Sample Philippine Legal Forms 2015

PHILIPPINE LEGAL FORMS 2015
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PARTS OF A PLEADING
COMPLAINT AFFIDAVIT
COMPLAINT 3
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION AGAINST NON-FORUM
SHOPPING
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
JURAT 7
AFFIDAVITS 8
AFFIDAVIT OF LOSS 9
AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF FACTS ALLEGED IN MOTION11
AFFIDAVIT OF ADVERSE CLAIM
13
AFFIDAVIT OF CITIZENSHIP 15
AFFIDAVIT OF CHANGE OF MOTOR REGISTRATION
17
AFFIDAVIT OF CHANGE OF COLOR OF MOTOR VEHICLE .. 19
AFFIDAVIT OF CESSATION OF BUSINESS OPERATION
21
AFFIDAVIT OF CANCELLATION OF ENCUMBERANCE
23
AFFIDAVIT OF CANCELLATION
AFFIDAVIT OF BIRTH
25
27
AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION
29
AFFIDAVIT OF ALTERATION 30
AFFIDAVIT OF AGGREGATE LAND HOLDINGS
AFFIDAVIT OF CONSENT AND SUPPORT
34
32
AFFIDAVIT OF PARENTAL CONSENT TO MARRIAGE
AFFIDAVIT OF NO KNOWLEDGE
36
38
AFFIDAVIT OF NATURALIZATION 40
AFFIDAVIT OF RECANTATION
42
AFFIDAVIT OF INSURANCE CLAIMS
AFFIDAVIT OF INCOME
46
AFFIDAVIT OF ILLEGITIMACY
AFFIDAVIT OF IDENTITY
44
47
49
AFFIDAVIT OF EMPLOYMENT
50
1
For Public Domain. For more: Scribd | Phil Legal | Phil Forms

AFFIDAVIT OF DECLARATION OF OWNERSHIP
52
AFFIDAVIT OF CONSOLIDATION OF OWNERSHIP 54
AFFIDAVIT FOR PRELIMINARY ATTACHMENT
AFFIDAVIT OF UNDERTAKING
56
58
JOINT AFFIDAVIT OF TWO DISINTERESTED PERSONS
AFFIDAVIT OF SINGLE STATUS
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
63
65
AFFIDAVIT OF SELF- ADJUDICATION
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
67
69
AFFIDAVIT TO USE THE SURNAME OF THE
FATHER/ACKNOWLEDGMENT
71
60
CORPORATION FORMS
73
AFFIDAVIT OF NON OPERATION
NOTICE OF CALL
74
75
NOTICE OF PRE-EMPTIVE RIGHTS 76
PROXY TO VOTE
77
RESOLUTION DECLARING CASH DIVIDEND
78
UNDERTAKING TO CHANGE CORPORATION NAME
WAIVER OF PRE EMPTIVE RIGHTS 80
WAIVER TO SUBSCRIBE NEW STOCK
TREASURERS AFFIDAVIT
81
82
AFFIDAVIT OF NON OPERATION
84
ARTICLES OF LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
86
79
REAL ESTATE AND PERSONAL PROPERTY FORMS
88
AFFIDAVIT OF CONSOLIDATION OF OWNERSHIP 89
DEED OF ABSOLUTE SALE 91
EARNEST MONEY RECEIPT AGREEMENT 93
OFFER TO PURCHASE
95
DEED OF SALE (MOTOR VEHICLE) 97
DEED OF ASSIGNMENT TRANSFER OF RIGHTS
CONTRACT OF LEASE
99
101
2
CHATTEL MORTGAGE .............................................................

103
DISCHARGE OF MORTGAGE .................................................
106
PETITION FOR RESTITUTION OF TCT ........................................
108
ACTION TO REMOVE CLOUD ................................................
110
AFFIDAVIT OF ADJUDICATION BY SOLE HEIR OF ESTATE OF
DECEASED PERSON...........................................................................
112
ASSIGNMENT OF REAL ESTATE ...............................................
114
COMPLAINT FOR FORECLOSURE ..........................................
116
DEED OF PURCHASE ...............................................................
118
DEED OF SALE OF AGRICULTURAL LAND .............................
120
DEED OF SALE OF REGISTERED LAND ...................................
121
DEED OF SALE OF REGISTERED LAND WITH PACTO DE RETRO
..................................................................................................
123
DEED OF SALE OF UNREGISTERED LAND ..............................
125
DEED OF SALE WITH MORTGAGE ..........................................
127
MANIFESTATIONS / MOTIONS AND COMMENTS ...........................
129
MANIFESTATION AND MOTION TO ISSUE CERTIFICATE OF
FULL COMPLIANCE WITH CIVIL OBLIGATION .....................

130
MOTION OF REQUEST FOR OFFICIAL COPY .......................
134
MOTION FOR ALLOWANCE TO APPEAR AS AMICUS CURIAE
.............................................................................................................
136
MOTION FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS ....................................
138
MOTION FOR CONSOLIDATION OF CASES ........................
141
URGENT MOTION FOR EARLY RESOLUTION ........................
143
MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF A HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER 145 MOTION

FOR LEAVE TO SERVE SUMMONS BY PUBLICATION
..........
149
MOTNFIRPEA
SD MI SAL . . .
153
156
MOTNICAELS
PEN DS . . . .
159
MOTNICEWSFR
CO NTE MP . .
162
EX-PARTOMNI
SD MI S. . . .
165
JOINT MOTION TO DISPOSE CONJUGAL REAL PROPERTIES
............................................................................................................. 168 MOTION

TO EXERCISE VISITATION RIGHTS OF PETITIONER 172
3
MOTION TO INHIBIT 175
MOTION WITH LEAVE TO INTERVENE AND TO ADMIT
ATTACHED COMPLAINT- IN- INTERVENTION
MOTION TO LIFT ORDER OF ARREST
179
MOTION TO RELEASE MOTOR VEHICLE
182
177
MOTION TO RENDER JUDGMENT 185
MOTION FOR RE-RAFFLE AND TO SET CASE FOR
ARRAIGNMENT
188
MOTION TO RESET 192
MOTION TO REVIVE CRIMINAL ACTION AND FOR THE
ISSUANCE OF WRIT OF EXECUTION ON THE COMPROMISE
AGREEMENT 195
MOTION TO SET CASE FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE . 199
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE DEMURRER TO EVIDENCE 202
MOTION WITH NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL
CIVIL AND SPECIAL ACTION
203
207
210
COMPLAINT FOR UNLAWFUL DETAINER 211
COMPLAINT FOR EJECTMENT WITH DAMAGES 214
COMPLAINT FOR SUM OF MONEY 216
ANSWER WITH COMPULSORY COUNTERCLAIM 218
CERTIORARI 221
PROHIBITION 223
MANDAMUS 225
COMPLAINT IN INTERPLEADER
226
ACTION FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF
QUO WARRANTO
228
230
APPEAL ON CIVIL CASES
231
NOTICE OF APPEAL 232
RECORD ON APPEAL 233
PETITION FOR REVIEW ON CERTIORARI 235
APPELLANTS BRIEF 237
APPELLEES BRIEF 239
PROVISIONAL REMEDY
241
COMPLAINT WITH PRAYER FOR ATTACHMENT
242
COMPLAINT WITH PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
244
REPLEVIN
246
APPLICATION FOR REPLEVIN
248
AFFIDAVIT FOR REPLEVIN 250
COMPLAINT FOR SEPARATE SUPPORT
252
CRIMINAL ACTION / INFORMATION
254
ABDUCTION WITH CONSENT
ABDUCTION, FORCIBLE
ABORTION
255
255
260
ACTS OF LASCIVIOOUSNESS
261
ADULTERY
262
BRIBERY
263
CONCUBINAGE
264
CORRUPTION OF MINORS
265
DAMAGE TO PROPERTY THROUGH RECKLESS IMPRUDENCE
266
ESTAFA
269
HOMICIDE
270
HOMICIDE THROUGH ABORTION 271
LIBEL 272
MALVERSATON
MURDER
276
275
PARRICIDE
277
PHYSICAL INJURIES 280
ROBERRY
283
THEFT 284
SEDITON
285
QUALIFIED TRESPASS TO DWELLING
CRIMINAL PROCEEDING
286
287
MOTION TO RELEASE CASH BAIL BOND 288
AFFIDAVIT OF DESISTANCE 289
AFFIDAVIT OF DESISTANCE THEFT291
AFFIDAVIT OF DESISTANCE VIOLATION OF BP 22 293
COMMENT ON FORMAL OFFER OF EVIDENCE
PRE-TRIAL BRIEF
298
LABOR CASES
301
POSITION PAPER
302
REPLY 318
REJOINDER
325
MEMORANDUM
CERTIORARI 353
333
295
6
PARTSOFAPLEADING
7
For Public Domain. For more: Scribd | Phil Legal | Phil
Forms
FORMNO.1:COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
RepublicofthePhilippines)
____________,________)s.s.xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
The
UNDERSIGNED,__________________________,accuses
_________,of_____________,committedasfollows,towit:
Thatonorabout_________,atabout_____________inthe
_________________,______________,Philippines,thesaidaccuseddid
thenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,feloniously,andbymeansof
_____________,committed_____________,upontheundersigneddirectly
byovertactstowit:(statethedetailshowthecrimewascommitted).
Theundersignedexecutedthisaffidavittoattestthetruthfulnessofthe
foregoingfactsandtosupportthefilingofCriminalCasesagainst
_______________________________ for
violations
of
________________________.
___________,this_____dayof__________,____.
____________________________
OffendedParty
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis___dayof_______
at_______________.IHEREBYCERTIFYthatIhavepersonallyexamined
8
thehereinoffendedpartyandIamsatisfiedthattheyvoluntarilyexecutedand
understoodtheirgivenaffidavit.
_______________________
Prosecutor
WITNESSES
FORMNO.2:COMPLAINT
(CaptionandTitle)
COMPLAINT
,MOSTRESPECTFULLYSTATESTHAT;COMESNOW,theplaintiff
togetherwiththeundersignedcounseltothismosthonorablecourt
1.
ThePlaintiffisoflegalage,marriedandaresidentof
_______________________.TheDefendantislikewiseoflegalage,marriedand
temporaryresidingat_____________________
ThePlaintiffistheownerofthetwostoreyhouseunitlocatedatthePetersville
Subdivision,BaguioCity,andhavingtheresidentialaddressofPV123as
evidencedbypertinentdocumentsliketaxdeclarationanddeedofsale.
(EXHIBITA)
TheDefendantisthelesseeofthehouseunitthatisownedbythePlaintiffas
evidencedbythewrittencontractofleasethatbothpartiessigned.(ExhibitB)
ThePlaintiffandtheDefendantcameupwithawrittenagreementofLeaseon
June26,2007,whichtheybothagreeduponandwasdulysignedbythetwo
partiesasshownintheircontractoflease.(ExhibitB)
ItemNo.16ofthecontractwhichthedefendantsignedexpresslyprovidesthathe
willonlybeoccupyingthepropertyforone(1)year,afterwhich,hewillvacate
thehousewhenthattermexpires.(ExhibitB)
Thecontractalsoprovidesthatthedefendantshouldalsotakecareoftheproperty
anditspremiseswiththeutmostdiligence.
OnJune28,2008,theplaintiff,afterreturningfromJapan,wassurprisedto
discoverthatthedefendantdidnotvacatethepropertyasheexpected.Worse,
9
heinstalledasarisaristoreintheoriginalbuildingstructureofthehouseunit.
Theplaintiffconfrontedthedefendantaboutitbutthedefendantclaimedthatit
wasaDEEDOFSALEwhichtheysignedandnotaCONTRACTOF
LEASEandtherefore,thedefendantisthenewownerofthehouseunit.
OnAugust20,2008,aftercontinuousdemands,thedefendantconstantlyrefuses
tovacatethehouseunitandeveninvitedrelativestostaywithhim.
Thedefendantwillfullyandmaliciouslyviolatedtheagreementwhichthey
mutuallyagreedupon,andwhichthedefendantsigned.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itismostrespectfullyprayedofthis
HonorableCourtthatjudgementberenderedinfavoroftheplaintiffandthatafter
judgement;
Thedefendantshallvacatethehouseunitownedbytheplaintiff.
ThedefendantshallbeorderedtopayP120,000fortheAttorneysFees.
Suchotherreliefsandremediesunderthepremisesarelikewiseprayed
for.
_________________,Philippines,this____dayof_________20__.
______________________
CounselforthePlaintiff
PTRNo.18909595:10407:B.C.IBPNo,693095:10407:B.C.
RollNo.42481:51097:ManilaRm.42/FBaguioBoatingCenter180Burnham
Lake,BaguioCity
10
FORMNO.3:VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONOFNON
FORUMSHOPPING
VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONOFNONFORUM
SHOPPING
I,_______________________,oflegalage,afterhavingbeendulyswornin
accordancewithlaw,deposeandstatethat:
Iamaplaintiffintheabovestatedcase;
Icausedthepreparationoftheforegoingcomplaint;
Ihavereadthecontentsthereofandthefactsstatedthereinaretrueand
correctofmypersonalknowledgeand/oronthebasisofcopiesofdocuments
andrecordsinmypossession;
Ihavenotcommencedanyotheractionorproceedinginvolvingthesame
issuesintheSupremeCourt,theCourtofAppeals,oranyothertribunalor
agency;
Tothebestofmyknowledgeandbelief,nosuchactionorproceedingis
pendingintheSupremeCourt,theCourtofAppeals,oranyothertribunalor
agency;
IfIshouldthereafterlearnthatasimilaractionorproceedinghasbeenfiledor
ispendingbeforetheSupremeCourt,theCourtofAppeals,oranyother
tribunaloragency,Iundertaketoreportthatfactwithinfive(5)days
therefromtothisHonorableCourt.
___________________________
Affiant
11
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis___dayof
__________200_at_________________affiantexhibitingtomehis
CommunityTaxCertificateNo.____________________issuedon
________________
200_
at
______________
Doc.No.;
PageNo.;
BookNo.;
Seriesof20__.
FORMNO.4:ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES)
CITY/MUNICIPALITYOF______)SS.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
City.
BEFOREME,aNotaryPublicforandinthe(Province/City/Municipality)of
_____________,personallyappeared_____________withCommunityTax
CertificateNo._____________issuedon_____________at_____________
(andTaxIdentificationNo.(T.I.N.)_____________),knowntomeandtome
knowntobethesamepersonwhoexecutedtheforegoinginstrumentwhich
(he/she)acknowledgedtomeas(his/her)freeandvoluntaryactanddeed,
consistingofonly______(____)page/s,includingthispageinwhichthis
Acknowledgementiswritten,dulysignedby(him/her)and(his/her)
instrumentalwitnessesoneachandeverypagehereof.
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEALthis_____________at_____________,
Philippines.
NOTARYPUBLIC
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof______;
12
FORMNO.5:JURAT
JURAT
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforeme,this_____________dayof
______________,
in
the
__________________, by
City
of
___________________withPassportNo.________________issuedon
__________________at_____________.
NotaryPublic
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof______;
13
AFFIDAVITS
14
For Public Domain. For more: Scribd | Phil Legal |
Phil Forms
FORMNO.1:AFFIDAVITOFLOSS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFLOSS
I,ELLENA.ADARNA,messengerofRaphaelEnriqueV.Coronado,ofLegal
Age,Filipino,Married,bornonwithresidentialaddressat316PalinSt.,Block
27,Lot77,AiAi,GeneralTinio,GMA,Cavite,subscribingunderoath,hereby
deposeandstate:
ThatabovementionedistheplaintiffinthecaseofSpousesCoronadovs
PorntakersIndustryCorporationfiledintheRegionalTrialCourtofImusCity,
Cavite,Branch22,forAnnulmentofTitlewithDamages;
15
Plaintiffisentitledtothereliefdemandedinthecomplaintinwholeorinpart
andsuchotherreliefconsistsinrestrainingthecommissionorcontinuanceof
theactscomplainedofeitherforalimitedperiodorperpetually;
Thecommissionorcontinuanceoftheactscomplainedofduringthelitigation
willworkinjurytohereinplaintiffandthatthedefendantisdoing,threatens,or
isabouttodo,orisprocuringorsufferingtobedonetheactstendingtorender
thejudgmentineffectual;
Thatplaintiffiswillingandreadytofileabondintheamountwhichmaybe
fixedbytheCourttotheeffectthathe,theplaintiff,willpaythedefendantall
thedamageswhichthelattermaysustainbyreasonoftheinjunctionifthecourt
shouldfinallydecidethattheplaintiffwasnotentitledthereto.
ELLENA.ADARNA
Affiant
________________________________________
________________________________________
BEFOREME,appearsthepersonofELLENA.ADARNApresentingthe
aboveAffidavit,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedbymethrough
competentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarialRulesastheperson
whosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathoraffirmationbefore
meastosuchdocument.
16
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEALthis8thdayofJanuary,2014inImus
City,Cavite
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.2:AFFIDAVITINSUPPORTOFFACTSALLEGEDIN
MOTION
RepublicofthePhilippines
CityofPuertoPrincesa )s.s.
AFFIDAVITINSUPPORTOFFACTSALLEGEDINMOTION
I,RUBENR.PADILLA,oflegalageandwithresidenceatBlk1,Lot1,
Brgy.StaMonica,PuertoPrincesaCity,havingbeendulysworn,deposeand
say:
ThatI,RUBENR.PADILLA,marriedandoflegalage,currentlyworkingas
ananalystatthePalawanDiagnosticLaboratory,PuertoPrincesaCity,
Palawan.
ThatIpersonallyknowthatthepersonnamedhereininthecomplaintandthe
personwhomIpersonallyknowareoneandthesameperson.
17
ThatheismyclassmateinHighschool,andafriendofmine.
RUBENR.PADILLA
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNTOBEFOREME,ANotarypublicinand
fortheCityofPuertoPrincesaandtheProvinceofPalawanthis3 rddayof
November2013.AffiantpersonallycameandappearedwithDriversLicense
IDNo.D11125477issuedbytheLandTransportationOfficeandvaliduntil
May1,2015,atPuertoPrincesaCity,bearinghisphotographandsignature,
knowntomeasthesamepersonwhopersonallysignedtheforegoing
instrumentbeforemeandavowedunderpenaltyoflawtothewholetruthof
thecontentsofsaidinstrument
ATTY.PERCIVAL
JAMESL.
LACEBAL
NotaryPublicMycommissionexpires
onDecember31,2011
PTRNo.906760issuedJan.3,2007IBPNo.918300RollNo.13466
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof2013;
18
FORMNO.3:AFFIDAVITOFADVERSECLAIM
CITYOFMAKATI
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFADVERSECLAIM
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,singleandaresidentof2223
WashingtonStreet,PiodelPilar,MakatiCity,afterhavingbeendulyswornto
inaccordancewithlaw,deposeandstate:
ThatonJuly10,2013,IhaveenteredintoaDeedofConditionalSalewhich
wasacknowledgedonthesamedatebeforeNotaryPublicJuanTamadof
MakatiCityandenteredinhisNotarialRegisterasDoc.No.2,Page2,Book
II,Seriesof2013.
AcopyofthesaidDeedisheretoattachedasANNEXAandmadean
integralpartofthisAffidavit;
19
ThatinthesaidDeedofConditionalSale,IwastheVENDEEofacertain
parceloflandcoveredbyTransferCertificateofTitleNo.111222,more
particularlydescribedasfollows:
(TechnicalDescriptionofProperty)
ThatbecauseIstillhaveabalanceonthepurchasepriceintheamountof
P500,000.00whichispayablewithinone(1)(year)fromthedateofsigning
thereof,itwasstipulatedintheaforementionedDeedthattitleandownership
overthesubjectpropertywillonlybetransferreduponfullpaymentofthe
same;
ThattheVENDORinthesaidDeedofConditionalSaleagreedthatuponits
execution,saidDeedshallbeannotatedintheTitlewiththeOfficeofthe
RegisterofDeedsofMakatiCity;
However,sincethesaidDeedofConditionalSalepersecouldnotbe
annotatedontheTitlewiththeOfficeoftheRegisterofDeeds,Iamtherefore
executingthisAffidavitforthepurposeofattestingtothetruthfulnessofthe
foregoingallegationsandinsupportofmyrequestfortheannotationofan
adverseclaimovertheparceloflandcoveredbytheTransferCertificateof
TitleNo.111222.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis27THdayof
January2014inMakatiCity,MetroManila,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
WithPhilippinePassportNo.123456
SUBCRIBEDANDSWORNTObeforemethis27THdayofJanuary2014in
MakatiCity,MetroManila,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomeher
PhilippinePassportNo.123456issuedinManilaonJanuary12,2012and
validuntilJanuary12,2017.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
20
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.4:AFFIDAVITOFCITIZENSHIP
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCITIZENSHIP
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,respectively,andpresentlyresiding
atBlk55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeenduly
sworntoinaccordancewithlaw,deposeandstate:
IamaFilipinoCitizenfrombirthuntilthepresent.
On09June1979,mysonROCCOSIFFREDIwasborninBrussels,
Belguium.
21
ROCCOSIFFREDIisalsoaFilipinoCitizenpursuanttotheprovisionsofthe
1987PhilippineConstitution.
AtthetimeofbirthofROCCOSIFFREDI,bothhisparents,were,andstillis,
FilipinoCitizens.
IthereforehaveexecutedthisAffidavittoattesttothetruthImentioned
hereinandforwhateverlegalpurposesitmayserve.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis3rddayof
February2014inImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
SUBCRIBEDANDSWORNTObeforemethis3rddayofFebruary2014in
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehervalidproofof
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
22
FORMNO.5:AFFIDAVITOFCHANGEOFMOTOR
REGISTRATION
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCHANGEOFMOTORREGISTRATION
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,married,andpresentlyresidingat
Blk55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulysworn
toinaccordancewithlaw,deposeandstate:
Iamtheownerofacertainregisteredmotorvehicle,whichIinheritedfrom
mydeceasedfatherthroughintestatesuccession,withtheparticular
descriptionasfollows,towit:
23
MAKE:
Honda
BODY:
Sedan
SERIES:
Civic
MODEL:
1998
PLATENO.:
UTS101
Serial/ChassisNo.:
US152B3509
MVFILENo.:
247733438
However,itsmotorparthasbeenrecentlyjunked,andinitssteadwasreplaced
byMotorNo.C240300014.
IthereforehaveexecutedthisAffidavittoattestthetruthImentionedherein
andforwhateverlegalpurposesitmayserve.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis30thdayof
January2014inImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
PhilippinePassportNo.123456
validuntilJanuary13,2018
SUBCRIBEDANDSWORNTObeforemethis30thdayofJanuary2014in
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehercompetent
evidenceofidentityindicatedbelowhisabovestatedname.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
24
FORMNO.6:AFFIDAVITOFCHANGEOFCOLOROFMOTOR
VEHICLE
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCHANGEOFCOLOROFMOTORVEHICLE
25
MAKE:
Honda
BODY:
Sedan
SERIES:
Civic
MODEL:
1998
PLATENO.:
UTS101
Serial/ChassisNo.:
US152B3509
MVFILENo.:
247733438
Irecentlychangedthecolorofthesaidmotorvehiclefromcolorbluetopink.
3.
IthereforehaveexecutedthisAffidavittocausethenecessary
changesintheregistrationoftheabovementionedvehicleintheLand
TransportationOffice,toattestthetruthImentionedhereinandforwhatever
legalpurposesitmayserve.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Doc.No._____;
26
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.7:AFFIDAVITOFCESSATIONOFBUSINESS
OPERATION
CityofImus
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCESSATIONOFBUSINESSOPERATION
27
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,married,Filipino,andpresentlyresidingatBlk
55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulysworntoin
accordancewithlaw,doherebydeposeandsay:
ThatIamtheSoleProprietorofXHamsterPetShoplocatedatLot67
CaloocanBusinessPark,CaloocanCity;
ThatsaidbusinessisregisteredwiththeBureauofInternalRevenue(BIR)on
January16,2011withCertificateofRegistrationOCNNo.18999811;
ThatIamapplyingfortheterminationofthebusinesseffectivelyonJanuary30,
2014becauseIamabouttomigratetotheUnitedStates;
Thatthebusinesshasnooutstandingliabilityandobligation;
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavittoattesttothetruthofalltheforegoing
statementsandforwhateverlegalpurposeitmayserve.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis____dayof27th
dayofJanuary,2014atImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis27THdayofJanuary2014in
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,his/hercompetentevidenceofidentitybyway
of_______________issuedat
___________on________________.
DocNo.:_____
PageNo.:______
BookNo.:______
Seriesof2014.
28
FORMNO.8:AFFIDAVITOFCANCELLATIONOF
ENCUMBERANCE
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCANCELLATIONOFENCUMBRANCE
29
Forms
IamtheregisteredownerofaparceloflandsituatedinTagaytayCity,with
TransferCertificateofTitleNo.T73879oftheRegistryofDeedsfor
TagaytayCity.
Itwasannotatedinthepreviouscertificateoftitle,whichwascopiedfromthe
certificateoftitleinmyname,PursuanttoSec.8ofRepublicActNo.26,
thiscertificateoftitleiswithoutprejudicetoanypartywhoserightorinterest
inthepropertywasdulynotedontheoriginalofthereconstitutedcertificate
oftitleRT5(130a1337)atthetimeitwaslostordestroyed.
Fromthetimeoftheencumbrancewasdulyannotated,morethantwo
(2)yearshavealreadylapsedsincethetitlewastransferredinmyname.
Thus,ascanbededucedfromtheforegoing,thecancellationofthesaid
encumbranceiswarrantedandisinorder.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
30
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.9:AFFIDAVITOFCANCELLATION
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCANCELLATION
31
IampresentlyengagedinabusinessunderthenameandstyleofPrime
ChooseConsultancyServices.
Thebusinessisnowaimingforexpansionandisnowattractingother
investorsintheprocess.
Toprotectalltheinvestorswhoareputtingnotaninconsiderableamountof
capital,theplanistochangethepresentbusinessorganizationfromsole
proprietorshiptoincorporation.
Thusinsodoing,thecancellationofthebusinessregistrationinthe
DepartmentofTradeandIndustryisnowproperlycalledfor.
Inchangingthepresentorganizationalsetup,nocreditorswillbeprejudiced
becausethebusinesshasnoobligationarisingfromcontract,othermonetary
claimsandsourcesofobligation.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
32
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.10:AFFIDAVITOFBIRTH
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
33
AFFIDAVITOFBIRTH
IwasbornonFebruary15,1990,inAguy,Iloilo,tospousesMarcBlazerand
NikkiBenz;
Thisissupportedbynumerousauthenticdocumentsattachedinthisaffidavit;
andIherebycertifythattheforegoingstatementsarecorrect.
IthereforehaveexecutedthisAffidavittoattestthetruthImentionedhereinand
forwhateverlegalpurposesitmayserve.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehercompetentevidenceof
identityindicatedbelowhisabovestatedname.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
34
FORMNO.11:AFFIDAVITOFAUTHORIZATION
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
35
Phil Forms
AFFIDAVITOFAUTHORIZATION
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,single,andpresentlyresidingatBlk
55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulyswornto
IamtheownerofacertainparceloflandinthesubdivisioninTagaytayCity
knownasBlock1,Lot3whichisbeingdevelopedbyDoroteaville
DeveloperCorporation.
ThroughthisAffidavit,IherebyauthorizeMr.CedricLeenotonlytouseand
possessthesaidpropertybutalsotocontinuepayingitintheeventthereare
stillbalancestobepaidtothedeveloper,andhaveitconsequentlyregistered
inhisname.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomeherPhilippine
PassportNo.123456issuedinManilaonJanuary12,2014andvaliduntil
January13,2018.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO12:AFFIDAVITOFALTERATION
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
36
AFFIDAVITOFALTERATION
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,single,andpresentlyresidingatBlk
55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulyswornto
AsAssistantTreasureroftheSalinasElectricalCompanyInc.,Iissuedin
suchcapacitytheChargeInvoiceNo.7095dated06July2009totheManila
ElectricCompany;
However,thefirstdigitintheserialnumberofthesaidChargeInvoice,which
wasnumberseven(7),appearedtobeunclearandthusunreadable;
Toremedytheproblem,icausedthesuperimpositionofsuchfirstdigitwith
nootherpurposethantomakeitcleartotheperson/sconcernedorinwhose
favourthesamewasissued;
Thesamewasdoneingoodfaithandfornootherreasonthantodirectly
addresstheproblemandpursuanttothepurposestatedintheimmediately
precedingparagraph.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
37
January13,2018.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.13:AFFIDAVITOFAGGREGATELANDHOLDINGS
38
CITYOFILOILO
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFAGGREGATELANDHOLDINGS
I,NANAOGUYA,oflegalage,Filipina,marriedandaresidentofBalabago,
Jaro,IloiloCity,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordancewithlaw,
deposeandstate:
ThatIamtheVENDEEofaparceloflandlocatedatBrgy.Fooday,Miagao,
IloilowithanareaofTWENTYTHOUSANDTWOHUNDRED(20,200)
squaremeters,moreorless,coveredbyOriginalCertificateofTitleNo.
54321;
Thatasidefromtheabovementionedparcelofland,Idonotownanyagricultural
landinMiagao,IloilooranywhereinthePhilippines;
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavittoattesttothetruthoftheforegoingfacts
andforwhateverlegalintentsandpurposesthatitmaylegallyserve;
January2014inIloiloCity,MetroManila,Philippines.
NANAOGUYA
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
IloiloCity,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehisvalidproofof
identification.
39
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.14:AFFIDAVITOFCONSENTANDSUPPORT
40
Forms
)s.s.
AFFIDAVITOFCONSENTANDSUPPORT
I,RAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO,oflegalage,Filipino,married
toEllenA.Adarna,andpresentlyresidingatBlk.5,Lt.20,NarraHomes,
ImusCity,Cavite,afterbeingdulysworntoinaccordancewithlawdohereby
deposeandsay:
ThatIamthefatherofminorchildrenMARIOMAURERCORONADO
bornonDecember4,1996,B.JOHNLLOYDCORONADO,bornon09
February1998,andC.KATHRINEBERNARDOCORONADO,bornon28
September1999;
ThatIamgivingmyconsentformychildrentotravelabroadtobe
accompaniedbymywife,EllenA.Adarna;
ThatmywifeandIaresponsoringtheirtripandfinanciallycapabletosupport
theirstayabroad;
ThatIguaranteethattheywillnotviolateanyexistinglawsoftheircountryof
destination(FRANCE)and
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavitinconnectionwithmychildrenapplication
forapassportattheDepartmentofForeignAffairsand/ortravelclearance
fromtheDepartmentofSocialWelfareandDevelopmentfortheirtravel
abroad.
INWITNESSHEREOF,Ihereuntosetmysignatureatthe
___________________,this______dayof__________________.
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO
Affiant(Father)
________________________
________________________
________________________
41
BEFOREME,appearsthepersonofRaphaelEnriqueV.Coronado
presentingtheaboveAffidavit,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentified
bymethroughcompetentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarial
Rulesasthepersonwhosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoath
oraffirmationbeforemeastosuchdocument.
WITNESS
MYHANDANDSEALthis______dayof
________________in______________________.
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.___;
Seriesof2013.
42
FORMNO.15:AFFIDAVITOFPARENTALCONSENTTO
MARRIAGE
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFPARENTALCONSENTTOMARRIAGE
WE,SASHAGREYandRONJEREMY,bothoflegalage,Filipinos,
husbandandwife,respectively,andpresentlyresidingatBlk55,Lot66,
IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulysworntoin
accordancewithlaw,deposeandstate:
Iam/wearetheparentsofRoccoSiffrediborninbornon18October1998in
GracePark,CaloocanCity
My/OurchildisintendingtocontractmarriagewithNanaOguyain
Meycauayan,Bulacan;
Iwearegivingourconsenttoourchild,RoccoSiffredi,marryingsaidNana
Oguya;
WeareexecutingthisAffidavitforthepurposeofinformingtheauthorities
concernedoftheveracityoftheforegoingfactsandforwhateverlegal
purposesitmayserve.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,wehavehereuntosetourhandsthis27thdayof
January,2014inImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant(Mother)
RONJEREMY
Affiant(Father)
43
January13,2018.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
44
FORMNO.16:AFFIDAVITOFNOKNOWLEDGE
IMUSCITY,CAVITE )S.S
AFFIDAVITOFNOKNOWLEDGE
(CIRCUMSTANCESREGARDINGPLACEANDLOCATIONOF
GRANDPARENTSMARRIAGE)
I,SASHAGREYoflegalage,Filipinowithblk.12lt.1,TalisaySt.,Ibarra
HomesSubdivision,KalayaanUno,ImusCity,Cavite,4103,afterhaving
beendulysworntoinaccordancewithlaw,doherebydeposeandsay:
ThatIamtheonlychildofFIFTYandSHADESGREY,bothnowdeceased.
IamcurrentlyrequestingforthelateregistrationoftheBirthCertificateof
FIFTYGREY,whosemaidennamewasFIFTYCENTS,whoisthedaughter
ofOneandTwoCents,intheCivilRegistrarOfficeinImusCity,Cavite.
ThatwearecausingitsregistrationforthereasonthatIamintheprocessof
claimingmymotherssurvivorshipclaimsinGSIS.
Thatoneoftherequirementsforthesaidlateregistrationisthedetermination
ofthelocationanddateofmymaternalgrandparents,whichunfortunately
cannotberetrievedanymorebecausethemarriagecertificateofmymaternal
grandparentsgotlost.
45
ThatIhavenoknowledgeofanycircumstancesregardingthemarriageofmy
maternalgrandparents,astheydiedwhenIwasstillyoung,andthushadno
clearrecollectionofthem.
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavittoattestthetruthoftheforegoingfactsand
forwhateverlegalpurposeitmayserve.
AFFIANTSFURTHERSAYETHNOT.
January2014atImusCity,Cavite.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
EmploymentSRUDCIDno.1132014
BEFOREME,appearsthepersonof:
SASHAGREY
presentingtheaboveJOINTAFFIDAVITOFNOKNOWLEDGE,whoare
personallyknowntomeoridentifiedbymethroughcompetentevidenceof
identityasdefinedbytheNotarialRulesasthepersonswhosignthedocument
andinmypresencetakenanoathoraffirmationbeforemeastosuchdocument.
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis6thdayofJanuary2014at
ImusCity,Cavite.
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
46
BookNo.______;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.17:AFFIDAVITOFNATURALIZATION
CITYOFBACOOR
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFNATURALIZATION
I,JAMAICAMAYDELACRUZ,Filipino,oflegalage,single,residingat
194Salinas,CityofBacoor,Cavite,afterbeingsworntoinaccordancewith
law,deposesandsay:
ThatIamthevendeeinthesaleoftheabovedescribedprivateagricultural
land;
ThatIamnaturalizedcitizenofthePhilippinesbyvirtueofafinaldecisionof
theRTCImusBranchonFebruary,251990;
thatacertifiedcopyofmycertificateofnaturalizationisheretoattachedas
AnnexA;
ThatIamqualifiedtoacquireandholdpublicandprivatelandsinthe
Philippines.
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavitinallgoodfaithandtoattestthetruthofthe
foregoingfacts.
January,2014,intheCityofBacoor,CavitePhilippines
JAMAICAMAYDELACRUZ
Affiant
47
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis18thdayofJanuary,2014,in
theCityofBacoor,CavitePhilippines,affianthavingexhibitedtomehisLicense
No.3790682issueduntilJuly29,2016.
Doc.No.:________;
PageNo.:________;
BookNo.:________;
Seriesof2014.
48
FORMNO.18:AFFIVITOFLOSS
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES))S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFLOSS
I,ELLENA.ADARNA,ofLegalAge,Filipino,Married,bornonwith
residentialaddressat316PalinSt.,Block27,Lot77,AiAi,GeneralTinio,
GMA,Cavite,subscribingunderoath,herebydeposeandstate:
ThatIamtheholderofavalidPhilippinePassportissuedbytheDepartmentof
ForeignAffairs;
ThatlastDecember23,2012,Iplacedtheaforesaidpassportinsidemybag
whileIamattheCentral,Commonwealth,QuezonCity;
ThatwhenIlookedforthepassportinsidemybag,Icouldno
longerlocateit;
Thatmysaidpassportcouldnotbefoundnotwithstandingdiligenteffortsto
locatethesameandisnowconsideredlostforalllegalintentsandpurposes;
49
ThatIcertifythisoathtoreportthelossofmyPhilippinePassportissuedby
theDepartmentofForeigntoavoidthesaidmissingpassportfrombeingused
forillegalpurposesbyotherpersons;
ThatIexecutethisaffidavittoattesttothetruthofalltheforegoingfactsand
forsecuringanewPhilippinepassport.
Affiantfurthersaysnone.
ELLENA.ADARNA
Affiant
________________________________________
________________________________________
aboveAffidavit,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedbymethrough
whosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathoraffirmation
beforemeastosuchdocument.
City,Cavite
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
50
FORMNO.19:AFFIDAVITOFINSURANCECLAIMS
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFINSURANCECLAIMS
MAKE:
Honda
BODY:
Sedan
SERIES:
Civic
MODEL:
1998
PLATENO.:
UTS101
Serial/ChassisNo.:
US152B3509
MVFILENo.:
247733438
On03October2013at2olockintheafternoon,thesaidmotorvehiclemet
anaccident.
Thishadhappenedwhileiwasparkinginfrontofahardwarestorebetweenthe
twomotorvehicles,attheleftsidewasanelfvan,andwhileattherightwasa
car.Atthattime,Iwascarefullylookingatthe
51
caronmyright,thatIdidnotnoticetheelfvanintheparkingarea.WhenI
madeareverseturn,ihittheelfbymytaillightandbumper
Itisforthatreasonthatiamexecutingthisaffidavittofileaclaimfor
insurance.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
52
FORMNO.20:AFFIDAVITOFINCOME
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFINCOME
Ihavebeenengagedinthebusinessofsellingmerchandise.
ThebusinessisnowfirmlyestablishedeversinceIhavestarteditacoupleof
yearsago.
Havingbeenengagedinthisbusinessforalongtime,Ialreadyhavebeen
earningincomeintheamountofapproximatelyTHIRTYTHOUSAND
PESOS(PHP30,000.00)amonth.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
53
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.21:AFFIDAVITOFILLEGITIMACY
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFILLEGITIMACY
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,singleandaresidentofBlk55,Lot
66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulysworntoin
ThatIamathemotherofRoccoSiffrediwhowasborninDavaoCityon
October5,2006asevidencedbytheattachedBirthCertificateissuedbythe
localcivilregistrarofDavaoCity;
ThatmysonRoccoSiffrediwasbornoutofwedlock;
ThatIamnotlegallymarriedtohisfatherwhoInolongerhaveanycontact
with;
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavittoattesttotheabovefactsandtoconfirm
theillegitimatestatusofmychild;
ThatIamfurtherexecutingthisaffidavittocomplywiththeregulationsofthe
PhilippineauthoritiesinconnectionwithhistraveltoJapanandforalllegal
purposesandintentsbeneficialtomychild.
54
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
55
FORMNO.21:AFFIDAVITOFIDENTITY
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFIDENTITY
I,SASHAGREY,Filipino,oflegalage,single/marriedtoRONJEREMY,
andaresidentofBlk55,Lot66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhaving
beendulysworninaccordancewithlaw,herebydeposeandsay:
ThatVHONGHNAVARROandBONGNABAROareoneandthesame
person.
ThatIexecutedthisAffidavitofIdentityforthepurposeofattestingtothe
truthofalltheforegoingstatementsandforwhateverlegalpurposeitmay
serve.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntoaffixedmysignaturethis27th
dayofJanuary2014inImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
56
AFFIANT
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehisPhilippinePassport
No.123456issuedinManilaonJanuary12,2014andvaliduntilJanuary13,
2018.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.22:AFFIDAVITOFDESISTANCE
FourthJudicialRegion
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Branch21,ImusCity,Cavite
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES,
Complainant,
versus CRIMINALCASENO.993511
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
AFFIDAVITOFDESISTANCE
I,OGSABADO,oflegalage,Filipinowithpostaladdressatc/oImelda
Bautista448C,YOLOStreet,Pinasgsukuan,PasayCity,afterhavingduly
sworntoinaccordancewithlaw,herebydeposeandstate:
1.ThatIamtheprivatecomplainantoftheaboveentitledcriminalcomplaint
thatisnowpendingatBranch21,ImusCity,Cavite;
57
2.Thatafterhavingthoroughlyconsideredthefactsandcircumstances
surroundingthecase,Irealizedthatthecasefiledagainsttherespondentswas
merelyonaccountofmisunderstandingandmisapprehensionofthefactsand
Iamrequestingforthedismissalofthecaseagainsthim;
Thatfortherecord,Iamnolongerinterestedinprosecutingthiscaseandwill
furtherdesistingtherefrom;
IamexecutingthisAffidavitofDesistancewithoutForce,Intimidation,
UndueInfluenceofthreatsexerteduponmeandtothebestofmyknowledge
andability,andrealizesthatoncethechargeisdismissed,thesamecannotbe
refilled,reinstateorrevivedanymore.
Further,IexecutingthisAffidavitofDesistancetoattesttothetruthfulnessof
alltheforegoingfactsandforthepurposeofsecuringadismissalofthe
aboveentitledcriminalcomplaintagainsttherespondent.
January,2014atTemporaryVillage,ImusCity.
OGSABADO
Affiant
____________________
_____________________
SWORNATTESTATION
BEFOREME,appearsthepersonofOGSABADOpresentingtheabove
AffidavitofDesistance,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedbyme
throughcompetentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarialRulesasthe
personwhosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathor
affirmationbeforemeastosuchdocument.
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEALthis9thdayofJanuary2014inImusCity.
58
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.23:AFFIDAVITOFDECLARATIONOFOWNERSHIP
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFDECLARATIONOFOWNERSHIP
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,single,ManagerofRubinzons
Corporation,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordancewithlaw,depose
andstate:
ThatsaidCorporationistheownerofcertainparcelofland,moreparticularly
describedasfollows:
TCTNo.T2222
APARCELOFLAND(Lot32oftheconsolidationsubdivisionplan(LRC)
Pcs5141,beingaportionoftheconsolidationofLots1and2,Psu112287
Amd.,LRC(GLRO)Rec.No.N17511),situatedintheDist.OfConcepcion,
CityofSta.Rosa,Laguna,IslandofLuzon.BoundedontheNE.,points3to6,
byLot85;
59
ontheS.,points6to1byLot30;ontheSW.,points1to2,byLot31;andon
theN.,points2to3byLot35,alloftheconsolidationsubdivisionplan.
Beginningatapontmarked"1"onplan,beingN.51deg.36'E.,1321.76m.
fromB.L.L.M.No.1,Sta.Rosa,Laguna
ThatthesaidaforementionedTransferCertificateofTitleoversaidproperty
includesandcontainsallthepermanentimprovementsandbuildingslocated
andsituatedthereon;
ThatIexecutethisAffidavittoattestanddeclarethetruthoftheforegoing
factsandforwhateverlegalpurposesthatthisAffidavitmayserve.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
ImusCity,Cavite,Philippines,affiantexhibitingtomehisPhilippinePassport
No.123456issuedinManilaonJanuary12,2014andvaliduntilJanuary13,
2018.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
60
FORMNO.24:AFFIDAVITOFCONSOLIDATIONOFOWNERSHIP
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFCONSOLIDATIONOFOWNERSHIP
I,SASHAGREY,oflegalage,Filipino,singleandaresidentofBlk55,Lot
66,IbarraHomes,Tulingan,Cavite,afterhavingbeendulysworntoin
1.ThatinthepublicauctionconductedbytheCitySheriffofMakatiCityon
September3,2012pursuanttotheprovisionsofActNo.3135asamended,
theundersignedaffiantbecamethepurchaserofacertainforeclosedproperty
withallitsimprovements,moreparticularlydescribedasfollows:
TCTNo.T2222
APARCELOFLAND(Lot32oftheconsolidationsubdivisionplan(LRC)Pcs
5141,beingaportionoftheconsolidationofLots1and2,Psu112287Amd.,
LRC(GLRO)Rec.No.N17511),situatedintheDist.OfConcepcion,CityofSta.
Rosa,
61
Laguna,IslandofLuzon.BoundedontheNE.,points3to6,byLot85;onthe
S.,points6to1byLot30;ontheSW.,points1to2,byLot31;andontheN.,
points2to3byLot35,alloftheconsolidationsubdivisionplan.Beginningat
apontmarked"1"onplan,beingN.51deg.36'E.,1321.76m.fromB.L.L.M.
No.1,Sta.Rosa,Laguna
ThatthesaidSheriffsoldtheabovedescribedpropertywithallthe
improvementsandbuildingsthereontotheundersignedaffiantasthehighest
bidderforthesumofONEMILLIONPESOS(P1,000,000.00),Philippine
Currency;
ThatThataCertificateofSaleatPublicAuctionwasissuedbythesaid
Sheriffinfavoroftheundersignedaffiantandthesamewasdulyregistered
withtheOfficeoftheRegistryofDeedsofMakatiCityonSeptember14,
2012asEntryNo.123ontheaforementionedtitle;
ThataCertificateofSaleatPublicAuctionwasissuedbythesaidSheriffin
favoroftheundersignedaffiantisproperandinaccordancewithlaw.
WHEREFORE,byfailureoftheMortgagortoredeemthesaidproperty,I
amexecutingthisAffidavitforthepurposeofconsolidatingtitleand
ownershipoftheabovedescribedpropertywithalltheimprovementsand
buildingsthereon,asprovidedforbylaw,andIamrequestingtheOfficeof
theRegistryofDeedstoregisterthesameandissueanewtitleinthenameof
theundersignedaffiant.
January2014,inImusCity,Cavite,Philippines.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
SUBCRIBEDANDSWORNTObeforemethis27thdayofJanuary2014,in
62
January12,2017.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.25:AFFIDAVITFORPRELIMINARYATTACHMENT
CITYOFBACOOR
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITFORPRELIMINARYATTACHMENT
I,JAMAICAMAYDELACRUZ,Filipino,oflegalage,single,residingat
194Salinas,CityofBacoor,Cavite,afterbeingsworntoinaccordancewith
law,deposesandsay:
ThatIamtheplaintiffaboveentitledcase;
Thatasufficientcauseofactionsexistsagainstthedefendantnamed
therein;
ThatthisactionisoneofthosespecificallymentionedinSec.1ofRule
oftheRulesofCourt,wherebyawritofpreliminaryattachmentmaylawfully
issue,namely:
63
inanactionagainstapartywhohasremovedordeposedofhisproperty,
orisabouttodoso,withintenttodefraudhiscreditors;
Thatthereisnosufficientsecurityfortheclaimsoughttobeenforcedbythe
presentaction;
Thattheamountduetotheplaintiffintheaboveentitledcaseisasmuchas
thesumforwhichanorderofattachmentisproper.
January,2014,intheCityofBacoor,CavitePhilippines
JAMAICAMAYDELACRUZ
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis18thdayofJanuary,2014,
intheCityofBacoor,CavitePhilippines,affianthavingexhibitedtomehis
LicenseNo.3790682issueduntilJuly29,2016.
Doc.No.:________;
PageNo.:________;
BookNo.:________;
Seriesof2014.
64
FORMNO.26:AFFIDAVITOFUNDERTAKING
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES))S.S
AFFIDAVITOFUNDERTAKING
I,RAPHAELENIRQUEV.CORONADO,oflegalage,Filipino,married,with
residenceatBlk.5,Lot20,NarraHomes,ImusCity,Caviteafterhavingbeen
dulysworntoinaccordancewithlaw,doherebydeposeandsay:
65
ThatIampresentlyassignedbyourHorsepowerAgencyinVELTLOG
RealtyCorporationasFloorManager.
ThatthesaidassignmentcommencedonJanuary3,2014.
Thatuponmyresignation,orseparationfromemploymentfromouragency,I
undertakenottosecureanemploymenttoanyrealtycorporationwhichisa
directorindirectcompetitorofVELTLOG.
ThatIalsoundertakenottorevealanycompanysecretoranyknowledgeor
informationwhichIobtaineddirectlyorindirectlyfromVELTLOGinthe
courseofmyassignmentasFloorManager.
ThatincaseofbreachofthisUndertaking,I,willinglyandvoluntarilywithout
fearorintimidationemployedbyVELTLOGtoindemnifythelatterforall
damagesandlossesthatmightresultfrommydisclosureofanycompany
secretsorinformationwhichareprejudicialtoVELTLOG.
Thatweareexecutingthisaffidavittoattestthetruthoftheforegoing
facts.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,wehavehereuntosetourhandsandaffixour
signaturesonthis8thdayofJanuary,2014,inImusCity,Cavite.
Affiant
______________________
______________________
______________________
66
BEFOREME,appearthepersonofRAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO
presentingtheaboveAffidavit,whoarepersonallyknowntomeoridentified
bymethroughcompetentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarial
Rulesasthepersonswhosignthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoath
oraffirmationbeforemeastosuchdocument.
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEALthis8THdayofJanuary2014inImus
City,Cavite.
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.27:JOINTAFFIDAVITOFTWODISINTERESTED
PERSONS
IMUSCITY,CAVITE )S.S
JOINTAFFIDAVITOFTWODISINTERESTEDPERSONS
We,FIFTYCENTSGREYandSHADESO.GREY,bothoflegalage,
FilipinosandresidentsofBlock5Lot2Phase4,PerlaStreet,Kalayaan
67
Cinco,ImmortalVillageVillage8,ImusCity,afterhavingbeendulyswornto
inaccordancewithlaw,doherebydeposeandsay:
ThatwepersonallyknowJOLINAMAGDANGALandSHAINA
MAGDANGALsincetheirparents,PEDROV.MAGDANGALandJOYCE
Q.MAGDANGALareneighborsandclosefriendsofours;
ThatwearefullycognizantofthefactthatSPOUSESPEDROV.
MAGDANGALandJOYCEQ.MAGDANGALgotmarriedinMalabon
City,MetroManilasometimeinApril20,1993.Photocopyofthemarriage
contractisheretoattachedasAnnexA;
Thattheabovenamedpersonsareknowninourbarangay;
ThatthedateofmarriageappearinginthecertificatesoflivebirthofJOLINA
MAGDANGALandSHAINAMAGDANGAL,August16,1981andAugust
16,1980,respectively,waserroneouslywritten.
PhotocopiesofthecertificatesoflivebirthareheretoattachedasAnnexes
BandC;
ThatthetrueandcorrectdateofmarriageofSPOUSESPEDROV.
MAGDANGALandJOYCEQ.MAGDANGALisMarch19,1992;
Thatwecometoknowtheabovementionedfactsbecausewearegoodfriends
oftheabovementionedcouple,livinginthesameneighborhoodandclose
friendsoftheirfamily;
Thatwearenotinanywayrelatedtotheabovementionedpersonnordowe
havepecuniaryinterestinthismatterwhatsoever;
68
Thatweareexecutingthisaffidavittoattestthetruthoftheforegoingfacts
andforwhateverlegalpurposeitmayserve.
AFFIANTSFURTHERSAYETHNOT.
January2014atImusCity,Cavite.
FIFTYCENTSGREY SHADESO.GREY
Affiant Affiant
SeniorCitizensID
SeniorCitizensID
withno.114150withno.18820
BEFOREME,appearthepersonsof:
FIFTYCENTSGREY SHADESO.GREY
presentingtheaboveJOINTAFFIDAVITOFTWO(2)DISINTERESTED
PERSONS,whoarepersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedbymethrough
competentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarialRulesasthepersons
whosignthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathoraffirmation
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforeme4thdayofJanuary2014atImus
City,Cavite.
69
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof2014.
FORM28:AFFIDAVITOFSINGLESTATUS
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFSINGLESTATUS
1.THATIhavenevercontractedanymarriageinthePhilippinesorelsewhere
andIremainSINGLEtothisverydayandhour;
70
THATthereisnolegalimpedimentformetocontractmarriageunderthe
PhilippineLaws;
THATIamexecutingthisAffidavitforthepurposeofcomplyingwiththe
requirementsrelatingtomyforthcomingmarriagetoRONJEREMYin
CaloocanCity;
THATIdeclarethatthestatementsmadeinthisaffidavitaretrueandcorrect
andIamwillingtobearallthelegalresponsibilitiesarisingtherefrom.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
71
FORMNO.29:AFFIDAVITOFSERVICE
AFFIDAVITOFSERVICE
I,ELLENA.ADARNA,oflegalage,withresidentialaddressat316Palin
St.,Block27,Lot77,AiAi,GeneralTinio,GMA,Cavite,afterbeingsworn
inaccordancewithlawdeposeandstate:
ThatIamthewifeofRAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO.
72
Thaton26July2013,RicaKayeO.Lomibao,PresidentofXHamsters
Corporation,personallywenttothebusinessofficeofmyhusbandtotalkwith
himandsettleherfinancialobligations.
Asmyhusbandwasnotaroundduringthattime,IpersonallyhandedtoRica
KayeO.LomibaoademandletterdatedsometimeinthemonthofJune2012
aspermyhusbandsinstruction.
However,RicaKayeO.Lomibaorefusedtoreceivethedemandletterand
toldmeinsteadthatshewilljusttalkandsettleherobligationtomyhusband
personally.
ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavitinallgoodfaithandtoattestthetruthofthe
foregoingfacts.
AFFIANTFURTHERSAYETHNONE.
ELLENA.ADARNAAffiant
____________________
____________________
aboveAffidavitofService,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedby
methroughcompetentevidenceofidentityasdefinedbytheNotarialRulesas
thepersonwhosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathor
affirmationbeforemeastosuchdocument.
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEALthis_____dayofAugust2014in
___________________.
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
73
FORMNO.30:AFFIDAVITOFSELFADJUDICATION
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
AFFIDAVITOFSELFADJUDICATION
74
IamthesoleheirofthelateHUGHHEFNER,beinghisonlybiological
daughter;
ThelateHUGHHEFNERpassedawayonJanuary2,2014,anddiedwithout
anylastwillandtestament;
Atthetimeofdeathmyfather,hehadnodebts,liabilitiesorobligationsto
anypersons,agencyorinstitution;
Theonlypropertyleftbymylatefatherisahouseandlot,moreparticularly
describedasfollow:
TCTNo.T2222
APARCELOFLAND(Lot32oftheconsolidationsubdivisionplan(LRC)
Pcs5141,beingaportionoftheconsolidationofLots1and2,Psu112287
Amd.,LRC(GLRO)Rec.No.N17511),situatedintheDist.OfConcepcion,
CityofSta.Rosa,Laguna,IslandofLuzon.BoundedontheNE.,points3to6,
byLot85;ontheS.,points6to1byLot30;ontheSW.,points1to2,byLot
31;andontheN.,points2to3byLot35,alloftheconsolidationsubdivision
plan.Beginningatapontmarked"1"onplan,beingN.51deg.36'E.,
1321.76m.fromB.L.L.M.No.1,Sta.Rosa,Laguna
5.Assoleheirofthehereindecedent,Iherebyadjudicatetheabovementioned
propertysolelyforandinmynameaswellasanyandallliabilitiesarising
fromthesaidproperty;
6.Iherebyexecutethisaffidavitforthepurposeofprocessingthetransferof
thesaidpropertyinmyname,thesettlementoftheestateofthelateHUGH
HEFNER,aswellasforthereleaseofanyotherclaimorbenefitinrelationto
hisdeathbeforeanygovernment/privateofficeandbankinginstitutionandfor
anyotherlegalpurposethismaybestserve.
75
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.31:AFFIDAVITOFPUBLICATION
AFFIDAVITOFPUBLICATION
76
I,DIANAZUBIRI,oflegalage,Filipino,single,bornonwithbusinessaddress
at567OgbaogStreet,GeneralRojopotsuAvenue,CaviteCity,Cavite,after
beingdulysworninaccordancewithlaw,herebydeposeandstate:
ThatIamtheAdvertisingDirectorofBDSMInc.thatpublishesTiktik
Magazine,anewspaperofgeneralcirculationinthePhilippines,printedand
publishedinPortArea,QuezonCity;
ThataNOTICEOFPUBLICATIONORDERANDSUMMONS(by
publication)RaphaelEnriqueV.Coronado,petitioner,versusEllenA.
Adarna,respondent,CivilCaseno.CQTZ2425285Dfor:Declarationof
NullityofMarriage,RTC,NationalCapitalJudicialRegion,Branch113,Pasay
City.
Aprintedcopyofwhichisheretoattached,waspublishedinthesaidnewspaper
onJuly26andAugust09,2013.
AFFIANTFURTHERSAYETHNAUGHT.
DIANAZUBIRI
Affiant
________________________________________
________________________________________
BEFOREME,appearsthepersonofDIANAZUBIRIpresentingtheabove
Affidavit,whoispersonallyknowntomeoridentifiedbymethrough
77
whosignsthedocumentandinmypresencetakenanoathoraffirmation
City,Cavite
Doc.No.____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.32:AFFIDAVITTOUSETHESURNAMEOFTHE
CITYOFIMUS
)S.S.
78
AFFIDAVITTOUSETHESURNAMEOFTHE
ThatIamthebiologicalmotherofROCCOSIFFREDI.
ThatthebiologicalfatherofthechildisRONJEREMY.
ThatmychildROCCOSIFFREDIwasbornon18October1998inGrace
Park,CaloocanCity;
ThatthefactsofbirthofmychildweredulyregisteredattheOfficeofthe
CaloocanCityCivilRegistrar.
ThatI,RONJEREMYbeingthefatherofROCCOSIFFREDI,hereby
acknowledgedandrecognizedhimasmychildandlegalheir.
ThatIamallowingmychildROCCOSIFFREDItousemysurname
JEREMYtobehissurnameinhisCertificateofLiveBirth.
ThatIexecutethisaffidavittoattesttothetruthoftheabovefactsin
compliancewiththeprovisionsofRepublicActNo.9255.
SASHAGREY
Affiant
Voter'sIDNo.5555
79
identification.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2014.
80
CORPORATIONFORMS
FORMNO.1:AFFIDAVITOFNONOPERATION
City/Municipalityof_________)S.S.
81
Forms
xx
AFFIDAVITOFNONOPERATION
I,theundersignedCorporateSecretaryof_____________________
Corporation,adomesticcorporationdulyorganizedandexistingbyvirtueof
thelawsoftheRepublicofthePhilippines,withprincipalofficeat
___________________,Philippines,DOHEREBYCERTIFY:
Thatafteritsincorporationin____________,theaforesaidcorporationhas
notyetstarteditsoperationnorcommencedthetransactionofitsbusiness
untilthepresentdate;
Assuch,Iamexecutingthisaffidavittoattesttothetruthoftheforegoing.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis______in
___________,Philippines.
CORPORATESECRETARY
(JURAT)
FORMNO.2:NOTICEOFCALL
82
_____________________________
(NameofCorporation)
NOTICEOFCALL
Noticeisherebygiventhatatameetingoftheboardofdirectorsofthe
_____________heldon________,2____,unpaidsubscriptionstothecapital
stockofthecorporation(orthepercentagethereofdeclareddue)were
declareddueandpayabletotheprincipalofficeofthecorporationat
___________________on________________,2________.
Allstockuponwhichthesubscription,withinterestaccrued,hasnotbeenpaidon
________________,2____,willbedelinquentandadvertisedforsaleatpublic
auction,andunlesspaymentofthesubscription,withinterestsandcostsaccrued,
ismadebeforesaleofthestock,samewillbesoldon
___________________,2_____topaytheamountofthesubscriptionand
accruedinteresttogetherwiththecostsofadvertisingandexpensesofsale.
________________________,2_____.
_______________________
(Secretary)
FORMNO.3:NOTICEOFPREEMPTIVERIGHTS
83
Date:
__________________
TO:
__________________
__________________
NOTICEOFPREEMPTIVERIGHTS
DearValuedStockholder:
Pleasebeinformedthatinconnectionwiththeapplicationofthecorporation
toamenditsArticlesofIncorporationincreasingitsauthorizedcapitalstock
from___________________PESOSto_______________
PESOScommonshares(whichamendmentwasapprovedbythe
stockholdersrepresentingmorethan2/3oftheoutstandingcapitalstockatthe
annualstockholdersmeetingandunanimouslyapprovedbytheBoardof
DirectorsintheBoardmeeting,bothheld_______________),youmaynow
exerciseyourpreemptiverightstosubscribetotheincreaseintheauthorized
capitalstockinproportiontoyourpresentshareholding.
Consideringthatthecorporationneedstoprocesstheincreaseassoonas
possibleinlinewithitsexpansionprogramsforthisyear,youarehereby
given(10)daysfromreceiptofthisNOTICEwithinwhichtoexerciseyour
preemptiverights,otherwiseyouwillbedeemedtohavewaivedthesame.
___________________,Philippines.
VeryTrulyYours,
CorporateSecretary
Notedby:
President
FORMNO.4:PROXYTOVOTEINSTOCKHOLDERSMEETING
84
PROXYTOVOTEINSTOCKHOLDERSMEETING
KNOWALLMENBYTHESEPRESENTS:
ThatI,_____________________,Filipino,oflegalage,
(single/married/widow),andaresidentof__________________,Philippines,
doherebyconstituteandappointNameofProxy,whoisalsooflegalage,
Filipino,(single/married/widow),andaresidentof_____________,
Philippines,torepresentmeandvotethe________________________
(_________)sharesofthecapitalstockappearinginmynameattheAnnual
StockholdersMeetingofNameofCorporation,tobeheldon
_________________.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis_____,dayof
______,2____,attheCityof_______________,Philippines.
STOCKHOLDER
Acceptedby:
PROXY
SIGNEDINTHEPRESENCEOF:
_____________________
______________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FORMNO.5:RESOLUTIONDECLARINGCASHDIVIDEND
85
RESOLUTIONDECLARINGCASHDIVIDEND
of
___________________________
(NameofCorporation)
RESOLVED,thatcashdividendof___________________________
percentisherebydeclared,payableon___________________,2________,to
stockholdersofrecordatthecloseofbusinesson_____________________,2
_______.
Approvedthis__________dayof___________,2______.
(Sgd.)_______________________
(Directors)
Countersigned:
______________________
(Secretary)
FORMNO.6:UNDERTAKINGTOCHANGECORPORATENAME
86
UNDERTAKINGTOCHANGECORPORATENAME
Date________________
TheHonorableCommissioner
SecuritiesandExchangeCommission
SECBuilding,EDSA
Greenhills,Mandaluyong
MetroManila
Sir:
InconnectionwiththeregistrationofthearticlesofIncorporationof
_______________,theundersignedrepresentativeandonbehalfofthe
organizersthereof,herebymanifestourwillingnesstochangeitscorporate
nameintheeventthatanotherperson,firmorentityhasacquiredapriorright
totheuseofthesaidfirmnameoronedeceptivelyorconfusinglysimilartoit.
Verytrulyyours,
CorporateLegalCounsel
FORMNO.7:WAIVEROFPREEMPTIVERIGHTS
87
WAIVEROFPREEMPTIVERIGHTS
I,theundersignedstockholderofNameofCorporation,doherebywaivemy
preemptiverightstosubscribetotheincreaseintheauthorizedcapitalstock
ofthesaidcorporation_________________________
(P___________)Pesosto____________________(P____________)Pesos.
_________________,Philippines.__________dayof__________,
20___.
STOCKHOLDER
88
FORMNO.8:WAIVERTOSUBSCRIBETONEWSTOCK
WAIVERTOSUBSCRIBETONEWSTOCK
WE,theundersignedstockholdersof___________________hereby
declare:
Thaton______________________,2_______,thecapitalstockof
_________________hadbeendulyincreasedfrom__________________to
__________________;thatunderthelawbyreasonofsuchincrease,wehave
arighttosubscribetothenewstocktobeissuedbytheCorporationin
proportiontothenumberofsharesownedandheldbyusinsaidCorporation;
thatwe,individually,herebyvoluntarilyrenounceandwaiveourrightto
exerciseourrightofpreemptiontosubscribetothenewstockbyreasonof
saidincrease.
Signedonthis_____________dayof____________________,20_____.
(Sgd.)___________________________
(Stockholders)
89
FORMNO.9:TREASURERSAFFIDAVIT
Cityof______ )S.S.
xx
TREASURERSAFFIDAVIT
I,__________________,beingdulysworn,deposeandsay:
ThatIhavebeenelectedbythesubscribersofthecorporationasTreasurer
thereof,toactassuchuntilmysuccessorhasbeendulyelectedandqualifiedin
accordancewiththebylawsofthecorporation,andthatassuchTreasurer,I
herebycertifyunderoaththatatleast25%oftheauthorizedcapitalstockofthe
corporationhasbeensubscribedandatleast25%ofthesubscriptionhasbeen
paid,andreceivedbymeincashforthebenefitandcreditofthecorporation.
ThisisalsotoauthorizetheSecuritiesandExchangeCommissionand
BangkongPilipinastoexamineandverifythedepositinthe
____________________
inmynameastreasurerintrustfor
__________________________________
in
the
amount of
______________________(P_________________________)representing
thepaidupcapitalofthecorporationwhichisintheprocessofincorporation.
Thisauthorityisvalidandinspectionofsaiddepositmaybemadeevenafter
theissuanceoftheCertificateofIncorporation.Shouldthedepositbe
transferredtoanotherbankpriortoorafterincorporation,thiswillserveas
authoritytoverifyandexaminethesame.TherepresentativeoftheSecurities
andExchangeCommissionisalsoauthorizedtoexaminepertinentbooksand
recordsofaccountsofthecorporationaswellassupportingpapersto
determinetheutilizationanddisbursementofourCertificateofIncorporation.
90
Incasethesaidpaidupcapitalisnotdepositedorwithdrawnpriortothe
approvalofthearticlesofincorporation,waiveourrighttoanoticeand
hearingintherevocationofourCertificateofIncorporation.
_____________________
Treasurer
(JURAT)
91
FORMNO.10:AFFIDAVITOFNONOPERATION
Cityof______ )S.S.
xx
AFFIDAVITOFNONOPERATION
I,_________________,oflegalage,Filipinocitizen,andpresentlyresidingat
_____________________,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordance
withlaw,doherebydeposeandsay:
ThatIamthe(statepositionincorporation)of(statenameofcorporation),a
corporationdulyorganizationunderthelawsofthePhilippineswithprincipal
officeat(stateofficeaddress).
Thatsaidcorporationwasincorporatedon(statedateofincorporation)with
SECRegistrationNumber(stateSECregistrationnumber).
Thattodate,thecorporationhasnotcommencedoperationsdueto(state
reason/sfornonoperation).
ThatThestockholdersanddirectorsofthecorporationintendtocommence
operationsinthefuture.
92
5.ThatIamexecutingthisaffidavitinordertoattesttothetruthofthe
foregoingandforthepurposeofcomplyingwiththereportorialrequirements
oftheSecuritiesandExchangeCommission.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis____dayof
_______2014at______________,Philippines.
________________
Affiant
(JURAT)
93
FORMNO.11:ARTICLESOFLIMITEDPARTNERSHIP
ARTICLESOFPARTNERSHIP
Of
_____________,LTD.
TheseArticlesofPartnership,madeandexecutedbyandamong:
______________,generalpartner,(citizenship),residingat
_______________;
_______________;
_______________;
alloflegalage,witnesseth:
Thattheabovenamedpartnershaveformedalimitedpartnershipamong
themselvesunderthenameandstyleof
_______________________Ltd.;
Thatthepurposesforwhichsaidpartnershipisformedare:
(statetheobjectorcharacterofthebusiness)
Thattheprincipalofficeofthepartnershipshallbelocatedat
_______________;
Thatthetermofexistenceofthispartnershipshallbe______yearsfromand
aftertheexecutionofthesearticles;
94
Thatthecapitalofthepartnershipshallbe__________PESOS(P_____)
contributedbythepartners,asfollows,towit:
___________(generalpartner).P____________;
___________(limitedpartner).P____________;
___________(limitedpartner).P____________;therebymakinga
TOTALCAPITALof
P________
That_____________________,generalpartner,isherebydesignatedthe
managerofthepartnership,withamonthlysalaryof__________
PESOS(P________);
Thattheprofitsandlossesshallbeapportionedamongthepartnersofthe
partnership_________(stateinwhatproportiontheyshallshareintheprofits
andinthelosses).
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartiesheretohavehereuntosettheirhands,
this______dayof____________,20____,in
________________Philippines.
__________
_________________
_________________
_________________
_________________
(Signatureofpartners)
_____________________
95
_____________________
(Witnesses)
REALESTATEAND
PERSONALPROPERTY
FORMS
96
Forms
FORMNO.1:AFFIDAVITOFCONSOLIDATIONOFOWNERSHIP
CITYOF____)S.S.
xx
AFFIDAVITOFCONSOLIDATIONOFOWNERSHIP
I,______________,oflegalage,Filipino,singleandaresidentof
_____________,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordancewithlaw,depose
andstate:
Thaton__________,______________,oflegalage,Filipino,single,residingat
__________soldtomeacertainparceloflandunderpactoderetro,executed
beforeNotarialPublic________andbearingNot.Reg.No._,Page_,Book_,
Seriesof___ofhisNotarialRegister(copyofthesaidpactoderetrosaleishereto
attachedasANNEXA);
Thatpursuanttothedeedofsalewithpactoderetro,thesaidvendor,________,
shouldhaveexercisedhisrighttorepurchasethesaidpropertywithintheperiod
of___;
Thattheperiodexpiredon______withoutthesaidvendor,byhimselforbyany
otherpersoninhisbehalfcomplyingwiththeconditionandstipulationrequired
fortherepurchaseofthesaidproperty;
Thatthesaidperiodofrepurchasehasnotbeenextended,eitherexpresslyor
impliedly,byaffiantvendeearetro;
Thatbyvirtueofthesaiddeedofsalewithpactoderetro,andbythefailureof
thevendor,_______,todulyrepurchasethepropertywithintheperiodstipulated,
therewasconsolidatedintheaffiant,asvendeearetro,theabsoluteownershipof
thesaidproperty.Attachedhereto,asANNEXB,is
97
anorderoftheRegionalTrialCourtof______issuedon______,approving
andconfirmingtheaboveconsolidationofownershipinthenameofaffiant.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis_thdayof
________in__________.
_____________
Affiant
(JURAT)
98
FORMNO.2:DEEDOFABSOLUTESALE
DEEDOFABSOLUTESALE
ThisDEEDOFABSOLUTESALEismade,executedandenteredintoby:
_________________,Filipinocitizen,oflegalage,marriedto
_________________andresidentof_______________hereinafterreferredto
astheSELLER
AND
Spouses_______and_____________,oflegalages,bothFilipinoandwith
residenceandpostalat________________hereinafterreferredtoasthe
BUYER.
WITNESSETH;
WHEREAS,theSELLERistheregisteredownerofaparceloflandwith
improvementslocatedat________________________andcoveredby
TransferCertificateof
TitleNo.__________withatotalarea
of__________squaremeters
moreorlessandmoreparticularlydescribedas
follows:
TRANSFERCERTIFICATEOFTITLENO.______
(DETAILSOFTHEPROPERTY)
99
WHEREAS,theBUYERhasofferedtobuyandtheSELLERhasagreedto
selltheabovementionedpropertyfortheamountofThreeMillionThree
HundredThousandPesos(Php3,300,000.00)PhilippineCurrency;
NOWTHEREFORE,forandinconsiderationofthesumofThreeMillion
ThreeHundredThousandPesos(Php3,300,000.00)PhilippineCurrency,
handpaidbythebuyertotheseller,theSELLERDOHEREBYSELL,
TRANSFER,andCONVEYbywayofAbsoluteSaleuntothesaidBUYER,
hisheirsandassigns,thecertainparceloflandtogetherwithallthe
improvementsfoundthereon,freefromallliensandencumbrancesof
whatevernatureincludingrealestatetaxesasofthedateofthissale
_________
Seller
WITHMARITALCONSENT:
_________
Spouse
______________________________________________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
100
FORMNO.3:EARNESTMONEYRECEIPTAGREEMENT
EARNESTMONEYRECEIPTAGREEMENT
Receivedfrom__________withpostaladdressat______________,the
sumof________________coveredby______dated_____________
representingEARNESTMONEYforpaymentofa_____________
Locatedat__________________________coveredbyT.C.T.No.
_____________
ThisEARNESTMONEYformspartofthepurchasepriceof
_____________.Thebalanceandfullpaymentshallbepaidonorbefore
_____________.
TheBUYERherebyreservestheexclusiverighttopurchasethe
aforementionedpropertyandtheSELLERcannotofferthe
aforementionedpropertytoanythirdpartyuntil_____________
Uponfullpayment,theSELLERshallexecuteaDEEDOF
ABSOLUTESALEinfavoroftheBUYER,conveyingthesubject
propertywithfullwarrantyofalegalandvalidtitleasprovidedbylaw,
freeandclearfromanyliensandencumbrances.
UponexecutionoftheDEEDOFABSOLUTESALE,theSELLERshall
undertakethepaymentoftheCapitalGainsTax.TheBUYERshall
shoulderthepaymentoftheDocumentaryStampsTax,TransferTax,
101
RegistrationFeeandallotherexpensestotransferthetitleofthe
propertyunderhisname.
IncaseofvoluntarycancellationofthisagreementbytheBUYER
withoutanycauseonthepartoftheSELLERoriftheBUYERfailsto
complywithhisobligationsmentioned,thentheSELLERshallhave
therighttoterminatethisagreementinwhichcasetheEARNEST
MONEYintheamountof__________________________shallbe
forfeitedinfavoroftheSELLERasliquidateddamages.
(DATE)
SignatureoverPrintedName SignatureoverPrintedName
102
FORMNO.4:OFFERTOPURCHASE
DATE
OFFERTOPURCHASE
____________
____________
____________
Re:(PROPERTY)
Dear______________,
Thisistoexpressourfirmoffertobuytheabovestatedproperty
throughourauthorizedbrokers,_______,subjecttothefollowing
termsandconditions:
PurchasePrice_________________
TermsandConditions:
Uponacceptanceofthisoffer,earnestmoneyintheamountof
__________________shallbepaidandshallbecreditedaspartof
thepurchaseprice.
Thebalance,intheamountof______________shallbepaidinfull
within___workingdays.
TheCapitalGainsTaxandBroker'scommissionshallbeforthe
accountoftheSELLER,whiletheDocumentaryStamps,Transfer
TaxandRegistrationFeesshallbefortheaccountoftheBUYER.
103

