THE DIALOGUES OF PLATO —__vouume n THE SYMPOSIUM TRANSLATED WITH COMMENT BY R. E, ALLEN eee! Ye og Spare“a courenrs we cones Wisk and Wha le Priarly Vaaste Of Haman Bondage Abrahars Linea ad the Fig The Works of rs Bezeig x Beaty (206-3078) Inmate rat Nowe (apes Graton it Reto Bayon Sel (eB se9e) The Laer of ose (ogee The Ase a Baye (ote) “Te aes of Betty ‘Benuty abd Goodness Cnseplason Virtue so Contemplation Rewlesson “The Deen of Eros Eo and Payee toe and Agape Swot Poa arabe) ‘Arstophanes Redvivor Ince eS of Aides (26-2050) The Sch of alin (nese 290) Socata (san02538) Contin aap) ‘TRANSLATION INDEX, ” ERA The Spe the most widely read of Pao dialogues withthe sage {xceptin ofthe Rui, nd his for good reaton scr) ers ‘wosurpated and Beneath she hing splendor oft wrfae scone Scie with the pression and someting of the iuiy as Sins ‘watch I philosophical, pscholope, and relgiosfoee@ veveutog, 8p ering avon of what means to nea man ie ase eo transcendent principle of Beaty whic, hoteles the eae si etigity and the ulate ss fa kvng. ‘The Nace oe Astguer tthe Germans cll afer snd fencer Nea 3 broil the breadth of humane leur inthe Wen in the tater 06 ulster snes pring, bas mighy Ther Aros theory of ‘template Mcmahon Et, ae wel obs thology fn a, ‘pte RIL, where Go ise pany eer of both iit dete, se moves by beng lve, sindedted to Dina Sos Psonic avrandom: hire Eto cn ref ns Bach Sennen thn ep aye en he ge ye the sup they fa hing ony toe 26 io of wither Sr ets doe teas. Where thea lows th they do waster they ‘sppex td, god o the oppose ke Fr thi i ret + edhe gow who Younger by fa tan he othe tnd Bat Shave of lah lesen err Bute Eres of che Hone Apri fr doesnot parake of fens bo onto ale th io fer bye eee s fer and without sare of eurage or ann Tae hy those igre y tas Ero crt eal, dling nant isby nature szooger and pred of are iligrir, Ove Igepal ey ewe eo 4th inc fo they one Saye excep we ey Leia {ge eligence, he hen hy are on be ese of ag {ear These io bei ove then sts pol Ti ar sci ey cee Gah ned ye asd gered a pose ef Cage ERS hee meer eer oe Soe Seen eeansecee ‘tape ene reo Zw rae, oe te rsepee be wih dem Woop Be woe of BE and ps IEG coamen, sath tn deceiing then by eehing them inthe tougiconeofyouth and then emo ‘Siovoaing homie renege vreone ee, Tne ough ‘Dial Sein ving soe 90 tha pre llr not wat Shes th came b Snr fr wats by wb wen be Een indestdhor earch pet ae Sin" sak of hoy an sn” Now good men ey dwn as inv Jor haces wnt bat gar Ivers cog so Se ‘Sropeld todo he mam, ot ste compe them 2 we ‘Steak lne to iehorawomet Forts thy foc ot poses vee, dhe dscopton w sone goods for it ‘Shun thought athe tae made lee exactly what be Ghat he oul eagely do everything Tor everyone for the sake of vrwe {nd his own improneree sa thi turn ol tng st Upenuiful So tsi every vay beta w pronde gracias forthe sae of vitae, This isthe Ero oft Hemeny Godles, sd hemnenly bins, and of great worth ath w cy aad recive, eampelng the lover to be auch concerned or «Bion ee oe ne Love a th her Yedong wo the other gods, the waar one. “The nhatT hve woof you jason the pot, Phases, he sss shout Ero First Interlude: Aristophanes and His Hiccups (85e-€) Pausanist pased—fo the ween ech me to speak in gual ‘meats ike dan Arion ald that Arctophass oea6 supposed to peak, bt be ame dwn with Bieups fom being ‘lle emeding oe and wasn ale wo speak He raid Erp thacum the doen, warping gh below hin—"Brvximacins, outa. he sop ty heap or peak forme unl Fe sap (ea on my own "Rid ryuimacboe 8, "Why 1 do beth ake your tora speaking ta you ke mine when you sop. Bute i peak fig. if youl hod your bead along Une de becops wel sop ioe gree it water Bat if hey se pevbap very Seog. ge enneing tn tekle your ane, and mec: you do dhs one er ‘poke eva if they've very song, tl op "On with your sped” said Arspanes. “do ic ‘The Speech of Eryximachus (285¢-188e) So Eryrimach sad, Well since Pausanias began his speech ‘beauty bt ida end aston seme sup to me {Oery ca bing the argon to + codlasion. He di wel tink, to divide Eros a But Eres exis inthe sul often no only tard Seal poople ut also ovard any other things aod Inver thing-—to the boda ofall animal in wehat grows (Ge eat tin genera mal ht ik I ave Seen for fpediie, cur ars” how grea and wonderful sth god, bow Br cuneeer everything both haan and divine Uva wart then fom mediane iy speedy so that we May sip venerce dean “ort mature of toes has hit eof rors che heal and sickoess ofthe Body are aditely diferent and unthe, an Sra unlike desires and ner elke tings So the Eros inthe Testy tog one thing, tat inthe dene body smother AS ‘usar atmo oui 8 beau eo gray wha i good for ‘he bt eameful to grt he ntmperte; sao among bods {Bs themeles it ew to gry wha good aod eat ‘br each body, ad emus be Sone, and ts has the ame of ‘medicine, bots shame ro ray what bd and eased, {nd ent ot be gies oe ised to bea real pracsone. "For adie, 0 speak smart Kaowledge of te things raanauation sep tine othe body cae w ling and empryng>™ Sie nh ngs brastand sae Bet ae 4 ings te gene psn, he ef change at Se boy poses oe Ee stead ofthe tere who Kaos hae ‘© nl Eon where His not presen but agit to be, and to emore ewe psc sn ought fot bese ood Dractiioner for i neonary to be slew make the moe ie [cal cnet in he body ney and tive each oer, Ba the ‘ot nical are the mont opposite: cold to hot biter ose, «de net a tach sa by haowng et al on ‘au ania that our progenitor Asda ase poet here Sept and | mpc bale abled ear ae Se allmedine angered by tis god. mare gym stm sani and avntare, sa cv saponin py he Sigs reno tn mse i hn espero ames He ‘cts abo perbape seat to any tbegh sata words Jot : but k well He say hat the One, “cing at vanence wh el, Edrarmtogaer wth ful, Ihe the attunement of bo nd : yee" Bat in wey sured sy ht nce a ce or drives ony hinge a vrance™ Perhaps he meat (ony lead that kat Come tobe om tings rey at artes namely the high andthe io, wen they aterward are Trough i agesment ty thes of ne Sey steement + ould no derive from contig discord of high we low For Sanement i coecord, sna concord a Hind of agieetent—ie se sofa er ang cs tee 3 cet ar Sea eet me eri ee eta ngs te carat ee Tog Cosel hat popes Se are oes ieee aaa ae Seat SAT acta ag eae een Sie ccatieatCa Soe chen carom He cet eters Soren BLS Tecate ricerca ee rae eens re ube act pein lt ad rc Sc ae pe : pr pacer at a ey aews impose fr agreement to dre from ings a sins 0 Inns Oey ave arce ote ter Rane pone tosses aan snd dosnt age pate in too dates fon te quer as one a ore bee Shitthns tur ater come tape Man here ie ed SSEIESS pou sermons nt al tho ngs sonny Eros Su ueucly ihe oer. And me tune Rooedge he hinge ove coceagaonemen ad shyt ee See ape he tng of ve me sory oan oF ‘ncn St sie, or the wold re there yee Dut when ne sod ppp ons tian oe cider coopoung, wii aed mare eoaponton, or ‘Seve of noses and ter oe wicks ‘Shesedaclngandctre—tee heres