Kiran's Thoughts PDF

9/20/2016
Kiran'sThoughts..AsIs:IfIndiahastohitterrorfactoriesinPakistan,bereadyforawarwithChina!
IfIndiahastohitterrorfactoriesinPakistan,bereadyforawarwithChina!
Like 6.5kpeoplelikethis.SignUptoseewhatyourfriendslike.
Itisabout32hourssincetheattackonUriarmycampinIndia,byPakistaniterrorists.
ThereistremendousamountofangerinIndia,specificallyinthesectionsofsocietywhichI
normallydon'tseeoverreactonsocialmedia.
Thiswasthefrontpageofpaperatmyhome"Wehavehadenough!"
FrontpageofNewIndianXpress,thedayafterUriAttack
TheoverwhelmingmajorityarescreamingDearPrimeMinister..dosomething.do
quickly..
That"do"canbefullfledgedwar.
Itcanbeeconomicblockade.
ItcanbewaterstoppageforSindhuandfiveriversofPunjabgoingintoPakistan.
ItcanbesurgicalstrikesinsidePakistanlikeIndiadidinsideMyanmarlastyear.
Itcanbeasmanyasthereareopinionsonsocialmedia,papersandTV.
Butthebigquestionis..CanIndiaattackPakistanthisweek?
1.Iamsurethereismilitarywillpower.
2.Iamsuretherewouldbeenoughpoliticalwillpower.
3.IamsureIndiahasplentyoffinancialcushiontodothis.(Pakistan'sGDPissmaller
thanjustonestate'sinIndiaMaharashtra)
4.Iamsureinternallytherewon'tbemuchoppositiontoIndiaforasmallscalesurgical
strike.
Butstill..69yearsofhandlingofJammuandKashmirbyIndiaissomethingwehavetolook
atrightnow.CanIndiaaffordtohitPakistanwhereithurtsthemost,forPakistan's
obsessionwithJihaditerrorexportallthesedecades?
http://kiranasis.blogspot.in/2016/09/ifindiahastohitterrorfactoriesin.html
1/22
9/20/2016
WhileIwaslookingforsomepragmaticanswers,amidstveryloudwarcriesthatIseein
press,TVandsocialmedia,Ihappenedtoseethistweetset.Averythoughtfulsetof
tweetsbytheuser@vadakkus.Fromhereonward,Iammerelyreproducingthefantastic
probinganalysisdoneby@vadakkus,withverylittleinfofrommyside.Readitfullyand
thencommentonwhatIndiangovernmentcando,shoulddo,andmostimportantly,whento
do.VadakkusstartsoffatweetstormontheentirePakistanIndiafiasco.Thereismore
thanwhatmeetstheeyehere.AndissueisNOTKashmir.Italsodoesnotlooklike
anythingtodowithIslam,Separatism,HumanRights,Army,AFSPA,Track2negotiation
andmanyotherthingswehearonTV.
Itismustdeeperthanthat..Geopolitics!
WhyisPakistanobsessedwithKashmir?IhavealwayswonderedwhatmakesKashmir
soattractivetoPakistan,thattheyarewillingtokeeptheissueburningforever.WhatIS
there?
{PremShekhar,awellknownKannadacolumnistinformedafewweeksthatPakistanhad
evenofferedtogiveupEastPakistanin1950s,inreturnforJammuandKashmironthe
sidelinesofofficialdiscussionswithIndia!SodefinitelyitisnotreligionorKashmiris..itis
muchdeeperthanthat.Itwaswatersourcesthen,butnowmuchmoredeeper...}
WhyisIndiasoreluctanttohitbackatPakistan?AlsowhydoesIndiaalwaysseemto
beunabletoretaliatetoPakistaninkind(itshould,totally)andpussyfootsaroundPakistan,
despitealltheatrocitiesitcommitsinIndiafromdailyincursionsinKashmirtotheMumbai
attacks.Theyspendtoomuchmoneyonallthisandthecountry,despitenovisible
revenuegeneratingindustry(terrorismnorevenue)hasmanagedtosurviveuntiltoday,
developnukesandhassomuchinternationalclout?Wheredoesitgetitsmoneyfrom?
Why??WhyisIndiareluctanttostrike?Theremustbereasons.
Yes,waterisanissue.TheIndusanditstributaries.Butwheredotheygetmoneytokeep
theissuealive?Thereismoretothisthanwater.Today,someonetoldmeaboutthisthing
andIwasstumpedabouthowbloodyobviousthisis,andeventhen,NOBODYinIndiatalks
aboutthis!
ItisChina...stupid..ItisChinaandCPEC:The"thing"istheCPEC:ChinaPakistan
EconomicCorridor.Ifyoulookatitcloselysuddenlyeverythingfallsintoplace.Kashmir,
Balochistan,India'sunwillingnesstostrike,silenceofinternationalcommunity,everything
else.Pakistanisjustafront.
Therealsponsorishidingbehind.
MaybeitisbecauseIndianmethodofviewingeverythinginblack&white.Pakistan
sponsorsterrorismtogetKashmir.Itisnotthatsimple.PakistankepttheKashmirflame
burninguntilthe1990stomeettheirends,whenChinaconceivedtheCPECanddecidedto
2/22
9/20/2016
takeover.AbitontheCPECasnooneseemstohaveheardaboutit.Chinahasahuge
geographichandicap:noaccesstosouthernworldoceans.
SoChineseshipmentsfromEurope,MiddleEast,Africahavetotravelallthewayaround
India,MalaccaandASEAN.Chinahasseriousproblemswithmostcountriesinthatregion
duetoitsaggressivemilitaryposture.
CPECNeed.SourceTwitter.PleaseexcusesinceJ&KmapisnotasperIndia'sstandards.
WhyPakistanissoimportantforChineseeconomy?WhatifChinacouldgetaroute
throughPakistantoaccesstheArabianSea?Thatlineinblue.Lookatit,somuchdistance,
moneysaved!That,istheCPEC.AcorridorofhighwaysandrailwayswillrunfromKashgar
inChinatoGwadarinPakistan(Baluchistan)ontheArabianseanearIranborder.AndALL
theinfrastructureandassociatedstuffforCPECwillbeconstructedforPakistanbyChina,
freeorcostorfornegligibleloans.
WhatisCPEC?FourSixlaneExpresswaysfromnorthtosouthPakistan,fourdifferent
routes.Allmainrailwaylinesbeingupgradedto160kphdouble.Asixtoeightlanesuper
expresswayKarachitoGwadarandHyderabadInnumerablecoal,thermal,solarandhydro
powerplantsallacrossPakistan.AllofGwadar,includingamegainternationalairport!Then
Hospitals,schools,colleges,techinstitutes,evenaMetrolineinLahore!