Forms
Note:Reviseaboveconditions/addordeletetermsandconditions
asapplicabletoyou.
Iftheabovetermsandconditionsareacceptabletoyou,please
signifyyourconformitybysigningonthespaceprovidedbelow.
Trulyyours,
Conforme:
104
Forms
FORMNO.5:DEEDOFSALEOFMOTORVEHICLE
DEEDOFSALEOFMOTORVEHICLE
ThatI,RONALDRAEC.DELMUNDO,oflegalage,Filipino,singleanda
residentof#14MountVille,MuntinlupaCity,forandinconsiderationofthe
amountofFOURHUNDREDTHOUSAND(4000,000.00)PESOS,
PhilippineCurrency,receiptofwhichisherebyacknowledgedfromPAUL
JASONC.DOLENDO,oflegalage,Filipino,singleandaresidentof#16
LightsaberVille,PasayCity,doherebySELL,CEDE,TRANSFERand
CONVEYuntoandinfavorofPAULJASONC.DOLENDOhisheirs,
successorsandassignsamotorvehicleparticularlydescribedasfollows:
MakeandType:TOYOTAVIOSSEDAN
MotorNumber:90087654PP8765
Serial/ChassisNo.:YT980097549
PlateNo.:ZSX678
MVFILENO.:099789977
COLOR:SILVER
Freefromliensandencumbrances.
105
January2014atMuntinlupaCity,Philippines.
____________________________
RONALDRAEC.DELMUNDO
______________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
________________________
106
FORMNO.6:DEEDOFASSIGNMENTANDTRANSFEROFRIGHTS
DEEDOFASSIGNMENTANDTRANSFEROFRIGHTS
KNOWALLMENBYTHISPRESENTS:
Thisdeedmadeandenteredintothis4thdayofJanuary,2014attheCityof
Manila,byandbetween:
RONALDRAEC.DELMUNDO,FilipinoCitizen,oflegalage,marriedto
JESSYMENDIOLADELMUNDOwithresidenceandpostaladdressat
1234OakLane,StandardSubdivision,QuezonCity,hereinafterreferredtoas
the"ASSIGNOR"
and
PAULJASONC.DOLENDO,FilipinoCitizen,oflegalage,marriedto
PATRICIAM.DOLENDOwithresidenceandpostaladdressat123A
SomervillePlazaTower,5678MahoganyAvenue,Manila,hereinafter
referredtoasthe"ASSIGNEE".
WITNESSETHthat
107
WHEREAStheASSIGNORisthebuyerofa2bedroomunit,locatedat
18C,BeerandaTowersCondominium,234TaftAvenue,Manila,withanarea
ofSEVENTYEIGHT(78)SQUAREMETERSmoreorless,coveredby
CondominiumCertificateTitleNo.98765oftheregisterofDeedsofManila,
registeredinthenameoftheBankofthePhilippineIslands.;
WHEREAS,theASSIGNORhasofferedtoassignallhisrights,titleand
interestovertheaboveunit,asreferredinsaidContracttoSellandthe
ASSIGNEEherebyacceptstheassignmentinaccordancewiththeterms
hereinsetforth;
NOW,THEREFORE,forandinconsiderationoftheforegoingpremises
andthesumofONEMILLIONPESOS(1,000,000.00),PHILIPPINE
CURRENCY,whichtheASSIGNORherebyacknowledgedtohavereceived
fromtheASSIGNEE,theASSIGNORherebyassigns,transfersandconveys
untotheASSIGNEE,allhisrights,titleandinteresttotheaforementioned
propertyandappurtenantinterestintheCondominiumprojectpursuanttothis
AgreementandtheASSIGNEEbythesepresentsherebyacceptsthe
assignmentandagreestobeboundbythetermsandconditionsofthe
ContracttoSellandtherulesandregulations,andrestrictionspertainingto
thesaidunit.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartieshavehereuntosettheirhandsonthe
dateandplacefirstabovewritten.
RONALDRAEC.DELMUNDO
PAULJASONC.
DOLENDO
ASSIGNOR
ASSIGNEE
Signedinthepresenceof:
______________________
_____________________
ALLANJAMEST.ULIT
CHRISTIANV.CORPUZ
(ACKNOWLEDGEMENT)
108
FORMNO.7:CONTRACTOFLEASE
CONTRACTOFLEASE(MotorVehicle)
Thiscontractmadeandexecutedbyandbetween:RONALDRAEC.DEL
MUNDO,oflegalage,Filipinoandaresidentof#14MountVille,
MuntinlupaCity,hereinafterreferredtoastheLESSOR;andWARNER
BROS.,acorporationdulyorganizedandexistingunderPhilippinelawswith
officesat6750Ayala,MakatiCity,representedbyPAULJASONC.
DOLENDOoflegalageandaresidentof#16LightsaberVille,PasayCity,
hereinafterreferredtoastheLESSEE;
WITNESSETH:
Thatthepartieshaveheretoagreedasfollows:1.ThattheLESSORhereby
letsandleasesuntotheLESSEEhismotorvehicledescribedasfollows:
MAKE:BMWSERIES3SEDAN
109
MOTORNO.:DW0098789994
CHASSISNO.:RF9864754
ThatthemonthlyrentalshallbeintheamountofTWENTYFIVE
THOUSAND(25,000.00),permonth,payableattheendofeachandevery
month;
Thatthetermofthiscontractshallbeone(1)yearcommencingonJanuary1,
2014andendingonJanuary1,2015andautomaticallyrenewedfromyearto
yearunlesssoonerterminatedbyanoticeofatleastthirty(30)daysbefore
suchtermination;
Alltheexpensesfortheregistration,insurance,tire,battery,fuel,careand
maintenanceoftheleasedunit,aswellasanyandalldamagesandliabilities
causedtothirdpartiesorthepublicbyreasonofanyaccidentwhatsoever,
shallbeforthesoleaccountoftheLESSEE;
LESSEEmaysubleasetheunittoanyotherpersonbuttherightofLESSOR
ashereinstipulatedshallnotbeaffectedwhatsoever.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartieshavehereuntosettheirhandsthis4th
dayofDecember2013atMuntinlupaCity,Philippines.
__________________
RONALDRAEC.DELMUNDOLessor
______________________
WARNERBROS.Lessee
______________________
by:PAULJASONC.DOLENDO(authorizedrepresentative)
110
_____________________
______________________
ALLANJAMEST.ULIT
CHRISTIANV.CORPUZ
(ACKNOWLEDGMENT)
FORMNO.8:CHATTELMORTGAGE
CHATTELMORTGAGE
I,(NameofMortgagor)oflegalage,single/married
to____________________withpostaladdressat
_____________________________hereinafterknownastheMORTGAGOR,
and_________________________________oflegalage,single/marriedto
______________________
with
postal address at
_______________________________hereinafterknownasthe
MORTGAGEE,witnesseth:
ThattheMORTGAGORisindebteduntotheMORTGAGEEinthesumof
(AmountinWords)(000,000.00),PhilippineCurrency,receiptofwhichis
acknowledgedbytheMORTGAGORuponthesigningofthisinstrument,
payablewithinaperiodof_____years,withinterestthereonattherateof
(___)%perannum;
111
Thatfor,andconsiderationof,thisindebtedness,andtoassurethe
performanceofsaidobligationtopay,theMORTGAGORherebyconveysby
wayofCHATTELMORTGAGEuntotheMORTGAGEE,hisheirsand
assigns,thefollowingpersonalitynowinthepossessionofsaid
MORTGAGOR
MAKE
:
MOTORNO.
:
SERIES
:
SERIAL/CHASSISNO.
:
TYPEOFBODY
:
PLATENO.
:
YEARMODEL
:
FILENO.
:
ThattheconditionofthisobligationisthatshouldtheMORTGAGOR
performtheobligationtopaythehereinabovecitedindebtednessof(Amount
inWords)(000,000.00)togetherwithaccruedinterestthereon,thischattel
mortgageshallatoncebecomenullandvoidandofnoeffectwhatsoever,
otherwise,itshallremaininfullforceandeffect.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartieshavehereuntosettheirhands,this
____dayof____________20___at____Philippines.
_______________________
MORTGAGOR MORTGAGEE
_______________________
INTHEPRESENCEOF:
________________________
__________________________
112
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
________________________)S.S
BEFOREME,personallyappeared:
Name
CTCNumber
Date/PlaceIssued
(NameofMortgagor)
10000000
Jan01,__/QuezonCity
(NameofMortgagee)
10000000
Jan11,__/LasPinasCity
Knowntomeandtomeknowntobethesamepersonswhoexecutedthe
foregoinginstrumentandacknowledgedtomethatthesameistheirfreeand
voluntaryactanddeed.
WITNESSMYHANDANDSEAL,onthedateandplacefirstabovewritten.
NotaryPublic
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof20__.
113
AFFIDAVITOFGOODFAITH
We,theundersignedMORTGAGORANDMORTGAGEEherebyjointlyand
severallyswearthatweexecutedtheforegoingChattelMortgageinorderto
securetheindebtednessthereinandfornootherpurposeorpurposescontrary
tolaw.
_________________________ _________________________
MORTGAGOR MORTGAGEE
FORMNO.9:DISCHARGEOFREALESTATEMORTGAGE
DISCHARGEOFREALESTATEMORTGAGE
I,JUANDELACRUZ,oflegalage,singleandwithresidenceandpostal
addressatNo.17AcaciaStreet,Pembo,MakatiCity,isthemortgageeinthat
DeedofRealEstateMortgageexecutedbyPEDRODUHAYLUNGSODon
May1,2013andnotedasDoc.No.2;PageNo.3;BookNo.IV;Seriesof
2013,oftheNotarialRegisterofBENHUR,NotaryPublicforandintheCity
ofMakati;
ThathavingreceivedthefullamountofONEHUNDREDTHOUSAND
PESOS(P100,000.00),PhilippineCurrencytogetherwithaccruedinterest
fromtheMortgagor,thesaidPEDRODUHAYLUNGSOD,Idohereby
foreverRELEASE,DISCHARGE,andCANCELtheMortgagementioned
above,coveringLotNo.35withTransferCertificateofTitleNo.123456of
theRegistryofDeedsofMakatiCity.
114
January2014atMakatiCity.
JUANDELACRUZ
__________________________________________________
MARIAMAKILING
JUANTAMAD
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
CityofMakati )S.S.
BEFOREME,aNotaryPublic,forandintheCityofMakati,this7thdayof
January2014personallyappeared:
Name
IdentificationCard
IssuedOn/At
JUANDELACRUZ
SSSI.D.No.123
1111/Makati
MARIAMAKILING
SSSI.D.No.444
4111/Makati
JUANTAMAD
SSSI.D.No.555
5111/Makati
allknowntometobethesamepersonswhoexecutedtheforegoing
instrumentandherebyacknowledgedtomethatthesameistheirfreeand
voluntaryactanddeed.
115
WITNESSMYHANDANDNOTARIALSEAL.
Doc.No.____
PageNo.____
BookNo.____
Seriesof2014.
FORMNO.10:PETITIONFORRECONSTITUTIONOFTRANSFER
CERTIFICATEOFTITLE
NationalCapitalJudicialRegion
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Branch_____
MakatiCity
INTHEMATTEROFRECONSTITUTION
OFORIGINALCOPYOFTRANSFER
CERTIFICATEOFTITLENO.T123456
Spec.Proc.No.____
ALATITULO,
Petitioner.
116
xx
PETITIONFORRECONSTITUTION
OFTRANSFERCERTIFICATEOFTITLE
COMESNOW,petitionerALATITULOthroughcounsel,untothis
HonorableCourt,respectfullyalleges:
Thatpetitionerisoflegalage,married,Filipinocitizenandresidingat222
TeresaStreet,Valenzuela,MakatiCity;thatrespondentREGIESTERisthe
RegisterofDeedsofMakatiCitywherehemaybeservedwithsummonsand
othercourtprocesses;
Thatpetitioneristheregisteredownerofaparceloflandlocatedat4522Acacia
Street,Pembo,MakatiCityandcoveredbyTransferCertificateofTitleNo.T
123456,RegisterofDeedsofMakatiCity,freeofanyencumbrances;
ThatonApril5,2013theofficeoftheregisterofDeedsofMakatiCitywas
burnedandalltheTorrensTitlesinsaidofficeincludingT.C.T.No.T123456
wereburned;
Thatsaidtransfercertificateoftitlewasnevermortgagedorsoldtoanyone.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthattheRegisterofDeedsofMakatiCity
issueareconstitutedoriginalcertificateoftitlebasedontheownersduplicate
certificateoftitleheretoattachedinthenameofhereinpetitioner.
Otherjustandequitablereliefsarelikewiseprayedfor.
Respectfullysubmitted.
15August2013
CityofMakati.
ATTY.VXYZ
CounselforthePetitioner
117
FORMNO.11:ACTIONTOREMOVECLOUDON,ORQUIET
TITLETO,REALPROPERTY
ACTIONTOREMOVECLOUDON,ORQUIETTITLETO,REAL
PROPERTY
(CaptionandTitle)
PETITION
COMESNOWthepetitionerandrespectfullyavers:
Thatheisthespecialadministratoroftheestateof______________,
deceased;
Thatthedeceased,duringhislifetime,executedacertaindeedofsaleofapiece
ofrealestateinfavoroftherespondent,dated___________,
118
and
particularly
described
as
follows,to
wit:
________________________________________;
Thatthesaidsaleisforgedandfictitious,andisthereforeintruthandinfact
invalid;
Thattheexistenceofthesaidallegeddeedofsaleisprejudicialtothetitleof
thelawfulheirsofthedeceasedupontheabovedescribedrealproperty;
Thatequitydemandsthatthesaiddeedofsalebesurrenderedandcancelled,
asitisaclouduponthetitleofthedeceasedandhislawfulheirs.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthat:
_____________________________________________________
_________
_____________________________________________________
_________
___________________
(AttorneyforthePetitioner)
___________________
(Address)
119
FORMNO.12:AFFIDAVITOFADJUDICATIONBYSOLEHEIROF
ESTATEOFDECEASEDPERSON
AFFIDAVIT
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES
PROVINCEOF________________
SS
MUNICIPALITYOF_____________
I,_____,oflegalage,marriedto_______(orsingle)andnowresidingat
________,Philippines,afterhavingbeensworninaccordancewithlaw,
deposeandsay:
ThatIamtheonlysurvivingsonofone,named______whodiedinterstatein
themunicipalityof________,Philippines,on_________
asevidencebyDeathCertificateissuedbythe_______heretoattachedas
ANNEXAandmadeanintegralpartofthisAffidavit;
Thatsaiddeceasedleftanestateconsistingofaparceloflandmeasuring____
sq.m.,locatedinthemunicipalityof______,and
120
evidencedbyTransferofTitleNo._______oftheRegistryofDeedsof
______;
Thatthesaidparceloflandismoreparticularlydescribedasfollowtowit:
(Description)
Thatsaiddeceasedleftnodebts;
Thatthenetvalueofsaidestateisnotmorethanthreethousandpesos(P
3,000.00),andisthereforeexemptfromtheestateandinheritancetaxes,as
evidencedbyacertificateofexemptionissuedbytheBureauofInternal
RevenueheretoattachedasANNEXBandmadeanintegralpartofthis
affidavit;
ThatpursuanttoRule74,Sec.1oftheRulesofCourt,Iherebyadjudicateunto
myselftheabovedescribedrealestatebymeansofthisAffidavitandherebyfiles
samewiththeRegisterofDeedsof_____
withtherequestthatsaidadjudicationbemadeeffectivewithoutjudicial
proceedingsasprescribedbytheaforementionedRulesofCourt.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthisdayof______,
20___,inthe____,Philippines.
________________
(SignatureofAffiant)
JURAT
121
FORMNO.13:ASSIGNMENTOFREALESTATEINPAYMENTOF
DEBT
DEEDOFASSIGNMENT
ThisDEEDOFASSIGNMENT,madeandexecutedbyandbetween(full
nameofdebtorassignor),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
_____________),
address at
with
residence
and
postoffice
_____________________________________,hereinaftercalledtheASSIGNOR,
and(fullnameofcreditorassignee),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
_____________),withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
_____________________________________,hereinaftercalledthe
ASSIGNEEwitnesseth:
ThattheASSIGNORisindebtedtotheASSIGNEEinthesumof
___________PESOS(P_________),Philippinecurrencyandinfullpayment
andcompletesatisfactionthereof,theASSIGNORdoesherebyASSIGN,
TRANSFER,andCONVEYuntotheASSIGNEEthatcertainrealestatewith
allthebuildingsandimprovementsthereonsituatedin__________________,
andmoreparticularlydescribedasfollows,towit:
122
(Descriptionofpropertyassigned)
ofwhichrealestatetheASSIGNORistheregisteredowner,histitlethereto
beingevidencebyTransfer(orOriginal)CertificateofTitleNo.________of
theRegisterofDeedsof_____________:
ThattheASSIGNEEdoesherebyacceptthisassignmentinfullpaymentof
theabovementioneddebtof__________________PESOS(P________).
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartiesheretohavehereuntosettheirhands
this________dayof____________,20____,in_________________
Philippines.
____________________
___________________
(Assignor)
(Assignee)
_____________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
____________________
123
FORMNO.14:COMPLAINTFORFORECLOSUREOFREAL
ESTATEMORTGAGE
COMPLAINTFORFORECLOSUREOFREALESTATE
MORTGAGE
(CaptionandTitle)
COMPLAINT
COMESNOW,theplaintiffbytheundersignedattorney,anduntothis
HonorableCourt,respectfullystates:
Thatboththeplaintiffandthedefendantareofage,andresidentsof
______________________________________________;
Thaton_____________,thedefendant,inordertosecurethepaymentofthesum
of______________,acknowledgedtohavebeenreceivedbyhimonsaiddate,
executedinfavoroftheplaintiffafirstmortgageoncertainrealpropertylocated
in________________________,atruecopyofsaidmortgagecontractishereto
attachedasExh.A,andmadeanintegralpartofthiscomplaint.
Thattheconditionofsaidmortgage,asstatedtherein,issuch,thatifwithinthe
periodof_______________fromandaftertheexecutionofsame,thedefendant
shallpayorcausetobepaidtotheplaintiff,his
124
heirsorassigns,thesaidsumof________________togetherwiththe
stipulatedinterestof________%perannum,thenthesaidmortgageshallbe
discharged;otherwise,itshallremaininfullforceandeffect,tobe
enforceableinthemannerprescribedbylaw;
Thatthedefendanthasnotpaidorcausedtobepaidthemortgagedebtof
_________oranypartthereof,inspiteofthelapseofthestipulatedperiod;
Thattheplaintiffhasdemandedofthedefendanttopaytheabovesumof
_____________,plusthestipulatedinterest,butsaiddefendanthasfailedto
paythesame;
Thatthedefendanthasalsoagreedinthemortgagecontractthatshouldthe
plaintiffforeclosethemortgage,thelatterisentitledtoreceivethefurthersum
of__________%ofthetotalamountdueasattorneysfees,expensesand
costs.
Thattherearenootherpersonshavingorclaiminganinterestinthe
mortgagedproperty.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayed:
That,uponduehearing,judgmentberendered:(1)orderingthedefendanttopay
untothecourtwithinthereglementaryperiodofninetydaysthesumof
_____________togetherwiththestipulatedinterestat_______%perannum
fromandafter_______________,plustheadditionalsumof______%ofthe
totalamountdueasattorneysfees,expensesandcosts;(2)andthatindefaultof
suchpayment,theabovementionedpropertybeorderedsoldtopayoffthe
mortgagedebtanditsaccumulatedinterest,plus_____%ofthetotalamountdue
asattorneysfees,expensesandcosts,
Thatplaintiffbegrantedsuchotherreliefinlawandequity.
___________,______________________,20_____.
__________________
(AttorneyforthePlaintiff)
________________
(Address)
125
FORMNO.15:DEEDOFREPURCHASEOFLANDSOLDUNDER
PACTODERETRO
DEEDOFRESALE
I,(fullnameofvendor)Filipino,oflegalage,(singleormarriedto
________________),withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
____________________;forandinconsiderationofthesumof
_______________________PESOS(P_________),Philippinecurrency,to
meinhandpaidby
(fullnameofvendee),
Filipino,oflegalage,(singleormarriedto________________),with
residenceandpostofficeaddressat____________________doherebyby
thesepresentsRESELL,RETRANSFER,ANDRECONVEYuntothesaid
_______________________thatcertainparcelofland,withallthebuildings
andimprovementsthereon,situatedin____________________________and
moreparticularlydescribedasfollows,towit:
(Descriptionoflandasstatedinoriginalcontractofsalewithpactoderetro)
126
coveredbyTransfer(orOriginal)CertificateofTitleNo.______oftheRegistry
ofDeedsof________________,andwhichpropertywaspreviouslysoldtome
underpactoderetrobythesaid_________on_________________,executed
beforeNotaryPublic_____________,andbearingNo.Reg.No.
_____,Page______,Book________,Seriesof_______ofhisnotarial
register,copyofwhichisheretoattachedasANNEXA.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthisdayof
____________,20____,in_________________,Philippines.
__________________
(Vendor)
Withmyconsent:
_______________________
(Vendorswife,ifany)
_____________________
_____________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
127
FORMNO.16:DEEDOFSALEOFPRIVATEAGRICULTURAL
LAND
DEEDOFSALEOFPRIVATEAGRICULTURALLAND
AFFIDAVIT
PROVINCEOF________________
SS
MUNICIPALITYOF_____________
I,
__________________,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
________________),residentof______________________________,after
beingsworninaccordancewithlaw,deposeandsay:
ThatIamthevendeeinthesaleoftheabovedescribedprivateagricultural
land;ThatIamanaturalizedcitizenofthePhilippines,byvirtueofafinal
decisionoftheCFI_____________;on________________thatacertified
copyofmycertificateofnaturalizationisheretoattachedasAnnex
128
A;thatIamqualifiedtoacquireandholdpublicandprivatelandsinthe
Philippines.
_________________
(SignatureofAffiant)
JURAT
FORMNO.17:DEEDOFSALEOFREGISTEREDLAND
DEEDOFSALE
KNOWNALLMENBYTHESEPRESENTS:
I,(Fullnameofvendor),Filipino,single/marriedto____________,oflegal
age,withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
_____________________________________________,forandin
considerationofthesumof__________PESOS(P_______),Philippine
currency,tomeinhandpaidby
(Fullnameofvendee),
Filipino,oflegalage,withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
_______________________________,
doherebySELL,TRANSFER,andCONVEY,absolutelyand
unconditionally,untothesaid______________his/herheirsandassigns,that
129
certainparcel(orparcels)ofland,togetherwiththebuildings,improvements
thereon,situatedin(cityormunicipality,andprovince)andmoreparticularly
describedasfollows,towit:
(Description)
ofwhichIamtheregisteredownerinfeesimpleinaccordancewiththeLand
RegistrationAct,mytitletheretobeingevidencedbyTransfer(orOriginal)
CertificateofTitleNo._______,issuedbytheRegisterDeedsof
_____________________.
Itisherebymutuallyagreedthatthevendeeshallbearalltheexpensesforthe
executionandregistrationofthisdeedofsale.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosignedthisdeedofsale,this
________dayof_____,20_____,at_______________(cityor
municipality),Philippines.
_________________
(Vendor)
Withmyconsent:
_________________
(Vendorswife)
____________________
_____________________
(Witness)
(Witness)
130
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FORMNO.18:DEEDOFSALEOFREGISTEREDLANDUNDER
PACTOdeRETRO
DEEDOFSALEUNDERPACTODERETRO
KNOWNALLMENBYTHESEPRESENTS:
ThisDeedofSalewithPactodeRetromadeandexecutedbyandbetween
(fullnameofvendor),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
______________),withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
___________________,hereinaftercalledtheVENDOR,and
(fullnameofvendee),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
______________),
address at
with
residence
and
postoffice
____________________,hereinaftercalledtheVENDEE,
Witnesseth:
ThattheVENDORistheabsoluteownerofacertainparceloflandwithall
thebuildingsandimprovementsthereon,situatedin
_________________,andmoreparticularlydescribedasfollows,towit:
131
(Copydescriptionstatedincertificateoftitle),
histitletheretobeingevidencedbyTransfer(orOriginal)CertificateofTitle
No.______________issuedbytheRegisterofDeedsof____________;
ThattheVENDOR,forandinconsiderationofthesumof__________
PESOS(P______),inPhilippinecurrency,tohiminhandpaidandreceipt
whereofisherebyacknowledged,doesherebySELL,TRANSFER,and
CONVEY,underPACTODERETROuntothesaidVENDEE,hisheirsand
assigns,theabovedescribedpropertywithallthebuildingsandimprovements
thereon,freefromallliensandencumbranceswhatsoever;
ThattheVENDOR,inexecutingthisconveyance,herebyreservestherightto
REPURCHASE,andtheVENDEE,inacceptingsame,herebyobligates
himselftoRESELL,thepropertyhereinconveyedwithinaperiodof
______yearsfromandafterthedateofthis________instrument,forthe
samepriceof_________________PESOS(P_______),Philippinecurrency:
Provided,however,thatiftheVENDORshallfailtoexercisehisrightto
repurchaseashereingrantedwithintheperiodstipulated,thenthis
conveyanceshallbecomeabsoluteandirrevocable,withoutthenecessityof
drawingupanewdeedofabsolutesale,subjecttotherequirementsofthelaw
regardingconsolidationofownershipofrealproperty.
this______dayof__________,20_____,in_________________,
Philippines.
_________________
(Vendor)
________________
(Vendee)
Withmymaritalconsent:
___________________
(VendorsWife)
_____________________
_____________________
132
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FORMNO.19:DEEDOFSALEOFUNREGISTEREDLAND
DEEDOFSALE
KNOWALLMENBYTHESEPRESNTS:
(Fullnameofvendor),Filipino,single/marriedto____________,oflegalage,
andwithresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
_________________________________forandinconsiderationofthesum
of_____________PESOS(P_____),Philippinecurrency,tohiminhandand
paidby
(Fullnameofvendee),Filipino,oflegalage,withresidenceandpostoffice
addressat__________________________________________,DOES
HEREBYSELL,TRANSFER,ANDCONVEYuntothesaid
(Fullnameofvendee),his/herheirsandassigns,thatcertainparcel(orparcels
ofland,togetherwithallthebuildingsandimprovementsthereonbelonging
tothevendorandinpresentpossessionof
_______________________,
situated in
______________________________,andmoreparticularlydescribedas
follows,towit:
133
(Description:Statenatureofeachpieceoflandanditsimprovements,
situation,boundaries,areinsquaremeters,
whetherornottheboundariesarevisibleonthelandbymeansofmonuments
orotherwise,andintheaffirmativecase,inwhattheyconsist;thepermanent
improvements,ifany,existingontheproperty;thepagenumberofthe
assessmentofeachpropertyforcurrentyearoryearswhenregistrationis
made;theassessedvalueofthepropertyfortheyear.)
Thatitisherebydeclaredthattheboundariesoftheforegoinglandarevisibly
bymeansof____________________;thatthepermanentandimprovements
existingthereonconsistsof_____________________(Ifnone,stateso;that
thelandisassessedforthecurrentyearatP_______asperTaxDeclaration
No.______,andthebuildingsand/or
improvements,atP_____asperTaxDeclarationNo._____ofthe
City/ProvincialAssessorof_______;
Theabovedescribedrealestate,nothavingbeenregisteredunderActNo.496
orundertheSpanishMortgageLaw,thepartiesheretohaveagreedtoregister
thisinstrumentundertheprovisionsofSec.194oftheRevisedAdministrative
Code,asamendedbyActNo.3344.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,thepartiesheretohavesignedthisdeedthis
____dayof____,20____in______________,Philippines.
______________
(Vendor)
______________
(Vendee)
_____________________
_____________________
134
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FORMNO.20:DEEDOFSALEWITHMORTGAGE
DEEDOFSALEWITHMORTGAGE
ThisDEEDOFSALEWITHMORTGAGE,madeandexecutedbyand
between
(Fullnameofvendor),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
______________),withresidenceandpostofficeaddressat
___________________,hereinaftercalledtheVENDORMORTGAGEE,and
(Fullnameofvendee),Filipino,oflegalage,single(ormarriedto
______________),
address at
with
residence
and
postoffice
____________________,hereinaftercalledtheVENDEEMORTGAGOR,
Witnesseth:
ThattheVENDORMORTGAGEEistheownerinfeesimpleofacertainparcel
oflandtogetherwithallthebuildingsandimprovementsthereon,situatedin
___________,histitletheretobeingevidencebyTransfer(or
135
Original)CertificateofTitleNo._____oftheRegistryofDeedsof
____________whichlandismoreparticularlydescribedasfollows,towit:
(Descriptionofland)
Thatforandinconsiderationofthesumof__________PESOS
(P_________),Philippinecurrency,ofwhichamountthesumof
____________________PESOS(P________)hasbeenpaidbythe
VENDEEMORTGAGORandreceiptwhereofisherebyacknowledgedby
theVENDORMORTGAGEE,thesaidVENDORMORTGAGEEdoes
herebySELL,TRANSFER,andCONVEYuntothesaidVENDEE
MORTGAGORtheabovedescribedrealestatetogetherwithallthebuildings
andimprovementsthereon,freefromallliensandencumbranceswhatsoever;
ThatitisherebyagreedandstipulatedthattheUNPAIDBALANCEof
_______________PESOS(P_______),Philippinecurrency,ofwhichamount
thesumof__________________PESOS(P_________)shallbepaidbythe
VENDEEMORTGAGORtotheVENDORMORTGAGEEatthelatters
residence,asfollows,towit:
(herestatemannerofpayment)
That,inordertoguaranteethefulfillmentoftheaboveobligations,the
VENDEEMORTGAGORdoesherebyMORTGAGEuntotheVENDOR
MORTGAGEE,hisheirsandassigns,therealestatehereinabovedescribed,
togetherwithallthebuildingsandimprovementsthereon,undertheexpress
stipulationthatifthesaidVENDEEMORTGAGORshallwellandtrulypay
orcausetobepaiduntotheVENDORMORTGAGEEtheaforesaid
obligations,thenthisMORTGAGEshallbeofnofurtherforceandeffect;
otherwise,thesameshallremaininfullforceandeffectandshallbe
enforceableinthemannerprescribedbylaw.
this______dayof_________,20_____,in______________,Philippines.
_______________
________________
(VendorMortgagee)
(VendeeMortgagor)
136
_____________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
_____________________
MANIFESTATIONS/MOTIONS
ANDCOMMENTS
137
FORMNO.1:MANIFESTATIONANDMOTIONTOISSUE
CERTIFICATEOFFULLCOMPLIANCEWITHCIVIL
OBLIGATION
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MANIFESTATIONANDMOTIONTOISSUECERTIFICATEOF
FULLCOMPLIANCEWITHCIVILOBLIGATION
Accusedbycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
138
On10March2012,hereinpartiessubmittedtothisHonorableCourtaMotion
toApproveCompromiseAgreementandToRenderJudgmentontheBasis
Thereofthepertinentportionofwhichare,towit:
Forthesettlementofthecivilaspectoftheaboveentitledcase,FirstParty
herebyagreestothefollowingsumofmoneyasthetotalamountofcivil
liabilityoftheSecondParty,towit:
Php200,000.00thetotalamountofmoneyallegedlystolenbytheSecond
Party
Php50,000.00AttorneysFee
4.3TheSecondParty,uponsigninghereof,herebyagreestopaytheFirst
Partyandtendersthesum:
Php100,000.00
asdownpaymentoftheaforesaidamount
Php50,000.00
asandinpaymentforthesaidAttorneysfee
TheFirstPartyherebyacknowledgedreceiptofthetotalsumofPhp
100,000.00fromthesecondpartyonthedateofsigningthisinstrumenttobe
appliedforthepurposeaforesaid;
TheSecondPartyherebyagreesandundertakestopaytheremainingbalance
ofPhp100,000.00infour(4)equalmonthlyinstallmentsatPhp100,000.00
permonth.Thescheduleofpaymentsareasfollows:
1stinstallmentPhp25,000.00payableonorbeforeApril9,20112nd
installmentPhp25,000.00payableonorbeforeMay9,20113rdinstallment
Php25,000.00payableonorbeforeJune9,20114thinstallmentPhp25,000.00
payableonorbeforeJuly9,2011
Itisherebyagreedthatthepaymentoftheforegoingfour(4)installments
shallbecoveredbyfour(4)postdatedchecks;
Thefailureand/orrefusaloftheSecondPartytoreplacewithcashanyand/or
alloftheabovepostdatedcheck/s,ifthesameis/aredishonoredupon
presentmentforpaymentonitsduedate,afterfivebankingdaysfromnotice
shallrendertheentireremainingobligationimmediatelydueanddemandable;
Inthelattercase,SecondPartyherebyagreethatanOrderoftheCourtforthe
issuanceofthewritofexecutionshallbeissuedoutrightuponmotionforthe
satisfactionofhisremainingcivilobligation;
139
ThepartieshereinagreethattheforegoingCompromiseAgreementshallbe
submittedtotheHonorableCourtforapproval.
On09July2012,accusedhasfullycompliedwithhisfullobligationby
payingthetotalamountofTWENTYFIVETHOUSANDPESOS(Php
25,000.00)inaccordancewiththesaidAgreement.
Tosupportitsclaim,theundersignedattachedthebankcertification,
photocopiesoftheencashedchecksandapplicationformofBPIManagers
ChecksinfavorofprivateprosecutorAtty.JeffreyParilIntoandprivate
complainantOgSabadowhichareheretoattachedasAnnexesAtoA1,B
andCrespectively.
Inviewoftheforegoing,accusedpraysfortheissuanceofthecertificateof
fullcomplianceofthecivilobligationandpermanentdismissaloftheabove
entitledcriminalcase.
CityofManila,forImusCity,25July2012.
BAQUIRAN,CORONADO&RICAFRANCACounselforAccusedJasper
SolCruz
2ndFloor,RCVJBuilding,
DonP.CampaAvenue,BarrioUno,2662DasmarinasCity,Cavite
by:
RollNo.690069
IBPNo.990905/1032012/Cavite
PTRNo.1678611/1022012/Dasmarinas
MCLEComplianceNo.IV111255
NoticeofHearing
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
OfficeoftheCityProsecutor
140
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
1080NegrosStreet,BalicBalic
Sampaloc,Manila
ATTY.ALEXANDERLIQUIGAN
Unit3C,DeQuirozBldg.,
AguinaldoHighway,PerpetualVillage,
PalicoIII,ImusCity,Cavite
Greetings:
PleasesubmittheforegoingManifestationfortheconsiderationandapproval
oftheHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
Copyfurnished:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
Explanation
141
Thepleadingisbeingfiled,withcopyfurnishedtheotherparties,byprivate
couriersduetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromtheCourtandthesaid
parties,makingpersonalservicethereofnotpracticable.
FORMNO.2:MOTIONOFREQUESTFOROFFICIALCOPY
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONOFREQUESTFOROFFICIALCOPY
142
(OFHONORABLECOURTSRESOLUTIONDATED23
SEPTEMBER2010)
Accused,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
AccusedwasformerlyrepresentedxxxbyJANSENABESAMISKALAW
OLAGUERLAPUZLAWFIRM(JAKOLLaw).
On24August2011,accusedservednoticetoJAKOLLawofitsdecisionto
ceasealllegalrepresentationhandledbythelatteronbehalfofthepetitioner.
PetitioneralsorequestedJAKOLLawtomakearrangementsforthetransfer
ofallfilesrelatingtoitslegalrepresentationonbehalfofpetitionertothe
undersignedcounsel.
Theundersignedcounselwasengagedtoactascounselfortheaccusedinthe
aboveentitledcase;andthus,fileditsentryofappearanceon12September
2011.
Theundersignedcounsel,throughpetitioner,hasreceivedinformationthatthe
HonorableCourtpromulgatedaResolutiononaccusedsMotionfor
Reconsideration.
Todate,theundersignedcounselhasyettoreceiveanofficialcopyofthe
abovementionedResolution.
WHEREFORE,undersignedcounselherebyrespectfullyrequestsforan
officialcopyoftheHonorableCourtsResolutiononaccusedsMotionfor
Reconsideration
ImusCity,October192011.
SolCruz
by:
143
RollNo.690069
Notice
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
Greetings:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingmotionfortheconsiderationandapprovalofthe
HonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
FORMNO.3:MOTIONFORALLOWANCETOAPPEARAS
AMICUSCURIAE
SUPREMECOURT
Manila
PATRICIOTAN,FELIXFERRER,
JUANM.HAGAD,SERGIOHILADO,
VIRGILIOGASTON,CONCHITAMINAYA,
TERESITAESTACIO,DESIDERIODEFERIA,
ROMEOGAMBOA,ALBERTOLACSON,
FEHOFILENA,EMILYJISON,
NIEVESLOPEZANDCECILIAMAGSAYSAY,
Petitioners,
versusG.R.DOCKETNO.667SC901V
FOR:PetitionforProhibitionandMandamus
144
THECOMMISSIONONELECTIONSandTHEPROVINCIALTREASURER
OFNEGROSOCCIDENTAL,
Respondent.xx
MOTIONFORALLOWANCETOAPPEARASAMICUSCURIAE
Movant,byhimself,byspecialappearancetothisHonorableCourt,most
respectfullystates:
ThathereinMovantwasanelectedSenatorandservedduringtheyear1988
1995.
MovantwastheprincipalauthorofBatasPambansaBlg.885orAnAct
CreatingaNewProvinceintheIslandofNegrostobeknownastheProvince
ofNegrosdelNorte.Movanthasextensivelyandexhaustivelycraftedthe
saidbillduringthesenatedeliberationsforthesameduringtheyearshe
servedasaSenator.
ThatthepresentcasesprungfromtheconstructionofSec5(3)therein,whichthe
committeedeliberationshavenotaccompaniedanexplanatorynote.
Thattoensurethemeaningfuldiscussionandappreciationoftheissuesas
raisedintheabovementionedcasebeforetheHonorableCourt,Movant
requestthathebemadearesourcespeakertoaidtheCourtinthecases
speedydisposition.
WHEREFORE,undersignedherebyrespectfullyrequeststhathebeallowed
toappearbeforetheHonorableCourtasanamicuscuriaetoaidthecourtin
thespeedydispositionofthepresentcase.
CityofManila,October191996.
AMBROSIOPADILLA
Movant
145
Notice
HONORABLESUPREMECOURT
CityofManila
Greetings:
HonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
AMBROSIOPADILLA
FORMNO.4:MOTIONFORBILLOFPARTICULARS
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Branch47
PuertoPrincesaCity,Palawan
ALEXBERMEJ
Plaintiff,
CivilcaseNo.5524
versus
FOR:DAMAGES
ROELPONCEDELEON
Defendant
xx
MOTIONFORBILLOFPARTICULARS
146
Defendant,bycounselandtothisHonorableCourt,respectfully
states:
Thecomplaintallegesthatdefendantpublicofficial,togetherwithherein
defendantmovant,actingsinglyorcollectively,andorinunlawfulconcert
withoneanother,inflagrantebreachofpublictrustandofsheerfiduciary
obligationsaspublicofficerswithgrossandscandalousabuseofrightand
powerandinbrazenviolationoftheConstitutionandlawsofthePhilippines,
embarkeduponasystematicplantoaccumulateillgottenwealth.
Theforegoingallegationsareconclusionsoflaw,whichplaintiffshould
clarifyandfleshthemwithfactsandspecificactstoenabledefendantmovant
toprepareandfilearesponsiveanswertheretowhichrequiresinformationas
toprecisenature,character,scopeandextentofplaintiffscauseofaction.
WHEREFORE,defendantpraysthatplaintiffbeorderedtofileabillof
particularsofthefactsandactsconstitutingtheconclusionsallegedinthe
complaint.
ATTY.PERCIVALJAMESL.
LACEBAL
CounselfortheDefendant
NOTICEOFHEARING
Atty.JuanS.Magbanua
Counselforthedefendant
Bgy.SanPedro,PuertoPrincesaCity
Sir:
PleasebeinformedthattheundersignedcounselhassettheforegoingMotionfor
ReconsiderationforhearingonNovember25,2013at8:30am,for
147
theconsiderationoftheHonorableCourtorsoonthereafterascounselmaybe
heard.
ATTY.PERCIVALJAMESL.
LACEBAL
CounselforthePlaintiffBgy.Sta.Monica.PuertoPrincesa
City
AFFIDAVITOFPERSONALSERVICE
I,RUBENR.PADILLA,oflegalageandhavingbeendulysworndepose
andsay:
ThatIamthemessengerofAtty.ArnelB.Venturillo,Counselforthe
defendantinthecaseentitledAlexanderBermejovs.RoelPoncedeLeon,
CivilCaseNo.65448,andthatsuchmessengerIserveduponthecounselof
adversepartyandotherparties,theMotionforConsiderationfiledinsaid
case,asfollows:
Atty.BernardoU.Goy,counselforthePlaintiff,bypersonalserviceby
deliveringpersonallycopyofsaidMotionuponsaidlawyerwho
acknowledgedreceiptthereofasshownbyhissignatureorinitialonthesaid
pleading,this23rddayofOctober2013
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavesignedthisaffidavitthis24thdayof
October2013atPuertoPrincesaCity.
RubenR.Padilla
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNTOBEFOREME,ANotarypublicinandfor
theCityofPuertoPrincesaandtheProvinceofPalawanthis24thdayofOctober
2013.AffiantpersonallycameandappearedwithDriversLicenseIDNo.issued
bytheLandTransportationOfficeandvaliduntilMay1,2015,atPuertoPrincesa
City,bearinghisphotographandsignature,knowntomeasthesamepersonwho
personallysignedtheforegoinginstrumentbeforemeand
148
avowedunderpenaltyoflawtothewholetruthofthecontentsofsaid
instrument
ATTY.PERCIVALJAMESL.LACEBAL
NotaryPublic
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof2013;
Copyfurnished:
Atty.MarilenSaniel
Counselforplaintiff
Bgy.SanPedro,PPcity
FORMNO.5:MOTIONFORCONSOLIDATIONOFCASES
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO,
Petitioner,
versus
CIVILCASENO.CQTZ2425285DFor:DeclarationofNullityof
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
149
Respondent
x
x
EXPARTEMOTIONFORCONSOLIDATIONOFCASES
Petitioner,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
ThisisaPetitionforDeclarationofNullityofMarriagewhichwasfiledon26
June2013.
Onthesamedate,aProtectionOrderwithapplicationforTPOandSupport
PendenteLitepursuanttoAdministrativeMatterNo.041011CortheRules
onViolenceAgainstWomenandTheirChildrenActinvolvingtheabove
mentionedpartieswasfiledandraffledbeforetheRegionalTrialCourtof
PasayCityBranch113withCivilCaseno.BCV201384.
Thatthetwopetitionsinvolvethesamepartieswithintertwinedissuesand
subjectmatters.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatanorderbegrantedtoconsolidate
thetwoactionsintheRegionalTrialCourtBranch113,PasayCitywherethe
declarationofnullityofmarriagewasraffledwhichmaytendtoavoid
unnecessarycostsordelayandtoservethebestinterestsofthepartiesandto
settleexpeditiouslytheissuesinvolved
ImusCityforPasayCity,7July2013.
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
406ViolagoHomes,Litex,QuezonCity
Tel.No.09178032788
EmailAdd.:LLawOffice@yahoo.com
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
IBPNo.119739CAVITECHAPTER
PTRNo.3181314,ImusCity,11112
AttorneysRollNo.58500
MCLEComplianceNo.VI1111201
150
Notice
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
Greetings:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingmotionfortheconsiderationandapprovalof
theHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.6:URGENTMOTIONFOREARLYRESOLUTION
DepartmentofJustice
OFFICEOFTHECITYPROSECUTOR
HallofJusticeCompound,AguinaldoHighway,ImusCity
OGSABADO,
Complainant,
versus NPSDOCKETNO.V14INV22C1653
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Respondent.
151
xx
URGENTMOTIONFOREARLYRESOLUTION
Complainant,bycounsel,totheHonorableProsecutor,respectfullystates
that:
ThisisacriminalactionforQualifiedTheftundertheRevisedPenalCode
whichwasfiledon06May2011.
Sincethen,complainantispatientlywaitingfortheresolutionoftheabove
captionedcase.
Truthtotell,privatecomplainanthasreceivedreliableinformationfrom
unimpeachablesourcesthatrespondentsareprocessingpaperstogoabroad.
Thus,theundersignedisrequestingfortheearlyresolutionoftheabove
entitledcasesoasnotfrustratetheendsofjustice.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthataResolutionberenderedinthis
casebasedontheevidencepresented.
ImusCity,17December2012.
PARILLAWOFFICE
CounselforPrivateComplainant1080NegrosStreet,BalicBalicSampaloc,
Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
IBP#941296,SampalocChapter,12272010
PTR#176413,Sampaloc,Manila,122012
MCLEComplianceNo.II0009569
152
MCLEComplianceNo.III0000923
Copyfurnished:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
ATTY.RAPHAELCORONADO2ndFloor,RCVJBuilding,
FORMNO.7:MOTIONFORISSUANCEOFAHOLDDEPARTURE
ORDER
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
153
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONFORISSUANCE
OFAHOLDDEPARTUREORDER
PrivateComplainant,bycounsel,underthedirectcontrolandsupervisionof
theHonorablePublicProsecutorrespectfullyallegesthat:
ThisisacriminalcomplaintforQualifiedTheftundertheRevisedPenal
Codeagainsttheaccused.
Privatecomplainanthasreliableinformationthatsaidaccusedisintendingto
goabroadtoevadecriminalprosecution.
Consequently,toinsurethataccuseddonotleavethecountrytoevade
criminalprosecutionandtoguaranteethatheisproperlybroughtbeforethe
barofjusticetofacehischarge,itbecomesimperativethathebeplacedinthe
holddepartureorderlistoftheBureau;
FortheguidanceandinformationoftheCourt,wefurnishthecompletedata,
regardingaccusedJASPERSOLCRUZtowit;
CompleteName:
JASPERSOLCRUZ
Sex
:
male
CivilStatus
:
Separated
CompleteAddress
:
No.866W.CornettoStreet,
Malibay,PasayCity
DateofBirth
:
May18,1958
Birthplace
:
Tanauan,Batangas
Age
:
54yearsold
PhotocopyofthephotographoftheJASPERSOLCRUZisheretoattachedas
AnnexAforeasyreference.
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itisrespectfullyprayedthatthis
HonorableCourtissueanorderdirectingtheCommissioneroftheBureauof
ImmigrationtoplaceaccusedJASPERSOLCRUZintheirHoldDeparture
Orderlist.
154
Otherreliefandremediesjustandequitableunderthepremisesareprayed
for.
PARILLAWOFFICE
Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
Withmyconformityand
Undermycontrolandsupervision:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
Asst.CityProsecutor
Notice
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
155
Branch21,ImusCity
Greetings:
PleasebenotifiedtheundersignedhasrequestedtheBranchClerkofCourt
toincludetheforegoingMotionintheCourtCalendaronAugust23,2011at
8:30a.m.thatcounselandmattermaybeheard.
JEFFREYPARIL
Copyfurnished:
ImusCity,Cavite
Explanation
CopyoftheMotionwasfurnishedtotherespondentbyprivatecourierdueto
thedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidparties,makingpersonal
servicethereofnotpracticable.
156
JEFFREYPARIL
FORMNO.8:MOTIONFORLEAVETOSERVESUMMONS
BYPUBLICATION
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
157
Forms
Petitioner,
versus
CIVILCASENO.CQTZ2425285D
For:DeclarationofNullityofMarriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONFORLEAVE
TOSERVESUMMONSBYPUBLICATION
Petitioner,bycounseltothisHonorablerespectfullystatesthat:
On26June2013,petitionerfiledaPetitionforJudicialDeclarationofNullity
ofMarriage.
On21July2013,theundersignedreceivedaReturnofSummonsfrom
FernandoPohwzJr.,processserveroftheOfficeoftheClerkofCourtand
SheriffsofPasayCity,statingtowit:
THISISTOCERTIFYthatonJuly11,2013,undersignedtriedtocausethe
serviceofSummonsissuedintheaboveentitledcasetogetherwithacopyof
complaintwithitsannexesuponDefendantELLENA.ADARNAather
givenaddressinBarangay316PalinSt.,Block27,Lot77,AiAi,General
Tinio,GMA,Cavite,butfailedanunavailingonthegroundthatsaid
Defendantisnolongerresidingathergivenaddress.Informationgivenby
BrgychiefCVO,JESSIEVINEGARasevidencedbyhissignatureappearing
atthebottomofthecopySummons.
WHEREFORE,thecopyofSummonsandComplaintisnowhereby
respectfullyreturnedtotheHonorableCourtUNSERVED.
PasayCity,forCarmona,Cavite,this13dayofJuly,2013.
FERNANDOPOWHZ,JR.
Processserver
158
Despitetheprocessserversdiligenteffortsandafterbeingfurnishedwitha
maptotheaddressoftherespondent,thesummonswasreturnedtothecourt
unserved.AcopyoftheReturnofSummonsisattachedherewithasAnnex
A.
Section6oftheRuleonDeclarationofAbsoluteNullityofVoidMarriages
andAnnulmentofVoidableMarriages(SupremeCourtA.M.No.021110)
statesthefollowing,towit:
Section6.Summons.TheserviceofsummonsshallbegovernedbyRule14
oftheRulesofCourtandbythefollowingrules:
Wheretherespondentcannotbelocatedathisgivenaddressorhis
whereaboutsareunknownandcannotbeascertainedbydiligentinquiry,
serviceofsummonsmay,byleaveofcourt,beeffecteduponhimby
publicationonceaweekfortwoconsecutiveweeksinanewspaperofgeneral
circulationinthePhilippinesandinsuchplacesasthecourtmayorderIn
addition,acopyofthesummonsshallbeservedontherespondentathislast
knownaddressbyregisteredmailoranyothermeansthecourtmaydeem
sufficient.
Thesummonstobepublishedshallbecontainedinanorderofthecourtwith
thefollowingdata:(a)titleofthecase;(b)docketnumber;(c)natureofthe
petition;(d)principalgroundsofthepetitionandthereliefsprayedfor;and
(e)adirectivefortherespondenttoanswerwithinthirtydaysfromthelast
issueofpublication.
Thus,petitionerherebypraysthatsummonsbeservedonrespondentby
publicationinaccordancewiththeabovequotedrule.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itismostrespectfullyprayedofthis
HonorableCourt,inaccordancewithA.M.No.021110,thatsummonsbe
servedbypublication.
Otherequitablereliefsarelikewiseprayedfor.
159
ImusCityforPasayCity,25July2013.LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
406ViolagoHomes,Litex,QuezonCityTel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
NoticeofHearing
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
HON.SOLICITORGENERAL
134AmorsoloSt.,AmorsoloBldg.,
LegaspiVillage,MakatiCity
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
316PalinSt.,Block27Lot77
AiAi,GeneralTinio,GMA,Cavite
Greetings:
PleasetakenoticethattheundersignedhassettheforegoingMotionfor
LeavetoServeSummonsbyPublicationfortheconsiderationandapprovalof
thisHonorableCourtonJuly29,2013at8:30a.m.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
160
Copyfurnished:
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
TheforegoingmotionisbeingfiledtotheHonorableCourtwithcopy
thereforefurnishedtotheOfficeoftheSolicitorGeneral,Officeofthe
ProvincialProsecutorandtheotherpartybyregisteredmails,duetothe
distanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidofficesandotherparty,making
personalservicethereofnotpracticable.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.9:MOTIONFORPERMANENTDISMISSAL
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
161
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONFORPERMANENTDISMISSAL
ACCUSED,bytheundersignedcounsel,untothisHonorableCourt,most
respectfullystatesthat:
On02September2012,anOrderwasissuedbythisHonorableCourt
dismissingthecaseprovisionallywiththeexpressedconformityofthe
accused.AttachedisacopyofthesaidOrderheretomarkedasAnnex"1"and
formsandintegralparthereof;
UndertheRulesonCriminalProcedure,theprovisionaldismissalofthe
offensespunishablebyimprisonmentnotexceedingsix(6)years,shall
becomepermanentone(1)yearaftertheissuanceoftheorderwithoutthe
casehavingbeenrevived;
Ayearhadalreadylapsed,andtheprosecutionhasnotinstitutedanyactionto
revivethecase;hence,accusedrespectfullymovesthatthecasebe
permanentlydismissed.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsideredandintheinterestofjustice,itis
respectfullyprayedthattheHonorableCourtrenderthecasepermanently
dismissed.
Otherreliefsjustandequitablearealsoprayedfor.
ImusCity,forPasayCity,29December2013.
BAQUIRAN,CORONADO&RICAFRANCA
CounselforAccusedJasperSolCruz
162
by:
RollNo.690069
Notice
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
Greetings:
theHonorableOfficeimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
Copyfurnished:
163
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
FORMNO.10:MOTIONTOADMITAFFIDAVITOF
RECANTATION
164
Phil Forms
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONTOADMITAFFIDAVITOFRECANTATION
Respondent,bycounsel,respectfullystates:
1.Thattheinstantcasewasassignedforpreliminaryinvestigationto
HonorableCityProsecutorJackMiof.
ThatthecomplainantvoluntarilyexecutedanAffidavitofRecantation
assistedbyhisprincipal,RosaRosal,pertinentportionofwhichstates:
Thatafterprofoundreviewandcontemplation,takingintoconsiderationof
thefactsandcircumstancesoftheaboveentitledcase,IfullyrealizedthatI
committedaseriouserrorastotheidentityofalltheaccusedandhis
purportedparticipationintheabovecitedcase.
Thus,intheinterestofjustice,respondentthroughtheundersignedcounsel
implorethisHonorableOfficetoadmittheAffidavitofRecantationaspart
oftherecordsofthiscase.
Theinstantmotionisfiledingoodfaithandnotmeanttodelaytheproceedings
ofthiscasenorprejudicetherightsofcomplainant.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsideredandintheinterestofjustice,itis
respectfullyprayedthattheOfficeoftheCityProsecutortoadmitthe
AffidavitofRecantationaspartoftherecordsofthiscase.
165
Otherreliefsjustandequitablearealsoprayedfor.
ImusCity,forPasayCity,29December2013.
SolCruz
by:
RollNo.690069
Notice
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
Greetings:
theHonorableOfficeimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
166
Copyfurnished:
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
FORMNO.11:MOTIONTOCANCELLISPENDENS
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
167
Phil Forms
Branch47
ALEXBERMEJO,
CivilcaseNo.5524
Plaintiff,
versus
FOR:
DAMAGES
ROELPONCEDELEON,
Defendant
x
x
MOTIONTOCANCELLISPENDENS
Plaintiff,bycounselandtothisHonorableCourt,respectfullystates:
Defendantcausedtheannotationorregistrationofanoticeoflispendenson
thesubjectmatteroftheinstantsuit,
2.Defendantcausedtherecordingofthelispendensforthepurposeof
molestingplaintiff,andtherecordalthereofisnotnecessarytoprotecthis
rightstotheproperty,hisrightthereto,ifany,isonlyindirectandcontingent.
Therecordalofthelispendensisprejudicialtoplaintiffsinteresttothe
propertybecause,beingtheownerofsaidproperty,itisburdenanditrestricts
itstransferabilitybysale,asnoonewillbuyitduringthependencyofthecase
andforaslongasthelispendensisnotcanceled.
RELIEF
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysthatthenoticeoflispendensbe
orderedcancelled.
168
CityofPuertoPrincesa,December2,2013
ATTY.FELYQ.BALADAD
Counselfortheplaintiff
Brgy.SanPedro,PuertoPrincesaCity
RollNo.75648
IBPNo.0457Palawan,
PTRNo.11456788,issuedonApril13,2012,
MCLEComplianceCert.No.66587
NOTICEOFHEARING
Atty.JuanS.Magbanua
Counselforthedefendant
Bgy.SanPedro,PuertoPrincesaCity
Sir:
PleasebeinformedthattheundersignedcounselhassettheforegoingMotion
forReconsiderationforhearingonNovember25,2013at8:30am,forthe
considerationoftheHonorableCourtorsoonthereafterascounselmaybe
heard.
ATTY.FELYQ.BALADAD
Bgy.Sta.Monica.PuertoPrincesaCity
AFFIDAVITOFPERSONALSERVICE
I,JOSEPHD.DAJAY,oflegalageandhavingbeendulysworndeposeand
say:
ThatIamthemessengerofAtty.FelyQ.Baladad,Counselforthedefendantin
thecaseentitledAlexanderBermejovs.RoelPoncedeLeon,Civil
169
CaseNo.65448,andthatsuchmessengerIserveduponthecounselof
adversepartyandotherparties,theMotionforConsiderationfiledinsaid
case,asfollows:
Atty.ArnelBelarmino,counselfortheDefendant,bypersonalserviceby
deliveringpersonallycopyofsaidMotionuponsaidlawyerwho
acknowledgedreceiptthereofasshownbyhissignatureorinitialonthesaid
pleading,this23rddayofOctober2013
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavesignedthisaffidavitthis4thdayof
November12013atPuertoPrincesaCity.
JOSEPHD.DAJAY
Affiant
fortheCityofPuertoPrincesaandtheProvinceofPalawanthis3rddayof
November2013.AffiantpersonallycameandappearedwithDriversLicense
IDNo.D11125477issuedbytheLandTransportationOfficeandvaliduntil
May1,2015,atPuertoPrincesaCity,bearinghisphotographandsignature,
knowntomeasthesamepersonwhopersonallysignedtheforegoing
instrumentbeforemeandavowedunderpenaltyoflawtothewholetruthof
thecontentsofsaidinstrument
ATTY.FELYQ.BALADAD
NotaryPublic
UntilDecember31,2014
Doc.No.______;PageNo.______;BookNo.______;Seriesof2013;
FORMNO.12:MOTIONTOCITEWITNESSFORCONTEMPT
170
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Branch47
PEDROMANZANO
Plaintiff,
CivilcaseNo.5524
versus
For:DAMAGES
JUANDECASTRO
Defendant
xx
MOTIONTOCITEWITNESSFORCONTEMPT
PLAINTIFF,bycounselandtothisHonorableCourtrespectfully
alleges:
Plaintiffisoflegalageandwithresidenceat335MalvarStreet,Puerto
Princesawhilerespondentisalsooflegalageandwitresidenceat433Rizal
Avenue,PuertoPrincesaCitywherehemaybeservewithsummonsandother
legalprocesses.
PlaintiffisthePlaintiffItheabovecaptionedcase.
OnNovember3,20103,uponplaintiffsapplication,thecurtissuedasubpoena
forrespondenttoappearandtestifyonDecember3,2013beforetheHonorable
Court,andsaidsubpoenawasservedonhimonNovember15,2013bythe
sheriff,perlettersreturn.Certifiedtruecopiesofthesubpoenaandthesheriffs
returnareattachedheretoasAnnexesAandB,respectively.
Respondentdidnothonorthesubpoena,ashedidnotappearonthedate,time
andplaceindicatedinsaidsubpoena,therebydelayingplaintiffspresentation
ofhisevidence,asrespondentwouldhavebeenplaintiffslastwitness.
171
WHEREFORE,plaintiffpraysthatafterrespondentshallhavebeengiventhe
opportunitytobeheard,judgmentberenderedpunishinghimforindirect
contemptofcourtforwillfuldefianceanddisregardofthesubpoenaservedon
himonNovember15,2013.
PuertoPrincesaCity,December12,2013.
ATTY.PERCIVALJAMESL.LACEBAL
CounselforthePlaintiffBgy.Tanglaw,Puerto
PrincesaCity
RollNo.75648IBPNo.0457Palawan,PTRNo.11456788,issued
onApril13,2012,
MCLEComplianceCert.No.66587
VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATION
AGAINSTFORUMSHOPPING
I,PEDROMANZANO,oflegalageandwithresidenceatLaganSt.Puerto
PrincesaCity,afterhavingbeendulysworn,deposeandsay:
ThatIamtheplaintiffintheaboveentitledcomplaint.
ThatIhavecausedthepreparationbymycounselofsaidcomplaint.
ThatIhavereadtheallegationsthereincontained,andthatthesamearetrue
andcorrectofmypersonalknowledgeorbasedonauthenticrecords.
ThatIhavenottheretoforecommencedanyactionorfiledanyclaim
involvingthesameissuesinanycourt,tribunalorquasijudicialagencyand,
tothebestofmyknowledge,nosuchotheractionorclaimispendingtherein;
andifIshouldthereafterlearnthatthesameorsimilaractionoraclimhas
172
beenfiledorispendingtothecourtwhereintheaforesaidcomplaintor
initiatorypleadinghasbeenfiled.
Witnessmyhandthis23rddayofOctober2013atPuertoPrincesaCity,
Palawan.
PEDRO
MANZANO
Affiant
fortheCityofPuertoPrincesaandtheProvinceofPalawanthis24 thdayof
October2013.AffiantpersonallycameandappearedwithDriversLicense
IDNo.issuedbytheLandTransportationOfficeandvaliduntilMay1,2015,
atPuertoPrincesaCity,bearinghisphotographandsignature,knowntomeas
thesamepersonwhopersonallysignedtheforegoinginstrumentbeforeme
andavowedunderpenaltyoflawtothewholetruthofthecontentsofsaid
instrument
ATTY.PERCIVAL
JAMESL.
LACEBAL
NotaryPublicMycommissionexpires
onDecember31,2011
PTRNo.906760issuedJan.3,2007IBPNo.918300RollNo.13466
173
FORMNO.13:EXPARTEMOTIONTODISMISS
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
For:DeclarationofNullityof
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
EXPARTEMOTIONTODISMISS
Petitioner,totheHonorableCourt,mostrespectfullystatethat:
Thisisanactionfordeclarationofnullityofmarriagefiledon26June2013
onthegroundofpsychologicalincapacityoftherespondent.
Withouttheknowledgeofthepetitioner,respondentfiledadeclarationof
nullityofmarriagebasedonArticle35,par(4)oftheFamilyCodeon
bigamousandpolygamousmarriagebeforetheRegionalTrialCourt(Branch
143)ofUrdanetaCity,Pangasinan.
ThensometimeinNovember2013,petitionerreceivedacopyoftheDecision
inthesaidcasefiledbyrespondentthedispositiveportionofwhichstates:
WHEREFORE,premisesdulyconsidered,themarriageBETWEEN
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADOandELLENA.ADARNAishereby
declaredvoidfromtheverybeginning.
SOORDERED.
174
PRISCILLAALMEDA
PresidingJudge
UponverificationwiththeaforesaidHonorableCourt,thesaidDECISIONis
nowalreadyfinalandexecutory.
Thus,petitionerisconstrainedtomoveforthedismissalofthiscaseduetothe
aforesaidreason.
Otherreliefsasarejustandequitableunderthecircumstancesarelikewise
prayedfor.
PasayCity,February14,2014.
Petitioner
NOTICE
TheClerkofCourt
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
GREETINGS:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingexpartemotionfortheconsiderationand
approvaloftheHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.
CORONADO
Copyfurnished:
175
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
ThisExParteMotiontoDismissisbeingfiled,withcopythereoffurnished
theotherparty,totheOfficeoftheSolicitorGeneralbyregisteredmaildue
tothedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidotherparty,makingpersonal
filingandservicethereofnotpracticable.
176
FORMNO.14:JOINTMOTIONTODISPOSECONJUGALREAL
PROPERTIES
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
JOINTMOTIONTODISPOSECONJUGALREALPROPERTIES
HEREINParties,bytheundersignedcounsel,tothisHonorableCourt
respectfullystates:
ThatthisHonorableCourtrenderedaDecisionon06January2014declaring
marriagecontractedbyhereinpartieson17May1995inImusCity,Caviteto
beNULLandVOIDABINITIO.
ThattheaforesaidDecisionisnowfinalandexecutory.
Thatthereisapressingneedtoliquidatethetwo(2)parcelsoflandwith
improvementownedbyhereinpartiesdescribedasfollows:
177
TCTNo.T408811
RegisteredinthenameofSPOUSESRAPHAELandELLENA.
CORONADO
Aparcelofland(Lot47,Blk.29ofthecons.subd.planPcs04116928,
beingaportionofthecons.ofLots4762A,Fls2076D,Lot4762B2(LRC)
Psd99595&Lot4755A,Psd04018362,L.R.C.Rec.No.),situatedinthe
Bo.ofPagAsa1,Mun.ofImus,Prov.ofCavite.BoundedontheNW.,along
line12bylo37,Blk.18;ontheNE.,alongline23byRoad20;ontheSE.,
alonglines345byRoad13;ontheSW.,alongline51byLot35,Blk.18,
allofthecons.subd.plan.Beginningatapt.marked1onplan,beingN.
16deg.,18.3.,708.69m.fromMon.No.181,ImusEstate;thenceN.63deg.
01E.,9.56m.topt.2;thenceS.51deg.22E.,10.41m.topt.3;thenceS.5
deg.48W.,3.00m.topt.4;thenceS.62deg.59W.,11.93m.topt.5;thence
N.27deg.01W.,12.00m.tothept.ofbeginningcontaininganareaofONE
HUNDREDFORTY(140)SQ.METERS.Allpts.referredtoareindicatedon
theplanandmarkedonthegroundbyP.S.cyl.conc.mons.15x40cm.;
beatingstrue;dateoforig.survey,July56&1213,1994,andwasapproved
onSept.6,1995.
TCTNo.T050018
RegisteredinthenameofSPOUSESRAPHAELandELLENA.
CORONADO
Aparcelofland(Lot6Blk.19ofthecons./subd.planPcs04015051beinga
portionofthecons.ofLot4696,ImusEstate,Blk21,Psd04108597LRC
Rec.No.8843),situatedintheBrgy.ofPagAsa1,Mun.OfImus,Prov.Of
Cavite,Is.ofLuzon.BoundedontheNE.,alonglines1234byRd.Lot15;
ontheSE.,alonglines4567byRd.Lot16;ontheSW.,alongline78910
byLot7ofBlk.19;ontheNW.,alongline101byLot5ofBlk.19,allofthe
cons./subd.plan.Beginningatapt.marked1onplanbeingS.6509E
2477.37m.fromMon.No.111,ImusEstate;thenceS.2739E.,4.38m.to
pt.2;thenceS,2459E.,4.38m.topt.3;thenceS.0857E.,2.29m.topt.4;
thenceS.2028W.,2.29mtopt.5;thenceS.4953W.,2.29m.topt.6;
thenceS.6436W.,7.28m.topt.7;thenceN.2149W.,4.14m.topt.8;
thenceN.2441W.,4.14m.topt.9;thenceN.2733W.,4.14m.topt.10;
thenceN.6101E.,11.50m.tothept.ofbeginning,containinganareaof
ONEHUNDREDFORTYTWO(142)SQ.M.Allpts.referredtoare
indicatedontheplanandaremarkedonthegroundbyPscyl.cons.mons.
178
15x40cm.;bearingstrue;dateoforig.SurveyJuly27,1905June11,1909
andthatofthecons./subd.surveyFeb.1522,1998andwasapprovedon
April8,2000.
Thathereinpartiesmutuallyandvoluntarilyagreetodivideandliquidatethe
abovementionedconjugalestateinthefollowingmannertowit;
ThattheparceloflandcoveredbyTransferCertificateofTitleNoT408811
situatedintheBo.ofPagAsa1,Mun.ofImus,Prov.ofCaviteregisteredin
thenameofSPOUSESRAPHAELandELLENCORONADOcontainingan
areaofONEHUNDREDFORTY(140)SQ.METERSbeassignedsolelyin
favorofRAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO.
ThattheparceloflandcoveredbyTransferCertificateof
TitleNoTCTNo.T050018locatedinBrgy.ofPagAsa1,CityOfImus,
Prov.OfCaviteregisteredinthenameofRAPHAELCORONADO,married
toELLENCORONADOcontaininganareaofONEHUNDREDFORTY
TWO(142)SQ.METERSbeassignedsolelyinfavorofELLENA.
ADARNA.
4.3Thatbothpartiesagreethatthelotassignedtothembyvirtueofthis
dispositionshallbetheirrightfulshareintheconjugalassets.
4.4Thatbothpartieshaveagreedthatalltaxes/fees/chargesforthetransferof
ownershipandtheissuanceofnewcertificateoftitleofeachassignedparcel
oflandintheirnamesshallbeshoulderedbyeachparty.
WHEREFORE,inviewofallforegoing,itisrespectfullyprayedthatan
ORDERbeissuedbythisHonorableCourt;
OrderingthecorrespondingRegistrarofDeedsfortheProvinceofCaviteto
cancelTransferCertificateofTitlesTCTNo.T408811registeredinthe
nameofregisteredinthenameofRAPHAELCORONADO,marriedto
ELLENCORONADO,containinganareaofONEHUNDREDFORTY
(140)SQ.METERSandISSUEDANEWCERTIFICATEOFTITLEin
favorofRAPHAELENRIQUEV.CORONADO.
179
OrderingthecorrespondingRegistrarofDeedsfortheProvinceofCavite
tocancelTransferCertificateofTitlesTCTNo.T050018registeredinthe
nameofRAPHAELCORONADO,marriedtoELLENCORONADO
containinganareaofONEHUNDREDFORTYTWO(142)SQ.METERS
andISSUEDANEWCERTIFICATEOFTITLEinfavorofELLENA.
ADARNA.
Otherreliefs,whicharejustandequitable,arealsoprayedfor.
ImusCity,forPasayCity,January9,2014.
ADARNA
Assistedby:
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
ELLENA.
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
NoticeofHearing
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
Greetings:
180
Pleasebenotifiedthatinviewofthenatureoftheforegoingpleading,the
undersignedhasrequestedtheClerkofCourttosubmitthesametothe
HonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceiptthereof,foritsconsiderationand
approval.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.15:MOTIONTOEXERCISEVISITATIONRIGHTSOF
PETITIONER
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
For:DeclarationofNullity
of
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONTOEXERCISEVISITATIONRIGHTSOFPETITIONER
Sinceseparationdefactoofhereinparties,petitionerhasnotseennormeet
KATHRINEBERNARDOCORONADO,hisdaughterwithherein
respondent.Petitionersdaughterhasbeeninthecustodyofrespondentever
sincehedecidedtopackhisthingsandleavetheconjugalabodeinDecember
2003duetounbearablecircumstances.
181
Effortstovisithisdaughterprovedexceedinglydifficultifnotalmost
impossibleonthepartofthepetitionerduetohereinpartiespersonal
animosity.
Sincetheseparationdefactoofhereinparties,petitionerhascontinuedto
supporttohisdaughterbydepositingthemoneyintheaccountofthe
respondent.
Petitionerwishestoexercisehisvisitationrightsoverhisdaughter.
Henceforth,petitionerproposedtopickupherdaughtereveryotherSaturday
everymonthinthemallorresidenceoftherespondentoranyotherplace
designatedoragreeduponbyhereinpartiestobereturnedonthesamedayor
thenextdayasagreeduponbybothparties.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatafterduenoticeandhearing,an
orderbythisHonorableCourtenforcingthevisitationrightoverhisdaughter
beissuedinfavorofthepetitioner.
ImusCityforPasayCity,10December2013.
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Notice
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
182
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Greetings:
PleasetakenoticethatonTuesday,21May2013at3:00oclockinthe
afternoon,orassoonascounselmaybeheard,undersignedshallsubmitthe
foregoingurgentmotionfortheconsiderationandapprovalofthisHonorable
Court.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Copyfurnished:
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
thereforefurnishedtotheOfficeoftheSolicitorGeneral,Officeofthe
ProvincialProsecutorandtotheotherpartybyregisteredmails,duetothe
183
distanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidofficeandotherparty,making
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.16:MOTIONTOINHIBIT
DepartmentofJustice
HallofJusticeCompound,AguinaldoHighway,ImusCity
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONTOINHIBIT
Complainant,bycounsel,totheHonorableCourt,allegesthat:
Theinstantcomplaintwasfiledsometimein06May2011.However,upto
thistime,noresolutionhasyetbeenissuedbythehonorableoffice;
Thishasbeenthecasedespiteseveralfollowupsmadebythecomplainant
anditisveryapparentthatthereisanunreasonabledelayinrenderingthe
resolutiontotheextremeprejudiceofthecomplainants;
184
Inviewoftheforegoing,toavoidtheappearanceofbiasandimpropriety,it
ismostrespectfullyprayedoftheHonorableOfficethatthehonorable
investigatingprosecutorinhibithimselffromresolvingthiscriminal
complaint.
Otherreliefsjustandequitablearelikewiseprayedfor.
CityofManila,forImusCity,25May2012.
PARILLAWOFFICE
Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
CopyFurnished:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
DonP.CampaAvenue,BarrioUno,
185
2662DasmarinasCity,Cavite
EXPLANATION
Theforegoingmotionisbeingservedtotheotherpartybyregisteredmail
duetodistanceandlackofofficepersonneltoeffectpersonalservice
thereof.
FORMNO.17:MOTIONWITHLEAVETOINTERVENEANDTO
ADMITATTACHEDCOMPLAINTININTERVENTION
SUPREMECOURT
Manila
WHITELIGHTCORPORATION,
Plaintiff,
versus G.R.DOCKETNO.868SC922VI
FOR:PetitionforDeclaratoryRelief
CITYOFMANILA,representedby
MAYORALFREDOS.LIM,
Defendant.
xx
MOTIONWITHLEAVETOINTERVENEANDTOADMIT
ATTACHEDCOMPLAINTININTERVENTION
MovantIntervenors,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
ThisisaComplaintforDeclaratoryReliefwithPrayerforaWritof
PreliminaryInjunctionand/orTemporaryRestrainingOrderfiledonJanuary
186
2,2014,todeclareOrdinance7774prohibitingtheadmissionofcustomers
onashorttimebasisorforashorttimerateinvalidandunconstitutional.
Hereinmovantsareoperatorsandproprietorsofvariousbusiness
establishmentsintheCityofManilawhosemaincustomersarelocaltourists
andpeoplefromfarflungareasinthecountryhavingtheirvacationinthe
Metro.
ThatthepassageoftheaforesaidOrdinancewilladverselyaffectherein
movantslawfuloccupationandbusinesses,duetothefactthatthe
establishmentstheyoperatearetouristandpeoplefueled,andthepassage
oftheOrdinanceincontroversymayaffectthepatronageofthemovants
customers.
ThepassageoftheaforesaidOrdinance7774willadverselyaffectthe
businessoperationandoccupationofmovants,totheirdetrimentand
prejudice.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatanorderberenderedadmitting
hereinMovantsasIntervenorsintheaboveentitledcase.
ImusCityforCityofManila,7January2014.
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Notice
187
HONORABLESUPREMECOURT
CityofManila
Greetings:
theHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.18:MOTIONTOLIFTORDEROFARREST
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONTOLIFTORDEROFARREST
AccusedJasperSolCruz,bycounsel,totheHonorableCourt,most
188
Thaton20November2013,theHonorableCourtorderedthearrestofthe
accusedforherfailuretoappearduringthescheduledhearingonthesame
datedespiteduenotice;
WiththekindindulgenceofthisHonorableCourt,theaccuseddidnotneglect
herappearanceandtorefuseanddisobeythelawfulordersofthisHonorable
Court.However,duetothefactthathewasindisposedonthesaidhearing
date,hefailedtoappearbeforethisHonorableCourt.Moreover,accused
herebyundertakestoattendonthesaidhearingdate;
Thefilingofthismotionisnotinanymannerintendedtodelaythe
proceedingsandearlyresolutionoftheabovecaptionedcasebutissolelyfor
thereasonsabovestated;
RELIEF
INVIEWWHEREOF,itisrespectfullyprayedofthisHonorableCourtthat
theinstantmotionbegrantedandtheOrderofArrestdated20November
2013,belifted.
Accusedpraysforsuchotherreliefsasarejustandequitableunderthe
circumstances.
DasmarinasCity,forImusCity,13December2013.
SolCruz
by:
RollNo.690069
189
NoticeofHearing
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
Greetings:
PleasesubmittheforegoingMotiontoLiftOrderofArrestandkind
considerationoftheHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.
CORONADO
Copyfurnished:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
ATTY.JEFFREYPARIL
Sampaloc,Manila
190
FORMNO.19:MOTIONTORELEASEMOTORVEHICLE
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONTORELEASEMOTORVEHICLE
191
Forms
Accused,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
ThatinthehearingforthePetitionforBailheldlast12December2013,it
wasadmittedbyPO1EngelbertVillafranca,oneofthearrestingofficers,that
amotorvehiclewithbodynumberLBIXX3499ttandbearingplatenumber
DUO789belongingtotheaccusedisinpolicecustody.
Accusedmaintainedthattheimpoundedmotorvehiclewasnotusedinthe
commissionoftheoffense,norwasitincludedintheinventoryofconfiscated
itemsfromtheaccusedasadmittedbytheprosecutionwitnessPO2
Villafrancaduringthe12Decemberhearing.
Withallduerespect,itisillogicaltoconfiscate,muchmoreretaincustody,
overthesaidvehicle,whenthesamewasnotevenincludedintheinventory
ofpropertyconfiscatedfromtheaccused.
Truthtotell,thesaidmotorvehiclewasbeingusedbytheaccusedtoearna
livingandthatitwasneverintendedtobeusedforanyillegalpurpose;
Thecontinuedimpoundingofsaidvehiclehasdirectlyorindirectlydeprived
theaccusedofitsworkrelatedandpersonaluseandhasimpairedhiscapacity
toearn.
Inaddition,continuedimpoundingofsaidvehicleneedlesstostate,would
furthercauseditsdeteriorationbeyondrepair.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itisrespectfullyprayedthatanOrder
beissueddirectingPO2EngelbertVillafrancatoturnoverthepossessionof
thesaidvehicletotheaccusedorhisdulyauthorizedrepresentativesinthe
interestofjustice.
DasmarinasCity,forImusCity,13January2014.
SolCruz
192
by:
RollNo.690069
NoticeofHearing:
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
Greetings:
HonorableCourtonJanuary25,2014at1:30p.m.oratsuchtimeanddateas
maybeconvenienttotheHonorableCourt.
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.
CORONADO
Explanation
CopyoftheMotionwasfurnishedtothedefendantbyprivatecourierdueto
thedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidparty,makingpersonalservice
thereofnotpracticable.
193
RAPHAELENRIQUEV.
CORONADO
Copyfurnished:
ImusCity,Cavite
SUPT.NORAINAHBALAGUER,PESE
ImusPoliceStation
ImusCity,Cavite
PO1ENGELBERTVILLAFRANCA
ImusPoliceStation,
ImusCity,Cavite
FORMNO.20:MOTIONTORENDERJUDGMENT
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
194
MOTIONTORENDERJUDGMENT
PrivateComplainant,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfully
states:
Theaboveentitledcomplaintwasfiledon06May2011.
RespondentshouldhavefiledhisAnsweron21May2011yet,todate,upon
verificationwiththecourtrecords,respondentJasperSolCruzhasnotyet
filedtheaforesaidAnswer.
PrivateComplainantpraysforthespeedyresolutionofthiscaseasprovided
forbytheRevisedRulesofCourtandinconsonancewiththetimelesslegal
maximthatjusticedelayedisjusticedenied.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itisrespectfullyprayedthatadecision
berenderedintheaboveentitledcaseintheinterestofjustice.
CityofManila,forImusCity,25May2011.
PARILLAWOFFICE
Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
195
Copyfurnished:
PROSECUTORJACKMIOF
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
Branch21,ImusCity
Greetings:
Inviewofthenatureoftheforegoingmotion,theundersignedisrequesting
theClerkofCourttosubmitthesametotheHonorableCourtimmediately
uponreceiptthereof,foritsconsiderationandresolution.
JEFFREYPARIL
Notice:
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
196
Explanation
Copyofthepleadingwasfurnishedtothedefendantbyregisteredmaildueto
thedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidparties,makingpersonalservice
thereofnotpracticable.
JEFFREYPARIL
FORMNO.21:MOTIONFORRERAFFLEANDTOSETCASEFOR
ARRAIGNMENT
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Complainant,
FOR:QualifiedTheft
197
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
xx
MOTIONFORRERAFFLE
ANDTOSETCASEFORARRAIGNMENT
Privatecomplainant,byCounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
ThisisacriminalcaseforQualifiedTheftwhichwasfiledon06May2011
beforetheOfficeoftheCityProsecutorofCavite.
On14August2011,theHonorable3rdAssistantCityProsecutorJackMiof,
findingprobablecause,recommendedthefilingofQualifiedTheftagainstthe
accused.
ThatthecasewasraffledbeforethesalaofretiredHonorableJudgeTori
Black.
On10December2011,theHonorableCourtissuedanAliasWarrantof
ArrestagainstAccusedJasperSolCruz.
PhotocopyoftheAliasWarrantofArrestisheretoasAnnexAforeasy
reference.
Thenon27January2012,accusedwasarrestedbyParaaquePolice.Hewas
detainedatParaaquePoliceStation7andlatertransferredtoImusJail.Said
accusedpostedabailforhisprovisionalrelease.
Todate,therewasnoavailablejudgetohearthecasethustheundersigned
respectfullyrequeststorerafflethesameinordertosetthecasefor
arraignmentconsideringthatthecasewasfiledmorethantwoyears.
Needlesstostate,thelongyearsofdelayinthearraignmentofaccusedhas
causeduntoldsufferingandmentalanguishonthepartoftheprivate
complainant.
Tomakemattersworse,saidaccusedhasalreadygoneabroadsometimein
2012inBahrainduringthependencyofthiscase.
198
Thatbasedonreliableinformation,accusedJasperSolCruzisagain
intendingtoleavethecountryforthepurposeofabscondingandthereby
evadingprosecutionofthiscase.
Thatinordertoexpeditethetrialofthiscase,theundersignedrespectfully
beggedtheindulgenceofthisHonorableCourtthattheinstantcasebere
raffledandsetforhearingsoasnottofrustratetheendsofjustice.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatthisHonorableCourtissuean
ordergrantingthattheabovecaptionedcasebereraffledtoanothersalain
ordertosetthecaseforarraignment.
Otherreliefandremediesjustandequitableunderthepremisesareprayed
for.
ImusCity,Cavite,March6,2013.
PARILLAWOFFICE
Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
Withconformity:
JACKMIOF
Asst.ProvincialProsecutor
Notice
THECLERKOFCOURT
199
RTCBranch21
ImusCity,Cavite
ImusCity,Cavite
Greetings:
PleasesubmittheforegoingMotionfortheconsiderationandapproval
oftheHonorableCourtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
JEFFREYPARIL
Copyfurnished:
ImusCity,Cavite
200
Forms
Explanation
TheforegoingmotionisbeingfiledtotheHonorableCourtandCity
Prosecutorwithcopythereforefurnishedtotheotherpartybyregistered
mail,duetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidotherparty,making
JEFFREYPARIL
FORMNO.22:MOTIONTORESET
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
201
versus
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONTORESET
Petitioner,bycounsel,totheHonorableCourt,mostrespectfullystatesthat:
ThehearingoftheabovecaptionedcasewassetonOctober4,2013at8:30
AM.
However,theaforesaidhearingscheduleonOctober4,2013hasaconflict
withtheGlobalLPOConferenceandExhibitionorganizedbyGlobal
outsourcingAssociationofLawyerstobeheldfromOctober7to8,2013at
theNewYorkCityBARAssociation,42West44thStreetNewYorkNY
10036ofwhichtheundersignedisaparticipant.
AttachedherewithistheDelegatePassissuedtotheundersignedbythe
GlobaloutsourcingAssociationofLawyersasAnnexA.
Henceforth,itisrespectfullyprayedthatthehearingsetbytheHonorable
CourtonthesamedatebemovedtoOctober24,2013at8:30AMoratsuch
timeandplaceasmaybeconvenienttothescheduleoftheHonorableCourt.
Plaintiffpraysforsuchotherreliefsasarejustandequitableunderthe
circumstances.
ImusCity,forPasayCity,19September2013.
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
202
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Notice
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Greetings:
PleasesubmittheforegoingMotiontoresetandapprovaloftheHonorable
Courtimmediatelyuponreceipthereof.
RICA
KAYEO.LOMIBAO
203
Copyfurnished:
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
Thismotionisbeingfiled,withcopythereoffurnishedtheotherparties,by
registeredmailsduetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidparty,
makingpersonalfilingandservicethereofnotpracticable.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.23:MOTIONTOREVIVECRIMINALACTIONAND
FORTHEISSUANCEOFWRITOFEXECUTIONONTHE
COMPROMISEAGREEMENT
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
204
Complainant,
versus
CRIMINALCASENO.
993511
FOR:Qualified
Theft
JASPERSOLCRUZ,
Accused.
x
x
MOTIONTOREVIVECRIMINALACTION
ANDFORTHEISSUANCEOFWRITOFEXECUTIONONTHE
COMPROMISEAGREEMENT
Plaintiff,bycounseltothisHonorableCourtrespectfullystates:
On17March2012,theHonorableCourtissuedanOrderintheabove
entitledcase,thedispositiveportionofwhichreads:
Findingthemutualagreementofthepartiesbeforethemediatortobe
meritorious,thesameisherebyAPPROVED.
PendingcomplianceoftheCompromiseAgreementletthecriminalaspectof
thiscaseforARCHIVED.
SOORDERED.
Dasmarias,Cavite,March17,2012.
AMERIICHINOSE
ActingJudge
ThatthedefendantstartedpayingonlyTHREETHOUSANDPESOSon09
April2011.
205
Todate,defendanthasdefaultedinpayinghismonthlyobligationtoPlaintiff
CorporationforthelastTHREE(3)MONTHS.Todate,HEHASONLY
PAIDTHREETHOUSANDPESOSONLY.
Thatdefendantmadehislastpaymenton10May2011.On16June2012,
plaintiffsentademandlettertodefendantbyregisteredmail.
PhotocopiesofthelatestStatementofAccountofthedefendantandthe
demandletterandproofofserviceareheretoattachedasAnnexA,Band
B1foreasyreference.
Itbearsstressingthatpar.5and6oftheaforesaidCompromiseAgreement
statesthat:
ThatincaseoftheSecondPartysfailureand/orrefusaltopaytotheFirst
Partyanymonthlyinstallmentfortwo(2)cumulativemonths,itisunderstood
thattheremainingbalanceofthetotalobligationshallbecomedueand
demandable,withouttheneedofanywrittendemand.
ThatincaseofbreachofthetermsandconditionsofthisAgreement,the
SecondPartyshallpayTHIRTYTHOUSANDPESOS(Php30,000.00)as
liquidateddamageincaseofbreachofthisAgreement.
Inthelattercase,SecondPartyherebyagreethatanOrderoftheCourtforthe
issuanceofthewritofexecutionshallbeissuedoutrightuponmotionforthe
satisfactionofhisremainingcivilobligation;
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itisrespectfullyprayedthattheWritof
Executionbeissuedagainstthedefendant,orderinghimtopaytoplaintiffthe
remainingobligationintheamountofPhp60,000.00representingthetotal
amountofhiscivilliability.
PARILLAWOFFICE
CounselforPrivateComplainant1080NegrosStreet,BalicBalic
206
Sampaloc,Manila
by:
JEFFREYPARIL
MCLE
ComplianceNo.IV0007733
NoticeofHearing
ImusCity,Cavite
CLERKOFCOURT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch21,ImusCity
Greetings:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingmotionforconsiderationandapprovalofthe
HonorableCourtonAugust1,2011at8:30a.m.oratsuchtimeanddateas
maybeconvenienttotheHonorableCourt.
207
JEFFREYPARIL
Copyfurnished:
ImusCity,Cavite
Explanation
thereforefurnishedtotheOfficeoftheProvincialProsecutorandtotheother
partybyregisteredmails,duetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromthesaid
officeandotherparty,makingpersonalservicethereofnotpracticable.
JEFFREYPARIL
FORMNO.24:MOTIONTOSETCASEFORPRELIMINARY
CONFERENCE
208
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONTOSETCASEFORPRELIMINARYCONFERENCE
ThisisapetitionfortheDeclarationofNullityofMarriagefiledon26June
2013.
AstheserviceofSummonstotherespondentfailedbecausetherespondent
wasnolongerresidinginhisgivenaddress,petitionerthroughcounselfiled
amotionforleavetoservesummonsbypublicationwhichwassubsequently
granted.
Thelastdayofpublicationbeingon2August2013inDalaginding,a
newspaperofgeneralcirculation,thiscasecannowbesetforpreliminary
conference.
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysthattheaboveentitledcasebeset
forpreliminaryconferenceon___________________________orsuchdate
availableinthecourtcalendar.
Imus,Cavite,28August2013.
209
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
NOTICE
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
GreetIngs:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingmotionfortheconsiderationand
210
Forms
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Copyfurnished:
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
Thismotionisbeingfiled,withcopythereoffurnishedtheotherparty,by
registeredmailduetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromtheHonorable
Officeandsaidotherparty,makingpersonalfilingandservicethereofnot
practicable.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.25:MOTIONFORLEAVETOFILEDEMURRERTO
EVIDENCE
211

