Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Assassinations
in World History
Famous
Assassinations
in World History
An Encyclopedia
Volume 1: AP
MICHAEL NEWTON
17
16
15
14
Contents
Preface
xv
Introduction
xvii
The Encyclopedia
Volume 1
Abdallah Abderemane, Ahmed (19191989)
Aguiyi-Ironsi, Johnson Thomas Umunnakwe (19241966)
al-Banna, Sheikh Hasan Ahmed Abdel Rahman Muhammed
(19061949)
Albert I of Habsburg (12551308)
al-Din Shah Qajar, Nasser (18311896)
Alexander I of Serbia (18761903)
Alexander I of Yugoslavia (18881934)
Alexander II of Russia (18181881)
Ali, Muhammad Mansur (19191975)
Amin, Hafizullah (19291979)
Aquino, Benigno Simeon, Jr. (19321983)
Araujo, Manuel Enrique (18651913)
Argaa Ferraro, Luis Mara del Corazn de Jess Dionisio
(19321999)
Assassins Cult (ca. 10921275)
Bahonar, Mohammad-Javad (19331981)
Balbinus (165 CE238 CE)
Balewa, Abubakar Tafawa (19121966)
Bandaranaike, Solomon West Ridgeway Dias (18991959)
Bautista Gill Garca del Barrio, Juan (18401877)
Becket, Thomas (11181170)
Belzu Humerez, Manuel Isidoro (18081865)
Bearan Ordeana, Jos Miguel (19491978)
1
2
3
6
7
9
10
12
14
15
17
20
21
23
27
28
30
32
34
35
38
40
vi
CONTENTS
42
43
45
48
49
51
52
54
56
57
59
61
65
67
69
71
72
73
75
76
78
80
83
84
87
92
93
94
96
97
99
103
104
106
108
109
CONTENTS
111
113
115
117
118
120
121
125
128
129
131
132
135
136
138
140
142
145
146
148
150
152
155
156
161
164
165
167
169
171
173
176
177
179
vii
viii
CONTENTS
181
183
184
186
188
190
193
195
199
201
202
205
208
209
211
213
215
217
219
220
222
225
231
232
234
237
239
240
241
245
247
249
252
254
255
CONTENTS
257
264
269
271
277
281
282
285
288
291
295
298
299
302
305
307
309
311
312
317
320
321
323
326
328
330
331
333
335
336
339
341
342
344
ix
CONTENTS
351
353
355
358
361
366
369
375
381
384
386
391
393
397
401
403
406
409
412
415
418
420
422
425
427
431
435
438
Volume 2
Qadir, Haji Abdul (19512002)
Qutuz, Saif ad-Din (?1260)
Rabin, Yitzhak (19221995)
Radama II (18291863)
Rahman, Ziaur (19361981)
Rasputin, Grigori Yefimovich (18691916)
441
444
447
451
453
456
CONTENTS
460
462
464
465
470
471
473
475
476
481
483
486
491
494
497
499
502
504
505
507
511
513
515
517
520
522
525
526
528
530
534
535
538
541
543
xi
xii
CONTENTS
544
548
550
552
555
558
559
562
564
567
569
572
576
580
585
588
591
595
597
600
604
606
610
614
616
621
625
628
630
634
637
641
645
649
CONTENTS
652
655
Primary Documents
1. Assassination of Pompey the Great (48 BCE)
Plutarchs Description of the Murder of Pompey in Egypt
661
664
668
671
672
675
680
683
688
691
693
694
700
703
xiii
xiv
CONTENTS
709
715
720
727
780
797
800
808
812
815
Selected Bibliography
835
Index
837
Preface
xvi
P R E FA C E
backgrounds of participants, and describe events that sprang from violence directed against public figures.
The section of entries is followed by a selection of 23 primary documents.
Arranged chronologically, these documents comprise accounts of assassinations
and reports of investigations, as well as speeches and statutes that preceded or
resulted from the murders. The documents included range from Plutarchs description of the murder of Pompey the Great in Egypt in 48 BCE, through the
last speech of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, delivered moments before
his murder in 1995.
Finally, to ensure complete coverage of the subject, an appendix provides a
timeline of other prominent assassinations omitted from the main text entries
due to space constraints. That list includes 486 cases, spanning the globe and
the years from 748 BCE to 2012. In that timeline, continents and their countries
are arranged alphabetically, with assassinations and attempts for each specific
country listed chronologically. A detailed subject index will help users find important figures, events, and ideas in the main entries.
Every effort has been made to present timely, complete, and accurate information throughout Famous Assassinations in World History. That said, available
sourcesparticularly those concerned with ancient crimes and modern, controversial casesfrequently provide conflicting dates, names, and descriptions
of events. In each case, I have chosen what appears to be the best and most
substantive information currently available. Readers wishing to suggest corrections for perceived inaccuracies, or to offer further data on the cases here
described, may contact the author through ABC-CLIO, or directly through his
Web site at www.michaelnewton.homestead.com.
Introduction
xviii
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
whether they have any credence. In cases where facts are disputed, witnesses
contradicted, or evidence has vanished, further detailed information may be
found within the sources suggested for further readingand, in turn, through
their bibliographies. Although the author has opinions in most cases, they are
not presented here. Critics of the official verdictsand their detractors, in
turnare permitted to speak for themselves.
There can be no last word on assassinations, as long as discontent and violence persist on Earth. If anything, our world appears to be a more chaotic, violent place today than during many eras of the past. Between 2006 and 2012,
Mexicos drug war claimed at least 54,927 lives, with another 10,000 victims
disappeared; some estimates of the seven-year death toll top 99,000. Narcoterrorism in Central America is equally lethal: Honduras, El Salvador, Belize,
Guatemala, and Panama all had higher per-capita murder rates than Mexico in
2010. La Violencia (The Violence) engulfed Colombia in 1946, resulting in
300,000 homicides by 1958. Today, that nations plague of narcoterrorism produced 13,520 murders in 2011hailed by Colombias National Police as the
lowest violent death toll since 1984. Reports from Iraq, Afghanistan, and parts
of Africa are equally dismal.
Famous Assassinations in World History presents a chronicle of malice and
mistakes, in hope that something may be learned, at least, from the mistakes.
Whether those lessons are absorbed depends in equal part on public leaders,
law enforcement, and an educated populace.
xix
A
ABDALLAH ABDEREMANE, AHMED
(19191989)
On November 26, 1989, armed rebellion erupted in Moroni, capital of the
Comoros, an island chain located in the Mozambique Channel between Madagascar and the African mainland. The coups leader, Said Mohamed Djohar, was
the half-brother of former president Ali Soilih Mtsashiwa, chafing under the
rule of his siblings successor, President Ahmed Abdallah Abderemane. Rebels
captured President Abdallah during the first day of fighting, and executed him
on orders from Djohar.
Born on the island of Anjouan on June 12, 1919, when Comoros was still
a French colony, Abdallah entered politics in the 1940s, served as president
of the general council from 1949 to 1953, and assumed chairmanship of
the Chamber of Deputies in 1970. Two years later, leading his own political
partythe Comoros Democratic Union (UDC)Abdallah was elected chief
minister of Comoros and held that post until the islands achieved independence on July 6, 1975. Voters chose him as their new nations first president,
but he lasted less than a month, deposed by Said Mohamed Jaffar on August 3.
Jaffar, in turn, was overthrown by revolutionary socialist Ali Soilih Mtsashiwa
in January 1976.
Soilih sought to make Comoros a self-sufficient nation, melding Maoist
principles with certain progressive Islamic philosophies, a goal that brought
him into conflict with traditional Muslim society. He abandoned classic grand
marriage (Anda) and funerary rituals, banned veiling of women, discouraged young Comorians from studying history, and encouraged them to take
a greater role in government. To that end, Soilih young Moissy militia units
patterned on Chinas Red Guards, legalized cannabis, and proposed lowering
the voting age to 14. Moissy units raided rural pockets of resistance and killed
its conservative elders.
Soilihs reforms spurred hostile reactions in France, whose government
cut off financial and technical aid to Comoros. In Paris, Ahmed Abdallah
hired French mercenary Bob Denard to organize a team of 50 soldiers to depose Soilih. Their coup succeeded on May 13, 1978, installing former interior
minister Said Atthoumani as Chairman of the Politico-Military Directorate.
Ten days later, Abdallah and ally Mohamed Ahmed succeeded Atthoumani
as cochairmen. Abdallahs men executed Soilih on May 29, and Abdallah removed Ahmed to become sole chairman on October 3. Three weeks later he
assumed office as president of a newly proclaimed Islamic Federal Republic of
the Comoros.
Abdallah ruled Comoros for the remainder of his life, disbanding the UDC
in 1982 and replacing it with the Comorian Union for Progress as the nations
only legal party. Discord between Abdallah and Bob Denart inspired Supreme
Court judge Said Djohar to lead an uprising against Abdallah. On the day after
Abdallahs murder, Djohar assumed leadership of a new provisional government and became chief director of the African International Bank.
Ironically, Denarts mercenaries returned to depose Djohar in September 1995.
French authorities held him in Runion until January 1996, then permitted his
return to Comoros, where he briefly resumed his presidency. Rival Mohamed
Taki Abdoulkarim defeated Djohar in March 1996, whereupon Djohar retired
from public life.
Further Reading
Bratton, Michael, and Nicholas van de Walle. Democratic Experiments in Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
Ottenheimer, Martin, and Harriet Ottenheimer. Historical Dictionary of the Comoro Islands. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press, 1994.
Schraeder, Peter. African Politics and Society: A Mosaic in Transformation. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth, 2004.
Seddon, Peter. A Political and Economic Dictionary of Africa. London: Routledge, 2005.
Muslim Association in Cairo, Egypt. They were scheduled to meet Zaki Ali
Basha, a spokesman for King Farouk I, and negotiate a resolution of grievances
between the monarchy and al-Bannas rival Muslim Brotherhood. When Basha
failed to appear by 5:00 P.M., al-Banna and Mansur prepared to leave. They
stood outside, waiting for a taxi, when two gunmen approached and opened
fire at close range, fatally wounding both men.
Hasan al-Banna was born in Mahmoudiyah, northwest of Cairo in the Nile
Delta, on October 14, 1906. The son of a local imam (mosque leader) and
teacher of Hanbali (religious law of Sunni Islam), al-Banna was raised in accordance with strict conservative traditions. At age 13 he joined in demonstrations
against British colonial rule, and at 16 was initiated into Sufism, a mystical dimension of Islam defined by its leading scholars as a science whose objective
is the reparation of the heart and turning it away from all else but God. In
adulthood al-Banna struggled to earn a living, operating a watch-repair shop
and selling gramophones, while collaborating with fellow Sufis on theological
writings in his spare time. Married and relocated to Cairo in 1924, he found
himself unable to compete financially with manufacturers of cheap timepieces,
and he was increasingly distressed by the lax religious piety in Egypts capital.
Al-Bannas response, in March 1928, was the creation of the Society of Muslim Brothersmore commonly known as the Muslim Brotherhoodlaunched
as a quasi-fascist pan-Islamic political party, defining the Quran as the sole
reference point for . . . ordering the life of the Muslim family, individual, community . . . and state. The Suez Canal Company funded construction of the
Brotherhoods first mosque, at Ismailia, but al-Banna moved the headquarters
to Cairo four years later. From a membership of 800 in 1936, the Brotherhood
expanded to claim 200,000 by 1938, with branches established in Syria and
Transjordan. Despite recurring challenges to his leadership, al-Banna prevailed
as the movements general guide, steering the Brotherhood toward opposition
against British rule. A public admirer of Adolf Hitler, he nonetheless argued
for constitutional government to preserve in all its forms the freedom of the
individual citizen, to make the rulers accountable for their actions to the people and finally, to delimit the prerogatives of every single authoritative body.
A paramilitary wing carried out selective acts of terrorism, while al-Banna remained ambivalent toward violence.
World War II brought martial law to Egypt in 1941, and al-Banna was twice
imprisoned as a subversive. Brotherhood journals were suppressed, its meetings banned, and any reference to it in newspapers prohibited. Still the movement grew to include 2,000 branches by 1948, with an estimated two million
members. Renewed antigovernment violence in that year prompted a ban on
the Brotherhood in November 1948, with 32 leaders of its secret apparatus
arrested. Al-Bannas February 1949 meeting with Zaki Ali Basha was meant to
resolve that tension, but led to his own death instead.
Further Reading
Abdelkader, Deina. Islamic Activists: The Anti-Enlightenment Democrats. London: Pluto
Press, 2011.
Ikhwanweb: The Muslim Brotherhoods Official English Web site. http://www.ikhwanweb
.com.
Lia, Brynjar. The Society of the Muslim Brothers in Egypt: The Rise of an Islamic Mass
Movement. Reading, United Kingdom: Garnet, 1998.
ALBERT I OF HABSBURG
Mitchell, Richard. The Society of the Muslim Brothers. London: Oxford University Press,
1969.
Pargeter, Alison. The Muslim Brotherhood: The Burden of Tradition. London: Saqi Books,
2010.
Pryce-Jones, David. The Closed Circle: An Interpretation of the Arabs. Chicago: Ivan R.
Dee, 2009.
Rubin, Barry. The Muslim Brotherhood: The Organization and Policies of a Global Islamist
Movement. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
Albert continued scheming to obtain the throne, and by 1298 had secured
backing from several princes troubled over Adolfs alliance with Wenceslaus II.
The rival kings clashed at the Battle of Gllheim, on July 2, 1298, where Adolf
was slain. Albert was then elected to the thrown on July 27, and formally
crowned on August 24, though Pope Boniface VIII weakened his authority by
refusing to recognize Alberts election. Subsequent meddling in a quarrel over
succession to the Hungarian throne climaxed with Alberts defeat by Frederick I,
margrave of Meissen, at the Battle of Lucka on May 31, 1307.
Alberts final downfall resulted from a slight to John of Swabia in 1306. As
nephew of Albert, being the son of his younger brother, John suffered humiliation when Albert denied him his inheritance and placed his own son, Rudolf III,
on the Bohemian throne. Mocked thereafter as Duke Lackland, John plotted
Alberts murder with local allies and personally swung the axe that killed Albert on May 1, 1308. While Alberts sons sought vengeance, Duke Johnnow
dubbed John Parricida ( John the Parricide)escaped and vanished from history. Reports of his settlement at an Italian monastery, visited briefly by King
Henry VII of Luxembourg in 1313, remain unconfirmed. John appears briefly
in Friedrich Schillers play William Tell (1804), seeking Tells aid against a mutual enemy, Bailiff Albrecht Gessler. Tell refuses and suggests that John seek
papal absolution from Rome instead.
Further Reading
Berenger, Jean. A History of the Habsburg Empire, 12731700. Harlow, Essex: Longman
Group United Kingdom, 1994.
Holmes, George, ed. The Oxford History of Medieval Europe. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 1992.
Wheatcroft, Andrew. The Enemy at the Gate: Habsburgs, Ottomans, and the Battle for Europe. New York: Basic Books, 2008.
Wheatcroft, Andrew. The Habsburgs: Embodying Empire. New York: Penguin, 1997.
A L- D I N S H A H Q A JA R , N A S S E R
ALEXANDER I OF SERBIA
divorced him prior to his execution on August 10, 1896, while his son was reduced to being a slave.
Further Reading
Amanat, Abbas. Pivot of the Universe: Nasir al-Din Shah and the Iranian Monarchy,
18311896. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997.
Axworthy, Michael. A History of Iran: Empire of the Mind. New York: Basic Books, 2010.
Katouzian, Homa. The Persians: Ancient, Mediaeval and Modern Iran. New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press, 2010.
10
A L E X A N D E R I O F Y U G O S L AV I A
Nikodije and his brother, Nikola Main, died defending the palace, their corpses
tossed from a balcony onto a garden manure heap with Alexanders and Dragas. Captain Dimitrijevic, badly wounded, survived and was proclaimed the
savior of the fatherland by Serbias parliament, and appointed professor of
tactics at the nations military academy. Subsequently, as a leader of the secret
society Unification of Death, also called the Black Hand, Dimitrijevic plotted
unsuccessfully to kill Emperor Franz Joseph I of Austria in 1911, and played a
leading role in the 1914 assassination of Austrian archduke Franz Ferdinand.
The House of Karador
devi
c,
established through Dimitrijevics conspiracy,
ruled Serbiaand subsequently, Yugoslaviauntil King Peter II was deposed
and driven into exile in November 1945. Peter died in the United States in
1970, following a failed liver transplant to cure his longstanding cirrhosis.
Further Reading
Gildea, Robert. Barricades and Borders: Europe 18001914. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 2003.
Glenny, Misha. The Balkans: Nationalism, War, and the Great Powers, 18041999. New
York: Penguin, 2001.
Roberts, J. M. The European Empires. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002.
Sulzberger, C. L. The Fall of Eagles. New York: Crown, 1977.
A L E X A N D E R I O F Y U G O S L AV I A
11
12
ALEXANDER II OF RUSSIA
13
14
AMIN, HAFIZULLAH
Legislative Assembly in 1954, serving at various times as the provinces minister of law, food, agriculture, industry, parliamentary affairs, and commerce.
In October 1958, after Field Marshal Ayub Khan staged a military coup and
seized office as Pakistans president, declaring martial law nationwide, Ali was
jailed once more.
Released in 1959, Ali joined Mujibur Rahman Six Point Movement, agitating
for Bengali independence as the state of Bangladesh. With the outbreak of war in
March 1971, Ali went underground to lead the Mujibnagar government in exile,
serving as its minister of finance. Victory brought independence for Bangladesh
in December 1971, and Rahman emerged from prison to serve as the new nations first prime minister in January 1972, retaining Ali as minister of finance. In
January 1975, with Rahmans election to the presidency, Ali filled the prime ministers postan office left vacant following his murder, until June 1979.
On November 6, 1975, three days after Ali and his fellow inmates were murdered at Dhaka Central Jail, President Ahmad was himself deposed in a coup
led by two pro-Mujib military officers, Brigadier Khaled Mosharraf and Colonel Shafaat Jamil. The uprising unseated Rahman but failed to establish the
insurgents as rulers, with Mosharraf himself assassinated and Jamil arrested.
Ahmad survived the coup, succeeded by President Abu Sadat Mohammad
Sayem, but was imprisoned until 1978. On leaving prison, he formed a new
Democratic League and tried to revive his political career, but rallied no significant support. He died in 1996, shortly before Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina
opened fresh investigations of the 1975 political slayings.
Jail Killing Day is still commemorated in Dhaka each November 3, by
members of the Awami League. Twelve military officers were belatedly convicted for the murders in October 2004 and sentenced to death, eight of them
in absentia. The four in custodySyed Faruque Rahman, Shahriar Rashid
Khan, Mohammad Bazlul Huda, and A.K.M. Mohiuddin Ahmed were executed on January 28, 2010.
Further Reading
Lewis, David. Bangladesh: Politics, Economy and Civil Society. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 2011.
Mitchell, Neil. Democracys Blameless Leaders: From Dresden to Abu Ghraib, How Leaders
Evade Accountability for Abuse, Atrocity, and Killing. New York: New York University
Press, 2012.
Van Schendel, Willem. A History of Bangladesh. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2009.
15
16
AMIN, HAFIZULL AH
and effectively emasculating Amins. Furious, Amin staged a coup and arrested
Taraki on September 14, 1979, having him smothered with pillows (allegedly
on advice from Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev). On September 16 he replaced
Taraki as Afghanistans ruler.
Amin sought to pacify the mujahideen by dissociating himself from Taraki
and presenting himself as a devout Muslim, blaming Taraki for some 18,000
executions carried out since April 1978. Whereas that effort failed to win him
broad support, Amin also lost ground with the USSR. Never greatly admired
in Moscow, Amin seemed unaware that KGB agents had infiltrated the PDPA,
reporting on his secret meetings with anticommunist leader Gulbuddin Hekmatyar. Tataki loyalists exiled in Russia, branded Amin a CIA agent, even
as the murder of U.S. ambassador Adolph Dubs strained Amins relationship
with the United States. In early December 1979, when Amin proposed a summit meeting with Pakistani president Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq, Brezhnev and
Russias politburo announced their military-intervention plan. Soviet troops
crossed the border on December 24 and assaulted Amins Tajbeg Palace three
days later.
Before sending troops en masse to kill Amin, the Soviets first tried to poison
him (nearly killing a nephew), then sent a sniper to assassinate him (foiled by
tight security measures). A second poisoning attempt allegedly occurred mere
hours before the assault of December 27, causing Amin and several guests to
lose consciousness at a palace banquet celebrating Minister of Public Works
Ghulam Dastagir Panjsheris return from Moscow, but that near miss remains
unconfirmed. Amins successor, Babrak Karmal, promised sweeping democratic reforms but made limited progress before he was deposed, on orders
from Moscow, in November 1986.
Further Reading
Ansary, Tamim. Games without Rules: The Often-Interrupted History of Afghanistan. New
York: Public Affairs, 2012.
Coll, Steve. Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and Bin Laden, from
the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001. New York: Penguin Books, 2004.
Jones, Seth. In the Graveyard of Empires: Americas War in Afghanistan. New York: W. W.
Norton, 2010.
Male, Beverly. Revolutionary Afghanistan: A Reappraisal. London: Taylor & Francis,
1982.
Rasanayagam, Angelo. Afghanistan: A Modern History. London: I.B. Tauris, 2005.
17
18
AQ U I N O, B E N I G N O S I M E O N , J R .
senator Benigno Aquino Jr. Imprisoned from 1973 until a heart attack threatened his life in 1980, Aquino had been paroled to the United States for medical
treatment and had remained there in self-imposed exile since then. President
Marcos, unrelenting, had dispatched a prison van to collect Aquino and return
him to custody, with 1,000 soldiers to provide security. Despite that wall of
uniforms, supposed Communist Party member Rolando Galman allegedly shot
Aquino in the head as he left the aircraft, killing him instantly. Government
agents then riddled Galman with bullets.
Aquino was born in Concepcion on November 27, 1932, a descendant of
prosperous landowners, grandson of a general in Emilio Aguinaldos revolutionary army. His father served as vice president of Jos Laurels collaborationist government under Japanese occupation in World War II and died in 1947
while awaiting trial for treason. Educated in private schools, Aquino was the
youngest Filipino war correspondent during the Korean War, winning the
Philippine Legion of Honor at age 18 for courage under fire. Entering politics
at 22, he was elected mayor of Concepcion in 1955, as vice governor of Tarlac province in 1960, as governor in 1961, as secretary general of the Liberal
Party in 1966, and as the countrys youngest-ever senator in 1967. A year later,
Aquino launched an outspoken opposition to President Marcos, warning that
Marcos planned to establish a garrison state by militarizing our civilian government offices. Four years later, Marcos proved Aquino right with a declaration of martial law, imposing autocratic rule throughout the Philippines.
The precipitating cause of that announcement was a Liberal Party rally at
Manilas Plaza Miranda on August 21, 1971. Aquino was not present when
two hand grenades exploded in a crowd of 4,000, killing nine persons and
wounding 120. Liberals blamed President Marcos for the bombing, while
Marcos blamed the leftist New Peoples Army. Marcos suspended habeas corpus
and jailed Aquino with dozens of supposed Maoists, along with a bombing
suspect later identified as a sergeant of the Philippine Constabularys firearms and explosive section. Aquino subsequently claimed that the bomber,
once identified as a policeman, was spirited away and disappeared. Marcos
declared martial law on September 21, 1972, and Aquino was one of the
first subversives detained for trial by military commission on trumped-up
charges of murder and gunrunning. In the midst of his protracted trial, in
April 1975, Aquino declared a hunger strike to the death and shriveled to
75 pounds over the course of 40 days, before relenting and accepting nourishment. The court-martial dragged on until November 25, 1977, when Major
General Jose Syjuco convicted Aquino on all charges and sentenced him to
death by firing squad.
More delays ensued, while Marcos granted Aquino permission to participate in the 1978 parliamentary election from his prison cell, and granted him
a television interview on Face the Nation. That appearance rallied liberal support, but the partys candidates were buried in a Marcos landslide marked
19
20
A R AU J O, M A N U E L E N R I Q U E
Burton, Sandra. Impossible Dream: The Marcoses, the Aquinos, and the Unfinished Revolution. New York: Warner Books, 1959.
De Castro, Arturo. Mistrial: A Case Study of the Assassination of Senator Benigno S. Aquino, Jr.
Manila: Current Events Digest, 1986.
Festin Martinez, Manuel. The Grand Collision: Aquino vs. Marcos. Manila: Martinez,
1987.
Hill, Gerald. The True Story and Analysis of the Aquino Assassination. Aylesbury, United
Kingdom: Hilltop, 1984.
21
22
A R GA A F E R R A R O, L U I S M A R A D E L C O R A Z N D E J E S S D I O N I S I O
in 1958, and remained as a professor until he entered politics, with his election
to Paraguays Chamber of Deputies. He later served as a judge and as president
of Paraguays Supreme Court from 1983 to 1988, followed by a term as foreign minister (19891990). He lost a presidential bid in 1993, but rebounded
five years later with election as vice president.
Some observers speculated that Argaas murder may have been inspired by
his service as a judge, and later head of Paraguays judicial system, under the
despotic regime of Alfredo Stroessner Matiauda, who ruled the nation with an
iron hand from 1954 to 1989, while granting sanctuary to Nazi war criminals,
including Auschwitz Angel of Death Josef Mengele. Critics claimed that Argaa had used his position to abet and whitewash Stroessners reign of terror,
including political murders, torture, and unjust imprisonment amply documented by archives of terror discovered at a police station in the Asuncin
suburb of Lambar on December 22, 1992.
Another theory blamed Argaas death on ex-general Lino Csar Oviedo
Silva, commander of Paraguays army from 1993 until April 1996, when President Juan Carlos Wasmosy forced his resignation. Oviedo had threatened a
coup dtat, then relented when Wasmosy offered him a post as minister of
defensethen reneged on the day of Oviedos scheduled swearing-in ceremony. Embittered, Oviedo ran for president in 1998 and won the ruling Colorado Partys nomination, then was slapped with a 10-year prison term a month
before election day, for his abortive coup attempt in 1996. Running mate Ral
Cubas went on to win the election and liberated Oviedo days after taking office
in August 1998, over protests from opposition leaders and the Paraguayan Supreme Court. Luis Argaa was inaugurated as vice president of Paraguay under
Cubas, on August 15.
Argentina granted asylum to General Oviedo upon his departure from
prison, and refused an extradition request from Paraguays National Congress
following Argaas murder. Oviedo subsequently left for Brazil, where expresident Cubas had settled following his impeachment, then returned to Paraguay voluntarily on June 28, 2004. Arrested on arrival, he was taken to the
military prison at Vias Cu, near Asuncin, to complete his original 10-year
sentence. Authorities paroled him for good behavior on September 6, 2007, and
Paraguays Supreme Court overturned Oviedos conviction on October 30, 2007,
by a vote of eight to one, deciding that no coup dtat was actually attempted
in 1996.
Thus vindicated, Oviedo resumed his campaign for the presidency. In January 2008, he was nominated without opposition by a Colorado Party splinter
group, the National Union of Ethical Citizens. Whereas Oviedos party won
25 congressional seats in Aprils election, Oviedo lost his bid to rival Fernando
Armindo Lugo Mndez, candidate of the Patriotic Alliance for Change. Oviedo
received only 22.8 percent of the popular vote nationwide.
ASSASSINS CULT
Further Reading
Calvert, Peter. A Political and Economic Dictionary of Latin America. London: Europa
Publications, 2004.
Lambert, Peter. Muero con mi patria! Myth, Political Violence, and the Construction
of National Identity in Paraguay. In Political Violence and the Construction of Identity
in Latin America. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006.
Miranda, Carlos. The Stroessner Era: Authoritarian Rule in Paraguay. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1990.
Mora, Frank, and Jerry Cooney. Paraguay and the United States: Distant Allies. Athens:
University of Georgia Press, 2007.
23
24
A S S A S S I N S C U LT
early 12th century. Grand master Sabbah died at Alamut in 1124, succeeded
by Kiya Buzurg-Ummid, and the sect grew stronger than ever. Its next wellknown victim, in 1125, was Abul-Fad.l Ibn al-Khashshab, the foremost Shia
qadi ( judge) at Aleppo, Syria. A year later, also in Aleppo, a fedayin assassin
killed Emir Porsuki on November 26, 1126.
Later in the 12th century, Assassins seized nine castles in Syrias An-Nusayriyah
Mountains. From one of those, at Masyaf, Old Man of Mountain Rashid ad-Din
Sinan ran his own branch of the order, virtually independent of the grand master
at Alamut. Pledged to kill Saladin, the Kurdish Muslim sultan of Syria and Egypt,
Sinan twice dispatched assassins who failed to complete their assignment. Saladin
laid siege to Masyaf in August 1176, then retired after finding a threatening note
in his tent, pinned to a table with a poisoned dagger. Sinans last major contract
claimed the life of Conrad of Montferrat, elected king of Jerusalem on April 24,
1192, and killed four days later, allegedly on orders from King Richard I of England. Sinan himself died that same year, his successor handpicked by then
grand master Nur al-din Muhammad at Alamut.
Mongol invaders under Hulagu Khan laid siege to Alamut, commanded
at the time by Imam Rukn al-Din Khurshah, on December 15, 1256. Khurshah surrendered his stronghold soon thereafter, and although fedayin warriors
briefly recaptured the fortress in 1275, they were soon routed, the survivors
scattered and vanishing into obscurity. Mamluk Sultan Baibars of Egypt seized
control of the orders Syrian wing in 1273 and used its members as killers for
hire. Moroccan author Ibn Battuta (13041368) claims that remaining Assassins finally resulted to taqiyya, a tactic of religious dissimulation masking their
beliefs in mainstream Muslim society while waitingin vain, it appearsfor a
new leader to awaken them.
It comes as no surprise, perhaps, that the Assassins cult has featured frequently in literature, film, on televisioneven in modern computer and video
games. Friedrich Nietzsche seemed to admire the order when, in 1887, his On
the Genealogy of Morality referred to that invincible Order of Assassins. Vladimir Bartol, by contrast, seemed to take a decidedly negative view in his novel
Alamut (1938), though later critics maintain that he compared the order favorably to antifascist resistance fighters in his native Slovenia. Louis LAmour,
best known for novels set in the American Old West, departed from type with
The Walking Drum (1984), in which 12th-century hero Mathurin Kerbouchard
seeks to rescue his father from the Assassins. Peter Berlings The Children of the
Grail (1996) also examines the Assassins in their historical setting, and other
novelsDan Browns Angels & Demons (2000) and A. W. Hills Nowhere-Land
(2009)imagine the orders survival into modern times. In comics, the Assassins have contended both with ancient warrior Conan the Barbarian and quasisupernatural Wild West gunman Jonah Hex.
ASSASSINS CULT
25
B
BAHONAR, MOHAMMAD-JAVAD
(19331981)
On August 30, 1981, a bomb exploded in the Tehran office of Iranian prime
minister Mohammad-Javad Bahonar. The blast killed Bahonar, as well as
President Mohammad-Ali Rajai and three other members of the Islamic Republican Party. Survivors described the explosion occurring when one victim
opened a briefcase, brought into the office by Massoud Kashmiri, a state security official. Subsequent investigation revealed that Kashmiri was an agent
of the leftist Peoples Mujahedin of Iran (MEK), supported by Iraqi dictator
Saddam Hussein and blamed for 17,000 Iranian deaths during the IranIraq
War of 19801988.
Bahonar was born in Kerman, Iran, on September 3, 1933. A Muslim cleric
and author of textbooks on Islamic studies, he also engaged in politics and was
jailed in 1963, during protests led by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini against Shah
Mohammad Reza Pahlavis White Revolutiona program of supposed reforms
designed primarily to strengthen and legitimize the Pahlavi dynasty. Upon release
from custody, Bahonar abstained from further activism until the Islamic Revolution of 19781979 drove the shah into exile and established Khomeini as Irans de
facto ruler. For his service in the revolution, Bahonar was named to lead the new
governments ministry of culture and Islamic guidance, essentially responsible for
censoring any media disapproved by Muslim leaders in Tehran. From that post, he
also directed a purge of all secular influence from Iranian universities.
The outbreak of war with Iraq, in September 1980, hampered but did not
derail the ultraconservative Iranian Cultural Revolution. Mayhem on the home
front escalated as the MEKfounded by leftist Iranian students in 1965 to
oppose Shah Pahlavishifted focus to attack to attack Khomeinis rigid theocracy and its political organ, the Islamic Republican Party (IRP). Irans first
elected president, Abulhassan Banisadr, took office in February 1980 but was
impeached in June 1981 for bucking clerical authority. One week after his
removal, MEK militants bombed IRP headquarters, killing 70 high-ranking
members. In that tense atmosphere, presidential successor Mohammad-Ali
Rajai chose Mohammad-Javad Bahonar as his running mate. They won the
election with 91 percent of the popular vote, but survived less than four weeks
after taking office on August 4, 1981.
28
BALBINUS
BALBINUS
Emperor Balbinus of Rome, assassinated by his palace guards in 238 C.E. (Getty Images)
of the Second Parthian Legion. The senate then approached 79-year-old Gordian, regional governor of North Africa, who demurred until his son was accepted as co-emperor. Accordingly, Gordian I and II were named to rule in
tandem, but they reigned for only 36 days. Gordian II died fighting soldiers
loyal to Maximus at the Battle of Carthage, and Gordian I hanged himself
on learning of his sons demise. Next, on April 22, the senate elected elderly
members Balbinus and Pupienus as co-emperors, a decision so unpopular
with Gordian loyalists that they thronged Romes streets, pelting both men
with sticks and stones. As a pacifying measure, senators named Marcus Antonius Gordianus Pius Augustus, 13-year-old grandson of Gordian I, to nominally reign as Caesar, thus presumably defusing anger against Balbinus and
Pupienus.
29
30
B A L E WA , A B U B A K A R TA FAWA
That stopgap measure failed to guarantee smooth governance, however. Dissension simmered between Balbinus and Pupienus from the first day of their
joint reign, each emperor fearing assassination by the other. Seeking to crown
their election with military laurels, thereby achieving some legitimacy, they
planned an ambitious dual campaign, Balbinus plotting to subjugate the Carpians (inhabiting the eastern region of present-day Moldavia), and Pupienus
targeted the Parthians (occupying northeastern Iran). Collaborating on logistics failed to heal the rift between the emperors, however. Balbinus and Pupienus were engaged in yet another bitter quarrel on July 29, when disgusted
Praetorian Guards burst in and hacked both men to death.
With Gordian III still too young to rule, control of the empire was ceded to
aristocratic families who directed Romes affairs through the senate. Gordian
married Furia Sabinia Tranquillina, daughter of the newly appointed praetorian prefect Timesitheus, who assumed de facto rule of Rome until his death in
243. The following year, Gordian died combating Persian invaders at the Battle
of Misiche. Quickly deified by the senate, he was succeeded by Marcus Julius
Philippus Augustus, also called Philip the Arab.
Further Reading
Frey, Oliver. Complete Chronicle of the Emperors of Rome. Ludlow, United Kingdom:
Thalamus Publishing, 2005.
Grant, Michael. The Roman Emperors: A Biographical Guide to the Rulers of Imperial Rome
31 BCAD 476. New York: Charles Scribners Sons, 1985.
Kerrigan, Michael. Dark History of the Roman Emperors. London: Amber Books, 2012.
Potter, David. Emperors of Rome: Imperial Rome from Julius Caesar to the Last Emperor.
London: Quercus Books, 2008.
Scarre, Chris. Chronicle of the Roman Emperors: The Reign-by-Reign Record of the Rulers
of Imperial Rome. London: Thames & Hudson, 1995.
B A L E WA , A B U B A K A R TA FAWA
31
32
B A N D A R A N A I K E , S O L O M O N W E S T R I D G E W AY D I A S
B A N D A R A N A I K E , S O L O M O N W E S T R I D G E WAY D I A S
33
34
B AU T I S TA G I L L GA R C A D E L B A R R I O, J UA N
as a wealthy businessman and heavy drinker (an offense for Buddhist monks),
who had engaged in a sexual affair with Minister of Health Wimala Wijewardene, the only female member of Bandaranaikes cabinet. Convicted of murder
and sentenced to death in 1961, Buddharakkitha saw his sentence commuted
to life imprisonment on appeal. He died in prison, from a heart attack, in
1967. Talduwe Somarama was hanged on July 7, 1962. A third conspirator,
businessman H. P. Jayawardena, also received a life sentence.
Further Reading
De Alwis, Malathi. Gender, Politics, and the Respectable Lady. In Unmaking the
Nation: The Politics of Identity & History in Modern Sri Lanka. Colombo, Sri Lanka:
Social Scientists Association, 1995.
Manor, James. The Bandaranaike Legend. In The Sri Lanka Reader: History, Culture,
Politics. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2011.
Manor, James. The Expedient Utopian: Bandaranaike and Ceylon. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1990.
Tambiah, Stanley. Buddhism Betrayed? Religion, Politics, and Violence in Sri Lanka. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1992.
Weiss, Gordon. The Cage: The Fight for Sri Lanka and the Last Days of the Tamil Tigers.
New York: Bellevue Literary Press, 2012.
B E C K E T, T H O M A S
taking office on November 25 with cousin Jos Higinio Uriarte y Garca del
Barrio as vice president. Their administration initiated use of paper currency
and substantially increased taxation, while adopting the Argentine Civil Code
in a bid to stabilize Paraguays ravaged economy. Another statute, the Tobacco
Law of April 1875, granted the government a five-year monopoly on tobacco
exports while barring private dealers from the trade. The same law imposed a
three-year government monopoly on trading in salt and soap. Those measures
were predictably unpopular, as was the border treaty signed with Argentina on
February 3, 1876, surrendering Misiones Province and adjacent territory, plus
some islands in the Paran River. Bautistas establishment of a National College
in Asuncin failed to offset criticism of his other policies.
General Germain Serrano, former minister of the interior, led an insurrection against Bautistas regime at Caacup in December 1875, but that uprising collapsed with the death of Serrano and other rebel leaders. Conspiracies
against the president continued, however, with Don Juan Silvano Godoi hatching the plot that finally succeeded in April 1877. Following Bautistas assassination, Silvano spent 18 years in Buenos Aires, finally returning to Paraguay in
1895. Six years later he was appointed general director of the National Library
of Paraguay.
Vice President Higinio Uriarte completed Bautistas four-year term, succeeded by Cndido Pastor Bareiro Caballero, former Paraguayan charg
daffaires in Europe. Under his administration, Paraguay reclaimed some territory from Argentina's Ro de la Plata basin, subsequently named the Presidente
Hayes Department, after U.S. president Rutherford Hayes, who helped negotiate the transition.
Further Reading
Bethell, Leslie. The Cambridge History of Latin America, Vol. 5: c. 18701930. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Lewis, Paul. Political Parties and Generations in Paraguays Liberal Era, 18691940. Chapel
Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1993.
Tuohy, John. Biographical Sketches from the Paraguayan War18641870. Charleston,
SC: CreateSpace, 2011.
35
36
B E C K E T, T H O M A S
B E C K E T, T H O M A S
Meanwhile, Henry II had decided to crown his son, Henry the Young, as
kinga move that required approval from Canterburys archbishop. Becket
resisted, whereupon the coronation proceeded without him in June 1170,
performed by archbishop of York Roger de Pont Lvque, joined by bishop
of London Gilbert Foliot and bishop of Salisbury Josceline de Bohon. Becket
excommunicated all three in November, whereupon the three fled to Normandy. At that point, Henry uttered his famous rhetorical question, transcribed in various histories as Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest? or
What miserable drones and traitors have I nourished and brought up in my
household, who let their lord be treated with such shameful contempt by a
low-born cleric? Whatever the precise wording, Beckets assassins interpreted
Henrys words as a royal command and proceeded to kill Becket upon his return to England.
Pope Alexander III canonized Becket on February 21, 1173. Two months later,
French noblemen led a rebellion against Henry II in France (see sidebar), prompting Henry to perform acts of penance at Beckets tomb and at the Church of
St. Dunstans, Canterbury, in July 1174. Beckets killers fled to North Yorkshire
and were excommunicated in March 1171 by Pope Alexander, who further sentenced them to 14 years exile in Jerusalem. They were never charged in England,
nor required to forfeit any of their lands. Thomas Beckets remains were exhumed
in 1220 and transferred to a shrine at Canterbury Cathedrals Trinity Chapel.
REVOLT OF 11731174
Henry the Young mourned Thomas Beckets assassination as the slaying
of his surrogate father. Married by that time to a daughter of French king
Louis VII (also first husband of young Henrys mother, Eleanor of Aquitaine), young Henry was 18 in April 1173, when the Counts of Flanders and
Boulogne rose against his father, invading Normandy. Young Henry joined
in the attack, while William the Lion, king of Scots, launched an offensive
in Northumberland. Henry II defeated those offensives, but the rebellion
continued as the Earl of Leicester raised an army of Flemish mercenaries
and crossed from Normandy to England, joining forces with Hugh Bigod,
1st Earl of Norfolk. That thrust also failed, when it was met by superior
forces under Richard de Luci, chief justiciar of England. Even then, fighting continued until July 1174, when Henry II returned from France and
pacified most opponents with public acts of penance for Beckets slaying.
Henry and his son reconciled in September 1174, but the younger Henry
led a new rebellion in 1183. He died from dysentery in June of that year,
during a campaign against his father and brother Richard, later called The
Lionheart.
37
38
39
40
Klein, Herbert. A Concise History of Bolivia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003.
Scheina, Robert. Latin Americas Wars: The Age of the Caudillo, 17911899. Dulles, VA:
Potomac Books, 2003.
41
42
B E N T, C H A R L E S
Mickolus, Edward, and Susan Simmons. The Terrorist List. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger,
2011.
Woodworth, Paddy. Dirty Wars, Clean Hands: The ETA, the GAL, and Spanish Democracy.
Cork: Cork University Press, 2001.
Zulaika, Joseba. Terrorism: The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy. Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 2009.
BHUTTO, BENAZIR
Embudo Pass on January 29, and at Taos on February 35, 1847. Rebels repulsed a second force under Captain Israel Hendley at Mora, on January 24, but
were routed by Captain Jesse Morins troops on February 1. Pueblo rebel leader
Toms Romero was captured and jailed at Taos, shot dead in his cell by Private John Fitzgerald on February 8 without the formality of trial. A subsequent
court-martial convicted Jose Montoya and 14 other rebels on charges of murder
and treason against the territorial government. Montoya and five more rebels
were hanged on April 9, 1847, with the remainder executed two weeks later.
Meanwhile, combat between insurgents and occupying troops continued at Red
River Canyon (May 2627), Las Vegas ( July 6), and Cienega Creek ( July 9).
Further Reading
Crutchfield, James. Tragedy at Taos: The Revolt of 1847. Dallas: Republic of Texas Press,
1995.
Dunbar-Ortiz, Roxanne, and Simon Ortiz. Roots of Resistance: A History of Land Tenure
in New Mexico. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2007.
Durand, John. The Taos Massacres. Elkhorn, WI: Puzzlebox Press, 2004.
Flint, F. Harlan. Hispano Homesteaders, The Last New Mexico Pioneers, 18501910. Santa Fe,
NM: Sunstone Press, 2012.
Sides, Hampton. Blood and Thunder: The Epic Story of Kit Carson and the Conquest of the
American West. New York: Anchor Books, 2006.
43
44
B H U T T O, B E N A Z I R
B I N L A D E N , O S A M A B I N M O H A M M E D B I N AWA D
that killed 136 other victims and wounded 450. Two weeks later, on November 3, President Pervez Musharraf declared a nationwide state of emergency,
briefly placing Bhutto under house arrest until public outrage forced her release. Bhutto proceeded with her plan to win a third term as prime minister,
aborted by the suicide attack that claimed her life.
Al-Qaeda field commander Saeed al-Masri claimed responsibility for Bhuttos assassination, whereas the Pakistani government spokesmen named Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud as the attacks planner. Bhuttos family and the
PPP disputed both claims, blaming opponents in the militaryintelligence
community. A U.S. drone aircraft killed Mehsud at the home of his second
wifes father, on August 5, 2009, and another killed al-Masri with his wife and
three children on May 21, 2010. An antiterrorism court in Rawalpindi ordered
ex-president Musharrafs arrest on February 12, 2011, charging him with complicity in Bhuttos assassination, and the Sindh High Court charged him with
treason on March 8, 2011. At the time of this writing, he remains in London,
battling extradition.
Further Reading
Bhatia, Shyam. Goodbye Shahzadi: A Political Biography of Benazir Bhutto. New Delhi:
Lotus Roli Books, 2008.
Bhutto, Fatima. Songs of Blood and Sword: A Daughters Memoir. New York: Nation
Books, 2010.
Hughes, Libby. Benazir Bhutto: From Prison to Prime Minister. Lincoln, NE: iUniverse, 2000.
Hussain, Zahid. Frontline Pakistan: The Path to Catastrophe and the Killing of Benazir
Bhutto. London: I.B. Tauris, 2008.
United Nations Security Council. Report of the United Nations Commission of Inquiry
into the Facts and Circumstances of the Assassination of Former Pakistani Prime Minister
Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto. Blue Ridge Summit, PA: United Nations Publications, 2009.
45
46
B I N L A D E N , O S A M A B I N M O H A M M E D B I N AWA D
26 children. By the time of his first marriage, bin Ladens father and a halfbrother were partners with future U.S. president George H. W. Bush in the
Carlyle Group, a U.S.-based global asset management firm. In 1979, bin Laden
received a degree in civil engineering from King Abdulaziz University, then
moved to Pakistan, joining the CIA-assisted mujahideen resistance to Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. In August 1988, six months before the Soviet withdrawal, bin Laden organized al-Qaeda (The Base, in Arabic) to lift the word
of God, to make his religion victorious. In August 1990, following Iraqs invasion of Kuwait, bin Laden offered to defend Saudi Arabia in the event of an
attack. FBI agents raided the New Jersey home of al-Qaeda associate El Sayyid
Nosair two months later, discovering plans to bomb Manhattan skyscrapers.
Nosair subsequently confessed his involvement in the November 7, 1990,
murder of controversial rabbi Meyer Kahane.
Bin Laden, meanwhile, broke with the Saudi government over its U.S.
ties and was banished to Sudan in 1992, and stripped of his Saudi citizenship in 1994. In 1995, he joined in an abortive plot to kill Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak. May 1996 found bin Laden back in Afghanistan,
where he issued a declaration of war against the United States three months
later, declaring that the evils of the Middle East arose from Americas attempt to take over the region and from its support for Israel. Saudi Arabia
had been turned into an American colony. With Taliban support, he effectively seized control of Ariana Afghan Airlines, using it to shuttle terrorists
around the world.
Mayhem ensued, beginning with al-Qaedas bombing of the Gold Mihor
Hotel in Yemen, killing two persons on December 29, 1992. Principals in the
February 1993 World Trade Centers bombing were linked to al-Qaeda, though
the attack was not an official bin Laden project. Bin Laden financed the Luxor
massacre of November 17, 1997, which killed 62 civilians at an Egyptian archaeological site, and coordinated the bombings of U.S. embassies in Nairobi,
Kenya, and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, killing 223 persons and wounding more
than 4,000. In October 2000, al-Qaeda suicide bombers struck the destroyer
USS Cole in Aden, killing 17 seamen and injuring 39. Investigation of the 1998
embassy bombings placed bin Laden on the FBIs most wanted list, with a $6
million reward for information leading to his capture (subsequently increased
to $25 million).
On September 11, 2001, al-Qaeda members executed the worst terrorist
strikes in U.S. history, hijacking four airliners and using them as vehicles for
suicide attacks. Targets included New Yorks World Trade Centers, the Pentagon, and the White House, but passengers aboard the plane en route to strike
the presidential residence overpowered their kidnappers, crashing the jet into
a field near Shanksville, Pennsylvania. The days grim toll included 2,996 dead,
with more than 6,000 injured. On the same day, bin Ladens half-brother Shafig
B I N L A D E N , O S A M A B I N M O H A M M E D B I N AWA D
47
48
B I S H O P, M A U R I C E R U P E R T
49
50
B I S H O P, M A U R I C E R U P E R T
Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet and spoke publicly on paranormal subjects, declaring 1978 The Year of the UFO. Bishop and the NJM deposed
Gairy on March 13, 1979, suspending Grenadas constitution and ruling by
decree in the name of a Peoples Revolutionary Government, inviting Cuban
teachers, technicians, and physicians to help improve the countrys standard of living. Even then, the socialist reforms were not enough for hard-line
Marxists in the NJM, who rallied around Bernard Coard to unseat Bishop
in 1983.
Following Bishops execution, General Hudson Austin of the Peoples Revolutionary Army named himself chairman of a military junta. To forestall protests, Austin imposed a four-day total curfew, warning that any person found
away from home without official sanction would be shot on sight. Word soon
reached Washington that Cuban soldiers and construction workers were building a new 10,000-foot landing strip, presumably for use by military aircraft.
On October 23, President Ronald Reagan initiated Operation Urgent Fury,
invading Grenada with 7,300 U.S. troops and 353 supporting forces from various Caribbean nations. At a reported cost of 113 dead and 533 wounded, invaders toppled the juntaand incidentally rescued a number of U.S. medical
students from St. Georges University. The United Nations General Assembly,
by a vote of 108 to 9, condemned the invasion as a flagrant violation of international law.
In the wake of that invasion, Hudson Austin, Bernard Coard, his wife Phyllis, and various others were arrested on charges of murdering Bishop. At trial
in 1986, Austin, Coard, and six others were sentenced to death, but their penalty was later commuted to life imprisonment. In February 2007, Londons Judicial Committee of the Privy Council ordered resentencing of the defendants,
and in June their prison terms were reduced to 30 years. Austin and two others were released on December 18, 2008. Bernard Coard was the last to leave
prison, on September 5, 2009.
Further Reading
Adkin, Mark. Urgent Fury: The Battle for Grenada. Philadelphia: Trans-Atlantic Publications, 1989.
Brizan, George. Grenada: Island of Conflict. New York: Macmillan Caribbean, 1998.
Gilmore, William. The Grenada Intervention: Analysis and Documentation. New York:
Facts on File, 1984.
Marcus, Bruce, and Michael Taber. Maurice Bishop Speaks: The Grenada Revolution and
Its Overthrow 197983. Atlanta: Pathfinder Press, 1983.
Sandford, Gregory, and Richard Vigilante. Grenada: The Untold Story. Toronto: Madison
Books, 1984.
Seaga, Edward. The Grenada Intervention: The Inside Story. Kingston, Jamaica: University of the West Indies, 2009.
B O B R I K O V, N I K O L AY I VA N O V I C H
51
52
BOLLES, DON
BOLLES, DON
Back in civilian life, he joined the Associated Press, working in New York,
New Jersey, and Kentucky before Republic editor Eugene Pulliam hired him
in 1962. From sports reporting, Bolles quickly advanced to the investigative
beat, probing Mafia influence on Arizona dog and horse racing, revealing
bribery and kickbacks on the state tax and corporation commissions, exposing
real-estate swindles, and spotlighting a conflict-of-interest scandal involving
state legislators. In 1974, he was honored as Arizona Press Club Newsman of
the Year.
But by the next year, colleagues noted signs of disillusionment and burnout. Bolles requested and received a transfer from the crime beat to city government and the state legislature. It should have been less hazardous, but the
fatal bombing and Bolless final words suggested he was still probing organized
crime. Although the motive for his death remains obscure, early suspicion focused on Kemper Marley, Arizonas godfather of land fraud and a longtime
partner in the liquor trade with John Hensley, father-in-law of Senator John
McCain. Marley was never charged, however, though police did net a clutch
of suspects.
On the day Bolles died, Phoenix detectives arrested John Harvey Adamson, a
racing-dog owner and the informant who stood Bolles up on June 2. On January 15, 1977, Adamson confessed planting a remote-control bomb in Bolless
car, on orders from contractor Max Dunlap, assisted by plumber James Robison.
Adamson agreed to provide evidence on behalf of the state in exchange for a
20-year sentence, providing testimony that convicted Dunlap and Robison of
murder on November 6, 1977. Both men were sentenced to death in January
1978, but marathon appeals ensued. Arizonas Supreme Court ordered a new
trial in February 1980, but Adamson balked at testifying a second time. Murder
charges against both defendants were dismissed in June 1980, and authorities
revoked Adamsons plea bargain and charged him with first-degree murder. Convicted in October 1980 and sentenced to death the following month, Adamson
saw his sentence reduced to life imprisonment on appeal in May 1986 and again
(after its reinstatement) in December 1988.
Meanwhile, prosecutors refiled murder charges against Robison in November 1989, and against Dunlap in December 1990. They were granted
separate trials, with Dunlap convicted in April 1993 (receiving life with no
parole for 25 years), and jurors acquitted Robison in December 1993. On
cross-examination at his trial, Robison admitted asking a fellow inmate to
kill Adamson, a separate crime that earned him five years in federal prison
following a July 1995 guilty plea. John Adamson left prison on August 12,
1996, and entered the federal Witness Protection Program, then emerged
from hiding in the early 21st century. Robison was paroled in 1998, at age 76.
Dunlap died in prison on July 21, 2009. No suspects have been positively
named to date as instigators of the bombing.
53
54
B O R G I A , G I O VA N N I
EMPRISE CORPORATION
The company named as such by Don Bolles in his dying remarks was
founded in Buffalo, New York, in 1915. Its creatorsbrothers Charles,
Louis, and Marvin Jacobsoperated concession stands in various sporting
venues and theaters, expanding from the 1920s through the 1950s with
financial support that included interest-free loans from recognized Mafia
bosses in Cleveland and Detroit. Emprise, in return, occasionally granted
loans to mobsters, including Las Vegas godfather Moe Dalitz. Business
flourished under the firms original name, and later as Sportservice. In
1939, the company acquired its first racetrack, reborn in 1980 as Delaware
North Companies Gaming & Entertainment. In 1987, Delaware North acquired Sky Chefs, gaining a foothold in airports nationwide. Six years later,
it won the contract to provide visitor services in Yosemite National Park.
In 1995, the company assumed management of Floridas Kennedy Space
Center Visitor Complex. Delaware North entered the European market in
2006, with a contract for Londons Emirates Stadium, followed by another
for Wembley Stadium in 2007. By 2010, the company owned several casinos and had assumed management of RMS Queen Mary, permanently
docked at Long Beach, California. No link between the firm and the assassination of Don Bolles has been established.
Further Reading
Headly, Lake. Loud and Clear: The Don Bolles Murder Case. New York: Henry Holt,
1990.
Kaiser, Robert Blair. Desert Injustice. n.p. Amazon Digital Services, 2011.
Tallberg, Martin. Don Bolles: An Investigation into His Murder. New York: Popular
Library, 1977.
Wendland, Michael. The Arizona Project: How a Team of Investigative Reporters Got
Revenge on Deadline. Riverside, NJ: Sheed Andrews and McMeel, 1977.
B O R G I A , G I O VA N N I
failed to reappear next day, a search began and authorities found a Tiber boatman who had seen a man leading a horse with an apparent body draped across
its saddle. Moments later, after someone said, My lord, there came a splash.
Officers dragged the river and retrieved Borgias body, torn by nine stab wounds,
with 30 gold ducats still in his purse.
Giovanni Borgiaalso known as Juan or Joanwas the son of Pope
Alexander VI. Clerical vows of celibacy notwithstanding, Alexander also
sired Giovannis siblings Cesare, Lucrezia, and Gioffre. Different records cite
his year of birth as 1474 and 1476, with most historians today accepting the
latter date, which makes Cesare the oldest Borgia son and Giovanni the second of four children. In September 1493, Borgia married Maria Enriquez de
Luna, Spanish fiance of his deceased elder half-brother Pier Luigi de Borgia,
1st Duke of Ganda.
In the atmosphere of 15th-century Rome, motives for Borgias murder were
plentiful. Some observers suspected brother Cesare, Duke of Valentinois, noting that Giovannis death cleared the way for Cesare to launch a long-awaited
military career in the Italian War of 14991504. Others suspected that the
murder may have sprung from Giovannis dalliance with Sancha of Aragon,
illegitimate daughter of King Alfonso II of Naples. Sancha had married the
younger Borgia brother Gioffre in 1494, but still enjoyed romantic liaisons
with Cesare and Giovanni. Further confusing matters, Sanchas brother Alfonso married Lucrezia Borgia in 1498 and was murdered in 1500, allegedly
on orders from Cesare. By that time, as historian Barbara Tuchman observed,
In the bubbling stew of Romes rumors, no depravity appeared beyond the
scope of the Borgias. Even Pope Alexander was not immune from suspicion: humorist Jacopo Sannazaro dubbed him a fisher of men, referring to
Giovannis discovery in the Tiber.
Although no sure verdict is possible in Giovannis slaying, the House of Borgia is indelibly linked to murder. Historian Johann Burchard (ca. 14501506)
wrote of Cesare: One day he went so far as to have the square of St. Peter enclosed by a palisade, into which he ordered some prisonersmen, women and
childrento be brought. He then had them bound, hand and foot, and being
armed and mounted on a fiery charger, commenced a horrible attack upon
them. Some he shot, and others he cut down with his sword, trampling them
under his horses feet. In less than half-an-hour, he wheeled around alone in a
puddle of blood, among the dead bodies of his victims, while his Holiness and
Madam Lucrezia, from a balcony, enjoyed the sight of that horrid scene.
Like other famous assassination victims, Giovanni Borgia survives in popular fiction. His murder is a central feature of Mario Puzos novel The Family
(2001), and is portrayed in various films and television series: the 2010 animated short film Assassins Creed: Ascendance; the French/German series Borgia
(2011); and the second season of Showtimes series The Borgias (2012).
55
56
B O R S E L L I N O, PAO L O
Further Reading
Cloulas, Ivan. The Borgias. Danbury, CT: Franklin Watts, 1989.
Hibbert, Christopher. The Borgias and Their Enemies: 14311519. New York: Mariner
Books, 2009.
Johnson, Marion. The Borgias. New York: Penguin, 2002.
Mallett, Michael. The Borgias: The Rise and Fall of the Most Infamous Family in History.
Chicago: Academy Chicago Publishers, 2005.
B O U D I A F, M O H A M E D
of silence (omert) in exchange for leniency at trial. Mafiosi killed Rocco Chinnici in
July 1983, followed by Palermo chief of police Antonino Cassar in August 1985,
ex-mayor Giuseppe Insalaco in January 1988, Magistrate Rosario Livatino in September 1990, Supreme Court prosecutor Antonio Scopelliti in August 1991, and Salvo
Lima, another ex-mayor, in March 1992. On May 21, 1992, a half-ton car bomb
killed Giovanni Falcone, his wife, and three bodyguards on the highway between Palermon International Airport and the citys center.
Borsellino, serving since 1986 as chief prosecutor of Marsala, knew that he
was on the Mafias hit list. In his last interview, taped on the day of Falcones
assassination, Borsellino announced plans to probe links between the Mafia
wealthy Italian businessmen such as future prime minister Silvio Berlusconi.
Curiously, that interviewtaped by French journalistsdid not air in Italy
until 2000, with 20 minutes cut from its original 50-minute length.
Authorities named Mafia boss Salvatore Tot Riina, alias The Beast, as
the mastermind of the Falcone and Borsellino murders. He remained at large,
in hiding, until Carabinieri officers surprised him at traffic light in Palermo,
on January 15, 1993. Police credited informer Baldassare Di Maggio, Riinas
former chauffeur, with directing them to Riina, a revelation that led to the
murders of several Di Maggio relatives. At his first trial, in October 1993,
Riina was convicted of ordering hits on brothers Pietro and Vincenzo Puccio,
resulting in a life sentence. In 1998, he was convicted of Salvo Limas murder.
Meanwhile, in 1996, Giovanni Bruscanamed as the hit man who planted
the Falcone bombwas captured and turned informer. His testimony added further life terms to Riinas slate, for ordering the murders of Falcone and
Borsellino.
Palermo International Airport was subsequently renamed FalconeBorsellino
Airport, featuring a memorial to the slain magistrates by sculptor Tommaso
Geraci. Borsellinos sister Rita ran for president in the Sicilian regional election
of 2006, but lost to incumbent Salvatore Tot Cuffarowho was convicted of
collaboration with the Mafia in January 2008, receiving a five-year sentence.
Further Reading
Dickie, John. Cosa Nostra: A History of the Sicilian Mafia. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005.
Maran, A.G.D. Mafia: Inside the Dark Heart. New York: Thomas Dunne Books, 2010.
Seindal, Ren. Mafia: Money and Politics in Sicily 19501997. Copenhagen: Museum
Tusculanum Press, 1998.
Stille, Alexander. Excellent Cadavers: The Mafia and the Death of the First Italian Republic.
New York: Vintage, 1996.
57
58
B O U D I A F, M O H A M E D
BUBACK, SIEGFRIED
formed in 1988. In January 1992, Algerias military junta invited Boudiaf to return
from exile, accepting leadership of a new High Council of State, a figurehead
group hastily created to defuse popular opposition.
Boudiaf accepted the post, then surprised his junta sponsors by calling for
substantive reform, with an end to military rule. The civil war continued, and
although Boudiaf was presented as a victim of Muslim violence, his widow and
other observers had doubts. Rumors spread that Boudiaf had tried to open
dialogue between the government and ISF, while launching an investigation
into state corruption. That campaign indicted retired Major General Mustapha
Beloucif for embezzling $6.6 million. The lead investigator in that effort was
murdered several days before Boudiafs assassination.
Authorities clung to their portrayal of Lembarek Boumarafi as a crazed
lone assassin. Convicted of murder and sentenced to death on June 3, 1995,
Boumarafi lost his appeal before Algerias Supreme Court in March 1997.
Thus far, no report of his execution has surfaced. Mohamed Boudiaf is venerated as a martyr in Algeria today, with the countrys largest airport named in
his honor.
Further Reading
Burgat, Francois. Face to Face with Political Islam. London: I.B. Tauris, 2005.
Roberts, Hugh. The Battlefield: Algeria 19882002, Studies in a Broken Polity. London:
Verso, 2003.
Stone, Martin. The Agony of Algeria. New York: Columbia University Press, 1997.
Stora, Benjamin. Algeria, 18302000: A Short History. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University
Press, 2001.
Sueur, James Lee. Between Terror and Democracy: Algeria Since 1959. London: Zed
Books, 2010.
59
60
BUBACK, SIEGFRIED
German attorney general Siegfried Buback, shot by the Red Army Faction. (SVEN SIMON/
dpa/Corbis)
B U S H , G E O R G E WA L K E R
61
62
B U S H , G E O R G E WA L K E R
released from custody on September 19, 2003. Although President Bush was
never in actual danger, spokesmen for the U.S. Park Police said that Picketts
shots would have reached the White House if his view had not been obstructed.
A more serious attempt on Bush apparently occurred on September 11,
2001the day when coordinated terrorist strikes by al-Qaeda claimed 2,996
lives in New York and Pennsylvania. On that day, Bush was in Florida, lodged
at Colony Beach and Tennis Resort on Longboat Key, in preparation for a public appearance in Sarasota. While the president went jogging with Secret Service agents, a van occupied by several men of apparent Middle Eastern descent
arrived at the lodge, claiming they were scheduled for a poolside interview
with Bush. No such appointment was registered, and the still-unidentified
men were turned away. Authorities speculated that the strangers intended to
kill Bush, as a similar party had slain anti-Taliban militia leader Ahmad Shah
Massoud in Takhar Province, Afghanistan, only two days earlier. Although
nothing was provedand Secret Service agents failed to detain the men after
questioning themwitnesses subsequently claimed sightings of 9/11 skyjacking ringleader Mohamed Atta at the Longboat Key Holiday Inn, near the
Colony Beach, on September 7, 2001. That day, coincidentally or otherwise,
was the date when White House spokesmen announced Bushs upcoming visit
to Sarasota.
The last reported attempt on President Bush occurred in Tbilis, Georgia,
on May 10, 2005. Bush was speaking to an audience in Freedom Square, accompanied by his wife and Georgian president Mikheil Saakashvili, when
ethnic Armenian Vladimir Arutyunian tossed a hand grenade toward the podium. The grenade struck a bystander and fell short of its mark, then failed
to explode. Although it was live, and Arutyunian had pulled its pin, a handkerchief he wrapped around the grenade to conceal it from view prevented
the safety levers release to produce detonation. Arutyunian escaped from the
scene, but was caught on film by a tourists camera and subsequently identified by FBI agents, acting in concert with Georgian authorities. Cornered at
his mothers home on July 20, 2005, Arutyunian engaged in a shootout with
police, killing Zurab Kvlividze, chief of the interior ministrys counterintelligence department, before he was wounded and captured. Arutyunian initially confessed, then refused to speak at his trial, stitching his lips shut on
one occasion. On January 11, 2006, he received a life prison term without
possibility of parole.
George W. Bush was born on July 6, 1946, the grandson of a U.S. senator.
His father, George H. W. Bush, served variously in Congress (19671971), as
U.S. ambassador to the United Nations (19711973), as director of the Central
Intelligence Agency (19761977), as vice president (19811989), and as president (19891993). The younger Bush, commonly known by his middle initial, served as governor of Texas from 1995 to 2000, then won the presidency
B U S H , G E O R G E WA L K E R
63
C
CAESAR, GAIUS JULIUS (100 BCE44 BCE)
On March 15, 44 BCE, Roman chief of state Julius Caesar kept a scheduled appointment with the senate, some 40 to 60 of whose members had conspired
to kill him, thereby ending his seven-week reign as dictator in perpetuity. As
Caesar entered the chamber, Tillius Cimber approached him with a petition
for the recall of Cimbers exiled brother, while more conspirators crowded
around in support. The crowd drew knives, with Servilius Casca reportedly
striking first. Caesar received 23 wounds, but historian Gaius Suetonius
Tranquillus reports that only oneto the chestwas fatal. His account, and
that of historian Lucius Mestrius Plutarchus, records no dying words from
Caesar. The dying dictators comment Et tu, Brute?supposedly addressed
to friend-turned-killer Marcus Junius Brutuswas an apocryphal remark
added posthumously, already well known by the time it was echoed in
William Shakespeares play Julius Caesar.
Gaius Julius Caesar was born on July 13, 100 BCE, into the gens Julia, an
ancient patrician family that claimed descent from the goddess Venus by way
of Iulus, son of the mythical Trojan prince Aeneas. Four different explanations
are offered for the cognomen (third name) Caesar: Pliny the Elder asserts that
it derived from an ancestor born by caesarean section, whereas the Augustan
history speculates that the first Caesar either had gray eyes (Latin oculiscaesiis),
thick hair (Latin caesaries), or had killed an elephant (Moorish caesai) at some
point in time. Julius Caesar indirectly supported the last theory by minting
coins impressed with images of elephants.
Caesar came of age in an era of turmoil, marked by war and the political
purges of dictator Lucius Cornelius Sulla. With his fathers death in 85 BCE,
16-year-old Caesar became head of the family, promoted the following year to
serve as a high priest of Jupiter. As a nephew of Gaius Marius and son-in-law
of Lucius Cornelius Cinnaboth enemies of SullaCaesar was targeted for
eradication, stripped of his wealth and priesthood, driven into exile. He returned to Rome in 78 BCE, with Sulla safely dead, and labored to restore his fortune as a legal advocate, earning renown for captivating oratory.
In 75 BCE, while crossing the Aegean Sea, Caesar was taken prisoner by Sicilian pirates. After he was ransomed for a price of 50 talents (3,550 pounds)
of gold, Caesar raised a fleet, captured his kidnappers, and had them crucified.
66
CALIGULA
Back in Rome by 46 BCE, Caesar was reelected as consul, this time without
sharing the office. His subsequent election as dictator in perpetuity, in February 44 BCE, focused opposition from supporters of the late republic and set the
wheels in motion for his murder. Ironically, many Romans resented the aristocratic plot against Caesar, a sentiment Mark Antony used to stir up riotous
mobs. Gaius Octavian, Caesars grandnephew and sole heir led the disaffected
populace in a new round of civil warfare that ultimately doomed the republic
Caesars assassins had tried to save.
Further Reading
Freeman, Philip. Julius Caesar. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008.
Goldsworthy, Adrian. Caesar: Life of a Colossus. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press,
2006.
Parenti, Michael. The Assassination of Julius Caesar: A Peoples History of Ancient Rome.
New York: The New Press, 2003.
67
68
CALIGULA
Chaerea hated Caligula for the emperors relentless insults, focused chiefly on
insinuations of effeminacy after Chaerea had suffered a genital wound while
serving Caligulas father, General Germanicus. This day, after a furious exchange of words, Chaerea stabbed Caligula, with other soldiers joining in to
inflict 30 wounds. Hours later, conspirators also killed Caligulas wife, Milonia
Caesonia, and their daughter, Julia Drusilla, thus extinguishing the royal line.
Caligulaborn Gaius Julius Caesar Augustus Germanicus on August 31,
12 CEwas a member of Romes Julio-Claudian dynasty, founded by Julius
Caesar and ending with Nero. His popular name, translated from Latin as
little soldiers boot, refers to his father Germanicus, one of Romes best-loved
military champions. Following the death of Germanicus at Antioch in October 19, widow Agrippina the Elder returned to Rome and became embroiled
in a feud with Emperor Tiberius, whom she blamed for killing Germanicus
(his adopted son). That 10-year conflict decimated Agrippinas family and
ended with her own death in prison, leaving Caligula as her only surviving
son. When Tiberius died in March 37 CE, Caligula succeeded his adoptive
grandfather as emperor.
His reign was controversial, to say the least. Contemporary sources from
37 CE and 38 CE describe him as a moderate and exemplary ruler, whereas
later documents portray him tyrannical, perverse, and possibly insane. Historian Suetonius reports that 160,000 animals were sacrificed in celebration
during the first three months of Caligulas reign, and Philo described the first
seven months as completely blissful. Caligula granted bonuses to Roman
troops, repealed the convictions of alleged traitors prosecuted under Tiberius,
recalled some prominent Romans from exile, and staged lavish entertainment
in Rome, including gladiatorial contests.
On the other hand, he executed his cousin and adopted son Tiberius Gemellus (an act that drove their mutual grandmother to suicide), along with
father-in-law Marcus Junius Silanus and brother-in-law Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, sparing uncle Claudius to serve as a public laughingstock. Caligula also
exiled his sisters, Julia Livilla and Agrippina the Younger. Financial crises and
famines ensued, and Caligulas relations with the Roman senate deteriorated.
Aspiring to divinity by 40 CE, Caligula adopted the garb of various gods and
demigods from mythology, naming himself as Jupiter in certain public documents and posing as a sun god on newly minted coins. Royal scandals multiplied, involving adultery, sexual perversion, and murders committed for
sadistic pleasure. On occasion, he paraded his wife in the nude before visitors,
threatening to torture and kill her as an odd form of affection. The exile of
his sisters followed accusations that Caligula had forced them into incest.
Surrounded by enemies, Caligula ensured his own destruction by publicly
humiliating Cassius Chaerea. He mocked Chaereas high-pitched voice, compelled Chaerea to kiss his hand while forming and moving it in an obscene
C A L I N E S C U , A R M A N D
69
70
C A L I N E S C U , A R M A N D
their driver. The killers then proceeded to invade the headquarters of Radio
Romnia, holding employees at gunpoint for a bungled attempt to broadcast
news of Calinescus death.
A native of Pites ti, the son of an affluent veterinarian and landowner, Armand Calinescu was born on June 4, 1893. He studied law and philosophy
at the University of Bucharest, then earned a PhD in economics and political
science from the University of Paris. Rejected by Romanias National Liberal
Party for his leftist views, C a linescu joined the opposing Peasants Party and
won elections to the Chamber of Deputies in 1926, serving there for 11 years.
In 1931, he led a move to outlaw the Iron Guard, earning him the hatred of its
leaders. In December 1937, he accepted appointment as Prime Minister Octavian Gogas minister of the interiora move resulting in Ca linescus expulsion
from the Peasants Party. A stroke killed Goga in May 1938, thus leading to the
dissolution of his government. Calinescu retained his post under King Carol II,
and then replaced Prime Minister Miron Cristea at his death, on March 6, 1939.
Regarded as a man of steel who could defeat the Iron Guard, C a linescu
ordered sweeping arrests of its leaders in May 1939, resulting in an estimated
300 deaths. On September 1, in Copenhagen, Gestapo agents and representatives from Fascist Italy met with Iron Guard members and Mihail Sturdza
Romanias ambassador to Denmark and a friend of exiled Iron Guard leader
Horia Sima. Together, as later described by Iron Guard turncoat Mihai Vrfureanu, they planned to murder Calinescu, King Carol, and General Gavrila
Marinescu, among other Romanian leaders. Dumitru Dumitrescu received Gestapo training for the project, then returned home through Hungary to lead the
murder team on September 21.
Harsh repression of the Iron Guard followed Calinescus death. His assassins
were executed, their corpses displayed with a placard reading De acumnainte,
aceastava fi soartatradatorilor de tara (From now on, this shall be the fate of
those who betray the country), and another 253 Iron Guard members were
killed without trial in various towns. The movement subsequently triumphed,
briefly, in alliance with pro-Nazi prime minister Ion Antonescu, beginning in
September 1940, but its failure to unseat him in a coup on January 24, 1941,
doomed the Iron Guard in Romania. Sima and other leaders fled to Germany,
organizing a government in exile, while the regime at home collaborated in the
Holocaust. Antonescu was executed for war crimes on June 1, 1946.
Further Reading
Ancel, Jean. The History of the Holocaust in Romania. Lincoln: University of Nebraska
Press, 2011.
Dogaru, Mircea. History of the Romanians. Bucharest: Amco Press, 1996.
Georgescu, Vlad. The Romanians: A History. London: I.B. Tauris, 1991.
Hitchens, Keith. Rumania 18661947. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994.
71
72
C N O VA S D E L C A S T I L L O , A N T O N I O
Phillips Jr., William, and Carla Phillips. A Concise History of Spain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
CARLOS I OF PORTUGAL
U.S. senator Redfield Proctor (former secretary of war), and William Randolph
Hearst used his newspaper chain to agitate for U.S. intervention.
Seemingly oblivious to world opinion, Cnovas imposed the tactics used in
Cuba on dissident Spaniards at home. In June 1896, after a bomb exploded
during a Corpus Christi procession in Barcelona, Cnovas ordered the arrest of
300 anarchists, socialists, and trade unionists. Confined at Montjuc Fortress,
87 were condemned and executed, and others suffered brutal torture, some of
them driven insane. Seventy-one defendants were acquitted of all charges
but Cnovas still deported them to Ro de Oro, a Spanish colony in West Africa
(now Western Sahara).
It was during this period of turmoil that Michele Angiolillo traveled from
Paris to seek revenge against Cnovas. He was executed by garotte, at Bergara,
on August 20, 1897. The New York Times reported that he died bravely, with
his pulse quiet and unaltered, whereas Spanish newspapers suppressed details of his execution.
Further Reading
Barton, Simon. A History of Spain. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004.
Pierson, Peter. The History of Spain. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1999.
Ross, Christopher. Spain Since 1812. London: Hodder Education, 2009.
Trask, David. The War with Spain in 1898. New York: Macmillan, 1981.
73
74
CARLOS I OF PORTUGAL
75
76
C A R R E R O B L A N C O, L U I S
executed Madero in February 1913, installing himself as president, and Carranza drafted the Plan of Guadalupe, raising a Constitutional Army with support from rebel leaders including Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata. As that
armys Primer Jefe (First Chief ), he forced Huertas surrender in August 1914,
officially succeeding him on August 14.
The winning coalition soon dissolved, Zapata first deserting Carranza in
September 1914, when Carranza refused to institute the sweeping reforms
Zapata demanded. Villa soon followed, citing issues of his own, and fighting
resumed among the former allies. Victorious by January 1915, Carranza instituted his own program of reform, including propagation of a new constitution,
ratified in 1917. He was determined to retire with that accomplishment, when
his term expired in 1920, but insisted that Mexicos next president should be a
civilian. lvaro Obregn and other generals opposed that plan, prompting intrigue that culminated with Carranzas April assassination.
Adolfo de la Huerta served as Mexicos provisional president until December 1, 1920, when Obregn officially secured the office, with Huerta demoted
to secretary of the treasury. Obregn charged General Herrero with Carranzas
murder, but he was acquitted on grounds that the actual triggerman could not
be identified. Herrero still spent seven months in the military prison at Santiago Tlaltelolco, fighting treason charges, then was released with a dishonorable
discharge from the army. Curiously, Obregn later reinstated him as a general,
leaving President Lzaro Crdenas to make Herreros dismissal permanent, in
the 1930s.
Further Reading
Boot, Max. The Savage Wars of Peace: Small Wars and the Rise of American Power. New
York: Basic Books, 2002.
Gibbon, Thomas. Mexico Under Carranza: A Lawyers Indictment of the Crowning Infamy
of Four Hundred Years of Misrule. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, Page & Co., 1919.
Richmond, Douglas. Venustiano Carranzas Nationalist Struggle, 18931920. Lincoln:
University of Nebraska Press, 1984.
Stout, Joseph. Border Conflict: Villistas, Carrancistas and the Punitive Expedition,
19151920. Fort Worth: Texas Christian University Press, 1999.
C A R R E R O B L A N C O, L U I S
to church each Sunday. Tunneling beneath the road over a fivemonth period, the team planted
176 pounds of explosives stolen
from a government arsenal. As
Carrero Blancos car passed on
December 20, 1973, the bombers detonated their charge,
launching the vehicle 65 feet
in the air, over one five-story
building, to land on the secondfloor balcony of a Jesuit college.
Carrero Blanco died in the blast,
with a bodyguard and his chauffeur. The ETA claimed responsibility on January 22, 1974.
A native of Santoa, born
on March 4, 1904, Luis Carrero Blanco entered the Spanish
Naval Academy in 1918, subsequently participating in the
Rif War of 19241926, against
Moroccan Berber tribesmen. He Spanish prime minister Luis Carrero Blanco died at
initially supported the Second the hands of Basque separatists. (Bettmann/Corbis)
Spanish Republic when civil
war broke out in 1936, then defected in June 1937 to serve as a naval officer
with Francos rebel forces. Rising through the ranks and gaining influence in
Francos Falange Party, Carrero Blanco became a cabinet minister in 1957, a
vice admiral in 1963, and a full admiral in 1966. In 1967, he succeeded General Agustn Muoz Grandes as Spains vice president and heir apparent to post
of Caudillode Espaa (Leader of Spain) upon Francos demise.
ETA spokesman Julen Agirre justified Carrero Blancos assassination in a
manifesto that declared:
The execution in itself had an order and some clear objectives. From the beginning of 1951 Carrero Blanco practically occupied the government headquarters
in the regime. Carrero Blanco symbolized better than anyone else the figure of
pure Francoism and without totally linking himself to any of the Francoist tendencies, he covertly attempted to push Opus Dei into power. A man without
scruples conscientiously mounted his own State within the State: he created a
network of informers within the Ministries, in the Army, in the Falange, and also
in Opus Dei. His police managed to put themselves into all the Francoist apparatus. Thus he made himself the key element of the system and a fundamental
77
78
piece of the oligarchys political game. On the other hand, he came to be irreplaceable for his experience and capacity to manoeuvre and because nobody
managed as he did to maintain the internal equilibrium of Francoism.
Franco survived and controlled Spain through puppet presidents until November 1975. Carrero Blancos killers eluded police, but the teams leader,
Jos Bearan Ordeana, was himself assassinated with a car bomb in December 1978, a reprisal carried out by allied neo-fascist groups including Argentine Anticommunist Alliance and Italys National Vanguard, with collaboration
from Spains Naval Intelligence Service.
Further Reading
Agirre, Julen. Operation Ogro: The Execution of Admiral Luis Carrero Blanco. New York:
Ballantine, 1976.
Anderson, Wayne. The ETA: Spains Basque Terrorists. New York: Rosen Publishing, 2003.
Clark, Robert. The Basque Insurgents: ETA, 19521980. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1984.
Kurlansky, Mark. The Basque History of the World. New York: Penguin Books, 2001.
Woodworth, Paddy. Dirty War, Clean Hands: ETA, the GAL and Spanish Democracy.
Cork, Ireland: Cork University Press, 2001.
79
80
81
82
assassination plots in February 1963 and CIA agent William Harvey resumed
meetings with Rosselli in April. President Lyndon Johnson privately suspected
that attacks on Castro prompted Cuban retaliation in November 1963, with
the assassination of President John F. Kennedy ( JFK).
Be that as it may, efforts to murder Castro did not end with JFKs administration. The last known attempt on Castros life occurred in 2000, during a
visit to Panama. Cuban terrorist and ex-CIA agent Luis Posada Carriles placed
200 pounds of high explosives under a podium where Castro was scheduled
to speak, but Cuban security personnel discovered the bomb and defused it.
Posada and three accomplices were imprisoned for that attempt, later pardoned by outgoing president Mireya Moscoso in August 2004. Posada was
subsequently convicted by Venezuelan prosecutors in absentia for the October
1976 bombing of Cubana Flight 455, which killed 73 persons, and for a series
of 1997 bombings in Cuban hotels and nightclubs. Detained in Texas during
2005, Posada avoided extradition thanks to a superseding U.S. indictment and
trial, ending with his acquittal on April 8, 2011.
Although deadly serious, some of the plots against Castro assumed the aspect of black comedy. Supplied with poison pills, presidential lover Marita Lorenz hid them in a jar of cold cream, only to have them dissolve. She balked at
forcing the cream into Castros mouth while he slept, and finally confessed to
the plot. Castro, bemused, offered her his own pistol, whereupon Lorenz tearfully replied, I cant do it, Fidel.
Over time, Castros longevity became a running joke among his enemies.
Fidel himself once remarked, If surviving assassination attempts were an
Olympic event, I would win the gold medal. One apocryphal story, recounted
in New Yorker magazine, described a friend presenting Castro with a Galpagos
tortoise. On hearing that his new pet might live for 100 years, Castro declined
the gift, saying, Thats the problem with pets. You get attached to them and
then they die on you.
Further Reading
Bohning, Don. The Castro Obsession: U.S. Covert Operations against Cuba, 19591965.
Washington, DC: Potomac Books, 2005.
Breuer, William. Vendetta! Fidel Castro and the Kennedy Brothers. New York: John Wiley &
Sons, 1997.
Escalante, Fabin. The Cuba Project: CIA Covert Operations 195962. New York: Ocean
Press, 2004.
Hinckle, Warren, and William Turner. The Fish Is Red. New York: Harper and Row, 1981.
Russo, Gus. Live By The Sword: The Secret War against Castro and the Death of JFK. Baltimore: Bancroft Press, 1998.
Von Tunzelmann, Alex. Red Heat: Conspiracy, Murder, and the Cold War in the Caribbean.
New York: Henry Holt, 2011.
C ATA RG I U, BA R B U
83
84
Further Reading
Hitchins, Keith. The Romanians 17741866. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996.
Jelavich, Barbara. Russia and the Formation of the Romanian National State 18211878.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984.
the final years of Prohibition, Chicago insiders dubbed him Ten-percent Tony,
a reference to the share of cash he skimmed from local rackets and corrupt government deals. Where Mayor Thompson had allied himself with mobster
Al Caponeconvicted of tax evasion six months after Cermaks election
Cermak cast his lot with rival gangster Roger Touhys syndicate. On December 19, 1932, a police squad led by Detective Sergeants Harry Lang and Harry
Miller raided Capone successor Frank Nittis headquarters at the La Salle Hotel.
Lang shot Nitti three times, then gave himself a superficial wound and called
the shooting self-defense. Nitti surprised his would-be killers by surviving and
beat a charge of attempted murder in February 1933, when Sergeant Miller testified that Lang had received $15,000 to kill Nitti. Another member of the raiding party testified that Nitti was unarmed when shot by Lang. As a result, Lang
and Miller were fired and fined $100 each for simple assault.
Cermak was shot within days of that verdicts return. Miami prosecutors portrayed Giuseppe Zangara as a delusional immigrant and quasi-anarchist who
blamed chronic stomach pain on wealthy public figures. FDR was named as
his primary target, though he also appeared to despise Republican incumbent
Herbert Hoover. Gossip columnist Walter Winchell, coincidentally present at
the Miami shooting scene, later surmised that Cermak was Zangaras primary
target, marked for death after offending Chicago mobsters. The usual twist
to that story paints Cermak as a martyred reformer, but if gangsters were involved, retaliation for the attempted police assassination of Frank Nitti seems
a more likely motive.
Cermaks gangland ally, Roger Touhy, was indicted for kidnapping Missouri
brewer William Hamm in August 1933, but jurors acquitted him three months
later and the blame for that abduction was later (rightly) placed on the Barker
Karpis outlaw gang. FBI agents arrested Touhy again in December 1933, this
time for the faked kidnapping of Chicago felon Jacob Factor. Convicted on
that charge and sentenced to 99 years, Touhy was freed in 1959 after a federal
judge determined that Factor was never kidnapped. The case was a frame-up
concocted by Nitti and company, with aid from corrupt prosecutors. Soon after
his release, Touhy was gunned down in Chicago. His dying words: The bastards never forget.
Cermaks daughter, Helena, married Otto Kerner Jr., who served as governor
of Illinois from 1961 to 1968, then as a judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Seventh Circuit. Kerner resigned that position in July 1974, following his
conviction on 17 counts of bribery, conspiracy, perjury, and other charges. He
received a three-year prison term but was released early upon diagnosis of terminal cancer and died in Chicago on May 9, 1976.
The controversy surrounding Cermaks death makes it a natural subject for
fiction and drama. The first effort, a film billed as an imaginative biography
of Cermak, was hastily released on June 30, 1933, casting the mayor as an
85
86
inadvertent hero for saving FDR. Cermak also got the hero treatment in a twopart episode of The Untouchables, aired on February 25 and March 3, 1960,
then recycled later that same year as a full-length TV movie, The Gun of Zangara. Cermaks rise to power was portrayed in Jeffrey Archers novel Kane and
Abel (1979), and best-selling mystery author Max Allan Collins solved the
case four years later, blaming Frank Nitti in True Detective (1983). Unexpectedly, Cermaks murder also inspired a November 1998 episode of the science
fiction TV series, Babylon 5, titled Objects in Motion.
Further Reading
Allsop, Kenneth. The Bootleggers: The Story of Prohibition. New York: Arlington House, 1970.
Bergreen, Laurence. Capone: The Man and the Era. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1994.
Gottfried, Alex. Boss Cermak of Chicago: A Study of Political Leadership. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1962.
CHAI N MU RDERS ( I R AN )
Humble, Ronald. Frank Nitti: The True Story of Chicagos Notorious Enforcer. Fort Lee,
NJ: Barricade Books, 2008.
Lindberg, Richard. To Serve and Collect: Chicago Politics and Police Corruption from the
Lager Beer Riot to the Summerdale Scandal, 18551960. Carbondale: Southern Illinois
University Press, 1998.
Russo, Gus. The Outfit: The Role of Chicagos Underworld in the Shaping of Modern
America. New York: Bloomsbury, 2001.
87
88
CHAI N MU RDERS ( I R AN )
Ahmad Madani, the shahs former defense minister, poisoned with a gift of
candy in Paris on January 1, 1986.
Ahmadhamed Monfared, another ex-colonel, shot in Turkey by two men
with silenced pistols on October 24, 1986.
Vali Mohammad, a former marine officer under the shah, shot in Pakistan
on November 12, 1986.
Ali Akbar Mohammadi, former pilot for Chairman of Parliament Ali
Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, killed by two gunmen in Hamburg, Germany,
on January 16, 1987.
Hamid Reza Chitgar, First Secretary of Hezb Kaar (Labor Party), killed at
an apartment in Vienna, Austria, on May 19, 1987, with his corpse found
a week later. Suspect Ali Amiztab allegedly lured Chitgar from Paris to Vienna, after a two-year correspondence from Iran.
Alireza Hassanpour Sharifzadeh and Faramarz Aqai, killed at their homes
in Karachi on July 8, 1987, in an attack with rocket launchers and machine guns that left 33 other persons wounded. Pakistani border guards
detained nine members of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard as suspects.
Exiled dissident Mohammad Hassan Mansouri, killed with a companion
at his home in Istanbul, by two gunmen, on July 25, 1987.
Ahmad Talebi, former fighter pilot in the shahs air force, shot by two assassins in Geneva, Switzerland, on September 10, 1987.
Ali and Noureddin Nabavi Tavakoli, father and son royalists, shot in their
London home on October 3, 1987.
Javad Haeri, stabbed by two men at his home in Istanbul on December 1,
1987.
Behrouz Bagheri, son of a general in the shahs army, killed by a bomb at
his shop in Paris on November 28, 1987.
Ataollah Bayahmadi, ex-colonel with military intelligence, killed in his
Dubai hotel room on June 4, 1989.
Abdulrahman Ghassemlou, leader of the Kurdistan Democratic Party of
Iran (KDPI), ambushed at a meeting with Iranian officials in Vienna, on
July 13, 1989. Also killed in that shooting were KDPI members Abdollah
Ghaderi, Fadal Mala, and Mamoud Rassoul. Austrian police released the
suspects, then expelled them from the country.
Gholam Keshavarz, exiled member of the Worker-Communism Unity
Party of Iran, killed in Cyprus in August 1989.
Bahman Javadi, a member of Komalah (a Kurdish political party), killed
in an August 26, 1989, shooting in Cyprus that also wounded party member Youssef Rashidzadeh.
CHAI N MU RDERS ( I R AN )
Komalah member Sadiq Kamangar, murdered at his office in Iraq on September 4, 1989.
Exiled royalist Hadj Balouch Khan, shot by members of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard in Taftan, Pakistan, on February 16, 1990.
Dr. Kazem Rajavi, Irans first ambassador to the United Nations after the
1979 revolution and elder brother of Massoud Rajavi, leader of the National Council of Resistance, killed in a village near Geneva, Switzerland,
on April 24, 1990.
Ali Kashefpour, a member of the KDPIs Central Committee, kidnapped in
Turkey and tortured to death on July 15, 1990.
Effat Qazi, daughter of Kurdish dissident leader Gazi Mohammed, killed
by a letter bomb addressed to her activist husband in Sweden, on September 6, 1990.
Political refugee Gholam Reza Nakhai, beaten to death in a Turkish hotel
room on October 1, 1990.
Cyrus Elahi, a member of the opposition monarchist group Derafsh-e
Kaviani (Flag of Freedom), shot at his home in Paris on October 23, 1990.
KDPI members Ahad Aqa and Khaled Hosseinpour, killed by a bomb
planted at party headquarters in Iraq on January 1, 1991.
Abdolrahman Boroumand, executive committee member of the National Resistance Movement of Iran, stabbed on a Paris street, on April 8,
1991.
Dr. Shapour Bakhtiar, last prime minister under the shah and founder of
the National Resistance Movement, stabbed to death in Paris with his secretary, Soroush Katibeh, on August 7, 1991. Killers Nasser Ghasemi Nejad
and Gholam Hossein Shoorideh Shirazi escaped to Iran, and a thirdAli
Vakili Radwas captured in Switzerland, extradited to France, and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Saeed Yazdanpanah, member of the Revolutionary Union of Kurdish People, was fatally stabbed at his home in Iraq, on September 19, 1991, along
with his secretary Cyrus Katibeh.
Nareh Rafizadeh, wife and sister-in-law of exiled royal intelligence agents,
shot outside her home in New Jersey, on March 26, 1992.
Exiled dissident Seifollah Seimanpour, machine-gunned in Iraq on May 1,
1992.
KDPI member Shahpour Firouzi, shot with automatic weapons in Iraq on
May 31, 1992.
Union of Iranian Communists member Kamran Mansour Moqadam,
machine-gunned in Sulaymaniyah, Iraq, on June 3, 1992.
89
90
CHAI N MU RDERS ( I R AN )
MIRO member Ali-Akbar Ghorbani, kidnapped from his home in Istanbul on June 4, 1992, and tortured to death. Suspects in custody later confessed and led police to his grave.
Exiled singer Fereydoun Farrokhzad, beheaded at his home in Bonn, Germany, on August 8, 1992. The attackers also severed his tongue.
KDPI leader Dr. Sadeq Sharafkandi, shot with aides Homayoun Ardalan,
Fattah Abdollahi, and Nouri Dehkordi at a Berlin restaurant on September
17, 1992. Two Iranians were convicted in April 1997, and the court issued
an arrest warrant for Ali Fallahian, then Irans minister of intelligence.
Abbas Golizadeh, former bodyguard to the shah, kidnapped from home
in Istanbul on December 26, 1992, and still missing, presumed dead.
MIRO member Gholam-Hossein Kazemi, ambushed and shot while driving between the groups camps in Iraq, on January 21, 1993.
Heybatollah Naroui and Delaviz Naroui, exiled Naroui tribal chiefs from
Balochistan, killed at their home in Karachi, Pakistan, on March 9, 1993.
Mohammad Hossein Naghdi, spokesman for the National Council of Resistance of Iran, shot in Rome on March 16, 1993.
Mohammad Ghaderi, a former KDPI member, kidnapped from home in
Kirshahir, Turkey, on August 25, 1993. His mutilated corpse was found
10 days later.
KDPI member Bahram Azadifar, shot at his home in Ankara on August 28,
1993, by two men disguised as Turkish police officers.
Hossein Barazandeh, an engineer and close aide of expatriate scholar Dr.
Ali Shariati, reported missing after he left a Quran recitation session in
Mashhad on January 3, 1995. His body was found the next day, with his
death attributed to cardiac arrest, but colleagues believed he was poisoned.
Ahmad Khomeini, younger son of Iranian ruler Ayatollah Khomeini, pronounced dead from a heart attack on March 17, 1995, one month after
publicly criticizing regime hardliners. Outside observers claim the ministry of intelligence killed him with cyanide.
MIRO members Effat Haddad and Fereshteh Esfandiari, shot in Baghdad
on May 19, 1995.
Ahmad Mir Alaei, signatory of an open letter criticizing the Islamic Republic, reported missing en route to deliver a speech at the medical school
in Isfahan, on October 24, 1995. An unknown caller canceled his appearance, and Alaei was found six hours later, another victim of cardiac
arrest.
Javad Saffar and Jalal Mobinzadeh, kidnapped and killed in Mashhad,
Iran, on January 1, 1996.
CHAI N MU RDERS ( I R AN )
91
92
succeed Canute as Sverker II. Canutes four sons were exiled, but returned with
Norse support in 1205 to face Sverker II in the Battle of lgars. All but Erik
Knutsson died there, and he fled once again, but returned a second time with
more Norwegians in 1208, defeating Sverker II at the Battle of Lena. Crowned
Eric X thereafter, he disposed of Sverker once and for all two years later, at Gestilren. A sudden fever claimed his life in April 1216.
Further Reading
Kent, Neil. A Concise History of Sweden. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Moberg, Vilhelm. A History of the Swedish People from Prehistory to the Renaissance.
Vol. 1. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2005.
93
94
CHINNICI, ROCCO
CHINNICI, ROCCO
Promoted to chief prosecutor in 1979, upon the murder of predecessor Cesare Terranova, Chinnici organized the Antimafia Pool, a group of investigating magistrates that included Paolo Borsellino, Giuseppe Di Lello, Giovanni
Falcone, and Leonardo Guarnotta. One of their leading targets was Michele
Greco, head of the Sicilian Mafia Commission, known as The Pope for his
ability to mediate feuds between rival mob bosses. Indicted with 14 other mafiosi on July 9, 1983, for the September 1982 murder of Carabinieri general
Carlo Alberto Dalla Chiesa, Greco fled into hiding and plotted the eradication of his enemies. The bomb that killed Chinnici was triggered by Giuseppe
95
96
Pino Greco, Micheles nephew and enforcer, subsequently murdered in September 1985, while still a fugitive from justice.
Police captured Michele Greco on February 20, 1986, in time for him to join
354 codefendants for a Maxi Trial in Palermo. He was convicted of ordering 78
murders, including Chinnicis, and received a life prison term on December 16,
1987. An appellate court freed Greco on February 27, 1991, but his sentence
was reinstated in February 1992. He died in prison, still claiming innocence,
on February 13, 2008.
Further Reading
Jamiesen, Alison. The Antimafia: Italys Fight against Organized Crime. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2000.
Orlando, Leoluca. Fighting the Mafia and Renewing Sicilian Culture. Jackson, TN: Encounter Books, 2003.
Schneider, Jane, and Peter Schneider. Reversible Destiny: Mafia, Antimafia, and the
Struggle for Palermo. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003.
Seindal, Ren. Mafia: Money and Politics in Sicily 19501997. Copenhagen: Museum
Tusculanum Press, 1998.
Stille, Alexander. Excellent Cadavers: The Mafia and the Death of the First Italian Republic.
New York: Vintage Books, 1995.
97
98
Bill Clinton was born William Jefferson Blythe III, in Hope, Arkansas, on August 19, 1946. His father died in an auto accident before Clintons birth, and his
mother later remarried, with Clinton assuming his stepfathers surname. Scholarships enabled Clinton to attend Georgetown Universitys Edmund A. Walsh
School of Foreign Service, where he obtained a BS degree in 1968, followed by a
Rhodes Scholarship to University College, Oxford, in England. Clinton entered
Arkansas politics in 1974, losing a congressional race, then was elected as the
states attorney general (1976) and as governor (1978). Defeated by gubernatorial challenger Frank White in 1980, Clinton rebounded to win a second term,
unseating White in 1984thereby securing a reputation as the comeback kid.
Reelections as governor followed in 1986 and 1990. In 1992, Clinton defeated
incumbent President George H. W. Bush, and successfully defended that office
against challenger Bob Dole in 1996.
Despite Clintons 1996 reelection by some eight million votes in a threeparty race (including independent candidate Ross Perot), his White House tenure was beset by bitter controversy and dissension. First Lady Hillary Clinton
blamed a vast right-wing conspiracy for the attacks, and although extremist groups certainly played a role, fueled by flamboyant talk-show hosts, the
president contributed to his own difficulties as private behavior turned public.
In 1998, a Republican Congress led by Clinton foe (and presidential hopeful)
Newt Gingrich of Georgia voted to impeach Clinton for testifying falsely under
oath about a sexual affair with White House intern Monica Lewinsky. The U.S.
Senate acquitted Clinton in February 1999, and despite that sordid episode, he
left Washington in January 2001 with the highest end-of-office approval rating of any U.S. president since World War II. Subsequent public opinion polls
rank him high among all former presidents, ranging from second to fourth in
popularity.
See also: bin Laden, Osama bin Mohammed bin Awad (19572011).
Further Reading
Gormley, Ken. The Death of American Virtue: Clinton vs. Starr. New York: Crown, 2010.
Malanowski, Jamie. Did Osama Try to Kill Bill Clinton? True/Slant. December 21, 2009.
http://trueslant.com/jamiemalanowski/2009/12/21/did-osama-try-to-kill-bill-clinton.
Summary Statement of Facts (the September 12, 1994 Plane Crash and the October 29,
1994 Shooting) Background Information on the White House Security Review. http://
prop1.org/park/pave/rev6.htm.
99
100
opponents from the Irish Republican Army (IRA; see sidebar). En route from
Bandon to Cork, the column stopped at the village of Balnam Blth (The
Mouth of Flowers) to ask directions, inadvertently receiving advice from
Dinny Long, an IRA supporter. Long directed Collins and his men along a
route guarded by hostile troops under Liam Deasy, an officer in the IRAs 3rd
Cork Brigade. When the ambush party opened fire at 8 P.M., Collins ordered
his men to stop and return fire. The skirmish lasted 20 minutes, and Collins
was the sole fatality, struck in the head by a rifle shot. Participants in the firefight later named the triggerman as Denis (Sonny) ONeill, a former British
army marksman turned IRA sniper.
Michael Collins was born at Sams Cross, near Clonakilty, in West County
Cork, on October 16, 1890. His father was a retired member of the Fenian
Brotherhood, which opposed British rule of Ireland in the latter part of the
19th century. On his death bed, Michael Sr. reportedly predicted that his
son would do great work for Ireland. At first, however, Michael Jr. seemed
to serve the British. Leaving school at age 15, he worked for the Royal Mail
from 1906 to 1910, then moved to London as a messenger for Horne and
Company, a stockbroking firm. Unknown to his employers, though, he
joined Londons Gaelic Athletic Association, and through it, the covert revolutionary Irish Republican Brotherhood. After a stint with J.P. Morgan &
Company in New York, he returned to Ireland in time for the Easter Rising
of April 1916.
While that revolt failed to throw off British rule, landing Collins in custody at Frongoch internment camp in Wales, he escaped execution and was
freed in December 1916, later joining in the Irish War of Independence that
began on January 21, 1919. By then, he was a leading figure in Sinn Fin (We
Ourselves), a nationalist party, and director of its paramilitary Irish Volunteers, created to secure and maintain the rights and liberties common to the
whole people of Ireland. With the outbreak of war, that group expanded to
become the IRA, battling British troops and the Black-and-Tan Royal Irish
Constabulary.
In December 1919, Britains House of Commons introduced a Better Government of Ireland Bill, proposing two Irish parliaments: one for the six
northern counties of Ulster, and another for 26 southern counties of a proposed Irish Free State. That proposal of division split public opinion in Ireland, with strongest support drawn from Ulsters Protestant majority. It also
split the IRA, one faction willing to settle for partial victory, while the other
opposed any treaty. With the war for independence still ongoing, the AntiTreaty IRA began attacks on treaty supporters in June 1922, touching off the
Irish Civil War. As a defender of the existing provisional government, Michael
Collins took the field against his former IRA comrades, and thus went to his
death. Despite ongoing opposition, the treaty dividing Ireland was ratified in
December 1922. It took another five months to conclude the civil war, but
mayhem had become an ingrained habit, continuing with troubles spanning
eight more decades.
Ranked as one of Irelands greatest popular heroes, Michael Collins has been
portrayed several times on screen and stage. Beloved Enemy, a 1936 feature
film, cast Brian Aherne as Dennis Riordan in a fictionalized version of Collinss life (including survival of the final ambush by IRA rivals). Collins had his
real name restored for The Treaty, a 1991 film for television starring Brendan
Gleeson and Michael Collins (1996), with Liam Neeson in the title role. The
Cork Opera House commissioned a musical about Collins in 2005, staged for
101
102
the first time in 2009. In the interim, playwright Mark Kenny penned Allegiance in 2006, depicting a meeting between Collins (played by Michael Fassbender) and Winston Churchill (portrayed by Mel Smith).
Further Reading
Coogan, Tim Pat. Michael Collins: The Man Who Made Ireland. Boulder, CO: Roberts
Rinehart, 1996.
Dwyer, T. Ryle. Michael Collins: The Man Who Won the War. Blackrock, Ireland: Mercier
Press, 2009.
Hittle, J.B.E. Michael Collins and the Anglo-Irish War: Britains Counterinsurgency Failure.
Dulles, VA: Potomac Books, 2011.
MacKay, James. Michael Collins: A Life. Edinburgh: Mainstream, 1997.
OConnor, Frank. The Big Fellow: Michael Collins and the Irish Revolution. Dublin: Clonmore & Reynolds, 1965.
OConnor, Ulick. Michael Collins and the Troubles: The Struggle for Irish Freedom 19121922.
New York: W. W. Norton, 1996.
D
DANILO I, PRINCE OF MONTENEGRO
(18261860)
On August 13, 1860, while boarding a ship at Kotor, Montenegro, Prince
Danilo I was shot and fatally wounded by Todor Kadic,
a chief of the Bjelopavlici
tribe. Danilo died the following day, and although Kadic refused to explain the
killing, various theories were advanced. Some authors claim that Kadic was
enraged by Danilos adulterous affair with Kadi c s wife. Others claim he acted
to avenge atrocities committed on his kinsmen by Danilos troops. Another
theory claims that Austrian authorities recruited him to kill Danilo, fearing that
the prince would forge an alliance with Russian czar Alexander II. The truth
remains obscure.
A native of Njegui, born on June 29, 1871, Danilo was born into the House
of Petrovic-Njego,
hereditary rulers of Montenegro from 1696 to 1918. In October 1851, with the death of vladika (prince-bishop) Petar II Petrovic-Njego,
the senate proclaimed Petar IIs elder brother, Pero Tomov Petrovic,
to succeed
him. Danilo trumped that choice with popular appeal, having negotiated peace
between the warring Crmnica and Katunjani tribes, thereby winning recognition from all Serb bratzvos (clans) except the contentious Bjelopavlici.
At the
same time, he secured endorsement from Russian emperor Nicholas I and was
ordained as vladika Danilo II in Vienna, Austria. Returning to Montenegro in
1852, Danilo accommodated senators by permitting Montenegros change to a
secular principality, whereupon he became knyaz (prince) Danilo I.
That same year, he declared war on the Ottoman Empire, which claimed
jurisdiction over Montenegro. That struggle dragged on for seven years, ending in Montenegrin victory when Danilos elder brother, Grand Duke Mirko
Petrovic-Njego,
104
Petrovic chief among them. A plot was organized to oust Danilo and replace
him with exiled rival Stevan Perovic Cuca, but Danilo sent assassins to kill
Cuca in Istanbul. He failed to reckon with the vengeful Bjelopavlici,
though,
and thereby met his end.
Nephew Nikola Mirkov Petrovic-Njego
succeeded Danilo as Prince Nicholas I, pursuing a series of administrative, educational, and military reforms.
In 1900, he proclaimed himself Montenegros first (and only) king. Five years
later, bowing to popular pressure, he granted the nation its first constitution.
Deposed and exiled in 1918, Nicholas maintained his futile claim to the throne
until his death, in Antibes, in March 1921.
Further Reading
Boehm, Christopher. Blood Revenge: The Enactment and Management of Conflict in Montenegro and Other Tribal Societies. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1984.
Morrison, Kenneth. Montenegro: A Modern History. London: I.B. Tauris, 2009.
Roberts, Elizabeth. Realm of the Black Mountain: A History of Montenegro. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press, 2007.
Stevenson, Francis. A History of Montenegro. London: Jarrold & Sons, 1914.
President Mohammed Daoud Khan of Afghanistan, killed during a military coup. (Associated Press)
the king was also murdered, in Kabul. Daoud was thereafter tutored in politics
by an uncle, Prince Hashim Khan, and studied in France. He served two terms
as governor of the Eastern Province, in 19341935 and 19381939, with an
intervening term as governor of Kandahar. In 1939, as a lieutenant general,
he assumed command of the Kabul Army Corps, holding that post until his
promotion to minister of defense (19461948), ambassador to France (1948),
then minister of the interior (19491951). Back in uniform by 1951, he served
as commander of the Central Forces in Kabul until September 1953, when he
began a decade as prime minister.
As prime minister, Daoud courted antagonism with his plan to reunite the
Pashtun people (ethnic Afghans) of Pakistan with their ancestral homeland,
a move that simultaneously angered Pakistan and worried non-Pashtun minorities in Afghanistan, such as the Tajiks and Uzbeks. Pakistan closed its borders with Afghanistan in 1961, damaging the Afghan economy and pushing
Daouds regime into closer alliance with the Soviet Union as the countrys foremost trading partner. In 1962, armed with Russian tanks, planes, and artillery, Daoud invaded Pakistans Bajaur region, but was repulsed by superior
forces. That crisis was defused with Daouds forced resignation in March 1963,
105
106
107
108
DELIGIANNIS, THEODOROS
Tarver, H. Michael, and Julia Frederick. The History of Venezuela. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2005.
Trinkunas, Harold. Crafting Civilian Control of the Military in Venezuela: A Comparative
Perspective. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2009.
DESSALINES, JEAN-JACQUES
109
110
D E S S A L I N E S, J E A N -J AC Q U E S
warrior who granted his enemies no quarter. That March, Toussaint convened
a constitutional assembly, and by July had forged a document that made him
president for life, while reaffirming loyalty to France.
In Paris, Napoleon Bonaparte felt pressure to restore slavery in SaintDomingue. In December 1801, he sent his brother-in-law, General Charles
Leclerc, to restore French control on the island. Leclerc arrived with 40,000
troops in February 1802, arrested Louverture in May, and shipped him back to
France, where he later died in prison. Yellow fever killed Leclerc in November,
leaving Donatien-Marie-Joseph de Vimeur, vicomte de Rochambeau, in command of French forces. Dessalines defeated Rochambeau in November 1803,
at Vertires, and Napoleons army surrendered on December 4.
Dessalines declared Saint-Dominguenow Haitian independent nation
on January 1, 1804. The following month, he launched a campaign to eradicate the islands white minority, killing at least 3,000 persons (some accounts
say 5,000, including 1,700 whites and various loyal servants) by April 22,
when the campaign ceased. On September 22, Dessalines named himself as
emperor, with his official coronation occurring at Cap-Franais on October 6.
A constitution, published on May 20, 1805, established him as emperor for life
with the right to name his successor.
Under Dessaliness reign, whites were forbidden to own property, and a
harsh regimen of caporalisme agraire (agrarian militarism) was imposed, requiring that all black males work either as soldiers or plantation laborers. Dessalines also retained strict control of foreign trade, specifically export of sugar
and coffee, favoring British and American buyers over French. Dissension simmered until 1806, when conspirators Alexandre Ption and Henri Christophe
succeeded in eliminating Dessalines.
After the assassination, Ption and Christophe suffered a falling out. Both
hoped to rule in the late emperors place, resulting in the division of Haiti in
1810. Ption ruled the southern Republic of Haiti as president (transformed
to president for life in 1816), and Christophe proclaimed himself king of the
northern kingdom of Haiti. Ption suspended his realms legislature in 1818,
while seizing plantations from the landed gentry and granting parcels to peasants, a tactic that earned him the label Papa Bon-Cur (Good-hearted Father). Ption died from yellow fever in March 1818, succeeded by president
for life Jean-Pierre Boyer, and King Christophe committed suicide in October
1820. Haiti was reunified that same month, with full independence recognized
by France in 1825.
Although widely reviled in life for his despotic rule, Jean-Jacques Dessalines was rehabilitated in the early 20th century, emerging as a national icon.
The city of Dessalines is named in his honor, as is Haitis national anthem, La
Dessalinienne (The Dessalines Song). His great-grandson, Cincinnatus Leconte,
ruled briefly as president from August 1911 to August 1912.
DEVI, PHOOLAN
Further Reading
Dubois, Laurent. Avengers of the New World: The Story of the Haitian Revolution. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2005.
Girard, Philippe. Haiti: The Tumultuous HistoryFrom Pearl of the Caribbean to Broken
Nation. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
Girard, Philippe. The Slaves Who Defeated Napoleon: Toussaint Louverture and the Haitian War of Independence 18011804. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 2011.
Nicholls, David. From Dessalines to Duvalier: Race, Colour and National Independence in
Haiti. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1996.
Popkin, Jeremy. You Are All Free: The Haitian Revolution and the Abolition of Slavery.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
111
112
DEVI, PHOOL AN
she joined a gang of dacoits (bandits) and married its leader, Vikram Mallah.
The band soon raided her ex-husbands home and left him near death, with a
letter threatening other men who married young girls.
From that point, Devi joined enthusiastically in bandit raids across Uttar
Pradesh and neighboring Madhya Pradesh, robbing trains, looting high-caste
villages, and kidnapping wealthy victims for ransom. Over time, a rift developed between gang members of the mallah caste and rival Thakur Rajputs,
considered divine by some elements of Indian society. In September 1979,
Thakar brothers Shri and Lala Ram killed Vikram Mallah, seized control of
the gang, and left Devi at Behmai, where she endured three weeks of rape and
torture by their fellow clansmen. Upon escaping, she built a new gang and set
off on a quest for revenge, pursing Shri and Lala Ram while killing any other
men she met along the way, suspected of abusing women or children. Whenever I heard of it, Devi explained, I crushed the serpent they used to torture
women. I dismembered them.
On February 14, 1981, Devi returned to Behmai with her gang, disguised as
police; the gang executed 22 Thakur men and looted the village. She eluded police for two years, forcing the resignation of Vishwanath Singh, chief minister of
Uttar Pradesh, then surrendered in February 1983 on condition that she would
not face execution. Charged with 48 criminal counts, Devi spent 11 years in jail
awaiting trial; she was released in 1994, when Chief Minister Mulayam Singh
Yadav dismissed all charges. A film released that same year, Bandit Queen, dramatized Devis life and elevated her to folk hero status, although she protested
its inaccuracies and even threatened suicide until producers paid her 40,000.
In 1996, Devi won election to the Lok Sabha from Mirzapur, in Uttar Pradesh,
as a member of the Bharatiya Janata (Indian Peoples) Party, vowing to protect
the weaker sections of society. Her candidacy and successful reelection bid
in 1999 were bitterly opposed by widows of the Behmai massacre, and on
a broader scale by the Kshatriya Swabhimaan Andolan Samanvay Committee (KSASC), representing the military and ruling elite of the Vedic-Hindu social system. Ostensibly repulsed by the election of a once-indicted felon, the
KSASC also opposed Devis commitment to providing drinking water, electricity, schools, and hospitals to the poor, further exacerbated by her stand on
equal rights and opportunities for women.
The course of justice for Devis killers has been as slow and tortuous as her
own prosecution for the Behmai massacre (still officially unsolved at this writing, with a score of suspects awaiting trial). Sher Singh Rana escaped from
jail on February 17, 2004, with aid from an accomplice dressed as a policeman, and was not recaptured until April 20, 2006. Another suspect in Devis
assassination, Shravan Kumar, was not arrested until July 2004. Their longdelayed trial was transferred to a fast track court in January 2009, but was
still ongoing three years later. On January 24, 2012, Sher Singh Rana received
I N I C , Z O R A N
official permission to campaign from his jail cell, for a seat in the Uttar Pradesh
Assembly.
Further Reading
Devi, Phoolan. The Bandit Queen of India. Guilford, CT: Lyons Press, 2006.
Sen, Mala. Indias Bandit Queen: The True Story of Phoolan Devi. New York: HarperCollins, 2001.
Shears, Richard, and Isobelle Gidley. Devi: The Bandit Queen. London: Allen & Unwin,
1984.
I N I C , Z O R A N ( 1 9 5 2 2 0 0 3 )
Serbian prime minister Zoran indi
c had official business to perform on
March 12, 2003, specifically a meeting with Anna Lindh, Swedens minister of
foreign affairs, and colleague Jan Karlsson, minister for development cooperation, migration, and asylum policy. Despite an attempt on his life three weeks
earlier, indi
c chose to walk from his home in Belgrade to the National Assembly building, accompanied only by bodyguard Milan Veruovic.
At 12:23 P.M.,
Zvezdan Jovanovica
113
114
I N I C , Z O R A N
Meanwhile, nearly lost in the regions nightmare of civil war and ethnic
cleansing, Yugoslavia suffered a series of assassinations: Defense Minister
Pavle Bulatovic on February 7, 2000; Socialist Party officer ika Petrovic on
April 26, 2000; and ex-president Ivan Stambolic on August 25, 2000. Those
deaths and others were later blamed on Red Berets, acting in concert with the
Zemun Clan, a Belgrade organized-crime family.
indi
c played a leading role in the so-called Bulldozer Revolution that
unseated President Miloevic in October 2000, and thereafter he was chosen as prime minister, assuming office on January 25, 2001. He advocated
pro-democratic reforms and opposed civic corruption, a stance that placed
him at odds with the Zemun Clan and their Red Beret allies. On February 7,
2003, Zemun Clan member Dejan Milenkovic tried to ram indi
cs car with
a truck in New Belgrade, but indi
c escaped injury. A friendly judge released
Milenkovic,
explaining that he was a salesman whose absence imperiled his
business.
Serbian police continued their hunt for conspirators after Zvezdan Jovanovic
confessed to shooting indi
c.
On March 27, 2003, officers killed Zemu Clan
members Dusan Spasojevic and Mile Lukovic in a Belgrade suburb, during a
fierce shootout with automatic weapons. Roughly 1,000 other suspects were
detained, including Red Berets and members of Serbias secret police. Suspicion
quickly focused on Red Beret ex-commander Milorad Ulemek, alleged ringleader of the plots to kill indi
c and Ivan Stambolic,
as well as a bungled attempt to slay Serb opposition leader Vuk Drakovic in October 1999 and June
2000. Suspect Aleksandar Simovic was not apprehended until November 2006.
Finally, on May 23, 2007, Belgrade's High Court Special Department for
Criminal Acts of Organised Crime convicted Ulemek, Simovic,
and 10 other
defendants on charges of murdering indi
c. Ulemek and Zvezdan Jovanovic
received 40-year prison terms, and the othersincluding five still at large,
tried in absentiadrew sentences ranging from 8 to 35 years.
Anna Lindh, the Swedish minister of foreign affairs (and presumed future
prime minister), was herself assassinated on September 10, 2003, by an attacker who stabbed her repeatedly as she shopped, unprotected, in the ladies department of Stockholms Nordiska Kompaniet department store. Her
slayinglike that of Swedish prime minister Olof Palme in 1986remains officially unsolved.
Further Reading
Cox, John. The History of Serbia. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2002.
Gagnon, V. P. Jr. The Myth of Ethnic War: Serbia and Croatia in the 1990s. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press, 2004.
Judah, Tim. The Serbs: History, Myth and the Destruction of Yugoslavia. New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press, 2010.
Stojanovic, Svetozar. Serbia: The Democratic Revolution. Amherst, NY: Humanity Books,
2003.
115
116
D O E, SA M U E L K A N YO N
winning 75 percent of the vote from a populace hoping for peace. Instead, they
found themselves dwelling in a pariah state, as Taylor used blood diamonds
and illegal timber exports to finance the Revolutionary United Front in Sierra
Leones civil war. Bloodshed resumed in Liberia during April 1999, when exiles
fighting as the Organization of Displaced Liberians invaded the country from
Guinea. In June 2003, the Special Court for Sierra Leone indicted Charles Taylor for war crimes. Taylor resigned in August and fled to Nigeria, but he was
captured in March 2006 and convicted at The Hague on April 26, 2012.
Meanwhile, Prince Johnson returned to Liberia in March 2004, but left
again in April, citing death threats. He won a senate seat from Nimba County
in 2005, and sought the presidency in 2011, but failed to unseat incumbent
Ellen Johnson Sirleaf.
See also: Tolbert, William Richard, Jr. (19131980).
Further Reading
Ellis, Stephen. The Mask of Anarchy Updated Edition: The Destruction of Liberia and the
Religious Dimension of an African Civil War. New York: New York University Press,
2006.
DOLLFUSS, ENGELBERT
Meredith, Martin. The Fate of Africa: A History of the Continent Since Independence. New
York: Public Affairs, 2011.
Waugh, Colin. Charles Taylor and Liberia: Ambition and Atrocity in Africas Lone Star
State. London: Zed Books, 2011.
Williams, Gabriel. Liberia: The Heart of Darkness. Victoria, BC: Trafford, 2006.
117
118
DUBS, ADOLPH
DUBS, ADOLPH
officers drew guns and directed him to the government-owned Kabul Hotel,
two miles away. Arriving there, the gunmen removed their targetU.S. ambassador Adolph Spike Dubsfrom the car and marched him into the hotels
lobby. While three fired shots into the ceiling, the fourth made a phone call
to the Afghan foreign ministry, announcing, Weve got the ambassador. Proclaiming themselves members of the Settam-e-Melli (National Oppression)
movement, the kidnappers demanded release of imprisoned leader Badruddin
Bahes, in exchange for Dubs. Minister of national defense Hafizullah Amin
denied that Bahes was in government custody, and refused to negotiate with
terrorists in any case. Three hours after the abduction, Afghan security forces
and Russian advisors stormed Room 117 of the hotel, killing Dubs and his
kidnappers in a brief firefight.
Adolph Dubs was born in Chicago on August 4, 1920, earned a degree in
political science from Beloit College in 1942, and served in the U.S. Navy
during World War II. After the war, he completed his graduate studies in
political science at Georgetown University, then Foreign Service studies at
Harvard and at Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri. From there,
he joined the United States Foreign Service as a career diplomat, filling posts
in Canada, Germany, Liberia, Russia, and Yugoslavia, while earning a reputation as an expert on the Soviet Union. After the Saur Revolution of April
1978 brought the Khalq (masses) faction of the Peoples Democratic Party
to power in Afghanistan, Dubs was appointed ambassador to that perpetually
troubled nation.
Washington did not replace Dubs with a new ambassador. The Kabul embassy was closed in 1989, with no new ambassador appointed until 2002,
following occupation of the country by U.S. troops. Meanwhile, in 1992, defecting Soviet major Vasili Mitrokhin arrived in the United States with 25,000
pages of classified documents, including reports that KGB advisor Sergei Batrukihn recommended the failed rescue attempt over U.S. protestsand authorized execution of one captured gunman before he could be questioned by
U.S. investigators. In March 1992, President Mohammad Najibullah offered
to appoint a high-level investigative commission when an official appeal is
made to us by the U.S. State Department. In an interview with the Los Angeles Times, he added, I do not have so much hope, but we will begin the work.
My personal view is that there has been no document from the very beginning.
But of course, when we look, something will be found. At least we will achieve
something.
In fact, Najibullah left office the following month and was killed by Taliban opponents in 1996. The promised investigation never occurred. Vasili Mitrokhin published six volumes of KGB history and documents in the United
States between 1999 and 2005, known collectively as the Mitrokhin Archive,
with the final installment appearing after his death.
119
120
Further Reading
Ansary, Tamim. Games without Rules: The Often-Interrupted History of Afghanistan. New
York: Public Affairs, 2012.
Barfield, Thomas. Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History. Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press, 2012.
Fitzgerald, Paul, and Elizabeth Gould. Invisible History: Afghanistans Untold Story. San
Francisco: City Lights Books, 2009.
Tomsen, Peter. The Wars of Afghanistan: Messianic Terrorism, Tribal Conflicts, and the
Failures of Great Powers. Philadelphia: Public Affairs, 2011.
D U D AY E V, D Z H O K H A R M U S AY E V I C H
On November 14, 1933, King Carol II named Duca as prime minister, replacing Alexandru Vaida-Voevod of Transylvania. Duca clashed immediately
with the Iron Guard, ordering thousands of its members arrested for acts of violence preceding general elections scheduled for December 2029, 1933. That
action led directly to his murder by the three Nicadori, as an act of retaliation.
His murder was the first major Romanian assassination since that of Barbu
Catargiu in 1862, but it would not be the last.
With the Nicadori imprisoned, Iron Guardists formed a new death squad,
Decemviri, so called because it had 10 members. On July 16, 1936, they killed
Iron Guard defector Mihai Stelescu at a Bucharest hospital, where he had
checked in for an appendectomy. After shooting Stelescu at least 38 times (some
accounts say 200), they dismembered his corpse with axes and danced around
the ward in celebration until they were arrested. They were killed by guards,
together with the Nicadori, in November 1938. Another team, the Ra zbunatori
(Avengers), assassinated Prime Minister Armand C a linescu in 1939.
The Iron Guard ultimately gained control of Romania and struck back at its
enemies on November 26, 1940, executing at least 14 prisoners at Jilava penitentiary. Those slain included ex-prime minister Gheorghe Arges anu, former
justice minister Victor Iamandi, former Bucharest police prefect Gabriel Marinescu, former gendarmerie inspector general Ioan Bengliu, former chief of
secret police Mihail Moruzov, Colonel Vasile Zeciu (who organized the 1938
executions), Majors Aristide Macoveanu and Iosif Dinulescu (who carried
them out), and Staff Sergeant Srbu (who personally strangled Nicolae Constantinescu). Following the massacre, the killers thanked the prisons warden
for assisting them, then held a brief ceremony at Constantinescus grave.
Further Reading
Frantz, Douglas, and Catherine Collins. Death on the Black Sea. New York: HarperCollins, 2003.
Hitchens, Keith. Rumania 18661947. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994.
Petreu, Marta. An Infamous Past: E. M. Cioran and the Rise of Fascism in Romania. Chicago:
Ivan R. Dee, 2005.
Riley, Dylan. The Civic Foundations of Fascism in Europe: Italy, Spain, and Romania,
18701945. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2010.
121
122
D U D AY E V, D Z H O K H A R M U S AY E V I C H
location. The fighters fired two laser-guided missiles, and the ITAR-TASS news
agency subsequently announced that Dudayev died in the resulting explosions.
Chechen guerrilla commander Shamil Basayev confirmed Dudayevs death,
whereas Interfaxa nongovernmental Russian news agencycontradicted
that report, quoting Saipudi Khasanov, Dudayevs private secretary, as saying
that the president is alive and working as usual. Claims of Dudayevs survival
continued into 2003, but no evidence of a faked death has yet been produced.
Dzhokhar Dudayev was born at Yalkhoroy, a village named for its dominant
clan in the former ChechenIngush Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic, on
February 15, 1944. Days after his birth, the regions entire population was deported to the Kazakh Soviet Socialist Republic on orders from Russian dictator Joseph Stalin, living in exile until 1957. Following repatriation, Dudayev
studied to become an electrician, then joined the Russian army in 1962. Four
years later, he graduated from the Higher Military Aviation School for Pilots at
Tambov, then joined the Communist Party and thereby gained admission to
the Soviet Air Force Academy. Ultimately rising to the rank of major general,
he served in Afghanistan during 19861987, winning the Order of the Red
Banner and the Order of the Red Star for bravery. From 1987 to 1990, Dudayev commanded a unit of long-range nuclear bombers based at Tartu, Estonia, where he appeared to sympathize with nationalist dissidents, ignoring
orders to muzzle the Estonian media.
Retired from military service by May 1990, Dudayev returned to Chechnya and entered politics, winning election to the executive committee of the
separatist All-National Congress of the Chechen People (NCChP). Dissolution
of the Soviet Union in 1991 encouraged militant action, prompting NCChP
members to seize the local Supreme Soviet on September 6. A hasty referendum created the Chechen Republic of Ichkeria on November 1, with Dudayev
elected as its first president. Conflict between Ingush and Ossetian ethnic factions split the republic in June 1992, leaving the state of Ichkeria to declare
independence from the rest in June 1993. President Dudayev dissolved parliament and demanded withdrawal of all Russian troops from Chechnya.
The resultant First Chechen War erupted on December 1, 1994, when Russian bombers decimated Dudayevs air force at Grozny airport. A full-scale
invasion proceeded 10 days later, with Russian troops capturing Grozny, driving Dudayevs into hiding at a missile silo near the historic Chechen capital
of Vedeno. Although some native Muslims questioned their presidents faith,
based on his prior actions in Afghanistan, Dudayev appointed Akhmad Kadyrov as chief mufti of Ichkeria, followed by a declaration of jihad against Russian forces. Muslim volunteers from other nations bolstered Chechen ranks,
and the war dragged on, killing more than 23,000 soldiers and an estimated
100,000 civilians. Fighting continued for another four months after Dudayevs
assassination, ending with the Khasavyurt Accord on August 30, 1996.
D U D AY E V, D Z H O K H A R M U S AY E V I C H
123
E
EARP, MORGAN SETH (18511882)
The Wild Wests most famous gunfight occurred in Tombstone, Arizona, on
October 26, 1881. At 3:00 P.M. that Wednesday, the Earp brothersMorgan,
Virgil, and Wyatt, all local or federal lawmanjoined gambler John Doc Holliday to, as they later claimed, disarm a group of outlaws including William
Claiborne, Ike and Billy Clanton, and Frank and Tom McLaury. Claiborne
and Ike Clanton fled the battleground before the shooting started. When the
gun smoke cleared, with 30 shots fired in as many seconds, Billy Clanton and
both McLaury brothers were dead, and Holliday and two of the Earps suffered
flesh wounds. Ike Clanton charged the Earps and Holliday with murder, but a
month-long preliminary hearing exonerated them. Two months later, on December 28, unidentified gunmen shot Virgil Earp in an ambush, leaving him
with one arm permanently crippled. On March 18, 1882, at 10:50 P.M., an
unseen sniper killed Morgan Earp at a Tombstone billiards parlor, in the presence of Wyatt and three other witnesses. Recalling a family promise to share
any visions observed near the moment of death, Morgan gasped to Wyatt,
I cant see a damned thing.
Morgan Earp was born in Pella, Idaho, on April 24, 1851, the fourth of six
sons in a family today regarded as iconic Western figures. Eldest brother Newton Earp was satisfied to farm and raise a family after his service in the Civil
War, but his brothers passed into history, often lionized in fabricated tales of
derring-dofrom early dime novels to Hollywood filmsthat cast them as heroes. The truth, unearthed by slow degrees since the 1960s, is rather different.
James Earp, second oldest of the brothers, was a saloon keeper by preference, married in 1873 to a Wichita prostitute, but he also dabbled in law
enforcement as a deputy marshal in Dodge City, Kansas. Morgan joined him
there, also as a deputy, in 1875, followed by brother Wyatt in 1876 and Virgil in 1877. While arresting drunks, the brothers also managed gambling dens
and brothels in Dodge, earning a reputation as the fighting pimps for their
belligerence. James was the first to pull up stakes and move to Tombstone, in
1879, followed in 1880 by the other three and youngest brother Warren Earp.
Again, they settled in as gamblers, saloon keepers, and panderers, and Virgil
doubled as a deputy U.S. marshal for the eastern portion of Pima County, subsequently named as Tombstones city marshal. In that post, he deputized Morgan and Wyatt to help him enforce the Earps brand of law and order.
126
E A R P, M O R G A N S E T H
E A R P, M O R G A N S E T H
The day after that shootout, March 25, Tucsons grand jury indicted Pete
Spence, Frank Stilwell, Indian Charlie Cruz, Frederick Bode, and John Doe
Fries for Morgan Earps murder. Cruz and Spence were dead by then, and Fries
was absconding, but Spence and Bode faced trial on April 2. The prosecutor
called Spences wife, whereas defense attorneys objected to her evidence as
hearsay and insisted that a wife should not be forced to testify against her husband. The judge agreed, then dismissed the charges for lack of evidence.
Around the same time, Earps posse left Arizona for New Mexico Territory,
moving on from there to Colorado, beyond the reach of sheriff Behan. Denver police arrested Doc Holliday on May 15, 1882, for extradition to Tucson,
but Wyatt Earp persuaded friend Bat Mastersonthen marshal of Trinidad,
Coloradoto wangle Hollidays release from custody. Two months later, the
Cowboy gunman was shot and killed near Chiricahua Peak, in Arizonas Cochise County. His slayer was never identified, and whereas some researchers
blame Doc Holliday, court records from Pueblo County, Colorado, place Holliday there on July 11, 14, and 18, 1882.
Although Wyatt was unquestionably the most famous Earp brotherthanks
in large part to dime novels and his own self-promotional skillsMorgan also
appears in various film and television portrayals of the familys often-fictionalized
adventures. Actors who have portrayed him include Harvey Stephens in Tombstone, the Town Too Tough to Die (1942); Ward Bond in My Darling Clementine
(1946); Peter Graves in Wichita (1955); DeForest Kelley in Gunfight at the O.K.
Corral (1957); Sam Melville in Hour of the Gun (1967); Rex Holman in Spectre
of the Gun, a Star Trek episode originally aired on October 25, 1968; Philip
Shafer in Doc (1971); Bill Paxton in Tombstone (1993); Ray Boyle in Wyatt Earp:
Return to Tombstone (1994); Linden Ashby in Wyatt Earp (1994); and Austin
Nicols in an episode of HBOs Deadwood series, Leviathan Smiles, originally
aired on July 30, 2006. To date, the O.K. Corral gunfight and its aftermath
have been depicted in at least nine feature films since 1939, plus various documentaries. Perspectives on the conflict differ radically, and there seems little
doubt that controversy will continue.
Further Reading
Guinn, Jeff. The Last Gunfight: The Real Story of the Shootout at the O.K. CorralAnd
How It Changed the American West. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2012.
Marks, Paula. And Die in the West: The Story of the O.K. Corral Gunfight. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1996.
Roberts, Gary. Doc Holliday: The Life and Legend. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons,
2006.
Tefertiller, Casey. Wyatt Earp: The Life behind the Legend. New York: John Wiley & Sons,
1997.
Waters, Frank. The Earp Brothers of Tombstone. Lincoln, NE: Bison Books, 1976.
127
128
EDMUND I
EDMUND I (922946)
On May 26, 946, King Edmund I of England celebrated St. Augustines Mass
Day at Pucklechurch, a village in South Gloucestershire. While feasting with
other nobles, Edmund cast his eyes over the crowd and saw an exiled thief
named Leof (or Leofa, in some accounts) seated among the revelers. Recognizing the uninvited diner as an atrocious robber he had banished six years
earlier, Edmund rushed to arrest Leof himself. Grabbing the bandit by his hair,
he threw Leof to the floor, but was stabbed in the chest when Leof drew a hidden dagger. As Edmund lay dying, his attendants mobbed the killer, reportedly
tearing him limb from limb.
Born at Wessex in 922, Edmund was the son of King Edward the Elder and
his third wife, and half-brother to Aethelstan, first king of a unified England
from 927 to 939. In 937, he fought at Aethelstans side in the Battle of Brunanburh, defeating the combined forces of Norse-Gael king Olaf Guthfrithsson,
Constantine II of Scotland, and Owen I of Strathclyde. At Aethelstans death,
on October 27, 939, Edmund
succeeded him as king.
Olaf Guthfrithsson, still
smarting from his previous defeat, conquered Northumbria
and part of Mercia (now the
Midlands), but Edmund began
recapturing that territory after
Olaf died in 941. Four years
later, he conquered Strathclyde,
then ceded it to King Malcolm I of Scotland in return
for a pledge of mutual military
support. Those campaigns
as well as Edmunds revival of
monasteries in England, and his
role in restoring Louis IV to the
throne of Franceearned him
recognition in his lifetime as Edmund the Deed-doer, Edmund
the Just, and Edmund the Magnificent. In retrospect, his primary achievement as king was
the establishment of a safe borKing Edmund I of England, murdered by an exiled der and peaceful relations with
bandit at a feast. (Getty Images)
Scotland, to the north.
E D WA R D T H E M A R T Y R
129
130
E D WA R D T H E M A R T Y R
earthly relatives would not avenge him, but his Heavenly Father has much
avenged him.
The eldest son of King Edgar the Peaceable, born circa 962, Edward was
crowned at Edgars death in July 975, supported by Archbishops Dunstan and
Oswald, despite protests from his younger half-brother, dubbed thelred the
Unready. Hostile noblemen lfhere of Mercia and thelwine of East Anglia
soon took advantage of young Edwards weakness to seize lands bestowed by his
father to various Benedictine monasteries, briefly threatening a civil war that is
sometimes called the anti-monastic reaction to Edgars close relations with the
church. The appearance of a comet in the heavens seemingly encouraged many
superstitious folk to join church leaders in supporting Edwards coronation.
If so, his succession did not help clerical reformers who had supported his father. Corrupt secular clerics, banished under Edgar, soon returned and routed
their opponents from various English monasteries, and nobles forced beleaguered
abbots to surrender leases granted under Edgar. Although few documents remain
from Edwards reign, it is known that he reversed his fathers policy of minting
coins only at Westminster. That change, coupled with his inability to halt quarrels
between rival lords in the hinterlands, leaves an impression of weakness and disorganization for his short tenure as king.
Following Edwards murder, the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle declared that he was
buried at Wareham, in Dorset, without any royal honors. Archbishop Wulfstan II, writing between 1010 and 1016 in his Sermo Lupi ad Anglos (Sermon
of the Wolf to the English), goes further yet, stating that Edwards corpse was
burned. Something must have remained, because his corpse was reburied with
high ceremony in February 980, at Shaftesbury Abbey in Dorset, then moved
again in 1001 to a more prominent place at the same abbey. His portrayal as a
martyr apparently springs from Edwards support of his fathers policy toward
the church, as portrayed in clerical writings. King Henry VIII dissolved Englands monasteries in the 16th century, but monks concealed Edwards remains
to avert desecration. Archaeologists recovered and tentatively identified his
bones in 1931. A dispute arose, as to who should claim the relics, with claims
filed by Shaftesbury abbey and the Russian Orthodox Church outside Russia.
Edwardif it was Edwardspent decades in a Surrey bank vault, before he
was finally consigned to Wokings Brookwood Cemetery, in September 1984.
Further Reading
Fell, Christine. Edward, King and Martyr. Leeds: University of Leeds School of English,
1971.
Higham, Nick. The Death of Anglo-Saxon England. Stroud, United Kingdom: Sutton,
1997.
Panton, Kenneth. Historical Dictionary of the British Monarchy. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow
Press, 2011.
EISNER, KURT
131
132
ELISABETH OF AUSTRIA
the rebellion continued until August 1919, with adoption of the Weimar Constitution declaring Germany a democratic parliamentary. Eisner did not live to
see that transient victory, however, as German backlash over the harsh Treaty
of Versailles led to his partys electoral defeat in January 1919, overwhelmed by
the conservative Bavarian Peoples Party.
Anton Arco-Valley was convicted of Eisners murder and sentenced to death
in January 1920, but a friendly right-wing judge commuted his sentence to five
years in prison, and the state prosecutor declared, If the whole German youth
were imbued with such a glowing enthusiasm we could face the future with
confidence. Arco-Valley remained in Cell 70 at Stadelheim Prison until 1924,
when he was released to make room for recently convicted Adolf Hitler. Placed
on probation until 1927, Arco-Valley was then pardoned and apparently retired from public life, although Third Reich leaders later decorated him as a
hero of the [Nazi] movement. Hitler seemed ambivalent toward Arco-Valley,
writing that Eisners death only hastened developments and led finally to the
Soviet dictatorship, or to put it more correctly, to a passing rule of Jews, as
had been the original aim of the instigators of the whole revolution. Perhaps
ironically, Arco-Valleys elder brother married a cousin of Raoul Wallenberg, a
Swedish diplomat who rescued thousands of Jews from Nazi-occupied Hungary during World War II.
Further Reading
Grunberger, Richard. Red Rising in Bavaria. Galway, Ireland: M.W. Books, 1973.
Luhrssen, David. Hammer of the Gods: The Thule Society and the Birth of Nazism. Dulles,
VA: Potomac Books, 2012.
Mitchell, Allan. Revolution in Bavaria, 19181919: The Eisner Regime and the Soviet
Republic. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1965.
ELISABETH OF AUSTRIA
133
134
ELISABETH OF AUSTRIA
1889 (found with his murdered mistress, Baroness Marie Alexandrine von Vetsera). She avoided having any other children, and was heard to say, Children
are the curse of a woman, for when they come, they drive away Beauty, which is
the best gift of the gods. On the day of her assassination, Elisabeths trademark
corset initially prevented her from realizing that she had been stabbed.
On receiving news of his wifes death, Franz Joseph feared that it was suicide. An autopsy proved otherwise, after which the postmortem instruments
and photographs were destroyed on orders from the emperor. Meanwhile,
Luigi Lucheni was detained while fleeing from the scene of the attack, and his
discarded weapon was recovered on September 11. In custody, Lucheni said
he had chosen his toolused to file the eyes of industrial needlesbecause he
lacked 12 francs to purchase a stiletto. Committed to the propaganda of the
deed, he declared, I am an anarchist by conviction . . . I came to Geneva to
kill a sovereign, with object of giving an example to those who suffer and those
who do nothing to improve their social position; it did not matter to me who
the sovereign was whom I should kill . . . It was not a woman I struck, but an
Empress; it was a crown that I had in view.
At trial in October 1898, Lucheni was enraged to hear that Geneva had abolished capital punishment. Seeking martyrdom, he penned a letter demanding
trial in the Canton of Lucerne, where executions were still permitted, signing
the note, Luigi Lucheni, anarchist, and one of the most dangerous. Instead,
he was sentenced to life imprisonment and began work on a lengthy memoir.
After guards seized that manuscript, in October 1910, Lucheni hanged himself
in his cell.
Despite Luchenis insistence that he acted alone, Elisabeths murder inspired
the International Conference of Rome for the Social Defense against Anarchists,
held between November 24 and December 21, 1898, with delegates from 21
nations attending. After defining anarchism as as any act that used violent
means to destroy the organization of society, all participating countries agreed
to create special agencies to conduct surveillance on suspected anarchists, ban
membership in anarchist organizations, restrict civilian access to explosives,
limit press coverage of anarchist activities, and impose mandatory capital punishment for killing heads of state.
