Sunteți pe pagina 1din 33

Unit 3-4-1

Process Simulation IV:


Process Simulators

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-1

Unit 3-4-2

Objectives

Choose correct thermodynamic models


Distinguish EOS and activity models
Input correct equipment parameters for the
simulation

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-2

Unit 3-4-3

Structure

Basic computational elements


1
2

Component
database
Thermodynamic
model solver

Flowsheet
builder

Unit operation
block solver

5
6

Data output
generator
Flowsheet
solver

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

Input steps
Select chemical
components

Select thermodynamic
model

2*

Input topology of
Flowsheet

Select units and feed


stream properties

Select equipment
parameters

5*

Select output display


options

Select Convergence
criteria and simulate

7*

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-3

Physical Property Models

Unit 3-4-4

Everything from the energy balance to the


volumetric flowrates to the separation in the
equilibrium-stage units depends on
accurate thermodynamic data
Hysys has default thermodynamics
package, which will without warning blindly
miscalculate the entire flowsheet.
You must have knowledge of the working
system, the thermodynamics models and
the margin of error.
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-4

Simulation Results Trustable?

Unit 3-4-5

In many cases, simulation results DO NOT


reflect what is really happening in a plant
Improperly selected thermodynamic models
Inadequate model parameters
Incorrect hypothetical components generation
Problems with plant data consistency

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-5

Pure Component Properties

Unit 3-4-6

Density, viscosity, thermal conductivity and


heat capacities with reasonable accuracy.
Enthalpy of phase change with care
If the enthalpy of vaporization is an important
part of a calculation, simple equation of state
should not be used.
Use ideal options or latent heat instead.
If the substance is above or near its critical
temperature, equations of state must be used.
Water as the steam: using ASME model
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-6

Unit 3-4-7

Example 3-4-1

A gas stream at 3000 F of the following concentration is


to be cooled by evaporation of 500 kg/h water entering at
70 F. assume atmosphere pressure.
H2
22.72 kg/h
N2
272.24
CO
268.40
HCl
26.84
Perform a simulation to determine the final temperature of
the cooled gas stream with the default thermodynamic
model and with the ideal model.
The default EOS model either PR or SRK: 480 F
Ideal model: 348 F.
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-7

Unit 3-4-8

Phase Equilibria

Extreme care in models for phase equilibria


or fagacity coefficient, K-factor, or fluid
model
Two types of fugacity models
Equation of state
Calculating pressure of a mixture as a function of the
composition, volume, and temperature.
Applied to both liquid and vapor properties

Liquid state activity-coefficient models


Calculate liquid state fugacities and enthalpies of mixing
Not applied to supercritical conditions
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-8

Unit 3-4-9

Different Models

A equimolar mixture of Ethane and Propane at 30 atm

Peng Robinson EOS Vapor Pressure model NRTL Ideal


Dew point 50.1 C
Dew point 54.3 C
Dew point 64.8 C
Good predictions at low pressures

The PR Equation of State most closely represents


the true phase behavior of THIS system
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-9

EQUATIONS OF STATES

Unit 3-4-10

Default fugacity model


Peng-Robinson (PR)

Most enhanced model in Aspen HYSYS


Largest applicability range in terms of T and P
Special treatments for some key components
Largest binary interaction parameter database

Or SRK (Soave, Redlich and Kwong)


Modified RK model
Comparable results to PR in many cases, but its range of application is
significantly more limited

Use three pure-component parameters per substance and one


binary interaction parameter (BIP) for binary pair.
Poor predictors of enthalpy changes
Not quantitatively accurate for phase equilibria (except for light
hydrocarbons)
Best choices for light hydrocarbons and light gases

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-10

PR EOS

Unit 3-4-11

For oil, gas and petrochemical applications


A wide range of operation conditions
Suitable for single, two-phase or threephase system
Key components receiving special
treatment including He, H2, N2, CO2, H2S,
H2O, CH3OH
Method

Temp (oC)

Pressure (KPa)

PR
SRK

> -271
> -143

< 100,000
< 35,000

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-11

Unit 3-4-12

PR / SRK

NOT for non ideal chemicals such as


alcohols, acids or other components.
More accurate by the Activity Models
(highly non ideal) or the PRSV EOS
(moderately non-ideal).