Forms
REGIONALTRIALCOURTOFZAMBOANGADELNORTE
9thJudicialRegion
DIPOLOGCITY
BranchVI
PEOPLEOFTHEPHILIPPINES,
PlaintiffCriminalCaseNo.77versus
forMurder
JUANDELACRUZ,
Accused
xx
MOTIONFORLEAVETOFILE
DEMURRERTOEVIDENCE
Theaccusedthroughcounsel,untothisHonorableCourt,mostrespectfully
states:
1.Thattheprosecutionintheaboveentitledcasehasalreadyrestedits
case;
2.Thatthedefensebelievesthattheevidenceoftheprosecutionagainstthe
accusedisinsufficienttoestablishtheguiltoftheaccusedbeyondreasonable
doubt,thus,thedefensepraysforleavetofiledemurrertoevidenceinaccordance
withSection33,Rule113oftheRulesofCriminalProcedure.
WHEREFORE,premisedontheforegoingconsiderationandinthehighest
interestofjustice,itismostrespectfullyprayedofthisHonorableCourtthat
theaforesaidmotionbegranted.
September16,2010.DipologCity,Philippines.
FORMNO.26:MOTIONWITHNOTICETOTAKEDEPOSITION
212
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
CIVILCASENO.CQTZ2425285DFor:DeclarationofNullityof
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONWITHNOTICETOTAKEDEPOSITION
PETITIONER,bycounsel,tothisHonorableCourtrespectfully
alleges:
Thatpetitionerwouldbecominghomesolelytotestifyinthiscaseon
November24to26,2013.
Thepetitionerdeemsitimperativethathereportforworkafterthelastweek
ofNovember2013,ashisabsencefromworkmightdisrupthismonthly
remittancestosupporthisthreechildrenwithrespondent.
Inviewhereof,itisherebyrequestedofthisHonorableCourtthatpetitioner
beallowedtotestifypriortohisdepartureasprovidedunderSection1and14
Rule23oftheRulesofCourtwhichwillcontinuefromdaytodayatthe
sameplaceandtimeuntilcompleted.
213
Thusintheinterestofsubstantialjusticeandequity,andconsideringthat
petitionerneedstogobacktoworkabroadafterthelastweekofNovember
2013andshallremainthereforanindefiniteperiodoftime,petitioner
respectfullymovesthattheHonorableCourtallowthetakingofhisdeposition
uponoralexaminationbeforetheHonorablePresidingJudgepursuanttoRule
23,Section1,10and15ofthe1997RulesofCivilProcedure,withinthe
statedtimeanddate,basedonthediscretionoftheHonorableCourt.
Thismotionisnotinanywayintendedtodelaytheproceedingsbutdictated
solelyforthereasonsstatedabove.
WHEREFORE,petitionerrespectfullypraysthattheHonorableCourtallow
thetakingofdepositionuponoralexaminationofpetitioneron26November
2013at8:30oclockinthemorningpursuanttoRule23ofthe1997Rulesof
CivilProcedureonthedatesandtimestatedabove.
Petitionerpraysforsuchfurtherorotherreliefasmaybedeemedjustor
equitableunderthepremises.
Imus,CityforPasayCity,18October2013.LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
406ViolagoHomes,Litex,QuezonCityTel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
214
NoticeofHearing
THECLERKOFCOURT
RTCBranch113
PasayCity
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Greetings:
Pleasesubmittheforegoingmotionfortheconsiderationand
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Copyfurnished:
PasayCity
215
Forms
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
TheforegoingmotionisbeingfiledtotheHonorableCourt,Officeofthe
CityProsecutorandtotheotherpartybypersonalservicewithcopytherefore
furnishedtotheOfficeoftheSolicitorGeneralbyregisteredmail,duetothe
distanceoftheundersignedfromthesaidHonorableSolicitorGeneral,
makingpersonalservicethereofnotpracticable.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
FORMNO.27:MOTIONTOWITHDRAWASCOUNSEL
216
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH113
PasayCity
Petitioner,
versus
For:DeclarationofNullity
of
Marriage
ELLENA.ADARNA,
Respondent
xx
MOTIONTOWITHDRAWASCOUNSEL
COMESNOWtheundersignedcounselandtothisHonorableCourt
Sheisthecounselofrecordforthepetitionerintheaboveentitledcase.
Diligenteffortswereexertedtocommunicatewiththepetitionerinrelationto
theaboveentitledpetition,whichprovedtobeunfruitful.Also,thereare
somereasons,whichareconfidentialinnature,thus,theundersignedcounsel
isconstrainedtowithdraw,asheherebywithdrawshisappearanceascounsel
forthepetitionerwhoseconformityheretocannotbeobtaineddespite
previouseffortsexertedbytheundersignedcounsel.
217
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthattheappearanceoftheundersigned
counselforthepetitionerbeconsideredwithdrawn.
ImusCity,forPasayCity,December24,2013.
LOMIBAOLAWOFFICE
Tel.No.09178032788
by:
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Notice
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Greetings:
PleasetakenoticethatinviewofthenatureoftheforegoingMotion,the
undersignedhasrequestedtheClerkofCourttosubmitthesameforthe
218
considerationandapprovaltotheHonorable,immediatelyuponreceipt
hereof.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
Copyfurnished:
PasayCity
ELLENA.ADARNA
Explanation
Thismotionisbeingfiled,withcopythereoffurnishedtheotherparty,by
registeredmailduetothedistanceoftheundersignedfromtheCourtandsaid
otherparty,makingpersonalfilingandservicethereofnotpracticable.
RICAKAYEO.LOMIBAO
219
CIVILANDSPECIALACTIONS
220
FORMNO.1:COMPLAINTFORUNLAWFULDETAINER
METROPOLITANTRIALCOURT
CityofManila
Branch1
KRULACOSTA,
Plaintiff,
CIVILCASENo.98765
versusFOR:UnlawfulDetainer
MEGANVITUG,
Defendant.
xx
COMPLAINT
COMESNOW,theplaintiff,throughtheundersignedcounselanduntothis
HonorableCourt,mostrespectfullyavers:
Thattheplaintiff,KRULACOSTA,isoflegalage,Filipinocitizen,single,with
residenceandpostaladdressat123BenitezStreet,Manila;
Thatthedefendant,MEGANVITUG,isoflegalage,Filipinocitizen,single,with
residenceandpostaladdressat456ModestoStreet,Manila,wheretheymaybe
servedwithsummonsandothercourtprocesses;
Theplaintiffistheownerofalandoverwhichanapartmenthadbeenconstructed
located654SanPedroStreet,Manila;
Byvirtueofacontractoflease,theplaintiffleaseduntothedefendantthe
aforesaidapartmentforaconsiderationofP5,000.00amonthasrentaltobepaid
withinthefirstten(10)daysofeachmonthstartingNovember3,2011;
ThedefendantfailedtopaytheagreedrentalforseveralmonthsstartingFebruary
19,2012uptothepresent;
221
OnMay3,2012,theplaintiffsentaletterofdemandtovacatetheapartment
whichwasreceivedbythedefendantasshownintheregistryreturnreceipthereto
attachedasAnnexA;
Despitesaidletterofdemandwhichwasrepeatedbyoraldemands,thedefendant
failedandstillrefusedtopaytheagreedamountofrentalsandtovacatedthe
apartment;
Byreasonoffailureofthedefendanttovacatethepremisesandtopaytheunpaid
rentals,theplaintiffwascompelledtofilethiscomplaintengagingtheservicesof
counselintheamountofP10,000.00.
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itismostrespectfullyprayeduntothis
HonorableCourtthat,afterhearing,judgmentberenderedorderingthedefendant:
Tovacatethesubjectpremises;
TopaytheamountofP5,000.00permonthascompensationforthereasonableuseof
thesubjectpremisesuntiltheyfinallyvacatethesaidpremises;
Topaytheplaintiffthecostofthesuit.CityofManila,September24,2012.
REYES,TOLENTINOANDCRUZLAWOFFICE
Unit123,VictoriaTowerI
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
LouiseReyes
RollofAttorneyNo.98765
IBPNo.12345/2512/Manila
PTRNo.87654/122211/Manila
VERIFICATION/CERTIFICATIONOFFORUMSHOPPING
CityofManila )S.S.
222
I,KRULACOSTA,oflegalage,Filipinocitizen,singleandresidentof123
BenitezStreet,Manila,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordNancewithlaw
doherebydeposeandsay:
ThatIamtheplaintiffintheaboveentitledcase;
ThatIhavecausedthepreparationoftheforegoingcomplaintandhavereadthe
allegationscontainedtherein;
Theallegationsinthesaidcomplaintaretrueandcorrectofmyownknowledge
andauthenticrecords;
IherebycertifythatIhavenotcommencedanyotheractionorproceeding
involvingthesameissuesinanycourt,tribunalorquasijudicialagencyand,to
thebestofmyknowledge,nosuchotheractionorclaimispendingtherein;
ThatifIshouldlearnthereafterthatasimilaractionorproceedinghasbeenfiled
orispending,Iherebyundertaketoreportthatfactwithinfive(5)daystherefrom
tothecourtoragencywheretheoriginalpleadingandsworncertification
contemplatedhereinhavebeenfiled;
Iexecutedthisverification/certificationtoattesttothetruthoftheforegoingfacts
andtocomplywiththeprovisionsofAdm.CircularNo.0494oftheHonorable
SupremeCourt.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntoaffixedmysignaturethis24thof
September2012,intheCityofManila.
KRULACOSTA
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis_______dayofSeptember,
2012,intheCityofManila,affiantexhibitingtomehisDriversLicenseNo.
12345issuedbytheLandTransportationOfficeonApril8,2012attheCityof
Manila.
ATTY.NOCASE
NotaryPublic
MyCommissionExpiresDec.31,2012
Doc.No.________
PageNo._______
BookNo._______
Seriesof2012.
223
FORMNO.2:COMPLAINTFOREJECTMENTWITHDAMAGES
RegionalTrialCourt
QuezonCity,Branch33
ALISDIYANCOMPANY,
Plaintiff,
CivilCaseNo.2222
versus
For:Ejectment
YOKONGA,
Defendant.
xx
COMPLAINT
PLAINTIFF,bycounsel,respectfullystatesthat:
1.Plaintiffisaforeigncorporationorganizedandexistingunderthelawsof
Francewithbusinessaddressat111OceanDrive,TunaCompound,Quezon
City;DefendantisaFilipino,oflegalage,singleandcurrentlyresidentof112
OceanDrive,TunaCompound,QuezonCity,wherehemaybeservedwith
summonsandotherpertinentprocesses.
2.Plaintiffownsthatpropertylocatedat112OceanDrive,TunaCompound,
QuezonCitywhichitleasedtodefendantunderthetermsand
224
conditionsstatedintheContractofLeasedated1January2005,which
contractexpireson31December2006.Acopyofthecontractisattachedas
ANNEXA.
3.Uponexpirationofthecontract,plaintiffinformeddefendantofits
intentionnottorenewtheleaseasitwouldusethepropertyforitsbusiness
expansion;plaintiffthenaskeddefendanttovacatethepremises.Acopyof
plaintiffslettertodefendantisattachedasANNEXB.
4.Despitedemanddulymadeandreceived,defendanthasrefusedtovacate
thepremisesandcontinuestooccupythepropertywithoutplaintiffsconsent.
ResorttotheBarangayconciliationsystemproveduselessasdefendant
refusedtoappearbeforetheLupongTagapamayapa.ACertificationtoFile
ActionisattachedasANNEXC.
5.Defendantsactofdispossessionhascausedplaintifftosuffermaterial
injurybecauseplaintiffsbusinessexpansionplanscouldnotbeimplemented
despitethearrivalofmachineriesspecificallyleasedforthispurposeatthe
rentalrateofUS$500permonth.Defendantscontinuedoccupationofthe
premiseshasalsoforcedplaintifftosueandtoincurlegalexpenses
amountingtoFiftyThousandPesos(P50,000.00).
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysforjudgmentinitsfavorby
orderingdefendanttovacatethepropertyandpeacefullyturnoverpossession
toplaintiffandfordefendanttopayplaintifftheamountofUS$3,500
representingrentalsonthemachineriesforseven(7)monthsandFifty
ThousandPesos(P50,000.00)forAttorneysfees.
Otherjustandequitablereliefsarealsoprayedfor.
QuezonCity;13April2007.
(Sgd.)ATTICUSFINCH
CounselforPlaintiff
225
[Address]
FORMNO.3:COMPLAINTFORSUMOFMONEY
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
Branch101,MakatiCity
ESTAPADORA,
Plaintiff,
CivilCaseNo.000882
versus
For:SumofMoney
MANGGAGANTSO,
Defendant.
xx
COMPLAINT
1.PlaintiffisaFilipino,oflegalage,andresidentof6750ForbesPark,
MakatiCity;defendantisalsoaFilipino,oflegalageandresidentof6752,
ForbesPark,MakatiCity,wherehemaybeservedwithsummonsandother
processes.
2.SometimeinJanuary2005andoveraperiodofsix(6)months,defendant
borrowedcertainamountsfromplaintiff.Defendantpromisedtopaythese
amountsonaninstallmentbasismonthly.TheseamountsnowtotalNine
HundredThousandPesos(P900,000.00).
226
[4]3.Despiterepeateddemands,bothoralandwritten,defendantfailedorhas
refusedtopayanyamounttoplaintiffasnoinstallmentpaymenthaseven
beenmade.Acopyeachofplaintiffstwo(2)demandlettersisattachedas
ANNEXAandB.
ResorttotheBarangayConciliationprocessprovedfruitlessasdefendant
failedtoappear,despitenoticeonhimtoappear.Thus,aCertificationtoFile
Action,acopyofwhichisattachedasANNEXC,wasissuedbythe
BarangayChairman.
Defendantsobligationisdueanddemandableandplaintiffisentitledtothe
paymentoftheentireamountofNineHundredThousandPesos
(P900,000.00)pluslegalinterest.
Byreasonofdefendantsunreasonablefailureorrefusaltopayhisdueand
demandableobligation,plaintiffwasforcedtoengagetheservicesofcounsel
tovindicatehisrightstherebycommittinghimselftopaylegalexpenses
amountingtoFiftyThousandPesos(P50,000.00).
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysforjudgmentinhisfavorthrough
aDecisiondirectingdefendanttopayhimNINEHUNDREDTHOUSAND
PESOS(P900,000.00),withlegalinterest,asACTUALDAMAGESand
FIFTYTHOUSANDPESOS(P50,000.00)asAttorneysFees.
Otherjustandequitablereliefsarealsoprayedfor.
QuezonCityforMakati;13April2007.
(Sgd.)ATTICUSFINCHCounselforPlaintiff[Address]
227
FORMNO.4:ANSWERWITHCOMPULSORYCOUNTERCLAIM
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch33,QuezonCity
ALISDIYANCOMPANY,
Plaintiff,
CivilCaseNo.2222
versus
For:Ejectment
YOKONGA,
Defendant.
xx
ANSWER
(WithCOUNTERCLAIM)
DEFENDANT,bycounsel,respectfullystatesthat:
Admissions/Denials
1.Headmitsthecontentsofparagraph1onlyinsofarashispersonal
circumstancesbutspecificallydeniesthecontentsinsofarasplaintiffspersonal
circumstancesforthereasonstatedintheAffirmativeDefensesbelow.
228
Headmitsthecontentsofparagraph2onlywhereitstatesthataContractof
LeasewasenteredintobutspecificallydeniesthattheContractreflectsthe
trueintentofthepartiesasexplainedintheAffirmativeDefensesbelow.
Headmitsthecontentsofparagraph3onlyastothefactthatdemandto
vacatewasmadebutspecificallydeniesitscontentsastothetruthofthe
reasonsfortheletterforlackofknowledgesufficienttoformareasonable
beliefastoitstruthorfalseness..
Hespecificallydeniesthecontentsofparagraphs4to6forthereasonsstated
intheAffirmativeDefensesbelow.
AffirmativeDefense
5.Defendantreiterates,repleadsandincorporatesbyreferenceallthe
foregoinginsofarastheyarematerialandadditionallysubmitthatthe
Complaintshouldbedismissedbecause:
Plaintiffhasnocapacitytosueasitisaforeigncorporationdoingbusinessinthe
Philippineswithoutalicense.
TheComplaintfailstostateacauseofactionastheContractofLease
(ANNEXA)was,beforeitsexpiration,supercededbyaDeedofAbsolute
Salewherebyplaintiffsoldtodefendanttheparceloflandinquestion,acopy
ofwhichisattachedasANNEX1.
Counterclaim
6.Defendantreiterates,repleadsandincorporatesbyreferencealltheforegoing
insofarastheyarematerialandadditionallysubmitthatheisentitledtorelief
arisingfromthefilingofthismaliciousandbaselesssuit,asfollows:
6.1.MoralDamagesamountingtoOneMillionPesos(PHP1,000,000/00)
becausehisnameandreputationwerebesmirchedbythismaliciousand
baselesssuit.
229
6.2.AttorneysFeesamountingtoOneHundredThousandPesos
(P100,000.00)becausehewascompelledtosecureservicesofcounselto
vindicatehislegalrights.
WHEREFORE,Defendantrespectfullypraysthatjudgmentberenderedinhis
favorbydismissingtheComplaintandgrantingdefendantscounterclaimby
awardingdefendant:(a)OneMillionPesosasMoralDamages,and(b)Fifty
ThousandasAttorneysFees.
Otherjustandequitablereliefsareprayedfor.
QuezonCity;13April2007.
(Sgd.)MITCHMCDEERECounselforDefendant[Address]
230
FORMNO.5:CERTIORARI
(CaptionandTitle)
PETITION
PETITIONER,bycounsel,respectfullystatesthat:
(Statecapacityofpetitionerandrespondent/s,citizenship,statusand
residence.)
(StatethedateonwhichcopyofDecisionwasreceivedand/orResolutionon
MotionforReconsideration,iffiled,denied.)
(Statebrieflythefactsandcircumstancesunderwhichtherespondent/s
exercisingjudicialfunctionsactedwithout,orinexcessof,jurisdictionor
withgraveabuseofdiscretionamountingtolackorexcessofjurisdiction.)
(StateentitlementtoInjunctionand/orTRO,i.e.,[a]petitionerhas
aclear,legalright,[b]whichisthreatenedbyanactoromissionof
231
respondents,[c]andthat,unlessrestrained,willcausegraveandirreparable
injurytopetitioner.Allegealsothatpetitionerisreadytopostabondinan
amounttobefixedbytheCourtconditioneduponthepaymenttorespondents
ofanydamagessufferedarisingfromthewritshouldpetitionerbefoundnot
tobeentitledtothewrit.)
Thereisnoappealfromsuchdecisionoranyplainoradequatespeedyremedy
intheordinarycourseoflaw,exceptthispetition.
Acertifiedtruecopy(orduplicateoriginalcopy)oftheDecisionunderreview
isattachedasANNEXA.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatawritofcertioraribeissued
ANNULLINGthe(act,decisionorfinding)forbeingingraveabuseof
discretion;intheinterim,thatapreliminaryinjunctionand/ortemporary
restrainingorderissuetoENJOINanyfurtherproceedingsbyrespondents.
QuezonCity;7July2007.
(Sgd.)ATTICUSFINCHCounselforthePetitioner[Address]
232
FORMNO.6:PROHIBITION
(CaptionandTitle)
PETITION
(Statecapacityofpetitionerandrespondent/s,citizenship,statusand
residence.)
(Ifapplicable,statethedateonwhichcopyofDecisionwasreceivedand/or
ResolutiononMotionforReconsideration,iffiled,denied.)
(Statebrieflythefactsandcircumstancesunderwhichtherespondent/s
whetherexercisingjudicialorministerialfunctionsactedwithout,orin
excessof,jurisdictionorwithgraveabuseofdiscretionamountingtolackor
excessofjurisdiction.)
(StateentitlementtoInjunctionand/orTRO,i.e.,[a]petitionerhasaclear,
legalright,[b]whichisthreatenedbyanactoromissionofrespondents,[c]
andthat,unlessrestrained,willcausegraveandirreparableinjuryto
petitioner.Allegealsothatpetitionerisreadytopostabondinan
233
amounttobefixedbytheCourtconditioneduponthepaymenttorespondents
ofanydamagessufferedarisingfromthewritshouldpetitionerbefoundnot
tobeentitledtothewrit.)
Thereisnoappealfromsuchdecisionoranyplainoradequatespeedyremedy
intheordinarycourseoflaw,exceptthispetition.
Acertifiedtruecopy(orduplicateoriginalcopy)oftheDecisionunderreview
isattachedasANNEXA.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthataninjunctionorTRObeissued
directingrespondent/stodesistandrefrainfromfurtherproceedingsinthe
premises,andthatafterduenoticeandhearing,awritofprohibitionissue
directingrespondent/stodesistabsoluteandperpetuallyfromfurther
proceedings(inthesaidactionormatter).
234
FORMNO.7:MANDAMUS
(Captionandtitle)
PETITION
(Statethecapacityofpetitionerandrespondent/sandtheir
addresses.)
(Statethefactsandcircumstanceswherebyrespondent/sunlawfullyneglectedthe
performanceofanactwhichthelawspecificallyenjoinsasadutyresultingfrom
anoffice,trustorstation,orunlawfullyexcludedthepetitionerfromthe
enjoymentofarightorofficetowhichthepetitionerisentitled.)
Petitionerhasnoappealfromsuchdecisionoranyplainoradequatespeedy
remedyintheordinarycourseoflaw,exceptthispetition.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthat,afterduenoticeandhearing,a
writofmandamusissuecommandingrespondent/sforthwithto:(statetheact
requiredtobedone),withcostsagainstthem.
FORMNO.8:COMPLAINTININTERPLEADER
235
NALILITO,Plaintiff,
SCANo.
____________
versus
UMAAGAWandINAAGAWAN,
Defendants.
xx
COMPLAINT
Plaintiffanddefendantsarealloflegalage;plaintiffresidesat
________________whiledefendantsresideat_______________and
_______________,respectively,wheretheymaybeservedwithpertinent
notices.
On1June2007,plaintifffoundaGoldRolexOysterwatch,withoutknowing
whoitstrueowneris.Thewatchisnowinplaintiffspossession.Onorabout
5June1999,defendantsmadesimilarrepresentationstoplaintiffasto
ownershipofthewatch.
Plaintiff,whoclaimsnointerestinthewatch,cannotdeterminetheconflicting
claimsofdefendantsandthusseekstocompeldefendantstointerpleadand
litigatetheirseveralclaimsbetweenthemselves.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatthisHonorableCourtissuean
orderdirectingdefendantstointerpleadwithoneanothertodeterminetheir
respectiverightsandclaimsandtoallowplaintifftorecoverhisexpensesfor
safekeepingandthecostsofthissuit,asfirstlienuponthesubjectmatterof
thisaction.
236
FORMNO.9:ACTIONFORDECLARATORYRELIEF
237
Phil Forms
INAAPI,
Plaintiff,
versus
CivilCaseNo.2468
THECITYCOUNCIL
OFQUEZONCITY,
Defendant.
xx
COMPLAINT
PlaintiffisaFilipinocitizenoflegalageandresidentofQuezonCity;
defendantistheCityCouncilofQuezonCity,thedulyconstitutedlegislative
bodyforQuezonCity,itsmembersmaybeservedwithnoticesatQuezon
CityHall.
On1August1999,defendantCityCouncilpassedOrdinanceNo.2345
makingitunlawfultooperatecellularphoneunitswhileinsideamoving
vehicleandpenalizinganyviolationswithafineofP1,000.00foreach
offenseinadditiontoimpoundingofthecellularphoneunit.Therelevant
portionsoftheOrdinanceare,asfollows:
(Quotetherelevantportions)
3.Theabovequotedportionisambiguousbecauseitleavesunfettereddiscretion
totheauthoritiestostopevenurgentandimportantcallswhichmaybemadeonly
whilethepersonisintransit.Itfailstoconsiderthat,duetotheworseningtraffic
conditionsinMetroManila,majorityofbusinessisconductedintransitandover
cellularphones.Plaintiffisalawyerwhofrequentlyhastodictateimportant
pleadingsoverthephonewhileintransitduetotheworsening
238
trafficcondition.TheOrdinanceappearstobarhisdoingsobutplaintiffis
unawareofthelimitsofpermissibleactionundertheOrdinance.
4.Unlessdeclaratoryreliefisgranted,plaintiffwillsuffergraveand
irreparableinjurybecauseheisunsureoftheinstanceswhenhemaylawfully
usehiscellularphonewhileinamovingvehicleandwhensuchusemaylead
toconfiscationandafine.
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysthatthisHonorableCourtgrant
declaratoryreliefanddeclareplaintiffsrightsanddutiesundertheOrdinance.
FORM NO. 10: QUO WARRANTO
239
(Captionandtitle)
COMPLAINT
(Statethecapacityandaddressofbothplaintiffanddefendant.)
(Statefullyandclearlythefactsandcircumstancesshowingthatdefendantis
unlawfullyoccupyingapublicofficeandthatplaintiffisentitledtoholdthe
sameoffice.)
(Statethatplaintiffhasdemandedthatdefendantvacatesaidofficeand
deliverittoplaintiffbutthatdefendanthasunlawfullyrefusedtodoso.)
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysthatawritofquowarrantoissue
oustingandexcludingdefendantfromoccupyingtheofficeof
____________anddeclarethatplaintiffisentitledtothesaidofficeandthat
hebeplacedforthwithinpossessionthereof.
(Sgd.)ATTICUSFINCHCounselforthePlaintiff[Address]
240
APPEALONCIVILCASES
241
Forms
FORMNO.1:NOTICEOFAPPEAL
(CaptionandTitle)
NOTICEOFAPPEAL
DEFENDANT(orplaintiffasthecasemaybe)bytheundersignedcounsel,
herebyfilesanoticeofappealfromthejudgementofthisHonorableCourtin
theaboveentitledcase,dated______________,acopyofwhichwasreceived
bycounselon_____________________,andappealsthesametotheCourtof
Appeals.
(Venue,Date,Signature)
242
FORMNO.2:RECORDONAPPEAL
(CaptionandTitle)
RECORDONAPPEAL
BEITREMEMEBERED,thatonthedateshereinrespectivelymentioned,
thefollowingproceedingswerehadintheRegionalTrialCourtof
__________________:
Thaton_____________,theplaintiffappelleefiledacomplaintagainstthe
defendantappellant,inthefollowing:
(Copycomplaint)
That_______________,thedefendantappellantfiledhisAnswertosaid
complaint,asfollows:
(Copycomplaint)
3.
Thatafterduehearing,thecourt,on______________renderedthe
followingdecision:
(CopyDecision)
Thaton______________,defendantappellantfiledamotionfor
reconsiderationofthefollowingtenor:
(CopyMotionforreconsideration)
Thaton_______________,thecourtissuedanorderdenyingthesaidmotion
forreconsideration,towit:
Thaton_____________,defendantappellantreceivednoticeofthe
said
orderdenyinghismotionforreconsideration,andon
243
___________filedhisNoticeofAppealtotheCourtofAppealsasfollows:
(Copynoticeofappeal)
WHEREFORE,thedefendantappellantpraysfortheapprovalofthisRecord
onAppealandthatthesamebetransmittedtotheCourtofAppeal,together
withalltheoralanddocumentaryevidencegiveandpresentedatthetrialof
theaboveentitledcase.
(Venue,date,signature)
244
FORMNO.3:PETITIONFORREVIEWONCERTIORARI
(CaptionandTitle)
PETITIONFORREVIEW
PETITIONERintheaboveentitledcase,anduntothisHonorableCourt,
respectfullyavers:
Thatthepetitioneris______________;thattherespondentis
____________;
Thatthefollowing,inbrief,arefactsofthis:
SUMMARYSTATEMENTOFFACTS
(Heregiveasummarystatementofthemattersinvolved,innumbered
paragraphs,attachingcopiesofsuchmattersnecessaryinthedetermination
ofthelegalissuestoberaised,eachcopybeingmarkedasAnnexA,etc.)
ThefollowingassignmentoferrorshadbeenmadeintheCourtofAppeals,to
wit:______________________________________;
Thattherearespecialandimportantreasonsconsistingmainlyofquestionsof
lawjustifyingareviewbythisHonorableSupremeCourtofthedecisionof
therespondentCourtofAppeals(or
245
RegionalTrialCourt,Etc.,asthecasemaybe).Amongsaidreasonsarethe
following:
REASONSFORALLOWANCEOFWRIT
(Hereraiseonyquestionsoflaw
Whichmustbedistinctlyset
Forth)
ThatattachedtothispetitioniscertifiedcopyofthedecisionoftheCourtof
Appeals(orRTC,etc.,asthecasemaybe)hereinsoughttobereviewed,
markedAnnex___,togetherwithtwenty(20)printedcopiesoftherecordof
appeal.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthatthispetitionforonwritof
certioraribegranted.
(verification)
246
FORMNO.4:APPELLANTSBRIEF
(CaptionandTitle)
STATEMENTOFTHECASE
(Clearandconcisestatementofthenatureoftheaction)
STATEMENTOFTHEFACTS
(Asummaryoftheproceedings,theappealedrulingsandordersofthecourt,
thenatureofthejudgementandanyothermattersnecessarytoan
understandingofthenatureofthecontroversy,withpagereferencestothe
record)
THEISSUES/ASSIGNMENTOFERRORS
ARGUMENT
247
(Underthisheading,theappellantshouldargueoneachassignmentoferror
withpagereferencetotherecord.Theauthoritiesrelieduponshallbecited
bypageofthereportatwhichthecasebeginsandthepageofthereportat
whichthecitationisfound.)
Firsterror;
Seconderror;
Thirderror.
RELIEF
(Underthisheading,appellantshouldmakespecificationoftheorderof
judgmentwhichheseeks)
(Explanation)
(AffidavitofService)
248
FORMNO.5:APPELLEESBRIEF
(CaptionandTitle)
BRIEFFORTHEAPPELLEE
Appellee,thrucounsel,anduntothisHonorableCourtrespectfullysubmits
thebriefinanswertothatoftheappellant.
COUNTERSTATEMENTOFFACTS
Thestatementoffactsmadebyappellantinhisbriefissoinsufficientand
inaccurateinmanydetails,thatweprefertomakeourowncounterstatement
offactsasappearingintherecordsofthiscase.
(Here,statethefactsofthecase,withreferencetothepagesoftherecordin
supportthereof,butwithoutrepetitionofmattersintheappellantsstatement
offacts)
ARGUMENT
Firstallegederror:(herequotethefirstassignmentoferrormadeby
appellantinhisbrief.)
249
Inanswertotheaboveassignmentoferrorallegedlycommittedbythelower
court_________________(Heretheappelleeshallsetforthreferencestothe
record.Theauthoritiesrelineonshallcitedbythepageofthereportofwhich
thecasebeginsandthepageofthereportatwhichthecitationisfound;viz,
Macondrayv.Eustaquio,64Phil.446,456.)
Secondallegederror:(Herequotesecondassignmentoferrormadebythe
appellantinhisbrief.)
Inanswertotheaboveassignmentoferrorallegedlycommittedbythelower
court___________________(Heretheappelleeshallsetforthhisarguments
inanswertothesecondassignmentoferror,etc.)
INVIEOFTHEFOREGOING,itisrespectfullyprayedthattheappeal
interposedbytheappellantintheaboveentitledcasebedismissed,withcost
inbothinstances.
(Explanation)
(Affidavitofservice)
250
PROVISIONALREMEDY
251
Forms
FORMNO.1:COMPLAINTWITHPRAYERFORATTACHMENT
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
JuanTamadPlaintiff,
Civilcaseno.11111For:SumofMoney
versus
MariaMakiling
Defendant
xx
COMPLAINT
252
(withprayerforattachment)
Plaintiff,bytheundersignedcounselrespectfullystatesthat:
PlaintiffJuantamad,oflegalage,residingat22SanMiguelSt.Manila;while
defendantMariaMakilingisoflegalage,residingat42SanAntonioSt.
Manila;
DefendandborrowedmoneyfromtheplaintiffamountingtoP100,000and
evidencedbyapromissorynoteonDecember4,2009,hereinattatchedas
AnnexA;
ThedefendantisabouttodepartthePhiippineswithintenttodefraudher
creditors;
Thereisnosufficientsecurityfortheclaimsoughttoberecoveredfromthe
defendantintheinstantaction,andtheamountduetoplaintiffisasmuchas
thesumforwhichtheorderofattachmentmaybegrantedabovealllegal
counterclaims;
Plaintiffiswillingtoputupabondfortheissuanceofthepreliminary
attachmentinanamountfixedbycourt,whichisnotexceedingtheamountof
plaintiffsclaim;
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthat,pendingthehearingofthecase,a
writofpreliminaryattachmentbeissuedagainstthepropertyofthedefendantto
serveassecurityforthesatisfactionofanyjudgmentthatmayberecovered
herein,andafterduehearingontheprincipalcauseofthisaction,judgmentbe
renderedagainstthedefendantforthesumofP100,000withinterestatthe
stipulatedrateoftwelvepercentumperannum(12%)fromJanuary20,2010plus
costofthesuit.
CityofManila;March32010.
SIGNATUREOFCOUNSEL
Certificationofnonforumshopping
AffidavitforPreliminaryAttachment
253
FORMNO.2:COMPLAINTWITHPRELIMINARYINJUNCTION
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
JuanTamadPlaintiff,
versus
MariaMakiling
Defendant
xx
254
COMPLAINT
Plaintiff,bytheundersignedcounselrespectfullystatesthat:
PlaintiffJuantamad,oflegalage,residingat22SanMiguelSt.Manila;while
defendantMariaMakilingisoflegalage,residingat42SanAntonioSt.
Manila;
PlaintiffisengagedintheexclusivedistributionofNikeproductsinthe
Philippines;
DefendantisalsoengagedinthesaleofNikeproductsinthePhillipines;
Asaresultofdefendantsacts,plaintiffsuffereddamageamountingto
P500,000amonthstartingJanuary20,2010;
Defendantcontinuestocommittheactofillegallyinterferingwiththe
agreementbetweenplaintiffandNike;
Plaintiffisentitledtothereliefdemandedinwholeorpart,suchreliefconsists
inthediscontinuingoftheactscomplainedofforalimitedtimeor
perpetually;
Plaintiffherebyappliesforawritofpreliminaryinjunctiontorestrainthe
defendantfromtheacthereincomplainedof,andforthepurposeoffersa
bondinsuchsumthisHonorableCourtmayfix;
PRAYER
WHEREFOREitisrespectfullyprayedthat,afterduenoticeandhavinga
preliminaryinjunctionbeissuedforthwithtorestraindefendantfromdoingthe
actcomplainedof,toceaseanddesistfromsellingproductsofNikeinthe
Philippine,andthataftertrial,saidinjunctionbemadepermanent,withcosts
andsuchorderswhicharedeemedequitable.
CityofManilaMarch32010.
SIGNATUREOFCOUNSEL
VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONOFNONFORUMSHOPPING
255
FORMNO.3:REPLEVIN
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
JuanTamadPlaintiff,
Civilcaseno.11111For:Replevin
versus
MariaMakiling
Defendant
256
xx
COMPLAINT
PlaintiffbytheundersignedcounselanduntothisHonorablecourt
respectfullyaversthat:
BothPlaintiffanddefendatareofageandiscurrentlyresidingat3Rosest.
TondoManilaand4RoseSt.TondoManilarespectively;
Plaintiffistheownerofacertainpersonalproperty,namelyaHyundaiStarex
valuedatP450,000andmoreparticularlydescribedasfollowstowit;
AmotorVehiclenamelya4cylinder1999hyundaistarexvanrentedbythe
defendantonJanuary42012tobeusedindefendantscompanyouting.Which
vandefendantfailedtoreturnonthesamedayagreeduponbybothparties.
Saidpropertyhasnotbeendistrainedortakenforataxassessmentorseized
underawritofexecutionorpreliminaryattachmentorcustodialegis.
P;aintiffhasdemandedfromdefendantthereturnofsaidpropertybutthelater
refuseandcontinuestorefusetodoso.
Plaintiffhasexecutedaperformancebondindoublethevalueoftheproperty,
infavorofthedefendant,forthereturnofthepropertytoformerifsuchreturn
beadjudged,andforthepaymentofsuchsumasthedefendantmayrecover
intheaction.
WHEREFOREitisrespectfullyprayedthat
Thesubjectpropertybedeliveredtotheplaintiff;
Defendantbemadeforthecostofthissuit;
Theplaintiffbegrantedsuchotherreleifsconsistentwithlawandequity;
CityofManilaMarch29,2012.
SIGNATUREOFCOUNSELVERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONOF
NONFORUMSHOPPING
257
FORMNO.4:APPLICATIONFORREPLEVIN
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
JuanTamadPlaintiff,
versus
MariaMakiling
Defendant
258
xx
PETITIONFORAPPLICATIONFORREPLEVIN
PlaintiffbycounselandbythisHonorablecourtrespectfullyalleges
that:
PlaintiffhasfiledanactionforReplevinanddamagesintheabovecaptioned
caseagainstthedefendant,inconnectionoftherefusalofthedefendantto
returnthepersonalpropertyoftheplaintiffdespiterepeateddemands.
Plaintiffhavebeendeprivedoftheuseofsaidpersonalpropertyandincome
asaresultoffailuretoreturnproperty.
Plaintiffisreadytoandwillingtopostabondasthecourtmayfix,executed
tothedefendantincasejudgmentbenotinfavoroftheplaintiff,andforthe
paymentofsuchsumasthedefendantmayrecoverintheaction.
WHEREFORE,plaintiffrespectfullypraysthatsaidpersonalpropertybe
returnedbythedefendantwithsuchothercostsbywhichthecourtmaydeem
justaunderlawandequity.
Manila,Philippines.March5,2012.
SIGNATUREOFCOUNCEL
NOTICEOFHEARING
SERVICEOFPETITION
PROOFOFSERVICE
259
FORMNO.5:AFFIDAVITFORREPLEVIN
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
JuanTamadPlaintiff,
Civilcaseno.11111For:Replevin
versus
260
MariaMakiling
Defendant
xx
AFFIDAVIT
PlaintiffbytheundersignedcounselanduntothisHonorablecourt
BothPlaintiffanddefendatareofageandiscurrentlyresidingat3Rosest.
TondoManilaand4RoseSt.TondoManilarespectively;
Plaintiffistheownerofacertainpersonalproperty,namelyaHyundaiStarex
valuedatP450,000andmoreparticularlydescribedasfollowstowit;
AmotorVehiclenamelya4cylinder1999hyundaistarexvanrentedbythe
defendantonJanuary42012tobeusedindefendantscompanyouting.Which
vandefendantfailedtoreturnonthesamedayagreeduponbybothparties.
Saidpropertyhasnotbeendistrainedortakenforataxassessmentorseized
underawritofexecutionorpreliminaryattachmentorcustodialegis.
P;aintiffhasdemandedfromdefendantthereturnofsaidpropertybutthelater
refuseandcontinuestorefusetodoso.
Plaintiffhasexecutedaperformancebondindoublethevalueoftheproperty,
infavorofthedefendant,forthereturnofthepropertytoformerifsuchreturn
beadjudged,andforthepaymentofsuchsumasthedefendantmayrecover
intheaction.
WHEREFOREitisrespectfullyprayedthat
Thesubjectpropertybedeliveredtotheplaintiff;
Defendantbemadeforthecostofthissuit;
Theplaintiffbegrantedsuchotherreleifsconsistentwithlawandequity;
CityofManilaMarch29,2012.
261
SIGNATUREOFCOUNSELVERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONOF
NONFORUMSHOPPING
FORMNO.6:COMPLAINTFORSEPARATESUPPORT
COMPLAINT
Plaintiffbytheundersignedcounsel,anduntothisHonorablecourt,
respectfullyaversthat:
Plaintiffandthedefendantarewifeandhusband,respectively,havingbeen
marriedin______________________________on
__________________________:
Thatoutofwedlock(number)ofchildrenwerebornnamely:
_________;
262
Upto(date)themaritalrelationsbetweentheplaintiffandthedefendantwere
harmonious,until(date)whenthedefendantfrequently_______________;
(statethesufficientfactsentitlingtheplaintifftoaseparatesupport)
Inviewoftheinfidelityofthedefendant,theplaintiffwascompelledtolive
separately,withherminorchildren;
Thedefendantearnsafixedmonthlyincomeof______________
pesos;whiletheplaintiffandherchildrenhavenothing,andatpresent,liveon
charityoffriends;
Inviewofthenecessitiesoftheplaintiffandherminorchildren,thesumof
____pesoswouldbeareasonableamountforthesupportoftheplaintiffand
herminorchildren,pendetelite;
Plaintiff,withoutthefaultonherpart,wascompelledtofileactionfor
separatesupport,therebyhavingincurredthesumof
__________pesosbywayofattorneysfees.
WHEREFORE,itisrespectfullyprayedthat:
Pendentelite,thedefendantbeorderedtopaytheplaintiffthesumof
__________pesospermonth;
Afterduehearingontheprincipalcauseofthissuit,thedefendantbeordered
topaytheplaintiffbywayofregularsupportandmaintenancethesumof
_____pesos,payableonorbeforethefifthofthemonth;
Plaintifftorecoverfromthedefendantthesumof________pesosfor
attorneysfeesandthecostofthesuit.
CityofManila,March23,2010.
SignatureofcounselVerificationandCertificationofnonforumshopping.
263
264
Phil Forms
CRIMINALACTION/
INFORMATION
FORMNO1:ABDUCTIONWITHCONSENT
(CAPTION)
COMPLAINT
Theundersigned,_____________,accuses_____________ofthecrimeof
ABDUCTION,committedasfollows,towit:
Thatonorabout_____________,atabout__________(a.m./p.m.),inthe
City/Municipalityof_____________,Provinceof_____________and
withinthejurisdictionofthisHonorableCourt,thesaidaccused,didthenand
265
there
willfully,unlawfullyandfeloniouslyabductawomannamed
_____________whoisaminorof14yearswhileshewasonherwayhome
fromschool,takingandcarryingherawayonboardablackpassengervan,
againstherwillandwithlewddesigns.
Contrarytolaw.
_____________,Philippines,__Date__.
COMPLAINANT
(JURAT)
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
FORMNO.2:ABDUCTION,FORCIBLE
ProvinceOf____________________)S.S.
City/MunicipalityOf_____________
xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
266
I,AliciaBrazil,oflegalage,single,Filipinocitizenandaresidentof583D
MatibayStreetSta.Mesa,Manilaafterhavingbeendulyswornaccordingto
lawherebydeposeandsay:
ThatdefendantJulioJoseisoflegalage,single,Filipinocitizenandresident
of3456GitnangLikoStreet,PacoManila.
ThattheplaintiffworksasaparalegalforWalangLokohanLawOfficewith
anofficelocatedat678MarupokStreet,MakatiCityasevidencedby
ANNEXA.
Thatthedefendantisasecurityguardforthesamecompanyasevidencedby
ANNEXB.
Thatonorabout10:30intheeveningofFebruary14,2014,intheCityof
Makati,Philippines,thesaidaccused,withlewddesigns,didthenandthere
willfully,unlawfullyandfeloniouslyabductedmewhilecomingoutofatoilet
inmyofficebymeansofforce,violenceandintimidationbypullingmeand
forcingmetowalkattheparkinglotofthesameofficewithagunpointedat
thetopofmyheadandhearingdeaththreatsfromthedefendantshouldI
disobeyhiswishes.
HesucceededinbringingmeintohiscarwhichisaToyotaCorolla98withplate
numberTYU789,andbroughtmetohishousewherethesaidaccusedtriedto
forcemetohavesexualintercourseandmarryhimonseveraloccasionsbutstops
whenIstartcrying.
Hewasabletoabductmeforthreedaysleavingmewithnomeansof
communicationandlockingthedoorofthehousewhenhegoestowork.
Eventually,IwasabletoescapewithahelpofhislandlordnamedAugusto
Celis.
RELIEF
HonorableCourtthat,afterhearing,judgmentberenderedorderingthe
defendant:
267
Topaymoraldamages
TopaytheplaintiffactualdamagesforthedaysthatIwasnotabletogotowork
Topaytheplaintiffthecostofthesuit;
Suchotherreliefasthecourtmaydeemproper.
CityofManila,February20,2014.
FADERUGAOFORTALEZALAWOFFICE
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
MaricrisFaderugao
CERTIFICATIONOFNONFORUMSHOPPING
Provinceof____________________)S.S.
City/Municipalityof_____________)
xx
268
I,_____________,oflegalage,Filipino,(single/married/widow),anda
residentof_____________,Philippines,afterbeingsworninaccordance
withlaw,herebydeposeandcertifythat:
(a)Ihavenottheretoforecommencedanyotheractionorproceedingorfiled
anyclaiminvolvingthesameissuesormatterinanycourt,tribunal,orquasi
judicialagencyand,tothebestofmyknowledge,nosuchactionor
proceedingispendingtherein;(c)ifIshouldthereafterlearnthatthesameor
similaractionorproceedinghasbeenfiledorispendingbeforetheSupreme
Court,theCourtofAppeals,oranyothertribunalorquasijudicialagency,I
undertaketoreportsuchfactwithinfive(5)daystherefromtothecourtor
agencywhereintheoriginalpleadingandsworncertificationcontemplated
hereinhavebeenfiled.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis
_____________at_____________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforeme,this_____________,by
_____________whoexhibitedtome(his/her)CommunityTaxCertificate
No._____________issuedat_____________,Philippineson
_____________.
269
NotaryPublic
FORMNO3:ABORTION
INFORMATION
Theundersigned,_____________,accuses_____________ofthecrime
UNINTENTIONALABORTION,committedasfollows,towit:
270
Thatonorabout_____________,intheCity/Municipalityof
_____________,Provinceof_____________andwithinthejurisdictionof
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________whodidthenandthere
willfully,unlawfully,feloniously,whilehavingaquarrelwithone,
____________,beat,assault,strikeandusepersonalviolenceuponthelatter,
therebycausinganabortionbyviolence,butunintentionally.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
FORMNO.4:ACTSOFLASCIVIOOUSNESS
(CAPTION)
COMPLAINT
271
ACTSOFLASCIVIOUSNESS,committedasfollows,towit:
Thatonorabout_____________,atabout_________(a.m./p.m.),inthe
City/Municipalityof_____________,Provinceof_____________andwithin
thejurisdictionofthisHonorableCourt,thesaidaccused
_____________didthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,andfeloniously
embracetheundersigned,whenthelatterwasabouttoenterapublictoilet,
holdingherbreastsandtakinglibertiesuponherpersonbyforceandagainst
thewilloftheundersigned.
Contrarytolaw.
COMPLAINANT
(JURAT)
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
FORMNO.5:ADULTERY
RegionalTrialCourt
Branch1,Manila
272
GivenTulioPlaintiff
CriminalCaseno.12345For:Adultery
Versus
MarianRivera
Accused
xx
INFORMATION
TheundersignedCityProsecutor,uponsworncomplaintfiledbytheoffended
party,accuses_____________________ofthecrimeofadultery,commited
asfollows:
Thatinoraboutandduringthemonthsof_______and____________
andforsometimepriortheretointhecityof___________,province
of____________,Philippines,withinthejurisdictionofthecourt,the
said______,wilfullyandfeloniouslyhadsexsualintercoursewithherco
accused__________,whoisnotherhusband,whilethelatter,knowingherto
bemarried,wilfully,unlawfullyandfeloniouslyhadcarnalknowledgeofher.
ContrarytoLaw.
CityProsecutor
Witnesses:
BAILRECOMMENDED:
Certification
FORMNO.6:BRIBERY
COMPLAINT
TheUNDERSIGNED,__________________________,accuses_________,of
_____________,committedasfollows,towit:Thatonorabout_________,
273
atabout_____________inthe_________________,______________,
Philippines,thesaidaccuseddidthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,
feloniously,committedBRIBERY,upontheundersigneddirectlybyovert
actstowit:bymeansofcorruptsolicitation,demanded,acceptedandagreed
toacceptcashbriberypaymentsfromaconfidentialinformantintendingtobe
rewardedinconnectionwithbusinessaseriesoftransactionsinthecityof
PasayinvolvingathingofvalueP100,000.00.Theundersignedexecutedthis
affidavittoattestthetruthfulnessoftheforegoingfactsandtosupportthe
filingofCriminalCasesagainst_______________________________for
violationsof________________________.___________,this_____dayof
__________,____.
OffendedParty
thehereinoffendedpartyandIamsatisfiedthattheyvoluntarilyexecuted
andunderstoodtheirgivenaffidavit.
Judge
WITNESSES:
__________________________
__________________________
FORMNO.7:CONCUBINAGE
(CAPTION)
COMPLAINT
274
CONCUBINAGE,committedasfollows,towit:
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________whoisthehusbandofthe
undersignedComplainant,cohabitedandlivedtogetherwithhiscoaccused
_____________ashusbandandwifeinaprivatedwelling,begettingoutof
suchcohabitation,achildnamed_____________,thecoaccused
_____________knowingfullywellthataccused_____________wasavery
muchmarriedman.
Contrarytolaw.
COMPLAINANT
(JURAT)
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
FORMNO.8:CORRUPTIONOFMINORS
INFORMATION
275
CORRUPTIONOFMINORS,committedasfollows,towit:
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________,whodidthenandthere
willfully,unlawfully,feloniously,maliciouslyconcealhistruenametopublic
officer,____________________,dulyappointed,qualifiedandactingas
such,andwhileintheperformanceofhisduties,askedthesaidaccusedfor
histruenameandthesaidaccusedthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,
feloniouslyandwithabuseofconfidenceandauthority,promoteandfacilitate
theprostitutionandcorruptionofagirlnamed_____________,aminorof
_____________ofage,forthepurposeofsatisfyingthecarnallustofothers.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
FORMNO.9:DAMAGETOPROPERTYTHROUGHRECKLESS
IMPRUDENCE
276
ProvinceOf____________________)S.S.
xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
I,FrederickLupito,oflegalage,single,Filipinocitizenandaresidentof185C
MagandaStreet,Sta.Mesa,Manilaafterhavingbeendulyswornaccordingtolaw
herebydeposeandsay:
ThatIaminstitutingthiscomplaintagainstKristianBuenaventurawhoisoflegal
age,Filipinocitizenandaresidentof197MagandaStreetSta.MesaManila.
ThatonFebruary20,2014,atabout4:00a.m.Mr.Buenaventurawasdrivingalong
theneighbourhoodinhisToyotaAltiswhiledrunkasevidencedbytestimoniesof
witnessesontheincidentattachedheretoasANNEXAandANNEXB.
Withoutanyextraordinarycircumstancethatwouldwarrantanaccident,hiscar
bumpedthegateofmyhouse,renderingthesametobebeyondrepairas
evidencedbyaCCTVfootageattachedheretoasANNEXC.
Thatinviewoftheforegoingfacts,Iaminstitutingthiscomplaintastheownerof
theaforesaidproperty.
RELIEF
Topayactualdamagesintheamountoffiftythousandpesosrepresentingthecost
ofthepropertydamaged.
277
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
MaricrisFaderugao
Provinceof____________________)S.S.
xx
residentof_____________,Philippines,afterbeingsworninaccordancewith
law,herebydeposeandcertifythat:
278
_____________at_____________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
_____________.
NotaryPublic
FORMNO.10:ESTAFA
279
(CAPTION)
INFORMATION
SWINDLING/ESTAFA,committedasfollows,towit:
thejurisdictionofthisHonorableCourt,thesaidaccusedhavingreceived
from_____________avarietyofReadytoWeargoodsvaluedat
P_____________forthepurposeofsellingthesameoncommission,under
theexpressobligationofholdingthesameintrustfor_____________
andtoremittheproceedsofthesaleofthesaidgoods,ifsold,ortoreturnthe
sameincaseofnonsale,within________(____)daysfromreceipt
thereof,thesaidaccuseddidthenandthere,willfully,unlawfully,and
feloniously,misappropriateandconvertthesaidgoodsortheirproceedstohis
ownpersonaluseandbenefittothedamageandprejudiceof_____________
intheamountofP_____________.
Contrarytolaw.
PROSECUTOR
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
(CertificationofPreliminaryInvestigation)
280
FORMNO.11:HOMICIDE
(CAPTION)
INFORMATION
FRUSTRATEDHOMICIDE,committedasfollows,towit:
thejurisdictionofthisHonorableCourt,thesaidaccused,armedwithajungle
knife,andwithevidentintenttokill,didthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,
andfeloniouslyassault,attackandwoundone_____________inflicting
mortalwoundsindifferentpartsofhisbody,whichwouldhavedirectly
causedthedeathofsaid_____________,thusperformingallactsof
executionwhichwouldhaveproducedthecrimeofhomicideasa
consequence,butneverthelessdidnotproducethesamebyreasonofcaused
independentofhiswill,thatis,becauseofthetimelymedical
assistancerenderedonthesaid_____________.Contrarytolaw.
PROSECUTOR
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
281
FORMNO.12:HOMICIDETHROUGHABORTION
(CAPTION)
INFORMATION
HOMICIDETHROUGHABORTION,committedasfollows,towit:
thejurisdictionofthisHonorableCourt,thesaidaccused,armedwithajungle
knife,andwithevidentintenttokill,didthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,
andfeloniouslyassault,attackandwoundone_____________
inflictingmortalwoundsinvariouspartsofhisbodyresultingtohis
instantaneousdeath.
Contrarytolaw.
PROSECUTOR
Witnesses:
____________________
____________________
282
FORMNO.13:LIBEL
ProvinceOf____________________)S.S.
xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
I,ChristinaSanJuan,oflegalage,single,Filipinocitizenandaresidentof
163DMagandaStreetSta.Mesa,Manilaafterhavingbeendulysworn
accordingtolawherebydeposeandsay:
IaminstitutingthiscomplaintaffidavitagainstReklamadorSwangetwhois
oflegalage,single,Filipinocitizenandresidentof728SantolStreet,Bacood
Manila.
PlaintiffisthedeanoftheCollegeofCommunicationinPolytechnicCollege
ofManilawithgoodstandingasevidencedbyANNEXA.
DefendantistheeditorinchiefofTheInsiderwhichistheofficialstudent
publicationofPolytechnicCollegeofManila.
ThatonMarch15,2014,thestudentpublicationreleased2,500copiesoftheir
latestissuewithanarticleentitled,TheyWhoShouldBeFamousForthe
WrongReasonswrittenbythedefendantasevidencedbyANNEXB.
Thatinthesamearticle,thisstatementwasfound,DeanChristinaSanJuanis
incompetentinherpositionbutcouldnotbereplacedbyabetterfacultymember
becauseofherromanticaffairwithamarriedmanupintheranksofPCC
administrativeofficials.Ivehementlydenyanytruthtothisallegationbythe
defendant.
ThestatementwasreadbymycolleaguesandbossesandIwascalledforan
emergencymeetingonMarch16,2014andwasaskedtotakealeaveof
absencebytheboardfor60dayswithoutpayasevidencedbyANNEXC.
283
Asadirectandproximateresultofthedefamatorystatement,Isufferedinjuryto
myreputationincludingshame,mortification,hurtandemotionaldistressandwas
deprivedofearningopportunitybyvirtueofthesalarythatIwassupposedtoget
hadInotbeenorderedtotakealeaveofabsencefor60dayswithoutpayinthe
amountofPhp80,000.00
RELIEF
Topaymoraldamages
Topayactualdamagesintheamountofeightythousandpesosrepresentingthe
salaryoftheplaintifffortwomonths
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
MaricrisFaderugao
Provinceof____________________)S.S.
284
xx
_____________at_____________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
_____________.
285
NotaryPublic
FORMNO.14:MALVERSATON
(CAPTION)
INFORMATION
MALVERSATION,committedasfollows,towit:
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________whoisactingascashierof
saidcourt,andassuchaccountableforthepublicfundscollectedandreceived
byreasonofhisposition,inthewayoffees,costandbonds,willfully,
unlawfully,andfeloniously,andwithgraveofabuseofconfidence,
misappropriated,misapplied,andembezzledandconvertedtohisown
personaluseandbenefit,fromsaidfunds,thesum____________________,
Philippinescurrency,togreatdetrimentofpublicinterest.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
286
FORMNO.15:MURDER
(CAPTION)
INFORMATION
MURDER,committedasfollows,towit:
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________,didthenandthere,with
maliceaforestatedandwithdeliberateintenttotakethelifeof____________,
willfully,unlawfully,feloniously,suddenly,unexpectedly,andtreacherously
attackthelatterwithaknife,firstwoundinghiminthechest,andafterwards,
whenenfeebledandunabletodefendhimself,againinthestomach,both
woundsbeingnecessarilymortal,therebycausingthedirectandimmediate
deathofsaid___________________.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
Witnesses:
287
FORMNO.16:PARRICIDE
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES)ProvinceOf____________________)
S.S.City/MunicipalityOf_____________
xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
I,RobertoNores,Filipino,65,male,single,andaresidentof60PurezaStreet
Sta.Mesa,Manila,Philippines,afterbeingsworntoinaccordancewithlaw,
deposeandstate:
DefendantCarlesNores,ismysonresidingatthesamehouseatPurezaStreet
Sta.Mesa,Manila,Philippines;
That,ataround10:00intheeveningofOctober29,2012,afterdinner,myson
arrivedatourhouse;
That,hesawmywife,CeciliaNoresinthekitchenwashingthedishes,the
kitchenbeingatleast5feetfromthediningtable;
Withoutprovocation,thedefendantpulledaknifefromthesinkand
proceededtostabmywifewithit.
That,uponseeingwhatmysondid,rushedtomywifesaidandcalledthe
hospital;
That,uponseeingthatIwasapproachingheleftimmediatelywithout
288
evensayinganything;
Uponcallingformedicalassistanceandreachingthehospital,mywifewasdeadon
arrivalbecauseofseverebloodlossfromthestabbing;
Afterattendingtomywife,Ireportedthesaidincidenttothenearestpolice
station.Atrueandfaithfulmachinecopyofthepolicereportisherebyattached
hereasAnnexA;
IamthereforeexecutingthisComplaintAffidavitagainstmysonCarlesNores
whomaybeservedwithsubpoenaandotherprocessesofthisHonorableOfficeat
hisresidenceat60PurezaStreet,CityofManila,Philippines;
RELIEF
Topaymoraldamages
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
MaricrisFaderugao
289
Provinceof____________________)S.S.
xx
_____________at_____________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
_____________.
290
NotaryPublic
FORMNO.17:PHYSICALINJURIES
REPUBLICOFTHEPHILIPPINES)ProvinceOf____________________)
S.S.City/MunicipalityOf_____________
xx
COMPLAINTAFFIDAVIT
I,JasonDyer,25yearsofage,single,Filipinocitizen,aresidentofBrgy.
Bayanihan,ButuanCity,afterhavingbeensworntoinaccordancewithlaw,
doherebydeposeandstate:
ThatonNovember1,2011ataround6oclockintheeveningwhileIwas
headinghomefromthecemetery,ImetRedentorToro,Sr.atthecornerofIntino
BuildingalongJ.C.AquinoAvenue;
Thatwithoutwarning,hesuddenlyattackedmewitha2x2pieceofwood
whilesayinglayuanmosya!akinsya!;
Thatdespitebeinggrippedtostopbythebystandersnearby,hestillkepton
attackingmewhileshoutingmangaagawka!;
Thatduetothesaidincident,Isuffereda8inchwoundinmyhead,a
fracturedleftlegandtwobrokenribsduetotheseverebeating,andhasbeen
hospitalizedfor16daysandadvisedtoacompleterestfor4weeksormore
untilmylegbracewillberemovedandmyribswillbecompletelyhealed.
IamexecutingthiscomplaintaffidavitinordertofileacaseofSerious
PhysicalInjuriesagainstRedemtorOja,Sr.
RELIEF
291
Topaymoraldamages
Topayactualdamagesintheamounttobeprovedincourt
TaftAvenue,Manila
By:
MaricrisFaderugao
Provinceof____________________)S.S.
xx
residentof_____________,Philippines,afterbeingsworninaccordancewith
law,herebydeposeandcertifythat:
292
_____________at_____________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
_____________.
NotaryPublic
293
FORMNO.18:ROBERRY
INFORMATION
ROBBERY,committedasfollows,towit:
_____________,Provinceof_____________andwithinthejurisdictionofthis
HonorableCourt,theaccused_____________whodidthenandtherewillfully,
unlawfully,feloniously,withintenttogainandbyforceuponthingstowit:by
forciblybreakingopenwithbluntinstrumentawardrobebelongingto
__________________,takeandcarryawaytherefromagoldneckchainset
withthreediamondsandfourdiamondsvaluedat_____________________,
tothedamageandprejudiceofthesaidownerinthesum.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
294
FORMNO.19:THEFT
INFORMATION
THEFT,committedasfollows,towit:
_____________,Provinceof_____________andwithinthejurisdictionofthis
HonorableCourt,theaccused_____________whodidthenandtherewillfully,
unlawfully,feloniously,withintenttogainandbyforceuponthingstowit:by
forciblybreakingopenwithbluntinstrumentawardrobebelongingto
__________________,takeandcarryawaytherefromagoldneckchainset
withthreediamondsandfourdiamondsvaluedat_____________________,
tothedamageandprejudiceofthesaidownerinthesum.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
295
FORMNO.20:SEDITON
INFORMATION
TheUNDERSIGNED,__________________________,accuses_________,of
_____________,committedasfollows,towit:Thatonorabout_________,at
about_____________inthe_________________,______________,
Philippines,thesaidaccuseddidthenandtherewillfully,unlawfully,feloniously,
committedSEDITION,upontheundersigneddirectlybyovertactstowit:by
meansofviolenceagainstlawfulcivilauthoritywiththeintenttocauseMakati
MayorBinayoverthrow.Theundersignedexecutedthisaffidavittoattestthe
truthfulnessoftheforegoingfactsandtosupportthefilingofCriminalCases
against_______________________________forviolationsof
________________________.___________,this_____dayof
__________,____.
OffendedParty
296
thehereinoffendedpartyandIamsatisfiedthattheyvoluntarilyexecuted
andunderstoodtheirgivenaffidavit.
Judge
WITNESSES:
__________________________
FORMNO.21:QUALIFIEDTRESPASSTODWELLING
INFORMATION
QUALIFIEDTRESPASSTODWELLING,committedasfollows,towit:
thisHonorableCourt,theaccused_____________,aprivatepersonand
withoutanyjustifiablecause,enteredthehouseof______________,against
thewillofthelatter.
Contrarytolaw.
ASSISTANTPROSECUTOR
CERTIFICATION
297
CRIMINALPROCEEDING
298
Forms
FORMNO.1:MotiontoReleaseCashBailBond
(caption)
EXPARTEMOTIONTORELEASEBAIL
DEFENDANT,untothisHonorableCourt,mostrespectfullymovesforthe
releaseofhisBailBondintheabovecaptionedcase,allegingasfollows:
1.ThatthehereinDefendanthaspostedCashBailBondforhisprovisional
libertyduringthependencyoftheabovecaptionedcase,asevidencedby
OfficialReceiptNo._____________,dated_____________,acopyofwhich
isheretoattachedasAnnexAandmadeanintegralparthereof;
2.ThatintheJudgmentoftheHonorableCourtpromulgatedon
_____________,thehereinDefendantwasacquittedofallchargesand
liabilities;
3.However,thesaidJudgmentfailedtoprovideforthereleaseoftheBail
Bondpostedbythehereinaccused.
PRAYER
299
WHEREFORE,inviewoftheforegoing,Defendantmostrespectfullyprays
thathisCashBailBondbereleased.
Otherreliefjustandequitablearelikewiseprayedfor.
DEFENDANT
FORMNO.2:AFFIDAVITOFDESISTANCE
CITYOFMANILA
)S.S.
(thepersonsandcircumstancesbelowisfictional,pleaserevise)
I,JuandellaCruz,oflegalage,single,andaresidentof#123MainSt.,
Malate,Manila,afterhavingdulysworntoinaccordancewithlawhereby
deposeandstate:
IamthecomplainingwitnessforSeriousPhysicalInjuriesagainstJesusSantos
inthecaseentitled"PeopleofthePhilippinesversusJesusSantos",
CriminalCaseNo.12345,MetropolitanTrialCourt,BranchNo.11,Cityof
Manila.
Aftermysoberandsoulsearchingassessment
andanalysisoftheincident,IhaverealizedthatbecauseIwasnotwearingmy
eyeglassesanditwasdark,Icannot
300
pointout,withoutadoubttheaccusedoranyotherperson/swho
inflictedharmagainstme.
SinceIcouldnotstatewithcertaintyandwithoutdoubttheliability
ofJesusSantos,infairnesstohim,Iampermanentlywithdrawingmy
complaintagainsthim.Iclearhimofwhateverresponsibilityor
liabilitytome.
IherebyinformtheCityProsecutorofManilathatIamwithdrawing
mycomplaintforSerious
PhysicalInjuriesinCriminalCaseNo.12345entitled"Peopleofthe
PhilippinesversusJesus
Santos",MetropolitanTrialCourt,BranchNo.11,CityofManila.
IlikewiserequesttheMetropolitanTrialCourt,BranchNo.11,City
ofManilatodismisswithprejudicethesaidcriminalcase.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Iherebysetmyhandthis__dayof
September20__attheCityofManila.
JuandelaCruz
ComplainingWitness
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis22nddayofJanuary
20__attheCityofManila,Philippines.
RomeoAbad
PublicProsecutor
301
Forms
FORMNO.3:AFFIDAVITOFDESISTANCETHEFT
Provinceof_________________)S.S.City/Municipalityof____________)x
x
I,__________,
of
legalages,Filipino,(single
/
married/
widow),and
aresidentof____________,Philippines,after
havingbeendulyswornin
accordancewithlaw,herebydeposeandsay:
ThatIam
the
privatecomplainantin
the
criminal
caseentitled
"____________";
for
Theft
docketed
302
as____________before___________Trial
Court, Branch
_____,__________City,Philippines;
ThatIfoundoutthatthesaidaccusedatthetimeoftheincidentwasnotinhis
rightmindanddidnotknowthatwhathewasdoingwaswrongfuland
criminalconsideringthathewassufferingfromSchizophrenia,ParanoidType
inacuteexacerbationascertifiedtobyDr.____________of____________;
Thattheitemstakenbytheaccused,consisting
of____________and____________wereimmediatelyrecoveredfromhimand
theirvalueshadbeenvoluntarilyreimbursedbytherelativesofthesaid
Accused;
Inviewoftheforegoing,IfinallymanifestthatInowcompletelyand
absolutelyexoneratetheaccused__________fromanyliabilityinconnection
withtheabovementionedcriminalcaseandthatIamnolongerinterested,
andIherebydesist,inprosecutingthesaidcriminalcase;
ThatIexecutethisAffidavitofDesistancesothattheabovementioned
criminalcasebeimmediatelydismissedandconsideredfinallyclosedandthe
bondpostedbythehereinaccusedbereleasedtohim;
Assuch,Iamrespectfullyprayingthattheaforementionedcaseagainstthe
Accused____________bedismissedandfinallyclosed.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhand
this____________at__________City,Philippines.
Affiant
(JURAT)
303
FormNo4:AFFIDAVITOFDESISTANCEVIOLATIONOFBP22
Provinceof_________________)S.S.
City/Municipalityof____________)
xx
I,___________,oflegalage,FilipinoandaresidentofBacolodCity,after
havingbeendulysworninaccordancewithlaw,herebydeposeandsay:
1.That
I
am
the
private
complainant
in
the
Criminal
CasesNos.____________to____________entitled"PeopleofthePhilippines
vs._____________";
for
Violationof
BatasPambansa
Bilang22
pending
304
beforetheMunicipalTrialCourt,Branch______,____________City,
Philippines.
2.Inthisregard,theaccused___________hasalreadypaidinfulltheamount
representedbythecheckssubjectoftheabovementionedcases,towith:
CriminalCaseNo.CheckNo.Amount
3.Thatinviewofthepaymentinfullbytheaccused,Iwouldliketomanifestthat
Iamnolongerinterestedintheprosecutionoftheaforementionedcriminalcases
andIamrespectfullyrequestingtheHonorablePublicProsecutortomoveforthe
dismissaloftheaforementionedcasesagainsttheaccused.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihavehereuntosetmyhandthis_____________
at___________,Philippines.
AFFIANT
(JURAT)
305
FORMNO.5:CommentonFormalOfferofEvidence
NATIONALCAPITALJUDICIALREGION
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
BRANCH33,TAGUIGCITY
KRISAQUINO,
Plaintiff,
CIVILCASENO.18909
FOR:DAMAGES
versus
MELDYMARCOS,
Defendant.
XX
306
COMMENTONTHEFORMALOFFER
OFDEFENDANTSEVIDENCE
PLAINTIFF,thruundersignedcounsel,intheaboveentitledcase,andunto
thisHonorableCourtmostrespectfullymanifestshercommentsandobjections
totheDefendantsFormalOfferofEvidenceforthefollowingreasons:
EXHIBIT
DESCRIPTION
COMMENT/OBJECTION
Exhibit11
Official
Receipt
of
Tiffany
Plaintiffadmitsthesamewith
Circlet
Triple
Drop
reservation
as
to
its
Necklace
genuinenessanddueexecution.
Exhibit12
Official
Receipt
of
Frank
Sameasabove.
GehryMorphEarrings
Exhibit13
Official
Receipt
of
Sameasabove.
Diamondsby
the
Yard
Bracelet
Exhibit14
Official
Receipt
ofTiffany
Sameasabove.
MetroRing
Exhibit15
OfficialReceiptofLucinda
Sameasabove.
Ring
Exhibit2
HotelSecurityCamera
Exhibit2shouldnotbe
Footage
admittedfor
beingirrelevant
andmerelycircumstantial.The
merefactofbeingrecordedas
theonlypersonenteringthe
suite
does
not
sufficiently
provethatPlaintiffwastheone
whotookthejewelryasthe
exacttimeandcircumstances
ofthelosshavenotbeen
conclusivelyestablished.
Exhibit3
OfficialIncidentReport
Plaintiffadmitsthesamebut
FromHotelSecurity
withreservationastoits
genuinenessanddueexecution
andcommentsthatthesameis
merely
circumstantial
and
insufficient
toestablish
that
307
DefendantdidnotpubliclyimputeacrimetoPlaintiffandutterdefamatory
wordsagainstthelatterinfrontoftheBridesweddingpartyinSuite1051on
10October2009.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itismostrespectfullyprayedthatthis
HonorableCourttakecognizanceofthemattershereinsetforthandexclude
theobjectevidenceidentifiedabove.
Otherreliefsjustandequitablearelikewiseprayedfor.
MakatiCityfortheCityofTaguig,4February2010.
PROOFOFSERVICE
I,SpeedyGonzales,messengerofAtty.JonathanNepomuceno,hereincounselfor
PlaintiffKrisAquino,herebycertifythatIpersonallydeliveredPlaintiffs
CommenttoDefendantsFormalOfferofEvidencedated4February2010to
Atty.LauriceMarieAngelaAustria,counselfortheDefendant,withaddressat
8thFloor,Strata4000Towers,EmeraldAve.,PasigCity.TheCommentto
DefendantsFormalOfferofEvidencewasreceivedbycounselpersonally.
SPEEDYGONZALES
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis4THdayofFebruary2010at
MakatiCity,MetroManila,personallyappearedaffiantSPEEDYGONZALES
308
andexhibitingtomehisDriversLicensewithLicenseNo.N12345,issued
attheQuezonCityon14February2008.
Doc.No.______;
PageNo.______;
BookNo.______;
Seriesof2010
FORMNO.6:PreTrialBrief
REGIONALTRIALCOURT
NATIONALCAPITALJUDICIALREGION
MAKATICITY,BRANCH112
DEREKRAMSEY,
Plaintiff,
versus
CivilCaseNo.100110
For:Collectionofsumofmoney
JOHNLLOYD,
Defendants.
309
xx
PRETRIALBRIEF
DEFENDANT,bycounsel,respectfullysubmitshisPreTrialBrief,as
follows:
I.WILLINGNESSTOENTERINTOANAMICABLESETTLEMENT
ANDPOSSIBLETERMSOFANYSUCHSETTLEMENT
Plaintiffisopentosettlingthisdisputeamicably,subjecttoaconcrete
proposalthatisfairandreasonableandareciprocalmanifestationofopenness
fromdefendant,
PursuanttoRule18ofthe1997RulesofCivilProcedure,plaintiff
respectfullysubmitsthatthedesiredtermsofanyamicablesettlementwould
involve,first,anadmissionofamountdueandowingtoplaintiffand,second,
ascheduleofpayments.
BRIEFSTATEMENTOFCLAIMSANDDEFENSES
PlaintiffclaimsthatdefendantfailedtopaythepurchasepriceofFIVE
HUNDREDTHOUSANDPESOS(Php500,000.00)fortheRolexwatch
deliveredtothedefendant.
2.2Defendantraiseasdefensesthatnosaleevertranspiredandthatthechecks
issuedtoMr.Ramseywerestolenandthedefendantssignatureforged.
FACTSANDOTHERMATTERSADMITTEDBYTHEPARTIES
DefendantadmitsonlythosefactsstatedintheirAnswer,i.e.,theirpersonal
circumstancesandtheexistenceofthebankaccountandcorresponding
checks.
IV.ISSUESTOBETRIED
4.1.Plaintiffsubmitsthatthefollowingissueissubjecttoproof:
310
4.1.1.Thelossofthedefendantschecksasthecausefortheaccountsclosure
andforgeryofhissignature
Defendantsubmitsthatthefollowingissuesaresubjecttoproof:
Therewasacontractofsalewiththeplaintiff;V.EVIDENCE
Plaintiffintendstopresentthefollowingwitnesses:
Ms.ShainaMagdayao,toestablishthattheplaintiffanddefendantactually
metattheShangriLaMakatiHotel,thattheRolexwasthesubjectmatterofa
contractofsalebetweentheplaintiffanddefendant,andthatthedefendant
paidincashFOURHUNDREDTHOUSANDPESOS(P400,000)andissued
thecheckscoveringthebalance;
Ms.CristineReyes,managerofthehotelrestaurant,aswitnesstothemeeting
andthetransaction;
Plaintiffreservestherighttopresentanyandalldocumentary
evidence,whichshallbecomerelevanttorebutdefendantsclaimsinthe
courseoftrialaswellasanyotherwitnesseswhosetestimonywillbecome
relevanttobeliedefendantswitnesses,ifnecessary.
VI.RESORTTODISCOVERY
Consideringtherelativelysimpleissuespresented,plaintiffdoesnotintendto
availofdiscoveryatthistime;
Subject,however,toaconcreteandreasonablerequestfordiscoveryfrom
defendant,plaintiffreservestherighttoresorttodiscoverybeforetrial.
VII.AVAILABLETRIALDATES
March17,2011,March23,2011,March30,2011andApril4,2011
311
312
Phil Forms
LABORCASES
FORMNO.1:POSITIONPAPER
DepartmentofLaborandEmployment
NATIONALLABORRELATIONSCOMMISSION
NationalCapitalRegionArbitrationBranch
QuezonCity
JESUSTSOCORRO,
Complainant,
NLRCRABCaseNo.
NCR071105411
versus
313
Hon.LaborArbiter
ROMELITANRIOFLORIDO
UNISPORTMARKETINGCORP.,JOSE
YU,ELEANORYUOCAMPO,
Respondents.
xx
POSITIONPAPER
COMPLAINANT,throughtheundersignedcounselsandtothisHonorableOffice,
mostrespectfullysubmitsthisPositionPaper
PREFATORYSTATEMENT
Whenapersonhasnoproperty,hisjobmaypossiblybehisONLYpossessionor
meansoflivelihoodandthoseofhisdependents.
Whenapersonloseshisjob,hisdependentssufferaswell.Theworkershould
therefore,beprotectedandinsulatedagainstanyarbitrarydeprivationofhisjob 1.
Theesteemededucator,economist,authoranddedicatedfreemasonDeanConrado
F.Benitez,alwaysremindedhisbrothermasonsthat:
Philips Semiconductors [Phils.], Inc v Fradiquela, G.R. No
141717, April 14, 2004.
314
OneofthefivecardinalprinciplesofourConstitutionisthepromotionof
socialjusticetoinsurethewellbeingandeconomicsecurityofallthe
peoplewhichshouldbetheconcernoftheState.ButSocialJusticeshould
notbetheconcernoftheStatealone.Itshouldbetheconcernofallsuccessful
citizenswhosesuccessispossibleonlyinafreesocietythatenablesthemto
succeedaccordingtotheirindividualmeritandinitiative.Hence,theChristian
anddemocraticdutyofgivingandsharing,forverily,itismoreblessedto
givethantoreceive.2
Unfortunately,nowadaysthisexhortationfindsapplicationmoreinits
violationthaninitsobservanceespeciallyinthetreatmentbytheemployerof
hisworker.Hence,incaseofseverancefromemployment,thepoorlaborer
hasnooneelsetoturntobuttheStatealone.
Thiscallforaidisbroughttoforeonceagainintheinstantcomplaint.A
haplessemployeewho,afterspendingthebestyearsofhislifewiththesame
employerwasconstructivelydismissedfromemploymentthroughaseriesof
discriminatoryandoppressiveacts.
ACTION
Thisisacomplaintforillegalconstructivedismissalwithclaimforpayment
ofbackwages,moralandexemplarydamages,unpaidcommissions,
separationpayandattorneysfees.
underscoring and emphasis supplied; Sovereign Grand
Commanders Message (MW Conrado Benitez, PGM), Christmas

