Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
STUDY OF
THE COMEPTITIVE STRATEGY ADOPTED
BY
INDIGO AIRLINES
Group 7 Section A
Ankit Goyal(M007-15)
Nikhil Dalal(M018-15)
Prabhat Kerketta(M039-15)
Shilpa Tandon(M049-15)
Shrinidhi Kudi(M028-15)
V V B Satyanarayana (M058-15)
Executive Summary
Objectives
The objective of this report is to study the detailed study of the competitive strategy adopted by
IndiGo airlines and also to identify what has helped IndiGo outperform its competitors right from
its inception.
Methods
To understand the important factors responsible for the formulation of corporate strategy, we
have utilized Strategic Management tools like Porters Five Forces model, Value Chain analysis,
SWOT matrix, PEST and the VIRO framework.
Limitations
Due to confidentiality clause and corporate policies of the company, primary data could not be
sourced. However, we have used the data available on the open source channels to come up with
an analysis of the competitive strategy of IndiGo.
.
Contents
Executive Summary.........................................................................................................................2
Introduction..................................................................................................................................5
History.............................................................................................................................................5
Early Beginnings.........................................................................................................................5
Going international......................................................................................................................5
Rapid expansion...........................................................................................................................5
About Indigo....................................................................................................................................6
Industry Analysis.............................................................................................................................7
About the Industry.......................................................................................................................7
Make In India...............................................................................................................................8
Growth drivers.........................................................................................................................8
FDI Policy................................................................................................................................8
Investment Opportunities.........................................................................................................9
PEST Analysis.............................................................................................................................9
Political Factors.......................................................................................................................9
Economic Factors....................................................................................................................9
Social factors...........................................................................................................................9
Technological factors...............................................................................................................9
PORTER FIVE FORCES MODEL...........................................................................................11
Threat of new Entrants...........................................................................................................11
Bargaining power of suppliers...............................................................................................11
Bargaining power of buyers...................................................................................................11
Threat of substitutes...............................................................................................................11
Current Day Operations of Indigo Airlines...................................................................................12
Vision.........................................................................................................................................12
Resources...................................................................................................................................12
Operational Performance...........................................................................................................13
Value chain of Indigo.....................................................................................................................15
Internal Environment Analysis and sources of competitive advantage.........................................15
Aircrafts.....................................................................................................................................15
Fuel............................................................................................................................................16
Low fare flights......................................................................................................................18
Cost efficiency.......................................................................................................................18
On-time flights.......................................................................................................................19
Low turnaround time.............................................................................................................19
Using technology smartly......................................................................................................19
VRIO Framework......................................................................................................................21
Value......................................................................................................................................21
Rarity.....................................................................................................................................22
Imitability..............................................................................................................................22
Organization...........................................................................................................................22
The Competitive Advantage......................................................................................................22
SWOT Analysis for Indigo........................................................................................................23
Strengths................................................................................................................................23
Weaknesses............................................................................................................................23
Future strategy for Indigo airlines.................................................................................................24
References......................................................................................................................................25
Airbus A320-200 operated by IndiGo. SriLankan has been receiving contracts for the past 4
years to perform maintenance checks on IndiGo aircraft. IndiGo is believed to outsource its
aircraft to SriLankan because of the unbearable tax imposed on the local MRO providers making
them unfavorable when compared to the MRO providers in Sri Lanka.
About Indigo
India is one of the fastest growing aviation industries in the world. Because of the
introduction of liberalization policy in the Indian aviation sector, the industry has witnessed
difference with the entry of the privately owned full service airlines and low cost carriers. In
2006, the private carriers accounted for around 75% share of the domestic aviation market.