dees cay nd test bra good or be me aunt recone ot grater mend nv yoni ch ay Tetymnybecohe cic crdey tnd ah ot fore Er, Sede ena Neen Eros of te Homenty Dut at fr the Vlgr Eros tthe many Muse Po ‘yn on wu py wi caon ve whom oe psi nerds oben leure bt pot no nemper Se pena ancien mpm we ore tseuf desing the orf cookery that a peau rel iden dior In sand acon a al tet thing, henen ad in, one mont 0 fran practi, etch ‘utr ech Ling of Eos or ba are pee “nde even th consaio ofthe sen of the perl wit hes Toy ad whenever he ings Ia ut bom e- Ting tse a es ry tn ores Eros eae bea ae ond rece ice an anc eer Sprit cones ening promerty and batho men ado che {Ri is dl py sed Sis wo pins bt he the fon scoped yovrag nd wanna ery of Qo SSI oe pe ra of amin ah eee aes aes 1 ee aca rier ce a ae ea SuPCIRER PRRY Sra Daas, ee erence oo ie oe pnanadiase seansuarion ay ‘he seasons ofthe yea esos may hing and does nse. or plagues Uke tate fom such thing these and my ote ubustl dieates both in bess ane plans a fc. fot {od hai and gh aie rom mural overexcing aod Sender tinorg thing of ove suchas these, nowldge wich ‘oncerns es of sas and sesso of Jars tld stot ‘ay, Sl farther l succes andthe obese he were thats he muta interne of gs ad ex—bave dock thing ther fan pre an care of Eee. Fo al Kind ot mpi conering pares bts ing nt end acon the gos ike saree i one does met poy the early Ee shoot and revere hin i every ae but ised gates {he eter Eros The ser art haa here heen ondaaed 0 terse these hinds of ror and heal them a the ers ar Spann severan of uoatipBetwoes gots ed er by towing which ting alone non ent sma pry nd “San ete by ie ster a ‘seaman, very gre power oF power bt hc Ero RRC foo ng companied By EExperance and unis bth arong ss and nog gods, tat ashe green power apd prone happiness ene {Ble st sce with ich oor and eens, ee Mh the gos, wo ae songer an we re "Wel, erbas Tooele out may hing in prasng Eros, but at st nt will i id lee someting on yout 4b, Ainopane, nfl in Or i 90n lead ofr some ‘tor hind of encom Co Ue od please do 0, bea our ‘cups have stopped Second Interlude: Aristophanes Recovered from ‘His Hiccups (2892-<) Wal, Aristodeans site Arsopbenes wok over and ai, ‘er, the hiccup did indeed sop though se before {apie the sneeze 301 wonder if he more order) lent of the body [Soest desire the sort of moe and les sauce i Beat {Eoppod righ sway when Lappe the sonnet ‘nl Eyam mi, My dear Arioophanes, ook what youre ing You mabe oes jt wen yore ging spe, tn 90 ‘opal ane to become 2 guaran of yout on pee ee Ghatyou do's something rious when you could have spoken me ae pa ep pt faa ener eae gna pace eiaroeaay Frcharbeet eee ta rr ea wnat orn yout cepe? oy steton nnd pena fal be ead to SES Ricciardi ao “The Speech of Aristophanes (1Bge~193e) Why vel, Erysimachas, sd Arsoanes,Titen 10 sy somthing dierent fom wht yo nd Penis sak. For Think people do ot fully pense te pover of Bros since if they dik yi hal hin hs rene temps ae tues ene oie rae ete ers wy Seng ‘he Hind; ugh i wery much needs doing. Fore she most philanthropic of gods, elper of huzan beings anda phys [Be thowe Hs whee cave would be grenes:tappinest forthe human rue Soil ry © deseabeto you Bs power 2nd you seach others "You must ft fears human natare ands endiion. For our acon nature nos that kis bom, br of ane hd- the Fe place, there were three sees ang min, no wo a 20 fraleand female, bas tid ec in adi, being bots a te [EXmunon, whose nme ll remains hough the hing self has ‘ached, for ooe see wo then dered ia common from bah {le ad fone androgynour beth fers aod Rane though {he pane snow applied onlin reposch the fora ofeach haan beng 2 woe was round, iback and sides forming + ce Dt eho four srt and regal suber of loge, ad evo fen excl ae on 3 pine {tid necks there na gle head for bo faces, wich ed {oppose drecio, and four ete apd to sen of pun, thd Ube conan a therefrom ta. I aso aveled upright [juts now in never direction shel aed whenever ty Took of n'a pit rn hey Droog hela around right {nd sonessnued at table do an then, wh ht mbt 0 ‘apport ten, hey roe nit de 1 _“Thereaonthere were thee sexes ofthis tore wasthat he male cgay waste oping ofthe San, the female of the Ear, and what hava hae of bth ofthe Moon, basse the Moca seo ‘as shar of oth, They wee spel oth in shemales sin {hei gat because they were Be tee parents Wel they were ‘erble fa seeagh and force aod hey had high thoughts sad ‘onspired again the gd an wha Homer tldof Eps sod ‘Ora dali ofthe thy tid to orm Heaven inorder to dipace de gos "Wel Zeus the ete? god took count! about wht hey ugh o dy and were a or fo they cite bw they col UE them, they sid de Glan, howe race they wiped ott ith thethondetelt—decause the honor aad esrbret they reveved {pom human beings would dappear—nor pet could they allow ‘hems to eto congo After hnking saute ey ed o- ‘eed, Zoos say“ ble Ive got a device by wc en may ‘ominue wo ex and yt stp dar intemperance, macy y be 4 Galag weaker 1 sow en each of hein tw he syd theyllbe weaker and he sate tine not seal ous by Hang ‘ncteased in ouber, ad ey wal upg on to lege. But {hay sil sem to act so earageouly ae sre umeing to Keep ‘qe he ld Tl eat der two ai, so a hey hae [gested on oe leg, bopping Singh ot Hom nom wy pole se « seresherata™ to preerve them by drying or Uy 60 98 sch bir be ordored Apollo rn aro the face and te alfred of whoever bed tt where he cat way made 0 that ‘he man would be nore orderly by contepaing his own ison, ‘de Ud Apollo held oer wounds Apollo nned the face ‘round ad dre ogether om lies sino wh ow {te she bey spares are closed by a dranating, ag ‘fin he mid of the ely, be ada single mots which pos fou plea heave And hesmootna oxtmot ofthe other eres Sod earful shaped the chen wth aol he ort shoratker {Seto smooth ont wines nthe ear 0 abst but he ee = ‘en wrinkles asd the el athe ave, ae reminder of the suturing Now when ter ature a ried i eh 1 etn center nh vad. Sea oun ele ase aaaIn longing rushed othe other Bal f sl and they tare thar arn aos ea cer ane itertined the desing {row gether intone, dying of niger nd inact too case ES ete uawiling to Go anything apart fm one another. ‘Whescer any of the aes ied andthe eter wan let Uae oe lefesughs ev another nd embraced i weer oe bal of @ ‘toe woman what we now el awesan-—ar oC an. ABS So YE Tek py and povided anther device, rng ir puna so te ofr sp chen ey had hose on te out [Ges hyde sd ben clench es sin the tar be tse he ee thom {fer and cud them w bge ia eth otc the one ‘Eeuge lc le forthe ota eet fel ey ‘ipatntc garun tego apd tc ee comin Ca Shia etn anette “em nt romeo they teen and gtk wrk Sd nak ur he er concne oe So ro br each oe ‘Sinton pepe sn nga oa, aa ewes ‘er nar, mieeing taken fo soe Sores mire Ta frie tutte aken of haan bing sed hea Aaah two frone coh hese ating hen No scone tbe common then eed ogy ‘esoman-er etary of ahr ae fom ewe SSAEUnibe hc sand one