong mga pamamanhid. Parang pakiramdam ko ano
eh kasi yong ibang ano, yong ibang mga ka-age ko, yong iba nga
mga 40 plus lang tignan mo mukhang matanda na sila saka mahina,
eto pakiramdam ko so wow! Kasi ano iba na rin naman na sa edad ko
102
ngayong mga 62 mas medyo, medyo maano na rin ako, yong mga
dati kong ginagawa hindi ko na ginagawa, dati mahilig akong
magballroom, pero ngayon hindi na masyado. ( I take that B1 B2
Vitamins, for numbness. It feels like when someone is on my age even
on the 40s they look like weak and old but here I am at the age of 62
is still feel strong
Participant D: Oo kase yong tinitake ko, ganun din talaga Over-price
kaya lang sayo syempre as a person, di ba, Kailangan maramdaman
mo yong effect nong ginagamit mo. Kase ang hirap kapag bili ka ng
bili, mahal. Parang iyaano mo lang yong sarili mo sa gastos na wala ka
namang benefit. Yon ang pinakaano ko. Kinakailangan pag bumili ka
ng ano, may benefit. (Yes. Because the one that Ive been taking is
over price, of course as a person, you need to feel that the product
that youve using creates a change or an effect to you. Its difficult if
you keep on buying expensive medicines that has no effect for you.
Thats my opinion, you need to buy something that has benefit to you)
Participant E: hindi pa naman tapos eh. Tuloy tuloy pang gumagamit.
oo. Tulad nong sa aking ano yong sa cholesterol ko. Namemaintain
ko yong aking cholesterol. Mababa.Basta nakakatulong. Maganda ang
naging epekto sa katawan ko. (Im still using the product till now for
my cholesterol. I can now maintain my cholesterol level, it really helps
me. It has good effect on me
Participant F: Oo.Ayun nawawala ang mga dati naming
nararamdaman na hindi normal sa isang tao uhmmm... uncomfortable
ka, kapag natake mo na yung medicine na yun mapapansin mo
magaan na mawawala na yung problema mo.. pati pagtulog mo
pagkain mo kasi yung tao kung may sakit yan ang unang naapektuhan
pagkain at pagtulog kasi yung tao hindi na makakain pag ang tao...
magana kawala ng... highblood na lang ang katapat katatakutan mo
nun. Ah ayun nga syempre kaya ginagamit mo siya as maintenance
mo kasi nakakaramdam ka ng kaginhawaan mo diba. ( Yes. I dont feel
strange or sick or uncomfortable. If you take the medicine you will light
and active. Even when you sleep or eat, because usually if people are
sick thats the first thing that will be affected, eating and sleeping. So
if you take that as your maintenance you will relieved and healthy)
13.
In what way does the product/s affect your lifestyle?
(Sa paanong paraan naapektuhan ng mga produktong ito
ang iyong pamumuhay?)
103
namin. (It has a positive effect on me, since I got better now. Even if
you have a lot of money but still your immune system is weak, its
useless so might as well be on the side that even if you dont have
money at least your healthy)
know that it can really cure you, you have nothing to lose anyway if
you take it)
Participant C: ok naman sya maganda naman ok naman sya mas
maganda nga un kaysa sa mga antibiotic tapos ano rin naman yan
nakakatulong talaga yan, wala syang mga chemical na ano kundi mga
herbal talaga yan (Its ok, I think its much better than antibiotic, then
it can really help since it has no chemicals just herbal)
Participant D: Ah meron namang commercial na hindi nagclick pero
yung mga kinocommercial na ano ok naman siya epektib siya. (There
are commercials that doesnt click however for the others its ok, its
effective)
Participant E: ok lang nakaka engganyo sa mga hindi nakakaalam
kung paano gamitin ok lang na may mag advertisement (Its ok and
entertaining, for those who doesnt know how to use it, its ok to have
an advertisement)
Participant F:Ayos naman kaya sinusubukan ko lahat ng mga nakikita
ko sa commercial eh pero hindi agad ko hinihinto kung minsan
nakakaubos ako ng isang box ganon. (Its good, actually I tried all that
I see on commercial but I dont stop on using it eventually, I just empty
at least one box)
Participant G:
110
114
matagal nako gumagamit niyan (Yes because its good for the health
and body, since the tea can cleanse your urination since I have UTI)
Participant B:ayy hindi na ayyy kaya ko lang naman sya ginamit kasi
ano kasi inisip ko lang din sa dealer na inaano mo rin yun na.. para
bang ano.. ginamit mo. oo kasi meron akong naramdaman kasi dati
yung uminom ako noon nawala pero wala rin naman akong
naramdaman na side effects.. (I only use because of the dealer, since I
feel something before, then after I took it, its also gone and I dont
feel any side effects either)
Participant C:Di ko ganung inaano, paarang..parang nung naka-4
years naako, anglaki ng inimprove ng katawanko. Kasi tumaba ako
nun. Hindi payat lang ako nun, tapos parang wala akong ganang ano
(kumain)tapos, a month din bago naimprove yung katawan naming.