Andofcourse,thecapstone:reconstructionoftheKarakoramhighwaytosixtofourlanes.
Allprojectslistedhere.Click,zoomandread.
3/22
9/20/2016
CPECMap.SourceTwitter.PleaseexcusesinceJ&KmapisnotasperIndia'sstandards.
ButwhyisJammuandKashmirinvolvedhere?Now,ontheKarakoramhighway,thisis
whereitmattersmostforIndia.ItconnectsChinaandPakistan,thoughIndia!Through
JammuandKashmir,whichlegallyaccededtoIndiain1947October.Thisisaroutemapof
theKarakoramhighway(grey).Lookatthetop,insidetheredcircle.ItisGilgitBaltistan
areaofJammuandKashmirstate,whichlegallybelongstoIndia,butillegallyoccupiedby
Pakistan.Keepinmind,Chinaalsooccupiesillegallytheeasternandnorthernpartof
JammuandKashmirShaksgamvalley(giftedbyPakistanin1960s)andAksaiChin
(occupiedbyChinain1950swhenitannexedTibet).
Karakoramhighwaylocation.MapfromWiki.NotperIndia'sJ&Kmapstandards.
4/22
9/20/2016
ThehighwaypassesthroughGilgitBaltistan,PakistanOccupiedKashmir.Theredlineis
theLOC.PakistanandChinaareconnectedthroughPakistanOccupiedKashmir(PoKfor
short).PakistancallsthisGilgitBaltistanareaofJammuandKashmir,asNorthern
Territoriessometimes.
MoreonKarakoramhighway:Soontobea4/6lanehighwaythroughsomeoftheworld's
toughestterrain.AhighcapacityhighwayacrosstheHimalayas!
Now,thoughtheCPECisarecentthing,theideahadtakenbirthlongback.TheKarakoram
highwaystartedbuildingin1959,openedin1979!PossiblyPakistanhadrefusedChina
accesstoGwadarthenastheycould.Butnowtheyhavenootherchoicebuthandoverto
China.
WhyCPEC?OIL:Gwadarisjust400kmawayfromMuscatand500fromtheStraitof
HormuzthroughwhichallGulfoilpasses.12hoursatsea!ProximitytoAfrica:China
virtuallyownsmuchofAfricatoday.Billionsininvestment,buysnaturalresources.Nothing
betterthanthis.Pakistanasamarket:ChinawillfloodPakistanandGulfwithitscheap
productsandmakeawindfalltheretoo.ProximitytonewfriendSriLanka.IfUSA/UK(control
MalaccastraitSingapore)orIndiainIndianoceandecidetochokeit,Chinawillhaveno
problemasithasCPEC.
But,allofCPECandChina'sambitionsbearingfruitdependsontheKarakoramhighway.
ThatdependsonPoKcontinuedtobeoccupiedbyPakistan.
MoneyInvolved:WiththeCPEC,Chinahassunkcloseto50BILLIONDollarsinPakistan.
Ofcourse,ChinagetsfreeaccesstoallthisinfrastructureinPakistan.Withthis,20%of
Pakistan'sGDPisnowChinese.ChinahasPakistannowfirmlybytheb***s,somuchso
thatPakistancannowbeChina's24thprovince.Withsomuchinvestedandatstake,China
wouldn'teventhinktwiceaboutruthlesslysuppressinganyattackonPakistan,because
theyownitnow.
Doesn'tIndiaknowallthis?OfcourseIndiaknowsallthis.IfweweretoattackPakistan,
wewouldhavetodealwithChina.Pakistanissmallfry.Chinaisnot.
WhowouldsidewithIndia?Mostlynobody.Why?BecauseChinaisinvolved.How
internationalgeopoliticswork,mostdon'tgetthateither.USAwantstosupportusbecause
Chinamakesitnervous.ButUScorporationsareoverinvestedinChina,soUncleSamwill
looktheotherway.RussiaDon'teventhinkaboutit.Putinhasenoughtroublesathome,
andIndia'spanderingtoObamahasn'tgothimamused.Europewillsitjustandwatch
(becauseChina),andalloftheMiddleEastwill(clandestinely)supportPakistanforobvious
reasons(Islam).
Peoplethinkalliancesbetweencountriesareforgetlikehighschoolfriendshipson
emotionalgroundsofsomesortNo.Notatall.Internationalfriendshipsarealwaysbased
on"howcanIbenefitbyallying","whatterriblecanthisguydotomeifIdon'tally".
So,IndiawillleftoutcoldifitweretoasmuchastouchPakistan.Wewillmostlyhaveto
takeonBOTHPakistanandChina.Mostly.CanIndiatakeonbothPakistanandChina
alone?Fromtwo(orthree)flanks?WearesurroundedbyChina'sfriends.Whatdowedo?
Dunno.
AbitmoreontheKarakoramhighway:1962,remember?WhatiftheChineseweretesting
theIndianwatersbeforebuildingthehighway?Chinacould'vewalkedthroughIndia.Still,
theywithdrew.TheywereonlytestingIndia'sresolvetodefendPoKifitcametothat.We
haveallbutwrittenoffPoK.AllWikipediaarticlestellallofPoKas"Pakistan".NotPakistan
administered",butPakistan.Hurts:(
HereistheKhunjerabPass(PoK):the"top"ofIndia,theborderbetweenIndiaandChina,
5/22
9/20/2016
butnowPakistan.
AsigninPakistanOccupiedKashmirSourceTwitter
HereistheKarakoramhighwaynearGilgitinIndia(PoK)andunderconstructionsomewhere
inthemountains.ItshouldbeobviousbynowthatChinadoesNOTwantIndiatoreclaimits
landlosttoPakistanin1947and1948thestrategicKarakoramrangesinGilgitBaltistan
areaofJammuandKashmir.Itisassimplyasthat!
KarakoramHighwayinPoKpartofJammuandKashmirstate.PicsTwitter
HereistheentiremapoftheKarakoramHighwayfromKashgartoRawalpindi.Lookwhere
allitpassesthrough.
6/22
9/20/2016
Karakoramhighwaymap.SourceTwitter
ChinaownsPakistanformostparttoday:CPECandallassociatedstuffarecalled
"ChinaPakistanFriendship"somethingortheother.Nofriendshipthere.JustChinese
business.ChinaisnotdoingbusinesswithPakistan.ItisrunningitsbusinessinPakistan.