Besides, there was significant increase in the number of domestic air travel passengers. Some of
the factors that have resulted in higher demand for air transport in Indian clued the growing
purchasing power of middle class, low airfares offered by low cost carriers and the growth of the
tourism industry in India. In addition to the liberalization policy, the deregulation policy has also
played a major role to encourage private players in the aviation industry. Below graph shows the
gradual growth in the domestic air traffic: The growth in the aviation industry looked promising
and hence attracted many low cost carriers like Spice Jet, Go Air and IndiGo after the success of
Air Deccan in 2003
On one hand, the booming opportunities encouraged players to expand capacity but on
the other hand, rising fuel costs and taxation rates increased the operational costs. Thus the lowcost players found it difficult to maintain their commitment. In their urge to survive, they were
compelled to increase prices, add free refreshments and beverages on-board, etc. Some players
sought refuge in mergers, whereas some survived by modifying their business model. However,
amidst this aviation turmoil, IndiGo continued to fly high. In its endeavor to consistently
maintain low costs, IndiGo resorted to measures like outsourcing and having homogeneous fleet.
These efforts helped IndiGo to offer its passengers low air fares.
The IndiGo team uses all of these resources to design processes and rules that are safe
and simple, that make sense, and that cut waste and hassles, which in turn ensures a uniquely
smooth, seamless, precise, gimmick-free customer experience at fares that are
always affordable. It was awarded the title of Best Domestic Low Cost Carrier in India for 2008. The
airline currently operates 681 flights a day with a fleet of 102 planes and flies to 40 destinations
including 5 international. It has a market share of 36.5% as of September 2015.
Below are the key factors of the business model of IndiGo airlines:
travel agents.
Employees working in multiple roles.
Unbundling of ancillary charges to make the headline fare lower.
In this report, we will analyze what strategies IndiGo followed to enter the aviation
industry. Also, we will discuss how IndiGo implemented the low cost strategy to gain
competitive advantage and provide recommendations to sustain its competitive position in the
long-term. To know about the industry attractiveness of aviation and the factors that helped
IndiGo enter this market, we will use the Porters Five Forces model. This will be useful in
gaining insight about the entry barriers, power of buyers and suppliers, competition among the
existing players and the feasible alternatives in aviation industry. SWOT analysis of the company
will help us understand the current positioning of the company based on the analysis of external
and internal environments. For internal analysis, we will study the criteria for sustainable
competitive advantage as well as the Value Chain Analysis. This will help identify the strengths
and weaknesses of the company.
InterGlobe Enterprises
Category
Sector
Airlines
Tagline/ Slogan
Go IndiGo
USP
Segment
Target Group
Positioning
Competitors
Spicejet
JetKonnect (low cost brand of Jet Airways)
Air Asia
Industry Analysis
The Airports Authority of India (AAI) plans to revive and operationalise around 50
airports in India over the next 10 years to improve regional and remote air connectivity.
The Government of India, in its draft civil aviation policy released for inputs from
stakeholders, has proposed raising Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) limit in domestic
airlines from the current 49 per cent to over 50 per cent, along with other reforms such as
tax incentives for airlines, incentives for travellers to fly to small towns at affordable
rates.
Make In India
Growth drivers
Five international airports (Delhi, Mumbai, Cochin, Hyderabad, and Bengaluru) have
been completed successfully under Public Private Partnership (PPP) mode.
The Greenfield airport of Navi Mumbai, Mopa of Goa and some brownfield airports of
Airports Authority of India (AAI) and 50 airports have to be developed at low costs.
Focus on the development of the infrastructure; increasing liberalisation Open Sky
Policy; AAI driving modernisation of airports, Air and Navigation Systems.
Growth in aviation accentuating demand for MRO (maintenance, repair and overhaul)
facilities giving rise to employment opportunities.
By 2030 India plans to increase operational airports to 250.
FDI Policy
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) of 100 % is permitted for Greenfield airport projects
under the automatic route.
Up to 100% FDI is permitted in helicopter services and seaplanes under the automatic
route.
Up to 74% FDI permitted for existing airport projects under the automatic route.
Investment Opportunities
The number of things to be added in the next 5 years: 300 business jets, 300 small
aircraft and 250 helicopters.