Tumaba ako, Siguromgamagwa 1 year na.unti-unti lang. ( I took it for
over 4 years and it has a huge effect on my body. I gain weight
eversince because before Im skinny and I dont have any appetite at
all, then after a month when I noticed the improvement)
Participant D:
Participant E: ahh.. mas maganda kung tuloy-tuloy. Pero kung tuloytuloy. ( Its good if you take regularly)
testify that this product can really cure diseases like diabetese even
colds)
Participant C:Kasi yung kasama sa trabaho ng anak ko, sabi niya yun
daw, yung hindi siya nag tetake ng taheebo payat siya. Tapos ng maka
a year na siya, gumanda na yung katawan niya. Kaya nagtry din ako.
(My sons co worker told me that before he is just thin but after he took
taheebo his body went well)
Participant D:Aah. Kasi diba aattend kang seminar ganun ganito
ganun. Syempre ipapaliwanag nila, parang naniwala ka. Yan bumili ako
ng DXN. Yung mga gamot gamot, yung mga capsule. Tapos may kape
na sya. Yun, kape at tsaka yung capsule. ( Through seminars, of course
they will explain it and you will believe. I bought DXN capsule, teas and
coffee)
Participant E: yong isa ding kamag-anak ko na naging miyembro
dun. (My relative become a member of it)
117
118
10.
How often do you use the products? (Gaano kadalas
mong ginagamit ang mga poduktong ito?)
Participant A:Once a day yun tas yung tsaa ko un ung pinakaano ko.
Pero ngayon di na masyado. (Once a day)
Participant B:ayyy ano na yun kasi may ubo na kasi ako dati eh.
Ano daily mula umaga tapos hapon. ( Daily, twice a day)
Participant C:Everyday yung tea.Everyday din, Once a day lang kasi
yun eh. Yung tea kasi pag kagising mo nang umaga, yun yung pinag
kakape ko. (Everyday, once a day)
Participant D:Yung dati, araw-araw umiinom (Everyday)
119
11.
What are your other practices (eg. Exercise, diet
etc.) aside from taking No Approved Therapeutic Claim
products to improve your health condition? (Ano pa iyong
mga paraan o gawain bukod sa paggamit ng mga
produktong may No Approved Therapeutic Claims label
para mapabuti ang iyong kalusugan?)
Participant A:Nag wawater therapy ako eh tapos exercise tska fruits
kasama fruits.may iniinom ako yung sambong, dahon ng sambong.
(Water theraphy and exercise as well as fruits and sambong leaves)
Participant B:nag e-exercise. (Exercise)
Participant C:Wala naman.Oo yun lang, lakad lakad lang. (Nothing,
just walking)
Participant D:Maintenance sa highblood. Kaya yun, parang
nakakatulong din yung sa..kasi yung paliwanag sa paseminar seminar
na gamot sa ganito, gamot sa ganun, kahit na umiinom ka ng gamot
sa doktor, iinom ka rin nito para makatulong. Kaya yun, ginawa ko.Yun
lang. Pero kung ako ang tatanungin, gusto ko merong ganun. Kasi
bukod dun sa iniinom mo na mga maintenance ng doktor na nirereseta
sayo, mas parang nakakatulong sakin kasi sa..yung dugo ko
nagnonormal. Kasi nung di pa ko nag-iinom ng mga food supplement
yung dugo ko palaging..kahit may maintenance, hindi sya ganun
kababa, mataas. (Maintenance for high blood, because it was
explained in the seminar that this is a cure for this and that kind of
illness, even if you take prescribed medicine you should also take this
product since it can help you. Thats what I do, and it really do helped
me)
Participant E:oo. Yong mga pinagdaanan ko sa seminar, ano yong
mga pagkain, iniinom natin sa araw-araw, tandaan mo lang kung
hanggat maaari iwasan mo. Oo, yong mga juice, mga softdrinks, kung
anu-anong mga de-bote diyan, mga de-lata, nagtataglay yan ng mga
mataas na mga uric acid. Ang mainam, bumili ka ng mga prutas at yon
ang ijujuice mo araw-araw. Yon ang tumutulong pampaganda ng
katawan. Kase ang sakit nakukuha natin sa araw-araw nating kinakain.