Thoughts, Far Eastern Freemason, from the compilation, Reynold S.
Fajardo, Conrado Benitez, the Mason, p. 209.
315
THEPARTIES
Complainant,priortohisseverancefromemploymentworkedasaSales
ManageratUnisportMarketingCorporation,withresidenceatNo4Garden
GrooveSt.,ParkPlaceVillage,Cainta,Rizal,1900,andforpurposesofthis
case,isdulyrepresentedbytheJAWIDLAWOFFICEthroughthe
undersignedcounselswherehemaybeservedwithsummonsandother
processesofthisHonorableOffice;
Ontheotherhand,RespondentUNISPORTMARKETINGCORPORATION
(UNISPORT,forbrevity)isacorporationdulyorganizedandexistingunder
thelawsoftheRepublicofthePhilippineswithprincipal
officeat497PresidentQuirinoAvenue.,Ext.,CornerZuluetaSt.,Paco,
Manila,NCR1007.CoRespondentsJoseYuandEleanorYuOcampoarethe
PresidentandVicePresidentofUNISPORT,respectively.
FACTSOFTHECASE
ComplainantstartedworkingforUNISPORTinSeptember1998initially
underBradgateMarketingCorporation(MarketingOfficeofUNISPORT).
MrJoseYu(MrYu),thecompanypresidentofferedhimajobunderitsSales
Department.Asthedepartmentthenwasexperiencingtroubleinmarketing
andsellingtheirREVAproducts(slippers),Complainantliterallyorganized
anddevelopedmeasuresintendedtopromoteandincreasethesalesoutputof
UNISPORT;
ConsideringthatthemarketingofficeofUNISPORTonlystartedinJuly1998
andComplainantwasengagedonlytwo(2)monthsafterassalesmanager,he
performedthefollowingactivitiestostrengthenthemarketingoffice,towit:
HesystematizedCustomerListsnationwide;
HeformattedseveralsalesdocumentneededtoprocessSalesOrder;
316
Initially,hewasalsoinvolvedintheProduction,Costing,Distribution,
CollectionandMerchandisingoftheProduct;
HeestablishedPlanningandMarketingStrategiesandSalesProgramtoboost
InputOrdersfromcustomers;
ComplainantwasalsoresponsiblefortrainingEleanorYuOcampo,the
daughterofthePresidentandalsotheVicePresidentofUNISPORT.He
introducedhertovariouslongtimeclientsandstoreownersaliketohaveher
familiarizewithUNISPORTsprospectivecustomers;
TheeffortputforthbyComplainanteventuallypaidoff.FromUNISPORTs
humblebeginnings,itsRevaBrandwasabletohaveaplaceofitsowninthe
entirePhilippinemarketLuzon,VisayasandMindanao;
InNovember2007,althoughComplainanthadcompletedandreached
thesalesquotaforthatyearend,RespondentOcamposoughtadditional
salesofTHREEMILLIONPESOS(PhP3Million)intheVisayasarea.In
asmuchasComplainantdidnotwanttodisappointher,Complainant
proceededtoVisayasandtriedtopulloffoncemorethesales.Thisisin
spiteofthefactthatitwasnearingDecemberanditisdifficultto
getordersatthattimesincemostoftheproductsbythen,shouldhavebeen
alreadyoutinthestores;
Becauseofadditionallegworkrequiredandtoomuchstress,
ComplainantsufferedastrokeonDecember10,2007,notlongafterhe
arrivedfromvariousprovincesintheVisayas.
Complainanthadtobeconfinedinthehospitalfor13days.However,because
offinancialpredicament,thedoctorsallowedhimtotakearestinhishouse
butwasstrictlyprohibitedfromengaginginanystressfulactivity;
ComplainantreportedbackforworkinApril2008.Atthispoint,without
anyhintofcompassionforapersonwhosufferedastroke,Complainant
wastoldbyOcampothatifheshouldsufferagainamajorhealth
problem,shewillterminatehisservices;
317
10. OnDecember11,2008,MrYu,issueda Memorandum3 whichprovides,