The development of new airports the AAI aims to bring around 250 airports under
operation across the country by 2020.
AAI has plans to spend $1.3 bn from 2013-2017 in order to develop the airports and for
its modernization.
PEST Analysis
Political Factors
100 % FDI investments for Greenfield projects
100 % tax exemption for the airports projects for a period of 10 years
Slow initiatives taken by the government in the development
Indigo Airlines has benefited the most till date.
Economic Factors
The growing middle class population and their incomes
GDP growth in the Indian economy slowed down which has forced the airlines to cut
down on their costs so as to avoid wastage of capacity
Constantly fluctuating oil prices demand a greater operational efficiency from the
airlines.
Depreciating value of rupee adds costs to lease rentals, salaries, and sales commissions
when compared to the US economy.
Working capital requirement is high but Indigo is having a good financial condition
compared to the competitions
Social factors
The constantly changing incomes for population makes it difficult to recognize the needs
of each group which changes according to their salaries.
The quality and type of food had to be chosen carefully as different people have different
tastes and require special ingredients in their kind of food. It becomes difficult to cater to
their needs every time.
With the incomes of the people rising in Tier2 and Tier 3 cities air connectivity is in
demand for these cities with a good level frequency to as many parts of the word as
possible.
A huge amount of rise in the females travelling by airlines and hence their safety adds to
cost
Now, travelling by planes has become a status symbol for many people.
Technological factors
Growth of ecommerce and e-ticketing system in India with increase in the internet usage
10
11
12
Indigo occupied 38% of the market share in the domestic aviation sector in 2014-15.
There has been a marginal 100 bps increase in market share in H1 2015-16 to 39%. This increase
in market share has been resulted due to capacity addition and route expansion over a period of
time.
International market share has considerably declined to 5% in 2014-15 from 7% in 201314. It remained stable in H1 2015-16 with respect to 2014-15.
Share in the domestic market and international market (based on RPKM- Revenue Passenger
Km)
13
Note: Indigo started its international operations from September 2011. International market
share represents share of international traffic carried by Indian airliners, originating from and
terminating in India. It has been calculated based on international pax- km performed by Indigo
divided by international pax- km performed by all Indian airliners. Source: Indigo RHP
Segmental market share by passenger traffic for top 10 routes in each segment
Note: Top 10 routes by traffic for the above three categories are calculated on the basis of twoway, non-stop, origin-destination traffic for FY2015; Air India includes Alliance Air and Air
India Express, Jet Airways includes JetLite, Others include Air Costa, AirAsia India and Vistara.
Source: Indigo RHP
Operational Performance
Indigos domestic passenger traffic (which form a major portion of overall passenger traffic)
grew by 31% y-o-y to 23.7 mn in 2014-15. The PLF (Passenger Load factor) increased by 310
bps to 79.4% as RPKM (Revenue Passenger Km) growth outpaced capacity (ASKM-Available
Seat Km) growth - 27% increase in RPKMs and 22% growth in ASKMs. However, international
passenger traffic declined by 3% to1.45 mn in FY 2014-15. International PLF marginally
increased by 140 bps to 82.4% in 2014-15.
In H1 2015-16, domestic passenger traffic grew 40% y-o-y. PLF increased sharply by 680 bps to
83% as RPKM grew by 35% while ASKM rose by 24% during the same period. International
passenger traffic grew by 15% in H1 FY16 from H1 FY15. In the same period, PLFs however
declined by 200 bps to 83%.
14
15
Operational snapshot
16
17
age as all its aircraft by leasing for a period of 5-6 years. This way they avoid the D-Check which
is done after 8 years of operation of an airplane. (A D-check may take up to 2 months during
which the aircraft remains out of service.)
Human Resources
1. The human resources for indigo consist of the pilots, cabin crew members and ground staff.
2. No airline can recruit a trainee pilot and directly assign him to fly an airplane carrying around
500 passengers. The labor-force has to be trained and then assigned with tasks to perform after
proper evaluation.
