Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
5: 239-251 (1996)
The Role of
Psychological
Instruments in the
Assessment of
Child Sexual Abuse
Gloria Babiker
Martin Herbert
University of Exeter
The evaluation of
sexual abuse may
have dzgerent
aims and serve
dzgerent purposes
240
Many authors
have called f o r
specialized,
well-standardized
instruments
Assessment Interviews
It may be
necessary to
undergo a series of
evaluative
sessions
24 1
B ehaviour Scales
It was possible until only a few years ago to read that a
decision had been made as to whether a child had or had not
been abused based on whether the child did or did not
present with certain core symptoms, for example behavioural regression, somatic complaints, fearfulness, bedwetting, and so on (Conte, 1991). However, it is patently an
erroneous idea that such disturbed behaviour necessarily
proves sexual abuse. It is recognized (Herbert, 1993) that
these problems are indicators of stress in childhood which
parallel those of children experiencing other traumas.
Stressors might be any of a number of events, including,
but not exclusively, sexual abuse.
One of the effects of sexual abuse can be some form of
inappropriate sexual behaviour on the part of the child. But
as with other behavioural disturbance, not all abused
children exhibit sexualized behaviour while some nonabused children do. One avenue for research in this area
would be the development of a standardized measure, based
on developmental psychological theories of childrens knowledge about sex, to assess the appropriateness of childrens
sex knowledge.
The Louisville Behaviour Checklist (LBC) (Miller, 1981)
appears to be one of the well-established behaviour rating
measures frequently used in sexual abuse research (Tufts,
New England Medical Centre, 1984; Gomes-Schwanz,
Horowiz and Sauzier, 1985; Gomes-Schwartz, Horowitz
and Cardarelli, 1990). This measure consists of a true-false
questionnaire that addresses childhood behaviour problems
and is completed by the parents.
Conte, Berliner and Schuerman (Conte and Berliner,
1988) developed two measures to assess the effects of sexual
abuse in a large sample of 369 sexually abused children
assessed at or near the point of disclosure. One of these
Stressors might
be any of a number
of events,
including, but not
exclusively, sexual
abuse
242
Parents and
professionals are
likely to view
events and
behaviour
dzperent ly
Questionnaire Assessment
Many of the
questions on both
tests had to be
thought through,
explained or
discussed
Some researchers have attempted to establish the intermediate (several years subsequent to abuse) negative effect of
sexual abuse on self-esteem, and the Piers-Harris has been a
popular test for this purpose in the United States (Elmer,
1977; Oates, Forrest and Peacock, 1985).
Whether or not the Piers-Harris would be useful in this
country to assess the long-lasting impact of sexual abuse on
self-esteem remains to be seen. Some preliminary work with
this test by one of the authors (GB) of this study suggests
that three out of the 80 test questions would almost certainly
need to be anglicized in order to make it applicable to
English schoolchildren. The Culture-Free Self-Esteem
Inventory (SEI) (Battle, 198l), on the other hand, appeared
to live up to its name in that within the same group of
children, in a parallel study to the work presented here,
Babiker (1991) found that it did not seem to pose problems
with comprehension.
Babiker (1991) found when both of these questionnaires
were administered to a sample of children (abused and not
abused) on care orders with Avon Social Services, many of
the questions on both tests had to be thought through,
explained or discussed, as they referred, for example, to
parents and it was not clear to many children which parents
(natural, old foster parent, new foster parent) were intended.
Similarly, questions about school could not be assumed to be
243
Standardized
administration
could pose some
dificu1ties
Cognitive Tests
Until very recently, reports of standardized empirical
investigation into the cognitive signs of sexual abuse have
been extremely scarce. However, there have been reports of
cognitive testing of physically abused and neglected children. Many well-validated psychometric tests exist for this
purpose. For a detailed review of the effects of maltreatment
on cognitive development, the reader is referred to the
chapter by J. L. Aber et al. (1989) in Cicchetti and Carlsons
book on child maltreatment. Examination of intellectual
factors in child abuse detecrion is lacking in consensus as to
conclusions. The area of development most likely to be
affected was language, as these could be sea, as families
whose members find it hard to communicate their feelings in
words, using actions to express themselves instead (Lynch,
1988). This raises the question of whether a similar dynamic
could underlie sexual abuse and whether it would also be
expressed in difficulties with language.