Hindi alam kung papano ba magbabalance diet. Hindi pwedeng puro
120
13.
In what way does the product/s affect your lifestyle?
(Sa paanong paraan naapektuhan ng mga produktong ito
ang iyong pamumuhay?)
Participant A:Sa pag inom ko ok lang naman kasi basta ininom ko
lang siya, sa budget naman, wala naman, anak ko naman ang bumibili
(When I take it, its ok, in terms of budget, my son is the one who buys
it for me)
Participant B:ahhh sa pamumuhay namen ano medyo kasi
nakadagdag, nakatulong din yun sa ano eh.. yung expenses namen
kasi tumutulong din talaga. Saka ano pag maliit lang yung ano ng
isang tao meron ka ng incentives ( It helps yes, but it also adds on
your expenses)
Participant C: Ok lang naman, ok lang..( Its ok)
Participant D: Wala naman dahil nakatulong din naman sya sa akin.
(Nothing since it really helps me)
Participant E: ah kung talagang wala kang inaasahang income,
apektado talaga kase sa produktong food supplement, mahal yan.
Apektado. So ang taong gumagamit ng food supplement ( If theres no
one you can lean on about the income, it really affects me since food
supplements are expensive)
QUESTIONS
BARANGAY 1
COMMONWEALT
H (6)
BARANGAY
2
BATASAN
(11)
SUMMARY
ANALYSIS
PER
BARANGAY
BARANGAY 3
FAIRVIEW
(4)
BARANGAY 4
HOLY SPIRIT
(6)
122
BARANG
LUZON
(7)
1.Are you
familiar with
the No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claim label?
(Pamilyar ka ba
sa label na No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claims?)
2.Where
have
you
encountered
these kinds of
products?(Saan
ninyo
nakikita
itong
mga
produktong ito?)
All the
participants
are familiar
with the said
label.
Six (6) o
seven (
particip
familiar
the labe
-On T.V
Commercials
-On T.V
commercial
s
-Drug stores
-On T.V
Commercials
-Malls (evergotesco)
-On T.V
comme
-Malls (e
gotesco
3. What is your
idea/perception
about the label
No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claims Label?
(Ano ang iyong
ideya o pananaw
tungkol label na
No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claim?)
-Not
approved
by BFAD
-it does
indicate
can cure
specific
4. Does your
current medical
condition
require you to
purchase and
use these kinds
-yes
-Not
intended to
cure a
disease
-yes
-contains
small amount
of chemicals
-Not effective
-yes
-yes
-yes
123
of products?(Sa
kalagayan ng
kalusugan mo
ngayon,
nangangailangan
ka pa bang bumili
at gumamit ng
mga ganitong
produkto?)
5.
What -family members
influences you
to
purchase -friends
these products
with
No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claims label?
(Ano ang mga
nakaimpluwensya
sa iyo na bumili
ng mga produkto
na
may
No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claim na label?)
6. What can you
say about the
advertisement
of products
with No
Approved
Therapeutic
Claim label?
(Ano ang iyong
masasabi sa mga
patalastas ng
mga produkto na
may No
Approved
All
of
the
participants were
favored to the
advertisements
for the labeled
products
priory
to convince other
consumers to try
the product.
Advertisem
ents
-Friends
-Prescribed by
doctor
-Testimonies
-Dealers of
networking
company
-Family
members
-family
advertisements
-Testimonies
from the users -Seminars
of the product attended (on
networking
-Dealers of
company)
networking
company
-They purchase
because of
their medical
condition
-They
-They do
promote the commercials
products
through
people
-Dont
(networking)
believe
immediatel - Its good
y on the
advertisem
ents
because
some of
them have
false claims
Advertis
-Semina
attende
network
compan
-Dealers
network
compan
-Its good
-Its goo
-They use
influential
people in their
advertisements
such as famous
celebrities and
etc. to
encourage
people to buy
-Its effe
-I dont believe
in their
124
Therapeutic
Claim na label?)
commercials
-It was just a
pyramid
scheme
-testimonies
on
commercial
s
encourages
me to buy
-It encourages
people to use
the products
-Some are not
affected by it
because they
already used
the product
even without
advertisement
being seen.