The pay structure of the employees at IndiGo is as follows:
Experienced commanders
Experienced first officers
New Pilots
Cabin crew
Engineering
3-4 lacs pm
2-2.5 lacs pm
1 lac pm
35-50k pm
75-80k pm
Besides the pilots are rewarded for on time arrivals and fuel savings.
Fuel
Aircraft Turbine Fuel is the complementary product for airplane and it constitutes approximately
45% of the production costs.
Domestic fuel taxes can be as high as 30 per cent along with an 8.2 per cent excise duty. As a
result, fuel for Indian airlines accounts for about 45 per cent of total operating costs, compared to
the global average of 30 per cent. Indigo's aircraft try to save fuel by using software to optimize
flight planning for minimum fuel burning routes and altitudes and also by making use of latest
fuel saving technology. Indigo was one of the first airlines to place order for the Airbus A320neo
family which claims to deliver 15% less fuel consumption and 8% lower operating costs. IndiGo
was also among the first airlines to have the aircraft taxi to the terminal with one engine, shutting
down the second engine to save fuel. IndiGo has integrated fuel saving practices in its daily
processes. Their Standard Operating Procedure demands flights to fly with minimum required
fuel. In addition, holding fuel and contingency fuel are kept on bare minimums to avoid the
extra load and costs.
18
Intangible resources
Brand Equity/Reputation
IndiGo is the most reputed low cost carrier due to the following reasons:
1. On time arrivals is the key differentiating factor for IndiGo which sets it apart from its
competitors.
2. IndiGo keeps implementing new and innovative ideas to increase the quality of customer
service. One good example is the roving check-in counters Indigo uses to help passengers with
only cabin baggage to check-in with an IndiGo official with a handheld device, rather than lining
up at the check-in counter. This improves customer experience.
3. It gives the customers the freedom to carry their own eatables and snacks on board.
4. Compared to the direct competitors, that is, the other low cost carriers like SpiceJet,
Jetlite, etc. IndiGo offers the lowest airfare.
Social Capital:
1. IndiGo has amicable relationship with the other organizations that contribute to the value
addition for the service provided to the customers.
2. IndiGo has engaged many Travel web-portals and regional travel agents with incentives like
booking commissions, etc. There have been no instances of distress between IndiGo and its other
collaborators, that is, suppliers.
3. Collaboration with hotels: Mumbai-based hotel chain operator Sarovar Hotels and IndiGo
Airlines announced a marketing tie-up for frequent travelers. The highlights are:
a. The arrangement will allow guests staying at select Sarovar Hotels across 26 destinations in
India to avail a 10 per cent discount on their next travel booking with IndiGo.
b. While IndiGo flyers can avail up to 25 per cent discount on published room tariff, 10 per cent
discount on holiday stay packages and 10 per cent discount on restaurant dining at select Sarovar
properties 8.
Hence IndiGo has a remarkable Social Capital.
Brand Awareness:
IndiGo is a well-known Low Cost Carrier in India. The following points contribute to the brand
awareness of IndiGo:
1. Advertising using print media like newspapers, billboards, etc.
2. It may not pay for an advertisement in a newspaper, but has been covered in news for its low
cost strategy implementation.
19
3. As IndiGo provides better value added services to the customers, Word of Mouth, promotion
also works in its favor.
Employee Relationship:
Good Employee Relationship is a key factor to sustain competitive advantage. IndiGo provides
several incentives to its employees. IndiGo has been seeing a healthy growth in passenger
numbers and it is optimistic about its long term growth. Also, it is planning to expand its
employee strength and at the same time there is no indication of downsizing the current staff. At
a time when several domestic airlines are looking to prune their staff strength, the Delhi-based
low cost airline, IndiGo, has been on the lookout for more pilots, cabin attendants, customer
service and airport service agents
The above facts show that IndiGo has taken a positive approach while dealing with its loyal
employees at the time of economic slowdown.