Empress ElisabethSisi to her friends, frequently misspelled Sissi for
some unknown reason in fictional workshas proved irresistible to authors
of stage productions, films, novels, and television programs. Stage productions
based on her life include Fritz Kreislers comic operetta Sissi (1932); Jean Cocteaus play LAigle deux ttes (The Eagle with Two Heads), written in 1943 and
first produced in 1946; Kenneth MacMillans ballet Mayerling (1978); the musical Elisabeth (1992); and Maurice Bjarts 1993 ballet Sissi, limpratice anarchiste (Sissi, Anarchist Empress). Feature films include Kaiserin Elisabeth von
sterreich (1921), coauthored by Elisabeths niece, Marie Larisch; The King Steps
ERIC V OF DENMARK
Out (1936); Cocteaus The Eagle with Two Heads (1948); Sissi (1955); SissiThe
Young Empress (1956); SissiFateful Years of an Empress (1957); Forever My
Love (1962); Mayerling (1968); Michelangelo Antonionis The Mystery of Oberwald (1981); and Sisi/Last Minute (1991). Fictionalized television portrayals of
Elisabeth include Fall of Eagles (1974); Princess Sissi (1997); Sissi, limpratrice
rebelle (2004); The Crown Prince (2006); and Sisi (2009). Elisabeth also appears
as a character in at least three novels: Stars in My Heart, by Barbara Cartland
(1981); Spangle, by Gary Jennings (1987); and Elisabeth: The Princess Bride, by
Barry Denenberg (2003).
Further Reading
Buschek, Alfred. Elisabeth, Empress of Austria. Concord, MA: Infinity Publishing, 2010.
Cunliffe-Owen, Marguerite. Martyrdom of an Empress. Whitefish, MT: Kessinger Publishing, 2005.
Hamann, Bridget. The Reluctant Empress. Berlin: Ullstein Taschenbuch, 2000.
Haslip, Joan. The Lonely Empress: Elisabeth of Austria. Phoenix, NY: Phoenix Press,
2000.
Stephan, Renate. Empress Elisabeth of Austria, 18371898: The Fate of a Woman Under
the Yoke of the Imperial Court. Vienna: Austria Imperial, 1998.
135
136
end. Jarimar might have pressed farther, but he was slain by a rural farmers
wife, whereupon his leaderless army withdrew.
Queen Margaret, meanwhile, faced a new challenge from Duke Valdemar of
southern Jutland, supported by German allies. Their combined might defeated
Danish forces at the Battle of Lo Heath, capturing both Margaret and Eric in
1261, compelling Margaret to cede royal property in Jutland as the price of
their release. Archbishop Erlandsen, meanwhile, persisted in his efforts to depose the queen and Eric, until Pope Urban IV intervened.
As an adult monarch, Eric aggravated other Danish nobles by attempting to
reduce their personal authority, breaking his promises at every turn, and by
seducing any woman who aroused him, regardless of age or marital status. He
earned the nickname Klippingfrom the common medieval practice of cutting coins to reduce their valueas a demonstration of popular opinion that
he had cheated or short-changed both his subjects and the Danish monarchy
itself. Historians remain undecided as to which of his unfortunate character
traits contributed the most to Erics murder.
One point of broad agreement is that the conviction of his supposed assassins
was probably a miscarriage of justice. Although Stig Andersen Hvide had ample
reason to wish Eric dead, no evidence placed him or any of his codefendants at
the scene of the crime. Neither was the accused permitted to testify in their own
defense, or to call supporting witnesses, rights clearly granted to them under
Danish law. Even their motive was dubious, because all nine were intimates of
Eric and actually stood to lose influence at his death. Convicted nonetheless,
Andersen settled on the island of Hjelm and raised a band of pirates who terrorized the Danish coast until his death in December 1293. Count Nielsen retired
to Halland and allied himself with King Eric II of Norway, but his influence declined as Eric II and successor Haakon V lost interest in conquering Denmark.
Twelve-year-old Eric VI succeeded his father as king of Denmark in 1286,
with his motherqueen consort Agnes of Brandenburgruling as regent until
1294. Unrest persisted, and his reign continued Denmarks Age of Decay, including further conflict with the church and rival noblemen.
Further Reading
Jespersen, Knud. A History of Denmark. Houndsmill, Hampshire, United Kingdom:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2004.
Jordan William. Europe in the High Middle Ages. London: Penguin Books, 2004.
rebellious nobles on September 30, 1568. The rebels chose Erics half-brother,
Duke John of Finland, to replace him on the throne, while Eric was imprisoned, shuttled around various castles in Sweden and Finland over the next
eight years. He died on February 25, 1577, after consuming a meal of pea
soup that was said to be poisoned. A document signed by King John III and Sir
Bengt Bengtsson Gilt, a Swedish judge, empowered Erics jailers to poison him
if anyone tried to release him from custody, but his cause of death remained
uncertain until 1958, when exhumation and autopsy revealed lethal levels of
arsenic in Erics remains.
Born at Stockholms Tre Kronor (Three Crowns) Castle on December 13,
1533, Eric lost his motherqueen consort Catherine of Saxe-Lauenburg
seven weeks before his second birthday. Rumors spread that Erics father,
Gustav I, had murdered Catherine with a hammer, but a 20th-century examination of her skeleton revealed no evidence of homicide. Gustav married
Swedish noblewoman Margaret Leijonhufvud in 1536, and she bore him seven
children, including two future kings. At Gustavs death, in September 1560,
Swedens parliament elected Eric as the nations next monarch.
Whereas Gustav had satisfied himself with ruling an independent kingdom,
Eric sought to build an empire in the Baltic region and by seizing territory
from Estonia. By 1563, when those ambitions sparked the Northern Seven
Years War, with Sweden battling a coalition of Denmark, Norway, the Free
City of Lbeck, and the PolishLithuanian Union, Erics mental instability had
grown apparent to his family and other members of his court. Arbitrary rule,
marked by fits of personal violence, reached its nadir in July 1566, when a
group of concerned nobles gathered in Stockholm to discuss Erics increasingly erratic behavior. Learning of their treason, Eric invited them to Svartsj
Palace, where they were confined and placed on trial, convicted, and subsequently murdered in their cells on May 24, 1567.
That massacre, during which Eric personally stabbed one of the prisoners to death, paved the way for the rebellion that dethroned Eric in 1568. Although his life was spared, the order for jailers to kill him if escape seemed
imminent suggests the danger that was seen in his attempting to regain the
throne. John III ruled Sweden for another 15 years after his brothers death in
custody, also assuming the title Grand Prince of Finland in 1581. His son, Sigismund III Vasa, was crowned king of Poland in September 1587, thereby resolving one of Swedens foreign conflicts. At Johns death, in November 1592,
Sigismund succeeded him as Swedens king. He tried to rule from Poland,
while restoring strict Roman Catholicism to his homeland, but that effort led
to his defeat at Battle of Stngebro, in September 1598. Thereafter, Sigismund
ruled Sweden from abroad, but he returned to Poland and was then officially
deposed in July 1599.
137
138
E R I M , I S M A I L N I H AT
Further Reading
Bain, Robert. Scandinavia: A Political History of Denmark, Norway and Sweden from 1513
to 1900. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1905.
Robert, Michael. The Swedish Imperial Experience, 15601718. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1984.
Turkish prime minister Ismail Erim, shot by members of the Revolutionary Left in Istanbul. (Bettmann/Corbis)
E R I M , I S M A I L N I H AT
to 1943, when he was named as legal advisor to the Turkish ministry of foreign affairs. In 1945, he joined Turkeys delegation to the founding conference
of the United Nations, and was elected to represent Kocaeli Province in Turkeys parliament, as a member of the Republican Peoples Party. Appointed as
minister of public works in June 1948, Erim held that post until January 1949,
when he was elevated to the job of deputy prime minister.
Erims party lost its parliamentary majority in May 1950, whereupon he
became chief political editor for the newspaper Ulus (Nation). When that
paper shut down in 1953, Erim published his own, Yeni UlusHalk (New
NationPopulist). In 1956, he was elected as Turkeys representative to the
European Commission of Human Rights, and also participated in negotiations over Cyprus, held in London. His involvement with Cyprus continued
through 1959, when Erim led Turkeys committee on preparation of a new
Cypriot constitution.
Turkeys military coup of May 27, 1960, toppled the ruling Democrat Party,
but the junta restored civilian government in October 1961. Erim was reelected to parliament from Kocaeli Province, and began nine years of service
as Turkeys representative to the Council of Europe, winning election as that
bodys deputy secretary general. In 1969, he was appointed as a member of
the United Nations International Law Commission, at The Hague. Meanwhile,
political mayhem continued in Turkey, capped by another military coup on
March 12, 1971. Two weeks later, the ruling junta chose Erim as a neutral
prime minister, seated to form a coalition government for national unity. That
effort proved fruitless, and mass resignation of his cabinet led Erim to resign
on December 3, 1971. President Cevdet Sunay restored Erim to his post eight
days later, but poor health led Erim to resign for good on April 17, 1972.
Violence on right and left accelerated through the remainder of the 1970s,
with 5,388 political murders recorded by 1978. At the time of Erims death,
planning was underway for Turkeys third coup dtat, initially scheduled
for July 11, 1980, then pushed back to August 26, and yet again to September 12. On that final date, General Kenan Evren, army chief of staff, seized
Turkish airwaves and declared martial law nationwide in the name of the
National Security Council. Later investigation revealed that Evren had solicited
support from other army officers a full year earlier, beginning on September 11, 1979. The generals of Turkeys War Academy had voted to support the
coup on December 21, 1979, with a formal proposal for the plandubbed
Operation Flagdrafted in March 1980.
In June 1981, the junta appointed 160 persons to draft a new constitution for
Turkey, which was approved by public referendum in June 1982. Democratic
elections resumed in November 1983, but although the generals sought to dictate terms of their own retirement, they were not entirely successful. Another
referendum, in September 2010, launched an investigation of the coup and led
139
140
to the foundation of a Specially Authorized Ankara Deputy Prosecutors Office in June 2011. In January 2012, indictments were filed against ex-generals
Evren and Tahsin Sahinkaya, the only coup leaders still living. Charged with
the deaths of 191 political prisoners, the defendants were scheduled to face
trial in April 2012.
Further Reading
Ahmad, Feroz. The Making of Modern Turkey. London: Routledge, 1993.
Hale, William. Turkish Politics and the Military. London: Routledge, 1993.
Zrcher, Eric. Turkey: A Modern History. London: I.B. Tauris, 2005.
141
142
E WA R T- B I G G S, C H R I S T O P H E R T H O M A S
Further Reading
Evers, Myrlie, and William Peters. For Us, the Living. Oxford: University Press of Mississippi, 1996.
Massengill, Reed. Portrait of a Racist. New York: St. Martins Press, 1994.
Nossiter, Adam. Of Long Memory: Mississippi and the Murder of Medgar Evers. Boston:
Addison-Wesley, 1994.
Vollers, Maryanne. Ghosts of Mississippi: The Murder of Medgar Evers, the Trials of Byron
De La Beckwith, and the Haunting of the New South. New York: Back Bay Books, 1995.
Williams, Michael. Medgar Evers: Mississippi Martyr. Little Rock: University of Arkansas
Press, 2011.
E WA R T- B I G G S , C H R I S T O P H E R T H O M A S
occupied by British ambassador to Ireland Christopher Ewart-Biggs and others. The blast killed Ewart-Biggs and civil servant Judith Cooke, while wounding driver Brian ODriscoll and passenger Sir Brian Cubbon, then Northern
Irelands highest-ranking government official as permanent undersecretary of
state. Irish Taoiseach (prime minister) Liam Cosgrave declared the bombing an
atrocity [that] fills all decent Irish people with a sense of shame, and British
prime minister James Callaghan branded the killers a common enemy whom
we must destroy or be destroyed by. Authorities detained 13 suspected PIRA
members after the assassination, but no convictions were obtained and the
crime remains officially unsolved.
Christopher Ewart-Biggs was born in Thanet, Kent, on August 5, 1921, the
son of a captain in the Royal Engineers. He attended Wellington College, in
Berkshire, and University College, Oxford, prior to the outbreak of World
War II. Enlisting with the British armys Queens Own Royal West Kent Regiment, he participated in the Second Battle of El Alamein (October 1942), and
was wounded there, losing his right eye to shrapnel. Thereafter, Ewart-Biggs
wore a false eye partially disguised by a smoked-glass monocle that became his
personal trademark.
Leaving the army for a career in diplomatic service, Ewart-Biggs next found
his life at risk in Algeria, where he served as British consul in early 1961,
during transition from French colonial rule to independence. Perhaps fortunately, diehard colonialists operating as the Organisation de larme secrte (Secret Army Organization) focused most of their homicidal energy on French
president Charles de Gaulle, and Ewart-Biggs left Algiers unscathed, while an
estimated 50,000 persons were slain by lynch mobs in the wake of liberation.
Ireland was another danger zone for British diplomats in 1976, when
Ewart-Biggs replaced Sir Arthur Galsworthy as ambassador to Dublin. The latest
round of Northern Irelands troubles had begun in May 1966, when a loyalist paramilitary group, the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF), publicly declared war
on the Irish Republican Army. A campaign of sectarian murders targeting Catholics ensued, followed by rioting between loyalists and republicans in Belfast
and elsewhere. A split in IRA ranks spawned the new PIRA in December 1969,
pursuing a policy of armed resistance against right-wing terrorists, police, and
British occupation forces. By spring 1974, the PIRA had expanded its bombing
campaign to England and the Republic of Ireland, with lethal blasts in Dublin,
Monaghan, and West Yorkshire. A PIRA truce, announced in February 1975,
foundered in January 1976, as Ambassador Galsworthy prepared to retire. The
UVF renewed hostilities by executing six Catholic civilians in County Armagh,
whereupon PIRA gunmen killed 10 Protestants in the same district. As Britains
new ambassador to Ireland, appointed in July, Ewart-Biggs became an irresistible target.
Following her husbands murder, Jane Ewart-Biggs entered politics as a
member of the Labour Party and became a Life Peer in the House of Lords, in
143
144
E WA R T- B I G G S, C H R I S T O P H E R T H O M A S
May 1981. There, she campaigned to improve Anglo-Irish relations, and also
served in 1984 as president of the United Nations Childrens Fund (UNICEF).
Outside of politics, in 1977, she established the Christopher Ewart-Biggs Memorial Prize, awarding 5,000 annually to a book, a play, or a piece of journalism that promotes peace and reconciliation in Ireland, a greater understanding
between the peoples of Britain and Ireland, or closer cooperation between
partners of the European Community.
Further Reading
Bishop, Patrick, and Eamonn Mallie. The Provisional IRA. London: Corgi, 1987.
Coogan, Tim. The IRA. New York: Palgrave, 2000.
McKearney, Tommy. The Provisional IRA: From Insurrection to Parliament. London: Pluto
Press, 2011.
Shanahan, Timothy. The Provisional Irish Republican Army and the Morality of Terrorism.
Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2008.
F
FAISAL BIN ABDUL-AZIZ AL SAUD
(19061975)
On March 25, 1975, while entertaining petitions from his subjects at the royal
residence in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, King Faisal greeted visitors from neighboring
Kuwait. His half-brothers son, Prince Faisal bin Musa'id bin Abdul-Aziz, was
also present, having recently returned from the United States. As King Faisal
leaned in to kiss his nephew, Prince Faisal drew a pistol and shot his uncle
twice, in the chin and ear. A bodyguard slashed at the prince with a sheathed
sword, while Oil Minister Ahmed Zaki Yamani shouted orders to spare the
princes life. King Faisal reached the hospital alive, but surgeons could not save
his life. Despite reports that he forbade Prince Faisals execution with his dying
breath, the assassin was convicted of murder on June 18, 1975, and publicly
beheaded the same afternoon, before a crowd of thousands. His brother, Bandar, served a year in prison on suspicion of conspiracy, and was then released.
Born in Riyadh, in April 1906, Faisal was the third son of Abdul-Aziz ibn
Saud, first king of Nejd and Hejaz from 1926 to 1932, then first king of Saudi
Arabia from August 1932 until his death in November 1953. Son Saud bin
Abdul-Aziz Al Saud assumed the throne, and younger brother Faisal graduated from service as governor of Hijaz (appointed by their father in 1925) to
become minister of foreign affairs, also commanding an army unit that participated in the SaudiYemeni War of early 1934. Vast wealth derived from oil
in the wake of World War II sent King Saud on an epic spending spree that,
coupled with his evident incompetence in foreign affairs, appeared to threaten
both the monarchy and the nation.
In 1958, senior members of the royal family and high-ranking Muslim clerics persuaded Saud to make Faisal prime minister, with sweeping executive
powers. Faisal curbed spending, then resigned his post in December 1960,
in a dispute with Saud over the level of authority granted to Saudi Arabias
Council of Ministers. He was reinstalled as prime minister in 1962, but conflicts with his brother continued, prompting Saud to abolish the office by
royal decree. In January 1963, while Saud sought medical treatment abroad,
Faisal replaced key office holders with his own supporters and placed his
brother Abdullah in charge of the National Guard. Saud returned to find himself outnumbered and outgunned, pressured to accept a purely ceremonial
146
FA I S A L I I O F I R AQ
role and Faisal assumed command of the country. Saud resisted until March
1964, when Faisal was appointed as regent, formally replacing his brother as
king on November 2, 1964.
As king, Faisal balanced the nations budget, increased oil production, and
supported selective modernization of Saudi Arabias government, including
the establishment of a judicial system and civil service, a modern welfare system, creation of administrative regions, and pursuance of five-year plans for
economic development. Faisal had already established the nations first television station, although broadcasts were delayed until 1965. A year later, one of
his ultraconservative nephewsPrince Khalid ibn Musaid, brother of Faisals
assassinwas killed by police while attacking a Saudi television station he
condemned as decadent. In 1969, Faisal arrested hundreds of army officers,
announcing that they had conspired to depose him by force. Closely allied
with the United States, he reportedly learned of the budding coup from agents
of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA).
Journalists suggested three possible motives for Faisals assassination. One
school of thought suggested that Prince Faisal acted belatedly to avenge his
brothers killing by police, nine years earlier. The Lebanese newspaper An-Nahar
speculated that his death was retribution for deposing King Saud in 1964. A rival
paper, Al-Bayrak, alleged that King Faisal had restricted his nephewassassins
foreign travels, based on concern over Prince Faisals drinking and drug abuse
while outside the country. A fourth theory, popular with anti-American elements,
claimed that the CIA had used Prince Faisal to eliminate the king. No motive for
the agencys decision to assassinate a seeming friend was ever clarified.
King Faisal was succeeded by a younger brother, Khalid bin Abdul-Aziz
Al Saud, who reigned until his death from heart failure in June 1982. Another brother, Fahd bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud, then occupied the throne until
his death from pneumonia in August 2005. The countrys present king, brother
Abdullah bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud, maintains his familys longstanding alliance
with the United States.
Further Reading
Beling, Willard. King Faisal and the Modernisation of Saudi Arabia. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1980.
de Gaury, Gerald. Faisal: King of Saudi Arabia. Louisville, KY: Fons Vitae, 2008.
Stefoff, Rebecca. Faisal. Louisville, KY: Fons Vitae, 2008.
Vassiliev, Alexi. King Faisal of Saudi Arabia: Personality, Faith and Times. London: Saqi
Books, 2013.
FA I S A L I I O F I R A Q
147
148
FA L C N , R A M N L O R E N ZO
By the time Faisal assumed his throne, rebellion was already brewing inside
his army. A corps of pan-Arab Free Officers, inspired by those who toppled
Egypts monarchy in 1952, fomented uprisings in Hayy and Najaf in 1956. In
February 1957, a coalition of the Arab Socialist Baath Party, Iraqs Communist
Party, and the National Democrats organized a Front of National Union, supported by a parallel Supreme Committee of Free Officers within the Iraqi officer corps, which ultimately served as the spearhead of rebellion against King
Faisal.
Following destruction of the monarchy, a revolutionary council was established, with General Qasim serving as prime minister and minister of defense,
and Colonel Abdul Salam Arif became deputy prime minister, minister of the
interior, and commander in chief of the army. A three-man Sovereignty Council was created, with representatives from Iraqs three largest ethnic groups:
Muhammad Mahdi Kubbah spoke for Shiite Muslims; Muhammad Najib arRubaI represented Sunnis; and Khalid al-Naqshabandi served as spokesman
for the Kurds. Despite those measures, and announcement of a temporary
constitution on July 27, 1958, an era of political upheaval followed the July
revolution. In March 1959, the New York Times declared Iraq confused and
unstable, plagued by cross currents of communism, Arab and Iraqi nationalism, anti-Westernism and the positive neutrality of President Gamal Abdel
Nasser of the United Arab Republic.
That instability resulted in ultimate triumph for the Baath Party, which led a
coup against President Qasim in February 1963, supported by the U.S. Central
Intelligence Agency. Party chief Ahmed Hassan al-Bakr seized office as prime
minister, advanced to the presidency and chairmanship of the Revolutionary
Command Council in July 1968, then was replaced by fellow Baathist Saddam
Hussein in July 1979.
Further Reading
de Gaury, Gerald. Three Kings in Baghdad: The Tragedy of Iraqs Monarchy. London: I.B.
Tauris, 2008.
Khadduri, Majid. Independent Iraq, 19321958. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1960.
Tripp, Charles. A History of Iraq. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
FA L C N , R A M N L O R E N Z O
through the window. Its explosion fatally wounded both Falcn and Lartigau,
both victims dying before they reached the nearest hospital. Arrested at the
scene, Radowitzky described his attack as retribution for the Semana Roja (Red
Week) in May 1909, when Falcns police shot and brutalized striking workers in Buenos Aires. Convicted of murder and sentenced to death, 18-year-old
Radowitzky secured commutation of his sentence to indefinite imprisonment
by proving that he was a minor.
A native of Buenos Aires, born on August 30, 1855, Ramn Falcn was
among the first enrollees at Brazils National Military College, graduating with
honors in 1873. He subsequently served as aide-de-camp to President Domingo Faustino Sarmiento, then joined in General Julio Argentino Rocas Conquest of the Desert campaign during 18781879, annihilating native villages
whose land was coveted by wealthy cattle ranchers. As General Roca explained
the campaign: Our self-respect as a virile people obliges us to put down as
soon as possible, by reason or by force, this handful of savages who destroy our
wealth and prevent us from definitely occupying, in the name of law, progress
and our own security, the richest and most fertile lands of the Republic.
On a lighter note, in 1887, Falcn founded the Club de Gimnasia y Esgrima
La Plata, today the Western Hemispheres oldest soccer club, still in existence
today. Retiring from the army as a colonel, in 1898, he was elected to Argentinas Chamber of Deputies as a member of the ruling National Autonomist
Party. In 1906, with the outbreak of organized labor unrest, President Jos
Figueroa Alcorta chose Falcn to lead the Polica de la Capital and crush insurgent movements.
To that end, Falcn employed the tactics he had learned in military service, while annihilating aboriginal tribesmen. During the Buenos Aires Tenants
Strike of July 1907, he fielded mounted troops armed with sabers against unarmed protesters, and drove rent strikers from their homes with high-pressure
hoses. On May 1, 1909, members of the anarchist Argentine Regional Workers Federation (FORA) staged a May Day demonstration in the capital, where
Falcns shock troops killed 11 marchers and wounded more than 100. That
incident sparked a general strike, and led in turn to Falcns Red Week of unbridled violence, coupled with anti-Semitic propaganda against Russian Jewish
instigators and enforced censorship of newspaper reports on police brutality.
On Falcns orders, police also shut down FORAs newspaper, La Protesta Humana, and La Vanguardia, published by the Socialist Party of Argentina. Benito
Villanueva, president of Argentinas senate, later intervened to reduce the long
prison terms handed out to demonstrators jailed in May 1909, but President
Alcorta and members of the Buenos Aires Stock Exchange staged a rally in the
chiefs support.
Following Falcns assassination, President Alcorta declared a nationwide
state of siege and signed a Law of Social Defense, permitting deportation of
149
150
the temples entrance, fleeing with their victims severed limbs into Guangdong
Province.
Joao Ferreira do Amaral was born in Lisbon, Portugal, on March 4, 1803,
the eldest son of a sergeant in the Portuguese Legion who had joined Napoleons invasion of Russia in 1812 and lost his life there. Ferreira subsequently
joined the Portuguese navy as a midshipman, advancing to the rank of commander by 1821. That same year, he was wounded in a naval engagement with
Brazilian rebels, requiring amputation of one arm. After the surgery, performed
while Ferreira smoked a cigar, he reportedly tossed his severed limb overboard
with a shout of Viva Portugal!
That incident and other exploits marked Ferreira for further advancement.
By 1839, he was designated Captain of Sea and War (equivalent to full captain in the U.S. or British navies), and a knight fidalgo (son of somebody
i.e., an important person) of the Portuguese Royal household. After serving
as a legislator for Angola in Portugals Chamber of Deputies, Ferreira was appointed to serve as governor of Macau on April 21, 1846. Within a month
of taking office, he imposed a poll tax, property tax, and ground rent on all
Chinese residents of the colony. Protests from Beijing were immediate and
prolonged, ending only when Ferreira expelled Qing officials en masse from
Macau.
Ferreiras assassination prompted demands for retribution from Portugal,
echoed by supporting statements from the U.S., British, and Spanish consulates in nearby Hong Kong. It also triggered the Baishaling Incident, as Chinese imperial troops mobilized on the border separating mainland Guangdong
Province from Macau. On August 25, Second Lieutenant Vicente Nicolau de
Mesquita staged a preemptive strike against a Chinese fort at Baishaling, capturing the garrison of 400 soldiers and 20 cannons with a force of only 36 Portuguese troops. Authorities in Guangdong forestalled further attacks by arresting
and executing Shen Zhiliang. In the process, they also recovered Ferreiras
missing arms and legs, returning them to the Portuguese colonial government.
Guangdong villagers buried Shen under a headstone calling him a fighter for
justice, whereas the Portuguese stamped the seal of their nations royal family on a stone outside the Lin Fong Temple. Perhaps surprisingly, given conditions in the colony, Ferreira was the only one of 189 Portuguese rulers killed in
Macau by their Chinese subjects, during 450 years of colonial rule.
Further Reading
Ng, Maria. Pilgrimages: Memories of Colonial Macau and Hong Kong. Hong Kong: Hong
Kong University Press, 2009.
Yik-yi Chu, Cindy. Foreign Communities in Hong Kong, 1840s1950s. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005.
151
152
F O R D, G E R A L D R U D O L P H , J R .
who had kidnapped his daughter), fired a .38-caliber revolver at Ford as the
president left San Franciscos St. Francis Hotel. A bystander deflected the shot,
which struck a wall six inches from Fords head and ricocheted to wound a
taxi driver. As Moore explained her act: The government had declared war
on the left. Nixons appointment of Ford as vice president and his resignation
making Ford president seemed to be a continuing assault on America. I didnt
want to kill anybody, but there comes a point when the only way you can
make a statement is to pick up a gun. I do regret I didnt succeed, and allow
the winds of change to start. I wish I had killed him. I did it to create chaos.
Like Fromme, Moore was sentenced to life, paroled in December 2007 after
serving 32 years.
Gerald Ford was born Leslie Lynch King Jr., in Omaha, Nebraska, on July 14,
1913. His parents separated 16 days after his birth, and divorced when he was
five months old. His mother remarried in 1916, to Gerald Rudolff Ford, and
applied the same name to her son, although her new husband never adopted
the child. In later life, Ford changed the spelling of his middle name to the
more conventional Rudolph and kept the Junior.
Ford graduated from the University of Michigan in 1934, working as a boxing and basketball coach. Yale Law School rejected him in 1935, then reconsidered three years later, after Ford had spent a year of study at his alma maters
law school. He earned his LLB in 1941, was admitted to Michigans bar that
same year, then joined the U.S. Navy following the Japanese attack on Pearl
Harbor. Discharged as a lieutenant commander in 1946, he returned to Michigan and entered politics as a Republican, winning the first of 12 congressional
terms in 1948. During 19631964 he served on the Warren Commission, appointed to investigate the assassination of President John Kennedy, and critics of that investigation cite Fords close friendship with FBI Director J. Edgar
Hoover to support claims of a whitewash, suggesting that Ford was Hoovers
man on the commission. From January 1965 to December 1973, Ford served
as House Minority Leader.
In October 1973, President Nixon nominated Ford to succeed Vice President Spiro Agnew, who had resigned and later pled no contest to taxevasion charges. The House confirmed Ford on December 6, and Nixon
subsequently resigned in August 1974, leaving Ford as president. He remains the only Oval Office occupant in U.S. history who was never elected
as president or as vice president by the Electoral College. On September 8,
1974, when Ford pardoned Nixon for any and all crimes committed during
his presidency, many observers railed against the appearance of a corrupt
bargain between Ford and Nixon. Ford, for his part, described Nixons humiliation as a tragedy in which we all have played a part. It could go on and
on and on, or someone must write the end to it. I have concluded that only
I can do that, and if I can, I must.
153
154
F O R D, G E R A L D R U D O L P H , J R .
Lingering controversy over that pardon, coupled with various domestic and
foreign issues, ensured that Ford would be a one-term president. He agreed reluctantly to seek another term, but floundered in debates with former Georgia
governor Jimmy Carter, despite Carters own missteps in the public eye. On
election day, Ford carried 27 states to Carters 23, but he failed to secure an
electoral majority. Ford remained active in the Republican Party after his defeat, and lived longer than any other U.S. president, dying in December 2006
at the age of 93 years and 165 days.
Further Reading
Bravin, Jess. Squeaky: The Life and Times of Lynette Alice Fromme. New York: St. Martins
Press, 1997.
Brinkley, Douglas. Gerald R. Ford. New York: Times Books, 2007.
Livesy, Clara. The Manson Women: A Family Portrait. Florham Park, NJ: Richard
Marek, 1980.
Mollenhoff, Clark. The Man Who Pardoned Nixon: A Documented Account of Gerald Fords
Presidential Retreat from Credibility. New York: St. Martins Press, 1976.
Sanders, Ed. The Family. New York: Thunders Mouth Press, 2002.
155
156
FR ANZ FERDINAND
on statements from surviving SLA members professing his innocence. According to Little, Who actually pulled the trigger that killed Foster was Mizmoon
[Patricia Monique Soltysik]. Nancy [Ling Perry] was supposed to shoot Blackburn, [but] she kind of botched that and DeFreeze ended up shooting him with
a shotgun. Patricia Hearst, testifying at her own trial, named Soltysik and SLA
member Emily Yolanda Harris as Fosters killers. Harris served eight years in
prison for Hearsts kidnapping, and received another seven-year term in 2003,
after pleading guilty to second-degree murder related to an April 1975 bank
holdup. No charges were filed against her in the Foster case.
Further Reading
Bryan, John. This Soldier Still at War: The True Story of Joe Remiro and the Symbionese Liberation Army. London: Quartet Books, 1976.
McCorry, Jesse. Marcus Foster and the Oakland Public Schools. Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1978.
McLellan, Vin, and Paul Avery. The Voices of Guns. New York: Putnam, 1977.
Payne, Les, Tim Findley, and Carolyn Craven. The Life and Death of the SLA: A True
Story of Revolutionary Terror. New York: Ballantine Books, 1976.
Spencer, John. In the Crossfire: Marcus Foster and the Troubled History of American School
Reform. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2012.
Vaso Cubrilovi
c,
standing nearby with a pistol and bomb, likewise did noth
ing as his target came and went. The third man in line, Nedeljko Cabrinovi
c,
threw his bomb, but it bounced off the folded convertible roof of Franz Ferdinands car, detonating beneath the next car in line and wounding 20 people.
Cabrinovi
c instantly swallowed a cyanide pill and leaped into the Miljacka River,
but the poison failed to kill him and a furious mob dragged him from the
water, beating him before police arrested him and hauled him off to jail. The
motorcade, meanwhile, sped past assassins Cvjetko Popovic,
Gavrilo Princip,
and Trifun Grabe and reached the town hall without further incident.
FRANZ FERDINAND
157
158
FR ANZ FERDINAND
Triple Entente. Over the next four years, the global conflict would claim an estimated 16.6 million lives, with countless more wounded or missing.
All of the conspirators in Ferdinands assassination were eventually captured.
Twenty-five defendants faced trial at Sarajevo in October 1914, with 16 con
victed. Danilo Ilic,
Veljko Cubrilovi
c,
and Mihaijlo Jovanovic were sentenced
to death and hanged in February 1915. Two other condemned defendants,
Jakov Milovic and Nedjo Kerovic,
won commutation of their sentences to life
imprisonment and 20 years, respectively. The others receiving prison terms in
cluded Mitar Kerovic (life); Nedeljko Cabrinovi
c,
Gavrilo Princip, and Trifko
Grabe (20 years); Vaso Cubrilovic (16 years); Cvjetko Popovic (13 years);
FRANZ FERDINAND
Lazar Djukic and Ivo Kranjcevic (10 years); Cvijan Stjepanovic (7 years); and
Marko Perin and Branko Zagorac (3 years).
A second trial disposed of four more plotters in March 1917. Muhamed
Mehmedbaic,
who had failed to throw his bomb as planned, received a 15-year
sentence, but was pardoned in 1919. Three Serbian soldiers linked to the conspiratorial Black Hand movementColonel Ljuba Vulovic,
Captain Dragutin
Dimitrijevic,
and Rade Malobabicwere
159
G
GADDAFI, MUAMMAR (19422011)
On February 17, 2011, mass protests erupted in Libya against the regime of
Brotherly Leader Muammar Gaddafi, the nations dictator since 1969. The
states brutal response, including alleged importation of Ghanaian mercenaries,
prompted all-out civil war and intervention by elements of the North Atlantic
Treaty Organization (NATO). Officially deposed and stripped of international
recognition by mid-July, Gaddafi fought on from hiding until October 20,
when his troops made a last-ditch stand against opponents from the National
Transitional Council (NTC) in the Battle of Sirte. That morning, NATO aircraft
intercepted a satellite phone call from Gaddafi and fired on his motorcade, two
miles outside of Sirte. With their vehicles disabled, Gaddafi and others sought
refuge in nearby houses, where they were quickly surrounded by NTC soldiers.
Conflicting accounts of Gaddafis demise claim that he was wounded by gunfire
or grenade shrapnel, then captured alive, whereupon he was beaten, stabbed,
and shot at close range, with his body displayed on the hood of a car. Gaddafis
son, Mutassim, died in the same engagement.
Born in Qasr Abu Hadi, near the site of his desperate last stand, in June
1942, Muammar Muhammad Abu Minyar al-Gaddafi attended a Muslim elementary school, participated in anti-British demonstrations during the 1956
Suez Crisis, and graduated from the Benghazi Military University Academy in
1966, before pursuing further studied in Europe. He attended Britains Royal
Military Academy Sandhurst, then returned to Libya and joined the armys
engineering corps, rising to the rank of lieutenant in 1969. On September 1
of that year, while King Idris was touring Greece, Gaddafi led a bloodless
military coup dtat that abolished the Libyan monarchy. Assuming the rank
of colonel, Gaddafi proclaimed himself head of state, ruling for the next
42 years under ever-changing titles that included chairman of the Revolutionary Command Council, prime minister, secretary general of the General
Peoples Congress, and Brotherly Leader and Guide of the Revolution.
Once in power, Gaddafi ordered evacuation of U.S. and British military bases
in Libya, demanded an increased share of Western oil drilling proceeds from
50 to 79 percent, expelled Italian settlers, and replaced the Gregorian calendar
with an Islamic version, renaming the months to suit himself (August became
Hannibal, July became Nasser, and so on). After a lengthy contemplative
162
GADDAFI, MUA M M AR
Rebels killed Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi in February 2011. (Associated Press)
exile, Gaddafi published The Green Book, dictating his views on Islamic law
and advocating direct rule by Peoples Committees, while he retained power
as head of state and commander in chief of the armed forces. Using oil profits
to develop his country, Gaddafi increased Libyas literacy rate from 10 to 90
percent, established equal rights for women and blacks, and added 20 years
to average life expectancy through improved medical care. The reverse side of
that coin included cases of arbitrary arrest and detention under Law 73, which
restricted freedom of expression. Between 1980 and 1987, Libyan agents murdered at least 25 dissident expatriates, and at home, Gaddafi launched repressive campaigns against Libyas Berber minority.
In foreign affairs, Gaddafi sought to unify the Arab states of North Africa as a
single Great Islamic State of the Sahel. To that end, he invaded Chad, fought
a brief war with Egypt, and organized an Islamic Legion to agitate for Muslim
rule as far afield as Lebanon, Syria, Uganda, and Palestine. Gaddafis intelligence service also supported terrorist actions abroad, including various raids
on Israel and the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland,
GADDAFI, MUAMMAR
163
164
G A N D H I , I N D I R A P R I YA D A R S H I N I
165
166
G A N D H I , R A J I V R AT N A
decree went unrecognized by London and the world at large. More prison time
followed for Gandhi, marked by hunger strikes in custody, but it remained for
World War II to crack the British Empire, with India winning independence in
August 1947. Almost immediately, sectarian riots between Hindus, Sikhs, and
Muslims claimed an estimated half-million lives, climaxed by partition of the
country and creation of Pakistan as a primarily Muslim state.
Prior to his murder, Gandhi survived several other assassination attempts.
The first, a bombing of his motorcade in Pune on June 25, 1934, wounded
nine persons and remains officially unsolved today, with no surviving record of
police investigation. Ten years later, in May 1944, Nathuram Godse led a group
of 15 to 20 young men who rushed at Gandhi, Godse brandishing a knife, during a prayer meeting at Panchgani. The crowds prevented Godses gang from
reaching Gandhi, who followed his longstanding policy of refusing to press
criminal charges.
Nathuram Godse led another group that obstructed Gandhis passage from
Sevagram to Mumbai on September 9, 1944. Caught with another dagger,
Godse was released again, after uttering threats to kill Gandhi. Eight days before Gandhis actual murder, at Birla House in New Delhi, the Godse brothers
and five others detonated a bomb attached to a podium where Gandhi was
scheduled to speak, but its premature blast caused no damage. Confessions secured by police in that case were responsible for most of the charges filed after
Gandhis slaying on January 28, 1948.
In 1982, Sir Richard Attenborough produced and directed an epic motion
picture charting the life of Mohandas Gandhi. Starring Ben Kingsley, Gandhi
was nominated for 11 Academy Awards and won eight, including Best Picture,
Best Director, Best Actor in a Leading Role, Best Original Screenplay, Best Film
Editing, Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography, and Best Costume Design.
Further Reading
Brown, Judith. Gandhi: Prisoner of Hope. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1991.
Fisher, Louis. The Life of Mahatma Gandhi. New York: HarperCollins, 1997.
Lelyveld, Joseph. Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi and His Struggle with India. New York:
Vintage Books, 2011.
Wolpert, Stanley. Gandhis Passion: The Life and Legacy of Mahatma Gandhi. Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2001.
167
168
GA N D H I, R A J I V R AT N A
some 5,000 Tamil civilians, but the violence continued unabated. Investigators
generally agree that Gandhis promise to resume policing of Sri Lanka led directly to his death.
Six months after the assassination, in November 1991, Schweizer Illustrierte
(Swiss Illustrated) magazine published an expos on black money stashed by
15 leaders of various Third World nations. Gandhi was among those named,
accused of hiding 2.5 billion Swiss francs in Zurich. Critics raised the issue in
parliament a month later, but Gandhis name was subsequently expunged from
the record of those proceedings. Another posthumous scandal broke in 1992,
when two newspapersThe Hindu and The Times of Indiaalleged that Gandhi had received cash payments from the Soviet KGB. Russias new government confirmed the payments as an action necessary for the Soviet ideological
interest.
Despite those blemishes to his record, Gandhi holds the Bharat Ratna, Indias highest civilian award, thus far bestowed on 41 recipients (as of 2011).
The list also includes Gandhis grandfather and mother.
Further Reading
Kaarthikeyan, D. R., and Radhavinod Raju. Triumph of Truth: The Rajiv Gandhi AssassinationThe Investigation. Elgin, IL: New Dawn Press, 2004.
Mehta, Ved. Rajiv Gandhi and Ramas Kingdom. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press,
1996.
Nugent, Nicholas. Rajiv Gandhi: Son of a Dynasty. London: BBC Publications, 1991.
Sharma, Rajeev. Beyond the Tigers: Tracking Rajiv Gandhis Assassination. New Delhi: Kaveri Books, 1998.
169
170
GA R C A M O R E N O, GA B R I E L
only grazed their target, but Rayos blade split the presidents skull and nearly
severed one arm. Soldiers arriving on the scene shot Rayo as he fled, but the
other three conspirators escaped. Peruvian currency found in Rayos pockets
suggested a murder for hire, and although no other plotters were identified, officials declared that Garca Moreno was slain by members of a secret society,
presumably Freemasons.
Born in Guayaquil, Ecuador, on December 24, 1821, Gabriel Garca Moreno
was the son of an aristocratic Spanish merchant. He studied law and theology
at the University of Quito, preparing himself for the priesthood. He proceeded
to the minor orders and shaved his head in the traditional clerical tonsure, but
friends persuaded him to seek a secular career instead. At graduation from the
university, in 1844, he was admitted to the bar and simultaneously operated as
a freelance journalist, in opposition to the liberal regime of President Vicente
Ramn Roca.
Returning from travels abroad in 1856, Garca Moreno found Ecuadors government in the hands of liberal, anticlerical elements, on the verge of civil
war with strictly religious members of the Conservative Party. Garca Moreno
joined Jernimo Carrin and Pacfico Chiriboga in opposing incumbent president Francisco Garcia Robles, and General Guillermo Franco, commanding
the district of Guayas, sought to seize power for himself, bargaining with Peruvian president Ramn Castilla to trade land for military support. Defeated at
the Battle of Guayaquil, in September 1860, Franco fled to Peru, and Garca
Moreno assumed command of a provisional government in Quito. Similar governing bodies seized control in the provinces of Cuenca, Guayas, Loja, Caar,
and Azuay. That chaos was resolved, and Ecuador reunified, in January 1861,
with Garca Morenos election as interim president. A general election, held
four months later, confirmed him as president for a full four-year term.
Garca Morenos conservatism and outspoken support for the Catholic
Church alienated liberals throughout Ecuador and beyond, but he maintained
iron-fisted control. Vice President Rafael Carvajal Guzmn succeeded Garca
Moreno in August 1865, but lasted only two months before he was replaced
by Jernimo Carrin. The seesaw world of Ecuadorean politics saw Garca
Moreno reelected as president in January 1869, deposed in May of that same
year, then elected once again in August 1869. That year, he drafted a new constitution making Catholicism the nations official religion, welcomed fugitive
Jesuit priests from neighboring countries, and signed a law banning secret societies, which Freemasons viewed as a personal attack on their order. Liberals also condemned his use of Indian slave labor to build new roads and other
public works.
Perhaps anticipating his own murder, Garca Moreno wrote to Pope Piius IX,
seeking a special blessing prior to his scheduled inauguration in August 1875.
That letter read:
I wish to obtain your blessing before that day, so that I may have the strength
and light which I need so much in order to be unto the end a faithful son of our
Redeemer, and a loyal and obedient servant of His Infallible Vicar. Now that the
Masonic Lodges of the neighboring countries, instigated by Germany, are vomiting against me all sorts of atrocious insults and horrible calumnies, now that the
Lodges are secretly arranging for my assassination, I have more need than ever
of the divine protection so that I may live and die in defense of our holy religion
and the beloved republic which I am called once more to rule.
While prescient, that plea failed to protect him from his enemies.
Further Reading
Berthe, Augustine. Garcia Moreno. London: Burns and Oates, 1889.
Henderson, Peter. Gabriel Garca Moreno and Conservative State Formation in the Andes.
Austin: University of Texas Press, 2008.
Larson, Brooke. Trials of Nation Making: Liberalism, Race, and Ethnicity in the Andes,
18101910. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004.
171
172
G A R F I E L D, J A M E S A B R A M
within 16 years, Congress took no steps to mount a special guard over the
president until after the murder of William McKinley, in 1901.
Further Reading
Ackerman, Kenneth. Dark Horse: The Surprise Election and Political Murder of James A.
Garfield. New York: Avalon Publishing, 2004.
Millard, Candice. Destiny of the Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a
President. New York: Anchor Books, 2012.
Peskin, Allan. Garfield. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1978.
173
174
and condemned, Salan being tried in absentia (captured in April 1962). President de Gaulle granted the rebels amnesty in July 1968, with Challe and Zeller
restored to their former ranks in November 1982.
Meanwhile, the OAS made multiple attempts to kill de Gaulle in France.
Whereas some accounts claim 44 murder conspiracies in all, two in particular stand out. On September 8, 1961, de Gaulle and his wife traveled 150
miles by car from Paris to their country home, La Boisserie, in Colombeyles-Deux-Eglises. At one point on the road, a propane tank packed with 100
pounds of plastic explosive lay concealed under a sand pile, with a canister
containing 15 liters of napalm. Detonated by remote control as de Gaulle
sped past in his chauffeur-driven Citron DS, the bomb spewed burning
gasoline across the highway, but the de Gaulles and their driver escaped
injury.
On August 22, 1962, OAS member Jean-Marie Bastien-Thiry, a lieutenant
colonel in the French air force, staged another ambush for de Gaulle in PetitClamart, a suburb of Paris. In an eerie replay of the last attempt, de Gaulle and
his wife were en route once more to Colombey-les-Deux-Eglises, when OAS
thugs sprayed their car with submachine guns, firing 187 bullets. Once again,
the sturdy Citron DS saved its passengers, despite four flattened tires and a
shattered rear window. Two police escorts died in the fusillade, but President
de Gaulles sole injury was a scratch on one finger, suffered while brushing
broken glass from his jacket.
Bastien-Thiry was traveling in England, on OAS business, when his men
botched the ambush. Police arrested him on his return to France, and he faced
trial by court-martial with two accomplices, convened on January 28, 1963.
Bastien-Thirys defense team included Jean-Louis Tixier-Vignancour, a far-right
politician who would challenge de Gaulle for the presidency in 1965, placing
mafia boss hires a killer to assassinate the U.S. vice president. A British newspaper, The Guardian, dubbed international terrorist Ilich Ramrez
Snchez The Jackal in 1975, after police raiders found a copy of Forsyths novel in the fugitives London apartment. Twenty years later, a Hebrew translation turned up in the possession of Yigal Amir, right-wing
assassin of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. At the time, police suggested that Amir used the novel as a how to manual for murder, though
in fact he used a pistol to kill Rabin at close range, rather than employing
a sniper rifle.
fourth in a field of six candidates. The defense adopted a two-pronged strategy, first claiming that Bastien-Thiry only planned to capture de Gaulle and
hold him for trial on hypothetical charges, simultaneously claiming that his
death would have been justified as payback for the genocide of European residents in newly independent Algeria. Convicted on March 3, Bastien-Thiry was
condemned with codefendants Alain de La Tocnaye and Buisines Prevost. De
Gaulle later pardoned Tocnaye and Prevost, the actual shooters, but BastienThiry died before a firing squad on March 11, 1963.
The OAS dissolved after Bastien-Thirys execution, but some of its members
remained active as terrorists, linked to the murders of Parisian leftists Henri
Curiel in 1978 and Pierre Goldman in 1979, but the last known plot against de
Gaulle was hatched by a group of radical students in Paris. On July 1, 1966
the same day de Gaulle was featured on the cover of Time magazinethe president prepared to leave France for a visit to the Soviet Union. Parked along the
Boulevard Montparnasse, his route to Orly Airport, a car packed with nearly
a ton of dynamite waited to detonate by remote control, but the signal never
came. The would-be bombers, members of a self-styled National Resistance
Council, were arrested the night of June 30, during a robbery intended to raise
money for their flight abroad after they killed the president.
Further Reading
Aussaresses, Paul. The Battle of the Casbah: Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism in Algeria,
19551957. New York: Enigma Books, 2010.
Fenby, Jonathan. The General: Charles de Gaulle and the France He Saved. New York:
Simon and Schuster, 2010.
Lacouture, Jean. De Gaulle: The Ruler 19451970. New York: HarperCollins, 1991.
Le Sueur, James. Uncivil War: Intellectuals and Identity Politics during the Decolonization
of Algeria. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2005.
Williams, Charles. The Last Great Frenchman: A Life of General De Gaulle. New York:
John Wiley & Sons, 1993.
175
176
G AV I R I A C O R R E A , G U I L L E R M O
The philosophy of nonviolence brings spirits closer, brings souls closer, brings
human beings closer and will allow us, together, to build true roads to social
transformation. Nonviolence is not simply saying no to violence, because if so it
would end up being confused with passively accepting suffering, injustice and
abuse. Nonviolence is a way to overcome violence, investigating and discovering just means to oppose injustice. Nonviolence is not only about neutralizing all
forms of direct violence, but also all manifestations of structural violence, because
it builds peace through justice and solidarity and helps to prevent future forms
of violence, by offering methods and models of peaceful struggle to those social
groups left out and sacrificed by unbalanced power and systemic maladjustment.
If you are reading this letter it is surely because the FARC were not able to listen or understand my message. If I have been murdered, my spirit will be praying for peace in Colombia. In this case I hope that Anbal, my brother, will take
up the flag I have been carrying to build a new Antioquia.
177
178
capital. While at Nanpo, the rebels attacked Shidebalas party, killing the emperor and his companion Baiju, recently named to succeed Temuder as grand
councilor.
Born on February 22, 1303, Shidebala was the oldest son of Ayurbarwada
Buyantu Khan, Emperor Renzong of Yuan, who had captured the throne by
devious means. Ayurbarwadas elder brother, Khayishan, had ruled as Klg
Khan, Emperor Wuzong of Yuan, from June 1307 until January 1311, when
terminal illness forced him to confront his own mortality. Ayurbarwada promised that if Khayishan named him successor to the throne, Ayurbarwada would
anoint Khayishans eldest son as crown prince and next in line to rule. When
Khayishan died, however, Ayurbarwada banished his sons to the hinterlands
and purged the court of any loyal adherents to the former emperor. Formally
crowned in April 1311, Ayurbarwada ruled for eight years, dying from natural
causes on March 1, 1320.
Successor Shidebaladubbed Gegeen (enlightened) Khanintended to
continue various political reforms initiated by his father, but he inherited
Grand Councilor Temuder, formerly dismissed for corruption in 1317, but
reinstated by the new emperors powerful grandmother, Empress Targi, upon
the death of her son Ayurbarwada. Temuder quickly ordered the execution
of several persons he deemed responsible for his prior embarrassment, joining Empress Dowager Targi to manipulate and dominate the new teenage
emperor.
Gegeen Khan was chafing under control of his elders by October 1322,
when Temuder died in Dadu. He was married by then, to Empress Sugabala,
but their union produced no children. At Temuders death, influenced by Confucian scholars who had detested the tyrannical grand councilor, Shidebala appointed Baijua man of his own age and a descendant of the honored general
Mukhalito succeed Temuder. Relieved by his grandmothers death near years
end, Gegeen Khan embarked on a more aggressive course of reform that placed
him fatally at odds with Temuders protgs and the traditional Mongol warrior
elite. That conflict led inevitably to his murder and plunged the Yuan Empire
into a decade of chaos.
With the assassination accomplished, ringleader Tegshi asked Yesn Temr,
a great-grandson of Kublai Khan, to assume the throne, and while agreeing,
first annihilated Teghsis faction before taking office as Emperor Taiding of
Yuan. Crowned in October 1323, Yesn Temr Khan ruled as emperor until
his sudden death in August 1328. Son Ragibagh Khan succeeded him, but
was deposed and presumably executed (his body was not found) by rival
Tug Temr in mid-November of the same year. Tug Temr then occupied the
throne as Jayaatu Khan, Emperor Wenzong of Yuan, but died in September
1332, leaving six-year-old Rinchinbal Khan in charge of the swiftly declining
Yuan Empire.
GEORGE I OF GREECE
Further Reading
Brook, Timothy. The Troubled Empire: China in the Yuan and Ming Dynasties. Cambridge,
MA: Belknap Press, 2010.
Twitchett, Denis, Herbert Franke, and John Fairbank. The Cambridge History of China:
Volume 6, Alien Regimes and Border States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
1994.
179
180
GEORGE I OF GREECE
of Schleswig-Holstein-Sonderburg-Glcksburg, later King Christian IX of Denmark. Originally known as Prince Vilhelm (William), he joined the Royal Danish Navy at 17, then was elected king of the Hellenes on March 30, 1863, by
the Greek National Assembly, filling a throne left vacant since King Otto was
deposed by a coup in October 1862. That twist of fate made Vilhelmnow
Georgea king eight full months before his father ascended to the throne of
Denmark. In fact, however, George did not arrive in Athens until October 30,
1863, two weeks before his fathers coronation in Copenhagen.
Georges reign of nearly half a century began with lengthy constitutional debates, climaxed in November 1864 with the creation of a unicameral legislature and institution of Europes first universal male suffrage by secret ballots.
The constitution subordinated royal authority to that of duly-elected officials,
but it failed to eradicate corruption or political infighting, with the result that
between 1864 and 1910 Greece endured 21 elections and 70 government administrations, the longest lasting for 18 months.
On the international stage, George used his relationship with brother-in-law
Albert Edward, Prince of Wales (later Britains King Edward VII) to settle territorial disputes between Greece and Britain. Georges marriage to Grand Duchess Olga Constantinovna of Russia produced five sons and two daughters, all of
whom married into royal families of Prussia, France, Russia, and Britain, thus
creating an international dynasty. His relationship with Russia served George
well after the Russo-Turkish War of 18771878, when he laid claim to Cyprus,
Epirus, and Thessaly over strident Ottoman objections, seeing those territorial
gains confirmed in 1880. In February 1897, he sent his son, Prince George, to
liberate Crete from Turkish rule, but Greek forces lost that campaign in April.
On February 26, 1898, two men identified only as Giorgis and Karditza fired
rifles at King Georges open carriage, while George, his daughter Marie, and a
groom were returning to Athens from the seaside resort of Phalerum. The groom
and both horses were wounded, while George stood in plain view of the gunmen, brandishing a cane and shielding Marie. The nervous snipers missed their
target and fled, but Karditza surrendered the following day, describing himself
to police as a member of a secret society pledged to kill George in retribution
for Greeces recent military loss to Turkey. Giorgis was captured on February 28,
but no information on the disposition of their case is presently available.
The death of Britains Queen Victoria, in January 1901, left George I as the
second-longest-reigning European monarch, bound by marriage to Victorias
successor, King Edward VII. By 1908, George faced opposition from the Stratiotikos Syndesmos (Military League), a group of army officers who sought to
strip royal family members of their military commissions. The league staged an
abortive coup dtat on August 28, 1909, beginning at the Goudi barracks outside Athens, but loyal troops frustrated the rebellion, whereupon George gave
his support to revision of the Greek constitution.
181
182
G O N Z L E Z D U B N , E D U A R D O E PA M I N O N D A S
Further Reading
Cobb, Irvin. Exit Laughing. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1941.
Woodson, Urey. The First New Dealer, William Goebel: His Origin, Ambitions, Achievements, His Assassination, Loss to the State and Nation; the Story of a Great Crime. Louisville: Standard Press, 1939.
183
184
G O U L A R T, J O O B E L C H I O R M A R Q U E S
G O U L A R T, J O O B E L C H I O R M A R Q U E S
Portuguese immigrants from the Azores. His father was a prosperous rancher,
who also served as a colonel in the National Guard. Goulart enrolled early at
the Federal University of Rio Grande do Suls law school, aided by a birth certificate his father falsified, showing his birth year as 1918. While attending that
school, he reportedly contracted a venereal disease that, left untreated, virtually paralyzed his left knee. Graduating in 1939, Goulart was admitted to the
bar but never entered legal practice professionally. Instead, he managed his
fathers extensive land holdings, accruing substantial wealth by the time his
father died in 1943.
Two years later, Goulart accepted an invitation from Protsio Vargas,
brother of retiring president Getlio Vargas, to join the Brazilian Labor Party
(PTB), beginning as a local leader, swiftly rising through the ranks. Elected to
the state assembly in 1947, Goulart backed Getlio Vargass presidential campaign three years later, advancing at the same time to a seat in the Chamber
of Deputies. His service in that body was short-lived, however, as President
Vargas soon appointed him secretary of the interior and justice, with a mandate to reform Brazils archaic prison system. In 1953, Vargas shifted Goulart
to a new position in his cabinet, as minister of labor, helping to suppress a
coup dtat by the right-wing National Democratic Union (UDN).
By February 1954, when Goulart left the cabinet to resume his work in the
Chamber of Deputies, President Vargas was immersed in economic crisis, exacerbated when one of his bodyguards tried to kill UDN leader Carlos Lacerda
on August 5. Vargas called Goulart to his home on August 24, presenting him
with a sealed letter and orders to read it only upon his return to Rio Grande do
Sul. It proved to be the presidents suicide note, and he shot himself soon after
Goulart departed. After considering retirement from politics, Goulart changed
his mind and agreed to run for vice president in 1955, on the PTB ticket led
by Juscelino Kubitschek. Four years later, he was reelected as vice president,
this time under President Jnio da Silva Quadros. For reasons best known to
himself, Quadros resigned his office in August 1961, after serving only seven
months, and Goulart succeeded him.
Goularts liberal policiesincluding a Basic Reforms plan to improve adult
literacy and force reinvestment of foreign corporate profits in Brazilproved
unpalatable to Brazils right-wing elements. Following the pattern of subversion practiced elsewhere in Latin America, the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency
teamed with the ITT Corporation to organized and finance a coup against
Goularts administration, culminating in his ouster from office at gunpoint on
April 1, 1964. Goulart escaped to Uruguay, leaving Brazil in the hands of a
military dictatorship that set new records for brutality in its long dirty war
against the political left.
Argentine president Juan Domingo Pern invited Goulart to Buenos Aires
in 1973, to help expand the nations export markets, despite opposition from
185
186
GUERIN, VERONICA
right-wing minister of social welfare Jos Lpez Rega. In March 1976, after
far-right terrorists botched a plan to kidnap Goularts son for ransom, Goulart moved 450 miles south of Buenos Aires, to Mercedes, where he died nine
months later.
Today, with the collapse of Brazils military junta, Goulart is widely revered
in his native land. At least 10 schools bear his name, as do streets in at least
15 cities. In November 2008, the government granted amnesty to Goulart and
his widow, entitling Maria Teresa Goulart to restitution of some $372,000 for
her years in exile.
Further Reading
Frank, Andre. The Goulart Ouster: Brazil in Perspective. New York: J. H. Richards, 1964.
Skidmore, Thomas. The Politics of Military Rule in Brazil: 19641985. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 1990.
Tavora, Araken. Rehearsal for the Coup. In The Brazil Reader: History, Culture, Politics.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1999.
Vargas, Getlio. Vargass Suicide Letter, 1954. In The Brazil Reader: History, Culture,
Politics. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1999.
GUERIN, VERONICA
187
188
G U E VA R A , E R N E S T O C H E
G U E VA R A , E R N E S T O C H E
of U.S. activities in the region. Licensed to practice medicine in 1953, Che embarked on another epic journey through eight Latin American nations, finding
his way to Guatemala in time for the U.S.-sponsored coup that deposed President Jacobo Arbenz in 1954. At the same time, he made his first contact with
members of Cubas July 26 Movement, led by Fidel Castro.
From Guatemala, Che moved on to Mexico City, lecturing on medicine at the
National Autonomous University of Mexico and doubling as a photographer for
the Latina News Agency. He met Fidel and Raul Castro there, in June 1955, and
joined their movement to depose Cuban dictator Fulgencio Batista. Although
Che initially planned to serve as the small armys medic, he soon advanced to
become one of Castros leading strategists and field commanders. Finally, as second in command, he personally executed captured spies, informers, and deserters. Following Castros victory, in January 1959, Guevara played multiple roles
in the new revolutionary governmentsupervising a national literacy campaign, serving as minister of industries, promoting agrarian land reform, acting
as president of Cubas new national bank, training soldiers, and reviewing the
appeals of Batista loyalists sentenced to death by revolutionary courts.
In April 1961, Guevara played a key role in repelling the CIA-sponsored
Bay of Pigs invasion. Published reports also claim that he was instrumental
in bringing Soviet nuclear weapons to Cuba, thereby precipitating the Cuban
Missile Crisis of 1962. He left Cuba in 1965, tasked with exporting revolution to the world at large. That mission that led him first to the Republic of
the Congo, where he fought with rebels led by future president Laurent-Dsir
Kabila, opposing the national army, CIA contract agents, and South African
mercenaries. From Africa, he moved on to Bolivia in 1966, leading a 50-member
National Liberation Army of Bolivia against the military regime of President
Barrientos.
That campaign claimed his life, but Guevara remains an influentialand
controversialfigure worldwide, nearly half a century after his death. His
writings, including The Motorcycle Diaries (filmed in 2004), remain best-selling
works today. Alberto Kordas photo portrait of Che, titled Guerrillero Heroico (Heroic Guerrilla), has been labeled the most famous photograph in the
world by the Maryland Institute College of Art. World figures ranging from
Susan Sontag and Jean-Paul Sartre to Nelson Mandela have publicly hailed Che
as a freedom fighter and revolutionary inspiration. Conversely, posthumous
critics condemn him for his communist philosophy, his participation in executions, and the alleged role that his revolutionary actions played in strengthening U.S.-backed military dictatorships in Latin America.
Today, Che Guevara is arguably the Western Hemispheres most famous revolutionary, eclipsing Castro himself. His image appears on countless posters,
T-shirts, and other articles of clothing, and his life and death have been commemorated in at least 26 different songs, mostly in Spanish. Che had also been
189
190
G U I N N E S S, WA LT E R E D WA R D
portrayed in 14 feature films, by actors including Francisco Rabal (El Che Guevara, 1968), Omar Sharif (Che!, 1969), Michael Palin (Monty Python Live at the
Hollywood Bowl, 1982), Antonio Banderas (Evita, 1996), Miguel Ruiz Das (El
Che, 1997), Alfredo Vasco (Hasta la Victoria Siempre, 1999), Gael Garca Bernal
(Fidel, 2002), Karl Sheils (Meeting Che Guevara & the Man from Maybury Hill,
2003), Gael Garca Bernal (The Motorcycle Diaries, 2004), Jsu Garcia (The Lost
City, 2005), Martin Hyder (The Mark Steel Lectures: Che Guevara, 2006), Sam G.
Preston (The True Story of Che Guevara, 2007), Eduardo Noriega (Che, 2007),
and Benicio del Toro (Che, 2008).
Further Reading
Anderson, Jon. Che Guevara: A Revolutionary Life. New York: Grove Press, 1997.
Castaneda, Jorge. Companero: The Life and Death of Che Guevara. New York: Alfred A.
Knopf, 1997.
Crompton, Samuel. Che Guevara: The Making of a Revolutionary. New York: Gareth Stevens, 2009.
James, Daniel. Che Guevara: A Biography. Lanham, MD: Cooper Square Press, 2001.
G U I N N E S S , WA L T E R E D WA R D
191
192
G U I N N E S S, WA LT E R E D WA R D
ZIONISM
Zionism is broadly defined as a national movement for the return of the
Jewish people to their homeland and the resumption of Jewish sovereignty
in the land of Israel. Although theoretically dating from the Diaspora of
586 BCE, during the Babylonian occupation of Israel, the organized movement properly began with Joseph Nasi (15241579), a Portuguese Jew
who campaigned for Jewish emigration from the Ottoman Empire. Later
distinguished by many splinter ideologies, Zionism achieved its goal with
foundation of the state of Israel in 1948. Critics condemn the movement as
colonialist and racist, citing statements such as propagandist Israel Zangwills description of Arab-populated Palestine as a country without a people, for a people without a country. Acts of terrorism committed by the
Stern Gang and Irgun Zevai Leumi (National Military Organization in the
Land of Israel) between 1920 and 1948 also tarnished the broader movements reputation. Some critics of Zionism, particularly in the Arab states,
consider it a racist and/or colonialist movement. Some supporters of Zionism counter those arguments by claiming that any opposition to Zionism or Israel constitutes prima facie evidence of anti-Semitism. Meanwhile,
Zionism remains a hot topic for far-right groups worldwide, including
neo-Nazi and white nationalist groups in the United States. Spokesmen
for those organizations spin conspiracy theories involving Jewish world
domination, often referring to the U.S. federal government in Washington,
D.C., as ZOGthe Zionist Occupation Government. In 1983, a farright group called the Orderalso known in German as Brder Schweigen
(Brothers Keep Silent)declared war on ZOG and on America at large,
committing multiple murders and other acts of terrorism before its members were convicted of racketeering in 1986.
G U N N , D AV I D
Further Reading
Avner. Memoirs of an Assassin: Confessions of a Stern Gang Killer. London: Thomas
Yoseloff, 1959.
Golan, Zev. Stern: The Man and His Gang. Tel Aviv: Yahir Publishing, 2011.
Heller, Joseph. The Stern Gang: Ideology, Politics and Terror, 19401949. London: Frank
Cass Publishers, 1995.
193
194
G U N N , D AV I D
Nearby, in Columbus, Georgia, a clinic operated by the Womens Health Network (WHN) lost its elderly physician who had terminated pregnancies, and
executive director Susan Hill sought a replacement. Although raised in the
Church of Christ, with its prohibition against abortions, Gunn agreed to take
over the job, beginning a decade of relentless travel between six WHN clinics
in the South, often driving 1,000 miles per week. Hill described Gunn to reporters as a laid-back 60s kind of guy who didnt like the politics of medicine;
he wanted to help, but at the same time Gunn concealed his new activity from
members of his strictly religious parents and siblings.
Threats began immediately, from protesters outside the clinics Gunn served,
to North Carolinas White Patriot Party, formerly a branch of the Ku Klux Klan,
which issued Wanted posters on Gunn, including his photograph and home
address. Susan Hill recalled, He told me several times that he had been followed from city to city. He would take back roads and choose different paths
to throw them off. He didnt report the threats. None of us did. They happen
all the time. Gunn did prepare himself by carrying three pistols in his car
one in the glove compartment, one beneath the drivers seat, and another in
the trunkbut none of them helped on the day he was shot.
Acquaintances described assassin Michael Griffin as a fundamentalist
Christian and a loner with a bad temper. Two months before the shooting, he
had joined the Pensacola branch of Rescue America, an antiabortion group led
locally by self-ordained minister John Burta self-described former alcoholic
and ex-KKK member who claims that he abandoned the groups racist doctrine
when he became a born-again Christian. Before meeting Griffin, Burt served
as spiritual advisor to a group of zealots that bombed three womens clinics in
1984. Griffin initially told police that he shot Dr. Gunn for God, but at trial
ARMY OF GOD
The Army of God (AOG) is a loose-knit coalition of pro-life Christian
terrorists responsible for various acts of violence since August 1982,
when self-proclaimed members kidnapped Dr. Hector Zevallos and his
wife in Illinois, briefly holding them hostage under threat of death. In
1985, the groups East Coast Division claimed credit for clinic bombings in Maryland and Washington, D.C., which resulted in imprisonment
of Rev. Michael Bray and two accomplices. Rachelle Shelley Shannon,
who shot and wounded Kansas physician George Tiller in August 1993,
also declared herself a member of the AOG. Another self-described member, Scott Roeder, murdered Dr. Tiller in May 2009. The group also
claimed responsibility for Eric Rudolphs lethal 1997 clinic bombings in
G U S TAV I I I O F S W E D E N
Atlanta and Birmingham, along with a blast at a Georgia gay bar. Clayton Waagner, proclaiming himself a member of the AOGs Virginia Dare
Chapter, created an anthrax panic in 2001, by mailing some 500 envelopes filled with harmless white powder to 280 abortion providers nationwide. Paul Jennings Hill, executed in September 2003 for the 1994
Florida murders of Dr. John Britton and his bodyguard, advertised himself before that double killing as a national spokesman for the AOG.
Various researchers disagree as to whether the group has any leadership
structureor, in fact, whether it physically exists, outside the minds of
its fanatical activists. Meanwhile, the AOG, or some unknown person
claiming to represent it, maintains a Web site at http://www.armyofgod
.com. The site praises Paul Hill and Scott Roeder as American heroes,
offers graphic photos of aborted fetuses, and refers interested parties to
Rev. Donald Spitz, reachable via a post office box in Chesapeake, Virginia.
his attorneys claimed Griffin was brainwashed by Burt. No charges were filed
against Burt in Gunns murder, but he received an 18-year prison sentence in
2005, convicted on five counts of molesting a 15-year-old girl at Our Fathers
House, a home for troubled teenage girls and unwed mothers.
Gunns assassination prompted Congress to pass the Freedom of Access to
Clinic Entrances Act in May 1994, imposing federal penalties for any threats or
attacks against womens clinics, obstruction of free access to their facilities, or
stalking of clinic staff members. The statute upholds protesters First Amendment rights to assemble, picket, distribute literature, and shout outside clinics
from a safe distance, as long as no threats are made.
Further Reading
Baird-Windle, Patricia, and Eleanor Bader. Targets of Hatred: Anti-Abortion Terrorism.
New York: Palgrave, 2001.
Mason, Carol. Killing for Life: The Apocalyptic Narrative of Pro-Life Politics. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press, 2002.
Risen, James, and Judy Thomas. Wrath of Angels: The American Abortion War. New York:
Basic Books, 1999.
195
196
G U S T AV I I I O F S W E D E N
conspirators wearing black masks: Count Claes Fredrik Horn, Count Adolph
Ludvig Ribbing, and army officer Jacob Johan Anckarstrm. While the counts
distracted Gustav with the greeting, Good-day, fine mask, Anckarstrm shot
him in the back with a pistol containing two balls, five pellets of shot and
six bent nails. Gustav initially survived for nearly two weeks, continuing his
function as head of state until infection claimed his life on March 29. All three
plotters were arrested and confessed in custody. On April 16, Anckarstrm was
sentenced to flogging and confinement in irons, with his right hand severed
before he was beheaded on April 27. Count Ribbing was stripped of his title
and sentenced to death in May 1792, later pardoned and exiled to France. No
record survives of Count Horns sentence.
Gustav was born in Stockholm on January 24, 1746, the eldest son of King
Adolf Frederick. His father died on February 12, 1771, remembered as the
king who ate himself to death with an epic meal including lobster, sauerkraut,
caviar, kippers, champagne, and 14 helpings of his favorite dessert. Gustav was
in Paris when his father died, and did not return until March 25, with his official coronation occurring on March 29. Chafing at the parliamentary reforms
instituted since the death of King Charles XII, in 1718, and personally at odds
with parliaments dominant liberal Caps faction, Gustavplanned a coup with
Finnish nobleman Jacob Magnus Sprengtporten in July 1772. By late August,
their forces had seized control of Sweden, thus ending the nations 54-year
Age of Liberty. Soon thereafter, Sprengtporten abandoned his partnership with
Gustav, complaining that the king had grown so violent and insolent that anything like agreement between them became impossible.
Over the next 17 years, Gustav pressed for restoration of royal autocracy
or enlightened despotism, as he saw itand achieved his goal at last with
passage of the Union and Security Act in 1789. That statute delegated most of
parliaments former powers to the king, including the sole authority to declare
war and make peace. He proved fickle in foreign policy, first plotting to capture
Norway with aid from Russia, then scheming to invade Russias Baltic provinces when the first plan failed. The French Revolution of 17881789 alarmed
Gustav, who feared similar revolts against monarchs throughout Europe, and
he contributed substantial funds toward an abortive plan to reinstate Louis XVI
as king of France.
In terms of domestic policy, while remaining autocratic and restricting freedom of the press, Gustav granted a measure of religious liberty to Jews and
Catholics (Gustav himself was Lutheran). He was a renownedsome said extravagantpatron of the arts and literature, founding several Royal Academies
to promote the arts, culture, and science in Sweden, and built the Royal Swedish Opera in 1782where he would be slain 10 years later.
Gustav was succeeded by his son, 13-year-old Gustav Adolf, with Gustavs brother Charles serving as regent. In 1805, Gustav Adolf joined the
G U S TAV I I I O F S W E D E N
Third Coalition against Napoleon Bonaparte, with the result that France occupied Swedish Pomerania. A popular rebellion against the young, inept king
prompted Gustav Adolf to abdicate and flee into exile, leaving his uncle in
charge as Charles XIII.
Further Reading
Barton, H. Arnold. Scandinavia in the Revolutionary Era, 17601815. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1986.
Ihalainen, Pasi, Michael Bregnsbo, Karin Sennefelt, and Patrik Winton. Scandinavia in
the Age of Revolution. Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing, 2011.
197
H
HABYARIMANA, JUVNAL (19371994)
At 8:20 P.M. on April 6, 1994, a Dassault Falcon 50 private jet approached
Rwandas Kigali International Airport. Aboard the plane were Rwandan president Juvnal Habyarimana, the nations three highest-ranking military officers,
the presidents foreign affairs advisor, and his personal physician. Also on board
was Cyprien Ntaryamira, president of Burundi, accompanied by Burundis
minister of communication and minister of public works. As the presidential
jet prepared to land, two surface-to-air missiles struck the aircraft, killing all
nine passengers and three French crewmen.
Juvnal Habyarimana was born on March 8, 1937, in Ruanda-Urundi, a Belgian suzerainty from 1916 to 1924, then a League of Nations Class B Mandate
until 1945, and a United Nations Trust Territory. A member of the dominant
Hutu tribe, Habyarimana was 22 years old during the Rwandan Revolution of
1959, when Hutus killed at least 20,000 Tutsi tribe members (some accounts
claim 100,000), and driving thousands more into exile. Three years later, independence from foreign rule saw Ruanda-Urundi separated into the neighboring sovereign states of Rwanda and Burundi (with a ruling Tutsi majority).
Ethnic violence between Hutus and Tutsis persisted in Rwanda, and Hutus
dominated the government and army.
Habyarimana chose the military as a path to power, rising to army chief of
staff at age 36. On July 5, 1973, he led a coup that deposed President Grgoire
Kayibanda and his ruling Parti du Mouvement de lEmancipation Hutu (Party
of the Hutu Emancipation Movement). By 1975, Habyarimanas National Revolutionary Movement for Development was Rwandas only legal party, reinforced in 1978 with a new constitution affirming one-party rule. A unique
feature of the revised constitution was the policy of Umuganda, under which
all Rwandans were compelled to work one-half day each week on projects
related to national infrastructure. Passage of the constitution was accompanied by Habyarimanas election to another five-year presidential term, running
unopposed.
Habyarimana initially posed as a friend of both Hutu and Tutsi alike, but
soon dropped that faade, favoring members of his own tribe in Rwanda and
sponsoring Hutu attacks on Burundis Tutsi-run government. Cronyism was
the order of the day, ensuring Habyarimanas reelection as the only presidential
200
H A B YA R I M A N A , J U V N A L
H A M I D A D D I N , YA H YA M U H A M M A D
Tutsis slaughtered between April and July. That violence, in turn, led the Tutsi
RPF to renew its offensive against the predominately Hutu government, seizing the capital at Kigali on July 4. Fearing retribution, some two million Hutus
fled the country, leaving the government in Tutsi hands for the first time since
Rwanda achieved independence. RPF leader Paul Kagame assumed the presidency in March 2000 and retains it at the time of this writing.
Further Reading
Dallaire, Romo. Shake Hands with the Devil: The Failure of Humanity in Rwanda. New
York: Carroll & Graf, 2003.
Mamdani, Mahmood. When Victims Become Killers: Colonialism, Nativism, and the Genocide in Rwanda. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001.
Prunier, Grard. The Rwanda Crisis: History of a Genocide. New York: Columbia University Press, 1995.
Straus, Scott. The Order of Genocide: Race, Power, and War in Rwanda. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2006.
201
202
H A M M A R S K J L D, D A G H J A L M A R A G N E C A R L
203
204
H A M M A R S K J L D, D A G H J A L M A R A G N E C A R L
of those panels determined a cause for the airliners crash. Two Swedish bodyguards aboard the plane had suffered multiple bullet wounds, but the UNs report deemed their wounds superficial, apparently caused when ammunition
on board the plane detonated while burning. The planes wreckage showed no
signs of foul play, and reports of a flash in the sky were dismissed as inconsistent, possibly occurring after the DC-6 crashed.
Those inconclusive verdicts failed to quash conspiracy theories surrounding Hammarskjlds death. One proposed scenario blamed Belgian and/or
U.S. intelligence agencies, citing their support for the July 1960 secession
of Katanga from the Republic of the Congo, and their evident participation in the murder of Congolese prime minister Patrice Lumumba. Further
suspicion was raised by the prominent role of British military officers in
the Rhodesian inquiries, suggestive to some critics of a possible whitewash.
Supporting allegations that critical evidence was suppressed or misrepresented, ballistics expert Major C. F. Westell stated, I can certainly describe
as sheer nonsense the statement that cartridges of machine guns or pistols
detonated in a fire can penetrate a human body. Westell based that conclusion on British experiments conducted to see if firefighters faced risks of
being accidentally gunned down while responding to conflagrations at military arsenals.
Long after the fact, in August 1998, Archbishop Desmond Tutu reported
that letters uncovered by South Africas Truth and Reconciliation Commission
implicated the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, South African intelligence services, and Britains Security Service (MI5) in the 1961 plane crash. One letter
stated that a bomb in the aircrafts wheel bay had been set to explode when the
landing gear was lowered. Britains Foreign Office rejected that charge, branding the letters in question a product of a Cold War era Soviet disinformation
campaign.
In July 2005, Norwegian major general Bjrn Eggethe first UN officer
to view Hammarskjlds corpse 44 years earlierreported that Hammarskjld
had an apparent bullet hole in his forehead, which was airbrushed out of photos taken at the scene before their publication. Egge further suggested that
Hammarskjld might have been thrown from the wreckage alive, then was
shot while crawling away. Around the same time, a U.S. intelligence officer
stationed on Cyprus in September 1961 reported hearing a cockpit recording from Ndolas control tower. According to that witness, the tape included
sounds of gunfire and an unidentified pilot announcing, Ive hit it. In September 2009, Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi called for a new UN investigation of Hammarskjlds death and Patrice Lumumbas murder, but that
request was ignored.
See also: Lumumba, Patrice mery (19251961).
HAMPTON, FRED
Further Reading
Urquhart, Brian. Hammarskjld. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1972.
Van Dusen, Henry. Dag Hammarskjld: The Man and His Faith. New York: Harper &
Row, 1969.
Williams, A. Susan. Who Killed Hammarskjld? The UN, the Cold War, and White Supremacy in Africa. London: C. Hurst & Co., 2011.
205
206
HAMPTON, FRED
1948, and raised in the Chicago suburb of Maywood. He graduated with honors from Proviso East High School in 1966, then enrolled as a pre-law student
at Triton Junior College in River Grove, Illinois. First active as a leader of the
National Association for the Advancement of Colored Peoples Youth Council,
he demonstrated natural leadership qualities. Exposure to police racism in his
home environment drew Hampton to the BPP when its Chicago chapter organized, late in 1967. From that base, he negotiated a truce among the citys
largest African America street gangs, including the 30,000-member Blackstone
Rangers. Next came collaboration with the mostly white Students for a Democratic Society, the Hispanic Brown Berets, and the Chinese-American Red Guard
Party. In May 1969, Hampton publicly described that alliance as a rainbow
coalitiona term subsequently appropriated and popularized by Rev. Jesse
Jackson.
Hamptons charisma and achievements quickly made him a target for Chicago police and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), collaborating in
illegal harassment of the Panthers under one of the FBIs covert counterintelligence programs (COINTELPRO). FBI documents secured by Senate investigators in 1975 revealed that the bureau engaged in activities ranging from
outlawed wiretaps and anonymous hate-mail campaigns to active promotion
of violence between Black Panthers and other ghetto organizations, provoking
multiple murders in cities from coast to coast. In Chicago, FBI agents first tried
to provoke a shooting war between Panthers and the Blackstone Rangers. Failing that, they hired agents provocateurs to infiltrate the Panthers and encourage
criminal activity. One such hireling, William ONeal, later committed suicide
after admitting that he drugged a drink consumed by Hampton on the night of
the fatal police raid.
Other evidence of a set-up and summary execution came from within the
FBI itself. Retired agent Mont Wesley Swearingen, in a 1995 memoir, described
fellow agent Gregg York telling him, We expected about twenty Panthers to
be in the apartment when the police raided the place. Only two of those black
niggers were killed, Fred Hampton and Mark Clark. A survivor of the December raid, Panther Harold Bell, recalled the following exchange between uniformed raiders in the apartment:
Thats Fred Hampton.
Is he dead? Bring him out.
Hes barely alive.
Hell make it.
Two more shots rang out, then, and an officer replied, Hes good and
dead now.
Cook Countys Democratic Party declined to endorse Edward Hanrahan for
reelection, but he won the primary without party support, only to lose the general elections. In the 1970s he also lost two gubernatorial bids, and finished his
political career in the 1980s, defeated in a campaign for Chicagos City Council.
HAMPTON, FRED
Thirty-five years after Hamptons slaying that same council unanimously declared December 4, 2004, as Fred Hampton Day in Chicago.
Further Reading
Churchill, Ward. Agents of Repression: The FBIs Secret War against the Black Panther
Party and the American Indian Movement. Boston: South End Press, 2001.
Federal Bureau of Investigation. Fred Hampton. FBI Records: The Vault. http://vault
.fbi.gov/Fred%20Hampton.
Haas, Jeffrey. The Assassination of Fred Hampton: How the FBI and the Chicago Police Murdered a Black Panther. Chicago: Lawrence Hill Books, 2010.
Wilkins, Roy, and Ramsey Clark. Search and Destroy: A Report by the Commission of
Inquiry into the Black Panthers and the Police. New York: Metropolitan Applied Research Center, 1973.
207
208
H A R A L D I V O F N O R WAY
209
210
H A R A L D I V O F N O R W AY
H A R R I S O N , C A R T E R H E N R Y, S R .
211
212
H A R R I S O N , C A R T E R H E N R Y, S R .
HAYMARKET RIOT
In February 1886, managers of Chicagos McCormick Harvesting Machine
Company locked out union workers, prompting a general strike by some
40,000 Windy City laborers in sympathy with those discharged. On May 4,
1886, a demonstration was staged at Haymarket Square, proceeding
peacefully until some unknown person hurled a bomb at police on the
sidelines, killing one officer outright and fatally wounding six others. Police then fired on the crowd, killing four demonstrators and wounding 70
more. Subsequently, eight anarchists were indicted and convicted of conspiracy in the bombing, despite a prosecutors admission that none had
thrown the fatal bomb. All eight were convicted, with seven sentenced
to die, and one received a 15-year sentence. Governor Richard Oglesby
commuted two of the death sentences to life imprisonment, and a third
condemned prisoner committed suicide in jail before the other four were
hanged on November 11, 1887. Six years later, Governor John Altgeld
pardoned the surviving Haymarket defendants, criticizing the conduct of
their trial. The actual bomber remains unidentified.
Carter Harrison was Chicagos first five-term mayor, although his last term
was cut short. His son, Carter Jr., subsequently followed in his fathers political footsteps, serving five terms as mayor in his own right, from 1897 to 1905,
and 1911 to 1915. The younger Harrison hoped for the Democratic presidential nomination in 1904, but his party chose Alton Brooks Parker instead, then
suffered a crushing defeat by incumbent Theodore Roosevelt. During his final
term as mayor, Carter Jr. established the Chicago Vice Commission, closing
manybut by no means allof the Levee districts notorious brothels. His
efforts to clean up the Windy City were defeated by the advent of successors
William Big Bill Thompson and Anton Cermak, allied with rival crime syndicates during the era of Prohibition.
Further Reading
Abbott, W. J. Carter Henry Harrison: A Memoir. New York: Dodd, Mead and Company,
1895.
Johnson, Claudius. Carter Henry Harrison I: Political Leader. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press, 1928.
Larson, Erik. The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair that
Changed America. New York: Crown Publishers, 2003.
H E N N E S S Y, D AV I D C . , J R .
213
214
H E N N E S S Y, D AV I D C . , J R .
H E N R I O T, P H I L I P P E
William Parkerson, mouthpiece for the Committee of Fifty, met the assembled
mob and demanded that they remedy the failure of justice. An estimated 150
vigilantes marched to the Parish Prison, led by Parkerson, chanting, Kill the
dagos! On arrival, they battered their way inside against feeble resistance from
guards, removing 11 of the 19 defendants indicted for Hennessys murder (including four who had not yet been tried). Parkerson personally led a 12-man execution squad in lynching the 11, urged on by deafening cheer from bystanders.
Reactions to the New Orleans lynching were mixed. In far-off New York
City, a Times headline declared: Chief Hennessy avenged . . . Italian murderers shot down. Mayor Shoemaker told reporters, The Italians had taken the
law into their own hands and we had no choice but to do the same. A national
survey of 100 major newspapers found 42 in accord with the lynching, versus
58 opposed. As in most other Southern lynchings, a grand jury refused to indict the identified killers, proclaiming that so many had joined in the act that
guilt was collective. Italys ambassador protested the murders, prompting an
eventual $25,000 settlement from Congress. Mayor Shoemaker lost his bid for
a third term in 1892, but Charles Matranga fared considerably better. He survived the massacreby hiding under a mattress, he claimedand was later
released, remaining in control of the New Orleans Mafia until he voluntarily
retired in 1922.
Further Reading
Gentile, Joseph. The Innocent Lynched: The Story of Eleven Italians Lynched in New Orleans. San Jose, CA: Writers Showcase, 2000.
Hunt, Thomas, and Martha Sheldon, Deep Water: Joseph P. Macheca and the Birth of the
American Mafia. Scotts Valley, CA: CreateSpace, 2010.
Smith, Tom. The Crescent City Lynchings: The Murder of Chief Hennessy, the New Orleans
Mafia Trials, and the Parish Prison Mob. Guilford, CT: Lyons Press, 2007.
215
216
H E N R I O T, P H I L I P P E
largest right-wing party, the Republican Federation, but soon found even that
groups policies too liberal. In 1932, he was elected to the Chamber of Deputies in Gironde, one of 83 dpartements of France created after the French Revolution in 1790. His campaign speeches were virtually indistinguishable from
those of Adolf Hitler in Germany, coupling anti-Semitism and anticommunism
with attacks on Freemasons and opposition to the French parliamentary system. Henriots constituents agreed with him sufficiently to grant him a second
four-year term in 1936.
At the outbreak of World War II, Henriot joined most of his countrymen in
condemning Nazi Germany, but he changed his tune the following year, working as a propagandist for the collaborationist Vichy regime of puppet leader
Philippe Ptain. Broadcasting over Radio Paris, Henriot praised Germany for
its June 1941 invasion of the Soviet Union and waged a bitter war of words
against the exiled Free French Forces led by Charles de Gaulle from London.
He also frequently attacked resistance activists Pierre Dac (n Andr Isaac) and
Maurice Schumann for their anti-Nazi broadcasts over the British Broadcasting
Corporation. In January 1944, Ptain appointed Henriot as the Vichy regimes
official minister of information and propaganda, earning him scorn among
loyal Frenchmen and their allies as the French Goebbels.
In fact, however, Henriot never enjoyed the power held by Joseph Goebbels
in the Third Reich, and must have known he was a hunted man. In 1943, he
joined the paramilitary Milice franaise, organized that January with German
aid to fight COMAC and other French resistance groups, but no evidence exists that he participated in militia raids. If he was armed, his weapons failed to
save him when his enemies arrived on his doorstep.
Vichy France did not long survive its minister of information and propaganda. Aged Philippe Ptain stepped down as chief of state on August 19,
1944, and France was officially liberated from German control on September 7.
Convicted of treason in August 1945, Ptain was sentenced to die, that sentence later commuted to exile on an island off the French Atlantic coast. Some
1,500 other French collaborators were also condemned, and although many
of those later received amnesty, estimates of traitors executed without formal
trial range from 10,000 to 40,000. A handful of trials for war crimes continued
into the 1980s, and Ren Bousquet, former Vichy secretary general, was assassinated on June 8, 1993, while awaiting trial for crimes against humanity.
Further Reading
Azema, Jean-Pierre. From Munich to Liberation 19381944. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1985.
Levendel, Isaac. Not the Germans Alone: A Sons Search for the Truth of Vichy. Evanston,
IL: Northwestern University Press, 2001.
Neiberg, Michael. The Blood of Free Men: The Liberation of Paris, 1944. New York: Basic
Books, 2012.
217
218
toll as high as 70,000). Still, at age nine, Henrythen Alexandrehad flirted with
Protestantism himself, refusing to attend mass and haranguing his sister Margaret
to abandon Catholicism. Mother Catherine took him in hand, but he had earned a
reputation at court as un petit Huguenot, and the moderation of his religious bigotry
from 1573 onward counted against him with his Catholic subjects.
Another strike against Henry was the persistent rumorstill debated by
historiansof his supposed homosexuality or bisexuality. Some modern researchers refute that claim with reference to Henrys many famous mistresses,
including Italian courtesan Veronica Franco, Louise de La Braudire du
Rouhet, Rene de Rieux de Chteauneuf, and Marie van Kleef, countess of
Beaufort. In retrospect, it seems that Henrys religious and political opponents
may have branded him as homosexual based on his dislike of hunting, deemed
effeminate and thus a handy weapon to assail his reputation.
As successor to King Sigismund II Augustus of Poland, elected by the Polish
Lithuanian Commonwealth in September 1573, Henry ruled only briefly, distracted by warfare in France. He did not arrive in Poland for his coronation
until 1574, then left again that June, on learning of Charles IXs death. Warned
that he could not retain the Polish throne unless he returned by May 12, 1575,
Henry let the deadline pass and was accordingly deposed.
Meanwhile, in France, he was crowned on February 13, 1575. Fifteen
months later, he angered French Catholics by signing the Edict of Beaulieu,
which granted Huguenots the right of public worship throughout France, except in Paris and at court. Pressure from a newly formed Catholic League of
France forced him to backpedal in September 1577 with the Edict of Poitiers,
restricting open Protestant worship to the suburbs of one town in each judicial
district. Even that reversal failed to satisfy Catholic League founder Henry I,
Duke of Guise, who invaded Paris on May 12, 1588, forcing Henry III to flee.
The Duke of Guise did not live to enjoy that triumph, however. On December 22, 1588, Henry I spent the night with mistress Charlotte de Sauve,
a secret member of Catherine de Medicis female spy network, the Flying
Squadron. Next morning, summoned to meet the king at his Chteau de Blois
in the Loir Valley, Henry I was ambushed and stabbed to death by the kings
bodyguards, while Henry III stood watching. Henry Is brother, Louis II, cardinal of Guise, was slain in identical fashion on Christmas Eve, so outraging the
Catholic League that zealot Jacques Clment embarked on a path of personal
vengeance. At his death, Henry III was succeeded by Henry IV.
Further Reading
Freer, Martha. Henry III, King of France and Poland: His Court and Times. London: Hurst
and Blackett, 1858.
Major, J. Russell. From Renaissance Monarchy to Absolute Monarchy: French Kings, Nobles, and Estates. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997.
HENRY IV OF FRANCE
219
220
H E U R E A U X L E B E R T, U L I S E S
four years before issuing the Edict of Nantes, granting substantial rights to Huguenots and finally ending the French Wars of Religion.
Despite his widespread popularity in France, Henry faced multiple assassination attemptssome accounts claim 20before the one that finally ended
his left. Details of most attempts are lacking, but we know that Pierre Barrire,
an Orlans boatman and soldier of the Catholic League, planned to kill Henry
in August 1593. Betrayed by a Dominican priest to whom he had confessed
his plan, Barrire was arrested on August 27 and executed four days later, by
breaking on the wheel prior to dismemberment.
Jean Chtel, the 19-year-old son of a cloth merchant, crept into Henrys private quarters on December 27, 1594, and attacked him with a knife, slicing the
kings lip. Captured at the scene and convicted of lse majest (injured majesty), Chtel received the prescribed punishment: the hand with which he
struck his king was burned with molten lead, sulfur and wax, before he was
dismembered while alive. Under interrogation, Chtel had described his education by Jesuit priests at the Collge de Clermont, which was subsequently
closed and confiscated as further punishment for the assault.
Punishment for Henrys assassination also extended beyond the slayer. In
January 1611, an acquaintance of Franois Ravaillac, Maddame Jacqueline
dEscoman, accused Jean Louis de Nogaret de La Valette, Duke of pernon,
of complicity in Henrys murder. Although she was swiftly imprisoned for life,
modern historian Philippe Erlanger claims a link between the duke and Ravaillac through the dukes mistress, Charlotte du Tillet. Erlanger suggests that
du Tillet and Henrys own mistress, Catherine Henriette de Balzac dEntragues,
planned the assassination.
Further Reading
Baird, Henry. The Huguenots and Henry of Navarre. New York: Charles Scribners Sons,
1886.
Holt, Mack. The French Wars of Religion, 15621629. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2005.
H E U R E A U X L E B E R T, U L I S E S
one bullet struck Heureaux, killing him instantly, although reports disagree as
to whether he was shot in the head or the heart. Another round missed and
killed an elderly beggar standing nearby. Both gunmen escaped in the confusion, aided by accomplices.
Ulises Heureaux, widely known as Lilis, was born in Puerto Plata on October 21, 1845, to a Haitian father and a mother from Saint Thomas, raised to
be fluent in English, French, and Spanish. He was 16 when Spain annexed the
Dominican Republic, and joined in the fight to regain independence, rising
to become a primary lieutenant of General Gregorio Lupern. That rebellion
was victorious in 1874, but governing the new republic proved to be a dicey
proposition. Multiple revolutions rocked the island nation, with Heureaux in
the thick of the action. In April 1876, he led a revolt that installed Ulises Francisco Espaillat Quiones as president for a brief six-month term, forced out by
a superior governing junta. Two more presidents rose and fell during the last
two months of 1876, before four-time president Buenaventura Bez Mndez
returned for a fifth time, on December 26.
Another coup deposed Bez in March 1878, and Heureaux helped overthrow the next two Dominican presidents within six months. It was during
that year that Heureaux arranged the murder of Manuel Cceres, an influential aide to President Bez, and thus lit the slow fuse for his own assassination two decades later. Gregorio Lupern finally attained the presidency
in December 1879, but he preferred life on his Puerto Plata tobacco plantation, delegating much of his authority to Heureaux in Santo Domingo.
Fernando Arturo de Merio succeeded Lupern in September 1880, but Lupern threw his substantial support behind Heureaux at the next election,
in September 1882.
Dominican politics remained volatile, but Heureaux faced only one minor
insurrection during his first two-year term as president. Following Luperns
advice and example, Heureaux stepped aside in 1884, succeeded by Francisco
Gregorio Billini. Billini resisted Heureauxs attempt to persist in the role of
puppet-master, declaring an amnesty for political prisoners, whereupon Heureaux spread rumors that Billini was conspiring to restore unpopular President
Cesreo Guillermo. The fabricated scandal forced Billinis resignation in May
1885, succeeded by more pliable Vice President Alejandro Woss y Gil. He, in
turn, resigned on January 6, 1887, ceding the presidents office once more to
Heureaux.
During his second term, Heureaux faced a rebellion in the Cibao Valley region, led by rival Casimiro de Moya, but suppressed the insurrection ruthlessly. In 1888, he exiled mentor Gregorio Lupern, presumably fearing his
influence with Dominicans who might resent Heureauxs strong-arm rule if
encouraged to rebel by a popular icon. Heureaux also established a network of
secret police to monitor signs of unrest, and he set about looting the country
221
222
H E Y D R I C H, R E I N H A R D T R I S TA N E U G E N
for personal profit, prompting one observer to remark that the separation between the presidents private means and state finances was vague, fluid and almost non-existent. The combination of kleptocracy and extensive borrowing
from European creditors drove the Dominican economy into crisis, slipping
toward bankruptcy over the next decade.
Mindful of growing discontent, Heureaux resigned on February 27, 1889,
then grew restive and reclaimed his office from acting president nine weeks
later, on April 30, retaining power thereafter until his own death. Before
the final act, in July 1894, he faced an insurrection plot described by the
New York Times as particularly daring and well-planned. The ringleader,
a general named Bobadilla, was arrested with 10 cohorts and shot with his
friends looking on, before Heureaux contemptuously pardoned the rest.
The Times referred to innumerable other plots against Heureaux before he
was finally killed, leaving the nation $35 million in debta sum 15 times
its annual budget.
Far from being punished, assassin Ramn Cceres Vasquez survived to become vice president under Carlos Felipe Morales, and was elevated to the presidents office when Morales resigned in December 1905. Perhaps ironically,
Cceres was himself assassinated on November 19, 1911, by rebels who ambushed his car in Santo Domingo.
Further Reading
Moya-Pons, Frank. Dominican Republic: A National History. New Rochelle, NY: Hispaniola Books, 1995.
Rodman, Selden. Quisqueya: A History of the Dominican Republic. Seattle: University of
Washington Press, 1964.
Wucker, Michelle. Why the Cocks Fight: Dominicans, Haitians, and the Struggle for Hispaniola. New York: Hill and Wang, 1999.
H E Y D R I C H , R E I N H A R D T R I S TA N E U G E N
223
224
H E Y D R I C H, R E I N H A R D T R I S TA N E U G E N
Heydrichs various duties included orchestration of the 1936 Summer Olympics for use as a Nazi propaganda tool, and leadership of a new Reich Main Security Office, created after the outbreak of World War II in September 1939.
In August 1940, he was named as chief of Interpol, a selection that prompted
the U.S. FBI to sever contact with the international police agency. In 1941, he
ran the Nacht und Nebel (Night and Fog) campaign, under which some 7,000
persons endangering German security vanished without a trace. In September 1941, Heydrich was named Deputy Reich Protector for Bohemia and Moravia (parts of Czechoslovakia annexed by Germany in 1939), where he became
known as the Butcher of Prague for his ruthless tactics. Perhaps most critically, he chaired the Wannsee Conference of January 1942 (see sidebar), where
Nazi leaders met to sketch the outlines of Hitlers Final Solutionsystematic
extermination of Jews within German-occupied territory.
Although Nazis used Heydrichs assassination for propaganda purposes, Hitler himself blamed Heydrich for his own demise, saying, Since it is opportunity which makes not only the thief but also the assassin, such heroic gestures
as driving in an open, unarmoured vehicle or walking about the streets unguarded are just damned stupidity, which serves the Fatherland not one whit.
That a man as irreplaceable as Heydrich should expose himself to unnecessary
danger, I can only condemn as stupid and idiotic.
Still, reprisals were made. Heydrichs killers sought sanctuary at a church in
Prague, but a traitor in the Czech resistance betrayed them and they committed
WANNSEE CONFERENCE
On January 20, 1942, 15 senior officials of the Third Reich met in the
Berlin suburb of Wannsee to discuss mechanics of the genocidal program Adolf Hitler termed the final solution to the Jewish question.
Schutzstaffel (SS) General Reinhard Heydrich chaired the meeting and
presented an agenda calling for all Jews from Europe and French North
Africa (present-day Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia) to be relocated in
German-occupied parts of Eastern Europe. Their destination, though not
plainly stated in the minutes of the conference, would be a series of extermination camps in Poland, including Auschwitz, Belzec, Chalmno,
Majdanek, Sobibor, and Treblinka. Calculations made at the conference
and recorded by SS-Obersturmbannfhrer (lieutenant colonel) Adolf Eichmann included removal of 15,153,468 identified Jews from regions
under Nazi control or earmarked for future conquest, including England,
Ireland, and Switzerland.
HITLER, ADOLF
225
226
HITLER, ADOLF
HITLER, ADOLF
227
228
HITLER, ADOLF
German attorney Nikolaus von Halem, from Oldenberg, plotted Hitlers death
in 1941, but cohort Joseph Roman was arrested and named him under torture,
sending von Halem to prison, where he was executed on October 9, 1944.
Military plots against Hitler proliferated in 1943 and 1944, as German forces
suffered critical defeats on various fronts. A group led by General Karl Hubert
Lanz planned to strike in February 1943, when Hitler visited Poltawa in the
Ukraine, but a change in the Fhrers itinerary foiled the plan. The same sort
of glitches foiled two more plots organized around Smolensk, in the USSR,
during March 1943. Captain Rudolf von Gersdorff planned to kill Hitler with
a suicide bomb on March 13, at an exhibition of captured Russian weapons in
Berlin, but he was unable to get past Hitlers bodyguards. German nobleman
Axel von dem Bussche-Streithorst also volunteered as a suicide bomber, planning to kill Hitler during a troop inspection in East Prussia on November 16,
but an Allied air strike deprived him of transportation.
Wehrmacht officer Ewald-Heinrich von Kleist-Schmenzins was the next volunteer for a suicide strike against Hitler, in January 1944, during an inspection of new army uniforms, but postponement of the meeting foiled his plan.
Another soldier, Eberhard von Breitenbuch, took a concealed pistol to a military briefing with Hitler at the Berghof in Bavaria, on March 11, but SS guards
barred him from the room where Hitler met with higher-ranking officers.
By July 1944, military conspirators led by Eastern Front veteran Claus von
Stauffenberg were committed to eliminating Hitler. After one accomplice, General Helmuth Stieff, failed to succeed with a bomb at a uniform exhibition at
Klessheim castle near Salzburg, on July 7, von Stauffenberg decided to do the
job himself. He brought a bomb to Obersalzberg on July 11, then refrained
from detonating it because top Nazis Hermann Gring and Heinrich Himmler
missed the meeting. Nine days later, his bomb detonated on schedule, during
a strategy meeting at Hitlers Wolfs Lair near Rastenber, East Prussia (now
Ketrzyn, Poland). The blast killed four persons, but a heavy oak table spared
Hitler from serious injury.
Following that botched attempt, conspirator Friedrich Fromm panicked
and named his associates in futile attempt to save his own life. Von Stauffenberg and three other leading plotters were quickly arrested and executed by firing squad on July 21. Von Stauffenbergs older brother was convicted in August
and executed by slow strangulation. Before investigation of the plot was finally
concluded, some 20,000 suspected resistance members were either executed
or shipped off to concentration camps. Friedrich Fromm was discharged from
the army in September 1944, then sentenced to death for cowardice and shot
on March 12, 1945.
The last known plot to kill Hitler was allegedly conceived by Albert Speer,
Germanys minister of armaments and war production, in early 1945. Speer
later testified that he planned to drop a canister of poison gas into the air-intake
HITLER, ADOLF
system of Hitlers bunker in Berlin, but a high wall around the access hatch
foiled his plot.
Adolf Hitler married his longtime mistress, Eva Braun, in the same bunker as Soviet troops advanced through Berlin, on April 28, 1945. Two days
later, the couple reportedly committed suicide and their corpses were burned
by loyal officers. Some conspiracy theorists, however, still contend that Hitler
faked his own death and escaped to South America, along with other Nazis
such as Adolf Eichmann, Josef Mengele, and Klaus Barbie.
Further Reading
Fest, Joachim. Plotting Hitlers Death: The Story of German Resistance. New York: Holt
Paperbacks, 1997.
Hoffmann, Peter. The History of the German Resistance, 19331945. Montreal: McGillQueens University Press, 1996.
Kershaw, Ian. The End: The Defiance and Destruction of Hitlers Germany, 19441945.
New York: Penguin Books, 2011.
Kershaw, Ian. Hitler, 18891936: Hubris. New York: W. W. Norton, 1998.
Kershaw, Ian. Hitler, 19361945: Nemesis. New York: W. W. Norton, 2000.
Toland, John. Adolf Hitler. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1976.
229
I
IDIARTE BORDA, JUAN BAUTISTA
(18441897)
On August 25, 1897, Uruguayan president Juan Idiarte Borda attended a
church service at Montevideos cathedral on Constitution Square. As he left
the church, Idiarte was shot and killed by Avelino Arredondo, a member of a
dissident faction within Idiartes own Colorado Party. Curiously, the newspaper
El Da had erroneously named Arredondo as a participant in a previous attempt
on Idiartes life, in April 1897. Arrested at the murder scene, Arredondo was
convicted and imprisoned, but attempts to locate more conspirators proved
fruitless.
Juan Idiarte Borda was born and raided in Mercedes, Uruguay, to affluent
parents of Basque origin. As a teenager, his talent with the clarinet led relatives to think he would pursue a musical career, but his fathers death in 1860
placed him prematurely in charge of the familys cattle ranch at age 16. Three
years later, Idiarte and his brother, Peter, joined in a revolution against the ruling National Party, led by Venancio Flores, which sparked a civil war in Uruguay and ended with Flores assuming the presidency. Idiarte emerged from
that conflict as a lieutenant and parlayed his renown into a new political career,
supporting reforms deemed radical at the time.
In 1879, Idiarte left Mercedes for Montevideo and won election to parliament. He served until 1886, when personal conflicts with President Mximo
Benito Santos Barbosa encouraged Idiarte to leave the country, settling for eight
years in Buenos Aires, Argentina. He returned to Uruguay in February 1894,
seeking the office vacated by retiring president Julio Herrera y Obes. Three
weeks of voting and riotous senate debate climaxed on March 21, when Idiarte edged out interim president Duncan Antonio Stewart Agell by a margin of
47 ballots.
From the outset of his term as president, opponents charged Idiarte with electoral fraud. Jose Battle y Ordonez, editor of El Da in Montevideo, was among
Idiartes harshest critics, publishing charges of vote rigging and corruption that
encouraged violent dissent against Idiartes regime. In March 1897, members
of the White Party led by Aparicio Saravia rebelled against the Colorado Partys
government, sparking another civil war. In April, while alighting from a carriage
at his home, Idiarte was accosted by would-be assassin John A. Rabecca, who
232
pressed a pistol to the presidents neck but did not fire. Idiartes family took the
incident as a warning from the White Party, but the president refused to back
down from his enemies.
Political struggles continued after Idiartes assassination, as Juan Lindolfo
Cuestas succeeded the murdered chief of state. By September 1897, White
Party forces controlled most of the Uruguayan countryside, and Aparicio Saravia was ranked as the countrys second most powerful figure when Jose Batlle
y Ordonez ascended to the presidency in 1903. Savaria died from wounds suffered in battle, in September 1904, and his party did not long survive him.
President Batlle held office until 1907, and the Colorado Party ruled Uruguay
without interruption until 1959.
Further Reading
Bethell, Leslie. The Cambridge History of Latin America, Vol. 5, c. 18701930. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Lpez-Alves, Fernando. State Formation and Democracy in Latin America, 18101900.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2000.
Akintola and Olusola Olaosebikan vying for endorsement as Awolowos political heir. That rivalry ended with Akintolas assassination during the military
coup that ended the First Republic in January 1966.
Nigerias new ruler, General Yakubu Jack Dan-Yumma Gowon, named Ige
as commissioner for agriculture for Nigerias western region, operating from
the capital at Ibadan. A year later, that region was abolished, subdivided into
Lagos State and Western State, with Ige serving the latter from Ibadan. There,
he befriended army commander and future president Olusegun Obasanjo,
while dividing his time between official duties and antiracism campaign sponsored by the World Council of Churches.
General Murtala Ramat Mohammed led a successful coup against Gowons
regime on July 29, 1975, and proclaimed himself head of state, with Obasanjo
as his second-in-command. Ige, still loyal to Obafemi Awolowo, joined his
newest vehicle, the United Party of Nigeria (UPN). Following General Mohammeds assassination in 1976, General Obasanjo assumed control and laid the
groundwork for establishment to Nigerias Second Republic in 1979. In October of that year, Ige won election as the governor of Oyo State, serving one
term before he lost a reelection big to Dr. Victor Omololu Olunloyo in 1983.
Ige contested that election, but left office in October, when the courts ruled
against him. Olunloyo, in turn, was deposed three months later by another
military coup.
The leaders of that uprising detained Bola Ige for two years, on charges of
misappropriating UPN funds, but he was liberated in August 1985, following
yet another coup, led by General Ibrahim Badamasi Babangida. Returning to
legal practice with a sideline in writing, Ige shunned further political activity
until May 1999, when a new constitution established Nigerias Fourth Republic
and institution of sweeping democratic reforms. (A short-lived Third Republic
had been virtually stillborn during 1993.) Ige ran for president, representing
a new Alliance for Democracy, but lost the race to Olusegun Obasanjowho
then appointed Ige first as minister of mines and power (19992000), then as
minister of justice and attorney general. On the eve of his assassination, Ige
was earmarked to serve as Africas representative on the United Nations International Law Commission.
Some Nigerians blamed President Obasanjo for Iges assassination, although no clear motive was advanced beyond assertions that he may have
uncovered deep-seated government corruption and planned to expose it.
Calls for establishment of an independent truth commission have thus far
been ignored.
Further Reading
Ahworegba, Prosper. The Nigerian 100: The Most Influential Nigerians of All Time. Dartford, United Kingdom: Xlibris, 2008.
233
234
INEJIRO ASANUMA
Banjo, Ayo, ed. Bola Ige: Passage of a Modern Cicero. Lagos, Nigeria: Bookcraft, Ltd.,
2003.
Mohammed, Abubakar. Chief Bola Ige and the Destabilization of Nigeria. Zaria, Nigeria:
Centre for Democratic Development Research and Training, 1999.
INEJIRO ASANUMA
235
J
JACKSON, ANDREW (17671845)
ATTEMPTED
On January 30, 1835, President Andrew Jackson attended the funeral of South
Carolina congressman Warren Davis at the United States Capitol. Afterward, as
Jackson left the building from the East Portico, unemployed British housepainter
Richard Lawrence aimed a pistol at Jackson, but the weapon misfired. Bystanders, including legendary frontiersman (then congressman) Davy Crockett, disarmed Lawrence, with some accounts claiming that Jackson used a cane to strike
his would-be killer. In custody, Lawrence raved incoherently, blaming Jackson
for his unemployment and claiming that heLawrencewas King Richard III
of England (deceased for 350 years). At trial in April, prosecuted by Francis Scott
Key, Lawrence was found insane and committed to an asylum where he died in
June 1861.
Aside from the first attempted U.S. presidential assassination, Jackson had
also experienced the first attack on an U.S. president, two years earlier. On
May 6, 1833, he sailed aboard the USS Cygnet from Washington to Fredericksburg, Virginia, to lay the cornerstone for a monument to George Washingtons
mother. Stopping along the way near Alexandria, Jackson was accosted and
punched by Robert B. Randolph, earlier dismissed from the navy for embezzlement by Jacksons order. Again, bystandersthis time including author Washington Irgingcaptured Jacksons assailant, but the president declined to press
charges in that case.
Born at some uncertain point on the border between North and South Carolina, on March 15, 1767, Andrew Jackson was the son of Scot-Irish colonists. In
later life, he referred to rumors that his Mother . . . [was] held to public scorn
as a prostitute who intermarried with a Negro, and [that his] . . . eldest brother
[was] sold as a slave in Carolina, but no such claims were ever substantiated. He
joined a local militia during the American Revolution, at age 13, and was captured
by British troops with one of his brothers, scarred by a saber in captivity when he
refused to shine a redcoat officers boots. That experience, coupled with another
brothers death in battle, left Jackson with a bitter hatred of England at wars end.
Despite his own erratic education, Jackson later taught school, studied law,
and was admitted to the bar in North Carolina, practicing along the frontier.
He was a delegate to North Carolinas constitutional convention in 1796 and
won election to Congress that same year. In 1797, he advanced to the U.S.
238
JACKSON, ANDREW
Senate, but resigned after a year in office. Appointed to the Tennessee Supreme
Court in 1798, he held that post until 1804, simultaneously operating a plantation run by slaves and serving as a general in the state militia. During the War
of 1812, Jackson initially waged rural campaigns against hostile Native American tribes, then secured fame by defeating British troops in the Battle of New
Orleans, ironically fought two weeks after the United States and Britain made
peace with the Treaty of Ghent. Two years later he was back in action, leading
troops against more hostile tribesmen in the First Seminole War.
Tennessees legislature sent Jackson back to the U.S. Senate in 1822, and two
years later he ran for president against three fellow members of the DemocraticRepublican Party: John Quincy Adams, William Harris Crawford, and Henry
Clay. Jackson won the popular vote, with 151,271 ballots to 113,122 for Adams,
and also shaded Adams by a margin of 15 votes in the Electoral College, but still
had only 99 votes, with 131 required for victory. Under terms of the Twelfth
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, the House of Representatives decided
the election, choosing Adams over Jackson in a move that many observers denounced as a corrupt bargain.
Jackson resigned from the Senate in October 1825, but rebounded three
years later with another presidential campaign, this time unseating incumbent
Adams with a decisive electoral margin of 178 to 83. He won reelection in
1832 with an even more decisive edge, receiving 219 electoral votes versus
49 for National Republican Party nominee Henry Clay, and seven for William
Wirt, representing the Anti-Masonic Party.
Jacksons eight years in office were marked by successive bitter controversies. He paid off Americas national debt in 1835the only such accomplishment by any presidentthen saw the country plunge into severe depression
two years later, increasing the debt tenfold. His reliance on the spoils system
prompted charges of cronyism and corruption, and his dismantling of the national bank caused financial speculation and manipulation to proliferate. His
relentless campaign of Indian removal amounted, in effect, to ethnic cleansing
of Native Americans from land desired by whites, claiming the lives of some
4,000 Cherokees alone on the long Trail of Tears from the Deep South to Indian Territory (now Oklahoma). On his last day in office, Jackson admitted
two lingering regrets: that he had been unable to shoot Henry Clay or to hang
John C. Calhoun. Tuberculosis claimed the former presidents life at his Tennessee plantation, on June 8, 1845.
Further Reading
Brands, H. W. Andrew Jackson: His Life and Times. New York: Anchor Books, 2006.
Meacham, Jon. American Lion: Andrew Jackson in the White House. New York: Random
House, 2008.
Wilentz, Sean. Andrew Jackson. New York: Times Books, 2005.
J A C K S O N , W H A R L E S T, S R .
239
240
Wharlest Jackson Case. The Civil Rights Cold Case Project. http://coldcases.org/
cases/wharlest-jackson-case.
Whitehead, Don. Attack on Terror: The FBI Against the Ku Klux Klan in Mississippi. New York:
Funk & Wagnalls, 1970.
J O H N PA U L I I
British troops in battle against France during 14201421, and married the Earl
of Somersets daughter in 1424. Meanwhile, long-winded negotiations for his
release dragged on, encompassing exchange of other prisoners. Murdoch Stewart, son of the Duke who allegedly killed Jamess brother, had been captured in
1402 and was finally exchanged for Henry Percy, 2nd Earl of Northumberland,
in 1416. He rushed home to succeed his father as Duke of Albany and governor of Scotland, while James awaited payment of 40,000 for his release in April
1424. That ransom was obtained by raising taxes, a circumstance that brought
James back to Scotland with one strike against him in the public mind.
Formally crowned on May 21, 1424, James anticipated the hostility of nobles
allied with the Duke of Albany. In March 1425, James arrested Murdoch, two
of his sons, and 25 of their allies on charges of treason. Murdoch, his sons, and
a fourth defendant were convicted in May, executed by decapitation at Stirling
Castle. Others detained by James at various times included Alexander of Islay,
Earl of Ross (1428), Archibald Douglas, 5th Earl of Douglas (1431), and George
II, Earl of March (1434). Each in turn was freed upon payment of ransom,
which James used for the construction of Linlithgow Palace in West Lothian.
Such treatment of his adversaries, coupled with ever-increasing taxation,
encouraged rebellion against James I. His ill-conceived alliance with France
against England, meanwhile, renewed hostilities across the border. James besieged the English outpost at Roxburgh Castle in August 1436, but suffered an
embarrassing defeat. Two months later came the attempt to arrest him, leading
ultimately to his murder.
Jamed II, only seven years old at his fathers death, ruled as best a child can
under the guidance of Archibald Douglashis first cousin and the same earl
imprisoned and ransomed by his father in 1431. Archibald died in June 1439,
and James II literally turned the tables on his keepers in November 1440, seizing and executing successor William Douglas and his brother during a banquet
in Edinburgh. Sporadic family feuding continued until August 1460, when
James II died in an attack on the same Roxburgh Castle that had broken his fathers spirit 24 years earlier.
Further Reading
Balfour-Melville, Evan. James I, King of Scots. London: Methuen, 1936.
Brown, Michael. James I. Edinburgh: Tuckwell Press, 2000.
Magnusson, Magnus. Scotland: The Story of a Nation. New York: Grove Press, 2003.
Traquair, Peter. Freedoms Sword: Scotlands Wars of Independence. London: HarperCollins, 1998.
241
242
J O H N PAU L I I
J O H N PA U L I I
243
K
KABILA, LAURENT-DSIR (19392001)
On January 16, 2001, while meeting with one of his top advisors, LaurentDsir Kabila, president of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), was
shot by one of his bodyguards. Other guards killed the shooter, Rashidi Kasereka,
as he tried to flee the scene. Kabila was rushed to Kinshasas hospital, where
he died on January 18. Son Joseph Kabila succeeded his father on January 26,
describing the assassination as the first move in an abortive coup. Police named
a cousin of Kabila, Colonel Eddy Kapend, as the coups ringleader, charging
him and 135 others with conspiracy. A military tribunal convicted Kapend and
89 other defendants, exonerating 45. Kapend and 25 others were sentenced to
death, but execution was deferred, sending them to prison with the 64 other
convicted defendants who received prison terms ranging from six months to
life. Observers of the proceedings differ in their opinions concerning the guilt
of those convicted.
Laurent-Dsir Kabila was a member of the Luba tribe, born at Baudoinville in the former province of Katanga, on November 27, 1939. His affluent
parents sent him abroad to study in France and Serbia, followed by graduation from Tanzanias University of Dar es Salaam. When Belgium granted independence to the Congo, in June 1960, Kabila was a member of the General
Association of the Baluba People of Katanga, allied with Patrice Lumumba in
conflict against rival Moise Tshombe. Lumumba won election as the DRCs first
prime minister, but was assassinated in September 1960. Five different prime
ministers held office in the next 12 months, before Cyrille Adoula managed to
complete a three-year tenure. Under Adoulas regime, in 1962, Kabila served as
cabinet chief for Minister of Information Ferdinand Tumba, while also being a
member of North Katangas provincial assembly.
Kabilas longtime adversary, Moise Tshombe, took office as prime minister in
July 1964, beginning a new round of conflict and violence. Kabila joined the
Conseil National de Libration, organizing revolution in the eastern Congo,
where he was assisted during 1965 by Che Guevara. Guevaras diaries indicate
his disappointment in Kabila as a revolutionary, noting his habitual distraction,
tardiness in joining various guerrilla actions, and failure to supply agreed-upon
support. Although Kabila possessed genuine qualities of a mass leader, Guevara found him sadly lacking in revolutionary seriousness.
246
K A B I L A , L AU R E N T- D S I R
That judgment aside, Kabila persevered in his war against Tshombe and his
successors, fighting on after the DRC was reborn in October 1971 as the Republic of Zaire. Leading a new Peoples Revolutionary Party (PRP), armed and
bankrolled by Chinese communists, Kabila established a stronghold in South
Kivu Province, declaring it a breakaway Marxist state, growing wealthy over
time from the proceeds of smuggling, extortion, and robbery. Kabila disappeared without a trace in 1988, leaving the PRP to flounder and disband. He
was presumed dead for eight years, then resurfaced in November 1996, at the
helm of a new Alliance of Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Congo, leading attacks on the regime of President Mobutu Sese Seko with backing from
Rwanda and Uganda.
The campaign was successful, forcing Mobutu into exile by May 1997,
whereupon Kabila proclaimed himself president, suspended the constitution,
and changed the countrys name back from Zaire to the Democratic Republic
of the Congo. Abandoning his former hard-line Marxism, Kabila offered concessions to foreign investors, but critics denounced him as corrupt, declaring that he had simply revived the former South Kivu kleptocracy on a larger
scale. Complaints of despotism and human rights violations proliferated. By
1998, Kabilas former allies in Uganda and Rwanda had established yet another revolutionary groupthe Congolese Rally for Democracyto depose
him. So began the Second Congo War, with Kabila seeking new allies in Angola, Namibia, and Zimbabwe. Despite insertion of United Nations peacekeeping forces, that war was still ongoing at the time of Kabilas assassination.
K A D Y R O V, A K H M A D A B D U L K H A M I D O V I C H
Conspiracy theories surround Kabilas murder. Critics of the trial that followed his assassinationincluding Mwenze Kongolo, who served as Kabilas
minister of justiceclaim that those convicted of plotting to slay Kabila are
scapegoats. Some investigative journalists believe the plot was orchestrated by
former child soldiers from South Kivu. Others point to agents of UNITA, the
National Union for the Total Independence of Angola, which had been at war
with the Angolan government since 1961. Yet another theory claims Rwandan
soldiers were involved, claiming that Colonel James Kabarebe, commander of
Rwandan forces inside the DRC, announced Kabilas death with the remark,
Good news from Kinshasa. Our boys did it.
See also: Lumumba, Patrice mery (19251961).
Further Reading
Autesserre, Sverine. The Trouble with the Congo: Local Violence and the Failure of International Peacebuilding. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Ngolet, Franois. Crisis in the Congo: The Rise and Fall of Laurent Kabila. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
Nzongola-Ntalaja, Georges. The Congo from Leopold to Kabila: A Peoples History. London:
Zed Books, 2002.
Trefon, Theodore. Congo Masquerade: The Political Culture of Aid Inefficiency and Reform
Failure. London: Zed Books, 2011.
247
248
K A D Y R O V, A K H M A D A B D U L K H A M I D O V I C H
KAHANE, MEIR
249
250
K AHANE, MEIR
Controversial rabbi and politician Meir Kahane, assassinated in November 1990. (Associated Press)
War II. At age 15, Kahane was arrested for lobbing eggs and tomatoes at Bevin,
upon his arrival at New Yorks waterfront.
Kahane pursued an Orthodox education at the Yeshivah of Flatbush
(Brooklyn) and the Brooklyn Talmudical Academy, before receiving his rabbinical ordination. A bachelors degree in political science followed, from
Brooklyn College, after which he studied law, earning a JD and an LLM. At
26, he was a rabbi for a synagogue in Queens, but sparked rebellion when he
tried to install a partition separating men from women in the congregation.
Politics dominated Kahanes life from the late 1950s onward. An ardent anticommunist, he joined the far-right John Birch Society, but wife Libby later
claimed that he only infiltrated the group as an informant for the Federal
Bureau of Investigation. In 1968, he founded the Jewish Defense League
(JDL; see sidebar), pledged to protect New York Jews from overt acts of
anti-Semitism. Clashes with neo-Nazis ensued, and the organization grew
quickly, with membership exceeding 15,000. By then, the JDL had branched
out into terrorism, focusing primarily on hostile Arab targets in the United
States and Russian embassies or other symbols of Soviet anti-Semitism.
Kahane immigrated to Israel in 1971, declaring his intent to focus on Jewish education, but the lure of politics proved irresistible. Between scores of
arrests for public demonstrations, he found time to found the Kach (This is
KAHANE, MEIR
251
252
El Sayyid Nosair was finally punished, after a fashion, for Kahanes murder.
In 1993, FBI agents arrested Sheik Omar Abdel-Rahman and others for participation in an elaborate conspiracy that included bombing New Yorks World
Trade Centers and an abortive plot to liberate Nosair from prison. The indictment included Kahanes assassination as a part of that conspiracy, and Nosair
was convicted with the others at trial, receiving a sentence of life without parole plus 15 years. In 2002, the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee reported
that Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden had paid for some of Nosairs legal expenses in 1991.
Further Reading
Breslauer, Daniel. Meir Kahane: Ideologue, Hero, Thinker. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen
Press, 1986.
Friedman, Robert. The False Prophet: Rabbi Meir Kahane, from FBI Informant to Knesset
Member. New York: Lawrence Hill, 1990.
Kahane, Meir. The Story of the Jewish Defense League. New York: Institute for Publication of the Writings of Rabbi Meir Kahane, 2000.
Rosenthal, Richard. Rookie Cop: Deep Undercover in the Jewish Defense League. Wellfleet,
MA: Leapfrog Press, 2000.
Although of royal descent, Kapodistrias was a dedicated liberal and democrat. He entered politics at age 25, as chief minister of state for the Septinsular
Republic, established under nominal Ottoman sovereignty in the Ionian Islands, with native nobles in charge. A Byzantine Constitution, imposed by
the sultan at Constantinople in 1800, loosely governed the seven-island republic until 1807, when French forces regrouped and recaptured the Ionian
Islands, dissolving Ottoman rule. Two years later, Kapodistrias volunteered
for Russias diplomatic service under Czar Alexander I, and was dispatched
to Switzerland Russias unofficial ambassador in November 1813. There, he
helped begin the process of restoring Switzerlands federal regime, dismantled
by Napoleon Bonaparte a decade earlier, and secured for himself a six-year
term as Russias foreign minister, beginning in 1816.
Kapodistrias retired from Russian service in 1822, settling in Geneva for
the next five years, though he continued to support the cause of Greek independence from Ottoman rule. That long struggle climaxed with victory in
April 1826, and the following year, a new Greek National Assembly chose Kapodistrias in absentia as the first governor of independent Greece. In January
1828, Kapodistrias arrived on the Greek mainland for the first time in his life,
proceeding to the capital at Nafplio.
During his three years and nine months in office, Kapodistrias built rural
schools and the first modern Greek university, reorganized military forces scattered during conflict with the Turks, and established the nations first quarantine system to end epidemics of cholera, dysentery, and typhoid fever. He
introduced potato cultivation, to enhance Greek agriculture, and created foundations to employ young women, while introducing modern currency in the
form of the Greek phoenix. Such sweeping changes inevitably sparked opposition in some quarters, including certain wealthy merchant families and rebellious inhabitants of the Mani Peninsula, with its capital at Areopoli, where
Petrobey Mavromichalis ruled in the style of a feudal warlord. The imprisonment of Petrobey, in 1831, provoked assassination in return.
Kapodistrias was briefly succeeded by his younger brother, Augustinos, but
his six-month term as governor proved chaotic. He left office in March 1832,
with three successive governing councils attempting to salvage the First Hellenic Republic between April 1832 and February 1833. They accomplished
nothing, beyond demonstrating the futility of government by committee, and
thereafter ceded power to King Otto, establishing a 114-year monarchy.
Further Reading
Clogg, Richard. A Concise History of Greece. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2002.
Sergeant, Lewis. Greece in the Nineteenth CenturyA Record of Hellenic Emancipation
and Progress: 18211897. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1897.
253
254
K A P U U O, C L E M E N S
Following the ICJs unenforceable ruling of 1971, Kapuuo led NUDO into
a new National Convention, joining SWANU, SWAPO, and other groups in a
united front against South African rule of Namibia. Two years later, the United
Nations undercut Kapuuo by declaring SWAPO the sole legitimate representative of native Namibians. That decision shattered the National Convention in 1974, and Kapuuo and NUDO joined in the Turnhalle Constitutional
Conference of 19751977, laying the groundwork for eventual Namibian
self-government.
South African authorities used Kapuuos assassination as an excuse to purge
SWAPO. On May 4, 1978, white troops launched Operation Reindeer, a sixday invasion of neighboring Angola that killed more than 1,200 SWAPO members in base camps at Chetequera and Dombondola. South African spokesmen
justified the attacks with a list of criminal incidents blamed on SWAPO, including the murder of Clemens Kapuuo.
Many Hereros still reject that theory. In January 2002, Herero paramount
chief Kuaima Riruako accused South Africas former apartheid regime of planning and executing Kapuuos assassination. According to him, Kapuuo was
killed by colonial imperial capitalists especially the South African regime and
their cohorts. I am saying this because even today the inquest on his death is
not clear. Let us be honest. The very same people who are refusing to find out
who killed Kapuuo, gave him a state funeral.
Further Reading
Leys, Colin, and Susan Brown, Histories of Namibia: Living through the Liberation Struggle. London: Merlin Press, 2004.
Wallace, Marion. A History of Namibia: From the Beginning to 1990. London: C. Hurst
& Co., 2011.
255
256
was a foreigner, possibly born in Uganda. That confusion may have arisen from
his widespread travels as a sailor, early in his life, achieving knowledge of the
world by experience, in lieu of formal education. Upon returning to his homeland, he entered politics as a member of the ASP, allied (and later merged)
with the Tanganyika African National Union. Britain controlled Zanzibar at
that time, but granted independence to the island in December 1963. In the
countrys first election, the ASP won a slim majority of the popular vote, but
the Arab-dominated Zanzibar Nationalist Party closed ranks with the mostly
African Zanzibar and Pemba Peoples Party to claim victory under Sultan Jamshid bin Abdullah.
On January 12, 1964, with Karume traveling on the African mainland,
members of the Umma Party and ASP rebelled in Zanzibar, led by ASP member John Okello. They deposed the sultan and declared Zanzibar a republic,
with a Revolutionary Council in charge. To Okellos surprise, the council chose
Abeid Karume as president, while naming Umma Party leader Abdulrahman
Mohamed Babu as prime minister (later vice president). Okello was shuffled
aside and left for the Congo, where he was jailed several times, then vanished
forever after being seen with Ugandan dictator Idi Amin, in 1971.
Hassan Nassor Moyo, a member of Karumes cabinet, described the president as a man who loathed discrimination, working tirelessly to unite the islands
28 separate ethnic groups. Karume chose an Arab, Salum Rashid, as the Revolutionary Councils First Secretary, thus extending an olive branch to the deposed
regime, but subsequent events suggest that he did not go far enough to please Abdulrahman Babu or the Umma Party. Sixteen attempts to overthrow the government were logged between 1964 and Karumes eventual death, eight years later.
Following Karumes murder, 57 defendants were charged with treason, held
for trial in a curious proceeding where Attorney General Wolfgang Dourado
served as both prosecutor and defender of the accused. Chief Justice Ali Haji
Pandu, presiding at the trial, also displayed an apparent conflict of interest, admitting that 15 of the defendants were his personal friends and former classmates. The trial produced 35 convictions, and 23 defendants were acquitted
of all charges. Babu, named as the plots mastermind, was sentenced to death
with the other 34 convicted prisoners, but all of the death sentences were later
commuted to various prison terms. Babu and 12 others served the longest sentences, released in 1978 under an amnesty declared by President Julius Nyerere.
Karumes death proved disastrous for the Umma Party that hoped to replace
him. With most of its leaders in prison, the party soon dissolved, leaving the
ASP stronger than ever. Karumes son, Amani Abeid Karume, served as principal secretary in the ministry of finance (19711974), principal secretary in
the ministry of planning (19741978), and principal secretary in the ministry
of communications and transport (19781980), and finally spent a decade as
president, from November 2000 to November 2010.
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
Further Reading
Burgess, G. Thomas. Race, Revolution, and the Struggle for Human Rights in Zanzibar.
Athens: Ohio University Press, 2009.
Petterson, Donald. Revolution in Zanzibar: An Americans Cold War Tale. Boulder, CO:
Westview Press, 2004.
257
258
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
Navy during World War II, in the Pacific theater. Elected to the House of Representatives in 1946, he served six years there, and seven in the Senate, before
emerging from a close and highly controversial White House race in 1960, as
the countrys youngest elected president. He also generated more public controversy than any president since Franklin Roosevelt, based in equal parts on
his religion (Roman Catholic), his civil rights initiatives for African Americans,
a failed invasion of Cuba in April 1961, a subsequent standoff with Russia over
missiles planted on that island, and his aggressive war against organized crime.
By 1963, as he began campaigning for a second term, there was no shortage of
potential enemies who wished him dead.
Murder of a U.S. president was still a state offense, equivalent to any other
murder, in November 1963. Dallas police emerged as seeming bunglers for
their handling of the case, from misidentification of the alleged murder rifle
detectives first described it as a 7.25-mm German Mauser; it was, in fact, a
6.5-mm Italian Mannlicher-Carcanothrough sensational press conferences,
to having their prime suspect gunned down live on national TV. Some other
agency would have to build a case, although if Oswald was a lone assassin,
there would be no trial.
There were problems, as well, with local handling of the presidents body
and analysis of his wounds. Physicians at Parkland hospital recorded three
wounds: one in front of Kennedys throat, described as an entrance wound; another in his back, five to six inches below the neck, with no projectile found
and no exit point; and a massive, obviously fatal wound at the right rear of
Kennedys skull. Texas law required that autopsies of murder victims be performed within the state, unless the crime occurred on federal property, yet Dallas Countys district attorney and medical examiner agreed to removal of the
corpse, at the demand of JFKs widow and President Lyndon Johnson. Kennedys autopsy was performed at Marylands Bethesda Naval Hospital (now Walter Reed National Military Medical Center), by Dr. George Burkley, then a rear
admiral in the U.S. Navy Medical Corps. He concluded that two shots struck
Kennedy, both from the rear, with neither projectile recovered.
Meanwhile, a single nearly pristine rifle bullet had been found at Parkland
Hospital, in Dallas, lying on a stretcher in the area where JFK and Governor
Connally were delivered for emergency treatment. No one could determine
which stretcher, but it was initially assumed that the slugtoday known as
Warren Commission Exhibit (CE) 399must have come from Kennedys
body, falling out of his shallow back wound, perhaps during cardiac massage.
That view changed radically in months to come, as we shall see.
J. Edgar Hoovers Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) seemed to jump the
gun with its pronouncement of a single shooter in the Kennedy assassination.
At 3:01 P.M. on November 22, eight hours and 25 minutes before Lee Oswald
was accused of killing Kennedy, Hoover wrote a memo to his assistant directors,
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
saying, I called the attorney general at his home and told him I thought we
had the man who killed the president down in Dallas, at the present time.
On November 24, shortly after Oswalds death, another Hoover memo stated:
The thing I am most concerned about, and so is Mr. [Deputy Attorney General Nicholas] Katzenbach, is having something issued so that we can convince
the public that Oswald is the real assassin. On November 26, Hoover wrote to
Assistant FBI Director Alan Belmont, Just how long do you estimate [completion of a final report] will take? It seems to me we have all the basic facts now.
President Johnsons blue-ribbon investigative commission, chaired by
Chief Justice Earl Warren, included Allen Dulles, former director of the Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA); John McCloy, former president of the World Bank;
Kentucky senator John Cooper; Georgia senator Richard Russell Jr.; House Majority Leader Hale Boggs; and House Minority Leader Gerald Ford. Evidence
appended to the commissions final report included testimony or depositions
of 552 witnesses, plus more than 3,100 exhibits. Even so, critics found much
challenge in the panels two-lone-gunmen verdict, complaining that testimony
from inconvenient witnesses was censored or ignored, that photographic evidence was altered prior to publication, and that unpublished portions of those
records were initially sealed for 75 years (to 2039) by order of President Johnson (later changed to 2017 under the JFK Records Act of 1992).
Examples of discrepancies in the commissions findings include a false denial of Jack Rubys longstanding ties to organized crime in Chicago, Dallas, and
elsewhere; omission of testimony from 51 witnesses who reported shots fired
at JFKs motorcade from a grassy knoll in front of the presidents car, rather
than the book warehouse behind the limousine, where Oswald was employed;
preoccupation with irrelevant trivia, filling pages with biographical data on
Oswald, Ruby, and their parents, wholly unrelated to JFKs murder; a complete
failure to investigate Kennedys outspoken enemies in the Mafia, right-wing extremist circles, and the Cuban exile committee; publication of selected frames
from a home movie of the shooting, filmed by witness Abraham Zapruder,
with the frames rearranged to show Kennedys head snapping forward, rather
than backward, on impact from the fatal head shot; and a magic-bullet theory advanced to explain how one virtually undamaged projectile could produce most of the wounds suffered by JFK and Governor Connally. Commission
member Allen Dulles, whose own CIA was suspected by some of plotting the
presidents death, encouraged suspicion of a cover-up in a comment concerning the Warren Commissions voluminous records, quoted in declassified minutes of a closed hearing. Nobody reads, he said. Dont believe people read in
this country. There will be a few professors that will read the record. The public will read very little.
As it happens, he was wrong. From 1965 until the present day, a nonstop
stream of books and articles dissecting Kennedys assassination have dissected
259
260
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
the commissions findings, evidence, and items it ignored, hypothesizing various conspiracies. A smaller, but no less ardent body of literature defends the
commissions work and final judgment. Confusion over the original forensic
evidenceincluding reports of an entry wound in Kennedys throat, the fact
that FBI marksmen could not hit any target with Oswalds cheap Italian rifle
until they braced its telescopic sight with special shims, and the disappearance of JFKs preserved brain from the National Archivesonly increased the
clamor for full disclosure.
The Warren Commissions most controversial finding was its claim that a
single shot inflicted one of Kennedys wounds and all of those suffered by Governor Connally, a claim quickly derided by critics as the magic-bullet theory.
Ignoring medical reports of a shallow back wound with no exit path, the panel
decided that the Dallas stretcher bullet, CE 399, struck Kennedy in the back
of his neck and passed out the front (where an entry wound was reported at
Parkland Hospital), then angled downward to penetrate Connallys back, shatter a rib and exit from his torso, smash bones in his wrist, then bury itself in
his thigh, afterward dropping onto the hospital stretcher. Aside from its proposed erratic flight pattern, CE 399 itself challenged the single-bullet theory. It
was found to weigh 158.6 grains (10.28 grams), whereas new, unfired 6.5-mm
bullets leave the factory assembly line weighing 159.8 to 161.5 grains, with an
average weight of 160.844 grains. Fragments found in Connallys wrist alone
weighed 2 grains. Additionally, CE 399 was barely marked by firing, undeformed by smashing ribs and other bones, bearing no characteristic markings
of passage through fabric, human flesh, or blood. Still, the single-bullet theory
was essential to discrediting reports of a second gunman, firing from in front
of JFKs motorcade.
In February 1968, at request of the Attorney General Ramsey Clark, four
physicians met in Washington, D.C., to review the original JFK autopsy records, photos, and X-rays, as well as clothing, films, motion pictures, and
bullet fragments. Their confirmation of the Warren Commissions findings
that Kennedy was struck by only two shots, both fired from behind him
predictably failed to mollify critics of the commissions 1964 report. Indeed,
the panels finding of metallic fragments along the higher bullet trail through
JFKs neck, seemed to further weaken the Warren Commissions magic-bullet
scenario.
Original commission member Gerald Ford, now president, tried once more
to still that criticism in 1975, with creation of the presidents commission on CIA
activities within the United States. Launched in response to CIA assassinations
abroad, and mind-control experiments at home, the new panelchaired by
Vice President Nelson Rockefellersought to disprove claims that JFK had been
murdered by CIA agents or rogue agency associates. Once again, the 1963 autopsy was reviewed, in addition to films of the assassination taken by witnesses
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
at Dealey Plaza. And once again, the panel confirmed Warren Commission findings, reporting that there was no evidence to support the claim that President
Kennedy was struck by a bullet fired from either the grassy knoll or any other
position to his front, right front or right side. . . . No witness who urged the
view that the Zapruder film and other motion picture films proved that President Kennedy was struck by a bullet fired from his right front was shown to
possess any professional or other special qualifications on the subject.
Again, predictably, critics were unconvinced.
A year later, spurred by unending controversy, Congress created the House
Select Committee on Assassinations, to reopen investigation of Kennedys death
and the slaying of Dr. Martin Luther King. Three years later, based chiefly on
acoustical evidence, the panel found a high probability that at least two gunmen fired at President John F. Kennedy, but that the grassy knoll shooter
had missed, leaving Oswald in effect the lone assassin. The Committee failed
to identify the second gunman or any potential conspirators, reporting that
the Mafia and Cuban exile organizations were not involved as groups, but
that the available evidence does not preclude the possibility that individual
members may have been involved in the conspiracy. That verdict, in turn,
produced mocking outcries from supporters of the Warren Commission, and a
new round of conspiracy literature.
Leading suspects in potential JFK assassination plots include:
The CIA, or some rogue element within it. Threatened with dismantling
by JFK after the Bay of Pigs fiasco in April 1961, pledged to continuance
of covert wars in Cuba, Central America, and Southeast Asia, the agency
had its own man on the Warren Commission, ideally placed to suppress
evidence. Several authors spin persuasive circumstantial webs linking
Oswald to the CIA, and Jack Ruby was a known participant in agencysponsored offensives against Fidel Castro.
The FBI, a long-shot contender for assassination per se, but clearly guilty
of suppressing evidence concerning its contacts with Oswald and Ruby
prior to November 1963. Agent James Hosty in Dallas admittedly destroyed notes of his pre-assassination interviews with Oswald, as well
as a note delivered to his office by Oswald shortly before JFKs murder.
J. Edgar Hoover personally despised both Kennedy brothers for their personal behavior, their liberal politics, and their insistence that the FBI belatedly engage in prosecution of high-ranking mobsters (some of whom
were the directors personal friends). It was also widely rumored that JFK
would celebrate his reelection by replacing Hoover with a younger successor, more amenable to the administrations goals.
Right-wing extremists, including violent segregationists such as the Ku Klux
Klan (KKK), White Citizens Council, and similar groups, bankrolled by
261
262
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
K E N N E D Y, J O H N F I T Z G E R A L D
regime as muscle in Southern states. Prime suspects in the JFK assassination are New Orleans mafioso Carlos Marcello and colleague Santo Trafficante, from Tampa, Florida. Jack Ruby worked for Marcello in Dallas,
and had visited Trafficante in Cuba, during 1959. Both mobsters denied
involvement in the crime when questioned by the House Select Committee on Assassinationsbut both allegedly admitted their key roles in the
murder to underworld associates, before their deaths in the 1980s.
