Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
http://www.csemag.com/single-article/classifying-generator-powersources/2e47f196b559d8fed7243956fac2436b.html?print=1
The NEC has several categories that apply to generator power sources. It is important to
review the code requirements when deciding on the classification of an alternate power
source.
Brian A. Rener, PE, LEED AP, M+W Group, Chicago
04/17/2012
The term emergency generator is often used mistakenly as a description of any type
of generator used to provide power in a facility. However, it is important that the
engineer review the code requirements when deciding on the classification of an
alternate power source. The NEC has several categories that apply to generator power
sources: emergency, legally required standby, and optional standby systems.
A newer classification, critical operations power systems (COPS) was added in the
2008 NEC. These system classifications affect how generators are applied within the
distribution system. There are big differences between these types of systems. When
communicating with code officials, it is important to use the correct termemergency
or standbyand not mix up the two, unless you have a system with both types of
loads.
Several relevant codes and standards have requirements for these classifications:
NEC Article 700 classifies emergency systems as those systems legally required and
classified as emergency by municipal, state, federal, or other coded, or by any
governmental agency having jurisdiction. The NEC further states that these systems
... automatically supply illumination, power or both essential for safety to human life.
In practical terms this normally includes providing power to egress lighting, fire
detection and protection, certain types of elevators, public safety communications, or
any system where loss of power would cause serious endangerment to life or health
within 10 secs of normal power loss.
The NEC also contains requirements for legally required standby systems in Article
701. Code-required standby systems may include communications, selected ventilation
or smoke removal systems, lighting, or certain types of industrial processes that may
create hazards or hamper firefighting operations if power was not available. The coderequired standby systems must be available within 60 secs and may be routed in the
same raceway as normal power systems.
Beyond emergency or standby systems, there are two other systems that can be
applied as generator power sources. Optional standby systems (Article 702) consist of
loads that do not affect life safety but would result in unacceptable financial or
operational losses to a facility. Typical loads could include data processing,
communication systems, refrigeration, selected HVAC loads, and manufacturing or
critical industrial processes. Second, the 2008 version of the NEC added a new section
on COPS (Article 708). These are systems, operations, or facilities designated by local,
state, or federal government as mission critical. Examples can include police or fire
stations or other facilities for reasons of public safety, national security, or business
continuity. This new section has some notable requirements for engineering practices
like commissioning, which have long been practiced in data centers and other
previously unclassified mission critical facilities.
The power factor rating of generators should also be of particular note to engineers.
Engine generators are kW limited, that is, they are rated using a 0.8 lagging power
factor. Therefore, engineers need to focus on using the kW rating as well as the kVA
rating of a generator. An additional consideration for sizing is that most engine-driven
generator sets are rated for 77 F. You must derate 0.4% for every 10 F above 77 F.
Most generator sets are rated for 3300 ft above sea level. You must derate the unit by
1.5% for every 1000 ft above that altitude.
As part of the generator sizing, voltage drop is an issue with emergency or standby
generators. Most systems can function with a 20% maximum voltage dip. However,
certain systems require less. Examples of voltage drop requirements are shown in
Table 1.
Examples of voltage drop limits for generator loads
System
Voltage drop
Fire pump controllers
<15% NEC 695.7 (A)
Elevator controllers
<15%
UPS systems
<15%
HID lighting
<20%
Variable speed drives
<20%
Courtesy: Generac
When a single alternate power source, such as a generator, is used to supply both
emergency and nonemergency loads, the system must be carefully reviewed.
Emergency and nonemergency loads are allowed to be placed on a single generator
under certain conditions. Unless the generator has the capacity to handle the full load
(including starting currents), load shedding or sequencing must be implemented on the
nonessential loads.
Power distribution requirements
normally leads engineers to specify diesel. However, dual-fuel generators may also be
considered. The amount of on-site fuel should be sufficient to provide a minimum of 2
hours of run time.
A rough rule of thumb for diesel consumption by a generator is 7 gal/hour for every 100
kW of generator capacity. In many cases where generators used, the desired run times
are much longer. It is not unusual to see 8, 24, or even 72 hours of fuel needed for
some mission critical facilities. In these cases, the engineer will need to carefully
examine where to store the fuel. Belly tanks under the generator are common, as are
separate fuel tanks. The size of these storage tanks can be very significant, and the
use of belly tanks may notably elevate the generator and require catwalks for access.
NFPA 110 7.9.5 specifies a maximum of 660 gal diesel storage inside or on the roof of
a structure.
Testing
For both emergency and legally required standby generators, testing is required. There
are two types of tests to be performed: The first is an acceptance test done upon
installation but before becoming operational. A good source for acceptance testing is
ANSI/NETA ATS-2009. The second test is operational testing to be performed
periodically, subject to the local authority, during the life of the system. NPFA 110-2010
has requirements for testing and maintenance procedures. Written records are to be
maintained for either type of system. Of note, emergency systems are required to be
tested under maximum anticipated load whereas legally required systems are
required to be tested under load.
As mentioned earlier, generators are also used in COPS defined under Article 708 of
the NEC. This section goes beyond the testing required for emergency and legally
required standby systems to require commissioning. Commissioning is a common
practice in mission critical facilities and includes component, system, baseline, and
functional performance tests.
There are notable differences between emergency and standby generators within NEC.
The engineer should be careful in using the terms, and understand the requirements,
considerations, and specifications when designing generator power systems.
Rener is manager, electrical platform leader and manager of quality assurance with
M+W Group, Chicago. He is a member of the Consulting-Specifying Engineer editorial
advisory board. This article is dedicated to his late father, Pierre J. Rener, who taught
him and many others about effective communication, dedication to ones profession,
and the importance of education and lifelong learning.