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-12

Unit 3-4-13

Applications

EOS

TEG Dehydration

PR

Sour Water

PR, Sour PR

Cryogenic Gas Processing

PR, PRSV

Air Separation

PR, PRSV

Atm Crude Towers

PR, PR Options, GS

Vacuum Towers

PR, PR Options,
GS <10mm Hg, Braun K10, Esso K

Ethylene Towers

Lee Kesler Plocker

High H2 Systems

PR, ZJ or GS (see T/P limits)

Reservoir Systems

PR, PR Options

Steam Systems

Steam Package, CS or GS

Hydrate Inhibition

PR

Chemical Systems

Activity Models, PRSV

HF Alkylation

PRSV, NRTL

TEG Dehydration with Aromatics

PR

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-13

Binary Interaction Parameters

Unit 3-4-14

BIPs strongly affect predicted phase equiibrium


Assuming the unknown BIPs to be zero can be dangerous
Aspen HYSYS provides over 16,000 BIPs by default
Never use UNIFAC method if experimental data available
Missing BIPs for phase equilibrium data for the binary pairs
will be obtained from a regression with the simulator
For binary pairs with no measured phase equilibria,
UNIFAC estimation for BIPs, one for VLE and the other for
LLE. Running simulation more than once with different
BIPs and with different models to judge the uncertainty of
the result is recommended.
Most of the BIPs are user modifiable, except those
receiving special treatment
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-14

Example Di-iso-Propyl-Ether/H2O Binary

Unit 3-4-15

Equimolar mixture at 1atm with BIP =0


Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-15

Unit 3-4-16

Example

Equimolar mixture at 1atm with Hysys default BIPs


Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-16

Unit 3-4-17

ACTIVITY MODELS

Apply to most chemical systems below the critical region.


NRTL (Non-Random-Two-Liquid)
Extension of Wilson equation by combining Van Laar Model.
Using statistical mechanics and liquid cell theory to represent VLE,
LLE, VLLE

UNIQUAC (UNIversal QUAsi Chemical)


Using statistical mechanics and quasi-chemical theory to give
results comparable to NRTL

Extended NRTL
Define individual activity parameters for components if boiling
range is large and VLE and LLE are to be simultaneously solved

General NRTL
Similar to Extended NRTL
Able to define equation parameters
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-17

Unit 3-4-18

Activity Models

If no BIPs are available for a given binary system, results


will be similar to an ideal solution.
The standard version of the Wilson equation can not
predict liquid-liquid immiscibility
BIPs can be estimated by UNIFAC. With caution for
result uncertainty.
Parameters regressed from VLE data are often
unreliable when used for LLE prediction ( and vice
versa).
Often ternary or higher data are not well predicted by
activity models

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-18

Unit 3-4-19

General Guideline

Wilson - generally chosen if the system


does not exhibit phase splitting.
NRTL or UNIQUAC - generally chosen if
the system exhibits phase splitting.
General NRTL - should only be used if an
abundant amount of data over a wide
temperature range was used to define its
parameters. Otherwise it will provide the
same modelling power as NRTL.

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-19

Unit 3-4-20

Recommendations

Check simulator databank for BIPs for all the binary pairs
Regression with the simulator for given equilibrium data
for binary pairs with missing BIPs
Choose UNIFAC to estimate BIPs if no measured phase
equilibria: VLE and LLE
Check ternary data for extraction or other unit operations
involving LLE or VLLE.
Compare the simulation results from different models for
uncertainty analysis
Use experimental data to verify or calibrate the model and
parameters

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-20

Unit 3-4-21

Recommended Models

Application

Margules

van Laar

Wilson

NRTL

UNIQUAC

Binary Systems

Multiple
component Systems

LA

LA

Azeotropic Systems

Liquid-Liquid
Equilibria

N/A

Dilute Systems

Self-Associating
Systems

Polymers

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Extrapolation

A: applicable; LA: Limited applications; N/A: not applicable;


? Questionable, G: Good
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-21

Unit 3-4-22

Vapour Pressure Model

Modified Antoine Model


Applicable for low pressure systems that
behave ideally

Braun K10 Model


Strictly applicable to heavy hydrocarbon
systems at low pressures

Esso K Model
Also strictly applicable to heavy hydrocarbon
systems at low pressures

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-22

Unit 3-4-23

Specialty Models

Amines Models
For modelling sour system sweetening
processes using amines (DEA, TEA, MEA,
MDEA, DGA and DIPA)