It remains to be seen whether the final release of Warren Commission files
in 2017 will resolve the nagging questions that surround President Kennedys
death. One thing seems fairly certain: controversies will continue.
INFAMOUS WEAPONS
Famous weapons are prized by collectors. Dallas police returned Jack Rubys revolver to his family, sparking a 28-year legal contest that climaxed
with a court order awarding custody to brother Earl Ruby. He sold it for
$220,000, but police in Washington, D.C., seized the gun when its buyer
offered to show it to Speaker of the House Thomas Foley. He regained it
through litigation in November 1993. He subsequently had Earl Ruby
fire 100 shots from the .38 and offered to sell the spent casings for $2,500
apiece.
Police also returned Lee Oswalds rifle to his widow. It was later purchased by the National Archives, along with the revolver that allegedly
killed Dallas Patrolman J. D. Tippit on November 22, 1963.
The derringer used to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln may be
viewed in the basement museum of Fords Theatre, in Washington, D.C.
The bullet removed from Lincolns head during his autopsy was kept by
the U.S. War Department until 1940, then passed to the Department
of the Interior. Today, it resides at the National Museum of Health and
Medicine in Washington, D.C.
The pistol used to kill Archduke Franz Ferdinand in 1914 was presented to the priest who administered last rites to the archduke and his
wife. It vanished when he died in 1926, then reappeared in 2004, whereupon it was donated to the Vienna Museum of Military History.
The rifle allegedly used to kill Dr. Martin Luther King in April 1968
remains in storage at the Shelby County Court, in Memphis, Tennessee.
Jerry Ray, brother of convicted assassin James Earl Ray, brought multiple
lawsuits to reclaim the weapon, but all were dismissed on grounds that
the rifle was voluntarily abandoned near the murder scene.
263
264
K E N N E D Y, R O B E R T F R A N C I S
Further Reading
Adams, Don. From an Office Building with a High-Powered Rifle: One FBI Agents View of
the JFK Assassination. Walterville, OR: Trine Day, 2012.
Anson, Robert. Theyve Killed the President!: The Search for the Murderers of John F. Kennedy. New York: Bantam Books, 1976.
Benson, Michael. Whos Who in the JFK Assassination: An A to Z Encyclopedia. New York:
Citadel Press, 2003.
JFK Assassination Records. National Archives. http://www.archives.gov/research/jfk.
Meagher, Sylvia. Accessories after the Fact. New York: Vintage Books, 1992.
Posner, Gerald. Case Closed. New York: Random House, 1993.
Report of the Select Committee on Assassinations of the U.S. House of Representatives.
National Archives. http://www.archives.gov/research/jfk/select-committee-report.
Waldron, Lamar. Legacy of Secrecy: The Long Shadow of the JFK Assassination. Berkeley,
CA: Counterpoint Press, 2008.
K E N N E D Y, R O B E R T F R A N C I S
Bobby as U.S. attorney general, with a mandate to hunt mob bosses nationwide. Following brother Johns assassination, longtime rival Lyndon Johnson
demoted Bobby, then fired him from the Justice Department, whereupon RFK
pursued and won a U.S. Senate seat from New York state in November 1964.
By March 1968, when Johnson declined to seek a second term, Bobby was a
leading voice against the war in Vietnam, and a front-runner for the looming
presidential race.
The second Kennedy assassination within five years appeared to be an
open-and-shut case. Sirhan had been literally caught red-handed, with the
smoking pistol in his fist, surrounded by eyewitnesses and television cameras.
Investigators found his diary, filled with wild, semi-coherent rants denouncing Kennedy over the candidates remarks supporting IsraelSirhan was a
Jordanian expatriateand endlessly repeating RFK Must Die! His attorneys
broached the topic of a guilty plea in February 1969, hoping for life imprisonment, but Sirhan then dismissed the lawyers, telling Judge Herbert Walker,
I will ask to be executed. At trial, a month later, Sirhan admitted shooting
Kennedy with 20 years of malice aforethought. Jurors took his word for it,
convicting him and recommending death.
And yet, there were significant discrepancies in what appeared, at first, to be
a flawless case.
To start, the pistol seized from Sirhan held eight cartridges, but witnesses
reported hearing 13 shots or more. Although that could easily be written off to
panic of the moment, there remained the awkward count of bullets logged by
FBI agents, the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD), and Associated Press
(AP) photographers. Eight bullets struck the shootings victimsthree for Kennedy alonebut annotated crime scene photographs and notes clearly identify
at least five other bullet holes in door frames and ceiling panels. The frames
and panels were quickly removed and destroyed, allowing prosecutors to claim
that the bullets observed by detectives were nail heads, but contemporary
notes and statements contradict those claims. One AP photo showed two uniformed patrolmen pointing at a bullet hole, circled by a pencil mark, in the
door frame; the officers also told prosecutor Vincent Bugliosi that they saw a
bullet in the hole. FBI agent William Bailey saw another bullet in the double
doors central divider. Hotel waiter Martin Patrusky described watching policemen dig a bullet out of that divider, and carpenters who later removed the
door frame reported similar finds.
Another problem arose from Kennedys wounds. Los Angeles County coroner Thomas Noguchi reported that all of the shots that struck Kennedy came
from behind him, with the fatal head shot behind his right ear fired no farther
than one inch away from his skull. Meanwhile, unanimous eyewitness testimony and the TV tapes confirm that Sirhan stood in front of Kennedy, never
getting closer than three to four feet from his target. Even if Kennedy turned
265
266
K E N N E D Y, R O B E R T F R A N C I S
from the first shots, as prosecutors suggested, Sirhans gun was never close
enough to scorch his skin with powder burns at anything approaching skintouch range.
A third problem involved the murder weapon itself. On June 11, 1968,
LAPD criminalist Dewayne Wolfer test-fired Sirhans supposed revolver and reported a ballistic match to the bullets removed from Kennedys body. Wolfer recorded the weapons serial number as H18602but in fact, the serial number
of Sirhans revolver was H53725. Questioned about the strange discrepancy
later, Wolfer called it a simple clerical error. By then, however, both revolvers had been melted down for scrap metal, so Wolfers test results could never
be confirmed.
In 1973, world-renowned criminologist Dr. Herbert Leon MacDonell examined bullets from the Kennedy crime scene, reporting in a sworn affidavit that
the slug from Kennedys neck (Exhibit #47) could not have been fired from
the same gun as Exhibit #54, removed from kitchen survivor William Weisel.
The following year, at a public hearing, Dr. Lowell Bradford, state criminologist for the California Division of Criminal Investigation, agreed with MacDonells findings. In 1975, a court-appointed panel of seven ballistics experts
convened to review the evidence, and although newspapers ran their decision
under headlines reading RFK Second Gun Theory Ruled Out, the panels report actually said that the question of a second shooter was more open than
before. Subsequently, researcher Rose Lynn Mangan discovered that Exhibit
#47, which should have had the coded designation TN31 etched in its base,
actually bore the etching DWTN. From that, she speculated that at least one
crime scene bullet had been switched with a slug from some other shooting,
accidentally or by design.
Another suggestion of evidence suppressed involves reports of a young
woman clad in a polka-dot dress, allegedly seen running from the Ambassadors kitchen area on June 5, saying, We shot him! We shot him! Witness
Sandra Serrano stopped the woman and asked what she meant, to which the
still-unidentified female replied, We shot Senator Kennedy! Several other
witnesses reported seeing the same person, including an elderly couple who
met her in a parking lot behind the hotel and reported her suspicious behavior
to LAPD officer Paul Sheraga. He, in turn, issued an all-points bulletin (APB)
for the young woman, described as well-built, with dirty blond hair and a
crooked or funny nose, wearing a white dress with blue or black polka-dots.
Stranger still, reports later surfaced of the same woman, or her virtual twin, loitering around the Ambassador days before the assassination, with a man who
resembled Sirhan.
Despite Sheragas APB on the mystery woman, investigators quickly abandoned their search for her and devoted unusual energy toward persuading
eyewitnesses that she did not exist. Sandy Serrano bore the brunt of what she
K E N N E D Y, R O B E R T F R A N C I S
267
268
K E N N E D Y, R O B E R T F R A N C I S
(Y13332), but was never test fired for comparison with the crime-scene bullets. Cesars odd, seemingly pointless lie fueled conspiracy theories, although
journalist Dan Moldeaan outspoken proponent of a Mafia conspiracy behind the JFK assassinationclaimed in 1995 that Cesar took a polygraph test
years after the fact and passed with flying colors. (Those tests are inadmissible in most U.S. courts, based on uncertain reliability.)
Controversy over details of the second Kennedy assassination continues to
the present day. In 2004, an audio recording of gunfire from the hotel kitchen,
taped by Polish freelance journalist Stanislaw Pruszynski, surfaced and was
analyzed by a team under audio technician Philip Van Praag, who reported
sounds of 13 shots fired in the space of five seconds. Although skeptics dismissed those findings, concurring views were logged by forensic audio specialists Wes Dooley and Paul Pegas of Audio Engineering Associates in Pasadena,
California, forensic audio and ballistics expert Eddy B. Brixen in Copenhagen, Denmark, and audio specialist Phil Spencer Whitehead of the Georgia
Institute of Technology in Atlanta, Georgia. In 2008, assassination eyewitness
John Pilger reiterated his longstanding belief in a second kitchen gunman. Another witness to the slaying, Nina Rhodes-Hughes, told CNN in April 2012
that FBI agents had twisted her original statement, reporting the sound of
eight shots. I never said eight shots. I never, never said it, Rhodes-Hughes
insisted. There were more than eight shots. There were at least 12, maybe 14.
And I know there were because I heard the rhythm in my head.
Potential motives for a plot behind the RFK assassination mirror those suggested in his brothers case, with the added incentive of forestalling any reinvestigation of the Dallas murder. Intimates of RFK contend that he had promised,
if elected, to use his authority as president pursuing answers to the nagging
questions still unanswered from November 1963. Whoever set the stage in
Dallas, it is argued, had the most to fear from another Kennedy presidency. So,
too, would major mobsters, still recovering from persecution (as they saw it)
suffered in the years when Bobby Kennedy was the attorney general.
Aside from CIA involvement in the Los Angeles murder investigation, BBC
reporter Shane OSullivan produced a near-confession of sorts in November
2006. On the networks Newsnight program, he identified three men photographed at the Ambassador Hotel on June 5, 1968, as agents of the CIAs JMWAVE operation in Miami, Florida, headquarters of covert action against
Cuban leader Fidel Castro. OSullivan identified them as Chief of Operations
David Morales, Chief of Maritime Operations Gordon Campbell, and Chief of
Psychological Warfare Operations George Joannides. The program also aired
an interview with Robert Walton, attorney for the late David Morales, who
quoted his client as saying, I was in Dallas when we got the son of a bitch
[JFK] and I was in Los Angeles when we got the little bastard.
Some students of the RFK assassination suggest that Sirhan may have been
used by the CIA as a brainwashed or hypnotized Manchurian candidate
K H O Y S K I I S G E N D E R O G L U , FATA L I K H A N
gunman. As evidence, they cite Sirhans consistent claims that he has no memory of the assassination or its immediate aftermath, bolstered with odd writings from his diary that include disjointed phrases like pay to the order of,
interspersed with ravings that Robert F. Kennedy must be assassinated before
5 June 68 and my determination to eliminate RFK is becoming more the [sic]
more of an unshakable obsession. A psychologist and hypnotist, Dr. Eduard
Simson-Kallas, spent 35 hours studying Sirhan in prison, during 1969, and
came away convinced that the convicts amnesia was legitimate.
Evidence also suggests at least a coincidental link between Sirhan and elements of organized crime. Prior to Kennedys murder, Sirhan worked for a time
at a race track owned by a mob associate, and one of his defense attorneys at
trial, the late Grant B. Cooper, also represented mafioso John Rosselli in a 1968
card-cheating scandal at the Los Angeles Friars Club. In that case, Cooper was
found in possession of stolen grand jury reports and fined $1,000. After his
conviction and death sentence, Sirhan complained that Cooper was crooked;
he had Mafia and CIA connections. More specifically, Sirhan alleged, Cooper
was picked to make sure I was convicted and sent to my death, and Cooper
complied because they were planning to kill him.
Kennedys death in 1968, for all intents and purposes, ensured victory for
presidential hopeful Richard Nixonbankrolled, as we know today, by illegal
campaign donations from the Teamsters Union, organized crime, and reclusive
billionaire casino magnate Howard Hughes. All that followed after, from escalation in Southeast Asia to the Watergate scandal and Nixons near-impeachment,
may arguably be seen as results of the kitchen ambush in Los Angeles.
Further Reading
Kaiser, Robert. R.F.K. Must Die!: Chasing the Mystery of the Robert Kennedy Assassination. New York: Overlook Press, 2008.
Melanson, Philip. The Robert F. Kennedy Assassination: New Revelations on the Conspiracy
and Cover-Up, 19681991. New York: S.P.I. Books, 1994.
Moldea, Dan. The Killing of Robert F. Kennedy: An Investigation of Motive, Means, and Opportunity. New York: W. W. Norton, 1995.
OSullivan, Shane. Who Killed Bobby?: The Unsolved Murder of Robert F. Kennedy. New
York: Union Square Press, 2008.
Turner, William, and John Christian. The Assassination of Robert F. Kennedy: The Conspiracy and Coverup. New York: Basic Books, 2006.
269
270
K H OYS K I I S G E N D E R O G L U, FATA L I K H A N
target was Fatali Khan Khoyski, then foreign affairs minister of the Azerbaijan
Democratic Republic and a key organizer of Armenian massacres at Baku that
claimed at least 10,000 lives (some accounts claim 30,000) in September 1918.
ARF leaders tried Khoyski for mass murder in absentia, convicted him, and sentenced him to death. On June 19, 1920, hand-picked gunman Aram Yerganian
shot and killed Khoyski on a street in Tiflis (now Tbilisi), then surrendered
to police for trial and execution. As ARF leader Shahan Natalie explained his
chosen tactic: You blow up the skull of the Number One nation-murderer and
you dont try to flee. You stand there, your foot on the corpse and surrender to
the police, who will come and handcuff you.
Fatali Khan Khoyski was born in Shaki, Azerbaijan, on December 7, 1875,
the son of a colonel in the Russian army, a descendant of the Donboli tribe that
ruled Khoy in the 18th century. His great-grandfather, Jafargulu Khan, allied
himself with Russia in the Russo-Persian War of 18041813, ending the conflict as a lieutenant colonel and head of the Shaki Khanate, installed by Tsar
Alexander I. Khoyski studied law at Moscow University, graduating at age 26,
serving as a court attorney and prosecutor in various jurisdictions. In 1906,
he was elected to the Second Duma of the Russian Empire from Elisabethpol,
using his office to oppose Russian colonization of Azerbaijan.
Russias February Revolution of 1917 upset the balance of empire. A month
later, Khoyski joined the newly formed Temporary Executive Committee of
Muslim National Councils, and argued for Azerbaijanian independence at the
first Msavat (Equality) Party convention in October. In December 1917, he
was elected to a new Transcaucasian Commissariat, and with creation of the
Transcaucasian Democratic Federative Republic in February 1918, Khoyski
became its minister of justice. That republic was short-lived, dissolving at the
end of May 1918, whereupon the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic was established as the worlds first Muslim republic, with Khoyski serving as prime minister. He held that post until April 14, 1919, simultaneously serving as minister
of internal affairs (May 28June 18, 1918), minister of defense (November 18
December 25, 1918), and minister of foreign affairs (December 26, 1918
March 14, 1919).
The Baku massacre, for which he was condemned and subsequently
killed, was carried out on Khoyskis orders, in retaliation for a massacre of
Azerbaijanis and other Muslims, perpetrated at Baku by Bolshevik troops
between March 30 and April 2, 1918. Estimates of the civilian death toll in
that slaughter range from 12,000 to 30,000. Following Khoyskis assassination, Operation Nemesis went on to claim prominent victims in Berlin, Constantinople (now Istanbul), Rome, and Russia. Soviet occupation doomed
the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic in 1920, transforming it into the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic until 1991, with the collapse of Russian
communism.
Further Reading
Derogy, Jacques. Resistance & Revenge. Edison, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 1990.
Isgenderli, Anar. Realities of Azerbaijan: 19171920. Bloomington, IN: Xlibris, 2011.
271
272
K I N G, M A R T I N L U T H E R , J R .
During the Montgomery boycott, King and close associates founded a new
civil rights group, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC),
pledged to eliminate racial discrimination through nonviolent civil disobedience, in the style of Mohandas Gandhi. He subsequently led campaigns in
Albany, Georgia (1962); Birmingham, Alabama (1963); St. Augustine, Florida (1964); Selma, Alabama (1965); and Chicago, Illinois (1966), where he
protested de facto residential segregation and was struck with a brick during
one protest march. At every turn, he was stalked by racists from the KKK and
other groups that pledged to murder him, his close associates, and members
of his family. Specific attacks included two bombings in Birmingham on May
12, 1963, targeting Kings motel room and the home of his brother, Rev. A. D.
King; and a St. Augustine raid that left Kings rented beach cottage riddled with
bullets on May 29, 1964.
In June 1966, when King joined a March against Fear through Mississippi,
militant Klansmen hatched several plots to kill him with bombs or long-range
rifles. None worked out, but one Ku Klux factionthe self-styled Cottonmouth Moccasin Gangkidnapped elderly sharecropper Ben Chester White
on June 10, murdering him outside Natchez in the hope that Dr. King would
come to lead a memorial service, thereby presenting himself as a target. Once
again, their plans fell through.
On April 4, 1967, King delivered the first of several televised speeches denouncing U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War, calling U.S. government the
greatest purveyor of violence in the world today. That stance alienated many
self-styled liberalsincluding President Lyndon Johnsonwho were happy to
support black civil rights, as long as African Americans abstained from meddling in foreign policy. King also cited U.S. poverty as a critical issue, regardless of race, and planned a massive Poor Peoples March on Washington, D.C.,
for April 1968. Two months before that campaigns scheduled launch, black
sanitation workers in Memphis struck against discrimination in their salaries
and unsafe work conditions. Dr. King arrived to lead a protest demonstration
on March 28, but it degenerated into violence and left King disconsolate, refusing to proceed with the march on Washington unless he first could lead a
peaceful demonstration in Memphis.
King returned to the River City on April 3, in the face of numerous death
threats, and that night delivered his final speech to a capacity crowd at the
Mason Temple. Weve got some difficult days ahead, he declared. But it
doesnt really matter with me now. Because Ive been to the mountaintop.
I dont mind. Like anybody, I would like to live a long life; longevity has its
place. But Im not concerned about that now. I just want to do Gods will. And
Hes allowed me to go up to the mountain. And Ive looked over. And Ive seen
the Promised Land. I may not get there with you. But I want you to know tonight, that we, as a people, will get to the Promised Land. So Im happy, tonight.
Im not worried about anything. Im not fearing any man. Mine eyes have seen
the glory of the coming of the Lord. With his murder the following day, some
observers hailed his last speech as prophetic.
Following Kings murder, African Americans rioted in 125 cities nationwide,
leaving 46 persons dead, 2,600 injured, and 21,270 jailed on various charges.
Published estimates of property damage ranged from $45 million ($296 million today) to $67 million (now $441 million). Kings death also persuaded
many African Americans to abandon nonviolent protestthe Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee promptly shortened its namewhile affiliating
with more militant groups, such as the Black Panther Party for Self Defense.
Indications of conspiracy in Kings assassination were apparent from the moment when the fatal shot was fired. Witnesses at the Lorraine Motel reported
a masked figure fleeing on foot from shrubbery across the street, and prosecutors later claimed the shot came from a bathroom in a nearby rooming house
(whose windows, critics noted, offered a poor view at best of the snipers target).
On Beale Street, where the killer conveniently dropped a rifle (never positively
matched to the fatal bullet) and other evidence incriminating James Earl Ray,
observers described a white Ford Mustang as the probable getaway car. During the manhunt that ensued, a CB (Citizens' Band) radio broadcast diverted
police to the wrong side of town, reporting a nonexistent car chase with shots
fired from a mythical second white Mustang (later dismissed as a prank by an
unidentified teenager). When Ray was finally identified from fingerprints and
traced to an Atlanta rooming house, FBI agents found the abandoned Mustangs
ashtray filled to overflowingbut Ray had never smoked a day in his life.
The FBI, in fact, was part of the problem. Director J. Edgar Hoover had despised King since the ministers emergence as a civil rights leader in 19551956,
and had conducted countless illegal harassment campaigns against King, his
colleagues, and the SCLC. Aside from bugging offices and bedrooms, furnishing prurient tapes of Kings extramarital affairs to President Lyndon Johnson and
Southern congressmen who held the FBIs budgetary strings, Hoover publicly
denounced King as the most notorious liar in the United States and regaled
anyone who would listenfrom the White House to the tabloid presswith
tales of Kings alleged communist ties. On one occasion in 1964, Hoover approved mailing of one bedroom recording to Kings home, with an anonymous
letter suggesting that King should commit suicide to avoid public disgrace. In
1967, Hoover launched a secret and illegal COINTELPRO operation (short for
Counter Intelligence Program) that labeled the SPLC a black nationalist hate
group and stated its goal in simple terms: Prevent the RISE OF A BLACK
MESSIAH who could unify, and electrify, the black nationalist movement. No
one who knew Hoover doubted that Dr. King was his primary target.
With that background, it is no surprise that some observers criticized the
FBIs performance in pursuit of Kings assassin. First, the bureaus legendary
273
274
K I N G, M A R T I N L U T H E R , J R .
proven). Rays lone-gunman motive for killing King? A combination of personal racism (possible, but wholly absent from his long record of mercenary offenses), and pursuit of a hypotheticalpossibly mythicalbounty on King,
floated in prison rumors while Ray was incarcerated. How he planned to collect the payoff, if he lived and escaped, is anyones guess.
The House Select Committee on Assassinations (HSCA) tried to solve that
riddle in 1979, after concluding that although Ray shot King himself (a fact
that he denied), there is a likelihood that it was the result of a conspiracy.
The plotters, according to Congress, were Ray and his two brothers (neither
ever charged), the trio hoping to collect an open $30,000 contract ($206,000
today) on Kings life, offered to all comers by wealthy bigots John Kauffmann
and John Sutherland (both deceased when the committee accused them). The
HSCA speculated on possible contacts between Rays brothers and the wouldbe murder financers, but produced no evidence.
At least three alternate conspiracy theories exist. The suspects include:
(1) The Ku Klux Klan or an affiliated racist group. Klansmen undeniably
stalked King from 1956 to 1968, making several unsuccessful attempts
on his life. When James Earl Ray was arrested in London, he initially
retained defense lawyer Arthur Hanes Sr.a former FBI agent, segregationist ex-mayor of Birmingham, and (according to FBI informant Gary
Thomas Rowe) a dues-paying member of the KKK. Although Hanes denied Klan membership, his best-known clients prior to Ray included
Klansmen charged with murder in Alabama and North Carolina. The
HSCA heard testimony indicating that Klan headquarters paid Hanes
to represent Ray in 1968; Hanes and various KKK leaders denied it,
claiming his fee only covered representation of the North Carolina defendants. Later, while appealing his conviction, Ray was represented by
longtime Klansman J. B. Stoner, head of the neo-Nazi National States
Rights Party (NSRP). NSRP member Joseph Milteer described several
plots to kill King in 1963, at the same time that he predicted the murder
of President John F. Kennedy ( JFK).
(2) Unnamed racist politicians. Alabama author William Bradford Huie
joined to Rays defense team in 1968, and wrote a three-part series
for Look magazine about Ray. The first two installments claimed that
Huie had knowledge of a plot to kill King during that presidential election year, to spark ghetto riots (which it did) and thus elect a conservative successor to President Lyndon Johnson (which occurred, with
the victory of Richard Nixon). Strangely, in the third installment of the
seriesand a later book, He Slew the Dreamer (1970)Huie contradicted himself, contending that Ray either killed King himself, or as part
of an insignificant little conspiracy, involving only little men who
275
276
K I N G, M A R T I N L U T H E R , J R .
were, presumably, not worth pursuing. Explaining the strange turnaround, Huie claimed that his contract with Ray required him (Huie) to
publish only Rays version of events prior to adjudication of the case.
Publication of the full contract by journalist Harold Weisberg, in 1971,
disproved that contention. The contract contained no such stipulation.
(3) Organized crime. In early 1968, soon after joining the Memphis garbage strike, King reportedly called comedianactivist Dick Gregory with
questions about the Mafia. Gregory briefed him on underworld ghetto
rackets, and the Mobs extensive interests in trucking and waste-haulage
trades. Carlos Marcello, a prime suspect in the JFK assassination, was a
die-hard racist and supporter of the KKK, who used Klansmen as muscle to avoid self-incrimination. His empire encompassed Memphis
where witness John McFerren allegedly heard a Marcello associate on
April 4, 1968, giving some unknown phone caller instructions to shoot
the son of a bitch on the balcony. Unknown gunmen later fired on McFerrens home, and although the HSCA confirmed association between
Marcello and the man McFerren overhead, the committee ultimately
found McFerrens testimony meaningless.
Although actual courts consistently denied Rays appeals, a three-hour mock
trial was televised by HBO on April 4, 1993. That broadcast condensed 54
hours of testimony heard in January, in a Memphis courtroom, with a friend of
Dr. KingNew York attorney William Francis Pepperrepresenting Ray (who
attended the trial via satellite, from prison). The mock trials mock jury, perhaps predictably, acquitted Ray, which had no impact whatsoever on his reallife legal situation. Pepper subsequently wrote a book, Orders to Kill (1995),
which claimed to identify the elusive Raoul and labeled Kings murder a government contract killing.
Aside from Raoul, two identified suspects other than James Earl Ray have
been publicly named as alleged conspirators in Dr. Kings death. One, Loyd
Jowers, owned the Memphis Beale Street diner where the supposed murder
weapon and other items bearing Rays fingerprints were discarded on April 4,
1968. A quarter-century later, in December 1993, Jowers appeared on ABCs
Primetime news program, relating details of a supposed Mafiagovernment plot
to kill King, using Ray as a scapegoat. According to Jowers, King was actually
shot by a now-deceased Memphis policeman, Lieutenant Earl Clark. Kings
family filed a civil wrongful-death lawsuit in 1998, naming Jowers and other
unknown coconspirators as responsible for Kings murder. Jurors found Jowers alone responsible, on December 9, 1999, commenting that the plot also
included unspecified governmental agencies. (The King family claimed vindication, but received no financial award from the court.) A parallel investigation by the U.S. Justice Department, launched in August 1998, reported in
KU KLUX KLAN
2000 that conflicting statements and other odd behavior from Jowers made
it impossible to work with him. Jowers died from a heart attack on May 20,
2000, at age 73.
Later still, on April 5, 2002, a minister in Graham, Florida, named his late
father as the triggerman in Dr. Kings slaying. At a press conference convened
to clear his conscience, Rev. Ronald Denton Wilson, named his father, KKK
member Henry Clay Wilson, as the assassinor, at least, one of them. My father was the main guy, Wilson said. It wasnt a racist thing; he thought Martin
Luther King was connected with communism, and he wanted to get him out of
the way. He kept saying it was the patriotic thing to do. He said he had to save
the country. Three other Klansmen were involved, he said, while declining to
offer their names. Dead from emphysema since 1990, Henry Wilson was beyond interrogation, but FBI agent Ron Grenier interviewed the son, telling reporters that he took the statement seriously, but the issue had not risen to the
level of a full investigation. Rev. Wilson went on to say, My dad told me James
Earl Ray had nothing to do with the shooting other than to buy a rifle for them.
My dad was the one who shot Dr. King. He seemed about to disclose the rifles
whereabouts, when his sonalso a ministerinterrupted to read a statement
expressing sympathy for Kings family, adding that his own would make no further statements. Thus far, no evidence of any kind has been forthcoming.
Further Reading
Melanson, Philip, and Noah Griffin. The Martin Luther King Assassination: New Revelations on the Conspiracy and Cover-Up, 19681991. New York: Shapolsky Publishers,
1994.
Newton, Michael. A Case of Conspiracy. Los Angeles: Holloway House, 1980.
Pepper, William. An Act of State: The Execution of Martin Luther King. London: Verso,
2008.
Posner, Gerald. Killing the Dream: James Earl Ray and the Assassination of Martin Luther
King, Jr. New York: Random House, 1998.
Report of the Select Committee on Assassinations of the U.S. House of Representatives.
National Archives. http://www.archives.gov/research/jfk/select-committee-report.
Wexler Stuart, and Larry Hancock. The Awful Grace of God: Religious Terrorism, White
Supremacy, and the Unsolved Murder of Martin Luther King, Jr. Berkeley, CA: Counterpoint, 2012.
277
278
KU KLUX KL AN
Six young Confederate veterans founded the original Klan as a social group
at Pulaski, Tennessee, in spring 1866. They adopted arcane titles, donned
ghostly costumes, and amused themselves by frightening the countys superstitious ex-slaves. More chapters organized, with some members acting as vigilantes to keep newly freed African Americans in their place. In April 1867,
with the advent of Radical Reconstruction, Klansmen reorganized their order
as a paramilitary force to defend white supremacy and Democratic home
rule. Ex-general Nathan Bedford Forrest served as the Klans grand wizard,
and other Confederate officers ruled individual states as grand dragons. At
its peak, with a purported 550,000 members, the KKK rode in all 11 former
Confederate states, plus Kentucky and Missouri. Reports of a small chapter
in New York, supported by a photograph that may have been hoaxed, remain
unconfirmed.
Wherever they gathered, Klansmen waged guerrilla war against Republicans, black freedmen, Northern carpetbaggers, and Southern-born scalawags who supported Reconstruction. They murdered thousands1,081 in
Louisiana alone, between April and November 1868and wounding, flogging, and mutilating many more. Most victims were not public figures, but
the list of dead included judges, law enforcement officers, state legislators,
and local officials. Federal prosecutions, including declaration of martial
law in South Carolina, allegedly dissolved the Klan by 1872, but reports of
masked violence continued through 1876. Related groups, including Louisianas White League and Red Shirts in the Carolinas, redeemed every Southern state for white rule by 1877. Vigilante whitecaps spread the Klans
tradition in the early 20th century, with migration of Southern farmers to the
Midwest.
William Joseph Simmons, a defrocked minister, revived the Klan as a fraternal order in 1915, restricting membership to native-born white Protestant
males, with auxiliaries added for women and children, plus a parallel Riders of the Red Robe for naturalized citizens. By 1924, the Klan had spread
to every state, with estimates of peak membership ranging from two to nine
million. The order dominated politics in several states, on both sides of the
MasonDixon Line, reputedly enlisting President Warren Harding. Although
most historians dispute that claim, various governors, U.S. senators and congressmen were certainly Klansmen, as were thousands more state and local
officials.
Again, the Klan pursued a violent course, adding attacks on immigrants,
Catholics, Jews, labor unions, and immoral whites to its traditional targets.
Less lethal than their forebears, Klansmen still killed dozens of victims over
two decades and flogging and assaulting hundreds more. The eras only bona
fide assassination occurred in May 1926, when Klansman Asa Bartlett killed
three persons with a bomb mailed to a political rival in Muskegon, Michigan.
KU KLUX KLAN
279
280
KU KLUX KL AN
See also: Evers, Medgar Wiley (19251963); Jackson, Wharlest, Sr. (19301967);
King, Martin Luther, Jr. (19291968); Moore, Harry Tyson (19051951).
Further Reading
Chalmers, David. Hooded Americanism. 3rd ed. Durham, NC: Duke University Press,
1987.
Newton, Michael. The Ku Klux Klan: History, Organization, Language, Influence and Activities of Americas Most Notorious Secret Society. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2006.
Trelease, Allen. White Terror. New York: Harper & Row, 1971.
Wade, Wyn. The Fiery Cross: The Ku Klux Klan in America. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1987.
L
LAMBRAKIS, GRIGORIS (19121963)
On May 22, 1963, Dr. Grigoris Lambrakis, a Greek gynecologist and member
of parliament, delivered the keynote speech to an antiwar rally in Thessaloniki.
Soon afterward, right-wing extremists Emannouel Emannouilides and Spyro
Gotzamanis drove past him in a three-wheeled open truck, one striking Lambrakis over the head with a club in plain view of numerous witnesses. Lambrakis suffered a fractured skull and brain damage, dying in a local hospital
on May 27. Police initially described the killing as a traffic accident, assigning young magistrate Christos Sartzetakis to prove that contention. Instead,
Sartzetakis uncovered a network of extremists serving the police as extralegal terrorists. Emannouilides Spyro Gotzamanis were subsequently charged
with murder, and four high-ranking officers were indicted as accomplices.
They went to trial in February 1966 and were convicted in October, receiving
11-year prison terms.
Grigoris Lambrakis was born at Kerasita, a village in the Tegea district of Arcadia, Peloponnese, on April 3, 1912. He left home after high school, to study
medicine at the University of Athens, while simultaneously pursuing a lifelong
passion for athletics, breaking the Greek record for the long jump and winning
a spot on the national team. World War II interrupted his medical studies, as
the Axis Powers occupied his homeland. Lambrakis joined the Greek resistance, and in 1943 financed public food banks for displaced persons with proceeds from a newly created Union of Greek Athletes. After the war, Lambrakis
completed his studies and joined the University of Athenss School of Medicine
as a lecturer in gynecology. On the side, he maintained a free clinic for patients
unable to pay for health care.
His wartime experience with fascism pushed Lambrakis to the left, politically. He joined the pacifist movement, opposing nuclear weapons and war in
general. The Greek Civil War of 19461949 resulted in near-eradication of the
nations Communist Party, leaving the United Democratic Left (EDA) as the
only legally recognized leftist party in Greece. Lambrakis joined, and in 1961
was elected to the Hellenic parliament from Piraeus. During that same year, he
played a leading role in the creation of the Commission for International Dtente and Peace, serving as its first vice president. On April 21, 1963, the Commission for International Dtente and Peace led a pacifist march from Marathon
to Athens, interrupted by police who jailed many demonstrators. Lambrakis,
282
L APORTE, PIERRE
Z
The murder of Grigoris Lambrakis inspired Greek diplomat and author
Vassilis Vassilikos to publish a novel dramatizing the case in 1967. The
books title, Z, derives from the first letter of the Greek word Zei (translated as He lives!), frequently drawn on walls by graffitists during the
1960s. Expatriate Greek filmmaker Constantinos Gavras brought the
story to theaters worldwide in 1969, with Yves Montand caste as the martyred pacifist, and Jean-Louis Trintignant in the role of Magistrate Sartzetakis (avoiding all use of real names). The film received five Academy
Award nominations, winning Oscars for Best Film Editing and Best Foreign Language Film in 1970.
shielded from arrest by parliamentary immunity, finished the march alone with
a banner bearing a peace symbol.
Those activities made Lambrakis a natural target for right-wing forces led by
Prime Minister Konstantinos Karamanlis. Supporters of Lambrakis blamed the
Karamanlis regime for orchestrating his murder, and although criminal charges
never reached the prime ministers office, Karamanlis and his National Radical Union party lost the parliamentary election in November 1963. Karamanlis
himself soon left Greece, traveling under the pseudonym Triantafyllides, and
spent the next 11 years in Paris, under self-imposed exile.
That victory for the moderate left was short lived. Greek generals staged a
coup in April 1967, imposing rule by a brutal military junta that continued
through 1974. Under the junta, Magistrate Sartzetakis and the attorney general
who prosecuted Lambrakiss killers were dismissed from their positions, and
Sartzetakis spent a year in prison. Many Greeks still feel that those responsible
for the assassination went unpunished.
Further Reading
Dulis, Thomas. The Iron Storm: The Impact on Greek Culture of the Military Junta,
19671974. Bloomington, IN: Xlibris, 2011.
Miller, James. The United States and the Making of Modern Greece: History and Power,
19501974. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2008.
Nafpliotis, Alexandros. Britain and the Greek Colonels: Accommodating the Junta in the
Cold War. London: I.B. Tauris, 2012.
LAPORTE, PIERRE
and Minister of Labor Pierre Laporte from his home in Saint-Lambert, across
from Montreal on the south bank of the St. Lawrence River. The abductors,
members of the FLQs Chnier Cellbased in Montreal and named after JeanOlivier Chnier, a martyr of the Lower Canada Rebellion against British rule, in
November 1837dubbed Laporte the Minister of Unemployment and Assimilation, holding him hostage in exchange for release of perceived political
prisoners jailed by the federal government. British diplomat James Richard
Cross had been kidnapped five days earlier, resulting in identical demands.
Canadian prime minister Pierre Trudeau invoked the War Measures Act of
1914, authorizing widespread raids against suspected FLQ supporters, telling
journalists, Nothing that either the Government of Canada or the Government of Quebec has done or failed to do, now or in the future, could possibly
excuse any injury to either of these two innocent men. The gun pointed at
their heads have FLQ fingers on the trigger. Should any injury result, there
is no explanation that could condone the act. Should there be harm done
to these men, the Government promises unceasing pursuit of those responsible. Laporte, shot dead, was found on October 18, in the trunk of a car
owned by Chnier Cell leader
Paul Rose. Cross was released,
unharmed, on December 3,
1967.
Pierre Laporte was born
in Montreal on February 25,
1921, a grandson of renowned
statesman Alfred Leduc, who
served in the Canadian House
of Commons from 1917 to
1921, and in the legislative assembly of Qubec from 1921
to 1931. Laporte was a reporter
for the newspaper Le Devoir
from 1945 through 1961, best
known for his attacks on Qubec premier Maurice Duplessis, between 1945 and 1959. In
1958, Laporte was one of the
reporters who broke the scandal linking Duplessis to kickbacks from sales of natural gas,
resulting in creation of a Royal Qubec separatists murdered Deputy Premier and
Commission on Morality in Minister of Labor Pierre Laporte. (Brian Smith/
Corbis)
Public Spending.
283
284
L APORTE, PIERRE
After Duplessis died in office, in September 1959, Laporte tried his own
hand at politics, winning election to the National Assembly of Qubec from
Chambly as a member of the Qubec Liberal Partys left wing. In 1970, he ran
for the seat of retiring premier Jean Lesage, but was edged out by rival Robert
Bourassa. Upon taking office, Bourassa, in turn, named Laporte to serve as his
vice premier and minister of labor. The FLQ was not impressed by Laportes
left-wing credentials, and selected him as a target during Qubecs 1970 October Crisis.
Between October 16, 1967, and years end, authorities in Qubec staged
1,628 raids under terms of the War Measures Act, jailing 468 persons on
suspicion of subversion; of those, 408 were later released without any formal charges being filed. FLQ members charged with participating in Laportes
abduction and murder or related crimes included Chnier Cell members
Paul Rose, Pierre Vallires, Robert Lemieux, Jacques Rose, Michel Chartrand,
Charles Gagnon, Jacques Larue-Langlois, Marc Carbonneau, Francis Simard,
and Bernard Lortie. Paul Rose received a life sentence for Laportes murder
on March 13, 1971, with a matching term for kidnapping on November 30.
Francis Simard was sentenced to life for murder on May 20, 1971. Jurors convicted Bernard Lortie of kidnapping on September 22, 1971, and he received
a life sentence on November 22. Jurors acquitted Jacques Rose of kidnapping
on December 9, 1972, whereupon prosecutors charged him with the lesser offenses of assisting kidnappers after the fact and forcible confinement, but jurors cleared him of those counts as well, on February 23, 1973. Pierre Vallires
received a one-year suspended sentence on October 4, 1972, for conviction on
three counts of counseling kidnapping for political purposes. Paul Rose was released on December 20, 1982, after a new investigation found he was not present when Laporte was killed.
Further Reading
Gray, Carol. The FLQ: Seven Years of Terrorism. Richmond Hill, ON: Simon & Schuster
of Canada, 1970.
Wainstein, Eleanor. The Cross and Laporte Kidnappings, Montreal, October 1970.
Arlington, VA: Rand Publications, 1976.
285
286
scene with a single, (Just Like) Starting Over, and followed that with his
Double Fantasy album in November. A full-scale comeback appeared to be in
the offing, when Mark Chapman cut short his life.
Some observers ranked Lennons murder as an assassination, due to his
high public profile coupled with political activities, but no conspiracy theories surfaced until 1990, when author Fenton Bresler blamed the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) for plotting Lennons death. Breslers contention grew
from the observation of New York Police Department (NYPD) homicide detective Arthur OConnor, who said, Its possible Mark [Chapman] could have
been used by somebody. I saw him the night of the murder. I studied him
intensely. He looked like he could have been programmed. Chapmans own
statements in custody, describing dead silence in the brain and disembodied
voices chanting Do it, do it, do it, evoked memories of the CIAs long-running
mind-control experiments (Project MKUltra) during the 1950s and 1960s.
Similar allegations, involving hypnosis and drugs, have been raised in the case
of Sirhan Bishara Sirhan, convicted of assassinating Senator Robert F. Kennedy
in 1968.
In 1997, after 15 years of litigation by the American Civil Liberties Union,
FBI headquarters released the bureaus file on John Lennons under the Freedom of Information Act. Documents collected in 1972 reveal that President
Richard Nixon ordered surveillance on Lennon, along with other antiwar activists, and that agents of the CIA collaborated in that surveillance as a part of
Operation Chaosa criminal violation of the CIAs charter, which at the time
forbid any activity on U.S. soil.
In 2010, British author Phil Strongman published a new study of Lennons
assassination, building on the Bresler theory that Chapman was in fact a CIA
pawn. His evidence includes the fact that Chapmana self-described obsessive fan of Lennonsdid not own a single one of Lennons recordings, nor
any books or magazines about his idol; that Chapman visited Beirut, Lebanon, for no apparent reason during a period of intense CIA activity there; and
that he embarked on an round-the-world trip in 1975, while unemployed and
virtually destitute. In fact, Strongman claims that Chapman was not Lennons
killer in fact. As he told The Guardian in December 2010, The bullets slapped
into Lennons body so closely together that pathologists later had trouble marking out the different entry points. If all of these shots came from Chapman, it
was a miraculous piece of shooting. Put simply, the authorities investigation,
or lack of it, into the assassination was shockingly slack and beggars belief. In
fact, if any of them came from him it was miraculous because Chapman was
standing on Lennons right and, as the autopsy report and death certificate later
made clear, all Lennons wounds were in the left side of his body. Prosecutors
in New York rejected the Bresler and Strongman conspiracy theories. The CIA,
thus far, has no comment.
287
288
Further Reading
Bresler, Fenton. Who Killed John Lennon? New York: St. Martins Press, 1990.
The John Lennon FBI Files. http://www.lennonfbifiles.com.
Seaman, Fred. The Last Days of John Lennon. New York: Birch Lane Press, 1991.
Strongman, Phil. John Lennon: Life, Times and Assassination. Liverpool: Bluecoat Press,
2010.
President Allende recalled Letelier from Washington in 1973, to serve successively as minister of foreign affairs, interior, and defense, but it was too late
to save Allendes administration. General Augusto Pinochet led a military coup
against the government on September 11 of that year, and Allende reportedly
committed suicide while besieged by troops at La Moneda Palace in Santiago.
Letelier was arrested the same day, and spent 12 months under torture at various concentration camps before his release and exile to Caracas, Venezuela, in
September 1974. From there, he made his way to Washington in 1975, and
became a senior fellow of the Institute for Policy Studies. Later, he served as director of the Amsterdam-based Transnational Institute and taught at American
Universitys School of International Service in Washington, D.C. On the side,
he wrote, lectured, and lobbied tirelessly against the Pinochet regime, emerging as the primary voice of Chilean opposition to dictatorship. As a result, in
September 1976, the junta stripped Letelier of his Chilean citizenship.
FBI agents identified DINA agent Michael Vernon Townley, a U.S. expatriate and former CIA employee, as the mastermind behind Leteliers murder.
Townley and his chief accomplice, Armando Fernandez Larios, had received
visas to the United States from the U.S. ambassador to Paraguay, collaborating with neo-fascist dictator Alfredo Stroessner, whose regime provided forged
Paraguayan passports. Chile agreed to Townleys extradition on murder charges
in 1978. In custody, Townley admitted hiring five Cuban exilesJos Dionisio
Surez, Alvin Ross Daz, Virgilio Paz Romero, Guillermo Novo Sampoll, and
Ignacio Novo Sampollto plant the bomb under Leteliers car, and to bomb
Cubana Flight 455 two weeks later, killing all 78 persons aboard. Townley and
his wife turned states evidence against the bombers, in exchange for immunity
from prosecution, testifying against Daz and the Novo Sampoll brothers at
their trial in January 1979. (Pinochets regime declined to extradite DINA officers Romero and Surez.)
The three defendants were convicted of first-degree murder, with the Novo
Sampoll brothers receiving life prison terms, and Daz was sentenced to 80
years. Townley and his wife vanished into the Witness Protection Program,
and remain in hiding today. Armando Fernandez Larios fled Chile with FBI
assistance in 1987, fearing that President Pinochet planned to kill him for refusal to cooperate in cover-ups related to Leteliers slaying. On February 4,
1987, he pled guilty to one count of serving as an accessory to the murder,
then was freed in exchange for testimony naming other plotters. Following
Pinochets retirement in 1990, Chilean authorities undertook their own belated investigation of Leteliers assassination. Ex-DINA leaders General Manuel
Contreras and Brigadier Pedro Espinoza Bravo were convicted of participation
in the slaying on November 12, 1993, receiving lenient prison terms of seven
and six years, respectively. General Pinochet was never charged with Leteliers
murder, though Chilean prosecutors indicted him for human rights violations
289
290
LINCOLN, ABRAHAM
charge, Montana shoots him, thereby touching off a war with the Colombian
cartel that ends with Montanas death in a flamboyant gun battle.
Further Reading
Dinges, John, and Saul Landau. Assassination on Embassy Row. New York: Pantheon
Books, 1981.
Freed, Donald. Death in Washington: The Murder of Orlando Letelier. Chicago: Lawrence
Hill, 1980.
Hancock, Larry. Nexus: The CIA and Political Assassination. Southlake, TX: JFK Lancer
Productions, 2011.
Kornbluh, Peter. The Pinochet File: A Declassified Dossier on Atrocity and Accountability.
New York: The New Press, 2004.
McCann, Joseph. Terrorism on American Soil: A Concise History of Plots and Perpetrators
from the Famous to the Forgotten. Boulder, CO: Sentient Publication, 2006.
291
292
with a pistol and a Bowie knife, first pistol-whipping Sewards son, then stabbing Seward repeatedly as he lay in bed, recuperating from a fall suffered on
April 5. A splint on Sewards broken jaw saved him from fatal injury, before
Powell fled into the night.
Abraham Lincoln was born at Hodgenville, Kentucky, on February 12,
1809, and moved to Indiana with his family at age seven. He lost his mother
two years later, then resettled in Illinois with his father and siblings at 13. He
rarely saw the inside of a classroom, but educated himself at home, later remarking, I studied with nobody. Self-taught in law while working as a county
surveyor, Lincoln won election to the Illinois state legislature in 1834, and
was admitted to the bar two years later, practicing law with his wifes cousin in
Springfield. Although a free soil advocate, he did not favor outright abolition
of slavery, declaring that the institution of slavery is founded on both injustice and bad policy, but the promulgation of abolition doctrines tends rather to
increase than abate its evils. In 1846, he was elected to Congress, with a vow
to serve only one term, then kept his promise and returned to private practice.
Increasing agitation over slavery prompted Lincoln to seek a U.S. Senate seat
in 1854, and again in 1858. He lost both races, but his speeches won sufficient
admiration to secure the Republican presidential nomination in 1860. Lincolns victory in that contest, on a free soil platform, propelled 11 Southern
states into secession from the Union, leading to the outbreak of Americas Civil
War in April 1861. Three years later, he won reelection by uniting Republicans
and War Democrats in the common cause of defeating the breakaway Confederacy and restoring the Union, an effort that ultimately proved successfulat
least, on the surfacein April 1865.
John Wilkes Booth and his fellow conspirators initially planned to kidnap
President Lincoln and deliver him to the Confederate army as a hostage, to
compel release of Southern prisoners of war. Those involved in the plot, aside
from George Atzerodt and Lewis Powell, included Samuel Arnold, David
Herold, Michael OLaughlen, John Surratt, and Johns mother Mary Surratt,
who moved from Maryland to Washington, D.C., hosting repeated meetings
of the plotters at her home. An attempt to snatch Lincoln on March 17, 1865,
during a scheduled visit to Campbell Military Hospital, fell through when
Lincoln canceled the trip. Following General Lees surrender at Appomattox,
Booth switched his plan from abduction to assassination, writing in his diary,
Our cause being almost lost, something decisive and great must be done.
After the attacks in Washington, Booth rendezvoused with David Herold
in Maryland and rode to the home of Dr. Samuel Mudd (see sidebar), who set
Booths broken ankle and provided him with crutches. Moving on from there,
they spent five days and nights in a swamp, finally reaching Richard Garretts
tobacco farm on April 24. Union soldiers arrived two days later, surrounding
the barn where Booth and Herold were concealed. Herold chose surrender,
LINCOLN, ABRAHAM
and Booth refused to be taken alive. With the barn in flames, he fled, holding a
rifle in one hand and a pistol in the other. Private Boston Corbett shot Booth in
the neck, clipping his spinal cord, and Booth died two hours later, after muttering, Tell my mother I die for my country.
Back in Washington, meanwhile, police raided Mary Surratts home, arresting her and son George, then remained to nab Lewis Powell when he turned
up on April 17. George Atzerodt was captured on a farm at Germantown,
Maryland, on April 20. Nine other suspects, including Booths brother Junius and the owner of Fords Theater, were jailed on suspicion of aiding the
conspirators, but seven were soon released. Those facing trial before a military tribunal on May 1, 1865, included Arnold, Atzerodt, Herold, Dr. Mudd,
OLaughlen, Powell, Mary Surratt, and Edmund Spangler (a Fords Theater
stagehand who briefly held Booths horse on April 14). All were convicted
on June 30, with Atzerodt, Herold, Powell, and Surratt sentenced to die, and
hanged in Washington on July 7. Arnold, Mudd, and OLaughlen received
life prison terms, and Spangler was sentence to six years. President Johnson
pardoned Mudd and Spangler in 1869.
Conspirator John Surratt escaped the original dragnet, fleeing through
Canada to Europe, and on from there to Egypt, where a U.S. government
agent nabbed him in November 1866. At his trial, in summer 1867, defense
attorneys called four witnesses who claimed sightings of Surratt in Elmira,
New York, between April 13 and 15, 1865. Fifteen prosecution witnesses
placed him in Washington on the day of Lincolns murder, but confused jurors failed to reach a verdict. A mistrial was declared, and prosecutors declined to try the case a second time.
Lincolns death effectively scuttled his plan for reintegration of the late Confederate states with malice toward none, sparking imposition of harsh terms
that embittered Southern Democrats and spawned various terrorist groups opposed to Radical Reconstruction, the Ku Klux Klan chief among them. After 12
years of bloodshed, violence redeemed the South for single-party home rule
by white supremacist Democrats, inaugurating the age of Jim Crow and another
century of oppression for African Americans below the MasonDixon Line.
Because Mary and John Surratt were Roman Catholics, conspiracy theories arose surrounding their church. Anti-Catholicism had found fertile soil
in North America from the 16th century onward, exacerbated by the violently
xenophobic Know-Nothing movement, active nationwide from 1845 until
the outbreak of the Civil War. Details of the supposed Vatican/Jesuit plot were
fine-tuned and expanded from 1865 onward by Charles Chiniquy, a Canadian priest born in 1809 and expelled from the church in 1858, after three
years of acrimonious litigation against a prominent Catholic layman in Illinois.
Abraham Lincoln served as Chiniquys attorney in that case, and Chiniquy accused Chicagos bishop of secretly aiding the opposition. After his expulsion,
293
294
Chiniquy became a Presbyterian, regaling audiences with claims that the Catholic Church was pagan and anti-Christian. After the Civil War and Lincolns
death, he added allegations that Pope Pius IX had plotted both the war and
the assassination, themes expanded in two books: Fifty Years in the Church of
Rome and The Priest, the Woman and the Confessional. Chiniquy died in 1899,
but his claims were resurrected by the 1920s Ku Klux Klan, kept alive through
the 1960s by certain fundamentalist Protestant sects, and still circulate as fact
on the Internet today.
John Wilkes Booth, although not a Catholic, stands at the center of yet another Lincoln conspiracy theory. John Young, a seven-year-old witness to the
murder at Fords Theatre, later moved to Michigan and met James Kelley, who
once shared a dressing room with Booth as a member of the Richmond Theatre Company. Kelley, in turn, related the tale of a former slave who had served
L I T V I N E N K O , A L E X A N D E R VA L T E R O V I C H
Booths brother Edwin, claiming that Lincolns killer escaped from the United
States alive, while Sergeant Corbett shot and killed a look-alike, one James
William Boyd. Booth fled to England, and from there to India, living out his
days in Bombay (now Mumbai) as John Wilkes. In 1977, director James Conway released a film, The Lincoln Conspiracy, promoting that story and going
further stillclaiming that Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, Chief of National
Police Colonel Lafayette Baker, and various Northern congressmen conspired
to kill Lincoln, thereby short-circuiting Lincolns plan of readmission for Confederate states on lenient terms. That film included photographs of Booths
alleged mummified remains. NBCs Unsolved Mysteries program echoed that
conspiracy theme in an episode aired on September 25, 1991.
Two years later, researchers sought to have Booths presumed remains exhumed from Baltimores Green Mount Cemetery for DNA testing, to confirm
or refute his identity. The cemetery fought that move, resulting in a civil trial
before Judge Joseph Kaplan in 1995. Kaplan denied the petition for exhumation, and an appellate court upheld that ruling in 1996. The debate continues.
Further Reading
Bishop, Jim. The Day Lincoln Was Shot. New York, Harper, 1955.
Good, Timothy. We Saw Lincoln Shot: One Hundred Eyewitness Accounts. Oxford: University Press of Mississippi, 1996.
Kauffman, Michael. American Brutus: John Wilkes Booth and the Lincoln Conspiracies.
New York: Random House, 2004.
Steers, Edward, and James Swanson. The Lincoln Assassination Encyclopedia. New York:
Harper Perennial, 2010.
295
296
L I T V I N E N K O , A L E X A N D E R VA L T E R O V I C H
interest of some hypothetical future trial. Prime suspect Andrei Lugovoi escaped to Russia, and since his election to the Duma (Russian parliament) he is
legally immune to extradition.
Alexander Litvinenko was born in Voronezh, with conflicting reports citing
his birth date as August 30 and December 4, 1962. At age 18 he was drafted
into the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, a now-defunct Soviet a paramilitary police force. He attended the Kirov Higher Command School
from 1981 to 1985, graduating as a platoon commander. The KGB recruited
him as an informant in 1986, and two years later Litvinenko officially joined
the KGBs Third Chief Directorate, Military Counter Intelligence, serving with
that branch until 1991, when the Soviet Union collapsed and the KGB officially
disbanded. Litvinenko remained with the new agency, reborn as the Federal
Counterintelligence Service (FSK), specializing in counterterrorist activities and
infiltration of Russian Mafia groups (see sidebar). At the same time, he also
continued to play an active military role during Russian campaigns in Chechnya
and Dagestan. In 1997, Litvinenko was promoted to serve as a deputy chief of
the FSB Directorate of Analysis and Suppression of Criminal Groups.
Litvinenko later claimed that his disaffection with Russia began in December 1997, when he received orders to kill Boris Berezovsky, a businessman and
member of the Russian Academy of Sciences. He stalled until March 1998,
then warned Berezovsky, who went public with the claim and thus provoked a
major scandal. The FSB dismissed Litvinenko, disbanded his unit, then jailed
him for a month in 1999 on charges of abusing duties. Released on stipulation that he leave the country, Litvinenko moved to London, entering collaboration with MI6Britains Secret Intelligence Serviceat a reported wage of
2,000 per month. He became a naturalized British citizen in October 2006,
and continued working with the government until his death. At the same time,
he attracted death threats for his public statements and writings, condemning
Russian president Vladimir Putins regime. In January 2007, the Polish news
paper Dziennik Polska-Europa-Swiat
reported that Litvinenkos photograph was
used for target practice at a training center for private paramilitary security
forces in Balashikha, near Moscow.
Two days after Litvinenkos death, an article appeared under his byline in
Londons Mail on Sunday, titled Why I Believe Putin Wanted Me Dead. It read,
in part:
this may be the time to say one or two things to the person responsible for my
present condition. You may succeed in silencing me but that silence comes at a
price. You have shown yourself to be as barbaric and ruthless as your most hostile critics have claimed. You have shown yourself to have no respect for life,
liberty or any civilised value. You have shown yourself to be unworthy of your
office, to be unworthy of the trust of civilised men and women. You may succeed
L I T V I N E N K O , A L E X A N D E R VA L T E R O V I C H
in silencing one man but the howl of protest from around the world will reverberate, Mr. Putin, in your ears for the rest of your life. May God forgive you for
what you have done, not only to me but to beloved Russia and its people.
RUSSIAN MAFIA
Although membership in the historical Mafia is strictly limited to individuals of Italian descent, it is common practice to use the term Mafia
for any crime syndicate, regardless of ethnic complexion. Thus, we read
reports of an Albanian Mafia, Cuban Mafia, Black Mafia, and so on, with
the Russian Mafiaor Russkaya Mafiyaranked among the more notorious syndicates of modern times. Russia, like all other countries, has
harbored a criminal underworld throughout its history, traditionally
known as a bratva (brotherhood), composed of vor v zakone (thieves in
law), with the present generation spawned in the Soviet Gulag network
of prison labor camps. Some eight million convicts were released upon
the death of dictator Josef Stalin in 1953, with hard-core gangsters establishing an unprecedented criminal class nationwide. Since the collapse
of the Soviet Union in 1991, competing crime syndicates have vastly increased their influence and have established lucrative outposts worldwide, involved in illegal gambling, prostitution and human trafficking,
drug trafficking, and sale of black-market weapons, reportedly including
loose nukes from postcommunist Eastern Bloc arsenals. Official opinions differ on the extent and organization of the Russian organized crime.
Timur Lakhonin, head of Russias Interpol branch, said in December
2009, Certainly, there is crime involving our former compatriots abroad,
but there is no data suggesting that an organized structure of criminal
groups comprising former Russians exists abroad. Eight months later,
French criminologist Alain Bauer disputed that view, calling the Russian
Mafia one of the best structured criminal organisations in Europe, with
a quasi-military operation. Worldwide, in 2010, Russian crime syndicates operated in at least 50 countries, with an estimated membership
of 300,000. The largest single group, with some 5,000 identified members, is the Moscow-based Solntsevskaya Bratva, founded in 1985 by Boris
Arshavin and Sergei Mikhailov.
297
298
L I U, H E N RY
cited included a hotel, a restaurant, a tavern, multiple taxi cabs, and British
Airways commercial jet airliners.
Further Reading
Cowell, Alan. The Terminal Spy: A True Story of Espionage, Betrayal and Murder.
New York: Random House, 2008.
Goldfarb, Alex, and Marina Litvinenko. Death of a Dissident: The Poisoning of Alexander
Litvienko and the Return of the KGB. New York: Free Press, 2007.
Sixsmith, Martin. The Litvinenko File: The Life and Death of a Russian Spy. New York:
St. Martins Press, 2007.
299
300
L O N G, H U E Y P I E RC E , J R .
Senator Huey Longs 1935 assassination still spawns conspiracy theories. (Getty Images)
University Law School, completing its course of study in one year. Admitted to
the bar in 1915, Long courted working-class clients and won renown by suing
the Standard Oil Company for unfair business practices.
Long entered politics in 1918, after being elected to the Louisianas Railroad
Commission. His continuing attacks on Standard Oil rallied popular support,
propelling him to chairmanship of the states Public Service Commission in
1922 and election as governor in 1928, campaigning on the slogan Every man
a king, but no one wears a crown. Soon, he was dubbed The Kingfish, for
his power in Louisiana politics. While condemning giant corporations and the
wealthy parasites who ran them, Long used the governors office to enrich
himself. Every state employee was required to pay a portion of his or her salary into Longs political war chestdubbed the deduct boxduring election
years. Long also approved placement of illegal slot machines in New Orleans
and elsewhere, by arrangement with mobsters Frank Costello and Meyer Lansky, after Mayor Fiorello La Guardia had purged their New York City gambling
operations. By the time voters sent Long to the U.S. Senate in 1932, he was a
rich man in his own right and prepared to challenge the federal government.
Long initially supported President Franklin Roosevelts (FDR) New Deal, but
broke with the administration during summer 1933, promoting his own Share
Our Wealthand, some said, paving the way for his own White House race in
1936. In the Senate, Long opposed FDRs National Recovery Act as a sellout
to big business, and led a three-week filibuster against the Banking Act of 1933
until amendments extended deposit insurance to state banks. Roosevelt retaliated with federal investigations of Louisiana election procedures and Longs
income taxes, resulting in several indictments, but the Kingfish remained untouchable until his murder. Following Longs death, his family maintained control over Louisiana politics, with brother Earl serving as governor (19391940,
19481952, 19561960) and son Russell as U.S. senator (19481987).
Longs assassination, though officially solved, remains controversial. No autopsy was performed, despite requests from attending physician Edgar Hull,
and allegations of conspiracy or cover-up persist. In a 1973 biography of Meyer
Lansky, author Hank Messick claimed that the mobsterangry over Longs
demands for larger gambling payoffsordered physicians to let him die.
A quarter-century later, Dr. Donald Pavya nephew of Longs enemy, Judge
Pavypublished an account claiming that Dr. Weiss only punched Long during their September 1935 encounter, whereupon Longs troop of bodyguards
killed Weiss and fatally wounded the Kingfish with wild gunfire, then planted
a gun on Weiss in a posthumous frame-up.
Longs flamboyant life and murky death have prompted several fictional
portrayals, most portraying Long-like characters under various pseudonyms.
The first, Hamilton Bassos Cinnamon Seed (1934), lampooned Long with satire
and was followed by a posthumous sequel, Sun in Capricorn, eight years later.
Between those novels, Long critic Sinclair Lewis published It Cant Happen
Here (1935), a novel penned with the avowed purpose of undermining Longs
presidential hopes in 1936. Fictionalized in that work as President Berzelius
Windrip, Longs character emulates tactics from then-powerful Nazi Germany,
transforming the United States into a fascist dictatorship. Adria Locke Langleys novel, A Lion is in the Streets (1945), reached the silver screen eight years
later, with James Cagneys starring as rabble-rousing politician Hank Martin. Robert Penn Warren won a Pulitzer Prize for his novel of corrupted
idealist Willie Stark. All the Kings Men (1946), filmed under the same
title in 1949 and 2006 (with an opera, Willie Stark, produced in 1981).
Mystery novelist Max Allan Collins, having solved Anton Cermaks murder in 1983, with True Detective, did the same for Longs in 1995, in Blood
and Thunder. Meanwhile, sci-fi excursions into alternate history also feature
Huey Long. Harry Turtledoves American Empire trilogy (20012003) sees
Long assassinated for refusing to cast his lot with the Confederate States of
America. Barry N. Malzbergs short story Kingfish, in the Alternate Presidents anthology (1992), permits Long to survive the 1935 attempt on his life,
capture the White House in 1936, and conspire with ally John Nance Garner
to kill Adolf Hitler in the early days of World War II.
301
302
L U M U M B A , PAT R I C E M E RY
Further Reading
Pavy, Donald. Accident and Deception: The Huey Long Shooting. New Iberia, LA: Cajun
Publications, 1999.
White Jr., Richard. Kingfish: The Reign of Huey P. Long. New York: Random House,
2006.
Zinman, David. Who Killed the Kingfish? The Enduring Controversy over the Assassination of Huey Long. New York: Newsday, 1985.
L U M U M B A , PAT R I C E M E R Y
discussions in Brussels, charting the Congos future, after the MNC carried
Decembers local elections.
That conference concluded on January 27, 1960, with the announcement of
Congolese independence scheduled for June 30. Lumumba and the MNC triumphed in Mays national elections, with Lumumba declared prime minister on
June 23, and Joseph Kasa-Vubu was slated to serve as president. On Independence Day, Belgian king Baudouin cautioned his former African subjects, Dont
compromise the future with hasty reforms, and dont replace the structures that
Belgium hands over to you until you are sure you can do better . . . Dont be
afraid to come to us. We will remain by your side, give you advice.
Lumumba took a different view, telling his native audience, For this independence of the Congo, even as it is celebrated today with Belgium, a friendly
country with whom we deal as equal to equal, no Congolese worthy of the
name will ever be able to forget that it was by fighting that it has been won,
a day-to-day fight, an ardent and idealistic fight, a fight in which we were
spared neither privation nor suffering, and for which we gave our strength and
our blood. We are proud of this struggle, of tears, of fire, and of blood, to the
depths of our being, for it was a noble and just struggle, and indispensable to
put an end to the humiliating slavery which was imposed upon us by force.
A few days later, Lumumba unilaterally raised the pay of all government
employees except those serving in the army, which remained under control of
white Belgian officers. The reaction was immediate and hostile, with rebellions
nationwide by soldiers who engaged in pillaging and mayhem. Meanwhile,
on July 11, Katanga Province declared independence under Premier Moise
Tshombe, backed by Belgiums government and Union Minire du Haut Katanga, a Belgian mining company. Prime Minister Lumumba sought military
and humanitarian aid from the Soviet Union, which encouraged the Joseph
Mobutu and the CIA to move against him as an alleged communist.
Conspiracy theories surround Lumumbas assassination. Most sources
agree that the execution was carried out under direction of a Belgian officer, Captain Julien Gat. Some accounts claim that Lumumba was first
buried by a CIA agent, but Belgian police commissioner Gerard Soete
later admitted exhuming the corpse, with his brothers help, dismembering and dissolving it before it was reburied at a site near the Rhodesian border. In 1975, the U.S. Senate Select Committee to Study
Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities reported that CIA director Allen Dulles had ordered Lumumbas assassination as an urgent and prime objective, after President Dwight Eisenhower
said something to the effect that Lumumba should be eliminated.
A later report, issued in August 2000 by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, agreed that the CIA had conspired to murder Lumumba, but denied active participation by the agency in his assassination.
303
304
L U M U M B A , PAT R I C E M E RY
L U W U M , J A N A N I J A K A L I YA
305
306
L U W U M , J A N A N I J A K A L I YA
M
MADERO GONZLEZ, FRANCISCO IGNACIO
(18731913)
On February 18, 1913, Mexican general Jos Victoriano Huerta Mrquez staged
a coup dtat against President Francisco Madero, arresting both Madero and
his brother Gustavo, along with Vice President Pino Suarez. Over the course of
that afternoon, Gustavo Madero was tortured by Huertas soldiers, then shot and
buried in an unmarked grave. President Madero and Suarez initially refused to
sign their resignations, as Huerta demanded, then agreed on February 19, after
they were promised safe passage out of Mexico with their families. Huerta assumed the presidency on February 20, while Madero and Suarez remained in
prison, and then executed both hostages near midnight on February 21.
Francisco Madero Gonzlez was born in Coahuila on October 30, 1873, to
one of Mexicos richest families, educated at a Jesuit college, then at the cole
des Hautes tudes Commerciales de Paris, founded in 1881 by the Paris Chamber of Commerce and Industry. From France, he moved on to study agriculture
at the University of California in Berkeley. At age 20, he assumed management
duties at his familys ranch in San Pedro, Coahuila, introducing cotton as a cash
crop, while installing irrigation systems and constructing plants to manufacture
ice and soap. At the same time, he earned a reputation for philanthropy, building rural schools, hospitals, and community kitchens.
Madero entered politics in 1904, disgusted with the authoritarian tactics of
longtime president Porfirio Daz. Madero founded the Benito Jurez Democratic Club in San Pedro that year, narrowly losing a municipal election race,
but continued opposition to Daz through his own newspaper, El Demcrata,
and a satirical magazine, El Mosco (The Fly). An ardent spiritualist, Madero
published a best-selling bookThe Presidential Succession of 1910in 1908,
citing the supposed claim of spirits from beyond that Dazs dictatorship had
sickened Mexico. He noted that Daz initially campaigned on a platform of
No Re-election in 1870, but after losing that campaign to incumbent Benito
Jurez had, in fact, had himself been elected to the presidency three timesin
1876, 1877, and 1884. Now, with Daz still in office, Madero claimed the No
Re-election slogan as his own, campaigning to unseat the dictator.
In 1910, as founder and presidential candidate of the Anti-Reelectionist
Party, Madero campaigned nationwide, warning supporters that Daz would
308
not leave office peacefully. That prophecy proved accurate in June, as Daz
jailed Madero and 5,000 other members of his party, subsequently claiming
victory and a fourth term by an electoral vote of 196 to 187. Madero escaped
from custody on October 4, 1910, and fled to San Antonio, Texas, where he
hatched the Plan of San Luis Potos, calling for Mexicos citizens to rise in force
against Daz on November 20.
So began the Mexican Revolution, tacitly supported by U.S. president William Howard Taft. Maderos forces were led by commanders including Francisco Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata, expanding to incite rebellions in
18 of Mexicos 31 states by April 1911. A month later, following a decisive victory by rebel troops at Ciudad Jurez, Daz resigned and ceded control of the
country to interim president Francisco Len de la Barra. Madero won the next
presidential election, taking office on November 6, 1911, and began dismantling the machinery of dictatorship. Ironically, after he instituted freedom of
the press, Madero faced a storm of criticism for his handling of several regional
uprisings during 19111912, prompting brother Gustavo Madero to complain
that the newspapers bite the hand that took off their muzzle.
One rebellion, led by ex-general Pascual Orozco in Chihuahua, brought Victoriano Huerta to the forefront of Maderos army after General Jos Gonzlez
Salas committed suicide. Huerta suppressed the uprising in September 1912,
driving Orozco into exile, but their relationship soured when guerrilla leader
Pancho Villa refused to take orders from Huerta. Huerta ordered Villas execution, but Madera commuted the sentence, leaving bad blood between them.
A month later, in October 1912, Flix Daza nephew of Maderos deposed
predecessorled a mutiny in Veracruz to reclaim the honor of the army trampled by Madero. Captured and condemned, Daz was spared by commutation
of his sentence from Mexicos Supreme Court, leaving him embittered and determined to strike back. By early 1913, Huerta and Daz were joined by U.S.
ambassador Henry Lane Wilson in a plot to depose Madero, culminating in the
actions of La Decena Tragicathe Ten Tragic Days of February.
Today, we know that Ambassador Wilson began predicting Maderos downfall on February 11, wiring President William Howard Taft for authority to
force negotiations between the contending rivals. When British, Spanish, and
German diplomats counseled peace, Lane advised them that President Taft
was visibly embarrassed and endeavored to fix the responsibility on General
Flix Daz. Wilson changed his tune on February 13, informing Secretary of
State Philander Knox that Public opinion, both Mexican and foreign, holds the
Federal Government responsible for these conditions. Two days later, Wilson
and Germanys ambassador visited the presidential palace, hoping to confer
with General Huerta privately, but as Wilson complained, upon arrival, much
to our regret, we were taken to see the President. By February 16, Wilson had
M A H E R PA S H A , A H M E D
received a covert message from Huerta saying that he expected to take steps
tonight towards terminating the situation.
By what means? According to Wilsons next memo, Huerta has sent his
messenger to say that I may expect some action which will remove Madero
from power at any moment, and that plans were fully matured. . . . I asked no
questions and made no comment beyond requesting that no lives be taken
except by due process of law. By Monday night, the 17th, Wilson was predicting Maderos arrest by noon on Tuesdaywhich, in fact, occurred. Following
the murders on February 22, Wilson washed his hands of the matter, claiming
it would be an impertinence for a foreign power to demand an investigation
into a purely domestic matter. Then, in a cruel twist, he added, In fact, the
person really responsible for Maderos death was his wife. She was the one to
blame. Madero had to be eliminated. By her telegram to the commander at Veracruz, she made it impossible to allow him to leave the Capital.
Mexicos revolution continued for another seven years. President Huerta,
although supported by Germany, was driven from office and into exile by
July 1914. Successor Francisco Carvajal lasted one day short of a month,
then ceded power to Venustiano Carranza, who restored a measure of peace
and promoted a new constitution prior to his assassination in May 1920.
Sporadic violenceendemic to Mexico then, as todaycontinued under
successors Adolfo de la Huerta (JuneNovember 1920), lvaro Obregn (December 1920 to November 1924), and Plutarco Elas Calles (December 1924
to November 1928).
Further Reading
Gonzales, Michael. The Mexican Revolution: 19101940. Albuquerque: University of
New Mexico Press, 2002.
Krauze, Enrique. Mexico: Biography of Power. A History of Modern Mexico, 18101996.
New York: HarperCollins, 1997.
McLynn, Frank. Villa and Zapata: A History of the Mexican Revolution. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2000.
Ross, Stanley. Francisco I. Madero: Apostle of Mexican Democracy. Whitefish, MT: Literary Licensing, 2011.
309
310
M A H E R PA S H A , A H M E D
wounds that claimed the prime ministers life a half-hour later. Captured at the
scene, dressed in a dapper black shirt and red necktie, Essawy was variously
described in press reports as a pro-Nazi lawyer and a veterinary student,
interned during 1940 for unspecified pro-German activities. Later reports
speculated that he was a member of the Muslim Brotherhoodthe target of a
fatwa declared by Prime Minister Maher in 1944but prior to his execution by
hanging, in September 1945, Essawy admitted membership in the Wafd ( Delegation ) Party, a group opposed to dynastic rule and favoring a constitutional
monarchy.
Details of Ahmed Maher Pashas early life are sparse. He was born in 1888,
and by the early 1920s he was serving as Egypts minister of education, appointed by King Fuad I. Maher had vacated that post by May 1925, when
British colonial authorities detained him as a suspect in the November 1924
assassination of Sir Lee Oliver Fitzmaurice Stack, governor-general of AngloEgyptian Sudan, but Maher was not among the eight defendants subsequently
convicted and hanged for that crime.
In 1937, Maher was a member of Egypts senate, elevated that December to
lead King Farouk Is royal cabinet. The move provoked tension when Farouk
rejected the cabinets nomination of a senate candidate to replace Maher,
choosing one of his own. By August 1939, Maher was installed as minister of
finance, charging members of the rival Wafd Party with libel after they accused
him of corruption. King Farouk named Maher as prime minister on October 10, 1944, whereupon Maher declared his fatwa against hostile Wafdists.
Striving for neutrality, on February 6, 1945, Maher announced that Egypt
would not tolerate any airfield belonging to any foreign power on her soil,
but his attitude toward the Allies soon changed after meetings with U.S. president Franklin Roosevelt and British prime minister Winston Churchill, resulting in his assassination.
Mahers state funeral, on February 26, 1945, featured one of the longest
processions ever assembled in Cairo, including Indian, British, South African,
and U.S. troops in full dress uniform. His successor as prime minister, Mahmoud
Fahmi an-Nukrashi Pasha, served until December 1948, when he was murdered
in his office by a 21-year-old Muslim Brotherhood member disguised as a policeman. Ahmed Maher Pashas grandson, Ahmad Maher, served as Egypts foreign
minister from 2001 to 2004. Another grandson, Aly Maher, held various posts
including service as Egypts ambassador to France, secretary general of the Arab
Thought Foundation, director of the Institute for Peace Studies (20062008),
and as an officer of the Bibliotheca Alexandrina (2008 to present).
Further Reading
Flower, Raymond. Napoleon to Nasser: The Story of Modern Egypt. Bloomington, IN:
AuthorHouse, 2002.
Vatikiotis, P. J. The History of Modern Egypt: From Muhammad Ali to Mubarak. Baltimore:
Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991.
311
312
MALCOLM X
MALCOLM X (19251965)
On February 21, 1965, Muslim minister Malcolm X prepared to address
a gathering of the Organization of Afro-American Unity (OAAU) at Upper
Manhattans Audubon Ballroom. Some 400 persons were present as Malcolm
approached the podium, but before he could speak, a man in the audience
shouted, Nigger, get your hand outta my pocket! A puff of smoke erupted
and a scuffle began, and while Malcolms bodyguards moved to control it,
three men rushed the dais. One fired a sawed-off shotgun at Malcolm, while
the other two blazed away with pistols, striking him 21 times in the chest,
left shoulder, arms and legs.
Malcolm survived to reach
Columbia Presbyterian Hospital, but was pronounced dead
at 3:30 P.M. Members of the
audience seized one shooter,
Talmadge Hayer (aka Thomas
Hagan), beating him before
police could intervene, and
witnesses identified two other
gunmen as Norman 3X Butler
and Thomas 15X Johnson. All
three belonged to the Nation
of Islam (NOI), a religious sect
widely known as Black Muslims.
At trial Hayer/Hagen admitted
the shooting, while denying that
Butler and Johnson were his accomplices. Jurors convicted all
Black nationalist Malcolm X, murdered by Nation three, resulting in life prison
of Islam gunmen in 1965. (Associated Press)
terms.
MALCOLM X
Malcolm X was born Malcolm Little on May 19, 1925, in Omaha, Nebraska.
His father, Earl Little, was a transplanted Georgia native, a Baptist lay minister, and an outspoken admirer of Marcus Garveys Universal Negro Improvement Association, a Pan-African movement that encouraged black Americans
to seek freedom in the homeland of their ancestors. According to Malcolms
autobiography, harassment by the racist Ku Klux Klan drove his family from
Nebraska to Wisconsin, then to Lansing, Michigan, where pressure continued
from Klansmen and from members of a spin-off faction, the Black Legion. Malcolms father accused Black Legion members of burning the familys home in
1929. Two years later, when Earl Little was struck and killed by a streetcar in
Lansing, Malcolm claimed Black Legion members had pushed him onto the
tracks. Years later, Malcolm also wrote that white supremacists had murdered
three of his paternal uncles.
Malcolms mother suffered a mental collapse in 1938, when her presumed
fianc discovered she was pregnant and left her to fend for herself. Louise
Little spent the next 24 years in a Michigan state hospital, her children scattered to various foster homes, until Malcolm and his siblings could afford
to support her themselves. Meanwhile, Malcolm excelled in junior high
school, but dropped out after a white teacher told him that practicing law
was no realistic goal for a nigger. Settled in New York Citys Harlem ghetto
by 1943, he survived in a criminal milieu by pimping, gambling, robbery
and drug dealing. Faced with the prospect of military conscription during
World War II, he avoided service by telling his draft board that he steal guns
and kill crackers.
Shifting his focus to Boston in 1945, Malcolm embarked on a series of burglaries targeting affluent white homes. Police nabbed him after he left a stolen
watch for repair at a jewelry shop, resulting in imposition of a 10-year prison
term in February 1946. At Bostons Charlestown State Prison, Malcolm met
John Bembry, a self-educated inmate who impressed Malcolm with his command of English and the respect it evoked. Encouraged by a brother on the outside, Malcolm studied the NOI, adopting its tenets in 1948 and discarding his
slave surname in favor of an X by 1950. Paroled in August 1952, he visited
NOI leader Elijah Muhammad in Chicago, and in June 1953 was named assistant minister of the sects Temple Number One in Detroit, Michigan. Further
service in Boston and Philadelphia saw Malcolm promoted to lead Harlems
Temple Number Seven by May 1954.
Immensely popular with NOI audiences, promoting the groups doctrine
that blacks are Earths original people, whereas whites are grafted blue-eyed
devils, Malcolm established new temples in Massachusetts, Connecticut, and
Georgia during 1955. By then, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) was
also interested in his activities, initiating surveillance on orders from Director
J. Edgar Hoover in 1953. A notorious police brutality case from Harlem brought
313
314
MALCOLM X
Malcolm to national public attention in April 1957, whereupon the New York
City Police Department (NYPD) also initiated surveillance of Malcolm and the
NOI. By July 1959, when he was prominently featured in a television documentary on the Black Muslims, titled The Hate That Hate Produced, Malcolm
had begun to call himself Malcolm Shabazz or Malik el-Shabazz, though most
admirers still referred to him as Malcolm X. FBI/NYPD fears of Malcolms possible communist leanings spiked in September 1960, when he led a delegation
welcoming Cuban leader Fidel Castro to Harlem, during Castros visit to the
United Nations.
Malcolm remained the most visible face of the NOI through 1963, a circumstance that placed him in stark contrast to pacifist civil rights leader Martin
Luther King Jr. Malcolm himself emphasized the difference between their approaches to black liberation, branding King and his allies as stooges, mocking Kings August 1963 March on Washington as the farce on Washington.
In that instance, Malcolm expressed dismay that so many blacks were roused
by a protest run by whites in front of a statue of a president who has been
dead for a hundred years and who didnt like us when he was alive. In December 1963, asked to comment on the slaying of President John F. Kennedy,
Malcolm shocked many whites by saying that chickens coming home to
roost never did make me sad; theyve always made me glad. The public outcry against that statementand, some said, personal jealousy over Malcolms
growing popularity within the NOIprompted Elijah Muhammad to forbid
Malcolm from speaking publicly for 90 days.
Malcolm initially accepted the disciplinary order, then changed his mind at
the end of his sentence, announcing his break with the NOI on March 8, 1964.
Although still a committed Muslim himself, Malcolm said the NOI had gone as
far as it can based on strict religious doctrines. Instead, he hoped to heighten
the political consciousness of African Americans with a new movement, his
OAAU. J. Edgar Hoover, predictably, penned memos to his staff describing the
OAAU as a threat to U.S. national security, launching a campaign of illegal harassment designed to prevent the rise of a messiah from black America.
On March 26, 1964, Malcolm and Dr. King attended Senate hearings on a
pending civil rights bill, then emerged to hold a joint press conferencetheir
first and only meeting. In an April speech, titled The Ballot or the Bullet, Malcolm urged black Americans to register as voters and use their electoral power
to effect meaningful change. That same month, Malcolm converted to Sunni
Islam and embarked on a pilgrimage to Mecca, required by sharia law of every
Muslim who is able. That journey soon evolved into a tour of Africa, including
visits to Algeria, Egypt, Ethiopia, Ghana, Guinea, Liberia, Morocco, Nigeria,
Tanganykia (now Tanzania), Senegal, and Sudan. By the time he returned to
New York, in November 1964, Malcolm had met every African leader of consequence and had established himself as a global political figure.
MALCOLM X
Meanwhile, tension increased between Malcolm and the NOI. Even before
their rift, in February 1964, a leader of Harlems Temple Number Seven ordered
a bombing of Malcolms car. A member of the NOIs paramilitary arm, the Fruit
of Islam, wired an explosive charge to the vehicle, but it failed to detonate. The
following month, on March 23, Elijah Muhammad told Boston minister Louis X
(now Louis Farrakhan) that hypocrites like Malcolm should have their heads
cut off. An April issue of the sects newspaper, Muhammad Speaks, featured a
cartoon of Malcolms severed head. On July 9, NOI spokesman John Ali declared that anyone who opposes the Honorable Elijah Muhammad puts their
life in jeopardy. Septembers issue of Ebony magazine ran a photo of Malcolm
guarding his home with a rifle, as a result of incessant death threats that he
blamed on the NOI.
FBI agents kept track of the threats against Malcolm through illegal wiretaps. On June 8, 1964, a caller warned Malcolms wife to tell him hes as good
as dead. Four days later, an FBI informant told the bureau that Malcolm X is
going to be bumped off. One week before Malcolms murder, still-unidentified
arsonists burned his familys home to the ground. Despite the public NOI
threats, however, during the winter of 19631964 Malcolm told close friends
that he thought someone elseperhaps from the U.S. governmentwas responsible for the harassment.
Reactions to Malcolms assassination varied dramatically. Some 30,000 persons viewed his body while it lay in state at Harlems Unity Funeral Home, and
his funeral drew many of the nations highest-ranking black civil rights leaders
and celebrities on February 27, 1965. (Dr. King did not attend, but sent his condolences by telegram to Malcolms widow.) Actor/activist Ossie Davis delivered
Malcolms eulogy before live television cameras, calling him our shining black
prince. The white press, meanwhileincluding many reporters from J. Edgar
Hoovers private list of friendly journalistsreviled Malcolms memory. The
New York Times condemned Malcolm posthumously as an extraordinary and
twisted man who turn[ed] many true gifts to evil purpose, declaring that his
life had been strangely and pitifully wasted. Elijah Muhammad, speaking from
Chicago, ironically proclaimed that Malcolm X got just what he preached,
while insisting, We didnt want to kill Malcolm and didnt try to kill him. We
know such ignorant, foolish teachings would bring him to his own end.
Allegations of conspiracy in Malcolms murder were inevitable. The New
York Times itself spawned one, reporting the arrest of four suspects in its early
coverage of the shooting, dropping one without explanation from later editions. Who was the fourth man, some readers asked, and what had become
of him? Declassification of FBI documents under the Freedom of Information
Act revealed the bureaus long surveillance of Malcolm, and raised questions
about its failure to protect him. Other prime suspects included the NYPDs
Bureau of Special Servicesa Red squad that worked closely with the FBI
315
316
MALCOLM X
NATION OF ISLAM
The Nation of Islam (NOI) was founded in Detroit, in July 1930, by Wallace Dodd Ford, alias Wallace Fard and Wallace Fard Muhammad. An exconvict who served three years for drug dealing in California, Ford was
described in 1920 Census rolls as a white immigrant from New Zealand,
but he sometimes claimed to hail from Afghanistan. After several disputes
with Detroit police, Ford vanished forever in July 1934. NOI spokesmen
claim he is still alive aboard the Mother Plane, a spaceship described in
the biblical book of Ezekiel. Ford taughtand the NOI believesthat
Earth is 76 trillion years old, populated solely by blacks until an evil
scientist called Yakub grafted other races from them 6,600 years ago.
Committed to racial separatism, the NOI held meetings with the Ku Klux
Klan and American Nazi Party in the 1960s, supporting segregation. Various NOI spokesmennotably Louis Farrakhanhave also denounced
Jews in terms more familiar from white racist hate groups. In 1995, Farrakhan led a Million Man March on Washington, D.C., promoting African American solidarity. At least 400,000 attended that rally, making it
the largest gathering of its kind in U.S. history. Membership estimates in
the early 21st century range from 10,000 to 50,000.
M A R AT, J E A N - PA U L
on the TV program 60 Minutes, saying, I may have been complicit in words that
I spoke. I acknowledge that and regret that any word that I have said caused the
loss of life of a human being.
No charges were filed against the NOI suspects named in Hayers sworn affidavits. Norman 3X Butler (now Muhammad Abdul Aziz) was paroled in 1985
and assumed leadership of the NOIs Harlem mosque in 1998. Thomas 15X
Johnson (now Khalil Islam) abandoned the NOI while imprisoned and became a Sunni Muslim, winning parole in 1987. Talmadge Hayer (now Mujahid
Halim) was released from custody in 2010. The OAAU, deprived of Malcolms
guiding hand, survived briefly with his half-sister at the helm, then dissolved
due to declining membership.
Further Reading
Breitman, George, Herman Potter, and Baxter Smith. The Assassination of Malcolm X.
New York: Pathfinder Press, 1976.
Carson, Clayborne. Malcolm X: The FBI File. New York: Carroll & Graf, 1991.
Cone, James. Martin & Malcolm & America: A Dream or a Nightmare. Maryknoll, NY:
Orbis Books, 1991.
Evanzz, Karl. The Judas Factor: The Plot to Kill Malcolm X. New York: Thunders Mouth
Press, 1992.
Friedly, Michael. Malcolm X: The Assassination. New York: One World, 1992.
Goldman, Peter. The Death and Life of Malcolm X. Urbana: University of Illinois Press,
1979.
Lincoln, C. Eric. The Black Muslims in America. Boston: Beacon Press, 1961.
Lomax, Louis. To Kill a Black Man: The Shocking Parallel in the Lives of Malcolm X and
Martin Luther King Jr. Los Angeles: Holloway House, 1968.
317
318
M A R A T, J E A N - P A U L
M A R AT, J E A N - PA U L
In 1788, as France began its drift toward revolution, Marat abandoned science in favor of campaigning for the Third Estatethat is, all Frenchmen
who were not among the clergy or nobility. In September 1789, he launched
his own radical newspaper, LAmi du peuple (The Friend of the People), which
attacked the high and might throughout French society. When the newspaper was banned, Marat sought refuge literally underground, hiding beneath
the streets of Paris in the citys sewers. Despite his appearance and fugitive life
style, he managed to marry a woman 23 years his junior, and emerged from
hiding after full-scale revolution erupted on August 10, 1792. A month later,
when France was declared a republic, Marat claimed a seat in the ruling National Convention and renamed his newspaper Le Journal de la Rpublique franaise (Journal of the French Republic). Following the execution of King Louis
XVI in January 1793, Marat devoted the rest of his life to pursuit of surviving
Girondists.
Marats assassination had the opposite effect of that intended by Charlotte
Corday, in that it helped precipitate the Reign of Terror that claimed some
42,000 lives nationwide between September 1793 and July 1794. Marat himself became a martyr to the revolutionary cause, glamorized in posthumous
portraits with unblemished skin and finely sculpted features. The entire National Convention attended Marats funeral, with his heart embalmed separately. In November 1793, his remains were exhumed and transferred to the
Panthon, where his good friend, the Marquis de Sade, delivered a eulogy comparing Marat to Jesus. His memory lived on 128 years later, in far-off Russia,
where Bolshevik revolutionists renamed the tsarist battleship Petropavlovsk
DUHRINGS DISEASE
Technically known as dermatitis herpetiformis, or DH, this chronic skin
disease is characterized by painful blisters filled with watery fluid. Its
Latin name refers to inflammation of the skin resembling herpes, but DH
is not in fact related to the herpes virus. Named after Dr. Louis Duhring,
who first officially described the ailment in 1884, DH is now believed to
result, in some still-uncertain manner, from celiac disease (gluten intolerance), an autoimmune disorder of the small intestine occurring in genetically predisposed persons of both sexes and all ages. Published estimates
of DH prevalence range from 1 in 400 to 1 in 10,000. If the suspected
link to celiac disease is true, that hypothesis apparently negates claims
that Jean-Paul Marat caught the ailment while hiding as a fugitive in the
Parisian sewers.
319
320
M A S K H A D O V, A S L A N A L I Y E V I C H
the Marat. The same year, after Soviets captured Sevastopol, they renamed the
citys main street for Marat.
Further Reading
Bax, Ernest. Jean-Paul Marat: The Peoples Friend. London: G. Richards, 1901.
Conner, Clifford. Jean Paul Marat: Scientist and Revolutionary. Buffalo, NY: Humanity
Books, 1997.
Gottschalk, Louis. Jean Paul Marat: A Study in Radicalism. Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 1967.
M C G L I N C H E Y, D O M I N I C
The First Chechen War against Russian rule erupted on December 11, 1994,
with Maskhadov serving as first deputy chairman of the State Defence Council under President Dzhokhar Dudayev. He joined in peace talks at Grozny, in
June 1995, but the war continued for another 14 months, until the Khasavyurt
Accord achieved a temporary ceasefire. Appointed as prime minister on October 17, 1996, Maskhadov continued serving defense minister and army chief
of staff, while declaring himself a presidential candidate in elections scheduled
for January 1997. He won 60 percent of the popular vote in that contest, and
assumed office on February 12, 1997. Three months later, he signed a peace
treaty with Russian president Boris Yeltsin, but tension continued to simmer
between the two nations.
As president, Maskhadov inherited a republic infested with organized crime,
rife with ransom kidnappings, in which regional warlords constantly challenged
his authority. Maskhadov responded by imposing Islamic Sharia law, with
courts that imposed draconian sentences for crimes including adultery and
blasphemy. Several assassination attempts quickly followedon July 23, 1998;
March 21, 1999; and April 10, 1999with Maskhadovs assailants employing
bombs and antitank rockets. Maskhadov blamed Russian agents for those attacks, and was in turn accused of invading Dagestan on August 7, 1999, a raid
in fact carried out by warlord Shamil Basayevs Islamic International Brigade,
over Maskhadovs protests. Russia also blamed Chechnya for a series of apartment bombings that killed 293 people and wounded 651 in September 1999.
A Second Chechen War ensued, officially concluded with a Russian victory
in May 2000. Maskhadov refused to surrender, leading a guerrilla insurgency
that included terrorist actions both in Chechnya and Russianotably including the Dubrovka Theater siege of October 2002, which claimed at least 170
lives, and the Nazran raid of June 2004, which killed 98 police officers in the
Republic of Ingushetia. Finally repulsed by the Beslan school siege that left 385
dead in September 2004, Maskhadov issued an order suspending all military
action, other than self-defense, on January 15, 2005. The unilateral ceasefire
was supposed to facilitate peace talks, but Russias FSB took advantage of the
lull to eliminate their primary rival.
Further Reading
Schaefer, Robert. The Insurgency in Chechnya and the North Caucasus: From Gazavat to
Jihad. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger Security International, 2011.
Smith, Sebastian. Allahs Mountains: The Battle for Chechnya. London: Tauris Parke,
2005.
321
322
M C G L I N C H E Y, D O M I N I C
conversation, a car stopped nearby and two gunmen emerged, shooting McGlinchey 14 times with instantly fatal results. The crime remains officially unsolved today, with suggested suspects including loyalist paramilitary forces, the
rival Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA), state security forces, or some
element of Irish organized crime. At McGlincheys funeral in Bellaghy, Northern
Ireland, Bernadette Devlin McAliskeyherself a target of would-be assassins
in 1981condemned journalists who accused McGlinchey or gangster activity as curs and dogs. May everyone of them rot in hell. They have taken away
Dominic McGlincheys character and they will stand judgment for it. He was
the finest Republican of them all. He never dishonored the cause he believed
in. His war was with the armed soldiers and the police of this state.
Dominic McGlinchey was one of 10 children born to staunch republican
parents in Bellaghy, raised from infancy to oppose British rule in Northern
Ireland. In August 1971, he was arrested and detained for 10 months without charges, on suspicion of participating in PIRA activity. Still devoted to the
struggle, he was jailed again in 1973, on weapons charges, and in 1977 for
hijacking a police car, threatening its driver with a gun. While confined at
Portlaoise Prison, in 1982, McGlinchey quarreled with PIRA leaders over the
proper tactics and course of armed struggle, prompting his expulsion from the
organization. Paroled before years end, he quickly found a place in the competing INLA, enlisting as operations officer for South Derry and winning promotion to chief of staff within six months.
McGlinchey streamlined the INLA and set it on a path of more aggressive
and effective action. British agents blamed him for planning a bombing at the
Droppin Well Bar, in Ballykelly, which killed 11 soldiers and six civilians in
December 1982, among other violent actions. Six days after that blast, on December 12, authorities tried to trap McGlinchey at a roadblock, but killed two
other INLA members instead. That bungled ambush was apparently planed by
The Det14 Field Security and Intelligence Companya unit of the British
armys Intelligence Corps, known for collaboration with Protestant gunmen in
acts of loyalist terrorism.
In addition to government plots and McGlincheys squabbles with the PIRA,
Irish historian Tim Pat Coogan reports that McGlinchey ran the INLA in autocratic fashion, executing members who challenged his authority and thereby
making enemies. In one such case, members of one INLA chapter were killed
for misappropriating 50,000 collected from a mail fraud operation mounted
to finance the organization. Some observers believe that internecine feud may
have resulted in McGlincheys death, years after the fact.
Meanwhile, in March 1994, he was wounded and captured in a shootout
with Garda officers in Ralahine, County Clare. Extradited to Northern Ireland, McGlinchey was convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment, but an appellate court overturned his conviction in October 1985, citing
M C K I N L E Y, W I L L I A M , J R .
323
324
M C K I N L E Y, W I L L I A M , J R .
M C K I N L E Y, W I L L I A M , J R .
hand-picked successor, William Howard Taft. Taft, in turn, handed a third defeat to William Jennings Bryan, who retired thereafter to private legal practice
and the Chautauqua lecture circuit.
McKinleys assassination drove Congress to demand better security for
U.S. presidents. Accordingly, the U.S. Secret Servicefounded in 1865, but
confined to investigation of counterfeiting and federal fraud violationswas
ordered to assume responsibility for safety of the president in 1902. Sixtysix years later, following the assassination of Senator Robert Kennedy, Secret
ANARCHISM
Anarchism is broadly defined as a philosophy opposing hierarchical
government and supporting a stateless society. Within that wide generalization, many different schools of thought exist, ranging from radical
left-wing ideologies to far-right libertarianism. Some historians trace the
first anarchist philosophy ideology to Taoist philosopher Laozi, in the
6th century BCE, evolving through the ages to find expression from British author William Godwin (17561836). The first person to publicly
call himself an anarchist was French philosopher Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (18091865), although he altered his self-designation to federalist
in 1848. That same year, revolutions against traditional authority rocked
10 European nations, most of which failed to unseat reigning monarchies.
The short-lived Paris Commune of spring 1871 was another radical experiment, doomed by a falling out between anarchists and more doctrinaire Marxists. Although many anarchists were also pacifists, Johann
Most (18461906) argued for violencepropaganda of the deedas
a means of deposing monarchs or other heads of state. By the 1880s,
bombing and assassination were staple tactics of the radical anarchist
movement, labeled illegalism. Aside from President McKinley, famous
victims of anarchist assassins include Tsar Alexander II of Russia, Spanish prime minister Antonio Cnovas del Castillo, King Umberto I of Italy,
King Carlos I of Portugal, and King George I of Greece. State repression
inevitably followed, creating an escalating climate of violence. In the
United States, a rash of anarchist bombings after World War I culminated
with a blast on Wall Street, in New York City, that killed 38 persons and
seriously wounded 143 on September 16, 1920. Following World War II,
anarchism resurfaced internationally with a network of organizations including the Mexican Anarchist Federation, the French Fdration Anarchiste, Italys Federazione Anarchica Italiana, and Koreas League of Free
Social Constructors, among others.
325
326
MEDICI, GIULIANO DE
Service protection was extended to all major presidential and vice presidential
candidates and nominees.
Further Reading
Johns, A. Wesley. The Man Who Shot McKinley. South Brunswick, NJ: A. S. Barnes,
1970.
Miller, Scott. The President and the Assassin: McKinley, Terror, and Empire at the Dawn of
the American Century. New York: Random House, 2011.
Morgan, H. Wayne. William McKinley and His America. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 2003.
Rauchway, Eric. Murdering McKinley: The Making of Theodore Roosevelts America. New
York: Hill and Wang, 2004.
MEDICI, GIULIANO DE
support, with the weak proviso as long as no one is killed. Less concerned with
bloodless victory, conspirator Federico da Montefeltro, Duke of Urbino and condottieri (mercenary warlord) for the Vatican, stationed 600 troops outside Florence, prepared to strike when the order was given.
In fact, however, the assassins botched their bid to kill Lorenzo de Medici
at the Duomo, and coordinated moves against the Gonfaloniere of Justice and
the nine-member Signoria of Florence also failed. Still hopeful of success,
Francesco and Jacopo de Pazzi convened a rally of supporters at the Palazzo
della Signoria (now Palazzo Vecchio) on April 27, chanting for liberty. To the
Pazzis surprise, enraged Florentines attacked the rally and hurled Francesco
to his death from the palazzos roof, then dragged him through the streets and
tossed his corpse into the Arno River. The mob also hanged Francesco Salviati,
and killed other suspected conspirators on sight. Jacopo de Pazzi managed to
escape, hiding in San Gimignano, but was hunted down and killed there in
1480. In his absence, the surviving Pazzis were divested of their titles and possessions and driven into exile.
With the conspiracys failure, Pope Sixtus IV placed Florence under interdict, forbidding its residents from participating in mass or communion. He
enlisted Ferdinand I, king of Naples, but Lorenzo the Magnificent trumped
Sixtus by sailing to Naples and placing himself in Ferdinands custody for three
327
328
months, while negotiating a truce. Lorenzo survived until 1492, ruling Florence and adopting Giulianos illegitimate son, grooming him for his future role
as cardinal and pope. The Pazzis returned to Florence in 1494, when Lorenzos
sonPiero the Unfortunateproved himself incompetent and was deposed
by King Charles VIII of France.
Further Reading
Hibbert, Christopher. The House of Medici: Its Rise and Fall. New York: William Morrow, 1999.
Knecht, R. J. Catherine deMedici. Harlow, United Kingdom: Longman, 1998.
Martines, Lauro. April Blood: Florence and the Plot against the Medici. New York: Oxford
University Press, 2004.
Parks, Tim. Medici Money: Banking, Metaphysics, and Art in Fifteenth-Century Florence.
New York: W. W. Norton, 2005.
Unger, Miles. Magnifico: The Brilliant and Violent Times of Lorenzo de Medici. New York:
Simon & Schuster, 2008.
moving to Uruguay in 1969. There, operating from a private home in Montevideo with a basement interrogation chamber beneath its garage, Mitrione held regular classes, employing kidnap victims as his subjects. Speaking to a Cuban exile,
Manuel Hevia Cosculluela, Mitrione described his technique as employing the
precise pain, in the precise place, in the precise amount, for the desired effect.
Mitrione went on to say, When you get what you want, and I always get it, it
may be good to prolong the session a little to apply another softening-up. Not to
extract information now, but only as a political measure, to create a healthy fear
of meddling in subversive matters. You must always leave him some hope . . . a
distant light. A premature death means a failure by the technician. Its important
to know in advance if we can permit ourselves the luxury of the subjects death.
According to Hevia, he watched Mitrione personally kill four subjects with
electric shocks. As he described it in his published memoir:
Soon things turned unpleasant. As subjects for the first testing they took beggars, known in Uruguay as bichicomes, from the outskirts of Montevideo, as well
as a woman apparently from the frontier area of Brazil. There was no interrogation, only a demonstration of the effects of different voltages on different parts
of the human body, as well as demonstrating the use of a drug which induces
vomitingI dont know why or what forand another chemical substance.
The four of them died.
329
330
M O A W A D, R E N
M O H A M M E D , M U R TA L A R A M AT
national education and fine arts in October 1980, serving through September 1982.
Much of Moawads political career played out against the background of
Lebanons multifaceted civil war, begun with violence between Christians and
Muslims in April 1975. Over the next 15 years, Moawad advocated nonviolent solutions to the countrys ethnic and religious schisms, stating his premise
as follows: There can be no country or dignity without unity of the people,
and there can be no unity without agreement, and there can be no agreement
without conciliation, and there can be no conciliation without forgiveness and
compromise. The Taif Agreement, ratified on November 4, 1989, ostensibly
ended the fightingalthough Syrian troops remained active in Lebanon until
April 2005and Lebanons National Assembly met the following day, electing Moawad as the countrys first president since Amine Gemayel left office
in 1988. Elias Hrawi succeeded Moawad on November 24, two days after the
fatal bombing in Beirut.
No serious investigation of Moawads assassination was ever attempted. Syrian spokesmen blamed Michel Naim Aoun, a former Lebanese army officer and
head of the countrys second largest political party, the Free Patriotic Movement. Aoun served as prime minister from September 1988 to October 1990,
in one of two rival governments, and he is currently a member of parliament.
No specific evidence against Aoun was offered by detractors who accused him
of plotting Moawads murder.
Further Reading
Johnson, Michael. All Honourable Men: The Social Origins of War in Lebanon. London:
I.B. Tauris, 2002.
Obalance, Edgar. Civil War in Lebanon, 197592. New York: Palgrave-Macmillan, 1998.
331
332
M O H A M M E D, M U R T A L A R A M A T
M O N D L A N E , E D U A R D O C H I VA M B O
None of those moves endeared Mohammed to the West, and in the wake of
his assassination, allegations of conspiracy were leveled against the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency and the Israeli Mossad. Despiteor because ofthat
foreign opposition, Mohammed remains one of the recognized national heroes
of the Nigerian nation. General Olusegun Obasanjo succeeded Mohammed
as Nigerias military head of state, until October 1979, and subsequently was
elected to a term as the countrys civilian president, serving from May 1999 to
May 2007.
Further Reading
Campbell, John. Nigeria: Dancing on the Brink. Plymouth, England: Rowman & Littlefield, 2010.
El-Rufai, Nasir. The Accidental Public Servant. Seattle, WA: CreateSpace, 2011.
Osaghae, Eghosa. Crippled Giant: Nigeria Since Independence. Bloomington, IN: Indiana
University Press, 1998.
333
334
M O N D L A N E , E D U A R D O C H I VA M B O
Eduardo Mondlane was born on June 20, 1920, at Manjacaze, in Gaza Province, the fourth of 16 sons sired by a Tsonga tribal chieftain. He worked as a
shepherd through early adolescence, while completing his primary education
at local schools, then enrolled at a Swiss-Presbyterian college in South Africas
Transvaal Province. From there, Mondlane proceeded to study at the Jan Hofmeyer School of Social Work and Johannesburgs University of the Witwatersrand, until the institution of apartheid resulted in expulsion of that schools
black students in 1949. The following year, Mondlane enrolled at the University of Lisbon, then transferred to Ohios Oberlin College in 1951. He graduated in 1953, with a degree in anthropology and sociology, before pursuing
doctoral studies at Northwestern University in Illinois, finally obtaining his
PhD from Harvard University.
By 1957, Mondlane was back in Africa, working as a researcher for the
Trusteeship Department of the United Nations (UN). The UNs ban on overt
political activity cramped his style, and Mondlane soon resigned to serve as an
assistant professor of anthropology at New Yorks Syracuse University, developing the schools East African Studies Program. In 1963, Mondlane left that post
and moved to Tanzania, immersing himself full-time in his homelands struggle
for independence with FRELIMO, founded the previous year. He arrived in the
second year of the Mozambican War of Independence, and was soon elected as
FRELIMOs president, operating from Dar es Salaam.
Mondlanes majority faction supported guerrilla war against Portuguese
colonial authorities, coupled with a campaign to establish Mozambique as a
socialist society. Opponents within FRELIMO, led by Lazaro Nkavandame
and Uria Simango, opposed a radical overhaul of Mozambican society
or, in the view of their critics, supported replacement of the ruling white
elite with a black FRELIMO elite. A party congress held in July 1968 chose
the socialist position and elected Mondlane to a second term as president,
while the war in Mozambique continued. Some historians believe that vote
prompted supporters of Nkavandame and Simango to assassinate Mondlane
seven months later.
Others blame Portugals Polcia Internacional e de Defesa do Estado (PIDE:
International and State Defense Police) for Mondlanes murder. Founded in
1945, the PIDE changed its title shortly after Mondlanes assassination, becoming the General Security Directorate (DGS). Mozambiques liberation
struggle continued until September 8, 1974, when a ceasefire was declared
with negotiations proceeding toward independence in June 1975. That victory was occasioned, at least in part, by Portugals own Carnation Revolution of April 1974, which deposed the dictatorship established in 1926.
Peace remained elusive, however, as civil war erupted in Mozambique during May 1977 and continued through October 1992, claiming an estimated
one million lives.
Further Reading
Finnegan, William. A Complicated War: The Harrowing of Mozambique. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1993.
Mondlane, Eduardo. The Struggle for Mozambique. Harmondsworth, United Kingdom:
Penguin Books, 1969.
Saul, John. Invasion from the Outside? The Roots and Resolution of Mozambiques
Un/Civil War. In Civil Wars in Africa: Roots and Resolution. Montreal: McGill-Queens
University Press, 1999.
335
336
M O R O, A L D O
the U.S. Supreme Court in April 1951. Seven months later, while transporting
two of the defendants from prison to court, sheriff Willis McCall shot both at
close range, killing one and gravely wounding the other. Survivor Walter Irvin
was convicted and condemned a second time; his sentence was later commuted to life, with parole granted in 1968.
Moores civil rights campaigns and the Groveland case sparked a revival of
the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) in Florida, producing a reign of terror against blacks,
Catholics, and Jews. Florida suffered 11 racist bombings in 1951, before the
blast that killed the Moores, plus several botched attempts and other KKK
crimes including homicides and floggings. Sheriff McCallan open Klan supporter, if not an actual memberescaped indictment in the 1951 shootings
and remained in office until 1972, when Governor Reuben Askew suspended
him for beating a black prisoner to death in the Lake County jail. Around the
same time, author Stetson Kennedy named McCall as a suspect in the Moore
bombing, but insufficient evidence existed to indict him.
Florida attorney general Charles Crist Jr. reopened Moores case in 2005, announcing the results of his investigation in August 2006. That report named
four deceased KKK members as suspects in the case. They included: Earl
Brooklyn and Tillman Belvin, both of whom died from natural causes within
a year of the bombing; Joseph Neville Cox, alleged ringleader of the plot, who
committed suicide after an FBI interview in 1952; and Edward Spivey, a Klansman who implicated Cox prior to dying from cancer in 1978.
See also: Ku Klux Klan (1866 ).
Further Reading
Green, Ben. Before His Time: The Untold Story of Harry T. Moore, Americas First Civil
Rights Martyr. New York: The Free Press, 1999.
Newton, Michael. The Invisible Empire: The Ku Klux Klan in Florida. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2001.
Saunders, Robert. Bridging the Gap: Continuing the Florida NAACP Legacy of Harry T.
Moore. Tampa, FL: University of Tampa Press, 2000.
M O R O, A L D O
337
338
M O R O, A L D O
(sentenced to life, released in 1994). Confessed triggerman Mario Moretti remained at large until 1981, then received six life sentences but was paroled in
1998. Barbara Balzerani, arrested in 1985, received a life term and was paroled
in 2006. Rita Algranati, extradited from Egypt in 2004, remains in custody at
the time of this writing.
Conspiracy theories surrounding Moros murder include accusations directed at the secret Masonic lodge Propaganda Due (P2), linked to terrorist
activities worldwide and sometimes described as a shadow state within Italy.
Other students of the case claim that the Red Brigades were infiltrated by the
U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) or by agents of NATOs Operation Gladio, ostensibly to discredit leftist elements and the Soviet Union by promoting
random acts of terrorism. In 2005, former Christian Democracy vice-secretary
RED BRIGADES
Founded in 1970, the Brigate Rosse (Red Brigades) was a leftist organization based in Italy, initially pledged to creation of a revolutionary
state and Italys withdrawal from the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Modeled on Latin American guerrilla movements, the movements
motto was embodied in the title of its official newspaper: Mai piu Senza
Fusile (Never without a Gun). The Red Brigades began their campaign of armed struggle by sabotaging factories and staged their first
kidnappingof a factory foremanin 1972. The group committed its
first homicides in June 1974, killing two members of the neo-fascist Italian Social Movement in Padua. Police captured Red Brigades founders
Renato Curcio and Alberto Franceschini three months later, resulting in
18-year prison terms. Notoriety from that case helped the group expand,
and its activities expanded into robbery, drug, and arms trafficking. Rightwing extremist groups responded in kind, sparking an era known in
Italy as the Years of Lead, with some 2,000 murders, plus thousands of
bombings, armed robberies, kidnappings, nonfatal shootings, and other
terrorist actions through 1981. In that year, the Red Brigades split into
two rival factions, the Communist Combatant Party (PCC) and the Union
of Combatant Communists (UCC). Both apparently dissolved in 1988,
but a new incarnationthe Red Brigades-PCCclaimed credit for two
political murders in 20022003. Five members received life prison terms
for those slayings in June 2005. In October 2007, police charged former
Red Brigades commander Cristoforo Piancone with stealing C170,000 in
a bank robbery, while he was free on a good conduct parole from a previous conviction.
Giovanni Galloni claimed that Moro, prior to his abduction, had described
infiltration and manipulation of the Red Brigades by CIA agents and operatives of Israels Mossad intelligence network. Similar charges of infiltration have
been labeled at traditional Italian crime syndicates, including the Sicilian Mafia
and Calabrias Ndrangheta, although neither qualifies as a left-wing or revolutionary organization.
Further Reading
Alexander, Yonah, and Dennis Pluchinsky. Europes Red Terrorists: The Fighting Communist Organizations. London: Routledge, 1992.
Drake, Richard. The Aldo Moro Murder Case. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
Press, 1996.
Katz, Robert. Days of Wrath: The Ordeal of Aldo Moro, the Kidnapping, the Execution, the
Aftermath. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1980.
Sciasia, Leonardo. The Moro Affair. New York: New York Review Books, 1978.
339
340
Mayor George Moscone was assassinated by retired Supervisor of the Board, Dan White
on November 27, 1978. (Bettmann/Corbis)
as Majority Leader. Voters reelected Moscone to the senate in 1970 and 1974.
His most noteworthy achievement was a bill repealing Californias old sodomy
law, which gave him a crucial advantage in San Franciscos 1975 mayoral race.
Unexpected support in that campaign came from the Peoples Temple, an
ostensibly liberal church with a mostly black congregation, led by white minister James Warren Jones. In return for that support, which helped carry certain minority precincts by 12-to-1 margins over Moscones Republican rival,
Moscone appointed Jones as chairman of the San Francisco Housing Commission. That move backfired in August 1977, when a media investigation of the
Temple revealed apparent criminal activity. Jones and most of his followers
decamped to Guyana, where the sectnow branded a cultcommitted mass
suicide nine days before Moscones murder in San Francisco. While the initial
investigation was still under way, defeated mayoral candidate John Barbagelata
agitated for a recall vote against Moscone, but Moscone easily survived that
challenge.
Dan Whites criminal defense at trial included claims that a change in his
diet, from healthy food to Twinkies and other sugary snacks, exacerbated his
depression and made him prone to explosive violence. Whatever its impact
on the jury, derisive comments concerning the Twinkie defense certainly
stimulated public condemnation of Californias statute concerning diminished
M O S H A R R A F, K H A L E D
341
342
M O U N T BAT T E N, LO U I S FR A N C I S A L B E R T V I C TO R N I C H O L A S G E O RG E
M O U N T B AT T E N , L O U I S F R A N C I S A L B E R T V I C T O R N I C H O L A S G E O R G E
saying: This operation is one of the discriminate ways we can bring to the attention of the English people the continuing occupation of our country.
Louis Mountbatten was born in Windsor, England, as His Serene Highness
Prince Louis of Battenberg, on June 25, 1900. His father, Prince Louis Alexander of Battenberg, served 45 years in the British Navy, rising to First Sea Lord
of the Admiralty in 1912, but subsequent hostilities with Germany forced his
demotion and retirement. In 1917, Britains royal family cut all overt German
ties and changed their surname to Windsor. Prince Louis Alexander then became Louis Mountbatten, Marquess of Milford Haven, and his son became
Lord Louis Mountbatten. Tutored at home to age 10, young Louis later attended Britains Naval Cadet School and joined the Royal Navy as a midshipman in World War I. Following the armistice, he studied engineering at Christs
College, Cambridge, followed by training at the Portsmouth Signal School in
1924, before he returned to the navy. In 1926, he was appointed assistant fleet
wireless and signals officer of the Mediterranean Fleet, promoted three years
later to senior wireless instructor. His first command, of a destroyer in the Pacific, came in 1934. Two years later, Mountbatten was appointed to the Admiralty at Whitehall as a member of the Fleet Air Arm.
Lord Mountbatten served with distinction and controversy during World
War II, first as commander of the 5th Destroyer Flotilla. German bombers sank
his ship, HMS Kelly, during the evacuation of Crete, on May 23, 1941. Five
months later, he was named to serve as chief of Combined Operations Headquarters, a post from which he organized the bungled Dieppe Raid of August
19, 1942, sacrificing 3,367 Canadian troops in a futile invasion of occupied
France. Another of Mountbattens brainstorms, Project Habakkuk, sought
to construct an invincible aircraft carrier from pykretea mixture of wood
pulp and icewhich was ultimately found to be impractical because of the
enormous production resources required and technical difficulties involved.
Despite those failures, Prime Minister Winston Churchill named Mountbatten
as Supreme Allied Commander of the South East Asia Command in October
1943; he remained in that post until the unit was dissolved in November 1946.
From there, Mountbatten was appointed as the last viceroy and governorgeneral of India, charged with supervising the transition from British India to
an independent nation by 1948. In fact, Indian independence was achieved in
August 1947, but for an unexpected cause, as Muslim portions of the country seceded to become East and West Pakistan. Winston Churchill, formerly a
great admirer of Mountbatten, was so angered by the viceroys roll in severing a
major portion of the British Empire that the two men never spoke again.
From India, Mountbatten moved on to command a cruiser squadron in the
Mediterranean Fleet (19481950), served as Fourth Sea Lord of the Admiralty
(19501952), as commander in chief of the Mediterranean Fleet (19521955),
and, finally, in his fathers old post as First Sea Lord of the Admiralty (19551959).
343
344
Later, in civilian life, he served as president of the United World Colleges Organization (19681978) and as governor of the Isle of Wight (19691974). In a life
of historic attainments, it comes as no surprise that Lord Mountbatten also had
detractors. Philip Ziegler, author of Mountbattens official biography, wrote: His
vanity, though child-like, was monstrous, his ambition unbridled. The truth, in
his hands, was swiftly converted from what it was, to what it should have been.
He sought to rewrite history with cavalier indifference to the facts to magnify his
own achievements. There was a time when I became so enraged by what I began
to feel was his determination to hoodwink me that I found it necessary to place
on my desk a notice saying: REMEMBER, IN SPITE OF EVERYTHING, HE WAS
A GREAT MAN.
Following Mountbattens assassination, authorities identified the bomber as
PIRA member Thomas McMahon, who crept aboard the Shadow V the night
before its final sail, to plant a radio-controlled bomb. Ironically, McMahon was
arrested two hours before the explosion, by Garda officers who suspected him
of driving a stolen car. Forensics experts found flecks of paint from the boat
and traces of nitroglycerine on his clothes, resulting in McMahons conviction
and imposition of a life prison term on November 23, 1979. He was released
in 1988, under the Good Friday Agreement crafted to advance the Northern
Ireland peace process.
Further Reading
Butler, David. Lord Mountbatten: The Last Viceroy. New York: Pocket Books, 1986.
Knatchbull, Timothy. From a Clear Blue Sky: Surviving the Mountbatten Bomb. London:
Hutchinson, 2009.
Ziegler, Philip. Mountbatten: The Official Biography. Glasgow: William Collins, 1985.
345
346
Nine days after Italys surrender, on September 12, 1943, German commandos rescued Mussolini from captivity at the Hotel Campo Imperatore, at Gran
Sasso dItalia. Adolf Hitler planned to arrest Victor Emmanuel III and Marshal
Badoglio, but they eluded him while Allied forces proceeded with the liberation of Italy. Under pressure from Hitler, Mussolini returned to Italy, acting
under Nazi orders to revive his fascist government. On arrival, he announced,
I am not here to renounce even a square meter of state territory. We will go
back to war for this. And we will rebel against anyone for this. Where the Italian flag flew, the Italian flag will return. And where it has not been lowered,
now that I am here, no one will have it lowered. I have said these things to the
Fhrer.
Over the next two years, Mussolini lived at Gargnano, on Lake Garda, operating as a puppet of Berlin. He supervised the executions of former fascists
who had turned against him, but was fatalistic in his outlook, telling an interviewer in January 1945, Seven years ago, I was an interesting person. Now, I am
little more than a corpse. Yes, madam, I am finished. My star has fallen. I have
no fight left in me. I work and I try, yet know that all is but a farce. I await the
end of the tragedy andstrangely detached from everythingI do not feel any
more an actor. I feel I am the last of spectators.
Following his execution and the desecration of his corpse, Mussolini was
buried in an unmarked grave north of Milan. Neo-fascists located the grave
and stole his body on Easter Sunday 1946, leaving a message at the site that
read: Finally, O Duce, you are with us. We will cover you with roses, but the
smell of your virtue will overpower the smell of those roses. Authorities recovered Mussolinis remains in August 1946 and held them for 10 months, before
he was interred at his birthplace in Predappio. His crypt is flanked by marble
fasces and an idealized sculpture of Il Duce in life.
Mussolinis political philosophy and melodramatic mode of self-expression
made him a target of satire in life, beginning with Charlie Chaplins 1940 film
The Great Dictator. Chaplin starred as tyrant Adenoid Hynkel, clearly modeled on Adolf Hitler, and co-star Jack Oakie mocked Mussolini in the role of
Benzino Napaloni. A year later, Il Duce was also lampooned by the Three
Stooges in Ill Never Heil Again, with Cy Schindell appearing as Chizzolini,
in conjunction with dictator-ally Moe Hailstone (played by Moe Howard),
Field Marshal Herring (Curly Howard), and Larry Fine cast as a minister of
propaganda modeled on Joseph Goebbels.
Serious portrayals of Mussolini on-screen include two by Rod Steiger in
Mussolini: The Last Act (1974) and Lion of the Desert (1981). Other portrayals include Mussolini: The Untold Story (1985), produced for television with
George C. Scott in the title role; Mussolini and I (1985), with Bob Hoskins cast
as Il Duce and Susan Sarandon portraying his daughter; Benito (1993) with
Antonio Bander, which depicts Mussolinis early years from his service as a
347
348
FASCISM
Although definitions of fascism vary, most sources agree that its major
tenets include extreme right-wing nationalism, an authoritarian or totalitarian state, aggressive militarism, xenophobia and racism, enforcement
of societal conformity, and state control or domination of a mixed economy (with regulation shared by government and wealthy private interests). Whereas fascisms ideology has its roots in the late 19th century, the
first self-styled fascist party appeared in October 1914, when a breakaway faction of the Italian Socialist Party created the Revolutionary Fascio for International Action. Fascism draws its name from the Latin fasces
(bundle)specifically a bundle of birch rods surrounding a bronze axe,
carried as a symbol of authority in ancient Rome. Variant forms of fascism include German National Socialism (Nazism) and its successor ideologies, as well as Spanish Falangism, exemplified by dictator Francisco
Franco. The Great Depression of the 1930s encouraged fascisms spread,
rejuvenating the economies of various nations through militarization and
foreign conquest, seizing upon author Randolph Bournes assertion that
war is the health of the state. Fascism survived the defeat of the Axis
Powers in World War II, surviving for decades in Spain and Portugal,
in Latin America (where fugitive Nazis found refuge), and elsewhere as
Allied victors actively encouraged far-right military governments in opposition to communism. Fascism also influenced the postwar apartheid
regime in South Africa, and various anti-Israeli groups in the Middle East,
including Lebanons Kataeb or Phalange Party, and the revolutionary Arab
nationalist philosophy known as Baathism, adapted by dictator Saddam
Hussein in Iraq.
teacher to the outbreak of World War I; and Tea with Mussolini (1999) with
Claudio Spadaros appearance as the dictator.
Further Reading
Bosworth, R.J.B. Mussolini. New York: Bloomsbury Academic Press, 2011.
Finaldi, Giuseppe. Mussolini and Italian Fascism. Harlow, United Kingdom: Pearson
Education Limited, 2008.
Garibaldi, Luciano. Mussolini: The Secrets of his Death. New York: Enigma Books, 2004.
Hibbert, Christopher. Mussolini: The Rise and Fall of Il Duce. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.
Morgan, Philip. The Fall of Mussolini: Italy, the Italians, and the Second World War. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.
Moseley, Ray. Mussolini: The Last 600 Days of Il Duce. Dallas: Taylor Trade Publishing,
2004.
Saunders, Frances. The Woman Who Shot Mussolini. New York: Metropolitan Books,
2010.
349
N
DER SHA
H AFSHA
R (16881747)
NA
In June 1747, Nader Shah Afsharrenowned as the Napoleon of Persia and
the Second Alexanderset off from Tabriz, then capital of Persia (now Iran),
to purge Kurdish rebels from the northeastern province of Khorasan. By the
time his army reached Fathabad, Nader had learned that one of his officesin
fact, his nephewwas plotting to depose him. Fearing that other officers had
joined in the conspiracy, Nader planned a preemptive strike, quietly recruiting
Turkmen and Uzbek soldiers from his ranks to massacre the Persian officers on
the night of June 19. Unknown to Nader, one of his Georgian slaves heard the
order given and reported it to the shahs would-be victims. An officer named
Salah Beg (or Bey) volunteered to kill Nader before the shahs assassins could
strike. Leading several confederates to Naders tent, Beg attacked, killing two
of shahs attendants before Nader confronted them with his saber in hand.
Although wounded in the first exchange of blows, Nader fought on, killing two
of his assailants, before he tripped on a tent rope and fell. Nader reportedly
pled for his life, whereupon Beg replied, You have not shown any mercy, and
therefore merit none, then beheaded the shah with a single sword stroke.
Accounts of Nader Shahs birth are confused, with reported dates ranging
from October 22, 1687, to August 6, 1698. Most agree that he was born in the
fortress at Dastgerd, in Khorasan Province, and named Nader Kouli. His family
belonged to the Qereqlu clan of the seminomadic Afshar tribe, a subgroup of
the Oghuz Turks. His father, a herdsman, died when Nader was 13. Four years
later, a band of Uzbek Tartar marauders enslaved Nader and his mother, but
Nader soon escaped, joining a rival band of outlaws. Despite his youth, based
on ferocity and cunning, Nader rose to lead the gang, while his mother languished and died in captivity.
Tiring of life as a fugitive by 1712, Nader approached a local chieftain, Baba
Ali Beg (or Baig), to seek employment. Beg retained him as a courier, delivering messages to the royal court at Isfahan with a companion, but Nader was
determined to be the chiefs sole messenger. On one trip to the shahs court,
Beg killed his coworker, then pled self-defense before Sultan Shah Hussein
and received a pardon. Chief Beg was less forgiving, when Nader returned
alone, and Nader surmised that he was marked for execution. Speaking either
from the heart or from self-interest, Nader proposed marriage to one of Begs
352
N A D E R S H A H A F S H A R
daughters, but the chief refused him. Nader then followed a practice that became his trademark, striking first to kill Beg, before fleeing to the mountains
with his fiance (some accounts say two). Other servants of the late chief followed Nader, forming his latest bandit gang to terrorize Mazandaran Province.
After two years of looting and murder, in 1714, Nader offered his services to
Babulu Khan, the governor of Khorasan Province. He proved himself in battle
against Tartar invaders, and by 1717 was placed in command of a 6,000-man
army, defeating a Tartar force that outnumbered his troops nearly two to one.
Idolizing Mongol warlords Genghis Khan and Tamerlane, Nader secured his
triumph with a combination of audacity and strategic planning that set him
apart from other regional commanders of the day. When he demanded promotion to a generals rank, however, Babulu Khan put him off, first requiring that
Nader seek approval from Shah Sultan Hussein, then promoting a younger,
less experienced officer in his place. When Nader accused Babulu Khan of acting dishonorably, he was subjected to falakaa form of torture where the victim is placed in stocks and beaten across the soles of his feetthen exiled in
disgrace.
Nader returned immediately to a life of crime, leading a band of some 800
brigands to loot villages in Khorasan Province, later extracting tribute payments
to ward off future pillage. In March 1722, Afghan invaders led by Mahmud Hotaki defeated Persian troops at the Battle of Gulnabad and captured Sultan Hussein; they then moved on from there to besiege and capture the Safavid Empires
capital at Isfahan. In Khorasan Province, Nader feigned subservience to the new
Afghan governor, Malek Mahmud, then raised an army to revolt against the intruders. A long war ensued, Nader joining forces with the sons of Sultan Hussein, defeating larger Afghan forces in a series of engagements at Herat (May
1729), Damghan (September 1729), and Murchakhort (November 1729).
Afghans were not Naders only enemies, however. In the spring of 1730, he
attacked Ottomans who had seized part of Persia after the Afghan invasion,
recapturing most of his homelands lost territory by 1733. In the process, he
also schemed to assassinate fellow general Fateh Ali Khan Khajar, a favorite of
Sultan Husseins son, Shah Tehmas. Tehmas then favored Nader with the title
of Khan, but Naders gratitude did not extend to the royal family at large.
At odds with another of Husseins sons, appointed successor Shah Tahmasp,
Nader lured Tahmasp into a drinking contest in 1732, then mocked him before the royal court, asking if a drunkard was fit to rule Persia. Rather than risk
his life in a war against Nader, Tahmasp abdicated in favor of his infant son,
Abbas III, whom Nader served as regent and de facto ruler. When Abbas died
in 1736, Nader ascended to the throne as shah, hailed on newly minted coins
as King of Kings and Glory of the Age.
Unsatisfied with the scope of his realm, Nader raised an army of 80,000 men
and marched for India in December 1736. He captured Kandahar in March
1738, razing that city in the process, building a new town nearby, which he
named Naderabad. From there, he moved on to capture Ghazni, Kabul, Peshawar, Sindh, and Lahore, then crossed the Indus River, killing an estimated
20,000 Indian soldiers at the Battle of Karnal, in February 1739. A month
later, amid false rumors that Nader had been assassinated, his troops entered
Delhi, killing 200,000 men, women, and children in the nations capital. Captive ruler Mohammad Shah surrendered the keys to his national treasury, and
suffered further humiliation when Nader seized the empires famed Peacock
Throne. English historians estimate that Naders total haul from the Indian
campaign was valued in excess of 85.5 million at the time (6.7 trillion today,
or $7.1 trillion).
While looting India, Nader left his son Reza Qoli Mirza to rule Persia. Believing rumors of his fathers death in battle, Mirza laid plans to rule in his own
right, then saw them dashed when Nader returned alive. Mirza then hired an
Afghan to assassinate his father, but the sniper missed his shot, only wounding
Nader in the arm. A full-scale inquisition followed, exposing Mirzas treachery.
Nader showed his version of mercy to Mirza, sparing his life, but having his
firstborn blinded and castrated.
So it went, with successive purges of Naders royal court and army, until
none of his closest advisors felt they could trust him. After his assassination,
nephew Ali Qoli claimed the Persian throne, renaming himself Adil Shah
(righteous king). A likely suspect in the plot to kill his uncle, Adil Shah was
deposed in June 1748 and was blinded by coup leader Ebrahim Mirza. Six
months later, Naders grandson Shahrukh toppled Mirza and had him blinded,
and Adil Shah was tortured to death.
Further Reading
Axworthy, Michael. The Sword of Persia: Nader Shah, from Tribal Warrior to Conquering
Tyrant. London: I.B. Tauris, 2006.
Floor, Willem. The Rise and Fall of Nader Shah: Dutch East India Company Reports,
17301747. Waldorf, MD: Mage Publishers, 2009.
Tucker, Ernest. Nadir Shahs Quest for Legitimacy in Post-SafavidIran. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2006.
353
354
met a similar fate, gunned down at point-blank range by teenage student Abdul
Khaliq Hazara. Guards captured Hazara at the scene, quickly discovering that
he had sought revenge for the execution of his father, ordered by the king in
1932. After 40 days of torture, Hazara was condemned to public execution. A
sword wielding executioner demanded to know which finger he had used to
pull the pistols trigger, which eye he had aimed with, and with which foot he
stepped forward prior to firing. When Hazara answered, the executioner cut
off that finger and foot, gouged out his eye, then proceeded to dismember him
alive. Several relatives of the assassin were also tortured and hanged as suspected accomplices to the kings slaying.
Mohammed Nadir Shah was born on April 9, 1883, at Dehradun India,
then subject to the British Raj. He was a member of the Mohammadzai clan
(sons of Mohammed in Pashto), grandson of Sultan Mohammed Khan Telai
(17951861), who served as chief minister of Afghanistan during 18241826.
At age 18, Nadir returned to his ancestral homeland and joined the Afghan army,
rising through the ranks to serve as a general under King Amanullah Khan during the brief Third Anglo-Afghan War (May 6 to August 8, 1919). Following the
armistice in that conflict, Amanullah Khan named Nader as his minister of war.
King Amanullah, meanwhile, embarked on a course of reform designed to
modernize Afghanistan, including establishment of a small air force staffed by
pilots from the newly emergent Soviet Union. At the same time, Amanullah
changed recruiting standards for the army, stripping tribal leaders of their
influence on the selection of recruits. Turkish advisors urged the king to retire his older army officers, promoting younger and more professional replacements; Nadir objected, counseling mindfulness of longstanding tribal
traditions. When Amanullah spurned his advice, in 1924, Nadir resigned as
minister of war and left Afghanistan to serve as its ambassador to France.
In Nadirs absence, during 1927, Amanullah embarked on an extended
tour of Europe, collecting even more ideas for the improvement of his country. Shortly after his return, in November 1928, dissident Shinwari tribesmen
rebelled in Jalalabad and marched on Kabul, prompting many royal troops to
desert and join the revolt. On January 14, 1929, Amanullah abdicated in favor
of elder brother Inayatullah Khan, who ruled as king for three days, then fled to
exile in Europe. Kabul fell on January 17 to Habibullah Kalakani, a Tajik tribesman who ruled as Emir of Afghanistan until October 16, 1929, when troops led
by Nadir Khan recaptured Kabul. Nadir installed himself as king that same day,
hanging Kalakani, his brother, and 10 other rebel leaders on November 1.
Nadirs four-year reign as king was an exercise in despotism. His first act
involved abolition of most reforms imposed by Amanullah Khan, which
strengthened tribal leaders to Nadirs detriment. The royal army, though triumphant over Habibullah Kalakani, remained relatively weak by comparison to
tribal forces still resentful of the monarchy and its ties to the Soviet Union. One
NARUTOWICZ, GABRIEL
Uzbek leaders raids across the Russian border prompted a Soviet incursion
in April 1930, and before years end, Nadir faced uprisings by Tajiks in Kabul
Province, as well as Shinwari rebellions farther south. Most were subdued by
late 1931, by Nadirs growing army, but the kings ruthless tactics aggravated
tribal dissatisfaction in the countryside.
In Kabul, meanwhile, Nadir organized a 10-member cabinet and a larger
loyajirga (grand council) of 286 members who formally confirmed his installment as king. In 1931, Nadir promulgated a new constitution in the name of
Allah the most merciful, confirming himself as a fit and worthy King who
was accepted by the Afghan nation in general . . . with the greatest esteem and
respect. Nadirs subjects were free to enjoy all rights conferred by Shariat [Islamic] law, although they were required to observe the injunctions and prohibitions of their Government in religious and political matters. Torture was
absolutely abolished, at least on paper, and freedom of the press was granted
to publications such as are not against religion.
In practice, conflict with regional tribes continued, and executions of offenders ultimately paved the way for Nadirs own assassination after four years on the
throne. His son and successor, Mohammed Zahir Shah, proved more durable, ruling as Afghanistans last monarch from November 8, 1933, until July 17, 1973,
when a coup dtat, deposed him. At the time, Zahir was in Italy, undergoing eye
surgery. Rather than risk a civil war, he abdicated and remained in exile for the
next 29 years, returning to Afghanistan in 2002. While still abroad, in 1991, Zahir
survived an assassination attempt by a knife-wielding assailant posing as a Portuguese reporter. Zahir died in Kabul, from natural causes, on July 23, 2007.
Further Reading
Baker, Kevin. War in Afghanistan: A Short History of Eighty Wars and Conflicts in Afghanistan and the Northwest Frontier, 18392011. Kenthurst, NSW, Australia: Rosenberg
Publishing, 2011.
How did Nadir accede to the throne? Afghana! http://afghana.com/SocietyAndCulture/amanula.htm.
Mohammad Nader Shah. Encyclopdia Iranica. http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/
mohammad-nader-shah-king-of-afghanistan.
Tanner, Stephen. Afghanistan: A Military History from Alexander the Great to the War
against the Taliban. Philadelphia: Da Capo Press, 2009.
Tomsen, Peter. The Wars of Afghanistan: Messianic Terrorism, Tribal Conflicts, and the
Failures of Great Powers. New York: Public Affairs, 2011.
355
356
NARUTOWICZ, GABRIEL
NARUTOWICZ, GABRIEL
buildings, more than 300 bridges, and 125 miles of highway. During the same
hectic period, he oversaw construction of several dams, hydroelectric power
plant at Porabka, and extensive work to control Polands longest and most
important river, the Vistula. As if that were not enough, in April and May 1922
he joined Minister of Foreign Affairs Konstanty Skirmunt at the Genoa Conference, where representatives of 34 countries met to discuss postwar economic
collaboration.
On June 28, 1922, Narutowicz became minister of foreign affairs under
Prime Minister Artur Sliwinski,
357
358
N D A D AY E , M E L C H I O R
N D A D AY E , M E L C H I O R
groups, under the rule of Burundis Supreme Revolutionary Council, led since
November 1976 by Colonel Jean-Baptiste Bagaza.
While traveling in Europe, on September 3, 1987, Bagaza was deposed by
a rival military faction that imposed its own dictatorship over Burundi. Ndadayes FRODEBU continued covert operations under President Pierre Buyoya appointed, while HutuTutsi violence persisted, claiming another 20,000 lives
in August 1988 alone. Buyoya appointed a commission to mediate those conflicts, resulting in a new constitution that Buyoya approved in 1992, mandating
ethnic balance in a government run by a president and parliament. National
elections were scheduled for June 1993, and Ndadaye challenged President
Buyoya, winning 65 percent of the vote from a coalition of four Hutudominated political parties.
International observers certified the voting as free and fair, an endorsement echoed later in June, when legislative elections gave 65 of 81 available
parliamentary seats to FRODEBU members. Tutsi opponents voiced no complaints at the time, although a coup dtat against president-elect Ndadaye was
attemptedand swiftly defeatedon July 3, 1993. Inaugurated one week
later, Ndadaye thus became Burundis first Hutu president and its first leader
elected by democratic process.
Well aware of his homelands bitter ethnic divisions, President Ndadaye
charted a moderate, conciliatory course for governance. He appointed female
Tutsi leader Sylvie Kinigi as prime minister on July 10, while granting one-third
of his cabinet seats and two regional governorships to members of Pierre Buyoya UPRONA. At the same time, Ndadaye liberated most of Burundis political
prisoners, declared unfettered freedom of the press, and granted amnesty to
exiled Jean-Baptiste Bagaza. Moves to ameliorate longstanding Tutsi discrimination against Hutus progressed at a cautious pace, to avert further bloodshed.
None of it helped.
When President Ndadaye challenged sweetheart contracts and concessions
granted to Tutsis by politicians from their own tribe, members of the Tutsi
militaryindustrial elite balked and schemed against him. Military reforms
further aggravated high-ranking Tutsi officers, and the return of exiled Hutus
driven from the country in the 1970s raised specters of impending vengeance.
Burundis new free press divided along ethnic lines, each side hurling inflammatory charges at the other. In such an atmosphere, the coup that claimed
Ndadayes life was probably inevitable.
An estimated 100,000 persons died in ethnic violence following the coup
of October 1993, but the military plotters failed to seize control of Burundi
as planned. A military committee of Public Salvation chose a Hutu, former
minister of the interior Franois Ngeze, as head of state, but he ruled for only
four days, then persuaded Prime Minister Kinigi to emerge from hiding at
the French embassy and assume the post of acting president. Meanwhile, the
359
360
N D A D AY E , M E L C H I O R
United Nations condemned Ndadayes assassination and launched an investigation into the coup, releasing a report in 1996 that blamed Tutsi army commanders for the assassinations and subsequent Hutu massacres. Meanwhile,
Burundi had descended into civil war between Hutus and Tutsis (see sidebar),
claiming an estimated 300,000 more lives before hostilities officially ended in
August 2005. Establishment of a national army, merging Hutu and Tutsi armed
forces, appeared to quell the violence, but sporadic outbreaks continueas
when Hutu rebels from the National Forces of Liberation bombarded Bujumbura in April 2008, killing 33 persons.
While the civil war was still ongoing, in May 1999, authorities tried 117
defendants on charges related to President Ndadaye assassination. Alleged
ringleader Paul Kamana and four others were sentenced to death, although
Kamana was then in exile and safe from execution. Another 74 defendants
received prison terms ranging from one to 20 years, and 38 were acquitted.
Those discharged by the court included Colonel Jean Bikomagu, the armys
former chief of staff; Colonel Charles Ntakije, former minister of defense; and
Colonel Isaie Nibizi, who had charge of the presidents security detachment
during the fatal coup.
Further Reading
Abdallah, Ahmedou. Burundi on the Brink, 199395: A UN Special Envoy Reflects on
Preventive Diplomacy. Washington, DC: United States Institute for Peace, 2000.
Burundi Civil War. GlobalSecurity.org. http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/
war/burundi.htm.
Chronology for Hutus in Burundi. Minorities at Risk. http://www.cidcm.umd.edu/
mar/chronology.asp?groupId=51601.
Lemarchand, Ren. Burundi: Ethnic Conflict and Genocide. Cambridge, MA: Woodrow
Wilson Center Press, 1996.
Mwakikagile, Godfrey. Burundi: The Hutu and the TutsiCauldron of Conflict and Quest
for Dynamic Compromise. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: New Africa Press, 2012.
Mwakikagile, Godfrey. Identity Politics and Ethnic Conflicts in Rwanda and Burundi:
A Comparative Study. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: New Africa Press, 2012.
Scherrer, Christian. Genocide and Crisis in Central Africa: Conflict Roots, Mass Violence,
and Regional War. Westport, CT: Praeger, 2001.