ItisrunningPakistan.Chinapaysforprotection.Ifthingsgetpushtoshove,Chinacantell
US:"Wewillnationalizeyourbusinessesifyoudon'ttellIndiatowithdraw".Whatwillwe
do?
WhatweshouldfirstrealizeisthatthereisnoPakistan.ThereisonlyChina.Pakistanis
justafront.Weshoulddealaccordingly.ItisinChina'sinteresttokeepKashmirburning.If
thereispeaceinthevalley,IndiaMIGHTsetitseyesonPoK.ChineseknowthatIndiahas
astrongPrimeMinistertodaywhocanthinkofthat.ChinadoesnotwantIndiatoeventhink
ofgettingPoKback.Ofcourse,ChinadidnotlighttheKashmirfire,butitcertainlylooks
likeitisthemwhokeepsitburningthatnoconsensusisreached.So,inadditiontowater,
religion,ego,demographicsandsoonthereisonemorereasonbehindtheKashmirunrest:
ChinaandCPEC.
IsdialoguewithPakistansensible?Itisutterfoolishnesstothinkthatinsuchacasewe
canresolvethisthroughdialogue!Wetalkonethingwhileissueisanother!IssueisNOT
whatwethinkistheissue!Weandourgovtshouldfirstunderstandthis.Iamsurethey
have.Hopefullytheyaren'thelpless.Chinaiswagingaproxyproxydeceptivewarwhichwe
cannotunderstandorproveorblame.Weneedtomobilizesomeotherway.
WarwithPakistan?VadakkussaidattheendIamnotgenerallynotawarmonger,butthis
hasgonetoofar.Weshouldstrike.Dosomething.Ionlywishsomethingbedoneabout
those17Indiansoldierswhowerekilledwithoutanyprovocation.Theydidn'thavetodie.
TakeonbothChinaandPakistan.Maybe.Canwe?Idon'tknowwhatweshoulddo.
Hopefullyourhandsaren'ttiedandsomeoneiscomingupwithaplantohitthem.
Hopefully.
Baluchistan'srole:WhyPakistangotallworkedupwhenIndiaraisedBalochistan?Gwadar
isinBalochistan.MuchofCPECinfrapassesthroughBalochistan.TheCPECisChina's
hopeatliftingitssaggingeconomyandsecuringitsstrategicpositionintheregion.Itsfuture
maybedependsonit.KarakoramHindukushPamirregionsinceancienttimesbeen
7/22
9/20/2016
strategicallysensitive.TheSilkRoad.ChinawantscontrolofthenewSilkRoad.IfIndia
weretotakePoKwewouldsqueezetheKarakoramHighwayshut.NomoreCPEC,Silk
Road.Chinadonefor.Thatisthewholegame.Highwaysareprimarymilitaryconduitsrather
thancivilian.Whoevercontrolsthehighwaycontrolstheregion.
Ultimately..Pakistan'sultimateaimistoestablishanIslamiccaliphate.Apartfromthis
ChinahelpsthemthroughCPEC.YoumightdisagreewithModietalbutpleasesupportthe
govtrightnowinwhateveractionittakes.Politickingcanwait.Waittwomoremonthsbefore
takinganyharshdecisions.ThingsmightchangepostNovember.
WhatdoyouthinkIndiashoulddonow,afterreadingthisfully?
PostedbyKiranKumarSat2:55AM
+8 Recommend this on Google
Labels:Baluchistan,China,CPEC,Gilgit,Gwadar,India,JammuandKashmir,Karakoram,Kashgar,Kashmir,Khunjerab
Pass,Modi,Oil,Pakistan,PoK,Srinagar,Uri
79comments:
SujataSrinath September19,2016at3:56AM
Verywellput.OffthetopofmyheadIcanonlythinkofthis:GetSubramaniamSwamytonegotiatewithChina.
He knows Mandarin and the Chinese mentality and has even offered to talk to them in the past. There is no
reason to not collaborate with China to build highways that would benefit a region's people and
economy...PakistaninthemeanwhileshouldbemadetobiteitsnailswonderingwhatitcandowhenIndiaChina
become mutually beneficial friends instead of foes. Ajit Doval, Narendra Modi and Manohar Parrikar, I believe,
know what they are doing. All those gestures to China, and then the thundering support to Baluchistan...these
are big geopolitical moves that NaMo has done with a specific goal in mind. Ignoring Pakistan selectively and
visiting Nawaz Sherif were also part of a game plan. Its like a mighty chess game being played. Unfortunately
and heartbreakingly we lost some of our soldiers...because of Pakistan's imbecile and immature SOPs...10 of
12infiltrationswereintercepted,andthishorrificincidenthappenedwhentroopswerebeingchanged.Wehaveto
dealwithinformerstoo...thoseverminthatdissolvedallthedeepassetspostedinneighbouringcountries.India
willcheckmateChinaandPakistan.Ithasto!
Reply
Replies
XtremeSpeaks September19,2016at10:30PM
Well said! I also believe "A Business for a business" is another way to resolve this. Make a robust
businessdealwithChinawhichitcannotrefuse.
sharma September19,2016at10:39PM
WellputurwordsIndiaanditspoliticalpartieshavenostrongwillandIamsuremanypoliticalparties
big leaders does not even know and understand the issues properly as they lack of geo political
knowledgeanditsseriousnessmostofthemindulgingincast,creedandreligiouspoliticstheywork
forthemselves.Nationissecondary.
sharma September19,2016at10:40PM
WellputurwordsIndiaanditspoliticalpartieshavenostrongwillandIamsuremanypoliticalparties
big leaders does not even know and understand the issues properly as they lack of geo political
knowledgeanditsseriousnessmostofthemindulgingincast,creedandreligiouspoliticstheywork
forthemselves.Nationissecondary.
8/22
9/20/2016
Reply
Vibs September19,2016at4:26AM
Good Analysis. So I guess we are stuck here in situation for a long long time. Also I would like to know any
factorthatJapancanplay?
Reply
Replies
tryalphaa September19,2016at7:36AM
Of course it would be a new twist if Japan backs India !India must collectively work to bring all anti
Chinese nations in one line to counter dragon knock ! We shd not forget Japan who once been
nightmaretodragon
Unknown September20,2016at3:18AM
If really we attack than China will also attack from the back door, we will take our share, and China
willtakethereshare.ItisadvisabletowinoverPakistanandtakewhataretheareasofourinterest.
ButremovePakistanfromthemap.
