Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Fallacies of Relevance
The conclusion is logically irrelevant to the premises, even if it is psychologically or
emotionally relevant. They key to spotting a fallacy of relevance is to distinguish
genuine evidence from emotional appeal.
1. Appeal to Force:
Arguing via threat: "I deserve a good grade, wouldn't you agree? If you don't agree,
I'm afraid about what might happen: I just can't control Bruno here".
2. Appeal to Pity:
Trying to support a conclusion by evoking pity in the listener. I need to pass this class
in order to graduate, if I don't graduate,, my parents will kill me. Therefore, I should
receive a passing grade in the class".
Circumstantial: Lynch says that we should spend more state revenue on education.
But Lynch is a professor who wants a better salary -- so you know that his opinion is
worthless.
From Hypocrisy: You've claimed that smoking is bad for one's health; but you smoke
too.
Notice: if a person with low credibility asserts something without supplying evidence
for it, then we should withhold judgment. But, if the person does supply reason for the
claim, then we still need to look at those reasons and evaluate whether they support
the conclusion in question.
Another thing to be aware of is convicting someone of holding contradictory beliefs.
If we can show this, then we have indeed supplied a good reason to believe that the
person is confused. But notice that people can change their minds. Changing your
mind is fine; contradictory beliefs are not.
5. Accident:
Applying a general rule to a case it was not designed to cover. Example: Killing is
bad: therefore, it was wrong for us to go to war against the Nazi's.
6. Straw Man:
Attacking an oversimplified version of an opponent's actual position. Example: Those
who support gun control are wrong; they believe that no one should has the right to
defend themselves in any situation.
should be drawn. Example: The death penalty is the only way to punish criminals.
Why? Because the justice system in this country has gone straight to hell -- what with
murderers, rapists and robbers getting off scot-free! It has got change!