- It encourages
people to use
the products
because of the
testimonies
they show
-Encour
the peo
use the
-Im fond of it
bec. It gives
solutions to my
problems
-It didnt affect
my buying
decision
Participants
started
using the
products on
the range of
7 years- 20
years ago.
Participants
started using
the products
on the range
of 5 months- 2
years ago.
Participants
started using
the products on
the range of 5
months- 2
years ago.
Particip
started
the prod
the rang
months
years ag
-Drugstores
-Drugstores
-Drugstores
-Drug S
-On the
-Dealers of a
-Malls (S
125
mo nabibili itong
mga produktong
ito?)
networking
company
main outlet
of the
suppliers
networking
company
-On the main
outlet of the
suppliers
-Daily
outlet of the
suppliers
(novaliches,
ortigas
-Daily
-Daily
-Daily
-Depends on
the budget
-Exercising
-Exercising
-some only
use the
products
when they are
not feeling
well.
-Proper diet
-Proper diet
-Proper diet
-Taking
medicines
Ever-Go
-On the
outlet o
supplier
(Makati
ortigas,
Muntinl
-Daily
-Exercising
-Exercis
-Proper diet
-Proper
-Taking other
vitamins
-Taking
vitamin
126
-Exercising
-Exercising
-Proper diet
-Proper diet
-Normalizes my
blood pressure
-Proper diet
-Exercising
-Exercis
-Proper diet
-Proper
-Taking other
vitamins
-Taking
vitamin
-It boost my
immune
system
-My health
condition have
been improved
-I became
active and
healthy
-When I
take the
product
became
again
-Taking
medicines
-Stabilize uric
acid
-Lost numbness
on my hands and
feet
-Having a normal
bowel movement
-I feel better and
energetic
-It feels
okay, but it
has side
effects.
-My disease
is cured by
this product
-Its not
effective
-I experience
cleansing
through
vomiting
crystals that
looks like a
phlegm.
127
produkto?)
13. In what way
does
the
product/s affect
your
lifestyle?
(Sa
paanong
paraan
naapektuhan ng
mga produktong
ito
ang
iyong
pamumuhay?)
-I feel better
thats why it
boost my
confidence and
become lively.
-It helps me to
achieve a
healthy living in
a cheapest way
-it helps me
to achieve a
healthy
living in a
cheapest
way
-It helps
prevent
diseases
-I became
active and
productive.
-It only
increases my
expenses
because the
supplements
are very
expensive.
-It
doesnt
affect me in
any way
128
-it didn
my lifes
-the pro
are exp
129
And also the researchers noticed that even if they know the real meaning of
the No Approved Therapeutic Claim label they still use the product as a drug
substitute
130
CHAPTER V:
RECOMMENDATIONS
1. As part of selling, advertisements were used in promoting the products.
Food supplements advertisements commonly show testimonies regarding the
effectiveness and other attracting details about the product for them to
make a sale.
But we noticed that some of these advertisements contain false claims such
as claiming that their products can cure specific diseases such as cancer,
hypertension, diabetes and many more; but these products are not allowed
because food/dietary supplements are not scientifically proven to treat
diseases.
The said activities obviously violates the Consumer Protection Act (Book 2,
Article 5, Section 2a) which states that: No claim in advertisements,
promotion and sponsorship, and other marketing activities shall be made
other than those contained in the approved label or packaging of the health
product, or as duly approved by FDA;
The researchers recommend that CFDR (under FDA) must pre-screen the
advertisements before submitting to Advertisement Standard Council (ASC),
to protect the consumers from the dissemination of false information.
FDA should have a strict regulation on the limitations of the food
supplements before you make advertisement to prevent misconception
about what the product. The ff. are the misconceptions encountered:
Article 123; a). The said amount is too small for big businesses, for the DTI
and/or DOH, to increase the responsibility and penalties of those who violate.