United Nations Security Council. International Commission of Inquiry for Burundi: Final
Report. June 7, 2002. http://www.usip.org/files/file/resources/collections/commis
sions/Burundi-Report.pdf.
Uvin, Peter. Life after Violence: A Peoples Story of Burundi. New York: Macmillan, 2009.
361
362
and kept under close surveillance after he asked French leaders to create a
Vietnamese legislature.
Formally unemployed over the next decade, Diem saw opportunity in the
Japanese invasion of French Indochina. In 1942, he lobbied Japanese occupation forces to declare Vietnamese independence, but they ignored his please.
Diem then founded a resistance group of sorts, the Association for the Restoration of Great Vietnam, which led to issuance of a warrant for his arrest in summer 1944. Disguised as a Japanese officer, Diem escaped to Saigon and made
one last effort to collaborate with the invaders in early 1945. The Japanese offered Diem the post of prime minister in a puppet regime under Emperor Bao
Dai, their parting gift to Vietnam, but he first declined, then changed his mind
too late, after the post was filled by Tran Trong Kim. Diem thus accidentally
escaped arrest as a collaborator when the Japanese withdrew, but his problems
were not over.
Whereas Diem had sought accommodation with his homelands enemies,
resistance leader Nguyen Sinh Cungbetter known to history as Ho Chi
Minhhad fought the Japanese at every turn. In September 1945, Ho declared
a Democratic Republic of Vietnam and turned his Viet Minh army against
French colonial forces. Diem embarked for Hue, hoping he could dissuade Bao
Dai from joining Ho Chi Minh, but he was arrested in transit and was held for
six months, during which he nearly died from a combination of virulent diseases. At liberty again in 1946, as conflict between the French and Viet Minh
erupted into full-scale war, Diem settled in Saigon and cofounded the Vietnam
National Alliance, calling on France to grant dominion status for his homeland. Although that effort ultimately failed, Diem gathered enough support
to be taken seriously in Paris, where diplomats sought his help in persuading
Emperor Bao Dai to join and endorse their fledgling State of Vietnam in 1949.
By 1950, Ho Chi Minh had sentenced Diem to death in absentia, and an attempt on his life that same year drove Diem into exile, first at the Vatican, then
in Japan.
Both sides in Vietnam requested aid from the United States, and although
President Harry Truman rejected overtures from Ho Chi Minh to expel French
colonial forces, the outbreak of war in Korea encouraged support for an anticommunist regime in Vietnam. Pope Pius XII lobbied European leaders on Diems behalf, and Diem spent the next three years at Cardinal Francis Spellmans
Maryknoll Seminary in Westchester County, New York. Thanks to Spellman,
Diem was named as a consultant to Michigan State Universitys Government
Research Bureau, where he joined Professor Wesley Fishel and various CIA
agents to form the Michigan State University Vietnam Advisory Group, collaborating to save Vietnam from communism.
Viet Minh forces finally defeated the French at Dien Bien Phu, in May 1954,
prompting an international conference in Geneva, Switzerland, to decide the
363
364
political fate of Indochina. That conference divided the former French colony
into three countriesVietnam, Laos, and Cambodiawhile imposing the 17th
parallel as a provisional military demarcation line between North and South
Vietnam, pending reunification with national elections in 1956. Ho Chi Minh,
confident of election based on his wartime record, ruled North Vietnam in the
interim, and Bao Dai named Diem as prime minister of South Vietnam, with
U.S. support. An estimated one million persons, mostly Catholics, left North
Vietnam for the south, and some 52,000 moved north of the 17th parallel.
Diem, meanwhile, had difficulty consolidating his rule in South Vietnam,
despite the influx of Catholic supporters. He quarreled incessantly with General Nguyen Van Hinh, a French citizen installed as army chief of staff by departing French officials; grappled for control of the countryside against large
militias of rival religious sects, the Cao Dai and Hoa Hao; and lost control of
his national police force to Saigons Bien Xuyen crime syndicate, courtesy of
a $1.25 million bribe paid by monsters to Bao Dai. General Hinh attempted
a coup in August 1954, foiled by the CIA, and Diem rebounded with a landslide victory in October 1955, when South Vietnamese voters affirmed him
as prime minister. His triumph was doubly remarkable for obtaining 605,025
votes in Saigon, where only 450,000 voters were registered. Three days later,
on October 26, Diem proclaimed himself president of a new Republic of South
Vietnam. With U.S. support, he cancelled the elections scheduled for 1956,
thereby negating the Geneva Accords.
Over the next eight years, despite occasional sham elections, Diem ruled
South Vietnam as a virtual despot in the French colonial style, filling his top
government posts with Catholic cronies. Although personally corrupt, he made
a show of moralism, banning abortion and prosecuting adulterers, reclaiming
Saigon from the Binh Xuyen gang, and crushing the larger religious militias.
Draconian punishment for various infractions included beheading with a mobile guillotine, towed around rural villages behind an army truck, with Viet
Minh supporters and anticorruption whistleblowers bearing the brunt of execution and torture. Observers estimate that Diems regime killed at least 50,000
persons in that manner, and imprisoning at least 75,000 more.
Increasing opposition to Diem was not limited to the Viet Minh or South Vietnams native National Liberation Front (the Viet Cong). Communist gunman Ha
Minh Tri failed in the first known attempt to kill Diem, on February 22, 1957,
but other attempts followed. On November 11, 1960, Colonel Nguyen Chanh
Thi and Lieutenant Colonel Vuong Van Dong led an abortive coup against
Diem, then fled the country when it failed. On February 27, 1962, two air force
pilotsFirst Lieutenant Pham Phu Quoc and Second Lieutenant Nguyen Van
Custrafed the presidential palace, killing three staffers and wounding 31 others. They missed Diem, however, and whereas Cu escaped to Cambodia, Quoc
was imprisoned until after Diems assassination in November 1963.
Diems final crisis stemmed from his mostly Catholic regimes persistent discrimination against Buddhists, who comprised an estimated 80 percent of the
population. Exclusion of Buddhists from most public service positions, coupled with special concessions to Catholics on taxation and in business, were
among the chief Buddhist complaints. Diem also promoted Catholics to most
command positions in the military, and distributed weapons for counterinsurgency to Catholic villagers, while leaving most Buddhist settlements defenseless against Viet Cong raiders. The Catholic Church remained South Vietnams
largest landowner, and Catholics were exempted from the neo-feudal corve
system of forced labor required by Diems regime from most citizens.
By May 1963, when Buddhist flags were banned from the mostly Buddhist
city of Hue, where Diems elder brother served as Catholic archbishop, South
Vietnam stood on the verge of a religious uprising. Soldiers and police fired on
protesters, killing dozens, later spraying demonstrators with caustic chemical
weapons. Buddhist monk Thich Quang Duc publicly burned himself to death
in Saigon, on June 11, and other fiery protests followed, prompting Diems
sister-in-law to gloat over her pleasure at the Buddhist barbecues. In August,
soldiers raided a pagoda in Saigon, vandalizing it and seizing Ducs cremated
MADAME NHU
Although South Vietnamese president Ngo Dinh Diem never married,
his sister-in-law, wife of presidential brother and chief advisor Ngo Dinh
Nhu, served as the nations de facto First Lady. Born Tran Le Xuan (Tears
of Spring), on August 22, 1924, South Vietnams future Dragon Lady
was yet another Catholic aristocrat whose family had forged alliances with
French colonial administrators. She married Ngo Dinh Nhu in 1943, at
age 18, and rose to power with him in the 1950s, as Nhus brother won
the presidency, taking Nhu along as his chief advisor in a regime notorious for nepotistic cronyism. Under President Diem, Madame Nhus father became South Vietnams ambassador to the United States, and her
mother served as an observer at the United Nations. In 1962, while erecting a monument to the Trung sistersheroines of an ancient rebellion
against ChinaMadame Nhu insisted that the statue bear her likeness.
The following year, her callous comments about Buddhist barbecues
focused animosity against her family and longstanding discrimination
against Vietnams religious majority. Following her husbands death, she
fled into exile, her property seized by Diems successors. Madame Nhu
died in Rome on Easter Sunday, April 24, 2011.
365
366
NGOUABI, M ARIEN
remains, after beating the priests. By November, most historians today agree,
Diem had become such an embarrassment that his erstwhile U.S. supporters
approved ofor, at least, refrained from preventinghis assassination.
One who did not approve, and who apparently was shocked by the Saigon
killings, was President John F. Kennedy. He called the double murder particularly abhorrent, telling National Security Council staffer Michael Forrestal that
it bothered him as a moral and religious matter. Coupled with the Cuban Bay
of Pigs fiasco from 1961, the Saigon incident probably influenced Kennedys
remark to future Secretary of Defense Clark Clifford that Something very bad
is going on within the CIA and I want to know what it is. I want to shred the
CIA into a thousand pieces and scatter them to the four winds. Kennedy lost
that chance three weeks later, with his own assassination in Dallas, Texas.
In Vietnam, no one was ever prosecuted for killing Diem and his brother.
A French physician signed the death certificates without performing an autopsy, listing Diem occupations as Chief of Province and his brothers as
Chief of Library Service, posts they last held in the 1940s. They were buried
at an undisclosed location, still kept secret to the present day. General Duong
Van Minh succeeded Diem as president for two months, then ceded the office
to ex-general Nguyen Khanh. Minh would return as president in April 1975,
for an even shorter three-day tenure, prior to the communist capture of South
Vietnam.
See also: Kennedy, John Fitzgerald (19171963).
Further Reading
Hammer, Ellen. A Death in November: America in Vietnam, 1963. New York: E. P. Dutton,
1987.
Hoang Ngoc Thanh and Than Thi Nhan Duc. Why the Vietnam War? President Ngo Dinh
Diem and the US: His Overthrow and Assassination. Tuan-Yen, Vietnam: Mai-Nam
Publishers, 2001.
Jacobs, Seth. Americas Miracle Man in Vietnam: Ngo Dinh Diem, Religion, Race, and U.S.
Intervention in Southeast Asia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2005.
Jacobs, Seth. Cold War Mandarin: Ngo Dinh Diem and the Origins of Americas War in
Vietnam, 19501963. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2006.
Weiner, Tim. Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA. New York: Anchor Books, 2008.
NGOUABI, MARIEN
were issued, described the killers as a suicide squad, although its alleged
ringleaderformer army captain Barthlemy Kikadidihad escaped alive. In
his absence, the committee rounded up more than a dozen other suspects, including ex-president Alphonse Massamba-Dbat, whom Ngouabi had deposed
by force in September 1968. All were convicted of treason, despite what some
observers called a dearth of solid evidence, and they were executed en masse
on March 25, 1977.
Marien Ngouabi was born at Ombell, in the Cuvette Department of thenFrench Equatorial Africa, on December 31, 1938. Completing his primary
education at Owando, in 1953, Ngouabi then matriculated to Brazzavilles military academy, Ecole des enfants de troupes Gnral Leclerc, graduating in 1957.
His first posting was to Bouar, in Oubangui-Chari (now the Central African Republic), followed by service in the FrenchBritish mandate of Cameroun from
1958 until January 1960, when it achieved independence as the Republic of
Cameroon.
Eight months later, in August 1960, France granted full independence to the
Republic of the Congo. Ngouabis superiors then dispatched him to the Ecole
Militaire Prparatoire in Strasbourg, France, and to the Ecole Spciale Militaire de
Saint-Cyr, for training as an officer. He returned home as a second lieutenant in
1962, promoted to full lieutenant the following year. In 1965, Ngouabi created
and trained the countrys first paratrooper battalion, simultaneously earning a
reputation for outspoken leftist views. In April 1966, when he refused a posting to Pointe-Noire, second-largest city in the nation, Ngouabi suffered demotion to the rank of soldier second-class. He nonetheless continued his political
agitation, and was arrested by order of President Alphonse Massamba-Dbat
on July 29, 1968.
Two days later, sympathetic soldiers freed Ngouabi and a fellow prisoner,
Second Lieutenant Eyabo, organizing a new National Revolutionary Council
on August 5, with Ngouabi in charge. President Massamba-Dbat retained his
office, as an emasculated figurehead ruler, until Ngouabi proclaimed himself
president on December 31, 1968. His first official act involved renaming his
homeland as the Peoples Republic of the Congo (PRC), Africas first Marxist
Leninist state. At the same time, Ngouabi established a new Parti Congolais du
Travail (Congolese Party of Labour, or PCT) as the PRCs only legal political
party. His regime forged close ties with the Soviet Union, but also maintained
relations with Franceat least, until he refused demands from Paris that he
annex Angolas oil-rich Cabinda Province. Some observers claim that France
thereafter promoted and financed a series of attempts to depose Ngouabi.
The first such coup occurred on February 22, 1972, prompting Ngouabi
to purge his armys ranks of suspected traitors. Former Congolese prime minister Ambroise Noumazalayewas among 13 defendants sentenced to die on
March 25, but President Ngouabi commuted their death sentences to life
367
368
NGOUABI, M ARIEN
Further Reading
Clark, John, and Samuel Decalo. Historical Dictionary of Republic of the Congo. Lanham,
MD: Scarecrow Press, 2012.
Decalo, Samuel. Africa: The Lost Decades. Gainesville: Florida Academic Press, 2012.
Decalo, Samuel. Coups and Army Rule in Africa: Motivations and Constraints. New
Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1990.
NICHOLAS II
Onwumechili, Chuka. African Democratization and Military Coups. Westport, CT: Praeger, 1998.
Shubin, V. G. The Hot Cold War: The USSR in Southern Africa. London: Pluto Press,
2008.
NICHOLAS II (18681918)
On March 15, 1917, in the midst of the Russian Revolution, Tsar Nicholas II abdicated his throne, naming his brother, Grand Duke Michael, as the next emperor
of all of Russia. Michael declined, preferring election by popular vote, but Russian peasants wanted no more monarchs, opting instead for a provisional socialist
government. On March 22, Nicholas, his wife, and children were placed under
house arrest at the Alexander Palace in Tsarskoye Selo, south of Saint Petersburg.
In August, as fighting continued, the royal family was evacuated to Tobolsk, in Siberia, then transported once again to Yekaterinburg, in May 1918. Their captors
sought to keep them from advancing Bolsheviks (majority), battling to seize
control of Russia from Alexander Kerenskys Menshevik (minority) regime.
Captured by the Bolsheviks (or
Reds) at Yekaterinburg, Nicholas and his family were scheduled for trial, but their captors
panicked upon receiving word
of an anticommunist white
armys advance. On July 16,
1918, a telegram from Moscows
Supreme Soviet (council) ordered the Romanov familys
mass execution. Commandant
Yakov Yurovsky led the firing
squad that carried out that order, shooting Nicholas, his wife,
and their five children in a basement chamber, finishing the job
with bayonets.
Russias last tsar was born
Nikolay Alexandrovich Romanov, in Saint Petersburg,
on May 18, 1868. His paternal
grandfather was Tsar Alexander
II, and his maternal grandfather was King Christian IX of Bolshevik revolutionaries killed Tsar Nicholas II
Denmark. His father was Tsar and his family in 1918. (Getty Images)
369
370
NICHOLAS II
NICHOLAS II
on January 22, 1905, a series of strikes and uprisings launched Russias first
revolution against the royal family, continuing until resistance was crushed in
June 1907. Although overall casualty figures are vague and unreliable, an estimated 14,000 dissidents were executed during the revolution, with at least
75,000 imprisoned. Meanwhile, the Russo-Japanese War cost Russia some
53,000 lives lost in combat, and another 18,830 from disease. The Treaty of
Portsmouth, signed on September 5, 1905, ended that conflict and established
Japan as a global power, dominant over the Pacific Ocean.
The 1905 revolution produced a new constitution, ratified in April 1906.
Aside from charting guidelines for royal succession and promulgation of laws,
Chapter 8 detailed the rights and obligations of Russian citizens. For the
first time in history, they were guaranteed protection from arbitrary arrest and
imprisonment, with protection from illegal search and seizure, and promised
inviolability of their homes. They also gained the right to own private property, to travel through Russia (subject to restrictions), to assemble and express
themselves freely, to choose their own religion, and to organize labor unions or
guilds. Military service remained mandatory for all males, regardless of social
rank, as did payment of taxes and performance of other duties in accordance
with lawful decrees.
Count Sergei Yulyevich Witte took office as Russias first prime minister on
November 6, 1905, and although Nicholas initially enjoyed cordial relations
with him, Alexandra disliked him for personal reasonsspecifically Wittes
investigation of Grigori Rasputin, a shady mystic who had attached himself to
the Romanov clan that same year, with promises to cure Tsarevich Alexeis hemophilia. Rasputin failed in that, but still exerted quasi-hypnotic control over
Alexandra, and through her, over the tsar. Conflicts with the empress consort
and the State Duma (lower house of the federal legislature) forced Wittes resignation in May 1906, and his successor as prime minister, Pyotr Stolypin, dissolved the Duma two months later. A Second Duma fared no better, dissolved
by Stolypin in June 1907.
The eruption of World War I, in July 1914, involved Russia through its
Triple Entente alliance with France and Great Britain, squaring off against the
Central Powers of Germany, Bulgaria, the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the
Ottoman Empire. Before the 1917 revolution removed Russia as a combatant
in that global conflict, estimated military losses for the tsars empire ranged
from 1,811,000 to 2,254,369, with at least 1.5 million civilian deaths from
military action, or from disease, famine, and other war-related causes. Losses
on that scale were bound to spark dissension, even among loyal monarchists.
One such defender of the tsar, Vladimir Purishkevich, rose in the Duma on
December 2, 1916, to complain of dark forces surrounding the throne
specifically Grigori Rasputin. If the mad monks influence was not removed,
Purishkevich warned to thunderous applause, Revolution threatens and an
371
372
NICHOLAS II
obscure peasant shall govern Russia no longer! Enemies of Rasputin murdered him two weeks later, but time was already running out for the Romanov dynasty.
The year 1917 found Russia on the brink of collapse. Millions of deaths aside,
the country had lost 55 percent of its locomotives and 34 percent of its railroad
cars since 1914, and wartime prohibition of alcoholic beverages unexpectedly
drained the treasury through loss of tax revenue. Starvation prompted looting
in Petrograd, in February 1917, with public denunciation of Nicholas and the
German woman he had married. When police fired on the demonstrators,
widespread rioting resulted. Reserve troops mustered to suppress the rebels
mutinied instead, killing those officers who did not join them. By March 12,
1917, an estimated 60,000 soldiers were on the march against their monarch.
Nicholas abdicated three days later, in favor of his youngest brother, but it was
already too late to save the empire.
Alexander Kerensky, then minister of war in Russias new provisional government, ordered the countrys last military offensive of World War I on July 1,
1917. By then, discipline within the army had degenerated to the point that the
campaign was bound to fail, collapsing on July 19 with an estimated 60,000
Russian casualties. Vladimir Lenins Bolsheviks consolidated power over Russia
in November 1917, and although they sued for peace, German demands were so
extreme that fighting dragged on for another four months. Finally, on March 3,
1918, the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk ended combat on the Eastern Front, while
affirming independence for Belarus, Estonia, Finland, Latvia, Lithuania, and
Ukraine. Twelve days later, execution of the Romanovs signaled the final end
of monarchy in Russia.
As news of the murders spread through Yekaterinburg, Yakov Yurovsky ordered the corpses removed to another location. The chosen vehicle broke down
en route to Yurovskys chosen burial site, whereupon Nicholas and his family
were hastily planted in a pit along Koptyaki Road, 12 miles north of Yekaterinburg. In 1991, a Soviet government reclamation team found the remains of
five victimsexcluding daughter Maria and son Alexeiand reinterred them
in a state funeral at the St. Catherine Chapel of the Peter and Paul Cathedral in
Saint Petersburg. On August 15, 2000, the Russian Orthodox Church canonized the late tsar and his family, rather curiously citing their humbleness, patience and meekness as qualifications for sainthood.
In the summer of 2007, searchers found another grave site near the pit
where Nicholas, his wife, and three children were unearthed in 1991. This
grave held the remains of two more victims, identified through DNA, in May
2008, as Maria and Alexei Romanov. Five months later, on October 1, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation rehabilitated the slain Romanovs,
calling them victims of political repression. On August 26, 2010, Moscows
Basmanny Court ordered a new investigation of the Romanov murders with
NICHOLAS II
Further Reading
The Execution of Tsar Nicholas II, 1918. Eyewitness to History. http://www.eyewit
nesstohistory.com/nicholas.htm.
The Home of the Last Tsar. Alexander Palace Time Machine. http://www.alexander
palace.org/palace/mainpage.html.
Lieven, D. C. B. Nicholas II: Twilight of the Empire. New York: St. Martins Griffin, 1996.
Lyons, Marvin. Nicholas II: The Last Tsar. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1974.
McNeal, Shay. The Secret Plot to Save the Tsar: New Truths behind the Romanov Mystery.
New York: HarperCollins, 2003.
Radzinsky, Edvard. The Last Tsar: The Life and Death of Nicholas II. New York: Doubleday, 1992.
Richards, Guy. The Rescue of the Romanovs: Newly Discovered Documents Reveal How
Czar Nicholas II and the Russian Imperial Family Escaped. Greenwich, CT: DevinAdair Publishing, 1975.
Slater, Wendy. The Many Deaths of Tsar Nicholas II: Relics, Remains and the Romanovs.
London: Taylor & Francis, 2009.
Warth, Robert. Nicholas II: The Life and Reign of Russias Last Monarch. Westport, CT:
Praeger, 1997.
373
O
OBAMA, BARACK HUSSEIN, II (1961 )
ATTEMPTED/THREATENED
Arguably the most controversial U.S. chief executive since Franklin D. Roosevelt, Barack Obama made history in 2008 with his election as the nations first
African American president. From the announcement of his candidacy in 2007,
he became a lightning rod for vitriolic attacks by white supremacists and other
far-right extremists, resulting in a series of assassination threats and alleged
murder plots spanning five years, as of this writing in November 2012.
Obama was a U.S. senator from Illinois when he announced his presidential candidacy in February 2007, and the first racist death threats came three
months later. As a result, Secret Service agents were assigned to guard Obama
and his family from that date onward, although federal law only mandates
protection of major candidates for 120 days preceding a presidential election.
No details of the threats in question are available today, and although the National Journal ran an August 2007 article headlined Authorities play down plot
against Obama, the protection detail remained in place.
On July 15, 2008, six weeks before the Democratic National Convention
nominated Obama as its presidential candidate, two residents of Charlotte,
North Carolina, reported threats made against Obama by local accountant
Jerry M. Blanchard, described today on racist Web sites as a stalwart Republican. Speaking to diners at a restaurant, Blanchard declared, Obama and his
wife are never going to make it to the White House. He needs to be taken out
and I can do it in a heartbeat. A third witness told authorities of a second incident, at a hotel, where Blanchard said, Ill get a sniper rifle and take care of
it myself. Somebodys got to do it. We both know Obama is the anti-Christ.
Indicted for threatening Obama in August 2008, Blanchard pled guilty in February 2009, receiving a 366-day prison term and a fine of $3,100, plus three
years supervised federal probation. In September 2009, he was permanently
stripped of his state accountants license.
On July 31, 2008, two weeks after the initial Blanchard incident, Raymond
H. Geisel held a training class for bail-bonds enforcement agents in Miami,
Florida. During the course of his lecture, Geisel referred to Obama as a nigger
and told the class, If he gets elected, Ill assassinate him myself. He also threatened to shoot then-president George W. Bush, but later claimed the comments
376
were made in jest. Secret Service agents arrested Geisel in August and searched
his motel room, seizing a loaded pistol and quantities of ammunition; tear gas;
various knives, including a machete; body armor; and military-style fatigues.
He spent a month in custody before being released.
On August 24, 2008, one day before Democrats convened to nominate
Obama in Denver, Colorado, authorities arrested three supposed white supremacists in Denver on charges of plotting to kill Obama. The suspects included cousins Shawn Robert Adolf and Tharin Gartrell, with a friend, Nathan
Johnson. Gartell was nabbed first, with four guns and a quantity of methamphetamine, and the other two were jailed later the same day. Authorities alleged that the trio traveled to Denver with murder in mind, a claim apparently
confirmed by Johnson in a radio interview, when he said, He [Obama] dont
belong in political office. Blacks dont belong in political office. He ought to
be shot.
Secret Service spokesmen later said the Denver plot was crude and posed
no credible threat to Obama, so the three were not indicted for threatening
a presidential candidate. On January 29, 2009, District Judge Robert Blackburn sentenced Gartell to 15 days in jail and six months in a halfway house
for possessing methamphetamine, adding, Frankly, Mr. Gartell, its time you
grew up. Gartell was released on June 12, 2009. Held on outstanding drug
warrants, Adolf faced additional charges of possession of a firearm by a prohibited person, possession of body armor by a violent felon, and possession of
methamphetamine with intent to distribute. He pled guilty to the gun charge
on November 6, 2009, and the other counts were dismissed. On February 5,
2010, Adolf received a 30-month federal sentence, concurrent with a 10-year
Colorado sentence on unrelated robbery charges. Prosecutors charged Nathan
Johnson with simple possession of methamphetamine and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon. He pled guilty to the weapons charge on December
16, 2008, and completed his federal prison sentence on March 10, 2010.
While those events were still unfoldingon September 23, 2008Chicago
police arrested local resident Omhari L. Sengstacke near Obamas home, armed
with a pistol and wearing a bulletproof vest. Held in lieu of $250,000 bond
on charges of trespassing and unlawful use of a weapon by a convicted felon,
Sengstacke was convicted on both counts and received a five-year sentence on
July 10, 2009.
On October 22, 2008, officers in Memphis, Tennessee, arrested selfproclaimed white supremacists Daniel Cowart and Paul Schlesselman for
plotting a racist mass-murder spree. Their plan included robbery of a local
gun store and home-invasion robberies to bankroll their conspiracy, culminating in the assassination of Barack Obama and the murder of 88 African
Americans in Tennessee, 14 of whom would be decapitated. (Among neoNazis, the number 88 symbolizes the letters HH, for Heil Hitler, and
the number 14 refers to the Fourteen Words originally penned by imprisoned racial terrorist David Lane: We must secure the existence of our people
and a future for White Children.) Cowart and Schlesselman got no further
with their plot than shooting up a Baptist church in Brownsville; they foolishly boasted of the attack to friends who reported the crime. Secret Service
spokesmen said they took the threat to Obama very seriously, but questioned the defendants ability to follow through. On November 5, 2008, a
federal grand jury indicted both men on charges of threatening to kill and inflict bodily harm upon a major presidential candidate, conspiracy, interstate
unlawful transportation of an unregistered firearm, interstate transportation
of a firearm with the intent to commit a felony, transporting a short-barreled
shotgun across state lines without a license, and unlawful possession of a
short-barreled shotgun. Cowart faced additional charges of damaging religious property and using a firearm during a crime of violence. Schlesselman
pleaded guilty to three counts on January 14, 2010, receiving a 10-year sentence. Cowart pled guilty to eight counts on March 29, 2010, and was sentenced to 15 years.
On November 10, 2009, Kristy Lee Roshia phoned the Boston office of the
Secret Service, stating that she planned to blow away First Lady Michelle
Obama during a forthcoming Christmas trip to Hawaii. Roshia declared that
she knew the exact location where the Obamas would be staying, and added
a threat to kill unspecified U.S. Marines. Already known to agents for her 2004
threat to kill President George W. Bush, Roshia was captured within two miles
of the Obamas Honolulu lodgings on December 19, 2009, punching a Secret
Service agent in the process. A judge ordered Roshia held without bond, pending psychiatric examination on February 9, 2010, but no further details are
presently available on disposition of her case.
On December 30, 2009, John Turnpaugh of New Orleans, Louisiana, called
that citys 911 emergency number and told a police dispatcher, Hey, yeah,
Im going to kill President Barack Obama and his wife this month. Although
Turnpaugh did not give his name, Secret Service agents traced the call to his
cell phone, leading to his arrest on January 2, 2010. Aside from threatening the
president, Turnpaugh faced charges of possessing of marijuana with intent to
distribute it and possessing four guns to aid his drug trafficking. He pled guilty
to the charges on February 2, 2010, and received an eight-year sentence from
U.S. District Judge Jay Zainey on May 11, 2010.
An unusual case involved Kentucky resident Johnny Logan Spencer, who
posted a poem titled The Sniperdescribing Obamas murderon a whitesupremacist Web site in 2007, and again after President Obama took office in
2009. Authorities arrested Spencer in February 2010, and a federal grand jury
indicted him in March. Despite claims that he wrote the poem to somehow vent
grief over his mothers recent death, Spencer abandoned a First Amendment
377
378
defense and pled guilty in July 2010, receiving a 33-month prison sentence on
December 5, 2010.
On March 21, 2010, Brian Dean Miller of Dallas, Texas, posted an Internet
message to Craigslist under the heading Obama Must Die. The body of his
message read: People, the time has come for revolution. It is time for Obama
to die. I am dedicating my life to the death of Obama and every employee of
the federal government. As I promised in a previous post, if the health care reform bill passed I would become a terrorist. Today I become a terrorist. In a
subsequent post, he invited readers to contact the Secret Service, saying, Feel
free to notify them if it helps you sleep better tonight. You should tell them I
threatened to kill the president and destroy the U.S. government. Maybe you
would like to quote the post as your evidence. A resident of nearby Arlington complied, and authorities traced Miller to his mothers home through his
e-mail address. Miller admitted posting the threat and repeated it to arresting
officers. On November 2, 2010, Miller received a 27-month prison term without possibility of parole.
On April 25, 2010, police in Asheville, North Carolina, arrested Ohio native Joseph Sean McVey at the citys airport, as President Obama arrived aboard
Air Force One. Armed with a pistol and driving a car disguised to resemble a
police cruiser, complete with working lights and siren, McVey was jailed on
charges of impersonating a police officer and going armed to the terror of the
public. The latter charge was dropped for lack of evidence, and McVey posted
$100,000 bond on April 28. Police who testified at his August trial admitted
that everything found in his car might have had some logical use for McVeys
public service volunteering in the Buckeye State. On August 25, 2010, Judge
Shirley Brown convicted McVey of violating an ordinance banning guns from
city property, sentencing him to time served in April.
The next threat came from Ireland, where ex-nurse and ex-convict Terence
Edward Kellyknown to fellow Irish Muslim converts as Khalid Kelly, Abu
Osama, and Taliban Terryonce led the outlawed Al-Muhajiroun militant
group in Dublin. A fugitive from British justice in 20082009, Kelly returned
to Dublin in April 2010 and briefly settled his legal affairs. In May 2011, interviewed by the Sunday Mirror, Kelly said that al-Qaeda was likely to kill Obama
on the presidents upcoming visit to Ireland, adding that heKellywould
like to do it himself. Personally I would feel happy if Obama was killed, he
said. How could I not feel happy when a big enemy of Islam is gone? Police
detained Kelly during Obamas visit, but he was not formally charged.
On the night of November 11, 2011, Idaho resident Oscar Ramiro OrtegaHernandez fired nine rifle shots at the White House from his car, parked on
Constitution Avenue. In custody, he told authorities that President Obama
was the devil and the Anti-Christ, sentiments shared with Idaho neighbors before he left the Gem State for Washington, D.C. Those neighbors
recalled his claims that he needed to kill Obama and will not stop until
379
380
year, he joined a law firm specializing in civil rights litigation and neighborhood economic development, where he remained through 2004. At the same
time, he was elected to the Illinois state senate in 1997, serving through 2002.
In 2004, he was elected to the U.S. Senate, serving there until his election as
the first nonwhite president of the United States in 2008.
Obamas race and liberal politics inspired a right-wing backlash unrivaled
since attacks on Franklin Roosevelt during the Great Depression, or perhaps
on John F. Kennedy during his brief White House tenure in the early 1960s.
Aside from his race and paranoid suspicions that he was not American,
Obama inflamed the far right with policies that included withdrawal of U.S.
troops from Iraq, reform of national health care and immigration guidelines,
economic stimulus measures to lift the country from a near-depression, and
advocacy of equal rights for gay U.S. citizens. In November 2012, Obama was
reelected, defeating Republican challenger Mitt Romney by a margin of 3.5 million popular votes and 332206 in the Electoral College.
Further Reading
Bradley, Jim. Charlotte Man Charged with Making Threats against Obama. http://www
.wsoctv.com/news/news/charlotte-man-charged-with-making-threats-against-/nG4Jh.
Burnett, Sara. Drug Suspect Wanted to Shoot Obama at Invesco. Rocky Mountain
News (Denver, CO), September 3, 2008.
Bynum, Russ. Case Uncovers Terror Plot by Soldiers to Kill Obama. USA Today, August 27, 2012.
Date, Jack. Feds Thwart Alleged Obama Assassination Plot. ABC News, October 27,
2008. http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/Vote2008/story?id=6122962&page=1.
FBI Thwarts Obama Assassination Plot. Examiner.com. http://www.examiner.com/
article/fbi-thwarts-obama-assassination-plot.
Gardner, David. White Supremacists Cleared of Gun Plot to Assassinate President
Obama. Daily Mail (London), August 27, 2008.
Jordan, Lara. Feds Disrupt Skinhead Plot to Assassinate Obama. USA Today, October 28, 2008.
Lichtblau, Eric. Arrests in Plan to Kill Obama and Black Schoolchildren. New York
Times, October 27, 2008.
Man Arrested after Obama Leaves North Carolina. CNN, April 25, 2010. http://
news.blogs.cnn.com/2010/04/25/man-arrested-after-obama-leaves-north-carolina.
Man Indicted for Obama threat. United Press International, August 30, 2008.
http://www.upi.com/Top_News/2008/08/30/Man-indicted-for-Obama-threat/
UPI-27211220119296.
Maraniss, David. Barack Obama: The Story. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2012.
Mendell, Davis. Obama: From Promise to Power. New York: Amistad/HarperCollins,
2007.
Riccardi, Nicholas. Mens Threat to Kill Obama is Downplayed. Los Angeles Times,
August 26, 2008.
O B R E G N S A L I D O , L VA R O
Savage, Charlie. Idaho Man Charged with Trying to Assassinate Obama. Seattle
Times, November 17, 2011.
Woman Threatened to Murder Michelle Obama. Sky News, December 23, 2009.
http://news.sky.com/story/747031/woman-threatened-to-murder-michelle-obam.
381
382
O B R E G N S A L I D O , LVA R O
to civilian life, but Huerta deposed Madero on February 22, 1913, whereupon
Obregn offered his services to loyalist forces in Sonora. Appointed as chief of
Sonoras War Department in March 1913, he defeated Huertas forces in four
successive battles over the next two months.
On September 30, 1913, Coahuila governor Venustiano Carranza named
Obregn commander in chief of the Constitutional Army in the Northwest,
with jurisdiction over five states. In April 1914, Obregn began his advance
toward Mexico City, capturing the nations capital on August 16. Convinced
that the Catholic Church had backed Huerta, Obregn fined the church
500,000 pesos, payable to a newly created Revolutionary Council for Aid to
the People. Likewise distrusting the wealthy, Obregn imposed punitive taxes
on capital, mortgages, real estate, automobiles, and other luxury items, while
forcing selected foreign businessmen to sweep the capitals streets.
While Obregn was thus engaged, Carranzanow the presidentsuffered
a falling out with his other top commanders, Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata. Obregn, fearing another civil war, tried to remain neutral, but matters
came to a head after Carranza refused to attend the Convention of Aguascalientes in October 1914. The Convention declared itself sovereign, choosing
General Eulalio Gutirrez Ortiz as president, while naming Villa commander of
the Conventionalist Army, now at war with Carranzas forces. Obregn enlisted
Red Battalions from leftist labor unions, defeating Conventionalist troops at
Puebla on January 4, 1915, rolling on to victory in a series of four engagements (collectively known as the Battle of Celaya) between April 6 and June 5.
Although victorious, Obregn suffered a wound necessitating amputation of
his right arm. In the midst of his final battles against Villa and Zapata, in May
1915, Obregn accepted appointment as Carranzas minister of war. His efforts
to make the Mexican army more professional included establishment of a staff
college and school of military medicine, together with a Department of Aviation to train and field combat pilots.
In September 1916, President Carranza announced a forthcoming constitutional convention to revise and strengthen the liberal 1857 Federal Constitution of the United Mexican States. When that body met in December, however,
it was bitterly divided between conservative delegates backing Carranza and
radicals insisting on agrarian reform, which Carranza opposed. Obregn supported the leftists, including full separation of church and state, with a ban on
clergymen holding public office, canvassing on behalf of political parties or
candidates, or inheriting from persons other than blood relatives. Carranza,
courting Catholic support, opposed those provisions as well.
In June 1919, Obregn announced his presidential candidacy, promising
labor reforms and a new minister of industry and commerce if elected. Carranza retaliated by stripping Obregn of his military rank, which backfired
to create a new wave of popularity for the challenger. Hand-picked Carranza
successor Ignacio Bonillas defeated Obregn at the polls in April 1920, after
O B R E G N S A L I D O , L VA R O
Carranza falsely accused Obregn of plotting a military coup, but that lie soon
became a self-fulfilling prophecy. On April 23, supported by Sonoran governor
Adolfo de la Huerta, Obregn rose in revolt against Carranza. Carranza died in
an ambush on May 20, and de la Huerta served as provisional president until
December 1920, when Obregn won a special election, naming de la Huerta as
his secretary of the treasury.
Obregns first term as president, from 1920 to 1924, witnessed sweeping
educational reforms, including construction of more than 1,000 rural schools
and 2,000 public libraries. He also promoted artistic endeavors, inaugurating
the 50-year era of Mexican muralism, and forged an alliance with the Regional
Confederation of Mexican Workers to promote widespread (if imperfect)
labor reforms. In terms of land reform, Obregns administration distributed
921,627 hectares to Mexican farmers. Still suspicious of the Catholic Church
and its influence, Obregn proved less extreme than many church leaders had
feared, though they still condemned and despised him. An encyclical issued by
Pope Pius XI, in 1922, spawned militant Catholic Action groups that violently
opposed secular labor unions.
In 1923, Obregn endorsed Plutarco Elas Calles as his successor in the
following years presidential contest. Adolfo de la Huerta, who expected
the endorsement, organized a rebellion that enlisted more than half of Obregns standing army. Nonetheless, with the remainder of his troops, Obregn
crushed the insurgents on February 9, 1924, at Ocotln, Jalisco. Calles was
subsequently elected, and Obregon briefly retired from politics.
His successoran outspoken atheistproved more radical in dealings
with the Catholic Church, sparking the Cristero War. Scattered uprisings between August and October 1926 paved the way for a formal declaration of
rebellion on January 1, 1927, and the self-styled Cristeros scored their first
victory over federal troops at San Francisco del Rincn, Guanajuato, on February 23. Obregn, briefly content as a farmer and entrepreneur in Sonora,
donned his uniform once more to battle Yaqui insurgents between October
1926 and April 1927, then announced his candidacy for a second presidential term in May of that year. He emerged victorious from that election, but
did not survive to see inauguration day. He was succeeded by Minister of the
Interior Emilio Portes Gil, who held office for 14 months, until a new election was organized.
See also: Villa, Francisco Pancho (18781923); Zapata Salazar, Emiliano (18791919).
Further Reading
Beller, Susan. The Aftermath of the Mexican Revolution. Minneapolis: Twenty-first Century Books, 2008.
Brenner, Anita, and George Leighton. The Wind That Swept Mexico: The History of the
Mexican Revolution of 19101942. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1984.
383
384
O LY M P I O , S Y LVA N U S E P I P H A N I O
Buchenau, Jrgen. The Last Caudillo: Alvaro Obregn and the Mexican Revolution. Chichester, United Kingdom: Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.
Hall, Linda. lvaro Obregn: Power and Revolution in Mexico, 19111920. College Station, TX: Texas A&M University Press, 1981.
Tuck, Jim. Cristero Rebellion: Part 1Toward the Abyss. Mexconnect. http://www
.mexconnect.com/articles/286-cristero-rebellion-part-1-toward-the-abyss.
Wasserman, Mark. The Mexican Revolution: A Brief History with Documents. New York:
Bedford/St. Martins, 2012.
O L Y M P I O , S Y L VA N U S E P I P H A N I O
outbreak of World War I, French and British forces invaded Togoland, forcing
German occupation forces to surrender on August 26. On December 27, 1916,
the invaders divided Togoland into French and British administrative zones.
The Treaty of Versailles, ratified on July 20, 1922, made Togoland a League
of Nations Class B mandate, with France controlling roughly two-thirds of its
territory and Britain the remainder. Joint control persisted through the early
1950s, with Togolands status altered to that of a United Nations trust territory.
In May 1956, London authorized a referendum to decide the fate of British
Togoland, and a majority of voters chose to join Britains Gold Coast colony,
forming the newly independent nation of Ghana in March 1957.
Meanwhile, in October 1956, a similar referendum in French Togoland produced an overwhelming vote in favor of autonomy within the French union.
Nicolas Grunitzky was elected as the countrys first prime minister, but irregularities in that vote prompted another election in April 1958, supervised by
the United Nations. Sylvanus OlympioGrunitzkys brother-in-law and leader
since 1946 of Togos dominant party, the Committee of Togolese Unity
replaced Grunitzky as prime minister. Six months later, in October 1958,
France announced that it would grant Togo full independence as of April 27,
1960. Olympio remained in office as prime minister until April 9, 1961, when
the adoption of a new constitution required elections to seat a president for a
seven-year term. Nicolas Grunitzky challenged Olympio for that office, but a
statute banned his Togolese Progressive Party from participating in the contest, whereupon Olympio swept the field with 90 percent of the popular vote.
Grunitzky fled into exile, while other opposition leaders were imprisoned.
As president, Olympio adopted a pro-Western foreign policy that endeared
him to U.S. presidents Dwight Eisenhower and John Kennedy. On the domestic front, Olympio terrorized opponents with a private militia, the Ablode
Sodjas, and supported dissident guerrilla forces opposing President Kwame
Nkrumah in neighboring Ghana. Nkrumah returned the favor, joining French
intelligence officers to bankroll Olympios enemies. Olympios ultimate downfall, however, stemmed from dissatisfaction among some 300 Togolese who
had served in the French colonial army, but were then discharged with the advent of full independence. Former sergeant Emmanuel Bodjoll chaired a ninemember Insurrection Committee, created to topple Olympios regime, and led
the final group of 30-odd men who killed the president in January 1963, while
arresting other leading members of his government.
The day after Olympios murder, President Kennedy issued a statement from
Washington, saying, President Olympios tragic assassination is a blow to the
progress of stable government in Africa. It is also a loss not only for his own
country but for all those who knew him here in the United States. In Togo,
Emmanuel Bodjoll held power in the name of the Insurrection Committee
for two days, then ceded the presidency to Nicolas Grunitzky, who had
385
386
O P E R AT I O N W R AT H O F G O D
returned from exile on January 16. Grunitzky sought to unify the country, inviting various parties to join in his administration, but the task was beyond
him. He survived on abortive coup dtat, on November 21, 1966, then was
ousted by Lieutenant Colonel tienne Eyadma Gnassingb on January 13,
1967. Grunitzky decamped for Paris, and Gnassingb installed himself as
Togos president on April 14, 1967. Declaring that that democracy in Africa
moves along at its own pace and in its own way, Gnassingb remained in office until February 5, 2005, when he died in a plane crash, on a visit to Tunisia.
His son, Faure Essozimna Gnassingb, assumed the presidency three months
later and rules Togo today.
Despite President Kennedys praise for Sylvanus Olympio, rumors persist
that the United States sanctioned and/or participated in his assassination. Specifically, some Togolese believe that then-ambassador Leon Poullada deliberately left Olympio exposed to his enemies in the U.S. embassy compound,
alerting his French counterpart in Lom to tell the rebels where they could find
their target. The late presidents son, Gilchrist Olympio, presently leads Togos
largest opposition party, the Union of Forces for Change.
Further Reading
Houngnikpo, Mathruin. Determinants of Democratization in Africa: A Comparative Study
of Benin and Togo. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 2001.
Melady, Thomas, and Margaret Melady. Ten African Heroes: The Sweep of Independence in
Black Africa. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 2011.
Schwab, Peter. Designing West Africa: Prelude to 21st Century Calamity. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004.
Seely, Jennifer. The Legacies of Transition Governments in Africa: The Cases of Benin and
Togo. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
O P E R AT I O N W R AT H O F G O D
Meir sought a more direct response against Black September and its allies.
To that end, she created and chaired Committee X, with Defense Minister
Moshe Dayan, Mossad director Zvi Zamir, and General Aharon Yariv. The resultant assassination campaignvariously dubbed Operation Wrath of God
and sometimes Operation Bayonetwas conceived, in the words of Mossad
deputy director David Kimche not so much revenge but mainly to make them
[the terrorists] frightened. We wanted to make them look over their shoulders
and feel that we are upon them.
Mossad agent Michael Harari supervised creation of a 15-member team,
divided into five squads designated by letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Taken
in alphabetical order, the group included two skilled assassins, called Alefs;
two guards for the killers, designated Bets; two agents labeled Hets, who
established cover by renting apartments and vehicles; seven Ayin operatives who mounted surveillance on targets and mapped escape routes; and
two Qoph members responsible for communications. Thus organized, Operation Wrath of God proceeded to hunt down its prey.
The first to die was Wael Zwaiter, a PLO spokesman ambushed in Rome on
October 16, 1972, shot 11 times in honor of the slain Israeli athletes. Next,
in Paris, PLO representative Dr. Mahmoud Hamshari was fatally injured by a
booby-trapped telephone on December 8, 1972, dying from his wounds on
January 9, 1973. Details remain vague on a third reported killing, around the
same time, of a Palestinian activist expertly pushed under a London bus.
Two weeks after Dr. Hamsharis death, on January 24, 1973, another Israeli bomb killed Jordanian Hussein Al Bashir, representative of the PLOs
Fatah political party, in his room at the Olympic Hotel in Nicosia. Dr. Basil
al-Kubaissi, a law professor at the American University of Beirut, died in a
drive-by shooting on April 6, 1973, prompted by suspicion that he helped
supply Black September with weapons.
Three more targets in LebanonBlack September operations leader Muhammad Youssef al-Najjar, PLO chief of operations Kamal Adwan, and
PLO executive committee member Kamal Nasserlived in heavily guarded
homes that frustrated normal assassination methods. To eliminate them, Israel launched Operation Spring of Youth as a Wrath of God special project,
enlisting Israeli Defense Forces commandos for an amphibious landing, supported by naval missile boats offshore. Disguised as civilians, some dressed
as women, the raiders struck by night, killing their intended targets, along
with al- Najjars wife, two Lebanese police officers, and an Italian citizen. As
part of the same operation, Israeli paratroopers struck at local headquarters
of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), and at several
PLO facilities nearby. Estimates of the final death toll ranged from 12 to 100
PLO and PFLP members, plus two Israelis.
After that sweep, Operation Wrath of God proceeded in its established style.
On April 11, 1973, a hotel bombing in Athens killed Zaiad Muchasi, Hussein
387
388
O P E R AT I O N W R AT H O F G O D
Al Bashirs replacement as Fatahs front man in Cyprus. A short time later, while
en route to raid Romes office of El Al Airlines, Black September activists Abdel
Hadi Nakaa and Abdel Hamid Shibi suffered fatal wounds from an explosion
in their car. (Police in that case blamed a faulty detonator and closed the
case.) On June 28, 1973, another car bombing in Paris claimed the life of Mohamed Boudia, Algerian-born coordinator of PFLP terrorist actions for Europe
at large.
High on the list of Israeli targets was Red Prince Ali Hassan Salameh,
founder of Fatahs Force 17 commando unit and alleged mastermind of the
Munich Olympics massacre. Mossad agents believed they had tracked Salameh to Lillehammer, Norway, in summer of 1973, but when they struck on
July 21, they actually killed Ahmed Bouchiki, an innocent Moroccan waiter
with no link to Arab terrorists. Local police captured five members of the hit
team, all of whom were convicted and sentenced to prison, then released and
deported to Israel in 1975.
Six months after that fiasco, the Mossad tried again for Salameh, this
time in Switzerland. Expecting him to meet PLO leaders at a church on January 12, 1974, two Israeli assassins and killed three men of Arab appearance,
but failed to locate Salameh. Another false lead placed Salameh in London,
where a freelance female assassin seduced and killed an Israeli agent at the
Europa House Hotel. Traced to her home in Amsterdam, that killer was in
turn eliminated by Mossad gunmen on August 21, 1974. Michael Harari
then officially called off the plot to kill Salameh, but agents made one more
try, killing a security guard at Salamehs alleged safe house in Tarifa, Spain.
Once again, they missed their main prize.
Embarrassed by the Lillehammer scandal, Golda Meir suspended Operation
Wrath of God for the remainder of her term in office. Successor Menachem
Begin revived the program in 1977, including the contract on Ali Salameh.
Agents traced him to Beirut in November 1978, and a three-member team
mounted surveillance on a neighborhood around Rue Verdun that Salameh
was said to frequent. At 3:35 P.M. on January 22, 1979, a car bomb detonated
by remote control killed Salameh, four bodyguards, and four bystanders
including a German nunwhile wounding 18 others.
And the murders continued. On December 15, 1979, Palestinians Ali Salem
Ahmed and Ibrahim Abdul Aziz were gunned down at close range with silenced weapons, in Cyprus. Assassins struck twice in Rome on June 17, 1982,
shooting PLO official Nazeyh Mayer at his home, then killing another PLO
member, Kamal Husain, with a car bomb seven hours later. Fadl Dani, deputy
director of the PLO in Paris, died when a bomb demolished his car on July 23,
1982. Two gunmen on a motorcycle executed PLO official Mamoun Meraish in
Athens, on August 21, 1983. Khaled Ahmed Nazal, secretary general of a PLO
splinter faction, was shot four times outside an Athens hotel on June 10, 1986.
O P E R AT I O N W R AT H O F G O D
Four months later, on October 21, senior PLO official Munzer Abu Ghazala
died in an Athens car bombing. On February 14, 1988, yet another car bomb
killed Hamdi Adwan and Abu Al Hassan in Limassol, Cyprus, wounding a
third passenger in the vehicle.
Confusion surrounds some killings attributed to Operation Wrath of God.
Victims in those cases include PLO representative Said Hammami, shot in
London on January 4, 1978; Ezzedine Kalak, chief of the PLOs Paris bureau,
and deputy Hamad Adnan, killed in a raid on their office that left also three
other persons wounded on August 3, 1978; Zuheir Mohsen, head of PLO military operations, shot outside a casino in Cannes, France, on July 27, 1979;
PLO spokesman Naim Khader, killed in Brussels, Belgium, on June 1, 1981;
Abu Daoud, self-proclaimed planner of the Munich massacre, wounded by
gunshots at a caf in Warsaw, Poland, on August 1, 1981; PLO official Nabil
Wadi Aranki, murdered in Madrid, Spain, on March 1, 1982; and PLO chief
of intelligence Atef Bseiso, slain by two gunmen with silenced pistols in Paris,
on June 8, 1992. Whereas various authors credit Wrath of God agents with
all those assassinations, other sources blame the Hammami, Kalak, Adnan,
and Bseiso murders on a rival Palestinian terrorist group, the Abu Nidal Organization. Abu Daoud blamed his shooting on a Palestinian double agent for
Mossad, killed by the PLO in 1991.
Controversy also surrounds the fate of two Munich hostage-takers liberated
after the Lufthansa hijacking in October 1972, Adnan Al-Gashey and Mohammed Safady. Various published accounts claim that Israeli agents found
and executed both men, years after the Munich massacre, but other sources
disagree. Israeli author Aaron Klein asserts that Al-Gashey died from natural
causes in the latter part of the 1970s, and Lebanese Christian Phalangists murdered Safady sometime in the early 1980s. Meanwhile, in 2004, PLO veteran
Tawfiq Tirawi told Klein that Safady was still as alive as you are, refusing to
disclose his location. The third Munich survivor, Jamal Al-Gashey (cousin of
Adnan), was alive as late as 1999, when he sat for interviews with reporters in
North Africa.
Aside from outright assassinations, Operation Wrath of God engaged in
an extensive letter-bombing campaign that wounded various persons. Identified victims include: Emile Khayyat, a Rif Bank employee in Beirut (July 18,
1972); Dr. Anis Sayegh, director of the PLO Research Center in Beirut (July 19,
1972); Ahmad Wafi, a Palestinian intellectual in Algiers (October 25, 1972);
PLO representative Mustafa Awad Zaid and two bystanders in Tripoli (October 25, 1972); two employees of Beiruts Import-Export Bank (October 26,
1972); an Egyptian police officer checking suspicious parcels (October 26, 1972);
Omar Sufan, a representative of the Red Crescent humanitarian organization
in Stockholm (November 29, 1972); Palestinian student leader Adnan Hammad in Germany (November 29, 1972); three post office employees in Tunis
389
390
O P E R AT I O N W R AT H O F G O D
(November 29, 1972); and Palestinian student leader Ahmed Awadallah in Copenhagen (November 30, 1972).
When not engaged in lethal operations, Wrath of God agents practice psychological warfare against their enemies, publishing obituaries of Palestinian activists still alive, sometimes blackmailing others to leave the movement
with threats of releasing embarrassing personal information. In the wake of
some assassinations, Mossad agents also sent flowers to surviving relatives of
the victims, with cards reading A reminder we do not forget or forgive.
Predictably, Black September activists sought to retaliate for Israels campaign of retribution. Palestinian letter bombs were mailed to Israeli diplomatic
missions around the world in September and October 1972, one claiming the
life of Ami Shachori, agricultural counselor at Israels embassy in London, on
September 19. On December 28, 1972, four Black September gunmen invaded the Israeli embassy in Bangkok, Thailand, seizing 12 hostages as a diversion from plans to assassinate Golda Meir on an upcoming visit to Pope
Paul VI in Rome. Mossad agents foiled that conspiracy, but they could not
protect Israelis worldwide. Baruch Cohen, representing Mossad in Madrid,
was murdered by a Palestinian contact on January 23, 1973. Black September
members also killed Vittorio Olivares, an Italian El Al employee in Rome, four
months later, and executed Colonel Yosef Alon, Israeli military attach to the
United States, in Chevy Chase, Maryland, on July 1, 1973.
Israels retaliation against Black September has inspired two feature films. Michael Anderson directed Sword of Gideon for HBO in November 1986, and Steven Spielberg produced Munich for the big screen in December 2005. The latter
film garnered many award nominations, including five Oscar nominations for
Best Picture, Best Director (Spielberg), Best Screenplay, Best Editing, and Best
Original Score. Although losing out on all of those, it won a Central Ohio Film
Critics Association Award for Best Ensemble Cast; Washington D.C. Area Film
Critics Association Awards for Best Director and Best Picture; and Kansas City
Film Critics Circle Awards for Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Screenplay.
Further Reading
Byman, Daniel. A High Price: The Triumphs and Failures of Israeli Counterterrorism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Jonas, George. Vengeance: The True Story of an Israeli Counter-Terrorist Team. Toronto:
Lester & Orpen Dennys Ltd., 1984.
Klein, Aaron. Striking Back: The 1972 Munich Olympics Massacre and Israels Deadly Response. New York: Random House, 2005.
Nasr, Kameel. Arab and Israeli Terrorism: The Causes and Effects of Political Violence,
19361993. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company, 1996.
Reeve, Simon. One Day in September: The Full Story of the 1972 Munich Olympics Massacre
and the Israeli Revenge Operation Wrath of God. New York: Arcade Publishing, 2000.
OSMAN II
OSMAN II (16041622)
On May 19, 1622, soldiers of the Turkish Janissary corps staged an uprising
against Emperor Osman II of the Ottoman Empire in Constantinople (now
Istanbul). After holding Osman captive overnight in the capital citys Yedikule
Fortress, leaders of the rebellion sent a soldier to kill him on May 20. The
assassin, accompanied by several guards, attempted to strangle Osman with
a bowstring, but the 18-year-old emperor slipped a hand under the noose,
dislodging it, and knocked his would-be slayer to the floor. A brawl ensued,
during which Osmans former grand vizier seized him by the most sensible
part of his body, while another soldier clubbed him with the blunt head of an
axe. Barely conscious and unable to resist further, Osmon was finally throttled
to death by his appointed executioner.
Osman IIwidely known to his subjects as Gen Osman (Osman the
Young)was born at Constantinoples Topkapi Palace on November 3, 1604,
the son of Sultan Ahmed I. His Greek mother supervised Osmans education, ensuring his fluency in Arabic, Greek, Italian, Latin and Persian, plus the
harem sign language employed by members of the royal court to communicate with deaf-mute pages, doormen, eunuchs, and executioners. From his
youth, Osman was also recognized as an accomplished poet.
Typhus claimed Ahmed Is life on November 22, 1617, whereupon he was
succeeded by his brother, Mustafa I. Prior to Ahmeds death, he had confined
Mustafa under house arrest in a wing of the imperial harem from age 12, beginning in 1603. That practiceknown as kafes (the cage)was routine
treatment for royal heirs, though some Ottoman sultans went further, killing
their brothers to weed out potential rivals. Because Mustafa had been spared,
and the Imperial Council deemed Osman too young to rule at age 13, Mustafa
became the first royal brother in 14 generations to succeed a sultan. Unfortunately for Mustafadubbed The Intestable (literally, incompetent to make a
will)and was deposed after less than a year on the throne, when Osman led
a coup dtat against him in summer of 1618. While replacing his uncle as sultan, however, Osman did not have Mustafa killed.
Eager to prove himself, Osman set out to make his mark against neighboring
states. In September 1618, he negotiated the Treaty of Serav, ending a threeyear war between the Ottoman Empire and Safavid Persia (now Iran), establishing a firm border between the two countries and exacting annual tribute
from Persia amounting to 100 wagonloads of treasure. Next, in the wake of
raids launched from Poland, Osman threatened King Sigismund III with invasion and sacking of Krakw. When bluster failed, Osman invaded Moldavia
to defeat a combined PolishLithuanian army at the Battle of Cecora, waged
between September 17 and October 7, 1620. Victorious in that engagement,
Osman next led an army of some 250,000 men from Constantinople to conquer Ukraine, in 1621. This time, defenders stopped him at the month-long
391
392
OSMAN II
Further Reading
Finkel, Caroline. Osmans Dream: The Story of the Ottoman Empire, 13001923. New
York: Basic Books, 2006.
Goffman, Daniel. The Ottoman Empire and Early Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002.
Goodwin, Jason. Lords of the Horizons: A History of the Ottoman Empire. New York:
Picador, 1998.
Imber, Colin. The Ottoman Empire, 13001650: The Structure of Power. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
Piterberg, Gabriel. An Ottoman Tragedy: History and Historiography at Play. Berkeley:
University of California Press, 2003.
393
394
O U KO, J O H N R O B E R T
governor Malcolm MacDonald. With the advent of independence, in December 1963, he was posted as a permanent secretary to the ministry of works
under Prime Minister Jomo Kenyatta. Kenyatta advanced to the presidency in
December 1964, leading Kenya into the East Africa Common Services Organization (later the East African Community) with Burundi, Rwanda, Tanzania, and Uganda. While remaining with the ministry of works, Ouko received
an honorary PhD from Pacific Lutheran University in Seattle, Washington,
in 1971.
Dissension within the East African Community forced its dissolution in
1977, whereupon Ouko was promoted to serve as Kenyas minister for economic planning and community affairs. Two years later, he was elected to parliament from Kisumu, reelected in 1983 and 1988 as a member of the nations
only legal political party, the Kenya African National Union. In 1990, while
pursuing doctoral studied at the University of Nairobi, he advanced to serve as
Kenyas minister of foreign affairs and international cooperation. On January 27
of that year, he visited Washington, D.C., with Kenyan president Daniel Toroitich arap Moi and 82 other officials, for a widely publicized prayer breakfast with U.S. president George H. W. Bush. Returning Nairobi on February 4,
Ouko spent the following morning in meetings with President Moi, Japans
ambassador to Kenya, the Canadian high commissioner, and various cabinet
ministers, before proceeding to his farm at Koru, where he was abducted and
killed one week later.
Kenyan authorities initially claimed that Ouko had committed suicide, a
finding made ridiculous by evidence that he was shot, then set afire. Public
outcry forced President Moi to seek help from Britain, in the person of Detective Superintendent John Troon and two other officers from New Scotland
Yards International Organized Crime Branch and a forensic pathologist provided by the Home Office. Troon and company first examined rumors that
President Moi held a grudge against Ouko, allegedly based on Ouko meeting with President Bush in Washington, while Moi was snubbed. In fact, no
evidence emerged of Ouko ever meeting Bush, and the investigators turned to
other suspects.
One source of conflict involved disputes within Oukos own family, dating
from 1985. Witnesses including Oukos wife, three siblings, and the familys
physician claimed that brother Barrack Ouko blamed John for an unwelcome
political transfer from Nakuru, in the Rift Valley Province, to the capital at Nairobi. Another brother, Collins Ouko, allegedly supported Barrack in that feud,
extending animosity to their mother and threatening her life. In his final report
of August 1990, Detective Superintendent Troon wrote that, with respect to
Oukos immediate family, I am not satisfied that they have told me everything
they know. There appears to be a shroud of fear surrounding the whole family
which prevents them fully disclosing what I believe some of them must know.
Meanwhile, the investigators also probed claims that Ouko was killed as a
result of fraud allegations surrounding the Kisumu Town Council. That tale involved claims of bribery at a local molasses plant, which Ouko threatened to
expose. That case involved Domenico Airaghi and his mistress, self-described
international escort Marianne Briner-Mattern, who served as directors of BAK
International, a firm based in Switzerland. They had approached Ouko about reopening the molasses plant in Kisumu, with Airaghi seeking $1 million to complete a feasibility study, finally settling for $300,000. Ouko had canceled the
project in November 1987, and Troon found it unlikely that the alleged conspirators would have waited more than two years to retaliate against him. Troon
also deemed Airaghi and Briner-Mattern truthful and honest, despite the fact
of Airaghis March 1987 conviction on perjury charges in Italy, resulting in a
30-month prison term and a fine of 2 million lire, upheld on appeal in 1991.
Critics dismissed Troons final report as fatally flawed, persisting with
investigations into Oukos death. President Moi launched a public inquiry,
chaired by Chief Justice Evans Gicheru, in October 1990. In its 13th month,
with Detective Superintendent Troon on the witness stand in Nairobi, Moi
ended the inquiry abruptly, stating that Troon was urgently required in London. Troon never returned to Kenya, and the commission dissolved without
issuing a final report.
Soon afterward, Kenyan police began a new inquiry, reexamining Oukos
dealings with BAK International, including an anonymous letter mailed from
Rome, claiming that Mrs. Marianne and Mr. Airaghi were the masterminds
behind the murder of the late Dr. Ouko. In that instance, police found no
evidence to support the allegations. Officers also detained 10 government officials, including Hezekiah Oyugi and Energy Minister Nicholas Biwott, but ultimately filed no charges against them. A district commissioner from Nakuru,
Jonah Anguka, was charged with killing Ouko, then was acquitted in 1992, his
trial judge declaring that The manner the heinous act was planned and eventually executed . . . was so neat and professional that it could not have been
undertaken by an ordinary person in the nature of the accused.
President Emilio Mwai Kibaki convened a Parliamentary Select Committee of Inquiry in March 2003, which revisited claims that President Moi had
banished Ouko during their 1990 visit to Washington, stripping him of his
ministerial rank and sending him home on a separate flight, but airline records disproved the latter claim conclusively. Dissension within the committee,
including several resignations, doomed it to failure. The panel disbanded in
2005, claiming interference with its deliberations, and its incomplete report
sank without a ripple in the Kenyan House of Assembly, with several committee members voting against its final endorsement.
The last word on Oukos assassination, thus far, came in the form of another
parliamentary report, issued in 2010. That document alleged that Ouko was
395
396
O U KO, J O H N R O B E R T
killed at one of President Mois official residences, and called for further investigation of various ex-officials including Nicholas Biwott (who still denies any
involvement in the crime). Parliament rejected the report in December 2010,
citing dissent within the committee that filed it. Oukos murder remains officially unsolved today.
Further Reading
Branch, David. Kenya: Between Hope and Despair, 19632011. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press, 2011.
Cohen, David, and E. S. Odhiambo. The Risks of Knowledge: Investigations into the
Death of the Hon. Minister John Robert Ouko in Kenya, 1990. Athens: Ohio University Press, 2004.
Hornsby, Charles. Kenya: A History Since Independence. London: I.B. Tauris, 2012.
P
PALME, SVEN OLOF JOACHIM (19271986)
On the night of February 28, 1986, Swedish prime minister Olof Palme
walked from their residence in Stockholm to the nearby Grand Cinema theater. Despite his high position in the government, Palme preferred to travel
without bodyguards whenever possible, and the Palmes were unguarded on
this occasion. After the filma Swedish comedy, The Mozart Brothersthe
Palmes began walking home along Sveavgen Street, near the citys center.
At 11:21 P.M., a lone individual approached them from behind and fired two
close-range gunshots from a .357 Magnum revolver. The first bullet struck
Olof, and the second wounded Lisbet Palme. Bystanders saw the shooter flee
on foot and disappear before police were summoned to the scene. An ambulance arrived 11:25 P.M., transporting the victims to Sabbatsberg Hospital,
where Olof Palme died at 12:06 A.M. on March 1. Lisbet Palme survived her
relatively minor wound and later identified the gunman as drug addict Carl
Gustaf Christer Pettersson, previously convicted of manslaughter in a 1970
stabbing, from a police lineup. Convicted of Palmes murder and sentenced
to life imprisonment in 1988, Pettersson won reversal of that verdict in 1989,
with the appellate court citing lack of evidence. He sued Stockholm police for
defamation and received an award of $50,000, which he spent on drugs and
alcohol. The crime remains officially unsolved today.
Olof Palme was born on January 30, 1927, to an affluent family in the stermalm district of Stockholm. Poor health kept him from school in early childhood, receiving his first education from private tutors, but he subsequently
graduated from the Sigtuna School of Liberal Arts at age 17 and proceeded into
mandatory military service. Discharged as a captain, Palme enrolled at the University of Stockholm, then attended Ohios Kenyon College on a scholarship,
earning his BA there in 1948. Hitchhiking through the United States and Mexico acquainted him with poverty, racism, and ongoing labor struggles, which
prompted Palme to join the Swedish Social Democratic Party in 1949. In 1951,
he was elected president of the Swedish National Union of Students, traveling
widely through Europe and Asia over the next two years.
Palme formally entered politics in 1953, as a secretary for Prime Minister
Tage Erlander. By 1955, he was a board member of the Swedish Social Democratic Youth League, lecturing at Bommersvik, the Youth Leagues college in
398
PA L M E , S V E N O L O F J OAC H I M
PA L M E , S V E N O L O F J O A C H I M
numerous extramarital affairs, including one with psychic actress Shirley MacLaine (who claimed he was a reincarnation of Emperor Charlemagne). He
survived three years and 143 days in his second term as prime minister.
Physical evidence was sparse in Palmes murder. Revolvers do not eject cartridge cases, and although police test-fired some 500 revolvers, they failed
to locate the murder weapon. Neither were they aided by 130 false confessions to the crime from mentally unbalanced individuals. Detectives pursued
10 Magnum revolvers that were reported stolen prior to the killing and found
all but one, a pistol owned by Swedish filmmaker Arne Sucksdorff that went
missing in 1977. The presumed thief was a friend of Stockholm drug dealer
Sigvard Sigge Cedergrenwho, on his deathbed in March 1996, claimed he
had loaned a gun of the same type to assassination suspect Carl Pettersson
in December 1985. Pettersson phoned Mrten Palme, son of the murdered
prime minister, in September 2004, saying he had something to tell the family. Before they could meet, on September 16, Pettersson suffered critical head
injuries in obscure circumstances and lapsed into a coma, dying at Karolinska
University Hospital 13 days later. In February 2006, a television documentary
aired comments from friends of Pettersson, claiming he confessed the Palme
slaying to them and described it as a case of mistaken identity. Meaning to kill
a drug dealer who resembled Palme and who commonly walked along Sveavgen Street, Pettersson allegedly shot the wrong man.
Or did he?
Aside from Sigvard Cedergrens missing pistol, police also examined a .357 stolen
from Haparanda in 1983, with 91 Teflon-coated bullets designed to pierce
metal. The gun was supposedly used in a post office holdup at Mockfjrd that
same year, and fragments of a slug fired there possessed the same isotopic
composition as bullets from the Palme assassination. The gun in question was
pulled from a lake at Dalarna in autumn 2006, identified by its serial number,
but corrosion prevented test-firing. Thus, the bullets, although indistinguishable, could be traced no further than their manufacturer, without any connection to a specific weapon.
Conspiracy theories abound in Palmes murder case. Right-wing extremist
Victor Gunnarsson was questioned as a suspect on four occasions between
March and April 1986, also subjected to wiretap surveillance, but faced no
charges in the case. (He later moved to North Carolina, where an ex-policeman
murdered him in December 1993.) Several Kurds living in Sweden, members
of the militant Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), were also questioned and released for lack of evidence, though allegations of PKK involvement in the slaying persisted as late as 2008.
In September 1996, former police colonel Eugene de Kock told South
Africas Truth and Reconciliation Commission that Palme was murdered to
silence his criticism of apartheid and end his financial support for Nelson
399
400
PA L M E , S V E N O L O F J OAC H I M
PA R D O L E A L , J A I M E
401
402
PA R D O L E A L , J A I M E
MEDELLN CARTEL
Founded by Pablo Escobar and the Ochoa Vzquez brothers in 1976,
the Medelln Cartel became one of the worlds most lucrative and violent
organized crime syndicates over the ensuing decade. By 1982, cocaine
surpassed coffee as Colombias primary export, amounting to 30 percent
of all cargo shipped to foreign countries. Defense of their multibilliondollar empire prompted cartel leaders to create a private army, acting
in conjunction with corrupt public officials, military leaders, and foreign allies. In early 1982, investigative journalists documented a series
of meetings at Puerto Boyac, involving cartel leaders and high-ranking
Colombian military officers, native legislators, industrialists, and cattle
ranchers, plus representatives of various U.S. industries. The participants
shared animosity toward leftist guerrillas who victimized wealthy targets,
resulting in the creation of a paramilitary force dubbed Muerte a Secuestradores (Death to Kidnappers). By late 1983, Colombian security agents
credited the group with 240 political murders. Rampant narcoterrorism
followed, claiming countless lives before the Colombian government responded, orchestrating a campaign that killed Escobar on December 2,
1993, andat least theoreticallyforced the cartel to disband.
351 councilmen, and 23 municipal mayors in local contests. Jaime Pardo Real
ran third in the years presidential race, with 350,000 votes, but later faced
charges of voter intimidation by soldiers of the FARC. In the elections of 1988
the party lost ground, electing only 14 of Colombias 1,008 mayors. By that
time, a rift had developed between FARC leaders and the Communist Party,
with the FARC escalating its guerrilla warfare campaigns. Another Patriotic
Union leader, Jose Antequera, was shot and killed on March 3, 1989, during an assassination attempt against President Ernesto Samper. Suspects
including some Colombian military personnelwere tried and convicted in a
few of the attacks, but most remain unpunished. Senator Manuel Cepeda Vargas, elected as a Patriotic Union member in July 1994, was murdered in Bogot
three weeks after taking office.
Further Reading
Bowden, Mark. Killing Pablo: The Hunt for the Worlds Greatest Outlaw. New York: Penguin Books, 2002.
Dudley, Steven. Walking Ghosts: Murder and Guerrilla Politics in Colombia. London:
Routledge, 2004.
Leech, Garry. The FARC: The Longest Insurgency. Halifax, NS: Fernwood Publishing, 2011.
PA R K C H U N G - H E E
Leech, Garry. Killing Peace: Colombias Conflict and the Failure of U.S. Intervention. New
York: Information Network of the Americas, 2002.
Livingstone, Grace, and Jenny Pearce. Inside Colombia: Drugs, Democracy and War. New
Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2004.
Marcy, William. The Politics of Cocaine: How U.S. Foreign Policy Has Created a Thriving
Drug Industry in Central and South America. Chicago: Lawrence Hill Books, 2010.
403
404
PA R K C H U N G - H E E
Director Kim escaped, but was captured soon afterward. At trial, he offered
five motives for killing Park: Firstly, to restore free democracy; secondly, to
prevent further bloodshed of Korean people; thirdly, to prevent North Korean
aggression; fourthly, to completely restore the close relationship with our strong
ally the United States, which fell to the worst point since the founding of South
Korea and advance our national interest through closer cooperation in defense,
diplomacy, and economy; and fifthly, to restore Koreas honor in the international community by cleansing the bad image of Korea as a dictatorship country. None sufficed to save him, and he was hanged on May 24, 1980. Four
alleged KCIA conspiratorsPark Seon-ho, Yoo Seong-ok, Lee Ki-ju, and Kim
Tae-wonwere hanged the same day. A fifth, Park Heung-ju, had already been
shot by a military firing squad on March 6, 1980. Chief Secretary Kim and
Jeong Seung-hwa were also condemned as conspirators, then released after
Major General Chun Doo-hwan staged a military coup against Parks successor, President Choi Kyu-hah. Chief investigator Yi Hak-bong confused the issue
of conspiracy by ruling that Director Kims shooting of Park and Cha was too
careless for a deliberate act and yet too elaborate for an impulsive act.
Park Chung-hee was born at Gumi, in Koreas North Gyeongsang Province, on September 30, 1917, seven years after Japan annexed his homeland.
In April 1932, he enrolled at the Daegu Teachers Gymnasium, training as a
primary teacher and graduating in March 1937. He taught for three years in
Mungyeong, then opted for a military career instead, entering the Manchukuo
Imperial Army Academy in April 1940 and graduating in 1942, during the
fifth year of the Second Sino-Japanese War. From there, Park moved on to Tokyos Army War College, graduating a lieutenant in the 8th Infantry Division
of the Manchukuo Army. He saw active duty in the final months of World War
II, then shifted to the South Korean Army, but he was expelled in 1948, on
charges of joining a communist cell. That charge remained unproven, though
Parks name did appear on the membership roll of the communist Workers
Party of South Korea. Nonetheless, despite the onset of the Cold War, Park
was readmitted to the military after North Korea invaded the South, in June
1950. He received a year of training in logistics at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, eventually rising to the rank of general under President Syngman Rhee.
A popular uprising forced Syngman Rhee out of office on April 26, 1960,
succeeded by Prime Minister Chang Myon and his puppet, President Yun Boseon. Neither commanded widespread support, and Park led a military coup
against their inefficient government on May 16, 1961, emerging as chairman
of a new Supreme Council for National Reconstruction. One month later, he
created the Korean Central Intelligence Agency (KCIA)initially led by a relative, Kim Jong-pilto suppress political opposition. President Yun formally
resigned, in favor of Park, on March 24, 1962. Park subsequently permitted
civilian rule, under pressure from the Kennedy administration in Washington,
PA R K C H U N G - H E E
and defeated Yun at the polls in December 1963, running as a candidate of the
newly created Democratic Republican Party. Ex-president Yun tried again in
1967, as standard bearer for the Civil Rule Party, and was once again defeated.
As president, Park was credited for overhauling South Koreas economy,
vastly expanding industry and creating economic development agencies that
included an economic planning board, a ministry of finance, and a ministry
of trade and industry. In foreign policy, he had become a dedicated anticommunist, committing more than 300,000 troops to aid the United States in the
Vietnam War. At home, meanwhile, he ruled as a virtual dictator under South
Koreas state of emergency dating from 1950, frequently curtailing freedom of
speech and the press, and the KCIA enjoyed authority to arrest, detain, and
torture alleged subversives.
The first attempt on Parks life came from North Korea, when 31 members
of Unit 124, a Korean Peoples Army commando unit, tried to storm the Blue
House on January 21, 1968. Parks soldiers stopped them a half mile from their
target, killing 29 and capturing one, and the last soldier escaped back to North
Korea. In response to that raid, Park reportedly created Air Force Unit 684 to
kill North Korean Eternal President Kim Il-Sung, but the group was disbanded
three years later without trying to carry out its goal.
Despite a promise to vacate his office when his second term expired in
1971, thus abiding by the Korean Constitutions two-term presidential limit,
Park promoted an amendment permitting him to seek a third four-year term,
then retained the presidency by a narrow margin in that years election. Then,
on October 17, 1972, he declared a new state of emergency based on the
dangerous realities of the international situation, suspended the constitution, invoked martial law, dissolved the National Assembly. A new constitution
quickly followed, ratified by a rigged plebiscite on November 21. Under the
new Yushin (rejuvenation) regime, President Park ruled South Korea as a legally established dictator.
Economic growth continued under the new government, but dissent also
simmered. On August 15, 1974, while delivering a speech at Seouls National
Theater of Korea, Park came under fire from 22-year-old Mun Segwang, a North
Korean sympathizer born in Japan. Mun missed Park, but fatally wounded the
presidents wife, Yuk Young-soo, and a teenage choir singer. Park completed
his speech while his dying wife was carried offstage. Under KCIA interrogation, Mun allegedly confessed to plotting the attack with aid from Chongryon,
the General Association of Korean Residents in Japan. He was hanged in Seoul
on December 20, 1974.
By the eve of his assassination in October 1979, Park faced widespread
student demonstrations of the same kind that had forced Syngman Rhee out
of office in April 1960. He was also under pressure from a New Democratic
Party (NDP), led by Chairman Kim Young-sam, who brooked no compromise
405
406
PAT T E R S O N , A L B E R T L E O N
with Park in efforts to repeal the 1972 constitution. In September 1979, amid
mounting protests, a court suspended Kim from the party, and he was expelled
from the National Assembly, prompting a walkout by 66 more NDP members
on October 5. Riots then erupted in Busan, the topic of discussion at Parks
fatal banquet on October 26.
Although KCIA director Kim Jaegyu clearly murdered President Park, debate surrounding his motive persists. Theories range from insanity sparked
by progressive liver disease to personal jealousy over the rise of Cha Ji-cheol
in Parks esteem, and a frustrated yearning for national liberty. Based on Kims
frequent meetings with Robert G. Brewster, station chief of the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in Seoul, some conspiracy theorists maintain that the
CIA promoted Parks assassination, perhaps opposing his plan to develop nuclear weapons for use against North Korea. In support of that claim, observers
note that Kim met with U.S. ambassador William Gleysteen five hours before
the shooting.
In spite of despotism, many South Koreans still revere Park Chung-hee as
an anticommunist hero and his nations most efficient ruler of the postWorld
War II era. In 1999, Time magazine listed Park among the top 10 Asians of the
Century for rebuilding South Korea in the wake of the Korean War.
Further Reading
Brazinsky, Gregg. Nation Building in South Korea: Koreans, Americans, and the Making of
a Democracy. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2009.
Clifford, Mark. Troubled Tiger: Businessmen, Bureaucrats and Generals in South Korea. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 1993.
Kim, Byung-kook, and Ezra Vogel, eds. The Park Chung Hee Era: The Transformation of
South Korea. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2011.
Lee, Byeong-cheon. Developmental Dictatorship and the Park Chung-hee Era: The Shaping of Modernity in the Republic of Korea. Paramus, NJ: Homa & Sekey Books, 2005.
Lee, Chong-sik. Park Chung-Hee: From Poverty to Power. Seoul: Kyung Hee University
Press, 2012.
PAT T E R S O N , A L B E R T L E O N
407
408
PAT T E R S O N , A L B E R T L E O N
PA U L I O F R U S S I A
Further Reading
Albert L. Patterson. Encyclopedia of Alabama. http://www.encyclopediaofalabama
.org/face/Article.jsp?id=h-1250.
Barnes, Margaret. The Tragedy and Triumph of Phenix City, Alabama. Macon, GA: Mercer
University Press, 1999.
Grady, Alan. When Good Men Do Nothing: The Assassination of Albert Patterson. Tuscaloosa, AL: Fire Ant Books, 2005.
409
410
PAU L I O F R U S S I A
he was strangled and stomped to death. One of the killers, Count Nikolay Alexandrovich Zubov, then proceeded to Alexanders suite in the palace, informing
him of his fathers death and saying, Time to grow up! Go and rule!
Paul I (n Pavel Petrovich) was born in the St. Petersburg Palace of Empress
Elizabeth on October 1, 1754. His parents were listed as Elisabeths nephew,
Grand Duke Peter (later Emperor Peter III) and Grand Duchess Catherine
(later Empress Catherine the Great), though Catherines memoirs suggest that
Pauls father was actually her lover, Count Sergei Vasilievich Saltykov. Some
biographers of Catherine contend that she despised Paul, and may have attempted to kill him. All accounts agree that she was distant from her son, leaving his upbringing to a governor and tutors. Isolated and sickly after a bout of
typhus at age 17, Paul entered into an arranged marriage two years later, but
his first wife died during childbirth on April 15, 1776. Less than six months
later, on October 7, Catherine arranged his second marriage to Sophie Dorothea of Wrttemberg.
Around that same time, Paul
became obsessed with the notion that others were plotting
to kill him, once accusing Catherine of mixing ground glass
with his food. Catherine generally ignored him, preoccupied
with a succession of lovers, and
tutor Nikita Ivanovich Panin
summarized Pauls status at
court as that of a bastard who
owed his position to his mothers sufferance. Paul responded,
after his appointment as fleet
admiral of the Russian navy and
colonel of the Cuirassier regiment at age 18, by criticizing
Catherines expansionist military policies. Catherine apparently planned to exclude Paul
from succession to the throne,
favoring his son Alexander, but
a stroke claimed her life on November 5, 1796, before she formalized that arrangement.
Pauls first act as emperor was
Disgruntled military officers murdered Emperor
Paul I of Russia in 1801. (De Agostini/Getty Images) to destroy Catherines testament,
PA U L I O F R U S S I A
perhaps in fear that it would cheat him of his role as emperor. Soon afterward, he
promulgated the Pauline Laws, establishing strict primogeniture and repealing
the decree of Peter the Great, which allowed each Russian monarch to designate
his or her successor. He also recalled the army that Catherine had dispatched
to invade Persia (now Iran), led by Count Valerian Alexandrovich Zubov,
younger brother of Catherines then current paramour, Prince Platon Alexandrovich Zubov. Pauls hatred for the whole Zubov family subsequently played a
key role in his death.
During the five years of his reign, Paul I was frequently accused (behind
his back) of engaging in eccentric behavior. He liberated some of Catherines
imprisoned critics, notably Tadeusz Kosciuszko
411
412
P E R C E VA L , S P E N C E R
Lithuania in 1801 and made him a cavalry general the following year. Theophil
remained in military service until 1818, then retired, and died at age 81, in December 1826. Conversely, Alexander dismissed Prince Yashvil from his rank of
major general, banning him from Moscow and St. Petersburg until Napoleon
invaded Russia in 1812. Briefly appointed as a militia officer, he was promptly
sacked once more on Alexanders order and returned to exile, dying at his rural
estate on July 20, 1815.
Some historians regard Alexander I as an active participant inor, at least, a
tacit supporter ofthe conspiracy against his father. In either case, he seemed
to live in fear of plots against him, particularly after an abortive attempt to kidnap him while he was en route to the 1818 Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle. On
December 1, 1825, Alexander died from typhus while touring the port city of
Taganrog, in southern Russias Rostov Oblast. Despite his interment in St. Petersburg, three months later, rumors persist that Alexander faked his own death and
retreated to life as a hermit, perhaps resurfacing as the Russian Orthodox elder
Feodor Kuzmich. Kuzmich died on February 1, 1864, when Alexander would
have been 86 years old, and was canonized as a saint 120 years later.
Further Reading
Almedingen, E. M. So Dark a Stream: A Study of the Emperor Paul I of Russia, 17541801.
London: Hutchinson & Co., 1959.
Masson, Charles. Secret Memoirs of the Court of Petersburg: Particularly towards the End
of the Reign of Catherine II and the Commencement of That of Paul I. North Stratford,
NH: Ayer Company Publishers, 1971.
McGrew, Roderick. Paul I of Russia, 17541801. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992.
Sablukov, N. A. Reminiscences of the Court and Times of the Emperor, Paul I of Russia, up
to the Period of His Death: From the Papers of a Deceased Russian General Officer. London: J. Fraser, 1865.
P E R C E VA L , S P E N C E R
413
414
P E R C E VA L , S P E N C E R
trial of Irish journalist John Binns. Although acquitted in that case, Binns spent
two years in prison for supporting the Society of United Irishmen, and emigrated to the United States upon release from custody. Known as a dynamic
speaker in the House of Commons, Perceval was appointed to serve as solicitor general in 1801 and as attorney general from 1802 through 1805, notably
prosecuting seven revolutionaries led by Colonel Edward Despard for conspiring to assassinate King George III. All were convicted, sentenced to be hanged,
drawn, and quartered, commuted to simple hanging and beheading before
their execution in February 1803. On a less draconian note, Perceval relaxed
some restrictions on British trade unions and improved conditions for convicts
deported to Australia.
Perceval resigned as attorney general in January 1806, unwilling to serve
under Prime Minister William Grenville, and became the opposition leader in
the House of Commons. Over the next 12 months, he successfully defended
Princess Caroline of Brunswick against charges of bearing an illegitimate child
(found to be adopted). Grenvilles government fell in March 1807, in a dispute
with George III over Catholic emancipation, whereupon Perceval emerged as
Chancellor of the Exchequer and Leader of the House of Commons under
successor William Cavendish-Bentinck, 3rd Duke of Portland. Percevals preference had been appointment as home secretarygiven instead to Robert Jenkinson, 2nd Earl of Liverpoolbut he accepted the Exchequer posting when
the Duchy of Lancaster offered to supplement his salary, making it equal to the
home secretarys.
Failing health and a public duel between two of his cabinet ministers drove
Prime Minister Cavendish-Bentinck from office on October 4, 1809, and he
died three weeks later, succeeded by Perceval. Percevals administration got off
to a rocky start, with a parliamentary investigation in January 1810 of a bungled military attempt to seize Antwerp, in Belgium. Next came the mental collapse of George III, prompting Perceval to promulgate the Regency Act 1811,
pushed through parliament despite opposition to some of its terms from the
Prince of Wales. Many expected the prince to dismiss Perceval while he served
as regent, but they were surprised when Perceval kept both his post and his
cabinet. Meanwhile, Percevals opponents in parliament launched an investigation of various Orders in Council that had strained British relations with the
United States. On the day of his assassination, Perceval was on his way to hearings on that matterwhich, in fact, would spark the War of 1812 five weeks
later.
At his death, Perceval left his widow Jane and 12 children, the youngest three
years old, with only 106 5s 1d in the bank. Before the end of May, parliament
voted 50,000 for his children, plus annuities for his widow and eldest son.
Jane Perceval remarried in 1815, and was widowed once more in 1821. Nicholas Vansittart, 1st Baron Bexley, succeeded Perceval as prime minister, serving
until 1823. Henry Bellingham, a distant relative of Precevals killer, also served
in parliament from 1983 to 1997. Perceval remains today the only British
prime minister to die by assassination.
Further Reading
Hanrahan, David. The Assassination of the Prime Minister: John Bellingham and the Murder of Spencer Perceval. Stroud, Gloucestershire, United Kingdom: Sutton Publishing, 2008.
Gray, Denis. Spencer Perceval: The Evangelical Prime Minister, 17621812. Manchester:
Manchester University Press, 1963.
Linklater, Andro. Why Spencer Perceval Had To Die: The Assassination of a British Prime
Minister. New York: Walker & Company, 2012.
Treherne, Philip. The Right Honourable Spencer Perceval. Charleston, SC: BiblioLife,
2009.
Williams, Charles. The Life and Administration of the Right Hon. Spencer Perceval: Including . . . a Detail of His Assassination, &c. &c. . . . . Dublin: Ulan Press, 2011.
415
416
was unhappy from the start, with both parties taking numerous lovers, but it
still apparently produced two children, future Emperor Paul I and daughter
Anna Petrovna (who died before her second birthday). We say apparently,
because Catherine later intimated that the marriage was never consummated,
naming Pauls father as Count Sergei Vasilievich Saltykov. Anna was allegedly
sired by future King Stanisaw II of Poland, and two subsequent children
Elizabeth Alexandrovna Alexeeva and Aleksey Grigorievich Bobrinskywere
fathered by Grigory Orlov.
That strange marital arrangement may have contributed to Peters heavy
drinking and reputed mental instability. Catherines memoirs reviled him as
good-for-nothing, an idiot, and a drunkard from Holstein, a view accepted
by the Encyclopdia Britannicas 11th edition in 19101911, saying of Peter
that Nature had made him mean, the smallpox had made him hideous, and
his degraded habits made him loathsome. German historian Elena Palmer
strongly disagrees, portraying Peter as a courageous liberalat least by Russian standardswho expanded religious freedom, abolished the countrys secret police (revived upon Catherines accession), criminalized the killing of
serfs by landowners, required education for the children of aristocrats (with
proof submitted to the senate), established technical schools for middle- and
lower-class children, and exempted nobles from obligatory state and military
service established under Peter the Great. The latter move alone prompted parliament to propose erecting a solid-gold stature of Peter III, but he demurred
with the observation that Russia had better uses for its gold.
Peters greatest sin, in Russian eyes, may finally have been an enduring
attachment to his German roots in Holstein and his habit of surrounding
himself with friends from that region. Upon his ascension to the throne in
January 1762, Peter instantly withdrew Russian troops from the Seven Years
War and concluded a separate peace with Frederick II of Prussia, hailed in
Germany as the Miracle of the House of Brandenburg. Worse yet, in the
eyes of some European rulers, Peter offered 12,000 soldiers to Frederick for
his ongoing battle with Austria, permitting Prussia to capture Silesia and negotiate the final Treaty of Hubertusburg in February 1763. Meanwhile, Peter
planned a new war against Denmark, massing 40,000 troops at Pomerania
in June 1762, but that campaign was aborted by his overthrow at the end of
that month.
Historians still debate Catherines role in Peters forced abdication and subsequent death. Certainly, the Orlov brothers prospered under her reign, and
Grigory Orlov continued sharing her bed. Grigory also received the alleged
murder site, Ropsha Palace, as a gift from Catherine, conditional upon her
order that its name was not to be mentioned again. (Orlov soon ceded the
property to Admiral Ivan Chernyshyov, who in turn sold it for 12,000 roubles
Further Reading
Bain, Robert. Peter III, Emperor of Russia: The Story of a Crisis and a Crime. New York:
E. P. Dutton & Co., 1902.
Julicher, Peter. Renegades, Rebels and Rogues under the Tsars. Jefferson, NC: McFarland,
2003.
Leonard, Carol. Reform and Regicide: The Reign of Peter III of Russia. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1993.
Palmer, Elena. Peter III: Der Prinz von Holstein. Erfurt, Germany: Sutton Verlag, 2005.
417
418
P E T L I U R A , S Y M O N VA S Y LY O V Y C H
P E T L I U R A , S Y M O N VA S Y LY O V Y C H
That same month, Petliura attended the first All-Ukrainian Army Congress
in Kiev, where he was elected to lead the Ukrainian General Army Committee.
The creation of Ukraines first Central Rada (Council) found Petliura named
to serve as First Secretary for military matters, but he soon quarreled with
Volodymyr Vynnychenko, first chairman of Ukraines ruling Directorate, and
left his government post to lead the rival Haydamatskyj Kish paramilitary
movement based in Kharkiv. A see-saw struggle for control ensued, climaxed
with Petliuras arrest on April 28, 1918. He spent four months in custody
at Bila Tserkva, but emerged to continue his opposition against the Vynnychenko regime, finally capturing Kiev and driving Vynnychenko into exile in
February 1919. Petliura then assumed command of the Directorate, fielding
troops against both Bolshevik and anticommunist White Guard forces primacy in Ukraine.
The ensuing UkrainianSoviet War resulted in defeat of the White Guards
army in autumn 1919, but the more numerous Red Bolsheviks finally prevailed, forcing Petliura to seek refuge in Poland on December 5, 1919. Recognized there as head of the Ukrainian Peoples Republic, Petliura forged an
alliance with Poland, launching an attack on Kiev with mixed forces, on
May 7, 1920. Bolsheviks repulsed that movement, leaving Petliura to declare
himself the leader of a government in exile, initially based in Tarnw, then Warsaw. After Bolshevik forces secured control of Russia and proclaimed the Soviet
Union, in December 1922, Petliura embarked upon a European odyssey, living
successively in Budapest, Vienna, Geneva, and finally settling in Paris by 1924,
where he established the Ukrainian language newspaper Tryzub (Trident).
Although separated from his homeland, Petliura could not escape the onus
of events that had occurred there during World War I and afterward. Specifically, between 1918 and 1921, a total of 1,236 violent attacks on Jews had
been recorded in 524 towns throughout Ukraine, with 493 of those carried
out by Petliuras soldiers. Various estimates of the Jewish death toll ranged
from 35,000 to 60,000. This, despite broad expansion of civil rights for
Jews under Petliuras government, with a May 1919 declaration from Jewish
cabinet minister Arnold Margolin that his coreligionists enjoyed more freedom in Ukraine than in any other European state. Some latter-day historians
suggest that Petliura permitted local military commanders to pursue antiSemitic campaigns as a means of broadening their peasant base, whereas
others assert that he simply lost control of army units in the hinterlands.
On April 12, 1922, the communist All-Ukrainian Central Executive Committee publicly named Petliura as one of seven fierce perpetrators against
the liberty of the Ukrainian toiling people, irreconcilable enemies of workers
and peasants of Ukraine. That move, as some historians today suggest, may
have arisen chiefly from Moscows fear of Petliuras influence among ardent
Ukrainian nationalists.
419
420
P H I L I P O F S WA B I A
Peter Deriabin, a Russian KGB agent who defected to the United States in
1953, testified before Congress six years later that Petliuras assassination was a
Soviet-sponsored event. Triggerman Schwartzbard allegedly received his orders
from Christian Rakovsky, a former chairman of the Soviet Ukrainian government, then Soviet ambassador to France. Logistical support, it was said, came
from Russian intelligence agent Mikhail Volodin. Far from defusing Ukrainian
nationalism, however, news of Petliuras murder sparked spontaneous rebellions in more than a dozen cities across Ukraine. Petliuras two sisters, both
Russian Orthodox nuns who remained in Ukraine, were arrested and executed
by the Soviet secret police in 1928.
Although historians continue to debate Petliuras role in Ukrainian pogroms,
his reputation was substantially rehabilitated inside Ukraine following the
Soviet Unions collapse in 1991. Several cities, including Kiev, now display
monuments erected in his honor, and a 12-volume edition of his writings was
released in 2006, on the 80th anniversary of his murder. In June 2009, Kievs
city council renamed Kominterns Street as Symon Petliura Street, in honor of
his 130th birthday.
Further Reading
Friedman, Saul. Pogromchik: The Assassination of Simon Petliura. New York: Hart Publishing, 1976.
Gerwath, Robert, and John Horne. War in Peace: Paramilitary Violence in Europe after
the Great War. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.
Hunczak, Taras. Symon Petliura and the Jews: A Reappraisal. Barrington, IL: Ukrainian
Historical Association, 1985.
Klier, John, and Shlomo Lamroza, eds. Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian
History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992.
Marples, David. Heroes and Villains: Creating National History in Contemporary Ukraine.
Budapest: Central European University Press, 2008.
P H I L I P O F S WA B I A
421
422
PHILIP II OF M ACEDON
France, and Englands King Richard I and successor King John backed Otto.
Pope Innocent III threw the Vaticans influence behind Otto, exerting influence
to retire France from the struggle in March 1201. More setbacks followed for
Philip, as King Ottokar I of Bohemia joined the fight on Ottos side, but the
tide turned in his favor during 1204, prompting Adolf of Altena to defect and
join him, soon followed by Henry I, Duke of Brabant. On January 6, 1205,
Philip was crowned anew at Aachen, this time by former foe Adolf of Altena.
Pope Innocent III retaliated by excommunicating Adolf in July 1205, and the
war continued for another two years, until Philip captured Cologne in 1207.
The final treaty was signed in March 1208, when Pope Innocent agreed to perform a marriage ceremony between Otto IV of Brunswick and Philips daughter
Beatrice.
Queen Irene Angelina was pregnant with a fifth daughter at the time of
Philips assassination. She gave birth to the girl, named Beatrice Postuma, on
August 27, 1208, but both mother and child died soon afterwards. Otto IV
succeeded his former rival, then father-in-law, as king of the Germans in October 1209, but was excommunicated by Innocent III in November 1210 and
ceded his throne to Philips nephew, Frederick II, in December 1212.
Further Reading
Arnold, Benjamin. Medieval Germany, 5001300: A Political Interpretation. New York:
Palgrave Macmillan, 1997.
Fuhrmann, Horst. Germany in the High Middle Ages: c.10501200. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Haverkamp, Alfred. Medieval Germany 10561273. New York: Oxford University
Press, 1992.
Jeep, John, ed. Medieval Germany: An Encyclopedia. New York: Garland Publishing,
2001.
Lewis, Brenda. A Dark History: The Kings and Queens of Europe from Medieval Tyrants to
Mad Monarchs. New York: Metro Books, 2008.
Wiler, Bjrn, and Simon Maclean, eds. Representations of Power in Medieval Germany:
8001500. Turnhout, Belgium: Brepols Publishers, 2006.
PHILIP II OF M ACEDON
423
424
PHILIP II OF M ACEDON
PHOENIX PROGRAM
thereafter. Before years end, Alexander executed Attalus, and Olympias murdered a nephew of Attalus whom Attalus preferred over Alexander as Philips
successor.
Further Reading
Ashley, James. The Macedonian Empire: The Era of Warfare Under Philip II and Alexander
the Great, 359323 BCE. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2004.
Bradford, Alfred. Philip II of Macedon: A Life from the Ancient Sources. Westport, CT:
Praeger, 1992.
Carney, Elizabeth, and Daniel Ogden, eds. Philip II and Alexander the Great: Father and
Son, Lives and Afterlives. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.
Gabriel, Richard. Philip II of Macedonia: Greater than Alexander. Dulles, VA: Potomac
Books, 2010.
Worthington, Ian. Philip II of Macedonia. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2010.
425
426
PHOENIX PROGR AM
In 1967, authority for Phoenix operations fell under a new umbrella organization called Civil Operations and Revolutionary Development Support
(CORDS), which included creation and maintenance of a 500,000-member
peasant militia to fight the VC in conjunction with regular U.S. and South Vietnamese military forces. Lieutenant Colonel Anthony Herbert, fated to become
the wars most decorated U.S. soldier, found the Phoenix Program operating at
high gear when he reached Saigon in 1968. Five years later, in his autobiography Soldier, Herbert recalled that in his first meeting with CIA agents, They
wanted me to take charge of execution teams that wiped out entire families and
tried to make it look as though the VC themselves had done the killing. Although the VC themselves certainly perpetrated numerous atrocities, that revelation raises doubts concerning some allegations made against them.
The Tet Offensive of 1968 convinced CIA and U.S. Army leaders that the
Phoenix Program should be broadened in a bid to decimate the VC infrastructure (VCI in military shorthand). Directive 38141, issued by the U.S. Military Assistance Command, Vietnam (MACV), specified that Phoenix operators
would attack communist rebels with a rifle shot rather than a shotgun approach to target key political leaders, command/control elements and activists
in the VCI. Although statistics concerning covert operations are notoriously
unreliable, one official estimate cites 81,740 suspected VC members and supporters neutralized by Phoenix teams, of whom 26,369 were assassinated.
The latter figure, presumably, does not include detainees killed in custody or
others who simply disappeared. In addition to murdering Vietnamese nationals, some accounts maintain that Phoenix agents also killed U.S. and South
Vietnamese military personnel who were deemed to be security risksa
theme fictionalized in the 1979 motion picture Apocalypse Now.
Most accounts claim the Phoenix Program was disbanded in 1972, due in
large part to negative publicity generated by returning veterans such as former
army counterintelligence agent Ed Murphy, who exposed the program publicly
in April 1970, and Barton Osborn, whose 1971 congressional testimony described the Phoenix campaign as a sterile depersonalized murder program.
In fact, however, it appears that the programor something very similar
continued in South Vietnam under the code name F-6, following the 1972
Easter Offensive, and may have endured until the on April 30, 1975.
Further Reading
Allen, Joe, and John Pilger. Vietnam: The (Last) War the U.S. Lost. Chicago: Haymarket
Books, 2008.
Andrad, Dale. Ashes to Ashes: The Phoenix Program and the Vietnam War. Lexington,
MA: Lexington Books, 1990.
Appy, Christian. Patriots: The Vietnam War Remembered from All Sides. New York: Penguin Books, 2003.
Herbert, Anthony. Soldier. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1973.
Herrington, Stuart. Silence Was a Weapon. New York: Presidio Press, 1982.
McCoy, Alfred. A Question of Torture: CIA Interrogation, from the Cold War to the War on
Terror. New York: Macmillan, 2006.
Moyar, Mark. Phoenix and the Birds of Prey: The CIAs Secret Campaign to Destroy the Viet
Cong. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press, 1997.
Valentine, Douglas. The Phoenix Program. New York: William Morrow, 1990.
427
428
70-year-old Pizarro struggled into his armor. Once confronted by his enemies,
Pizarro reportedly killed two invaders, then was fatally stabbed when his sword
became lodged in a third opponents torso. Initially buried in the courtyard
of Limas cathedral, Pizarro was later exhumed and beheaded, his skull and
body reburied in separate caskets under the cathedrals floor. Young Almagro,
also known as El Mozo (the lad), fought on against Pizarros successor for the
right to rule Peru. Defeated in battle and captured at Chupas on September 16,
1542, Almagro was executed the same day.
Francisco Pizarro Gonzlez was born in Trujillo, Spain. Most histories place
that event sometime during 1471, though some opt for 1476. The illegitimate son of infantry colonel Gonzalo Pizarro and a peasant mother, Francisca
Gonzlez, Pizarro was a distant cousin of another future Spanish conquistador,
Hernn Corts de Monroy y Pizarro, who toppled Mexicos Aztec Empire in 1520.
Eleven years before that familial triumph, in November 1509, Pizarro sailed
with Alonso de Ojeda to Venezuela, and from there joined the fleet of explorer
Martn Fernndez de Enciso, probing Colombias Guajira Peninsula. In 1513,
Pizarro accompanied Vasco Nez de Balboas expedition to the Pacific Ocean.
Six years later, acting on behalf of Governor Pedro Arias Dvila, Pizarro arrested
Balboa on charges of usurping
the governors authority. Balboa
and four alleged accomplices
were executed, and Dvila installed Pizarro as mayor and
magistrate of Panama City.
Pizarro held that post
through 1523, then embarked
on his first attempt to conquer the rich Inca Empire. Native resistance and inclement
weather defeated him in 1524,
and again in 1526, but Pizarro
persevered in his quest to rival
Corts. Panamas governor,
Pedro de los Ros, sought to
recall Pizarro after the second
abortive invasion, but Pizarro
ignored his orders, finally penetrating northern Peru in April
1528. The wealth of precious
Francisco Pizarro, Spanish governor of Peru, was metals he discovered there enassassinated by rebels in June 1541. (Michael couraged him, but Governor
Nicholson/Corbis)
Ros refused to fund a third
expedition. Going over the governors head, Pizarro sailed back to Spain and
secured backing from King Charles I, who granted approval and offered Pizarro
control over any new lands that he conquered for the Spanish crown. Pizarros
new status as Adelantado (military governor) of New Castille gave him virtually
unlimited authority within 200 leagues (600 miles) of South Americas newly
discovered Pacific Coast. Thus encouraged, Pizarro rallied family and friends,
sailed back to Panama, and pushed off for Peru in January 1530.
Participants in the new invasion of Peru included Pizarros brothers
(Gonzalo, Hernando and Juan), a cousin (Pedro Pizarro), Francisco de Orellana (who would later discover and explore the Amazon River), and Diego de
Almagro, a partner of Pizarro in his Peruvian adventures since 1524. Their
military force included 180 men70 below the minimum number demanded
by King Charlesand 27 horses. At risk of arrest for failure to meet his enlistment quota, Pizarro sailed clandestinely with three ships, first to the Canary
Islands, then to Panama. His third and final expedition to Peru embarked
from Panama on December 15, 1530, reaching the coast of present-day Ecuador after 13 days at sea. There, Pizarro obtained some gold, silver and emeralds, shipping the booty back to Panama, where Diego de Almagro had
remained to recruit more soldiers.
April of 1531 brought Pizarros force to the Inca city of Tumbes, in northwestern Peru, where the Spaniards met resistance from Chief Chilimaza in
the Battle of the Manglares. Victorious, Pizarro planted a cross and claimed
the area for Spain, then moved on to kill 400 warriors under Chief Tumbala
in the Battle of Pun, against Spanish losses of three dead and 26 wounded.
Joined by Hernando de Soto with another band of soldiers, Pizarro pressed
forward, founding the first Spanish settlement in Peruonly the third in
South Americain July 1532, at the site of present-day Piura.
As Pizarro advanced, Incan emperor Atahualpa was briefly distracted by
a civil war against his brother Huscar, which concluded with Huscars defeat at the Battle of Quipaipan in April 1532. Resting at Cajamarca with some
80,000 soldiers, Atahualpa was initially contemptuous of the small force led
by Pizarro and de Soto, but he decided to crush them as an object lesson to
future invaders. Pizarro, though vastly outnumbered, conspired to achieve
by guile what he could not secure by brute force. On November 15, 1532,
Pizarro invited Atahualpa to a meeting at Cajamarca. The emperor arrived
on November 16 with 2,000 bodyguards, unwisely divested of armor and all
weapons aside from small ceremonial knives used to sacrifice llamas. Pizarro
promptly staged an ambush, complete with a cavalry charge and volleys from
four cannons, killing an estimated 2,000 Incas, capturing Atahualpa and
some 5,000 more as they rampaged through the stricken city.
While looting Cajamarca of gold and other treasures worth billions of dollars today, Pizarro held Atahualpa hostage to forestall retaliation by the Incan
429
430
P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
Pizarro Demarkes, Don Francisco Pizarro who discovered Peru and presented
it to the crown of Castile. Forensic pathologists examined both bodies, reporting that the latters skull bore multiple sword wounds, thereby confirming it as
Pizarros.
Further Reading
Gabai, Rafael. Francisco Pizarro and His Brothers: The Illusion of Power in SixteenthCentury Peru. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1997.
Hemming, John. The Conquest of the Incas. San Diego: Harvest Books, 2003.
Koch, Peter. The Spanish Conquest of the Inca Empire. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2007.
MacQuarrie, Kim. The Last Days of the Incas. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008.
431
432
P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
Carbo. Sulla, once installed as dictator, expressed his gratitude by offering his
stepdaughter Aemilia Scaura to Pompey as his bride. Undeterred by the fact
that both were marriedand Aemilia was pregnant by her current husband
Pompey arranged a double divorce followed by his second hasty marriage. Aemilia subsequently died in childbirth, and Pompey remained firmly ensconced
in Sullas good graces.
In 82 BCE, Pompey conquered Sicily on Sullas behalf, thereby securing
Romes source of grain, executing rival Gnaeus Papirius Carbo and many
of his supporters in a slaughter that earned Pompey the nickname adulescens carnifex (adolescent butcher). A year later, he secured Romes Provincia
Africa (part of present-day Tunisia) by defeating Gnaeus Domitius Ahenobarbus and Nubian king Hiarbas at Utica. In the wake of those victories,
Pompey returned to Rome and was greeted by Sulla as Magnus (The Great),
although he remained a private citizen with no political rank. At the same
time, Sulla denied Pompeys request for a triumpha civil ceremony and religious rite celebrating achievement of a military commander in wartime
and ordered Pompey to disband his legions. Pompey refused, rallying his
soldiers at the gates of Rome, whereupon Sulla relented after a fashion. The
dictator granted Pompey his triumph, but only after lavish ceremonies for
himself and General Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius.
Pompey began his maneuvers for political power in 78 BCE, backing Marcus Aemilius Lepidus over Sullas objections in that years consular election.
Sulla died before years end, and when Lepidus sought to seize Rome by force,
Pompey turned against him, driving him to exile in Sardinia, where he died in
78 BCE. Next, he sought appointment as proconsul of Hispania (the Iberian
Peninsula), where General Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius had thus far failed
to suppress rebel forces led by Quintus Sertorius. Granted joint command over
Hispania with Metellus, Pompey arrived on the scene in 76 BCE, facing stiff
guerrilla warfare until Sertorius was assassinated in 72 BCE. Hispania was fully
secured for Rome by the following year, when Pompey returned to Italy.
He arrived in time to join yet another conflict, the Third Servile War, pitting General Marcus Licinius Crassus against an army of 120,000 rebellious
slaves led by Spartacus. Crassus had fared poorly in the wars first two years,
but Pompeys reinforcements tipped the balance in Romes favor, killing
12,300 rebels and capturing 5,000 more in battle near present-day Strongoli,
in Bruttium (now Calabria). Latecomer Pompey claimed full credit for suppressing the three-year revolt and received his second formal triumph, for victory in Hispania, December 31, 71 BCE. Swathed in glory, he won election as
co-consul, serving with Crassus, at the unprecedented age of 35.
Pompeys next famous campaign was waged against Mediterranean pirates,
under terms of the Lex Gabinia, passed in 67 BCE, granting him vast military
power over all Roman territory within 50 miles of the coastline. (See sidebar.)
Mounting a rapid and ruthless campaign, Pompey killed thousands of pirates,
P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
sank hundreds of ships, and razed scores of seaports, driving those buccaneers
who survived far inland to pursue their trade as landlocked bandits, reducing
Mediterranean piracy to scattered incidents for the next four centuries.
Before Pompey could return to Rome from that sweeping victory, Tribune
Gaius Manilius nominated him to succeed Lucius Licinius Lucullus as commander in the Third Mithridatic War, ongoing in the region of present-day
Armenia since 73 BCE. Lucullus resented Pompeys appointment, calling him
a vulture who fed on the hard work of other commanders, but the senate
confirmed his replacement. True to form, Pompey arranged a treaty with King
Tigranes the Great in 67 BCE, then pursued Mithridates VI of Pontus to his defeat and ultimate assassination four years later. In the process, Pompey secured
Roman supremacy in Phoenicia and Coele-Syria, while laying siege to Jerusalem and killing 12,000 Jews under King Aristobulus II, restoring Hyrcanus II
to the throne.
Returning to Rome as a near-legendary figure, worshipped by a cult at
Delos, Pompey celebrated his third triumph on his 45th birthday in 61 BCE,
claiming conquests that exceeded those of Alexander the Great. For the first
time in 21 years, Pompey dismissed his legions with land grants to surviving
veterans, settling into an uneasy political alliance with Marcus Licinius Crassus
and Gaius Julius Caesar, known as the First Triumvirate. Although lacking any
official status, the arrangement served all three men, electing Caesar as consul
in 61 BCE with a promise to promote various claims from Pompey and Crassus.
(Again, in familiar style, Pompey helped cement the alliance by marrying Caesars daughter Julia.) Caesar named Pompey governor of Hispania in absentia,
supervising transportation of grain to Rome, and then moved on to serve as
proconsul in Gaul (now France).
The First Triumvirate was showing signs of strain by 56 BCE, as Caesar
surpassed his colleagues in popularity and military glory. At the same time,
rumors spread that Crassus had conspired to murder Pompey. At a secret
meeting in Lucca, Caesar suggested that Pompey and Crassus should seek reelection as joint consuls in 55 BCE, a goal accomplished at some cost through
a campaign of bribery, intimidation, and violence. Once in office, they agreed
to extend Caesars rule over Gaul for five years. Their own rewards, upon retirement from office, would be continued control over Hispania (for Pompey)
and governorship of Syria for Crassus (desired as a launching pad for invading Parthia). The Triumvirate finally dissolved after Julias death during childbirth, in 54 BCE, and the Parthian defeat of Crassus a year later, which killed
20,000 Romans (Crassus among them) and led to the capture of 10,000 more
at the Battle of Carrhae.
Rome was humiliated by that defeat, which cost the Pathians only 100 soldiers. Pompey assuaged his grief at losing Julia and their infant child by wedding the newly widowed daughter of Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius Scipio
Nasica, an archenemy of Julius Caesar. Again, marriage advanced Pompey,
433
434
P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
LEX GABINIA
Enacted in 67 BCE, ancient Romes Lex Gabinia (Gabinian Law) granted
Pompey the Great extraordinary proconsular powers over any province lying within 50 miles of the Mediterranean Sea. Named after its
author, Tribune Aulus Gabinius, the law granted Pompey a command of
500 warships, 120,000 infantry, and 5,000 cavalry, with orders to suppress rampant piracy on the Mediterranean within three years time.
In fact, he accomplished that goal within 40 days. Roman senators approved the law with considerable trepidation, fearing that the power
placed in Pompeys hands might establish him as a new dictator. A year
later, passage of the Lex Manilia (named for Tribune Gaius Manilius)
further expanded Pompeys authority, granting him supreme command
in the war against King Mithridates VI of Pontus, in place of predecessor Lucius Licinius Lucullus. Today, historians regard passage of the Lex
Gabinia as a major step toward the senates collapse as Romes ruling
body, marking a point of no return in that legislatures ability to block
concentration of power in the hands of powerful generals such as Pompey and Julius Caesar, a prelude to civil war that was, in turn, a precursor to the Roman Republics dissolution.
Further Reading
Greenhalgh, Peter. Pompey: The Republican Prince. London: George Weidenfeld and
Nicolson Ltd, 1981.
Leach, John. Pompey the Great. London: Routledge, 1986.
Rawson, Beryl. The Politics of Friendship: Pompey and Cicero. Sydney: Sydney University
Press, 1978.
Seager, Robin. Pompey the Great: A Political Biography. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing,
2002.
Southern, Pat. Pompey the Great: Caesars Friend and Foe. Stroud, Gloucestershire,
United Kingdom: Tempus Publishing, 2002.
PREMADASA, RANASINGHE
Sri Lankan president Ranasinghe Premadasa, killed by a terrorist bomb in 1993. (Time &
Life Pictures/Getty Images)
435
436
the 1950s, Premadasa shifted his allegiance to the center-right United National
Party (UNP), founded in September 1946. Ceylon, meanwhile, had achieved
its independence from Great Britain in February 1948, with Don Stephen
Senanayake elected as the nations first prime minister. Senanayakes son Dudley succeeded him in March 1952, and named Premadasa to serve as minister
of broadcasting, in charge of Radio Ceylon.
Premadasa bided his time through successive administrations, while Ceylon
underwent dramatic changes. In 1972, it became the Free, Sovereign and Independent Republic of Sri Lanka, with a new constitution. Five years later, with
an 80-percent majority in parliament, the UNP amended that document to
create an executive presidency, first occupied in February 1978 by then prime
minister Junius Richard Jayewardene. In September 1978, a new constitution
scrapped the bicameral legislature in favor of a single house, and established
the presidents term as six years. Premadasa, chosen as prime minister in February 1978, found himself with less power than his predecessors in that office,
but was determined to make the best of it.
Premadasa retained the prime ministers office until January 2, 1989,
when he succeeded fellow UNP member Junius Jayewardene as president
of Sri Lanka. He found himself presiding over a nation in rebellion, with
LTTE guerrillas battling members of an Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF)
in the north, and members of the MarxistLeninist Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (Peoples Liberation Front) wreaking havoc in the south. Indias
intrusion on Sri Lanka was unwelcome, and when the IPKF refused to withdraw, Premadasa reportedly brokered a secret agreement to arm the LTTE.
That effort backfired when 774 Sri Lankan policemen surrendered to the
LTTE at Premadasas request, then were slaughtered en masse. A presidential commission also determined, years later, that President Premadasa and
members of the Sri Lankan army were directly responsible for the death of
Lieutenant General Denzil Kobbekaduwa, killed by a land mine in August
1992, after he announced Operation Final Countdown, aimed at wiping
out the LTTE.
Another thorn in Premadasas side was Lalith Athulathmudali, his leading
rival in the 1988 presidential election. Defeated in that contest, Athulathmudali joined third-place contender Lionel Gamini Dissanayake to create a new
political party, the Democratic United National Front (DUNF), in 1991. The
DUNF moved to impeach Premadasa that autumn, charging that the president had circumvented legal procedures in naming cronies to high political
positions, and blocking Athulathmudali and Dissanayake from influential positions. A more serious accusation blamed Premadasa for the disappearance of
Luxman Perera, a Sri Lankan playwright and close ally of Athulathmudali. Parliament rejected the impeachment petition in October 1991, but tension escalated nationwide, soon flaring into violence.
PREMADASA, RANASINGHE
Between November 1991 and August 1992, DUNF leaders reported four
mob attacks on their rallies: at Pannala on November 2, at Madapatha on
April 23, at Colombos Fort Railway Station on August 7, and at Dehiwala on
August 29. On March 16, 1993, Premadasas regime dissolved the countrys
seven provincial councils and announced elections for new members to be
held on May 17. Lalith Athulathmudali promptly announced his attention to
seek the chief ministership of the Western Province Council, but he was shot
dead on April 23. One day later, police produced the corpse of a Tamil youth
and supposed LTTE member named Ragunathan, branding him the assassin
and claiming that he had killed himself with a cyanide capsule. Detectives
from Scotland Yard were investigating those claims when a bomb killed President Premadasa on May 1.
British detectives eventually filed their report, confirming the original verdict
on Athulathmudalis death and finding no evidence, direct or circumstantial, to
support allegations that Athulathmudali was slain by government agents. Still,
controversy persisted, contributing to a 1994 electoral victory for the Peoples
Alliance, an amalgam of the DUNF and six other leftist parties, which installed
Chandrika Kumaratunga as president. In 1995, Kumaratunga appointed a
three-member commission to investigate Athulathmudalis murder. The commissions final report, submitted in October 1997, exonerated Ragunathan as
the killer, finding that he had been shot, then force-fed cyanide by persons unknown, presumed to be Athulathmudalis actual assassins. The report named
Colombo underworld godfather Arambawalage Don Ranjith Upali de Silva
as Ragunathans probable slayer, and tagging gang member Janaka Priyanka
Jayamanna as Athulathmudalis killer. Other syndicate members implicated in
the plot, and in prior attacks on DUNF rallies, included Wathudula Bandulage
Somaratne, Nandasiri Karunatilake, and Bulathsinhalage Ajith Coorey (son of
Sri Lankas minister of housing and construction, Bulathsinhalage Srisena Cooray). The report also charged Uswatte Liyanage Senivaratne, a UNP provincial councilor for the Western Province, of leading attacks on DUNF members.
Finally, Sri Lankan police faced accusations of negligence and tampering with
evidence in their investigation.
Based on that report, in September 1998, prosecutors charged five police
officersincluding Inspector Devasundara, chief of the Terrorism Investigation Departmentwith framing and murdering suspect Ragunathan. Unknown gunmen killed three of those defendants prior to trial, apparently
to silence them. Janaka Jayamanna was also slain, gangland-style, before he
could be tried for Athulathmudalis murder, as was Arambawalage Upali. Several other suspects spent up to four years in prison awaiting trial, then were
apparently released. On December 18, 1999, President Kumaratunga was
partially blinded in an LTTE attack in Colombo, during a campaign rally, but
she survived to win reelection and served until November 2005.
437
438
P R I M Y P R AT S, J UA N
Further Reading
Clarence, William. Ethnic Warfare in Sri Lanka and the UN Crisis. London: Pluto Press,
2006.
Jeganathan, Pradeep, and Qadri Ismail, eds. Unmaking the Nation: The Politics of Identity
& History in Modern Sri Lanka. Colombo, Sri Lanka: Social Scientists Association,
2009.
Little, David. Sri Lanka: The Invention of Enmity. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press, 1994.
Pratap, Anita. Island of Blood. New York: Penguin Books, 2003.
Richardson, John. Paradise Poisoned: Learning about Conflict, Terrorism and Development
from Sri Lankas Civil Wars. Kandy, Sri Lanka: International Center for Ethnic Studies, 2005.
Uyangoda, Jayadeva. Ethnic Conflict in Sri Lanka: Changing Dynamics. Washington, DC:
East-West Center Washington, 2007.
Weiss, Gordon. The Cage: The Fight for Sri Lanka and the Last Days of the Tamil Tigers.
New York: Bellevue Literary Press, 2012.
P R I M Y P R AT S , J U A N
439
440
P R I M Y P R AT S, J UA N
the brutality of his methods prompted Queen Isabella to demand his resignation in July 1866. ODonnells successor, Ramn Mara Narvez, fought on
against Prim until his death in April 1868. Five months later, Prim and ally
Francisco Serrano defeated royal troops at the Battle of Alcolea, thereby concluding the Glorious Revolution and driving Isabella herself into exile.
Serrano was appointed Regent in October 1868, doubling as prime minister
from February 1869, and Prim became president of the Council of Ministers.
The Chamber of Deputies thereafter moved to restore Spains monarchy under
a new dynasty, electing the Duke of Aosta as King Amadeo I on November 16,
1870. Prim considered it a personal triumph, but he would not live to help
Amadeo rule Spain under its new constitution. Two days after Prim expired
from his gunshot wounds, Amadeo vowed to support the constitution, granting election of parliament by universal male suffrage. That agreement survived
until Amadeos abdication on February 11, 1873, with Spains First Republic
proclaimed that same night.
Spanish author Benito Prez Galds (18431920) offered a quasi-fictional
solution to the mystery of Prims assassination in his 1909 novel Espaa trgica
(Spanish Tragedy). Starting with events from his adolescence in Madrid, Galds
spun a tale of evil omens leading up to Prims murder, creating an almost surrealistic view of the crime. After personally naming Jos Pal y Angulo as a prime
suspect during the 1870s, based on published claims that Prim had recognized
Pals voice during the shooting, Galds changed his tune three decades later,
presenting an alternate cast of culprits via a list compiled by fictional character
Segismundo Garca. As noted by University of Alabama scholar Brian Dendle
in 1969, Galds ultimately blames the assassination on a mixed cast of characters including surviving rebels from the Carlist Wars and offering what Dendle
calls a red herring in the person of Antoine dOrlans. Jos Pal y Angulo,
meanwhile, is reduced to the status of a peripheral player, branded a deranged
epileptic incapable of plotting or carrying out the murder. The case remains officially unsolved.
Further Reading
Barker, Nancy. The French Experience in Mexico, 18211861: A History of Constant Misunderstanding. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2011.
Dendle, Brian. Galds and the Death of Prim. Bibliotecha Virtual Miguel de Cervantes.
http://www.cervantesvirtual.com/obra-visor/anales-galdosianos3/html/0254d158
82b211df-acc7002185ce6064_42.html.
Holt, Edgar. The Carlist Wars in Spain. Chester Springs, PA: Dufour Editions, 1967.
Pierson, Peter. The History of Spain. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1999.
Thomson, Guy. The Birth of Modern Politics in Spain: Democracy, Association and Revolution, 185475. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
Williams, Mark. The Story of Spain: The Dramatic History of Europes Most Fascinating
Country. Rancho Mirage, CA: Golden Era Books, 2009.
Famous
Assassinations
in World History
Famous
Assassinations
in World History
An Encyclopedia
Volume 2: QZ
MICHAEL NEWTON
17
16
15
14
Contents
Preface
xv
Introduction
xvii
The Encyclopedia
Volume 1
Abdallah Abderemane, Ahmed (19191989)
Aguiyi-Ironsi, Johnson Thomas Umunnakwe (19241966)
al-Banna, Sheikh Hasan Ahmed Abdel Rahman Muhammed
(19061949)
Albert I of Habsburg (12551308)
al-Din Shah Qajar, Nasser (18311896)
Alexander I of Serbia (18761903)
Alexander I of Yugoslavia (18881934)
Alexander II of Russia (18181881)
Ali, Muhammad Mansur (19191975)
Amin, Hafizullah (19291979)
Aquino, Benigno Simeon, Jr. (19321983)
Araujo, Manuel Enrique (18651913)
Argaa Ferraro, Luis Mara del Corazn de Jess Dionisio
(19321999)
Assassins Cult (ca. 10921275)
Bahonar, Mohammad-Javad (19331981)
Balbinus (165 CE238 CE)
Balewa, Abubakar Tafawa (19121966)
Bandaranaike, Solomon West Ridgeway Dias (18991959)
Bautista Gill Garca del Barrio, Juan (18401877)
Becket, Thomas (11181170)
Belzu Humerez, Manuel Isidoro (18081865)
Bearan Ordeana, Jos Miguel (19491978)
1
2
3
6
7
9
10
12
14
15
17
20
21
23
27
28
30
32
34
35
38
40
vi
CONTENTS
42
43
45
48
49
51
52
54
56
57
59
61
65
67
69
71
72
73
75
76
78
80
83
84
87
92
93
94
96
97
99
103
104
106
108
109
CONTENTS
111
113
115
117
118
120
121
125
128
129
131
132
135
136
138
140
142
145
146
148
150
152
155
156
161
164
165
167
169
171
173
176
177
179
vii
viii
CONTENTS
181
183
184
186
188
190
193
195
199
201
202
205
208
209
211
213
215
217
219
220
222
225
231
232
234
237
239
240
241
245
247
249
252
254
255
CONTENTS
257
264
269
271
277
281
282
285
288
291
295
298
299
302
305
307
309
311
312
317
320
321
323
326
328
330
331
333
335
336
339
341
342
344
ix
CONTENTS
351
353
355
358
361
366
369
375
381
384
386
391
393
397
401
403
406
409
412
415
418
420
422
425
427
431
435
438
Volume 2
Qadir, Haji Abdul (19512002)
Qutuz, Saif ad-Din (?1260)
Rabin, Yitzhak (19221995)
Radama II (18291863)
Rahman, Ziaur (19361981)
Rasputin, Grigori Yefimovich (18691916)
441
444
447
451
453
456
CONTENTS
460
462
464
465
470
471
473
475
476
481
483
486
491
494
497
499
502
504
505
507
511
513
515
517
520
522
525
526
528
530
534
535
538
541
543
xi
xii
CONTENTS
544
548
550
552
555
558
559
562
564
567
569
572
576
580
585
588
591
595
597
600
604
606
610
614
616
621
625
628
630
634
637
641
645
649
CONTENTS
652
655
Primary Documents
1. Assassination of Pompey the Great (48 BCE)
Plutarchs Description of the Murder of Pompey in Egypt
661
664
668
671
672
675
680
683
688
691
693
694
700
703
xiii
xiv
CONTENTS
709
715
720
727
780
797
800
808
812
815
Selected Bibliography
835
Index
837
Preface
xvi
P R E FA C E
backgrounds of participants, and describe events that sprang from violence directed against public figures.
The section of entries is followed by a selection of 23 primary documents.
Arranged chronologically, these documents comprise accounts of assassinations
and reports of investigations, as well as speeches and statutes that preceded or
resulted from the murders. The documents included range from Plutarchs description of the murder of Pompey the Great in Egypt in 48 BCE, through the
last speech of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, delivered moments before
his murder in 1995.
Finally, to ensure complete coverage of the subject, an appendix provides a
timeline of other prominent assassinations omitted from the main text entries
due to space constraints. That list includes 486 cases, spanning the globe and
the years from 748 BCE to 2012. In that timeline, continents and their countries
are arranged alphabetically, with assassinations and attempts for each specific
country listed chronologically. A detailed subject index will help users find important figures, events, and ideas in the main entries.
Every effort has been made to present timely, complete, and accurate information throughout Famous Assassinations in World History. That said, available
sourcesparticularly those concerned with ancient crimes and modern, controversial casesfrequently provide conflicting dates, names, and descriptions
of events. In each case, I have chosen what appears to be the best and most
substantive information currently available. Readers wishing to suggest corrections for perceived inaccuracies, or to offer further data on the cases here
described, may contact the author through ABC-CLIO, or directly through his
Web site at www.michaelnewton.homestead.com.
Introduction
xviii
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
whether they have any credence. In cases where facts are disputed, witnesses
contradicted, or evidence has vanished, further detailed information may be
found within the sources suggested for further readingand, in turn, through
their bibliographies. Although the author has opinions in most cases, they are
not presented here. Critics of the official verdictsand their detractors, in
turnare permitted to speak for themselves.
There can be no last word on assassinations, as long as discontent and violence persist on Earth. If anything, our world appears to be a more chaotic, violent place today than during many eras of the past. Between 2006 and 2012,
Mexicos drug war claimed at least 54,927 lives, with another 10,000 victims
disappeared; some estimates of the seven-year death toll top 99,000. Narcoterrorism in Central America is equally lethal: Honduras, El Salvador, Belize,
Guatemala, and Panama all had higher per-capita murder rates than Mexico in
2010. La Violencia (The Violence) engulfed Colombia in 1946, resulting in
300,000 homicides by 1958. Today, that nations plague of narcoterrorism produced 13,520 murders in 2011hailed by Colombias National Police as the
lowest violent death toll since 1984. Reports from Iraq, Afghanistan, and parts
of Africa are equally dismal.
Famous Assassinations in World History presents a chronicle of malice and
mistakes, in hope that something may be learned, at least, from the mistakes.
Whether those lessons are absorbed depends in equal part on public leaders,
law enforcement, and an educated populace.
xix
Q
QADIR, HAJI ABDUL (19512002)
Shortly after noon on July 6, 2002, Haji Abdul Qadir completed his days duties
as Afghanistans minister of public works and one of five vice presidents. Leaving his office in downtown Kabul, he started for home in a Toyota Land Cruiser
driven by his son-in-law. At 12:30, two men armed with automatic weapons
ambushed Qadirs vehicle, riddling it with bullets and killing both occupants,
before escaping in a taxi that waited nearby. A report from the United Nations
High Commissioner for Refugees, published in September 2005, asserts that
one man was condemned to die for the murders in June 2004, with two accomplices sentenced to prison, but no further details were available as this volume
went to press.
Haji Abdul Qadir was born in Jalalabad, the capital of eastern Afghanistans
Nangarhar Province, sometime in 1951. He was a member of the Pashtun
people, Afghanistans largest ethnic group, which has produced nearly all the
countrys native leaders for the past 250 years. Involved in politics before the
December 1979 Soviet invasion of his homeland, Qadir joined a mujahideen
resistance faction led by Mohammad Yunus Khalis. That nine-year struggle
ended with Russias withdrawal from Afghanistan in February 1989, and the
pro-Soviet Peoples Democratic Party of Afghanistan dissolved in March 1992,
whereupon Qadir was named to serve as governor of Nangarhar Province.
He held that post until September 1996, when Taliban forcessupported
from Pakistan and Saudi Arabiaseized control of Afghanistan. Qadir fled into
Pakistan, but found exile there untenable when leaders of the Islamic Republic
recognized his opposition to the Taliban. Over the next three years, Qadir divided his time between Germany and Dubai, where he prospered as the leader
of a successful trading company. In 1999, Qadir returned home to join Ahmad
Shah Massouds United Islamic Front for the Salvation of Afghanistan, an antiTaliban movement better known in the West as the Northern Alliance. The
group joined Pashtuns with ethnic Hazaras, Tajiks, and Uzbeks in opposition
to the Talibans ultra-fundamentalist version of Islam, waging armed resistance
against the ruling regime, and the Taliban received assistance from Pakistan
and Osama bin Ladens al-Qaeda terrorist network.
The terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, brought the United States into
Afghanistans chaotic civil war. Qadirs younger brother, Abdul Haqhimself a
442
veteran of the anti-Soviet resistance, lately returned from Pakistan to fight the Talibanwas
captured and executed by Taliban members on October 26,
2001, shortly after meeting
with agents of the U.S. Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA) to coordinate strikes on the enemy.
(An alternate version blames
the CIA for his death, citing an
interview in which Haq reportedly said, We cannot be Americas puppets.) Soon afterward,
on November 13, Haji Qadir
emerged as a leader of the
Eastern Shura, a regional antiTaliban unit operating in Nangarhar and Khost Provinces. In
December 2001, Qadir traveled
to Bonn, Germany, as a delegate
Afghani politician Haji Abdul Qadir, killed in an
to the International Conference
ambush in July 2002. (Reuters/Corbis)
on Afghanistan, where he endorsed selection of Hamid Karzai as president of the Afghan Transitional Administration (still in power as this
volume went to press). Karzai, in turn, rewarded Qadir for his support with appointment to serve as a vice president and minister of public works, the post he
held until his murder.
Upon learning of Qadirs assassination, U.S. president George W. Bush told
reporters, Theres all kinds of scenarios as to who killed him. It could be drug
lords. It could be rivals. Who knows? All we know is that a good man is dead,
and we mourn his loss. Some observers questioned his designation of Qadir
as a good man, citing persistent allegations of his ties to Afghanistans burgeoning opium trade. Taliban leader Mullah Mohammed Omar had collaborated with the United Nations to eradicate heroin production in Afghanistan,
slashing production by 91 percent in 2000. No opium production was found
the following year, a circumstance that earned the Taliban a $43 million reward payment prior to 9/11, but U.S. liberation of Afghanistan reversed that
trend dramatically. By November 2001, the United Nations Office on Drugs
and Crime found 1,300 square kilometers under opium cultivation, with the
illicit trade expanding until Afghanistan produced 92 percent of the worlds
nonpharmaceutical-grade opiates by November 2007.
Peter Symonds, writing for the World Socialist Web Site in July 2002,
branded Qadi a thug and smuggler, calling him notorious for his association with the regions lucrative smuggling operations and opium trade,
further contending that Qadirs sordid past is well known in Washington.
His trading company during the latter part of the 1990s, Symonds wrote,
was actually a large-scale smuggling racket that operated from Afghanistan into Pakistan. Symonds further claimed that Qadir stood accused of
manipulating the countrys Western-financed drug eradication program to
siphon off money and narcotics for his private benefit. Although Symonds
cited no specific evidence, the CIAs collaboration with narcotics traffickers
worldwide is well established, dating from the first year of the agencys creation in France, extending through the Vietnam War and the Iran-Contra
scandal under President Ronald Reagan.
Qadir received a full state funeral in Kabul, attended by some 10,000
mourners, and government spokesman Sayed Fazl Akbar told reporters that
President Karzai had asked the NATO-led International Security Assistance
Force (ISAF) to help ensure a completely neutral, fair, quick and professional investigation into Qadirs assassination. Turkish major general Hilmi
Akin Zorlu, in charge of that force, readily agreed, declaring, It is vital to
bring the perpetrators of this crime to justice as soon as possible and ISAF
will donate every resource required to achieve it. Even so, two years elapsed
before a trial was held, and details of its result remain elusive.
A month after the conviction of three alleged conspirators in Qadirs slaying,
on July 29, 2004, a crowd gathered to commemorate his death at the Kabul
site where he was slain. Authorities averted a catastrophe with the discovery of
an explosive charge, concealed inside a cart near the memorial gathering. Defused before it detonated, the bomb was clearly meant to kill attending cabinet ministers and other prominent public figures still loyal to Qadirs memory.
Qadirs son, Zahir Qadirformerly a Taliban prisoner, then a general in Afghanistans Border Guard, serves today in the nations parliament.
Further Reading
Dorronsoro, Gilles. Revolution Unending: Afghanistan, 1979 to the Present. New York:
Columbia University Press, 2005.
Refugee Review Tribunal Report on Afghanistan. September 16, 2005. United Nations
High Commissioner for Refugees. http://www.unhcr.org/refworld/pdfid/4b6fe117d.pdf.
Rubin, Barnett. The Fragmentation of Afghanistan: State Formation and Collapse in the International System. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2002.
Saikal, Amin. Modern Afghanistan: A History of Struggle and Survival. London: I.B. Tauris, 2012.
Symonds, Peter. Afghan Vice-President Murdered in Broad Daylight. World Socialist Web Site. July 9, 2002. http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2002/07/afgh-j09.html.
443
444
Tanner, Stephen. Afghanistan: A Military History from Alexander the Great to the War
against the Taliban. Philadelphia: Da Capo Press, 2009.
Tomsen, Peter. The Wars of Afghanistan: Messianic Terrorism, Tribal Conflicts, and the
Failures of Great Powers. New York: Public Affairs, 2011.
He accomplished that at the Battle of Ain Jalut, on September 3, 1260. Fielding 20,000 troops against a Mongol force of equal size, led by Kitbuqa Noyan,
Qutuz suffered heavy losses but succeeded in annihilating his opponents. His
determination, doubtless, was encouraged by a warning sent to him before the
battle from Hulagu Khan, a grandson of Genghis Khan who ruled the Mongol
Empire from 1256 to 1265. That message read:
From the King of Kings of the East and West, the Great Khan. To Qutuz the
Mamluk, who fled to escape our swords. You should think of what happened to
other countries and submit to us. You have heard how we have conquered a vast
empire and have purified the earth of the disorders that tainted it. We have conquered vast areas, massacring all the people. You cannot escape from the terror of
our armies. Where can you flee? What road will you use to escape us? Our horses
are swift, our arrows sharp, our swords like thunderbolts, our hearts as hard as
the mountains, our soldiers as numerous as the sand. Fortresses will not detain
us, nor armies stop us. Your prayers to God will not avail against us. We are not
moved by tears nor touched by lamentations. Only those who beg our protection
will be safe. Hasten your reply before the fire of war is kindled. Resist and you
will suffer the most terrible catastrophes. We will shatter your mosques and reveal
the weakness of your God and then will kill your children and your old men together. At present you are the only enemy against whom we have to march.
In the midst of battle, Qutuz was heard to shout, Oh, Islam! Oh God, grant
your servant Qutuz a victory against the Mongols! Kitbuqa died at the head of
his troops and was decapitated, his head shipped back to Cairo as a trophy. At
the battles end, Qutuz reportedly kissed the earth and prayed, and his surviving troops engaged in looting of the Mongol dead.
As a result of their loss at Ain Jalut, Mongol forces abandoned Damascus,
occupied in March 1560, and soon withdrew from the northern Levant entirely. Meanwhile, Baibarsone of Qutuzs leading field commanders in the
climactic battlebrooded over his perceived mistreatment by the sultan and
schemed for revenge, resulting in Qutuzs murder on October 24.
Qutuz was buried first at Al-Qusair, later exhumed and reburied in Cairo,
where a mosque in the Heliopolis today commemorates his name. Baibars
succeeded him as sultan, defeated another Mongol invasion of Syria at the
First Battle of Homs (December 10, 1260), and enjoyed repeated victories
over Christian Crusaders. He invaded Cicilian Armenia in 1266, captured Antioch and enslaved its population in May 1268, and lay siege to Tripoli in
May 1271. In that same year, during the Ninth Crusade, Baibars failed in an
attempt to poison Prince Edward I of England. In 1277, Baibars invaded the
Mongol-occupied Seljuk Sultanate of Rum, but failed to conquer the territory despite several significant victories. Historians report that Baibars died in
Damascus on July 1, 1277, from drinking poisoned kumis (fermented mares
445
446
milk), but they disagree as to whether his poisoning was murder or a clumsy
accident.
Further Reading
Amitai-Preiss, Reuven. Mongols and Mamluks: The Mamluk-Ilkhanid War, 12601281.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
Armstrong, Karen. Holy War: The Crusades and Their Impact on Todays World. New York:
Anchor Books, 2001.
Asbridge, Thomas. The Crusades: The Authoritative History of the War for the Holy Land.
New York: HarperCollins, 2010.
Riley-Smith, Jonathan. The Oxford History of the Crusades. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 2002.
Tyerman, Christopher. Gods War: A New History of the Crusades. Cambridge, MA:
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2009.
R
RABIN, YITZHAK (19221995)
On November 4, 1995, a rally heralding ratification of the Oslo I Accord between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) was staged in
Tel Avivs Kings of Israel Square. The rally began to break up, at 9:30 P.M., and
Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was leaving for home when he was approached
by Yigal Amir, a right-wing law student at Tel Avivs Bar-Ilan University who
bitterly opposed the Oslo Accords concessions to Palestinian Arabs. Acting
on a personal interpretation of din rodefa traditional Jewish law of the
pursuerfired three pistol shots at Rabin, striking the prime minister twice.
His third shot wounded a security guard, Yoram Rubin, before others subdued
and disarmed him. Rabin survived to reach Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center,
but he died during surgery, 40 minutes after the shooting. Investigators learned
that Yigal Amir had been under surveillance by Shin Bet, Israels internal security service, but the agent in charge of his case had declared that Amir posed
no threat to Rabin. Convicted at trial in March 1996, Amir received a life sentence plus six years for wounding Yoram Rubin. Although such sentences are
normally commuted to a 30-year maximum, President Moshe Katsav refused
clemency, stating that Amir deserved no forgiveness, no absolution and no
pardon.
