Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
5 Report
2/24/2011
$13.99
LCCATRIANG(12,13.96,16)
$22.11
LCCATRIANG(20,22.34,24)
$26.96
LCCATRIANG(25,26.89,29)
2. Analysis Options
Include User Costs in Analysis
Include User Cost Remaining Life Value
Use Differential User Costs
User Cost Computation Method
Include Agency Cost Remaining Life Value
Traffic Direction
Analysis Period (Years)
Beginning of Analysis Period
Discount Rate (%)
Yes
Yes
Yes
Calculated
Yes
Both
50
2015
4.0
LCCATRIANG(3,4,5)
Number of Alternatives
3. Project Details
State Route
Project Name
Region
County
Analyzed By
Mileposts
Begin
End
Length of Project (miles)
Comments
57.00
58.00
1.00
This project will create an
improved multi-lane highway
4. Traffic Data
AADT Construction Year (total for both directions)
Cars as Percentage of AADT (%)
Single Unit Trucks as Percentage of AADT (%)
Combination Trucks as Percentage of AADT (%)
Annual Growth Rate of Traffic (%)
Speed Limit Under Normal Operating Conditions (mph)
No of Lanes in Each Direction During Normal Conditions
Free Flow Capacity (vphpl)
Rural or Urban Hourly Traffic Distribution
Queue Dissipation Capacity (vphpl)
Maximum AADT (total for both directions)
Maximum Queue Length (miles)
Page 1
35,700
72.9
6.9
20.2
2.1
65
3
1470
Rural
1323
LCCANORMAL(1323,132)
113,600
20.0
2/24/2011
Alternative 1
Number of Activities
Activity 1
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
50.0
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 2
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
6
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
End
8
Page 2
17
17
2/24/2011
Grind and inlay - Lanes only 2.5"
$762.00
LCCANORMAL(762,76.2)
Activity 3
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
17
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 4
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
17
End
8
Page 3
17
17
2/24/2011
Overlay -100% surface 2.5"
$925.00
LCCANORMAL(925,92.5)
Activity 5
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
6
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
17
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 6
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
17
End
8
Page 4
17
17
2/24/2011
Grind and inlay - Lanes only 2.5"
$762.00
LCCANORMAL(762,76.2)
Activity 7
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
End
8
Page 5
17
17
2/24/2011
Alternative 2
Number of Activities
Activity 1
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
50.0
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 2
18
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
End
8
Page 6
17
17
2/24/2011
3/8" Diamong grinding 100%
lanes; grind and inliay shoulders,
8% panel repair
$1,936.00
LCCANORMAL(1936,194)
Activity 3
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
23
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
8
Start
End
8
Page 7
17
17
2/24/2011
Alternative 3
Number of Activities
Activity 1
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
50.0
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 2
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
6
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
End
20
0
Page 8
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
Grind and inlay - Lanes only 2.5"
$762.00
LCCANORMAL(762,76.2)
Activity 3
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
24
6
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 4
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
0
0
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
24
6
End
0
0
Page 9
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
Overlay -100% surface 2.5"
$925.00
LCCANORMAL(925,92.5)
Activity 5
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
6
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
24
6
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 6
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
20
0
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
24
6
End
0
0
Page 10
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
Grind and inlay - Lanes only 2.5"
$762.00
LCCANORMAL(762,76.2)
Activity 7
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
7
2
8.0
LCCATRIANG(6,8,10)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
End
0
0
Page 11
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
Alternative 4
Number of Activities
Activity 1
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
50.0
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Start
End
Activity 2
18
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
End
20
0
Page 12
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
3/8" Diamong grinding 100%
lanes; grind and inliay shoulders,
8% panel repair
$1,936.00
LCCANORMAL(1936,194)
Activity 3
Agency Construction Cost ($1000)
User Work Zone Costs ($1000)
Work Zone Duration (days)
No of Lanes Open in Each Direction During Work Zone
Activity Service Life (years)
Activity Structural Life (years)
Maintenance Frequency (years)
Agency Maintenance Cost ($1000)
Work Zone Length (miles)
Work Zone Speed Limit (mph)
Work Zone Capacity (vphpl)
Traffic Hourly Distribution
Time of Day of Lane Closures (use whole numbers based on a 24hour clock)
Inbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
Outbound
First period of lane closure
Second period of lane closure
Third period of lane closure
23
2
25.0
LCCATRIANG(20,25,30)
1.00
45
1191
Week Day 1
Start
End
20
0
Start
End
20
0
Page 13
24
6
24
6
2/24/2011
Deterministic Results
Total Cost
Undiscounted Sum
Present Value
EUAC
Alternative 1: HMA
Pavement (Day
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$8,626.5 $3,866.6
0
1
$6,137.9
$881.49
5
$285.72
$41.03
Alternative 2: PCC
Pavement (Day
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$7,362.0
$438.27
0
$6,274.0
$164.40
8
$292.06
$7.65
Agency Cost
Alternative 4: PCC
Pacement (Night
work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$7,362.0
$85.89
0
$6,274.0
$32.22
8
$292.06
$1.50
User Cost
1,000.00
900.00
800.00
700.00
600.00
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00
100.00
0.00
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
Alternative 3: HMA
Pavement (Night
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$8,626.5 $4,030.6
0
6
$6,137.9
$885.53
5
$285.72
$41.22
Page 14
2/24/2011
Probabilistic Results
Alternative 1: HMA
Pavement (Day
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$6,140.7
$911.24
7
$470.17 $208.18
$4,633.4
$471.79
2
$7,665.0 $2,340.9
4
9
Mean
Standard Deviation
Minimum
Maximum
Alternative 2: PCC
Pavement (Day
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$6,296.5
$382.90
3
$574.70 $283.30
$4,051.3
$123.46
3
$8,520.6 $1,447.9
5
7
Agency Cost
Probability Scale
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
Probability Scale
User Cost
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Page 15
Alternative 3: HMA
Pavement (Night
Work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$6,145.1
$888.77
2
$466.47 $188.16
$4,563.3
$421.94
5
$7,531.4 $1,652.3
1
7
Alternative 4: PCC
Pacement (Night
work)
Agency
User
Cost
Cost
($1000)
($1000)
$6,289.2
$34.27
9
$575.89
$5.88
$4,363.7
$20.88
5
$8,257.3
$61.48
2
Probability Scale
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
User Cost
Probability Scale
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
Page 16
2/24/2011
0.90
Discount Rate
-0.27
0.18
-0.13
-0.11
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
-0.43
-0.34
-0.16
0.16
-0.14
-0.11
-0.11
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
Page 17
2/24/2011
0.97
-0.16
Discount Rate
-0.12
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
-1.0
-0.41
-0.26
-0.5
0.0
Correlation Coefficient
Page 18
2/24/2011
0.90
Discount Rate
-0.29
0.15
-0.13
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
-1.0
-0.5
0.18
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
Page 19
2/24/2011
0.97
-0.16
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
-0.58
-0.42
-1.0
0.11
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Correlation Coefficient
Page 20
2/24/2011