on chs mun ve “Shs Women cloned froma woman py saat eed Joon bu se ocd er owand women ad Tobin come Romine The cto bom mete puee the mse {Ste hy aver of easy ae mens sl os ‘Sighg i wh non and be craced y tem The oe ‘het ile yy a othe ome iy ary ate ok Miah Sneha reyes hey 22 tee Crete a tae: eRe dapat eater a rnb at ae or umm Md cal eb ran ig nf eh ce rie alan carne ede eens ine seat nartne te Seas E ST eee apace 4 se do ono sen cd ug ‘Strain Seng hae Apes pro aah ter enclose aoe » fama hen hey excuse pn Spe porn etm rd he geting les lips cdo ty san er st tno rear nm oe cS abe Shoavhan ape eee ate clon ograr ne Seapets” Ve cimerabpanay ey oer oer nanos seperate we then aro ey Sep «Estat an onde wing pl ek Sheth enn ne "Phe he poe et Serotonin oa arto canteen wht wate hmsby Seng witch er Noone Tisewat catome bese eng gs {Sg toes cel enn efercaty eae 4 Sopeng ceca pn mo cena wakes Saouchapnssran Spc Hepes wits std nr ten they geen se "wane poe ok nga Caer "An pn fy oe pp fer ‘Stead beaten pewter ‘isa peo hye mc ped fom eh her Sind pec tt ys a nak + Sie heme hing tha om gyn ae Seta overestimated Soule cn term fs ote Dsante eral de eng ed emer. Se Sopot an ees Oro sl pp Tih oa ge on bern le serappen ihr anungeae soy tat heb ‘Hetil seg mae eon te eed hs Tac toe fam Tike a ot ‘ecommerce ans ve Siiveslyetar attain asietog aboeero Soin eho teen peep oe plane cere igus roy spunea net ee Be 8nea srmansrarion ‘sth Arcadian were persed the Spartans So theres fear ‘Raclé we sould norte wel ordered toned he gods, westall be ‘pla two apn aed goszound lke be people eld nfl Gh imines, ted im al ough the ose born ike pit ie "This lle sould urge each cher in all ings v0 wor. 1 akip de gods so we may spe thir and mee wih tat becuse [Ere uous guide sn genera Let noone aco the contary— thoeer acs the cara shad by she ‘py becom Ing ends and recone ty the god we shall Svar and meet, sh our orn bowed stich ew new 2. "kod Exyricacus mas no iterrapt ne and poke fun ti scegunton te ground hac only mesh Tapia and Again Peshope dey seal eof tit Hod and are bth taseline in Foc n toying tout evergone men and women ake, Thats how ou Tac would becone happy, fe ould ul ‘ur love and cach et ith hit ow baton, earning 2 Ms finishes tn necessary hats are oitunder present cigcumtanee ao best tha fo meets beloved wo 8 st Sally Hlewded and congenial i slging praises to dhe god r= Spal fone would ily ena Eros, hot present rings ihe greet beefs and ads usin wba properly our ov, Ud proves genet hope in fuare haf wes reerence (© ‘re goue be wll restore ure our upden nate and helo, art bake or ewed and bappy. “There, Enna fe aid. That speech about Eos, of a dierent Bind than yours As T begged you, done poke fun at ips tayo er wha each of the reraing speakers wiley ar ates tat ech of he wo le or only Again Und Soc area ss, ena im primis pane es Fi opment soca som Sk ‘oe ere ain atl cil, oe ta el been Site fe Boma ok ‘Tbe cited thepene i lace oma at v9 SSUES Sea ‘Third Interlude: Socrates and Agathon (agse-r94e)| Ariens si hat Expat, Wy, Tobey yo, 1 cern enayed your spec And Wt were not znatetat Soc tries and Agata sre over Soot he ings of line, Te ery ‘nh ear they'd be ata oss for word, because ofthe any aod ‘led things already sid; butt, 1m paves content ‘So Socrates, Yes, yulmads because you yeusel com pet n nel bat yu were ere now amor ater pers ‘here Tile once Afathon abo speaks, you'd be very as aod (tea bewildered 3 Tam noe "You mean tocasta spl on me, Socrates Agahon, so tat ibe thrown ts conan by hiking ny tester ha grt ex pecan spe we Tel be forget! indeed, Agathon, sad Socrates, ater seeing yur courage ad ei coaftente aging ap onthe tage ‘ithe srr ane looking oat ono great sn audience about 3 ‘Rhine your cen play and in no way at all coped, Tom ‘Shug: ytd be oye i confuse becte of few pope ies aly Socrates? std Aguhon. You suey den’ believe a 40 ‘ul of theater shar I dont even Koo that 03 person of ood sense, 8 few ligent mem are ore frmidabve tha ay at "No, Agathon, Iss arly do wellto think you capable of nytiag oor; Lye now tat you met omen wom You elev we, oud ive eed to hem rather than te made But mabe were nt they—for alr al we were alto there ad ‘auong the mulitide—bu il #f you tet bers uo ae wise, Send perhaps fel ame before them if ou tought yo were “artoderassid Phaedra ntervupeed and sai My dear Ag sc een a os SESS18. ‘hon, iyo aoawer Socrates ic wl wo Inger make the Sight {dterene to fim how anything ee urns ou here, ony Be bas fomeone o eer Wi, especialy someone handsome. But ‘ough I enjoy bearing Soceses comvese, Tam cesar om (ened abut te ecm of Frond Tate ect a speech ‘om earn one of you the two of 700 ay hs Way ol ‘fer enderng what ede the od ‘Why, yore ight Phairus sid Agthon, and nothing pre sens ay speing fr wl be posse to converse often ith Secretar ‘The Speech of Agathon (i94—197e) | ah then sy how muse pea. and then to speak For al who spoke before sem v0 me ato ale coma 0 the {dbo flea nen forthe goo things of eh the god {Sita cut; hat of wht sore betel s wo ge then, no ‘See he spc There re sight way to pre soe in ay ‘hing atc to describe i pec the maare of eset of the speech, aod the satreof that of which he ide couse. 18 [ght then foro fo pase Eos ti apo ast his ature, hes Bees ayn that hough al gs are hay. ros it meecand “pany, heppet tong them, because he sox beat TRTiJ tase He ow tel oes rene Be ae Grube in ounge of ge hime provides a grestproot Eamonn cng el ge igh boogie deel qu St ay se omer on ws goth han fe tou But res by are ts a wl te go ere ear Bute eet ‘ite young, tnd bes young ford sont cout sound, Teer dave nero ike” And dhaugh agre wit Phe (Eevim ny ole ting [nore nth, dat rosie thn hes sd ae 1 cao he acy hat he Younger among god and eve young andthe ann alla ROBUNn ied sat mace ey oretling ie hs Gree at oe te lt te nk Saeed (Ste isa beat Rawrannd condo Ot neon tls SRV oes ‘7th, ve taken place hough Newey and nr trough ros {br here would have been catations and fetering of each (ther sr al that other vee Eros had teen presen anong ‘hem, bt fendip ane peace as there now dace Bros les (he gods sng. “ies young: hen, and in aditon to being young, dex “There Wacol of post such a Homes to show 2 go bn Howrey ta At ude fcr aloo eanehe fet tary tare ater he her fe are dle: for she eps not ‘on he ground twas upon the hens fren Soshe shows he delay, Think, by «prety proof because she wks neton'wias hard baton whats Bu wey so we The ene proof wo show that ror dec: he acs no walk 00 ‘ard nor on beads, which ae fer mt very soft away But Inc wake and dels the ote hinge tere are Fore makes [heme te chara and sole of god sed men, hough not inewery sul ener ance onthe conan, any sl enmes ‘spon thei hardin charac he leaves, bt theft he del in. ‘Sree toning wih hfe and in every way the mest sl of soli ings, hes necestry mos delete: He syounge then, {Int mou dete, aod ination hi shape ost