Steam Table Models


ASME Steam ASME 1967 Steam Tables
NBS Steam NBS 1984 Steam Tables

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-23

Unit 3-4-24

Y
Use G-S

General Guidelines
N
Start

T < 250 K
Y

Use P-R
or R-K-S

H2
present

Hydrocarbon
C5 or lighter

N
Use B-W-R Y
or L-K-P

Polar or
Hydrogen
bonding

Use G-S

H2
present

N
Y

P < 200 bar

0<T<750K

N
Use R-K-S

N
Y

P < 350 bar

N
Need more
experimental
data

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

Sour
Water

Use sour
water system

T < 250 K

Use G-S
or P-R

Electrolytes
N

P < 4 bar
T < 150C
Y
Use UNIFAC to
estimate
interaction
parameters

N
i
experimental
data
Y
Two
N
Liq phases
Y
Use NRTL
or UNIQUAC

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

Use
electrolyte

Use Wilson,
NRTL
or UNIQUAC
Select model that
gives best fit to
data

3-4-24

Unit 3-4-25

Hybrid Systems

Use of different models for different unit


operations
Use subflowsheet to use different fluid
packages.

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-25

Unit 3-4-26

Thermo Selection Utility

Tool to help you select of the most


appropriate thermodynamic method

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-26

Select Equipment Parameters

Unit 3-4-27

Input required by simulator


Process stream in

Outlet conditions of process stream

Heat
Exchanger

Level I Basic

Duty

Calculated
by simulator

Outlet conditions of process stream


Utility conditions
Heat transfer coefficient
Exchange effective factor

Input required
by simulator
Process stream in

Process stream out

Heat
Exchanger

Level II Design
/Performance
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

Process stream out

Duty
Heat exchange area
Utility flowrate

Calculated
by simulator

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-27

Unit 3-4-28

Level I Input

To simulation a process for mass / energy balances as


the first step, level I input only
Pumps, Compressors, and Power Recovery Turbines
Pumps: desired pressure of the fluid leaving the pump or desired
pressure increase
Compressors or turbines: desired pressure of the stream out of
the device or desired pressure increase, and mode of
compression or expansion-adiabatic, isothermal, or polytropic

Heat Exchangers
Heater or cooler: exit process stream condition, single (P, T) or
two-phase (P, VF)
Shell-tube HEX: exit conditions for both process streams.

Fired Heaters
exit process stream condition, single (P, T) or two-phase (P, VF)
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-28

Unit 3-4-29

Level I Input

Mixers and Splitters


Mixers: outlet pressure or pressure drop at the mixing point.
Pressure drop normally set as zero.
Two feed streams with different pressures, the outlet stream is
assumed to be at the lowest pressure of the feed streams
Splitter: split one stream into two or more streams with different
flow rates with identical compositions. Requiring outlet pressure
or pressure drop and relative flows of the output streams.

Valves
Outlet pressure or pressure drop

Flash Units
Single stage vapor-liquid equilibrium. For two output streams, two
parameters must be required, such as T&P, T& heat load, P &
molar ratio etc.

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-29

Unit 3-4-30

Level I Input

Absorbers & Strippers


Requiring two feeds: one at the top and the other at the bottom
Using rigorous distillation module but without condensers and
reboilers, requiring number of theoretical plates, column pressure,
and pressure drop, more to be covered in distillation column.

Liquid/Liquid extractors
Rigorous tray-by-tray module is used.
Thermodynamic model must be able to predict the presence of
two liquid phases.

Distillation columns
Reactors

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-30

Unit 3-4-31

To Be Successful

Build the unit operation model one step at


a time, get one working before the next one
Save a whole series of backups, not just
the latest version
Use meaningful names on all streams and
units
If a piece of equipment does not work
although the parameters are set correct, try
deleting the unit and reconstructing it.
Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-31

Unit 3-4-32

Summary

Inputs required for the simulator


Thermodynamics models
Input for equipment parameters

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-32

Unit 3-4-33

References

Chapter 13 (423-461)
Turton, R., Bailie, R.C.,, Whiting W.B., Shaeiwitz, J.A.
2009. Analysis, synthesis, and design of chemical
processes. 3rd edition. Prentice Hall

Copyright, The University Of Adelaide, Australia.

3025/3030/7054 Convergence

3-4-33

S-ar putea să vă placă și