Yitzhak Rabin was born in Jerusalem, to European immigrant parents, on
March 1, 1922. His father, Nehemiah Rubitzov, had come to the British Mandate of Palestine from Ukraine, as a member of the British armys Jewish Legion,
in 1917. Rabins parents moved to Tel Aviv in 1923, where he graduated with
honors from Kadoorie Agricultural High School, hoping to become an irrigation engineer. He abandoned that goal at age 19, in May 1941, joining the Palmach (strike force) of the paramilitary Haganah (The Defense, in Hebrew).
British military officers initially trained the Palmach in guerrilla tactics, but in
1943 attempted to disarm them. Operating as terrorists or freedom fighters,
depending on ones point of view, members of the Haganah carried out numerous assassinations and bombings directed at British diplomats and military
personnel in Palestine. Wholesale civil war erupted in November 1947, ending
in May 1948 when the independent State of Israel was established.
That move brought no peace to the region, as the first Arab-Israeli War began
one day later, on May 15. By that time, Rabin had risen through the Palmach
448
R ABIN, YITZHAK
A right-wing Israeli killed Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin in November 1995. (Bettmann/
Corbis)
ranks to serve as its chief operations officer. The Haganah, meanwhile, emerged
as the core of the new Israel Defense Forces (IDF). During a truce, in June 1948,
Rabin was involved in the Altalena Affair, in which IDF forces seized a cargo
ship loaded with weapons earmarked for the Irgun, self-styled National Military Organization in the Land of Israel, which had split off from the Haganah
in 1937. When the Arab War resumed, Rabin served as deputy commander of
Operation Danny, seizing territory east of Tel Aviv in July 1948. Another promotion established him as chief of operations for the Southern Front during
Operation Yoav (October 1948) and Operation Horev (December 1948 to
January 1949). In January 1949, on the island of Rhodes, Rabin participated in
negotiations that produced an armistice between Israel, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, and Syria.
At wars end, Rabin was the oldest Palmach veteran remaining in the IDF.
In 1964, Prime Minister Levi Eshkol named Rabin to serve as the IDFs chief of
staff, and Rabin reached the pinnacle of his martial career in June 1967, defeating Egypt, Jordan, and Syria in the Six-Day War. He then retired from military
service to become Israels ambassador to the United States (19681973). Prime
RABIN, YITZHAK
Minister Golda Meir appointed Rabin as minister of labor in March 1974, but
her resignation on April 11 of that year left him briefly unemployed. Before the
month was out, Rabin defeated rival Shimon Peres in a bid for leadership of the
Alignment Party, which named him to succeed Golda Meir as prime minister
on June 3, 1974.
Rabins first term as prime minister was distinguished by the Sinai Interim
Agreement on September 1975, in which Israel and Egypt vowed to resolve
disputes between them without resorting to military force, and by Operation
Entebbe (October 1976), wherein IDF commandos liberated 102 passengers
from an Air France flight hijacked by members of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, parked at Ugandas Entebbe Airport under the protection
of dictator Idi Amin. The raiders killed seven hijackers and 45 Ugandan soldiers, also destroying 31 Soviet-built warplanes, against one IDF soldier killed
and five wounded. Three hostages also died in the raid, and oneseparated
from the others for hospitalizationwas subsequently executed on Amins orders. Amin also ordered the slayings of several doctors and nurses who tried to
prevent that execution, and hundreds of Kenyans living in Uganda, whom he
blamed for their homeland supporting the IDF strike.
Later in 1976, Rabins political alliance faced a vote of no confidence from
the Agudat Yisrael party, alleging violation of the Sabbath when four fighter
planes were delivered to an Israeli air force on Saturday. Further trouble arose
in March 1977, when Rabin and U.S. president Jimmy Carter publicly disagreed on the extent of Israels legitimate defensible borders. Rabin dissolved
his government on April 22, 1977, with new elections scheduled for May 17.
Menachem Begin, representing the Likud (Consolidation) Party, carried that
vote by a landslide and succeeded Rabin on June 21.
Rabin did not leave politics upon resigning as prime minister. Rather, he
filled a seat in the Knesset, Israels unicameral national legislature, until September 13, 1984, when he replaced Moshe Arens as minister of defense under
Prime Minister Shimon Peres. He retained that cabinet post under Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir until March 1990, when Moshe Arens resumed the office
and Rabin returned to his Knesset seat, as a member of Israels Foreign Affairs
and Defense Committee. In 1992, Rabin was elected as chairman of the Labor
Party, replacing Yitzhak Shamir as prime minister on July 13.
After a lifetime as a leader in Israels wars, Rabin spent his second term as
prime minister pursuing peace. The Oslo Accords created a Palestinian National Authority with partial control over the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip and
West Bank of the Jordan River, followed on September 9, 1993, by Israels formal recognition of PLO leader Yasser Arafat as the Palestinian National Authoritys president. In October 1994, Rabin joined King Hussein of Jordan in
signing the IsraelJordan Treaty of Peace, which made Jordan the second Arab
country (after Egypt) to normalize relations with Israel. In 1994, with Arafat
449
450
R ABIN, YITZHAK
and Shimon Peres, Rabin was awarded a Nobel Peace Prize. During the same
year, Rabin also received the Ronald Reagan Freedom Award, reserved for
those who have made monumental and lasting contributions to the cause of
freedom worldwide.
Right-wing Israelisand many U.S. Jewsbitterly protested Rabins peace
overtures toward nations they regarded as mortal enemies. Likud party leader
(and current prime minister) Benjamin Netanyahu condemned Rabins administration as being removed from Jewish tradition . . . and Jewish values. More
extreme critics marched with posters depicting Rabin in a Nazi uniform and
with the cross-hairs of a snipers telescopic sight superimposed on his face.
Rabin either ignored those protests or publicly condemned them as chutzpah
(insolence or audacity). Although Netanyahu denied any intent to provoke
violence, Yigal Amirs post-assassination statements clearly demonstrate that he
viewed Rabin as a danger to Israel.
Despite the seemingly open-and-shut case against Amir, buttressed by the
gunmans public statements, conspiracy theories flourished in the wake of
Rabins assassination. An official commission of inquiry, convened in November
1995, published its report on the crime in March 1996. That document named
Amir as the lone assassin, but criticized Shin Bet for putting Rabin at risk and
ignoring extremist threats to his life. Shin Bet director Carmi Gillon resigned
in the wake of that accusation, subsequently facing allegations (but no formal
charges) of human rights violations during his tenure. Nonetheless, he was later
named as Israels ambassador to Denmark, serving from 2001 to 2003.
Suggestions of conspiracy arose from the forensic evidence in Rabins case,
including a police report of gunpowder found on his body and clothing (Amir
fired from a distance that precluded powder stippling). Surgical reports also
described an entry wound in Rabins chest, inconsistent with eyewitness accounts and a video recording of the murder indicating that Amir fired at the
prime ministers back. Three police escorts testified that Rabin displayed no
visible wounds when then prepared to move him from the shooting scene.
Stranger still, Dr. Mordechai Gutman, one of the surgeons who worked on
Rabin, declared that the first two wounds, to the chest and abdomen occurred
before Rabins arrival. The third, frontal chest wound, had to have been inflicted after he entered the hospital. Concerning Amir, reports circulated that
cartridge cases found at the shooting scene failed to match his semiautomatic
pistol, and that no gunshot residue was found on his hands or clothinga circumstance which, if true, suggests that he fired blank cartridges. Several police
officers and Shin Bet agents at the scene were also overheard suggesting that
the shots were blanks.
The implication of those claimsa second gunman, possibly one of Rabins
bodyguardsfollow a trend of conspiracy theories from various high-profile
assassinations in the United States and elsewhere. Lone-gunman proponents
RADAMA II
RADAMA II (18291863)
On May 7, 1863, over objections from his key advisors, King Radama II of
Madagascarthen known as the Merina Kingdomannounced a plan to legalize dueling. Fearing that the kings scheme would result in anarchy, Prime Minister Rainivoninahitriniony blocked traditional announcement of the new law at
the Zoma (Friday) market gathering on May 8. On Saturday, May 9, the prime
ministers younger brotherRainilaiarivony, commander of the royal army
led troops to arrest members of Radamas menamaso (red-eyes) personal entourage. Eleven were caught and executed before soldiers laid siege to Radamas
royal palace, the Rova of Antananarivo. On May 10, Radama surrendered the
remaining menamaso, based on Rainivoninahitrinionys promise that their lives
would be spared, but they were speared to death en masse on May 11. Finally,
on May 12, a band of soldiers stormed the palace and strangled Radama with
a silk sash, to avoid the taboo of spilling royal blood. His wife, Rabodo, was
spared and permitted to rule as Queen Rasoherina on condition that she grant
certain reforms, including freedom of religion and abolition of capital punishment based on royal decrees alone. A public announcement declared that Radama had committed suicide, whereupon his name was stricken from the list of
Madagascars kings, and mourning of his death was banned by law.
Radama was born Prince Rakotosehenondradama on September 23, 1829,
the only son and heir of widowed Queen Ranavalona I, who ruled Madagascar
451
452
R ADA M A II
RAHMAN, ZIAUR
(1877), establish a new legal system (1878), and promulgate a new constitution (1881). Napoleon III belatedly used the Lambert Charters revocation
as a pretext for invading Madagascar in May 1883, compelling recognition
of French property principles and an indemnity of 1,500,000 francs in May
1885. A second invasion, in December 1894, reduced Madagascar to the status of a French protectorate (called Malagasy) by September 1895. A wave of
antiforeign, anti-Christian rioting ensued, prompting France to annex Madagascar as a colony in 1896.
Despite the muddled circumstances of his death, murder described as suicide, rumors circulated that his strangling in May 1863 had only rendered
him unconscious, reviving unexpectedly as his corpse was carried toward
Ilafy for burial. In that scenario, the frightened bearers fled and Radama escaped, living to a ripe old age in anonymity near Lake Kinkony, in northwestern Madagascar. That story was apparently believed by certain prominent
foreigners including Jean Laborde and William Ellis, a representative of the
London Missionary Society, but no evidence of Radamas survival was ever
produced.
Further Reading
Diouf, Sylvianne. Kings and Queens of East Africa. New York: Grolier Publishing, 2000.
Laidler, Keith. Female Caligula: Ranavalona, the Mad Queen of Madagascar. Chichester,
West Sussex, United Kingdom: John Wiley & Sons, 2005.
Oliver, Samuel. Madagascar: An Historical Descriptive Account of the Island and Its Former Dependencies, Volume 1. New York: Macmillan and Co., 1886.
Prout, Ebenezer. Madagascar: Its Mission and Its Martyrs. London: London Missionary
Society, 1863.
453
454
Ziaur Rahmancommonly
known as Ziawas born at
Bagbari, in the Bogra district
of Bengal, British-ruled India,
on January 19, 1936. His father, a chemist, worked for the
government in Calcutta (now
Kolkata) when Rahman was
a child. In July 1947, passage
of the Indian Independence
Act sparked sectarian violence
between Hindus and Muslims, both of whom wanted to
rule the new nation. Instead,
a month later, the Muslimcontrolled Dominion of Pakistan was created in two segments, widely divided by the
bulk of northern India. East
Pakistan achieved its own
quasi-independence in 1955,
with its capital at Dhaka, and
West Pakistan (today simply
Rebel soldiers assassinated President Ziaur Rah- Pakistan) formally ruled both
man of Bangladesh, in May 1981. (Associated
regions from Islamabad.
Press)
While those changes altered
his homelands geography and
politics, Ziaur Rahman pursued a military career. While rising through the armys
ranks to serve as a major with the 8th East Bengal Regiment in Chittagong, he
bridled at institutional discrimination practiced against Bengali-born officers by
their superiors from West Pakistan. Diplomatic tension reached a head in 1970,
when East Pakistans dominant political partythe Awami League, led by Sheikh
Mujibur Rahman (known as Mujib, again, no relation to Ziaur Rahman)won
all but two of 169 seats allotted to East Pakistan in the Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament of Pakistan). Alarmed by the growing trend toward independence for East
Pakistan, President General Yahya Khan attempted to forge a coalition of the
Awami League and the Pakistan Peoples Party, dominated by Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Bhutto first threatened to break the legs of any party member
who participated in negotiations, then struck a secret deal with Mujib, agreeing
to create a coalition with himself as president and Mujib as prime minister.
At that point, Yahya Khans military police arrested Bhutto and Mujib, and
Khan launched Operation Searchlight, invading East Pakistan on March 26,
RAHMAN, ZIAUR
1971. A parallel naval assault, Operation Barisal, began on April 25. Major
Zia read Mujibs Declaration of Independence for East Pakistanhenceforth
known as Bangladeshthen plunged into action as war enveloped his homeland. The resultant conflict, including Indian intervention against West Pakistan in December 1971, ultimately claimed at least 200,000 lives (some
published estimates exceed 3 million). Bangladesh secured its independence
via the Simla Agreement, signed by India and Pakistan in July 1972, and joined
the United Nations in 1974.
Ziaur Rahman was recognized as a hero of the war for independence, his
brigade dubbed Z Force, after his first initial. He retired from military service as a lieutenant general with a Bir Uttom (Better among Braves in Bengali),
the nations second-highest award for valor. Sadly, peace was not forthcoming for the war-torn fledgling nation. Sheikh Mujib sought financial aid from
the Soviet Union in 1972, which prompted U.S. president Richard Nixon to
ban grain imports to Bangladesh. The ensuing famine claimed 70,000 lives,
and leftist elements began agitation against Mujibs Awami League regime. In
January 1975, Mujib declared a state of emergency, renamed his party the Bangladesh Farmers and Workers Awami League, and banned all other parties.
Dissident army officers slaughtered Mujib and his family on August 15, 1975,
installing conspirator Khondaker Mostaq Ahmad as president. He, in turn, appointed Ziaur Rahman as a major general and the armys new chief of staff.
Unhappy with that result, Brigadier Khaled Mosharraf and Colonel Shafat
Jamil staged a countercoup on November 3, 1975, arresting Ziaur and compelling him to resign. Four days later, Lieutenant Colonel Abu Taher and a group
of leftist officers from the Jatiyo Samajtantrik Dal (National Socialist Party, unrelated to Adolf Hitlers Nazis), killed Mosharraf and imprisoned Jamil, while liberating Ziaur Rahman and reinstating him as chief of staff. The rebels formed
an interim government led by Chief Justice Abu Sadat Mohammad Sayem, with
Zia, Air Vice Marshal Muhammad Ghulam Tawab, and Rear Admiral Musharraf Hussain Khan as his chief deputies. In addition to his role as army chief of
staff, Zia also served the new government as minister of home affairs, finance,
industry, and information. Fearing future coups against the new regime, Ziaur
convened a secret court-martial for his savior, Abu Taher, and had Taher executed on July 21, 1976. Officers who protested that action soon found themselves dispatched to diplomatic missions abroad.
President Sayem resigned on April 21, 1977, citing poor health as he passed
his office to Ziaur Rahman. Whether Sayem was truly illhe lived another
20 yearsor he was pushed aside in what amounted to a bloodless coup, remains a matter of continuing debate. In either case, Ziaur proceeded to rule
as a dictator, restoring martial law and banning political parties, censoring the
media and jailing dissidents, ruthlessly crushing grassroots insurrections such
as the Bogra mutiny of September 30October 2, 1977. His 19-point program
455
456
for curing Bangladeshs domestic ills sidestepped socialism, emphasizing selfreliance, population control, and decentralization of government, buoyed by
lectures on the politics of hope. In foreign policy, he retreated from ties to the
Soviet Union, seeking closer bonds with the United States and Western Europe.
In 1978, he founded the BNP, an ultraconservative bloc based on Islamic fundamentalism and militant nationalism. After the BNP swept national elections
in 1979, it passed the Indemnity Act, retroactively immunizing Sheikh Mujibs
assassins against future prosecution.
That legitimization of military coups, subsequently enshrined as the Fifth
Amendment to the Bangladesh Constitution, rebounded against President
Ziaur with his own assassination. The coup that killed him ultimately failed,
thanks to Army Chief of Staff (later president) Hussain Muhammad Ershad.
Justice Abdus Sattar succeeded Ziaur as president, winning popular election to
the office in December 1981, then was deposed by Hussain Ershad in another
coup, on March 24, 1982.
Following Ziaurs assassination, an 18-day court-martial delivered death
sentences to 12 alleged conspirators; a 13th, wounded during the attack on
Ziaur, was hanged on September 30, 1983, after recovering from his injuries.
Some observers suspected that Major General Abul Manzooronce an ally of
Ziaurs in the war for independence, later a jealous rivalmay have been the
assassinations ringleader, but he was never charged. For all his faults, Ziaur
Rahman is widely known today in Bangladesh as Shaheed (Martyred) Zia.
Further Reading
Choudhury, Ziaudddin. Assassination of Ziaur Rahman and the Aftermath. Dhaka, Bangladesh: The University Press Ltd., 2009.
Franda, Marcus. Ziaur Rahmans Bangladesh. Hanover, NH: AUFS, 1979.
Hossain, Golam. General Ziaur Rahman and the BNP: Political Transformation of a Military Regime. Dhaka, Bangladesh: Mohiuddin Ahmed University Press, 1988.
Lifschultz, Lawrence. Bangladesh: The Unfinished Revolution. London: Zed Books, 1979.
Mascarenhas, Anthony. Bangladesh: A Legacy of Blood. London: Hodder and Stoughton,
1986.
over Russias royal family. Meeting in the castles basement, the trio reportedly
fed Rasputin cakes and wine spiked with cyanide, but he showed no reaction
to the poison. Frustrated, Yusupov then shot Rasputin with a pistol, leaving
him to die, but when the plotters returned some time later, the monk lunged
at Yusupov, trying to strangle him. Shot three more times by Pavlovich and
Purishkevich, Rasputin still survived, struggling to rise and fight. The wouldbe killers bludgeoned him next, then wrapped his presumed corpse in a carpet
and dumped it into the Neva River. Found three days later, minus the carpet,
Rasputin was finally deadfrom drowning, according to his autopsy.
Grigori Yefimovich Rasputin was born in the Siberian village of Pokrovskoye, Tyumen Oblast, on January 22, 1869. A son of peasants, his siblings included an epileptic sister, Maria, who drowned in a local river. Brother Dmitri
nearly suffered the same fate, but Grigori rescued him, only to see Dmitri die
from pneumonia. Legends credit Rasputin with quasi-psychic powers from an
early age, though none of the purported events can be substantiated. At age
18, he was consigned for three months to a monastery at Verkhoturye, on Tura
River, as punishment for theft. While there, Rasputin claimed a vision of the
Virgin Mary that diverted him to the life of a strannik (wandering pilgrim). Detractors later linked him to a banned Christian sect, the Khlysty (flagellants),
who flogged themselves into fits of orgiastic ecstasy, though Rasputin denied
the association.
Although generally labeled a monk, Rasputin rarely denied himself pleasures of the flesh. He married Praskovia Dubrovina in 1889, siring three children with her, and later fathered at least one more child with a second partner,
out of wedlock. In 1901, he deserted his family, traveling for two years through
Greece and the Middle East, including a stop in Jerusalem. Rasputin reached
Saint Petersburg in 1903, building a reputation as a prophet and faith healer
that subsequently reached the ears of Empress Alexandra Feodorovna. Her
son, Tsarevich Alexei Nikolaevich, suffered from hemophilia that frustrated
royal physicians. Hearing of Rasputin from her best friend and lady-in-waiting,
Anna Vyrubova, the empress arranged for Rasputin to heal her son in 1905.
Accounts of Alexeis treatment by Rasputin vary radically, though most agree
that the royal heirs health seemed to improve. Some historians credit the calming effects of hypnosis, Rasputins interdiction of Alexeis treatment with aspirin
(itself an anticoagulant), or application of leeches (unlikely, because their saliva
facilitates bleeding). Whatever the actual method, Alexeis apparent recovery
earned Rasputin the eternal gratitude of Empress Alexandra and her husband,
Tsar Nicholas II. Nicholas described Rasputin to acquaintances as a holy man
and our friend, thereby ensuring his welcome at the royal court in Saint Petersburg. Despite that endorsement, however, the Holy Synod of the Eastern
Orthodox Church shunned Rasputin, accusing him of various corrupt and immoral actions.
457
458
Much remains mysterious about Rasputins death. His autopsy report vanished during the Stalin era (though some photographs survived), as did those
attendants who had witnessed the postmortem. Details of the slaying offered
publicly by Felix Yusupov on various occasions between 1917 and 1965 cast
doubt on now-legendary portrayals of the assassination. Some reports now
claim that pathologists found no poison in Rasputins corpse, and Professor
Derrick Pounder, head of the Department of Forensic Medicine at the University of Dundee (Scotland), claimed in 2006 that Rasputin died from a gunshot
to the forehead, rather than from drowning. Naming the murder weapon as a
British-made Webley .455-caliber revolver, Pounder suggested that Rasputin
may have received his coup de grce from a British Secret Intelligence Service
(SIS) agent, one Lieutenant Oswald Rayner, identified as a longtime friend of
Yusupov from their days as classmates at Oxford University. Michael Smith, hi
his history of the SIS, claims that agency boss Mansfield Cumming personally
ordered Rasputins elimination.
Today, even the mad monks notorious sexual escapades have been called
into doubt. Rasputin biographer Edvard Radzinsky, working from Russian archives, suggests that the clerics pursuit of women was, if not entirely fabricated, at least grossly exaggerated. True or not, film portrayals of Rasputin
general hew to the traditional form. Two silent films depicting Rasputin, The
Fall of the Romanovs and Rasputin, the Black Monk, were released in September
1917. Conrad Veidt took the title role in Rasputin, Demon with Women (1932),
and the same year saw Lionel Barrymore case at the libidinous pilgrim in
Rasputin and the Empress. Christopher Lee played Rasputin: The Mad Monkom
(1966), followed by Gert Frbe (of Goldfinger fame) a year later, in I Killed
Rasputin. Tom Baker kept Rasputin in the classic mold for Nicholas and Alexandra (1971). Alan Rickman was suitably sinister in HBOs Rasputin, first aired
in 1996. The following year, Rasputin sold his soul for magical powers in
the animated film Anastasia. In Hellboy (2004), Karl Roden played the resurrected fiend, invoking Lovecraftian demons to conquer Earth. Most recently,
in 2011, French actor Grard Depardieu portrayed Rasputin in the eponymous film Rasputin.
See also: Nicholas II (18681918).
Further Reading
Colin Wilson. Rasputin and the Fall of the Romanovs. London: Arthur Baker Limited,
1964.
Cook, Andrew. To Kill Rasputin: The Life and Death of Grigori Rasputin. Stroud, Gloucestershire, United Kingdom: Tempus Publishing, 2006.
Fuhrmann, Joseph. Rasputin: The Untold Story. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2013.
King, Greg. The Man Who Killed Rasputin: Prince Felix Youssoupov and the Murder That
Helped Bring Down the Russian Empire. New York: Carol Publishing, 1995.
459
460
R AT H E N AU, WA LT H E R
Moe, Richard. Prelude to the Revolution: The Murder of Rasputin. Chula Vista, CA: Aventine Press, 2011.
Moynahan, Brian. Rasputin: The Saint Who Sinned. New York: Random House, 1997.
Radzinsky, Edvard. The Rasputin File. New York: Anchor Books, 2000.
Smith, Michael. Six: A History of Britains Secret Intelligence Service. London: Biteback,
2010.
R AT H E N A U , WA L T H E R
461
462
R A T S I M A N D R AVA , R I C H A R D
nature; maintenance of arms and the preservation of military ability; the education of youth in the use of arms.
Notice: Only those men who have determination, who obey unconditionally
and who are without scruples . . . will be accepted. . . . The organization is a secret organization.
R AT S I M A N D R AVA , R I C H A R D
463
464
R A Z M A R A , S E PA H B O D H A J A L I
Razmaras murder achieved the goal desired by his assassin. On March 12,
1951 the National Consultative Assembly voted to nationalize Irans oil fields,
followed by another vote to expropriate Anglo-Iranian Oils property on March
28. A month later, on April 28, Mohammad Mossadegh was confirmed as prime
minister. In August 1953, British and U.S. troops staged Operation Ajax,
forcibly deposing Mossadegh and placing Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlav in
charge of a military junta with General Fazlollah Zahedi as his chief enforcer.
The brutal tactics of that dictatorship eventually spawned the Iranian Revolution of 1979, deposing the shah and establishing extreme fundamentalist Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini as the nations new ruler.
Conspiracy theories persist in Razmaras assassination. Although Khalil Tahmasebi supported and publicly praised the National Front, no member of that
group was ever linked to the prime ministers slaying. An alternative theory,
raised by several Iranian authors, claims that the shah and one of his top aides,
Assadullah Alam, sought to eliminate Razmara for murky reasons of their own.
In that scenario, Tahmasebi tried to kill Razmara but missed his target, whereupon an army sergeant fired the fatal shots.
Further Reading
Abrahamian, Ervand. The Coup: 1953, the CIA, and the Roots of Modern U.S.-Iranian Relations. New York: The New Press, 2013.
De Ballaique, Christopher. Patriot of Persia: Muhammad Mossadegh and a Tragic AngloAmerican Coup. New York: HarperCollins, 2012.
Heiss, Mary. Empire and Nationhood: The United States, Great Britain, and Iranian Oil,
19501954. New York: Columbia University Press, 1997.
Kinzer, Stephen. All the Shahs Men: An American Coup and the Roots of Middle East Terror. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2003.
465
466
from his chest. Luckily, although Hinckley had loaded his pistol with Devastator rounds designed to explode on impact, the round that penetrated Reagans
body proved to be a dud. James Brady was less fortunate, left paralyzed and
permanently disabled after his slug shattered inside his skull.
Ronald Reagan was born in Tampico, Illinois, on February 6, 1911. He
earned a BA in economics and sociology from Eureka College, a private institution affiliated with the Disciples of Christ, then moved to Iowa and entered
show business as a radio broadcaster in 1937. Later that year, he moved again,
this time to Hollywood, for his first role in a feature film, Love is on the Air. Another 33 films followed before the United States entered into World War II,
with titles ranging from the obscure (Swing Your Lady, Cowboys over Brooklyn,
Girls on Probation) to acknowledged cinema classics (Dark Victory and Knute
Rockne, All American).
Reagan joined the U.S. Army Reserve in 1937 and was ordered up for active duty in April 1942, but nearsightedness barred him from combat and he
spent most of the war in Culver City, California, as a member of First Motion
Picture Unit (officially, the 18th Army Air Force Base Unit), composed entirely
of film-making professionals. Before wars end, Reagan worked on 13 more features and short films, including five where he provided voice-overs for army productions. Even so, he found time to appear in Kings Row (nominated for three
Academy Awards in 1942), along with the forgettable Juke Girl (also 1942).
Reagans career in Hollywood continued after V-J Day, with another 19 films
between 1947 and 1954. His star seemed to be waning through the latter part
of the 1950s and early 1960sa total of three big-screen appearances between
1955 and 1964, the last as a decidedly unsympathetic felon in The Killers. At
the same time Reagan switched to television, appearing in a dozen episodes of
programs such as Lux Video Theatre and Schlitz Playhouse of Stars between 1950
and 1954. In the latter year, he landed an eight-year stint as host of General
Electric Theater, introducing 235 teleplays and acting in 35. Occasional appearances on Dick Powells Zane Grey Theater, Wagon Train, and similar TV shows
kept Reagan in the public eye through 1964, but many critics were ready to
write him off when politics intervened.
Originally a self-styled liberal Democrat, Reagan had been drifting toward
the political right since becoming disillusioned with President Franklin Roosevelts New Deal. Elected to his first term as president of the Screen Actors
Guild in 1941 (with later terms following in 19461952 and 1959), Reagan
collaborated with the U.S. House Committee on Un-American Activities in
striving to rid Hollywood of alleged communists. He participated in compiling
blacklists of subversive actors and writers, purging radical union members
while collaborating in some cases with underworld infiltration of the film industry. For a time, he also served the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as
467
468
never communicated, left him no alternative but to proceed, and in the final
act he failed. At trial, Hinckley faced 13 felony charges, but jurors found him
not guilty by reason of insanity on June 21, 1982. That verdict prompted
near-universal dismay and outrage. As a result, four statesIdaho, Kansas,
Montana, and Utahabolished the insanity defense entirely, and other states
revised their statutes and Congress ultimately passed the Insanity Defense Reform Act of 1984, restricting psychiatric expert testimony on ultimate legal issues and placing the burden of proof on a defendant to establish insanity by
clear and convincing evidence.
John Hinckley apparently suffered from erotomania, the delusional that a total
strangercommonly a public figure or celebrityshared his one-sided obsessive love. Fueled by 15 viewings of the Taxi Driver (see sidebar), he became convinced that only murder of a president could seal their illusory romantic bargain.
First, he stalked Reagan predecessor Jimmy Carter, and was arrested in October 1980 with a gun at Nashville International Airport, but FBI agents made no
connection to Carters simultaneous visit and thus failed to notify Secret Service
agents of Hinckleys behavior. Briefly consigned to psychiatric treatment by his
parents after that arrest, Hinckley shifted his attention to the president-elect after
Novembers election, and carried on with his plan. In custody, Hinckley wrote
that shooting Reagan the greatest love offering in the history of the world.
TAXI DRIVER
Written by Paul Schrader and directed by Martin Scorsese, Taxi Driver is a
psychological thriller starring Robert De Niro as mentally unstable Manhattan cabbie Travis Bickle. Suffering from depression and insomnia, disgusted
with the citys corruption, Bickle becomes infatuated with an adolescent
prostitute portrayed by Jodie Foster. After botching an attempt to kill a
U.S. presidential candidate, Bickle redirects his rage at Fosters pimp for a
climactic massacre of underworld lowlifes, which, ironically, makes him
a hero with the media. Nominated for four Academy Awards, including
Best Picture, the film lost out on those but won a Palme dOr, the highest
prize awarded at the 1976 Cannes Film Festival. John Hinckley Jr. cited
his obsession with Jodie Foster as his motive for shooting President Reagan in 1981, claiming that he hoped it would impress the actress. In 1994,
the U.S. Library of Congress selected Taxi Driver as a film worthy of preservation in the National Film Registry as being culturally, historically, or
aesthetically significant. In 1998, the American Film Institute listed Taxi
Driver at No. 47 in its AFIs 100 Years . . . 100 Movies. Ten years later, in the
10th-anniversary edition, the film was demoted to No. 52 on the list.
After trial, from his hospital room, Hinckley sent letters to condemned
Florida serial killer Theodore Bundy and tried to obtain an address for California killer-cult leader Charles Manson, but was blocked from further correspondence with notorious slayers. On December 30, 2005, a federal judge
approved visits to Hinckleys family home in Virginia, supervised by his parents, after various psychologists deemed his depression and psychotic disorder to be in full remission. Month-long visits to his parents were denied in
June 2007, then a series of 10-day visits were approved in June 2009. Legal
debates over his ultimate release from custody continued as this volume went
to press.
Predictably, conspiracy theories arose from the shooting of President
Reagan. Reporters discovered that Hinckleys father had contributed money
to the 1980 Republican primary campaigns of George H. W. Bush, Reagans
top competitor and later running mate. Furthermore, brother Scott Hinckley had a dinner date scheduled at the home of Bushs son, Silverado Savings & Loan board member Neil Bush, on the very day Reagan was shot.
Neils wife at the time, Sharon Bush, told journalists that Scott Hinckley
was invited to her home as a date for one of her friends, describing the
Hinckley clan as a very nice family, whose members had given a lot of
money to the Bush campaign. She denied ever meeting John, but knew
him vaguely as the renegade brother in the family. From those connections, some theorists contrived a Bush family plot to eliminate Reagan and
propel the senior Bush into the presidency, but no supporting evidence has
been forthcoming.
Further Reading
Allen, Richard. The Day Reagan Was Shot. Hoover Institution. http://www.hoover
.org/publications/hoover-digest/article/6281.
Assassination Attempt of Ronald Reagan. Video. Maniac World. http://www.maniac
world.com/Assassination-Attempt-President-Ronald-Reagan.html.
Bonnie, Richard, John Jeffries, and Peter Low. A Case Study in the Insanity Defense: The
Trial of John W. Hinckley, Jr. New York: Foundation Press, 2008.
Cannon, Lou. President Reagan: The Role of a Lifetime. New York: Public Affairs Books,
2000.
Caplan, Lincoln. The Insanity Defense and the Trial of John W. Hinckley, Jr. New York:
Laurel Publishing, 1987.
Clarke, James. On Being Mad or Merely Angry: John W. Hinckley, Jr., and Other Dangerous
People. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1990.
Moldea, Dan. Dark Victory: Ronald Reagan, MCA and the Mob. New York: Viking Penguin, 1987.
Wilbur, Del. Rawhide Down: The Near Assassination of Ronald Reagan. New York: Henry
Holt, 2011.
469
470
Reinas tenure in the presidential palace was as troubled as his predecessors. While attempting to solidify some modest reforms instituted
by his uncles regime, Reina increased the power of the landowners over
rural peasants, thereby making enemies. While promoting the first Central American Exposition in 1897, he printed money to cover its cost, thus
causing runaway inflation. In the process, Reina banked a personal fortune
of some $8 million, while asking the National Assembly for permission to
seek a loan of 3 million from Great Britain. Threats from various enemies
drove Reina to a series of mass arrests, and 200 soldiers guarded his palace around the clock. After his murder, the New York Times reported that
two or three attempts were made to kill him more than a year ago. In fact,
the Times editorialized, the fate of Barrios, who has of late been sending
a good many of his enemies to the executioner, can excite neither surprise
nor very much pity.
Successor Manuel Estrada Cabrera would rule Guatemala until public antipathy and rumors of senility drove him from office at age 67, in April 1920.
During his tenure, he laid the groundwork for more tragic history by opening
Guatemala to wholesale exploitation by the U.S.-based United Fruit Company.
Estrada was also strongly suspected of ordering predecessor Manuel Barillass
assassination in Mexico City, during 1907. The quirkiest aspect of Estradas
tenure was his institution of a cult dedicated to Minerva, the ancient Roman
goddess of wisdom, music, and poetry, with temples erected to her glory in cities throughout Guatemala.
Further Reading
Adams, Richard. Accustomed to Be Obedient. In The Guatemala Reader: History, Culture, Politics. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2011.
Grandin, Greg. The Blood of Guatemala: A History of Race and Nation. Durham, NC:
Duke University Press, 2000.
471
472
President Haruo Remeliik of Palau, slain by unknown gunmen in June 1985. (Corbis)
473
474
Guizado as the plots mastermind. Mir recanted his statement at trial, claiming coercion,
and was subsequently acquitted. Guizado remained in
custody, pending a trial that
never materialized, until his final release in December 1957.
Remns murder remains officially unsolved today.
Jos Remn Cantera was
born in Panama City, to a politically prominent family, on
April 11, 1908. He graduated
from the Military Academy
in 1931, then joined the National Police, rising to serve as
Panamanian president Jos Antonio Remn died its chief by 1947. Two years
on January 2, 1955 shortly after he was shot with later, Panama entered a period
a machine gun at a racetrack in Panama. (Associ- of political turmoil, with four
ated Press)
presidents holding office between July 1949 and October
1952. Some historians regard Remn as a prime mover in the coup dtat
that deposed President Arnulfo Arias Madrid in May 1951, although Remn
would not claim the presidencyfrom Alcibades Arosemena Quinzada
until October 1, 1952.
He brought a measure of stability to Panama at last, as leader of a conservative National Patriotic Coalition. His pro-U.S. stance, including suppression of various communist groups, pleased Washington, and in 1953 Remn
began negotiation of the RemnEisenhower Treaty (formally ratified after his
death) that raised Panamas annual annuity for the international canal from
$430,000 to $1.9 million, while transferring $20 million in property from the
U.S.-owned Panama Canal Company to Panama. Although an authoritarian
figure, Remn is perhaps best remembered for his motto Neither millions nor
almswe want justice.
Documents from the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), declassified
in the early 21st century, suggest that Remn may have been killed on orders
from exiled U.S. mafioso Salvatore Lucania, alias Charles Lucky Luciano,
after Remns police seized a shipment of heroin passing though Panama on
its way to the United States. Spanish author Gloria Guardia elaborates on that
theme in her novel Lobos al Anochecer (Wolves at Dusk), published in 2006 and
currently offered only in Spanish. That tale implicates both the Mafia and the
R I TAV U O R I , H E I K K I
475
476
An early member of the National Progressive Party, founded in December 1918, Ritavuori served briefly as deputy minister of justice under Finlands first president, Kaarlo Juho Sthlberg, then returned as minister of
defense under Prime Minister Juho Heikki Vennolain August 1919, holding
that post until his murder 526 days later. Right-wing extremists labeled him
a red minister for his legal defense work during the late civil war, and they
were further angered by his support for the liberal Sthlberg over Baron Carl
Gustaf Emil Mannerheim in the 1919 presidential campaign. The crowning
insult, to proto-fascist circles, came when Ritavuori blocked independent action by their paramilitary protection guard units during the East Karelia
uprising of 19211922.
With so much agitation against him, some observers suspected that Ritavuori was slain by members of a right-wing conspiracy. Knut Tandefelt initially
said that he acted alone, but later implicated several accomplices, including
Helsinki mayor General Paul von Gerich and a local pharmacist, Oskar Jansson. A belated investigation, undertaken from 1927 to 1930, failed to produce
any evidence against those named by Tandefelt as plotters. Baron Mannerheim
served as commander in chief of Finlands defense forces during World War II,
and as president from August 1944 to June 1946. In June 1942, he welcomed
Adolf Hitler to Finland, ostensibly to celebrate Mannerheims 75th birthday,
but in fact to discuss German defense of Finland in the event of a Russian
invasion.
Heikki Ritavuoris younger brother, Eero Rydman, kept the original family name as a member of the Progressive Party, serving as Helsinkis mayor
for 12 years (19441956), and running unsuccessfully for president in 1956,
Ritavuoris grandson, Pekka Tarjanne, also entered politics, serving in parliament, as chairman of the Liberal Peoples Party, as a government minister, as
chairman of the board of the Post and Telephone Bureau, and as chairman
of the board of the United Nations International Telecommunication Union.
Further Reading
Bidwell, Robin. Bidwells Guide to Government Ministers: The Major Powers and Western
Europe 19001971. New York: Routledge, 1973.
Kirby, David. A Concise History of Finland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2006.
Singleton, Fred. A Short History of Finland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
1998.
477
478
his second discharge from active service, in October 1954, Rockwell remained
in the U.S. Navy Reserve, but his political extremism soon marked him as not
deployable in the eyes of his superiors. He was discharged for good in February
1960, later writing that he had basically been thrown out of the Navy.
For that, he blamed the Jews.
Rockwells progression to the far-right fringe was aided by the onset of the
Cold War, personified in Red-hunting senator Joseph McCarthy and ex-general
Douglas MacArthur, who impressed Rockwell so much that Rockwell bought
a corncob pipe to match MacArthurs. Other influences included Gerald L. K.
Smith, founder of the anti-Semitic Christian Nationalist Crusade, and Conde
McGinley, founder of the equally racist Christian Educational Association.
Rockwells enlightenment was finally completed via study of Adolf Hitlers
Mein Kampf and The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. The latter publication, posing as a blueprint for Jewish world domination, had been exposed as a forgery
by Russias secret police soon after its initial publication in 1903, but Rockwell
appeared to accept it as genuine.
Rockwells odyssey through the radical right included flirtation with various groups, ranging from the respectable John Birch Society to the notoriously violent National States Rights Party. In March 1959, he created his own
World Union of Free Enterprise National Socialists, renamed the American
Nazi Party in December of that year, with ramshackle headquarters in Arlington, five miles from downtown Washington, D.C. The partys first public
outing occurred at the National Mall in Washington, where Rockwell regaled
spectators with a two-hour speech on April 3, 1960. At the next, at Manhattans Union Square on June 22, Rockwell faced a crowd of Holocaust survivors and Jewish war veterans. Asked how he would deal with Jews if given
power in the United States, Rockwell replied that traitors of all races and religious should be executed. Press to estimate how many Jews that might involve, he said, Eighty percent.
The partys third rally, back at the National Mall on July 4, 1960, sparked a
riot that resulted in Rockwells detention for court-ordered psychiatric evaluation. Released after two weeks, he promptly wrote and published a pamphlet
titled How to Get Out or Stay Out of the Insane Asylum. Already well attuned to
the value of publicitywhether negative or otherwiseRockwell set out to
capitalize on the growing black civil rights movement. In 1961, he procured a
Volkswagen van and sent it through the South as his Hate Bus, trailing teams
of integrated freedom riders. Two years later, he led counterprotests against
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.s historic March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom. In 1964, he sought the U.S. presidency as a write-in candidate, receiving 212 popular votes (and none in the Electoral College). A year later, he did
slightly better in Virginias gubernatorial contest, polling 5,730 votes to place
fourth in a field of four candidates.
Throughout the troubled 1960s, Rockwell searched for allies in the murky
world of extremism. Dominant Ku Klux Klan leader Robert Shelton denounced
Rockwells party, but several of Sheltons grand dragons in Northern states
were active membersincluding Daniel Burros of New York, who killed himself in 1965, after the New York Times revealed his Jewish ancestry. Rockwell
joined Klansmen to protest Dr. Kings open-housing marches in Cicero, Illinois, in 1966, but also sought alliances among black nationalists. As early as
1962, Rockwell met with Elijah Muhammad, leader of the Black Muslims, and
emerged to praise Muhammad as the Black peoples Hitler. In 1966, after debating Black Panther Party spokesman Stokely Carmichael, Rockwell adopted
Carmichaels black power slogan and used its oppositeWhite Poweras the
title of his final manifesto, published in 1967.
Aside from overt racism and anti-Semitism, Rockwell ranked among the
earliest proponents of historical revisionism on the Holocaust, essentially
denying Adolf Hitlers genocide of Jews and other so-called undesirables.
Interviewed for Playboy magazine in April 1966, he said, I dont believe for
one minute that any 6,000,000 Jews were exterminated by Hitler. It never
happened. Meanwhile, during a covert visit to England and Ireland, he
joined in founding a World Union of National Socialists, publishing a newsletter, National Socialist World, edited by ex-physics professor William Luther
Pierce. On January 1, 1967, Rockwell changed his partys name one more,
this time calling it the National Socialist White Peoples Party (NSWPP).
The first attempt on Rockwells life came six months later, on June 28, 1967.
As he returned to party headquarters from shopping, he found the driveway
blocked by a fallen tree and piles of brush. While Rockwell attempted to clear
it, two shots rang out, one narrowly missing his head before striking his car.
Rockwell pursued the gunman, but failed to catch or identify him. His application for a gun permit, filed two days later, was still pending in August, when
he was assassinated.
Even in death, Rockwell continued to incite controversy. Matthias Koehl
Jr., second in command at NSWPP headquarters, assumed control of the
party and its estimated 300 members, claiming legal control over Rockwells
corpse and the groups meager assets. On August 27, 1967, Koehl announced
that federal officials had approved Rockwells burial as an honorably discharged military veteran, at Virginias Culpeper National Cemetery, but military and civilian police barred mourners dressed in Nazi uniforms from the
graveyard on August 29. A day-long standoff ensued, before Koehl withdrew
and had Rockwell cremated on August 30. His remains were still in limbo
when Koehl filed litigation, in February 1968, to secure internment in any
national cemetery. The following month, a federal court supported the armys
refusal to bury Rockwell with military honors. Today his ashes rest at party
headquarters in Wisconsin.
479
480
Koehls ascension to leadership of the NSWPP split the party, which he renamed the New Order, cast as a quasi-religious group merging esoteric Nazism with elements of Hinduism. More traditional neo-fascists followed
William Pierce into a new National Alliance, subsequently regarded as the
dominant neo-Nazi group of the 1980s and 1990s. Dissension on the fringe
continues today, with new groups forming and dissolving constantly.
Virginias Supreme Court upheld John Patlers murder conviction in November
1970 and ordered him to begin serving his 20-year sentence. After a failed appeal
to the U.S. Supreme Court, rejected unanimously in May 1972, Patler was paroled
with support from his trial judge in August 1975. A year later, he violated terms
of his release and was returned to prison for another six years. In December 1977,
Patlera son of Greek immigrantspetitioned a Virginia court to restore his birth
surname of Patsalos. The court agreed, and Patsalos was released once more
upon completion of his sentence, reportedly settling somewhere in New York City.
Further Reading
Federal Bureau of Investigation. The American Nazi Party. FBI Records: The Vault.
http://vault.fbi.gov/American%20Nazi%20Party%20/American%20Nazi%20
Party%20Part%201%20of%202/view.
Rockwell, George. White Power. Dallas: Ragnarok Press, 1967.
Rosenthal, A. M., and Arthur Gelb. One More Victim. New York: New American Library, 1967.
Schmaltz, William. Hate: George Lincoln Rockwell and the American Nazi Party. Washington, DC: Brasseys, 2001.
Simonelli, Frederick. American Fuehrer: George Lincoln Rockwell and the American Nazi
Party. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1999.
481
482
to 100,000 men under the Treaty of Versailles) with the SA, which he would
command as minister of defense. Days later, Hitler told Anthony Edensoon
to be Britains foreign secretary, later prime ministerthat he planned to reduce the SAs ranks by two-thirds.
Further impetus for the SA purge came in April 1934, when Hitler learned
that Paul von Hindenburg, president of the Weimar Republic, was terminally
ill and not expected to live out the year. While still in power, though, Hindenburg remained determined to suppress political mayhem in Germany. Early
June brought a warning from Defense Minister Werner von Blomberg, advising Hitler that failure to curb SA violence would result in martial law, handing the reins of government to the Reichswehr. Hitler then struck a bargain
with army leaders to eliminate the SA via Operation Hummingbird. Others killed with Rhm in the ensuing purge included ex-chancellor Kurt von
Schleicher, former Bavarian minister president Gustav Ritter von Kahr (who
suppressed the Munich putsch in 1923), and Gregor Strasser (leader of a relatively left-wing faction of the Nazi Party). With President Hindenburgs death
in August 1934, Adolf Hitler effectively seized absolute control of the German
government.
See also: Heydrich, Reinhard Tristan Eugen (19041942); Hitler, Adolf (18891945)
Attempted.
Further Reading
Atcherly, Tony, and Mark Carey. Hitlers Gay Traitor: The Story of Ernst Rhm, Chief of
Staff of the S.A. Bloomington, IN: Trafford Publishing, 2007.
Gallo, Max. The Night of the Long Knives: June 2930, 1934. New York: Da Capo Press,
1997.
Hancock, Eleanor. Ernst Rhm: Hitlers SA Chief of Staff. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.
Hatch, Nicholas. The Brown Battalions: Hitlers SA in Word and Deed. Nashville, TN:
Turner Publishing, 2000.
Jablonsky, David. Rohm and Hitler: The Continuity of Political-Military Discord.
Journal of Contemporary History 23 (July 1988): 36786.
Maracin, Paul. The Night of the Long Knives: Forty-eight Hours that Changed the History of
the World. New York: The Lyons Press, 2004.
483
484
today. Romeros murder came one day after he delivered a sermon calling upon
El Salvadors soldiers, as Christians, to obey Gods law and cease brutal repression of their fellow Salvadorans. Romero was the seventh Roman Catholic
priest to be slain by death squads since March 1977.
scar Romero y Galdmez was born on August 15, 1917, at Ciudad Barrios in El Salvadors San Miguel Department. At that time, the country was
run by the Melendez-Quinonez dynasty, with 13 wealthy families controlling
40 percent of El Salvadors land. Despite parental training as a carpenter,
Romero was drawn to the Catholic Church, being ordained in Rome on April 4,
1942. His plans to remain in Italy and earn a doctorate in theology were interrupted by Allied invaders a year later, prompting Romero to return home by
way of Spain and Cuba. At the latter stop, he was detained for several months
as a suspected fascist fugitive, the finally released to Mexico, and one from
there toward home.
Upon returning to El Salvador, Romero served as a parish priest in Anamors
and San Miguel, remaining in the latter post until 1966, when he was named
as secretary of the Bishop Conference for El Salvador, doubling as director of
the archdiocesan newspaper Orientacin. His relatively conservative outlook
irritated more progressive priests, committed to liberation theologys quasiMarxist focus on helping the poor, but it pleased Romeros superiors. In 1970,
he was named auxiliary bishop to San Salvador archbishop Luis Chvez y
Gonzlez, then promoted to bishop of the Diocese of Santiago de Mara in December 1975. On February 23, 1977, Romero reached the pinnacle of his career with appointment as archbishop of San Salvador.
Seventeen days after Romeros last promotion, death squad gunmen murdered a personal friend, progressive Jesuit Father Rutilio Grande Garca,
and two companions near El Paisnal, in the parish of Aguilares. The triple
murder radically changed Romeros outlook, prompting him to say, When
I looked at Rutilio lying there dead I thought, If they have killed him for
doing what he did, then I too have to walk the same path. After newspapers blamed the murders on common criminal activity, Romero published
a rebuttal reading:
The true reason for [Grandes] death was his prophetic and pastoral efforts to
raise the consciousness of the people throughout his parish. Father Grande,
without offending and forcing himself upon his flock in the practice of their religion, was only slowly forming a genuine community of faith, hope and love
among them, he was making them aware of their dignity as individuals, of their
basic rights as words, his was an effort toward comprehensive human development. This post-Vatican Council ecclesiastical effort is certainly not agreeable to
everyone, because it awakens the consciousness of the people. It is work that
disturbs many; and to end it, it was necessary to liquidate its proponent.
President Arturo Armando Molina ignored Romeros demand for a full investigation, and the slaughter of clergy continued. On May 11, 1977, Father
Alfonso Navarro Oviedo was gunned down on the outskirts of San Salvador.
Father Ernesto Barrera died in an ambush at Mejicanos, on November 28,
1978. On January 20, 1979, government troops stormed a Catholic retreat
for young workers, killing Father Octavio Ortiz Luna and four other victims,
crushing the priests head beneath a military vehicle to prevent an open-casket
funeral. Six months later to the day, on June 20, gunmen killed Father Rafael
Palacios at Suchitoto. Father Alirio Napolen Macas was the last to die before
Romero, murdered on August 4, 1979.
Two months later, a five-man revolutionary junta deposed Salvadoran president Carlos Humberto Romero, initiating a program of land reform coupled
with nationalization of El Salvadors the banking, coffee, and sugar industries. Dissension within the junta frustrated further progress, however, and
violence against the church persisted, culminating with Archbishop Romeros assassination in March 1980. On January 10, 1981, the leftist Farabundo
Mart National Liberation Front launched a guerrilla war against the government, prompting U.S. support for the ruling junta in the civil war continuing
until January 1992. In the midst of that mayhem, government troops massacred six more Jesuit priests at San Salvadors Central American University
on November 16, 1989. Victims included Fathers Ignacio Ellacura, Amando
Lpez, Joaqun Lpez y Lpez, Ignacio Martn-Baro, Segundo Montes, and
Juan Ramn Moreno.
Archbishop Romero was buried in San Salvador, following a mass attended
by 250,000 mourners. At that ceremony, Cardinal Corripio Ahumada declared
Romero a beloved, peacemaking man of God, predicting that his blood will
give fruit to brotherhood, love and peace. That did not prove to be the case,
in fact, as gunfire and explosions rocked the capital, leaving an estimated 30 to
50 persons dead by days end.
Romeros assassination remains officially unsolved today, despite a 1986 statement from former U.S. ambassador Robert White that there was sufficient evidence to convict Roberto DAubuisson, ex-mayor of San Salvador, on charges
of ordering the murder. DAubuissons chief of security, Salvadoran air force
captain lvaro Rafael Saravia, allegedly directed the assassination. In 2003, the
U.S.-based Center for Justice and Accountability filed a federal lawsuit against
Saravia under the Alien Tort Claims Act, on charges of aiding, conspiring, and
participating in Romeros murder. The court found him responsible and imposed a $10 million fine on Saravia, then a resident of California. On the 30th
anniversary of Romeros death, President Mauricio Funes officially apologized
for the crime, noting admitting that those responsible unfortunately acted with
the protection, collaboration or participation of state agents.
485
486
R O O S E V E L T, T H E O D O R E
In 1997, Romero was named as a candidate for beatification and canonization as a saint. Pope John Paul II graced him that year, with the title Servant
of God, but progress toward sainthood has been held in abeyance pending
further investigation of Romeros heroism and martyrdom. Under canonical
law, if he is found to be a hero without martyrdom, he must then be attributed
with performing a verified miracle. The Church of England, meanwhile, recognizes Romero as one of ten 20th-century martyrs depicted in statuary above
the Great West Door of Londons Westminster Abbey. In 2008, the European
magazine A Different View listed Romero among its 15 Champions of World
Democracy. On December 21, 2010, the United Nations General Assembly
cited Romero by name in proclaiming March 24 as the International Day for
the Right to the Truth concerning Gross Human Rights Violations and for the
Dignity of Victims.
Romeros life and death have also inspired multiple Hollywood productions.
Ren Enrquez portrayed Romero in a 1983 made-for-television film, Choices
of the Heart, focused on the rape-murders of four U.S. nuns in El Salvador.
Director Oliver Stone cast Jos Carlos Ruiz as Romero in Salvador (1986), and
Raul Julia claimed the title role in Romero (1989). Another made-for-TV movie,
Have No Fear: The Life of Pope John Paul II (2005), cast Joaquim de Almeida as
Romero. A year later, Carlos Kaniowsky tackled the part in the Italian biopic
Karol, una papa rimastouomo (also charting the life of John Paul II). Most recently, in 2010, file footage of Romero in life was compiled for Monseor, the
Last Journey of scar Romero.
Further Reading
Americas Watch. El Salvadors Decade of Terror: Human Rights Since the Assassination of
Archbishop Romero. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1991.
Dada, Carlos. How we killed Archbishop Romero. El Faro. http://www.elfaro.net/
es/201003/noticias/1416.
Doyle, Kate, and Emily Willard. Learn from History: 31st Anniversary of the Assassination of Archbishop Oscar Romero. The National Security Archive. http://www
.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB339/index.htm.
Erdozain, Placido. Archbishop Romero: Martyr of Salvador. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books,
1981.
Wright, Scott. Oscar Romero and the Communion of the Saints. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis
Books, 2010.
R O O S E V E L T, T H E O D O R E
487
488
R O O S E V E L T, T H E O D O R E
a rancher in the Dakota Badlands, he returned to run for mayor of New York
City in 1886, placing third in a field of three candidates.
Roosevelt revived his political career in 1888, campaigning for victorious
presidential hopeful William Henry Harrison. Rewarded with an appointment to the U.S. Civil Service Commission, he served there until 1895, then
accepted appointment as New York Citys police commissioner. The departments official history describes Roosevelt as an iron-willed leader of unimpeachable honesty, possessed a reforming zeal. As commissioner, he
established new disciplinary rules, created a bicycle squad to enforce traffic ordinances, issued standardized firearms to all officers, mandated annual
physical examinations for his officers, punished corruption, and shunned
political cronyism, appointing 1,600 recruits based solely on physical and
mental qualifications.
Roosevelt left the police force in April 1897, when President William McKinley appointed him to serve as assistant secretary of the navy. That job proved
short-lived, as the outbreak of war with Spain led Roosevelt to form the 1st
United States Volunteer Cavalry, commonly nicknamed Rough Riders. Leading that unit as a lieutenant colonel, Roosevelt engaged in several battles, most
famously at San Juan Hill on July 1, 1898 (where his cavalry fought as dismounted infantry). Roosevelt dubbed the four-month conflict with Spain a
splendid little war, emerging with his political future assured.
Elected as New Yorks governor in November 1898, Roosevelt brought
the same reforming zeal to that office as he had to the New York Police Department. In fact, he proved such an ardent foe of political corruption that
Republican Party boss Thomas Collier Platt persuaded President McKinley
to draft Roosevelt as his second-term running mate, thereby removing Roosevelt from the governors mansion two years ahead of schedule. Other party
bosses, including Senator Mark Hanna of Ohio, opposed Roosevelts vicepresidential nomination, regarding him as a loose cannon beyond their
control. Those fears proved accurate in September 1901, when McKinleys
assassination elevated Roosevelt to the White House. Hanna, enraged, told
colleagues, Now look! That damned cowboy is president of the United
States!
It was worse than that for Roosevelts political enemies, as he inaugurated
the United States Progressive Era, establishing himself as an ardent conservationist and zealousif selectivetrust buster, curbing the power of monopolistic corporations. (U.S. Steel was exempt under Roosevelts tenure, labeled
a good trust.) He also violated precedent by negotiating with labor unions,
as when he intervened in a May 1902 strike to obtain higher pay and shorter
hours for members of the United Mine Workers. Influenced by the work of
muckraking journalists, in 1906, Roosevelt promoted the Federal Meat Inspection Act and the Pure Food and Drug Act to protect U.S. consumers. From
1907 to 1908, Roosevelt served as president of the American School Hygiene
R O O S E V E L T, T H E O D O R E
489
490
R O O S E V E L T, T H E O D O R E
Further Reading
Brinkley, Douglas. The Wilderness Warrior: Theodore Roosevelt and the Crusade for America. New York: HarperCollins, 2009.
Foley, W. J. A Bullet and a Bull Moose. JAMA, The Journal of the American Medical Association 209 (1969): 203538.
Gores, Stan. The Attempted Assassination of Teddy Roosevelt. Madison: Wisconsin Historical Society, 1977.
Gould, Lewis. Theodore Roosevelt. New York: Oxford University Press, 2012.
Morris, Edmund. The Rise of Theodore Roosevelt. New York: Random House, 1979.
R YA N , L E O J O S E P H , J R .
491
492
R YA N , L E O J O S E P H , J R .
R YA N , L E O J O S E P H , J R .
MARK LANE
Mark Lane (born on February 24, 1927) is a U.S. attorney, author, and former New York state legislator, most commonly associated with criticism of
the Warren Commissions report on the assassination of President John F.
Kennedy. His books on that subject include Rush to Judgment (1966),
A Citizens Dissent (1968), Plausible Denial (1991), and Last Word: My Indictment of the CIA in the Murder of JFK (2011). The 1973 conspiracy thriller
Executive Action was reportedly based in large part on Lanes earlier writings. Before that films release, in 1970, Lane joined several committees
investigating alleged U.S. war crimes in Vietnam and published his findings in Conversations with Americans: Testimony from 32 Vietnam Veterans.
Another of Lanes books, Arcadia (1970), helped secure the release of a
defendant wrongfully convicted of mass murder in Florida. In his legal capacity, Lane has represented James Earl Ray, convicted assassin of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and also the Peoples Temple, emerging as a survivor
of the 1978 Guyana massacre. He published books on both cases: Code
Name Zorro (1978, coauthored with activist-comedian Dick Gregory) suggests a government conspiracy against Dr. King, and The Strongest Poison
(1980), claims involvement by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency in the
Jonestown tragedy.
deputy chief of mission for the United States in Guyana. On March 3, 1987,
Layton received concurrent life prison terms for aiding and abetting Ryans
murder, and for conspiracy to murder an internationally protected person
(Dwyer), plus 15 additional years on lesser counts. He was paroled in April
2002.
Leo Ryans death at Jonestown proved irresistible to Hollywood. Actor Gene
Barry was cast as Ryan in the feature film Guyana: Crime of the Century (1979),
and Ned Beatty took over the role a year later, for the television miniseries Guyana Tragedy: The Story of Jim Jones. On November 18, 1983, Ryan was posthumously awarded a Congressional Gold Medal, marking his status as the only
member of Congress ever killed in the line of duty.
Further Reading
Hall, John. Gone from the Promised Land: Jonestown in American Cultural History. New
Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 1987.
Lane, Mark. The Strongest Poison. New York: Hawthorn Books, 1980.
Nugent, John. White Night: The Untold Story of What Happened BeforeAnd After
Jonestown. New York: Rawson, Wade Publishers, 1979.
493
494
R Z AY E V G U R B A N O G L U , R A I L
Reiterman, Tim, and John Jacobs. Raven: The Untold Story of the Rev. Jim Jones and His
People. New York: Dutton, 1982.
U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Foreign Affairs. The Assassination of Representative Leo J. Ryan and the Jonestown, Guyana Tragedy (May 15, 1979). http://
www.rickross.com/reference/jonestown/jonestown2.html.
R Z AY E V G U R B A N O G L U , R A I L
Despite a short list of possible suspects, no cogent motive for Rzayevs murder
has yet been suggested. An Azeri criminal lawyer, speaking anonymously, suggested that the triggerman was a foreign contract killer, saying, He came to Baku,
fulfilled the order, and managed to leave Azerbaijan the same day or shortly after
that. Another attorney in Baku, Eyyub Kerimovalso the editor in chief of the
legal newspaper Femida (Justice) 007, noted in October 2005 that the states
failure to produce a motive or suspect shows the lack of any real progress in the
investigation.
Further Reading
Abbasov, Shahin. Azerbaijan: Air Force Commanders Assassination May Have Been an
Inside JobBaku Prosecutor. Eurasianet (October 4, 2009). http://www.eurasianet
.org/departments/insightb/articles/eav100509a.shtml.
Azerbaijan air force head killed. BBC News, February 11, 2009. http://news.bbc
.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7882911.stm.
De Waal, Thomas. Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War. New
York: New York University Press, 2013.
495
S
S CARNEIRO, FRANCISCO MANUEL
LUMBRALES DE (19341980)
On December 4, 1980, Portuguese prime minister S Carneiro, left Lisbon,
traveling with Defense Minister Adelino Amaro da Costa, their wives, and two
pilots to a presidential election rally in Porto, Portugals second-largest city.
On takeoff from Lisbon Portela Airport, witnesses reported seeing pieces falling off the prime ministers light twin-engine Cessna 421. Moments later, the
plane crashed into a building in Camarate, a Lisbon suburb, killing all six
persons aboard. Twenty-four years later, Nuno Melo, president of the fourth
parliamentary commission to investigate the crash, told journalists, We have
evidence of an explosive device placed under the floor of the pilots cabin,
which had sufficient strength to damage control cables and injure the pilots. It
seems sufficiently clear to me that the Cessna 421A crashed at Camarate during the night of December 4, 1980 due to sabotage. Thus far, no suspects have
been charged with the crime.
Francisco de S Carneiro was born in Porto, Portugal, the son of a successful
attorney and a mother descended from Spanish royalty, on July 19, 1934. He followed in his fathers footsteps as a lawyer, then turned to politics as a National
Assembly member, working toward gradual dissolution of Prime Minister Antnio de Oliveira Salazars quasi-fascist dictatorship. Salazar retired in September
1968, after 36 years in charge, but successor Marcelo Caetano proved no more
tolerant of dissent. In April 1974, a nearly bloodless military coupthe Carnation Revolutiondeposed Caetano and restored democracy in Portugal.
One month later, S Carneiro founded the Popular Democratic Party (later
the Social Democratic Party) with a group of like-minded liberals, serving as
its first secretary general. He served as minister without portfolio under the
National Salvation Junta and Prime Minister Vasco Gonalves, then won election as a deputy to the new Constitutional Assembly in 1975. The following
year, in another government shuffle, S Carneiro was elected to the Assembly
of the Republic, doubling as president of his party. He resigned the latter post
in 1977, but was called back by acclamation to reclaim it in 1978. In 1979, S
Carneiro forged the Democratic Alliancea coalition of his Social Democrats,
the right-wing Democratic and Social Centre Party, and two small groups
to win 128 of 250 seats in parliament. In January 1980, President Antnio
498
S C A R N E I R O, F R A N C I S C O M A N U E L L U M B R A L E S D E
Ramalho Eanes called on S Carneiro to form Portugals first majority government since the revolution, leading it as prime minister. At the time of his death,
S Carneiro was campaigning for Democratic Alliance presidential candidate
Antnio Soares Carneiro (no relation).
According to investigator Nuno Melo, the plot that claimed S Carneiros
life had its roots in the United Statesspecifically, the so-called October Surprise related to the recent U.S. presidential elections. Incumbent president
Jimmy Carter had failed to rescue or negotiate release of U.S. hostages held in
Iran since November 1979, while aides to opponent Ronald Reagan worked
secretly to free the captives on or around Election Day in November 1980. To
that end, they arranged illegal shipments of weapons (labeled as farm machinery) to Iran, with some passing through Portugal. Defense Minister Costa reportedly seized one of those shipments, angering two Portuguese collaborators
in the scheme: General Francisco da Costa Gomes (president of Portugal from
September 1974 to July 1976) and Admiral Jos Baptista Pinheiro de Azevedo
(prime minister from September 1975 to June 1976). With S Carneiro and
Costa silenced, another arms shipment cleared Lisbon for Tehran on January 22,
1981two days after President Reagan announced release of the hostages in
his inauguration speech.
Two former members of the now-defunct far-right terrorist group Commandos para a Defesa da Civilizao OcidentalCommandos for Defense of Western Civilization, or CODECOhave admitted knowledge of the S Carneiro
bombing. Fernando Farinha Simes, imprisoned on unrelated charges, waited
for Portugals 25-year statute of limitations to expire before telling his story to
journalist Jos Esteves in April 2012. That 18-page statement implicates the
U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, former secretary of state Henry Kissinger,
and convicted Iran-Contra conspirator Oliver North, whoSimes says
participated in advance discussions of the bombing. No charges have been
filed in relation to the case, nor does it seem likely that any shall be.
Further Reading
Anderson, James. The History of Portugal. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2000.
How They Killed Mr. Francisco S Carneiro and Mr. Adelino Amaro de Costa.
Scribd. http://www.scribd.com/doc/90035961/How-they-killed-Mr-Sa-Carneiro-andMr-Amaro-da-Costa.
Magone, Jose. European Portugal: The Difficult Road to Sustainable Democracy. New York:
St. Martins Press, 1997.
Maxwell, Kenneth. The Making of Portuguese Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
Mitchell, Paul. Portugal: Inquiry Concludes Bomb Killed Prime Minister Carneiro
in 1980. World Socialist Web Site (January 10, 2005). http://www.wsws.org/en/ar
ticles/2005/01/port-j10.html.
Wiarda, Howard, and Margaret Mott. Catholic Roots and Democratic Flowers: Political
Systems in Spain and Portugal. Westport, CT: Praeger: 2001.
S A D AT, A N WA R E L
Egyptian president Anwar El Sadat and 11 others died in a 1981 military uprising. (Alain
Keler/Sygma/Corbis)
499
500
S A D A T, A N W A R E L
13 children prohibitive, and Sadat spent his early childhood with his paternal
grandmother, raised to venerate a cast of heroes including Indias Mohandas
Gandhi, Turkish nationalist leader Mustafa Kemal Atatrk, and Egyptian villagers who battled British soldiers in the Denshawai Incident of June 1906.
Committed to Egyptian nationalism, Sadat graduated from Cairos Royal Military Academy in 1938 and joined the army as a second lieutenant posted in
Sudan (then part of Egypt). After meeting future president Gamal Abdel Nasser
there, Sadat joined the Free Officers Movement, dedicated to toppling Egypts
monarchy and expelling its British supporters.
That goal was naturally deemed subversive, and Sadat was jailed in World
War II on charges of collaborating with Axis forcesItaly and Germany
against Britain and Egypts king Farouk I. Seven years after V-E Day (Victory
in Europe Day), Sadat joined in the military coup led by Nasser and General
Muhammad Naguib, which deposed Farouk and established the Republic of
Egypt on July 23, 1952. Naguib took office as Egypts first president five days
later, succeeded by Nasser in November 1954. Nasser chose Sadat to serve as
minister of state in 1954, and promoted him five years later to secretary to the
National Union (at the time, Egypts only political party). From 1960 through
1968, Sadat served as president of the National Assembly, doubling in 1964
as a member of Egypts Presidential Council and as one of two vice presidents
in February of that year. December 1969 saw his return as vice president, that
time serving until October 14, 1970.
At the time of Gamal Nassers death on September 28, 1970, he served
both as president of Egypt and of the larger United Arab Republic (UAR),
formed by a merger with Syria in February 1958. Sadat inherited both offices on October 15, 1970, then dissolved the UAR in September 1971. At
home, meanwhile, in May 1971, he declared a Corrective Revolution to
purge Nasser supporters whom he viewed as being too inclined toward collaboration with the Soviet Union. At the same time, he imprisoned various
liberals and Muslims, particularly members of Takfir wal-Hijra (Excommunication and Exodus), a radical offshoot of the banned Muslim Brotherhood, founded in Egypt during the 1960s. That move, along with Sadats
peace overtures toward Israel, would ultimately rebound against him with
fatal consequences.
Israel had dealt a humiliating defeat to Egypt and its alliesJordan and
Syria, with expeditionary forces from eight other nationsin the Six Day
War of June 1967. Four years later, a war of attrition persisted along the
Suez Canal, characterized by air raids, border skirmishes, and acts of terrorism claiming at least 5,753 lives (some estimates exceed 15,000). Sadat and
President Hafez al-Assad of Syria sought to break that stalemate in October
1973, with a surprise attack on Israeli forces occupying the Egyptian Sinai
Peninsula and Syrias Golan Heights. The result, after 19 days of combat, was
S A D AT, A N WA R E L
another Israeli triumph, with some 18,500 attackers slain, 35,000 wounded,
and 8,783 captured, against Israeli losses of 2,800 killed and 8,800 wounded.
Nonetheless, Sadat was hailed in Egypt as Hero of the [Suez] Crossing, and
the first day of the Yom Kippur War became a holiday marked by national
celebration.
In realistic terms, the latest war forced Sadat to pursue peace negotiations
with Israel, initially geared toward reopening the Suez Canal as a safe passage for merchant vessels. Agreements signed in January 1974 and September
1975 secured that goal, winning Sadat the praise of Western diplomatsand
Evangelical minister Billy Grahamwhen Sadat visited the United States in
October 1975. April 1976 saw Sadat invited to the Vatican, where Pope Paul
VI shared his opinions on the Middle East, including a fair settlement for displaced Palestinian Arabs. In November 1977, Sadat broke new ground as the
first Arab leader to visit Israel, addressing the Knesset in Jerusalem after a private meeting with Prime Minister Menachem Begin. There, he called for implementation of United Nations Security Council Resolution 242, withdrawing all
Israeli troops from territory seized in October 1967.
Israel would not agree to those terms, but Prime Minister Begin did join
Sadat in the United States 10 months later, to negotiate the Camp David Accords with President Jimmy Carter. Their agreement, accompanied by various
side letters, paved the way for signing of the EgyptIsrael Peace Treaty on
March 26, 1979, a momentous event that earned both Sadat and Begin a Nobel
Peace Prize. That treaty, coupled with Sadats close ties to Shah Mohammad
Reza Pahlavi of Iran (deposed by radical Islamic fundamentalists one month
before the treaty was signed between Israel and Egypt), left Sadat a marked
man among Muslim extremists.
Egyptian public opinion was far from unanimous in ascribing blame for Sadats assassination. Sheikh Omar Abdel-Rahman, author of the fatwa condemning Sadat, spent three years in Egyptian jails before a court acquitted him and
ordered his expulsion from the country. Granted a tourist visa to the United
States in July 1990, despite his inclusion on a State Department terrorist watch
list, Rahman received a life prison term in October 1995, for his role in the February 1993 car-bombing of New York Citys World Trade Centers.
Meanwhile, conspiracy theories surround Sadats presidential successor,
Muhammad Hosni El Sayed Mubarak, who escaped the 1981 fusillade of bullets and grenade shrapnel with only a sprained thumb, while sitting at Sadats
right hand. Defense Minister Abu Ghazala, seated to Sadats immediate left,
also came through the storm of fire with only a bullet hole drilled through his
uniform cap. Named by one of Sadats daughters as the probable prime mover
behind her fathers assassination, Mubarak would rule Egypt as a de facto dictator until a revolution deposed him in February 2011. Six months later, he
faced trial on charges of negligence for not giving orders to stop the killing
501
502
S A D U L AY E V, A B D U L - H A L I M A B U - S A L A M O V I C H
S A D U L AY E V, A B D U L - H A L I M A B U - S A L A M O V I C H
eruption of the First Chechen War in December 1994, when military forces
of the Russian Federation moved to crush the secessionist Chechen Republic
of Ichkeria, founded three years earlier by Dzhokhar Dudayev. Abandoning
his studies, Sadulayev joined a militia unit based at Argun and participated in
various battles until the Khasavyurt Accord of August 1996 temporarily halted
hostilities.
The First Chechen War killed at least 25,000 combatants and 35,000 civilians (some tabulations top 100,000). It also changed Sadulayevs life forever, diverting him from academia to full-time Muslim zealotry. Between
August 1996 and the outbreak of renewed fighting three years later, he made
the obligatory Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca and returned to become a fixture
on Chechen television, lecturing on the tenets of Islam. In Argun, he led his
hometowns jamia, an Islamic education center that combined missionary activity with community policing and militia drills. In 1998, Sadulayev clashed
with Khabib Abdurrakhman, a Jordanian cleric living in Chechnya whose
followers attacked Russians and non-Muslim Chechens alike. Victorious in
that brief conflict, Sadulayev saw Abdurrakhman stripped of Chechen citizenship and expelled from the country.
A year later, President Aslan Maskhadov offered Sadulayev the chairmanship
of Chechnyas Supreme Sharia Court, but Sadulayev declined, citing a lack of
desire to judge others. That choice was taken from his hands in August 1999,
when members of the Chechnya-based Islamic International Brigade invaded
Dagestan, thus touching off the Second Chechen War. Some Chechens later
claimed the raid was planned by Russia, to justify its invasion of Chechnya
on October 1. In any case, the latest war would formally continue until May
2000, then settle into a decade-long war of insurgency and terrorism, claiming
at least 75,000 lives.
Abdul-Halim Sadulayev was in the thick of it, supporting Aslan Maskhadov
and being designated as his heir apparent to the separatist presidency in
2002. A year later, FSB agents kidnapped Sadulayevs wife and executed her,
after failed ransom negotiations. Members of the same agency assassinated
President Maskhadov at Tolstoy-Yurt, on March 8, 2005, and the Chechen
rebel council confirmed Sadulayev as Maskhadovs successor. Once installed,
Sadulayev called for decolonization of Muslim-dominated regions adjoining Chechnya and urged promulgation of a constitution based on Sharia law,
allowing for democratic election of the next president at wars end.
Despite his dedication to the struggleand his bitterness over the murder of his wifeSadulayev did his best to conduct the ongoing war on civilized lines. He discouraged hostage-taking and terrorist attacks on civilians,
urging Chechen warlords to focus on legitimate targets including federal
troops, police, government officials. Sadulayevs successor, Dokka Umarov, proved less discriminating as he carried the battle to Russia, with incidents such as the 2010 Moscow Metro bombings (40 dead, 100 injured)
503
504
SALIM, EZZEDINE
and the 2011 Domodedovo International Airport bombing (37 dead, 173
wounded).
There are two conflicting versions of Sadulayevs death. In the first, Kadyrovite militia leader (and future president) Ramzan Kadyrov claimed that his
men hoped to capture Sadulayev alive, but were forced to kill him and one of
his bodyguards when they resisted arrest. In June 2006, Memoriala human
rights organization active in post-Soviet statesdeclared that Sadulayevs death
was accidental, resulting from a grenade blast when FSB agents stormed a
rebel safe house without knowing that Sadulayev was inside.
Further Reading
Bodansky, Yossef. Chechen Jihad: Al Qaedas Training Ground and the Next Wave of Terror.
New York: Harper, 2007.
Russias Tactics Make Chechen War Spread across Caucasus. Kavkaz Center. http://
www.kavkaz.org.uk/eng/content/2005/09/16/4074.shtml.
Schaefer, Robert. The Insurgency in Chechnya and the North Caucasus: From Gazavat to
Jihad. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2011.
Terrorist Leader Sadulayev Killed in Chechnya Was Planning Big Terrorist Act. Pravda.
http://english.pravda.ru/news/hotspots/terror/18062006/82150-sadulayev-0.
505
506
S N C H E Z C E R R O, L U I S M I G U E L
its elected officials, then demanded their governments support for the invasion. Although opposed to the move, President Luis Snchez Cerro could not
resist the groundswell of strident nationalism. On April 30, he visited Limas
Hipdromo de Santa Beatriz racetrack (now El Campo de Marte) to review
20,000 new army recruits. As he completed the inspection, gunman Abelardo
de Mendoza, a member of the banned American Popular Revolutionary Alliance (APRA), shot Snchez with a pistol at close range, killing him instantly.
Presidential guards returned fire, slaying Mendoza. Parliament selected Field
Marshal and former president scar Raymundo Benavides Larrea to succeed
Snchez.
Luis Miguel Snchez Cerro was born at Piura, in northwestern Peru, on August 12, 1889, to parents of the Malagasy ethnic group from Madagascar. After
completing basic education in his hometown, he enrolled at Limas Chorrillos Military School in 1906, graduating as a lieutenant in 1910. In February
1914, Snchez joined in a coup dtat against unpopular President Guillermo
Enrique Billingshurst Angulo, suffering wounds that included the loss of two
fingers on his right hand. Promoted to captain by the victors, Snchez was sent
to Washington, D.C., as a military attach, then returned to Peru in 1915 as a
member of the Army Geographical Service.
More promotions followed for Snchez, but his career hit a snag when he
joined in another coup, this one meant to depose dictator Augusto Bernardino
Legua y Salcedo in August 1922. Wounded once again, Snchez was drummed
out of the service and spent two years in exile before Legua granted amnesty
to the failed rebels. Appointed to a post at the ministry of war in 1924, Snchez
was promoted to serve as chief of Cajatambo Province the following year, then
departed for Europe in August 1925, on a military fact-finding mission that
kept him abroad until January 1929.
Despite mending his fences with Augusto Legua, Snchez still despised the
autocratic president. On August 22, 1930, he led the Arequipa garrison in revolt and marched on Lima, forcing Leguas resignation three days later. A junta
led by Snchez ran Perus government from August 27, 1930, to March 1, 1931,
when David Samanez Ocampo and Sobrino assumed the interim presidency,
pending national elections. Snchez carried that campaign as a candidate for
the newly founded Revolutionary Union party, and was inaugurated as Perus 27th constitutional presidentthe first of indigenous Peruvian ancestry
on December 8. 1931.
The APRA contested that election, and member Jos Melgar Marquez made
the partys first attempt to kill Snchez on March 6, 1932, outside Limas
Church in Miraflores. Snchez drew his own pistol and was about to shoot
Melgar when guards subdued the gunman. At trial, Melgar claimed his actions
were entirely personal, without political motivation. He was condemned, but
Snchez commuted the sentence to 25 years in prison. Three months after
507
508
S A N D I N O, AU G U S T O N I C O L S C A L D E R N
met with White House emissary Henry Stimson to negotiate the Pact of Espino
Negro, whereby President Diaz agreed to finish out his term, then guarantee a
fair election for his successor in 1928. Both the government and rebels agreed
to disarm, leaving matters of Nicaraguan security to a new nonpartisan National Guard. Sandino and Bautista both refused to sign the pact; Bautista fled
to Mexico, and Sandino effectively declared war on both the National Guard
and its supporting force of U.S. Marines, led by General Logan Feland. General
Moncada signed the pact, thereby ensuring his election as president in 1928,
and Sandino branded him a vendepatria (country-seller) and condemned the
Colossus of the North as the enemy of our race.
During the seven-year conflict that followed, Sandinos Army in Defense
of the National Sovereignty of Nicaragua, armed only with obsolete firearms
and simple machetes, claimed the lives of at least 3,000 soldiers. Despite initial
losses and the ever-growing odds against him, Sandino fought some 500 engagements against Marines and the National Guard, winning more often than
he lost. Buoyed by frequent (if minor) victories, Sandino changed his name
to Augusto Csar Sandino, as a symbol of his confidence and defiance. Sandinos attitude was summarized in a letter published in Mexico City, which
read in part:
I will not abandon my resistance until the . . . pirate invaders . . . assassins of
weak peoples . . . are expelled from my country. . . . I will make them realize
that their crimes will cost them dear. . . . There will be bloody combat. . . .
Nicaragua shall not be the patrimony of Imperialists. I will fight for my cause as
long as my heart beats. . . . If through destiny I should lose, there are in my arsenal five tons of dynamite which I will explode with my own hand. The noise
of the cataclysm will be heard 250 miles. All who hear will be witness that Sandino is dead. Let it not be permitted that the hands of traitors or invaders shall
profane his remains.
Pursuit of Sandino proved fruitless, and a letter from his mother, forced by
Marines to plead for his surrender, failed to move him. In April 1928, Sandinos troops destroyed equipment at the Bonanza and La Luz gold mines,
owned by brothers of Harry Fletcher, the U.S. ambassador to Italy. Marines
hunted Sandino from airplanes and canoes, all in vain, while dissatisfaction
with their failure mounted at home. Senator Burton Wheeler of Montana
railed in Congress that if U.S. troops were needed stamp out banditry, lets
send them to Chicago to stamp it out there. . . . I wouldnt sacrifice . . . one
American boy for all the damn Nicaraguans. Sandino, meanwhile, stuck
to his demands: President Diazs resignation, withdrawal of U.S. forces, repeal of the 1914 BryanChamorro Treaty (granting the United States exclusive rights to dig a canal across Nicaragua), and free elections supervised by
Latin American statesmen. American paranoia spiked as the U.S. Communist
509
510
S A N D I N O, AU G U S T O N I C O L S C A L D E R N
Party endorsed Sandino, followed by the Soviet Unions Pan-American AntiImperialist League.
Mexican president Emilio Portes Gil offered sanctuary to Sandino in June
1929, and Sandino accepted, dividing his time in exile between discussions
with communist leaders and further dabbling in fringe religions, this time the
Magnetic-Spiritualist School of the Universal Commune, promoting a hybrid
form of communism based on spiritism of Light and Truth. Founded in Brazil by an expatriate Basque electrician, the sect believed that all humans would
eventually be Hispanic, sharing Spanish as their common language. Sandino
named sect founder Joaqun Trincado as one of his official advisors, while severing most of his links to traditional communist parties.
In January 1931, Henry Stimsonnow U.S. secretary of stateannounced
that U.S. troops would withdraw from Nicaragua after the countrys next election, in 1932, leaving only officers to advise the National Guard. Sandino returned from Mexico in the summer of 1931, launching a new offensive against
federal and foreign troops, seizing various small towns along principal railway
lines. Juan Bautista Sacasa won the 1932 presidential election, and U.S. Marines departed as promised after his inauguration. In February 1933, Sandino
met with Bautista and promised to disarm his guerrillas by May, if they were
granted squatters rights in the Ro Coco Valley bordering Honduras. Bautista
stalled, and the war continued for another year, until Sandinos betrayal and
murder in February 1934.
For decades after his assassination, Sandinos name remained a rallying cry
for opponents of Nicaraguas brutal Somoza dynasty, which seized control
of the country in January 1937. The Sandinista National Liberation Front,
founded in 1961, finally deposed the last Somoza in July 1979 and established its own duly elected government. Still unwilling to relinquish control
over Central America, the White House inaugurated a brutal (and illegal)
guerrilla war to destabilize the Sandinista regime in 1981, nearly bankrupting Nicaragua by 1990. Still, Sandinistas name and his message endure, resuscitated as the Sandinista Renovation Movement in 2006, under President
Daniel Ortega.
See also: Somoza Debayle, Anastasio (19251980); Somoza Garca, Anastasio (18961956).
Further Reading
Hodges, Donald. Sandinos Communism: Spiritual Politics for the Twenty-First Century.
Austin: University of Texas Press. 1992.
Ibarra Grijalva, Domingo. The Last Night of General Augusto C. Sandino. New York: Vantage Press, 1973.
Macaulay, Neil. The Sandino Affair. Chicago: Quadrangle Books, 1967.
Navarro-Gnie, Marco. Augusto Csar Sandino: Messiah of Light and Truth. Syracuse,
NY: Syracuse University Press, 2002.
511
512
S A R G S YA N , VA Z G E N
on charges of conspiring to overthrow the government. Subsequently, Compaor was elected president in 1991 (with only 25 percent of the electorate
voting), then won reelection in 1998. A constitutional amendment, passed in
2000, limited the president to five-year term, but Compaor was exempted
from the rule on grounds of his incumbency. Reelected once again in November 2005, Compaor survived an army mutiny in April 2011 and shows no inclination to surrender his office.
See also: Castro Ruz, Fidel Alejandro (1926 )Attempted; Guevara, Ernesto Che
(19281967).
Further Reading
Cudjoe, Alfred. Who Killed Sankara? Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988.
Dembl, Demba. Sankara 20 years later: A Tribute to Integrity. Pambazuka News
(October 10, 2008). http://www.pambazuka.org/en/category/features/51193/print.
Manson, Katrina, and James Knight. Burkina Faso. Guilford, CT: Pequot Press, 2006.
Sankara, Thomas. Thomas Sankara Speaks: The Burkina Faso Revolution: 198387. New
York: Pathfinder, 2007.
513
514
S A R G S YA N , VA Z G E N
(restructuring) and Glasnost (openness) during 19861988 sparked political stirrings in Armenia, including demands for reunion with NagornoKarabakh, a region occupied by many Armenians and promised to Armenia
by Vladimir Lenins Bolsheviks in 1920, then made part of Azerbaijan instead. On February 20, 1988, supported by mass demonstrations in Yerevan,
the Supreme Soviet of the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast voted to
unify with Armenia. A harsh reaction by Azerbaijani authorities ignited ethnic rioting between Armenians and Azeris, quickly escalating into full-scale
war. On May 5, 1990, a New Armenian army was created, operating independently of Russian occupation troops, and the two units were locked in
battle by May 27.
Sargsyan, fired with a sudden enthusiasm for politics, took his first
step in 1990, winning a National Assembly seat in Armenias first semi-free
elections. Upon arrival in parliament, Sargsyan was appointed to the Internal Affairs and State Defense Committee. On September 21, 1991, Armenia declared its independence from the Soviet Union. Sargsyan traveled to
Nagorno-Karabakh, commanding guerrilla units that defended rural villages
from the Azerbaijani army. Before that conflict ended in May 1994, Sargsyan was recalled to Yerevan, named as Armenias new minister of defense. In
1996, Sargsyan crushed street demonstrations protesting the rigged reelection of incumbent President Levon Ter-Petrosyan, but a year later switched
his support to former president of Nagorno-Karabakh Robert Kocharyan,
named as prime minister in March 1997.
Kocharyan was on his way up, succeeding Ter-Petrosyan as president in April
1998. His first prime minister, Armen Darbinyan, resigned on June 11, 1999,
allowing Kocharyan to promote Vazgen Sargsyan. Sargsyans tenure would be
briefonly 138 daysbut he left a deep impression on his homeland, receiving posthumous awards as a Hero of Artsakh (highest decoration from the selfproclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic) and as a National Hero of Armenia
(again, the countrys ultimate award). Various streets and schools in Karabakh
bear his name today.
At trial, Nairi Hunanyan claimed that he led the fatal National Assembly raid to
save the Armenian people from perishing and restore their rights. Soviet defector
Alexander Litvinenko told a different story, asserting that the Main Intelligence
Directorate of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces planned and supported the attack. The alleged motive: to derail ongoing peace negotiations over the
Nagorno-Karabakh territorial dispute that, despite cessation of open hostilities in
1994, is unresolved today. Russias embassy in Yerevan denied Litvinenkos charge,
and no evidence of conspiracy was forthcoming. As for Litvinenko himself, he was
murdered in 2006, perhaps by Russian intelligence agents.
See also: Litvinenko, Alexander Valterovich (19622006).
Further Reading
Marsden, Chris. Shooting Death of Armenian Prime Minister Heightens Crisis in
the Caucasus. World Socialist Web Site (October 29, 1999). http://www.wsws
.org/articles/1999/oct1999/arme-o29.shtml.
Melkonian, Markar. My Brothers Road: An Americans Fateful Journey to Armenia. London: I.B. Tauris, 2007.
Payaslian, Simon. The History of Armenia. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007.
Payaslian, Simon. The Political Economy of Human Rights in Armenia: Authoritarianism
and Democracy in a Former Soviet Republic. London: I.B. Tauris, 2011.
515
516
S C H N E I D E R C H E R E AU, R E N
exist to guarantee the regular work of the political system and the use of force
for any other purpose than its defense constitute high treason. With those
words and his determination to enforce them, Schneider frustrated would-be
putschists and ultimately sealed his own fate.
Armed with sterilized CIA weapons, conspirators made multiple attempts to neutralize Schneider by kidnapping him. The first, on October
16, 1970, failed because an anonymous tip to his whereabouts proved false.
Three days later, plotters waited to snatch him after an official dinner, but
Schneider eluded them by leaving in a private car, rather than his normal
chauffeured limousine. On October 20, CIA headquarters authorized payment of $50,000 each to Viaux and his chief accomplice for speedy resolution of the problem. Following the botched kidnapping-cum-assassination,
outgoing President Frei Montalva named General Carlos Prats Gonzlez as
Schneiders successor.
President Allendes prosecutors undertook investigation of Schneiders murder, placing equal blame on General Viauxs clique and another led by General
Camilo Valenzuela. Declassified CIA memos demonstrate direct payments of
cash to Viaux, plus a promised $250,000 life insurance policy for the benefit
of his family, should he die in the attempt. In separate trials, Viaux was convicted of organizing Schneiders abduction, and Valenzuela was convicted on
the lesser charge of plotting a coup. Both were released from custody in August
1973, after a U.S.-sponsored coup dtat deposed and killed President Allende,
replacing him with a neo-fascist military junta under dictator Augusto Jos
Ramn Pinochet Ugarte.
Pinochet left office at long last, in March 1990. More time elapsed before
the role of the United States in destabilizing Chiles government was documented, and Schneiders family filed a lawsuit against former U.S. secretary
of state Henry Kissinger on September 10, 2001, charging him with conspiracy in General Viauxs murder of Schneider. A federal court in Washington, D.C., dismissed that case in June 2005, on grounds that the case posed
a political question and the court could not proceed without expressing a
lack of respect to coordinate branches of government. The Supreme Court
later declined to review that judgment.
Further Reading
Cames, Nat. Chile-New York: The Eleventh of September. Lincoln, NE: iUniverse,
2004.
Chile and the United States: Declassified Documents Relating to the Military
Coup, September 11, 1973. The National Security Archive. http://www.gwu
.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB8/nsaebb8i.htm.
Collier, Simon. A History of Chile, 18082002. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2004.
Davis, Nathaniel. The Last Two Years of Salvador Allende. London: I.B. Tauris, 1985.
SELEUCUS I
517
518
SELEUCUS I
SELEUCUS I
519
520
meeting of the United Nations Unit against Apartheid. Further activities across
Europe culminated in 1983, with Septembers appointment as the ANCs chief
representative in France, Switzerland, and Luxembourg.
September did not limit her activities entirely to antiapartheid issues, nor
was she strictly committed to nonviolent protest. In 1984, she underwent brief
military training in the Soviet Union, and in the following year, she supported
both the Communist and Socialist Parties in French electoral contests. Between
October 1986 and September 1987, she was also immersed in the Albertini
Affair, campaigning for the release of French language instructor Pierre Albertini, detained in South Africa for his affiliation with the ANC. Prior to his release, September petitioned French president Franois Mitterand to reject the
credentials of South Africas new ambassador.
Such activities caused South African police and intelligence agencies to
focus on ANC representatives abroad. Godfrey Motsepe, an ANC colleague of
September in Belgium, narrowly escaped death when a 35-pound bomb was
defused at his office in Brussels, on March 27, 1988. Dulcie September reportedly sought police protection the same dayFrench police later denied it
but she was unguarded when assassins overtook her two days later. A decade
after her murder, a city square in Paris was named in her honor.
521
522
Further Reading
The Case of Dulcie September. Truth Commission Files. http://www.withmalicean
dforethought.com/pdf/dulcie_september.pdf.
Forde, Fiona. Unsolved murder of activist is reopened. Independent Online News
(August 23, 2009). http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/unsolved-murder-of-activistis-reopened-1.456016.
Holland, Heidi. The Struggle: A History of the African National Congress. New York:
George Braziller, 1990.
Who killed Dulcie September? Cape Times (May 18, 2012). http://www.iol.co.za/
capetimes/who-killed-dulcie-september-1.1299720.
SHAKA KASENZANGAKHONA
tribes. Shakas father died four years later, and his heir apparentson
Sigujanawas found dead soon after, in murky circumstances. Supported
by Dingiswayo, Shaka proclaimed himself king of the Zulus, forging alliances
with other nearby tribes against a common enemy, the Ndwandwe people
dwelling north of Zululand.
As chief, Shaka still recognized Dingiswayo as his overlord, continuing traditional tribute payments to the Mthethwa Paramountcy. That changed in
1817, when King Zwide kaLanga of the Ndwandwe clan led an invasion of
Zululand and killed Dingiswayo, scattering his army. Shaka rallied the stragglers and sought revenge for his mentor, igniting the NdwandweZulu War
with heavy odds against himhis troops outnumbered roughly six to one.
Even so, Shakas tactical skillemploying diversions and combat formations
reminiscent of the Roman phalanxproved superior to Zwides. At the Battle
of Gqokli Hill, in May 1818, Shaka killed 7,500 Ndwandwe against Zulu losses
of 2,000. Soon afterward, Shaka captured Zwides mother, Queen Ntombazi,
and executed her by locking her inside a hut with hungry hyenas. Zwide tried
to emulate Shakas tactics in 1819, at the Battle of Mhlatuze River, but Shaka
switched to guerrilla warfare and Zwide barely escaped with his life. The war
officially ended that year, but Shakas hatred of Zwide endured, culminating
with Zwides death in a final battle at Pongola, in 1825.
By that time, Shaka ruled a Zulu empire sprawling over thousands of square
miles. He was suspicious of European encroachment, but allowed some whites
to enter Zululand after British trader Henry Francis Fynn furnished Shaka
with medical aid, in the wake of a murder attempt by Ndwandwe assassins.
One beneficiary of Shakas flexible attitude was Nathaniel Isaacs, another Brit
whom Shaka named as his InDuna (advisor), granting him a large tract of
land where Durban stands today. Shaka also interceded in disputes between
tribes in his Zulu alliance, appointing sub-chiefssuch as Nqetho in Qwabe
to do his bidding.
As a military leader for his place and time, Shaka was unrivaled. In addition to refining battle strategy, he introduced large shields made from cow hide
and shortened traditional assegai spears for use as stabbing weapons, rather
than throwing them at enemies and leaving his warriors unarmed. His troops
marched barefoot to toughen their feet, and those who objected to losing
their sandals were killed. Fifty-mile forced marches were routine, with stragglers severely punished. Traveling battalions marched with herds of cattle, and
were thus spared carrying provisions on their backs. Troops were placed in
regiments by age, with different groups assigned to combat, cattle herding,
guarding kraals, and so on. For major battles, Shaka devised the bull horn
formation, wherein one unit (the chest) confronted enemies directly, while
two others (the horns) encircled the target from its flanks, with other troops
(the loins) held in reserve as reinforcements.
523
524
ZULU WAR
A half-century after Shakas assassination, the British high commissioner
Sir Henry Bartle Frere issued an ultimatum for evacuation of South Africa
to Zulu king Cetshwayo kaMpande. Fully aware that the Zulus would
refuse to leave their homeland, Frere proceeded to invade Zululand in
January 1879, and thus provoked the tribes last great war against white
encroachment. The first thrust was halted at Isandlwana on January 22,
in an epic battle that left 1,000 Zulus and 1,300 white invaders dead on
the field, with thousands more wounded. Later the same day, a small
British garrison at Rorkes Drift repulsed attacks by some 4,000 Zulus
and held their position. Heavy Zulu losses continued through successive
engagements until the Battle of Ulundi, on July 4, when British troops
captured the capital of Zululand using artillery and Gatling guns against
warriors armed with spears and a few captured rifles. King Cetshwayo
was captured in August and held prisoner until Frere partitioned Zululand, then restored him as nominal king in January 1883. Feuds within
the tribe further decimated Zulu numbers prior to Cetshwayos death on
February 8, 1884. His son Dinuzulu kaCetshwayo replaced him as king
three months later.
Dingane kaSenzangakhona, Shakas assassin and successor, did not share his late
half-brothers tolerance for white settlers in Zululand. Dinganes hostility toward
Europeans drove Nathaniel Isaacs from the territory in 1831 and sparked repeated
conflicts with Dutch Voortrekkers (pioneers) intruding on Zulu lands from the
Cape Colony (founded by the Dutch East India Company in 1652, but occupied
and ruled by Britain since 1795). Dingane suffered a stunning defeat at the Battle
of Blood River, in December 1838, when 470 Voortrekkers faced 10,000 Zulus,
killing at least 2,000 tribesmen against losses of three wounded on their side. In
the wake of that debacle, Dingane personally strangled field commander Ndlela
kaSompisi, but Dinganes reputation had suffered irreparable harm. Supported
by the Dutch, another of Shakas half-brothersMpande kaSenzangakhona, son
of Senzangakhonas ninth wiferebelled against Dingane and assassinated him
in January 1840. Mpande ruled Zululand until his death in 1873, then was succeeded by his son Cetshwayo kaMpande, last great war chief of the nation.
Further Reading
Chanaiwa, David Shingirai. The Zulu Revolution: State Formation in a Pastoralist Society. African Studies Review 23 (December 1980): 120.
Hamilton, Carolyn. Terrific Majesty: The Powers of Shaka Zulu and the Limits of Historical
Invention. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1998.
Morris, Donald. The Washing of the Spears: The Rise and Fall of the Zulu Nation. New
York: Simon & Schuster, 1989.
Omer-Cooper, J. D. The Zulu Aftermath. London: Longman, 1965.
Ritter, E. A. Shaka Zulu: The Biography of the Founder of the Zulu Nation. New York: Penguin Books, 1985.
Wylie, Dan. Myth of Iron: Shaka in History. Athens: Ohio University Press, 2008.
525
526
Police commissioner George Duckett was the first to die, in September 1972,
described by the BBC as a mercenary and a killer who has virtually a free
hand in suppressing black people. He was shot at home, in an attack that also
wounded his daughter. Following the SharplesSayers ambush, shopkeepers
Mark Doe and Victor Rigo were slain at their store in Hamilton, the islands
capital city. Erskine Burrows was arrested after being identified as the bandit
who stole $28,000 from the Bank of Bermuda at gunpoint, in September 1973.
In his confession to the SharplesSayers murders, Burrows said, The motive
for killing the Governor was to seek to make the people, black people in particular, become aware of the evilness and wickedness of the colonialist system
in this island. Secondly, the motive was to show that these colonialists were
just ordinary people like ourselves who eat, sleep and die just like anybody
else and that we need not stand in fear and awe of them.
Unconfirmed reports suggest involvement of a third man in the March 1973
assassinationsor, perhaps, a second, because jurors acquitted Larry Tacklyn
of killing Sharples and Sayers. According to those stories, the elusive suspect
escaped from Bermuda disguised as a woman, then returned to visit his prominent family in Bermuda during the 1990s. Mel Ayton, after examining files from
the British Foreign Office in 2005, implicates other members of the BBC in the
various murders, but no additional charges have been filed thus far.
Burrows and Tacklyn were the first persons hanged in Bermuda since World
War II, and the last executed anywhere under British law. Their deaths sparked
rioting in Bermuda, with property damage estimated at $2 million. Soldiers
from the 1st Battalion Royal Regiment of Fusiliers were deployed to suppress
that outbreak, when authorities on Bermuda proved unequal to the task. No
further violence by the BBC was reported from Bermuda or elsewhere. Founder
John Bassett died in 1998, at age 49.
Further Reading
Assassination of Sir Richard Sharples. Bernews. http://bernews.com/bermuda-facts/
government/assassination-of-sir-richard-sharples.
Ayton, Mel. Assault on Law and Order in Bermuda, 19721973: The Assassination of Governor Sir Richard Sharples and the Related Killings. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 2010.
Ayton, Mel. Justice Denied: Bermudas Black Militants, the Third Man, and the Assassinations of a Police Chief and Governor. Rock Hill, SC: Strategic Media Books, 2013.
Darrell, Neville. Aceldama: The Untold Story of the Murder of the Governor of Bermuda,
Sir Richard Sharples. Surrey, BC: Coastline Mountain Press, 2004.
527
528
S H E V K E T PA S H A , M A H M U D
S H E V K E T PA S H A , M A H M U D
529
530
position of influenceand was widely blamed for killing Nazim Pasha, ultimately leading to his own assassination.
Said Halim Pasha succeeded Shevket as Grand Vizier, in time for Turkeys
entry into World War I, signing the OttomanGerman Alliance. That move rebounded against him in February 1917, forcing his resignation and later sending him to prison on a charge of treason. Mehmed Talaat Pasha was next in line
as Grand Vizier, tarnished by his passage of the Tehcir (Displacement) Law of
May 1915 that initiated Turkish genocide of some 1.8 million ethnic Armenians. Turkeys defeat at wars end doomed the Ottoman Empire and the Three
Pashas. Mehmed Talaat fled into exile and was assassinated by agents of the
Armenian Revolutionary Federation in Berlin, on March 15, 1921. Members
of the same group killed Djemal Pasha in Tbilisi, Georgia, on July 25, 1922.
Enver Pasha survived until August 4, 1922, when he was slain in battle with
Red Army cavalry near Dushanbe, in present-day Tajikistan.
Further Reading
Balakian, Peter. The Burning Tigris: The Armenian Genocide and Americas Response. New
York: HarperCollins, 2003.
Finkel, Caroline. Osmans Dream: The History of the Ottoman Empire. New York: Basic
Books, 2007.
Hanioglu, M. Skr. Preparation for a Revolution: The Young Turks, 19021908. Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2001.
Quataert, Donald. The Ottoman Empire, 17001922. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2005.
Joseph Smith Jr. was born in Sharon, Vermont, on December 23, 1805. By age
12, his family had settled in western New Yorks burned-over district, so called
because incessant religious proselytization had left no human fuel for new conversion. There, Smiths family tried to supplement their meager farm income by
digging (in vain) for buried treasure. Joseph put a new twist on the enterprise
by claiming possession of seer stones that let him spy gold underground and
selling the coordinates to neighbors. Years later, a local newspaperthe Wayne
Democratic Pressclaimed that:
As early as 1820, Joe Smith, at the age of about 19 years, began to assume the gift of
supernatural endowments, and became the leader of a small party of shiftless men
and boys like himself who engaged in nocturnal money-digging operations upon the
hills in and about Palmyra. . . . Numbers of men and women, as was understood,
were found credulous enough to believe there might be something in it, who were
induced by their confidence and cupidity to contribute privately towards the cost of
carrying on the imposture, under the promise of sharing in the expected gains; and
in this way the loaferly but cunning Smith, who was too lazy to work for his living,
(his deluded followers did all the digging) was enabled to obtain a scanty subsistence
for himself without pursuing any useful employment.
531
532
proved more hostile since Smiths revelation supporting polygamy. (Smith had
three wives by 1838, and a total of 34 by November 1843.) Anti-Mormon agitation grew so militant, in fact, that Smith organized a covert force of Danites
to combat enemies of the churchand, some said, to weed out dissenting Mormons. Thus began the first of several Mormon Wars (see sidebar), in which
Missouri governor Lilburn Boggs ordered that Mormons be exterminated or
driven from the state. Gentile raiders complied, killing at least 17 Mormons at
Hauns Mill on October 30, 1838. Two days later, surviving Mormons surrendered to state troops, with an agreement to forfeit their property and leave Missouri. Smith was charged with treason, but escaped from custody on April 6,
1839, while awaiting trial.
Illinois accepted the LDS refugees, and Smith established a new community
called Nauvoo (from Hebrew, to be beautiful). A recent convert, Dr. John Cook
Bennett, used his influence as quartermaster general of Illinois to obtain Nauvoos municipal charter, approving formation of an LDS militia led by Lieutenant General Smith and Major General Bennett. Smith simultaneously named
Bennett as Nauvoos first mayor and assistant president of the church, but had
cause to regret it when Bennetts sexual relations with various women in town
were revealed. Other rumors circulated charging Nauvoos Mormons with adultery, homosexuality, and performing illegal abortions. Smith replaced Bennett as
mayor, and his former ally went on to write lurid exposs of Mormon life. One
controversial doctrine that he did not have to fabricate was baptizing the dead,
introduced by Smith in 1840. In the summer of 1842, Smith proclaimed a new
revelation for establishment of a theocracy spanning the globe.
Hostility against Mormons escalated in May 1842, after a botched attempt to
kill ex-governor Boggs in Missouri. Smith had predicted Boggss death, and reputed Danite gunman Owen Porter Rockwell was charged with attempted murder, then acquitted at trial. (The crime remains officially unsolved.) Missouri
sought to extradite Smith, but federal authorities deemed the writ unconstitutional. Prosecutors tried again in June 1843, demanding Smiths extradition on
the 1838 treason charge, but Smith obtained a writ of habeas corpus that foiled
the arrest. Six months later, he petitioned Congress to make Nauvoo an independent territory. Failing that, he announced his third-party candidacy for the
presidency in early 1844.
By then, Smiths relationship with several of his top advisors had soured,
prompting them to criticize him in their newly founded Nauvoo Expositor.
Smiths intemperate response led to his death, and left successor Brigham
Young in charge of the LDS Church. Prosecutors charged five menMark Aldrich, Jacob Davis, William Grover, Thomas Sharp, and Levi Williamswith
murdering the Smith brothers, but jurors acquitted all five at trial. Mormons
suspected Illinois governor Thomas Ford of complicity in the murders, and although he denied it, Ford later expressed satisfaction with the Mormon exodus
MORMON WARS
Three separate conflicts in American history are commonly referred to as
Mormon Wars. The first, in 1838, pitted Latter-day Saints (LDS) Church
members against hostile neighbors in northwestern Missouri, claiming 22
lives. All but one of those killed were Mormons, including 17 summarily
executed at the Hauns Mill massacre on October 30. A second war in Illinois, between church members and state militia during 18441845, followed the murders of Joseph Smith and his brother and claimed another
10 Mormon lives. The final Mormon War, in 18571858, arose from conflicts between the U.S. government and Brigham Youngs regime in Utah
Territory, chiefly over the issue of polygamy. That war had no battles
per se, but troops were mobilized on both sides in May 1857 and a group
of Mormon guerrillas led by John Doyle Lee massacred 120 members of
a westward-bound wagon train at Mountain Meadows on September 11,
1857. Seventeen surviving children were spared and adopted by Mormon
families. State authorities indicted Lee and three other militia leaders on
murder charges in 1874, but only Lee was punished, being executed by a
firing squad on March 23, 1877. Meanwhile, Congress banned polygamy
in U.S. territories with the Morrill Act of July 1862.
from Illinois, calling Joseph Smith the most successful impostor in modern
times. With regard to the double lynching, Ford wrote that some persons expect more protection from the laws than the laws are able to furnish in the face
of popular excitement.
See also: Strang, James Jesse (18131856).
Further Reading
Brodie, Fawn. No Man Knows My History: The Life of Joseph Smith. New York: Knopf,
1971.
Fullmer, John. The Assassination of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, the Prophet and the Patriarch of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. London: Latter-day Saints Book
Depot, 1855.
Hill, Marvin. Carthage Conspiracy Reconsidered: A Second Look at the Murder of
Joseph and Hyrum Smith. Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society 97 (Summer
2004): 10734.
Nickerson, Freeman. Death of the Prophets Joseph and Hyram [sic] Smith. Boston: John
Gooch, 1944.
Wicks, Robert, and Fred Foister. Junius and Joseph: Presidential Politics and the Assassination of the First Mormon Prophet. Logan, UT: Utah State University Press, 2005.
533
534
SOGDIANUS
S O M O Z A D E B AY L E , A N A S TA S I O
kill him at Colossae, in 359 BCE. The bitter queen is commemorated by asteroid 888 Parysatis, discovered by German astronomer Maximillian Wolf in
February 1918.
Further Reading
Allen, Lindsay. The Persian Empire. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005.
Olmstead, A. T. History of the Persian Empire. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,
1948.
Van de Mieroop, Marc. History of the Ancient Near East ca. 3000323 BC. Malden, MA:
Blackwell Publishing, 2007.
Wiesehofer, Josef. Ancient Persia. London: I.B. Tauris, 2001.
535
536
S O M O Z A D E B AY L E , A N A S T A S I O
Nicaraguan dictator Anastasio Somoza Debayle, killed in exile, in September 1980. (Shepard Sherbell/CORBIS SABA)
S O M O Z A D E B AY L E , A N A S TA S I O
537
538
S O M OZ A GA RC A , A N A S TA S I O
Further Reading
Alegria, Claribel, and Darwin Flakoll. Death of Somoza. Willimantic, CT: Curbstone
Press, 1996.
Berman, Karl. Under the Big Stick: Nicaragua and the United States Since 1848. Boston:
South End Press, 1986.
Crawley, Eduardo. Dictators Never Die: A Portrait of Nicaragua and the Somoza Dynasty.
Palgrave Macmillan, 1979.
Diederich, Bernard. Somoza and the Legacy of U.S. Involvement in Central America. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener Publishers, 2007.
Morley, Morris. Washington, Somoza and the Sandinistas: State and Regime in US Policy toward Nicaragua 19691981. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Towell, Larry. Somozas Last Stand: Testimonies from Nicaragua. Trenton, NJ: Red Sea
Press, 1990.
S O M O Z A G A R C A , A N A S TA S I O
539
540
S O M OZ A GA RC A , A N A S TA S I O
reelection in 1947. Somoza obliged, directing his party to nominate 69-yeaarold Dr. Leonardo Argello Barreto as his latest front man. Inaugurated on May 1,
Dr. Argello suddenly displayed a startling independent streak, declaring,
I will not be, by the way, a simple figurehead. Somozas National Guard deposed Argello on May 26, replacing him with Benjamn Lacayo Sacasa, another of Somozas uncles by marriage. Lacayo, in turn, lasted less than three
months, ceding the presidency to Vctor Manuel Romn y Reyes (yet another
Somoza uncle). Reyes died on May 6, 1950, and Manuel Fernando Zurita followed as acting president, surrendering the pretense and his office to Somoza
on May 21.
Tired of playing games with the United States, Somoza amended the Nicaraguan constitution once again, in 1955, permitting himself to seek another presidential term without employing stand-ins. By that time, he had also
founded a merchant marine company and Lneas Areas de Nicaragua, Nicaraguas national airline. While milking profits from those enterprises, he built
a new container port near Managua, predictably named after himself. His assassination failed to break the dynasty Somoza had established, as he was succeeded first by son Luis Somoza Debayle, and later by son Anastasio Somoza
Debayle, maintaining control of the country (with various puppet rulers) until
July 1979.
Once the family was finally expunged from Nicaragua, supplanted by a
leftist government named in honor of murdered Augusto Sandino, assassin
Rigoberto Lpez Prez was officially rehabilitated. The Sandinista Liberation
Front named one of its regional commands after Lpez in April 1979; three
months later, with the movements triumph, Managuas national stadium was
named after Lpez. (President Arnoldo Alemn changed the stadiums name
once again, in November 1998, to name it after Major League Baseball player
Dennis Martinez.) On the 25th anniversary of his death in Len, the government issued Decree No. 825, naming Lpez as a National Hero. In 2006, a
monument dedicated to Lpez was erected in Managua. Somozas name, meanwhile, has been removed from sundry landmarks nationwide.
See also: Sandino, Augusto Nicols Caldern (18951934); Somoza Debayle, Anastasio
(19251980).
Further Reading
Berman, Karl. Under the Big Stick: Nicaragua and the United States Since 1848. Boston:
South End Press, 1986.
Diederich, Bernard. Somoza and the Legacy of U.S. Involvement in Central America. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener Publishers, 2007.
Lake, Anthony. Somoza Falling: A Case Study of Washington at Work. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, 1990.
S TA M B O L I Y S K I , A L E K S A N D A R
Millett, Richard. Guardians of the Dynasty. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 1977.
Schmitz, David. Thank God Theyre On Our Side: The United States & Right-Wing Dictatorships. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1999.
Walter, Knut. The Regime of Anastasio Somoza, 19361956. Chapel Hill: University of
North Carolina Press, 1993.
541
542
S TA M B O L I YS K I, A L E KSA N DA R
S TA M B O L O V, S T E FA N N I K O L O V
543
544
S T E U N E N B E RG, FR A N K
STEUNENBERG, FRANK
when he visited the murder scene with hotel clerk Clinton Wood, stating his
view that Idaho mine owners had paid Steunenberg a big wad of money for
suppressing strikes during his second term as governor. Detained by private
Pinkerton detectives and promised leniency, Orchard confessed to the bombing
and implicated leaders of the Western Federation of Miners (WFM), who were
also arrested. Jurors acquitted the alleged conspirators in 1907, and Orchard
later pled guilty and was sentenced to hang. That sentence was later commuted
to life imprisonment.
Frank Steunenberg was born in Keokuk, Iowa, on August 8, 1861. He attended Iowa State College, and upon graduation found work as a printers apprentice. He worked at the Des Moines Register in 1881, then moved on to
publish a newspaper in tiny Knoxville, Iowa, remaining there until 1886. During that year, he moved west to join his brother in Caldwell, in Idaho Territory,
and published the Caldwell Tribune.
While engaged in that pursuit over the next six years, Steunenberg also
tried his hand at politics. In 1889, the year before Idaho achieved statehood,
he was a delegate to the state constitutional convention. From 1890 to 1893,
he was a member of the state legislature. In 1896, running as a fusion candidate with support from both the Democratic and Populist Parties, Steunenberg won election as Idahos fourth governor. After a relatively uneventful
two-year term, Steunenberg was reelected by the same coalition in November 1898.
By then, unrest was common among minters in Idaho and other nearby
states. The WFM pushed for higher wages and safer working conditions,
whereas stubborn mine owners resisted. In Idaho, fearing that Governor
Steunenberg would support strikers in the event of a walkout, most mine owners
reluctantly granted higher pay, but the Bunker Hill Mining Company refused
to cooperate. Its miners earned 50 cents less per hour than those employed by
other companies, whereas Bunker Hill shareholders received $600,000 in dividends. Mine superintendent Albert Burch fired 17 suspected WFM members,
while declaring that Bunker Hill would rather shut down and remain closed
twenty years than recognize the union. In April 1899, strikers bombed the
companys mill at Wardner, in the Silver Valley, sparking a battle that left two
men dead.
Governor Steunenberg responded to that violence by declaring martial law,
but found himself without troops, because Idahos National Guard had been
sent to the Philippines, fighting native insurgents in the wake of the SpanishAmerican War. Accordingly, he asked President William McKinley for federal
troops, a move viewed as rank betrayal by his union and Populist supporters. Soldiers arrested hundreds of miners, cramming them into open-air bull
pens with minimal sanitary facilities. Martial law remained in effect for the
545
546
S T E U N E N B E RG, FR A N K
STEUNENBERG, FRANK
547
548
S T E W A R T, J A M E S , E A R L O F M O R AY
S T E W A R T, J A M E S , E A R L O F M O R AY
servants found him murdered in the garden. Prime suspect James Hepburn was
acquitted in that case and married Queen Mary in May 1567, but their joint
reign was brief. In July of that year, rebels imprisoned Mary and forced her to
abdicate in favor of James, her one-year-old son by Henry Stewart, and James
Hamilton, Duke of Chtellerault, served as regent.
James Stewart was not idle in the meantime. In August 1557, he led raids
against the English in Northumbria, and two years later supported the Scottish
Reformation, a rift with the Papacy that would create the Church of Scotland.
Queen Mary, Stewarts half-sister, clung to the Catholic faith, thereby sowing the seeds of rebellion that would later unseat her. In June 1559, Stewart
led a Protestant march against Perth, where he removed icons from Catholic
churches and defeated French forces rallied in Marys support.
Mary escaped to France that time, but would return in 1561 to settle her
differences with James Stewart. Despite their separate and hostile religions,
she named Stewart Earl of Moray in 1562, a post that included title to Darnaway Castle, southwest of Forres. In October 1562, when George Gordon,
4th Earl of Huntly, led a revolt against Mary, Stewart defeated him at the Battle of Corrichie, near Aberdeen. He opposed Marys marriage to Henry Stewart in July 1565, and the following month led an ill-conceived rebellion later
dubbed the Chaseabout Raid, because opposing forces pursued each other
without making contact. Declared an outlaw, James fled to England, then to
France, missing the murder of Marys husband, her hasty marriage to James
Hepburn, 4th Earl of Bothwell, and her subsequent abdication. Returning to
Scotland on August 11, 1567, Stewart was named to serve as regent for young
James VI eleven days later.
When Mary escaped from prison on May 2, 1568, she raised an army of
6,000 men, clashing with Stewarts troops near Glasgow, in the Battle of Langside, on May 13. Although outnumbered, Stewart swept the field, forcing
Marys flight to England. There, she was taken into protective custody while
her Scottish supporters waged the five-year Marian Civil War. Her supporters
allegedly planned to assassinate Stewart during a diplomatic visit to York, in
September 1568, but cancelled their plans at the eleventh hour. Back in Scotland, during 1569, Stewart celebrated successive victories, capturing the rural
home of John Fleming, 5th Lord Fleming, along with other Marian strongholds
at Crawford, Hoddom, Annan, Skirling, Kenmuir, and Sanquhar.
After Stewart was shot in Linlithgow, both Hamiltons fled from the scene.
The archbishop sought refuge at Dumbarton Castle, a stronghold of Queen
Marys supporters, but Captain Thomas Crawford led a nocturnal raid that
captured him on April 2, 1571. Quickly tried and convicted of aiding in
Stewarts murderand in the slaying of Henry Stewart, 1st Duke of Albany,
with his valet in February 1567John Hamilton was hanged at Stirling on
April 6, 1571.
549
550
S T R A N G, JA M E S J E S S E
Triggerman James Hamilton was more fortunate. He outran mounted pursuers and escaped to France, where he found sanctuary with kinsmen of Queen
Mary. They asked him to assassinate Gaspard II de Coligny, a Huguenot leader
in the French Wars of Religion, but Hamilton refused on grounds that an honorable man should slay his own enemies, but not kill on behalf of others.
Hamilton remained in France and died there, unpunished, in 1581. Meanwhile, four of his relatives were jailed in Scotland as accomplices in Stewarts
assassination, and Scotlands parliament declared the entire family rebels in
October 1579. A year after Hamiltons death, in June 1582, George Hume of
Spott faced Scottish charges of aiding James and John Hamilton in their flight
from Linlithgow. Humes acquittal marked the final closing of the case.
Queen Mary ultimately found that protective custody in England offered
no protection at all. Still confined in August 1586, she was implicated in a
Catholic plot to depose Elizabeth I, and faced trial with 14 accomplices on
charges of conspiracy and treason. All were convicted and executed, with Mary
publicly beheaded on February 8, 1587.
Further Reading
Cadell, Patrick. Sudden Slaughter: The Murder of the Regent Moray. Glasgow: West Lothian History and Amenity Society, 1975.
Ives, Edward. The Bonny Earl of Murray: The Man, the Murder, the Ballad. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1997.
Lawson, John. Life of the Celebrated Regent Moray, Patron of Scottish Reformation, Who
Was Assassinated 23d Jan. 1570: Including an Account of the Contention between the
Queen Regent and the Lords of the Congregation. Glasgow: John Lothia, 1828.
Lee, Maurice. James Stewart, Earl of Moray: A Political Study of the Reformation in Scotland. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1971.
fined $1.25 after a mock trial, then treated to a celebratory banquet. Neither the
gunmen nor two presumed conspirators, Alexander Wentworth and Doctor
J. Atkyn, were ever punished for Strangs assassination.
James Strang was born on a farm near Scipio, New York, on March 21,
1813. Given to flights of fancy in his youth, at age 19 he penned an entry in his
diary complaining that he ought to have been a member of the Assembly or a
Brigadier General before this time if I am ever to rival Cesar [sic] or Napoleon
which I have sworn to. Another entry from the same year declared: I have
spent the day in trying to contrive some plan of obtaining in marriage the heir
to the English Crownthe future Queen Victoria, then 12 years old. Instead,
he married a Baptist ministers daughter, moving from New York to Burlington,
Vermont, with his wife and first child in 1843.
In Vermont, after dabbling in journalism and lectures on temperance, Strang
turned to practicing law, apparently without formal training. That winter, he
converted to Mormonism and traveled to Nauvoo, Illinois, where he was baptized as an elder by church president Joseph Smith Jr. Back in Burlington,
Strang began converting others, building up a congregation of his own. When
an Illinois lynch mob killed Smith and his brother, leaving the parent church
leaderless in June 1844, Strang saw no reason why he should not fill the martyred prophets shoes. Brigham Young had other ideas, rallying support in Nauvoo and leading the Mormon Exodus westward to Utah, whereupon Strang
defected to form his own Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Strangite), casting himself as the sole legitimate heir to Smiths legacy. A letter of appointment, allegedly signed by Smith the week before his murder, supported
Strangs case. Serving as prophet, seer, and revelator of his church was not
enough for Strang, however. Subtly altering Smiths message to include a divine grant of royalty, he declared himself a king. In 1845, Stranglike Smith
before himannounced that an angel had led him to buried gold plates which
he alone could translate from lost Levantine languages, producing a Book of
the Law of the Lord to rival Smiths Book of Mormon.
All he lacked now was a kingdom, secured when Strang led his own mini exodus
from Burlington to Beaver Island in 1847. A man of many parts, when not leading
his flock of some 12,000 acolytes, Strang served in Michigans state legislature and
penned a natural history of Beaver Island that was published by the Smithsonian
Institution. In 1849, after years of opposing polygamy, Strang abruptly changed
his view, accumulating four more wives. That turnabout caused some defections
from his sect, whereas others were occasioned by his strictsometimes selective
discipline. One of Strangs slayers, Thomas Bedford, had been flogged for adultery;
the other, Alexander Wentworth, professed outrage over Strangs recent order that
female church members must dress in bloomers. An accomplice in the murder
plot, Dr. Hezekiah McCulloch, was excommunicated for his heavy drinking and
assorted other sins. The other, Doctor Atkyn, was a swindler and blackmailer
Strang had threatened to ban from his island.
551
552
SVERKER I
Strangs murder doomed his church. While he lay dying at Voree, on July
5, a mob from Mackinac stormed Beaver Island, robbing and evicting its
2,600 inhabitants. The power vacuum left by Strangs assassination proved
particularly difficult to fill, because he had claimed angels must hand-pick
his successor. Lorenzo Dow Hickey eventually filled the post, until his death
in 1900, succeeded until 1922 by High Priest Wingfield Watson. Neither
claimed to be a prophet of the Lord, however, and most of Strangs flock
subsequently joined the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day
Saints, known since 2001 as the Community of Christ. Remnants of Strangs
original sect persist today as the Church of Jesus Christ (Drewite), founded
by Thomas Drew in 1965, and the Holy Church of Jesus Christ, founded by
Alexandre Caffiaux in 1978.
See also: Smith, Joseph, Jr. (18051844).
Further Reading
Fitzpatrick, Doyle. The King Strang Story: A Vindication of James J, Strang, the Beaver Island Mormon King. Lansing, MI: National Heritage, 1970.
Foster, Lawrence. James J. Strang: The Prophet Who Failed. Church History 50
(1981): 18292.
Russell, William. King James Strang: Joseph Smiths Successor? In Mormon Mavericks: Essays on Dissenters. Salt Lake City, UT: Signature Books, 2002.
The Society for Strang Studies. http://www.strangstudies.org/James_Jesse_Strang.
Speek, Vickie. God Has Made Us a Kingdom: James Strang and the Midwest Mormons. Salt
Lake City, UT: Signature Books, 2006.
van Noord, Roger. King of Beaver Island: The Life and Assassination of James Jesse Strang.
Champaign: University of Illinois Press, 1988.
Weeks, Robert. For His Was the Kingdom, and the Power, and the Glory . . . Briefly.
American Heritage 21 (June 1970): 47, 7886.
SVERKER I (?1156)
On December 25, 1156, King Sverker I of Sweden set out from deshg, in
stergtland, to attend Christmas services at nearby Alvastra Abbey. Sverker
had donated land for construction of the Cistercian Orders edifice, and would
have been an honored guestif he had reached the church. Along the way,
however, as coach crossed the Alebck Bridge, he was attacked and stabbed
to death by one of his own escorts. Two pretenders to the Swedish throne,
Magnus Henriksson and Erik Jedvardsson, were suspected conspirators in
Sverkers assassination, and Erik in fact succeeded him, as King Erik IX.
Little is known of Sverkers early. Life, and what remains is mixed with legend. His birth date is unknown, surviving accounts disagree on the name of
his father. The Vstgtalagen (Westgothic law), Swedens oldest text in Latin,
SVERKER I
includes an appendix by a priest called Laurentius listing Christian Swedish kings, which names Sverkers father as Cornube. Another documentthe
Skldatal (Catalogue of Poets), in Old Norsedisagrees, naming his sire as Kol.
In any case, tradition identifies Sverker as a wealthy landowner in stergtland by 1113, when he was chosen as king of Gothiscandza, settled by an East
Germanic tribe of Goths in the first century CE.
His rival for control of Sweden at that time was King Inge the Younger, of the
House of Stenkil, whose death in 1125possibly poisoned by his queen and
her clandestine lovereffectively extinguished the dynasty. Sverker later married Inges widow, Ulvhild Hkansdotter, but not before she spent four years
married to King Niels of Denmark. Niels died in battle Fotevik, in June 1134,
supporting son Magnus Nilssonkilled in the same engagementagainst
rival Canute Lavard, thus freeing Ulvhild to take her third husband.
In the meantime, Sverker had ascended to the Swedish throne, in 1130.
Twelve years later, he successfully defended Swedens borders against forces
from the Novgorod Republic. Queen Ulvhild died in 1148, and Sverker soon
remarried to Riquilda (or Riclitza) or Poland, daughter of Polish king Boleslao
III and widow of the aforementioned Magnus Nilsson. Their union was brief,
ending with Riquildas death in 1150. Before years end, Sverker found himself challenged as king by Erik Jedvardsson of Vstergtland. Another rival,
deemed less dangerous perhaps, was Danish lord Magnus Henriksson, greatgrandson of Inge I and an illegitimate grandson of late Danish king Sweyn II
Estridsson.
Whichever adversary planned Sverkers assassination, Erik claimed the
Swedish throne in 1156, thereafter known as King Eric IX, Eric the Lawgiver,
Erik the Saint, and/or Eric the Holy. If he did kill Sverker, Eriks own fate presents a lesson in irony. On May 18, 1160, he was ambushed and slain by agents
of Magnus Henriksson outside a church in Uppsala, reportedly tortured by
his killers before he was finally beheaded. Magnus II then claimed the throne,
but only briefly. In 1161, he was slain by Karl Sverkersson, son of Sverker I,
who then assumed the throne as Charles VIIand was himself assassinated on
April 12, 1167, by supporters of rival Knut Eriksson.
Further Reading
DuBois, Thomas. Sanctity in the North: Saints, Lives, and Cults in Medieval Scandinavia.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2008.
Kent, Neil. A Concise History of Sweden. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Morby, John. Dynasties of the World: A Chronological and Genealogical Handbook. New
York: Oxford University Press, 2002.
Svanstrom, Ragnar. A Short History of Sweden. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1934.
553
T
TAKAHASHI KOREKIYO (18541936)
On February 26, 1936, pursuing the ideal of a Showa Restoration proposed by author Kita Ikki, some 1,500 soldiers of the Imperial Japanese
Army attempted a coup dtat to purge destroying the deadly spirit that was
poisoning Japan. Their targets in Tokyo included Prime Minister Okada
Keisuke, Grand Chamberlain Suzuki Kantaro, Lord Keeper of the Privy Seal
Saito Makoto, former Keeper of the Privy Seal Makino Nobuaki, Inspector General of Military Education Watanabe Jotaro, and Finance Minister
Takahashi Korekiyo. Before loyal troops suppressed the uprising on February 29, Saito, Takahashi, and Watanabe were dead. The prime minister
escaped through a fluke of mistaken identity, when the rebels shot his brotherin-law, Captain Matsuo Denzo. Following a round-up of the insurrectionists,
two coup leaders committed suicide, 18 were executed for mutiny, seven
received life prison terms, and 28 received lesser sentences, ranging from
one to 15 years.
Takahashi Korekiyo was born out of wedlock in Edo (now Tokyo), the capital of Japans Tokugawa shogunate, on July 27, 1854. Adopted by Takahashi
Kakuji, a samurai warrior of the clan led by Date Kunishige, he learned English
and studied American culture at a missionary school, then was sent to London
in 1866, as a servant for the son of Count Katsu Kaishu. In 1867, Takahashi
traveled to Oakland, California, and spent a year as a common laborer, refining
his skill in English before he returned to Japan in 1868.
Despite his menial employment overseas, Takahashis fluency in English
permitted him to teach the language upon his return to Tokyo, established
that same year as Japans imperial capital. Soon, he was first master at Kyoritsu
Gakko (now Kasei) High School, progressing from there to serve in the ministry of education, then the ministry of agriculture and commerce. Within the
latter department, he was soon promoted to First Chief of the Bureau of Patents, overhauling Japans antiquated patent system. A private business venture
in Peru proved disappointing, but Takahashi was back in Tokyo by 1892, now
working at the Bank of Japan. Finding his mtier in the realm of finance, he
assumed vice presidency of the bank by 1898, and won national recognition
for securing $200 million in critical loans for Japan during the Russo-Japanese
War of 19041905.
556
TA K A H A S H I KO R E K I YO
TA K A H A S H I K O R E K I Y O
557
558
TA R A K I, N U R M U H A M M A D
TA S E E R , S A L M A A N
Tarakis presidency was fraught with controversy from its beginning, marked
by a purge of PDPA officers whom he regarded as prospective rivals. His program of agrarian reform, launched on January 1, 1979, generated anger when
family holdings were restricted, any excess acreage seized by the state without
compensation. Further implementation of Marxist programs clashed with traditional Afghan-Islamic values and threatened the power of local leaders, thus
breeding more enemies for the regime. In education, Taraki scrapped a 20-year
plan to wipe out illiteracy, created under President Daoud by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, declaring its curriculum rubbish and replacing textbooks with PDPA leaflets. At the same time,
Taraki signed a Twenty-Year Treaty of Friendship with the Soviet Union that
expanded Russian aid to Afghanistan. Even so, Moscow found Tarakis domestic programs too radical, rejecting his plea for practical and technical assistance with men and armament. Leonid Brezhnev personally warned Taraki
that arming Afghanistan would only play into the hands of our enemies, both
yours and ours.
Thus rebuffed, in September 1979 Taraki turned to Cubas Fidel Castro and
the growing Non-Aligned Movement, established in 1961 as the Conference
of Heads of State or Government of Non-Aligned Countries. Stopping briefly
in Moscow, on his return flight from Havana, Taraki met with Brezhnev and
other Soviet officials who, unknown to him, supported Hafizullah Amins plan
to depose Taraki. Once that object was achieved, however, matters quickly
went from bad to worse. Amin reportedly slaughtered dissidents by the tens of
thousandssome 27,000 at Kabuls Pul-e-Charkhi Prison alone, and Soviet
troops intervened on December 24, 1979, eliminating Amin at the outset of a
nine-year occupation.
See also: Amin, Hafizullah (19291979).
Further Reading
Adamec, Ludwig. Historical Dictionary of Afghanistan. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press,
2011.
Dorronsoro, Gilles. Revolution Unending: Afghanistan, 1979 to the Present. London:
C. Hurst & Co., 2005.
Misdaq, Nabi. Afghanistan: Political Frailty and External Interference. New York: Taylor &
Francis, 2006.
Reddy, L. R. Inside Afghanistan: End of the Taliban Era? New Delhi: APH Publishing,
2002.
559
560
TA S E E R , SA L M A A N
TA S E E R , S A L M A A N
brokerage house, which Taseer ran as chief executive officer. Two years later,
he filled the same position with a new firm, WorldCall, first operating a network of public pay telephones, later expanding into a major media company
with broadband wireless, cable television, and other services. Oman Telecommunications Company purchased a majority share of WorldCall in May 2008.
Meanwhile, Taseer also operated Business Plus (Pakistans first English-language
news channel), Wikkid Plus (the first TV channel for children), and an Englishlanguage newspaper, Lahores Daily Times.
In November 2007, caretaker Prime Minister Muhammad Mian Soomro
chose Taseer to serve as his interim federal minister for industries, production,
and special initiatives. Six months later, on May 15, 2008, a voters coalition
dominated by the PPP elected him as governor of Punjab, succeeding Lieutenant General Khalid Maqbool Vohra. Already unpopular with conservative
Muslims, Taseer sparked controversy in June 2009, when Asia Bibia Christian woman living in the Sheikhupura Districtwas sentenced to death for
blasphemy against the Prophet Mohammed. Taseer joined Minister for Minorities Affairs Clement Shahbaz Bhatti in condemning that sentence and the statute itself, passed by the National Assembly in 1986. Both men received death
threats, and Taseer reportedly left Pakistan briefly in December 2010, prompting Punjab Assembly Speaker Rana Muhammad Iqbal Khan to call for his removal as governor under constitutional provision that barred a governor from
leaving the province.
That petition was still pending at the time of Taseers assassination in January 2011. Eight hours before his murder, Taseer posted a message on Twitter,
quoting a couplet from Urdu poet Shakeel Badayuni: My resolve is so strong
that I do not fear the flames from without, I fear only the radiance of the flowers, that it might burn my garden down. Two months after Taseers murder,
on March 2, Shahbaz Bhatti also was slain by gunmen in Islamabad, outside
his mothers home. On August 26, 2011, Taliban members kidnapped Shahbaz
Taseer, son of the murdered governor. Conflicting reports of his fate include an
announcement of his execution in June 2012, and a government claim from
January 2013 that negotiations for his safe release had reached an advanced
stage.
See also: Bhutto, Benazir (19532007).
Further Reading
Asghar, Mohammed. Assassin Linked to Dawat-i-Islami. Dawn ( January 5, 2011).
http://dawn.com/2011/01/05/assassin-linked-with-dawat-i-islami.
Bruillard, Karin. Salman [sic] Taseer Assassination Points to Pakistani Extremists
Mounting Power. Washington Post ( January 5, 2011). http://www.washingtonpost
.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/01/04/AR2011010400955.html.
561
562
T I S Z A D E B O R O S J E N O E T S Z E G E D, I S T V N
T I S Z A D E B O R O S J E N O E T S Z E G E D , I S T V N
Blood Red Thursday for the harsh police response that left six dead and 300
incarcerated. Sixteen days later, on June 7, opposition party member Gyula
Kovcs tried to kill Tisza in parliament, missing him with three pistol shots,
then failing in an attempt to commit suicide. At trial, Kovcs was acquitted on
grounds of insanity. Despite such animosity, Tisza was elected to a second term
as prime minister in June 1913, retaining that post for four years.
His second term in office coincided with the assassination of Archduke
Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo and the outbreak of World War I. Prior to Ferdinands murder, Tisza had opposed Serbian demands for independence from
Austria-Hungary, but after the slaying he argued against military action, fearing that war would doom the Hungarian monarchy. Once battle was joined,
Tisza passed new laws restricting freedom of speech and association, further
obstructing moves toward universal suffrage proposed by the apostolic king
of Hungary and emperor of Austria, Charles I. During the war, Tisza was also
dogged by charges of forced Magyarization against Hungarys ethnic minorities. Ongoing conflict with King Charles forced Tiszas resignation as prime
minister on May 23, 1917.
A short time later, he visited the nearest battlefront and nearly lost his life,
when a disaffected soldier fired a rifle shot at him and missed. The third attempt on Tiszas life occurred on October 16, 1918, when Jnos Lkaia
member of the antiwar Galilei Circle led by communist Ott Korvinlay in
wait for Tisza outside parliament. Lkais revolver misfired and he was arrested,
sentenced to prison, then freed two weeks later during the Aster Revolution.
President Mihly Krolyis government pretended to investigate Tiszas assassination, but professed itself unable to identify the killers. Tiszas family encountered no such difficulty once the communist regime collapsed, naming
the men responsible as Sndor Httner, Pl Kri, Jzsef Pogny, Tivadar Horvth Sanovics, and Tibor Sztanykovszky. Sanovics fled the country after Tiszas
murder and was never apprehended. Httner, Kri, and Sztanykovszky were
convicted of murder at trial in October 1921, receiving 18-year prison terms.
Kri was subsequently freed in a prisoner exchange with the Soviet Union;
Httner died in custody, in 1923; and Sztanykovszky was paroled in 1938.
Jzsef Pogny enjoyed a life of intrigue and adventure after Tiszas assassination, emerging as a leader of the Budapest Soldiers Soviet. In March 1919,
he supported Bla Kuns rise to lead a new Hungarian Soviet Republic and was
named to serve as the Peoples Commissar of War. Internal dissension within
the Communist Party saw Pogny demoted in April 1919 to Deputy Peoples
Commissar of Foreign Affairs, then moved once more, to become Peoples
Commissar of Education. A proponent of Red Terror in Hungary, Pogny
fled to Austria when Admiral Mikls Horthy deposed the communist regime
and reestablished Hungarys monarchy in March 1920. A year later, he tried to
foment revolution in Germany, then traveled to the United States as an agent
563
564
TJ I BAO U, J E A N - M A R I E
Further Reading
Deak, Istvan. The Decline and Fall of Habsburg Hungary, 191418. In Hungary in
Revolution. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1971.
Kann, Robert. A History of the Habsburg Empire, 15261918. Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1974.
Menczer, Bela. Bela Kun and the Hungarian Revolution of 1919. History Today 19
(May 1969): 299309.
Vermes, Gabor. The October Revolution in Hungary. In Hungary in Revolution. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1971.
TJIBAOU, JEAN-MARIE
New Caledonian politician Jean-Marie Tjibaou, shot by tribal extremists in 1989. (AFP/
Getty Images)
Motivated by that experience, and his ongoing work with poor tribesmen,
Tjibaou left New Caledonia in 1968, to study sociology at the Catholic University of Lyon, then pursued courses in ethnology in 1970, under anthropologist
Jean Guiart at the Practical School of Higher Studies, also in Lyon. His father
died that year, while Tjibaou was writing his thesis on adaptation of traditional
Kanak society in the modern world, and Tjibaou subsequently renounced his
religious vocation, choosing social activism instead with the comment that it
is impossible for a priest in this area to take a position, for example in favor of
the restitution of land to the Kanak people.
In that same year, 1971, Tjibaou joined New Caledonias Territorial Administration as a teacher, there encountering his future wife, Marie-Claude Wetta.
Two years later, he also joined the Union of Native Caledonian Friends of
Liberty and Order, created by the Catholic Church in 1946 to eliminate discrimination against indigenous natives as a means of frustrating communist
agitation among them. In September 1975, Tjibaou organized the first Melanesian arts festival, dubbed Melanesia 2000, despite opposition from the Frenchdominated Caledonian Union and the newly created radical separatist Kanak
Liberation Party. Taking the final step from advocacy to political candidacy in
Mach 1977, Tjibaou won election as mayor of Hienghne, running a separatist
campaign under the slogan Maxha Hienghen (Raise Your Head). Two months
565
566
TJ I BAO U, J E A N - M A R I E
later, at the Caledonian Unions congress in Bourail, Tjibaou was elected as the
partys vice president.
In June 1979, on the eve of territorial elections, Tjibaou helped organize
a new Independence Front (FI), forging a tenuous alliance of five competing
nationalist groups. Together, they led the field with 63 percent of the popular
votes, winning five of seven available parliamentary seats. Three years later,
the FI coalition outnumbered opposition members in the Territorial Assembly,
with Tjibaou elected as vice president of New Caledonias Governing Council,
but the islands French masters still resisted any substantive move toward independence. In September 1984, with Tjibaous blessing, the FI transformed
itself into the more radical FLNKS.
Tjibaou still favored a peaceful road to independence, including a boycott
of territorial elections scheduled for November 1984, but others in the FLNKS
disagreed. A militant faction led by Yann Cln Uregei sought aid from Libyan
dictator Muammar Gaddafi. Violence erupted for the first time on December 5,
1984, when a party of Caldoches (New Caledonians of European ancestry) fired
on a party of Kanaks at Hienghne, killing 10 persons. Trial of the gunmen took
three years, resulting in acquittal by an all-white jury on October 27, 1987.
Before that case was concluded, FLNKS militants retaliated, killing young
Caldoche Yves Tual on January 11, 1985. That, in turn, sparked anti-independence
riots in Noumea, and French antiterrorist troops killed FLNKS member Eloi
Machoro near La Foa. Tjibaou still persisted in calls for nonviolence, petitioning the United Nations for help. In December 1986, three-fifths of the
UNs General Assembly supported a resolution affirming the inalienable right
of the people of New Caledonia to self-determination and independence,
adding New Caledonia to a list of nonautonomous territories deserving full
recognition.