amongothers,theincreaseofSalesQuotafor2009,2010and2011.Thesaid
issuanceindicatedthatwhilethesalesquotawasincreasedthecommission
wasreduced.Allthemorefrustratingisthatthememorandumspecifically
targetsComplainantinthefollowingmanner
Itisalsoadvise(sic)toallsalespersonneltodisciplineyourhealth,a
sicklypersoncantbetolerated.Themanagementexpectsthatallsales
personnelshouldkeeptheirhealthybody;asickpersonisalsoconsidering
havingasickmind.
Bytheperiod2010uptotheearlypartof2011,thereweredrasticdropinthe
salesofproducts.TheProductDevelopmentheadedby
Ocampo,placedherordersinChinawithoutconsultingtheSales
Departmentontheproductcategoryandstyle.Asaresult,therewasa
highrejectionratefromclients,highinventoryinthewarehousesand
negativecommentsfromthedealers.Thisfactissupportedbyseveral
correspondencesfromUNISPORTscustomersandalsofromitsveryown
managers.TheproblemwiththedecliningsalesoftheproductREVAwas
notbecauseofthesalesmanagersinefficiencybutbecauseofthevery
styleoftheproductbeingintroducedbytheproductdevelopment
department,headedbyRespondentherself.However,despitetheobvious
reasonwhyclientswerebackingofffromplacingtheirorders,Ocampo
blamedComplainantonthereductionofsales;
DuringthesecondweekofMay2011,aMemorandumwasissuedannouncing
thetransferofeachDepartmenttoanotherlocation.Ocampoorderedthatthe
airconditioningunitatComplainantsroomdismantled,includingthecabinet,
sofaandtheglasspartitionoftheroom.Whatisappallingisthatonly
Complainantsairconunitwaspulledoutwhiletherestoftheroomsthen
maintainedventilation.Tomakemattersworse,theperiodoftransferwas
extendeduntilJune30,2011.Theintentionalpulloutoftheairconunit
wastomaketheworkingenvironmentofComplainantanunbearable
one.
Annex A
318
13. AsearlyasApriltoMay2011thedesignsoftheproducts affectedthe