132
APPENDICES
133
APPENDICE A:
BIBLIOGRAPHY
134
BOOKS
Foreign
1. Autio, Brown, Frazier,Garrity, Nunn,Cheng, Nowakowski. (1993). The
New prescription drug reference guide (p. 7,22). United states of
america: Publications international
2. Beers, Fletcher, Jones, & Porter. (2003). Merck Manual of Medical
Information. United states of america: Merck and Co Inc.
3. Brown, J. (2005). Nutrition Now (5th ed., pp. 24-3,24-5,24-6).
4. Craig, C., & Stitzel, R. (1990). Modern Pharmacology (3rd ed., p. 3).
United states of america: Craig and Stitzel.
5. Creighton. (1975). Health education encounter. Sydney: The Jacaranda
Press
6. Edmunds, M. (2009). Introduction to clinical pharmacology (p.
20,56,58,59). Singapore: Elsevier Inc.
7. Gauwitz, D. (2011). Administering medications.
8. Hamilton, Whitney, & Sizer. (n.d.). Nutrition concepts and
controversies (4th ed., p. 344,372,373,379,).
9. Halligan, P., & Alyward, M. (n.d.). The Power of Belief: Psychosocial
Influences on Illness, disability, and medicine. United states of america:
Oxford University Press.
10.
Karch, A., Williams, L., & Wilkins. (n.d.). Focus on Nursing
Pharmacology (4th ed.).
11.
Ksir, Hart, Ray, C. (2006). Drugs, society and human behavior.
New York: McGraw Hill Companies.
12.
Merki. (1996). Teen Health. United states of america: Visual
Education Corporation.
13.
Prentice, W. (2009). Get Fit, Stay Fit (5th ed., p. 211, 212,214).
New york: McGraw-Hill
14.
Robinson III, J., & McCormick, D. (2005). Essentials of Health and
Wellness. United states of america: Thomson Learning.
15.
Roizen, M., & Mehmet, C. (2006). YOU The Smart Patient.
16.
Steroids Supplements Body Building (p. 64). (1998). Cyrus
Publishing.
135
17.
Thompson, Manore, M., & Vaughan, L. (n.d.). The Science of
Nutrition (p. 7)
18.
Trease, & Evans. (2002). Pharmacognosy (p. 499,450). Elvisier
Inc.
19.
Williams, S. (2005). Essentials of Health Services (3rd ed., p.
127,128). United states of america: Thopmphson pelmer Learning.
Local
1. Naciano, H. (2010). Sales Promotion Principles and Best Procedures.
Pasig city, Philippines: Anvil Publishing.
2. Perez, Luna, Tomas, Clemente Ed.D. (2005) MAPEH IV (p.31). Quezon
City, Philippines: St. Bernadette Publications, Inc.
Journals
1. Firenzouli, & Gori. (2007). Evidence Based Complementary and
Alternative Medicine. Herbal Medicine Today:Clinical and Research
Issues, 4, 37-40.
2. Rose, J., Geers, A., Fowler, S., & Rasinski, H. (2014). Choice Making,
Expectations, and Treatment Positivity. Journal of Behavioral Decision
Making, 27(1), 1-9.