Still, the UN took no further action and Kanak impatience simmered on
the island. On April 22, 1988, in the midst of a French presidential election,
FLNKS stormed a police station at Fayou, on the island of Ouvea, killing four
officers and taking 27 hostages. Elite troops were dispatched from France, and
after questioningsome say torturingrelatives of the hostage-takers, staged
a rescue attempt on May 5, killing 19 FLNKS members and losing two of their
own. Witnesses later claimed that some prisoners were either summarily executed after the assault.
A month later, Tjibaou proposed a referendum to decide the issue of independence, but no action had been taken at the time of his assassination. One
day after Tjibaou was killed, French prime minister Lionel Jospin signed the
Noumea Accord, providing for a referendum on the independence issue to
be held sometime between 2014 and 2019, while granting additional autonomy to the island. Under terms of the accord, if the president of New Caledonias Governing Council was a person who was opposed to independence from
T O L B E R T, W I L L I A M R I C H A R D , J R .
567
568
T O L B E R T, W I L L I A M R I C H A R D, J R .
Many world leaders viewed the peaceful transition of power with relief, failing to recognize Liberia as a de facto one-party state. Likewise, its
constitutionwritten with the U.S. model in mindfailed to prevent the
governments executive branch from dominating the legislative and judicial branches in a virtual dictatorship. President Tolbert did permit creation
of the countrys first opposition party since 1878, but he still won reelection easily in 1975, although his claims of liberal reform left indigenous
ethnic groups economically subjugated to a minority of Americo-Liberians.
Nepotism determined many of his cabinet appointments, and half-hearted
efforts to include indigenous people in the governing process evoked protests against radical change from Americo-Liberians. It came as a surprise
to some, therefore, when Tolbert promulgated a constitutional amendment
limiting himself and future presidents to eight years in office.
In foreign policy, Tolbert also reversed his predecessors stolid alliance with
the West. Although supporting the U.S. involvement in Vietnam, he paradoxically forged trade agreements with Cuba, the Peoples Republic of China, the
Soviet Union, and other Warsaw Pact nations. During the October 1973 Yom
Kippur War, Tolbert severed diplomatic relations with Israel and called for recognition of an Arab state in Palestine. That relatively independent status played
well in Africa at the time, as did Tolberts May 1975 signing of a treaty creating
the Economic Community of West African States. Such efforts led to Tolberts
election as chairman of the Organization of African Unity (OAU) in July 1979,
a post he held until he was assassinated nine months later.
Despite Tolberts best efforts, Liberias economy still suffered in the face of
depressed rubber prices worldwide. New problems arose in April 1979, when
Minister of Agriculture Florence Chenoweth proposed an increase in government subsidies to rice farmers. Critics quickly noted that the $4 increase
per 100 pounds of rice would personally enrich the Tolbert clanand
Chenowethvia their own huge rice farms. The Progressive Alliance of Liberia (PAL) scheduled peaceful protests in Monrovia for April 14, but the 2,000
party marchers found themselves outnumbered five to one by local hooligans,
resulting in a riot that left 40 persons dead, more than 500 injured, with property damage exceeding $40 million. Eleven months later, Tolbert banned the
PAL, arresting leader Gabriel Baccus Matthews and most of his fellow officers
on charges of treason. They would be liberated following the April coup, with
Matthews chosen to serve as foreign minister under President Samuel Doe.
Following Tolberts murder on April 12, 1980, most his cabinet members
were held for trial by a military court and sentenced to death; they were executed by a firing squad in Monrovia 10 days after the coup. One who survived
was Minister of Finance Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, who would be elected president
of Liberia in 2005, and again in 2011. In 2011, Sirleaf also received a Nobel
Peace Prizeshared with Leymah Gbowee of Liberia and Tawakkol Karman of
T O M B A L B AY E , F R A N O I S
Yemenfor their non-violent struggle for the safety of women and for womens rights to full participation in peace-building work.
See also: Doe, Samuel Kanyon (19511990).
Further Reading
Gray, Beverly. Liberia during the Tolbert Era: A Guide. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan
Library, 1983.
Hlophe, Stephen. Class Ethnicity and Politics in Liberia: A Class Analysis of Power Struggles in the Tubman and Tolbert Administrations From, 19441975. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1979.
Levitt, Jeremy. The Evolution of Deadly Conflict in Liberia: From Paternaltarianism to
State Collapse. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press, 2005.
Olukoju, Ayodeji. Culture and Customs of Liberia. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press,
2006.
Sankawulo, Wilton. Tolbert of Liberia. Denver: Ardon Press, 1979.
Williams, Gabriel. Liberia: The Heart of Darkness. Victoria, BC: Trafford, 2002.
569
570
T O M B A L B AY E , F R A N O I S
T O M B A L B AY E , F R A N O I S
571
572
T R O T S K Y, L E O N
Following the fatal coup of April 13, 1975, victorious rebels announced that
they had exercised their responsibilities before God and the nation. General
Malloum emerged from prison to lead a nine-man military junta on April 15,
jailing most of Tombalbayes men, dissolving all political parties and the National Assembly. Ironically, because Malloum was also a member of the Sara
ethnic group, his ascension changed little in terms of Tombalbayes governing policies. Discontent among Muslims continued, as did the FROLINAT
rebellion.
See also: Gaddafi, Muammar (19422011).
Further Reading
Azevedo, Mario. The Roots of Violence: A History of War in Chad. London: Routledge,
1998.
Burr, J. Millard, and Robert Collins. Africas Thirty Years War: Chad, Libya, and the
Sudan, 19631993. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1999.
Decalo, Samuel. Africa: The Lost Decades. Gainesville: Florida Academic Press, 2012.
Decalo, Samuel. Historical Dictionary of Chad. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press, 1997.
Powell, Nathaniel. The Claustre Affair: A Hostage Crisis, France, and Civil War in
Chad, 19741977. In An International History of Terrorism: Western and Non-Western
Experiences. London: Routledge, 2013.
Reyna, S. P. A Cold War Story: The Barbarization of Chad (196691). In The State,
Identity and Violence: Political Disintegration in the Post-Cold War World. London:
Routledge, 2003.
T R O T S K Y, L E O N
573
574
T R O T S K Y, L E O N
entire people. Arrested the following day, Trotsky was convicted in 1906 of
supporting armed rebellion, and was sentenced once again to Siberian exile.
This time, he escaped before reaching his destination, in January 1907, and
returned briefly to London before settling in Vienna, where he joined the Social Democratic Party of Austria and made occasional forays into neighboring
Germany. Between October 1908 and April 1912, with fellow revolutionaries, Trotsky published the newspaper Pravda (Truth), primarily for Russian
workers.
Tension between the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks escalated during the years
before World War I, as Lenins group participated in expropriationsarmed
robberiesto finance their cause. A unification meeting chaired by Trotsky
in January 1912 failed to bridge the divide, and Trotsky departed for the Balkans as a war correspondent nine months later. Back in Vienna by August
1914, when Austria-Hungary went to war with Russia, Trotsky fled to Switzerland, fearing arrest as an enemy alien. November found him in France as a
war correspondent for Nashe Slovo (Our Word), promoting the slogan peace
without indemnities or annexations, peace without conquerors or conquered.
Lenin, meanwhile, called for Russias defeat as a means of unseating the tsar.
French authorities deported Trotsky to Spain in March 1916, for his opposition to the war; Spain in turn deported him to the United States on Christmas Day. Arriving in New York City on January 13, 1917, Trotsky spent three
months writing for Novy Mir (New World) and Des Forverts (The Forward),
thereby missing the February Revolution that finally deposed Tsar Nicholas II.
Attempting to reach Russia in March, Trotsky was detained for a month in Canada, then released on April 29. June saw him elected to the first All-Russian
Central Executive Committee of the new Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic, but he was arrested in Petrograd (formerly Saint Petersburg) on August 7
and spent 40 days in jail after General Lavr Kornilov, commander in chief of
the Russian army, led an abortive rebellion against the Russian Provisional Government led by Alexander Kerensky. Kerensky, in turn, was unseated by Lenins Bolsheviks on November 7, with Trotsky ranked as second in command of
Russias latest revolution.
Lenin rewarded Trotskys service by appointing him as Peoples Commissar for Foreign Affairs, in which post Trotsky joined in peace negotiations at
Brest-Litovsk, marking Russias exit from the war in February 1918. Trotsky
then resigned his diplomatic post to serve as Peoples Commissar of Army and
Navy Affairs, commanding Russias new Red Army during the Russian Civil War
against the anticommunist White Guard led by Alexander Kolchak. Jealous
rival Josef Stalin rallied opposition against Trotskys leadership but failed to oust
him from command. Upon defeat of the White Guard, Trotsky received the
Order of the Red Banner, then moved on to rebuilding Russias war-ravaged
economy and railroad network. Once again, tension flared between Lenin and
T R O T S K Y, L E O N
Trotsky over Trotskys plan to create a new regime of militant trade unions, climaxed by victory for Lenins faction at the Tenth Party Congress in March 1921.
By then, however, Lenin was in poor health, plagued by a series of strokes
that sidelined him from May 1922 onward, finally killing him in January 1924.
Trotsky was expected to succeed him, but Stalin subverted his election by the
Politburo through political maneuvers and rumors that Trotsky suffered from
epilepsy. Publicly declaring that the Party is always right, Trotsky retreated
from active political life to focus on writing until 1926, when he joined in a
New Opposition to Stalins increasingly dictatorial rule. At the end of January
1928, Trotsky was exiled to Kazakhstan, then deported to Turkey in February
1929. France granted him asylum in 1933, then expelled him two years later,
whereupon Trotsky settled briefly in Norway, then moved on to Mexico City.
He might have survived in exile, but for his continued prolific writings, including a History of the Russian Revolution (1930) and a critique of Stalin titled
The Revolution Betrayed (1936). Of Stalins party purges in the Great Depression,
Trotsky said, The Moscow trials are perpetuated under the banner of socialism. We will not concede this banner to the masters of falsehood! . . . Neither
threats nor persecutions nor violations can stop us! Be it even over our bleaching
bones the future will triumph! We will blaze the trail for it. It will conquer! In
1939, Trotsky visited the United States as a witness before the Dies Committee, forerunner of the House Committee on Un-American Activities, describing
Soviet secret police harassment of his family and friends. The American Communist Party retaliated by branding him an agent of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and wealthy oil interests.
Trotskys long-distance criticism was more than Stalin could bear. In March
1939, Stalin reportedly gave orders that Trotsky should be eliminated within
a year. The first attempt missed that deadline, occurring on May 24, when
would-be assassins Iosif Grigulevich, David Alfaro Siqueiros, and Vittorio Vidale staged a raid on Trotskys home, shooting his grandson in the foot and
abducting a bodyguard, Robert Harte, whom they murdered. The second attempt, by Jaime Mercader del Ro three months later, proved successful.
Stalin was grateful, awarding Mercaders mother the Order of Lenin for her
part in the plot against Trotsky. Paroled from prison in May 1960, Mercader
was welcomed in Cuba by Fidel Castro, then moved to Russia in 1961, receiving the countrys highest decoration, Hero of the Soviet Union. He spent the
rest of his life traveling between Russia and Cuba. Mercader died in Havana on
October 18, 1978, and was buried at Moscows Kuntsevo Cemetery. He is honored by a plaque at the Museum of Security Services, on Moscows Lubyanka
Square. Trotskys former home in Coyoacn is today preserved as a museum.
Publication of his writings was forbidden in the Soviet Union until 1989. He
was formally rehabilitated by order of the Russian General Prosecutors Office
on June 16, 2001.
575
576
T R U J I L L O M O L I N A , R A FA E L L E O N I DA S
Further Reading
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Armed: Trotsky 18791921. London: Oxford University
Press, 1954.
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Outcast: Trotsky 19291940. London: Oxford University
Press, 1963.
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Unarmed: Trotsky 19211929. London: Oxford University
Press, 1959.
Patenaude, Bertrand. Downfall of a Revolutionary. New York City: HarperCollins, 2009.
Service, Robert. Trotsky: A Biography. New York: Macmillan, 2009.
Wistrich, Robert. Trotsky: Fate of a Revolutionary. New York: Stein & Day, 1982.
T R U J I L L O M O L I N A , R A FA E L L E O N I D A S
577
578
T R U J I L L O M O L I N A , R A FA E L L E O N I DA S
staged the Mirabal slaughter to resemble a traffic accident, such incidents severely strained the presidents relations with the United States and the Catholic
Church.
In terms of foreign policy, Trujillo supported Cuban dictator Fulgencio Batista in his futile war against rebels led by Fidel Castro, and pursued a relentless
campaign of Antihaitianismo against immigrants from Haiti (which occupies
the western part of the island formerly known as Hispaniola). Batista landed in
the Dominican Republic after Castro ousted him in January 1959, then found
himself a virtual prisoner of Trujillo until payment of some $3 million secured him passage to Portugal. Castro retaliated by landing several small raiding parties on the Dominican coast in June 1959, and Trujillo fumbled his own
attempt to infiltrate Cuba two months later.
Trujillos brutality and corruptioncontrolling at least 111 companies, collecting 2,000 suits and 10,000 neckties, cavorting with rotating shifts of very
young females who dubbed him el chivo (the goat)increasingly caused
U.S. diplomats to view him as a grave embarrassment. CIA involvement in Trujillos death remains a subject of debate, but three of the assassins rifles traced
back to the agency, and internal CIA memorandum submitted to the Office
of Inspector General, later declassified, conceded quite extensive Agency involvement with the plotters.
Even so, Trujillos slayers had their own motives. Aside from opposition to
his brutal style of governance, some of the reasons were personal. Antonio de
la Maza ran a sawmill owned by Trujillo near Restauracion until his brother,
Octavio, was framed as a scapegoat in the December 1956 murder of American
airline pilot Gerald Lester Murphy near Ciudad Trujillo. Octavio de la Maza allegedly hanged himself in jail on January 7, 1957, but analysts from the Federal Bureau of Investigation later declared his suicide note a forgery. Murphy,
they surmised, had flown kidnapped writer Jess Galndez Surez from New
York to the Dominican Republic in November 1956, then was killed to ensure
his silence.
Conspirator Amado Garca Guerrero harbored an equally personal grudge
against Trujillo, who had forbidden him to marry the woman he lovedsister
of a dangerous communist rebelwhile Garca served Trujillo as a military
aide. Going further still, Trujillo ordered Garca to personally execute a prisoner held in army custody, later identified as Ren Gil, his fiances rebellious
brother. His life thus blighted, Garca took a vow with like-minded friends to
eliminate Trujillo.
One of the surviving plotters, Antonio Imbert Barrera, hated Trujillo for removing him as governor of Puerto Plata in 1940. Nursing that grudge for two
decades, he joined in the plot to kill Trujillo and managed to escape the ensuing manhunt, later earning recognition as a National Hero. In the subsequent
Dominican Civil War of 1965, Imbert led one faction battling the regime of
T R U J I L L O M O L I N A , R A FA E L L E O N I D A S
PARSLEY MASSACRE
On October 2, 1937, President Rafael Trujillo ordered the eradication of
Haitian immigrants living in districts of the Dominican Republic that bordered Haiti. To explain the order, Trujillo said, I have traveled and traversed the border in every sense of the word. I have seen, investigated,
and inquired about the needs of the population. To the Dominicans who
were complaining of the depredations by Haitians living among them,
thefts of cattle, provisions, fruits, etc., and were thus prevented from enjoying in peace the products of their labor, I have responded, I will fix
this. The fix was mass execution of at least 20,000 persons, with some
estimates placing the total at 30,000. The five-day slaughter earned its
nickname from sprigs of parsley carried by the murder teams. Suspected
Haitians were required to pronounce its Spanish name (perejil), then executed if their accents indicated they spoke French or Haitian Creole.
Trujillo tried to blame the murders on Dominican civilians, but U.S. observers reported that most victims were shot with Krag-Jrgensen rifles
carried exclusively by soldiers of the Dominican army. Trujillo later paid
$525,000 in reparations to Haiti$30 per victim, of which the corrupt
Haitian government kept $29.70.
Colonel Francisco Alberto Caamao De, with U.S. support. Caamao was
defeated in his effort to restore ex-president Juan Bosch Gavio, and the presidency passed instead to Joaqun Balaguer. Presumed Trujillo loyalists shot Imbert in an ambush in Santo Domingo, on March 21, 1967, but he survived the
attack and drove himself to a hospital.
Further Reading
Crassweller, Robert. Trujillo: The Life and Times of a Caribbean Dictator. New York: Macmillan, 1966.
Derby, Lauren. The Dictator s Seduction: Politics and the Popular Imagination in the Era of
Trujillo. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2009.
Diederich, Bernard. Trujillo: The Death of the Dictator. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener
Publishers, 2000.
Interview with General Rafael Trujillo (1961). National Archives. http://archive.org/
details/gov.archives.arc.647563.
Lpez-Calvo, Ignacio. God and Trujillo: Literary and Cultural Representations of the
Dominican Dictator. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2005.
Roorda, Eric. The Dictator Next Door: The Good Neighbor Policy and the Trujillo Regime
in the Dominican Republic, 19301945. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1998.
579
580
Turits, Richard. Foundations of Despotism: Peasants, the Trujillo Regime, and Modernity in
Dominican History. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2004.
Wiarda, Howard. Dictatorship and Development: The Methods of Control in Trujillos
Dominican Republic. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 1968.
Harry S. Truman survived two assassination attempts during his first term in office.
(Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division)
TRUMAN, HARRY S.
581
582
TRUMAN, HARRY S.
his welcome with Democratic Party leaders as the 1944 presidential election
approached. Seeking his third vice president since 1933, President Franklin
Roosevelt preferred Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas, but state and
local leaders weighed in for Truman and Roosevelt agreed, in what some called
the Second Missouri Compromise. Their ticket won easily, and Truman was
sworn in as vice president in January 1945.
The first weeks of his term were uneventfulin fact, he was virtually ignored,
not even informed of Americas race to build an atomic bombbut Roosevelts
death on April 12 changed all that. After 82 days in office, he was suddenly
commander in chief of a nation at war worldwide, with the Manhattan Project
nearing completion. Soon after taking the oath as president, Truman told reporters, Boys, if you ever pray, pray for me now. I dont know if you fellas ever
had a load of hay fall on you, but when they told me what happened yesterday,
I felt like the moon, the stars, and all the planets had fallen on me.
He had been dropped into a maelstrom: Germanys surrender, the Potsdam
Conference with Winston Churchill and Josef Stalin, the decision to use atomic
bombs against the Japs he had hated from his youth. Debate still rages over
his employment of nuclear weapons against Japan, with some historians insisting that Truman saved at least 250,000 U.S. lives, and others brand the bombings an immoral racist act. Truman himself would later write, I knew what
I was doing when I stopped the war. . . . I have no regrets and, under the same
circumstances, I would do it again.
Wars end confronted Truman with a host of new problems: labor upheavals, a new postwar Red Scare with critics who branded him soft on communism, exposure of corruption among his closest aides, threats of Red
revolution in Europe and Asia. Seeking reelection to the White House in 1948,
he found the Democratic Party split three ways, as the left followed Henry Wallace into a new Progressive Party, and Southern racists defected to Strom Thurmans Dixiecrat movement. Pundits predicted Trumans defeat by Republican
contender Thomas Deweyand the Chicago Tribune famously printed electioneve headlines reading Dewey Defeats Trumanbut he stunned detractors
with a surprise victory, establishing a Democratic Partys majority that endured
for another two decades.
Trumans second term produced more crises. Aside from the Puerto Rican
attempt on his life, he promoted the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, confronted the Korean War and rebellious General Douglas MacArthur, fended
off attacks Senator Joseph McCarthy and other congressional Red hunters, endured criticism of losing China to Mao Zedongs communists, and haphazardly defended basic civil rights for African Americans, and still found time
to threaten music critic Paul Hume for criticizing daughter Margaret Trumans
concert style: Some day I hope to meet you. When that happens youll need
a new nose, a lot of beefsteak for black eyes, and perhaps a supporter below!
583
584
U
B (586/590644)
UMAR IBN AL-KHATTA
In October 644, Umar ibn Al-Khattabthe second caliph of Sunni Islam
received a visit from Pirouz Nahavandi, a Persian soldier captured and enslaved
eight years earlier, now employed as a carpenter at Medina, in the Kingdom
of Saudi Arabia. Nahavandi, also known as Abu Lulu, complained to Umar of
the wages held back from him by his master, Mughira ibn Shuba. Umar rejected Nahavandis plea for intervention, leaving the supplicant embittered. On
November 3, as Umar led morning prayers at his mosque, Nahavandi sprang
from hiding, stabbing the caliph five times with a dagger. Fleeing the scene,
Nahavandi stabbed another dozen people who tried to subdue him, fatally
wounding six (or nine, in some accounts), then killed himself when cornered
by Umars bodyguards. Umar survived until November 7, issuing various religious pronouncements before he succumbed to his wounds.
Umar ibn Al-Khattab was born in Mecca, a member of the Banu Adi clan
from the Quraish tribe that sometimes served as arbiters of disputes between
other rival tribes. His birth date is uncertain, placed sometime between 586
and 590 CE by different historians. Various accounts describe Umars father,
Khattab ibn Nufayl, as a middle-class merchant of exceptional intelligence, and
as an abusive father. Umar himself later wrote of frequent beatings and being
worked to the point of exhaustion. On the other hand, he was taught to read
and write in a society where few were literate, developing a passion for literature and poetry that rivaled his skill in the manly arts of horseback riding and
combat. He followed in his fathers footsteps as a merchant, traveling as far as
Rome in pursuit of commerce.
Umar and his father were contemporaries of Muhammad, the founder of
Islam, but Khattab ibn Nufayl despised the new religion and Umar initially
joined Khattab in persecuting Muslims. Umar reportedly hatched a plot to kill
Muhammad, but Muhammad foiled the conspiracy by ordering his hundredodd disciples to migrate southward, finding sanctuary in the kingdom of
Aksum (now Eritrea and northern Ethiopia) in 615. Muslim historian Ibn
Ishaq (704770) described Umar following the fugitives, intent on killing Muhammad, but a chance encounter with a friend along the way brought news
that Umars sister and her husband, Saeed bin Zaid, had converted to Islam and
joined the migration. After a tense meeting with the couple, Umar accepted the
586
B
U M A R I B N A L- K H AT TA
new faith in 616 and began to preach its tenets around Mecca, in defiance of
his hostile tribal chief, Amr ibn Hisham.
Umars conversion is regarded in Islamic history as a crucial breakthrough
for the young religion. In 622, on orders from Muhammad, he led a migration
of Muslims to Medina, soon recognized as the capital of Islam. Other members
of Umars Quraish tribe still remained hostile to the point of homicide, and
Umar fought against them repeatedly, in the Battle of Badr (March 13, 624),
the Battle of Uhud (March 9, 625), the Battle of the Trench (April 627), and
forged a 10-year truce in March 628, with the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah. In the
midst of those conflicts that spread Islam throughout Arabia, Umars widowed
20-year-old daughter, Hafsah, became the fourth of Muhammads 13 wives.
Meanwhile, the Quraish were not alone in opposing Islams advance. In 629,
he joined in a campaign against Jews inhabiting the Khaybar Oasis, 95 miles
north of Medina, who agitated other Arab tribes against Islam. Once again,
Muhammads forces were victorious, moving on to the conquest of Mecca in
December 629. That proved to be a nearly bloodless victory, with 12 Quraish
slain, against two Muslim fatalities. The following year, Umar fought Bedouins
at the Battle of Hunayn, clashed with soldiers of the Byzantine Empire in the
Battle of Tabouk, and participated in the unsuccessful Siege of Taif.
Muhammads death in June 632 left Umar grieving and dismayed that the
Messenger of God was actually mortal. To preserve and further spread the
faith, he joined in founding the Rashidun (Rightly Guided) Caliphate, with
Abu BakrMuhammads senior companion and, like Umar, his father-inlawchosen as the first caliph (Muslim chief of state). A rift at once developed, as some Muslims claimed Muhammads cousin/son-in-law, Ali ibn Abi
Talib, had been hand-picked to succeed the Prophet, but Abu Bakr prevailed,
with Umar designated as his chief secretary and advisor. During the Ridda wars
of 632633, also known as the Wars of Apostasy, Umar advised Abu Bakr on
his campaigns against rival prophets Tulayha ibn Khuwaylid (defeated at the
Battle of Buzakha, in September 632), Musaylimah (killed at the Battle of Yamamah, in December 632), and Sajah (who returned to mainstream Islam after
Musaylimahs defeat).
At Abu Bakrs death, in August 634, Umar succeeded him as Islams second
caliph. A final self-styled prophet, Tulayha ibn Khuwaylid, returned to the fold
out of personal loyalty to Umar, and went on to fight for the cause against Persias Sassanid Empire, including the Battle of al-Qadisiyyah (November 636),
the Battle of Jalula (April 637), and the Battle of Nahavand (in 642). Known
during his tenure as Farooq the Greatfrom Al-Farooq, one who distinguishes
right from wrongUmar expanded the Islamic realm to encompass all of Persias Sassanid Empire and some two-thirds of the Byzantine Empire. At the
same time, despite his earlier conflicts with Jews, he lifted the ban formerly imposed by Christians that prevented Jews from entering Jerusalem.
B
U M A R I B N A L - K H AT TA
587
588
UMBERTO I
Majdalawi, Farouk. Islamic Administration Under Omar Ibn Al-Khattab. Syracuse, NY:
Syracuse University Press, 2003.
Numani, Shibli. Umar: Makers of Islamic Civilization. London: I.B. Tauris, 2004.
Sallabi, Ali. Umar bin Al-Khattab: His Life and Times. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: International Islamic Publishing House, 2007.
UMBERTO I (18441900)
On July 29, 1900, King Umberto I of Italy visited Monza, nine miles northeast
of Milan in Lombardy, to present medals to the winners of a local athletic competition. The ceremony was completed, and Umberto had returned to his open
coach when Gaetano Bresci, a 30-year-old Italian-American anarchist, fired four
shots from a revolver, striking the king three times in his chest. Umberto died
at the scene, and Bresci was disarmed and arrested while shouting, I have not
shot Umberto. I have killed the king, I have killed a principle! At trial, in late
August, Bresci said he killed
Umberto to avenge the deaths
of striking workers slain by soldiers in Milan, during the BavaBeccaris massacre of May 1898.
Sentenced to life imprisonment,
Bresci was the first European
regicide to escape execution.
Italy had abolished capital punishment in 1889, but it hardly
mattered. On May 22, 1901,
Bresci was found dead in his
prison cell under circumstances
still unclear.
Future king Umberto Ranieri Carlo Emanuele Giovanni
Maria Ferdinando Eugenio di
Savoia was born in Turin, then
the capital of the kingdom of
Sardinia, on March 14, 1844. At
the time, his fatherVictor Emmanuel IIwas the king of Sardina, married to Archduchess
Adelaide of Austria. As a child,
Umberto was educated by tuKing Umberto I of Italy, slain by an anarchist gun- tors, including lawyerjournalist
man in 1900. (Mondadori via Getty Images)
Pasquale Stanislao Mancini and
UMBERTO I
589
590
UMBERTO I
U W I L I N G I Y I M A N A , A G AT H E
Further Reading
Bencivenni, Marcela. Italian Immigrant Radical Culture: The Idealism of the Sovversivi in
the United States, 18901940. New York: New York University Press, 2011.
Cannistraro, Philip, and Gerald Meyer, eds. The Lost World of Italian-American Radicalism: Politics, Labor, and Culture. Westport, CT: Praeger, 2003.
Ciancabilla, Giuesppe. Fired by the Ideal: Italian-American Anarchist Responses to Czolgoszs Killing of McKinley. London: Kate Sharpley Library, 2002.
Duggan, Christopher. The Force of Destiny: A History of Italy Since 1796. London: Allen
Lane, 2007.
Khuri-Makdisi, Ilham. The Eastern Mediterranean and the Making of Global Radicalism,
18601914. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2010.
Levy, Carl. The Anarchist Assassin and Italian History, 1870s to 1930s. In Assassinations and Murder in Modern Italy: Transformations in Society and Culture. New York:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2007.
591
592
U W I L I N G I Y I M A N A , AGAT H E
Uwilingiyimana graduated from Notre Dame des Citeaux High School, and
in 1973 received her certificate to teach humanities. Three years later, after
graduate studies in mathematics and chemistry, she was hired as a mathematics
teacher in in Butare. That same year, she married former high school classmate
Ignace Barahira, keeping her maiden name, and in 1977 bore the first of their
five children.
Their growing family prospered through education. By 1983, Uwilingiyimana was teaching chemistry at Butares National University of Rwanda,
and Ignace held a lucrative post at the universitys laboratory. Two years later,
Uwilingiyimana completed studies for her BSc and spent the next four years
teaching chemistry at various schools in Butare Province. Although some traditionalists criticized her, both for studying science and sharing her knowledge
with female students, Uwilingiyimana persevered and broadened her activities
to include support for fellow teachers, creating a Sorority and Credit Cooperative Society for school staffers in Butare. In 1989, official recognition of her
efforts led to Uwilingiyimanas appointment as minister of commerce under
President Habyarimana.
Six years later, after opposition parties were legitimized, Uwilingiyimana
left President Habyarimanas National Republican Movement for Democracy
and Development to join the Republican and Democratic Movement (MDR).
That partys leader, Dismas Nsengiyaremye, was elected as prime minister
in April 1992 and named Uwilingiyimana to serve as his minister of education. Although a member of the dominant Hutu ethnic group, Uwilingiyimana
abolished Rwandas academic ethnic quota system that gave Hutus an edge
on higher education, instead using a merit system for awarding public school
placement and scholarships. That move, coming as it did in the midst of Rwandas civil war between Hutus and Tutsis, marked Uwilingiyimana as a target for
extremists within her own tribe.
Even as war divided the nation, so politics created turmoil in the capital,
with five opposition parties challenging President Habyarimana. After a contentious meeting between rival party leaders, Uwilingiyimana was chosen
as Rwandas next prime minister on July 17, 1993. Dismas Nsengiyaremye,
disgruntled at being replaced, immediately suspended Uwilingiyimana membership in the MDR. Just over two weeks later, on August 4, Habyarimana
and Uwilingiyimana reached a tentative agreement with their enemies from
the Tutsi-dominated Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), signing the Arusha Accords at a meeting in Tanzania. Under that agreement, a new government
would be formed, with Habyarimana holding the transitional presidency and
five of 21 cabinet posts, the MDR would hold four posts and name the prime
minister, and three other parties would divide the remaining cabinet seats.
The Arusha Accords posed a problem for Prime Minister Uwilingiyimana, due to her suspension from the MDR. Party leaders named Faustin
U W I L I N G I Y I M A N A , A G AT H E
RWANDAN GENOCIDE
Over the course of roughly 100 days, between April and July 1994, more
than 500,000 peoplemostly members of the Tutsi ethnic groupwere
slaughtered by Hutu enemies in Rwanda. Some estimates double that
death toll, accounting for 20 percent of the African countrys population.
Rwandas Hutu majority harbored centuries of animosity against their former rulers from the Tutsi minority, exacerbated by the Rwandan Patriotic
Fronts 1990 invasion from Uganda and the resulting civil war. The assassinations of April 6, 1994, sparked a furious homicidal reaction in the name
of Hutu Power, carried out in well-organized fashion by the Rwandan
military and mobs of sympathetic civilians. Machetesincluding 581,000
imported from Chinawere often employed as cheaper methods of killing than firearms. An International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, established in November 1994, heard testimony from Rwandan prime minister
Jean Kambanda that mass murder of Tutsis was openly discussed in cabinet meetings, then carried out by high-ranking army officers. Scheduled to
complete its work in December 2014, the tribunal had 50 trials and convicted 29 defendants as this volume went to press, with 11 more trials in
progress, 14 defendants awaiting trial, and 13 others still at large.
593
594
U W I L I N G I Y I M A N A , AGAT H E
Further Reading
Bartrop, Paul. A Biographical Encyclopedia of Contemporary Genocide: Portraits of Evil and
Good. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2010.
Hill, Kevin. Agathe Uwilingiyimana. In Women and the Law: A Bio-Bibliographical
Sourcebook. Edited by Kevin Hill. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1996.
Melvern, Linda. A People Betrayed: The Role of the West in Rwandas Genocide. London:
Zed Books, 2000.
Nyankanzi, Edward. Genocide: Rwanda and Burundi. Rochester, VT: Schenkman Books,
1998.
Prunier, Grard. The Rwanda Crisis: History of a Genocide. New York: Columbia University Press, 1995.
Scherrer, Christian. Genocide and Crisis in Central Africa: Conflict Roots, Mass Violence,
and Regional War. Westport, CT: Praeger, 2002.
V
VALKO, ERNEST (19532010)
On November 8, 2010, visitors found prominent Slovak attorney Ernest Valko,
former chief of the Czechoslovak Constitutional Court, shot to death at his
home in Limbach, near Bratislava, capital of the Slovak Republic. The motive
for his murder is unknown. As this work went to press, the crime remained officially unsolved, still under active investigation by agents of Zsahov skupina
radu boja proti organizovanej kriminalite Prezdia Policajnho zboru (the Engagement Group of the Office for Combating Organized Crime of the Presidium of
the Police Force).
Ernest Valko was born on August 10, 1953, at Spisk Nov Ves, in the
Koice region of Czechoslovakia. He enrolled at Bratislavas Comenius University in 1973, receiving his MA from that institutions faculty of law in 1977.
Two years later, Valko received his doctoral degree in law from Comenius, then
entered private practice in Bratislava.
By then, he had already witnessed momentous events, beginning with Alexander Dubceks attempt to reform the nations communist government in the
Prague Spring of 1968, crushed by a Soviet invasion that August which left
Czechoslovakia occupied by Russian troops until the so-called Velvet Revolution of November 16 to December 10, 1989. On the last day of that bloodless
rebellion, President Gustv Husk swore in the first government since 1948
not dominated by the Communist Party. By December 29, dissident poet and
playwright Vclav Havel had been installed as president of the new republic,
his government legitimized by free elections in June 1990. Running unopposed for a second term in July 1992, Havel was defeated by lack of support
from Slovak delegates in the Federal Parliament. On January 1, 1993, Czechoslovakia peacefully dissolved in a Velvet Divorce, with Havel chosen as president of the new Czech Republic, and voters in the Slovak Republic elected
President Michal Kovc.
Ernest Valko continued his practice of law while the face of his homeland
evolved, rising to become one of the countrys best-known attorneys. He also
tried his hand at politics, winning election to the Federal Assembly in 1990,
where he was instrumental in revising national laws related to labor, trade, civil
liberties, and the conduct of referendums. He served as Speaker for the lower
house of parliament in 19901991, and was chairman of the Constitutional
596
VA L K O , E R N E S T
VA N C E , R O B E R T S M I T H
Slovak Electric Power (20032010). Somewhere within Valkos public or private connections, presumably, lay the roots of his murder.
Investigators noted that in November 2006, police charged Valko and financier Ladislav Rehk with attempting to extort $2 million from owners of the
firm Ravi Slovakia, a manufacturer of doors and windows in Zhorie, claiming
that Rehk had been cheated on a business deal. Those charges were dropped
blamed Valkos death on an
without trial, in 2008. The newspaper Nov Cas
unnamed crime syndicate in Bratislava, and other theories involved the Tipos
lawsuit and the similar slaying of Valko client Jn Duck in 1999 (gunned
down in the lobby of his apartment house). In that case, police charged Ukrainian suspect Oleg T., said to reside and work for underworld boss Ivan Miskov, but the charge was dismissed in in 2000. Bratislava police officially closed
that case, leaving it unsolved, in July 2007.
Another Slovakian newspaper, the tabloid SME, raised alternative theories
for Valkos murder. One was a straightforward robbery gone wrong, based
on prior burglaries at his home. Another suggestion involved a case in which
Valko represented Tobi Loyka, owner of a lucrative peat bog operation, in a
lawsuit filed against Slovak Information Service (SIS) agents Michal Hrbcek
and Martin Lieskovsk. The SIS is a Slovakian intelligence agency, established
in January 1993 as a descendant of Czechoslovakias defunct Federal Security Information Service. In 1995, its agents kidnapped and lightly tortured
the son of President Michal Kovc, then allegedly killed prosecution witness
Rbert Remi, a Bratislava policeman, in April 1996.
Further Reading
Leff, Carol. The Czech and Slovak Republics: Nation versus State. Boulder, CO: Westview
Press, 1996.
Schwartz, Herman. The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000.
Shepherd, Robin. Czechoslovakia: The Velvet Revolution and Beyond. New York: St. Martins Press, 2000.
Wheaton, Bernard, and Zdene k Kavan. The Velvet Revolution: Czechoslovakia,
19881991. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1992.
Whipple, Tim. After the Velvet Revolution: Vaclav Havel and the New Leaders of Czechoslovakia Speak Out. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1991.
597
598
VA N C E , R O B E R T S M I T H
VA N C E , R O B E R T S M I T H
While denying that OFerrell was their chief suspect, agents noted that he
had filed a lawsuit against his former employer, the Gulf Life Insurance Company of Jacksonville, and Judge Vance had dismissed OFerrells claim.
While OFerrell was still under scrutiny, the case moved in yet another direction. An agent of the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, who
had defused the recent Atlanta bomb, told investigators that its construction
reminded him of another incident dating from 1972. In that case, Georgia resident Walter Leroy Moody Jr. had been arrested after a homemade bomb exploded in his house, injuring his wife. Moody had received a four-year prison
term in that case, which prosecutors linked to an abortive extortion scheme,
subsequently filing an unsuccessful motion with the Eleventh Circuit Court
to have his criminal record expunged. Judge Vance was not a member of the
panel that rejected Moodys plea, but federal prosecutors still cited revenge as
his motive, claiming that the three subsequent bombings were red herrings
designed to focus attention on Southern racists.
Arrested on July 11, 1990, Moody faced a slate of federal charges that included 72 felony counts by January 1991. Defense attorneys obtained an order
recusing all federal judges within the Eleventh Circuit, whereupon Moodys
trial was moved to St. Paul, Minnesota, in June 1991. In that proceeding,
Moody took the stand against advice from his lawyers, denying any role in the
bombing and suggesting that the mail bombs could have been sent by members of the Ku Klux Klan. Jurors rejected that notion, convicting Moody on 71
of the counts filed against him, on June 28. Two months later, on August 21,
Judge Edward J. Devitt imposed a sentence of seven life terms plus 400 years
without possibility of parole. Triumphant prosecutor Louis Freeh was subsequently named director of the FBI, filling that post in September 1993.
Walter Moodys legal troubles were not all behind him, meanwhile. Indicted
by Alabama state authorities for Judge Vances murder, he was convicted once
again, and received a death sentence on February 10, 1997. Alabamas Supreme Court rejected Moodys appeal of that sentence on May 18, 2012. At this
writing, he remains on death row at the Holman Correctional Facility, outside
Atmore, Alabama. Some observers, however, still question his guilt in the 1989
bombings.
A year after Moodys state murder conviction, scandal engulfed the FBI
Laboratory in Washington, D.C. Dr. Frederic Whitehurst, a chemist and Supervisory Special Agent at the lab from 1986 to 1998, emerged in 1999 as a
whistleblower detailing perceived mishandling of evidence and violations of
established FBI investigative procedures in many notorious cases, including
VANPAC and the 1995 bombing of Oklahoma Citys Alfred P. Murrah Federal
Building. In Moodys case, Whitehurst alleged that agents J. Thomas Thurman
of the Explosives Unit and Roger Martz of the Chemistry-Toxicology Unit circumvented standard procedures, specifically bypassing mandatory analysis of
599
600
V E R W O E R D, H E N D R I K F R E N S C H
explosives residue by the labs Materials Analysis Unit. He further charged that
Martz reached a flawed opinion in concluding that the mail bombs contained
a particular smokeless powder, traced to Moody; that Thurman improperly
based his opinions on the flawed residue analysis performed by Martz; that
Thurman improperly testified outside his field of expertise on various matters;
and that Thurman lacked a factual basis for certain testimony about the explosives used in the bombs. Whitehurst also accused Thurman and Martz of fabricating evidence, perjuring themselves, and obstructing justice in the VANPAC
case, while suggesting that prosecutors Freeh and Howard Shapiro may have
committed misconduct by offering testimony from Martz and Thurman.
An investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector
General subsequently dismissed all of Whitehursts claims against the FBI Laboratory, as well as Thurman, Martz, Freeh, and Shapiro, but conspiracy theorists persist in suggesting that Moody may be an innocent patsy. Supporting
that case, they point to a mail-bombing that wounded Maryland judge John P.
Corderman on December 22, 1989, later deemed dissimilar from the explosive parcels in the VANPAC case. Supporters of Moodys innocence contend
that both judges were targeted for their involvement in federal narcotics cases.
Meanwhile, Robert OFerrell sued the FBI, seeking $50 million for damage to
his reputation from their abortive investigation of him, but U.S. District Judge
Harold Albritton of Birmingham dismissed that claim in November 1998.
See also: Ku Klux Klan (1866 ); Wallace, George Corley, Jr. (19191998)Attempted.
Further Reading
A Byte Out of History: The Mail Bomb Murders. Federal Bureau of Investigation.
http://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2006/december/vanpac_122606.
Jenkins, Ray. Blind Vengeance: The Roy Moody Mail Bomb Murders. Athens: University of
Georgia Press, 1997.
Kelly, John, and Phillip Weaver. Tainting Evidence: Inside the Scandals at the FBI Crime
Lab. New York: The Free Press, 2002.
Winne, Mark. Priority Mail. New York: Scribner, 1995.
Schuur Hospital. In custody, Tsafendas told police that he killed Verwoerd because he was so disgusted with the racial policy of apartheid that Verwoerd
and other South African leaders had crafted since 1948. He also claimed that a
giant tapeworm inside his body regularly spoke to him. At trial, Judge Andries
Beyers declared Tsafendas not guilty of murder by reason of insanity. Diagnosed
as schizophrenic, Tsafendas spent the remainder of his life in various prisons
and psychiatric hospitals, dying in October 1999, at age 81.
Hendrik Verwoerd was born in Amsterdam on September 8, 1901, the son
of a Dutch merchant who favored the Afrikaner side in the Second Boer War
(18991902). In 1913, Verwoerds family emigrated to Bulawayo, Southern
Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe), where his father served as an evangelist for the
Dutch Reformed Church. Verwoerd attended Milton High School and received a Beit Trust Scholarship, but had to decline it when his father moved
the clan again, this time to Brandfort in South Africas Orange Free State. He
subsequently enrolled at Stellenbosch University, with a theology major, then
switched to psychology, receiving both a masters and a doctorate cum laude. He
declined an Abe Bailey scholarship to Oxford University, preferring study in
Germany during 19251927, when Adolf Hitlers Nazi Party was on the rise.
That movements influence on Verwoerds racial attitudes remains a subject of
speculation by South African historians today.
Back in South Africa by
1928, Verwoerd was appointed
to chair the Department of Applied Psychology at his alma
mater, Stellenbosch University,
advancing professor of sociology and social work in 1934.
Two years later, he led a deputation of six professors opposing
admission of German-Jewish
refugees from Nazism to South
Africa. By 1937, Verwoerd
was an active member of the
far-right National Party in the
Transvaal and editor of its racist newspaper, Die Transvaler. A
Supreme Court judgment subsequently found as fact that
Die Transvaler, with Verwoerds
knowledge and collaboration, An opponent of apartheid assassinated South Afoperated as an organ of the Ger- rican prime minister Hendrik Verwoerd. (Getty
man Nazi Party in South Africa. Images)
601
602
V E R W O E R D, H E N D R I K F R E N S C H
Whereas Hitlers Third Reich lay in ruins after World War II, the National
Party grew stronger under Verwoerds leadership, sweeping to power in the
South African general election of May 1948. Its platform hinged on apartheid
(the status of being apart)that is, white minority rule over a strictly segregated society. Step one was passage of the 1949 Prohibition of Mixed Marriages
Act. A year later, with Verwoerds appointment as minister of native affairs
under Prime Minister Daniel Malan, more restrictive legislation followed. In
1950, came the Immorality Amendment Act (banning interracial adultery and
extramarital sex), the Population Registration Act (creating a national registry
of every citizens race), the Group Areas Act (imposing residential segregation),
and the Suppression of Communism Act (banning the Communist Party and
any form of radical change). In 1951, legislators passed the Bantu Building Workers Act (banning black artisans from work in white urban areas), the
Separate Representation of Voters Act (removing coloreds from the common
voters roll), the Prevention of Illegal Squatting Act (moving blacks from public lands to resettlement camps), and the Bantu Authorities Act (establishing
black homelands with illusory self-government).
The onslaught of racist legislation continued throughout Verwoerds tenure as minister of native affairs and accelerated in September 1958, when he
succeeded Johannes Strijdom as South Africas prime minister. By early 1960,
apartheid had been formally condemned by British prime minister Harold
Macmillan. On March 21 of that year, black protests against discrimination and
police brutality culminated in the Sharpeville massacre (see sidebar). Less than
three weeks later, Verwoerd survived his first assassination attempt.
That attack came on April 9, 1960, when Verwoerd opened the Union Exposition on the Witwatersrand, a large sedimentary range of rocky hills that
forms a continental divide in South Africa. David Pratt, a farmer from Natal,
fired two shots at Verwoerd from a .22-caliber pistol, at point-blank range,
striking the prime minister in his right cheek and right ear. Surgeons at Pretoria Hospital called Verwoerds survival absolutely miraculous, resulting from
Pratts selection of a small-caliber weapon. Disarmed and arrested at the scene,
Pratt faced trial in Johannesburg Magistrates Court on April 11, where he was
judged to be mentally disordered and epileptic. Sentenced to indefinite detention pending indication of the Governor Generals pleasure, Pratt hanged
himself at Bloemfontein Mental Hospital on October 1, 1961.
Seemingly unfazed by his near miss with death, Verwoerd pressed on with
ever-tightening restrictions on South Africas racially divided society. United
Nations Secretary General Dag Hammarskjld failed to negotiate more liberal
terms with Verwoerd in 1961, and the UN General Assembly passed Resolution 1761 on November 6, 1962, formally condemning apartheid and asking
all UN member states to sever diplomatic relations with Pretoria. A second UN
resolution, passed on August 7, 1963, called for a voluntary international arms
SHARPEVILLE MASSACRE
On March 21, 1960, an estimated 19,000 black residents of Sharpeville,
in the Transvaal, rallied at a local police station to protest laws requiring
colored citizens to carry special pass books whenever they ventured
outside of segregated black homelands. The demonstrators left their
pass books at home, offering themselves for mass arrest to highlight the
laws inequity. When overflights by jet fighters failed to discourage the
crowd, 150 police officers supported by armored vehicles opened fire on
the protesters with rifles and automatic weapons, killing at least 69 persons and wounding 180 more. Those gunned downmany shot in the
back as they fledincluded 39 women and 29 children. Police subsequently blamed the shooting on panic among young and inexperienced
officers, but testimony offered before South Africas Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1998 suggested a degree of deliberation in the
decision to open fire. The massacre sparked international outrage and
prompted the African National Congress to organize a paramilitary wing,
Umkhonto we Sizwe (Spear of the Nation), to carry out guerrilla actions
against the white-supremacist state.
embargo against South Africa. A year later, the United States and Britain suspended arms sales to Verwoerds racist state.
Despite international condemnation, the National Party remained in control
of South Africa, winning the 1966 general elections. Throughout the 1960s,
South Africa developed its own militaryindustrial complex, producing military hardware ranging from small arms to nuclear and biological weapons.
Even after Verwoerds murder, the National Party would remain intransigent,
defending apartheid by any and all means available until 1994.
Some 250,000 white mourners attended Verwoerds funeral, at the Heros
Acre in Pretoria. Countless public facilities, roads, and other locations were
named in his honor, though most have been renamed since 1994. Pretorias
H. F. Verwoerd Hospital, as an example, today bears the name of martyred
black activist Steve Biko. The last vestige of Verwoerds regimethe bloodstained carpet where his body lay in parliament after his stabbingwas finally
removed in 2004.
Further Reading
Ainslie, Rosalynde. The Unholy Alliance: Salazar, Verwoerd, Welensky. London: M. W.
Books, 1962.
Attempted Assassination of Dr. Verwoerd 1960. British Path. http://www.britishpathe
.com/video/attempted-assassination-of-dr-verwoerd.
603
604
Bunting, Brian. The Rise of the South African Reich. New York: Penguin African Library,
1969.
Hepple, Alexander. Verwoerd. New York: Pelican/Penguin Books, 1967.
Kenny, Henry. Architect of Apartheid: H. F. Verwoerd, an Appraisal. London: J. Ball, 1980.
Welsh, David. The Rise and Fall of Apartheid. Charlottesville: University of Virginia
Press, 2010.
pistol to Londons Constitution Hill and fired a cloud of smoke at the queens
passing carriage. Whether he included a projectile is unclear, but the shooting
produced no casualties. At trial, on June 14, Hamilton pled guilty to attempted
regicide and was transported to Australia for a term of seven years.
Next in line to stalk the queen was Robert Francis Pate Jr., a 31-year-old
lieutenant in the 10th Light Dragoons (now the 10th Royal Hussars), who
began to exhibit strange behavior in 1844, after his favorite horse and dog
were euthanized for rabies during a tour of duty in Ireland. On the evening of
June 27, 1850, after Victoria had visited a dying uncle at Cambridge House in
Picadilly, Pate attacked her with cane, inflicting a scar on the queens forehead
that remained visible for years afterward. At trial, while shunning a plea of insanity, Pate sought leniency by claiming he had suffered a momentary lapse
caused by a weak mind. Convicted and transported to Tasmania for a sevenyear term, he later returned to London and died there in 1895.
Britains Irish troubles prompted the next attack on Queen Victoria, on February 29, 1872. The assailant, 17-year-old youth Arthur OConnor, accosted
Victoria outside Buckingham Palace, brandishing a pistol and demanding freedom for Fenian prisoners incarcerated over their struggle for Irish freedom
from England. A servant, John Brown, tackled and disarmed OConnor, only
then discovering that the teenagers gun was both defective and unloaded.
A court sentenced OConnor to one years imprisonment and 20 lashes with a
birch whip, but Victoria waived the public beating.
Victorias next would-be slayer was Roderick MacLean, a London poet who
had mailed some of his verses to the queen and received a curt response that
he deemed insulting. On March 2, 1882, MacLean fired a pistol at Victorias
carriage outside Windsor Station, wounding no one. Two students from Eton
College attacked MacLean with their umbrellas, beating him until a constable
arrived to seize him. Charged with high treason, MacLean was deemed not
guilty, but insane on April 20. That verdict reportedly enraged Victoria, but
she took consolation from another outpouring of public support, remarking
that it was worth being shot at, to see how much one is loved.
Five years later, on June 20, 1887, Victoria celebrated her Golden Jubilee,
marking half a century as Britains queen. Irish nationalists found the temptation
to disrupt that ceremony irresistible, allegedly plotting to blow up Westminster
Abbey with Victoria and half her cabinet inside. We say allegedly today, because the mastermind of the conspiracyFrancis Millen, a member of Clan
na Gael, a successor to the defunct Fenian Brotherhoodhad been employed
since 1885 as a spy for the British Home Office. According to later reports,
Scotland Yard officer Edward Jenkinson encouraged the plot, with approval
from Prime Minister Lord Salisbury, as a means of arresting militant nationalists
and embarrassing the Irish Parliamentary Party, created in 1882 to seek home
rule for Ireland. British newspapers exposed the plot in June 1887, when
605
606
two Irish-American suspectsThomas Callan and Michael Harkinswere arrested for smuggling dynamite into London. Jurors convicted both in February
1888 and sentenced to 15-year terms, and ringleader Millen slipped through
police hands and escaped to the United States. The Times of London named deceased American James Monro as a financier of the plot, and although he could
not defend himself, Irish politician Charles Stewart Parnell sued the paper for
linking him to nationalist violence, winning a judgment of 5,000 for libel.
Future queen Alexandrina Victoria was born on May 24, 1819, granddaughter of King George III and daughter of heir apparent Prince Edward, Duke of
Kent and Strathearn. George and Edward died within six days of one another,
in January 1820, leaving Victoria to inherit the British throne at age 18. Three
years later, she married a first cousin, Prince Albert of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha,
producing the first of their nine children in November 1840. Albert died in
December 1861, after a protracted illness, and Victoria then entered a long
period of mourning, avoiding public appearances for several years. Momentous events of her long reign include the Irish potato famine (1844), establishment of Britains first public libraries (1850), the Crimean War (18531856),
transfer of government in India from a private trading company to the Crown
(1858), extension of suffrage to tax-paying men of the urban working class
(1867), institution of compulsory primary education to age 11 (1870), expanding property rights of married women (1883), extension of suffrage to
agricultural workers (1884), and still-unsolved serial murders by Jack the
Ripper (1888), believed by some historians to be Victorias grandson, Prince
Albert Victor, Duke of Clarence and Avondale. At her death in 1901, Victoria
was succeeded by her son, Edward VII.
Further Reading
Campbell, Christy. Fenian Fire: The British Government Plot to Assassinate Queen Victoria.
London: HarperCollins. 2002.
Charles, Barrie. Kill the Queen! The Eight Assassination Attempts on Queen Victoria.
Stroud, Gloucestershire, United Kingdom: Amberley Publishing, 2012.
Marshall, Dorothy. The Life and Times of Queen Victoria. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1972.
St. Aubyn, Giles. Queen Victoria: A Portrait. London: Sinclair-Stevenson, 1991.
Strachey, Lytton. Queen Victoria. London: Chatto and Windus, 1921.
Woodham-Smith, Cecil. Queen Victoria: Her Life and Times 18191861. London:
Hamish Hamilton, 1972.
hours of March 2, soldiers raided the home of General Na Waies bitter rival,
President Joo Nino Vieira, killing him as he attempted to flee. Reports differ as
to the cause of Vieiras death. European media reports quoted a pathologist who
performed his autopsy as saying the president was savagely beaten before being
finished off with several bullets. Best-selling novelist Frederick Forsyth, visiting
Guinea-Bissau at the time of the assassination, later claimed that the pathologist, over dinner, told him that Vieira survived an explosion at the presidential
villa, then was captured and carried to his mother-in-laws home, where soldiers
hacked him to death with machetes. Thousands attended Vieiras funeral at the
National Peoples Assembly, but foreign world leaders shunned the event.
Joo Vieira was born in Bissau, then the capital of Portuguese Guinea, on
April 27, 1939. Details of his early life are vague, beyond the fact that he belonged to the minority Papel ethnic group and trained to work as an electrician.
In 1960, Vieira joined the African Party for the Independence of Guinea and
Cape Verde (PAIGC), led by nationalist spokesman Amlcar Lopes da Costa Cabral, rising to serve as the partys political commissioner and military chief for
the Tombali region by 1961. In January 1963, Cabral declared all-out guerrilla
war against Portugal, launching a 10-year struggle for independence. Vieira
rose swiftly through the PAIGCs ranks, serving as military commander of its
southern front in 1964, as a member of its Political Bureau in 19641965, as
vice president of its War Council from 1965 to 1967, as a southern front political bureau delegate from 1967 to 1970, and as a member of the War Council
Executive Committee during 19701971.
In 1972, Amlcar Cabral began to organize a Peoples Assembly, meant to
govern his homeland when it achieved independence. Based in Conakry, in
neighboring Guinea, the Peoples Assembly served as a government in exile for
what would become Guinea-Bissau. Assassins murdered Cabral in Conakry on
January 23, 1973, but his half-brother Luis Cabral assumed command of the
PAIGC. Joo Vieira, at the time, was both the partys deputy secretary general
and a member of its Permanent Secretariat. The PAIGC declared Guinea-Bissau
independent on September 24, 1973, but Portuguese resistance continued
until Portugals Carnation Revolution of April 1974 deposed dictator Marcelo
Caetano. Guinea-Bissau officially achieved its independence on September 10,
1974, with Luis as its first president.
Joo Vieira, meanwhile, had advanced to serve as president of the Peoples
National Assembly in 1973, a post he held for the next five years. On September 28, 1978, President Cabral named Vieira to serve as prime minister. He
held that post for two years, while Guinea-Bissaus economy declined, then led
a bloodless coup against Cabral on November 14, 1980, driving Cabral into
exile. That move, exacerbated by racial tension within the PAIGC, split the
partys Guinea-Bissau faction from its apparatus in Cape Verde. Vieira ruled
the roost in Guinea-Bissau, as chairman of the Council of the Revolution, and
607
608
the partys Cape Verdean branch was reborn as the African Party for the Independence of Cape Verde.
In May of 1984, Guinea-Bissau adopted a new constitution. To preserve an
image of propriety, Vieira ceded his office to acting president Carmen Pereira
on May 14, then resumed it two days later, with his title changed from chairman of the Council of the Revolution to chairman of the Council of State. Already fond of calling himself Gods gift to Guinea-Bissau, Vieira banned rival
political parties until 1991, then bowed to pressure from the Democratic Front
led by Aristide Menezes, scheduling the countrys first presidential election
for July 3, 1994. Running as one of seven candidates, Vieira led the field with
46 percent of the popular vote, but his failure to achieve a clear majority forced
a run-off with second-place contender Kumba Ial on August 7. In that contest,
Vieira emerged with 52 percent of the vote, against Ials 48 percent. He was
inaugurated as Guinea-Bissaus first elected president on September 29, 1994.
By then, more was at stake than command of the country. Guinea-Bissau,
since the 1980s, had emerged as West Africas hub of trafficking in Colombian cocaine. Outside observers recognized the well-known secret that Vieira stood as the Biggest Man in the cocaine trade, dealing ruthlessly with his
competitors. Reelected to a second term as president in May 1998, Vieira dismissed Army Chief of Staff Ansumane Man on June 6, based on allegations
that Man had smuggled weapons to rebel separatists in Senegal. Mans supporters retaliated with a bungled coup against Vieira on June 7, sparking a civil
war that continued until May 1999, claiming thousands of lives and displacing
some 350,000 persons. Finally outmatched, Vieira resigned as president on
May 7, 1999, sought refuge in the Portuguese embassy, then fled to Portugal.
Man invited ex-president Cabral home from exile, and although Cabral briefly
returned to Guinea-Bissau, he declined the presidency.
Seven days after Vieiras expulsion, Man named Malam Bacai Sanh as acting president. In September 1999, a PAIGC party congress expelled Vieira for
what it called treasonable offences, support and incitement to warfare, and
practices incompatible with the statutes of the party. Kumba Ial defeated
President Sanhs reelection bid in February 2000, serving until a coup led
by General Verssimo Correia Seabra deposed him in mid-September 2003.
Seabra ruled for two weeks, then appointed acting president Henrique Rosa.
Vieira returned from Portugal on April 7, 2005, met by 5,000 cheering admirers when his helicopter landed at Bissaus National Stadium. Buoyed by a
petition with 30,000 signatures urging him to run for president again, Vieira
announced his candidacy on April 16.
Some opponents considered Vieira ineligible for election, based on his years
in exile and still-pending charges of killing suspected coup leaders 20 years
earlier, but in May 2005 the nations Supreme Court approved his participation in a field of 13 candidates. As before, the first round of voting on June 19
609
610
V I L L A , F R A N C I S C O PA N C H O
V I L L A , F R A N C I S C O PA N C H O
was rich and influential enough to spare Arangos life, on the condition that
he join Mexicos army. Arango agreed, then deserted in 1903, killing an officer and fleeing on the dead mans horse. Thereafter, he assumed the name
Francisco Pancho Villa, in honor of his paternal grandfather. Over the next
seven years, Villa waffled between legitimate odd jobs and robbery, until the
outbreak of the Mexican Revolution in 1910. Revolutionary leader Francisco
Madero Gonzlez soon persuaded Villa to forsake a life of banditry for the
crusade against dictator Porfirio Daz. Villa soon proved himself a skilled field
commander, helping Maderos forces triumph in the month-long Battle of Ciudad Jurez (AprilMay 1911). As a result, Daz fled into exile, ceding the
presidency to Madero.
Thus ended the first state of the Mexican Revolution, but not Pancho Villas
long war. Villa despised Venustiano Carranza, a former Daz loyalist selected by
Madero as his minister of war. Despite that disappointment, Villa balked at joining Pascual Orozcos rebellion against Madero in March 1912, joining General
Victoriano Huerta to suppress the uprising. In the process, Huerta recognized
Villa as an ambitious potential rival, trumping up charges of insubordination
and horse theft to justify Villas execution. President Madero intervened at the
eleventh hour, commuting Villas death sentence to life imprisonment, but Villa
soon escaped from custody. He was on the run in February 1913, when Huerta,
conspiring with U.S. ambassador Henry Wilson and Flix Daz (a nephew of the
exiled former president), deposed and murdered Madero.
With Huertas installation as president, Villa swallowed his dislike for Venustiano Carranza, joining lvaro Obregn, Emiliano Zapata, and Pablo Gonzlez
Garza as leaders of a new Constitutional Army, pledged to Huertas defeat.
Villa supervised the armys operation in northern Mexico, redoubling his efforts in March 1913, after Huerta executed a close friend of Villas, Chihuahua
governor Abraham Gonzlez Casavantes. Four months later, U.S. president
Woodrow Wilson dismissed Ambassador Wilson (no relation) and threw U.S.
support behind Carranza. Huerta fought on for another year, then resigned in
July 1914 and fled into exile. By that time, Carranza had named Villa to serve
as provisional governor of Chihuahua, financing his army through selective
robberies and coercive assessments on hostile ranchers such as those who had
held his parents in peonage.
Villa had not been President Carranzas first choice as governor of Chihuahua, but local military officers demanded his appointment over Carranzas
preferred candidate, Manuel Chao. Once in office, Villa prepared for a move
against Carranza, supplementing his income from holdups and hacienda taxation with reams of paper currency he printed himself, compelling its acceptance on an equal basis with standard gold pesos. In Texas, Brigadier General
John Pershing was impressed enough with Villa to invite him for a visit at Fort
Bliss, outside El Paso.
611
612
V I L L A , F R A N C I S C O PA N C H O
On October 1, 1914, Carranza summoned a Great Convention of Commanding Military Chiefs and State Governors, meeting first in Mexico City,
then relocating to Aguascalientes for sessions lasting through November 9.
Designed to settle differences between Carranza, Villa, Zapata, and Obregn,
the convention surprised Carranza by picking General Eulalio Gutirrez Ortiz
as president of the new Mexican Republic, and Villa emerged as commander
of the Conventionalist Army. That force entered Mexico City on December 6,
1914, driving Carranza and his troops to seek sanctuary in Veracruz. Carranza
established his new capital there, controlling Mexicos primary seaport, as lvaro Obregn came to Carranzas defense.
Battle was joined between Villa and Obregn at Celaya, Guanajuato, on
April 13, 1915. Obregn lost 600 men in that fight, but still defeated Villa,
killing 4,000 Conventionalist soldiers and capturing 6,000 more (of whom
120 were executed). Retreating to Trinidad Garca de la Cadena, in Zacatecas, Villa fought Obregn again on June 1, fielding 25,500 men against Obregns 23,900. Obregn lost his right arm in that battle, but still crushed
Villas army, inflicting some 8,000 casualties. Another defeat followed on
November 1, 1915, at Agua Prieta, Sonora, where 15,000 Villistas were unable to conquer 6,500 troops led by General Plutarco Elas Calles. In the wake
of that loss, 1,500 survivors deserted Villas ranks. He tried to recoup morale
by attacking Hermosillo on November 21, but lack of discipline produced yet
another defeat.
Next, Villa turned his eyes toward the border. On January 11, 1916, Villas
men stopped a Mexico North Western Railway train near Santa Isabel, Chihuahua, executing 16 U.S. employees of the American Smelting and Refining Company. Villa admitted ordering the raid, presumably in response to
Washingtons support for President Carranza, but he denied authorizing the
executions. While General Pershing marshaled troops along the southwestern border, Villa sent 100 men to raid Columbus, New Mexico, on March 9.
The Villistas killed eight members of the 13th Cavalry Regiment and 10 civilians, torching the town before they fled with stolen weapons, ammunition, and
horses, but it was pyrrhic victory, with 67 raiders dead on the field.
Six days later, Pershing led 4,800 troops into Mexico, pursuing Villa. Their
first clash, at a ranch near Guerrero, Chihuahua, on March 29, drove Villa from
that town with 75 men dead or wounded. Other battles followed, with Lieutenant George Pattons 8th Cavalry joining the hunt in May. Most were fought
on Mexican soil, but Villistas still crossed the border as well, striking a ranch
in Texas on Christmas Day 1917 and another in March 1918. By the time Pershing concluded his Mexican Punitive Expedition, 8 U.S. soldiers were dead,
against 171 Villistas and (ironically) 24 of Carranzas federal troops.
Villa, although hunted and harried, continued his war against Carranza.
In June 1919, he nearly captured Ciudad Jurez from Carranzas army, then
V I L L A , F R A N C I S C O PA N C H O
retreated when U.S. troops from El Paso intervened. From there, he attempted
a siege of Durango, but was once again defeated. Another bitter loss occurred
near years end, when Carranza captured Villas best-surviving ally, General Felipe ngeles Ramirez, and executed him on November 26. A break came for
Villa in May 1920, when supporters of lvaro Obregn assassinated Carranza,
replacing him with interim President Adolfo de la Huerta. Villa negotiated
peace terms with de la Huerta, whereby Villa received a 25,000-acre hacienda
near Hidalgo del Parral, plus a pension of 500,000 gold pesos, in return for a
cessation of hostilities. Those terms were still in force when Obregn became
president in December 1920, but Villas fate was effectively sealed.
Whereas some historians blame President Obregn for Villas assassination,
two alternate theories exist. One is that Plutarco Elas Calles, frontrunner for
the Mexican presidency in 1924, who may have feared Villas announced intent to contest that election, may have been responsible. The other holds Jess
Herrera, last surviving son of former Villista General Jose de la Luz Herrera,
who had shifted to Carranzas side in 1914, responsible for the assassination.
Subsequently, son Malclovia Herrera died in battle against Villistas in 1915,
and another sonLuis Herrerawas captured and executed in 1916. Finally,
in 1919, General de la Luz Herrera was captured with two more sons and likewise put to death. Thereafter, Jess Herrera allegedly spent the remainder of
his familys fortune in a long vendetta against Villa.
613
614
Further Reading
Katz, Friedrich. The Life and Times of Pancho Villa. Stanford, CA: Stanford University
Press, 1998.
McLynn, Frank. Villa and Zapata: A History of the Mexican Revolution. New York: Basic
Books, 2002.
Orellana, Margarita de. Filming Pancho Villa: How Hollywood Shaped the Mexican Revolution. London: Verso, 2009.
Tuck, Jim. Pancho Villa and John Reed: Two Faces of Romantic Revolution. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1984.
Welsome, Eileen. The General and the Jaguar: Pershings Hunt for Pancho Villa: A True
Story of Revolution and Revenge. New York: Little, Brown and Company, 2006.
Williams, Ben Jr. Pancho Villa: A Lifetime of Vengeance. Tucson, AZ: Smokin Z Press,
2010.
nations traditional order. To that end, he supported the military coup dtat
that deposed President Jos Tejada Sorzano on May 16, 1936, replacing him
with Colonel Jos Toro Ruilova. As president, Toro instituted a regime of Military Socialism aimed at lifting Bolivia out of its postwar economic depression.
A primary target was Standard Oil, accused of smuggling Bolivian oil into Argentina for sale. In March 1937, Toros regime nationalized the companys Bolivian holdings, and although that move was popular with Bolivias workers,
they were less pleased by Toros adoption of trapping resembling fascist governments then on the rise in Italy, Spain, and Germany. Four months after his
move against Standard Oil, Toro was deposed and driven into exile by fellow
army officer Germn Busch Becerra.
Gualberto Villarroel supported the Busch regime as he had Toros, pleased
when Busch restored the constitution Toro had suspended in 1936. Two years
later, Bolivias Constituent Assembly proclaimed Busch the countrys constitutional president, but he soon tired of political wrangling with opponents and
reverted to the role of dictator, pledged to deepening the Military Socialism
inaugurated by his predecessor. That claim of reformist zeal was undercut by
Buschs employment of German advisors to train his soldiers, particularly when
Chaco War veteran Major Achim von Kries formed the Landesgruppe-Bolivie as
a branch of the German Nazi Partys Auslands-Organisation (Foreign Organization) in La Paz. Busch himself tooled around the capital in a Mercedes Benz
he received as a gift from Adolf Hitler, while insisting that his government was
uniquely Bolivian. A greater problem, perhaps, was Buschs erratic temper,
displayed in 1938 when he personally beat up prominent author Alcides Arguedas in retaliation for a critical newspaper column. Finally, on August 23,
1939, Busch shot himself in the Palacio Quemado.
With the constitution once again suspended, Gualberto Villarroel and other
military leaders chose General Carlos Quintanilla Quiroga as president. Frightened by Bolivian extremists on both political wings, Quintanilla held office
for barely eight months, ceding the presidency to General Enrique Pearanda
del Castillo. Increasingly repressive and corrupt, influenced heavily by Bolivias large mining interests, President Pearanda soon saw his popularity wane
with both the nations lower classes and among military officers led by Villarroel, who wished to broaden the scope of ToroBusch Military Socialism. On
December 20, 1943, Villarroel led a coup dtat and seized the presidency for
himself, in the name of Razon de Patria (Reason for the Fatherland), and Pearanda decamped for Spain.
Within his limits as a Latin American military officer, Villarroel was committed to reform. He recognized labor unions and supported pensions for retired workers, while abolishing the system of pongueaje that bound Bolivias
Indians in de facto slavery as unpaid domestic servants. Collaborating with
the countrys Movimiento Nacionalista Revolucionario (Revolutionary Nationalist
615
616
VO M R AT H, E R N S T E D UA R D
Movement, or MNR), created in June 1942, Villarroel called a National Assembly and promulgated a new constitution that established him as president
for a six-year term, beginning in August 1944, while bucking opposition from
Washington based on Bolivias long-running flirtation with European fascists.
By the end of World War II, Villarroels regime was caught in a tug-of-war between conservative interests financed by rich mine owners, and workers inclined to take their newly granted freedoms seriously. He ultimately proved
unable to resist harsh military measures against labor and certain prominent
intellectuals, who were executed with their bodies tossed from a 3,000-foot
cliff. The revolt that claimed Villarroels life in 1946 was seemingly inevitable.
In the wake of that rebellion, Major Jorge Eguinoformer chief of Villarroels national policewas captured on July 26, attempting to flee the country
disguised as an Indian. In custody, he confessed to kidnapping Mauricio Hochschild, a wealthy Argentine industrialist held for ransom in Bolivia during August 1944. On August 3, interim President Nstor Guilln Olmos announced a
purge of 41 army officers from the Villarroel regime, while members of Bolivias
largest tin miners union pledged support to the new administration. Twelve days
later, Guilln ceded the presidency to Toms Monje Gutierrz, chief justice of
the La Paz Court of Appeals. He, in turn, stepped down when voters elected
successor Enrique Hertzog Garaizabal in March 1947. Two more presidents
followed in turn, before deterioration of the national economy sparked another
revolution in 1952.
Today, despite his unpopularity in later life and his death at the hands of
a howling mob, Gualberto Villarroel Lpez is revered by many Bolivians as a
martyr, El Presidente Colgado (The Hanged President). In hindsight, his admirers regard him as a national hero ahead of his time, lynched by a populace
that failed to grasp his vision of reform.
Further Reading
Dorn, Glenn. The Truman Administration and Bolivia: Making the World Safe for Liberal
Constitutional Oligarchy. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 2011.
Farcau, Bruce. The Chaco War: Bolivia and Paraguay, 19321935. Westport, CT: Praeger,
1996.
Gotkowitz, Laura. A Revolution for Our Rights: Indigenous Struggles for Land and Justice in
Bolivia, 18801952. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2007.
Scheina, Robert. Latin Americas Wars Volume I: The Age of the Professional Soldier,
19002001. Washington, D.C.: Brasseys, Inc., 2003.
Smale, Robert. I Sweat the Flavor of Tin: Labor Activism in Early Twentieth-Century Bolivia. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2010.
V O M R AT H , E R N S T E D U A R D
the German embassy, where he met Ambassador Graf Welczeck on the street.
Claiming that he had to deliver an unspecified document, Grynszpan gained
admittance to the embassy and to the office of Ernst vom Rath, a secretary on
Welczecks consular staff. Moments later, a clerk heard cries for helpbut no
gunshotsand found vom Rath wounded. He died two days later, at a local
hospital. Legal arguments stalled Grynszpans trial for 19 months, by which
time Germany had conquered France. In June 1940, the Gestapo transported
him to Berlin. Testimony at the 1961 trial of Adolf Eichmann indicated that
Grynszpan was still alive, in Nazi custody, as late as 1943, but no further record
of his fate exists today.
Ernst vom Rath was born in Frankfurt, Germany, on June 3, 1909, the son
of a local politician. He studied law at the University of Knigsberg, receiving
his degree in 1932, and joined the Nazi Party that same year. By April 1933, he
was a member of the partys paramilitary Sturmabteilung (Storm Detachment,
or SA), which specialized in guarding Nazi rallies, disrupting opposition parties, and intimidating Jews with random acts of violence. He survived Adolf
Hitlers bloody purge of the SA in June and July 1934, transferring to the German Foreign Office. Posted first to Bucharest, then Paris, he was shipped out
to Calcutta in 1935. There, vom Rath contracted a bowel disorder, reportedly
diagnosed by a German specialist in sexually transmitted disease as resulting
from anal intercourse. Upon recovering, vom Rath returned to Paris in July
1936, and was promoted to legation secretary three months later.
By 1938, Hitlers government had begun stripping German Jews of their financial resources, aryanizing formerly Jewish businesses in an effort to force
Jews out of Germany. Registration of all Jewish property was scheduled for
completion by September 30, followed by deportation orders and spontaneous riots against Jews in various cities. Against that background, vom Raths
murder by a Jew provided Nazis with a prime excuse for escalating violence.
Soon after the announcement of vom Raths death, on November 9, antiJewish riots erupted across Germany and parts of Austria (annexed by Germany in March 1938). By sunrise on November 10the end of Kristallnacht
(Crystal Night), the Night of Broken Glassat least 91 Jews had died in
mob violence, with some estimates topping 600. More than 1,000 synagogues
were torched (95 in Vienna alone), along with some 7,500 Jewish businesses.
Further draconian laws were enacted, including a November 12 decree banning Jews from attending theaters, cinemas, concerts, or public exhibitions.
Today, few historians doubt that the Kristallnacht was planned in advance by
top-ranking Nazi leaders.
The orchestration of events in Germany and Austria fueled conspiracy theories surrounding Ernst vom Raths assassination. Police could not explain
why Grynszpan passed on killing Ambassador Welczeck outside the embassy,
where he might have escaped, rather than shooting a secretary inside, where
he was sure to be captured. Embassy witnesses insisted that Grynszpan did not
617
618
VO M R AT H, E R N S T E D UA R D
ask for any particular person by name, simply requesting time with any staff
member. His admission to the embassy raised further questions, because no
one recalled asking Grynszpan for any identification papers, and a French policeman claimed that he had found Grynszpan five-shot revolver unfired on the
floor of vom Raths office after the attack.
In custody, before he was seized by Gestapo agents, Grynszpan claimed that
he had killed vom Rath for seducing him into a homosexual tryst. Although
Nazi minister of propaganda Joseph Goebbels branded that claim an insolent
argument and a shameless lie, it raised the specter of vom Raths rumored
homosexuality, with allegations that he had been treated for rectal gonorrhea
at the Berlin Institute of Radiology, after his return from Calcutta. Grynszpans
gay-sex defense is regarded by some as the reason why Nazi prosecutors bypassed their normal tactic of staging a public show trial, consigning Grynszpan
to obscurity in a concentration camp where he presumably died before the end
of World War II.
Other conspiracy allegations surround vom Raths medical treatment in the
wake of his shooting. Ambassador Welczecks physician, a Dr. Claas, listed the
patients condition as serious, whirs the ambassador told reporters that treatment up until this point . . . gives us hope that he [vom Rath] will make further
progress. Dissatisfied with that prognosis, Hitler sent his personal physician
Dr. Karl Brandt, a high-ranking officer in the elite SSto Paris aboard Hitlers
private plane on the night of November 7, accompanied by a Professor Magnus. The pair spent half an hour alone with vom Rath on November 8 and pronounced his condition grave, including signs of weak circulation. When vom
Raths mother arrived to visit him, shortly before his death on November 9,
she was forbidden from seeing her son. Back in Berlin, meanwhile, a journalist asked Dr. Heinrich Muehsam if he expected vom Rath to die. Although
Muehsam had never met vom Rath, he replied, Of course he will die. If not,
the whole thing is worthless. The greater the mourning, the more fanatical the
hatred will be.
Could Dr. Brandt have guaranteed vom Raths death, for the partys benefit? Vom Raths father, also a Third Reich diplomat, apparently had doubts
about his sons assassination, reportedly telling a friend that he blamed
a creature hired by the Nazis [rather] than a Jewish assassin. The senior vom
Rath opined that his son knew too much, but declined to elaborate. As for
Dr. Brandt, he went on to plan and participate in mass murder of Jews under
Hitlers euthanasia program, targeting defective humans characterized as life
unworthy of life. He also coordinated and joined in various medical experiments conducted on prisoners in Nazi concentration camps, which ultimately
placed him on trial for his life in December 1946, charged with 22 codefendants in the case titled United States of America v. Karl Brandt et al. That doctors trial concluded in April 1947, with Brandt and six others condemned for
V O M R AT H , E R N S T E D U A R D
crimes against humanity; nine more defendants were sentenced to prison, and
seven were acquitted. Before he was hanged, on June 2, 1948, Dr. Brandt defended his actions by saying that any personal code of ethics must give way to
the total character of the war.
Further Reading
Gilbert, Martin. Kristallnacht: Prelude to Destruction. London: HarperCollins, 2006.
Kirsch, Jonathan. The Short, Strange Life of Herschel Grynszpan: A Boy Avenger, a Nazi
Diplomat, and a Murder in Paris. New York: Liveright Publishing, 2013.
Pehle, Walter. November 1938: From Kristallnacht to Genocide. London: Berg Publishers, 1990.
Read, Anthony, and Dawn Fisher. Kristallnacht: The Nazi Night of Terror. New York:
Crown Publishing, 1990.
Schwab, Gerald. The Day the Holocaust Began: The Odyssey of Herschel Grynszpan. New
York: Praeger, 1990.
Schwarz, Meier. The Mysterious Murder of Ernst vom Rath. Ashkenaz House. http://
www.ashkenazhouse.org/vomrath.htm.
619
W
W A L L A C E , G E O R G E C O R L E Y, J R .
(19191998)ATTEMPTED
On May 15, 1972, in the midst of his second independent campaign for the
U.S. presidency, Alabama governor George Wallace staged a campaign rally at
a shopping center in Laurel, Maryland. After his speech, as he passed through
the crowd, 21-year-old Arthur Herman Bremer opened fire with a revolver,
wounding Wallace and three bystanders. All four victims survived, though a
bullet lodged in his spinal column left Wallace paralyzed from the waist down
for the remainder of his life. Investigators found that Bremer had been seen at
two prior Wallace rallies: one in Dearborn, Michigan, on May 13, and another
at Wheaton, Maryland, earlier on May 15. His diary, later published, indicated
that the shooting was inspired by a desire for notoriety. At trial, in August 1972,
Bremer received a 63-year sentence, later reduced by a decade. Bremer was
paroled from custody on November 9, 2007.
George Wallace Jr. was born in Clio, Alabama, on August 25, 1919. Although Wallace was named after his father and grandfather, his parents disliked the suffix Junior and distinguished him from his forebears by calling
him George C. In time, his own sontechnically named George Corley Wallace IIIwould be commonly known as George Jr.
Wallaces father, a physician like his father before him, abandoned medicine
to try his hand at farming after World War I. It was a failed attempt, his death
in 1937 forcing wife Mozell to sell the property in settlement of the outstanding mortgage. Entranced by politics from childhood, George C. won a contest
at age 16 to serve as a page in Alabamas state senate. Two years later, with his
fathers death, he bypassed conventional college study to enroll at the University of Alabamas School of Law, earning his LLB in 1942. From law school,
Wallace joined the U.S. Army Air Corps, failed at training as a pilot, but became a bomber crewman in the Pacific Theater. There, he suffered a near-fatal
case of spinal meningitis, emerging from the war partially deaf, with a medical
disability pension.
That handicap did not keep Wallace out of politics, beginning with his
1945 appointment as an assistant to Alabama attorney general William McQueen. May 1946 saw Wallace elected to the lower house of the state legislature, where he was viewed as a moderate on racial matters by Alabama
622
W A L L A C E , G E O R G E C O R L E Y, J R .
standards. Selected as a delegate to the 1948 Democratic National Convention, Wallace refused to join in the Dixiecrat walkout protesting President
Harry Trumans. Later, following appointment as a judge for Alabamas Third
Judicial Circuit in 1952, Wallace straddled the fence on matters of race. He
treated African Americans fairly in court, referring to black attorneys as Mister, but blocked federal attempts to review his countys mostly white voter
rolls and issued an injunction barring segregation signs from local railroad
depots.
Running for governor in 1958, Wallace cast himself as a relative liberal,
courting endorsement from the National Association for the Advancement
of Colored People and criticizing rival John Pattersons alliance with the Ku
Klux Klan (KKK). Patterson crushed Wallace at the polls, prompting Wallace to complain that They outniggered me. Ill never be outniggered again.
True to his word, Wallace actively recruited Klan support for his next gubernatorial bid, in 1962, employing former KKK wizard Asa Earl Carter as
his chief speech writer and tactician. Victorious in that campaign, Wallace
relied on Carter for a combative inauguration speech in January 1963, telling a crowd of cheering racists, In the name of the greatest people that have
ever trod this earth, I draw the line in the dust and toss the gauntlet before
the feet of tyranny, and I say segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever!
WA L L A C E , G E O R G E C O R L E Y, J R .
Under Wallace, from 1963 to 1966, the Klan had a virtual free hand against
blacks and civil rights workers in Alabama. Robert Shelton, leader of the states
largest KKK faction, landed a million-dollar contract for his then employer,
Goodyear Tire and Rubber, to supply tires for all state vehicles; a publishing
company that produced the Klans Fiery Cross newsletter was hired to print all
state textbooks; and Wallace cronies in the legislature killed a bill designed
to restrict access to dynamite. When Klansmen were accused of murder, Albert Lingoa self-described good friend of the KKK, named by Wallace to
head the state policeobstructed criminal investigations and provided bail for
those arrested. Wallace even called for the impeachment of Attorney General
Richmond Flowers after Flowers launched his own investigation of the Klan.
The charge: collaborating with the federal government.
Despite such antics, Wallace failed to halt desegregation in the Cotton State,
meekly surrendering after a brief stand in the schoolhouse door to bar black
students from the state university. During the 1965 civil rights march from
Selma to Montgomery, Wallace hid inside the governors mansion, peering at
the crowd with binoculars, from behind Venetian blinds. Despite such failures, though, he was a champion of racists and far-right radicals nationwide,
a fact that spurred him into presidential politics in early 1964. That February,
in Wisconsins Democratic primary, Wallace logged 266,000 votes, one-third
of all the ballots cast. Three months later, in Indiana, he secured 30 percent
of the Democratic primary vote, then landed 47 percent of the Maryland primary vote, reaching the Democratic National Convention with 672,984 electors pledged to support him. He could not unseat incumbent Lyndon Johnson,
but the heady campaign convinced Wallace to try again in 1968.
Meanwhile, state law barred him from a second consecutive term as governor. Wallace dodged that legal obstruction by securing the nomination for
his wife, Lurleen, who won election handily (and once again with public
KKK support). Effectively running the state as Alabamas First Gentleman,
Wallace focused on 1968 but suffered a setback in May of that year, when
cancer left him a widower, costing Wallace both his wife and much of his in
the state capital. Undeterred by grief, he forged ahead with his presidential
race as standard-bearer for the American Independent Party (AIP), an alliance of far-right and racist groups founded in July 1967, ostensibly directed
by segregationist attorney Tom Turnipseed. Drawing its members from the
Klan, White Citizens Council, John Birch Society, and other fringe groups
even more extreme, the AIP nominated Wallace in August 1968, with retired Air Force General Curtis LeMay as his running mate. (Wallace had first
considered ex-Kentucky governor Albert Happy Chandler for vice president, but dropped him when reminded that Chandler, while commissioner
of baseball, had integrated the Major League by hiring black player Jackie
Robinson in 1946.)
623
624
W A L L A C E , G E O R G E C O R L E Y, J R .
Given Wallaces recent record and the AIPs constituency, the partys program was predictable. It favored segregation in the name of states rights,
condemned foreign aid as money poured down a rat-hole, and promised U.S.
withdrawal from Vietnam if that war proved unwinnable within 90 days of
Wallaces inauguration. (General Lemays prescription: Bomb North Vietnam
back to the Stone Age.) Law and order proved a catch-all slogan, chiefly
targeting ghetto upheavals from the long hot summers of 19641967, and
was eagerly adopted from the AIP by Republican candidate Richard Nixon.
All-white audiences cheered Wallaces promise to run down any demonstrators who blocked his campaign limousine, and laughed uproariously when he
declared that the only four-letter words unknown to hippies were soap and
work. Closer to home, in Alabama, a reporter who photographed Wallace
shaking hands with Klansman Robert Shelton was roughed up, and his camera
smashed. Ultimately, Wallace had no chance, but he polled nearly 10 million
popular votes and won 46 votes in the Electoral Collegeenough to guarantee
that he would try again.
Meanwhile, he moved to recaptured Alabamas governorship in 1970, running a blatantly racist campaign with ads declaring, Wake Up! Blacks vow
to take over Alabama. Incumbent Albert Brewer fought back with pleas that
Alabama needs a full-time governor, leading Wallace to promise (falsely) that
he would not mount another presidential race. Easily elected to his second
term, Wallace flew to Wisconsin the very next day, to kick off his next White
House race. He officially declared himself a Democratic candidate on January
13, 1972, but this time his road to Washington was cut short by gunfire. Even
crippled, he won primaries in Maryland and Michigan, but had to settle for
delivering a speech before the national convention that nominated George McGovern in July.
Wallace soon resumed his gubernatorial duties, and easily won reelection in
1974 (the state constitution having been amended, at his urging, to permit it).
Wallace announced his fourth presidential bid in November 1975, then lost
several Southern primaries to ex-Georgia governor Jimmy Carter before quitting the race in June 1976. Elected to a final term as governor in 1982, Wallace
renounced his former dedication to segregation, declaring I was wrong. Those
days are over, and they ought to be over. Such statements prompted one Klan
leader to complain that Wallace was not as white as he used to be. Wallace
rejected intimations of a fifth term in 1986, and died from a bacterial infection
on September 13, 1998.
Arthur Bremers attempt on Wallaces life inspired two feature films: Nashville, directed by David Hayward in 1975, and Taxi Driver, directed by Martin
Scorsese the following year. Ironically, the latter film inspired an attempt on the
life of President Ronald Reagan by John Hinckley Jr. in March 1981.
See also: Ku Klux Klan (1866 ); Patterson, Albert Leon (18941954); Reagan, Ronald
Wilson (19112004)Attempted.
Further Reading
Bremer, Arthur. An Assassins Diary. New York: Pocket Books, 1973.
Carter, Dan. The Politics of Rage: George Wallace, the Origins of the New Conservatism, and
the Transformation of American Politics. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1995.
Frady, Marshall. Wallace. New York: Random House, 1996.
Governor George C. Wallaces Schoolhouse Door Speech. Alabama Department of
Archives and History. http://www.archives.state.al.us/govs_list/schooldoor.html.
Healey, Thomas. The Two Deaths of George Wallace: The Question of Forgiveness. Montgomery, AL: River City Publishing, 1996.
Lesher, Stephan. George Wallace: American Populist. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley,
1994.
Stang, Alan. Arthur Bremer: The Communist Plot to Kill George Wallace. Appleton, WI:
American Opinion, 1972.
625
626
Denmark, the Netherland, Norway, and Sweden. However, because the junta
was rigidly anticommunist and promoted a high rate of economic growth, it
enjoyed both diplomatic and financial support from the United States under
Presidents Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon. On November 17, 1973, the
regime used tanks and troops to crush a student rebellion National Technical University of Athens, thus inspiring the 17N group to name itself for that
date. The junta collapsed in 1974, and 20 of its leaders were awaiting trial on
charges of mutiny and high treason when Richard Welch arrived for the second
time in Athens.
Meanwhile, in the United States, the Watergate scandal exposed President
Nixons extensive abuses of power, including misuse of both the CIA and the
Federal Bureau of Investigation to persecute his political enemies. Beginning
in 1975, the U.S. Senate Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations
with Respect to Intelligence Activitiesbetter known as the Church Committee, after its chairman, Senator Frank Church of Idahoheld extensive hearings on both agencies, including allegations of CIA involvement in foreign
assassinations, mind-control experiments, and illegal operations on U.S. soil
(specifically banned by the agencys 1947 charter). Information from those
hearings, contained in a series of reports published during 1975 and 1976,
supported many charges of CIA misconduct in foreign nations, deeply embarrassing the agency and then-director William Colby. Some observers cite the
Welch assassination as a first step toward regaining public sympathy for the
CIA and its covert role in protecting U.S. national security. Welchs death also
contributed to passage of the Intelligence Identities Protection Act of 1982,
making it a federal crime to intentionally reveal the identity of U.S. intelligence
agents.
Welch was the first of 23 known victims murdered by 17N, in a series of
103 attacks targeting Greek, American, British, and Turkish adversaries of the
group. Other crimes included 11 bank robberies netting some $3.5 million,
several kidnappings, four bombings, 24 rocket attacks, and various symbolic
assaults on government and corporate offices. Aside from Welch, 17Ns murder
victims included five Greek policemen, two prosecutors, four industrialists,
one newspaper editor, three Greek politicians, two Turkish diplomats, British
military attach Stephen Saunders, U.S. Navy Captains William Nordeen and
George Tsantes, U.S. Air Force Sergeant Ronald Stewart, and U.S. Army Master
Sergeant Robert Judd.
Between June and September 2002, Greek police arrested 19 members of
17N, charging them with a total of 2,500 crimes. Three of those defendants
Nikos Papanastasiou, Pavlos Seriffs, and Alexandros Yiotopouloswere
named as participants in Richard Welchs slaying. They could not be charged
with that crime since the 20-year statute of limitation had elapsed, but trial
commenced in more recent cases on March 3, 2003. Nine months later, on
627
628
WENCESL AUS I
WENCESLAUS I (907935)
In September 935, Prince Boleslaus (or Boleslav) invited his elder brother,
Duke Wenceslaus I of Bohemia (now the Czech Republic) to celebrate the feast
of Saints Cosmas and Damian, scheduled to be held in Brands nad LabemStar Boleslav on September 28. Unknown to Wenceslaus, Boleslaus had conspired with other Bohemian nobles to assassinate his brother at the banquet.
The deed was carried out by three accomplices remembered only as Csta,
Hnevsa,
and Tira, who set upon the duke and stabbed him to death. Tradition has it that
one of Wenceslauss servants, named Podevin, killed one of the assassins and
was subsequently hanged on orders from Boleslaus, who succeeded his brother
as planned. Ironically, a son was born to Boleslaus on the day of the murder,
saddled with the name Strachkvas, which translates to English as a dreadful
feast.
Born in 907, Wenceslaus was the son of Vratislaus I, third duke of Bohemia under the Premyslid dynasty. Vratislaus died in battle against Hungarian
Magyar invaders, in 921, succeeded by Wenceslaus, but the new dukes youth
precluded him from ruling directly. His staunchly Christian grandmother,
Ludmila of Bohemia, served as regent, inspiring jealously from Wenceslauss
mother, Drahomra. A former princess of the pagan Hevelli tribe, Drahomra
had been baptized prior to marrying Vratislaus, but she was not prepared to
take a backseat in her sons education. She persuaded two noblemen to murder
Ludmila on September 15, 921, then assumed Ludmilas place as regent until
924, when Wenceslaus attained his majority. Little more is known about Drahomra, and whereas some accounts claim she tried to lure Wenceslaus from
Christianity back to paganism, most histories describe the new duke as an ardent and pious Christian. Claims of the pagan conversion are undermined by
the fact that Wenceslaus exiled Drahomra when he came of age.
As duke in his own right, Wenceslaus faced continuous incursions by the
Magyars, and threats from Henry the Fowler, Duke of Sazony and first king
WENCESLAUS I
629
630
Collins, Ace. Stories behind the Best-Loved Songs of Christmas. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2001.
Panek, Jaroslav, and Oldrich Tuma, eds. A History of the Czech Lands. Chicago: Karolinum Press, 2009.
Schulman, Jana. The Rise of the Medieval World 5001300: A Biographical Dictionary.
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2002.
Wolverton, Lisa. Hastening Toward Prague: Power and Society in the Medieval Czech
Lands. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2001.
Orange at age 11, inheriting the large estates of his late, childless cousin, Ren
of Chlon. Deemed too young to rule his newly acquired lands, William was
dispatched by his regent, Holy Roman emperor Charles V, to complete his education in Brussels. William further expanded his holdings in 1551 by marriage
to Dutch heiress Anna van Egmont, thus gaining new titles as Lord of Egmond
and Count of Buren. Anna bore William three children before her death in
March 1558, and he soon produced a fourth child (and his second son) with
mistress Eva Elincx. In August 1561, William remarried Anna of Saxony. That
union produced five more children, though some observers believed Williams
primary interest lay in expanding his influence over Germany.
Meanwhile, Charles V had abdicated in August 1556, in favor of his son,
Philip II. Still friendly with Philip at that point, William won appointment in
1559 as stadtholder (governor) of the Dutch provinces of Holland, Utrecht,
and Zeeland. Two years later, Philip named William as stadtholder of FrancheComt, in Burgundy. Although Williams relationship with Philip seemed outwardly cordial, and he never directly attacked the king, William gradually
allied himself with Dutch nationalist spokesmen including Philip de Montmorency, Count of Horn, and Lamoral, Count of Egmont. Raised first as a
Lutheran, then as a Catholic, William advocated freedom of religion and resented persecution of Dutch Protestants under Cardinal Antoine Perrenot de
Granvelle, who doubled as prime minister under Philips half-sister and governor
of the Netherlands, Margaret of Parma. In 1565, addressing the Dutch Council
of State, William affirmed his Catholic faith, but simultaneously disavowed monarchs who sought to rule their subjects souls by dictating religious faith.
In April of that year, Williams younger brother Louis joined other Dutch
nobles to form a Compromise of Nobles, presenting Margaret of Parma with a
petition urging religious freedom for Protestants. Between August and October
1566, angry Protestants throughout the Low Countries engaged in a Beeldenstorm (statue storm), invading Catholic churches and monasteries, defacing
religious icons. Margaret initially agreed to demands from the Compromise of
Nobles, then reneged under pressure from Philip, who dispatched The Iron
DukeGeneral Fernando lvarez de Toledo, 3rd Duke of Albato restore
order in the Netherlands.
Arriving in Alba established a Council of Troubles to judge the Beeldenstorm rebels. William of Orange was among some 10,000 summoned to testify before that tribunal, but he declined to appear, whereupon Alba declared
him an outlaw and confiscated his Dutch estates. That action propelled William into armed resistance, bankrolling the Watergeuzen (sea beggars), a
fleet of Protestant privateers who ranged along the Dutch coast, raiding ports,
sometimes killing Spaniards. William also funded battalions on land, including French Huguenots and German mercenaries who engaged Albas forces in
combat. Brother Louis was a leader of the latter army, invading the northern
631
632
Spain dragged on. Peace negotiations failed in 1575, but rebel prospects improved when Don Requesens died suddenly in Brussels, on March 5, 1576.
Spanish soldiers, short-changed on their pay by King Philip since the previous
September, mutinied and ran amok in Antwerp on November 4, 1876, scoring
a propaganda coup for Dutch insurgents with the slaughter of 7,000 townsfolk. Four days later, William secured the Pacification of Ghent, an alliance of
provinces in the Habsburg Netherlands to drive Spanish forces from Holland
and Zeeland.
Don John of Austria, Spanish governor-general of the Habsburg Netherlands,
made that alliance perpetual with the Edict of 1577, signed in February, then
reneged five months later and prepared a fresh invasion of the Netherlands.
William was ready with a new ally, Queen Elizabeth I of England, who pledged
troops and 100,000 in cash to resist John if he pressed the attack. Despite that
aid, John captured Namur, in southern Belgium, and entered Brussels on September 24, 1577. At the time, William was preoccupied with trouble from his
fellow Calvinists, campaigning to eliminate Catholicism from the regions they
controlled. That persecution sparked a backlash in the southern Netherlands,
embodied in the Union of Arras, signed on January 6, 1579, wherein the district pledged loyalty to King Philip and Governor-General Don John. Philip, in
return, agreed to withdraw his troops from Dutch soil.
Seventeen days later, leaders of five northern provinces signed the Union
of Utrecht, opposing Philips rule. William of Orange, still hoping to unite
all provinces of the Netherlands, withheld endorsement of the Union until
May 3, 1579, when he reluctantly signed on. On September 29, 1580, most
of the Staten Generaal (except Holland and Zeeland) agreed to the Treaty of
Plessis-les-Tours, accepting Francis, Duke of Anjou (brother of French king
Henry III), as Protector of the Liberty of the Netherlands. Ten months later,
the Staten Generaal passed an Act of Abjuration, formally declaring independence of the Dutch Low Countries from Spain. William welcomed the Duke
of Anjou to Vlissingen in February 1582, and Spanish gunman Juan de Juregui tried to assassinate William in Antwerp on March 18, leaving William with
bullet fragments in his neck and jaw. Guards killed Juregui on the spot, and
two conspiratorsAntonio de Venero and Antonio Timmerman, a Dominican
monkwere executed on March 28.
The Dutch alliance with France caused more trouble for William, peaking
when the Duke of Anjou marched to seize Antwerp on January 17, 1583. He
was surprised when townsfolk mobbed his troops, killing more than 1,500 soldiers. The duke survived to suffer scathing reprimands from Queen Elizabeth,
and fled the Netherlands six months later, leaving William largely discredited.
Widowed the previous May, William increased Catholic alienation in April
1583, with his marriage to a French Huguenot, Louise de Coligny, who bore
his fourth and last legitimate son in January 1584. Williams eldest son, Philip
633
634
WILLIAM II OF ENGLAND
William, succeeded him as Prince of Orange, and the fight for Dutch independence continued until October 1648, with the Peace of Westphalia.
British historian Lisa Jardine names William of Orange as the first national
head of state assassinated with a pistol. His was not the first assassination with
a firearm, however, since James Stewart, 1st Earl of Moray and regent of Scotland for his infant nephew, King James VI of Scotland, had been shot by a
sniper on January 23, 1570.
Further Reading
Blok, Petrus. History of the People of the Netherlands. New York: G. P. Putnams Sons,
1898.
Jardine, Lisa. The Awful End of William the Silent: The First Assassination of a Head of State
with a Handgun. London: HarperCollins, 2005.
Motley, John. History of the United Netherlands from the Death of William the Silent to the
Synod of Dort. London: John Murray, 1860.
Motley, John. The Rise of the Dutch Republic. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1855.
Rowen, Herbert. The Princes of Orange: The Stadholders in the Dutch Republic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988.
WILLIAM II OF ENGLAND
his horse, and escaped with the utmost speed. Indeed there were none to pursue
him: some helped his flight; others felt sorry for him.
The kings body was placed on a cart and conveyed to the cathedral at Winchester . . . blood dripped from the body all the way. Here he was buried
within the tower. The next year, the tower fell down. William Rufus died in
1100 . . . aged forty years. He was a man much pitied by the clergy . . . he had
a soul which they could not save. . . . He was loved by his soldiers but hated by
the people because he caused them to be plundered.
Some current historians describe Williams death as a simple hunting accident, and othersnotably Emma Mason, former Senior Lecturer in History
at Birkbeck College, author of two books on William II and various others on
British royaltyconfidently treat the incident as an assassination.
William IIcommonly known as William Rufus for his ruddy complexionwas the third son of King William I, also known as William the Conqueror (and to some as William the Bastard). His birth date is uncertain, with
various histories offering a four-year spread, between 1056 and 1060. William
Is second son, Richard of Normandy, also died in an apparent hunting accident
in the New Forest, and details of his passing are similarly vague, dated between
1069 and 1075 by different historians. Equal confusion surrounds the number of Williams sisters, with the existence of four confirmed, and two others
Adeliza and Matildaare dismissed by some scholars as mythical.
Elder brother Robert Curthose might have been expected to succeed William the Conqueror as king, but familial conflict hurt his case. English chronicler Orderic Vitalis (10751142), in his Historia Ecclesiastica, described an
incident occurring in 1077 or 1078, when William and younger brother Henry
dumped a chamber pot over Roberts head, sparking a brawl that forced their
fathers intervention to forestall serious injury. Angered when his brothers went
unpunished for that insult, Robert laid siege to King Williams castle at Rouen,
the capital of Normandy. That ill-conceived campaign nearly resulted in Roberts arrest, but he escaped to Rmalard, and then to Flanders. The estranged
father and son met in battle, in January 1079, at which time Robert wounded
King William. They reconciled in 1080, through the persistent efforts of Queen
Matilda of Flanders, but her death in November 1083 left them at odds once
more. When a riding accident killed William I in September 1087, William II
ascended to the English throne, and brother Robert was relegated to service as
the Duke of Normandy.
William II proved to be a ruthless and unpopular king, described in the
Anglo-Saxon Chronicle as hateful to almost all his people and odious to God.
The latter charge involved his frequent conflicts with the Anglican Church,
including his appointment of Ranulf Flambard, from Normandy, as bishop
of Durham in 1099. He also engaged in long-running disputes with Anselmo
dAosta, archbishop of Canterbury, whom William appointed in 1093, then
635
636
WILLIAM II OF ENGLAND
almost instantly regretted his selection as they wrangled over Anselmos support for reforms initiated by Pope Gregory VII. By 1097, when he finally drove
Anselmo into exile, William had been heard to say, Yesterday I hated him
with great hatred, today I hate him with yet greater hatred and he can be certain that tomorrow and thereafter I shall hate him continually with ever fiercer
and more bitter hatred.
William II also proved unconventional in his refusal to marry, and by failing
to sire any children, legitimate or otherwise. His father had conquered England
in 1066, and William still faced uprisings from rebellious nobles in his own
time. In 1095, when Robert de Mowbray, the Earl of Northumbria, supported
Stephen of Aumales attempt to seize the English throne, William led troops to
crush the rebels. Mowbray was captured and imprisoned for life, accomplice
William of Aldrie was executed, and another, William of Eu, was castrated and
blinded. Stephen was also sentenced to prison, but escaped from England, and
his French father, Count Odo of Champagne, was stripped of his English estates for joining in the conspiracy.
In France, William asserted himself aggressively, invading Normandy in
1091 to defeat brother Robert and claim portions of his inherited territory.
They later made peace, and Robert joined William in defeating Elias I, Count
of Maine, when he laid claim to that province, supported by Fulk IV, Count
of Anjou. During the same period, William beat back an invasion of England
by King Malcolm III of Scotland, in May of 1091. The following year, William erected Carlisle Castle in Cumbria, frustrating Scottish claims to Cumberland and Westmorland. Malcolm retaliated by invading Northumbria, but
that campaign proved fatal. Both Malcolm and his eldest son, Edward, suffered fatal wounds at the Battle of Alnwick, on November 13, 1093. Malcolms brother Donald claimed the Scottish throne, and William backed the
late kings son Edgar in a campaign to unseat Donald, finally achieving success
in 1097.
Following Williams death in the New Forest, brother Henry rushed first
to Winchester, seizing the royal treasury, then on to London, where he was
crowned as King Henry I on August 5, 1100. He reigned until December 1,
1135, when he died during a visit to Normandy. His death was attributed to
food poisoning, allegedly from consuming a surfeit of lampreys.
Further Reading
Barlow, Frank. William Rufus. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2000.
Grinnell-Milne, Duncan. The Killing of William Rufus: An Investigation in the New Forest.
Newton Abbot, United Kingdom: David & Charles, 1968.
Hart, Ray. William Rufus: The Second Norman King. Far Hills, NJ: New Horizon, 1984.
Hollister, C. Warren. The Strange Death of William Rufus. Speculum 48 (1973):
63753.
Mason, Emma. King Rufus: The Life & Murder of William II of England. Stroud, Gloucestershire, United Kingdom: The History Press, 2008.
Mason, Emma. William II: Rufus, the Red King. Stroud, United Kingdom: Tempus, 2005.
637
638
W O O D, J O H N H O W L A N D, J R .
told Chagras attorney/brother, Joe Chagra, that Jimmy could expect the worst
if found guilty. After an alleged $10 million bribe failed to soften Woods attitude, Chagra reportedly decided to kill Wood, instead.
Authorities did not immediately link Jamiel Chagra to Woods assassination. His drug case proceeded to trial with a new judge, and upon conviction,
Chagra received a 30-year sentence rather than life. In 1981, FBI microphones
eavesdropped on conversations between Chagra and his brother Joe, in a visiting room at Leavenworth Federal Prison. (Although Joe Chagra was a lawyer,
he was not his brothers attorney, and a court found that recording conversations between blood relatives did not violate attorneyclient privilege.) Despite those tapes, jurors at his murder trial acquitted Jimmy Chagra of ordering
Woods assassination when brother Joe refused to testify against him. A separate panel convicted Joe Chagra of conspiracy, resulting in a 10-year prison
term. Joes relatively lenient sentence came in exchange for his testimony
against brother Jimmys wife, convicted at trial for paying off Woods killer. She
received a 30-year sentence and died in prison, from cancer.
The triggerman in Woods assassination was contract killer Charles Voyde
Harrelsonfather of film and television actor Woody Harrelsonparoled in
September 1978 after serving barely three years of a 15-year sentence imposed
for the 1968 murder-for-hire of Texas victim Sam Degelia Jr. Indicted on the
basis of the Chagra Prison tapes, Harrelson denied killing Wood, insisting that
he only claimed credit for the murder to collect Chagras $250,000 bounty on
the judge. Jurors disbelieved that tale, convicting Harrelson of on his second
count of murder for hire, resulting in a double life sentence. Harrelsons wife,
who purchased the murder weapon using false identification, was also convicted on five counts of perjury, receiving a 20-year sentence (later reduced on
appeal).
Jimmy Chagra subsequently confessed his part in conspiring to murder
Judge Wood and an abortive plot to kill Assistant U.S. Attorney James Kerr of
San Antonio in 1978, in a futile legal maneuver designed to free his incarcerated wife. The court imposed a life sentence on those charges, but declining
health resulted in Chagras release from custody December 9, 2003. Some accounts suggest that he entered the Federal Witness Security Program, but no
official confirmation of that story is available today. Chagra married his third
wife in Las Vegas, on November 22, 2005, using the name the name James
Madrid. They were living in Mesa, Arizona, when cancer claimed Chagras life
on July 25, 2008.
Charles Harrelson remains a somewhat enigmatic figure. At Harrelsons murder trial, Joe Chagra testified that Harrelson had boasted of assassinating President John F. Kennedy ( JFK) in November 1963, supporting his statement with
hand-drawn diagrams of the murder scene at Dealey Plaza in Dallas, Texas.
In 1989, conspiracy author Jim Marrs suggested that Harrelson was one of
three unidentified tramps arrested by Dallas police near Dealey Plaza moments after the Kennedy shooting. Marrs also alleged that Harrelson was acquainted with gangster Jack Rubyslayer of accused JFK assassin Lee Harvey
Oswaldand with other criminals connected to intelligence agencies and the
military.
Harrelson and two other inmates, Michael Rivers and Garhy Settle, tried to
escape from the federal prison in Atlanta, Georgia, on July 4, 1995, but surrendered after a guard fired a warning shot over their heads. Transferred thereafter to a federal supermax at Florence, Colorado, Harrelson penned letters to
friends describing his enjoyment of the new facility, where, he said, the silence
is wonderful. Guards found Harrelson dead in his cell on March 15, 2007. An
autopsy attributed his passing to coronary artery disease.
Further Reading
Cartwright, Gary. Dirty Dealing: Drug Smuggling on the Mexican Border and the Assassination of a Federal Judge. New York: Atheneum, 1984.
Denton, Sally. The Bluegrass Conspiracy: An Inside Story of Power, Greed, Drugs and Murder. Lincoln, NE: iUniverse, 1999.
Marrs, Jim. Crossfire: The Plot That Killed Kennedy. New York: Carroll & Graf Publishers, 1989.
United States of America v. Jo Ann Harrelson. United States Court of Appeals, Fifth
Circuit, 754 F.2d 1182 (February 15, 1985). http://openjurist.org/754/f2d/1182/
united-states-v-harrelson.
Varhola, Michael. Texas Confidential: Sex, Scandal, Murder, and Mayhem in the Lone Star
State. Cincinnati: Clerisy Press, 2011.
639
X
XERXES I OF PERSIA (519 BCE465 BCE)
In August 465 BCE, Xerxes I, fourth king of the Achaemenid Persian Empire, was
assassinated in Persepolis (43 miles northeast of present-day Shiraz, Iran) by a
palace eunuch called Aspamitres, acting under orders from Artabanus the
Hyrcanian, commander of the kings bodyguards. Prior to the assassination,
Artabanus had placed his seven sons in key positions at the royal court, all
serving his plan to topple the Achaemenid dynasty. Xerxess eldest son, Crown
Prince Darius, was also slain in the abortive coup dtat, though ancient Greek
historians differ on the order of the murders. Aristotle wrote that Artabanus
killed Darius before Xerxes, whereas Ctesias claimed that Artabanus accused
Darius of killing Xerxes, then persuaded younger brother Artaxerxes to avenge
their fathers death by executing Darius. In either event, Artaxerxes soon learned
the truth, personally killing Artabanus and ordering the execution of his sons
in by 464 BCE.
Xerxes was born sometime in 519 BCE, the eldest son of King Darius I and
Atossa, daughter of Achaemenid Empire founder Cyrus the Great. Darius
claimed the imperial throne in 522 BCE, after killing the assassins of predecessor Bardia, son of Cyrus the Great and his brother-in-law. In 487 BCE, prior to
launching a military campaign against Athens, Darius complied with Persian
law by naming Xerxes as his successor, in the event of his death. That choice
proved timely when a rebellion in Egypt sidetracked the Persian army, and
Darius died from natural causes in October 486 BCE. Artobarzanes, an older
son of Darius with his commoner first wife, briefly contested Xerxess right to
claim the throne, they wisely abandoned his bid, thus sparing his family from
annihilation.
Soon after his coronation, Xerxes completed his fathers unfinished work
of suppressing the Egyptian revolt, naming his brother Achaemenes as satrap
(provincial governor) over that region. In 484 BCE, Xerxes provoked a new uprising in Babylon, when he seized and melted down a golden statue of Marduk,
the sun god. Babylonian tradition required each rightful king to lay hands on
the statute each New Years Day, and its destruction was regarded as an act of
sacrilege. Xerxes suppressed the rebellion by 482 BCE, in the process renouncing his fathers title of king of Babylon, to call himself instead the King of Persia
and Media, Great King, King of Kings, and King of Nations.
642
XERXES I OF PERSIA
More recently, popular fascination with the Battle of Thermopylae has carried Xerxes into fiction and film, typically portrayed as a villain and megalomaniac. British actor David Farrar first struck that tone in The 300 Spartans
(1962), opposite Richard Eagan as King Leonidas. Author/artist Frank Miller
followed that trend in his graphic novel 300 (1999), and in production of its
2007 film adaptation, casting Brazilian actor Rodrigo Santoro as Xerxes, complete with piercings and gold body paint. A year later, Meet the Spartans spoofed
that feature for slapstick laughs, with Kevin Davitian portraying the comically
grotesque opposite of Santoros seven-foot-tall God-king.
Further Reading
Abbott, Jacob. Xerxes. North Charleston, SC: CreateSpace, 2012.
Allen, Lindsay. The Persian Empire. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005.
Holland, Tom. Persian Fire: The First World Empire and the Battle for the West. London:
Little, Brown, 2005.
Martin, Thomas. Ancient Greece: From Prehistoric to Hellenistic Times. New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press, 1996.
Olmstead, A. T. History of the Persian Empire. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,
1959.
643
Y
YULDASHEV, TOHIR ABDUHALILOVICH
(19672009)
On September 30, 2009, a Pakistani English-language newspaper, The News International, reported that Tohir Yuldashev, cofounder of the Islamic Movement
of Uzbekistan (IMU) and an ally of al-Qaeda terrorists, had been killed by a
rocket fired from a U.S. drone aircraft. According to that article, Yuldashev lost
an arm and a leg in the blast on August 27, but survived to reach a hospital at
Zhob, in the Pakistani province of Balochistan, where he died on August 28.
IMU headquarters in Tajikistan subsequently confirmed that account, naming
Abu Usman Adil as Yuldashevs successor on August 17, 2010.
Tohir Yuldashev, widely known in later life as Tohir Yoldosh, was born in
the Uzbek Soviet Socialist Republic (SSR) on October 2, 1967. Little is known
of his life under communist rule, when the Uzbek SSR was commanded by
Sharof Rashidov (19591983) and his successors. Despite official suppression of religion and closing of mosques throughout Central Asia, Yuldashev
was raised in a strict Muslim home and remained a committed ideologue until
his death. By the time Uzbekistan declared independence from Russia, in August 1991, Yuldashev had joined a veteran of the Soviet war in Afghanistan,
Jumaboi Ahmadzhanovich Khojayev (alias Jummah Khan Namangani and/or
Jumma Kasimov), to found the IMU. That groups immediate objective was to
overthrow authoritarian President Islam Karimov and establish a Muslim state
ruled by Sharia religious law.
Official retaliation for that campaign soon drove Yuldashev and Khojayev
into exile, operating from Tajikistan, where, where civil war erupted during
1992, between the regime of President Emomalii Rahmon and United Tajik
Opposition (UTO), as Islamic group led by Sayid Abdulloh Nuri, founder of
the Islamic Renaissance Party of Tajikistan. Jumaboi Khojayev soon established
himself as a UTO field commander, while Yuldashev traveled through the Middle East, forging alliances with like-minded Islamic militant groups. By 1995,
he had settled in Peshawar, Pakistan, working closely with al-Qaeda founder
Osama bin Laden. He also forged close ties with the Taliban, which seized effective control of neighboring Afghanistan in September 1996.
A year later, after President Rahmon agreed to peace terms with the UTO
in Tajikistan, Yuldashev and Jumaboi Khojayev turned their full attention
646
Y U L D A S H E V, T O H I R A B D U H A L I L O V I C H
Y U L D A S H E V, T O H I R A B D U H A L I L O V I C H
state Colin Powell. If true, that effort clearly failed, and Muttawakil next turned
up in the United Arab Emirates, on October 15, announcing his defection from
the Taliban.
Since 2001, some sources have deemed IMU has been declared operationally inactive in Uzbekistan, whereas others strongly disagree. In 2003, U.S.
assistant secretary of state for Europe and Eurasia A. Elizabeth Jones told Congress that the group is still active in the regionparticularly in Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, and Kazakhstanand it represents a serious threat to the
region and therefore to our interests. Russias government banned the IMU in
2006, under an alternative label, the Islamic Party of Turkestan. Kyrgyzs special forces killed an alleged IMU field commander at Kara-Suu in August 2006,
and two months later, the head of organized crime investigations in Tajikistan
told reporters that the Islamic Movement of Turkestan is the Islamic Movement
of Uzbekistan, operating under a cover name created by Uzbek intelligence
agencies. Yuldashev ostensibly controlled the whole network from hiding, in Afghanistan, until the drone attack claimed his life in September 2009.
His death did not destroy the IMU, nor did the killing of successor Abu
Usman Adil by another U.S. drone aircraft in in April 2012. Deputy Usman
Ghazi succeeded Adil, and 10 alleged IMU members faced trial in Paris, on December 3, 2012, for collecting millions of euros from mosques in French cities,
sending the cash to finance terrorist operations between 2003 and 2008.
Further Reading
Akbarzadeh, Shahram. Uzbekistan and the United States: Authoritarianism, Islamism and
Washingtons New Security Agenda. London: Zed Books, 2005.
Carlisle, Donald. Uzbekistan Under Russian Rule: Communism, Nationalism and Islam in
Central Asia. New York: Routledge, 2006.
Marat, Erica. The Military and the State in Central Asia: From Red Army to Independence.
New York: Routledge, 2009.
Melvin, Neil. Uzbekistan: Transition to Authoritarianism on the Silk Road. Amsterdam:
Harwood Academic Publishers, 2000.
Rasanayagam, Johan. Islam in Post-Soviet Uzbekistan: The Morality of Experience. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
647
Z
ZAPATA SALAZAR, EMILIANO (18791919)
In April 1919, Colonel Jess Maria Guajardo of the Mexican army issued a
surprise invitation to Emiliano Zapata Salazar, commander of the revolutionary
Southern Liberation Army. After pursuing Zapata for the past six years, on behalf
of General Pablo Gonzlez Garza and President Venustiano Carranza, Guajardo
now suggested that he might be ready to defect and join Zapata in opposing the
Carranza government. To prove it, he had recently attacked an army column,
killing 57 soldiers as a sign of dedication to the revolution. Zapata kept their
appointment on April 10, at the Hacienda de San Juan in Chinameca, in the
state of Morelos. On arrival, Zapata was greeted by an honor guard presenting
armsuntil a bugle blared and the soldiers fired on Zapata from point-blank
range, killing him instantly. Guajardo then delivered Zapatas corpse to General
Gonzlez at Cuautla, expecting a reward, but reportedly received only half the
amount originally promised.
Emiliano Zapata was born at Anenecuilco, Morelos, on August 8, 1879, the
ninth of ten children in an impoverished family. Mexicos quasi-feudal system,
established by President Porfirio Daz in 1876, bound peasants to the land and
generally crushed any hope of upward mobility. Zapata received a limited education, and worked full time to support his family after his father died in 1895.
Marriage to the daughter of a middle-class family spared him from abject peonage, but Zapata remained unsatisfied, dabbling in revolutionary politics from
1906 onward. A brief stint in military service, during 1908, failed to curb his
inbred opposition to Mexicos ruling elite, and in 1909 Zapata won election
as council president of Anenecuilco with a program of agrarian reform. When
Governor Pablo Escandn y Barrn resisted those reforms, Zapata began to expropriate land at gunpoint.
In 1910, Zapata supported Francisco Maderos electoral challenge to President Daz. Daz responded by imprisoning Madero, but Madero escaped from
custody and fled to Texas, where he drafted the Plan of St. Luis Potosi, calling for rebellion against the ruling regime. The Mexican Revolution formally
began in November 1910, with Madero directing field commanders Pascual
Orozco and Francisco Pancho Villa from his provisional capital in El Paso.
After losing Juarez to his opposition in May 1911, Daz fled to exile in France,
and Madero won election as his successor. The new president carried out
some land reforms, but Zapata was dissatisfied and recognized Orozco as the
650
Z A PATA S A L A Z A R , E M I L I A N O
revolutions rightful leader in November 1911. His own Plan of Ayala, drafted
at the same time, demanded return of all land seized under Daz to its rightful peasant owners, a condition that Madero could not bring himself to meet.
Allied with Orozco and Emiliano Vzquez Gmez, Zapata led his Liberation
Army of the South in pursuit of Reforma, Libertad, Ley y JusticiaReform,
Freedom, Law and Justice. He branded President Madero a counterrevolutionary, skirmishing with federal troops in southern Mexico, as far north as
Mexico City. Madero assigned Panch Villa and Jos Victoriano Huerta Mrquez
to defeat Zapata, who, by early 1912, had been proclaimed Supreme Chief of
the Revolutionary Movement of the South. Fighting under the motto Its better to die on your feet than to live on your knees, Zapata continued his efforts
to topple Madero, but General Huerta staged a preemptive strike in February
1913, conspiring with U.S. ambassador Henry Lane Wilson and a nephew of
Porfirio Daz to seize the presidency and execute Madero. That move officially
ended Mexicos civil warwhile leaving Huerta branded as El Chacal (The
Jackal) or El Usurpador (The Usurper)but it brought no peace.
Huerta had barely occupied the presidents office when Venustiano Carranza
announced his Plan of Guadalupe, calling for creation of a Constitutional Army
to depose Huertas dictatorship. Zapata supported that movement, joined by
Pancho Villa and lvaro Obregn Salido, defeating Huertas forces at the Battle
of Zacatecas in June 1914, forcing his resignation and departure for Jamaica
in July. Francisco Carvajal y Gual briefly succeeded Huerta, handing power to
Carranza on August 20, then departed for New Orleans.
Still, peace remained elusive. Neither Zapata nor Villa had signed Carranzas
Plan of Guadalupe, and Villa in particular despised the new presidenta feeling returned in full measure by Carranza. Villa continued his guerrilla raids,
in defiance of orders from Carranza, while lvaro Obregn backed the new
president and Zapata watched from the southern sidelines, generally more
supportive of Villa than Carranza. In October 1914, Carranza summoned his
opponents to the Convention of Aguascalientes, seeking to resolve their differences, but the effort quickly went awry. Neither Zapata nor Villa attended in
person, but their supporters hijacked the convention, declared themselves sovereign, and elected Eulalio Gutirrez Ortiz as president of republic, while naming Villa to command a new Conventionalist Army, battling against Carranzas
Constitutionalists. President Gutirrez fled from Mexico City in January 1915
and formally resigned six months later, after branding both Carranza and Villa
traitors to Mexicos revolutionary spirit.
So the chaotic war continued, with General Obregn hunting Pancho
Villa in northern Mexico, joined by U.S. troops staged cross-border raids
in early 1916, while General Pablo Gonzlez stalked Zapata in the south.
In that pursuit, Gonzlez adopted a policy of scorched earth and mass executions, capturing Zapatista headquarters at Tlaltizapan in June 1916.
Z A PATA S A L A Z A R , E M I L I A N O
651
652
ZHANG ZUOLIN
Further Reading
Brunk, Samuel. Emiliano Zapata! Revolution and Betrayal in Mexico. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1995.
Mclynn, Frank. Villa and Zapata. New York: Basic Books, 2002.
Parrkinson, Roger. Zapata: A Biography. New York: Stein & Day, 1975.
Womack, John. Zapata and the Mexican Revolution. New York: Vintage Books, 1970.
ZHANG ZUOLIN
Zhang Zuolin was born at Haicheng, in southern Fengtian Province, sometime in 1875. His family was poor, and Zhangnicknamed Pimple in his
youthacquired little formal education, though he did achieve a smattering
of amateur veterinary skill while hunting and working in stables. A brawler by
nature, he became affiliated with one of Manchurias numerous outlaw gangs,
and by his 20s led his own band of armed brigands on horseback. During the
so-called Boxer Rebellion of 18981901, Zhang and his bandits joined the
Qing Dynastys imperial army in a futile attempt to expel Western elements
from China, earning a reputation as the Mukden Tiger in the process. Three
years later, in the Russo-Japanese War of 19041905, Zhang and his men
served Japan as mercenaries, battling Russian troops in Manchuria and along
the Russo-Chinese border.
In October 1911, republican forces led by the Tongmenghui (Chinese United
League) and Gelaohui (Elder Brothers Society) rebelled against Emperor Puyi,
toppling the Qing Dynasty in February 1912. Zhang and his troops resisted the
new order, intimidating would-be rebels as the head of a Manchurian Peoples
Peacekeeping Council. When revolutionary leader Sun Yat-sen declared himself president of a new Chinese republic, based in Nanking (now Nanjing),
monarchist Yuan Shikai reached out to Zhang from Beijing, seeking support for
the resistance. Meanwhile, Yuan struck a bargain with Sun Yat-sen, arranging
Emperor Puyis abdication in exchange for Suns support in a presidential election scheduled for March 1912. Within a year, Yuan moved to suppress Suns
Kuomintang (Chinese Nationalist Party), and in December 1915 he declared
himself the new emperor of China.
Zhang supported the new imperial regime, defeating an attempt by the
Kuomintang and Japans Kwantung Army to expel him from Manchuria. Chastened by that experience, Beijing named Zhang the superintendent of military
affairs for Fengtian Province, promoting him to serve as both the civil and
military governor after Yuan Shikais death in June 1916. Still a Qing loyalist at heart, Zhang conspired with like-minded General Zhang Xun to restore
Emperor Puyi to his throne. At the last moment, however, while Zhang Xun
marched to Beijing on July 1, 1917, Zhang Zuolin withheld his critical support, thereby dooming the rebellion, which collapsed 12 days later. In fact, he
used the debacle to increase his own power, first seizing Heilongjiang Province
for himself, then captured Jilin Province, securing control over all of Manchuria except for the southeastern quadrant occupied by Japan.
By 1918, Zhang Zuolin ranked among Chinas most powerful warlords. His
nearest rival, the Beiyang (North Ocean) Army, was fragmented after Yuan
Shikais death, distracted by internecine conflict while Zhang consolidated his
power. After two wars with a rival force commanded by Cao Kun, warlord of
Zhili Province (now Hebei), in 1922 and 1924, Zhang joined in a provisional
653
654
ZHANG ZUOLIN
ZORIG, SANJAASUREN
Shai, Aron. Zhang Xueliang: The General Who Never Fought. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012.
Spence, Johnathan. The Search for Modern China. New York: Norton & Sons, 1991.
655
656
ZO R I G, S A N JA A S U R E N
to Ulan Bator as a teacher for the Mongolian Revolutionary Youth League, then
lectured on scientific communism at the National University of Mongolia. His
family history, meanwhile, undermined commitment to doctrinaire tenets prescribed from Moscow. In 1988, he founded a New Generation movement of
college-age dissidents pledged to spread democracy throughout Mongolia. On
December 10, 1989, Zorig led a demonstration by 200 protesters seeking free
elections and a free-market economy. A month later, as a member of the Democratic Party of Mongolia, he began staging regular weekend protests in Ulan Bators Skhbaatar Square, growing in size through February 1990.
Mongolias communist regime, led by Jambyn Batmnkh since 1984, initially resisted any democratic reforms, but Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev influenced Russias client state with his policies of perestroika (reconstruction)
and glasnost (openness). In March 1990, the Mongolian Politburo resigned
en masse, thereby ending one-party rule nationwide. Three months later, Zorig
was elected to a seat in the Peoples Great Khural (national assembly). That
body, in turn, was reconstituted in 1992 as the unicameral State Great Khural,
with Zorig first elected as a minority member, then reelected in 1996 as a leading spokesman for the dominant Democratic Union Coalition, defeating the
now ex-communist Mongolian Peoples Party.
In April 1998, Prime Minister Tsakhiagiin Elbegdorj named Zorig to
serve as his minister for infrastructure, but the new government soon foundered on an unexpected crisis. Shortly after taking office as Prime Minister,
Elbegdorj sold the state-owned Reconstruction Bank to Mongolias largest
privately owned banking firm, the Golomt Bank, controlled by members
of the Democratic Union Coalition. Furious members of the Mongolian
Peoples Party staged a walkout from the State Great Khural, thereby forcing Elbegdorjs resignation. An urgent conference between rival party leaders settled on Zorig as a compromise successor to Elbegdorj, with public
announcement of his selection scheduled for October 5. His murder, three
days prior to that declaration, foiled the plan.
In place of Zorig, Janlavyn Narantsatsralt became Mongolias new prime
minister, in December 1998. He held the post until July 1999, when a furor
over the wording of a letter to Russias first deputy prime minister on the subject of copper-mining rights forced his resignation in turn. Soon after Zorigs
murder, voters sent his sister Sanjaasrengiin Oyuun to the State Great Khural,
and she later served as Mongolias minister of foreign affairs. Well known for
her belief that Zorig was slain to prevent him from interfering with government
corruption, Oyuun founded the Civil Will Party (now the Civil Will-Green
Party) in March 2000, pursuing liberal policies with an emphasis on environmentalism. In Mongolian, the new partys nameIrgenii Zorig Namincluded
her martyred brothers name.
ZORIG, SANJAASUREN
Further Reading
Batbayar, Tsedenambyn and Sharad Soni. Modern Mongolia: A Concise History.
New Delhi: Pentagon Press, 2007.
Bawden, Charles. Modern History of Mongolia. London: Routledge, 2002.
Bosson, James. Modern Mongolia. Richmond, Surrey, United Kingdom: Curzon Press,
1997.
Rossabi, Morris. Modern Mongolia: From Khans to Commissars to Capitalists. Berkeley:
University of California Press, 2005.
Sabloff, Paula, ed. Modern Mongolia: Reclaiming Genghis Khan. Philadelphia: Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, 2001.
657
PRIMARY DOCUMENTS
Document 1
ASSASSINATION OF POMPEY THE GREAT
(48 BCE)PLUTARCHS DESCRIPTION OF
THE MURDER OF POMPEY IN EGYPT
On August 9, 48 BCE, the Battle of Pharsalus, a decisive encounter of the Roman
civil war, was fought in central Greece between the forces of Julius Caesar and those
of the Roman senate commanded by Pompey (Gnaeus Pompeius). Caesars victory
forced the senatorial leaders to flee, with Pompey deciding to go to Egypt. As Pompey approached, the advisors of the young Egyptian ruler, Ptolemy XIII, debated
the advisability of offering Pompey refuge. Believing such a decision would offend
Caesar, who was known to also be sailing to Egypt, the kings eunuch Pothinus successfully argued that Pompey should be killed. Accordingly, when Pompey landed
in Egypt on September 28, 48 BCE, he was met and murdered on the shore by a
party that included Achillas, one of the guardians of Ptolemy XIII, and Septimius,
the commander of Roman troops serving in the Egyptian army. Pompeys body was
cremated where it fell by his servant Philip, and his head and seal were presented
to Caesar upon the latters arrival in Egypt. Angered rather than pleased by the
treacherous murder of his former friend and son-in-law, Caesar ordered the executions of both Pothinus and Achillas.
So when it was decided that he should fly to Egypt, he set sail from Cyprus on a Seleucian trireme with his wife (of the rest, some sailed along with
him in ships of war like his own, and others in merchant vessels), and crossed
the sea in safety; but on learning that Ptolemy was posted at Pelusium with
an army, making war upon his sister, he put in there, and sent on a messenger to announce his arrival to the king and to ask his aid. Now, Ptolemy was
quite young; but Potheinus, who managed all his affairs, assembled a council
of the most influential men (and those were most influential whom he wished
to be so), and bade each one give his opinion. It was certainly a dreadful thing
that the fate of Pompey the Great was to be decided by Potheinus the eunuch,
and Theodotus of Chios, who was a hired teacher of rhetoric, and Achillas the
Egyptian; for these were the chief counsellors of the king among the chamberlains and tutors also gathered there. And it was such a tribunals verdict which
Pompey, tossing at anchor some distance of the shore, was waiting for, a man
who would not deign to be under obligations to Caesar for his life.
The opinions of the other counsellors were so far divergent that some advised to drive Pompey away, and others to invite him in and receive him. But
Theodotus, making a display of his powerful speech and rhetorical art, set
forth that neither course was safe for them, but that if they received Pompey,
they would have Caesar for an enemy and Pompey for a master; while if they
662
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
rejected him, Pompey would blame them for casting him off, and Caesar for
making him continue his pursuit; the best course, therefore, was to send for
the man and put him to death, for by doing so they would gratify Caesar and
have nothing to fear from Pompey. To this he smilingly added, we are told,
A dead man does not bite.
Having determined upon this plan, they entrusted the execution of it to
Achillas. So he took with him a certain Septimius, who had once been a
tribune of Pompeys, and Salvius besides, a centurion, with three or four
servants, and put out towards the ship of Pompey. Now, all the most distinguished of Pompeys fellow-voyagers had come aboard of her to see what was
going on. Accordingly, when they saw a reception that was not royal, nor
splendid, nor in accordance with the hopes of Theophanes, but a few men
sailing up in a single fishing-boat, they viewed this lack of respect with suspicion, and advised Pompey to have his ship rowed back into the open sea,
while they were beyond reach of missiles. But meanwhile the boat drew near,
and first Septimius rose up and addressed Pompey in the Roman tongue as
Imperator. Then Achillas saluted him in Greek, and invited him to come
aboard the boat, telling him that the shallows were extensive, and that the
sea, which had a sandy bottom, was not deep enough to float a trireme. At
the same time some of the royal ships were seen to be taking their crews
aboard, and men-at-arms were occupying the shore, so that there seemed to
be no escape even if they changed their minds; and besides, this very lack of
confidence might give the murderers an excuse for their crime. Accordingly,
after embracing Cornelia, who was bewailing his approaching death, he ordered two centurions to go into the boat before him, besides Philip, one of
his freedmen, and a servant named Scythes, and while Achillas was already
stretching out his hand to him from the boat, turned towards his wife and
son and repeated the verses of Sophocles:
Whatever man upon a tyrant takes his way,
His slave he is, even though a freeman when he goes.
After these last words to his friends, he went into the boat. And since it was
a long distance from the trireme to the land, and none of his companions in
the boat had any friendly word for him, turning his eyes upon Septimius he
said: Surely I am not mistaken, and you are an old comrade of mine! Septimius nodded merely, without saying anything to him or showing any friendliness. So then, as there was profound silence again, Pompey took a little roll
containing a speech written by him in Greek, which he had prepared for his
use in addressing Ptolemy, and began to read in it. Then, as they drew near the
shore, Cornelia, together with his friends, stood on the trireme watching with
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F P O M P E Y T H E G R E AT
great anxiety for the outcome, and began to take heart when she saw many
of the kings people assembling at the landing as if to give him an honourable
welcome. But at this point, while Pompey was clasping the hand of Philip that
he might rise to his feet more easily, Septimius, from behind, ran him through
the body with his sword, then Salvius next, and then Achillas, drew their daggers and stabbed him. And Pompey, drawing his toga down over his face with
both hands, without an act or a word that was unworthy of himself, but with
a groan merely, submitted to their blows, being sixty years of age less one, and
ending his life only one day after his birth-day.
When the people on the ships beheld the murder, they uttered a wailing cry
that could be heard as far as the shore, and weighing anchor quickly, took to
flight. And a strong wind came to their aid as they ran out to sea, so that the
Egyptians, though desirous of pursuing, turned back. But they cut off Pompeys
head, and threw the rest of his body unclothed out of the boat, and left it for
those who craved so pitiful a sight. Philip, however, stayed by the body, until
such had taken their fill of gazing; then he washed it in sea-water, wrapped it
in a tunic of his own, and since he had no other supply, sought along the coast
until he found the remnants of a small fishing-boat, old stuff, indeed, but sufficient to furnish a funeral pyre that would answer for an unclothed corpse, and
that too not entire. As he was gathering the wood and building the pyre, there
came up a Roman who was now an old man, but who in his youth had served
his first campaigns with Pompey, and said: Who art thou, my man, that thinkest to give burial rites to Pompey the Great? And when Philip said that he was
his freedman, the man said: But thou shalt not have this honour all to thyself;
let me too share in a pious privilege thus offered, that I may not altogether regret my sojourn in a foreign land, if in requital for many hardships I find this
happiness at least, to touch with my hands and array for burial the greatest of
Roman imperators. Such were the obsequies of Pompey. And on the following day Lucius Lentulus, as he came sailing from Cyprus and coasted along the
shore not knowing what had happened, saw a funeral pyre and Philip standing
besides it, and before he had been seen himself exclaimed: Who, pray, rests
here at the end of his allotted days? Then, after a slight pause and with a groan
he said: But perhaps it is thou, Pompey the Great! And after a little he went
ashore, was seized, and put to death.
This was the end of Pompey. But not long afterwards Caesar came to Egypt,
and found it filled with this great deed of abomination. From the man who
brought him Pompeys head he turned away with loathing, as from an assassin;
and on receiving Pompeys seal-ring, he burst into tears; the device was a lion
holding a sword in his paws. But Achillas and Potheinus he put to death. The
king himself, moreover, was defeated in battle along the river, and disappeared.
Theodotus the sophist, however, escaped the vengeance of Caesar; for he fled
663
664
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F J U L I US C A E SA R
out of Egypt and wandered about in wretchedness and hated of all men. But
Marcus Brutus, after he had slain Caesar and come into power, discovered him
in Asia, and put him to death with every possible torture. The remains of Pompey were taken to Cornelia, who gave them burial at his Alban villa.
Source: Plutarch Lives: Agesilaus and Pompey. Pelopidas and Marcellus. Translated
by Bernadotte Perrin. Vol. 5. Loeb Classical Library 87. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1917, 31829.
Document 2
ASSASSINATION OF JULIUS CAESAR (44 BCE)
LETTER OF BRUTUS TO CICERO ON CAESARS
ASSASSINATION (43 BCE)
Marcus Tullius Cicero, considered one of the greatest Roman orators, was also a lawyer, statesman, philosopher, and author of works on legal, rhetorical, and philosophical subjects. He was also a prolific writer of letters to various professional colleagues,
friends, and family members; these letters provide insight into the social, cultural,
and intellectual life in Rome during the late Republican period. Moreover, because
Cicero was so deeply involved in the complex and competitive political situation of his
day, his letters often contain valuable first-hand observations of many of the influential events, powerful men, and personal rivalries that marked the Roman Republics
tumultuous last decades.
Marcus Junius Brutus, one of the leading conspirators in Julius Caesars assassination in 44 BCE, wrote this letter to Cicero in 43 BCE. Because he was no longer safe at
Rome, where Caesars heir, the young Octavian (the future emperor Augustus, here
called Octavius), was gaining support, Brutus was then living in Crete. In the letter,
he urges Cicero not to underestimate the ambition of Octavian (often called a boy
in the letter), who Brutus sees as a second Caesarthat is, another dictator in the
making. He also asks Cicero to reevaluate his animosity toward Mark Antony, whom
Brutus considers less dangerous than Octavian. Throughout the letter, Brutus appeals
to Ciceros republican idealism and hopes of reviving Roman liberty. Ciceros attempts
to play Octavian against Antony ultimately failed, and he was murdered on Antonys
orders in December 43 BCE. Brutus, defeated in October 42 BCE by the forces of Octavian and Antony at the Battle of Philippi, committed suicide.
I have read a small part of your letter to Octavius, transmitted to me by Atticus. Your zeal and concern for my safety gave me no new pleasure, for it is
not only our common, but our daily news to hear something which you have
said or done with your usual fidelity in support of my honour and dignity. Yet
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F J U L I US C A E SA R
that same part of your letter affected me with the most sensible grief which
my mind could possibly receive. For you compliment him so highly for his
services to the republic, and in a strain so suppliant and abject that what shall
I say? I am ashamed of the wretched state to which we are reduced; yet it must
be said, you recommend my safety to him, (to which what death is not preferable?) and thus make it manifest that our servitude is not yet abolished, but
our master only changed. Recollect your words, and deny them, if you dare,
to be the prayers of a subject to his king. There is one thing, you say, which is
required and expected from him that he would allow those citizens to live in
safety, of whom all honest men and the people of Rome think well. But what if
he will not allow it? Shall we be the less safe for that? It is better not to be safe,
than to be saved by him. For my part, I can never think all the gods so averse
to the preservation of the Roman people, that Octavius must be entreated for
the life of any one citizen; not to say for the deliverers of the world. These are
the lofty terms in which I have a pleasure in declaring myself, and it becomes
me to use this language to those who know not what to fear from, or what to
ask of, any one.
Can you allow Octavius to possess this power, and yet be his friend? Or if
you have any value for me, would you wish to see me at Rome; when it behoves me first to be recommended to this boy, that he would permit me to be
there? What reason can you have to thank him, if you think it necessary to beg
of him that he would suffer us to live in safety? Or is it to be considered a kindness that he chooses to see himself rather than Antony, in the condition to have
such petitions presented to him? One may supplicate, indeed, the successor,
but what need is there to supplicate the abolisher of a tyranny, that those who
have deserved well of the republic may be safe? It was this weakness and despair, not more blameable, indeed, in you than in all, which first incited Caesar
to the ambition of reigning; and after his death encouraged Antony to think of
seizing his place; and which has now raised this boy so high, that you judge
it necessary to address your supplications to him for the preservation of men
such as we are; and that we are to be saved only by the mercy of one, scarcely
yet a man, and by no other means. But if we had remembered ourselves to be
Romans, these infamous men would not be more daring to aim at dominion
than we to repel it; nor would Antony be more encouraged by Caesars reign,
than deterred by his fate. How can you, a consular senator, and the avenger of
so many treasons, (by suppressing which, you have but postponed our ruin,
I fear, for a time) reflect on what you have done, and yet approve these things,
or bear them so tamely, as to seem to approve them?