decreaseinsales.Thisisevidencedbyemails4sentbyothermanagersof
UNISPORT,indicatingtheproblemwiththeproductsstyle;
14. Eveninthelatterdaysofcomplainantsservicewith UNISPORT,inan

email5sentonJune13,2011byDonnaSia,MerchandisingManagerof
GaisanoCapitalGroup(clientofUnisport),sheexpressedherproblemwith
thedesignsoftheslippersandthatshecannotforceherbuyerstoorder.This
informationiswellwithintheknowledgeofOcampo.Infact,asearlyas
October2010,Ocamposentanemail6tothemanagerstellingthemofthe
problem.Again,atthispoint,itbearsstatingthattheProductDevelopment
DepartmentheadedbyOcampoistheoneresponsibleintheselectionofthe
productstylesanddesigns;
OcampodidnotstoppressuringComplainant.Infact,forfour(4)
straightdays,ComplainantwasquarantinedfromJune1417,2011
insideOcamposoffice.Sheincessantlyaccusedhimofbeinganswerable
forthesalesoutput.OcampoblamedComplainantforthelowsalesinspite
ofthefactthatshewasawarethattheveryproblemwasthedesignsofthe
productsheselected;
OnJune14,2011,inanotheremail7sentbyOcampotoComplainant,she
againfaultedhimonthereducedsalesbooking.Ocamponeverstopped
pressuringComplainantandtorturinghimoftheproblem.Infact,againon
June15,2011,inanemail8sentbyOcampo,sheagainmanifestedherill
willandpersonalresentmentagainstComplainant.Ocampothreatened
Complainantthatshewillretirehim,thus:
6.)ATTHEENDOFTHEYEARIFJTSSTILLNOIMPROVEMENT
THAN(sic)WEWILLRETIREHIM
Annex B C
Annex D
Annex E
Annex F
Annex G
319
Onthatsameday,OcampotookpainstoremovefromComplainantseveral
accountshewasthenhandlingtherebydiminishinganddeprivinghimofhis
dutiesassalesmanager.Thisisevidencedbyanemail9shesenttoother
employees.ThiswasundertakenwithouttheknowledgeofComplainant;
NotlongthereafteroronJune16,2011,RespondentOcampocalled
Complainanttoheroffice.Sherelentlesslypressuredhimontheproduct
sales.Atthispoint,RespondentutteredtoComplainant
JESMASMABUTIPAMAGRESIGNKANALANG.MAGPAHINGA
KANA.BABAYARANKANALANGNAMINNGCOMMISSIONMO
19. OnJune17,2011,OcampotoldComplainanttojustgohome whenhe

reportedforwork.OcamposanimosityagainstComplainantisshowninthe
email10shesenttothestaffonthesameday,instigatingthemtocome
togetherandpressureComplainant,thus:
xxx.Awaitingyouropinionssowillforwardtojts(JesusT
Socorro)/bom,thustheywillseeitsacommitteewhoisdeciding.
imempoweringallofyousothatyouhaveavoicethatjtswillalsolearnto
workwithyouandhindiparangbossdatingniya.
AKOLANGANGBOSINGDITOHAHA
(Italic,emphasisandunderscoring
supplied)
Annex H
10
Annex I
320
ByJune21,2011whenhereportedbacktowork,EfrenGranada,the
ManageroftheHumanResourceDepartmentandWarehouseDivision,called
complainantsattentionandshowedhimacopyofthedirectiveissuedby
Ocampoinherownhandwriting,directinghimtocomputeComplainants
accruedbenefits.WhenComplainantsawthis,hewassooverwhelmedwith
emotionsthathethoughtthatOcampowasreallyseriousinhavinghim
terminated.
Feelingataloss,unwanted,anddespisedbyOcampo,becauseofthe
tortureandneverendingaccusationsofdismalperformance,Complainant
eventuallygavein.
HewasorderedbyEfrenGranadaofHRDtosignaQuitclaim.
Complainant,howeverrefuseduntilheseesthecomputationandreceives
allhisunclaimedsalariesandcommission.WhenComplainantwentback
toofficeonJuly1,2011Ocampowenttohisroomanddirectedhimthat
hehastomakeaResignationLetter11firstsotheAccountingDepartment
canstartthecomputationofhisreceivables.AllthewhileComplainant
wasmakingaresignationletter,Ocampodictatedthematterswhich
ComplainantmustwriteinhisResignationLetterashewassittingjustin
frontofher;
ItwillhavetobeemphasizedinherethattheresignationletterofComplainant
wasinitiallydatedJuly1,2011,thedayhewenttotheoffice.However,as
appearingatthelatterportionoftheletter,theeffectivityofsaid
resignationwaschangedtoJune30,2011.Thiswaswrittenunderthe
directionofOcampo,bearinguponherpromisetoprocessallhissalariesand
commissionsimmediately;
24. ComplainantwentbackonJuly15,2011tofollowuponhis unpaid

salaryandcommissions.Tohisdismay,uponcheckingwiththe
11
Annexes J
321
accounting,hewasinformedthatNOCOMPUTATIONwasevermade.To
thisdate,RespondentsturnedadeafearandablindeyeuponComplainant;
Complainantwascoercedtoresignbecauseoftheanxietyandburden
imposeduponhimbyRespondents.Hewasnotonlyforcedbutalsoenticed
andincitedintomakingaresignationletterunderthepretextthathewillbe
givenhiscommissionandsalarypromptly.Albeitthesame,uptonow,his
claimsweretotallyignored;
Duetotheforegoing,Complainantfiledthisinstantactionforillegal
dismissalbeforethisHonorableOfficeonJuly19,2011.
Withthefailuretosettleamicably,bothpartieswerethendirectedtofiletheir
respectivePositionPaper,hencethissubmission.
ISSUES
Theissuestoberesolvedinthiscaseareasfollows:
Whethertherewasconstructivedismissal;
Whethercomplainantisentitledtoreliefsprayedfor.
DISCUSSION
ComplainantwasConstructivelyDismissed
28. Thereisconstructivedismissalif anactofclear discrimination,

insensibility,ordisdainbyanemployerbecomessounbearableonthepart
oftheemployeethatitwouldforecloseanychoicebyhimexcepttoforego
hiscontinuedemployment.Itexistswherethereiscessationofworkbecause
continuedemploymentisrenderedimpossible,
322
unreasonableorunlikely12,asanofferinvolvingademotioninrankanda
diminutioninpay;
ComplainantwaswithUNISPORTforalmostthirteen(13)years.He
basicallyinstitutionalizedandestablishedthemarketingarmofUNISPORT
untilitreacheditspeakofearningitsplaceinthemarketthroughitsREVA
slippers.
However,whenprogresshadstoppedandsignsofdecliningsalesappeared
duetoseveraldoggederroneousdecisionmakingpolicyintheproduct
development,Complainantwasblamedandpressuredattheveryexpenseof
hisownhealth.NotonlydidRespondentsburyComplainants
accomplishmentandcontributionwiththecompany,littlebylittlehewas
boxedataverycompromisingsituation;
ThediscriminationstartedwithaMemorandum13whichobviously
singledoutComplainantbutevidentlywasissuedonthepretextthatthe
issueishishealthcondition.TheMemorandumwasissuedthesameyear
Complainantreportedbacktoworkafterhisstroke.Insteadof
compassion,Complainantwastreatedwithdisdainandoppression.In
spiteofthefactthathisstrokewasprincipallyassociatedwitheveryeffort
andstressheputacrossforhisworkatUNISPORT,Respondentstreatedhis
healthconditionwithcontempt;
RespondentstorturedComplainantintothinkingthathisconditionwashis
owndoingandthatthismadehimaliabilitytoUNISPORT.Thiscontinued
whenthecompanywasduetotransfertoanotherlocation.Respondentsmade
ComplainantfeelthathewasnolongerwelcomeintheCompany.
Ofallpeopleagainstwhomthiscouldhavebeendone,itwas
Complainantsairconditioningunitwhichwasfirstpulledoutfromthe
building.WithoutregardtoComplainantshealth,Respondentsmade
Complainantworkinsuchafatiguingandwearyingenvironment;
Norkis Trading v Gnilo, 544 SCRA 279.
Annex A
323
34. Jurisprudenceestablishedthatthegaugeforconstructive dismissalis

whetherareasonablepersonintheemployee'spositionwouldfeel
compelledtogiveuphisemployment,undertheprevailingcircumstances 14.
Inthiscase,RespondentsmadeComplainantfeelthatheis
nolongerneededbythecompany,shortofsendinghimaterminationnotice.
RespondentsmadeitimpossibleforComplainanttoperformhisworkwith
motivationbutratheronlywithunreasonablepressureandunnecessaryburden;
OcamposanimositytowardsComplainantissocleartobemistaken.Her
intenttoseparatehimfromUNISPORTiswellidentifiedinvarious
correspondencessheissuedthroughemail.Wordssuchas,wewillretire
himisunmistakableOcampowantshimoutofthecompany;
Shemadeitappearthatthecauseofthedeclineinsaleswasthefailureofthe
salesdepartmenttohandletheaccountsofthecustomers.Tocutshort,
Ocampowantedtocleanherhandsoffthedirtattheexpenseofanother.
Sadlyinthiscase,itwasattheexpenseofComplainantsemployment;
Thirdly,OcamposulteriormotivetoterminateComplainantfromworkwas
visiblymanifestedwhenshedirectedhimtoresignwithafalsepromisethat
shewilljustgivehimhisunpaidcommissionsandsalaries;
Atthispoint,Complainanthadalreadylosthope.Insteadofencouragement,
theygavehimfrustration.Insteadofhope,hewascastigatedwithresentment.
UntilallthisputaserioustolluponComplainant,hewasdisheartenedand
eventuallyforcedtoresign;
ComplainantknewthatstayingwouldonlymakeRespondentsrenderitmore
difficultforhimtocontinueworking.Hefeltthathejusthadtoletgoofhis
employment.Thisplaneventuallymaterializedwhenafterfour
14
Siemens Philippines, Inc. v. Domingo, G.R. No. 150488, July 28,
2008, 560 SCRA 86.
324
(4)daysofbeingpressured,Ocampoinducedhimintowritingaresignation
letter
underthepretextthatthecompanywouldimmediatelyaccountallmoney
claimsduehimifhedoessoresign.
However,althoughalmosttwo(2)monthshadalreadypassedstillnosingle
centavowassparedtoComplainant.Thismadeitmoredifficultfor
Complainanttofindthemeansforhisfamilysdailywherewithalespecially
nowthathesendshisfour(4)childrentoschool;
Tostressoutthematteroftheforcedresignationofcomplainant,thisletter
waswritteninfrontofRespondentOcampoandsolelyuponherdirection.
Thisassertionishighlightedbythefactthateventhedateofsuchresignation
letterwhichwaswrittenandsupposedtobedatedJuly1,2011,wasmadeto
becomeeffectiveretroactivelyonJune30,2011;
Asdiscussedabove,Complainantwaspromisedtohavehissalaryanddue
commissionsreleasedprovidedheexecutesfirsthisresignationletterinhis
ownhandwriting.Complainantwasstrategicallyforcedtoseparatehimself
fromthecompanywiththepromiseoffinancialassistance.Thisfactwas
distinctlymanifestedintheresignationletterComplainantdraftedinthe
presenceofOcampo,towit
AndtheassistanceyourgoingtogivewouldbeabighelpsoIwuldstart
againandwillbetreasured.thiswillbeabighelptotheeducationof
childrenseducation
43. Cleary,Complainantwaspromisedfinancialassistance.Yet, noamount

ofmonetaryaidwaseverextendedtohimevenuptothistime.Eventhe
mannerinwhichtheresignationletterwaswrittencouldhavebeen
constructedinamorearticulateandardentfashionifitwasreallywritten
voluntarily.Apparently,eventhewordsasspelledandsentencesphrased
indicatedthatComplainantwasunderalotofpressureandstressatthetime
hewaswritingit;
325
Complainantwouldnothaveoptedtoresign.Circumstancessurroundinghis
resignationshowthattherewasnoreasonforhimtodoso.Hebasically
startedtheMarketingArmofUNISPORT.Itwasbyhisinitialeffort,skills
andstrategywhichmadethefaceofREVAproductrecognizedinthe
consumermarket.
REVAispracticallyComplainantsveryownchildwhichhenurturedand
developedthroughtheyears.Andjustbecauseofanillnesswhichwasrooted
onComplainantsownefforttoempowerUNISPORT,hewaslateron
underratedanddisowned.Insteadofgratitudeandbenevolencehewas
treatedwithscorn,contemptandoppression;
WasthereanyreasonforComplainanttoresign?Complainantpriortobeing
coercedintoresigningfromworkhasfour(4)childrentosendtoschool.He
hadschoolfeestopay,allowancestodisburseandutilitybillstosettle.Why
wouldheresignwhenhehadeveryreasontostayforhisfamily?Thisisonly
becausehewasforcedtodoso;
Insum,ComplainantsoughtreliefandjusticebeforethisHonorableOffice,
againsttheoppressionhesufferedinthehandsofRespondents.Complainant
haspassionandloveforhisemploymentwhichwasasourceofa
greatdealofpride.Heevenwenttotheextentofseverelycompromisinghis
health,buthiseffortwasreturnedwithridiculeandworst,hewasstrickenoff
withthehopeofabetterlifeforhischildrenandfamily;
Havingbeenillegallyconstructivelydismissed,Complainantisthusentitledto
thepaymentofhisbackwagesandhisunpaidcommissions.Aconstructively
dismissedemployeehavingbeenseparatedfromemploymentinamannerwhich
thelawconsidersillegalisentitledtoreceivebackwages;
AsregardsComplainantsclaimforunpaidcommissions,theMemorandum
15
issuedbyMrYudatedDecember11,2008 clearlydeclaresthatsalespersonnel
areentitledtoreceiveanoverridingcommissionbasedontotalsalesnationwide.
ComplainantscommissionhoweverforthemonthsofMarch,April,May
andJune2011wereneverreleasedtohim.Todate,
15
Please see Annex A.
326
RespondentsstillwithholdComplainantsduecommissionswithoutanyjust
cause.TakingintoaccountthatComplainantinthiscasewascompelledto
litigateandengagetheservicesofacounseltoprotecthisinterest 16,theaward
ofattorneysfeesisjustifiedunderthepremises;
ConsideringalsothattherelationshipofComplainantwithRespondentshas
beenseverelystrained,paymentofseparationpayinsteadofreinstatementis
warranted.
Also,astheactsperpetuatedbyRespondentsmanifestconsciousand
intentionaldesigntodoawrongfulactagainstComplainant,thelatterisalso
entitledtobepaidmoralandexemplarydamages.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,itisrespectfullyprayedofthis
HonorableOfficethatafterdueconsiderationofthiscase,judgmentbe
rendereddeclaringComplainantillegallydismissedandorderRespondents
jointlyandseverallyliabletopayhisbackwages,separationpay,unpaid
commissions,damagesandattorneysfees.
Prayingforsuchotherreliefjustandequitableunderthepremises.PasigCity
forQuezonCity,14September2011.
JAWIDLAWOFFICE
CounselforComplainant
Unit910AntelGlobalCorporateCenter
Nr3DoaJuliaVargasAvenue,OrtigasCBD,PasigCity
TelNos.7824297/6875363MobileNos.09189115853/
09328827435
EmailAdd.counsellor12@rocketmail.com
By:
16
Article 2208 (2) of the New Civil Code.
327
ARIELGENAROGARCIA
JAWID
PTRNr10113456;01.04.11;Las
PiasCity
IBPLifetimeMemberNr01904RollNr39314
MCLE ComplianceNrIV
0001196;01.19.11
CHATOANCHETACABIGAS
PTR
Nr
1142858;01.05.11;TaguigCity
IBPNr858976;03.31.11;Makati
City
RollNr58436
MCLE ComplianceNoIV
0002307;08.03.11
CopyFurnished
UNISPORTMARKETINGCORP
JOSEYU,ELEANORYUOCAMPO
Respondents
497PresidentQuirinoAvenue.,Ext.,
CornerZuluetaSt.,Paco,
Manila,NCR1007
VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATIONFOR
NONFORUMSHOPPING
I,JESUSTSOCORRO,Filipino,married,oflegalage,andwithaddressat
No4GardenGrooveSt.,ParkPlaceVillage,Cainta,Rizal,1900,hereby
deposeandstatethat:
328
IamtheComplainantintheabovecaptionedcase;
Icausethepreparationoftheforegoingpositionpaper;
Ihavereadtheallegationscontainedthereinandherebycertifythattheyare
trueandcorrecttomyknowledgeandbasedonthetruerecordsofthecase;
IherebycertifythatIhavenotfiledorcausedtobefiledanyothercaseor
proceedinginvolvingthesameissuesorsubjectmatterintheSupremeCourt,
theCourtofAppeals,oranyotherCourt,tribunalorquasijudicialagency,
andtothebestofmyknowledge,nosuchactionorclaimispendingtherein;
ShouldhereafterIlearnthatthereisasimilarpendingbeforeanysuchCourts,
tribunaloragency,Iundertaketoreportsuchfacttothisagencywithinfive
(5)daysfromsuchknowledge;
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihereuntoaffixedmysignatureonthesamedate
asabovewritten.
JESUSTSOCORRO
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis14dayofSeptember2011
attheCityof_________,affiantexhibitingtomehis
____________________.
DocNo.______;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2011.
FORMNO.2:REPLY
329
QuezonCity
JESUSTSOCORRO,
Complainant,
NLRCRABCaseNo.
NCR071105411
versus
Hon.LaborArbiter
ROMELITANRIOFLORIDO
YU,ELEANORYUOCAMPO,
Respondents.
xx
REPLY
mostrespectfullysubmitsthisReplytoRespondentsPositionPaper
1.RespondentsallegedintheirpositionpaperthatComplainantwasreceivingquitea
comfortablecompensationpackageofP53,000/monthpriortoseveranceofhis
employment.WhileComplainantadmitssuchanamounthereceivesashismonthlysalary
fromUNISPORT,hebegstocontendthatthecompensationisnowherenearbeing
comfortable.TakingintoaccountthefactthatComplainantbasicallystructuredand
establishedtheinitialoperationofUNISPORT,untilsuchtimethatitreacheditsstature
andposition
330
inthemarket,theamountheisgettingasmonthlypayisnotasmuchashe
deserves;
Inaddition,itisbearsemphasizingthatComplainantsworkdoesnotonly
includesimpletaskofprocuringsalesinalimitedareaandmarket.When
BenjieValenzuela,salesmanagerofLuzon,resignedbackin2009,hewasthe
onewhotookoverhisplaceandcovertheLuzonmarketforsales.Inthe
comingyearof2010,whenthesalesmanagerofVisayasalsoleft
UNISPORT,Complainantwasalsodisposedofftoreplacethepositioninthe
Visayasmarket.ThisgoestoshowonlythatwhileComplainantwasbacking
upandcoveringmarketareasofLuzonandVisayas,whichsupposedlyshould
befilledinbytwo(2)differentmanagers,hewasactuallyholdingthree(3)
positionsatonetime,yet,hissalarywasnailedtoP53,000.00.Respondents
nowhadtheaudacitytocallComplainantssalarycomfortable;
ComplainantstronglydeniesthatheinsistedinresigningoutofUNISPORT.
InsupportoftheirtheorythatComplainantdidsovoluntarily,theyargued
thattheresignationletterwasmadeinComplainantsownhandwriting;that
heappliedforemploymentclearance17;andthathesurrenderedallofficetools
andgadgetsissuedtohimbyUNISPORT.
First,thefactthatComplainantappliedforanemploymentclearance,doesnot
ipsofactoconcludethattheresignationwasfreelymade.InfacttheReleaseand
QuitclaimformattachedtheretowasneverfilledoutnorsignedbyComplainant.
Complainantwasleftwithoutanychoicebuttoapplyforaclearanceconsidering
thathewastoldthathecanonlygetthepaymentofhisduecommissionand
unpaidsalariesafterthecompletionofhisclearance;
Second,hereturnedtheissuedlaptopandmobilephonesashedeemedit
appropriateconsideringthatthesethingswerenothisownbutofthecompany.
ThereisjustnoreasonforComplainanttowithholdthesame.Third,
17
See Annex 2 Respondents Position Paper.
331
whiletheresignationletterisindeedwritteninComplainantsown
handwriting,thesamedoesnotatallpaintapictureofvoluntaryresignation;
Complainantfirmlyreiteratesthattheexecutionofsaidletterwasundertaken
underrelentlesscompulsionandpressurecomingfromRespondentEleanor
Ocampo.Tostartwith,theresignationletterwaspreparedinfrontandinthe
verypresenceofOcampo.ShewaspracticallydirectingComplainantas
regardswhathisletterofresignationshouldcontain.Eventhedateappearing
inthelettersuggestsaclearnotionthatsomeonewasdirectinghimthethings
oughttobewrittentherein.TheletterwasinitiallydatedJuly1,2011,but
whatcouldComplainantbepossiblythinkingwhenhechangedtheeffectivity
ofhisresignationtoJune30ifnotthatsomeoneactuallyorderedhimtodoso,
and,whencomplainantisfullyawarethatresignationmustbemadewithat
least30dayspriornoticetohisemployer;
AgainComplainantwasrequiredtodraftaresignationletterrightthereand
thenwiththefalsepromiseofpayinghiscommissionsatthesoonestpossible
time.IfRespondentstrulyintendedtogiveComplainantwhatisduehim,why
isitthattodatenotasinglecentavowaspaidtohim?Worse,heisevenbeing
demandedtopaytheloanhesupposedlyoweUNISPORT.And,although
Complainantadmitsthathehasanexistingloanobligationwiththe
Respondentcompany,isthattherighttreatmentthatshouldbeaccordedto
someonewhohaspracticallyspent13yearsofhisbestlifetoestablish,
developandimproveUNISPORT.Complainantwillneverdenyhisloan
obligation,butwhattrulyhurtshimisthatitnowappearsthatRespondents
hadtotallydiscountedanddisacknowledgedComplainantsworthand
contributiontothecompanybyshovingofftohisfacethatheisnotdeserving
ofanything,notevencompassion;
ComplainantwasconstructivelydismissedbyRespondents.Hewasthrown
withoverwhelmingcircumstancespromptinghimtofeelthathehasnoplace
inthecompany.Thefollowingarebutjustoftheparticularsandconditions
whicheventuallyconstrainedComplainanttoletgoofhisemployment;
332
Memorandum18issuedin2008directedagainsttheComplainant
althoughdepictedasifmeantforeveryandallemployeesnotice;
ComplainantwasheldfordaysinsideRespondentOcamposoffice
wherehewasverballypressuredandpsychologicallystressedoutby
respondent;
Email(AnnexF)datedJune14,2011sentbyRespondentOcampo
urginghimtoexplainthedropinsaleswhensheknewallalongthat
theveryproblemwasthedesignsheherselfchosefortheproducts;
Email(AnnexG)datedJune15,2011,RespondentOcampodeclared
herillwillagainstComplainantbystatingWEWILLRETIRE
HIM;
Email(AnnexH)datedJune15,2011,sentbyRespondentOcampoto
everyonewithwordslike;decidedtolessenaccountsofjtsxxx
(referringtoJesusTSocorro);
June16,2011RespondentOcampoverballytoldComplainantto
justresignandtakearestandthattheywilljustgivehimhis
commissions;
Email(AnnexI)sentbyRespondentOcampoincitingother
individualstogoagainstComplainant;
ResignationLetterisinitselfaproofthatComplainantwasdirected
andforcedtoresign;
RespondentOcampoafterforcingComplainanttoresign,bymeansof
deception,madeitappearthatComplainantwouldbereceiving
somethingwhenintruthandinfact,Respondenthadreallyno
intentiontodoso;
18
See Annex A of Complainants Position Paper.
333
Forms
ThereisnotruththatComplainantwillinglywantedtoseparatehimselffrom
UNISPORTandthatheinsistedtoresign.TheanimosityofRespondentOcampo
19
againstComplainant,assheexhibitedinvariousemails ,senttovarious
employees,wouldevidentlydiscloseherulteriormotiveofputtingComplainant
underextremeconditionofstressuntilsuchtimehewasforcedtoresign.Onthis
matter,RespondentOcampowassuccessful.
AsregardstheclaimofRespondentsforpaymentofComplainantsloan
obligation,whileadmittedlythesameinfactistrue;Respondentscannotjust
automaticallydeductthesameagainsthis13thmonthpayandunpaid
commissions.Thereisnoagreement,whetherverbalorwritten,nocontractwas
everenteredintobyComplainantwithRespondentsallowingthemtodeduct
automaticallytheemployeesloanfromthosethatareduehimunderthelaw.
Sincenonoticewasevergivenhim,thisiscompletelyaviolationof
Complainantsrighttodueprocess.IfRespondentswanttorecover
Complainantsloanobligation,thereisanappropriateforumforthat.Itiswrong
tomuddlesuchissueinthiscontroversyasthesameshouldnotinanymanner
affectComplainantsrightgrantedbytheConstitutionandlaborlaws;
Lastly,Complainantemphasizesthatitisahornbookdoctrinethatthecourts
indecidingcasesbetweenlaborandemployer,theyshouldbeguidedbythe
timehonoredprinciplethatifdoubtexistsbetweentheevidencepresentedby
theemployerandtheemployee,thescalesofjusticemustbetiltedinfavorof
thelatter.Theruleincontroversiesbetweenalaborerandhismasterdistinctly
statesthatdoubtsreasonablyarisingfromtheevidence,orintheinterpretation
ofagreementsandwriting,shouldberesolvedintheformersfavor 20;
52. ConsideringthatComplainantwasindeedconstructively illegally

dismissed,heisentitledtobepaidhisbackwages,unpaidcommission,moral
andexemplarydamages,attorneysfeesandseparationpayinlieuof
reinstatement;
See Annexes F ,G , H and I of Complainants Position Paper.
Lores Realty Enterprises, Inc., v Pacia, G.R. No. 171189, March 9,