The closest sexual abuse research has come to the area of
cognitive assessment is in evaluating scholastic achievement.
Behavioural and academic problems at school are commonly
reported symptoms for sexually abused school-aged children
(Adams-Tucker, 1981; Tong, Oates and McDowell, 1987).
Few, if any, studies, however, have been carried out which
were solely concerned with the measurement of the cognitive
effects of sexual abuse in children.
Nevertheless, an assessment of a childs functioning that
indicates an abnormal pattern of psychometric results is, of
necessity, a matter of clinical concern (and action), whether
or not it is linked to physical or sexual abuse.
Examination of
intellectual factors
in child abuse
detection is
lacking in
consensus
An assessment of
a childs
functioning that
indicates an
abnormal pattern
of psychometric
results is a matter
of clinical concern
244
Projective Tests
A variety of
techniques are
used to ascertain
how a child feels
and what they have
experienced
245
The presence of
genitalia in the
drawing m a y
suggest the
possibility of
sexual abuse, it
does not prove it
246
Projective tests
are of potential
value aythey are
used judiciously as
a means to help
children to
communicate
personal
information
Multi-Dimensional Assessment
Very few studies appear to have provided a multi-dimensional psychological assessment of the effects of sexual abuse.
Einbender and Friedrich (1989) examined the relation of
abuse to several broad categories of childhood functioning,
including cognitive abilities and school achievement, emotional functioning and overt behaviour problems. They
hypothesized that a higher number of behaviour problems
and a lower quality of psychosocial functioning would be
evident in young sexually abused girls when compared with
a matched non-abused control group. This was a welldesigned study in which the 3-hour assessment included:
two subtests from the Wechsler Intelligence scale for
Children-Revised (WISC-R) to assess the childs intellectual abilities; the Rorschach Test to provide information
about aspects of the childs emotional adjustment; the Wide
Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R) to provide
achievement scores for arithmetic, reading and spelling;
five cards from the Roberts Apperception Test for Children
to calculate pathological indicators for each child. In
addition, two self-report questionnaires were administered:
the Childrens Depression Inventory and the Piers-Harris
Childrens Self-concept Scale. Parents or guardians completed a checklist about each child.
Sexually abused children demonstrated: (1) a heightened
sexual awareness and sexual preoccupations (as measured by
the projective testing) and (2) lower cognitive abilities and
school achievement as measured by the WISC-R IQ and
scoring on the WRAT-R. In addition, the standardized
interviewing of the adults concerned revealed that (3) the
sexually abused children had more stressful life events in
their past histories.
The finding that the sexually abused girls in this study
were more sexualized and had more sexual preoccupations
is consistent with other studies reporting this difference
between sexually abused subjects and controls. Some
authors (Conte, 1991) would even claim that this is the most
247
Projective tests
are perhaps best
used along with
other measures as
part of a multidimensional
assessment
Sexually abused
girls in this study
were more
sexualized and had
more sexual
preoccupations
248
The sexually
abused children
had several out-ofhome placements
while the
comparison
group had none
I
None of the
three tests
discriminated
adequately
between sexually
abused subjects
and other groups
References
Aber, J.L., Allen, J.P., Carlson, V. and Cicchetti, D. (1989). The
effects of maltreatment on development during early childhood:
recent studies and their theoretical, clinical, and policy implications. In D. Cicchetti and V. Carlson (Eds), Child Maltreatment:
Theory and Research on the Causes and Consequences of Child
Abuse and Neglect. Cambridge: University Press.
Adams-Tucker, C. (1981). A socioclinical overview of 28 sex-abused
children. Child Abuse & Neglect, 5 , 361-367.
Asher, S.J. (1988). The effects of childhood sexual abuse: a review
of the issues and evidence. In L.E.A. Walker (Ed.), Handbook on
Sexual Abuse of Children: Assessment and Treatment Issues.
New York: Springer.
Babiker, G. (1991). Emotional adjustment and sexual abuse among
children in care. Paper presented to Dartington Social Research
Unit.
Babiker, G. (1992). Psychological measurement and the identification of sexual abuse in children and adolescents. PhD Thesis,
University of Bristol.
249
None of these
appeared
suficiently
powerful to
suggest that any
single measure
could be used in
isolation to detect
sexual abuse
Clinicians are
encouraged to
combine the use of
standardized
measures with the
traditional
interview
250
25 1