ppc: For Iecould not ine Ninel rou i every essen and dough iherysonlandyererape nce when Sat enteringand departing, ‘Bho werehard His geecefulnes which everyone agrees ror sur passngir posse, great proof of his wel-proporsoned an [pple one, fr ankwardnese and Eroy are ever ata th one ‘ther The goals dueling among Sowers sigisos beauty of {ior fr Fron does nt pts his ent in abd oF solo anything ‘Se fom which the Bloom faded and gone But whete« place ite fered ap fragrant. there e aes his seat apd cides. ‘Concerning the baa of the god, then tise rlicent sd spore nl reais: but one us est speak about the vibe of roe Whats mon importa Unt Eros ner does injustice to god or man nor rlfer iusie from pod of man. Fora fected by anything, he bic noe fered by viene lence des net ic Ero, nor doe ae vey when he se foreveryone wing serves Eros in eveyhng, ad whats l-‘ingly agreed by wing partis, "he Laws, Rings four Gy old soe jai In ton nice he pareahes of verperancein fllest mex sur. For ei agreod that emperancels maser of Pleasures and {tread na plesanesstonger than os out freak, hey fre matered by Fron sod he masters ther, and a0 mastering Deseures and desees, Ero wold be urpssinglytmperate ‘Spun in rapes to courage, “oot even Ares witands"=™ ‘ros Fer Are dows ot pot Bros bat Eros Aves—an Ero for [Apiradiy sv the mary goet™—and the posenoe i srorger Qin tie poses Bet, arin hi who ls move courageous ‘Shoag oer be wuld be mont courageous ofl ‘ne god but Fernie spent of wom: far pose ncn meson Fs ofa en, inorder Oat ay {ium henry owt an faymachor honored hi tbe got AB pees wee at bess males hers poets al whom Hes touches any te beam poes “even if he was wid mae ‘le So may Stn aes proaf tat ori poet Shote ins, good larexpettoallcreaon er wc theses rsd for ont ca oo ge somcone ce orteachaaother vat ne ier has nor kno eee no wl den ha the creation of animals is te wi deat oy oy whom lamas ae born ad Sete? But 0 Senora fogw in he craftmanship ofthe as at eof won {Tiped becomes tencher trout 0 be nowble and ious, ‘tfc Ene loner monet emi the she? Yer ntsc Spates tee of tery ne med ad rose unter she pidane of Eon alder, to hat eve be ‘tala tea pup of Erm og i the Maes of mini and o> Coyiant Heghnants is neaborking and Athen wen zen Sn ullng of god a nes Whence hen Ut eee (ey Epes steers tat eee ees Ge pSevine nro Regn e Stnaed a, sien ya tdi ae agen raanauarion: 190 Ue fis of he gods were arranged when Eros as born snong them, Eros for beauty outyfor there i no ror of ge before that msde begin with, many tele things osatred among the gos, a i lt, Ureugh the saver dig of Nesey. But sce the gad a orm a good ange ‘ve come be foa lve of Bese ings, Boh Or god 0 « MSoicscens to me, Phaedra that Eros, being himself est 2s most bentfl aad bes yea, cause of eter suc Uy i (thers. Tam moved speak iver though Rishe whe composes Peace among men, wees en ase, Rest from wins smber frou gre. 4 Hee cpio of errangemen: but fil sw Kinship, asing ‘sto coe togubern al roc gatherings ar hese. edn ‘Scenes a Ted; he itroduces genes, but bat ‘shes dees: geng of goodnl,unging of I wi gracout, food: gusedupoa by the wie, elie a by the gos coveted [yoae whoo portion ponamed by ove of food foes ‘eral dlany ofan of harm, of gracousmen of ese, oF Jonging: earing fr goo! thing, uearng for bed things Inbox, «feria longing i dbcoures guide, defender coma ams sd bx rior beauty and goodorderfall gods men leader ‘os beautiful and test wom every man fust flow chasing equally, sting Ue song that he sg, touching wit mage over the thug of algo snd men" “Theres my spect Phat he wie Lt it be dedicated to te go. Ithas 2 share. some of tof ply but aso of eased veriates so far as Lan rode Fourth Interlude: Two Kinds of Encomivm Cag8a~1990) ge Aitodemas ail tt afer Agzthon spoke, eveyone in the company sppsued, becuse the jung man’s oprech did 20 ‘ach ered both hime and wo the go. Then he said Soe 4, ore Gm, pnt ede of pg sod sc TRE ee eaets rt03n ‘nies gland at Brjmachus an sid, Wel, son of Arne Adnyou chink Fve bse teoabed al his by gros far? ‘Was I no propbedewhen I sid jst now tat Ageton wuld speak wonderfll apd I would beats lo? "You were propess i the one thing Tin, sid Eryaima anuedhat Apathon would speak wel Buta you beng at tote daub “Aad iw am Tmo to beats le dese Send a Socrates oth Tard pone ce who intend speak aero beatiful ed ‘aed 3 speci? The oter pars were wonder bat ot equal {She end who could fal wo beasonses x hearing the beaity ofits words end phrases? Since Ieaize I wl nt be abe 1 Snyhing mera eau asthis mse, lewe and ran aay {er ery same fT euld Atal te speech renga eof Gorgias so that | experienced exacy what Hower descbed. 1 tna afraid at Agatnon at he conclusion of hk speech woud ‘od up the hed of Corgis, formidable fn peaking, pasos my ‘Spechy and tur me toute stones And then {Fekied hom ‘Blaas Iwas eo agre to tae turns with yu im eleing 3m comm o Bros, lam Twas clever inthe ngs cove wer cmaly Tit podtng about how one should fer any tort of comm tal Forza foashoes {suppose one shold wl the ruth stout each thay prased, andthe shoud be the ase fer picking out rom that the most beau things and peting ‘he inthe most suitable wa Tas vet confent haf wok Speak well becuse | knew the ech abou hw to pie ting. Bott tars ot ser at fine pie atti, bat cons serbing the highest and ont beau strut {Thing wether has the orn realy con mari ‘bes Farias caer propor, seen ot hat each of ut Shovidofteran encmtum of re, butthteath of ur shou sen ‘eofferanencomium o him. Thats why, Lauppose ous ap [tery Kind of sory ad apply to Eroy, and cam he of sch Sette cass egy it a open an {ful snd good st pombe nnd daly to hore wb donot Kon Sim "noe sry vo thne who do=yout pra bel Sprite Bosley det soe deme fpr and ot Eebwing agreed wath you oe ys rag sctiaGhie ates oe ee Tansuariox a ‘be tengue swore, but ne the ind Bat tit go. Fr T dott 235 ell cco nis manne ined, Teapots 1 bot neverthelswling to el ou the rath in ny ove yi you uh ough nari comperion wit our specs the ‘nay aotncur Your mugher Conde then, Phaedra ohh ‘heres ealy any nce far a pee of thie to hear he es spoken about Erin uch word and atvagement of pases "ay happen to oeuts™ ‘Wath Atsodemus si that Phaedros ad the hes bid hin speak in whatever way be hough he cal, ‘Why then, Phas, Socrates si, plese le te ok Agshon usa fe stall questions sl so dat may speak tas afer ge ting his agree «Wins So permit sad Padus, Ask your questions ie feed im, that Ero by ty acount woul be ner eal or got “Aad TH do you mean Dina? Frosthen sug and war nd she si, Hsh dow’ apee! Ordo you opps tat steer not enti ecard)? "on of eoure. ‘oduct igcrai Ae yn ro mre hat thee ome: ching internet bemece wor and ignore? ‘What Dont you know, he sit, hat right opin wos aii 1 rear scour snot Laowdgee-for ow exal an wae ‘Gomuble thing be Lanwedge?