2011 citing E.G. & I Corporation v. Sato, G.R. No. 182070,
February 16, 2011.
334
PRAYER
rendereddeclaringComplainantconstructivelyillegallydismissedandorder
Respondentstobejointlyandseverallyliabletopayhisbackwages,
separationpay,unpaidcommissions,damagesandattorneysfees.
forQuezonCity,06October2011.
JAWIDLAWOFFICE
09328827435
By:
ARIELGENAROGARCIA
JAWID
PTRNr10113456;01.04.11;Las
PiasCity
MCLE ComplianceNrIV
0001196;01.19.11
CHATOANCHETACABIGAS
335
PTR
Nr
1142858;01.05.11;TaguigCity
City
RollNr58436
MCLE
ComplianceNoIV
0002307;08.03.11
CopyFurnished
Respondents
Manila,NCR1007
336
FORMNO.3:REJOINDER
QuezonCity
JESUSTSOCORRO,
Complainant,
NLRCRABCaseNo.
NCR071105411
versus
Hon.LaborArbiterROMELITANRIOFLORIDO
YU,ELEANORYUOCAMPO,
Respondents.
xx
REJOINDER
mostrespectfullysubmitsthisReply
Respondents,intheirReply,attachedtheaffidavitofUnisportsPresident,MrJoseYu,
whomadevariousallegationsthatarewhollyirrelevantto
controvertthematerialallegationofconstructiveillegaldismissalandcorresponding
proofsprofferedbyComplainant;
337
MrYuevendeclaredthatalthoughComplainantsjobanddutiesareindeed
multifarious,histheoryisthattheywerefarfrombeingstressful.Toreiterate
thepurposesofComplainantsjob,areasfollows:
Todelivertheassignednationwidesalesquotafortheyear;
Tosupervisethesalesforceintheimplementationofthesalesprogram;
TocomplementwithConsignmentandBoutiqueSectioninthe
implementationofoverallcorporatestrategies;
ToadministerthedailyactivitiesoftheCollectionUnit
ToassisttheCMSOinthedevelopmentofmarketingplansandsales
program.
WhileMrYusopinionthatComplainantsjobwasneverstressful,thesame
observationrunscounteragainsttheverypurposeofComplainantsjob.Itis
hisresponsibilitytoseetoitthathedeliverstheassignedsalesquotafor
theyear.Evenanordinaryperson,notadepttotheintricaciesofthesales
world,wouldfinditdifficulttothinkintheoutstretchedimaginationthat
procuringsalesquotaislikeawalkinapark.Letalonetobeburdenedwith
additionalmultitudeofduties,suchas,butnotlimitedto:providingstrategic
andoperatingguidelinestothesalesforce,takingcareofthecollectionof
payables,ensuringproperdispositionandreceiptofdeliveries,directly
handlingkeyaccountsinMetroManila,developingsalesprogramand
training,directlyhandlingsalescomplaintbeyondthelevelofthesales
forceandmakingperiodicroundstokeyprovincialcustomerstosustain
businessrelation;
MrYualsodeniesComplainantsallegationsinparagraphs3,4,and5ofhis
PositionPaper.Hementionedthat,Complainantsallegedclaimthathesingle
handedlydevelopedmeasuresintendedtoincreasethesalesoutput,isfallacious.
Tostartwith,Complainantneversaidthathesingle
338
handedlydevelopedmeasuresadoptedinsales.Complainantmerelypointedout
thatthestrategiesusedinincreasingthesalesmostlyoriginatedfromhisideas
whichwerelateronadoptedbythesalesworkforcetoboostsalesoutput;
Whatismostlydepressinginthiscaseisthat,MrYu,underparagraph6of
RespondentsReply,indesperateattempttorejectComplainantscause,
optedtoattacktheverypersonofComplainantbyimputingagainsthimthe
dispositionofbeingadrunkard,awomanizer,andevenhisworkinghabits.
TheseallegationsapparentlywereembodiedinanIncidentReport21made
byacertainDoloresRResuelloandadocument22containingseveral
imputationsallegedlysignedbyacertainMsMacam;
Thesedocumentsarewantingofanyprobativevalue.Itisabasicruleon
evidencethatthemoralcharacterofapartyisgenerallyinadmissible.Itmay
beadmittedonlywhentheissueofpertinentcharacterisitselfinvolvedinthe
case.23Also,notonlythattheallegationsintheincidentreportareself
serving,theincidentreportitselfdoesnothaveanyevidentiaryweight
consideringthatitcanbeeasilypreparedatanytime,evenatpresent,with
printeddateallegedlypertainingtoa2008incident.Complainantwouldalso
wishtomakeanobservationanentthewrittencellphonenumberonthe
incidentreport.Fromthisstandpoint,whatappearsisthatthesameiswritten
inordertorelateittoacellphonebillofBradgateMarketingCorporation
indicatingseveralcallsmadetothesamecellphonenumber.Theonly
problemisthatsuchbillingstatementalonecouldneverprovewhomadethe
callsmuchlesstheidentityoftheownerofsuchcellphonenumber;
Inthiscase,ComplainantsprimarycauseofactionagainstRespondentsisthat
hisworkingenvironmentwasattendedwithsomuchanimosity,insecurityand
hatredagainsthim.ThecircumstancesComplainanthadtoputupwithatthe
companystartingatthetimehesufferedstrokeweresomuchforhimtobear.
Addinginsulttotheinjury,MrYusdaughterEleanor
Annex 9 Respondents Reply.
Annex 10 Respondents Reply.

23
Section 51, Rule 130, Rules on Evidence.
339
OcampomaliciouslypavedthewayinordertomakeComplainants
remainingdayswiththecompanysostrenuousandunyielding;
8.InMrYusownstatement,hemaintainedthatthepurposeofthe
Memorandum24istoREWARDthosewhoEXERTEDEFFORTtoattain
theirtargetsandPENALIZEthosewhohadlacklustersales
performance.ThesubjectMemorandumprovidesthefollowingmandated
SalesQuota:
2009QUOTAPhp85,000,000.00
QUOTA
RATEOFCOMMISSION
Above100%
1.03%
91%100%
1.00%
86%90%
0.90%
81%85%
0.85%
76%80%
0.80%
75%andBelow
.0.00%
2010QUOTAPhp95,000,000.00
QUOTA
RATEOFCOMMISSION
Above100%
0.96%
91%100%
0.93%
86%90%
0.84%
81%85%
0.79%
76%80%
0.74%
75%andBelow
.0.00%
2011QUOTAPhp85,000,000.00
QUOTA
RATEOFCOMMISSION
Above100%
0.93%
91%100%
0.90%
24
Annex A Complainants Position Paper.
340
86%90%
0.81%
81%85%
0.76%
76%80%
0.72%
75%andBelow
.0.00%
WhileMrYuclaimsthatthepurposeofthenewcommissionschemeisto
rewardthosewhoexertefforttoattainthetargetquota,thisappearsquite
contrarytothefiguresreflectedinthememorandum.Observethechangeof
commissionratefrom2009,2010to2011.TheAMOUNTOF
COMMISSIONWHICHASALESMANMAYRECEIVECLEARLY
DECREASESintheyearsfollowingthrough;
NowRespondentYuarguesthatthepurposeofthecommissionschemeisto
REWARDthosewhoexertedefforttoattainthequotasales.Howcanthisbe
truewhenthecommissionrateismarkedlyreducedanddiminishedwhilethe
salespercentagequotaisretained.Onedoesnotneedtohaveabrilliantmind
torealizethattherecanneverbeaREWARDinthiscaseWHENTHE
COMMISSIONISDISCOUNTEDwhiletheTOTALSALESQUOTA
REQUIREDEVERYYEARINCREASES;
Whilemoreeffortisrequiredtobeextractedfromthesalesmen,the
correspondingcommissionspertinenttheretonevercommensuratethe
exertionputforthbythem.Itseemstousthatwhetheroneattainsthequotaor
not,thememorandumleadstothesameeffectdissatisfactionand
disheartenmentonthepartofthesalesmen.
MrYuaverredthatthememorandumisanexerciseofmanagement
prerogative.Headdedundersecondstanza,paragraph10oftheirReplythat
healsomadeitapolicytowithholdanycommissionfromthosewhohave
beensickleaveforacontinuousonemonthperiod.Evidently,what
Respondentsoughttoimposeagainstanemployeewhohadjustsufferedfrom
illnessistoholdbackthecommissionduefromhimatthemomentheneedsit
themost.Clearly,compassionforthesickisnotoneofthevirtuesbeing
practicedbyRespondents.ThismerelybolsterstheallegationofComplainant
thatthememorandumwasillmotivatedandwasissuedto
341
personallyattackandfurtheraggravatethepoorhealthconditionof
Complainant;
Respondentsalsoquestionedwhythe2008Memorandumwasusedasbasis
ofthechargeofconstructivedismissalwhenComplainantseparatedfrom
UnisportonlyonJuly1,2011.Inreplytothisquery,itbearsemphasizingthat
theMemorandumwasnotthesolebasisutilizedbyComplainantinhisclaim
forconstructiveillegaldismissal.Thememorandummerelyignitedtheseries
ofharassmentanddiscriminationundertakenagainsthim,byandthroughhis
daughterEleanorOcampo;
Inadditiontothememorandum,severalcorrespondencessentthroughemail
evidencingRespondentOcamposdisplayofdisdainandcontemptagainst
Complainantliterallyledhimtofeelthestressinstayingandpressuredhimin
lettinggoofhisemployment;
Wordsusedintheemailssuchas,WEWILLRETIREHIM,
DECIDEDTOLESSENTHEACCOUNTSOFJTCandIM
EMPOWERINGALLOFYOUSOTHATYOUHAVEAVOICESO
THATJTSWILLALSOLEARNTOWORKWITHYOUANDHINDI
PARANGBOSINGDATINGNYAAKOLANGANGBOSINGDITO
HAHA,whichliterallycallforemployeestoriseupagainstComplainantare
toohardpiecesofevidenceshowingthatuptothelastdaysofComplainantin
thecompany,RespondentOcampomadeitsodifficultforhimtocontinue
workingatUnisport;
16.Lastly,intheswornstatementofEfrenGrandana,hedeniedhavingshown
ComplainantawrittendirectivefromRespondentOcampo,tocomputehis
accruedbenefits.Thisbaredenialcannotstandagainstanaffirmative
allegationofanemployee.Nonetheless,intheregularcourseofbusiness,the
accountingdepartmentundertakesthecomputationofwhateverisduean
employee.However,thisprocedurewasnolongerfollowedbythecohortsof
RespondentOcampowhowerealsoequallyresponsibleinpressuring
Complainanttoleavethecompany;
342
17.EfrenGranadaalsoallegedlysawonlyComplainantinwritinghis
resignationletterwithoutRespondentOcampo.Thisdeclarationisablatant
lie.AllthewhileComplainantwaswritinghisresignationletter,hewasinthe
verypresenceofOcampowhodirectedthematterstobewrittentherein.
Noteworthytostate,inthenormalcourseofevents,anemployeemostwilling
toresignwouldnothavedrafted,preparedandwrittenthesameinsidethe
companypremises,orattheveryleast,inthepresenceofhisownboss;
PRAYER
rendereddeclaringComplainantconstructivelyillegallydismissedandorder
Respondentstobejointlyandseverallyliabletopayhisbackwages,
separationpay,unpaidcommissions,damagesandattorneysfees.
forQuezonCity,27October2011.
JAWIDLAWOFFICE
09328827435
By:
343
ARIELGENAROGARCIA
JAWID
PTRNr10113456;01.04.11;Las
PiasCity
MCLE ComplianceNrIV
0001196;01.19.11
CHATOANCHETACABIGAS
PTR
Nr
1142858;01.05.11;TaguigCity
City
RollNr58436
MCLE ComplianceNoIV
0002307;08.03.11
CopyFurnished
Respondents
Manila,NCR1007
344
FORMNO.4:MEMORANDUM
COURTOFAPPEALS
MANILA
(SpecialFourthDivision)
JESUST.SOCORRO, C.A.G.R.S.P.No.
Petitioner,
126946
(NLRCRABNo.071105411)
versus
(NLRCLACNo.0300106712)
NATIONALLABORRELATIONS
COMMISSION,
UNISPORT
MARKETINGCORP.,ETAL.,
Respondents.
345
XX
MEMORANDUMFORPETITIONER
PETITIONER,throughtheundersignedcounsels,incompliancewiththe
ResolutionofthisHonorableCourtdatedMarch13,2013,mostrespectfully
submitsthisMemorandumandstate:
PREFATORYSTATEMENT
Itissaidthatoneofthemostpainfulhurtiscausedbytheoneclosetous.
Thepainisevenexacerbatedwhenwhatisusedtobeatusisahardandvery
coldimplementcalledINGRATITUDE.
STATEMENTOFFACTS
346
PetitionerstartedoutworkingforUNISPORTassalesmanagerinSeptember
1998underBradgateMarketingCorporation,whichisthenthemarketingarm
ofUNISPORT.Asthecompanyatthattimewasexperiencingtroublein
marketingandsellingtheirREVAproducts(slippers),Petitionerorganized
anddevelopedmeasurestopromoteandincreasethesalesofUNISPORT.All
theeffortsexertedbyPetitionerpaidoff.UNISPORTsRevaBrandwasable
toestablishanicheofitsownintheentirePhilippinemarket.
Becauseoftoomuchstressbroughtaboutbytheadditionalsalesdemand,
PetitionersufferedfromstrokeonDecember10,2007afterhecameback
fromtheVisayasprovince.PetitionerreportedbacktoworkonlyinApril
2008.Atthispoint,withoutdueregardtoPetitonershealthcondition,
OCAMPOtoldhimthatifheshouldsufferagainamajorhealthproblem,she
willterminatehisservices.OnDecember11,2008,YU,issueda
Memorandum(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexAofpetitioners
PositionPaper)whichprovides,amongothers,therequirementofincreasein
SalesQuotafor2009,2010and2011.TheMemorandumadvisedallsales
personneltodisciplinetheirhealthandmadeapronouncementthatasickly
personcannotbetolerated;
Byyear2010uptotheearlypartof2011,thereweredrasticdropinthesales
ofproducts.TheProductDevelopmentheadedby
OCAMPO,placedherordersinChinawithoutconsideringtheposition
oftheSalesDepartmentontheproductcategoryandstyle.What
OCAMPOdidwasmerelytocirculatetothesalesdepartmenttheimageof
theproductswhichhavealreadybeenplacedinorder,onlyFORNOTICE.As
aresult,therewasahighrejectionratefromclients,highinventoryinthe
warehousesandnegativecommentsfromdealers;
thetransferofeachDepartmenttoanotherlocation.
OCAMPOorderedthattheairconditioningunitatPetitionersroom
dismantled,includingthecabinet,sofaandtheglasspartitionoftheroom.
WhatwasmoreawfulwasthatitwasonlyPetitionersairconditioningunit
thatwaspulledoutwhiletherestoftheroomsmaintainedtheirs.Tomake
mattersworse,theperiodoftransferwasextendeduptoJune30,2011.
Themotivebehindtheintentionalpulloutoftheairconunitwas
347
undoubtedlycleartomaketheworkingenvironmentofPetitionermore
unbearable;
OCAMPOdidnotstoppressuringPetitionerOCAMPOalwaysputthe
blameonPetitionerforthelowsalesinspiteofthefactthatshewaswell
awarethattheveryproblemwasthedesignsoftheproductsheselected;
OnJune14,2011,inanotheremail(PleaserefertoAnnexD
AnnexFofpetitionersPositionPaper)sentbyOCAMPOtoPetitioner,she
againfaultedhimonthereducedsalesbooking.OCAMPOneverstopped
pressuringandtorturinghimoftheproblemsheherselfcreated.Infact,againon
June15,2011,inanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexGof
petitionersPositionPaper)sheagainmanifestedherillwillandpersonal
resentmentagainstHIM.OCAMPOeventhreatenedhimthatshewouldretire
himearlybymentioningintheemailthatifattheendoftheyearandPetitioner
stillhasnotimproved,thenshewillterminatehisemployment.Thethreatwas
followedbyseriesofharassmentwhenOCAMPOremovedfromPetitioner
severalaccountshewasthenhandling.Bydoingso,Petitionerwasdeprived
ofpossiblecommissionsforthelostaccounts.Thiswasevidenced
byanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexHofpetitionersPosition
Paper)shesenttootheremployees.
8. NotlongthereafterOCAMPOverballydemandedthat Petitionermightas
wellresignfromthecompany.OCAMPOsgrudgeagainstPetitioner
escalated.Inanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexIofpetitioners
PositionPaper)OCAMPOsenttoherstaffsheeveninstigatingthemtocome
togetherandpressurePetitioner,bysaying:
(emphasisandunderscoringsupplied)
9. ByJune21,2011whenPetitionerreportedtowork,Efren Granada,the
ManageroftheHumanResourceDepartment(HRD)andWarehouse
Division,calledhisattentionandshowedhimacopyofthe
348
directiveissuedbyOCAMPOinherownhandwriting,directinghimto
computePetitionersaccruedbenefits.Atthispoint,Petitionercouldnot
believethatOCAMPOwasreallyseriousinterminatinghisemployment.All
theseputahugetolluponhimthathewaseventuallyforcedtojustleavehis
work.SometimeonJuly1,2011OCAMPOwenttohisroomanddirected
himthathehastomakeaResignationLetterwhichwaswrittenunderthe
directionofOCAMPOwhodictatedthematterstobewrittenthereon.
Petitionerwasleftwithnootheroptionbuttoresignbecauseoftheanxiety,
discriminatoryworkingenvironment,maliciousremarksurginghimtoresign,
andotherunnecessaryburdenimposeduponhimbyOCAMPO;
10. Duetotheforegoing,Petitionerfiledthisinstantactionfor illegal

constructivedismissalbeforetheOfficeoftheLaborArbiteronJuly19,2011.
TheLaborArbitersubsequentlyrenderedadecisiondatedFebruary23,2012
resolvingthecaseinfavorofRespondents.Petitionerappealedthedecisionof
theLaborArbitertotheNLRCwhichdecidedinfavoroftheRespondents.
PetitionersMotionforReconsiderationwaslikewisedenied.Hence,this
petition.
II
ISSUESTOBERESOLVED
WhetherornotPublicRespondentNLRC,gravelyabuseditsdiscretion
whenitaffirmedtheDecisionoftheHonorableLaborArbiterfinding
thatPetitionervoluntarilyresigned.
WhetherorPublicRespondentNLRC,gravelyabuseditsdiscretionwhenit
foundthatthereisnoconstructivedismissalinthiscase.
349
III
ARGUMENTSANDDISCUSSION
TheNLRCerredinaffirmingthefindingsoftheLaborArbiterthat:
RespondentswereabletoshowthattheresignationofPetitionerwas
madevoluntary.
PublicRespondentaffirmedtherulingoftheLaborArbiterfindingthat
Petitionersresignationwasdonevoluntarily.Itharpedontheresignation
letterexecutedbyPetitioneremphasizingthatresignationiswrittenin
Petitionersownhandwritingandthatitcontainedwordsofgratitude.
Additionally,itmentionedthatPetitionerwaspromisedthereleaseofhis
receivables(commissions)andthathefiledthiscomplaintuponlearningthat
Respondentsdidnotmakeacomputationofhiscommissions.Moreover,
PublicRespondentlikewisereiteratedtherationaleadoptedbytheLabor
ArbiterinrebuttingPetitionersclaimofforcedresignation;
Wesubmitthatwhiletheletterofresignationwasinfactwrittenin
Petitionersownhandwritingitdidnotipsofactomaketheresignation
voluntary.Thecircumstancesastohowtheletterwaswrittenmustbe
scrutinizedtodeterminethevoluntaryor,toputitmoreaccurately,the
involuntarynatureoftheact;
TheLaborArbiterstressedthatthewordsofgratitudeappearingontheletter
couldhardlycomefromsomeoneforcedtoresign.
350
Allwecansayisthatthisobservationcouldhavebeencorrectifitwerefreely
writtenbythehaplessemployee.Butsadtosaythisisnotthecaseinhere.
Oncemoreandwitharenewedemphasiswewouldliketostressthatat
thetimetheresignationwasmadeOCAMPOwasatPetitionersthroat
directingthematterswhichshouldbeputintheletter;
ThedenialmadebyGranadawhoallegedlysawPetitionerwritinghis
resignationletterbyhimselfcouldnotbetreatedasareliablesourceoftruth.
ThisallegationwasnotonlyspecificallydeniedbyPetitioner,thefactsare
undisputedthatduringtheentiretimePetitionerwaswritinghis
resignationletter,theonlyonepresentwasOCAMPOwhodirectedand
checkedthecontentswritteninhisletter.Granadawasnowhereinthe
roomwhenOCAMPOorderedPetitionertowritetheletter.Howcouldhe
haveknownwhatPetitionerwaswritinginhisresignationletter?Granadas
claimisincredibleinlightofthesecircumstances.Granadahadnopersonal
knowledgeoftheeventssurroundingtheincidentwhenPetitionerwrotesuch
letterunderthedictatesofOCAMPO,thus,hisstatementsarenotonly
incompetentbutalsodoubtful.
Morethanthat,whywouldsuchanactofappreciationtowardthecompany
whichPetitionerhashelpedestablishedandeventuallycametolovefor13
years,betakenagainstPetitioner?Petitionerdoesnotdenythathewas
gratefulforhavingbecomeapartofUNISPORT.Andtrueenough,hislove
forthecompanyisdeclaredinhisletter.Butitshouldnotbeoverlooked
thattheincidentsthatsteeredhimandpushedhimintoresigningandto
writetheletterofresignationwasduetoOCAMPOsunfairtreatment,
hatred,andcleardisdainagainsthim.Sadly,thiswasneverpassedupon
norconsideredbytheHonorablePublicRespondent.
TheLaborArbitermentionedthatPetitionerisnotagulliblepersonwho
couldbeinfluencedinwritingaresignationletterinsuchtenor.
Trueenough,Petitionerisnotanunletteredindividual,butitisnoteworthythatat
thetimetheletterwaswrittenPetitionerwasunderseverestressandpressure.It
isnothighlyunlikelyforanyindividualtoactuponthingswhichundernormal
circumstancewouldhavebeencarefullythoughtof.Petitioner,stillasahuman
being,becamesensitivetohighlyhostileandantagonizingenvironmenthehadto
putupwith.Petitionerherespentthirteen
351
(13)yearsofhislifewithacompanythathehelpedbuild.Itwashisdreamto
placethebrandREVAinthemapofthesportingworldadreamandpromise
whichhesuccessfullyfulfilled.Howwouldamanwhohelpedimprovethe
REVAbrandfeelwhenfacedwithsuchresentment?Therewasjustsomuch
disdainandutteringratitudethrownathim?Inthefaceofallthese,whowould
nothavelosthisequanimity,balanceandfocus?
Webelievethatthevoluntarinessoftheresignationmustnotonlybe
assessedonthebasissolelyofahandwrittenresignationletteranditscold
wordingsbutalsoonthecircumstancesandreasonswhyitwaswritten;
InthecaseofPeaflorvs.OutdoorClothingManufacturingCorporation25,
theSupremeCourtruledinfavorofPeaflor,whoaftersubmittinghis
resignationletteralsofiledacaseforconstructivedismissalagainsthis
employer.TheCourtindecidinginhisfavorruledthathewas
constructivelydismissedgiventhehostileanddiscriminatoryworking
environmenthefoundhimselfin.
TheSupremeCourtalsoruledinthecaseofSHSPerforatedMaterials
Incorporatedvs.Diaz26thattherespondentwasforcedtoresigndespitethe
factthatthelatterservedhisresignationletter.TheCourtconsideredthesame
asconstructivedismissal,citingthecaseofDuldulaov.CourtofAppeals27,
wherethecourtruledthatthereisconstructivedismissalifanactofclear
discrimination,insensibility,ordisdainbyanemployerbecomesso
unbearableonthepartoftheemployeethatitwouldforecloseanychoiceby
himexcepttoforegohiscontinuedemployment.Itexistswherethereis
cessationofworkbecausecontinuedemploymentisrenderedimpossible,
unreasonableorunlikely,asanofferinvolvingademotioninrankanda
diminutioninpay.Inthatcase,whatmadeitimpossible,unreasonableor
unlikelyforrespondenttocontinueworkingforSHSwastheunlawful
withholdingofhissalary;
G.R. No. 177114, January 21, 2010.
G.R. No. 185814, October 13, 2010.
G.R. No. 164893, March 1, 2007.
352
Theforegoingcasesonlyshowthatinnumerousinstances,theHighestCourt
ofthislandlookedbeyondtheexistenceofaresignationletterandconsidered
thecircumstancessurroundingthecaseandtheevidencepresentedinruling
thattheresignationswerenotvoluntaryandthatthesameconstitute
constructivedismissal;
PublicRespondentevenagreedwiththeHonorableLaborArbiterthatwhen
Petitionerreturnedhislaptop,cellularphones,calculator,staplerand
companycarassignedtohimthiswasanindicationofthevoluntarynatureof
hisresignation;
Webegtodisagreeontheaboveconclusion.Petitionerhadtoreturnthe
issuedlaptopandmobilephonesconsideringthatthesethingswerenothisbut
thatofthecompany.Notonlythatthereisnoreasonforhimtowithhold
them,hewasalsoafraidthathiscontinuedpossessionofthesecompany
suppliesmightbeusedagainsthim.Thisisnotrocketsciencenorunfounded
suppositionbutispracticalreality;
PublicRespondentisoftheopinionthatPetitionerfiledthiscomplainant
uponlearningthatRespondentsdidnotmakeacomputationofhis
receivablesaspromise.
WithallduerespecttothePublicRespondent,butitseemedtohave
erroneouslyconcludedoftheproximatecausewhyPetitionerdecidedtoleave
work.ThepromiseofRespondenttogivePetitionerhiscommissioncamein
thelatterpartoftheeventsonlyaftertheseriesofdiscriminationOcampo
burdenedPetitioner.ThiswasneverTHEPROXIMATEREASONwhy
Petitionerhadtoresign.Thereceivablesweremerelytheconsequenceofthe
forcedresignation.AndwhatfurtherinfuriatedPetitionerwasthathewas
deceivedbyrespondents.Theyneverintendedtofulfilltheirpromise.Itwas
justascheme,aploytothrowPetitioneroutofthecompanydestituteinall.Is
thisnotaclassiccaseofINJUSTICECRYINGOUTTOHIGHHEAVENS?
Petitionerhadnochoicebuttofilethiscase.Infact,itisourstandthatthe
promiseofdisbursingPetitionersreceivableswasevenadoptedbyOcampo
toenticePetitionerandultimatelyoverwhelmPetitionertograbin
353
theopportunitytoleavehisworkandreceivehismoneyinreturn.To
Petitionersmind,ifhewouldnotwritesuchletterofresignation,Respondent
Ocampowilljusthurthimmoreandcausefurtherdifficultyinclaiminghis
commissions.IfRespondentswereevenactinginallgoodfaithwhenthey
offeredPetitionertoreleasehisreceivables,whyisthattodatethereisstillno
attemptontheirtogivewhatisduePetitioner?Ifthisisnotcorrected,where
isSocialJusticeinhereaseloquentlydescribedbyJusticeLaurelinCalalang
Williams28?
Resignationisaformalpronouncementorrelinquishmentofanoffice,with
theintentionofrelinquishingtheofficeaccompaniedbytheactof
relinquishment.Astheintenttorelinquishmustconcurwiththeovertactof
relinquishment,theactsoftheemployeebeforeandafterthealleged
resignationmustbeconsideredindeterminingwhether,infact,heintendedto
severhisemployment29;
Inthiscase,theovertactsofPetitionerbeforeandafterthealleged
resignationdonotshowhisintentiontoseverhisemployment.Whateven
stronglynegatestheclaimofresignationisthesubsequentfilingof
complaintforconstructivedismissal;
28
G.R. No. 47800, December 2, 1940; Social justice is neither
communism, nor despotism, nor atomism, nor anarchy, but the

humanization of laws and the equalization of social and economic
forces by the State so that justice in its rational and objectively secular
conception may at least be approximated. Social justice means the
promotion of the welfare of all the people, the adoption by the
Government of measures calculated to insure economic stability of all
the competent elements of society, through the maintenance of a
proper economic and social equilibrium in the interrelations of the
members of the community, constitutionally, through the adoption of
measures legally justifiable, or extraconstitutionally, through the
exercise of powers underlying the existence of all governments on the
time-honored principle of salus populi est suprema lex.
29
BMG Records (Phils.), Inc. v. Aparecio, G.R. No. 153290,
September 5, 2007.
354
Resignationisinconsistentwiththefilingofthecomplaintforillegal
dismissal.30Itwouldhavebeenillogicalforpetitionertoresignandthenfilea
complaintforillegaldismissallateron.31IfPetitionerwasdeterminedto
resign,hewouldnothavefiledthecomplaintforillegaldismissal.Thisis
plainandsimple;
ThetruthofthematteristhatPetitionerwascompelledbycircumstancesat
theworkplacecreatedbyRespondentOCAMPO.Theseeventswas
deliberatelyadoptedbyRespondentOCAMPOtoensurethatPetitioner
wouldbeputinaplacewherehenolongerhasanychoicebuttoleave
work;
ThecircumstancessurroundingPetitionersresignationmustalsobetaken
intoconsiderationtodeterminewhethertheresignationwasvoluntary:
MayweinvitetheattentionofthisHonorableCourttotheseriesofemails
32
sentbyOCAMPOtoseveralemployeesofUNISPORTwhichshowsher
hostilityandantagonismtowardsPetitioner;
OCAMPO,withlackofrespectandcourtesy,likewiseremovedseveral
accountsfromPetitionertherebydiminishinghisdutiesassalesmanager,
withouthisknowledge.Byreducinghisaccounts,Petitionerlikewiseloss
commissionsforsaleshecouldearnfromtheseaccounts.Thisisevidenced
byanemailthatOCAMPOsenttoheremployees;
Blue Angel Manpower and Security Services, Inc. v. Court of Appeals,
G.R. No. 161196, July 28, 2008.
Fungo v. Lourdes School of Mandaluyong, G.R. No. 152531, July 27,

2007.
Please refer to Annex D Petitioners Position Paper (See
Annexes G, H, and I ).
355
OnJune17,2011,OCAMPOtoldPetitionertojustgohomewhenhereported
forwork.OnJune21,2011,EfrenGranadadirectiveissuedbyOCAMPO,in
herownhandwriting,directingGranadatocomputePetitionersaccrued
benefits.WhenPetitionersawthis,hewasdeeplyhurtandsaddenedbythe
thoughtthatOCAMPOwasseriousinhavinghisemploymentterminated;
HewassubsequentlyorderedbyGranadatosignaquitclaimbutpetitioner
refused.OnJuly1,2011,OCAMPOwenttoPetitionersroomanddirected
himtomakearesignationletteronthepretextthattheAccounting
Departmentwouldstartcomputinghisreceivablesuponreceiptofhis
resignationletter.Hopelessanddejected,
Petitionerwasemotionallycompelledtowritearesignationletter.To
makethesituationworse,hewroteitinfrontofOCAMPOwhodictated
thematterswhichhemustwriteinhisresignationletter.
Therecanbenovalidresignationwheretheactwasmadeunder
compulsionorundercircumstancesapproximatingcompulsion,suchas
whenanemployeesactofhandinginhisresignationwasareactionto
circumstancesleavinghimnoalternativebuttoresign.33Clearlyinthis
case,Petitionerdidnotresignvoluntarily.Heresigneduponsubmissionto
Respondentspressureandclearactofdiscrimination.Hewasscornedby
RespondentOcampo,thisisthereasonwhyshehadtodeviceaschemeand
setaplanthateventuallycompelledPetitionertoresign.
TheNLRCerredinrulingthatthiswas
33
Peaflor vs. Outdoor Clothing Manufacturing Corp.,et al, G.R.No.
177114, January 21, 2010 citing Metro Transit Organization, Inc. v.

NLRC, G.R.No.122046, January 16,1998.
356
notacaseofconstructivedismissal
ThePublicRespondentallegedlyfoundanapparentvoluntarinessofwriting
theresignationpersonallywithoutanyduressandwhichshowednoforce
employedinitsexecution;
Itmustbepointedouthoweverthatwhiletheremaynotbeactualphysical
forceoreventhreatemployedbyRespondentswhicheventuallylead
Petitionertowritetheresignationletter,theconditionsthenexistingshould
havebeenconsideredintheirtotalityinascertainingwhetherpetitioners
resignationwasvoluntaryorthathewasmerelycompelledtoresignandwrite
aletterinsuchmannerandtenor;
WhatimpelledPetitionertoresignwerenotonlyduetotheunreasonableacts
andunfairtreatmenthesufferedinthehandsofOCAMPOandother
colleaguesbutthedictateofnolessthanhisbossOCAMPOthatheshould
resign.TheHonorablePublicRespondentfailedtoconsidertheevidence
thatwerepresentedinsupportofthisclaim.Itsimplyignoredthefact
thatonseveraloccasions,OCAMPOthroughemailsexpressedherdesire
toendtheemploymentofPetitionerandthisdesirewasVERBALIZED
andpracticallyDICTATEDtothehaplessemployeefirstonJune16,
2011andfinallyonJuly1,2011whenOCAMPOwenttoseePetitionerin
hisroom;
Itisnotablelikewisethatwhilethecompanyatthattimemayhavebeen
experiencingproblemsonthesalesofitsslipperproductsduetopoordesigns,
itwasrespondentOCAMPOherselfwhoheadstheProductDevelopment
Departmentandwhoisresponsiblefortheselectionandproductstyles.Why
wouldOCAMPOsolelyblamePetitionerforlowturnoutofsaleswhenshe
knewthattheendresultofwhateversalesoutput;isabyproductofthe
companysconsolidatedeffort?
Trueenough,petitionerwasamanageratthattime,buthewasalsoapartofa
teamandrespondentOCAMPOontheotherhandwastheHeadoftheProduct
DevelopmentDepartment.Yet,whatisapparentandwhichtheHonorablePublic
RespondentfailedtotakecognizanceofisthatOCAMPOseeminglyburdened
petitionerALONEwithallthesestrugglesandpushedhim
357
tohislimitsinordertomakehimfeelunwantedandunworthyofcontinuing
theservicehewasrenderingforthecompanyinmorethanadecade;
39. Thesefeelingsdidnotariseoutofthinair,butthefollowing specifically

identifiedcircumstancesestablishedtheoppressiveworkingenvironmentfor
thepetitioner,towit
39.1AfterpetitionercamebacktoworkinApril2008,withouttheslightest
considerationtopetitionershealthcondition,OCAMPOtoldhimthatifhe
shouldsufferagainamajorhealthproblem,shewillterminatehisservices;
andwhilehewasstillrecoveringfromstroke,bythemonthofDecember
2008,respondentissuedMemorandum(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnex
AofPetitionersPositionPaper)directedagainstpetitioneryetdisguisedas
ifapplicableandnoticetoallemployeeswhichprovides:
havingasickmind.
ThatwasjustthebeginningofPetitionerspredicament.ByJune2011,after
thecompanyexperiencedproblemsonsales,petitionerwassolelyblamedfor
thesalesoutput.Hewaspressuredtothepointthathewasevenheldfordays
inOCAMPOsroomwhereheanguishedafterOCAMPOtoldhimfabricated
issuesandallegednegativecommentscomingfromotheremployees;
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexF
ofPetitionersPositionPaper)datedJune14,2011sentby
358
OCAMPOwhourgedhimtoexplainthedropinsaleswhensheknewall
alongthattherootcauseoftheproblemwasthedesignsheherselfselected;
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexG
ofPetitionersPositionPaper)datedJune15,2011sentbyOCAMPOwhere
sheshowedherpersonalgrudgeagainstpetitionerbydeclaring:
ATTHEENDOFTHEYEARIFJTSSTILLNOIMPROVEMENT
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexH
ofPetitionersPositionPaper)datedJune15,2011sentbyOCAMPOto
everyonesayingihavedecidedtolessentheaccountsofjtsxxx(referring
topetitionerJesusTSocorro);
39.6OnJune16,2011,afterpressuringhimontheproductsales,OCAMPO
verballypressedonpetitionertoresignbytellinghim:
JESMABUTIPAMAGRESIGNKANALANG.MAGPAHINGAKANA.
BABAYARANKANAMINNGCOMMISSIONMO
39.7Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexIofPetitioners
PositionPaper)datedJune16,2011sentbyOCAMPOincitingsomeofthe
employeestogoagainstpetitionerinthefollowingmanner:
359
xxx.Awaitingyouropinionssowillforwardtojts(JesusTSocorro)/bom,
thustheywillseeitsacommitteewhoisdeciding.
AlltheforegoingincidentswerecappedbyOCAMPOpersonallyseeing
PetitioneronJuly1,2011demandinghisresignation;
Asthecompanywasexperiencinglowsalesofslippersduetopoordesigns
adoptedandselectedbyOCAMPOasheadoftheProductDevelopment
Department,shecouldnotbearthethoughtthatherfatherwouldblame
herlaterforwhatthecompanyhassuffered.Thereisnobetterescape
goatandlateronassacrificiallambbuthereinPetitioner.OCAMPO
knewwhatwascoming.Inordertosaveherselffromherfathers
disappointment,shehadtodeviseawaytopassalltheblameto
petitioner.Shehadtodothissopetitionerwouldbecompelledtoleave
thecompanybeforeherfathercomesbackfromabroad.Thatisthereason
whyOCAMPOhadtoresorttoallthesethingsforpetitionertofeel
constrainedinresigningfromthecompany;
Clearly,theHonorablePublicRespondentaltogetherignoredthepiecesof
evidencepresentedshowingthehostileanddiscriminatoryworking
environmentwhichPetitionerhaddealtwithandwhichfinallyculminated
withOCAMPOsdemandforhisresignation.
TheHonorableCommissionlikewiseerredingivingweighttothetext
messagessentbyOCAMPOtoPetitionertellinghimtowaitYUsreturn
beforesubmittinghisresignationletterasevidencethatPetitionerwasnot
compelledtoresign;
Thetextmessagesdonotprovethevoluntarinessofresignation.Ifthecontent
ofthetextmessageisexamined,OCAMPOwas
360
merelysuggestingthatPetitionershoulddeferhisresignationuntilthearrival
ofYU.Themessagesuggests,however,thathestillhastoresign.
WhetherornotPetitionerwascompelledtoresignisdeterminednot
merelyonthebasisofasingleisolatedactorcircumstancebutthe
totalityofhisconductbefore,during,andaftertheresignation;
Atlength,otherthantheselfservingallegationsofOCAMPOandthe
allegedlycorroborativetestimonyofoneofRespondentsemployees,
UNISPORThasnotsubstantiallydischargeditsburdenofprovingthat
Petitionersresignationwasvoluntary.Petitionerwasonthelosingendinthis
caseforhehasnoaccesstothecompanyrecordsandhaslessinfluenceonthe
peoplethatcouldtestifyonhisdefense.Itisalsoforthesereasonsthat
PetitionermeeklyseekstheassistanceofthisHonorableCourttogivehimthe
justicethathewasunfairlydeprivedof.Petitionerisevenoftheopinionthat
apparentlythePublicRespondentswereguiltyofDOUBLESTANDARDand
ofbeingSELECTIVEintheirdiscussionofthefactsandargumentsofboth
parties;
SurelythedecisiontoresignwasthatofPetitionerbutthiswas
broughtaboutbytheantipathyheexperiencedfromOCAMPO.Itis
unmistakablethatOCAMPOsillfeelingrevealedherulteriormotivetoput
petitionerunderextremeconditionofastressfulenvironmentwhich
compelledhimtofinallyforegoofhisemployment.Clearlytheresignation
wasnevervoluntary;
47. Inanillegaldismissalcase,the onusprobandi stillrestsonthe employer

toprovethatthedismissalofanemployeeisforavalidcause.Havingbased
theirdefenseonresignation,itislikewiseincumbentuponrespondents,as
employer,toprovethatpetitionervoluntarilyresigned.Fromthetotalityof
circumstancesandtheevidenceonrecord,itisclearthatRespondentsfailed
todischargethisburden.Infact,eveniftheevidence
361
presentedbytheemployerandtheemployeeareinequipoise,thescales
ofjusticemustbetiltedinfavorofthelatter 34;
Unfortunately,theHonorablePublicRespondenttotallyignoredthefactsand
theevidencethatwerepresentedshowingnotonlytheattendanthostileand
discriminatoryworkingenvironmentofPetitionerbut,moreso,themannerby
whichRespondentOCAMPOpracticallyforcedandeventuallycompelled
himtowritetheresignationletter;
Article4oftheLaborCodeprovidesthatalldoubtsintheinterpretationand
implementationoftheLaborCodeshouldbeinterpretedinfavoroflabor.
TheevidencethatthePetitionerpresentedhasshownseriousdoubtsonthe
meritsofhisemployerscase.TheSupremeCourthasheldthatinsuch
contestofevidence,Article4shouldoperateinfavoroftheemployee. 35To
Petitionersdisappointmenthowever,thisprinciplewasdisregardedbythe
HonorablePublicRespondentattheexpenseofPetitioner.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,inthelightoftheforegoing,itismostrespectfullyprayedof
thisHonorableCourtofAppeals,thatthePetitionbegivenduecourse,and
thattheassailedNLRCDecisiondated31May2012,dismissingPetitioners
AppealandtheNLRCResolutiondated23July2012,denyingpetitioners
MotionforReconsideration,besetaside.
34
Uy v Centro Ceramica Corporation et al., G.R. No. 174631,
October 19, 2011 citing Mobile Protective & Detective Agency v.