136
APPENDICE B:
LIST OF
PARTICIPANTS
137
Natividad Borbon
#10 Kagitingan St. Batasan Hills, Quezon City
09201327159
Purisima Patriarca
#19 Antillery Rd. Brgy. Holy Spirit, Quezon City
09217863003
Gina De Celis
#30 San Simon Brgy. Holy Spirit, Quezon City
09283866592
Gisela Echano
#84 Samonte Interior Brgy. Holy Spirit, Diliman, Quezon City
09206467983
Ellen De Castro
#21 Samonte St. Brgy. Holy Spirit, Diliman, Quezon City
Feliciano Moncog
#325 Sta. Catalina Brgy. Holy Spirit, Quezon City
09279957564
Reynaldo Pascual
#30 BF Road Brgy. Holy Spirit, Quezon City
09474006837
Jean Morados
#2538 San Pedro St. Brgy. Commonwealth, Quezon City
09397817903
Irma Nava
#252 Kasunduan Extension, Commonwealth, Quezon City
09079664889
Nenita Marquez
#287 Don Fabian St. Brgy. Commonwealth, Quezon City
138
Imelda Japones
#300 Ecols St. Brgy. Commonwealth, Quezon City
09296071422
Elizabeth Sevilla
#688 Grape St. Brgy. Commonwealth, Quezon City
09323347251
Maricor Marquez
#14 Riverside St. Unit 4, Commonwealth, Quezon City
09195237601
Amelia de Torres
Dirhan St. North Fairview, Quezon City
Amelia.abes@yahoo.com
Marilyn Alon
Drachma St. North Fairview, Quezon City
Vilma Abilong
#32 Yakal Sapamanai, Quezon City
09336262793
Teresita David
#53 Regalado Extension Fairview Park, Quezon City
264-3221
Eriberta Seguirel
#74 Kalayaan B. Batasan Hills, Quezon City
09091270430
Gloria Remedillo
#74 Kalayaan B. Batasan Hills, Quezon City
Marcela Haboc
B15 Lot23 Sugartowne Subd. Batasan Hills, Quezon City
263-2081 / 09299569478
Florante Andas
139
Norma Rolida
Ally Tree Lower Everlasting, Payatas A, Quezon City
Melanie Luzentales
#004 Palmera St. Lower Everlasting Payatas, Quezon City
09078947590
Antonia Bello
Phase3 Blk7 Payatas, Quezon City
09324747630
Hanita Sanaco
#032 Lower Everlasting Payatas A. Quezon City
Reynaldo Bravo
Lot7 Blk18 Donya Nicasia Subd. Quezon City
Gina Baseirto
5 Jasmin St. Payatas A, Quezon City
Rosalina Gonzales
#40B Mapangakit St. Pinyahan, Quezon City
09466232254
Pearlita Antiquen
Blk8 Lot3 Area 1 Sammar St. Luzon Ave. Old Balara, Quezon City
09435246082
Alicia Fampo
#94 Macopa St. Purok 2 Luzon Ave. Culiat, Quezon City
Marconi Belarmino
Blk8 Lot3 Area 1 Sammar Luzon Ave. Old Balara, Quezon City
994-8560
Rodolfo Reyes
#33C Aurigue Drive Tandang Sora, Quezon City
09108756252 / 09982067064
Zenaida Valique
#38 Villarca Proj. 8, Quezon City
140
09215901701
Luzviminda Bonon
#251 Calderon St. Old Balara, Quezon City
09155345712
Lorna Marcos
#254 San Rafael St. Old Balara, Quezon City
Andy Sitjar
Zone 1 #11 Visayan Hills, Old Balara, Quezon City
09087664559
Nora Caldito
#036 Pugong Ginto Brgy. Santa Monica, Novaliches, Quezon City
09289658554
Teresita Caldito
Pugong Ginto Santa Monica, NOvaliches, Quezon City
09073913719
Alice Reas
2016 Sitio San Roque, Sangandaan, Quezon City
09425830580
Nemesia Sillezesa
2016-45 Sitio San Roque, Sangandaan, Quezon City
09067137330
Zabaria Fe
#14 Woodpecker St. Zabarte Subd. Brgy. Kaligayahan, Quezon City
09109385530
141
APPENDICE C:
142
LETTERS
146
147
APPENDICE D:
MATERIALS
Address:____________________________________________________
Contact no.: _______________________
Age: _____________
Gender: ___Male ____ Female
Civil Status: ___single ___married ___widowed
Employment Status: ____Employed ___ Unemployed ___Self-employed
Medical Condition: _____________________________________________
What particular product do you use?______________________________
How long have you been using the products?________________
Do you use the products regularly? ____yes ____no
Informed Consent
of
________________________________________________________________________
___________________after having been explained of the purpose of the
149
150
APPENDICE E:
TIMETABLE
TIMETABLE
June
-
July
151
Construction of Chapter 1
Presentation of Chapter 1
Changing of Title/Topic ( Safe Consumers: The Risk of taking No
Approved Therapeutic Claim Drugs in the Market)
Construction of Chapter 1
Presentation of Chapter 1
August
-
Construction of Chapter 2
Gathering of all Literatures and Studies
September
-
Revision of Chapter 2
Changing of Title (Drug Substitute: The Risk of taking No Approve
Therapeutic Claim Drugs in the Market)
Construction of Chapter 3 and Questionnaires
October
-
December
-
January
-
February
-
March
-
Final Defense
Final Revisions
152
Copyright
HardBound
153
APPENDICE F:
CURICCULUM
VITAE
154