—nor Bf igprance—for how Been, 1 Seth et ont ana fap ith tee miencEer ke ve ‘raid wha mets th what be gnorance Right pinion i ure tat ore of hing ntenmene beween wim aig “Te si Ther dao compel what snot beautiful to be uly. par wha i not god ota So too fr oy, ice Yu Youre agree Ut Ie wether good nor beauty do nt any the more for tha ‘reason suppose he must be Ugly and bad, sbe wd, But Falher Somehing between ese two “hod yet Tid everybody ares hei gest god, ‘You mean everybod) who docu! huge, © ao those who Soon? se id ‘Why asses every ‘Shelaaghed soos, And how ould ebe agreed thea great, gr, Socrates, thre who say hein ven» god at al? Wh are these people Isai “outro, emai an fen anther ‘And id How can you sya Easier. For tlle; don't you ca hat all god are happy and-beauifi? Or wold oe dave des Wat a god is eau and happy? Emplcaly nu sa [But you say that it thee who possess good and beau slag ta hp «Moreover you hav agreed tha rosy reaton of lack of god. ed beaut igy, dete se very things Re BCs Yes, The, How then would what without porton of beat and ood hinge toa ge? no way sees. ‘Then ou se, shed that even ou do nt ecole Bos wbeagod “Thevtat i he? Tid. A ore? arly Bat what ten [As I id betoe, she wid, inurmedine between moral and ‘amoral 5 Seon ae ona ad ey An a gp46. Eros as Daimon (2oad~203a) ‘ict he, Dima? A great dvi, Socrates for inf, the whole ran of vin. ‘ies Btermaate beeen god sd te ating wit pone sd neering and eoaveying things from meno gd and things Som gas tomen, papers a vrs Fou ce oe commas fd requis i cachange for teifcs from the he ee, Ing in between le ls the regi berween bh ott Alls boond together wi uct Tog ths rea tenes al prophet et and hear of picts having oo wid eins {drake an pel, anal power papery stench ‘ent God does noningl wt an, lentercoare sd ei ‘rsnon of gods wid nen, wakingandleeping are sought eal He oi wie about ch things ate is vie nay, ‘oh wth ewe about any ether anor crates mere me. chanic®™ These divas, tt are many aed mani, ad Got ‘of them i ree “The Myth of Poros and Penia (goga-e) ines 1s tego elt en eo, ‘When Apbodie ss brs the gods tango bh the others ‘el et aur ec Me Wii Whos ey Sie ein acing sent alee er i Sen and bg abou dots Wo ede oo tecarer trent swine we ab be gnen ‘Go tee ped dey Woe 8 ens Ged he a ry en tis somes Sy wit ew and enced Eon ssp Erbe ovr od eva of Spensbems he a bapracra Sedayaertihwin ome neces sare Silay tne piredar beat FRI octet te riye be dice Cee centaur anne op eeepc armen (Setnaer ae hemaered cuneate dt herccapae Heunseariow “ar Because then Eros ton of Foro a Pea sis is orca: Bate sever poor, and far from beng dette and bes, = tos people suppose” he on the contrary rough sad begs 4 ndhemeets and urn evr ping onthe ound at So ‘ing. slecpngindorseps an bse roc une ae open soy ‘Becse he has his mebers nature be Gels ever wth won, Boe ‘on the eer and, by favor of his fey he Set bs fo geek sl esi things, because hei coragtous age ad noe fhe clever hunter tnt wearing ome new device, dengue, ‘sanding and capable of a inves of wisiom hough te whe lie clever Cachantmeaa sorcerer and a sphkt=> And he +S by micore peter moral nr immoral ut ynetines on the ‘ne dy elves aed utes, whenever he ult Feo, ‘bathe he des and comes tack to lie sgun by reson he ‘stare of his ue. though what provid ever sips tony oo {ha Hees never ih sot aca as Eros a Philosopher (20ge-2040) a eae he an es been wid ad ignores. er thing snd thos nog ores ws ot deen eee swe hereto to atyne ce me, Sor hee won Ortiecthes hand nether dothegnrat ire sdoeorea ‘Shawne ter br poset lane dar oes ‘Yea and gee ort, yee seo oth cee Aten He wo erotik nef in nced dos tot das ‘hat be es tt bed, “hen whe are hs lero wim, Dit, hey are titer the ie norte won oat pene car a oe sh ia Shey amet inenmedinte teen ba thes Sad tar Eee ig th or wisn ay tog soe Beto ‘hing, bt Br ove he hea So Eres cents hopes mer of widamy am, eng «proper aoe Sedat betes wnt a rors He hte ee {ie forte sofa wae and oud ter betas eee nd roomie moter 5 Ri Le ina ar me eh ‘an acomplbed soph” toh ‘oraus “Tis thn isthe ature ofthe divin, my dea Socrates: but there is othng surprising about what you thowphe Ero You ‘ough tI gather fom what yous hat rons what ved dot heaving Tati wy, Ero sere te bes (0 you nc rth bled that eal beta ard ‘arming and perfect and dered Mend ba loving Bas this ler charac of te sore dened. ros as Wish for Happiness (2o4c~2058) Au sd: Vary wel ten, my dear ny ou spe beat ‘Bul roe sof thir or har Ueflgen does behave fo en “That the ex thing Twi 89 to each ou, Sore, hem. ‘ene Heo i and purl ‘hinges yous. Bar uppose someone asked un, Why s Ero of beau hings, Sore end Diem wile more leary: “Wy does he wo loves love eau hinge? ‘Aided, To poses them fr hime ‘Bat the newer slang ee fling kindof ueton, she ssid: Wie wile ave wo poses bel tinge? alent quite rely answer tat question, ‘ut soppone soutoae changed “tensfl" tooo she sak and then ingured: Come, Socrates, Be who lve, lone good ‘Bing. Why does he lore thea? “To posses the for hinsele And wat wl he have who powenes good ting? ‘This can anorer more ely, sid Hew be happy Yes she id force happy tre happy by possession of good ‘hing, and there no ned in addion vo ae forthe fr hat Purpote he wo wisest be appy wishes On the contrary he iosima's Definition of Eros (2058-206) ‘Bo you chink tls wih and shi oearecommon al men snd har erersone nsbs toposes oud thing for terse fe “Yes Lid igcommon wo eversone Why isc then, Socrates she sad that wedo not any that every- Taasuarion 49 one lowes, if ndeed everyone loves tesa thins ad soa, ‘na erate sy hat someone and ome don Tin alo surprised uy Fed ete, she sid. et becane we subtract a certain species of ‘om and name it Eros apphing he nae of he whl but we ‘ie other names forthe hes ‘asset Atthis You Know shat making pies something mani {or suey ee cae Gt psng fom not being nt beg fo ry thing wanever alla aking so that he preductons otal the ‘aru are makings, ad the prottioners of them ave al aers ‘oii rene id oto ah ae tld as ae Po a eed remit eal ee Semen one hae Hees eee oe melons ETL te twin gl ct ry dan tpt ago ggg fear oo es end iectean meee oni ee Siuniceranumreinete teeny Sateecealamy crac eine ieee Tackett rarer ere ese TET vit wat aauoe nba seh caring ae ts tor ac Coir ota Seer eae EG ceca ert meeps SSE a rae recto ate os Sarah See ser ps se Sans eerease ee ee SSeS ace ga oe on a ay “ty rg oem ped eck Samo1 ot erty do i “Then onc may Hie wthouc quali chat men love the ike wid rat ey Ic not tobe add, she sid that they a love the sont ether? ‘heave ‘Aad only beer ah but ao roe hes forever? ‘Ths tonto besos Traum tun, sh sn Eo ifthe goed, bing his own or Very tre, I rep ‘The Works of Eros: Regetting in Beauty (aobb-2078)| “henge ht si ert he il nt .2in soi id Speen su ve among box pring REET Si wieder woe append arouse? SSSTELLTA a nssbncceomnenr oh, isu tl cp eoming nye ere fer ing Sol Sen ek beeen Sea inrapectbe toss te ay aaa ol aT den aderted