If really we attack than China will also attack from the back door, we will take our share, and China
willtakethereshare.ItisadvisabletowinoverPakistanandtakewhataretheareasofourinterest.
ButremovePakistanfromthemap.
Reply
VishnumurthyPrabhu September19,2016at4:48AM
Let'shopethatnoonefilespetitioninSCforthis.Ifyouremember,fewdaysback(notevenlongago),AGofthe
countryhastoexplicitlytelltheSCthatthisisnotyourdomain.
Reply
VasudhaivKutumbkamALLTHEWORLDISBUTONE September19,2016at4:56AM
Veryimpressed!WasalreadydyingtolookforsomehardhittingdatabasedarticleonthisissueandIamglad,I
foundone
Reply
NitishGarg September19,2016at5:12AM
WhynotgoaroundPoK?Isn'tthatbigadetour.
Reply
Replies
Sharath September19,2016at6:00PM
9/22
9/20/2016
ThatwaswhatIwasthinkingtoo!
SushilDwivedi September19,2016at8:16PM
Well analysed. Very well written a d presented. These are long term national issues requiring a
focused approach by the govt. Here in India, our vibrant democracy has made us so fragile on
national issues that there is no unity of thought towards our national problems. Hope good sense
prevailsadpoliticalpartiesunitetosupportgovtofIndiaonthiscriticalissue.
Aditya_MCA September20,2016at1:44AM
Not possible as this would mean involving Tajikistan & Afghanistan... POK is something which is
readyduetoourChachaNehru...IamthinkingnowwasthisdonedeliberatelybyNehrutogiveChina
afreehand?
Reply
RamKinkarPandey September19,2016at7:22AM
Do exactly what Sri Lanka did to LTTE. Eliminate all the separatists (all key people). Human rights will cry for
some time like what they did when there were military actions in Sri Lanka. Suppress them brutally. Get your
houseintheorderbeforethinkingforcrossborderstrike.Terroristscan'ttravelfromPakistanandstrikeinIndia
ontheirownwithoutlocalssupport.Suppressthemsobrutallythatnoonecaneventhinktosupportthem.
Reply
Replies
RajeshChhibber September19,2016at9:20AM
Wellsaid!Exactlymywords!
SushilDwivedi September19,2016at8:17PM
Wellsaid!
Youhaveapoint!Buttherewillmuchdifficultiesinfindingoutlocalsupports.
Reply
RajeevSharma September19,2016at7:59AM
TocontainChinawealsohavedosomethingproactivelikeweareplanningtodowithPakistanbyraisingissue
of Baluchstan, Pastunabad, Sindh and POK. Push captured Jihadis from Indian Territory into muslim majority
disturbedregionofXinjianginChina.TheaimoftheJihadiistodieafterkillingKafirs,forhimChinesearealso
Kafirsohewon'tbehavingproblemtoblowhimselfupinChineseareas.StartgivingMilitarytrainingtopeopleof
Tibet (directly or indirectly), at one call of Dalai Lama thousands of his followers from world over will join in to
pushformilitarysolutiontoliberateTibetfromChina.AllBuddhistlivinginallpartsoftheworldincludingChina
canbemobilizedtopushforthecauseoffreedomtoTibet.OncehighlyreligiousBuddhistpeopledecidetotake
on atheist China militarily China wont be able to handle it. Taiwan and Hong Kong are ready to be inflamed
10/22
9/20/2016
againstmainlandChina,theyjustneedlittleencouragement.
Reply
Replies
Only encouragement wont help. They are far far behind from China when it comes to firepower. And
as you know, only protest by Buddhist monks in Tibet will be and has been brutally suppressed by
Chinese. In the end, Chine is a closed society, hence you will never get to know how/when the
suppressionishappening.
Reply
sumit September19,2016at8:08AM
@kiran ...u said wait till November...things may change....what points would u like to add to those
changes...Thankuforthearticle.
Reply
Replies
KISHANMUNDRA September19,2016at10:52AM
USpresidentialresultswillbeIN.
Reply
ShreedharaKedilaya September19,2016at8:10AM
1..shortofwarhelpafganistanmilitarilyandeconomically..establishindoafganmilitaryalongpakborder
2..helpbaluchistanfinancially.createmajorunrestthere..
3..providealtafhussain,mojahirleaderfinanceandcreateenirmousunrestinsind
4..providearmamentstomohajirsandbaluchthroughafganistanintensively.
5..samedittowithPOKANDGILGITBALTISTAN
6..makepakfeelunsafe..andvulnarabkeanddesperate
7..whilemodernisearmybevijilantalongtheentireborderswiththehelpofisrael
8..armvietnamphilipinesheavily.butshortofdirectlyinvolvinginsouthchinasea..keeptherelationswarmwith
china
9..investheavilyininfrastructureinkashmir,schools,hospitas,industries..etc
10..ignore hurriet but deeply involve rest of kashmiri leaders like pandits,buddists,dogras,and quarentine rest of
thepartofkashmirfrombtroubles..involvethemdeeplyinnationalpoliticsbymakingthemleaders
11..invest heavily in modernisation of army with a declaration that no first use of nuclear war heads is under
reconsideration.
12..improve and try to make india an economic superpower inviting investments from china and consider an
economiccoridorfromchinatomumbaitoowithinvestmentsfromchina
Reply
Replies
Lalit September20,2016at4:25AM
Greatidea
11/22
9/20/2016
Lalit September20,2016at4:26AM
Greatidea
Reply
ShreedharaKedilaya September19,2016at8:12AM
1..shortofwarhelpafganistanmilitarilyandeconomically..establishindoafganmilitaryalongpakborder
2..helpbaluchistanfinancially.createmajorunrestthere..
3..providealtafhussain,mojahirleaderfinanceandcreateenirmousunrestinsind
4..providearmamentstomohajirsandbaluchthroughafganistanintensively.
5..samedittowithPOKANDGILGITBALTISTAN
6..makepakfeelunsafe..andvulnarabkeanddesperate
7..whilemodernisearmybevijilantalongtheentireborderswiththehelpofisrael
8..armvietnamphilipinesheavily.butshortofdirectlyinvolvinginsouthchinasea..keeptherelationswarmwith
china
9..investheavilyininfrastructureinkashmir,schools,hospitas,industries..etc
10..ignore hurriet but deeply involve rest of kashmiri leaders like pandits,buddists,dogras,and quarentine rest of
thepartofkashmirfrombtroubles..involvethemdeeplyinnationalpoliticsbymakingthemleaders
11..invest heavily in modernisation of army with a declaration that no first use of nuclear war heads is under
reconsideration.
