Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Juel (1988).
through it. As the parts of the system are refined and developed in
proper relation to one another, each guides and reinforces the growth
of the other.
Finally, although this book is principally about developing reading
skills in young children, we must remember that the attention and
cooperation that any student invests in reading activities depends on
the degree to which her or his interests and sense of progress are
engaged. Texts and activities recommended for young children may be
wholly inappropriate for older students in content, pace, and cognitive
assumptions. Although instructional principles do not change for older
students, instructional practice must. For developing and refining the
word recognition skills of older children, computerized reading
environments might hold more promise.2 In contrast, vocationally
oriented reading instruction may be best conducted with job materials
and manuals.3 The best idea I have encountered along these lines
comes from Dorothy Strickland, who has recently proposed to help
young mothers learn about print by teaching them to read to their
babies.
Although issues of the personal relevance and accessibility of text are
beyond the scope of this book, they must always be central to our
thoughts on how to teach reading. We must also bear in mind that
skillful reading encompasses much more than mastery of the basics.
Indeed, none of us neither teachers nor students can say that we have
learned (past tense) to read. Reading is and should be a continuously
developing skill.
The body of this book is divided into six parts. The goal of this
introductory part is to place contemporary concern over reading
instruction in a broader historical and educational context. Thus chapter
2 begins with a discussion of the basic tension in any writing system
between the codability of meaning and the decodability of the code. It
includes a brief overview of the ways in which this tension has
expressed itself in the philosophies and instructional practices of
reading educators in the United States.
In part II attention is turned to the question of why phonic instruction,
in particular, is so often seen as the proper cure for children's reading
ills. Chapter 3 provides a review of experimental comparisons of the
relative effectiveness of different approaches to beginning reading
instruction. Collectively these studies suggest that, among broad
classes of programs, those that include systematic phonic instruction
generally give young readers an edge in spelling and word recognition
skills. Yet, the class of programs that purport to teach phonics is large
and varied, which leaves us wondering about the precise methods and
materials from which their general advantage derives.
The focus of chapter 4 is on studies of the extent to which successful
reading acquisition can be predicted by various measures of
prereaders' knowledge and capacities. This body of literature indicates
that familiarity of the letters of the alphabet and awareness of the
speech sounds, or phonemes, to which they correspond, are strong
predictors of the ease or difficulty with which a child learns to read.
Research reviewed later in the book confirms that letter recognition
facility and phonemic awareness are causally related to reading
acquisition and that each is prerequisite for the young reader.
Even so, a catch-22 emerges. Closer analysis indicates that children
who have learned their letters and acquired a solid level of phonemic
awareness before entering school have also begun to learn to read
before entering school. By implication, we are left with the conclusion
that the likelihood that a child will succeed in the first grade depends,
most of all, on how much she or he has already learned about reading