For what particular quarrel had you with Antony? No other, but that he assumed all this to himself; that our lives should be begged of him; that we from
whom he had received liberty, should hold our safety in precarious dependence upon his will; that the republic should be at his disposal. You thought
665
666
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F J U L I US C A E SA R
it necessary to take arms to arrest his tyranny. But was this done only, that a
stop being put to him, we might carry our submission to another, who might
condescend to be put in his place; or was it that the republic might be its own
mistress: unless after all, our quarrel was not with slavery, but with the conditions of it. No doubt, we might have had an easy master in Antony, and whatever share with him we pleased, could we have been content with such a state
of things: for what could he have denied to those whose tolerance would have
been the best support of his domination. But nothing was of such value to us
as to be worth the sacrifice of our fidelity and liberty. This very boy, whom the
name of Caesar seems to stimulate against the slayers of Caesar, how would he
value (if there were really room to treat with him,) our help towards the attainment of his objects; we being content to live, and to be rich, and to be called
consulars. But Caesar would then have perished in vain. For what reason have
we to rejoice at his death, if still our lot is to be slaves? Let others be as unconcerned as they will; but may the powers of heaven sooner take all from
me, than the determination not to allow to the heir of the man I killed what
I would not allow to the man himself. No, nor would I suffer my father, were
he living, to possess a power above the laws and the senate.
Can you persuade yourself, that any one can be free under him, without
whose leave there is no place for us in that city? Or how is it possible for you,
after all, to obtain what you ask? You ask that he would allow us to be safe.
Shall we then receive safety when we receive life? But how can we receive it,
if we first part with our honour and our liberty? Do you fancy that to live at
Rome is to be safe? It is the thing, and not the place, which must secure that
to me; for I was never safe, while Caesar lived, till I had resolved on that attempt: nor can I be an exile any where as long as I continue to abhor slavery
and contumely beyond all other evils. Is it not to fall back into the same state
of darkness in which we were, when he who has taken upon him the name of
the tyrant must be entreated that the avengers of tyranny may be safe, while
in the cities of Greece the punishment of tyrants is extended to their children?
Can I ever wish to see that city or think it a city, which would not accept liberty when offered, and even forced upon it, but has more dread of the name
of their late king in the person of a boy, than reliance on itself, though it has
seen that very king taken off in the plenitude of his power by the virtue of a
few? If you listen to me, you will no more after this recommend either me or
yourself to this your Caesar. You set a high value on the few years that remain
to you at your age, if for their sake you can become a supplicant to that boy.
Henceforth have a care, lest what you have done and are doing with respect to
Antony, instead of being praised as the effect of magnanimity, be imputed to
fear: for if you are so pleased with Octavius as to petition him for our safety,
you will be thought not to have disliked a master, but to have wanted only a
more friendly one.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F J U L I US C A E SA R
As to your praising him for the things that he has hitherto done, I approve
of it; they deserve to be praised, provided he did them to repel the power of
others, not to advance his own. But when you adjudge him not only to have
this power, but think you ought to submit to it so far as to entreat him that he
would not destroy us, you make him too great a recompense; you give to him
what the republic seemed to enjoy through him. Nor does it seem to occur
to you, that if Octavius deserves any honours, because he makes war against
Antony, that those who extirpated the very evil of which these are but the relics, can never be sufficiently requited by the Roman people, though they were
to heap upon them everything in their power to bestow; but see how much
stronger peoples fears are than their memories; because Antony still lives, and
is in arms.
As to Caesar, all that could and ought to have been done has been done,
and cannot be undone, to be done again in any other manner. Is then Octavius so great a man, that the people of Rome are to wait in suspense his judgment upon us? Or are we so little, that any one man is to be entreated for our
safety? As for me, that I may return to Rome, not only will I not supplicate any
man, but I will restrain those from doing it who are disposed to do it for themselves: or I will remove to a distance from all such who can be slaves, and will
think myself at Rome wherever I can live free, and shall pity you whose fond
desire of life neither age, nor honours, nor the example of other mens virtue
can reduce. For my own part, I shall ever think myself happy, solaced with
the constant and perpetual conviction, that my piety to my country has met
its reward; for what condition can be better than for a man supported by the
recollection of noble actions, and in full content with his liberty, to look with
indifference on all human things. Never will I yield to those who suffer themselves to be trampled upon by others, nor be conquered by those who submit
to be conquered. I will make experiment of all things, and try every resource,
nor will ever desist from dragging our state out of slavery. If that fortune attends me which ought to attend me, we shall all rejoice; if not, still I shall rejoice myself. For how can this life be better spent than in acts and thoughts
which tend to make my countrymen free.
I beseech you, Cicero, not to desert the cause through weariness or want of
confidence. In repelling present evils have your eyes always on the future, lest
it steal upon you before you are aware. Consider that the fortitude and courage with which you delivered the republic, when consul, and again a consular,
are nothing without constancy and perseverance. The case of tried, is, I own,
harder than of untried virtue. We exact services as debts in the former case,
and if disappointed, we feel especially resentful, as persons deceived. Wherefore, for Cicero to withstand Antony, though very commendable, yet because
such a consul promised such a consular, nobody wondered at it: but if the
same Cicero in the case of others should waver at last in that resolution, which
667
668
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F T H E RO M A N E M P E RO R C A L I G U L A
he exerted with such firmness and greatness of mind against Antony, he would
deprive himself not only of the hopes of future glory, but make even his glory
past to disappear. Nothing is great in itself but that in which a determination
of the judgment is apparent. Nor is it the duty of any man more than of you to
shew attachment and devotion to the republic, and to be a patron of liberty;
called upon as you are by your abilities, by the things you have performed, by
the regard and expectation of all men. Wherefore, I hold, that Octavius ought
not to be asked to permit us to live in safety. Rather encourage yourself to think
the city, in which you have done such great things, to be free and honourable,
only so long as there are in it leaders of the people to oppose the designs of the
profligate.
Source: William Roberts. History of Letter-Writing, from the Earliest Period to the
Fifth Century. London: W. Pickering, 1843.
Document 3
ASSASSINATION OF THE ROMAN EMPEROR CALIGULA
(41 CE)SUETONIUSS ACCOUNT OF THE MURDER
Gaius Julius Caesar Augustus Germanicus, known to history as Caligula, became
emperor of Rome in 37 CE upon the death of his great uncle Tiberius. Sources for
the reign of Caligula depict him as cruel, extravagant, sexually perverse, and even
insane. In 41 CE, Cassius Chaerea, commander of the Praetorian Guard, headed
a plot to kill the emperor. Although the actual murder was carried out by Chaerea
and a few others, the conspiracy was supposedly known and approved by many in
the senate and the military command. Chaerea and his colleges are said to have
stabbed Caligula as he passed through an underground passage at the imperial
palace on his way to address a troupe of actors. Hoping to restore the republic, the
conspirators also murdered Caligulas wife Caesonia and his young daughter Julia
Drusilla. The solders of the Praetorian Guard, whose privileged position depended
upon the existence of an emperor, elevated Caligulas uncle Claudius to the imperial
throne, and Claudius ordered the executions of Chaerea and the other assassins.
Reproduced below is the account of Caligulas death written by the Roman historian
Suetonius in about 121 CE.
During this frantic and riotous career several thought of attempting his life.
But when one or two conspiracies had been detected and the rest were waiting
for a favourable opportunity, two men made common cause and succeeded,
with the connivance of his most influential freedmen and the officers of the
praetorian guard; for although the charge that these last were privy to one of
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F T H E RO M A N E M P E RO R C A L I G U L A
the former conspiracies was false, they realised that Caligula hated and feared
them. In fact, he exposed them to great odium by at once taking them aside
and declaring, drawn sword in hand, that he would kill himself, if they too
thought he deserved death; and from that time on he never ceased accusing
them one to the other and setting them all at odds.
When they had decided to attempt his life at the exhibition of the Palatine games, as he went out at noon, Cassius Chaerea, tribune of a cohort of
the praetorian guard, claimed for himself the principal part; for Gaius used to
taunt him, a man already well on in years, with voluptuousness and effeminacy by every form of insult. When he asked for the watchword Gaius would
give him Priapus or Venus, and when Chaerea had occasion to thank him
for anything, he would hold out his hand to kiss, forming and moving it in an
obscene fashion.
His approaching murder was foretold by many prodigies. The statue of
Jupiter at Olympia, which he had ordered to be taken to pieces and moved
to Rome, suddenly uttered such a peal of laughter that the scaffoldings collapsed and the workmen took to their heels; and at once a man called Cassius turned up, who declared that he had been bidden in a dream to sacrifice
a bull to Jupiter. The Capitol at Capua was struck by lightning on the Ides
of March, and also the room of the doorkeeper of the Palace at Rome. Some
inferred from the latter omen that danger was threatened to the owner at
the hands of his guards; and from the former, the murder of a second distinguished personage, such as had taken place long before on that same day.
The soothsayer Sulla too, when Gaius consulted him about his horoscope,
declared that inevitable death was close at hand. The lots of Fortune at Antium warned him to beware of Cassius, and he accordingly ordered the death
of Cassius Longinus, who was at the time proconsul of Asia, forgetting that
the family name of Chaerea was Cassius. The day before he was killed he
dreamt that he stood in heaven beside the throne of Jupiter and that the
god struck him with the toe of his right foot and hurled him to earth. Some
things which had happened on that very day shortly before he was killed
were also regarded as portents. As he was sacrificing, he was sprinkled with
the blood of a flamingo, and the pantomimic actor Mnester danced a tragedy
which the tragedian Neoptolemus had acted years before during the games
at which Philip king of the Macedonians was assassinated. In a farce called
Laureolus, in which the chief actor falls as he is making his escape and
vomits blood, several understudies so vied with one another in giving evidence of their proficiency that the stage swam in blood. A nocturnal performance besides was rehearsing, in which scenes from the lower world were
represented by Egyptians and Aethiopians.
On the ninth day before the Kalends of February at about the seventh hour
he hesitated whether or not to get up for luncheon, since his stomach was still
669
670
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F T H E RO M A N E M P E RO R C A L I G U L A
disordered from excess of food on the day before, but at length he came out
at the persuasion of his friends. In the covered passage through which he had
to pass, some boys of good birth, who had been summoned from Asia to appear on the stage, were rehearsing their parts, and he stopped to watch and to
encourage them; and had not the leader of the troop complained that he had
a chill, he would have returned and had the performance given at once. From
this point there are two versions of the story: some say that as he was talking
with the boys, Chaerea came up behind, and gave him a deep cut in the neck,
having first cried, Take that, and that then the tribune Cornelius Sabinus,
who was the other conspirator and faced Gaius, stabbed him in the breast.
Others say that Sabinus, after getting rid of the crowd through centurions who
were in the plot, asked for the watchword, as soldiers do, and that when Gaius
gave him Jupiter, he cried So be it, and as Gaius looked around, he split
his jawbone with a blow of his sword. As he lay upon the ground and with
writhing limbs called out that he still lived, the others dispatched him with
thirty wounds; for the general signal was Strike again. Some even thrust their
swords through his privates. At the beginning of the disturbance his bearers
ran to his aid with their poles, and presently the Germans of his body-guard,
and they slew several of his assassins, as well as some inoffensive senators.
He lived twenty-nine years and ruled three years, ten months and eight days.
His body was conveyed secretly to the gardens of the Lamian family, where it
was partly consumed on a hastily erected pyre and buried beneath a light covering of turf; later his sisters on their return from exile dug it up, cremated
it, and consigned it to the tomb. Before this was done, it is well known that
the caretakers of the gardens were disturbed by ghosts, and that in the house
where he was slain not a night passed without some fearsome apparition, until
at last the house itself was destroyed by fire. With him died his wife Caesonia,
stabbed with a sword by a centurion, while his daughters brains were dashed
out against a wall.
One may form an idea of the state of those times by what followed. Not even
after the murder was made known was it at once believed that he was dead,
but it was suspected that Gaius himself had made up and circulated the report,
to find out by that means how men felt towards him. The conspirators too had
not agreed on a successor, and the senate was so unanimously in favour of reestablishing the republic that the consuls called the first meeting, not in the
senate house, because it had the name Julia, but in the Capitol; while some in
expressing their views proposed that the memory of the Caesars be done away
with and their temples destroyed. Men further observed and commented on
the fact that all the Caesars whose forename was Gaius perished by the sword,
beginning with the one who was slain in the times of Cinna.
Source: Suetonius. The Lives of the Twelve Caesars. Translated by J. C. Rolfe. London, 191314, 5660.
D E AT H O F W I L L I A M I I , K I N G O F E N G L A N D
Document 4
DEATH OF WILLIAM II, KING OF ENGLAND
(1100)DESCRIPTION OF WILLIAMS DEATH
BY CHRONICLER PETER OF BLOIS
On August 2, 1100, King William II (known as William Rufus), the son of William I,
the Conqueror, was killed by an arrow while hunting in the New Forest. The arrow
was supposedly shot by Walter Tirel, a member of the hunting party who was later
described as a skilled bowman. Although initial accounts seemed to indicate that the
kings death was an accident, an act of God that brought down divine retribution on
a cruel and wicked king, later historians have seen the death as an assassinated,
perhaps plotted by Williams brother Henry, who in the hunting party that day
and who succeeded his brother on the throne as Henry I. Whereas the assassination
theory is accepted by many modern historians, the death of William II is still controversial. Reproduced below is an account of the kings death written by Peter of Blois
(1070c. 1117), who was a continuator of the possibly spurious chronicle of Ingulf.
Peter, like many chroniclers of the time, viewed William II as a tyrant.
William Rufus reigning over the land, and having with a powerful arm conquered all his adversaries, so much so as to have brought all his foes beneath
the yoke, while there was no one who dared in any way to murmur against
his sway, Ranulph, the bishop of Durham, was his especial adviser in affairs of
state. This Ranulph proved a most cruel extortioner, and being the most avaricious and most abandoned of all men in the land, woefully oppressed the
whole kingdom, and wrung it even to the drawing of blood; while at the same
time Anselm, the most holy archbishop of Canterbury who had succeeded
Lanfranc, dragging out a weary existence in exile beyond sea, mercy and truth
with him had taken to flight from out of the land, and justice and peace had
been banished therefrom. Confession and the fair graces of repentance fell into
disesteem, holiness and chastity utterly sickened away, sin stalked in the streets
with open and undaunted front, and facing the law with haughty eye, daily triumphed, exulting in her abominable success.
Wherefore, the heavens did abominate the land, and, fighting against sinners, the sun and the moon stood still in their abode, and spurning the earth
with the greatest noise and fury, caused all nations to be amazed at their numerous portents. For there were thunders terrifying the earth, lightnings and thunderbolts most frequent, deluging showers without number, winds of the most
astonishing violence, and whirlwinds that shook the towers of churches and
levelled them with the ground. On the earth there were fountains flowing with
blood, and mighty earthquakes, while the sea, overflowing its shores, wrought
infinite calamities to the maritime places. There were murders and dreadful seditions; the Devil himself was seen bodily appearing in many woods; there was
671
672
a most shocking famine, and a pestilence so great among men, as well as beasts
of burden, that agriculture was almost totally neglected as well as all care of the
living, all sepulture of the dead.
The limit and termination at last of so many woes, was the death of the king,
a cause, to every person of Christian feelings, of extreme grief. For there had
come from Normandy, to visit king William, a very powerful baron, Walter
Tirel by name. The king received him with the most lavish hospitality, and
having honored him with a seat at his table, was pleased, after the banquet
was concluded, to give him an invitation to join him in the sport of hunting.
After the king had pointed out to each person his fixed station, and the deer,
alarmed at the barking of the dogs and the cries of the huntsmen, were swiftly
flying towards the summits of the hills, the said Walter incautiously aimed an
arrow at a stag, which missed the stag, and pierced the king in the breast.
The king fell to the earth, and instantly died; upon which, the body being
laid by a few countrymen in a cart, was carried back to the palace, and on the
morrow was buried, with but few manifestations of grief, and in an humble
tomb; for all his servants were busily attending to their own interests, and few
or none cared for the royal funeral. The said Walter, the author of his death,
though unwittingly so, escaped from the midst of them, crossed the sea, and
arrived safe home in Normandy.
Source: Ingulfs Chronicle of the Abbey of Croyland with the Continuation of Peter
of Blois. Translated by Henry T. Riley. London: Henry G. Bohn, 1854, 22930.
Document 5
MURDER OF ARCHBISHOP THOMAS BECKET (1170)
THE EYEWITNESS ACCOUNT OF EDWARD GRIM
On December 29, 1170, four knights entered Canterbury Cathedral and murdered
Thomas Becket, the Archbishop of Canterbury, as he prepared to say Mass. The murder was the culmination of a long quarrel between Becket and his former friend, King
Henry II of England. At contention was the right of royal courts to try clergymen; the
king maintained this right, whereas Becket denounced it as an infringement of the
rights and privileges of the English Church. According to tradition, Henry, exasperated by Beckets excommunication of three English bishops, cried out Will no one rid
me of this turbulent priest? What Henry actually said is uncertain, but, whatever
his words, they were interpreted as a call to action by Reginald FitzUrse, Hugh de
Morville, William de Tracy, and Richard le Breton. The four knights left France,
where Henry was holding court, and returned to England, where they confronted and
killed Becket in his cathedral. After the murder, Becket was held to be a saint and
Canterbury Cathedral became an important pilgrimage site until the Becket shrine
was dismantled in 1538 by order of Henry VIII. Reproduced below is an account
of the murder written by Edward Grim, who was present in the cathedral on December 29, and who was himself injured in an attempt to assist the archbishop.
After the monks took [Thomas] through the doors of the church, the four
aforementioned knights followed behind with a rapid pace. A certain subdeacon, Hugh the Evil-clerk, named for his wicked offense and armed with their
malice, went with themshowing no reverence for either God or the saints
because by following them he condoned their deed. When the holy archbishop entered the cathedral the monks who were glorifying God abandoned
vesperswhich they had begun to celebrate for Godand ran to their father
whom they had heard was dead but they saw alive and unharmed. They hastened to close the doors of the church in order to bar the enemies from slaughtering the bishop, but the wondrous athlete turned toward them and ordered
that the doors be opened. It is not proper, he said, that a house of prayer, a
church of Christ, be made a fortress since although it is not shut up, it serves
as a fortification for his people; we will triumph over the enemy through suffering rather than by fightingand we come to suffer, not to resist. Without
delay the sacrilegious men entered the house of peace and reconciliation with
swords drawn; indeed the sight alone as well as the rattle of arms inflicted not
a small amount of horror on those who watched. And those knights who approached the confused and disordered people who had been observing vespers
but, by now, had run toward the lethal spectacle exclaimed in a rage: Where
is Thomas Becket, traitor of the king and kingdom? No one responded and
instantly they cried out more loudly, Where is the archbishop? Unshaken he
replied to this voice as it is written, The righteous will be like a bold lion and
free from fear, he descended from the steps to which he had been taken by the
monks who were fearful of the knights and said in an adequately audible voice,
Here I am, not a traitor of the king but a priest; why do you seek me? And
[Thomas], who had previously told them that he had no fear of them added,
Here I am ready to suffer in the name of He who redeemed me with His blood;
God forbid that I should flee on account of your swords or that I should depart
from righteousness. With these wordsat the foot of a pillarhe turned to
the right. On one side was the altar of the blessed mother of God, on the other
the altar of the holy confessor Benedictthrough whose example and prayers
he had been crucified to the world and his lusts; he endured whatever the
murderers did to him with such constancy of the soul that he seemed as if he
were not of flesh. The murderers pursued him and asked, Absolve and restore
to communion those you have excommunicated and return to office those who
have been suspended. To these words [Thomas] replied, No penance has
been made, so I will not absolve them. Then you, they said, will now die
673
674
and will suffer what you have earned. And I, he said, am prepared to die
for my Lord, so that in my blood the church will attain liberty and peace; but
in the name of Almighty God I forbid that you hurt my men, either cleric or
layman, in any way. The glorious martyr acted conscientiously with foresight
for his men and prudently on his own behalf, so that no one near him would
be hurt as he hastened toward Christ. It was fitting that the soldier of the Lord
and the martyr of the Savior adhered to His words when he was sought by the
impious, If it is me you seek, let them leave.
With rapid motion they laid sacrilegious hands on him, handling and dragging him roughly outside of the walls of the church so that there they would
slay him or carry him from there as a prisoner, as they later confessed. But when
it was not possible to easily move him from the column, he bravely pushed one
[of the knights] who was pursuing and drawing near to him; he called him
a panderer saying, Dont touch me, Rainaldus, you who owes me faith and
obedience, you who foolishly follow your accomplices. On account of the
rebuff the knight was suddenly set on fire with a terrible rage and, wielding
a sword against the sacred crown said, I dont owe faith or obedience to you
that is in opposition to the fealty I owe my lord king. The invincible martyr
seeing that the hour which would bring the end to his miserable mortal life
was at hand and already promised by God to be the next to receive the crown
of immortalitywith his neck bent as if he were in prayer and with his joined
hands elevated abovecommended himself and the cause of the Church to
God, St. Mary, and the blessed martyr St. Denis.
He had barely finished speaking when the impious knight, fearing that
[Thomas] would be saved by the people and escape alive, suddenly set upon
him and, shaving off the summit of his crown which the sacred chrism consecrated to God, he wounded the sacrificial lamb of God in the head; the lower
arm of the writer was cut by the same blow. Indeed [the writer] stood firmly
with the holy archbishop, holding him in his armswhile all the clerics and
monks fleduntil the one he had raised in opposition to the blow was severed. Behold the simplicity of the dove, behold the wisdom of the serpent in
this martyr who presented his body to the killers so that he might keep his
head, in other words his soul and the church, safe; nor would he devise a trick
or a snare against the slayers of the flesh so that he might preserve himself because it was better that he be free from this nature! O worthy shepherd who
so boldly set himself against the attacks of wolves so that the sheep might not
be torn to pieces! and because he abandoned the world, the worldwanting
to overpower himunknowingly elevated him. Then, with another blow received on the head, he remained firm. But with the third the stricken martyr
bent his knees and elbows, offering himself as a living sacrifice, saying in a low
voice, For the name of Jesus and the protection of the church I am ready to
embrace death. But the third knight inflicted a grave wound on the fallen one;
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A L B E R T I O F H A B S B U RG
with this blow he shattered the sword on the stone and his crown, which was
large, separated from his head so that the blood turned white from the brain
yet no less did the brain turn red from the blood; it purpled the appearance of
the church with the colors of the lily and the rose, the colors of the Virgin and
Mother and the life and death of the confessor and martyr. The fourth knight
drove away those who were gathering so that the others could finish the murder more freely and boldly. The fifthnot a knight but a cleric who entered
with the knightsso that a fifth blow might not be spared him who had imitated Christ in other things, placed his foot on the neck of the holy priest and
precious martyr and (it is horrible to say) scattered the brains with the blood
across the floor, exclaiming to the rest, We can leave this place, knights, he
will not get up again.
But during all these incredible things the martyr displayed the virtue of perseverance. Neither his hand nor clothes indicated that he had opposed a murdereras is often the case in human weakness; nor when stricken did he utter
a word, nor did he let out a cry or a sigh, or a sign signaling any kind of pain;
instead he held still the head that he had bent toward the unsheathed swords.
As his bodywhich had been mingled with blood and brainlaid on the
ground as if in prayer, he placed his soul in Abrahams bosom. Having risen
above himself, without doubt, out of love for the Creator and wholly striving
for celestial sweetness, he easily received whatever pain, whatever malice, the
bloody murderer was able to inflict. And how intrepidlyhow devotedly and
courageouslyhe offered himself for the murder when it was made clear that
for his salvation and faith this martyr should fight for the protection of others
so that the affairs of the church might be managed according to its paternal traditions and decrees.
Source: Edward Grim. Vita S. Thomae, Cantuariensis Archepiscopi et Martyris. In
James Robertson, ed., Materials for the Life of Thomas Becket. Vol. II. London:
Rolls Series, 187585.
Document 6
ASSASSINATION OF ALBERT I OF
HABSBURG (1308)ACT V, SCENE 2 OF THE PLAY
WILHELM TELL BY FRIEDRICH SCHILLER (1804)
On May 1, 1308, Albert I, the first king of Germany from the House of Habsburg,
was murdered as he crossed the Reuss River near Windisch. The assassin was Alberts nephew, Duke John of Swabia, who was henceforth known as John the Parricide or John Parricida. Albert had become separated from his attendants, when a
675
676
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A L B E R T I O F H A B S B U RG
small party on horseback led by John attacked the German king. John, without any
warning, supposedly charged his uncle and split his skull with a sword. The murder
apparently stemmed from Johns belief that he had been deprived of his inheritance
by Albert, who had forced his younger brother, Johns father, to waive his rights to
the duchies of Austria and Styria. John virtually disappears from the historical record after 1308. Reproduced here is Act V, Scene 2 of Friedrich Schillers 1804 play
Wilhem Tell, in which Tell encounters Duke John, who is on the run after murdering his uncle. John begs for Tells help, saying that, like Tell, he had taken proper
vengeance on an enemy. Tell rejects the dukes arguments and advises him to seek
papal absolution for his crime.
TELL (to the Monk).
You are the Duke Of AustriaI know it.
You have slain The Emperor, your uncle and liege lord.
JOHN.
He robbd me of my patrimony.
TELL.
How! Slain himyour king, your uncle! And the earth
Still bears you! And the sun still shines on you!
JOHN.
Tell, hear me; are you
TELL.
Reeking, with the blood
Of him that was your Emperor, your kinsman,
Dare you set foot within my spotless house,
Dare to an honest man to show your face,
And claim the rights of hospitality?
JOHN.
I hoped to find compassion at your hands.
You took, like me, revenge upon your foe!
TELL.
Unhappy man! Dare you confound the crime
Of blood-imbrued ambition with the act
Forced on a father in mere self-defence?
Had you to shield your childrens darling heads,
To guard your firesides sanctuaryward off
The last, the direst doom from all you loved?
To Heaven I raise my unpolluted hands,
To curse your act and you! I have avenged
That holy nature which you have profaned.
I have no part with you. You murdered, I
Have shielded all that was most dear to me.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A L B E R T I O F H A B S B U RG
JOHN.
You cast me off to comfortless despair!
TELL.
I shrink with horror while I talk with you.
Hence, on the dread career you have begun!
Cease to pollute the home of innocence!
[John turns to depart.]
JOHN.
I cannot and I will not live this life!
TELL.
And yet my soul bleeds for you. Gracious Heaven,
So young, of such a noble line, the grandson
Of Rudolph, once my lord and Emperor,
An outcastmurdererstanding at my door,
The poor mans doora suppliant, in despair!
[Covers his face.]
JOHN.
If you have power to weep, oh let my fate
Move your compassionit is horrible!
I amsay, rather wasa prince. I might
Have been most happy, had I only curbd
The impatience of my passionate desires:
But envy gnawd my heartI saw the youth
Of mine own cousin Leopold endowd
With honour, and enrichd with broad domains,
The while myself, of equal age with him,
In abject slavish nonage was kept back.
TELL.
Unhappy man, your uncle knew you well,
When from you land and subjects he withheld!
You, by your mad and desperate act have set
A fearful seal upon his wise resolve.
Where are the bloody partners of your crime?
JOHN.
Whereer the avenging furies may have borne them;
I have not seen them since the luckless deed.
TELL.
Know you the Empires ban is out,that you
Are interdicted to your friends, and given
An outlawd victim to your enemies!
JOHN.
Therefore I shun all public thoroughfares,
677
678
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A L B E R T I O F H A B S B U RG
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A L B E R T I O F H A B S B U RG
TELL.
I will describe the road, so mark me well!
You must ascend, keeping along the Reuss,
Which from the mountains dashes wildly down.
JOHN (in alarm).
What! See the Reuss? The witness of my deed!
TELL. The road you take lies through the rivers gorge,
And many a cross proclaims where travellers
Have been by avalanches done to death.
JOHN.
I have no fear for natures terrors, so
I can appease the torments of my soul.
TELL.
At every cross, kneel down and expiate
Your crime with burning penitential tears
And if you scape the perils of the pass,
And are not whelmd beneath the drifted snows,
That from the frozen peaks come sweeping down,
Youll reach the bridge thats drenchd with drizzling spray.
Then if it give not way beneath your guilt,
When you have left it safely in your rear,
Before you frowns the gloomy Gate of Rocks,
Where never sun did shine. Proceed through this,
And you will reach a bright and gladsome vale.
Yet must you hurry on with hasty steps,
You must not linger in the haunts of peace.
JOHN.
O, Rudolph, Rudolph, royal grandsire! Thus
Thy grandson first sets foot within thy realms!
TELL.
Ascending still, you gain the Gotthardts heights,
Where are the tarns, the everlasting tarns,
That from the streams of Heaven itself are fed,
There to the German soil you bid farewell;
And thence, with swift descent, another stream
Leads you to Italy, your promised land.
[Ranz des Vaches sounded on Alp-horns is heard without.]
But I hear voices! Hence!
HEDW. (hurrying in).
Where art thou, Tell?
My father comes, and in exulting bands
All the confederates approach.
679
680
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N CO L N
Document 7
ASSASSINATION OF ABRAHAM
LINCOLN (1865)OFFICIAL MESSAGES AND
CORRESPONDENCE RELATING TO THE SHOOTING
OF PRESIDENT LINCOLN (APRIL 15, 1865)
Reproduced below are a series of telegrams and messages that passed between various government and military officers during the early morning hours of April 15,
1865, as President Abraham Lincoln lay dying of the gunshot would he suffered the
night before at Fords Theater in Washington. The messages report the presidents
condition and his death, trace the early stages of the investigation into his murder,
and indicate the growing certainty that John Wilkes Booth was at the head of a
conspiracy to murder not only Lincoln, but also other government officials, such
as Secretary of State William Seward. Among the correspondents are Secretary of
War Edwin M. Stanton; Major-General John Adams Dix, department commander
in New York City; General John Potts Slough, military governor of Alexandria, Virginia; Major-General Christopher Columbus Augur, commander of the Department
of Washington; Brigadier-General John Reese Kenly, commander of the District
of Eastern Shore, Maryland; Samuel B. Lawrence, the assistant adjutant-general;
Major-General George Gordon Meade, the commander of the Army of the Potomac; and Thomas T. Eckert, chief of the War Department telegraph staff.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N CO L N
681
682
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N CO L N
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N C O L N
took refuge was fired. Booth, in making his escape, was shot through the head
and killed, lingering about three hours, and Herold captured. Booths body and
Herold are now here.
EDWIN M. STANTON,
Secretary of War.
Source: U.S. War Department. War of the Rebellion: A Compilation of the Official
Records of the Union and Confederate Armies, Ser. I, Vol. XLVI/3.
Document 8
ASSASSINATION OF ABRAHAM
LINCOLN (1865)GENERAL COURT-MARTIAL
ORDERS NO. 356 FOR TRIAL OF THE LINCOLN
ASSASSINATION CONSPIRATORS
Reproduced here are the list of charges and specifications brought against the defendants accused of taking part in the conspiracy to murder President Abraham Lincoln
and other high government officials. John Wilkes Booth, who shot President Lincoln on
April 14, had been killed by federal troops on April 26, but the rest of the conspirators
were brought to trial before a military commission on May 9, 1865.
WAR DEPARTMENT, ADJUTANT-GENERALS OFFICE, Washington,
July 5, 1865.
I. Before a military commission which convened at Washington, D.C., May 9,
1865, pursuant to paragraph 4 of Special Orders, No. 211, dated May 6, 1865,
and paragraph 91 of Special Orders, No. 216, dated May 9, 1865, War Department, Adjutant Generals Office, Washington, and of which Maj. Gen. David
Hunter, U.S. Volunteers, is president, were arraigned and tried
David E. Herold, G. A. Atzerodt, Lewis Payne, Mary E. Surratt, Michael
OLaughlin, Edward Spangler, Samuel Arnold, and Samuel A. Mudd.
CHARGE I: For maliciously, unlawfully, and traitorously, and in aid of the existing armed rebellion against the United States of America, on or before the 6th day
of March, A.D. 1865, and on divers other days between that day and the 15th day
of April, A.D. 1865, combining, confederating, and conspiring, together with one
John H. Surratt, John Wilkes Booth, Jefferson Davis, George N. Sanders, Beverly
Tucker, Jacob Thompson, William C. Cleary, Clement C. Clay, George Harper,
George Young, and others unknown, to kill and murder, within the Military
Department of Washington, and within the fortified and intrenched lines
thereof, Abraham Lincoln, late, and at the time of said combining, confederating,
683
684
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N CO L N
and conspiring, President of the United States of America and Commander-inChief of the Army and Navy thereof; Andrew Johnson, now Vice-President of
the United States aforesaid; William H. Seward, Secretary of State of the United
States aforesaid, and Ulysses S. Grant, lieutenant-general of the Army of the
United States aforesaid, then in command of the Armies of the United States,
under the direction of the said Abraham Lincoln; and in pursuance of and in
prosecuting said malicious, unlawful, and traitorous conspiracy aforesaid, and
in aid of said rebellion, afterward, to wit, on the 14th day of April, A.D. 1865,
within the Military Department of Washington aforesaid, and within the fortified and intrenched lines of said military department, together with said John
Wilkes Booth and John H. Surratt, maliciously, unlawfully, and traitorously
murdering the said Abraham Lincoln, then President of the United States and
Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, as aforesaid;
and maliciously, unlawfully, and traitorously assaulting, with intent to kill and
murder, the said William H. Seward, then Secretary of State of the United States,
as aforesaid; and lying in wait, with intent maliciously, unlawfully, and traitorously, to kill and murder the said Andrew Johnson, then being Vice-President
of the United States; and the said Ulysses S. Grant, then being lieutenantgeneral and in command of the Armies of the United States, as aforesaid.
Specification 1.In this, that they, the said David E. Herold, Edward
Spangler, Lewis Payne, Michael OLaughlin, Samuel Arnold, Mary E. Surratt,
George A. Atzerodt, and Samuel A. Mudd, together with the said John H.
Surratt and John Wilkes Booth, incited and encouraged thereunto by Jefferson Davis, George N. Sanders, Beverly Tucker, Jacob Thompson, William C.
Cleary, Clement C. Clay, George Harper, George Young, and others unknown,
citizens of the United States aforesaid, and who were then engaged in armed
rebellion against the United States of America, within the limits thereof, did,
in aid of said armed rebellion, on or before the 6th day of March, A.D. 1865,
and on divers other days and times between that day and the 15th day of
April, A.D. 1865, combine, confederate, and conspire together at Washington City, within the Military Department of Washington, and within the intrenched fortifications and military lines of the said United States, there being,
unlawfully, maliciously, and traitorously to kill and murder Abraham Lincoln,
then President of the United States aforesaid, and Commander-in-Chief of the
Army and Navy thereof; and unlawfully, maliciously, and traitorously to kill
and murder Andrew Johnson, now Vice-President of the said United States,
upon whom, on the death of said Abraham Lincoln, after the 4th day of March,
A.D. 1865, the office of President of the said United States and Commanderin-Chief of the Army and Navy thereof would devolve; and to unlawfully, maliciously, and traitorously kill and murder Ulysses S. Grant, then lieutenant-general,
and, under the direction of the said Abraham Lincoln, in command of the Armies
of the United States aforesaid; and unlawfully, maliciously, and traitorously to
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N C O L N
kill and murder William H. Seward, then Secretary of State of the United States
aforesaid, whose duty it was by law, upon the death of said President and VicePresident of the United States aforesaid, to cause an election to be held for electors of President of the United Statesthe conspirators aforesaid designing
and intending by the killing and murder of the said Abraham Lincoln, Andrew
Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, and William H. Seward, as aforesaid, to deprive
the Army and Navy of the said United States of a constitutional commanderin-chief; and to deprive the Armies of the United States of their lawful commander; and to prevent a lawful election of President and Vice-President of
the United States aforesaid; and by the means aforesaid to aid and comfort the
insurgents engaged in armed rebellion against the said United States, as aforesaid, and thereby to aid in the subversion and overthrow of the Constitution
and laws of the said United States.
And being so combined, confederated, and conspiring together in the prosecution of said unlawful and traitorous conspiracy on the night of the 14th
day of April, A.D. 1865, at the hour of about 10 oclock and 15 minutes P.M.,
at Fords Theater, on Tenth street, in the city of Washington, and within the
military department and military lines aforesaid, John Wilkes Booth, one of the
conspirators aforesaid, in pursuance of said unlawful and traitorous conspiracy,
did, then and there, unlawfully, maliciously, and traitorously, and with intent to
kill and murder the said Abraham Lincoln, discharge a pistol, then held in the
hands of him, the said Booth, the same being then loaded with powder and a
leaden ball, against and upon the left and posterior side of the head of the said
Abraham Lincoln; and did thereby, then and there, inflict upon him, the said
Abraham Lincoln, then President of the said United States and Commanderin-Chief of the Army and Navy thereof, a mortal wound, whereof afterward, to
wit, on the 15th day of April, A.D. 1865, at Washington City aforesaid, the said
Abraham Lincoln died; and thereby, then and there, and in pursuance of said
conspiracy, the said defendants and the said John Wilkes Booth and John H.
Surratt did, unlawfully, traitorously, and maliciously, and with the intent to aid
the rebellion as aforesaid, kill and murder the said Abraham Lincoln, President
of the United States, as aforesaid.
And in further prosecution of the unlawful and traitorous conspiracy aforesaid, and of the murderous and traitorous intent of said conspiracy, the said
Edward Spangler, on said 14th day of April, A.D. 1865, at about the same hour
of that day, as aforesaid, within said military department and the military lines
aforesaid, did aid and assist the said John Wilkes Booth to obtain entrance to
the box in said theater in which said Abraham Lincoln was sitting at the time
he was assaulted and shot, as aforesaid, by John Wilkes Booth; and also did
then and there aid said Booth in barring and obstructing the door of the box of
said theater so as to hinder and prevent any assistance to or rescue of the said
Abraham Lincoln against the murderous assault of the said John Wilkes Booth,
685
686
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N CO L N
and did aid and abet him in making his escape after the said Abraham Lincoln
had been murdered in manner aforesaid.
And in further prosecution of said unlawful, murderous, and traitorous
conspiracy, and in pursuance thereof and with the intent, as aforesaid, the
said David E. Herold did, on the night of the 14th of April, A.D. 1865, within
the military department and military lines aforesaid, aid, abet and assist the
said John Wilkes Booth in the killing and murder of the said Abraham Lincoln,
and did then and there aid and abet and assist him, the said John Wilkes
Booth, in attempting to escape through the military lines aforesaid, and did
accompany and assist the said John Wilkes Booth in attempting to conceal
himself and escape from justice after killing and murdering said Abraham
Lincoln, as aforesaid.
And in further prosecution of said unlawful and traitorous conspiracy, and
of the intent thereof, as aforesaid, the said Lewis Payne did, on the same
night of the 14th day of April, A.D. 1865, about the same hour of 10 oclock
and 15 minutes P.M., at the city of Washington, and within the military department and the military lines aforesaid, unlawfully and maliciously make
an assault upon the said William H. Seward, Secretary of State, as aforesaid,
in the dwelling-house and bedchamber of him, the said William H. Seward,
and the said Payne did then and there, with a large knife, held in his hand,
unlawfully, traitorously, and in pursuance of said conspiracy, strike, stab, cut,
and attempt to kill and murder the said William H. Seward, and did thereby,
then and there, and with the intent aforesaid, with said knife inflict upon the
face and throat of the said William H. Seward divers grievous wounds. And
the said Lewis Payne, in further prosecution of said conspiracy, at the same
time and place last aforesaid, did attempt, with the knife aforesaid, and a pistol held in his hand, to kill and murder Frederick W. Seward, Augustus H.
Seward, Emrick W. Hansell, and George F. Robinson, who were then striving
to protect and rescue the said William H. Seward from murder by the said
Lewis Payne, and did then and there, with said knife and pistol held in his
hands, inflict upon the head of said Frederick W. Seward, and upon the persons of said Augustus H. Seward, Emrick W. Hansell, and George F. Robinson,
divers grievous and dangerous wounds with intent, then and there, to kill
and murder the said Frederick W. Seward, Augustus H. Seward, Emrick W.
Hansell, and George F. Robinson.
And in further prosecution of said conspiracy and its traitorous and murderous designs, the said George A. Atzerodt did, on the night of the 14th
of April, A.D. 1865, and about the same hour of the night aforesaid, within
the military department and the military lines aforesaid, lie in wait for Andrew Johnson, then Vice-President of the United States aforesaid, with the
intent unlawfully and maliciously to kill and murder him, the said Andrew
Johnson.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A B R A H A M L I N C O L N
And in the further prosecution of the conspiracy aforesaid, and of its murderous and treasonable purposes aforesaid, on the nights of the 13th and
14th of April, A.D. 1865, at Washington City, and within the military department and military lines aforesaid, the said Michael OLaughlin did then and
there lie in wait for Ulysses S. Grant, then lieutenant-general and commander
of the Armies of the United States, as aforesaid, with intent then and there to
kill and murder the said Ulysses S. Grant.
And in further prosecution of said conspiracy, the said Samuel Arnold did,
within the military department and military lines aforesaid, on or before the
6th day of March, A.D. 1865, and on divers other days and times between that
day and the 15th day of April, A.D. 1865, combine, conspire with, and aid,
counsel, abet, comfort, and support, the said John Wilkes Booth, Lewis Payne,
George A. Atzerodt, Michael OLaughlin, and their confederates, in said unlawful, murderous, and traitorous conspiracy and in the execution thereof, as
aforesaid.
And in further prosecution of the said conspiracy, Mary E. Surratt did,
at Washington City, and within the military department and military lines
aforesaid, on or before the 6th day of March, A.D. 1865, and on divers other
days and times between that day and the 20th day of April, A.D. 1865. receive, entertain, harbor and conceal, aid and assist the said John Wilkes
Booth, David E. Herold, Lewis Payne, John H. Surratt, Michael OLanghlin,
George A. Atzerodt, Samuel Arnold, and their confederates, with knowledge
of the murderous and traitorous conspiracy aforesaid, and with intent to aid,
abet, and assist them in the execution thereof, and in escaping from justice
after the murder of the said Abraham Lincoln, as aforesaid.
And in further prosecution of said conspiracy, the said Samuel A. Mudd
did, at Washington City, and within the military department and military
lines aforesaid, on or before the 6th day of March, A.D. 1865, and on divers
other days and times between that day and the 20th day of April, A.D. 1865,
advise, encourage, receive, entertain, harbor and conceal, aid and assist the
said John Wilkes Booth, David E. Herold, Lewis Payne, John H. Surratt, Michael OLaughlin, George A. Atzerodt, Mary E. Surratt, and Samuel Arnold,
and their confederates, with knowledge of the murderous and traitorous
conspiracy aforesaid, and with intent to aid, abet, and assist them in the execution thereof, and in escaping from justice after the murder of said Abraham Lincoln, in pursuance of said conspiracy in manner aforesaid.
To which charge and specification the accused, David E. Herold, G. A. Atzerodt, Lewis Payne, Mary E. Surratt, Michael OLaughlin, Edward Spangler,
Samuel Arnold, and Samuel A. Mudd, pleaded not guilty.
Source: U.S. War Department. War of the Rebellion: A Compilation of the Official
Records of the Union and Confederate Armies. Ser. II, Vol. VIII.
687
688
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F C Z A R A L E X A N D E R I I O F RUS S I A
Document 9
ASSASSINATION OF CZAR ALEXANDER II
OF RUSSIA (1881)PRINCE PETER KROPOTKINS
ACCOUNT OF THE MURDER
On March 13, 1881, Czar Alexander II traveled by carriage to the Mikhailovsky
Mange, an architectural monument in central St. Petersburg. The czar was known
to attend the military roll-call held at the monument every Sunday. On this Sunday,
three members of the Russian terrorist organization Narodnaya Volya (The Peoples
Will) lay in wait for the czar along the route he always took. The first, Nikolai
Rysakov, threw a small bomb wrapped in a handkerchief under the carriage. The
explosion injured the driver and several in the crowd, but the carriage, being bulletproof, was only slightly damaged and Alexander emerged unhurt. Urged on by
Rysakov, who was immediately arrested, the second terrorist, Ignaty Grinevitsky,
tossed a bomb at Alexanders feet, where it exploded, horribly mutilating the czar and
killing or wounding some 20 others. Alexander died shortly thereafter at the imperial
palace. Reproduced below is an account of Alexanders assassination, as well as of attempts on the life of his son, Alexander III, written by Prince Peter Kropotkin, a noted
philosopher, writer, and socialist revolutionary.
For some time before March 13, 1881, Gen. Count Loris Melikoff, the officer responsible for the safety of Czar Alexander II, had received disquieting reports which gave him the greatest anxiety. On the 10th of the month Jelaboff,
the ringleader of the conspiracy, was arrested by accident, and the direction
of the attempt on the Czars life was accordingly left to Sophie Perowskaia, a
young, pretty and highly educated noblewoman, who had left everything to
join the Nihilists. It is said that on the morning of the 13th Melikoff begged the
Czar to forego his purpose of reviewing the Marine Corps, and keep within the
palace. The Emperor laughed at him, and declared there was no danger. There
was no incident until after the review. As the Emperor drove back beside
the Ekaterinofsky Canal, just opposite the imperial stables, a young woman on
the other side of the canal fluttered a handkerchief, and immediately a man
started out from the crowd that was watching the passing of the Czar, and threw
a bomb under the closed carriage. There was a roaring explosion, a cloud of
smoke. The rear of the vehicle was blown away, and the horror-stricken multitude saw the Czar standing unhurt, staring about him. On the ground were
several members of the Life Guard, groaning and writhing in pain. The assassin
had pulled out a revolver to complete his work, but he was at once mobbed by
the people. Col. Dvorjitsky and Captains Kock and Kulebiekan, of the guards,
rushed up to their master and asked him if he was hurt.
Thank God! no, said the Czar. Come, let us look after the wounded.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F C Z A R A L E X A N D E R I I O F RUS S I A
689
690
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F C Z A R A L E X A N D E R I I O F RUS S I A
The evidence was soon got in shape, and early in April the trial began. It was
shown that Jelaboff was agent in the third degree of the Revolutionary Executive Committeethat he had issued the call for volunteers for the killing of the
Czar, and that forty-seven persons had offered themselves, out of whom Risakoff, Mikhaeloff, Hessy Helfmann, Kibaltchik, Sophia Perowskaja and Thilkoff
had been accepted. Elnikoff was dead, but the others, with Jelaboff, were put
in the dock. They all confessed except Hessy Helfmann, and upon April iith all
were condemned to death, with the proviso needed under the Russian law that
the sentence of Sophia Perowskaja should be approved by the Czar, as she was a
member of the class of nobles, and a noble may not be put to death without the
Emperors concurrence. The Czar concurred, and on April 15th, at 9 A.M., all the
prisoners save Hessy Helfmann were hung. This woman was reprieved because
she was about to become a mother. The execution was a most brutal one.
The present Czar [Alexander III] has had several narrow escapes, none of
them more nearly fatal than the conspiracy of the book-bomb in March last.
On the 13th of March, 1888, the anniversary of his fathers terrible death, the
Czar made the usual visit to the Cathedral of St. Peter and Paul, where the
body of Alexander II is buried. For some time before the ceremony St. Petersburg was full of rumors that a catastrophe was impending, and, although the
police took the most careful precautions, the Czar himself paid no attention
to the warnings of the Third Section, and would permit no alteration in the
preparations for the requiem.
In Christmas week of 1887, the Russian agents at Geneva, in Switzerland,
reported the presence in that city of two revolutionary agents who, seemed to
have the closest relations with the committee of the discontents in London and
Paris. They were shadowed for a time, but lost. In February they reappeared in
Berlin. They were known to be in communication with the St. Petersburg Nihilists. Before facts enough had accumulated to justify their arrest they disappeared
once more and were believed to have gone to the Russian capital. The facts were
reported to the Czar, but he laughed at Chief Gresser of the capital police.
In solemnizing the requiem of the late Czar a public progress was made
to the Cathedral, amid a dense throng of citizens, among whom were all the
detectives that Chief Gresser could get together. In a small cafe in one of the
side streets of the Morokaya two of the detectives ran across a couple of uniformed university studentsin Russia the students have a peculiar costume
who were acting suspiciously. They were conversing in a most excited manner
with a man dressed as a peasant. The trio were watched. At the cafe door they
separated, but all three made by different routes for the Nevsky Prospect, the
chief drive of the capital and the one along which the Czar was to return. The
peasant was lost by the detectives, but the other two were kept in sight, and
the suspicions of the police were made all the more keen by the fact that the
young men passed each other in the crowd several times with an elaborate
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J A M E S A . G A R F I E L D
appearance of not knowing each other. One of them had a law-book in his
hand; the other had a traveling bag over his shoulder.
A few moments before the Czar was to pass on his return from the Cathedral
the students came together and whispered, and the two were immediately and
quietly arrested. Their names were given as Andreleff sky and Petroff, university students, and this was proven to be the truth.
A thrilling discovery was made, however, at once. The innocent-looking
law-book was really a most dangerous infernal machine-sufficiently powerful
not alone to kill everybody in the Czars carriage, but many in the crowd. . . .
Hardly had the arrest been made when the Czar was notified at the Cathedral.
He ordered that the news should be withheld from the Empress, although he was
himself visibly affected. He sprang into his sleigh with the Czarowitz, and drove by
an unused route to the railway station. The Czarina followed shortly after in a carriage, greatly agitated by a presentiment of evil. Not until the train had started was
she informed of the occurrence. She burst into tears, and was inconsolable for the
rest of the journey. Once safe in his Gatschina Palace, the Czar is said to have given
vent to his feelings in the strongest language, heaping anathemas upon the heads
of the, Nihilists, and threatening dire revenge.
Less than two hours after the arrest of Andreleff sky and Petroff their companion peasant fell into the hands of the police. His name was Genezeraloff, a
native of Jaroslav, South Russia. He had been actively engaged in the Nihilist
propaganda for some time past. He also carried bombs on his person.
These arrests were supplemented by numerous others. The lodgings of the
prisoners in the suburbs of St. Petersburg known as the Peski (the Sands) were
searched, and other explosives as well as documents incriminating other persons were found. As a result the procession of prisoners to the Peter and Pauls
Fortress for a time was almost unremitting, and no one felt safe against police
intrusion. All three of the prisoners were subsequently executed.
Source: James Harvey Robinson and Charles Beard, eds. Readings in Modern
European History. Vol. 2. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1908, 36263.
Document 10
ASSASSINATION OF JAMES A. GARFIELD (1881)
ADDRESS OF VICE PRESIDENT CHESTER A. ARTHUR
UPON ASSUMING THE PRESIDENCY
On July 2, 1881, President James A. Garfield was shot twice from behind as he walked
through a railway station in Washington. The shooter was Charles J. Guiteau, a
disappointed federal office seeker who was mentally unstable. Believing God was
691
692
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J A M E S A . G A R F I E L D
telling him to eliminate Garfield, Guiteau stalked the president for weeks armed
with a .44 caliber revolver. Garfield survived until September 19, when he died from
his wounds. Upon Garfields death, Vice President Chester A. Arthur assumed the
presidency. Arthur never delivered an official inaugural address, but instead
gave the following short speech on September 22. In the speech, Arthur focused
upon Garfields death, the stability of the republic, and the peaceful transfer of
power. He promised to continue to focus on the issues that Garfield had begun to
address.
For the fourth time in the history of the Republic its Chief Magistrate has
been removed by death. All hearts are filled with grief and horror at the hideous crime which has darkened our land, and the memory of the murdered
President, his protracted sufferings, his unyielding fortitude, the example and
achievements of his life, and the pathos of his death will forever illumine the
pages of our history.
For the fourth time the officer elected by the people and ordained by the
Constitution to fill a vacancy so created is called to assume the Executive chair.
The wisdom of our fathers, foreseeing even the most dire possibilities, made
sure that the Government should never be imperiled because of the uncertainty of human life. Men may die, but the fabrics of our free institutions remain unshaken. No higher or more assuring proof could exist of the strength
and permanence of popular government than the fact that though the chosen
of the people be struck down his constitutional successor is peacefully installed
without shock or strain except the sorrow which mourns the bereavement. All
the noble aspirations of my lamented predecessor which found expression in
his life, the measures devised and suggested during his brief Administration to
correct abuses, to enforce economy, to advance prosperity, and to promote the
general welfare, to Insure domestic security and maintain friendly and honorable relations with the nations of the earth, will be garnered in the hearts of the
people; and it will be my earnest endeavor to profit, and to see that the nation
shall profit, by his example and experience.
Prosperity blesses our country. Our fiscal policy is fixed by law, is well
grounded and generally approved. No threatening issue mars our foreign intercourse, and the wisdom, integrity, and thrift of our people may be trusted to
continue undisturbed the present assured career of peace, tranquilly, and welfare. The gloom and anxiety which have enshrouded the country must make
repose especially welcome now. No demand for speedy legislation has been
heard; no adequate occasion is apparent for an unusual session of Congress.
The Constitution defines the functions and powers of the executive as clearly as
those of either of the other two departments of the Government, and he must
answer for the just exercise of the discretion it permits and the performance
of the duties it imposes. Summoned to these high duties and responsibilities
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F M O R G A N E A R P
and profoundly conscious of their magnitude and gravity, I assume the trust
imposed by the Constitution, relying for aid on divine guidance and the virtue,
patriotism, and intelligence of the American people.
Source: James D. Richardson, ed. A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of
the Presidents. Vol.8, Part 2. New York: Bureau of National Literature, Inc.,
1902.
Document 11
ASSASSINATION OF MORGAN EARP (1882)
TOMBSTONE EPITAPH ACCOUNT OF THE MURDER
On March 18, 1882, less than five months after the notorious gunfight at the O.K.
Corral, Morgan Earp, the younger brother of lawman Wyatt Earp, was gunned
down while playing billiards in a Tombstone, Arizona, billiard parlor. Morgan died
less than an hour after being shot. Although several members of the Cowboys outlaw organization, who had been threatening the Earps since some of their associates
had died at the O.K. Corral, were arrested for the crime, the judge eventually dismissed the charges for lack of evidence. Taking the law into his own hands, Wyatt
Earp led a heavily armed posse into the countryside surrounding Tombstone, where,
over a two-week period, the party killed at least four members of the Cowboys who
were thought to have been involved in Morgan Earps murder. Reproduced below is
a report of Morgans death that appeared in the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper
two days after the attack.
The Assassin at Last Successful in His Devilish Mission
Morgan Earp Shot Down and Killed While Playing Billiards
At 10:00 Saturday night while engaged in playing a game of billiards in Campbell & Hatchs Billiard parlor, on Allen between Fourth and Fifth, Morgan Earp
was shot through the body by an unknown assassin. At the time the shot was
fired he was playing a game with Bob Hatch, one of the proprietors of the house
and was standing with his back to the glass door in the rear of the room that
opens out upon the alley that leads straight through the block along the west
side of A.D. Otis & Co.s store to Fremont Street. This door is the ordinary
glass door with four panes in the top in place of panels. The two lower panes
are painted, the upper ones being clear. Anyone standing outside can look
over the painted glass and see anything going on in the room just as well as
though standing in the open door. At the time the shot was fired the deceased
must have been standing within ten feet of the door, and the assassin standing
693
694
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
near enough to see his position, took aim for about the middle of his person,
shooting through the upper portion of the whitened glass. The bullet entered
the right side of the abdomen, passing through the spinal column, completely
shattering it, emerging on the left side, passing the length of the room and lodging in the thigh of Geo. A.B. Berry, who was standing by the stove, inflicting a
painful flesh wound. Instantly after the first shot a second was fired through
the top of the upper glass which passed across the room and lodged in the
wall near the ceiling over the head of Wyatt Earp, who was sitting as a spectator of the game. Morgan fell instantly upon the first fire and lived only about
one hour. His brother Wyatt, Tipton, and McMasters rushed to the side of the
wounded man and tenderly picked him up and moved him some ten feet away
near the door of the card room, where Drs. Matthews, Goodfellow and Millar,
who were called, examined him and, after a brief consultation, pronounced
the wound mortal. He was then moved into the card room and placed on the
lounge where in a few brief moments he breathed his last, surrounded by his
brothers, Wyatt, Virgil, James and Warren with the wives of Virgil and James
and a few of his most intimate friends. Notwithstanding the intensity of his
mortal agony, not a word of complaint escaped his lips, and all that were heard,
except those whispered into the ear of his brother and known only to him
were, Dont, I cant stand it. This is the last game of pool Ill ever play. The first
part of the sentence being wrung from him by an attempt to place him upon
his feet.
The funeral cortege started away from the Cosmopolitan hotel about
12:30 yesterday with the fire bell tolling its solemn peals of Earth to earth,
dust to dust.
Source: The Tombstone Epitaph, The Deadly Bullet, March 20, 1882.
Document 12
ASSASSINATION OF WILLIAM MCKINLEY (1901)
NEWSPAPER ACCOUNTS OF THE SHOOTING
AND DEATH OF THE PRESIDENT
On September 6, 1901, anarchist Leon Czolgosz shot President William McKinley
while he was visiting the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, New York. McKinely
lingered for over a week, dying of his wounds on September 14. Reproduced here are
various newspaper accounts of the shooting and its aftermath. The first article is an
account of the shooting that appeared in the New York Times on September 7. The
article is remarkably detached and adopts the unemotional tone and language of the
physicians reporting on the presidents condition, complete with reports of his vital
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
statistics. This tone can be interpreted as an example of the ages supreme confidence
in the triumph of reason and science over chaos, or, as the Timess attempt to reassure
the public that despite the attack, all was under control.
In the second article, an editorial from September 8, the New York Times continued in this moderate tone. The editorial describes the assassination attempt as an
act hearkening back to the Old World and that has no place in a modern democratic
nation. The Times assured its readers that the individual violent act of an individual
against the government had no lasting effect when the government was chosen democratically, organized rationally, and secured in stability.
In the third article, also from September 8, the Chicago Tribune used the tragedy
to make comparisons between disorder and order. The Tribune celebrated the publics
restraint in the heat of the moment and the American legal system that would ensure
the assassin got his just deserts. This was much in keeping with the Tribunes general
attitude toward mob violence, for it had been conducting a vigorous campaign against
the lynching of blacks in the South for the past decade. For the Tribune, Czolgoszs
orderly arrestdespite the enormity of his crimewas a vindication of Americas
form of government and the rule of law.
The fourth article, from the San Francisco Chronicle, describes the presidents death
on September 14. The Chronicles description of a peaceful and forgiving McKinley
at the hour of his death might be trite or even a complete fabrication, but it does succeed in promoting a certain confidence that all would be well.
New York Times, September 7
PRESIDENT SHOT AT BUFFALO FAIR
Wounded in the Breast and Abdomen
HE IS RESTING EASILY
One Bullet Extracted, Other Cannot Be Found Assassin is Leon Czolgosz of Cleveland, Who Says He is an Anarchist and Follower of Emma
Goldman
Buffalo, Sept. 6President McKinley, while holding a reception in the
Temple of Music at the Pan-American Exposition at 4 oclock this afternoon,
was shot and twice wounded by Leon Czolgosz, an Anarchist, who lives in
Cleveland.
One bullet entered the Presidents breast, struck the breast bone, glanced
and was later easily extracted. The other bullet entered the abdomen, penetrated the stomach, and has not been found, although the wounds have been
closed.
The physicians in attendance upon the President at 10:40 oclock to-night
issued the following bulletin:
The President is rallying satisfactorily and resting comfortably. 10:15 P.M.,
temperature, 100.4 degrees; pulse 124; respiration 24.
695
696
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
P.M. rixey,
m.b. mann,
r.e. parke,
h. mynter
eugene wanbin
Signed by George B. Cortelyou, Secretary to the President.
This condition was maintained until 1 oclock A.M. when the physicians
issued the following bulletin:
The President is free from pain and resting well. Temperature, 100.2; pulse,
120; respiration 24.
The assassin was immediately overpowered and taken to a police station on
the Exposition grounds, but not before a number of the throng had tried to
lynch him. Later he was taken to police headquarters.
The exact nature of the Presidents injuries is described in the following bulletin issued by Secretary Cortelyou for the physicians who were called:
The President was shot about 4 oclock. One bullet struck him on the upper
portion of the breast bone. . . .
Leon Czolgosz, the assassin, has signed a confession, covering six pages
of foolscap, in which he states that he is an Anarchist and that he became an enthusiastic member of that body through the influence of Emma
Goldman, whose writings he had read and whose lectures he had listened
to. He denies having any confederate, and says he decided on the act three
days ago and bought the revolver with which the act was committed in
Buffalo.
He has seven brothers and sisters in Cleveland, and the Cleveland Directory has the names of about that number living in Hosmer Street and Ackland
Avenue, which adjoin. Some of them are butchers and others are in other
trades.
Czolgosz is now detained at Police Headquarters pending the result of the
Presidents injuries. He does not appear in the least degree uneasy or penitent
for his action. He says he was induced by his attention to Emma Goldmans
lectures and writing to decide that the present form of government in this
country was all wrong, and he thought the best way to end it was by the killing of the President. He showed no sign of insanity, but is very reticent about
much of his career.
While acknowledging himself an Anarchist, he does not state to which
branch of the organization he belongs.
Source: New York Times, September 7, 1901.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
697
698
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F W I L L I A M M C K I N L E Y
the assassin limb from limb would not have undone any of the harm inflicted
by his bullets, but would simply have added a new cause for regret. It would
have been a temporary lapse into the anarchy which this criminal stands for
and which is the enemy of all government except that of brute force. Even the
excited crowds that called for the assassins death realized this fact the moment
their reason had a chance to assert itself.
Source: Chicago Tribune, September 8, 1901.
San Francisco Chronicle, September 14, 1901
Death Stills the Heart of President Mkinley in the Early Morning Hours
Mrs. McKinley with Him during His Last Conscious Moments
Touching Incidents at the Deathbed
BUFFALO, September 14President McKinley died at 2:15 this morning. His
last breath passed calmly and almost imperceptibly. Peace and forgiveness were
written on his white face. He had been unconscious for several hours before the
end came, and his death was free from pain.
Secretary Cortelyou made the announcement. He came out of the Milburn
house and walked slowly down to the newspaper men, who were congregated
behind the rope barrier.
The President died at 2:15 oclock, said he, in an even address.
He then turned and walked back to the house, maintaining even after all was
over, the calm demeanor which has characterized all his actions during the anxious days and the sleepless nights which have passed since the President was shot.
All night the President battled with death. At 10 oclock he was alone in the
combat. Science, skill, infinite tenderness, were beaten and hopeless. Surgeons
and physicians measured his brief span by moments. They had no hope and
offered none. Mystified, baffled and defeated, they stood aside and left William
McKinley alone to face the inevitable.
Meanwhile the nationthe worldstood watching for the final word. Buffalo, where the President was assassinated, stood agape with horror and rage.
Doctors of known and heralded cunning were summoned from all available
quarters. They came by special trains, and were rushed into the presence of
death and its unyielding victim. The wires were hot with summonses for the
Vice-President, for the Cabinet, for the friends nearest to the dying man, and
they came.
From all quarters men who have known the dying man as a man first and
then as a leader of his people came rushing, pale with sad-eyed and hopeless
grief. . . .
Source: San Francisco Chronicle, September 14, 1901.
699
700
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A RC H D U K E FR A N Z FE R D I N A N D
Document 13
ASSASSINATION OF ARCHDUKE FRANZ
FERDINAND (1914)AUSTRIAN OFFICIAL
REPORT ON THE ASSASSINATION
The event that triggered World War I was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria and his morganatic wife, Duchess Sophie, on June 28, 1914, in Sarajevo, the capital of the Austrian province of Bosnia. The archduke was the nephew
and heir of Emperor Franz Josef II of Austria. The assassin was Gavrilo Princip, a
Bosnian political activist and member of the Black Hand, a Serbian terrorist organization that supported the incorporation of Bosnia into Serbia. Princip shot the imperial couple in the hope of precipitating a crisis within the Austrian Empire that would
facilitate this objective. Black Hand received weapons and assistance from elements
within the Serbian army and secret police, but the extent of Serbian government
involvement in the assassination plot is unclear. The Austrian government, however,
sought to use the assassination as a pretext for taking military action against Serbia. Thus, the Austrian court at Sarajevo that produced the following report on the
murder slanted the report to throw maximum suspicion on the Serbian government.
Record of the District Court at Sarajevo, touching the proceedings there
instituted against Gavrilo Princip and confederates on account of the crime
of assassination perpetrated on June 28, 1914, on His Imperial and Royal
Highness the Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Este and Her Highness
the Duchess Sophie of Hohenberg.
Gavrilo Princip, Nedeljko Cabrinovic, Trifko Grabez, Vaso Cubrilovic and
Cetres Popovic confess that in common with the fugitive Mehemed Mehmedbasic they contrived a plot for the murder of the Archduke Franz Ferdinand
and, armed with bombs and in the case of some of them with Browning pistols,
laid in wait for him on June 28, 1914, on his progress through Sarajevo for the
purpose of carrying out the planned attack.
Nedeljko Cabrinovic confesses that he was the first of the conspirators to
hurl a bomb against the Archdukes carriage, which missed its mark and which
on exploding injured only the occupants of the carriage following the Archducal motor car.
Gavrilo Princip confesses that he fired two shots from a Browning pistol
against the Archducal motor car, by which the Archduke Franz Ferdinand and
the Duchess Sophie of Hohenberg received fatal wounds.
Both perpetrators confess that the act was done with intent to murder.
These confessions have been fully verified by means of the investigations
which have taken place, and it is established that the deceased Archduke Franz
Ferdinand and the deceased Duchess Sophie of Hohenberg died as a result of
the revolver shots fired at them by Gavrilo Princip.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A RC H D U K E FR A N Z FE R D I N A N D
The accused have made the following declarations, which are essentially
consistent, before the examining magistrate:
In April, 1914, Princip, during his stay at Belgrade, where he associated
with a number of Serbian students in the cafs of the town, conceived the plan
for the execution of an attempt on the life of the late Archduke Franz Ferdinand. He communicated this intention to his acquaintance, Cabrinovic, who
also was in Belgrade at the time. The latter had already conceived a similar idea
and was ready at once to participate in the attempt. The execution of an attempt on the Archdukes life was a frequent topic of conversation in the circle
in which Princip and Cabrinovic moved, because the Archduke was considered to be a dangerous enemy of the Serbian people.
Princip and Cabrinovic desired at first to procure the bombs and weapons
necessary for the execution of the deed from the Serbian Major Milan Pribicevic or from the Narodna Odbrana [Defense of the People, a Serbian independence group founded in 1908], as they themselves did not possess the
means for their purchase. As, however, Major Pribicevic and the authoritative
member of the said association, Zivojin Dacic, were absent from Belgrade at
that time, they decided to try to obtain the weapons from their acquaintance
Milan Ciganovic, who had formerly been a Komitadji [brigand or guerrilla
fighter] and was at that time in the employment of the State railways.
Princip, through the instrumentality of an intimate friend of Ciganovic, now
got into communication with the latter. Thereupon Ciganovic called on Princip and discussed the planned attempt with him. He entirely approved it, and
thereupon declared that he would like to consider further whether he should
provide the weapons for the attempt. Cabrinovic also talked with Ciganovic on
the subject of the weapons.
At Easter Princip took Trifko Grabez, who also was in Belgrade, into his confidence. The latter is also shown by his own confession to have declared himself ready to take part in the attempt.
In the following weeks Princip had repeated conversations with Ciganovic
about the execution of the attempt.
Meanwhile Ciganovic had reached an understanding on the subject of
the planned attack with the Serbian Major Voja Tankosic, who was a close
friend of his and who then placed at his disposal for this object the Browning
pistols.
Grabez confesses in conformity with the depositions of Princip and Cabrinovic that on the 24th of May he, accompanied by Ciganovic, visited Major
Tankosic at the latters request at his rooms. He says that after he had been
introduced Tankosic said to him: Are you the man? Are you determined?
Whereupon Grabez answered: I am. Tankosic next asked: Do you know
how to shoot with a revolver? and when Grabez answered in the negative
Tankosic said to Ciganovic: I will give you a revolver, go and teach them how
to shoot.
701
702
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F A RC H D U K E FR A N Z FE R D I N A N D
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
accomplices with means of committing their crime. For, as Princip and Cabrinovic have expressly admitted, they lacked the necessary arms, as well as the
money to purchase them.
It is interesting to see where the accomplices tried to procure their arms.
Milan Pribicevic and Zivojin Dacie, the two principal men in the Narodna Odbrana, were the first accomplices thought of as a sure source of help in their
need, doubtless because it had already become a tradition amongst those ready
to commit crimes that they could obtain instruments for murder from these
representatives of the Narodna Odbrana. The accidental circumstance that
these two men were not at Belgrade at the critical moment doubtless balked
this plan. However, Princip and Cabrinovic were not at a loss in finding other
help, that of Milan Ciganovic, an ex-komitadji, and now a railway official at
Belgrade, and at the same time an active member of the Narodna Odbrana,
who, in 1909, first appeared as a pupil at the school at Cuprija. Princip and
Cabrinovic were not deceived in their expectations, as they at once received
the necessary help from Ciganovic.
Source: Charles F. Horne, ed. Source Records of the Great War. Vol. 1. Indianapolis: National Alumni, 1923, 24751.
Document 14
ASSASSINATION OF ARCHDUKE FRANZ
FERDINAND (1914)EXCERPTS FROM AMERICAN
NEWSPAPER ACCOUNTS OF THE MURDER OF
THE ARCHDUKE AND HIS WIFE
On June 28, 1914, Serbian nationalist Gavrilo Princip, a member of Black Hand, a
Serbian terrorist organization, assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the
Austrian throne, and his wife, Duchess Sophie. The murder, which occurred in the
Bosnian capital of Sarajevo, precipitated the outbreak of World War I in August 1914.
Nineteen at the time of the assassination, Princip was instructed, with other wouldbe assassins in the plot, to commit suicide so as to avoid having to divulge the plotters ties to high Serbian military officers. Princip apparently agreed because he had
tuberculosis and expected to die shortly anyway. However, after the assassination,
a bystander stopped Princip before he was able to turn the gun on himself. He was
convicted of murder, but because Austro-Hungarian law allowed capital punishment
only for adults over 20, Princip was sentenced to 20 years imprisonment. He died
in prison of tuberculosis in 1918. Reproduced here are accounts of the assassination
that appeared in various American newspapers in the days immediately following
the murder.
703
704
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
whether they are hated and hunted, or whether they have gained the loyalty
and love of their subjects, as had the Archduke Ferdinand. There was no
apparent reason for his taking off; but the absence of political or personal
motive more sharply emphasizes the danger of assassination at the hands of
lunatics and anarchists.
The empire of Austria-Hungary may be profoundly affected by Ferdinands
death. Emperor Franz Joseph is near his end, and the prospect of a transfer of
power to Ferdinand was acceptable to the people. He had proved himself a
good soldier and an able statesman, devoted to the empire, ambitious for its
aggrandizement, and strong-willed enough to defend its interests in the midst
of the tangled politics of western and southeastern Europe. He was credited
with being the controlling mind in Austrian policies with respect to the Balkans and Italy.
The extinction of Ferdinand as a factor in the Balkan situation may have farreaching consequences, when it is borne in mind that the kingdom of Servia is
rent with internal strife, and that Greece and Turkey are bent upon a renewal
of hostilities. The map of the Balkans, radically altered within the last three
years, seems to be subject to further alterations as a result of the weakening of
Austria-Hungarys influence.
Source: Washington Post, June 29, 1914.
Atlanta Journal & Constitution, June 29, 1914
Heir to Austro-Hungarian Throne and Wife Murdered in Serbia
The archduke and his wife were victims of the second attempt in the same day
against their lives. First a bomb was thrown at the automobile in which they
were driving to the town hall. Forewarned, however, of a possible attempt
against his life, the archduke was watchful and struck the missile aside with
his arm. It fell under the automobile following which carried members of the
archdukes suite, wounding count Von Boos-Waldeck and Colonel Merizzo.
Darted at Car and Fired
On their return from the town hall the archduke and the duchess were driving to the hospital when Gavrio Prinzip darted at the car and fired a volley at
the occupants. His aim was true and the archduke and his wife were mortally
wounded. With them at the time was the governor of the city, who escaped
injury. The bodies of his murdered companions collapsed across him and protected him from stray bullets.
The governor shouted to the chauffeur to rush to the palace. Physicians
were in prompt attendance, but their services were useless, as the archduke
and his wife were dead before the palace was reached.
705
706
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
The boy must have been carefully instructed in his part, for it was a wellguarded secret that the Archduke always wore a coat of silk strands which were
woven obliquely, so that no weapon or bullet could pierce it. I once saw a strip
of this fabric used for a motor-car tire, and it was puncture-proof. This new invention enabled the Archduke to brave attempts on his life, but his head naturally was uncovered.
The Duchess was shot in the body. The boy fired several times, but only two
shots took effect. The Archduke and his wife were carried to the Konak, or palace, in a dying condition.
Later details show that the assassin darted forth from his hiding place behind a house and actually got on the motor car in which the Archduke and
his wife were sitting. He took close aim first at the Archduke, and then at the
Duchess. The fact that no one stopped him and that he was allowed to perpetrate the dastardly act indicate that the conspiracy was carefully planned and
that the Archduke fell a victim to a political plot. The aspiration of the Servian
population in Bosnia to join with Servia and form a great Servian kingdom is
well known. No doubt todays assassination was regarded as a means of forwarding this plan.
Break News to Children
The Archdukes children are at Glumex, in Bohemia, and relatives already have
left Vienna to break the news to them. The Duke of Cumberland motored to
Ischl immediately upon receipt of the news and was received by the Emperor,
who will arrive in Vienna at 6 oclock tomorrow. The bodies of the Archduke
and his wife will not be brought to Vienna until tomorrow a week.
The Archduke Charles Francis Joseph, the new heir to the throne, is at
Reichenau, near Vienna, with his wife, Princess Zita of Parma, and their little
son and daughter. He is expected in Vienna tonight.
When the first news of the assassination became known in Vienna, early this
afternoon, crowds collected in solemn silence and discussed the report, which
was not credited at first. Everyone connected with the press was stormed by
crowds asking whether confirmation had been received, and on hearing the
truth they said, How awful! and then dispersed, to go about their ordinary
business or pleasure.
Source: New York Times, June 29, 1914.
Christian Science Monitor, June 29, 1914
Assassination Is Another Test for Austria-Hungary
Few men have experienced greater sorrows than the Emperor Franz Josef and
none have borne them with more serene fortitude. The latest, however, of these
707
708
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F A R C H D U K E F R A N Z F E R D I N A N D
misfortunes extends far beyond the interest of his private life. It raises questions not only of national but of European importance. . . . What all this will
mean no man can tell.
Source: Christian Science Monitor, June 29, 1914.
New York Times, June 29, 1914
Assassinations Exact Brutal Revenge for Austria
Hungarys Seizure of Bosnia
Some weeks since, when the life of the emperor Francis Joseph was daily despaired of, the whole world, in spite of its sympathy with the courageous old
ruler of Austria-Hungary, felt that there would be compensation for his loss in
the likelihood that his successor, the Archduke Francis Ferdinand, would be
able to hold together the various States united under Austrian rule. He was accounted a popular Prince, a sagacious and resourceful man, and he was known
throughout the empire. Today the situation is changed. The heir to the throne is
dead, the chief victim of one of the most horrible assassinations ever shamefully
associated with the sacred cause of liberty. The old Emperors failing health is
rendered still more precarious by the shock of this murder, and the prospect that
the tremendous responsibilities of his kingship may shortly fall upon a young
man whose capacity for rule has never been proved must disturb all Europe.
For the present, however, the unutterable brutality of the slaughter of the
Archduke and the wife for whose sake he risked all his kingly prospects, and
the wounding of some members of their escort, absorbs the attention. No political murder was ever more deliberately performed. It was a festal day in Sarajevo, and there was no suspicion that the heir to the throne and the lady who
has been looked upon throughout all Austria and its dependences as a popular
idol were in any danger. The event proves that the successor to Francis Josephs
throne will have a task set before him which might bewilder the most heroic
mind. This murder was inspired not by the spirit of anarchy, but by revenge.
The seizure by Austria of Bosnia and Herzegovina was high-handed and in defiance of the concert of Europe. The act has been punished in a manner which
reflects no credit on Bosnia.
Source: New York Times, June 29, 1914.
Atlanta Journal & Constitution, June 30, 1914
Assassination Will Only Increase Instability in Balkans
Abhorrent as is assassination under any conditions, it is doubly sinister in the
cases of Archduke Francis Ferdinand, heir to the Austria-Hungarian throne,
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
and his wife. The bloody deed climaxes the fatalities that have followed the
House of Hapsburg with the relentlessness of Nemesis.
While the assassination seems to have been of Servian origin, the circumstances under which it transpired simply illustrate the loose manner in which
the Austria-Hungarian empire is hung together. In this respect, the domain
over which Francis Joseph has held sway is one of the most complicated, if not
the most complicated, in all Europe.
Austrias insatiable land lust has led her to absorb peoples of totally dissimilar birth, breeding and traditions. The tragedy at Sarajevo is the tragedy of inherited hatreds, of racial antipathies, religious and tribal feuds reaching back
many years for their origins.
In its personal aspects, the affair is sorrowful enough. Ferdinand seems to
have been a rather forceful character, gallant and fearless of danger. His marriage to the Bohemian countess, Sophie Chotek, illustrates his independence.
Francis Joseph and the Austrian politicians generally opposed the marriage
since, under the Hapsburg laws, any children born of such a union were ineligible to royal rank or succession. But Ferdinand stubbornly rejected any efforts to enter into a typical royal marriage of convenience, and instead made
a marriage in which he served his affections rather than political interests. The
marriage was, of course, a morganatic one, and bars his wife and children from
any of the royal prerogatives of husband and father.
The principal menaces of the assassination are in the intensification of bitterness between Servia and Austria, and the unrest that is bound to follow in
the other heterogeneous elements of the empire.
Source: Atlanta Journal & Constitution, June 30, 1914.
Document 15
ASSASSINATION OF EMILIANO ZAPATA (1919)
THREE ACCOUNTS OF THE AMBUSH
On April 10, 1919, the Mexican revolutionary Emiliano Zapata was killed, the victim
of an act of betrayal and assassination that shocked not only his followers, known as
Zapatistas, but even high members of the Constitutionalist government then in power.
The plot was hatched by General Pablo Gonzlez, some believe in collaboration with
Venustiano Carranza, the president of the Mexican Republic. In March, Zapata discovered that Gonzlez was embroiled in a conflict with one of his subordinates, Colonel
Jess Guajardo. As had happened often during the Mexican Revolution, Zapata hoped
to suborn Guajardo and convince him to switch sides; he therefore proposed this in
a letter to the colonel. Gonzlez instructed Guajardo to play along, in the hopes of
709
710
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
trapping and killing Zapata. Guajardo lured Zapata to the Chinameca Hacienda on
April 10, where an ambush killed Zapata and a small number of his personal escorts.
Leadership of the Zapatistas passed to Gildardo Magaa, but the death of Zapata
demoralized his movement and prompted efforts to find the way out of the civil war
without losing everything that Zapatas peasant rebels had achieved in their state of
Morelos. As it turned out, the exit from the labyrinth appeared in the form of an Obregonista rebellion against Carranza one year later, in April 1920.
The three documents reproduced below address the killing of Zapata. The first two
are the earliest known reports of the ambush. The first is by Salvador Reyes, Zapatas
personal secretary, who survived the ambush and sent his account to Magaa later
that day. The second is Guajardos version, sent to Pablo Gonzlez five days after the
fact. The final document is from a Mexican American newspaper, El Heraldo Mexicano (The Mexican Herald) published in Los Angeles, California, which expresses
the grief and shock felt by many Mexicans abroad. The author of the article, Ramn
Puente, blames Carranza for the killing and compares him to Shakespeares Macbeth,
who was prepared to commit murder in pursuit of his political ambitions.
Zapata Was Treacherously Murdered
Salvador Reyes Avils,
April 10, 1919
It is with profound sorrow that I must inform you that today, at half past
one P.M., Citizen General-in-Chief, Emiliano Zapata was treacherously murdered by the troops of Colonel Jess Guajardo. They carried out this premeditated and cowardly act at the Hacienda of San Juan Chinameca. So that you are
properly informed about this tragic event I will recount the following details:
As you know, we had learned about the deep discord between Pablo
Gonzlez and Jess Guajardo. As a result, General Zapata wrote to the latter
with an invitation to join the revolutionary movement.
Guajardo replied to this letter: I am ready to work alongside you, as long
as you give sufficient guarantees for me and my soldiers. Citizen General-inChief Zapata immediately answered Guajardo and offered every kind of assurances and congratulated him for being a man of his word and a gentleman,
who will honour his promises to the letter. The negotiations continued in this
way, by correspondence.
That very day, in order to definitively arrange things, the Citizen General-inChief sent Citizen Colonel Feliciano Palacios to Guajardos camp in San Juan
Chinameca. He remained with Guajardo until yesterday at four in the morning, when Guajardo headed to Jonacatepec. Palacios wrote two letters to the
Chief, copies of which are attached to this. Here I must mention a fact that
made Citizen General-in-Chief Zapata confident in the sincerity of Guajardo.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
The rumours were circulating publicly that Guajardo was negotiating to join
with Citizen General Zapata. These rumours were so widespread that some
villagers asked the Citizen General-in-Chief to punish some traitors who were
responsible for looting, rapes, murders and robberies. These were committed
by Victoriano Brcenes and his men who were then under the command of
Guajardo.
In view of this justified request Citizen General Zapata ordered Guajardo
to arrest Brcenes and 59 of his soldiers, under the command of General Margarito Ocampo and Colonel Guillermo Lpez. They were all disarmed by
Guajardo at a place called Mancornadero. This was yesterday while Guajardo
was in Jonacatepec.
Upon learning this we went to Pastor Station, and from there Palacios wrote
to Guajardo, by order of the Chief, to say that we would meet in Tepalcingo.
General Zapata planned go with thirty men and asked Guajardo to do likewise.
The Chief ordered the rest of his men to withdraw and headed to Tepalcingo
with thirty men, where we waited for Guajardo. Guajardo arrived at four pm,
but not with thirty soldiers. He had sixty cavalry and a machine gun.
It was there that we saw for the first time the man who, the next day, would
be the murderer of our General-in-Chief, who with all the nobility of his soul
received him with opened arms. He smiled and said: My Colonel Guajardo,
I congratulate you with all my heart! At 10 PM, we left Tepalcingo and headed
for Chinameca, where Guajardo arrived with his column. It was nearly eight in
the morning at Chinameca.
The Chief then ordered his people (150 men had joined us in Tepalcingo)
to wait in the courtyard. Meanwhile he, Guajardo, Colonels Castrejn, Casals
y Camano, and Colonel Palacios, went to discuss the coming campaign. A few
moments later rumours began to spread that the enemy was approaching. So
the Chief ordered Colonel Jos Rodrguez of his escort to take some men and
scout towards Santa Rita. Then Guajardo said to the Chief: General, if you
head towards Piedras Encimada, I will head towards the plain. The Chief
agreed and took thirty men to the point indicated. Getting ready to march,
Guajardo mustered his men, and returned saying: My General, I am at you orders. Will you take Infantry or Cavalry?
The plain has a lot of fences; you take the infantry replied General Zapata. At
Piedras Encimadas we explored the countryside but, seeing no enemy movement, we returned to Chinameca. It was approximately half past twelve. The
Chief sent Colonel Palacios to Guajardo, to ask about the promised delivery of
five thousand cartridges.
Then Captain Ignacio Castillo and a sergeant presented themselves, and
in the name of Guajardo invited the Chief to enter the Hacienda, where Guajardo and Palacios were arranging things. We waited another half an hour
with Castillo, and after repeated invitations, the Chief agreed. Were going to
711
712
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
see the Colonel; no more than ten men are going with me, he ordered, mounting the sorrel horse that Guajardo had given him the previous day.
He approached the door of the house of the Hacienda. As ordered, we ten
men followed, leaving the others to rest confidently under the shade of the
trees with their carbines at rest. The guard formed and seemed ready to do our
Chief honours. The bugle sounded the call of honour three times, and as it
played the last note our General-in-Chief arrived at the threshold of the door.
Then in the most perfidious, most cowardly, and most villainous manner, at
point blank range, and without giving him time to draw his pistols, the soldiers who were presenting arms fired their rifles twice and our unforgettable
General Zapata fell, never to rise again!
His faithful assistant Agustn Cortes died at the same time. Palacios also
must have been killed inside the Hacienda. The surprise was terrible. Soldiers
of the traitor Guajardo were high up in the parapets, in the plain, in the gully,
and everywhere (about a thousand men) and they discharged their weapons
against us. Very soon resistance was futile. On the one hand, we were a handful of men shocked by the loss of our Chief, and on the other hand, the enemy
soldiers took advantage of our natural confusion to attack us fiercely. That was
the tragedy. So it happened. Guajardo betrayed the nobility of our General-inChief. So Emiliano Zapata died.
Official Report on the Assassination of Zapata
Colonel Jess Guajardo,
April 15, 1919
Commander:
I am honoured to report on the operations carried out during April 8 to 10 of
this month.
April 8: Having received instructions from Citizen General-in-Chief of the
Army Corps of Operations in the South, Pablo Gonzalez, I left with my escort
heading towards Chinameca at 8:15 AM, arriving at Moyotepec at 11 AM the
same day. There I waited for an escort of fifty men commanded by a second
captain. I left that point and reached Chinameca at 3 PM. I then proceeded to
communicate with Emiliano Zapata through the so-called General Feliciano
Palacios, secretary of the aforementioned Zapata, who spent a few days with
our detachment, finalizing arrangements to incorporate me and my men, unknown to the Supreme Government, receiving later instructions.
April 9: At one oclock this morning, leading my men, mounted, fully armed
and well-supplied with ammunition, we left the Chinameca Hacienda heading to Huichila Station, arriving there at 7 am, where we foddered the horses
and received instructions for the attack on Jonacatepec. We headed there at
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
9 AM and arrived within a kilometre of that place at 12:45 PM, where, as agreed,
I met the men waiting for me, led by Citizen Captain Salgado, of the 66th Regiment. We then proceeded to attack and capture the plaza, fighting for half an
hour, losing two men of the troop who died in the battle.
At 4 PM, I left Jonacatepec to meet Emiliano Zapata for the first time in front
of the Pastor Station, bringing approximately 600 men. I was well received by
the southern ringleader, who expressed his desire to meet my officers. This was
done immediately. I was invited to move out to Tepalcingo, where Zapata accepted my forces. We spent the night there, where there was a force of Zapatistas of close to 1300.
At 8 AM, Zapata, with a force of approximately four hundred men, came to
inform me that Constitutionalist forces numbering three thousand were advancing to attack us. He gave orders to some of his forces to fight them and ordered to me to stay in my place. Meanwhile Emiliano and his escort occupied
Piedra Encimada in order to repel an attack.
At this time the so-called Generals Castrejn, Zeferino Ortega, Lucio Bastida,
Gil Muoz and Jess Capistrn arrived, bringing with them forces close to
2500 men.
At 1:30 PM, I was at the Hacienda with Castrejn, Palacios, Bastida and another general whose name I do not remember, who came to call for Emiliano
Zapata. Citizen Captain Salgado also arrived at this time.
At 2 PM, Zapata arrived with 100 to enter the Hacienda. I had arranged in
advance to have the guard at the entrance give him honours, with orders to fire
on the ringleader at the second call of honour, while the rest of the force was organized and ready to fight his men. The result was that at 2:10 PM he appeared
before the guard who opened fire and killed Emiliano Zapata himself, Zeferino
Ortega, and Gil Muoz as well as other generals and troops who could not be
identified. The casualties, dead and wounded, were approximately 30 men.
At the same time, I personally shot Palacios, while Castrejn y Bastida was
also killed on the spot. I note that Citizen Captain Salgado, who had been at
my side left at the precise time of discharge, returning moments later. There
was already a mounted force that pursued the enemy in different directions to
completely disperse them, leaving large numbers of dead and wounded, including the so-called General Capistrn.
An hour later, the bugler sounded Bota Silla with the aim delivering the
corpse of Zapata. Half an hour later, at 4 PM, I left the Hacienda with my
force, heading towards Cuautla, where we arrived at 9:10 PM, delivering the
corpse to Citizen General-in-Chief of the Army Corps of Operations in the
South, Pablo Gonzlez, as proof that I fulfilled the order I was given 60 hours
earlier.
This day, we lost 16 men.
I am honoured, my General, to present my obedience and respect.
713
714
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F E M I L I A N O Z A PATA
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F S E N AT O R H U E Y P. L O N G
Document 16
ASSASSINATION OF SENATOR HUEY P. LONG
(1935)SENATOR LONGS SHARE
THE WEALTH PROGRAM (1934)
Senator Huey P. Long was a flamboyant, populist politician who dominated the politics of his home state of Louisiana, where he was wildly popular. In February 1934, in
the following statement that Long had read into the congressional record, he laid out
his Share the Wealth program for lifting the country out of the Great Depression.
The plan contained some elements in common with President Franklin D. Roosevelts
New Deal, such as old-age pensions for persons over 60 and public works projects
to provide employment. However, it also proposed caps on how much net worth an
individual could accumulate and limits on annual incomes and inheritances as well
as higher taxes on the wealthy. Many viewed the Share the Wealth Society that Long
founded to promote the program as merely a vehicle for a possible third party challenge to Roosevelt in 1936. When this was true or not, Longs ambition was stilled on
September 8, 1935, when he was shot in the Louisiana State Capitol in Baton Rouge
by Dr. Carl Weiss, the son-in-law of a long-time political opponent. Weiss was shot
and killed by Longs bodyguards and Long, who was wounded in the abdomen, died
two days later.
Mr. Long: Mr. President, I send to the desk and ask to have printed in the
RECORD not a speech but what is more in the nature of an appeal to the people of America.
There being no objection, the paper entitled Carry Out the Command of
the Lord was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows:
By Huey P. Long, United States Senator
People of America: In every community get together at once and organize a
share-our-wealth societyMotto: Every man a king
Principles and platform:
1. To limit poverty by providing that every deserving family shall share in
the wealth of America for not less than one third of the average wealth,
thereby to possess not less than $5,000 free of debt.
2. To limit fortunes to such a few million dollars as will allow the balance of
the American people to share in the wealth and profits of the land.
3. Old-age pensions of $30 per month to persons over 60 years of age
who do not earn as much as $1,000 per year or who possess less than
$10,000 in cash or property, thereby to remove from the field of labor in
times of unemployment those who have contributed their share to the
public service.
715
716
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F S E N AT O R H U E Y P. L O N G
4. To limit the hours of work to such an extent as to prevent overproduction and to give the workers of America some share in the recreations,
conveniences, and luxuries of life.
5. To balance agricultural production with what can be sold and consumed
according to the laws of God, which have never failed.
6. To care for the veterans of our wars.
7. Taxation to run the Government to be supported, first, by reducing big
fortunes from the top, thereby to improve the country and provide employment in public works whenever agricultural surplus is such as to
render unnecessary, in whole or in part, any particular crop.
Simple and ConcreteNot an Experiment
To share our wealth by providing for every deserving family to have one third
of the average wealth would mean that, at the worst, such a family could have
a fairly comfortable home, an automobile, and a radio, with other reasonable
home conveniences, and a place to educate their children. Through sharing
the work, that is, by limiting the hours of toil so that all would share in what
is made and produced in the land, every family would have enough coming in
every year to feed, clothe, and provide a fair share of the luxuries of life to its
members. Such is the result to a family, at the worst.
From the worst to the best there would be no limit to opportunity. One
might become a millionaire or more. There would be a chance for talent to
make a man big, because enough would be floating in the land to give brains
its chance to be used. As it is, no matter how smart a man may be, everything
is tied up in so few hands that no amount of energy or talent has a chance to
gain any of it.
Would it break up big concerns? No. It would simply mean that, instead of
one man getting all the one concern made, that there might be 1,000 or 10,000
persons sharing in such excess fortune, any one of whom, or all of whom,
might be millionaires and over.
I ask somebody in every city, town, village, and farm community of America
to take this as my personal request to call a meeting of as many neighbors and
friends as will come to it to start a share-our-wealth society. Elect a president
and a secretary and charge no dues. The meeting can be held at a courthouse,
in some town hall or public building, or in the home of someone.
It does not matter how many will come to the first meeting. Get a society
organized, if it has only two members. Then let us get to work quick, quick,
quick to put an end by law to people starving and going naked in this land of
too much to eat and too much to wear. The case is all with us. It is the word
and work of the Lord. The Gideons had but two men when they organized.
Three tailors of Tooley Street drew the Magna Carta of England. The Lord says:
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F S E N AT O R H U E Y P. L O N G
For where two or three are gathered together in My name, there am I in the
midst of them.
We propose to help our people into the place where the Lord said was their
rightful own and no more.
We have waited long enough for these financial masters to do these things.
They have promised and promised. Now we find our country $10 billion further in debt on account of the depression, and big lenders even propose to
get 90 percent of that out of the hides of the common people in the form of a
sales tax.
There is nothing wrong with the United States. We have more food than we
can eat. We have more clothes and things out of which to make clothes than
we can wear. We have more houses and lands than the whole 120 million can
use if they all had good homes. So what is the trouble? Nothing except that a
handful of men have everything and the balance of the people have nothing if
their debts were paid. There should be every man a king in this land flowing
with milk and honey instead of the lords of finance at the top and slaves and
peasants at the bottom.
Now be prepared for the slurs and snickers of some high-ups when you start
your local spread-our-wealth society. Also when you call your meeting be on
your guard for some smart-aleck tool of the interests to come in and ask questions. Refer such to me for an answer to any question, and I will send you a
copy. Spend your time getting the people to work to save their children and to
save their homes, or to get a home for those who have already lost their own.
To explain the title, motto, and principles of such a society I give the full information, viz:
Title: Share-our-wealth society is simply to mean that Gods creatures on this
lovely American continent have a right to share in the wealth they have created
in this country. They have the right to a living, with the conveniences and some
of the luxuries of this life, so long as there are too many or enough for all. They
have a right to raise their children in a healthy, wholesome atmosphere and to
educate them, rather than to face the dread of their under-nourishment and
sadness by being denied a real life.
Motto: Every man a king conveys the great plan of God and of the Declaration of Independence, which said: All men are created equal. It conveys that
no one man is the lord of another, but that from the head to the foot of every
man is carried his sovereignty.
Now to cover the principles of the share-our-wealth society, I give them in
order:
1. To limit poverty:
We propose that a deserving family shall share in our wealth of America at least for one third the average. An average family is slightly less
717
718
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F S E N AT O R H U E Y P. L O N G
than five persons. The number has become less during depression. The
United States total wealth in normal times is about $400 billion or about
$15,000 to a family. If there were fair distribution of our things in America, our national wealth would be three or four or five times the $400
billion, because a free, circulating wealth is worth many times more than
wealth congested and frozen into a few hands as is Americas wealth. But,
figuring only on the basis of wealth as valued when frozen into a few
hands, there is the average of $15,000 to the family. We say that we will
limit poverty of the deserving people. One third of the average wealth to
the family, or $5,000, is a fair limit to the depths we will allow any one
mans family to fall. None too poor, none too rich.
2. To limit fortunes:
The wealth of this land is tied up in a few hands. It makes no difference
how many years the laborer has worked, nor does it make any difference
how many dreary rows the farmer has plowed, the wealth he has created
is in the hands of manipulators. They have not worked any more than
many other people who have nothing. Now we do not propose to hurt
these very rich persons. We simply say that when they reach the place
of millionaires they have everything they can use and they ought to let
somebody else have something. As it is, 0.1 of 1 percent of the bank depositors nearly half of the money in the banks, leaving 99.9 of bank depositors owning the balance. Then two thirds of the people do not even
have a bank account. The lowest estimate is that 4 percent of the people
own 85 percent of our wealth. The people cannot ever come to light unless we share our wealth, hence the society to do it.
3. Old-age pensions:
Everyone has begun to realize something must be done for our old people who work out their lives, feed and clothe children and are left penniless in their declining years. They should be made to look forward to
their mature years for comfort rather than fear. We propose that, at the
age of 60, every person should begin to draw a pension from our Government of $30 per month, unless the person of 60 or over has an income of over $1,000 per year or is worth $10,000, which is two thirds of
the average wealth in America, even figured on a basis of it being frozen
into a few hands. Such a pension would retire from labor those persons
who keep the rising generations from finding employment.
4. To limit the hours of work:
This applies to all industry. The longer hours the human family can rest
from work, the more it can consume. It makes no difference how many
labor-saving devices we may invent, just as long as we keep cutting
down the hours and sharing what those machines produce, the better we
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F S E N AT O R H U E Y P. L O N G
719
720
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
The Lord prescribed the last form. It would preserve all our gains, share
them among our population, guarantee a greater country and a happy people.
The need for such share-our-wealth society is to spread the truth among the
people and to convey their sentiment to their Members of Congress.
Whenever such a local society has been organized, please send me notice of
the same, so that I may send statistics and data which such local society can
give out in their community, either through word of mouth in meetings, by circulars, or, when possible, in local newspapers.
Please understand that the Wall Street controlled public press will give you
as little mention as possible and will condemn and ridicule your efforts. Such
makes necessary the organizations to share the wealth of this land among the
people, which the financial masters are determined they will not allow to be
done. Where possible, I hope those organizing a society in one community will
get in touch with their friends in other communities and get them to organize
societies in them. Anyone can have copies of this article reprinted in circular
form to distribute wherever they may desire, or, if they want me to have them
printed for them, I can do so and mail them to any address for 60 cents per
hundred or $4 per thousand copies.
I introduced in Congress and supported other measures to bring about the
sharing of our wealth when I first reached the United States Senate in January
1932. The main efforts to that effect polled about six votes in the Senate at first.
Last spring my plan polled the votes of nearly twenty United States Senators,
becoming dangerous in proportions to the financial lords. Since then I have
been abused in the newspapers and over the radio for everything under the
sun. Now that I am pressing this program, the lies and abuse in the big newspapers and over the radio are a matter of daily occurrence. It will all become
greater with this effort. Expect that. Meantime go ahead with the work to organize a share-our-wealth society.
Source: Social Security Administration. Official Social Security Website. http://
www.ssa.gov/history/longsen.html.
Document 17
ASSASSINATION OF NGO DINH DIEM (1963)STATE
DEPARTMENT CABLES CONCERNING THE COUP THAT
OVERTHREW PRESIDENT DIEM OF SOUTH VIETNAM
Reproduced below is a series of cables involving U.S. ambassador to Vietnam, Henry
Cabot Lodge Jr., just before the coup that overthrew Ngo Dinh Diems regime in the
Republic of Vietnam, or South Vietnam, on November 1, 1963. Lodge sent the first
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
cable on October 25, 1963, to the special assistant to the president for national security affairs, McGeorge Bundy, regarding Ngo Dinh Diems oppressive regime in South
Vietnam. Lodge stated, It is vital that we neither thwart a coup nor that we are even
in a position where we do not know what is going on, although the United States had
unofficially agreed to support the generals planning the coup in the establishment of
a superior government.
The second cable, from Bundy to Lodge, expressed reservations, stating that the coup
needed to be delayed, that Bundy did not believe victory was possible, and that prolonged fighting might incur. The third document is a transcript of a phone conversation
between Ngo Dinh Diem and Lodge on November 1, 1963, in which Lodge denies any
U.S. involvement in the insurgency. The fourth document is a November 2 cable from
Lodge describing what was known of the circumstances surrounding the death of Diem.
Cable from Ambassador Henry Cabot Lodge
to National Security Adviser McGeorge
Bundy (October 25, 1963)
1. I appreciate the concern expressed by you in ref. a relative to the Gen.
Don/Conein relationship, and also the present lack of firm intelligence
on the details of the generals plot. I hope that ref. b will assist in clearing
up some of the doubts relative to generals plans, and I am hopeful that
the detailed plans promised for two days before the coup attempt will
clear up any remaining doubts.
2. CAS [Classified American Source-refers to CIA] has been punctilious in
carrying out my instructions. I have personally approved each meeting
between Gen. Don and Conein who has carried out my orders in each
instance explicitly. While I share your concern about the continued involvement of Conein in this matter, a suitable substitute for Conein as
the principal contact is not presently available. Conein, as you know, is a
friend of some eighteen years standing with Gen. Don, and General Don
has expressed extreme reluctance to deal with anyone else. I do not believe the involvement of another American in close contact with the generals would be productive. We are, however, considering the feasibility of
a plan for the introduction of an additional officer as a cut-out between
Conein and a designee of Gen. Don for communication purposes only.
This officer is completely unwitting of any details of past or present coup
activities and will remain so.
3. With reference to Gen Harkins comment to Gen. Don which Don reports
to have referred to a presidential directive and the proposal for a meeting
with me, this may have served the useful purpose of allaying the Generals fears as to our interest. If this were a provocation, the GVN could
have assumed and manufactured any variations of the same theme. As a
721
722
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
723
724
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
reporting with prompt account of any important divergences in assessments of Harkins and Smith.
8. If coup should start, question of protecting U.S. nationals at once arises.
We can move Marine Battalion into Saigon by air from Okinawa within
24 hoursif available. We are sending instructions to CINCPAC to arrange orderly movement of seaborne Marine Battalion to waters adjacent to South Vietnam in position to close Saigon within approximately
24 hours.
9. We are now examining post-coup contingencies here and request
your immediate recommendations on position to be adopted after
coup begins, especially with respect to requests for assistance of different sorts from one side or the other also request you forward contingency recommendations for action if coup (A) succeeds, (B) fails,
(C) is indecisive.
10. We reiterate burden of proof must be on coup group to show a substantial possibility of quick success; otherwise, we should discourage
them from proceeding since a miscalculation could result in jeopardizing U.S. position in Southeast Asia.
Phone Conversation between Ngo Dinh Diem and
Henry Cabot Lodge (November 1, 1963)
DIEM:
725
726
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F N G O D I N H D I E M
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Document 18
ASSASSINATION OF JOHN F. KENNEDY
(1963)EXCERPTS FROM THE WARREN
COMMISSION REPORT (1964)
In a report issued on September 27, 1964, the Warren Commission presented its
findings to the American people regarding the assassination of John F. Kennedy on
November 22, 1963. Headed by U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice Earl Warren, and
comprising many leading congressional and government figures of the day, including
future president Gerald R. Ford, the commission held that Lee Harvey Oswald had
acted alone in killing Kennedy and had not been part of a larger conspiracy. Officials
hoped that the report would put to rest a wide range of conspiracy theories regarding
the assassination, but, if anything, the report actually stirred more controversy. Many
Americans continue to believe that a conspiracy of one sort or another was behind
the assassination. The following excerpts from the report of the Warren Commission
include a narrative of the assassination and the commissions conclusions.
727
728
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
729
730
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
down the gradual descent toward a railroad overpass under which the motorcade would proceed before reaching the Stemmons Freeway. The front of the
Texas School Book Depository was now on the Presidents right, and he waved
to the crowd assembled there as he passed the building. Dealey Plazaan
open, landscaped area marking the western end of downtown Dallas stretched
out to the Presidents left. A Secret Service agent riding in the motorcade radioed the Trade Mart that the President would arrive in 5 minutes.
Seconds later shots resounded in rapid succession. The Presidents hands
moved to his neck. He appeared to stiffen momentarily and lurch slightly forward in his seat. A bullet had entered the base of the back of his neck slightly
to the right of the spine. It traveled downward and exited from the front of
the neck, causing a nick in the left lower portion of the knot in the Presidents
necktie. Before the shooting started, Governor Connally had been facing toward the crowd on the right. He started to turn toward the left and suddenly
felt a blow on his back. The Governor had been hit by a bullet which entered at
the extreme right side of his back at a point below his right armpit. The bullet
traveled through his chest in a downward and forward direction, exited below
his right nipple, passed through his right wrist which had been in his lap, and
then caused a wound to his left thigh. The force of the bullets impact appeared
to spin the Governor to his right, and Mrs. Connally pulled him down into her
lap. Another bullet then struck President Kennedy in the rear portion of his
head, causing a massive and fatal wound. The President fell to the left into Mrs.
Kennedys lap.
Secret Service Agent Clinton J. Hill, riding on the left running board of the
follow-up car, heard a noise which sounded like a firecracker and saw the
President suddenly lean forward and to the left. Hill jumped off the car and
raced toward the Presidents limousine. In the front seat of the Vice-Presidential
car, Agent Youngblood heard an explosion and noticed unusual movements in
the crowd. He vaulted into the rear seat and sat on the Vice President in order
to protect him. At the same time Agent Kellerman in the front seat of the Presidential limousine turned to observe the President. Seeing that the President
was struck, Kellerman instructed the driver, Lets get out of here; we are hit.
He radioed ahead to the lead car, Get us to the hospital immediately. Agent
Greer immediately accelerated the Presidential car. As it gained speed, Agent
Hill managed to pull himself onto the back of the car where Mrs. Kennedy
had climbed. Hill pushed her back into the rear seat and shielded the stricken
President and Mrs. Kennedy as the Presidents car proceeded at high speed to
Parkland Memorial Hospital, 4 miles away.
At Parkland, the President was immediately treated by a team of physicians
who had been alerted for the Presidents arrival by the Dallas Police Department
as the result of a radio message from the motorcade after the shooting. The doctors noted irregular breathing movements and a possible heartbeat, although
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
they could not detect a pulsebeat. They observed the extensive wound in the
Presidents head and a small wound approximately one-fourth inch in diameter
in the lower third of his neck. In act effort to facilitate breathing, the physicians
performed a tracheotomy by enlarging the throat wound and inserting a tube.
Totally absorbed in the immediate task of trying to preserve the Presidents life,
the attending doctors never turned the president over for an examination of
his back. At l P.M., after all heart activity ceased and the Last Rites were administered by a priest, President Kennedy was pronounced dead. Governor Connally underwent surgery and ultimately recovered from his serious wounds.
Upon learning of the Presidents death, Vice President Johnson left Parkland Hospital under close guard and proceeded to the Presidential plane at
Love Field. Mrs. Kennedy, accompanying her husbands body, boarded the
plane shortly thereafter. At 2:38 P.M., in the central compartment of the plane,
Lyndon B. Johnson was sworn in as the 36th President of the United States
by Federal District Court Judge Sarah T. Hughes. The plane left immediately
for Washington, D.C., arriving at Andrews AFB, Md., at 5:58 P.M., e.s.t. The
Presidents body was taken to the National Naval Medical Center, Bethesda,
Md., where it was given a complete pathological examination. The autopsy disclosed the large head wound observed at Parkland and the wound in the front
of the neck which had been enlarged by the Parkland doctors when they performed the tracheotomy. Both of these wounds were described in the autopsy
report as being presumably of exit. In addition the autopsy revealed a small
wound of entry in the rear of the Presidents skull and another wound of entry
near the base of the back of the neck. The autopsy report stated the cause of
death as Gunshot wound, head and the bullets which struck the President
were described as having been fired from a point behind and somewhat above
the level of the deceased.
At the scene of the shooting, there was evident confusion at the outset concerning the point of origin of the shots. Witnesses differed in their accounts
of the direction from which the sound of the shots emanated. Within a few
minutes, however, attention centered on the Texas School Book Depository
Building as the source of the shots. The building was occupied by a private
corporation, the Texas School Book Depository Co., which distributed school
textbooks of several publishers and leased space to representatives of the publishers. Most of the employees in the building worked for these publishers. The
balance, including a 15-man warehousing crew, were employees of the Texas
School Book Depository Co. itself.
Several eyewitnesses in front of the building reported that they saw a rifle
being fired from the southeast corner window on the sixth floor of the Texas
School Book Depository. One eyewitness, Howard L. Brennan, had been watching the parade from a point on Elm Street directly opposite and facing the
building. He promptly told a policeman that he had seen a slender man, about
731
732
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
5 feet 10 inches, in his early thirties, take deliberate aim from the sixth-floor
corner window and fire a rifle in the direction of the Presidents car. Brennan
thought he might be able to identify the man since he had noticed him in the
window a few minutes before the motorcade made the turn onto Elm Street.
At 12:34 P.M., the Dallas police radio mentioned the Depository Building as a
possible source of the shots, and at 12:45 P.M., the police radio broadcast a description of the suspected assassin based primarily on Brennans observations.
When the shots were fired, a Dallas motorcycle patrolman, Marrion L. Baker,
was riding in the motorcade at a point several cars behind the President. He
had turned right from Main Street onto Houston Street and was about 200 feet
south of Elm Street when he heard a shot. Baker, having recently returned from
a week of deer hunting, was certain the shot came from a high-powered rifle.
He looked up and saw pigeons scattering in the air from their perches on the
Texas School Book Depository Building. He raced his motorcycle to the building, dismounted, scanned the area to the west and pushed his way through the
spectators toward the entrance. There he encountered Roy Truly, the building
superintendent, who offered Baker his help. They entered the building, and
ran toward the two elevators in the rear. Finding that both elevators were on an
upper floor, they dashed up the stairs. Not more than 2 minutes had elapsed
since the shooting.
When they reached the second-floor landing on their way up to the top
of the building, Patrolman Baker thought he caught a glimpse of someone
through the small glass window in the door separating the hall area near the
stairs from the small vestibule leading into the lunchroom. Gun in hand, he
rushed to the door and saw a man about 20 feet away walking toward the other
end of the lunchroom. The man was empty handed. At Bakers command, the
man turned and approached him. Truly, who had started up the stairs to the
third floor ahead of Baker, returned to see what had delayed the patrolman.
Baker asked Truly whether he knew the man in the lunchroom. Truly replied
that the man worked in the building, whereupon Baker turned from the man
and proceeded, with Truly, up the stairs. The man they encountered had started
working in the Texas School Book Depository Building on October 16, 1963.
His fellow workers described him as very quieta loner. His name was Lee
Harvey Oswald.
Within about 1 minute after his encounter with Baker and Truly, Oswald was
seen passing through the second-floor offices. In his hand was a full Coke
bottle which he had purchased from a vending machine in the lunchroom. He
was walking toward the front of the building where a passenger elevator and
a short flight of stairs provided access to the main entrance of the building
on the first floor. Approximately 7 minutes later, at about 12:40 P.M., Oswald
boarded a bus at a point on Elm Street seven short blocks east of the Depository Building. The bus was traveling west toward the very building from which
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Oswald had come. Its route lay through the Oak Cliff section in southwest
Dallas, where it would pass seven blocks east of the roominghouse in which
Oswald was living, at 1026 North Beckley Avenue. On the bus was Mrs. Mary
Bledsoe, one of Oswalds former landladies who immediately recognized him.
Oswald stayed on the bus approximately 3 or 4 minutes, during which time it
proceeded only two blocks because of the traffic jam created by the motorcade
and the assassination. Oswald then left the bus. A few minutes later he entered
a vacant taxi four blocks away and asked the driver to take him to a point on
North Beckley Avenue several blocks beyond his roominghouse. The trip required 5 or 6 minutes. At about 1 P.M. Oswald arrived at the roominghouse.
The housekeeper, Mrs. Earlene Roberts, was surprised to see Oswald at midday and remarked to him that he seemed to be in quite a hurry. He made no
reply. A few minutes later Oswald emerged from his room zipping up his jacket
and rushed out of the house.
Approximately 14 minutes later, and just 45 minutes after the assassination, another violent shooting occurred in Dallas. The victim was Patrolman
J. D. Tippit of the Dallas police, an officer with a good record during his more
than 11 years with the police force. He was shot near the intersection of 10th
Street and Patton Avenue, about nine-tenths of a mile from Oswalds roominghouse. At the time of the assassination, Tippit was alone in his patrol car, the
routine practice for most police patrol officers at this time of day. He had been
ordered by radio at 12:45 P.M. to proceed to the central Oak Cliff area as part
of a concentration of patrol car activity around the center of the city following
the assassination. At 12:54 Tippit radioed that he had moved as directed and
would be available for any emergency. By this time the police radio had broadcast several messages alerting the police to the suspect described by Brennan at
the scene of the assassinationslender white male, about 30 years old, 5 feet
10 inches and weighing about 165 pounds.
At approximately 1:15 P.M., Tippit was driving slowly in an easterly direction on East 10th Street in Oak Cliff. About 100 feet past the intersection of
10th Street and Patton Avenue, Tippit pulled up alongside a man walking in
the same direction. The man met the general description of the suspect wanted
in connection with the assassination. He walked over to Tippits car, rested his
arms on the door on the right-hand side of the car, and apparently exchanged
words with Tippit through the window. Tippit opened the door on the left side
and started to walk around the front of his car. As he reached the front wheel
on the drivers side, the man on the sidewalk drew a revolver and fired several
shots in rapid succession, hitting Tippit four times and killing him instantly.
An automobile repairman, Domingo Benavides, heard the shots and stopped
his pickup truck on the opposite side of the street about 25 feet in front of Tippits car. He observed the gunman start back toward Patton Avenue, removing
the empty cartridge cases from the gun as he went. Benavides rushed to Tippits
733
734
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
side. The patrolman, apparently dead, was lying on his revolver, which was out
of its holster. Benavides promptly reported the shooting to police headquarters
over the radio in Tippits car. The message was received shortly after 1:16 P.M.
As the gunman left the scene, he walked hurriedly back toward Patton Avenue and turned left, heading south. Standing on the northwest corner of 10th
Street and Patton Avenue was Helen Markham, who had been walking south
on Patton Avenue and had seen both the killer and Tippit cross the intersection in front of her as she waited on the curb for traffic to pass. She witnessed
the shooting and then saw the man with a gun in his hand walk back toward
the corner and cut across the lawn of the corner house as he started south on
Patton Avenue.
In the corner house itself, Mrs. Barbara Jeanette Davis and her sister-in-law,
Mrs. Virginia Davis, heard the shots and rushed to the door in time to see the
man walk rapidly across the lawn shaking a revolver as if he were emptying it
of cartridge cases. Later that day each woman found a cartridge case near the
home. As the gunman turned the corner he passed alongside a taxicab which
was parked on Patton Avenue a few feet from 10th Street. The driver, William W.
Scoggins, had seen the slaying and was now crouched behind his cab on the
street side. As the gunman cut through the shrubbery on the lawn, Scoggins
looked up and saw the man approximately 12 feet away. In his hand was a pistol and he muttered words which sounded to Scoggins like poor dumb cop
or poor damn cop.
After passing Scoggins, the gunman crossed to the west side of Patton Avenue and ran south toward Jefferson Boulevard, a main Oak Cliff thoroughfare.
On the east side of Patton, between l0th Street and Jefferson Boulevard, Ted
Callaway, a used car salesman, heard the shots and ran to the sidewalk. As the
man with the gun rushed past, Callaway shouted Whats going on? The man
merely shrugged, ran on to Jefferson Boulevard and turned right. On the next
corner was a gas station with a parking lot in the rear. The assailant ran into the
lot, discarded his jacket and then continued his flight west on Jefferson.
In a shoe store a few blocks farther west on Jefferson, the manager, Johnny
Calvin Brewer, heard the siren of a police car moments after the radio in his
store announced the shooting of the police officer in Oak Cliff. Brewer saw a
man step quickly into the entranceway of the store and stand there with his
back toward the street. When the police car made a U-turn and headed back
in the direction of the Tippit shooting, the man left and Brewer followed him.
He saw the man enter the Texas Theatre, a motion picture house about 60 feet
away, without buying a ticket. Brewer pointed this out to the cashier, Mrs. Julia
Postal, who called the police. The time was shortly after 1:40 P.M.
At 1:29 P.M., the police radio had noted the similarity in the descriptions
of the suspects in the Tippit shooting and the assassination. At 1:45 P.M.,
in response to Mrs. Postals call, the police radio sounded the alarm: Have
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
information a suspect just went in the Texas Theatre on West Jefferson. Within
minutes the theater was surrounded. The house lights were then turned up.
Patrolman M. N. McDonald and several other policemen approached the man,
who had been pointed out to them by Brewer.
McDonald ordered the man to his feet and heard him say, Well, its all over
now. The man drew a gun from his waist with one hand and struck the officer
with the other. McDonald struck out with his right hand and grabbed the gun
with his left hand. After a brief struggle McDonald and several other police officers disarmed and handcuffed the suspect and drove him to police headquarters, arriving at approximately 2 P.M.
Following the assassination, police cars had rushed to the Texas School
Book Depository in response to the many radio messages reporting that the
shots had been fired from the Depository Building. Inspector J. Herbert Sawyer
of the Dallas Police Department arrived at the scene shortly after hearing the
first of these police radio messages at 12:34 P.M. Some of the officers who had
been assigned to the area of Elm and Houston Streets for the motorcade were
talking to witnesses and watching the building when Sawyer arrived. Sawyer
entered the building and rode a passenger elevator to the fourth floor, which
was the top floor for this elevator. He conducted a quick search, returned to
the main floor and, between approximately 12:37 and 12:40 P.M., ordered that
no one be permitted to leave the building.
Shortly before 1 P.M. Capt. J. Will Fritz, chief of the homicide and robbery
bureau of the Dallas Police Department, arrived to take charge of the investigation. Searching the sixth floor, Deputy Sheriff Luke Mooney noticed a pile of
cartons in the southeast corner. He squeezed through the boxes and realized
immediately that he had discovered the point from which the shots had been
fired. On the floor were three empty cartridge cases. A carton had apparently
been placed on the floor at the side of the window so that a person sitting on
the carton could look down Elm Street toward the overpass and scarcely be
noticed from the outside. Between this carton and the half-open window were
three additional cartons arranged at such an angle that a rifle resting on the
top carton would be aimed directly at the motorcade as it moved away from
the building. The high stack of boxes, which first attracted Mooneys attention
effectively screened a person at the window from the view of anyone else on
the floor.
Mooneys discovery intensified the search for additional evidence on the
sixth floor, and at 1:22 P.M. approximately 10 minutes after the cartridge cases
were found, Deputy Sheriff Eugene Boone turned his flashlight in the direction
of two rows of boxes in the northwest corner near the staircase. Stuffed between the two rows was a bolt-action rifle with a telescopic sight. The rifle was
not touched until it could be photographed. When Lt. J. C. Day of the police
identification bureau decided that the wooden stock and the metal knob at the
735
736
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
end of the bolt contained no prints, he held the rifle by the stock while Captain Fritz ejected a live shell by operating the bolt. Lieutenant Day promptly
noted that stamped on the rifle itself was the serial number C2766 as well
as the markings 1940 MADE ITALY and CAL. 6.5. The rifle was about
40 inches long and when disassembled it could fit into a handmade paper sack
which after the assassination, was found in the southeast corner of the building
within a few feet of the cartridge cases.
As Fritz and Day were completing their examination of this rifle on the sixth
floor, Roy Truly, the building superintendent, approached with information
which he felt should be brought to the attention of the police. Earlier, while
the police were questioning the employees, Truly had observed that Lee Harvey Oswald, 1 of the 15 men who worked in the warehouse, was missing.
After Truly provided Oswalds name, address, and general description, Fritz
left for police headquarters. He arrived at headquarters shortly after 2 P.M. and
asked two detectives to pick up the employee who was missing from the Texas
School Book Depository. Standing nearby were the police officers who had just
arrived with the man arrested in the Texas Theatre. When Fritz mentioned the
name of the missing employee, he learned that the man was already in the interrogation room. The missing School Book Depository employee and the suspect
who had been apprehended in the Texas Theatre were one and the sameLee
Harvey Oswald.
The suspect Fritz was about to question in connection with the assassination
of the President and the murder of a policeman was born in New Orleans on
October 18, 1939, 2 months after the death of his father. His mother, Marguerite Claverie Oswald, had two older children. One, John Pic, was a half-brother
to Lee from an earlier marriage which had ended in divorce. The other was
Robert Oswald, a full brother to Lee and 5 years older. When Lee Oswald was
3, Mrs. Oswald placed him in an orphanage where his brother and half-brother
were already living, primarily because she had to work.
In January 1944, when Lee was 4, he was taken out of the orphanage, and
shortly thereafter his mother moved with him to Dallas, Tex., where the older
boys joined them at the end of the school year. In May of 1945 Marguerite Oswald married her third husband, Edwin A. Ekdahl. While the two older boys
attended a military boarding school, Lee lived at home and developed a warm
attachment to Ekdahl, occasionally accompanying his mother and stepfather
on business trips around the country. Lee started school in Benbrook, Tex., but
in the fall of 1946, after a separation from Ekdahl, Marguerite Oswald reentered Lee in the first grade in Covington, La. In January 1947, while Lee was
still in the first grade, the family moved to Fort Worth, Tex., as the result of an
attempted reconciliation between Ekdahl and Lees mother. A year and a half
later, before Lee was 9, his mother was divorced from her third husband as the
result of a divorce action instituted by Ekdahl. Lees school record during the
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
next 5 and a half years in Fort Worth was average, although generally it grew
poorer each year. The comments of teachers and others who knew him at that
time do not reveal any unusual personality traits or characteristics.
Another change for Lee Oswald occurred in August 1952, a few months
after he completed the sixth grade. Marguerite Oswald and her 12-year-old
son moved to New York City where Marguerites oldest son, John Pic, was stationed with the Coast Guard. The ensuing year and one-half in New York was
marked by Lees refusals to attend school and by emotional and psychological problems of a seemingly serious nature. Because he had become a chronic
school truant, Lee underwent psychiatric study at Youth House, an institution
in New York for juveniles who have had truancy problems or difficulties with
the law, and who appear to require psychiatric observation, or other types of
guidance. The social worker assigned to his case described him as seriously
detached and withdrawn and noted a rather pleasant, appealing quality
about this emotionally starved, affectionless youngster. Lee expressed the feeling to the social worker that his mother did not care for him and regarded
him as a burden. He experienced fantasies about being all powerful and hurting people, but during his stay at Youth House he was apparently not a behavior problem. He appeared withdrawn and evasive, a boy who preferred to
spend his time alone, reading and watching television. His tests indicated that
he was above average in intelligence for his age group. The chief psychiatrist
of Youth House diagnosed Lees problem as a personality pattern disturbance
with schizoid features and passive-aggressive tendencies. He concluded that
the boy was an emotionally, quite disturbed youngster and recommended
psychiatric treatment.
In May 1953, after having been at Youth House for 3 weeks, Lee Oswald returned to school where his attendance and grades temporarily improved. By
the following fall, however, the probation officer reported that virtually every
teacher complained about the boys behavior. His mother insisted that he did
not need psychiatric assistance. Although there was apparently some improvement in Lees behavior during the next few months, the court recommended
further treatment. In January 1954, while Lees case was still pending, Marguerite and Lee left for New Orleans, the city of Lees birth.
Upon his return to New Orleans, Lee maintained mediocre grades but had
no obvious behavior problems. Neighbors and others who knew him outside
of school remembered him as a quiet, solitary and introverted boy who read
a great deal and whose vocabulary made him quite articulate. About l month
after he started the l0th grade and 11 days before his 16th birthday in October
1955, he brought to school a note purportedly written by his mother, stating
that the family was moving to California. The note was written by Lee. A few
days later he dropped out of school and almost immediately tried to join the
Marine Corps. Because he was only 16, he was rejected. After leaving school
737
738
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Lee worked for the next 10 months at several jobs in New Orleans as an office
messenger or clerk. It was during this period that he started to read communist
literature. Occasionally, in conversations with others, he praised communism
and expressed to his fellow employees a desire to join the Communist Party.
At about this time, when he was not yet 17, he wrote to the Socialist Party of
America, professing his belief in Marxism.
Another move followed in July 1956 when Lee and his mother returned to
Fort Worth. He reentered high school but again dropped out after a few weeks
and enlisted in the Marine Corps on October 1956, 6 days after his 17th birthday. On December 21, 1956, during boot camp in San Diego, Oswald fired a
score of 212 for record with the M-1 rifle2 points over the minimum for a
rating of sharpshooter on a marksman/sharpshooter/expert scale. After his
basic training, Oswald received training in aviation fundamentals and then in
radar scanning.
Most people who knew Oswald in the Marines described him as loner who
resented the exercise of authority by others. He spent much of his free time
reading. He was court-martialed once for possessing an unregistered privately
owned weapon and, on another occasion, for using provocative language to a
noncommissioned officer. He was, however, generally able to comply with Marine discipline, even though his experiences in the Marine Corps did not live
up to his expectations.
Oswald served 15 months overseas until November 1958, most of it in
Japan. During his final year in the Marine Corps he was stationed for the most
part in Santa Ana, Calif., where he showed marked interest in the Soviet Union
and sometimes expressed politically radical views with dogmatic conviction.
Oswald again fired the M-1 rifle for record on May 6, 1959, and this time
he shot a score of 191 on a shorter course than before, only 1 point over the
minimum required to be a marksman. According to one of his fellow marines, Oswald was not particularly interested in his rifle performance, and his
unit was not expected to exhibit the usual rifle proficiency. During this period
he expressed strong admiration for Fidel Castro and an interest in joining the
Cuban army. He tried to impress those around him as an intellectual, but his
thinking appeared to some as shallow and rigid.
Oswalds Marine service terminated on September 11, 1959, when at his
own request he was released from active service a few months ahead of his
scheduled release. He offered as the reason for his release the ill health and
economic plight of his mother. He returned to Fort Worth, remained with his
mother only 3 days and left for New Orleans, telling his mother he planned to
get work there in the shipping or import-export business. In New Orleans he
booked passage on the freighter SS Marion Lykes, which sailed from New Orleans to Le Havre, France, on September 20, 1959.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Lee Harvey Oswald had presumably planned this step in his life for quite
some time. In March of 1959 he had applied to the Albert Schweitzer College in Switzerland for admission to the Spring 1960 term. His letter of application contained many blatant falsehoods concerning his qualifications and
background. A few weeks before his discharge he had applied for and obtained
a passport, listing the Soviet Union as one of the countries which he planned
to visit. During his service in the Marines he had saved a comparatively large
sum of money, possibly as much as $1,500, which would appear to have been
accomplished by considerable frugality and apparently for a specific purpose.
The purpose of the accumulated fund soon became known. On October 16,
1959, Oswald arrived in Moscow by train after crossing the border from Finland, where he had secured a visa for a 6-day stay in the Soviet Union. He
immediately applied for Soviet citizenship. On the afternoon of October 21,
1959, Oswald was ordered to leave the Soviet Union by 8 P.M. that evening.
That same afternoon in his hotel room Oswald, in an apparent suicide attempt, slashed his left wrist. He was hospitalized immediately. On October 31,
3 days after his release from the hospital, Oswald appeared at the American
Embassy, announced that he wished to renounce his U.S. citizenship and become a Russian citizen, and handed the Embassy officer a written statement he
had prepared for the occasion. When asked his reasons, Oswald replied, I am
a Marxist. Oswald never formally complied with the legal steps necessary to
renounce his American citizenship. The Soviet Government did not grant his
request for citizenship, but in January 1960 he was given permission to remain
in the Soviet Union on a year-to-year basis. At the same time Oswald was sent
to Minsk where he worked in radio factory as an unskilled laborer. In January
1961 his permission to remain in the Soviet Union was extended for another
year. A few weeks later, in February 1961, he wrote to the American Embassy
in Moscow expressing a desire to return to the United States.
The following month Oswald met a 19-year-old Russian girl, Marina Nikolaevna Prusakova, a pharmacist, who had been brought up in Leningrad but was
then living with an aunt and uncle in Minsk. They were married on April 30,
1961. Throughout the following year he carried on a correspondence with
American and Soviet authorities seeking approval for the departure of himself and his wife to the United States. In the course of this effort, Oswald and
his wife visited the U.S. Embassy in Moscow in July of 1961. Primarily on the
basis of an interview and questionnaire completed there, the Embassy concluded that Oswald had not lost his citizenship, a decision subsequently ratified by the Department of State in Washington, D.C. Upon their return to
Minsk, Oswald and his wife filed with the Soviet authorities for permission to
leave together. Their formal application was made in July 1961, and on December 25, 1961, Marina Oswald was advised it would be granted.
739
740
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
A daughter was born to the Oswalds in February 1962. In the months that
followed they prepared for their return to the United States. On May 9, 1962
the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service, at the request of the Department of State, agreed to waive a restriction under the law which would have
prevented the issuance of a United States visa to Oswalds Russian wife until
she had left the Soviet Union. They finally left Moscow on June 1, 1962, and
were assisted in meeting their travel expenses by a loan of $435.71 from the
U.S. Department of State. Two weeks later they arrived in Fort Worth, Tex.
For a few weeks Oswald, his wife and child lived with Oswalds brother
Robert. After a similar stay with Oswalds mother, they moved into their own
apartment in early August. Oswald obtained a job on July 16 as a sheet metal
worker. During this period in Fort Worth, Oswald was interviewed twice by
agents of the FBI. The report of the first interview, which occurred on June 26,
described him as arrogant and unwilling to discuss the reasons why he had
gone to the Soviet Union. Oswald denied that he was involved in Soviet intelligence activities and promised to advise the FBI if Soviet representatives ever
communicated with him. He was interviewed again on August 16, when he
displayed a less belligerent attitude and once again agreed to inform the FBI of
any attempt to enlist him in intelligence activities.
In early October 1962 Oswald quit his job at the sheet metal plant and moved
to Dallas. While living in Forth Worth the Oswalds had been introduced to a
group of Russian-speaking people in the Dallas Fort Worth area. Many of them
assisted the Oswalds by providing small amounts of food, clothing, and household items. Oswald himself was disliked by almost all of this group whose help
to the family was prompted primarily by sympathy for Marina Oswald and the
child. Despite the fact that he had left the Soviet Union, disillusioned with its
Government, Oswald seemed more firmly committed than ever to his concepts
of Marxism. He showed disdain for democracy, capitalism, and American society in general. He was highly critical of the Russian-speaking group because
they seemed devoted to American concepts of democracy and capitalism and
were ambitious to improve themselves economically.
In February 1963 the Oswalds met Ruth Paine at a social gathering. Ruth
Paine was temporarily separated from her husband and living with her two
children in their home in Irving, Tex., a suburb of Dallas because of an interest
in the Russian language and sympathy for Marina Oswald, who spoke no English and had little funds, Ruth Paine befriended Marina and, during the next
2 months, visited her on several occasions.
On April 6, 1963, Oswald lost his job with a photography firm. A few days
later, on April 10, he attempted to kill Maj. Gen. Edwin A. Walker (Retired,
U.S. Army), using a rifle which he had ordered by mail 1 month previously
under an assumed name. Marina Oswald learned of her husbands act when
she confronted him with a note which he had left, giving her instructions in
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the event he did not return. That incident, and their general economic difficulties impelled Marina Oswald to suggest that her husband leave Dallas and go to
New Orleans to look for work.
Oswald left for New Orleans on April 24, 1963. Ruth Paine, who knew
nothing of the Walker shooting, invited Marina Oswald and the baby to stay
with her in the Paines modest home while Oswald sought work in New Orleans. Early in May, upon receiving word from Oswald that he had found a
job, Ruth Paine drove Marina Oswald and the baby to New Orleans to rejoin
Oswald.
During the stay in New Orleans, Oswald formed a fictitious New Orleans
Chapter of the Fair Play for Cuba Committee. He posed as secretary of this organization and represented that the president was A. J. Hidell. In reality, Hidell
was a completely fictitious person created by Oswald, the organizations only
member. Oswald was arrested on August 9 in connection with a scuffle which
occurred while he was distributing pro-Castro leaflets. The next day, while at
the police station, he was interviewed by an FBI agent after Oswald requested
the police to arrange such an interview. Oswald gave the agent false information about his own background and was evasive in his replies concerning Fair
Play for Cuba activities. During the next 2 weeks Oswald appeared on radio
programs twice, claiming to be the spokesman for the Fair Play for Cuba Committee in New Orleans.
On July 19, 1963, Oswald lost his job as a greaser of coffee processing machinery. In September, after an exchange of correspondence with Marina Oswald,
Ruth Paine drove to New Orleans and on September 23, transported Marina,
the child, and the family belongings to Irving, Tex. Ruth Paine suggested that
Marina Oswald, who was expecting her second child in October, live at the
Paine house until after the baby was born. Oswald remained behind, ostensibly to find work either in Houston or some other city. Instead, he departed by
bus for Mexico, arriving in Mexico City on September 27, where he promptly
visited the Cuban and Russian Embassies. His stated objective was to obtain
official permission to visit Cuba, on his way to the Soviet Union. The Cuban
Government would not grant his visa unless the Soviet Government would also
issue a visa permitting his entry into Russia. Oswalds efforts to secure these
visas failed, and he left for Dallas, where he arrived on October 3, 1963.
When he saw his wife the next day, it was decided that Oswald would rent a
room in Dallas and visit his family on weekends. For 1 week he rented a room
from Mrs. Bledsoe, the woman who later saw him on the bus shortly after the
assassination. On October 14, 1963, he rented the Beckley Avenue room and
listed his name as O. H. Lee. On the same day, at the suggestion of a neighbor,
Mrs. Paine phoned the Texas School Book Depository and was told that there
was a job opening. She informed Oswald who was interviewed the following
day at the Depository and started to work there on October 16, 1963.
741
742
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Meanwhile, at police headquarters Captain Fritz had begun questioning Oswald. Soon after the start of the first interrogation, agents of the FBI and the
U.S. Secret Service arrived and participated in the questioning. Oswald denied
having anything to do with the assassination of President Kennedy or the murder of Patrolman Tippit. He claimed that he was eating lunch at the time of
the assassination, and that he then spoke with his foreman for 5 to 10 minutes
before going home. He denied that he owned a rifle and when confronted, in
a subsequent interview, with a picture showing him holding a rifle and pistol,
he claimed that his face had been superimposed on someone elses body. He
refused to answer any questions about the presence in his wallet of a selective
service card with his picture and the name Alek J. Hidell.
During the questioning of Oswald on the third floor of the police department, more than 100 representatives of the press, radio, and television were
crowded into the hallway through which Oswald had to pass when being
taken from his cell to Captain Fritz office for interrogation. Reporters tried to
interview Oswald during these trips. Between Friday afternoon and Sunday
morning he appeared in the hallway at least 16 times. The generally confused
conditions outside and inside Captain Fritz office increased the difficulty of
police questioning. Advised by the police that he could communicate with
an attorney, Oswald made several telephone calls on Saturday in an effort to
procure representation of his own choice and discussed the matter with the
president of the local bar association, who offered to obtain counsel Oswald
declined the offer saying that he would first try to obtain counsel by himself.
By Sunday morning he had not yet engaged an attorney.
At 7:10 P.M. on November 22, 1963, Lee Harvey Oswald was formally advised that he had been charged with the murder of Patrolman J. D. Tippit. Several witnesses to the Tippit slaying and to the subsequent flight of the gunman
had positively identified Oswald in police lineups. While positive firearm identification evidence was not available at the time, the revolver in Oswalds possession at the time of his arrest was of a type which could have fired the shots
that killed Tippit.
The formal charge against Oswald for the assassination of President Kennedy
was lodged shortly after 1:30 A.M., on Saturday, November 23. By 10 P.M. of the
day of the assassination, the FBI had traced the rifle found on the sixth floor
of the Texas School Book Depository to a mail order house in Chicago which
had purchased it from a distributor in New York. Approximately 6 hours later
the Chicago firm advised that this rifle had been ordered in March 1963 by an
A. Hidel for shipment to post office box 2915, in Dallas, Tex., box rented by
Oswald. Payment for the rifle was remitted by a money order signed by A. Hidell.
By 6:45 P.M. on November 23, the FBI was able to advise the Dallas police
that, as a result of handwriting analysis of the documents used to purchase the
rifle, it had concluded that the rifle had been ordered by Lee Harvey Oswald.
743
744
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Throughout Friday and Saturday, the Dallas police released to the public many of the details concerning the alleged evidence against Oswald. Police
officials discussed important aspects of the case, usually in the course of impromptu and confused press conferences in the third-floor corridor. Some of
the information divulged was erroneous. Efforts by the news media representatives to reconstruct the crime and promptly report details frequently led to erroneous and often conflicting reports. At the urgings of the newsmen, Chief of
Police Jesse E. Curry, brought Oswald to a press conference in the police assembly room shortly after midnight of the day Oswald was arrested. The assembly
room was crowded with newsmen who had come to Dallas from all over the
country. They shouted questions at Oswald and flashed cameras at him. Among
this group was a 52-year-old Dallas nightclub operatorJack Ruby.
On Sunday morning, November 24, arrangements were made for Oswalds
transfer from the city jail to the Dallas County jail, about 1 mile away. The
news media had been informed on Saturday night that the transfer of Oswald
would not take place until after 10 A.M. on Sunday. Earlier on Sunday, between
2:30 and 3 A.M., anonymous telephone calls threatening Oswalds life had been
received by the Dallas office of the FBI and by the office of the county sheriff.
Nevertheless, on Sunday morning, television, radio, and newspaper representatives crowded into the basement to record the transfer. As viewed through
television cameras, Oswald would emerge from a door in front of the cameras
and proceed to the transfer vehicle. To the right of the cameras was a down
ramp from Main Street on the north. To the left was an up ramp leading to
Commerce Street on the south.
The armored truck in which Oswald was to be transferred arrived shortly
after 11 A.M. Police officials then decided, however, that an unmarked police
car would be preferable for the trip because of its greater speed and maneuverability. At approximately 11:20 A.M. Oswald emerged from the basement jail
office flanked by detectives on either side and at his rear. He took a few steps
toward the car and was in the glaring light of the television cameras when a
man suddenly darted out from an area on the right of the cameras where newsmen had been assembled. The man was carrying a Colt .38 revolver in his right
hand and, while millions watched on television, he moved quickly to within a
few feet of Oswald and fired one shot into Oswalds abdomen. Oswald groaned
with pain as he fell to the ground and quickly lost consciousness. Within
7 minutes Oswald was at Parkland Hospital where, without having regained
consciousness, he was pronounced dead at 1:07 P.M.
The man who killed Oswald was Jack Ruby. He was instantly arrested and,
minutes later, confined in a cell on the fifth floor of the Dallas police jail. Under
interrogation, he denied that the killing of Oswald was in any way connected
with a conspiracy involving the assassination of President Kennedy. He maintained that he had killed Oswald in a temporary fit of depression and rage over
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the Presidents death. Ruby was transferred the following day to the county jail
without notice to the press or to police officers not directly involved in the transfer. Indicted for the murder of Oswald by the State of Texas on November 26,
1963, Ruby was found guilty on March 14, 1964, and sentenced to death. As
of September 1964, his case was pending on appeal.
Conclusions
This Commission was created to ascertain the facts relating to the preceding
summary of events and to consider the important questions which they raised.
The Commission has addressed itself to this task and has reached certain conclusions based on all the available evidence. No limitations have been placed
on the Commissions inquiry; it has conducted its own investigation, and all
Government agencies have fully discharged their responsibility to cooperate
with the Commission in its investigation. These conclusions represent the reasoned judgment of all members of the Commission and are presented after an
investigation which has satisfied the Commission that it: has ascertained the
truth concerning the assassination of President Kennedy to the extent that a
prolonged and thorough search makes this possible.
1. The shots which killed President Kennedy and wounded Governor Connally were fired from the sixth floor window at the southeast corner of
the Texas School Book Depository. This determination is based upon the
following:
(a) Witnesses at the scene of the assassination saw a rifle being fired
from the sixth floor window of the Depository Building, and some
witnesses saw a rifle in the window immediately after the shots were
fired.
(b) The nearly whole bullet found on Governor Connallys stretcher at
Parkland Memorial Hospital and the two bullet fragments found
in the front seat of the Presidential limousine were fired from the
6.5-millimeter Mannlicher-Carcano rifle found on the sixth floor of
the Depository Building to the exclusion of all other weapons.
(c) The three used cartridge cases found near the window on the sixth
floor at the southeast corner of the building were fired from the same
rifle which fired the above-described bullet and fragments, to the exclusion of all other weapons.
(d) The windshield in the Presidential limousine was struck by a bullet
fragment on the inside surface of the glass, but was not penetrated.
(e) The nature of the bullet wounds suffered by President Kennedy and
Governor Connally and the location of the car at the time of the
745
746
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
shots establish that the bullets were fired from above and behind the
Presidential limousine, striking the President and the Governor as
follows:
1. President Kennedy was first struck by a bullet which entered at
the back of his neck and exited through the lower front portion of
his neck, causing a wound which would not necessarily have been
lethal. The President was struck a second time by a bullet which
entered the right-rear portion of his head, causing a massive and
fatal wound.
2. Governor Connally was struck by a bullet which entered on the
right side of his back and traveled downward through the right
side of his chest, exiting below his right nipple. This bullet then
passed through his right wrist and entered his left thigh where it
caused a superficial wound.
(f) There is no credible evidence that the shots were fired from the Triple
Underpass, ahead of the motorcade, or from any other location.