apt Ripwrcsone dealy hes Allan sve reget in copa heb ant ew etre a hen reece cou dre fee” amet eae ttn nbn he ce oft sere igeauy Ties de ting on epone se tt Bal denen eave peresare sees etic w vans ontario eee crdvihatincbaving eben concent SeSScauban at ete ware oa Fmd in Spe Caen fe ofc. Taco wheats pee Siegen to eal coe rw See pou acl it gent preset eeeasna bere uh tor hein engl ears IREPSSG Meander teres whey 25 LEER yw corrpnating noon the encepton win Whence is tha one who i pregame tod abe) eval s vebecemy eased oer ne bei + Sues pn sr pag or Sous be ‘Si rosa You oppor, Wotan bes? [Riso rsreaton and hegeting of chien nthe bes Nery Tne Tobe atthe sd Bo by of roreton? Ree pose sonst sdmmora trav pone ro vo mira ane go to that ar been agreed tai bette pusen Se god ar Ibat former Knecemny tna fo i scout em, et Eris ao in of nmoraiy. Immortality and the Mortal Nature (2078~£086) A dese things she aught meat vaso ties when shed course about mates af lve. Once beste Sate, et do You think cause of thine spd dese? Ora you toe mae ow strangely al bests ae disposed, oeued ad winged, whe hey deseo reproduce alls and eos caposs, efor {meceoure wi each or nd next forthe dagte ofthe off ‘sping In hele the weakest ae read odo bale whe ‘Mtongeat tdi the behalf tbe racked with unger the ‘eter so ato feed then, todo anything ee. One mig suppor, fhe sai, chat men do thee things cm the bof reece but ‘tithe cute of beats bang otal pone i ay? Cat yout «MA again used ws aida ow Ste sald, Then do you shink youl cer become sled in the ‘gee fe et ded a thas why [keep coming to you, Dita, a just sow ‘si, "hnoving need merucon Pls le theca of hy Sd her igs concerning mars of lve then you are pessuned se ad, at ove by anare of. hate hve often reed donot be urpied. Toe eta tie 4 na wold, Uy th same seeoune bere, the mer natre Senecioseks fara can ent freer an be nmr Ie can do ‘Soni in his ging rh evrlewing bed a dierent ‘es ing ia place ofthe ince even in he imei wich ea ‘ge lng ena i ald co ve ane toe the tame fore Snbleasin a ob th sare Tro you old age ‘hough Re never har Ge same hinge in imal, be nevertheless ‘Peale the sate ut he ever becoming new wile oherze ‘Pesoing im rspeet to har and sh and bo and ood and ‘he entire bod “hid ae only a respect to the ody but i i espect wo the soo ie character and habs, epnions, des leases Di fens ae eat ever ete each tan ae he sae, Bat {le are coming to be thers perting Mach sore extracrd ‘ay sl, ot al are some tnd of knowledge amigo be aa ‘eter nan nee brim cen eps. {othe kind of knowledge, but ao each single ane ameng = ods kamledgeis tect inthe ee ny Pr what cle studying exis tao knonedlge laren ws Exgeting is depar- tare ofbnomedge, bt study inseducig again anew memory In pcr ofwhae depart preserves the baovlege so that eee tobete ame" Pow hwy thal thas mortal pesered: not by ‘eng ever completely the sre ke the dine, bat Teving be indie departs snd becomer ber, cifferent new ding the ‘Stnccotsn vis By thidvie,Soorstes, sheriwst sort Barasharcofinmovaity beh body and cverhing ce; bat what nmoral by another ever Do not be surprise, then ener ‘hing by ature aos fr own oft ie for the sae ofa ‘mortality that this eagerness love sted upon al (Creation in Respect to Body and Soul (zotb-209¢) ‘When heard hisacroune was surprises and ssid, Why real, sym se Diosma, ae hse things acta re? “snd she rephed athe seco soph do, Koow ic wel, Sotrtes Siac indeed oa il look othe ive of anor aang ‘Bj Cama as dle at tan expec en peeks psf habe a muavsuarion sa ‘en, youd be surpritd by the unzenonabines of wich Ive ‘poke, unless you te in mind an eit om ow sangey di [ose nen are by Bros w makes ame td “yap soe of i {ore glory for everating ee" fo the ey ce ead wo rh 4 erry Tak oven more than forte cise, spend ony fern bors ef very sort ode fork Do oa think she aa ‘hat Alesis would have die or Admetus or Aches ates Pe uous, or oar qv Catia fr bce Kingdoms hey 5, woud te nmol? Fer fom she id rae Tia 1 formal rue and th ra fame wih rng ory tat _seyone dos renga the more ua os thy ae beer «+ Rorthey hve he immo Seren retain epee he i sum mare o women zd are lor that wy roving inl Inte tine athe supose moray ad ope the sss hong geting dren ene regan inept sor tharsoul~ fr theresre thos, he mids obo areal wer erte inthe souls than ir bose with hat peat sel to Hesafal bodes ad ‘Bt ie guide™ gudesighy ole one single body and beget ‘here Renu courses; now, recognize that he beny 00 ny boty whacver alin to ha on ty oer body ae i ‘cea to pure de bes st ataches forty ute “teneoaable wo baleve that the beauty onal Bole at oe ‘the sme Realing tha, bei conte ver fal en tif bodies ad rela ths reemenc or on, cing dow on ‘sand believing of sealimporene. ‘Aerts gat comet believe tt beuty in sul more to be valued than hati tod 2 tha even oman gd ‘ofsoul has bur igh loo, tees for ha, ae foes and ‘ares and beges and sek the vores of dures that wil ace ‘he young beter, nerd ate may be consid i ura to ont wots raul i racer and laws ado ee that itis in iue al aint ue a Srder hae ay behve body Dbenay smal hing. ‘Alfer practices, be must ead hm to the varios branches ‘ledge, nor chat he yin sure the beauty tan ooking now to te beautfal ni mage no lager delight like ate, artes, peyminded servants te Desay of ‘one single thing, whether benaty of oun cid ot an ora ‘ne practice; a rather, haeng been turned ows the el tdicons ocean of te beau and comempiing he begets ‘many besuafl and imsporing dacurses um thoagvs in Un ding lore of wisdom, unl having at hi point gown ed ‘ned song, he behols «eran nd of knee wis (and uch that tthe ling Sind bey ey, she sd {© py me the dsest season posible, ‘The Ascent to Beauty Itself (2100-214) ee who has een educate in thedhings of lve up toh pit, ‘etn beni ng igh ai ac ordeal su by ina inant, proceeding a hat pint othe cathe ‘hing of ove se someting raul ia matures tha ects rhe take ich cal is previo ers Fis ic ever i and ther comes wo be nr pertes, or has it owt or aininstion, Tae hee ennAsn tis norn one eget bean another aly. nor ‘crf atone tee ttn sabe, or bea dee 0 {hi bat why rele to tan or Beware bah theres ‘log beat oom a gy eo ber ‘Nor on the ther and wile =ppear esl ohm at fe dos or hand or sphing le of whch by pra sor Sy nour ty Koons doc net awit omc ‘lomcing cet inant orn, orn emesori Dying es at one Soe yo sue nent {Exe wi a ote hinge bea satin a ‘2s ugh he un ee eh ht Comes wo be nee in greats depres or le and no a aed ee ‘But hen tmeone, ueaing fom tings here dough the right ove of bows begins ety wo ee at, the Beas, be ould pet weltouh the en. For hr ithe ig way pro (eedinmatecefire orto edby anther bean rom thee bench hing re, sod er prard rte oof ‘atthe Bsus srthogh ang the ep falar, rom one toto an om oa bens bes a ss beau ‘dw Bena pace od from praca bold 1G and rn ae one ie edt soy wb rothing ober tanto, the Bell ad one Gow tnth ce by cea ne obe