Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
a Diverse Workforce
willing to buy the product/service. Although this ties back into the
benefits yielded by the firm, it is actually the money saved by each
individual customer that makes the biggest difference. If the savings
obtained by the customers are noticeable, this may in turn, allow
customers to either have more money to spend on other consumables
or have more money to spend on that particular product or service.
This would result in significantly more consumption per dollar than
there would have been without illegal laborers. If customers are happy,
and continue to buy more and more of a product or service, then that
will once again have an impact all the way up the ladder of the firm
resulting in a very noticeable increase in shareholders equity which is
the very goal of each and every manager in a publically traded
company.
On the other side, though, there are certainly a number of groups
who may be negatively influenced by the utilization of illegal labor.
Franchesca made the point that those who are hurt the worst from
using illegal labor are the other legal and authorized employees within
the company. The use of illegal laborers may ultimately affect other
employees pay, benefits, and even hours which can be detrimental to
any employee, especially those who have to take care of a family.
Since these lower wages and benefits earned by illegal workers
indirectly decreases all compensation given to regular employees, a
firm is not only putting their employees best interests at risk, but they
are also entering into a very sticky situation which has to do with
taxes. Although our group had some differing opinions on some of the
advantages and disadvantages behind the use of illegal laborers, the
one aspect that every member agreed upon was that illegal workers
have an incredibly large and negative impact on taxation. Specifically,
when the taxation is used by those governmental entities that are
funded by state and federal taxation. As Penny pointed out,
were brought up here in New Mexico, though from different parts of the
state, collectively we have had a lot of experience with or around the
use of illegal labor, which is why it is believed we are so close in our
assertions. As Penny pointed out, growing up in Northern New Mexico,
it is not difficult to see a significant number of illegal laborers working
in hotels, restaurants, or out on the farms. She also had a very
interesting take on why these are the most common industries as she
made the comment, that in her opinion, a lot of these jobs are held by
immigrants because of their fears of being noticed and being deported.
This is because a lot of illegal immigrants tend to be housekeepers,
cooks, cleaners, and laborers, which makes it logical to see why these
may be chosen professions for illegal works since there is little
interaction with the general public and the ability to be paid under the
table without raising many flags is present. Penny also pointed out
that if some of these illegal laborers held more prominent or noticeable
jobs they would be at a much higher risk for deportation as it would
effectively place them in the radar of the Immigration Border Patrol,
which I also firmly agree with. Especially in a state that so heavily
relies upon the immigrant labor in general, illegal immigrants must be
much more careful to stay under the radar, and many of these
industries are a safe and effective way of doing so which results in a
two way dependency so to speak.
Another industry that we believe heavily relies upon illegal labor
is construction, and as I have had lots of personal experience in this
area, I can say that the majority of laborers in the construction industry
here in New Mexico are immigrants of which I can only imagine what
percentage of those immigrants are working illegally. For construction
companies, usually the hardest part about hiring employees, is finding
people who will be consistent and last longer than a few months as
construction work is usually long, grueling, and tedious which forces
many people to withdraw from the industry. So, when illegal laborers
come along and are willing to work regardless of the task and often for
lower wages than a legal immigrant or American-born citizen, it is very
difficult not to hire them. As John pointed out, fast food, construction,
auto repair shops, farming, machine and welding shops, among others,
all tend to be high turnover and low paying jobs that the majority of
the population is unwilling to do. Furthermore, many of these jobs
have low profit margins and are seldom inspected by immigration
services. This, in combination with being paid under the table and the
absence of taxes, effectively renders these industries perfect for illegal
laborers.
The final industry that we would like to touch on is the
agriculture industry, and specifically, during the spring and summer
months when both production and tourism picks up, which fuels the
need for more laborers out in the fields. These situations are also ideal
for illegal laborers as they are often seasonal jobs which lowers their
risk of being detected by immigration and often provides them with
wages that are paid under the table which benefits both the
company and the unauthorized workers in terms of taxation. Michelle
ended up making one of the best comments on this particular topic
when she stated that most illegal workers are hired to perform jobs
that Americans simply wont do. Which, for the most part, Americans
shun nearly any and all unskilled labor positions that require hard
and dirty work. This opens the door for illegal laborers to come in and
benefit from this common perception. She then went on to point out
that because of this New Mexicos workforce, economy, and society, in
general, are quite dependent on illegal immigrants and indicates that
they play a much bigger role in society than what first meets the eye.
Making the comment that Americans benefit from the contributions
that immigrants make to our economy, including lower consumer