3. The weight of the evidence indicates that there were three shots fired.
4. Although it is not necessary to any essential findings of the Commission to determine just which shot hit Governor Connally, there is very
persuasive evidence from the experts to indicate that the same bullet
which pierced the Presidents throat also caused Governor Connallys
wounds. However, Governor Connallys testimony and certain other
factors have given rise to some difference of opinion as to this probability but there is no question in the mind of any member of the Commission that all the shots which caused the Presidents and Governor
Connallys wounds were fired from the sixth floor window of the Texas
School Book Depository.
5. The shots which killed President Kennedy and wounded Governor Connally were fired by Lee Harvey Oswald. This conclusion is based upon
the following:
(a) The Mannlicher-Carcano 6.5-millimeter Italian rifle from which the
shots were fired was owned by and in the possession of Oswald.
(b) Oswald carried this rifle into the Depository Building on the morning of November 22, 1963.
(c) Oswald, at the time of the assassination, was present at the window
from which the shots were fired.
(d) Shortly after the assassination, the Mannlicher-Carcano rifle belonging to Oswald was found partially hidden between some cartons
on the sixth floor and the improvised paper bag in which Oswald
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
brought the rifle to the Depository was found dose by the window
from which the shots were fired.
(e) Based on testimony of the experts and their analysis of films of the
assassination, the Commission has concluded that a rifleman of Lee
Harvey Oswalds capabilities could have fired the shots from the rifle
used in the assassination within the elapsed time of the shooting. The
Commission has concluded further that Oswald possessed the capability with a rifle which enabled him to commit the assassination.
(f) Oswald lied to the police after his arrest concerning important substantive matters.
(g) Oswald had attempted to kill Maj. Gen. Edwin A. Walker (Retired,
U.S. Army) on April 10, 1963, thereby demonstrating his disposition
to take human life.
6. Oswald killed Dallas Police Patrolman J. D. Tippit approximately 45 minutes after the assassination. This conclusion upholds the finding that
Oswald fired the shots which killed President Kennedy and wounded
Governor Connally and is supported by the following:
(a) Two eyewitnesses saw the Tippit shooting and seven eyewitnesses
heard the shots and saw the gunman leave the scene with revolver in
hand. These nine eyewitnesses positively identified Lee Harvey Oswald as the man they saw.
(b) The cartridge cases found at the scene of the shooting were fired
from the revolver in the possession of Oswald at the time of his arrest to the exclusion of all other weapons.
(c) The revolver in Oswalds possession at the time of his arrest was purchased by and belonged to Oswald.
(d) Oswalds jacket was found along the path of flight taken by the gunman as he fled from the scene of the killing.
7. Within 80 minutes of the assassination and 35 minutes of the Tippit killing Oswald resisted arrest at the theatre by attempting to shoot another
Dallas police officer.
8. The Commission has reached the following conclusions concerning Oswalds interrogation and detention by the Dallas police:
(a) Except for the force required to effect his arrest, Oswald was not subjected to any physical coercion by any law enforcement officials. He
was advised that he could not be compelled to give any information and that any statements made by him might be used against
him in court. He was advised of his right to counsel. He was given
747
748
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the opportunity to obtain counsel of his own choice and was offered
legal assistance by the Dallas Bar Association, which he rejected at
that time.
(b) Newspaper, radio, and television reporters were allowed uninhibited
access to the area through which Oswald had to pass when he was
moved from his cell to the interrogation room and other sections of
the building, thereby subjecting Oswald to harassment and creating
chaotic conditions which were not conducive to orderly interrogation or the protection of the rights of the prisoner.
(c) The numerous statements, sometimes erroneous, made to the press
by various local law enforcement officials, during this period of confusion and disorder in the police station, would have presented serious obstacles to the obtaining of a fair trial for Oswald. To the extent
that the information was erroneous or misleading, it helped to create doubts, speculations, and fears in the mind of the public which
might otherwise not have arisen.
8. The Commission has reached the following conclusions concerning the
killing of Oswald by Jack Ruby on November 24, 1963:
(a) Ruby entered the basement of the Dallas Police Department shortly
after 11:17 A.M. and killed Lee Harvey Oswald at 11:21 A.M.
(b) Although the evidence on Rubys means of entry is not conclusive,
the weight of the evidence indicates that he walked down the ramp
leading from Main Street to the basement of the police department.
(c) There is no evidence to support the rumor that Ruby may have been
assisted by any members of the Dallas Police Department in the killing of Oswald.
(d) The Dallas Police Departments decision to transfer Oswald to the
county jail in full public view was unsound. The arrangements made
by the police department on Sunday morning, only a few hours before the attempted transfer, were inadequate. Of critical importance
was the fact that news media representatives and others were not
excluded from the basement even after the police were notified of
threats to Oswalds life. These deficiencies contributed to the death
of Lee Harvey Oswald.
9. The Commission has found no evidence that either Lee Harvey Oswald
or Jack Ruby was part of any conspiracy, domestic or foreign, to assassinate President Kennedy. The reasons for this conclusion are:
(a) The Commission has found no evidence that anyone assisted Oswald
in planning or carrying out the assassination. In this connection it
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
749
750
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
(g) The Commission has found no evidence that Jack Ruby acted with
any other person in the killing of Lee Harvey Oswald.
(h) After careful investigation the Commission has found no credible
evidence either that Ruby and Officer Tippit, who was killed by Oswald, knew each other or that Oswald and Tippit knew each other.
10. Because of the difficulty of proving negatives to a certainty the possibility of others being involved with either Oswald or Ruby cannot be
established categorically, but if there is any such evidence it has been
beyond the reach of all the investigative agencies and resources of the
United States and has not come to the attention of this Commission.
11. In its entire investigation the Commission has found no evidence of
conspiracy, subversion, or disloyalty to the U.S. Government by any
Federal, State, or local official.
12. On the basis of the evidence before the Commission it concludes that
Oswald acted alone. Therefore, to determine the motives for the assassination of President Kennedy, one must look to the assassin himself. Clues to Oswalds motives can be found in his family history, his
education or lack of it, his acts, his writings, and the recollections of
those who had close contacts with him throughout his life. The Commission has presented with this report all of the background information bearing on motivation which it could discover. Thus, others may
study Lee Oswalds life and arrive at their own conclusions as to his
possible motives.
The Commission could not make any definitive determination of Oswalds motives. It has endeavored to isolate factors which contributed
to his character and which might have influenced his decision to assassinate President Kennedy. These factors were:
(a) His deep-rooted resentment of all authority which was expressed in
a hostility toward every society in which he lived;
(b) His inability to enter into meaningful relationships with people,
and a continuous pattern of rejecting his environment favor of new
surrounding;
(c) His urge to try to find a place in history and despair at times over
failures in his various undertakings;
(d) His capacity for violence as evidenced by his attempt to kill General
Walker;
(e) His avowed commitment to Marxism and communism, as he understood the terms and developed his own interpretation of them;
this was expressed by his antagonism toward the United States, by
his defection to the Soviet Union, by his failure to be reconciled
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
with life in the United States even after his disenchantment with the
Soviet Union, and by his efforts, though frustrated, to go to Cuba.
Each of these contributed to his capacity to risk all in cruel and irresponsible actions.
13. The Commission recognizes that the varied responsibilities of the President require that he make frequent trips to all parts of the United States
and abroad. Consistent with their high responsibilities Presidents can
never be protected from every potential threat. The Secret Services difficulty in meeting its protective responsibility varies with the activities and the nature of the occupant of the Office of President and his
willingness to conform to plans for his safety. In appraising the performance of the Secret Service it should be understood that it has to do its
work within such limitations. Nevertheless, the Commission believes
that recommendations for improvements in Presidential protection are
compelled by the facts disclosed in this investigation.
(a) The complexities of the Presidency have increased so rapidly in recent years that the Secret Service has not been able to develop or
to secure adequate resources of personnel and facilities to fulfill its
important assignment. This situation should be promptly remedied.
(b) The Commission has concluded that the criteria and procedures of
the Secret Service designed to identify and protect against persons
considered threats to the president, were not adequate prior to the
assassination.
1. The Protective Research Section of the Secret Service, which
is responsible for its preventive work, lacked sufficient trained
personnel and the mechanical and technical assistance needed
to fulfill its responsibility.
2. Prior to the assassination the Secret Services criteria dealt with
direct threats against the President. Although the Secret Service treated the direct threats against the President adequately,
it failed to recognize the necessity of identifying other potential sources of danger to his security. The Secret Service did not
develop adequate and specific criteria defining those persons
or groups who might present a danger to the President. In effect, the Secret Service largely relied upon other Federal or State
agencies to supply the information necessary for it to fulfill its
preventive responsibilities, although it did ask for information
about direct threats to the President.
(c) The Commission has concluded that there was insufficient liaison
and coordination of information between the Secret Service and other
Federal agencies necessarily concerned with Presidential protection.
751
752
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Recommendations
Prompted by the assassination of President Kennedy, the Secret Service has
initiated a comprehensive and critical review of its total operations. As a result
of studies conducted during the past several months, and in cooperation with
this Commission, the Secret Service has prepared a planning document dated
August 27, 1964, which recommends various programs considered necessary
by the Service to improve its techniques and enlarge its resources. The Commission is encouraged by the efforts taken by the Secret Service since the assassination and suggests the following recommendations.
1. A committee of Cabinet members including the Secretary of the Treasury
and the Attorney General, or the National Security Council, should be
assigned the responsibility of reviewing and overseeing the protective activities of the Secret Service and the other Federal agencies that assist in
safeguarding the President. Once given this responsibility, such a committee would insure that the maximum resources of the Federal Government are fully engaged in the task of protecting the President, and would
provide guidance in defining the general nature of domestic and foreign
dangers to Presidential security.
2. Suggestions have been advanced to the Commission for the transfer of
all or parts of the Presidential protective responsibilities of the Secret Service to some other department or agency. The Commission believes that
if there is to be any determination of whether or not to relocate these responsibilities and functions, it ought to be made by the Executive and
the Congress, perhaps upon recommendations based on studies by the
previously suggested committee.
3. Meanwhile, in order to improve daily supervision of the Secret Service
within the Department of the Treasury, the Commission recommends
that the Secretary of the Treasury appoint a special assistant with the
responsibility of supervising the Secret Service. This special assistant
should have sufficient stature and experience in law enforcement, intelligence, and allied fields to provide effective continuing supervision, and
to keep the Secretary fully informed regarding the performance of the Secret Service. One of the initial assignments of this special assistant should
be the supervision of the current effort by the Secret Service to revise and
modernize its basic operating procedures.
4. The Commission recommends that the Secret Service completely overhaul its facilities devoted to the advance detection of potential threats
against the President. The Commission suggests the following measures.
(a) The Secret Service should develop as quickly as possible more useful
and precise criteria defining those potential threats to the President
753
754
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
which should be brought to its attention by other agencies. The criteria should, among other additions, provide for prompt notice to
the Secret Service of all returned defectors.
(b) The Secret Service should expedite its current plans to utilize the
most efficient data-processing techniques.
(c) Once the Secret Service has formulated new criteria delineating the
information it desires, it should enter into agreements with each
Federal agency to insure its receipt of such information.
5. The Commission recommends that the Secret Service improve the protective measures followed in the planning, and conducting of Presidential motorcades. In particular the Secret Service should continue its
current efforts to increase the precautionary attention given to buildings
along the motorcade route.
6. The Commission recommends that the Secret Service continue its recent efforts to improve and formalize its relationships with local police
departments in areas to be visited by the President.
7. The Commission believes that when the new criteria and procedures
are established, the Secret Service will not have sufficient personnel or
adequate facilities. The Commission recommends that the Secret Service be provided with the personnel and resources which the Service
and the Department of the Treasury may be able to demonstrate are
needed to fulfill its important mission.
8. Even with an increase in Secret Service personnel, the protection of
the President will continue to require the resources and cooperation
of many Federal agencies. The Commission recommends that these
agencies, specifically the FBI, continue the practice as it has developed, particularly since the assassination, of assisting the Secret Service
upon request by providing personnel or other aid, and that there be a
closer association and liaison between the Secret Service and all Federal
agencies.
9. The Commission recommends that the Presidents physician always accompany him during his travels and occupy a position near the President where he can be immediately available in case of any emergency.
10. The Commission recommends to Congress that it adopt legislation
which would make the assassination of the President and Vice President a Federal crime. A state of affairs where U.S. authorities have no
clearly defined jurisdiction to investigate the assassination of a President is anomalous.
11. The Commission has examined the Department of States handling
of the Oswald matters and finds that it followed the law throughout.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
However, the Commission believes that the Department in accordance with its own regulations should in all cases exercise great care
in the return to this country of defectors who have evidenced disloyalty or hostility to this country or who have expressed a desire to renounce their American citizenship and that when such persons are so
returned, procedures should be adopted for the better dissemination
of information concerning them to the intelligence agencies of the
Government.
12. The Commission recommends that the representatives of the bar, law
enforcement associations, and the news media work together to establish ethical standards concerning the collection and presentation
of information to the public so that there will be no interference with
pending criminal investigations, court proceedings, or the right of individuals to a fair trial.
THIS CHAPTER describes President Kennedys trip to Dallas, from its origin
through its tragic conclusion. The narrative of these events is based largely on
the recollections of the participants, although in many instances documentary
or other evidence has also been used by the Commission. Beginning with the
advance plans and Secret Service preparations for the trip, this chapter reviews
the motorcade through Dallas, the fleeting moments of the assassination, the
activities at Parkland Memorial Hospital, and the return of the Presidential
party to Washington. An evaluation of the procedures employed to safeguard
the President, with recommendations for improving these procedures, appears
in Chapter VIII of the report.
Planning the Texas Trip
President Kennedys visit to Texas in November 1963 had been under consideration for almost a year before it occurred. He had made only a few brief visits
to the State since the 1960 Presidential campaign and in 1962 he began to consider a formal visit. During 1963, the reasons for making the trip became more
persuasive. As a political leader, the President wished to resolve the factional
controversy within the Democratic Party in Texas before the election of 1964.
The party itself saw an opportunity to raise funds by having the President speak
at a political dinner eventually planned for Austin. As Chief of State, the President always welcomed the opportunity to learn, firsthand, about the problems
which concerned the American people. Moreover, he looked forward to the
public appearances which he personally enjoyed.
The basic decision on the November trip to Texas was made at a meeting of
President Kennedy, Vice President Johnson, and Governor Connally on June 5,
1963, at the Cortez Hotel in El Paso, Tex. The President had spoken earlier that
755
756
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
day at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, Colo., and had stopped in
El Paso to discuss the proposed visit and other matters with the Vice President
and the Governor. The three agreed that the President would come to Texas in
late November 1963. The original plan called for the President to spend only
1 day in the State, making whirlwind visits to Dallas, Fort Worth, San Antonio,
and Houston. In September, the White House decided to permit further visits
by the President and extended the trip to run from the afternoon of November 21 through the evening of Friday, November 22. When Governor Connally
called at the White House on October 4 to discuss the details of the visit, it was
agreed that the planning of events in Texas would be left largely to the Governor. At the White House, Kenneth ODonnell, special assistant to the President, acted as coordinator for the trip.
Everyone agreed that, if there was sufficient time, a motorcade through
downtown Dallas would be the best way for the people to see their President.
When the trip was planned for only 1 day, Governor Connally had opposed
the motorcade because there was not enough time. The Governor stated, however, that once we got San Antonio moved from Friday to Thursday afternoon,
where that was his initial stop in Texas, then we had the time, and I withdrew
my objections to a motorcade. According to ODonnell, we had a motorcade
wherever we went, particularly in large cities where the purpose was to let the
President be seen by as many people as possible. In his experience, it would
be automatic for the Secret Service to arrange a route which would, within the
time allotted, bring the President through an area which exposes him to the
greatest number of people.
Advance Preparations for the Dallas Trip
Advance preparations for President Kennedys visit to Dallas were primarily the
responsibility of two Secret Service agents: Special Agent Winston G. Lawson, a
member of the White House detail who acted as the advance agent, and Forrest V.
Sorrels, special agent in charge of the Dallas office. Both agents were advised
of the trip on November 4. Lawson received a tentative schedule of the Texas
trip on November 8 from Roy H. Kellerman, assistant special agent in charge of
the White House detail, who was the Secret Service official responsible for the
entire Texas journey. As advance agent working closely with Sorrels, Lawson
had responsibility for arranging the timetable for the Presidents visit to Dallas
and coordinating local activities with the White House staff, the organizations
directly concerned with the visit, and local law enforcement officials. Lawsons
most important responsibilities were to take preventive action against anyone
in Dallas considered a threat to the President, to select the luncheon site and
motorcade route, and to plan security measures for the luncheon and the
motorcade.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
757
758
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the Secret Service that the President would arrive and depart from Dallas Love
Field; that a motorcade through the downtown area of Dallas to the luncheon
site should be arranged; and that following the luncheon the President would
return to the airport by the most direct route. Accordingly, it was important to
determine the luncheon site as quickly as possible, so that security could be
established at the site and the motorcade route selected.
On November 4, Gerald A. Behn, agent in charge of the White House detail, asked Sorrels to examine three potential sites for the luncheon. One building, Market Hall, was unavailable for November 22. The second, the Womens
Building at the State Fair Grounds, was a one-story building with few entrances and easy to make secure, but it lacked necessary food-handling facilities and had certain unattractive features, including a low ceiling with exposed
conduits and beams. The third possibility, the Trade Mart, a handsome new
building with all the necessary facilities, presented security problems. It had
numerous entrances, several tiers of balconies surrounding the central court
where the luncheon would be held, and several catwalks crossing the court
at each level. On November 4, Sorrels told Behn he believed security difficulties at the Trade Mart could be overcome by special precautions. Lawson also
evaluated the security hazards at the Trade Mart on November 13. Kenneth
ODonnell made the final decision to hold the luncheon at the Trade Mart;
Behn so notified Lawson on November 14.
Once the Trade Mart had been selected, Sorrels and Lawson worked out detailed arrangements for security at the building. In addition to the preventive
measures already mentioned, they provided for controlling access to the building, closing off and policing areas around it, securing the roof and insuring
the presence of numerous police officers inside and around the building. Ultimately more than 200 law enforcement officers, mainly Dallas police but including 8 Secret Service agents, were deployed in and around the Trade Mart.
The Motorcade Route
On November 8, when Lawson was briefed on the itinerary for the trip to Dallas, he was told that 45 minutes had been allotted for a motorcade procession
from Love Field to the luncheon site. Lawson was not specifically instructed to
select the parade route, but he understood that this was one of his functions.
Even before the Trade Mart had been definitely selected, Lawson and Sorrels
began to consider the best motorcade route from Love Field to the Trade Mart.
On November 14, Lawson and Sorrels attended a meeting at Love Field and on
their return to Dallas drove over the route which Sorrels believed best suited
for the proposed motorcade. This route, eventually selected for the motorcade
from the airport to the Trade Mart, measured 10 miles and could be driven easily within the allotted 45 minutes. From Love Field the route passed through
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
a portion of suburban Dallas, through the downtown area along Main Street
and then to the Trade Mart via Stemmons Freeway. For the Presidents return
to Love Field following the luncheon, the agents selected the most direct route,
which was approximately 4 miles.
After the selection of the Trade Mart as the luncheon site, Lawson and Sorrels met with Dallas Chief of Police Jesse E. Curry, Assistant Chief Charles
Batchelor, Deputy Chief N. T. Fisher, and several other command officers to
discuss details of the motorcade and possible routes. The route was further reviewed by Lawson and Sorrels with Assistant Chief Batchelor and members of
the local host committee on November 15. The police officials agreed that the
route recommended by Sorrels was the proper one and did not express a belief that any other route might be better. On November 18, Sorrels and Lawson
drove over the selected route with Batchelor and other police officers, verifying
that it could be traversed within 45 minutes. Representatives of the local host
committee and the White House staff were advised by the Secret Service of the
actual route on the afternoon of November 18.
The route impressed the agents as a natural and desirable one. Sorrels, who
had participated in Presidential protection assignments in Dallas since a visit
by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1936, as testified that the traditional parade route in Dallas was along Main Street, since the tall buildings along the
street gave more people an opportunity to participate. The route chosen from
the airport to Main Street was the normal one, except where Harwood Street
was selected as the means of access to Main Street in preference to a short
stretch of the Central Expressway, which presented a minor safety hazard and
could not accommodate spectators as conveniently as Harwood Street. According to Lawson, the chosen route seemed to be the best.
It afforded us wide streets most of the way, because of the buses that were in
the motorcade. It afforded us a chance to have alternative routes if something
happened on the motorcade route. It was the type of suburban area a good part
of the way where the crowds would be able to be controlled for a great distance, and we figured that the largest crowds would be downtown, which they
were, and that the wide streets that we would use downtown would be of sufficient width to keep the public out of our way.
Elm Street, parallel to Main Street and one block north, was not used for the
main portion of the downtown part of the motorcade because Main Street offered better vantage points for spectators.
To reach the Trade Mart from Main Street the agents decided to use the
Stemmons Freeway (Route No. 77), the most direct route. The only practical
way for westbound traffic on Main Street to reach the northbound lanes of the
Stemmons Freeway is via Elm Street, which Route No. 77 traffic is instructed
to follow in this part of the city. (See Commission Exhibit No. 2113, p. 34.)
Elm Street was to be reached from Main by turning right at Houston, going one
759
760
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
block north and then turning left onto Elm. On this last portion of the journey,
only 5 minutes from the Trade Mart, the Presidents motorcade would pass the
Texas School Book Depository Building on the northwest corner of Houston
and Elm Streets. The building overlooks Dealey Plaza, an attractively landscaped triangle of 3 acres. . . .
From Houston Street, which forms the base of the triangle, three streets
Commerce, Main, and Elmtrisect the plaza, converging at the apex of the
triangle to form a triple underpass beneath a multiple railroad bridge almost
500 feet from Houston Street. Elm Street, the northernmost of the three, after
intersecting Houston curves in a southwesterly arc through the underpass and
leads into an access road, which branches off to the right and is used by traffic
going to the Stemmons Freeway and the Dallas-Fort Worth Turnpike. . . .
The Elm Street approach to the Stemmons Freeway is necessary in order to
avoid the traffic hazards which would otherwise exist if right turns were permitted from both Main and Elm into the freeway. To create this traffic pattern,
a concrete barrier between Main and Elm Streets presents an obstacle to a right
turn from Main across Elm to the access road to Stemmons Freeway and the
Dallas-Fort Worth Turnpike. This concrete barrier extends far enough beyond
the access road to make it impracticable for vehicles to turn right from Main
directly to the access road. A sign located on this barrier instructs Main Street
traffic not to make any turns. . . . In conformity with these arrangements, traffic proceeding west on Main is directed to turn right at Houston in order to
reach the Dallas-Fort Worth Turnpike, which has the same access road from
Elm Street as does the Stemmons Freeway. . . .
The planning for the motorcade also included advance preparations for security arrangements along the route. Sorrels and Lawson reviewed the route in
cooperation with Assistant Chief Bachelor and other Dallas police officials who
took notes on the requirements for controlling the crowds and traffic, watching
the overpasses, and providing motorcycle escort. To control traffic, arrangements were made for the deployment of foot patrolmen and motorcycle police
at various positions along the route. Police were assigned to each overpass on
the route and instructed to keep them clear of unauthorized persons. No arrangements were made for police or building custodians to inspect buildings
along the motorcade route since the Secret Service did not normally request or
make such a check? Under standard procedures, the responsibility for watching the windows of buildings was shared by local police stationed along the
route and Secret Service agents riding in the motorcade.
As the date for the Presidents visit approached, the two Dallas newspapers carried several reports of his motorcade route. The selection of the Trade
Mart as the possible site for the luncheon first appeared in the Dallas TimesHerald.on November 15, 1963. The following day, the newspaper reported
that the Presidential party apparently will loop through the downtown area,
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
probably on Main Street, en route from Dallas Love Field on its way to the
Trade Mart. On November 19, the Times-Herald afternoon paper detailed the
precise route: From the airport, the Presidents party will proceed to Mockingbird Lane to Lemmon and then to Turtle Creek, turning south to Cedar
Springs. The motorcade will then pass through downtown on Harwood and
then west on Main, turning back to Elm at Houston and then out Stemmons
Freeway to the Trade Mart.
Also on November 19, the Morning News reported that the Presidents
motorcade would travel from Love Field along specified streets, then Harwood to Main, Main to Houston, Houston to Elm, Elm under the Triple Underpass to Stemmons Freeway, and on to the Trade Mart. On November 20 a
front page story reported that the streets on which the Presidential motorcade
would travel included Main and Stemmons Freeway. On the morning of the
Presidents arrival, the Morning News noted that the motorcade would travel
through downtown Dallas onto the Stemmons Freeway, and reported that the
motorcade will move slowly so that crowds can get a good view of President
Kennedy and his wife.
Dallas before the Visit
The Presidents intention to pay a visit to Texas in the fall of 1963 aroused
interest throughout the State. The two Dallas newspapers provided their readers with a steady stream of information and speculation about the trip, beginning on September 13, when the Times-Herald announced in a front page
article that President Kennedy was planning a brief l-day tour of four Texas
citiesDallas, Fort Worth, San Antonio, and Houston. Both Dallas papers
cited White House sources on September 26 as confirming the Presidents
intention to visit Texas on November 21 and 22, with Dallas scheduled as one
of the stops.
Articles, editorials, and letters to the editor in the Dallas Morning News and
the Dallas Times-Herald after September 13 reflected the feeling in the community toward the forthcoming Presidential visit. Although there were critical
editorials and letters to the editors, the news stories reflected the desire of Dallas officials to welcome the President with dignity and courtesy. An editorial in
the Times-Herald of September 17 called on the people of Dallas to be congenial hosts even though Dallas didnt vote for Mr. Kennedy in 1960, may
not endorse him in 64. On October 3 the Dallas Morning News quoted U.S.
Representative Joe Pools hope that President Kennedy would receive a good
welcome and would not face demonstrations like those encountered by Vice
President Johnson during the 1960 campaign.
Increased concern about the Presidents visit was aroused by the incident
involving the U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, Adlai E. Stevenson. On
761
762
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the evening of October 24, 1963, after addressing a meeting in Dallas, Stevenson was jeered, jostled, and spat upon by hostile demonstrators outside the
Dallas Memorial Auditorium Theater. The local, national, and international
reaction to this incident evoked from Dallas officials and newspapers strong
condemnations of the demonstrators. Mayor Earle Cabell called on the city
to redeem itself during President Kennedys visit. He asserted that Dallas had
shed its reputation of the twenties as the Southwest hate capital of Dixie.
On October 26 the press reported Chief of Police Currys plans to call in 100
extra off-duty officers to help protect President Kennedy. Any thought that
the President might cancel his visit to Dallas was ended when Governor Connally confirmed on November 8 that the President would come to Texas on
November 2122, and that he would visit San Antonio, Houston, Fort Worth,
Dallas, and Austin.
During November the Dallas papers reported frequently on the plans for
protecting the President, stressing the thoroughness of the preparations. They
conveyed the pleas of Dallas leaders that citizens not demonstrate or create disturbances during the Presidents visit. On November 18 the Dallas City Council
adopted a new city ordinance prohibiting interference with attendance at lawful assemblies. Two days before the Presidents arrival Chief Curry warned that
the Dallas police would not permit improper conduct during the Presidents
visit.
Meanwhile, on November 17 the president of the Dallas Chamber of Commerce referred to the citys reputation for being the friendliest town in America
and asserted that citizens would greet the President of the United States with
the warmth and pride that keep the Dallas spirit famous the world over. Two
days later, a local Republican leader called for a civilized nonpartisan welcome for President Kennedy, stating that in many respects Dallas County has
isolated itself from the main stream of life in the world in this decade.
Another reaction to the impending visithostile to the Presidentcame
to a head shortly before his arrival. On November 21 there appeared on the
streets of Dallas the anonymous handbill mentioned above. It was fashioned
after the wanted circulars issued by law enforcement agencies. Beneath two
photographs of President Kennedy, one full-face and one profile, appeared the
caption, Wanted for Treason, followed by a scurrilous bill of particulars that
constituted a vilification of the President. And on the morning of the Presidents
arrival, there appeared in the Morning News a full, black-bordered advertisement headed Welcome Mr. Kennedy to Dallas, sponsored by the American
Fact-finding Committee, which the sponsor later testified was an ad hoc committee formed strictly for the purpose of having a name to put in the paper.
The welcome consisted of a series of statements and questions critical of the
President and his administration. . . .
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
763
764
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
crowd of spectators that had gathered behind it. Secret Service agents formed a
cordon to keep the press and photographers from impeding their passage and
scanned the crowd for threatening movements. Dallas police stood at intervals
along the fence and Dallas plain clothes men mixed in the crowd. Vice President and Mrs. Johnson followed along the fence, guarded by four members of
the Vice-Presidential detail. Approximately 10 minutes after the arrival at Love
Field, the President and Mrs. Kennedy went to the Presidential automobile to
begin the motorcade.
Organization of the Motorcade
Secret Service arrangements for Presidential trips, which were followed in the
Dallas motorcade, are designed to provide protection while permitting large
numbers of people to see the President. Every effort is made to prevent unscheduled stops, although the President may, and in Dallas did, order stops in
order to greet the public. Men the motorcade slows or stops, agents take positions between the President and the crowd. The order of vehicles in the Dallas
motorcade was as follows:
Motorcycles.Dallas police motorcycles preceded the pilot car.
The pilot car.Manned by officers of the Dallas Police Department, this automobile preceded the main party by approximately quarter of a mile. Its
function was to alert police along the route that the motorcade was approaching and to check for signs of trouble.
Motorcycles.Next came four to six motorcycle policemen whose main
purpose was to keep the crowd back.
The lead car.Described as a rolling command car, this was an unmarked
Dallas police car, driven by Chief of Police Curry and occupied by Secret Service Agents Sorrels and Lawson and by Dallas County Sheriff J. E.
Decker. The occupants scanned the crowd and the buildings along the
route. Their main function was to spot trouble in advance and to direct
any necessary steps to meet the trouble. Following normal practice, the
lead automobile stayed proximately four to five car lengths ahead of the
Presidents limousine.
The Presidential limousine.The Presidents automobile was specially designed 1961 Lincoln convertible with two collapsible jump seats between
the front and rear seats. . . . It was outfitted with a clear plastic bubbletop which was neither bulletproof nor bullet resistant. Because the skies
had cleared in Dallas, Lawson directed that the top not be used for the
days activities. He acted on instructions he had received earlier from Assistant Special Agent in Charge Roy H. Kellerman, who was in Fort Worth
with the President. Kellerman had discussed the matter with ODonnell,
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
whose instructions were, If the weather is clear and it is not raining, have
that bubbletop off. Elevated approximately 15 inches above the back
of the front seat was a metallic frame with four handholds that riders in
the car could grip while standing in the rear seat during parades. At the
rear on each side of the automobile were small running boards, each designed to hold a Secret Service agent, with a metallic handle for the rider
to grasp. The President had frequently stated that he did not want agents
to ride on these steps during a motorcade except when necessary. He had
repeated this wish only a few days before, during his visit to Tampa, Fla.
President Kennedy rode on the right-hand side of the rear seat with Mrs.
Kennedy on his left. Governor Connally occupied the right jump seat, Mrs.
Connally the left. Driving the Presidential limousine was Special Agent William
R. Greer of the Secret Service; on his right sat Kellerman. Kellermans responsibilities included maintaining radio communications with the lead and followup cars, scanning the route, and getting out and standing near the President
when the cars stopped.
Motorcycles.Four motorcycles, two on each side, flanked the rear of the
Presidential car. They provided some cover for the President, but their
main purpose was to keep back the crowd. On previous occasions, the
President had requested that, to the extent possible, these flanking motorcycles keep back from the sides of his car.
Presidential follow-up car.This vehicle, a 1955 Cadillac eight-passenger
convertible especially outfitted for the Secret Service, followed closely behind the Presidents automobile. It carried eight Secret Service agents
two in the front seat, two in the rear, and two on each of the right and
left running boards. Each agent carried a .38-caliber pistol, and a shotgun and automatic rifle were also available. Presidential Assistants David
F. Powers and Kenneth ODonnell sat in the right and left jump seats,
respectively.
The agents in this car, under established procedure, had instructions to
watch the route for signs of trouble, scanning not only the crowds but the windows and roofs of buildings, overpasses, and crossings. They were instructed
to watch particularly for thrown objects, sudden actions in the crowd, and any
movements toward the Presidential car. The agents on the front of the running
boards had directions to move immediately to positions just to the rear of the
President and Mrs. Kennedy when the Presidents car slowed to a walking pace
or stopped, or when the press of the crowd made it impossible for the escort
motorcycles to stay in position on the cars rear flanks. The two agents on the
rear of the running boards were to advance toward the front of the Presidents
car whenever it stopped or slowed down sufficiently for them to do so.
765
766
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Vice-Presidential car.The Vice-Presidential automobile, a four-door Lincoln convertible obtained locally for use in the motor-cade, proceeded
approximately two to three car lengths behind the Presidents follow-up
car. This distance was maintained so that spectators would normally turn
their gaze from the Presidents automobile by the time the Vice President
came into view. Vice President Johnson sat on the right-hand side of the
rear seat, Mrs. Johnson in the center, and Senator Yarborough on the left.
Rufus W. Youngblood, special agent in charge of the Vice Presidents detail, occupied the right-hand side of the front seat, and Hurchel Jacks of
the Texas State Highway patrol was the driver.
Vice-Presidential follow-up car.Driven by an officer of the Dallas Police
Department, this vehicle was occupied by three Secret Service agents and
Clifton C. Garter, assistant to the Vice President. These agents performed
for the Vice President the same functions that the agents in the Presidential follow-up car performed for the President.
Remainder of motorcade.The remainder of the motorcade consisted of
five cars for other dignitaries, including the mayor of Dallas and Texas
Congressmen, telephone and Western Union vehicles, a White House
communications car, three cars for press photographers, an official party
bus for White House staff members and others, and two press buses. Admiral George G. Burkley, physician to the President, was in a car following those containing the local and national representatives.
Police car and motorcycles.A Dallas police car and several motorcycles at
the rear kept the motorcade together and prevented unauthorized vehicles from joining the motorcade.
Communications in the motorcade.A base station at a fixed location in
Dallas operated a radio network which linked together the lead car, Presidential car, Presidential follow-up car, White House communications
car, Trade Mart, Love Field, and the Presidential and Vice-Presidential
airplanes. The Vice-Presidential car and Vice-Presidential follow-up car
used portable sets with a separate frequency for their own car-to-car
communication.
The Drive through Dallas
The motorcade left Love Field shortly after 11:50 A.M. and drove at speeds up
to 25 to 30 miles an hour through thinly populated areas on the outskirts of
Dallas. At the Presidents direction, his automobile stopped twice, the first time
to permit him to respond to a sign asking him to shake hands. During this brief
stop, agents in the front positions on the running boards of the Presidential
follow-up car came forward and stood beside the Presidents car, looking out
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
toward the crowd, and Special Agent Kellerman assumed his position next to
the car. On the other occasion, the President halted the motorcade to speak to
a Catholic nun and a group of small children.
In the downtown area, large crowds of spectators gave the President a tremendous reception. The crowds were so dense that Special Agent Clinton J.
Hill had to leave the left front running board of the Presidents follow-up car
four times to ride on the rear of the Presidents limousine. (See Commission
Exhibit No. 698, p. 47.) Several times Special Agent John D. Ready came forward from the right front running board of the Presidential follow-up car to
the right side of the Presidents car. Special Agent Glen A. Bennett once left his
place inside the follow-up car to help keep the crowd away from the Presidents
car. When a teenage boy ran toward the rear of the Presidents car, Ready left
the running board to chase the boy back into the crowd. On several occasions
when the Vice Presidents car was slowed down by the throng, Special Agent
Youngblood stepped out to hold the crowd back.
According to plan, the Presidents motorcade proceeded west through
downtown Dallas on Main Street to the intersection of Houston Street, which
marks the beginning of Dealey Plaza. From Main Street the motorcade turned
right and went north on Houston Street, passing tall buildings on the right,
and headed toward the Texas School Book Depository Building. The spectators
were still thickly congregated in front of the buildings which lined the east side
of Houston Street, but the crowd thinned abruptly along Elm Street, which
curves in a southwesterly direction as it proceeds downgrade toward the Triple
Underpass and the Stemmons Freeway.
As the motorcade approached the intersection of Houston and Elm Streets,
there was general gratification in the Presidential party about the enthusiastic reception. Evaluating the political overtones, Kenneth ODonnell was
especially pleased because it convinced him that the average Dallas resident
was like other American citizens in respecting and admiring the President.
Mrs. Connally, elated by the reception, turned to President Kennedy and said,
Mr. President, you cant say Dallas doesnt love you. The President replied,
That is very obvious.
The Assassination
At 12:30 P.M., e.s.t., as the Presidents open limousine proceeded at approximately 11 miles per hour along Elm Street toward the Triple Underpass, shots
fired from a rifle mortally wounded President Kennedy and seriously injured
Governor Connally. One bullet passed through the Presidents neck; a subsequent bullet, which was lethal, shattered the right side of his skull. Governor
Connally sustained bullet wounds in his back, the right side of his chest, right
wrist, and left thigh.
767
768
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
The Time
The exact time of the assassination was fixed by the testimony of four witnesses.
Special Agent Rufus W. Youngblood observed that the large electric sign clock
atop the Texas School Book Depository Building showed the numerals 12:30
as the Vice-Presidential automobile proceeded north on Houston Street, a few
seconds before the shots were fired. Just prior to the shooting, David F. Powers,
riding in the Secret Service follow-up car, remarked to Kenneth ODonnell that
it was 12:30 P.M., the time they were due at the Trade Mart. Seconds after the
shooting, Roy Kellerman, riding in the front seat of the Presidential limousine,
looked at his watch and said 12:30 to the driver, Special Agent Greer. The
Dallas police radio log reflects that Chief of Police Curry reported the shooting
of the President and issued his initial orders at 12:30 P.M.
Speed of the Limousine
William Greer, operator of the Presidential limousine, estimated the cars speed
at the time of the first shot as 12 to 15 miles per hour. 144 Other witnesses
in the motorcade estimated the speed of the Presidents limousine from 7 to
22 miles per hour. A more precise determination has been made from motion
pictures taken on the scene by an amateur photographer, Abraham Zapruder.
Based on these films, the speed of the Presidents automobile is computed at an
average speed of 11.2 miles per hour. The car maintained this average speed
over a distance of approximately 186 feet immediately preceding the shot
which struck the President in the head. While the car traveled this distance,
the Zapruder camera ran 152 frames. Since the camera operates at a speed of
18.3 frames per second, it was calculated that the car required 8.3 seconds to
cover the 136 feet. This represents a speed of 11.2 miles per hour.
In the Presidential Limousine
Mrs. John F. Kennedy, on the left of the rear seat of the limousine, looked toward her left and waved to the crowds along the route. Soon after the motorcade turned onto Elm Street., she heard a sound similar to a motorcycle noise
and a cry from Governor Connally, which caused her to look to her right. On
turning she saw a quizzical look on her husbands face as he raised his left hand
to his throat. Mrs. Kennedy then heard a second shot and saw the Presidents
skull torn open under the impact of the bullet. As she cradled her mortally
wounded husband, Mrs. Kennedy cried, Oh, my God, they have shot my husband. I love you, Jack.
Governor Connally testified that he recognized the first noise as a rifle shot
and the thought immediately crossed his mind that it was an assassination attempt. From his position in the right jump seat immediately in front of the
President, he instinctively turned to his right because the shot appeared to
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
come from over his right shoulder. Unable to see the President as he turned to
the right, the Governor started to look back over his left shoulder, but he never
completed the turn because he felt something strike him in the back. In his testimony before the Commission, Governor Connally was certain that he was hit
by the second shot, which he stated he did not hear.
Mrs. Connally, too, heard a frightening noise from her right. Looking over
her right shoulder, she saw that the President had both hands at his neck but
she observed no blood and heard nothing. She watched as he slumped down
with an empty expression on his face. Roy Kellerman, in the right front seat
of the limousine, heard a report like a firecracker pop. Turning to his right in
the direction of the noise, Kellerman heard the President say My God, I am
hit, and saw both of the Presidents hands move up toward his neck. As he
told the driver, Lets get out of here; we are hit, Kellerman grabbed his microphone and radioed ahead to the lead car, We are hit. Get us to the hospital
immediately.
The driver, William Greer, heard a noise which he took to be a backfire from
one of the motorcycles flanking the Presidential car. When he heard the same
noise again, Greer glanced over his shoulder and saw Governor Connally fall.
At the-sound of the second shot he realized that something was wrong, and he
pressed down on the accelerator as Kellerman said, Get out of here fast. As he
issued his instructions to Greer and to the lead car, Kellerman heard a flurry
of shots Within 5 seconds of the first noise. According to Kellerman, Mrs.
Kennedy then cried out: What are they doing to you! Looking back from
the front seat, Kellerman saw Governor Connally in his wifes lap and Special
Agent Clinton J. Hill lying across the trunk of the car.
Mrs. Connally heard a second shot fired and pulled her husband down into
her lap. Observing his blood-covered chest as he was pulled into his wifes lap,
Governor Connally believed himself mortally wounded. He cried out, Oh, no,
no, no. My God, they are going to kill us all. At first Mrs. Connally thought
that her husband had been killed, but then she noticed an almost imperceptible movement and knew that he was still alive. She said, Its all right. Be still.
The Governor was lying with his head on his wifes lap when he heard a shot
hit the President. At that point, both Governor and Mrs. Connally observed
brain tissue splattered over the interior of the car. According to Governor and
Mrs. Connally, it was after this shot that Kellerman issued his emergency instructions and the car accelerated.
Reaction by Secret Service Agents
From the left front running board of the Presidents follow-up car, Special Agent
Hill was scanning the few people standing on the south side of Elm Street after
the motorcade had turned off Houston Street. He estimated that the motorcade
769
770
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
had slowed down to approximately 9 or 10 miles per hour on the turn at the
intersection of Houston and Elm Streets and then proceeded at a rate of 12 to
15 miles per hour with the follow-up car trailing the Presidents automobile by
approximately 5 feet. Hill heard a noise, which seemed to be a firecracker, coming from his right rear. He immediately looked to his right, and, in so doing,
my eyes had to cross the Presidential limousine and I saw President Kennedy
grab at himself and lurch forward and to the left. Hill jumped from the followup car and ran to the Presidents automobile. At about the time he reached the
Presidents automobile, Hill heard a second shot, approximately 5 seconds after
the first, which removed a portion of the Presidents head.
At the instant that Hill stepped onto the left rear step of the Presidents automobile and grasped the handhold, the car lurched forward, causing him to
lose his footing. He ran three or four steps, regained his position and mounted
the car. Between the time he originally seized the handhold and the time he
mounted the car, Hill recalled: Mrs. Kennedy had jumped up from the seat and
was, it appeared to me, reaching for something coming off the fight rear bumper of the car, the right rear tail, when she noticed that I was trying to climb on
the car. She turned toward me and I grabbed her and put her back in the back
seat, crawled up on top of the back seat and lay there.
David Powers, who witnessed the scene from the Presidents follow-up car,
stated that Mrs. Kennedy would probably have fallen off the rear end of the car
and been killed if Hill had not pushed her back into the Presidential automobile. Mrs. Kennedy had no recollection of climbing onto the back of the car.
Special Agent Ready, on the right front running board of the Presidential
follow-up car, heard noises that sounded like firecrackers and ran toward the
Presidents limousine. But he was immediately called back by Special Agent
Emory P. Roberts, in charge of the follow-up car, who did not believe that he
could reach, the Presidents car at the speed it was then traveling. Special Agent
George W. Hickey, Jr., in the rear seat of the Presidential follow-up car, picked
up and cocked an automatic rifle as he heard the last shot. At this point the
cars were speeding through the underpass and had left the scene of the shooting, but Hickey kept the automatic weapon ready as the car raced to the hospital. Most of the other Secret Service agents in the motorcade had drawn their
sidearms. Roberts noticed that the Vice Presidents car was approximately onehalf block behind the Presidential follow-up car at the time of the shooting and
signaled for it to move in closer.
Directing the security detail for the Vice President from the right front seat
of the Vice-Presidential car, Special Agent Youngblood recalled: As we were beginning to go down this incline, all of a sudden there was an explosive noise.
I quickly observed unnatural movement of crowds, like ducking or scattering,
and quick movements in the Presidential follow-up car. So I turned around
and hit the Vice President on the shoulder and hollered, get down, and then
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
looked around again and saw more of this movement, and so I proceeded to go
to the back seat and get on top of him.
Youngblood was not positive that he was in the rear seat before the second shot, but thought it probable because of President Johnsons statement to
that effect immediately after the assassination. President Johnson emphasized
Youngbloods instantaneous reaction after the first shot: I was startled by the
sharp report or explosion, but I had no time to speculate as to its origin because Agent Youngblood turned in a flash, immediately after the first explosion, hitting me on the shoulder, and shouted to all of us in the back seat to
get down. I was pushed down by Agent Youngblood. Almost in the same moment in which he hit or pushed me, he vaulted over the back seat and sat on
me. I was bent over under the weight of Agent Youngbloods body, toward
Mrs. Johnson and Senator Yarborough.
Clifton C. Carter, riding in the Vice Presidents follow-up car a short distance
behind, reported that Youngblood was in the rear seat using his body to shield
the Vice President before the second and third shots were fired.
Other Secret Service agents assigned to the motorcade remained at their
posts during the race to the hospital. None stayed at the scene of the shooting, and none entered the Texas School Book Depository Building at or immediately after the shooting. Secret Service procedure requires that each agent
stay with the person being protected and not be diverted unless it is necessary
to accomplish the protective assignment. Forrest V. Sorrels, special agent in
charge of the Dallas office, was the first Secret Service agent to return to the
scene of the assassination, approximately 20 or 25 minutes after the shots were
fired.
Parkland Memorial Hospital
The Race to the Hospital
In the final instant of the assassination, the Presidential motorcade began a race
to Parkland Memorial Hospital, approximately 4 miles from the Texas School
Book Depository Building. On receipt of the radio message from Kellerman to
the lead car that the President had been hit, Chief of Police Curry and police
motorcyclists at the head of the motorcade led the way to the hospital. Meanwhile, Chief Curry ordered the police base station to notify Parkland Hospital
that the wounded President was en route. The radio log of the Dallas Police Department shows that at 12:30 P.M. on November 22 Chief Curry radioed, Go to
the hospitalParkland Hospital. Have them stand by. A moment later Curry
added, Looks like the President has been hit. Have Parkland stand by. The
base station replied, They have been notified. Traveling at speeds estimated
at times to be up to 70 or 80 miles per hour down the Stemmons Freeway and
Harry Hines Boulevard, the Presidential limousine arrived at the emergency
771
772
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
entrance of the Parkland Hospital at about 12:35 P.M. Arriving almost simultaneously were the Presidents follow-up car, the Vice Presidents automobile, and
the Vice Presidents follow-up car. Admiral Burkley, the Presidents physician,
arrived at the hospital between 3 and 5 minutes following the arrival of the
President, since the riders in his car were not exactly aware what had happened and the car went on to the Trade Mart first.
When Parkland Hospital received the notification, the staff in the emergency
area was alerted and trauma rooms 1 and 2 were prepared. These rooms were
for the emergency treatment of acutely ill or injured patients. Although the first
message mentioned an injury only to President Kennedy, two rooms were prepared. As the Presidents limousine sped toward the hospital, 12 doctors to the
emergency area: surgeons, Drs. Malcolm O. Perry, Charles R. Baxter, Robert N.
McClelland, Ronald C. Jones; the chief neurologist, Dr. William Kemp Clark;
4 anesthesiologists, Drs. Marion T. Jenkins, Adolph H. Giesecke, Jr., Jackie H.
Hunt, Gene C. Akin; urological surgeon, Dr Paul C. Peters; an oral surgeon,
Dr. Don T. Curtis; and a heart specialist, Dr. Fouad A. Bashour.
Upon arriving at Parkland Hospital, Lawson jumped from the lead car and
rushed into the emergency entrance, where he was met by hospital staff members wheeling stretchers out to the automobile. Special Agent Hill removed
his suit jacket and covered the Presidents head and upper chest to prevent
the taking of photographs. Governor Connally, who had lost consciousness on
the ride to the hospital, regained consciousness when the limousine stopped
abruptly at the emergency entrance. Despite his serious wounds, Governor
Connally tried to get out of the way so that medical help could reach the President. Although he was reclining in his wifes arms, he lurched forward in an
effort to stand upright and get out of the car, but he collapsed again. Then he
experienced his first sensation of pain, which became excruciating. The Governor was lifted onto a stretcher and taken into trauma room 2. For a moment,
Mrs. Kennedy refused to release the President, whom she held in her lap, but
then Kellerman, Greer, and Lawson lifted the President onto a stretcher and
pushed it into trauma room 1.
Treatment of President Kennedy
The first physician to see the President at Parkland Hospital was Dr. Charles J.
Carrico, a resident in general surgery. Dr. Carrico was in the emergency area,
examining another patient, when he was notified that President Kennedy was
en route to the hospital. Approximately 2 minutes later, Dr. Carrico saw the
President on his back, being wheeled into the emergency area. He noted that
the President was blue-white or ashen in color; had slow, spasmodic, agonal
respiration without any coordination; made no voluntary movements; had his
eyes open with the pupils dilated without any reaction to light; evidenced no
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
palpable pulse; and had a few chest sounds which were thought to be heart beats.
On the basis of these findings, Dr. Carrico concluded that President Kennedy
was still alive.
Dr. Carrico noted two wounds: a small bullet wound in the front lower
neck, and an extensive wound in the Presidents head where a sizable portion
of the skull was missing. He observed shredded brain tissue and considerable
slow oozing from the latter wound, followed by more profuse bleeding after
some circulation was established. Dr. Carrico felt the Presidents back and determined that there was no large wound there which would be an immediate
threat to life. Observing the serious problems presented by the head wound
and inadequate respiration, Dr. Carrico directed his attention to improving the
Presidents breathing. He noted contusions, hematoma to the right of the larynx, which was deviated slightly to the left, and also ragged tissue which indicated a tracheal injury. Dr. Carrico inserted a cuffed endotracheal tube past
the injury, inflated the cuff, and connected it to a Bennett machine to assist in
respiration.
At that point, direction of the Presidents treatment was undertaken by
Dr. Malcolm O. Perry, who arrived at trauma room 1 a few moments after the
President. Dr. Perry noted the Presidents back brace as he felt for a femoral
pulse, which he did not find. Observing that an effective airway had to be established if treatment was to be effective, Dr. Perry performed a tracheotomy,
which required 3 to 5 minutes. While Dr. Perry was performing the tracheotomy, Drs. Carrico and Ronald Jones made cutdowns on the Presidents right
leg and left arm, respectively, to infuse blood and fluids into the circulatory
system. Dr. Carrico treated the Presidents known ad-renal insufficiency by administering hydrocortisone. Dr. Robert N. McClelland entered at that point
and assisted Dr. Perry with the tracheotomy.
Dr. Fouad Bashour, chief of cardiology, Dr. M. T. Jenkins, chief of anesthesiology, and Dr. A. H. Giesecke, Jr., then joined in the effort to revive the President. When Dr. Perry noted free air and blood in the Presidents chest cavity,
he asked that chest tubes be inserted to allow for drainage of blood and air.
Drs. Paul C. Peters and Charles R. Baxter initiated these procedures. As a result
of the infusion of liquids through the cutdowns, the cardiac massage, and the
airway, the doctors were able to maintain peripheral circulation as monitored
at the neck (carotid) artery and at the wrist (radial) pulse. A femoral pulse was
also detected in the Presidents leg. While these medical efforts were in progress, Dr. Clark noted some electrical activity on the cardiotachyscope attached
to monitor the Presidents heart responses. Dr. Clark, who most closely observed the head wound, described a large, gaping wound in the right rear part
of the head, with substantial damage and exposure of brain tissue, and a considerable loss of blood. Dr. Clark did not see any other hole or wound on the
Presidents head. According to Dr. Clark, the small bullet hole on the right rear
773
774
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
of the Presidents head discovered during the subsequent autopsy could have
easily been hidden in the blood and hair.
In the absence of any neurological, muscular, or heart response, the doctors
concluded that efforts to revive the President were hopeless. This was verified
by Admiral Burkley, the Presidents physician, who arrived at the hospital after
emergency treatment was underway and concluded that my direct services to
him at that moment would have interfered with the action of the team which
was in progress. At approximately 1 P.M., after last rites were administered to
the President by Father Oscar L. Huber, Dr. Clark pronounced the President
dead. He made the official determination because the ultimate cause of death,
the severe head injury, was within his sphere of specialization. The time was
fixed at 1 P.M., as an approximation, since it was impossible to determine the
precise moment when life left the President. President Kennedy could have
survived the neck injury, but the head wound was fatal. From a medical viewpoint, President Kennedy was alive when he arrived at Parkland Hospital; the
doctors observed that he had a heart beat and was making some respiratory efforts. But his condition was hopeless, and the extraordinary efforts of the doctors to save him could not help but to have been unavailing.
Since the Dallas doctors directed all their efforts to controlling the massive
bleeding caused by the head wound, and to reconstructing an airway to his
lungs, the President remained on his back throughout his medical treatment
at Parkland. When asked why he did not turn the President over, Dr. Carrico
testified as follows:
A. This man was in obvious extreme distress and any more thorough inspection would have involved several minuteswell, severalconsiderable time
which at this juncture was not available. A thorough inspection would have
involved washing and cleansing the back, and this is not practical in treating
an acutely injured patient. You have to determine which things, which are immediately life threatening and cope with them, before attempting to evaluate
the full extent of the injuries.
Q. Did you ever have occasion to look at the Presidents back?
A. No, sir. Beforewell, in trying to treat an acutely injured patient, you
have to establish an airway, adequate ventilation and you have to establish adequate circulation. Before this was accomplished the Presidents
cardiac activity had ceased and closed cardiac massage was instituted,
which made it impossible to inspect his back.
Q. Was any effort made to inspect the Presidents back after he had expired?
A. No, sir.
Q. And why was no effort made at that time to inspect his back?
A. I suppose nobody really had the heart to do it.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Moreover, the Parkland doctors took no further action after the President
had expired because they concluded that it was beyond the scope of their permissible duties.
Treatment of Governor Connally
While one medical team tried to revive President Kennedy, a second performed
a series of operations on the bullet wounds sustained by Governor Connally.
Governor Connally was originally seen by Dr. Carrico and Dr. Richard Dulany.
While Dr. Carrico went on to attend the President, Dr. Dulany stayed with
the Governor and was soon joined by several other doctors. At approximately
12: 45 P.M., Dr. Robert Shaw, chief of thoracic surgery, arrived at trauma room 2,
to take charge of the care of Governor Connally, whose major wound fell within
Dr. Shaws area of specialization.
Governor Connally had a large sucking wound in the front of the right chest
which caused extreme pain and difficulty in breathing. Rubber tubes were inserted between the second and third ribs to reexpand the right lung, which
had collapsed because of the opening in the chest wall. At 1: 35 P.M., after Governor Connally had been moved to the operating room, Dr. Shaw started the
first operation by cutting away the edges of the wound on the front of the Governors chest and suturing the damaged lung and lacerated muscles. The elliptical wound in the Governors back, located slightly to the left of the Governors
right armpit approximately five-eighths inch (a centimeter and a half) in its
greatest diameter, was treated by cutting away the damaged skin and suturing
the back muscle and skin. This operation was concluded at 3:20 P.M.
Two additional operations were performed on Governor Connally for wounds
which he had not realized he had sustained until he regained consciousness
the following day. From approximately 4 P.M. to 4:50 P.M. on November 22,
Dr. Charles F. Gregory, chief of orthopedic surgery, operated on the wounds of Governor Connallys right wrist, assisted by Drs. William Osborne and John Parker.
The wound on the back of the wrist was left partially open for draining, and the
wound on the palm side was enlarged, cleansed, and closed. The fracture was
set, and a cast was applied with some traction utilized. While the second operation was in progress, Dr. George T. Shires, assisted by Drs. Robert McClelland,
Charles Baxter, and Ralph Don Patman, treated the gunshot wound in the left
thigh. This punctuate missile wound, about two-fifths inch in diameter (1 centimeter) and located approximately 5 inches above the left knee, was cleansed and
closed with sutures; but a small metallic fragment remained in the Governors leg.
Vice President Johnson at Parkland
As President Kennedy and Governor Connally were being removed from the
limousine onto stretchers, a protective circle of Secret Service agents surrounded
775
776
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Vice President and Mrs. Johnson and escorted them into Parkland Hospital
through the emergency entrance. The agents moved a nurse and patient out of
a nearby room, lowered the shades, and took emergency security measures to
protect the Vice President. Two men from the Presidents follow-up car were detailed to help protect the Vice President. An agent was stationed at the entrance
to stop anyone who was not a member of the Presidential party. U.S. Representatives Henry B. Gonzalez, Jack Brooks, Homer Thornberry, and Albert Thomas
joined Clifton C. Carter and the group of special agents protecting the Vice
President. On one occasion Mrs. Johnson, accompanied by two Secret Service
agents, left the room to see Mrs. Kennedy and Mrs. Connally.
Concern that the Vice President might also be a target for assassination
prompted the Secret Service agents to urge him to leave the hospital and return
to Washington immediately. The Vice President decided to wait until he received definitive word of the Presidents condition. At approximately 1:20 P.M.,
Vice President Johnson was notified by ODonnell that President Kennedy was
dead. Special Agent Youngblood learned from Mrs. Johnson the location of her
two daughters and made arrangements through Secret Service headquarters in
Washington to provide them with protection immediately.
When consulted by the Vice President, ODonnell advised him to go
to the airfield immediately and return to Washington. It was decided that
the Vice President should return on the Presidential plane rather than on the
Vice-Presidential plane because it had better communication equipment. The
Vice President conferred with White House Assistant Press Secretary Malcolm
Kilduff and decided that there would be no release of the news of the Presidents death until the Vice President had left the hospital. When told that
Mrs. Kennedy refused to leave without the Presidents body, the Vice President said that he would not leave Dallas without her. On the recommendation of the Secret Service agents, Vice President Johnson decided to board
the Presidential airplane, Air Force One, and wait for Mrs. Kennedy and the
Presidents body.
Secret Service Emergency Security Arrangements
Immediately after President Kennedys stretcher was wheeled into trauma
room 1, Secret Service agents took positions at the door of the small emergency
room. A nurse was asked to identify hospital personnel and to tell everyone,
except necessary medical staff members, to leave the emergency room. Other
Secret Service agents posted themselves in the corridors and other areas near
the emergency room. Special Agent Lawson made certain that the Dallas police
kept the public and press away from the immediate area of the hospital. Agents
Kellerman and Hill telephoned the head of the White House detail, Gerald A.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
Behn, to advise him of the assassination. The telephone line to Washington was
kept open throughout the remainder of the stay at the hospital.
Secret Service agents stationed at later stops on the Presidents itinerary of
November 22 were redeployed. Men at the Trade Mart were driven to Parkland
Hospital in Dallas police cars. The Secret Service group awaiting the President
in Austin were instructed to return to Washington. Meanwhile, the Secret Service agents in charge of security at Love Field started to make arrangements
for departure. As soon as one of the agents learned of the shooting, he asked
the officer in charge of the police detail at the airport to institute strict security
measures for the Presidential aircraft, the airport terminal, and the surrounding area. The police were cautioned to prevent picture taking. Secret Service
agents working with police cleared the areas adjacent to the aircraft, including
warehouses, other terminal buildings and the neighboring parking lots, of all
people. The agents decided not to shift the Presidential aircraft to the far side
of the airport because the original landing area was secure and a move would
require new measures.
When security arrangements at the airport were complete, the Secret Service made the necessary arrangements for the Vice President to leave the hospital. Unmarked police cars took the Vice President and Mrs. Johnson from
Parkland Hospital to Love Field. Chief Curry drove one automobile occupied
by Vice President Johnson, U.S. Representatives Thomas and Thornberry,
and Special Agent Youngblood. In another car Mrs. Johnson was driven
to the airport accompanied by Secret Service agents and Representative
Brooks. Motorcade policemen who escorted the automobiles were requested
by the Vice President and Agent Youngblood not to use sirens. During the
drive Vice President Johnson, at Youngbloods instruction, kept below window level.
Removal of the Presidents Body
While the team of doctors at Parkland Hospital tried desperately to save the life
of President Kennedy, Mrs. Kennedy alternated between watching them and
waiting outside. After the President was pronounced dead, ODonnell tried to
persuade Mrs. Kennedy to leave the area, but she refused. She said that she
intended to stay with her husband. A casket was obtained and the Presidents
body was prepared for removal. Before the body could be taken from the hospital, two Dallas officials informed members of the Presidents staff that the
body could not be removed from the city until an autopsy was performed. Despite the protests of these officials, the casket was wheeled out of the hospital,
placed in an ambulance, and transported to the airport shortly after 2 P.M. At
approximately 2:15 P.M. the casket was loaded, with some difficulty because of
777
778
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
the narrow airplane door, onto the rear of the Presidential plane where seats
had been removed to make room. Concerned that the local officials might try
to prevent the planes departure, ODonnell asked that the pilot take off immediately. He was informed that takeoff would be delayed until Vice President
Johnson was sworn in.
The End of the Trip
Swearing in of the New President
From the Presidential airplane, the Vice President telephoned Attorney General
Robert F. Kennedy, who advised that Mr. Johnson take the Presidential oath of
office before the plane left Dallas. Federal Judge Sarah T. Hughes hastened to the
plane to administer the oath. Members of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential
parties filled the central compartment of the plane to witness the swearing in.
At 2:38 P.M., e.s.t., Lyndon Baines Johnson took the oath of office as the 36th
President of the United States. Mrs. Kennedy and Mrs. Johnson stood at the
side of the new President as he took the oath of office. Nine minutes later, the
Presidential airplane departed for Washington, D.C.
Return to Washington, D.C.
On the return flight, Mrs. Kennedy sat with David Powers, Kenneth ODonnell,
and Lawrence OBrien. At 5:58 P.M., e.s.t., Air Force One landed at Andrews
AFB, where President Kennedy had begun his last trip only 31 hours before.
Detailed security arrangements had been made by radio from the Presidents
plane on the return flight. The public had been excluded from the base, and
only Government officials and the press were permitted near the landing area.
Upon arrival, President Johnson made a brief statement over television and radio. President and Mrs. Johnson were flown by helicopter to the White House,
from where Mrs. Johnson was driven to her residence under Secret Service
escort. The President then walked to the Executive Office Building, where he
worked until 9 P.M.
The Autopsy
Given a choice between the National Naval Medical Center at Bethesda, Md.,
and the Armys Walter Reed Hospital, Mrs. Kennedy chose the hospital in
Bethesda for the autopsy because the President had served in the Navy. Mrs.
Kennedy and the Attorney General, with three Secret Service agents, accompanied President Kennedys body on the 45-minute automobile trip from Andrews AFB to the Hospital. On the 17th floor of the Hospital, Mrs. Kennedy
and the Attorney General joined other members of the Kennedy family to await
the conclusion of the autopsy. Mrs. Kennedy was guarded by Secret Service
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F J O H N F. K E N N E D Y
agents in quarters assigned to her in the naval hospital. The Secret Service
established a communication system with the White House and screened all
telephone calls and visitors.
The hospital received the Presidents body for autopsy at approximately
7:35 P.M. X-rays and photographs were taken preliminarily and the pathological examination began at about 8 P.M. The autopsy report noted that President
Kennedy was 46 years of age, 721/2 inches tall, weighed 170 pounds, had
blue eyes and reddish-brown hair. The body was muscular and well developed
with no gross skeletal abnormalities except for those caused by the gunshot
wounds. Under Pathological Diagnosis the cause of death was set forth as
Gunshot wound, head.. . .
The autopsy examination revealed two wounds in the Presidents head.
One wound, approximately one-fourth of an inch by five-eighths of an inch
(6 by 15 millimeters), was located about an inch (2.5 centimeters) to the right
and slightly above the large bony protrusion (external occipital protuberance)
which juts out at the center of the lower part of the back of the skull. The
second head wound measured approximately 5 inches (13 centimeters) in its
greatest diameter, but it was difficult to measure accurately because multiple
crisscross fractures radiated from the large defect. During the autopsy examination, Federal agents brought the surgeons three pieces of bone recovered
from Elm Street and the Presidential automobile. When put together, these
fragments accounted for approximately three-quarters of the missing portion
of the skull. The surgeons observed, through X-ray analysis, 30 or 40 tiny
dustlike fragments of metal running in a line from the wound in the rear of the
Presidents head toward the front part of the skull, with a sizable metal fragment lying just above the right eye. From this head wound two small irregularly shaped fragments of metal were recovered and turned over to the FBI.
The autopsy also disclosed a wound near the base of the back of President
Kennedys neck slightly to the right of his spine. The doctors traced the course
of the bullet through the body and, as information was received from Parkland
Hospital, concluded that the bullet had emerged from the front portion of the
Presidents neck that had been cut away by the tracheotomy at Parkland. The
nature and characteristics of this neck wound and the two head wounds are
discussed fully in the next chapter.
After the autopsy was concluded at approximately 11 P.M., the Presidents
body was prepared for burial. This was finished at approximately 4 A.M. Shortly
thereafter, the Presidents wife, family and aides left Bethesda Naval Hospital.
The Presidents body was taken to the East Room of the White House where it
was placed under ceremonial military guard.
Source: National Archives. JFK Assassination Records. http://www.archives
.gov/research/jfk/warren-commission-report/.
779
780
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
Document 19
ASSASSINATION OF MARTIN LUTHER
KING JR. (1968)EXCERPTS FROM THE DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE REPORT ON ALLEGATIONS OF
CONSPIRACY IN THE DEATH OF DR. KING (2000)
In December 1993, Loyd Jowers appeared on the ABC program Prime Time Live
to relate details of a conspiracy to kill Martin Luther King that involved both the
U.S. government and the Mafia. Jowers was the owner of a restaurant located near
the Lorraine Motel in Memphis, where Dr. King was assassinated in 1968. Jowers
claimed that convicted King assassin James Earl Ray was merely a scapegoat, and
that Dr. King was actually killed by a Memphis police officer named Earl Clark. In
1999, the King family initiated a wrongful death suit to bring before a jury evidence
of the conspiracy theory, which the family believed. The jury found that King had
been the victim of a conspiracy that involved both the federal government and the
Memphis Police Department. In June 2000, the Justice Department, after investigating the Jowers allegations, issued the report excerpted below. The report found
no good evidence to support Jowerss allegations and much evidence to refute them,
including numerous contradictions in Jowerss own statements. The report concluded
that no further investigation of the King assassination was warranted unless new
evidence surfaced.
VII. King v. Jowers Conspiracy Allegations
A. The King v. Jowers Trial
In November 1999, trial commenced in King v. Jowers, a wrongful death civil
action filed by Dr. Pepper on behalf of Dr. Kings wife and children. Jowers
was the only defendant and thus the only other party to the lawsuit. At the
conclusion of the nearly four week trial, the jury adopted a verdict offered by
the parties finding that Jowers and others, including government agencies
participated in a conspiracy to assassinate Dr. King.
We reviewed the trials evidence in connection with our ongoing investigation of the Jowers and Wilson allegations. We also conducted additional witness interviews and searched for and reviewed records as warranted by the
evidence.
In Sections IV and VI of this report, we discussed the evidence presented
in King v. Jowers related to the Jowers allegation, as well as the relevant, additional investigation we initiated. Much of the information we considered in
those sections was not presented to the jury. For instance, the parties did not
introduce Jowers many inconsistent claims, the inconsistent statements of
several critical witnesses, or information that contradicted and undermined
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
the trial evidence. As to the Wilson allegations, no evidence, other than newspaper articles recounting Wilsons claims, was offered. Accordingly, after considering the trial evidence in light of all available, relevant information, we
still conclude that the Jowers and Wilson allegations are not credible and that
there is no Raoul.
We also considered evidence from King v. Jowers suggesting the existence
of various conspiracies broader than the one claimed by Jowers. These conspiracies purportedly included government agents and two African American
ministers who were associates of Dr. King. The evidence never linked Jowers
or his alleged co-conspirators to any federal agency or the United States
military, even though the plaintiffs maintained that Dr. Kings assassination
was the result of a government-directed conspiracy and Jowers was the only
party sued.
Nonetheless, we examined the trial evidence relating to these far-ranging
conspiracy claims. We found that it was both contradictory and based on
uncorroborated secondhand and thirdhand hearsay accounts. Nor did we
find any credible, concrete facts to substantiate any of the conspiracy allegations. Because there was no reliable evidence presented at trial relating to a
conspiracy to assassinate Dr. King involving either Jowers, the government,
African American ministers, or anyone else, and because we know of no information to support such allegations, we find no justification for further
investigation.
To explain our conclusion, we have summarized the trial evidence relating
the purported conspiracies and analyzed that evidence in view of the results
of our investigation and other relevant information that was not presented in
King v. Jowers.
B. Evidence Alleging the Involvement of the Federal Government
1. Hearsay Evidence
Most of the witnesses and writings offered to support the various governmentdirected conspiracy claims relied exclusively on secondhand and thirdhand
hearsay and speculation. Additionally, none of these allegations were ever linked
together. Rather, the hearsay evidence alleged that various government agencies
participated in assorted assassination plots that are actually contradictory.
One allegation came from an acquaintance of Jowers who testified regarding
a double hearsay account of an alleged conversation in a barbershop in which
a supposed FBI agent remarked that the CIA was responsible for the assassination. Unrelated to this allegation, other hearsay evidence presented a different
conspiracy, one to silence Ray after he pled guilty. One of Rays former attorneys
related a double hearsay account from two deceased inmates suggesting that,
ten years after the assassination, Ray was the target of a government-directed
781
782
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
783
784
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
nothing to substantiate the speculative claims that the CIA was involved in a
conspiracy.
b. Allegations of a government conspiracy to silence Ray
Reverend Walter Fauntroy, former delegate to the United States House of Representatives, testified regarding a rumor. Fauntroy, who headed the HSCA probe
of the King assassination, stated that at the time of Rays escape from prison in
1977, he heard that FBI snipers had been sent to Tennessee. Fauntroy emphasized, I dont know that. I have no evidence, but thats what we heard and
that alarmed us.
Attorney April Ferguson, who assisted Mark Lane in representing Ray during the HSCA hearings, testified about a related, double hearsay account from
two inmates regarding an alleged contract to kill Ray. According to Ferguson,
in January 1979, she met a now deceased, incarcerated extortionist, William
Kirk, who told her that another now deceased inmate, Arthur Baldwin, advised
him of a supposed $5000 contract to murder Ray. Ferguson added that Kirk
told her, without providing any specifics or sources for his information, that he
got the impression that * * * Baldwin was working as an agent or informer for
the federal government.
We did not find anything to confirm either hearsay allegation about the
plots to kill Ray. Reverend Fauntroy correctly cautioned in his testimony that
he knew of no evidence to support the rumor he had heard. In fact, Ray was
in the custody of the government for over 30 years and died of liver disease
in 1998.
We did determine that Baldwin assisted the government in federal investigations that were unrelated to the assassination in return for a reduced sentence for his own criminal activity. We are aware, however, of no information
to substantiate the inference that Baldwin was thus involved in a governmentdirected plot to kill Ray. The former United States Attorney, who used Baldwin
as an informant, advised that, because of Baldwins poor credibility, he relied
on Baldwins information only when it could be independently corroborated.
We found nothing to corroborate the hearsay account of Kirks allegation of
Baldwins claim. Moreover, it is not uncommon for inmates to make false accusations with some hope of personal gain.
c. Allegation of a conspiracy involving the
President and Vice President
During the trial, Garrison, on behalf of Jowers, presented a John Doe deposition outlining a conspiracy involving the Mafia and implicating both the President and Vice President of the United States. The unidentified deponent, whose
name was withheld for unexplained security reasons, claimed to have worked
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
for the Houston Post in 1968. His deposition provides that he was contacted by
a former treasurer of the United Auto Workers at the request of a bookmaker
acquaintance and offered $400,000, allegedly to be supplied by the union, to
satisfy Mr. [Hubert] Humphrey and Mr. [Lyndon] Johnson by making Martin
Luther King * * * shut up about the Vietnam War * * * by just taking him
out. According to the deposition, the deponent accepted the offer, and along
with the assistance of several others, including Raoul and Mafia figure, Carlos
Marcello, assassinated Dr. King.
The deposition provides details as to how the murder was allegedly accomplished. It states that on April 4, 1968, the deponent and others flew to Memphis from a secret airstrip owned by Marcello. Upon arrival, a woman from
Belize, South America, now deceased, drove them to downtown Memphis and
dropped off Raoul near Mulberry Street. Raoul then went into a building and
left a bag outside. Afterwards, Raoul drove to New Orleans, picked up Ray in
Atlanta, and flew with him to Canada. The deposition also alleges that after the
actual shooting of King took place [from] behind * * * a brushy little wall, the
woman from Belize c[a]me around and pick[ed] up the shooter in a Chevrolet
Corvair. The shooter, along with the deponent, flew back to the Mafia airstrip
and, while passing over the Mississippi River, threw the rifle into the river.
While the John Doe deposition presented the most detailed evidence alleging a government-directed conspiracy, no live witness testimony or documentary or physical evidence corroborated any part of its allegations. Conveniently,
Doe remained unidentified for security reasons and virtually all of his alleged
co-conspirators are supposedly dead. Moreover, many of Does claims are contradicted by otherwise established facts. For example, none of the many witnesses
at the Lorraine, nor the police who immediately responded, saw a woman drive
by and pick up the shooter, and Ray never claimed that he flew to Canada with
Raoul. Thus, this far-fetched, anonymous story has no indicia of reliability and
is not credible.
d. Allegations of military involvement in a conspiracy
The King v. Jowers trial included evidence relating allegations of United States
military involvement in the assassination. Although no evidence specifically alleged that military personnel killed Dr. King, hearsay accounts and speculation
suggested that military personnel were somehow connected to the assassination and actually witnessed it.
Dr. Pepper introduced redacted copies of notes purporting to document interviews with unidentified military sources who claimed to have observed the
assassination. One set of notes records allegations by an unidentified source,
claiming that he was one of two soldiers with the 902d Military Intelligence
Group who was on the rooftop of Fire Station No. 2 conducting surveillance of
785
786
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
Dr. King at the time of the assassination. This source reported that he observed
and his partner photographed the assassination and a white man with a rifle
on the ground leaving the scene. According to the notes, the source offered to
approach his partner to attempt to obtain the alleged photographs for $2,000.
Another set of notes purported to document the allegations of a different
unnamed source that he was one of two guardsmen with an Alabama National
Guard unit, the 20th Special Forces Group (SFG), who was watching Dr. King
and Ambassador Young from another rooftop near the Lorraine and observed
the assassination. That source also claimed that his team coordinated with the
Memphis police and someone he assumed to be with the CIA.
In a 1993 newspaper article from the Memphis Commercial Appeal, which
was also introduced, reporter Stephen Tompkins asserts, without citing sources
for the specific claims, that in the late 1960s, the 20th SFG conducted military
intelligence surveillance of Dr. King and others from the civil rights movement.
The article further provides that, on the day before the assassination, the 111th
Military Intelligence Group (MIG) shadowed [Dr. Kings] movements and
monitored radio traffic from a sedan crammed with electronic equipment and
that [e]ight Green Berets from an Operation Detachment Alpha 184 Team
were also in Memphis carrying out an unknown mission.
Douglas Valentine, who authored a book about CIA intelligence operations
during the Vietnam war, presented hearsay testimony from another unidentified source. He related that while writing his book, he learned that a single unnamed source allegedly involved in the militarys anti-war surveillance heard
a rumor that the 111th MIG was conducting surveillance of Dr. King in Memphis on April 4, 1968, and took photographs of the assassination. Valentine
advised us after the trial that he could not recall the identity of the person who
told him the rumor but thought it was a former military enlisted man.
Another writer, Jack Terrell, who claimed to have worked with a CIAdirected group supplying arms and military software to the Contra rebels in
Honduras in the 1980s, offered a hearsay opinion of a deceased source. Terrell testified that in the 1970s, as a private businessman, one of his employees,
J.D. Hill, now deceased, claimed to have been with the 20th SFG in the 1960s.
According to Terrell, Hill, who was a strange person with a drinking problem, expressed the view that in 1968 he had been trained specifically to participate in a military sniper mission to assassinate Dr. King that was canceled
without explanation.
(1) Allegations regarding the military that
are relevant to Jowers claim
Although none of the King v. Jowers conspiracy allegations were directly linked
to Jowers allegations, some of the evidence relating to claims of military
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
787
788
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
Official records reflect that the 111th MIG and the Tennessee National
Guard were the only military units which had personnel in Memphis on the
day of the assassination. We found no record to indicate that any other military
unit, including the 902d MIG, had personnel in Memphis on April 4, 1968.
The Department of Defense also confirmed Tompkins understanding that the
902d MIG did not conduct domestic intelligence work. Finally, we found no
written record of any surveillance of Dr. King at the Lorraine Motel by military
personnel from any unit.
In addition to reviewing records, we located and interviewed five surviving
members of the 111th MIG who were in Memphis on April 4, 1968. They all
claimed they were not aware that military personnel from any other unit, including the 902d MIG, were in Memphis around the time of the assassination.
Jimmie Locke, then a Major and the 111th MIGs ranking officer in Memphis
at the time of the assassination, advised that under the militarys standing operating procedures he would have been advised if personnel from another unit
were in his area. He specifically stated that, even if the other units operation
was covert, he would have been advised of the personnels presence, if not their
mission.
Additionally, no one from the 111th MIG had firsthand knowledge that any
military personnel were in the vicinity of the Lorraine on the day of the assassination or that military personnel ever conducted surveillance of Dr. King.
Steve McCall, then a Sergeant and investigator with the 111th MIG, did remember, however, somehow hearing that agents from his unit were being dispatched to the Lorraine on the day of the assassination to watch Dr. King and
his party. McCall could not recall the source for this information or any other
details, including whether anyone actually went to the Lorraine and, if they
did, who they were, when they went, or what they did.
Significantly, one witness from the 111th MIG also told us that he was on
the roof of Fire Station No. 2 beforebut not on the day ofthe assassination.
James Green, then a Sergeant and investigator, recalled going to the fire station
on the day that Dr. Kings advance party arrived in Memphis, perhaps March
31st. He claims he went with another agent from his unit, whom he could
not now recall, to scout for locations to take photographs of persons visiting
the King party at the Lorraine Motel at a later time, if necessary. According to
Green, someone from the station may have shown them to the roof, where he
and the other agent remained for 30 to 45 minutes before determining it was
too exposed a location from which to take photographs. Green stated he never
returned to the roof or the vicinity of the Lorraine and never conducted surveillance of or photographed Dr. King. He also advised that he never heard that
any other military personnel were in the area of the Lorraine on the day of the
assassination or conducted surveillance of Dr. King.
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
We also interviewed all surviving firemen who worked at Fire Station No. 2
at the time of the assassination. No fireman, other than Weeden, had any
knowledge about the presence of military personnel at the fire station.
While we found no reason to disbelieve Captain Weedens recollection that
he led two Army agents to the stations roof or Greens account to support it, we
found nothing to confirm that military personnel were in fact at that location
on the day of the assassination. Further, when we interviewed Weeden after
the trial, he acknowledged that his memory of an event 30 years ago might be
inexact, and, thus, it was possible that he took the military personnel to the
roof sometime beforenot the day ofthe assassination. He added that he
had never spoken with anyone about his recollection until Dr. Pepper interviewed him before [Pepper] wrote his book in 1995. Accordingly, Greens
recollection that military personnel went to the roof on a different day than the
assassination appears accurate.
We likewise found physical evidence to contradict Jacob Brenners story that
he or anyone else was on the fire stations roof at the time of the assassination. Attachments 4a and 4b, photographs taken by television producer Joseph
Louw of the police responding to the shooting, clearly depict the fire stations
roof most probably within a minute of the shooting. The photographs were
taken through the window of Louws balcony room, which was two doors from
where Dr. King lay mortally wounded. Had Brenner or someone else been on
the roof photographing the assassination when Louw was taking his photographs, they would necessarily appear in them. Louws photographs, however,
show no one on the roof.
After examining all relevant information, we have concluded that the King v.
Jowers hearsay evidence that military personnel witnessed and photographed
both the assassination and a man with a rifle as he left the scene is not credible.
We found no evidence to support the allegation. Rather, we discovered information to contradict it, including Louws photographs and the assessment of
the only person who heard the story, Tompkins, that it is not worthy of belief.
(2) Other allegations regarding the military
We have also concluded that allegations in a second set of interview notes relating to military personnel also authored by Tompkins and introduced at trial
are not credible. Those notes reflect the claims of two men, who alleged that
they were sent to Memphis with the 20th Special Forces Group of the Alabama
National Guard, met a Memphis police officer and someone appearing to be
a CIA agent, and witnessed the assassination. Although Tompkins declined
to provide the names of the guardsmen, asserting that they are news sources
whose identities he is obliged to protect, he nonetheless advised that he was
unable to corroborate their story and doubted their credibility.
789
790
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
Tompkins recounted that, during his investigation for the Memphis Commercial Appeal in the early 1990s, he received information that the 20th SFG had
been in Memphis at the time of the assassination. His inquiry led to a man then
living in Mexico, who claimed to have been a guardsman with that unit and on
the roof of a building (not the fire station) watching Dr. King at the time of the
assassination. Tompkins said that the guardsman introduced him to another
man in Mexico who allegedly was the teams observer. Tompkins emphasized
that the guardsman claimed that he was only conducting reconnaissance and
not deployed as a sniper to shoot Dr. King.
Tompkins told us that he never found anything to corroborate the allegations of the guardsman and his observer and no longer believes them. He
stated that the guardsman, like Brenner, wanted money in exchange for documents that he claimed would substantiate his story. Because Tompkins and
his newspaper did not credit the story, they did not attempt to purchase the
alleged documents or publish the account. Later, according to Tompkins, he
gave money from Dr. Pepper to the guardsman for the documents (he did not
recall the amount), but the guardsman never provided them. Tompkins explained that he did not think the guardsman was on the level and that what
he related may have been just bullshit and made up. Tompkins summed
up his evaluation of the guardsman by saying that he would not testify under
oath that [the guardsman] was truthful, and, in his view, it would be a waste
of taxpayers dollars to travel to Mexico to speak with him.
We found no evidence to corroborate the allegations of the guardsman or
his purported observer. We could find no record or witness to confirm that the
20th SFG or any other military unit besides the 111th MIG and the Tennessee
National Guard was in Memphis at the time of the assassination or anything
else alleged. Moreover, according to the National Guard Bureau of the Department of Defense, the 20th SFG was never authorized to engage in surveillance
or any other activities against civil rights leaders.
Additionally, one critical fact mentioned by the guardsman that was subject
to verification proved to be false. According to Tompkins, the guardsman said
his team leader, an officer whom he named, accompanied the team to Memphis. Tompkins interview notes also make several references to the team leaders activities in Memphis on the day of the assassination. In 1997, the team
leader, who was supposedly dead, came forward to contest the accusations. He
denied both being in Memphis on April 4, 1968, and knowing that other personnel from the 20th SFG were there, and provided an account of his whereabouts on the day of the assassination. We are aware of nothing to contradict
the team leaders denial.
We also considered both Tompkins claim in his 1993 article that the 111th
MIG monitored Dr. King in Memphis on the day before the assassination with
a sedan crammed with electronic equipment and police officer James Smiths
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
791
792
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
We reviewed the trial testimony relating to these claims. Based on an analysis of all relevant information, including numerous facts not presented to the
jury, we have concluded that the allegation that two of Dr. Kings associates
conspired to kill him is not credible and does not warrant further investigation.
1. Dr. King and the Lorraine Motel
During the trial, evidence suggested that Dr. Kings stay at the Lorraine was out
of the ordinary and intentionally directed by insiders to assist the assassination. For example, Jerry Williams, a former Memphis police officer, one of the
African American officers who provided security for Dr. Kings previous visits to
Memphis, testified that Dr. King had never stayed overnight at the Lorraine because of security concerns. Reverend James Lawson, an associate of Dr. Kings,
also testified that Dr. King mostly stayed at white motels, rather than the
motels patronized by African Americans, like the Lorraine.
Supporting the theory that one of Dr. Kings associates deliberately moved
him to a balcony room to facilitate the assassination, Leon Cohen testified that
on the day after the assassination he heard that Dr. Kings room assignment
at the Lorraine had been changed by someone within his own organization.
Cohen, who claimed to be a friend of the Lorraines owner, Walter Bailey, testified that Bailey told him that a male member of Dr. Kings group called from
Atlanta the day prior to Dr. Kings arrival to change his interior courtyard
room to an exposed, balcony room. According to Cohens hearsay account,
Bailey was adamantly against the move because of his concerns for Dr. Kings
security.
The historical record contradicts the trial testimony that Dr. Kings final stay
at the Lorraine was unusual. The motel owner, Walter Bailey, now deceased,
told investigators on several occasions that Dr. King was a frequent overnight
guest at the Lorraine. For example, on the day of the assassination, Bailey told
the FBI that Dr. King had stayed at his motel on approximately 12 occasions
since 1958. In 1969, Bailey similarly told investigators for James Earl Ray that
Dr. King had stayed at the Lorraine on and off for the past 15 years.
Others corroborate Baileys official statements about Dr. Kings frequent patronage of the Lorraine. Baileys daughter Caroline Champion, who worked at
the motel, advised our investigators that Dr. King stayed there many times.
Dr. Kings close friend and colleague, Reverend Ralph Abernathy, told the
HSCA under oath that he and Dr. King stayed in room 306 at the Lorraine so
often that it was referred to as the King-Abernathy suite. Memphis police officer Edward Redditt, who also provided security for Dr. King during an earlier
visit, corroborated the recollections of Bailey, Champion, and Abernathy that
Dr. King had previously stayed at the Lorraine. Accordingly, contrary to the
trial testimony, other information from several reliable sources demonstrates
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
that Dr. King was a frequent overnight guest at the Lorraine. Thus, there is
nothing suspicious about his being at the Lorraine on April 4, 1968.
The suggestion that one of Dr. Kings associates moved him to Room 306
on the balcony level to make him a target for the assassin is also contradicted
by well-documented accounts. When interviewed by the FBI the day of the
assassination, Bailey said that he had no knowledge that anyone had acted in
a suspicious manner and absolutely no information or thoughts on the assassination. He likewise expressed no concern about Dr. Kings room assignment
in statements to Rays investigators and specifically told them that there was
no advance registration for Dr. King, who was not registered until Reverend
Lawsons arrival on April 3, 1968. Had Bailey actually received instructions,
with which he disagreed, to change Dr. Kings room, it is inconceivable that he
would have related that fact only to Cohen and not to any of the several investigators, including those representing Ray, who interviewed him.
Moreover, Reverend Abernathys testimony to the HSCA about the KingAbernathy suite (balcony Room 306) completely contradicts Cohens testimony. Reverend Abernathy further testified that during the April 34, 1968
visit, he and Dr. King were moved to Room 306 at their own request as soon
as it was vacated by another guest. Accordingly, we found nothing to support
a conclusion that some unidentified associate of Dr. King deliberately moved
him to a balcony room to facilitate his assassination.
2. Dr. Kings Security
Evidence was also presented to suggest a plot to facilitate the removal of
Dr. Kings security. We discussed most of this trial evidence, along with other
related information not presented in the trial, when we considered general accusations that security was removed in Section IV.D.2.b.(1) above. However,
two additional pieces of evidence were presented in King v. Jowers in an effort to
suggest that Dr. Kings associates assisted the alleged plot to remove his security.
Philip Mellanson, a professor and author, testified that Memphis Police Inspector Sam Evans, now deceased, told him that he ordered tactical units away
from the Lorraine at the request of a specific Memphis Minister associated
with Dr. King, whom he named. In addition, other witnesses testified about
their belief that the eviction of the Invaders, a group of young Memphis, African American activists, from their room at the Lorraine minutes before the
shooting facilitated the assassination. One former Invader, Charles Cabbage,
testified that he was told that another minister, the SCLC Minister, a ranking member of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, ordered that his
group be immediately ejected.
We found nothing to support Mellansons hearsay account that the Memphis Minister was the specific source of the request to remove tactical units.
When we interviewed the Memphis Minister, he denied ever making such a
793
794
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
request. Moreover, the fact that TACT Unit 10 remained in the vicinity across
the street at the fire station undermines the inference that the Memphis Minister conspired with law enforcement.
Likewise, nothing supports a conclusion that the eviction of the Invaders
from the Lorraine, allegedly at the direction of the SCLC Minister, is related
to the assassination. We found no evidence that the Invaders had anything to
do with Dr. Kings security. Rather, according to associates of Dr. King and former Memphis police officers, the Invaders were young, African American activists who were attempting to associate with Dr. King. Accordingly, even if the
Invaders were evicted from the Lorraine by the SCLC Minister or some other
SCLC staff person, such action would not have diminished Dr. Kings security.
Moreover, Charles Cabbages recent trial testimony is inconsistent with his
testimony to the HSCA. Twenty years ago, Cabbage testified that did not recollect the specific sequence of events leading to the Invaders departure from the
Lorraine but that they decided to leave on their own because the SCLC would
not pay their room bill. Cabbage told the HSCA that one of the [SCLC] staffers, whose name he did not provide, somehow advised him that they [the
SCLC] were no longer going to pay for the room, and we [the Invaders] were
already overdue and that left no alternative but for us to check out.
Cabbages recent testimony is also uncorroborated and contrary to the recollections of others. Significantly, in Cabbages recent testimony in King v. Jowers,
he claimed that it was Reverend James Orange who evicted the Invaders, telling him that the SCLC Minister wanted them to leave immediately. When we
spoke with Orange after the trial, he told us he did not recall receiving that instruction from the SCLC Minister or anyone else. Also, when we interviewed
the SCLC Minister, a friend and associate of Dr. Kings, who has led a life of
public service, he denied the accusation and claimed that he did not recall
that the Invaders were even staying at the Lorraine. We are aware of nothing
to contradict his denial. Accordingly, the record does not support the inference
presented at trial that African American ministers associated with Dr. King facilitated the assassination by removing his security.
3. Dr. Kings Presence on the Balcony
During the trial, the Memphis Minister was also called as a witness and questioned so as to create the impression that he had deliberately lured Dr. King
to the balcony of the Lorraine at precisely 6:00 P.M. and left him exposed and
alone so that he could be shot. This claim is consistent with the view expressed
to us by Dr. Pepper and Dexter King prior to trial. To support this contention,
the plaintiffs attorney questioned the Memphis Minister regarding his conduct before the shooting and confronted him with words from his speech at
ceremonies commemorating an anniversary of the assassination. In the speech,
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
as he described the events of the assassination, the Memphis Minister recounted that just before the shot he moved away [from Dr. King] so he [the
assassin] could have a clear shot.
According to a number of witnesses interviewed by our investigation and
previous investigations, Dr. King walked out of Room 306 onto the balcony of
the Lorraine just before 6:00 P.M. in the company of the Memphis Minister.
Dr. King conversed with several of his other associates, who were assembled in
the parking lot below as they all were preparing to go to dinner. When the Memphis Minister walked a few steps away from Dr. King, the assassin fired. As discussed in Section IV.D.1.a.(1) above, we determined that Dr. Kings appearance
on the balcony at 6:00 P.M. for a 5:00 P.M. dinner engagement could not have
been anticipated with enough certainty to plan the time of the assassination.
The notion that the Memphis Minister was involved in the assassination
and inadvertently revealed his participation during a public speech is far-fetched.
The ministers comment, I moved away so he could have a clear shot, considered in the context of his speech, appears nothing more than an inartful
attempt to explain the sequence of events and the fact that Dr. King was shot
when he moved away from the speakers side. It hardly amounts to an inadvertent confession.
In any event, we are aware of no information to support the accusation that
the Memphis Minister led Dr. King to the balcony and moved away to allow
the assassin to shoot. We confronted the Memphis Minister with the accusation and he denied it. We are also aware of nothing that would have motivated
him to assist a conspiracy to murder a friend and associate, while his public life
demonstrates his integrity and dedication to non-violence.
D. Conclusions Regarding the King v. Jowers Conspiracy Claims
The evidence introduced in King v. Jowers to support various conspiracy allegations consisted of either inaccurate and incomplete information or unsubstantiated conjecture, supplied most often by sources, many unnamed, who did not
testify. Important information from the historical record and our investigation
contradicts and undermines it. When considered in light of all other available
relevant facts, the trials evidence fails to establish the existence of any conspiracy to kill Dr. King. The verdict presented by the parties and adopted by
the jury is incompatible with the weight of all relevant information, much of
which the jury never heard. Accordingly, the conspiracy allegations presented
at the trial warrant no further investigation.
VIII. Conclusion and Recommendation
After reviewing all available materials from prior official investigations and
other sources, including the evidence from King v. Jowers, and after conducting
795
796
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F M A R T I N LU T H E R K I N G J R .
a year and a half of original investigation, we have concluded that the allegations originating with Loyd Jowers and Donald Wilson are not credible.
We found no reliable evidence to support Jowers allegations that he conspired with others to shoot Dr. King from behind Jims Grill. In fact, credible
evidence contradicting his allegations, as well as material inconsistencies among
his accounts and his own repudiations of them, demonstrate that Jowers has
not been truthful. Rather, it appears that Jowers contrived and promoted a
sensational story of a plot to kill Dr. King.
Likewise, we do not credit Donald Wilsons claim that he took papers from
Rays abandoned car. Wilson has made significant contradictory statements
and otherwise behaved in a duplicitous manner, inconsistent with his professed interest in seeking the truth. Important evidence contradicting Wilsons
claims, including the failure of James Earl Ray to support Wilsons revelation,
further undermines his account. Although we were unable to determine the
true origin of the Wilson documents, his inconsistent statements, his conduct,
and substantial evidence refuting his claims all demonstrate that his implausible account is not worthy of belief. Accordingly, we have concluded that the
documents do not constitute evidence relevant to the King assassination.
The weight of the evidence available to our investigation also establishes
that Raoul is merely the creation of James Earl Ray. We found no evidence to
support the claims that a Raoul participated in the assassination. Rather, a review of 30 years of speculation about his identity presents a convincing case
that no Raoul was involved in a conspiracy to kill Dr. King.
In accordance with our mandate, we confined our investigation to the Jowers
and the Wilson allegations and logical investigative leads suggested by them,
including those concerning Raoul, who is central to both allegations. We however considered other allegations, including the unsubstantiated claims made
during the trial of King v. Jowers that government agencies and African American ministers associated with Dr. King conspired to kill him. Where warranted,
we conducted limited additional investigation. Thus, we evaluated all additional allegations brought to our attention to determine whether any reliable
substantiation exists to credit them or warrant further inquiry. We found none.
Similarly, we considered the suggestion of the House Select Committee on
Assassinations and the Shelby County District Attorney General to investigate
whether James Earl Rays surviving brothers may have been his co-conspirators.
We found insufficient evidentiary leads remaining after 30 years to justify further investigation. Finally, while we conducted no original investigation specifically directed at determining whether James Earl Ray killed Dr. King, we
found no credible evidence to disturb past judicial determinations that he did.
Questions and speculation may always surround the assassination of Dr. King
and other national tragedies. Our investigation of these most recent allegations, as well as several exhaustive previous official investigations, found no
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
reliable evidence that Dr. King was killed by conspirators who framed James
Earl Ray. Nor have any of the conspiracy theories advanced in the last 30 years,
including the Jowers and the Wilson allegations, survived critical examination.
We recommend no further federal investigation of the Jowers allegations,
the Wilson allegations, or any other allegations related to the assassination unless and until reliable substantiating facts are presented. At this time, we are
aware of no information to warrant any further investigation of the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice Website. http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/
crm/mlk/part1.php.
Document 20
ASSASSINATION OF ROBERT F. KENNEDY
(1968)EDWARD M. KENNEDYS EULOGY FOR
HIS BROTHER ROBERT F. KENNEDY
Senator Edward M. Kennedy delivered the eulogy reproduced below at the funeral
of his slain brother Robert Kennedy at St. Patricks Cathedral in New York City on
June 8, 1968. The text below is not a transcript of the recording of Senator Kennedys
eulogy. It is instead based on the version released to the press, which differs in a few
particulars. Because of its wide distribution, the press version has at least as strong a
claim on the historical record as the spoken version.
Senator Edward M. Kennedy
St. Patricks Cathedral
New York City
June 8, 1968
On behalf of Mrs. Robert Kennedy, her children and the parents and sisters
of Robert Kennedy, I want to express what we feel to those who mourn with
us today in this Cathedral and around the world. We loved him as a brother and
father and son. From his parents, and from his older brothers and sistersJoe,
Kathleen and Jackhe received inspiration which he passed on to all of us. He
gave us strength in time of trouble, wisdom in time of uncertainty, and sharing
in time of happiness. He was always by our side.
Love is not an easy feeling to put into words. Nor is loyalty, or trust or joy.
But he was all of these. He loved life completely and lived it intensely.
A few years back, Robert Kennedy wrote some words about his own father
and they expressed the way we in his family feel about him. He said of what
his father meant to him: What it really all adds up to is lovenot love as it is
797
798
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
described with such facility in popular magazines, but the kind of love that is affection and respect, order, encouragement, and support. Our awareness of this
was an incalculable source of strength, and because real love is something unselfish and involves sacrifice and giving, we could not help but profit from it.
Beneath it all, he has tried to engender a social conscience. There were
wrongs which needed attention. There were people who were poor and who
needed help. And we have a responsibility to them and to this country. Through
no virtues and accomplishments of our own, we have been fortunate enough
to be born in the United States under the most comfortable conditions. We,
therefore, have a responsibility to others who are less well off.
This is what Robert Kennedy was given. What he leaves us is what he said,
what he did and what he stood for. A speech he made to the young people
of South Africa on their Day of Affirmation in 1966 sums it up the best, and
I would read it now:
There is a discrimination in this world and slavery and slaughter and starvation. Governments repress their people; and millions are trapped in poverty
while the nation grows rich; and wealth is lavished on armaments everywhere.
These are differing evils, but they are common works of man. They reflect
the imperfection of human justice, the inadequacy of human compassion, our
lack of sensibility toward the sufferings of our fellows.
But we can perhaps remembereven if only for a time that those who live
with us are our brothers; that they share with us the same short moment of
life; that they seekas we donothing but the chance to live out their lives
in purpose and happiness, winning what satisfaction and fulfillment they can.
Surely this bond of common faith, this bond of common goal, can begin to
teach us something. Surely, we can learn, at least, to look at those around us
as fellow men. And surely we can begin to work a little harder to bind up the
wounds among us and to become in our own hearts brothers and countrymen
once again.
Our answer is to rely on youthnot a time of life but a state of mind, a
temper of the will, a quality of imagination, a predominance of courage over
timidity, of the appetite for adventure over the love of ease. The cruelties and
obstacles of this swiftly changing planet will not yield to obsolete dogmas and
outworn slogans. They cannot be moved by those who cling to a present that is
already dying, who prefer the illusion of security to the excitement and danger
that come with even the most peaceful progress. It is a revolutionary world we
live in; and this generation at home and around the world, has had thrust upon
it a greater burden of responsibility than any generation that has ever lived.
Some believe there is nothing one man or one woman can do against the
enormous array of the worlds ills. Yet many of the worlds great movements, of
thought and action, have flowed from the work of a single man. A young monk
began the Protestant reformation, a young general extended an empire from
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
Macedonia to the borders of the earth, and a young woman reclaimed the territory of France. It was a young Italian explorer who discovered the New World,
and the thirty-two-year-old Thomas Jefferson who proclaimed that all men are
created equal.
These men moved the world, and so can we all. Few will have the greatness to bend history itself, but each of us can work to change a small portion of
events, and in the total of all those acts will be written the history of this generation. It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human
history is shaped. Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve
the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of
hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and
daring, those ripples build a current that can sweep down the mightiest walls
of oppression and resistance.
Few are willing to brave the disapproval of their fellows, the censure of
their colleagues, the wrath of their society. Moral courage is a rarer commodity
than bravery in battle or great intelligence. Yet it is the one essential, vital quality for those who seek to change a world that yields most painfully to change.
And I believe that in this generation those with the courage to enter the moral
conflict will find themselves with companions in every corner of the globe.
For the fortunate among us, there is the temptation to follow the easy and
familiar paths of personal ambition and financial success so grandly spread before those who enjoy the privilege of education. But that is not the road history
has marked out for us. Like it or not, we live in times of danger and uncertainty.
But they are also more open to the creative energy of men than any other time
in history. All of us will ultimately be judged and as the years pass we will surely
judge ourselves, on the effort we have contributed to building a new world society and the extent to which our ideals and goals have shaped that effort.
The future does not belong to those who are content with today, apathetic
toward common problems and their fellow man alike, timid and fearful in the
face of new ideas and bold projects. Rather it will belong to those who can
blend vision, reason and courage in a personal commitment to the ideals and
great enterprises of American Society.
Our future may lie beyond our vision, but it is not completely beyond our
control. It is the shaping impulse of America that neither fate nor nature nor
the irresistible tides of history, but the work of our own hands, matched to reason and principle, that will determine our destiny. There is pride in that, even
arrogance, but there is also experience and truth. In any event, it is the only
way we can live.
This is the way he lived. My brother need not be idealized, or enlarged in
death beyond what he was in life, to be remembered simply as a good and decent man, who saw wrong and tried to right it, saw suffering and tried to heal
it, saw war and tried to stop it.
799
800
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
Those of us who loved him and who take him to his rest today, pray that
what he was to us and what he wished for others will some day come to pass
for all the world.
As he said many times, in many parts of this nation, to those he touched and
who sought to touch him:
Some men see things as they are and say why.
I dream things that never were and say why not.
Document 21
ASSASSINATION OF ROBERT F. KENNEDY (1968)
EXCERPTS FROM THE REPORT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL
THOMAS F. KRANZ ON HIS REINVESTIGATION OF
THE MURDER OF ROBERT KENNEDY (1977)
On August 12, 1975, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors appointed attorney Thomas F. Kranz as special counsel to conduct an independent investigation of
the assassination of Senator Robert F. Kennedy, which occurred in Los Angeles in June
1968. The need for a reinvestigation of the murder was justified by the growing support for various theories that alleged a conspiracy to murder Kennedy, which involved
more shooters than just convicted assassin Sirhan Sirhan. The most persistent theory
was that a second gunman actually fired the fatal shot because Kennedys orientation to Sirhan as described by witnesses did not match the placement and direction
of wounds described by Coroner Thomas Noguchi during Kennedys autopsy. In his
report, which was released in 1977, Kranz concluded that the overwhelming weight of
the evidence pointed to Sirhan acting alone, without the presence of a second gunman.
Reproduced below are excerpts from the report describing the murder on June 5 and
the main evidence uncovered against Sirhan in the following days.
Evidence Presented at Trial
On the evening of June 2, 1968, Senator Robert Kennedy had given a speech
at the Palm Terrace Room of the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles. Prior to the
Senators speech on the evening of June 2, William Blume, who had worked
as a stock boy in a liquor store located next door to the organic health food
store where defendant Sirhan had worked the few months previous to that
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
date, observed Sirhan in the lobby area adjacent to the Palm Terrace Room.
Mrs. Miriam Davis, a hostess for the Kennedy event that night, was walking
around the hotel twenty minutes after the speech when she observed Sirhan
seated in the kitchen area. After the Senators speech on June 2, Kennedy had
passed through the kitchen area.
On the morning of June 4, 1968, election day, Sirhan signed in at the San
Gabriel Valley Gun Club located Fish Canyon road in Duarte. Her wrote
Sirhan Sirhan and the address of 696 East Howard Street, Pasadena, on the
roster. After Sirhan had fired awhile on the shooting range, he told the range
master, Edward Buckner, I want the best box of shells you have, and I want
some that will not misfire. I got to have some that will not misfire. Buckner
then sold defendant Sirhan a box of shells, and Sirhan resumed shooting, engaging in rapid fire shooting, using a .22 revolver and remaining on the range
till 5:00 P.M.
Five other witnesses at the trial testified that they observed Sirhan engage in
rapid fire at the range. One witness, Harry Carreon, noticed 3004000 empty
casings where Sirhan was shooting. Sirhan told another witness, Mrs. Ronald
Williams, that his mini-mag bullets were superior to the bullets that she was
using, and when asked by witness Michael Saccoman if it was against the law
to use a pistol for hunting, Sirhan answered Well, I dont know about that. It
could kill a dog.
Earlier in the year, Sirhan had had a conversation with Alvin Clark, a trash
collector employed by the city of Pasadena, in which Sirhan had expressed
his concern about how the assassination of Martin Luther King would effect
Negro people and how the Negroes would vote in the coming election. Clark
testified at the trial that he told Sirhan he was going to vote for Senator Kennedy
and Sirhan responded by saying, What do you want to vote for that son-ofa-b for? Because Im planning on shooting him. Clark then told Sirhan that
Senator Kennedy had paid the expenses of bringing Martin Luther Kings body
back from Tennessee and that you will be killing one of the best men in the
country. Clark remembered that Sirhan stated that Senator Kennedy had done
this merely for the publicity involved, and that this conversation had occurred
in mid-April 1968.
On the evening of the election, June 4, an hour or two prior to Senator
Kennedys speech in the Embassy ballroom, a member of the Senators staff, Judy
Royer, observed Sirhan in the area to the rear of the Embassy ballroom stage.
Because Sirhan was not wearing a press badge or staff badge he was asked to
leave, and he turned and walked toward the doors leading out to the Embassy
ballroom. Shortly before midnight, as Senator Kennedy took the service elevator down to the pantry area in the rear of the Embassy ballroom, Jesus Perez,
a kitchen helper at the Ambassador, and Martin Petrusky, a waiter, observed
Senator Kennedy as he passed through the pantry on the way to the Embassy
801
802
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
ballroom where about 500 people awaited his speech. Both kitchen personnel
observed defendant Sirhan in the pantry at this time. Sirhan inquired whether
Senator Kennedy would be coming back through this way. Both hotel employees replied that they did not know, but testified that Sirhan remained in
the area of the pantry close to Perez at the corner of a serving table.
Upon concluding his address at approximately 12:15 A.M. (June 5) Senator
Kennedy was escorted off the platform toward the Colonial Room where he
was to meet the press. Karl Uecker, assistant Maitred at the Ambassador Hotel,
led the Senator through the pantry area behind the Embassy ballroom.
In the pantry area, Senator Kennedy stopped and shook hands with some of
the kitchen help, including Perez and Petrusky. At that time Sirhan appeared,
smirking, as testified by Perez and Petrusky, and began to fire his .22 caliber revolver at Senator Kennedy. Several shots were fired in rapid succession.
Uecker attempted to grab the weapon from Sirhan, and Senator Kennedy fell
to the floor of the pantry.
A struggle ensued as those present attempted to immobilize and disarm
Sirhan. Roosevelt Grier, Rafer Johnson, George Plimpton, Jess Unruh, and other
members of Kennedys entourage arrived seconds later. Later that night Rafer
Johnson turned the weapon over to the L.A.P.D., and it was booked into the
property division.
While Sirhan was being held in the pantry awaiting the arrival of the
L.A.P.D., Rafer Johnson asked Sirhan repeatedly, Why did you do it? Sirhan
replied, Let me explain or I can explain. At this time Sirhan also remarked
in answer to Jess Unruhs question Why him?, I did it for my country, and a
few seconds later, It is too late.
Two L.A.P. D. officers on patrol duty, Arthur Placentia and Travis White, answered the 12:20 A.M. all units call, Ambassador shooting, 3400 Wilshire,
and when the officers arrived they took Sirhan off the serving table where he
had been restrained and placed him in custody and handcuffed him. Sirhan
was transported through a hostile crowd, which was chanting Kill him, kill
him to the officers police car. Jess Unruh also entered the vehicle and the
officers drown toward Rampart station. Officer Placentia several times asked
Sirhan his name, but Sirhan did not reply. Sirhan was advised of his constitutional rights, and Sirhan replied that he understood his rights. Although the
officers did not address any further questions to Sirhan during the trip to the
station, Unruh asked Sirhan, Why did you shoot him?, and Sirhan replied,
Do you think Im crazy, so you can use it in evidence against me.
Both upon arrest, and later at the Rampart station, L.A.P.D. officers attempted
to examine Sirhans eyes, but did not form an opinion whether Sirhan was
under the influence of alcohol or drugs. He did not smell of any Odor of alcohol nor did Sirhan appear to Mr. Unruh to be under the influence of intoxicating liquor.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
At the Rampart station, Sirhans eyes were subjected to a light test, and on
the basis of that test, as well as Sirhans appearance and movements, Officer
White formed the opinion that Sirhan was not under the influence of alcohol
or drugs.
Sirhans pockets were emptied and the following items were taken from his
possession: an automobile key, two live .22 caliber bullets and an expended
bullet, two newspaper clippings (one from the Pasadena Independent Star
News dated May 26, 1968, a story by columnist David Lawrence which in part
noted that in a recent speech Senator Kennedy had favored aid to Israel with
arms if necessary; the other newspaper clipping, an advertisement from an
unidentified newspaper inviting the public to come and see and hear Senator
Robert Kennedy on Sunday, June 2, 1968, at 8:00 P.M., Coconut Grove, Ambassador Hotel, Los Angeles). Also removed from Sirhans pockets was $410.66
in cash, including four one hundred dollar bills. No wallet, identification, or
information indicating Sirhans identity was obtained from the examination of
Sirhans person. Sergeant William Jordon, who was watch commander at Rampart
detectives that night, assumed custody over petitioner around 12:45 A.M., and
asked Sirhan his name. Receiving no response, the officer informed Sirhan of
his constitutional rights. Sirhan asked some questions about his rights and requested the admonition be repeated which was done. Sirhan indicated that he
wished to remain silent.
At this time Sirhan was able to identify an absent officer to Sergeant Jordon
by the officers badge number, 3949. Sergeant Jordon formed the opinion at
this time that Sirhan was not under the influence of either alcohol or drugs.
Sirhan was not given an intoxication test because Jordon concluded there was
no objective symptoms of intoxication and no reason to administer such a test.
When Sergeant Jordon offered Sirhan a cup of coffee, Sirhan asked the officer
to drink from the cup first, and the officer did so.
For security reasons, Sirhan was transported to police headquarters at Parker
Center, arriving at the homicide squad room around 1:40 A.M. Sirhan requested
some water and again, at his request, Sergeant Jordon tasted it before passing
the cup to him. Shortly before 2:00 A.M., a Doctor Lanz examined Sirhan in
those areas where Sirhan complained of pain. Sirhan refused to tell the physician his name, and the physician told the officers present that Sirhan was not
in need of any immediate medical treatment but that Sirhan should keep as
much weight as possible off his left ankle as it was possibly sprained.
At this time Chief Deputy District Attorney Lynn Compton and Deputy District Attorney John Howard arrived, as did members of the District Attorneys
investigative staff. In an interrogation room, Howard asked Sirhan his name
and Sirhan did not answer and at that time Sirhan was advised by Howard of
his constitutional rights. Sirhan nodded in the direction of Sergeant Jordon and
stated I will stand by my original decision to remain silent.
803
804
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
During Sergeant Jordons various contacts with Sirhan, including the four to
five hours he spent with Sirhan at the arraignment and immediately prior and
subsequent thereto, Sirhan never appeared irrational. While refusing to identify himself by name or place of origin, Sirhan engaged in banter with Sergeant
Jordon. Jordon formed the opinion that Sirhan had a very quick mind, and
that Sirhan was one of the most alert and intelligent persons the officer had
ever interrogated or attempted to interrogate during his 15 years experience on
the police force.
About the same time that Sirhan was being taken to the police station, Senator
Kennedy was taken to Good Samaritan Hospital in Los Angeles. Surgery was
performed, but Senator Kennedy died at 1:44 A.M., on June 6, 1968. Dr. Thomas
Noguchi, Coroner and Chief Medical Examiner of Los Angeles County and two
deputy medical examiners, performed an autopsy on Senator Kennedys body
between 3:00 A.M. and 9:15 A.M., on June 6. It was disclosed that the gunshot
wound to the head, in the tight mastoid, had penetrated the brain and was the
cause of death. The bullet had fractured the skull and had itself been shattered.
According to Dr. Noguchi, powder burns on the right ear indicated that the
muzzle distance between the weapon and the ear at the time of the firing was
1 to 11/2 inches. The only other two gunshot wounds were in the area of the
right armpit and the right side. These shots were fired at very close range. The
location, alignment, and direction of the three wounds, in conjunction with
the clothing worn, indicated to Dr. Noguchi that the three shots in question
were fired in rapid succession.
L.A.P.D. criminologist DeWayne Wolfer testified at trial (and previously
before the Grand Jury in 1968) that a bullet taken from the base of Senator
Kennedys neck (Peoples exhibit 47) and bullets taken from victims Goldstein
and Weisel (Peoples exhibit 52 and 54) were fired from Sirhans gun and no
other gun in the world.
Additionally, Wolfer testified that he had test fired eight bullets from the
Sirhan weapon into a water tank, obtaining seven test bullets. Wolfer had
taken one of the seven test bullets and compared it to an evidence bullet and
determined that the bullets in question had come from the Sirhan weapon. . . .
Wolfer was unable to positively identify the bullet that actually killed Senator Kennedy, Peoples 48, as having been fired from the Sirhan gun due to the
fragmentation of the bullet. But Wolfer testified that it had been mini-mag ammunition, and had the same rifling specifications as the other bullets fired from
the Sirhan weapon.
Wolfer then described the trajectory of the bullets.
a. The first bullet entered Senator Kennedys head behind the right ear and
was later recovered from the victims head and booked as evidence
b. The second bullet passed through the right shoulder pad of Senator Kennedys suit coat (Never entering his body) and traveled upward striking
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
h.
victim Schrade in the center of his forehead. The bullet was recovered
from his head and booked into evidence.
The third bullet entered Senator Kennedys right rear shoulder approximately 7" below the top of the shoulder. This bullet was recovered by the
Coroner from the sixth cervical vertebra and booked as evidence.
The fourth bullet entered Senator Kennedys right rear back approximately 1" to the right of bullet #3. This bullet traveled upward and forward and exited the victims body in the right front chest. The bullet
passed through the ceiling tile, striking the second plastered ceiling and
was lost somewhere in the ceiling interspace.
The fifth bullet struck victim Goldstein in the left rear buttock. This bullet was recovered from the victim and booked as evidence.
The sixth bullet passed through victim Goldsteins left pants leg (never
entering his body) and struck the cement floor and entered victim Strolls
left leg. The bullet was later recovered and booked as evidence.
The seventh bullet struck victim Weisel in the left abdomen and was
recovered and booked as evidence.
The eighth bullet struck the plaster ceiling and then struck victim Evans
in the head. This bullet was recovered from the victims head and booked
as evidence.
Finally, an envelope containing three of the test bullets fired by Wolfer (and
having a serial number of another gunnot the Sirhan weaponon the coin
envelop) was stipulated into evidence by defense counsel. This introduction of
the mismarked bullet envelope passed without comment by defense, prosecution, or the trial court.
At approximately 9:30 A.M. on June 5, (after the shooting of Senator Kennedy,
but before his death) Sergeant William Brandt of the L.A.P.D. met with Adel
Sirhan, one of the defendants brothers, at the Pasadena Police Station. Adel
stated that he lived with his two younger brothers, Munir and Sirhan, and their
mother at 696 Howard Street, Pasadena. Adel, Sergeant Brandt, Sergeant James
Evans of the Homicide Division L.A.P.D., and agent Sullivan of the F.B.I. were
admitted to the Sirhan home by Adel at 10:30 A.M. Adel, whom the officers
knew to be the oldest male resident of the household, gave the officers permission to search the defendants bedroom. The officers did not have a search warrant and had not made an attempt to secure the consent of Sirhan to enter and
search, but their purpose in going to the Sirhan residence was to determine
whether or not there was anyone else involved in the shooting and to determine whether or not there were any things that would be relative to the crime.
Sergeant Brandt knew that there was a continuing investigation to determine
if there were other suspects.
805
806
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
Three notebooks were recovered from Sirhans bedroom. One was observed
on a corner of a dressing table in plain view from the entrance to the room.
A second notebook was observed by Sergeant Evans in plain view on the
floor at the foot of the bed next to a cardboard box filled with clothes. Both
of these notebooks were put in evidence (the third notebook was never put
in evidence by either party). The prosecution put in evidence (trial reporters
transcript, page 4364), eight pages (4 sheets) of the diary-notebook found
on the top of Sirhans dresser, which Mr. Laurence Sloan, employed in the
District Attorneys Office as specialist in handwriting and questioned documents, identified as having been written by Sirhan. These pages read in part
as follows:
May 18, 9:45 A.M./68My determination to eliminate R.F.K. is becoming
more and more of an unshakable obsession . . . R.F.K. must die . . . R.F.K. must
be killed . . . R.F.K. must be assassinated before 5 June 68 . . .
Other quotes taken from these pages were the following:
Ambassador Goldberg must die . . . Ambassador Goldberg must be eliminated . . . Sirhan is an Arab Kennedy must fall, Kennedy must fall . . . Senator
R. Kennedy must be disposed of. We believe that Robert F. Kennedy must be
sacrificed for the cause of the poor exploited people . . .
On the evening of June 5, Lieutenant Alvin Hegge of the L.A.P.D. used the
automobile key, which had been taken from Sirhans pocket at the Rampart
station, in a successful attempt to operate the lock on a door of a 1956 DeSoto
parked in the vicinity of the Ambassador Hotel. On the basis of this successful
entry, Hegge applied for and obtained the issuance of a warrant to search the
vehicle at approximately 12:30 A.M., ( June 6), and the following items were
recovered:
1. From inside the glove compart6ment, a wallet containing among other
items, current membership card in Sirhans name in the Ancient Mystical
Order of Rosacrucian, as well as other cards identifying Sirhan by name
and address;
2. From inside the gove compartment, a business card from the Lock, Stock
and Barrel gun Shop in San Gabriel and a receipt dated June 1, 1968,
from that gun shop for the purchase of mini-mag hollow point .22 caliber ammunition, and two boxes of Super X .22 caliber ammunition
(a total of 200 bullets);
3. From inside the glove compartment one live round of .22 caliber ammunition and an empty carton labeled .22 caliber mini-mag;
4. And on the right front seat two spent bullets.
A S S A S S I N AT I O N O F R O B E R T F. K E N N E D Y
Documents obtained from the California Department of Motor Vehicles established that Sirhan was the registered owner of the DeSoto searched in the
vicinity of the Ambassador Hotel.
Evidence introduced at trial established that at 8:00 A.M. on the morning of
June 6, Officer Thomas Young of the Pasadena Police Department arrived at
the Sirhan residence, having been assigned to security at the rear of the residence to guard the premises from unauthorized persons. At approximately
11:00 A.M., upon discarding a paper cup of coffee into the trash which lay inside several boxes and cans of trash on the Sirhan property, he observed an
envelope which bore on its face the return address of the Argonaut Insurance
Company. Mr. Laurence Sloan, handwriting specialist of the Los Angeles District Attorneys Office, testified that the writing on the back of the envelope
was that of Sirhan. The following words, repeated several times, were written
on the reverse side of the envelope, which had been put in evidence by the
prosecution:
R.F.K. must be . . . disposed of properly. Robert Fitzgerald Kennedy must
soon die.
Other trial evidence introduced was testimony of Mr. and Mrs. John
Weidner, the owners of a health food store in Pasadena, who had employed
Sirhan as a box boy and delivery boy. The Weidners had discussions with
Sirhan on the subject of politics in which Sirhan asserted that violence was the
only means by which American Negroes would achieve their goals, and that
the state of Israel had taken his home, and that the Jewish people were on top
and directing the events in America. When Sirhan stated to the Weidners that
there was more freedom in Russia and China than in America, Mr. Weidner
had inquired, Why dont you go there yourself? Sirhan replied, Maybe one
day I will go.
Witnesses Enrique Rabago and Humphrey Cordero testified that they went
to the Ambassador Hotel on primary election night, June 4, and observed
Sirhan at approximately 9:30 or 9:45 P.M. at the election night headquarters of
Max Rafferty, candidate for the U.S. Senate. The two men stated that Sirhan,
who had a mixed drink in his hand, remarked, Dont worry if Senator Kennedy doesnt win. That son-of-a bitch is a millionaire. Even if he wins he is not
going to win it for you or for me or for the poor people. When Sirhan paid for
a drink, he gave the waitress a $20 dollar bill and told her to keep the change
to show them. Sirhan also stated Its the money youve got that counts, not
the way you look.
807
808
AT T E M P T E D A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F RO N A L D R E AGA N
Document 22
ATTEMPTED ASSASSINATION OF RONALD
REAGAN (1981)BRADY HANDGUN
VIOLENCE PREVENTION ACT (1993)
On March 30, 1981, only 69 days into his presidency, President Ronald Reagan was
shot by John Hinckley Jr., as the president emerged from the Washington Hilton Hotel
after a speaking engagement. Reagan suffered a punctured lung and internal bleeding, but received prompt medical attention and recovered. Also wounded by Hinckley
was Reagans press secretary James Brady, who survived but was left permanently
paralyzed. With his wife Sarah, Brady later served as chair of the Brady Campaign
to Prevent Gun Violence, which lobbied Congress from stricter handgun control and
more restrictions on assault weapons. Reproduced below is the Brady Handgun
Violence Prevention Act, known as the Brady Bill, which was enacted by Congress
in 1993.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States
of America in Congress assembled,
Sec. 1. Short Title.
This Act may be cited as the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act.
Sec. 2. Waiting Period Required before Purchase of Handgun.
(a) IN GENERALSection 922 of title 18, United States Code, is amended
by adding at the end the following:
(1) It shall be unlawful for any licensed importer, licensed manufacturer, or licensed dealer to sell, deliver, or transfer a handgun to an
individual who is not licensed under section 923, unless
(A) after the most recent proposal of such transfer by the
transferee
(i) the transferor has
(I) received from the transferee a statement of the transferee
containing the information described in paragraph (3);
(II) verified the identification of the transferee by examining the
identification document presented; and
(III) within one day after the transferee furnishes the statement,
provided a copy of the statement to the chief law enforcement officer of the place of residence of the transferee; and
(ii)
AT T E M P T E D A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F RO N A L D R E AGA N
(I) 7 days have elapsed from the date the transferee furnished
the statement, and the transferor has not received information from the chief law enforcement officer that receipt or
possession of the handgun by the transferee would be in
violation of Federal, State, or local law; or
(II) the transferor has received notice from the chief law enforcement officer that the officer has no information indicating that receipt or possession of the handgun by the
transferee would violate Federal, State, or local law;
(B) the transferee has presented to the transferor a written statement, issued by the chief law enforcement officer of the place
of residence of the transferee during the 10-day period ending
on the date of the most recent proposal of such transfer by the
transferee, which states that the transferee requires access to a
handgun because of a threat to the life of the transferee or of
any member of the household of the transferee;
(C)
(i) the transferee has presented to the transferor a permit
which
(I) allows the transferee to possess a handgun; and
(II) was issued not more than 5 years earlier by the State in
which the transfer is to take place; and
(ii) the law of the State provides that such a permit is to be issued only after an authorized government official has verified that the information available to such official does not
indicate that possession of a handgun by the transferee
would be in violation of law;
(D) the law of the State
(i) prohibits any licensed importer, licensed manufacturer, or
licensed dealer from transferring a handgun to an individual who is not licensed under section 923, before at least
7 days have elapsed from the date the transferee proposes
such transfer; or
(ii) requires that, before any licensed importer, licensed manufacturer, or licensed dealer completes the transfer of a
handgun to an individual who is not licensed under section 923, an authorized government official verifies that the
information available to such official does not indicate that
809
810
AT T E M P T E D A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F RO N A L D R E AGA N
AT T E M P T E D A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F RO N A L D R E AGA N
(A) Any transferor who sells, delivers, or otherwise transfers a handgun to a transferee shall retain the copy of the statement of the
transferee with respect to the handgun transaction, and shall
retain evidence that the transferor has complied with paragraph
(1)(A)(i)(III) with respect to the statement.
(B) Unless the chief law enforcement officer to whom a copy of
the statement is sent determines that a transaction would violate Federal, State, or local law, the officer shall, within 30 days
after the date the transferee made the statement, destroy the
copy and any record containing information derived from the
statement.
(7) For purposes of this subsection, the term chief law enforcement officer means the chief of police, the sheriff, or an equivalent officer,
or the designee of any such individual.
(8) This subsection shall not apply to the sale of a firearm in the circumstances described in subsection (c).
(9) The Secretary shall take necessary actions to assure that the provisions of this subsection are published and disseminated to dealers
and to the public.
(b) HANDGUN DEFINEDSection 921(a) of such title is amended by
adding at the end the following:
(29) The term handgun means
(A) a firearm which has a short stock and is designed to be held
and fired by the use of a single hand; and
(B) any combination of parts from which a firearm described in
subparagraph (A) can be assembled.
811
812
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F Y I T ZH A K R A B I N
Document 23
ASSASSINATION OF YITZHAK RABIN (1995)
LAST SPEECH OF ISRAELI PRIME MINISTER RABIN
On November 4, 1995, Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin delivered a speech, reproduced below, at a peace rally held at Kings of Israel Square in Tel Aviv. The rally
had been called to serve as a reaffirmation of the commitment of the Israeli government and people to the ongoing Middle East peace process. Acts of violence committed
with increasing frequency in the mid-1990s by both Israelis and Palestinians provided
motivation for the rally. Shortly after completing his speech, Prime Minister Rabin
was assassinated by Yigal Amir, a fanatical right-wing religious settler, who hoped
that by killing Rabin he could derail the peace process.
The Last SpeechNovember 4, 1995
Allow me to say, I am also moved. I want to thank each and every one of you
who stood up here against violence and for peace. This government, which
I have the privilege to lead, together with my friend Shimon Peres, decided to
give peace a chance. A peace that will solve most of the problems of the State
of Israel. I was a military man for twenty-seven years. I fought as long as there
were no prospects for peace. Today I believe that there are prospects for peace,
great prospects. We must take advantage of it for the sake of those standing
here, and for the sake of those who do not stand here. And they are many
among our people.
I have always believed that the majority of the people want peace, are prepared to take risks for peace. And you here, by showing up at this rally, prove
it, along with the many who did not make it here, that the people truly want
A S SA S S I N AT I O N O F Y I T ZH A K R A B I N
813
The following list includes assassinations not covered in main entries of the
foregoing text, organized alphabetically by continents and their respective
countries, with the incidents listed chronologically.
Africa
Algeria
117 BCE:
February 3, 1987:
Botswana
May 21, 1985:
Burundi
October 13, 1961:
Cameroon
September 13, 1958:
Chad
August 26, 1973:
Comoros
May 29, 1978:
816
APPENDIX
Egypt
December 11, 1121:
October 7, 1130:
Guinea Bissau
March 1, 2009:
June 5, 2009:
June 5, 2009:
Kenya
July 5, 1969:
Libya
September 11, 2012:
Nigeria
January 15, 1966:
Rwanda
December 27, 1985:
Senegal
February 3, 1967:
Somalia
July 28, 2006:
APPENDIX
South Africa
January 22, 2009:
April 3, 2010:
Sudan
March 2, 1973:
March 2, 1973:
January 1, 2008:
February 9, 2011:
Swaziland
April 1, 2008:
Togo
July 29, 1992:
Uganda
September 22, 1972:
Western Sahara
June 18, 1970:
Zambia
March 18, 1975:
Zimbabwe
March 24, 1983:
Asia
Afghanistan
February 20, 1919:
September 9, 2001:
817
818
APPENDIX
July 6, 2002:
May 3, 2007:
Armenia
October 27, 1999:
Bangladesh
August 15, 1975:
November 3, 1975:
November 3, 1975:
Bhutan
April 6, 1964:
Burma/Myanmar
1167:
King Alaungsithu
King Tabinshwehti
July 9, 1628:
King Anaukpetlun
August 2, 1866:
Cambodia
January 14, 1950:
China
July 13, 815:
Chancellor Wu Yuanheng
Georgia
July 21, 1922:
December 3, 1994:
India
180 BCE:
APPENDIX
Indonesia
November 22, 1965:
Iran
October 10, 1092:
May 1, 1896:
September 3, 1933:
April 1937:
Iraq
February 11, 244:
November 1, 2004:
July 6, 2005:
Israel
February 135 BCE:
October 1174:
819
820
APPENDIX
Japan
592:
Emperor Sushun
August 1, 1507:
November 4, 1921:
Jordan
July 20, 1951:
King Abdullah I
Korea
304:
October 8, 1895:
Empress Myeongseong
Kuwait
March 30, 1971:
Laos
April 1, 1963:
Lebanon
1152:
Count Raymond II
APPENDIX
June 1, 1987:
Malaysia
November 2, 1875:
December 3, 1949:
October 6, 1951:
Pakistan
October 16, 1951:
February 8, 1975:
October 3, 1991:
March 2, 2011:
Philippines
October 11, 1719:
June 5, 1899:
February 6, 2001:
821
822
APPENDIX
Qatar
February 13, 2004:
Saudi Arabia
November 7, 644:
Sri Lanka
July 27, 1975:
March 2, 1991:
June 7, 2000:
Syria
246 BCE:
223 BCE:
175 BCE:
146 BCE:
138 BCE:
November 284:
July 7, 1940:
August 1, 2008:
Thailand
1548:
King Worawongsathirat
June 9, 1946:
Princess Laksamilawan
Turkey
June 11, 1913:
APPENDIX
Yemen
17 February 1948:
Australia
February 12, 1894:
New Caledonia
May 4, 1989:
Samoa
July 16, 1999:
Europe
Austria
October 21, 1916:
Belgium
August 18, 1950:
823
824
APPENDIX
Bulgaria
July 6, 1895:
October 2, 1996:
Croatia
June 22, 480:
Czech Republic
September 15, 921:
August 4, 1306:
Finland
January 20, 1156:
February 6, 1905:
France
January 8, 1354:
May 6, 1932:
July 7, 1944:
February 2, 1980:
APPENDIX
August 6, 1991:
February 6, 1998:
Germany
March 18/19, 235:
November 7, 1225:
Greece
514 BCE:
461 BCE:
404 BCE:
General Alcidiades
358 BCE:
251 BCE:
October 9, 1831:
March 8, 1907:
June 8, 2000:
Iceland
September 23, 1241:
Ireland
April 23, 1014:
May 6, 1882:
825
826
APPENDIX
579 BCE:
King Tarquin I
534 BCE:
133 BCE:
December 7, 43 BCE:
Cicero, philosopher/politician
Emperor Claudius
Emperor Galba
Emperor Vitellius
Emperor Domitian
Emperor Commodus
Emperor Pertinax
June 1, 193:
Emperor Geta
April 8, 217:
Emperor Caracalla
Emperor Elagabalus
April 238:
August 253:
September 275:
Emperor Aurelian
September 276:
Emperor Florianus
December 6, 1921:
March 2, 1925:
September 3, 1982:
Netherlands
June 5, 754:
Saint Boniface
Count Floris V
APPENDIX
May 6, 2002:
Ottoman Empire
October 11, 1579:
Poland
April 11, 1079:
February 1, 1944:
Portugal
138 BCE:
January 7, 1355:
February 1, 1908:
December 4, 1980:
Romania
November 27, 1940:
August 4, 1878:
April 8, 1902:
July 6, 1918:
December 1, 1934:
827
828
APPENDIX
May 9, 2004:
February 2, 2005:
June 5, 2009:
Serbia
July 24, 1817:
orde
Petrovic, ex-president
King Alexander I
Spain
March 8, 1921:
January 4, 1967:
Sweden
May 18, 1160:
King Eric IX
Switzerland
January 24, 1639:
February 4, 1936:
November 3, 1960:
Turkey
June 11, 1913:
APPENDIX
Ukraine
May 23, 1938:
Emperor Carausius
King Henry VI
May 3, 1679:
July 9, 1978:
December 3, 1987:
Yugoslavia
268:
Emperor Gallienus
282:
Emperor Probus
285:
Emperor Carinus
February 7, 2000:
829
830
APPENDIX
North America
Canada
April 7, 1868:
May 9, 1880:
Mexico
June 29, 1550:
Emperor Moctezuma II
March 7, 1913:
January 3, 1924:
February 7, 1986:
June 8, 2005:
May 8, 2008:
May 9, 2008:
May 7, 1955:
James Chaney, Andrew Goodman, and Michael Schwerner, civil rights activists
June 2, 1965:
APPENDIX
January 8, 2011:
Dominican Republic
February 16, 1973:
Haiti
October 14, 1993:
Puerto Rico
July 25, 1978:
El Salvador
February 1, 1932:
Guatemala
April 5, 1970:
831
832
APPENDIX
July 3, 1993:
Honduras
May 15, 1966:
Nicaragua
February 21, 1934:
Panama
January 2, 1955:
South America
Argentina
April 11, 1870:
June 2, 1976:
Bolivia
January 1, 1829:
Brazil
September 8, 1915:
APPENDIX
Chile
October 25, 1970:
June 8, 1971:
April 1, 1991:
Colombia
June 4, 1830:
April 9, 1948:
November 6, 1985:
July 5, 1989:
August 9, 1994:
833
834
APPENDIX
November 2, 1995:
May 5, 2003:
Ecuador
February 17, 1999:
Guyana
November 18, 1978:
Peru
July 26, 1872:
Uruguay
February 19, 1868:
Venezuela
November 18, 2004:
Selected Bibliography
836
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Hancock, Larry. Nexus: The CIA and Political Assassination. Southlake, TX: JFK Lancer
Productions, 2011.
Heaps, Willard. Assassination: A Special Kind of Murder. Des Moines, IA: Meredith Press,
1969.
Hernon, Ian. Assassin! 200 Years of British Political Murder. London: Pluto Press, 2007.
Hudson, Miles. Assassination. Barnsley, South Yorkshire: Pen and Sword, 2011.
Hurwood, Bernhardt. Society and the Assassin. New York: Macmillan, 1970.
Hyams, Edward. Killing No Murder: A Study of Assassination as a Political Means.
Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson & Sons, 1969.
Johnson, Francis. Famous Assassinations of History from Philip of Macedon 336 BC to
Alexander of Serbia AD 1903. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2009.
Kirkham, James, Sheldon Levy, and William Crotty. Assassination and Political Violence.
New York: Bantam, 1970.
Kulczyk, David. California Justice: Shootouts, Lynchings and Assassinations in the Golden
State. Sanger, CA: Quill Driver Books, 2007.
Laucella, Linda. Assassination: The Politics of Murder. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1999.
Lentz, Harris. Assassinations and Executions: An Encyclopedia of Political Violence, 18651986.
Jefferson, NC: McFarland, 1988.
McConnell, Brian. The History of Assassination. Torrance, CA: Aurora, 1970.
McGovern, Glenn. Targeted Violence: A Statistical and Tactical Analysis of Assassinations,
Contract Killings, and Kidnappings. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2010.
McKinley, James. Assassination in America. New York: HarperCollins, 1977.
Miller, Tom. The Assassination Please Almanac. Washington, DC: Regnery, 1977.
Oliver, Willard, and Nancy Marion. Killing the President: Assassinations, Attempts, and
Rumored Attempts on U.S. Commanders-in-Chief. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2010.
Porter, Lindsay. Assassination: A History of Political Murder. New York: Overlook Press,
2010.
Sanello, Frank. To Kill a King: A History of Royal Murders and Assassinations from Ancient
Egypt to the Present. Seattle: CreateSpace, 2011.
Scott, Peter, Paul Hoch, and Russell Stetler, eds. The Assassinations: Dallas and Beyond.
New York: Random House, 1976.
Sifakis, Carl. Encyclopedia of Assassinations. New York: Facts on File, 2001.
Spignesi, Stephen. In the Crosshairs: Famous Assassinations & Attempts from Julius Caesar
to John Lennon. Darby, PA: Diane Publishing, 2003.
Urwin, John. The Sixteen: The Sensational Story of Britains Top Secret Assassination Squad.
London: John Blake, 2004.
Index
838
INDEX
INDEX
Bagheri, Behrouz, 88
Bah faith, 8
Bahonar, Mohammad-Javad, 2728
Baibars, 444 445
BAK International, 395
Bakhtiar, Shapour, 89
Balbinus, 2830, 29 (portrait), 67
Balboa, Vasco Nez de, 428
Balewa, Abubakar Tafawa, 3, 3032, 31
(photo)
Balkan Wars (19121913), 10
Ballivin, Jos, 39
Balouch Khan, Hadj, 89
Balzerani, Barbara, 338
Bandaranaike, Solomon West Ridgeway
Dias, 3234, 33 (photo)
Bandi, Bernardo, 326
Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP),
453, 456
Bantu Authorities Act, 602
Bantu Building Workers Act, 602
Bao Dai, 362364
Baptist World Alliance, 567
Barazandeh, Hossein, 90
Barbie, Klaus, 229
Barrera, Ernesto, 485
Barrientos Ortuo, Ren, 188
Barrire, Pierrfe, 220
Bartlett, Asa, 278279
Bartol, Vladimir, 24
Bartolotta, Salvatore, 94
Bastien-Thiry, Jean-Marie, 174175
Batalln Vasco Espaol (Basque Spanish
Battalion) terrorist group, 40 41
Batista, Fulgencio, 578
Bautista Gill Garca del Barrio, Juan,
3435
Bautista Sacasa, Juan, 508510, 539
Bava-Beccaris massacre, 588
Bavaud, Maurice, 227
Bay of Pigs invasion (Cuba), 189, 261,
262, 366, 408
Bayahmadi, Ataollah, 88
BBC History magazine, 38
Bean, John William, 604
839
840
INDEX
INDEX
841
842
INDEX
INDEX
843
844
INDEX
INDEX
845
846
INDEX
Gbel, Wolfgang, 59
Godoi, Don Juan Silvano, 35
Godse, Nathuram Vinayak, 165, 167
Goebbels, Joseph, 216, 347, 618
Goebel, William Justus, 181182
Golden Voice of Africa. See Balewa,
Abubakar Tafawa
Golizadeh, Abbas, 90
Gllheim, Battle of, 7
Gonzlez, Pablo, 650
Gonzlez Dubn, Eduardo Epaminondas, 183184
Gonzlez Martin, Yolanda, 40 41
Good Friday Agreement (Ireland; 1988),
344
Gorbachev, Mikhail, 513, 656
Gore, Al, 63
Gring, Hermann, 223, 227228, 462
Gormley, Ken, 98
Gorriarn Merlo, Enrique, 535, 538
Gothic 3 (role-playing game), 25
Gotzamanis, Sypryo, 281
Goulart, Joo Belchior Marques,
184186
Gowon, Yakuba Jack Dan-Yumma,
233, 331332
Gqokli Hill, Battle of, 523
Graciano, Fabian, 20
Grahovac, Battle of, 103
GRAPO (First of October Anti-Fascist
Resistance Groups) (Spain), 41
Gratians, 67
Graves, Robert, 69
The Great Star of the East. See Amin,
Hafizullah
Greco, Giuseppe Pino, 9596
Greco-Turkish War (1897), 179, 529
Greek Civil War (19461949), 281
Greek War of Independence, 417
The Green Book (Gaddafi), 162
Grey Wolves organization, 242
Griffin, Michael Frederick, 193195
Group Areas Act, 602
Grynszpan, Herschel Feibel, 616618
Guajardo, Jess Maria, 649
INDEX
847
848
INDEX
INDEX
849
850
INDEX
INDEX
851
852
INDEX
INDEX
853
854
INDEX
INDEX
855
856
INDEX
INDEX
857
858
INDEX
INDEX
859
860
INDEX
INDEX
861
862
INDEX
INDEX
863
864
INDEX
Michael Newton is a full-time freelance writer with 266 books published since
1977 and 15 more scheduled for release from various houses through 2014.
Newtons 74 nonfiction books include 27 reference books, among them the
best-selling Encyclopedia of Serial Killers (2nd edition, 2005). In 2002, Newtons
history of the Florida Ku Klux Klan, The Invisible Empire, received the Florida
Historical Societys Rembert Patrick Award as Best Book in Florida History.
Four years later, the American Library Association ranked his Encyclopedia of
Cryptozoology (hidden or undiscovered animals) among its 12 Outstanding
Reference Books in 2006. Newton has also published 186 novels under his
own name and various pseudonyms. In 2010, one of his WesternsManhunt,
written as Lyle Brandtreceived the Western Fictioneers Peacemaker Award
as Best Western Novel of the year. For a full list of Newtons work see his Web
site at http://www.michaelnewton.homestead.com.