Ompad, G.R. No. 159195, May 9, 2005.
35
Peaflor vs. Outdoor Clothing Manufacturing Corp., et al, G.R.
No. 177114, January 21, 2010.
362
Prayingforsuchotherreliefsasmaybejustandequitableunderthepremises.
PasigCityfortheCityofManila,10April2013.
JAWIDLAWOFFICE
CounselforPetitioner
Unit910AntelGlobalCorporate
Center
No.3DoaJuliaVargasAve.,
OrtigasCBD,PasigCity1605
By:
ARIELGENAROGARCIAJAWID
PTRNr104478828;01.02.13;LasPias
City
IBPLifetimeMemberNr01904
RollNr39314
MCLE Compliance
0001196;01.19.11
363
Nr
IV
CHATO
ANCHETACABIGAS
PTRNr3671587;01.03.13;Makati
City
IBPNo.824626;04.19.10
RollNo.58436
MCLE Compliance
0002307;08.03.11
Copyfurnished:
No
IV
REYESFAJARDO&ASSOCIATES
CounselforPrivateRespondents
Unit12F,12thFloor,IBMPlazaBldg.,
No.8EastwoodAve.,EastwoodCity
CyberPark,Bagumbayan,QuezonCity
NationalLaborRelationsCommission
ThirdDivision
PublicRespondent
PPSTABldg.,BanaweSt.,
1100QuezonCity
364
EXPLANATIONFORSERVICEBYMAIL
AcopyofthisMemorandumwassenttoPlaintiffscounselandPublic
Respondentthroughregisteredmailduetodistanceandforpractical
considerations.
CHATOANCHETACABIGAS
365
FORMNO.5:PETITIONFORCERTIORARI
COURTOFAPPEALS
MANILA
JESUST.SOCORRO,
Petitioner,
C.A.G.R.S.P.No.
versus
(NLRCRABNo.071105411)
(NLRCLACNo.0300106712)
NATIONALLABORSRELATIONS
COMMISSION,
UNISPORT
MARKETING CORPORATION,
JOSE YUandELEANORYU
OCAMPO,
Respondents.
xx
366
PETITIONFORCERTIORARI
PREFATORYSTATEMENT
Whenthependulumofjudgmentswingstoandfroandtheforcesare
equalonbothsides,thesamemustbestilledinfavoroflabor.
(MarcopperMiningv.NationalLaborRelationsCommission,325
Phil.618).Anydoubtconcerningtherightsoflaborshouldbe
resolvedinitsfavorpursuanttothesocialjusticepolicy(Terminal
FacilitiesandServicesCorporationv.NLRC,199SCRA265).
PETITIONER,throughcounsel,mostrespectfullystatesthat:
NATUREANDTIMELINESOFTHEPETITION
NATURE
367

Forms
ThisisaspecialcivilactionforCertiorariunderRule65oftheRulesof
CourtseekingthereviewandannulmentoftheDecision36oftheThird
DivisionHonorableNationalLaborRelationsCommission(thereafterreferred
toasNLRCorCommissionforbrevity)dated31May2012inNLRCLAC
CaseNo.0300106712affirmingtheDecision37ofLaborArbiterRomelita
N.RiofloridoinNLRCRABNo.071105411dated23February2012;and
theResolution38oftheNLRCdated23July2012denyingpetitionersMotion
forReconsiderationdated5July2012.
PetitionerassailstheaforesaidDecisionoftheHonorableCommissionaffirming
theearlierdecisionoftheHonorableLaborArbiter,aswellasitsResolutionon
theMotionforReconsiderationforhavingbeenrenderednotinaccordancewith
lawandwithgraveabuseofdiscretion,amountingtolackand/orexcessof
jurisdiction,correctibleonlybyawritofCertiorari.
Petitionerlikewisemaintainsthatithasnoplain,speedyandadequateremedy
intheordinarycourseoflaw,otherthanthisPetition.
TIMELINESSOFTHEPETITION
ThechronologicalsequenceofthepromulgationofDecision/Resolutionson
theinstantcasecanbeenumeratedasfollows:
Initially,PetitionerJESUST.SOCORRO(SOCORROforbrevity)lodgeda
complaintagainstRespondentsUNISPORTMARKETINGCORPORATION,
(UNISPORTforbrevity),JOSEYU(YUforbrevity)andELEANORYU
OCAMPO(OCAMPOforbrevity)withtheRegionalArbitrationBranch
NCRoftheNLRCon19July2011.
MandatoryConciliation/MediationConferencewerepreviouslysetbutfor
failuretoamicablysettle,bothpartiesweredirectedtosubmittheirrespective
positionpaper.Afterbothpartieshavesubmittedtheir
A certified copy is hereto attached as Annex A-Certiorari .
A certified copy is hereto attached as Annex B-Certiorari .
A certified copy is hereto attached as Annex C-Certiorari .
368
respectivepleadingsPositionPaper39,Reply40andRejoinder41,thecase
wasdeemedsubmittedforResolution.
3.On23February2012,LaborArbiterRomelitaN.Riofloridorenderedher
Decision42,thedispositiveportionofwhichreads,thus:
WHEREFORE,adecisionisherebyrendereddismissingthecomplaintof
constructivedismissal.Respondentshoweverareorderedtopaycomplainant
JesusT.SocorrothesumofP76,996.89.Otherclaimsaredenied.
SOORDERED.
QuezonCity,Philippines,23February2012.
Copy of the Position Paper of Petitioner and Private Respondents are

hereto attached as Annexes D-Certiorari; E-Certiorari ,
respectively.
Copy of the Reply of Petitioner and Private Respondents are hereto

attached as Annexes F-Certiorari; and G-Certiorari , respectively.
Copy of the Rejoinder of Petitioner and Private Respondents are

hereto attached as Annexes H-Certiorari; and I Certiorari,
respectively.
Please see Annex B-Certiorari .
369
4.SOCORROappealedtheaforecitedDecisionon21March201243,which
wasdeniedon31May2012,thedispositiveportionofwhichreadsthus:
WHEREFORE,premisesconsidered,theappealisherebyDENIED.The23
February2012DecisionofLaborArbiterRomelitaN.Riofloridoishereby
AFFIRMEDwiththemodificationthatinadditiontohisaward,the
respondentsareorderedtopaycomplainantfinancialassistanceinthe
amountofP100,000.00.
SOORDERED.
QuezonCity,Philippines.
5.WhenSOCORROreceivedacopyofthisDecisionon25June2012,hetimely
44
movedforareconsiderationbyfilinghisMotionforReconsideration on5July
2012towhichrespondentsfiledtheirOppositiondated10July2012andthe
45
sameThirdDivisionoftheHonorableCommissionpromulgatedaResolution
on23July2012denyingthemotionforreconsiderationacopyofwhichwas
receivedbypetitionerscounselon14
August2012.
A copy is hereto attached as Annex J - Certiorari
Attached as Annex K - Certiorari
Please see Annex C - Certiorari
370
6.UnderSection4,Rule65oftheRulesofCourt,aPetitionforCertiorarimay
befilednotlaterthansixty(60)daysfromnoticeofjudgment,orderorresolution
soughttobeassailed.SincepetitionerscounselreceivedtheResolutionofthe
HonorableCommissiononitsMotionforReconsiderationlast14August2012,it
has60daysfromthereonoruntil14October2012withinwhichtofilehis
petition,hence,thetimelinessofthisPetition.
II
THEPARTIES
PetitionerSOCORROworkedasaSalesManageratUNISPORTpriortohis
severancefromemployment.HeisresidingatNo4GardenGrooveSt.,Park
PlaceVillage,Cainta,Rizal,1900,andforpurposesofthisappeal,hemaybe
servedwithsummonsandotherprocessesofthisHonorableCommission
throughtheundersignedcounsels(JAWIDLAWOFFICE);
RespondentUNISPORTisacorporationdulyorganizedandexistingunder
thelawsoftheRepublicofthePhilippineswithprincipaloffice
at497PresidentQuirinoAvenueExtensioncornerZuluetaSt.,Paco,Manila,
NCR1007.CorespondentsYUandOCAMPOarethePresidentandVice
PresidentofUNISPORT,respectively;
PetitionerandPrivateRespondentsmaybeservedwithlegalprocessesasmay
beissuedbythisHonorableCourtthroughtheirrespectivecounsel;
Lastly,theHonorablePublicRespondent,theNationalLaborRelations
Commissionisherebyimpleadedasanominalparty,andmaybeservedwith
summonsandotherprocessesofthisHonorableCourtatthePPSTABuilding,
BanaweSt.,1100QuezonCity;
371
III
STATEMENTOFESTABLISHEDFACTSANDTHECASE
Ascanbeculledfromtherecords,thefactsofthecasemaybecapsulizedinto
thefollowing:
SOCORROinitiallystartedworkingforUNISPORTinSeptember1998with
BradgateMarketingCorporation,thethenmarketingarmofUNISPORT.YU,
thecompanypresidentofferedhimtoworkunderitssalesdepartment.Asthe
companythenwasexperiencingtroubleinmarketingandsellingtheirREVA
products(slippers),petitionerorganizedanddevelopedmeasurestopromote
andincreasethesalesofUNISPORT;
ConsideringthatthemarketingarmofUNISPORTonlystartedinJuly1998
andSOCORROwasengagedonlytwo(2)monthsafterassalesmanager,he
performedthefollowingactivitiestostrengthenthemarketingofficewiththe
endinviewofincreasingitssales,towit:
a)HesystematizedCustomerListsnationwide;
HeformattedseveralsalesdocumentneededtoprocessSalesOrder;
Initially,hewasalsoinvolvedintheProduction,Costing,Distribution,
CollectionandMerchandisingoftheProduct;
HeestablishedPlanningandMarketingStrategiesandSalesProgramtoboost
InputOrdersfromcustomers;
HewasalsoresponsiblefortrainingOCAMPO,thedaughterofthePresident
andalsotheVicePresidentofUNISPORT.Heintroducedhertovariouslong
timeclientsandstoreownersaliketohaveherfamiliarizewithUNISPORTs
prospectivecustomers;
372
AlltheeffortsexertedbytheSOCORROpaidoff.UNISPORTsRevaBrand
wasabletoestablishanicheofitsownintheentirePhilippinemarket
Luzon,VisayasandMindanao;
InNovember2007,althoughSOCORROhadalreadyreachedhissales
quotaforthatyearend,respondentOCAMPOsoughtadditionalsalesof
THREEMILLIONPESOS(P3Million)intheVisayasarea.With
tremendouspressurefromOCAMPO,SOCORROproceededtoVisayas
andtriedtofurtherincreasethecompanyssalesoutput.Thiswasinspite
ofthefactthatitwasnearingDecemberanditwasdifficulttogetordersat
thattimesincemostoftheproductsbythenshouldhavealreadybeenoutin
thestores;
Becauseoftoomuchworkanduntoldstressbroughtaboutbytheadditional
salesdemand,SOCORROsufferedastrokeonDecember10,2007,notlong
afterhearrivedfromvariousprovincesintheVisayas.Forthisreasonhehad
tobeconfinedinthehospitalfor13days.However,becauseoffinancial
constraints,thedoctorsallowedhimtojusttakearestinhishouseandprohibited
himfromengaginginanystressfulactivity;
Aftermonthsofrest,SOCORROreportedbackforworkinApril2008.At
thispoint,withoutdueregardtoSOCORROshealthcondition,OCAMPO
toldhimthatifheshouldsufferagainamajorhealthproblem,shewill
terminatehisservices;
OnDecember11,2008,YU,issuedaMemorandum(PleaserefertoAnnex
DAnnexAofpetitionersPositionPaper)whichprovides,among
others,therequirementofincreaseinSalesQuotafor2009,2010and2011.
Theissuanceindicatedthatwhilethesalesquotawasincreasedthe
commissionwasreduced.Itwasalsofrustratingthatthememorandum
specificallytargetedSOCORROinthefollowingmanner
havingasickmind.
373
Byyear2010uptotheearlypartof2011,thereweredrasticdropinthesales
ofproducts.TheProductDevelopmentheadedby
OCAMPO,placedherordersinChinawithoutconsideringtheposition
oftheSalesDepartmentontheproductcategoryandstyle.What
OCAMPOdidwasmerelytocirculatetothesalesdepartmenttheimageof
theproductswhichhavealreadybeenplacedinorder,onlyFORNOTICE.As
aresult,therewasahighrejectionratefromclients,highinventoryinthe
warehousesandnegativecommentsfromdealers.Thisfactwassupportedby
severalcorrespondencesfromUNISPORTscustomersandalsofromitsvery
ownmanagers.TheproblemwiththedecliningsalesoftheREVAproduct
wasnotbecauseofthesalesmanagersinefficiencybutbecauseofthe
verystyleoftheproductbeingintroducedbytheproductdevelopment
department,headedbyOCAMPOherself.However,despitetheobvious
reasonswhyclientswerebackingofffromplacingtheirorders,OCAMPO
blamedSOCORROonthereductionofsales;
thetransferofeachDepartmenttoanotherlocation.
OCAMPOorderedthattheairconditioningunitatSOCORROsroom
dismantled,includingthecabinet,sofaandtheglasspartitionoftheroom.
WhatwasmoreawfulwasthatitwasonlySOCORROsairconunitthat
waspulledoutwhiletherestoftheroomsmaintainedtheirunits.Tomake
mattersworse,theperiodoftransferwasextendeduptoJune30,2011.The
motivebehindtheintentionalpulloutoftheairconunitwasundoubtedly
cleartomaketheworkingenvironmentofSOCORROmoreunbearable;
AsearlyasApriltoMay2011thedesignsoftheproductsaffectedthe
decreaseinsales.Thiswasevidencedbyemails(PleaserefertoAnnexD
AnnexesBandCofpetitionersPositionPaper)sentbyothermanagers
ofUNISPORT,indicatingtheproblemwiththeproductsstyles.Eveninthe
latterdaysofSOCORROsservicewithUNISPORT,inan
email(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexDofpetitionersPositionPaper)
sentonJune13,2011byDonnaSia,MerchandisingManagerofGaisanoCapital
Group(clientofUNISPORT),sheexpressedherproblemwiththe
374
designsoftheslippersandthatshecannotforceherbuyerstoorder.Thiswas
wellwithintheknowledgeofOCAMPObecauseasearlyasOctober2010,
OCAMPOsentanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexEof
petitionersPositionPaper)tothemanagerstellingthemtheproblem.Itbears
statingatthispointthattheProductDevelopmentDepartmentheadedby
OCAMPOistheoneresponsibleintheselectionoftheproductstylesand
designs;
OCAMPOdidnotstoppressuringSOCORRO.Infact,forfour(4)straight
daysfromJune1417,2011,SOCORROwasquarantinedinsideOcampos
officeeverytimehecameinforwork.Sheincessantlyaccusedhimofbeing
answerableforthedecliningsalesoutput.OCAMPOblamedSOCORROfor
thelowsalesinspiteofthefactthatshewaswellawarethattheveryproblem
wasthedesignsoftheproductsheselected;
OnJune14,2011,inanotheremail(PleaserefertoAnnexD
AnnexFofpetitionersPositionPaper)sentbyOCAMPOto
SOCORRO,sheagainfaultedhimonthereducedsalesbooking.OCAMPO
neverstoppedpressuringandtorturinghimoftheproblemsheherselfcreated.
Infact,againonJune15,2011,inanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexD
AnnexGofpetitionersPositionPaper)sheagainmanifestedherillwill
andpersonalresentmentagainstHIM.OCAMPOeventhreatenedhimthat
shewillretirehim,thus:
6.)ATTHEENDOFTHEYEARIFJTSSTILLNOIMPROVEMENT
Onthatsameday,OCAMPOremovedfromSOCORROseveralaccounts
hewasthenhandlingtherebyfurtherdiminishinghisdutiesassales
manageranddeprivinghimofpossiblecommissionsforthelostaccounts.
Thiswasevidencedbyanemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexHof
petitionersPositionPaper)shesenttootheremployees.Thiswasundertaken
withouttheknowledgeofSOCORRO;
NotlongthereafteroronJune16,2011,OCAMPOsummonedSOCORROto
heroffice.Sherelentlesslypressuredhimagainontheproductsales.Atthis
point,shecasuallybutfirmlytoldhim
375
JESMABUTIPAMAGRESIGNKANALANG.MAGPAHINGAKA
NA.BABAYARANKANALANGNAMINNGCOMMISSIONMO
65. Onthefollowingday,June17,OCAMPOtoldSOCORROto justgo

homewhenhereportedforwork.OCAMPOsgrudgeagainsthimwasshown
intheemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexIofpetitionersPosition
Paper)shesenttothestaffonthesameday,instigatingthemtocometogether
andpressureSOCORRO,thus:
(emphasisandunderscoringsupplied)
ByJune21,2011whenSOCORROreportedbacktowork,EfrenGranada,
theManageroftheHumanResourceDepartmentandWarehouseDivision,
calledhisattentionandshowedhimacopyofthedirectiveissuedby
OCAMPOinherownhandwriting,directinghimtocomputeSOCORROs
accruedbenefits.WhenSOCORROsawthis,hewassooverwhelmedwith
emotionsthathethoughtthatOCAMPOwasreallyseriousinterminatinghis
employment.SOCORROfeltataloss,unwanted,anddespisedby
OCAMPObecauseofthetortureandneverendingaccusationsofdismal
performance.Alltheseputahugetolluponhimthathewaseventuallyforced
tojustleavehiswork;
SOCORROwasinstructedbyEfrenGranadaofHRDtosignaQuitclaim,but
herefuseduntilheseesthecomputationandreceivesallhisunclaimed
salariesandcommission.WhenhewentbacktotheofficeonJuly1,2011
OCAMPOwenttohisroomanddirectedhimthathehastomakea
376
ResignationLetter(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexJofpetitioners
PositionPaper)firstsothattheAccountingDepartmentcanproceedwiththe
computationofhisreceivables.Theresignationletterwaswrittenunderthe
directionofOCAMPOwhodictatedthematterstobewrittenthereon;
ItwillhavetobeemphasizedinherethattheresignationletterofSOCORRO
wasoriginallydatedJuly1,2011,thedayhewenttotheoffice.However,as
appearingatthelatterportionoftheletter,theeffectivityofsaidresignation
waschangedtoJune30,2011.Thiswaswrittenundernolessthanthestrict
directionofOCAMPO;
SOCORROwentbackonJuly15,2011tofollowuponhisunpaidsalaries
andcommissions.Tohisdismay,uponcheckingwiththeaccounting,hewas
informedthatNOCOMPUTATIONwasevermade;
SOCORROwascoercedtoresignbecauseoftheanxietyandthemyriadof
problemsandburdenimposeduponhimbyOCAMPO.Hewasnotonly
forcedbutalsodeceivedintomakingaresignationletterunderthepretextthat
hewillbepromptlygivenhiscommissionandoverduesalarywhichupto
nowremainsunpaid;
Duetotheforegoing,SOCORROfiledthisinstantactionforillegaldismissal
beforetheOfficeoftheLaborArbiteronJuly19,2011.
Forfailuretoamicablysettle,thepartiesweredirectedtosubmittheir
respectivepositionpaper.Thereafter,thepartieswerealsogiventhe
opportunitytosubmittheirrespectivereply,andrejoinder,afterwards,the
LaborArbiterrenderedtheinstantdecisiondatedFebruary23,2012;
TheLaborArbiterresolvedthecaseinfavoroftheRespondentsonthebasis
oftheopinionthatSOCORROwasnotforcedtoresign,thushewasnot
illegallyconstructivelydismissed.Hence,SOCORROappealedthecasetothe
NLRCwhichdecidedinfavoroftherespondents.SOCORROSMotionfor
Reconsiderationwaslikewisedenied.Hence,thispetition,
377
IV
GROUNDSFORTHEALLOWANCEOFTHEPETITION
PublicrespondentNLRCgravelyabuseditsdiscretioninaffirmingthe
DecisionoftheHonorableLaborArbiterinfindingthatPetitionerwas
notconstructivelydismissed.
PublicrespondentNLRCgravelyabuseditsdiscretionindenying
petitionersMotionforReconsiderationwithoutclearlyanddistinctly
explainingthereasonforitsdenial.
ARGUMENTSANDDISCUSSION
378
TheNLRCerredinrulingthatthe
ResignationwasVoluntary.
Resignationisaformalpronouncementorrelinquishmentofanoffice,with
theintentionofrelinquishingtheofficeaccompaniedbytheactof
relinquishment.Astheintenttorelinquishmustconcurwiththeovertactof
relinquishment,theactsoftheemployeebeforeandafterthealleged
resignationmustbeconsideredindeterminingwhether,infact,heintendedto
severhisemployment(BMGRecords(Phils.),Inc.v.Aparecio,G.R.No.
153290,September5,2007);
Inthiscase,theovertactsofSOCORRObeforeandafterthealleged
resignationdonotshowhisintentiontoseverhisemployment.Whatstrongly
negatestheclaimofresignationisthesubsequentfilingofcomplaintfor
constructivedismissal;
Resignationisinconsistentwiththefilingofthecomplaintforillegal
dismissal(BlueAngelManpowerandSecurityServices,Inc.v.Courtof
Appeals,G.R.No.161196,July28,2008).Itwouldhavebeenillogicalfor
petitionertoresignandthenfileacomplaintforillegaldismissallateron
(Fungov.LourdesSchoolofMandaluyong,G.R.No.152531,July27,2007).
IfSOCORROwasdeterminedtoresignhewouldnothavefiledthecomplaint
forillegaldismissal;
Thecircumstancessurroundingpetitionersresignationmustalsobetaken
intoconsiderationtodeterminewhethertheresignationwasvoluntary:
379
MayweinvitetheattentionofthisHonorableCourttotheseriesofemails
46
sentbyOCAMPOtoseveralemployeesofUNISPORTwhichshowsher
hostilityandantagonismtowardsSOCORRO;
OCAMPO,withlackofrespectandcourtesy,likewiseremovedseveral
accountsfromSOCORROtherebydiminishinghisdutiesassalesmanager,
withouthisknowledge.ThisisevidencedbyanemailthatOCAMPOsentto
heremployees;
OnJune17,2011,OCAMPOtoldtheSOCORROtojustgohomewhenhe
reportedforwork.OnJune21,2011,EfrenGranada(Granada),theManager
oftheHumanResourceDepartmentandWarehouseDivision,calledhis
attentionandshowedhimacopyofthedirectiveissuedbyOCAMPO,inher
ownhandwriting,directingGranadatocomputeSOCORROSaccrued
benefits.WhenSOCORROsawthis,hewasoverwhelmedwithemotionsthat
hethoughtOCAMPOwasseriousinhavinghisemploymentterminated;
HewassubsequentlyorderedbyGranadatosignaquitclaimbutpetitioner
refused;
OnJuly1,2011,OCAMPOwenttoSOCORROsroomanddirectedhimto
makearesignationletterfirstsotheAccountingDepartmentcanstartthe
computationofhisreceivables.Hopelessanddownhearted,SOCORROwas
emotionallycompelledtowritearesignationletter.Tomakethesituation
worse,hewroteitinfrontofhisbosswhodictatedthematterswhichhemust
writeinhisresignationletter.
46
Please refer to Annex D Petitioners Position Paper (See Annexes G,
H, and I ).
380
Inanillegaldismissalcase,theonusprobandirestsontheemployertoprove
thatthedismissalofanemployeeisforavalidcause.
Havingbasedtheirdefenseonresignation,itislikewiseincumbentupon
respondents,asemployer,toprovethatpetitionervoluntarilyresigned.
Fromthetotalityofcircumstancesandtheevidenceonrecord,itisclearthat
respondentsfailedtodischargethisburden.Infact,eveniftheevidence
presentedbytheemployerandtheemployeeareinequipoise,thescalesof
justicemustbetiltedinfavorofthelatter47;
Webelievethattherespondentswerenotabletodischargethisburden.The
voluntarinessoftheresignationmustnotonlybeassessedonthebasis
solelyofahandwrittenresignationletteranditswordingsbutalsoonthe
circumstancesandreasonswhyitwaswritten;
Unfortunately,theHonorableCommissiontotallyignoredthefactsandthe
evidencethatwerepresentedshowingnotonlytheattendanthostileand
discriminatoryworkingenvironmentofpetitionerbut,moreso,themannerby
whichrespondentOCAMPOpracticallyforcedandeventuallycompelledthe
complainanttowritetheresignationletter;
TheHonorableCommissionagreedwiththeHonorableLaborArbiterthatthe
returnbySOCORROofhislaptop,cellphones,calculator,staplerand
companycarassignedtohimwasanindicationofthevoluntarynatureofhis
resignation.Webegtodisagree.Petitionerhadtoreturntheissuedlaptopand
mobilephonesconsideringthatthesethingswerenothisbutthatofthe
company.Notonlythatthereisnoreasonforhimtowithholdthem,hewas
alsoafraidthathiscontinuedpossessionofthesecompanysuppliesmightbe
usedagainsthim;
47
Uy v Centro Ceramica Corporation et al., G.R. No. 174631, October 19,
2011 citing Mobile Protective & Detective Agency v. Ompad, G.R. No. 159195,
May 9, 2005.
381
42.ThedenialmadebyGranadawhoallegedlysawSOCORROwritinghis
resignationletterbyhimselfwasbereftofmerit.Thisallegationwasspecifically
deniedbypetitioner.DuringtheentiretimeSOCORROwaswritinghis
resignationletter,theonlyonepresentwasOCAMPOwhodirectedandchecked
thecontentswritteninhisletter.Granadawasnowhereintheroomwhen
OCAMPOorderedSOCORROtowritetheletter.Assumingwithoutadmitting
thathesawSOCORROwritingaletter,howcouldhehaveknownthatwhat
SOCORROwaswritingwashisresignationletter.Granadahadnopersonal
knowledgeonthecircumstancessurroundingtheincidentwhenSOCORRO
wrotesuchletterunderthedictatesofOCAMPO,thus,hisstatementsarenotonly
incompetentbutalsototallyuntrue;
TheNLRCerredinrulingthatthiswas
Notacaseofconstructivedismissal
Clearly,thisisacaseofconstructivedismissal.Constructivedismissaldoes
notalwaysinvolveforthrightdismissalordiminutioninrank,compensation,
benefitandprivileges.Theremaybeconstructivedismissalifanactofclear
discrimination,insensibilityordisdainbyanemployerbecomesso
unbearableonthepartortheemployeethatitcouldforecloseanychoiceby
himexcepttoforegohiscontinuedemployment;
Constructivedismissalisdefinedasquittingwhencontinuedemploymentis
renderedimpossible,unreasonableorunlikelyastheofferofemployment
involvesademotioninrankordiminutioninpay(NewEverMarketing,Inc.
v.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.140555,July14,2005);
Itexistswhentheresignationonthepartoftheemployeewasinvoluntarydueto
theharsh,hostileandunfavorableconditionssetbytheemployer.Itisbrought
aboutbythecleardiscrimination,insensibilityordisdainshownbyanemployer
whichbecomesunbearabletotheemployee.An
382
employeewhoisforcedtosurrenderhispositionthroughtheemployer's
unfairorunreasonableactsisdeemedtohavebeenillegallyterminatedand
suchterminationisdeemedtobeinvoluntary(Aguilarv.BurgerMachine
HoldingsCorporation,G.R.No.172062,October30,2006);
TheHonorableCommissionallegedlyfoundanapparentvoluntarinessof
writingtheresignationpersonallywithoutanyduressandwhichshowedno
forceemployedinitsexecution.Itmustbepointedouthoweverthatwhile
theremaynotbeactualphysicalforceoreventhreatemployedbyrespondents
whicheventuallyleadpetitionertowritetheresignationletter,theconditions
thenexistingshouldhavebeenconsideredintheirtotalityinascertaining
whetherpetitionersresignationwasvoluntaryorthathewasmerely
compelledtoresignandwritealetterinsuchmannerandtenor;
WhatpromptedSOCORROtoresignwerenotonlytheunreasonableactsand
unfairtreatmenthesufferedinthehandsofOCAMPOandothercolleagues
butthedictateofnolessthanhisbossOCAMPOthatheshouldresign.The
HonorableCommissionfailedtoconsidertheevidencethatwerepresentedin
supportofthisclaim.Itoverlookedthefactthatonseveralinstances,
OCAMPOthroughemailsexpressedherdesiretoendtheemploymentof
SOCORROandthisdesirewasVERBALIZEDandpracticallyDICTATEDto
thehaplessemployeefirstonJune16,2011andfinallyonJuly1,2011when
OCAMPOwenttoseeSOCORROinhisroom;
Itisnotablelikewisethatwhilethecompanyatthattimemayhavebeen
experiencingproblemsonthesalesofitsslipperproductsduetopoordesigns,
itwasrespondentOCAMPOherselfwhoheadstheProductDevelopment
Departmentandwhoisresponsiblefortheselectionandproductstyles.Why
wouldOCAMPOsolelyblamepetitionerforlowturnoutofsaleswhenshe
knewthattheendresultofwhateversalesoutput;isabyproductofthe
companysconsolidatedeffort?
383
Trueenough,petitionerwasamanageratthattime,buthewasalsoapartofa
teamandrespondentOCAMPOontheotherhandwastheHeadoftheProduct
DevelopmentDepartment.Yet,whatisapparentandwhichtheHonorable
CommissionfailedtotakecognizanceofisthatOCAMPOseeminglyburdened
petitionerALONEwithallthesestrugglesandpushedhimtohislimitsinorder
tomakehimfeelunwantedandunworthyofcontinuingtheservicehewas
renderingforthecompanyinmorethanadecade;
Thesefeelingsdidnotariseoutofthinair,butthefollowingspecifically
identifiedcircumstancesestablishedtheoppressiveworkingenvironmentfor
thepetitioner,towit
AfterpetitionercamebacktoworkinApril2008,withouttheslightest
considerationtopetitionershealthcondition,OCAMPOtoldhimthatifhe
shouldsufferagainamajorhealthproblem,shewillterminatehisservices;and
whilehewasstillrecoveringfromstroke,bythemonthofDecember2008,
respondentissuedMemorandum(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexAof
petitionersPositionPaper)directedagainstpetitioneryetdisguisedasif
applicableandnoticetoallemployeeswhichprovides:
havingasickmind.
Thatwasjustthebeginningofpetitionerspredicament.ByJune2011,afterthe
companyexperiencedproblemsonsales,petitionerwassolelyblamedonthe
salesoutput.Hewaspressuredtothepointthathewasevenheldfordays
384
inOCAMPOsroomwhereheanguishedafterOCAMPOtoldhimfabricated
issuesandallegednegativecommentscomingfromotheremployees;
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexFofpetitionersPosition
Paper)datedJune14,2011sentbyOCAMPOwhourgedhimtoexplainthe
dropinsaleswhensheknewallalongthattherootcauseoftheproblemwas
thedesignsheherselfselected;
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexGofpetitionersPosition
Paper)datedJune15,2011sentbyOCAMPOwheresheshowedherpersonal
grudgeagainstpetitionerbydeclaring:
ATTHEENDOFTHEYEARIFJTSSTILLNOIMPROVEMENT
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexHofpetitionersPosition
Paper)datedJune15,2011sentbyOCAMPOtoeveryonesayingihave
decidedtolessentheaccountsofjtsxxx(referringtopetitionerJesusT
Socorro);
OnJune16,2011,afterpressuringhimontheproductsales,OCAMPO
verballypressedonpetitionertoresignbytellinghim:
JESMABUTIPAMAGRESIGNKANALANG.MAGPAHINGAKANA.
385
BABAYARANKANAMINNGCOMMISSION
MO
Theemail(PleaserefertoAnnexDAnnexIofpetitionersPosition
Paper)datedJune16,2011sentbyOCAMPOincitingsomeoftheemployees
togoagainstpetitionerinthefollowingmanner:
AlltheforegoingincidentswerecappedbyOCAMPOpersonallyseeing
SOCORROonJuly1,2011demandinghisresignation.Theworstpartis
thatOCAMPOdidnotevenbothertopaySOCORROtheunpaid
commissionswhichshedangledaspromisefortheemployees
resignation.Isthisnottheheightofinjusticeagainstaworkerwhofaithfully
servedhisemployerswiththebestyearsofhislife?
Asthecompanywasexperiencinglowsalesofslippersduetopoordesigns
adoptedandselectedbyOCAMPOasheadoftheProductDevelopment
Department,shecouldnotbearthethoughtthatherfatherwouldblameher
laterforwhatthecompanyhassuffered.Theeasypreytotargetisnolessthan
petitioner.OCAMPOknewwhatwascoming.Inordertosaveherselffrom
herfathersdisappointment,shehadtodeviseawaytopassalltheblameto
petitioner.Shehadtodothissopetitionerwouldbecompelledtoleavethe
companybeforeherfathercomesbackfromabroad.Thatisthereasonwhy
OCAMPOhadtoresorttoallthesethingsforpetitionertofeelconstrainedin
resigningfromthecompany;
386
Clearly,theHonorableCommissionaltogetherignoredthepiecesofevidence
presentedshowingthehostileanddiscriminatoryworkingenvironmentwhich
petitionerhadtodealwithandwhichfinallyculminatedwithOCAMPOs
demandforhisresignation.Moreover,althoughthewordsofgratitudemay
havebeenexpressedinpetitionersresignationletter,itisourhumble
submissionnonethelessthatthisaloneshouldnotbetakenonitsown
withoutconcomitantlyconsideringtheeventswhichtranspiredbefore,
duringandafteritspreparation;
Beyondthat,whywouldsuchanactofappreciationtowardthecompany
whichpetitionerhashelpedestablishedandeventuallycametolovefor13
years,betakenagainstpetitioner?Petitionerwouldnotdenythathewas
gratefulforhavingbecomeapartofUNISPORT.Andtrueenoughhislove
forthecompanyisdeclaredinhisletter.Butitshouldnotbeoverlooked
thattheincidentsthatsteeredhimtoresolveinresigningandtowritethe
letterofresignationwasduetoOCAMPOsunfairtreatment,hatred,
andcleardisdainagainsthim.Sadly,thiswasneverseennorconsidered
bytheHonorableCommission;
TheHonorableCommissionevenaffirmedtheLaborArbitersconclusionthat
whatrespondentdidwasnormalforthosewhosupervisedamarketingunitand
thatpetitionershouldnothavefeltbadaboutthemshebeinghistraineeandthat
allegedlyallpetitionerhadtodowastothreshoutthedifferencesandmakethe
adjustmentsifnecessary.Thisconclusionwebelievehoweverwasarrivedin
lightofmisplacedreflectionandevaluationoffacts;
Tobeginwith,duringthetimematerialtothiscase,OCAMPOwasnolongera
traineebuttheVicePresidentandHeadoftheProductDevelopment
DepartmentofUNISPORT.Shenotonlyhastheauthorityandpower;shealso
hasthecapacitytoinfluencethemindsofpetitionersco
387
employeesandevendirectlytellthemtogoagainstpetitioner.Infact
OCAMPOadmitteditherselfwhenshesaidinherJune16,2011email
imempoweringallofyousothatyouhaveavoicesothatjtswillalso
learntoworkwithyouandhindiparangbosingdatingnya.AKOLANG
ANGBOSINGDITOHAHA;
TheHonorableCommissiontogetherwiththeLaborArbitermistakenly
assumedthatpetitionercouldhaveoptedtothreshouttheirdifferences.
Underwhatcircumstancescouldpetitionerbeexpectedtojustsettle
whateverdifferencesheandOCAMPOhadwhenasearlyasJune16,
2011,OCAMPOalreadymanifestedherplanofterminatingpetitionerby
retiringhim?
TheHonorableCommissionlikewiseerredingivingweighttothetext
messagessentbyOCAMPOtoSOCORROtellinghimtowaitYUsreturn
beforesubmittinghisresignationletterasevidencethatSOCORROwasnot
compelledtoresign.Thetextmessagesdonotprovethevoluntarinessof
SOCORROsresignation.Ifthecontentofthetextmessageisexamined,
OCAMPOwasmerelysuggestingthatSOCORROshoulddeferhis
resignationuntilthearrivalofYU.Themessagesuggests,however,thathe
stillhastoresign.WhetherornotSOCORROwascompelledtoresignis
determinednotmerelyonthebasisofasingleisolatedactorcircumstancebut
thetotalityofhisconductbefore,during,andaftertheresignation;
WhileitistruethattheSOCORROisnotanunletteredandgullible
individualwhocanbeeasilycajoledorforcedtoresign,yetheisalsoa
humanbeingwhosesensitivitytohostilityandantagonismcouldnotbe
doubted.Thecomplainantherespentthirteen(13)yearsofhislifewitha
companythathehelpedbuild.ItwashisdreamtoplacethebrandREVAin
themapofsportingworldadreamandpromisewhichhesuccessfully
fulfilled.HowwouldamanwhohelpedimprovetheREVAbrandfeelwhen
thecompanythatheholdsdearlytohishearttreathimwithsuchresentment?
388
Surely,amanwhosefeelingshavebeenwoundedandbruisedwouldbefelt
compelledtowritesuchresignationletter.Itmightbetruethatthedecisionto
resignwasthatofpetitionerbuttheantipathyheexperiencedfromOCAMPO
forcedhimtodosoandlefthimwithnochoicebuttoleaveUNISPORT.And
itisunmistakablethatOCAMPOsillfeelingrevealedherulteriormotiveto
putpetitionerunderextremeconditionofastressfulenvironmentwhich
compelledpetitionertofinallyforegoofhisemployment.
Atlength,otherthantheselfservingallegationsofOCAMPOandthe
allegedlycorroborativetestimonyofoneofitsemployees,UNISPORThave
notsubstantiallydischargeditsburdenofprovingthatSOCORROs
resignationwasvoluntary.SOCORROwasonthelosingendinthiscasefor
hehasnoaccesstothecompanyrecordsandhaslessinfluenceonthepeople
thatcouldtestifyinhisdefense.Itisalsoforthesereasonsthatpetitioner
meeklyseekstheassistanceofthisHonorableTribunaltogivehimthejustice
whichhewasunfairlydeprived;
PRAYER
WHEREFORE,inthelightoftheforegoing,itismostrespectfullyprayedof
thisHonorableCourtthattheinstantPetitionbegivenduecourse,andthatthe
assailedLaborArbitersDecisiondated23February2012,theNLRC
Decisiondated31May2012,dismissingSOCORROSAppealandtheNLRC
Decisiondated23July2012,denyingSOCORROSMotionfor
Reconsideration,besetaside.
Prayingforsuchotherreliefsasmaybejustandequitableunderthepremises.
PasigCityfortheCityofManila,11October2012.
JAWIDLAWOFFICE
CounselforPetitioner
389
Unit910AntelGlobalCorporate
Center
Nr3DoaJuliaVargasAvenue,
OrtigasCBD,PasigCity
By:
ARIEL GENAROGARCIA
JAWID
PTRNr10273767;01.02.12;Las
PiasCity
MCLEComplianceNrIV000196;01.19.11
CHATOANCHETACABIGAS
PTR
Nr3247131;02.23.12;
MakatiCity
MCLE ComplianceNoIV
0002307;08.03.11
Copyfurnished:
Atty.ErnestoS.Dinopol
CounselforRespondentsSuite405B,WebJetBldg.,
64QuezonAvenuecor.BMAAve.QuezonCity
390
NationalLaborRelationsCommission
ThirdDivision
PPSTABldg.,BanaweSt.,
1100QuezonCity
VERIFICATIONANDCERTIFICATION
FORNONFORUMSHOPPING
I,JESUST.SOCORRO,married,oflegalage,andwithaddressatNo.4
GardenGrooveSt.,ParkPlaceVillage,Cainta,Rizal,1900,herebydepose
andstatethat:
IamthepetitionerintheabovecaptionedPetitionforCertiorari;
IcausedthepreparationoftheforegoingPetitionforCertiorariandthatIhave
readandunderstoodthecontentsthereof;
Theallegationscontainedthereinaretrueandcorrectofmypersonalknowledge
and/orbasedonauthenticrecordsofthiscase;
IherebycertifythatIhavenotfiledorcausedtobefiledanyothercaseor
proceedinginvolvingthesameissuesorsubjectmatterintheSupremeCourt,
theCourtofAppeals,oranyotherCourt,tribunalorquasijudicialagency,
andtothebestofmyknowledge,nosuchactionorclaimispendingtherein;
ShouldhereafterIlearnthatthereisasimilarpendingbeforeanysuchCourts,
tribunaloragency,Iundertaketoreportsuchfacttothisagencywithinfive
(5)daysfromsuchknowledge.
INWITNESSWHEREOF,Ihereuntoaffixedmysignatureon11October
2012attheCityofManila.
391
JESUST.SOCORRO
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNTOBEFOREmethis11thdayofOctober
2012attheCityofManila,affiantexhibitingtomehisDriversLicenseNo.
182025377ascompetentevidenceofaffiantsidentity.
Doc.No._____;
PageNo._____;
BookNo._____;
Seriesof2012.
AFFIDAVITOFSERVICE
I,MARVINPLATON,Filipino,oflegalage,singleandwithpostaladdress
atUnit910AntelGlobalCorporateCenter,No.3DonaJuliaVargasAvenue,
OrtigasCBD,PasigCity1605,afterhavingbeendulysworntoinaccordance
withlaw,herebydeposeandstatethefollowing:
IamtheliaisonofficeroftheJawidLawOffice,therepresentativeofthe
PetitionerintheaboveentitledPetitionforCertiorari;
OnOctober12,2012,Iservedthefollowingpleading/paper:
PETITIONFORCERTIORARIin
JESUSTSOCORROvs.
NATIONALLABORRELATIONSCOMMISSIONET
AL.,
392
pursuanttoSections3,5,and13ofRule13oftheRulesofCourtbypersonal
servicetothefollowing:
Atty.ErnestoS.Dinopol
CounselforRespondentsAppelleesSuite405B,WebJetBldg.,
64QuezonAvenuecor.BMAAve.QuezonCity
ThirdDivision
PPSTABldg.,BanaweSt.,1100QuezonCity
Iamexecutingthisaffidavitinordertoattesttothetruthofalltheforegoing.
CityofManila,October12,2012.
MARVIN
PLATON
Affiant
SUBSCRIBEDANDSWORNtobeforemethis12thdayofOctober,2012
affiantexhibitingtomehis____________________ascompetentevidence
ofaffiantsidentity.
Doc.No.:____;
PageNo.____;
BookNo.____;
Seriesof2012.
393
394
Phil Forms

Sample Philippine Legal Forms 2015

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Sample Philippine Legal Forms 2015

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

PHILIPPINE LEGAL FORMS 2015

VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION AGAINST NON-FORUM

AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF FACTS ALLEGED IN MOTION11

AFFIDAVIT OF ADVERSE CLAIM

AFFIDAVIT OF CHANGE OF MOTOR REGISTRATION

AFFIDAVIT OF CHANGE OF COLOR OF MOTOR VEHICLE .. 19

AFFIDAVIT OF CESSATION OF BUSINESS OPERATION

AFFIDAVIT OF CANCELLATION OF ENCUMBERANCE

AFFIDAVIT OF AGGREGATE LAND HOLDINGS

AFFIDAVIT OF CONSENT AND SUPPORT

AFFIDAVIT OF PARENTAL CONSENT TO MARRIAGE

AFFIDAVIT OF INSURANCE CLAIMS

PHILIPPINE LEGAL FORMS 2015

AFFIDAVIT OF CONSOLIDATION OF OWNERSHIP 54

AFFIDAVIT FOR PRELIMINARY ATTACHMENT

JOINT AFFIDAVIT OF TWO DISINTERESTED PERSONS

AFFIDAVIT OF SINGLE STATUS

AFFIDAVIT OF SELF- ADJUDICATION

AFFIDAVIT TO USE THE SURNAME OF THE

AFFIDAVIT OF NON OPERATION

NOTICE OF PRE-EMPTIVE RIGHTS 76

RESOLUTION DECLARING CASH DIVIDEND

UNDERTAKING TO CHANGE CORPORATION NAME

WAIVER OF PRE EMPTIVE RIGHTS 80

WAIVER TO SUBSCRIBE NEW STOCK

AFFIDAVIT OF NON OPERATION

ARTICLES OF LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

REAL ESTATE AND PERSONAL PROPERTY FORMS

AFFIDAVIT OF CONSOLIDATION OF OWNERSHIP 89

DEED OF ABSOLUTE SALE 91

EARNEST MONEY RECEIPT AGREEMENT 93

DEED OF SALE (MOTOR VEHICLE) 97

DEED OF ASSIGNMENT TRANSFER OF RIGHTS

PHILIPPINE LEGAL FORMS 2015

CHATTEL MORTGAGE .............................................................

FULL COMPLIANCE WITH CIVIL OBLIGATION .....................

MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF A HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER 145 MOTION

JOINT MOTION TO DISPOSE CONJUGAL REAL PROPERTIES

............................................................................................................. 168 MOTION

PHILIPPINE LEGAL FORMS 2015

MOTION TO INHIBIT 175

MOTION WITH LEAVE TO INTERVENE AND TO ADMIT

ATTACHED COMPLAINT- IN- INTERVENTION

MOTION TO LIFT ORDER OF ARREST

MOTION TO RELEASE MOTOR VEHICLE

MOTION TO RENDER JUDGMENT 185

MOTION FOR RE-RAFFLE AND TO SET CASE FOR

MOTION TO RESET 192

MOTION TO REVIVE CRIMINAL ACTION AND FOR THE

ISSUANCE OF WRIT OF EXECUTION ON THE COMPROMISE

MOTION TO SET CASE FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE . 199

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE DEMURRER TO EVIDENCE 202

MOTION WITH NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL

CIVIL AND SPECIAL ACTION

COMPLAINT FOR UNLAWFUL DETAINER 211

COMPLAINT FOR EJECTMENT WITH DAMAGES 214

COMPLAINT FOR SUM OF MONEY 216

ANSWER WITH COMPULSORY COUNTERCLAIM 218

ACTION FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF

APPEAL ON CIVIL CASES

NOTICE OF APPEAL 232

RECORD ON APPEAL 233