12..improve and try to make india an economic superpower inviting investments from china and consider an
economiccoridorfromchinatomumbaitoowithinvestmentsfromchina
Reply
the article is so sensitive instead of taking action on Pakistan it is better to stop business relations with
immediateeffectatleastwecanabletostopinflowofbusinessfundstoChinafromIndiaandhopefullydragon
willforcedtorethinkabouttheirpolicyandinthatspaceoftimewecanacquiresophisticatedmilitaryWeapons
andtheneasilytakestepsagainstPakistanandtrytoliberatePOKfromtheclutchesofChina
Reply
VasudevanP September19,2016at9:21AM
Nicearticle.ButIamwonderinghowonly4terrorists
wereabletocausethismuchdamage?
Reply
Replies
Incendiarytactics,sir
Harijee September20,2016at2:53AM
similartypeofattachtookplaceearliertooinJ&Konly.Thattimetoo,theycamethroughdrainage.
Reply
12/22
9/20/2016
VasudevanP September19,2016at9:22AM
Nicearticle.ButIamwonderinghowonly4terrorists
wereabletocausethismuchdamage?
Reply
sunaath September19,2016at9:28AM
Ididnotknowthisissocomplex.Thanksfortheanalysis.PMModitriedalottobefriendChinawhilekeeping
thematasafedistancebecauseitislikebefriendingadragon.ButIguessModiislikeChanakya.Hewillsurely
devisewaystokeepChinaatbay.HowevertherearemanyselfishandignorantenemiestohiminsideIndiathan
PakorChina!
Reply
ChiragUpadhyay September19,2016at9:31AM
Thebestmoveherewouldbecutoffalleconomic&resourceslikewatertoPakistan&giveChinaawarningby
stoppingtheirbusinessinIndia.
We'reamongbiggestmarket/consumersofChinesegoods
Reply
Replies
Yes!ChinatooneedsastrongmessagefromIndia.
Reply
chandrashekharSharma September19,2016at9:53AM
The analysis may be correct but looks like work of some Pak/China agent. It want to create false sense of
dangerinIndianminds.
I have been given to understand that India has been planning to fight simultaneously on two fronts of Pakistan
andChinaforlast50years.Irepeatpreparingforlast50years.ChinacouldnotdefeatconclusivelyVietnama
verysmallcountry
than India. So atleast India can take some surgical action against Pakistan. At present China is under
internationalpressureduetoSouthChinaSeadispute.AtpresentChinaisnotinapositiontowagewaronIndia
onbehalfofPakistan.
IrejectaboveanalysisasPakistanpropaganda.
Reply
Replies
Dopa September19,2016at7:05PM
Thiscommenthasbeenremovedbytheauthor.
Dopa September19,2016at7:07PM
Bingo! China won't intervene on behalf of Pakistan atleast for another 10 years, by when Chinese
investments are fully embedded in Pakistan's financial system. While I won't go so far to say the
authorisdoingPakistanipropaganda,he'sacutelyparanoidingeopoliticalsense.
13/22
9/20/2016
Idisagreewithyoursomepoints:
1. China has done magnificent development in their military assets after Vietnam war, hence this is
wrongtocomparethese2timeframes.
2.ChinaisNOTunderpressureasitrejectsinternationaltribune'srulesonsouthchinaseaandhas
beenmilitarizingthearea.
However,Iwouldlikwtoaddsomepoints:
1. Of course, China won't go for war with India as it may lead to economical destabilization. And for
now, south china sea is its 1st priority. However, China has capability to strike India with help from
Pakwhenevernecessary.
2.Therearemanythingsotherthanwarwhichcanblockonecountry'sinterest.
This is not fake analysis, I think. It's a detailed analysis. The issue is not so simple as it looks. It
demandsgreatdealofplanningandlongtermaction.
Reply
TejasSheth September19,2016at10:07AM
Great research...I think the biggest mistake India did was failure of Pat governments who did not mention
specificallythatPoKisdisputedregionandhencenoinvestmentsshallbeallowedbyChina...Congressfailedto
dothisandhenceletsbclearthatitshouldnotcometopoweragain
Secondly, Indian should work towards Independence of Balochistan...support them on global front, through
financiallyandpolitically...bykeepingChinainconfidencethatCPECwillnotimpacted...thatwayBalochwillbe
Indian ally...CPEC will operate but India will have its say...we cannot stop CPEC..but v can indirectly control it
thruthismove
Reply
Replies
Lets not repent about past! Blunders have been made and unfortunately, we are facing the
consequencesnow.
Iagreewithyour2ndparastating"Abusinessforabusiness"attitude.However,freedomofBalochis
alongtermprocess,whichmaytake15yearsatleast.
Yes!IndependentBaluchistanwillgiveafootholdinbetweentheCEPC.
Reply
14/22
9/20/2016
PrashantSaxena September19,2016at10:12AM
IfthathighwayissoimportantwhynotIndiatakesoverPOK&offerthathighwaytochina.Chinajustwantsthat
highway/CPEC,forchinaitdoesn'tmatterifthatHighwaylieswithIndia.
Thiswaychinesewillstillgetswhattheywant,IndiagetsPOKwheremajorterroristsarenurtured.Allthiscan
bestopped.
Ifwedontdoanythingnowthisissuewillpassthroughgenerations,gettingworse.
Reply
PrashantSaxena September19,2016at11:32AM
IfthathighwayissoimportantwhynotIndiatakesoverPOK&offerthathighwaytochina.Chinajustwantsthat
highway/CPEC,forchinaitdoesn'tmatterifthatHighwaylieswithIndia.
Thiswaychinesewillstillgetswhattheywant,IndiagetsPOKwheremajorterroristsarenurtured.Allthiscan
bestopped.
Ifwedontdoanythingnowthisissuewillpassthroughgenerations,gettingworse.
Reply
Replies
SamirBagde September19,2016at7:51PM
I think for China,negotiating with Pakistan should be much cheaper than with India. That's why they
don'twantthelandtogoinIndia'shandagain.
Reply
Raghavkumar September19,2016at12:33PM
Ithinkafterreadingthis...Ifthisisthetrueintentionandtheproxyproxywarthing...Thebestisjoinhandswith
China sign a treaty that let us fight pakis and once we take over POK China will have unhindered access to
highwaysthere...Itwon'thurtusatallastheyasitishaveafreeaccesstoit...Killthemiddlemanandgetyour
landback...