Sources of Competitive advantage
Low fare flights
Indigo won for the 3rd consecutive time at SKYTRAX World Airline Awards 2012 for being the
best low cost airline of India & Central Asia
Cost efficiency
Indigo has been offering low fare flights and is still able to have good cash flows. This is due to
the cost efficiency capability. They have managed to reduce the costs.
This can be attributed to various strategies adopted:
Operationally it would be impossible to make a profit at the very low fares they were offering
through the first four years of operations, where ticket prices on Indigo were roughly 40 percent
of cost of operation.
20
Even before starting operations in 2006, Indigo had placed a firm order for 100 Airbus A320
aircraft in June 2005, which gave it a pricing advantage. The airline then acquired parking lots in
Delhi and Mumbai, and by the time the first Indigo flight was announced, it had already
scheduled the first 20 aircraft.
Also it focused on inorganic expansion by adding a plane every six weeks.
On-time flights
Passengers all across India rave about Indigos on-time performance, the highest amongst all
airlines at 92.4%. They are always on time and often before time, which is remarkable. The
moment the flight lands an automatic message is triggered from aircraft to control center. Hence,
the on-time performance is diligently monitored for every flight in real time.
Low turnaround time
Turnaround time is the time taken for a plane to be ready for the next flight between landing and
takeoff. IndiGo boasts of a turnaround time of less than 30 minutes. Less time on the ground
means more time in the air which also reduces fuel burning. IndiGo's aircraft spend more than 11
hours a day in the sky, compared to the industry average of eight or 10 hours.
21
Routes:
Indigo operates over a lesser number of destinations than its competitors but with a higher
frequency not comparing Jet's fleet size as it operates more than double flights per day compared
to Indigo.
The network maps show that all Indigo's destinations are connected to at least two cities while
most are connected to 3 or more destinations, whereas this is not the case with Jet Airways. This
means Indigo can keep its aircraft in the air for a longer period of time and save up on airport
charges. Because of this Indigo has a high aircraft utilization rate of more than 11.5 hours per
day per plane. This also means that customers don't have to look for connecting flights with other
competing operators.
Spice Jet destinations also seem to be well connected, but they have a larger presence in Tier 2
and Tier 3 cities (especially in the south) and traffic to and from these cities tends to be seasonal.
22
VRIO Framework
VRIO is the acronym from the first letters of the dimensions - value, rareness, imitability, and
organization. So, the first question that has to be answered is whether a resource is valuable. It is
considered valuable if it can increase market share, achieve cost advantages, or both. Otherwise,
it is not a source of competitive advantage. Once a resource is deemed valuable, the next
question is whether it is rare or that it is not available to all competitors. If it is valuable but not
rare, meaning competitors possess the same resources, the organization has no inherent
advantage in this resource. The resource must also be difficult or costly for competitors to imitate
or acquire. This dimension is called imitability, which can result in a sustained competitive
advantage only if the organization can take advantage of it. Organization is where the resource is
supported by any provisions in the company and that it can be used properly. Otherwise, the
resource or capability is of little use. Thus, a resource that is valuable, rare, costly to imitate, and
the company is organized to capture its value can be a source of sustainable competitive
advantage for an organization.
Resources &
Competencies
Value
Rarity
Imitability
Organization
Low Fares
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Single type of
Aircraft
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Turnaround
Time
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Brand Name
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Value
IndiGo is offering the lowest fares to its customers. The way they do it is through having a single
type of Aircraft which reduce the overall maintenance cost of the Aircraft, since there is only one
kind of Aircraft. It also does Fuel Hedging which reduces the overall cost of fuel.
23
Rarity
IndiGo has the highest market share in the Airline industry and it owes everything to the low fare
tickets it offers to the customers. The low average fleet age, single type of aircraft and the policy
of on time every time is a rarity in the Indian Airline Industry.