Seu ethos ‘Seywhere dent Sate, the Mananean Seager ha ae inte es beled: incomming the Beal ac eer ieee cen te or a out, wich no ook spon dumb: ou. ‘ly snter ac ety ae ae ou ve ad rl ch ‘hem freer fs twee pole, not cata a at (iyo mc wb we oom ‘Wiarthen do we mapone oul be eae ai, i were esse fr veo ose th Deal Hk, pare,analoye, mid, not illo human es ao oor andthe many Oe Beds of nomen hr aach ono, bowie cou bebe thedhvne Beauty ie sign mae? Do you think a were cee ty se toys” sigue Fee mete TE ESS, cance ccateghenpa gtd ANSLAION 10 ‘sm leslie she i, fora mano ook and cote with {hat by which one mus contenant ™ adobe ithe Orie not convind he sade here sane wil fl Begg Secing the Beal with hat by which ts ve, to Bega a images of virtue, beciuse he does not touch anima, nce ‘ruc beese he wuches the rath Hat n begeung te Sny and nurturing i ts given ohn o Become der gah ‘ny ther among men eimai bento, Socrates’ Peroration (212b-c) Ths then, Paes ad you others ae the tags Dictins ‘sida Cam peruaded Beitgpervades 1 oy also pera ‘ths that ont would me easy ger ube prince ser ee ‘man nacre in aig this possesion that Eros Thescore 1 Sy that very man should honor Evora Tcl honor sad surpigly devote mye te ings oie ed summon co, {1510 do; now sn als, {pease the powers courage rosso far a Tam able. Consider ts spo them, Pi you will anencomium o Eros, er yeu prefer abe that you Aer Socrates thi the et prt hin, but Arinopanes ie thing bee ttn pking aed oh AIntertude: The Arrival of Alcibiades (2120-2152) ‘sth rag ce wParam » SSR Rr esrieaatre ace eS See ‘ean resin mesg gue ae are ce ete See Steigen me aeearaimaes _ SIRs ccna ater Ie Rs rae tome ep go i aneaor vile" and mle of le on his head, and Gren gene, Wil yu acep shar say que dean avs king camspanion? Or shal eae afr owning Ae thon long, whic what we ate Goel come fe {ay he aid but in Bee now, th les oy ae erent frre end and po ean te bee the et an cst esl ane ma speak of ime ou og at she for eng dru Event you daughter Tsp the {rh Tal te sigh sow“ I come ian hee tro nod Wibyou dk wae or net ‘Wal, certadyappsuded and bid him cme fn an reine, and Agu tin: Ana cee ed ys ee Se beease he ening the ile opens on Aguon, ead tum i for fh ees ol oe Sure at ‘Dario a egre one ld way oomeone's + Nally orhaany oer dtacion couse ossiety ema Ura! He thins al thse poetsons are wore ad tat we ‘ening re on Sb ead ure sl pes hip wile ie paying with people. Yet on kom wb ay ste nett anaes dlageeae caper eo oe ee ‘Reman svi gone = Rewer ate. wea ating ch pen saocaen poeta genoa » BeBe cere wan oer Ee ew esi wen ea i Le tetera ieee ered Sinpeepieetiomcat senate Seco ora cern . ESE eee cee spain pretense stone ta ie oatencie Siete iran eee iciatys weoktareameres Bominrgudauratingabnccatae eros «REEL vaee ura sores soe eg ere sete eet ear ieee Tales wags teat a gegen a toa Sener mernetereaeen fie aera ieecube tren etenewanta setter ane « TREE pam atv ae serene rt spin ened toerecuenares Eg a kraetelanegey Siwrucceinkectors Eee aise enemies Racor » RESRCREE ewataran oor eesti omit aka mye Simienccmunestane amas sedthing prove poany ara ics esas ae Estey rated ech sear ee,4 gy and nent appear wrongin eo continue pray {hg Scenes whe onenlng hr ogee Seed The, 9, Tm ‘SGowtaioued Inc manor bora teen bya mate Tey my ‘Eataoyon wf eed i waving ol wha wae ep the wat be ny bene ny he wl pe Frtlec and unccranif oneview dose eying Eh pat Wel tee bien teething more Pll and 35 he x pil pce ne canbe bathe ht oo {nee one tl name track spd ten by ements Spy hat hold more erly tan «werpen, en they SS ht os young and wx kennel yu and make Him {eg ying ween gan, Te bee people ie ‘Pisco and gabon Expimachar and Presta Ar omcs and Astophanes an hat shoul esi sb Ste Sima ad he ra of youd For you veal shared in lo- {ope sadn an Boch feys iens atyou fo ‘Sern pede ith the Ving he doe ad now tetera ed enone le pone ad ge, ut rogues cere ex, ‘We gennen, when he amp at ou ane snes wi i ougit shui Alsen br el hin ea matt ‘Boupae And mudges ium snd a Sora ae You weep? Gfeoue nt be Doe tno wn tink? We osc? he i Min tat yor slant daze wordy wo bea wy ves st you appatn arin ror saying me atthe how t Babee rd be vey fh nc ray you in {ri pow say net anyhing Ceo ete Oy end. Rare wing ore imporante oe hans become ood 2 poi and donk here npc wc lp thine atoriadrey tas you Tae uch mere se be: feet en got gach un tan bere a ‘untied #1 ai iepahe nl on ane etd eco ge uh Ss Rada enh wy ener clay and Le eee atin Seo Sa Punseerios 25 Wen he heard thie eth the wal ay honey tha ‘stp ot him, My dear Abide, you ae realy not be hen lg, fined wat you say about ne bappens ob ee, ad there sin ne some power through wich you gh become be te, you mold then sce nconsrable bony ite, wen So. ‘assing your eva ismenee cmetins of frm, Batf sceing ouate ting rk a bargain wth et exchange aay fot ‘eau chen orn take n light advantage cf neon the contrary. you eying ge poeston of what rly besa ited of wha eey secs to, and ely you intend wo ade bronze fr gl." But plewe dar ie ore ough Ist ecape yur nace tat a natn Be igh Oe ad Degas oar sharp when that of he ees ars oom dl Bat youre sls og way mn a heard hs and af, Thats how with mee nly ni hat hin Since thao, st concer weer Joudiskisber rye andes ‘Wh, yore sight be eed. Wea fatare conse and do what appears bent wo curses about hese and oer ge Tearing and ying thi, Pood sy arom av twee and {shoughe 8 wounded hi! ge up wie gh sy a ‘tora ec setbare conan pty oe ‘pm round sgn dry the nnn te hemi firth fod au Scr ou wi nk Saray iy ex bei ht evan sep eto my oul Won ae ced ousepealy Ie teen ap ene ng geen gare oveodgl earepece ‘fier knw a oi and pens, when ‘wear fvng pei Sote ev shige tan 78g watnalades oan ener Gnyon nage my soto afr a? conser my sefaltnns nd yee ae oes tenpernc se Crag, hg eta moet neste ‘pets winner ve ee Sirgcrany alte caped is comp roe nd aay tin mer Por nl ine bens ere nee 5: a apf ser Ce Bia pn amoney than Ajax eer wast ron, and he'd escaped sein the {aly ay I thoughe he cod be caught So I vas sen an ‘ret round ented by th msn scone ever vary aye Carag ond Coen (293-2010) At hs happeoed to me bie, and afterward we eve 1 thes on th empsiga to Peidaca™ and we were eats thee Wel ata eon ony spud er ceryoee inbearing hardshp—wicoever we gent ofenmesiere asap ees on cipal pd fad go wu fod the acy were hing espe frude-ut agin. atin of good ces, ‘be lene was et eno them tothe fli pare dough ‘orig toa, he beat cerpboy ce at ven compel {ova hat treme Ol no man as ever ee Soe ‘air drunk. 