Reply
SanjibDas September19,2016at12:41PM
nicewriting
Reply
NarendraBodhisatva September19,2016at12:49PM
Yes,I think India should understand chinese interest in Pakistan and it is because of CPEC,as this will boost
chinese economy to become world superpower in terms of GDP and can further dictate terms in UNO like
US.CPEC is bigest investment in Pakistan and it is spreaded all over Pakistan.So this will bring overall
developmmentinPakistanwhichisgood.
For India this chinese investment is not a big deal seeing the reserve of $370bn.India should play pure politics
andgiveassuranceofit'ssupportonsouthchinaseaprovided,ChinaisreadytonotsupportPakistanonanyof
it'sinternalmatter,ThereforeIndiacanalsogiveassuranceofchineaseinvestmentinPakistantwillkeepintact
fromanyIndianaction.
Thereafter India should carve out Balochistant from Pkistant,make a separate democratic country like
AfganistantandatthesametimefreePOKfromPakistan.
To carve out Balochistant very important is to have a Baloch leader who has national presence.This is to
15/22
9/20/2016
understandthat
1:ChinacannotbringtheirtroopsinPakistantlandtobringdownwidespreadunrestinBaloch.
2:Baloch people should also understand that these chinese investment has been done for growth of Chinease
economy,howevergrowthinPakistanandBalochGDPisjustafractionwrt.chinaanditisjusteyewash.
3:The Baloch governments overall focus would be towards chinese projects and their development even the
powerandotherinfrastructureshallbeusedfortheirtransportationpurposewhichisalsofreeofcost.Nobodyis
concernedforBalochownpopulationandtheirdevelopment.
4:Whereas baloch could have very easily charged their cost of strategical locations from china and with this
moneytheywouldhavedevelopedtheireconomy.
5:ThepowerofBalochlocalgovernmentwouldgoonshrinkandlatertheywouldbecometoyinchinesehand.
6:There are many small countries which are even lesser than baloch geography but their GDP is more than
todaysPakistan.
7:BalochistanshouldthinkforbecomingbigestallyandpartnerwithIndiawhichisworld3rdbiggestEconomy.
Indiashouldgetthesupportfromlocalleadersofbalochandshowsymmpathyonworldforum.
Maybecontinued.....
Reply
ParthasarathiR September19,2016at6:06PM
Analysisisbasedontoday'sperceptionofeconomicscenario.ChinaistakentodaytobeGoliathbasedonhuge
population and a massive army. Besides its growing technology. It has its own Muslim population who can get
jihadi mood. It would be a deterrent when assumes its size as it does all over the world. It is the cancer in
Europe.It'ssymptomsarevisibleinUSA.BesidessomedayallMuslimcountrieswouldbecryingtosavethem
from ISIS. Presently we are emotionally blackmailed by our hurt pride. Individually the death of 20 jawans is
devastating,butinarmylanguageitisajuckmi.Asmalljuckmi.Deathforajawanisincidental.Forbrassinthe
armyisuntowardandoughttohavebeenavoided.Theoilwealthisnotapermanentrevenue.Itisboundtodry
up.Elsethevacuumatthebottomofearthcreatedbysiphoningofwilltriggeranearthquake.Thesearedistant
possibilities.Myfinalconclusion:Weneedabsorbthisshockoflossofprideandemotions.Inacountryof130
crores,20arelostbutitistakentobeanationalpride.Wisemanwillwait.
Reply
Replies
RajinderVerma September19,2016at8:48PM
Iwouldsaywaitinginfinitelyisnotagoodidea..weneedtostrikebackatthePakistanifissuresand
indoublemeasure.....Surelywehavethemoneytodothat!!!!
Reply
Unknown September19,2016at6:30PM
Ok, but one must consider India's share with China's economy growth, i think that is much more than with
Pakistan.
Sochinaalsoneedtorethinkaboutherinvestmentoptionandfutureprospect,becauseonecantgrowbuisness
inhighlyinstableareaandofcourseislamicfactorsaretheretoowhichgoesagainstChina.
Reply
ManmohanKorde September19,2016at6:41PM
Iamalsosuresomethingisbeing"cooked"atthe.Governmentlevel.Betternottotalktoomuchaboutthisvia
thismedium.Weshouldallhavesomepatienceandletourgovernmentthinktheyallknowwhatiswhat.
Reply
16/22
9/20/2016
prafulla September19,2016at6:45PM
Just flexing muscle or sound bytes is beyond pointless. Modi will never any election if he does not show grit.
Backinthedays,Shivajietalneverthoughtlongandhardforthislongabouttheconsequenceswhenmuslim
rulerstimeandagaintroubledhim.Maybebecausethereisatimeforeverything.Shivajilostfewofthebattles
andendeduppayingreparationsbutthatdidn'tdeterhimfromstriking.Andthatspreciselywhytheyfearedhim.
MMShasreducedustoanarmyofmisfitswithhisposturing(orlackthereof).Modiadoptingasimilarstance
willbehardtodigestwithinhisownranks.
Allsaidanddone,itstoughtobeModiandDovalrightnow.Withsomuchofpressuretostrikeattheearliest,its
easy to get it wrong. I for one feel a strike is due. The whole of nation may not stand with him but that'll
broadcastaverypowerfulmessage.Ifchinaspoilstheparty,sobeit.
Reply
Excellent
Socametoknowwhyandhowwestuck.
IfIndiadealswithChina,thatIndiawilltransportit'soilfromMuscattoChinathroughIndianregion,Chinawillnot
enterbuthewillgethisoiltoo,
Sowecanbecamefriends.
Reply
RajinderVerma September19,2016at8:44PM
Thereismuchtowhatyousay!!ChinaisalsotheBullinthisShopthatneedstobetackledandsoon!!!!
Reply
NiharKuanr September19,2016at8:54PM
Ifarubberinvadesurhouse,gagsuandtriestomaimu,won'titbefoolishnottouseurstrengthtooverpower
himthinkingoffuturerepercussion....thesamemiscreantgetsemboldenedandventurestorubuagainand,u
leavehimagainevenifunjoyutmostsuperiorityoverhim...it'sjustnotwisetosaytheleast.....
Reply
NiharKuanr September19,2016at8:54PM
Ifarubberinvadesurhouse,gagsuandtriestomaimu,won'titbefoolishnottouseurstrengthtooverpower
himthinkingoffuturerepercussion....thesamemiscreantgetsemboldenedandventurestorubuagainand,u
leavehimagainevenifunjoyutmostsuperiorityoverhim...it'sjustnotwisetosaytheleast.....