Imitability
Even though IndiGo has create much value in the market and amongst its customers, but many of
its strategies like less turnaround time and using single type of Aircraft are imitable and hence, in
long run are not sustainable.
Organization
In the last few years, IndiGo has become the brand name in the Indian Airline Industry. It has
hardly been ten years since its inception and it has created a brand value through unique value
proposition.
However, apart from following a cost leadership strategy, Indigo has also taken steps to
differentiate itself in the highly competitive aviation industry. Indigo has successfully turned
regular business travelers into loyal customers because it never acted like a budget airline. From
the beginning, its purchase of all new aircraft helped it avoid maintenance problems, and
superior planning helped it to match or exceed the on-time performance record of its full-service
competitors. Also even rapid turnaround of its planes is the key differentiating factor and is one
of the major reasons behind the company making money
In a country where other carriers shared passenger-stair vehicles and the top airline still had to
have disabled passengers carried up the staircase to plane height by ground crew, for instance,
Indigo brought in larger, handicapped accessible passenger ramps from day one.
Similarly, the company equipped check-in staff with hand-held scanners that allowed passengers
without baggage to avoid the dreaded scrum at the counter. And at least in the beginning, flight
attendants manning the beverage carts addressed even lowly economy class passengers by name
with the aid of the seating chart.
24
These factors point towards a slight blend of differentiation competitive advantage being sought
by the airline within the broad competitive advantage of being a cost leader.
Weaknesses
1. Scope of product differentiation is less.
2. Benefits of the innovations implemented by
IndiGo to provide better services to the
Customers are short-lived, as these can be
easily imitated by the competitors.
3. IndiGo is not present in domestic air cargo
market.
4. Not present in International market
Threats
1. Rising ATF prices
2. Increasing competition
3. Economic slowdown
4. Poaching
5. Government interference
6. Scarcity of trained pilot
25
IndiGo has an average fleet age of four years and it is making sure that it continues at
least till 2032. It was a preplanned strategy that was made about 10 years back. It had placed a
bulk order of 530 aircrafts which it will be receiving in 2026. This includes 100 Airbus A-320 in
2005, 180 A-320 Neos in 2011 and 250 A-320 Neos in 2015. It can be noticed that the bulk
orders helped negotiating at lower rates. A strategy for cost cutting.
Currently at peak, IndiGo has 330 planes, but once all the planes are delivered it will be
having a fleet of 530 planes and this is due to the buy, sell and lease back strategy. The older
planes will be sold to lessors at market price and the planes are again leased back for the next 6
years, which means for the first six years IndiGo receives a plane every month.
Every month a plane goes out of the IndiGos fleet a new planes joins, reducing the
average fleet age which also reduces the average cost of maintenance. The Neos help IndiGo in
saving 10-15% of overall fuel cost and as we know that that he fuel costs more than 50% of the
carriers cost.
Due to the six years lease back plan, one-third of IndiGos fleet would be Neos within the
next two-and-half years. This will have a strong positive impact of about 7% on the companys
bottom line. As the IndoGo officials say, other airlines can copy their food, advertising and other
things but they cannot replicate the fleet IndiGo has.
Along with its current order of planes, IndiGo is planning to increase its presence in the
number of cities it flies to, increasing the number by two or three every year. It has planned to be
established in 56 cities compared to 33 now. It neither does have any plans on regional flying nor
buying smaller planes. And nobody currently has been able to implement a two model strategy.
We can see that such strategy which mainly focuses on the future planning and growth is really
helping IndiGo get an extra edge over its competitors.
26
References
http://www.india-aviation.in/pages/view/38/an_overview.html
http://www.ibef.org/industry/indian-aviation.aspx
http://www.makeinindia.com/sector/aviation
https://www.quora.com/Airlines-in-India/How-is-Indigo-different-from-other-airlines-and-howhas-it-been-able-to-churn-profits