1 thnk ht wl be eed ight one Phen aga ‘ere mais ott in ier=the wer there are greg Heid ether amaing things boone tte here wary or ‘hefrotand verybedy raped nsdn dl goo i hey {2 hy woe an tang tote ces a pt on he tee wiopping tha fet and Hees Bot he went round duis among hem with te se sore of sak he was ene toma owen before and got aroun onthe = waa Soc tore cay tan the oes shod Botte wes looked ‘Shaner ahi ining be dpsed hem ‘So much for that “Bat bre hse sch that ong ma ccllured and accomplished ence there co canes Ts ‘orth hearing One tine st daw he began o Wink Something ‘rerand odin thesume pot conterog snd when be fund Be aon, he id lee br sod ere gurng Keto be ‘Bia, and people bce sa le vomering St ong ‘Semele, ying Sots had tod here snc dn thing ‘Sout womcthing Flay seme ofthe ons, when evening cane ier they exten war hen marca heir ing Sut sep in the coo a and wo watch w ee bet ko and there aig He sood unl dace an te on roe then coffee sprayer tthe on, ane pitt pa Miner an en i Se eee 2h ey ag Remind at) C1 Dat if you wis, tai atest sony ja give hen his ‘Because when the bate occ afer wih he general gene +s the ana fr val, no other man edie i hin, Ts ‘rounded and he refused to leave ut sed both oe and ye ‘nor tll uhe generals even a the tne, Sorat, to ge the ‘ad to you, and for this oul srey nee ful se or ay Tro necteling the ut, But when the gener wahed to give me the prize for val out of er fry ank an eaten, you your selfnere move eager than the general that T should rove tend of yoo. Sill gun, gendemen, i was wrth sing Socrates when the sox anny mide is dSordeyreren from Delta" T happened be mounted, but he nas inthe heey intanry. Wel the men, were satrng ean Laces tgeer gave ground: happened {otenenby andas oon anv ihe hd dato hare rage nd ad I would dene bem, But hee leo wate Socrates ‘fen bese than at Poidaea-for Tra mye ee afraid bene Tras on hrseckand fs Tus how mh he surpassed even Lather in elfpesseio, snd then spun to quate that Ine of sean, Artpns I hghct ered rej e oes here tn, “ead held High, caning hs eyes about"? cally ‘surveying both end and foe making tes o everyone ad sc gute x dance, thf anybody touched ths ma bed deed : ‘ise ques. Thats be sd is coma gcamey sale they dat asully touch peopte wh dele hehe ik th + ini bt pure toe no fe heading, The Songs of Stes (2240-2228) Wel, one couk praise Socrates for many other remarkable ‘hing: with respeto ote avis One might ie perhaps ay te ssne sor: of ting abet someone ee but whens ay Stier a at nrc wor of wre One wig Compare hereof ms Ae ou Broa a oe sitar “hy eer on et y Fh, EAS ran quo mle en ei ae i ER icuiak ieemcratonectscioearine j pate Sit Sar a nitncs ma ispuell sheets4 Ghe might compar in theme way. But the sot ofan thas act te nloer thst have teen opened: For fone i wiling © however bat alo Charme on of Glneon, and Futian, sod Peri, agai, o Netr and Antenor and here are oters Sod his seangeness, ooh lms and hs words, oe eouldet Son dls Snting ioe ooked ether among poop present Sor pase excep prtape fone mere to compare hi nee ‘endon_-not any man bt lene and sei athe word ‘Acualy, Lets eu at stat ever i seen Ten w Socrates arguttens, bed appear qulesdcuous at {isc theyre wrapped found oa th outils wilt words aud rans ke te hide ofa strapons aye le als about packs {Sees ad ss and ootlers ara tanner, ad forever sppears ‘0 be sying the seme thing inthe sme way, 0 hat an ies elena sed unvesonabe an ight lei arguments Buti the argument are opened abl one ses therm frome the Inside he wll nd firth they ae he only arguments wh 27 Seasein tom, and next, ha tbe contain wn emis Ue ‘ety dine and mudd lage of vite, ad ha they are leant o mont or ater oa ge worth conderng fr ‘tha ints to be noble nd go, "Tis then, geile, omy pre of Socrates, On the cher dnand, ven mined the End in iy ad tld yoo [is onaageous nsw ees jst me Be tented ts wa, on of Diodes, and many anther wel hom he seduces 364 Iorerand ener uphimel!artsloved nad flower Twarm you, | ‘Ags, dont be deve by hs, but earn rom ou ew ex piensa atchout instead of asthe prove hast earning, Ep naferng ‘Socrates Replies (222e-209b) «Afar Ales sith, hey ughed a is Rankine, be- aise ven iin love nth Socrates So Sere Thi Jou'e tobe Albiades, Othervise, youd never ty to disguise Journ odevely and conceal why youve sid al iy ad putitactheendabifirwere merely an afterthoughts hough) ¢ ottal sida ocaue Aton nd met gare bee os tink shou lve you std nobody ee, ed tat Agathe ‘Sould be ey you and nt one ingle person, Bat yu fol ne: hep your tr faye ae Your St tems pli perfec cbous. My Car Again, det et im etavy with doit a anyone xe ou sa ef quate + So'Raathon maid, Why realy Socraemapbe youre sgh. fer ae proot the fact hath ay dows between Jou Sn sein rer wo exp ws apt Well be wont gene wn thing TH foment you “esd, sid Soerste. Come here blow me Ze! suid Alta The figs Ivete rom this tan! He sh sot the Deer in cer wa sy tion atl atone own teen “impel, sald Socrates, You prised ne, sd Tha to rae ‘neperon win sgt Sot Agatha bestow you, woithe have ‘Spee me eptnea lng poe Lr ‘inet ofrie seaman” Pose Ve mc “es, Abide! id Agation. Teas ere. Lab sate cange ssn rer be pred Sone “esthesume olds ad Ala When Sorts roa it imposible fr anyone cet get sare ofthe bene. Ad Dow nhs conincing argue hes fd: ado resol, tt, take feloe si set toh Se agthon got upto nao Socrte, Conclusion (229b-d) ‘Butt this pong udeny x mob of reveers cate to the doors nd when thy found then open Decne someone at caving they came sraigt im ou and ay dawn, verying asf aE Tesch tre pi ican ei SoS es ee caeimsesuproar, here was no Inger any onde, ad everyone wa come pel to drink a gret deal of wine ‘Arsene sal chat Expats ae Phases and yore sess gu up aad ey and he fl sie ad slept qe we, Drecase the night were lng, Su Be woke up tard dea Scocerom 9 se tome ap ami thes gene. Only Agno ‘nd Arsophanes and Socrates were sl wake inking ot Taig bow and passing from to igh “el, Socrates was dusting with them, Arstodemus id be ‘rulsremember the oder arguments he watt theres the ‘egining and be was drowsy—but the main pon, he sae that Souetes war making Wen agre tha hese a Koes ‘how to eumpase comedy and rage, and be whoa ag oct baie com poe wee Competed othe aiaons, snd ‘oe quite flowing, they deonsed a Arisophanes fel sleep rg. and thea, ust se booming gh, Agstton, ‘So after puting tem tw seep, Sorates got up an lef, and Arisodemus as ual fled Rim. He went othe Lyceum ad tthe passed there ofthe day athe wl any oe aod afer ‘bare went home in the evening and resed. 27 Te spe ty eget and ay a op Beppe Taal pata tamer saree Seon enn lesen oe ava INDE. en) SSnracamneaimae yarns Slr Sesriem lense ‘eeiaaapemuatet amin is ‘Aone of lvern Spe; so neural fy Prog tat wth Sct, poet So Sa ee = Bees RE ‘stop ee “raed rametinal fo i ‘Remariable crud, dale opie endow, and good sce are sewer here ‘Theteninareaiablesnainresrgboo thane eobechesanderdworkonth ‘Smpanmloraloagimetocone "Raber Tumi, On Sate Uae LEA profesor flac and pt Iovopty a Nortwesern Unni. “The Dialogues of Pato Euhype Alay, Crt, Mew, Gps, Menezes “Fred ith Anas by RE Allen “Animpoctnteretio the world fs) snahip?— Laon Rei of Boks “Alcona suprbtandaornbonelegent Single yx pret nguage ser sees Pint boukasa phlooophersnd as ates any iL oust,