Reply
AvayShukla September19,2016at10:39PM
Will someone please forward this article to Ms. Arnab Goswami, Rahul Shivshankar and Maroof Raza ? This
issueisfarmoreconvolutedthandevisingastrategyforgettingmoreTRPs.Anexcellentarticle:Iwonderwhy
mainstream(print)mediaisnottalkingaboutthisChinadimension?
Reply
17/22
9/20/2016
ArchimedhaMohapatra September19,2016at10:47PM
WelltheanalysisremindsmeofAgeofEmpires.Oneofthemostcommonstrategiestodefeattheenemyteam
istobreaktheirtraderoutes.AsimplewayofdoingsoisbyhelpingChinatobuildtraderoutesthroughIndia.
At a very basic level, create emporting stations at key Chinese borders (One near Uttarakhand and one near
Darjeeling or on the Bramhaputra) and corresponding ports near Katchh and WestBengal/Odisha. Emporting
stationsareoneswheregoodsfromaforeignvehicleareloadedintodomesticvehiclesandtransportedthrough
thedomesticroutes(allthesewhilethegoodsstillbelongtotheforeigncountry).Therailandriverlinksthrough
IndiansoilandthetransportationvehiclesusedtocarrytheseChinesegoodsbetweentheseemportingstations
will be owned by India. This way Chinese goods would travel through India under Indian supervision. For this
India can charge a small amount to China. Also if emporting stations are raised on the Brahmaputra, then it
wouldbeofhighinterestforChinatomaintainwaterlevelsintheriver(benefitforIndia).
By doing this India will eliminate Chinese interest on building infrastructure in Pakistan and also incentivize
ChinaagainstmaintainingtraderoutesthroughahighlyhostilegeographyinPakistan.Alsothiswouldopennot
onebuttwotraderoutesforChinathatwillgiveChinaeasyaccesstoAfrica,SuezandAustralia.AsfarasIndia
isconcerned,thistraderoutewillbeareasonforChinatomaintaingoodrelationshipwithIndiainsteadoflooking
atitasanenemystate.
Oncethesetraderoutesaredeveloped,Idon'tseeanyreasonforChinatodependonPakistanandhenceitwill
eliminateChinesesupporttoPakistan.AsfarastheSilkrouteisconcerned,itcanbypassPakistanentirelyby
routingthrougheitherKazakshtanorthroughTajikisthanandUzbekisthan.Indiacanalsohelphereandgetgas
pipelinesdirectlyfromAfghanistanthroughthesamerouteandnotthroughPakistan.
ThiswouldentirelycutoffPakistanandthentheIndiancausewouldbeeasytoachieve.
Pleasenote:Thisisjustanempiricalstrategycomingoutofanidlemind.
Reply
M$K September19,2016at10:54PM
IndeeditisagreateyeopenertoallofusthatwhatkindofplanningnstrategyCPECisdoing.Wemustplayour
cardsverycautiouslynsmartly.Yes,ourcourseofactionsdependonUSPresidentialelection.Wemightneed
towaittillNov.
Reply
subhashchand September19,2016at11:52PM
Awarstretegycantbdiscussedhere.
Chinahasalwaysbeenpakistanallay(economicallytoo)since1962.priortothatpakistanifavouredindiaagainst
china.
After1962pakwenttochinaflankseeingindiandefeat.
Chinaclddonohelpin1971war.evenchinaaskedpaknttoopenwesternfrontinkashmir.
Sowarisstetegy:wheretohit,whentohit,hottohit,howlongtohit.
Takeisraelintoconfidenceforsupplyofarteleriesandintelligencesupport.
Surgical strike becking by army navy air force to show os strenth is required. Atleast a message to b given to
world,notonlypaknchina.
Reply
Very nice article ...in present situation the only solution is to hit the terrorist camps in POK and not to declare
anywar.UniteallothercountriesagainstTerrorisminsteadofagainstPakistan.
18/22
9/20/2016
Reply
SudhirSalke September20,2016at12:45AM
Greatresearch!
ThismeansIndiacanneverhitpokorpak,unlesspakdeclaresofficialwaragainstIndia.
Thereshouldbesomestrongsolutiontoovercomethissituation!
Orwaittillpakdies!
Reply
SudhirSalke September20,2016at12:46AM
Greatresearch!
ThismeansIndiacanneverhitpokorpak,unlesspakdeclaresofficialwaragainstIndia.
Thereshouldbesomestrongsolutiontoovercomethissituation!
Orwaittillpakdies!
Reply
AshuSingh September20,2016at1:51AM
I agree totally that CPEC is very important to China & Pak, if Modi agrees to up the ante militarily or may be
evensurgicallyhitstheKarakoramhighway,theremaybesomecollateraldamageasmissileswillbexchanged
with Pak, but soon China will force Pak to pull back the jihadis, China cant take instability in & around
CPEC/PoK. So China will push Pak to control Jihadis. There is a small risk of full fledged war with Pak. But
ChinawilldefinitelynotallowsituationtoescalateasIndianmilitaryisnotsoweak,itcanshutdowntheCPEC
effectivelyincaseofwar,SothereshudbsomeretaliationagainstPaknow,whichgivesaclearhintthatifPak
sends terrorists to Kashmir, India will launch offensive, which the Chinese wont like. as they want CPEC
unhindered. India shud impose some cost on China & Pak, that jugular vein is CPEC. its a gr8 leverage
opportunityforPMModi,whichcanchangethecourseofhistory,andatlastbringpeacetotheKashmiriValley
Reply
Goodanalysistobekeptinmindfordecidingthemultifoldstrategyforsuitableaction.1.MFNstatustoPAkto
be stopped forthwith. 2.All business and cultural exchange including sport events to be stopped/ banned. 3.
Indianembassyandstaffshdbecalledoff.4.BustoPAkshdbestopped.5.VisaforPakistobedenied.6.All
Pakis employed anywhere in Indian govt outfits to be sacked. Corporate sector also to be approved on similar
lines. 7. Choke all remittances from PAk to India and vice versa. 8. Water and other resources to the extent
feasibleshdbedriedup.9.AllPAkgovtofficesandstafftobeclosed.10.Allhelp,fundingetctoallseparatists
organizationshdbewithdrawn.11.Emergencylikesituationtobecreatedforborderareaswithmorepowersto
armytostopinfiltration.12.KeepalivetheissueofPOKandBaluchistanatvariousforumsandtacticalsupport
toallrelatedactivities.Andallsuchactivitieswhichismainlyinternal.
On external front based on the analysis we can not keep quiet. Otherwise like POK let us not loose the
momentumgeneratedforbatchandinternationalawarenessetc.
Chinaisnotgoingtocomedirectlynorthesituationisgoingtogetconvertedintofullfledgedwar.PAkitselfis
undertremendousinternalpressure.Keepingoodmoodthesmallercountriesforsouthchinaissue,dosurgical
strikesonterrorcamps,engagechinaonSecuritycouncilmembershipissueandotherbusinessandinvestment
horizon.LetusnotwaittillNovforAmericanelection.ObamaadministrationiswithIndiasotakeadvantageof
thesituationandbringallroundsupport.IfbychanceChinaintervenes,themAmerica,JapanandRussiacanbe
usedtacticallytothwartanysuchattempt.
The time is not and right for a strike and message to be delivered without any further delay. All circumstances
are favourable, PAk is otherwise already separated, pull all pressure thru Afghanistan, Baluchistan, POK,
America, strong action against separatists in Kashmir, bad treatment of terrorists and thus engage PAk in its
19/22
9/20/2016
owncreation.
Reply
Ifthisistherealissue..ThenwemustsupportChinaandmakehighwayfortheminourowncountry..Thenwe
both...ChinaandIndiacanunitemuchstronglyandguessnoothercountrywilldarelookingthisway
Reply
croyind September20,2016at2:17AM
A very good analysis minus a very critical issue... THE CPEC is almost non starter, because of the same
reasonsthatmakeitsoundsolucrativetoChina...thedemographicsoftheplacesitpassesthrough...Thelocal
Pakistani communities are now realizing and this is a fact, now that the details of the US$ 46 billion are
emerging, that the only value addition their economy will have is providing Dhabas, Brothels and Gas Stations
alongtherouteandnothingelse...TheplannedPowerPlantsarenotviable,beingbasedonImportedCoaland
for environmental reasons, which means there cannot be additional industrialization because Pakistan has
severeEnergyCrisis.
ThewholescenarioisPakistan'splanningaswithoutKashmir,theywilllooseoutontheirbiggestSugarDaddy,
China, who needs to keep pumping liquid cash into the Pakistani system to ensure security for the proposed
corridor.
With a huge cash surplus, China is spending a few millions just to have a back up in place incase the trade
routesfromtheSouthChinaseaareblocked,andPakistanmilkingthemforthefewmillionsissomethingthey
donotmind,consideringthefactthatPakistanisanuclearstateandincaseofanyrealwarlikesituations,they
canusePakistanilandtogooduse.
The main reason for the present increase in Kashimir violence is also connected to the recent political gains
made by India in the Middle East, whereby Saudi Arabia, Qatar and UAE are more India friendly than ever
before, and Saudi is refusing the be milked like earlier... Pakistan is desperate to have India react militarily in
Kashmir, which as usual will be portrayed as "AntiIslam" in the ME region...but this time i.e. for the past 6
months,theireffortsarenotclearlynotworking.
Pakistan has no where to go, with a failing economy, a huge debt crisis, falling literacy levels, multiple power
centersandvirtualabandonmentbyitsoverseasdiaspora,thisistheonlywayforwardforthePakistaniArmy,
whorunthecountryanyway.
Reply
NareshKumar September20,2016at2:18AM
Ifthisistherealissue..ThenwemustsupportChinaandmakehighwayfortheminourowncountry..Thenwe
both...ChinaandIndiacanunitemuchstronglyandguessnoothercountrywilldarelookingthisway
Reply
sands September20,2016at2:19AM
iamsorrytosaythisbutpeopleofindiavotedforModisincethewerefedupwithstatusquobutonthisissue
particularly there is no change from status .. only ninda ,gor ninda,kadi ninda .. what is difference between
manmohanandmodithen?
Reply
20/22
9/20/2016
Replies
SurajJoel September20,2016at3:24AM
ExactlymythoughtsandprobablyyouechothewholeofIndia'ssentiment.
Reply
SurajJoel September20,2016at3:22AM
Yeahlet'swaitfor2moremonthsandwatchmanymoreofoursoldierbrothersandsistersdie,cribmoreaboutit
andkeepwaiting.Whoisnotwillingtosupportthegovernment?Everybodywantsaction.ThePMhasbeenall
wordswithnoaction.JustMMSwithabigmouth
Reply
SonalSingh September20,2016at3:43AM
OK. China is main player here and it's playing with India. Now what India can do is support Philippines and
VietnaminSouthChinaSeadispute.USAisalreadythere.Sowedon'thavetoworrymuch.Whatwehavetodo
istobecomevocalaboutourstandinSouthChinaSea.WeknowhowmuchChinawantthatarea.Andthenif
China consult India India can negotiate with China. If Chinese are going to help Pakistan on kashmir issue we
shouldhelpUSAPhilippinesandVietnamopenly.ThenwewillhaveleverageonChina.Indiashoulddecidehere
it'sstand.Chooseitsfriendcarefullyandtreadforward.
Reply
MgHirenTayung September20,2016at3:52AM
Thiscommenthasbeenremovedbytheauthor.
Reply
MgHirenTayung September20,2016at3:53AM
Thankyoukiranjiforelaboratingwholetopic
Reply
Edward September20,2016at4:10AM
IndiacanfinishPakistanandthenallowtheChinesecorridortoexistthruIndiaoccupiedPakistan.
InthiswayIndiagetswhatitrequires...Moreland..andletChinakeepthecorridor.
AlternativeroutecanbegiventoChinafortheircorridor.
Reply
AnkitSemwal September20,2016at4:15AM
Goodanalysis.Ireaditbeforealsobutindetailswithmapsthistimeonly.Nomatterwhateverthesituationis
butweIndianscanconfidentlysay'wearenotsoeasy'.
Reply
21/22
9/20/2016
AnkitSemwal September20,2016at4:21AM
Goodanalysis.Ireaditbeforealsobutindetailswithmapsthistimeonly.Nomatterwhateverthesituationis
butweIndianscanconfidentlysay'wearenotsoeasy'.
Reply
vipulacharya1@gmail.com September20,2016at4:23AM
It's wonder full geopolitical analysis,but to prevent killings of soldiers,immediate action is inevitable for wrong
doingsofPaksuppportedextremist.itishightime.
Reply
22/22

Kiran's Thoughts PDF

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Kiran's Thoughts PDF

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

9/20/2016

+8 Recommend this on Google

S-ar putea să vă placă și