Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
30th May
,2014
oFqtcE MEMORANpU{Vl
Subject:-
titled
s.s.
of HP and ors, cwP(T) No. 2960 of 200g tifled sanrvan Kumar and ors. Vs
state of HP and ors.and. cwp(T) No,7047l09 tifled satya par sharma and
ors.
Vs state of HP and ors. And cwp(T) No.gltgtzoog tifled Rajinder Kumarvs
state of HP & ors. Two petitions of Ashok sharma and Bikram singh Mehta
were decided during the year 200g by the. Hon,ble single judge. Against
the
decision rendered in case of Qh. Bikram singh Mehta, LpA No.65
of 200g was
filed by sh. Nathu Ram sharma, which was clubbed with the cwp
No.135g of
2008 titled as S.S' Kutlehria and Ors Vs State of HP before the Ld.
Division
Bench. Ultimately these cases were decided through a common judgment
by the
Division Bench of Hon'ble High court on 0g.01 .zo1o, tn comptiance
to gre ,lor"
directions, the review
and
Kumar soni
orders dated
29'3'2014 direct the respondent Department to re-draw the seniority
of Assistant
Engineers (Civil).
(Civil) and
service for their promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer
eceipt of recommejndations of the review DPCs held on
the promotion orders were issued vide this department's Notification
'
20.05.2014,
the Law
for the vacancies of the year 1994, 1995 and 1996, the opinion of
proceedings as under:Department was obtained which was incorporated in the
,*ExaminedintheLawDepartment.Recruitmentand
adoptedReCruitmentandPromotionRulesbythelPH
DePartment.
KeepinginviewtheadviceoftheLawDepartmentaswell
No'1302 of 2005 titled
as the decision of the Hon'ble High Court passed in CWP
posts which
s.K. Kapooi & ors. vs state of HP & Ors. on 18.3.2010, these 7
the year 1999' were
were filled up in the review bpC of 2010 for the vacancies of
not included in the review DPC held on 20'5'2014'
qr.rota
Vs State of HP. However, it is further clarified here that in the above mentioned
judgment, the Hon'ble High Court has catgorically stated to fill these posts as
per R&P rules. The relevant portion is re-produced as-under:-
;HH[1"t'",[',i1""1?'1,,,'130,r"r"9:f#"#::
it was administratively
of direct
recruitment given to the Graduate/AMIE Junior Engineers in the review DPC held
on 2gh June, 2011 may not be taken into account now as the relaxation which
was given earlier in the year 1998 was only for one time and that too by name
and the persons to whom relaxation was given, have already been placed prior to
the year 1'998 as per the recommendations of the review DPC held in the year
2010 while applying S.S. Kutleharia's judgment passed by the'Hon'ble High
Court. Accordingly, these 11 posts weie not included in the review DPC meeting
held on 20.5.2014.
to
objections/representations, if any within ten days from the date of issue of this
no
BY ORDER
VINEET CHAWDHRY
Add. Chief Secretary (lPH) to the
'
Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
No.lPH-A(8)8-312014-
300 spare copies for further distribution amongst the concerned officer's.
2. Allthe Chief Engineers, IPH Department in Himachal Pradesh
3. AIlthe superintending Engineers, IPH Department in Himachal Pradesh
Sr.
No.
Qualification
DOB
An
Direct
recruitees
or
nromotee
of
Apptt./
Date
Promotion
S/Sh.
Harinder Bhardwaj/
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Civil)
P.S. Dhanotia/
15.01.1961
Sarwan Kumar/
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Civil)
Joginder
Singh
08.03.1967
Chauhan/
Suresh Kumar/
B.E.(Civil)
ME (WRD)
B.E.(Civil)
24.lt.t966
7
Subhash
Vljay Kumar/
Chairder/
B.E. (Civil)
Upender
B.E. (Civil)
Anil Mehta/
11
12
31.10.1970
Surinder Kumar/
15.04.1958
Hemant
3t.t2.1996
-do-
Promotee
Direct
24.08.1996
Working
asEE-
24.08.1996
24.A8.t996
-do-
-do-
-do-
-do-
Ree.
-do-
-do-
Res.
BE(Civil),
31.t2.t996
Promotee
Res.
Kumar/
B.E. (Civil)
24.08.t996
Direct
B.E. (Civil)
15
29.:r1.1972
Dubey/
B.E. (Civil)
Rohit
24.08.1996
Working
as EE
Res.
Deepak Gxgl
-do-
-do-
-do-
-do-do-
Reg.
24.A8.1996
Res.
07.a2J972
Mukesh Kumar Hira/
26.t0.1972
Deepak Aggarwal/
18.08.1964
Keshav Ram/
14.01.1965
B.E. (Civil)
24.08.1996
-do-
B.E.(Civil)
Res.
31.12.1996Reg
Promotee
B.E. (Civil)
24.08.t996
Direct
Sardeep
Singh
Kaushal/12.07.1963
Singh/
Bheem
t5.11.1967
21
Vinod Kumltr
Thakurl
B.E. (Civil)
2A
04.r2.t968
Preet Mohinder Singh /
B.E. (Civil)
Working
as EE
Res.
B.E. (Civil)
0s.04.1960
Direct.
24.08.1996
B.E. (Civil)
t4
20
Working
as EE
Res.
24.08.1996
26.02.1972
19
Direct.
24.08.1996
B.E, (Civil)
20.02.1969
18
-do-
31.12.1995
Res.
0l.01.1968
T7
-do-
3t.t2.1995
Ree.
Vaidya/
10
r6
-do-
Reg.
B.E. (Civil)
02.Q2.1967
t3
3t.t2.t995
Res.
25.06.1962
as EE
Res.
25.06.1962
Working
Ree.
25.12.1961
Remarks
Reg.
Anil Manuja/
Promotee
Res.
30.06.1 960
2
3t.t2.1994
Year of
vacancy
-do-
-do-
-do-
-do-
24.08.1996
Ree
Direct.
-do-
31.12.199:6
Promotee
24.08.1996
Res.
B.E. (Civil)
24.08.1996
Reg.
Res.
Working
as EE
23
AMIE
09.11.1946
3t.12.1997
-do-
Reg.'
Since
retired
as
EE
24
Anil Kumar/
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.1997
Reg.
-do-
AMIE
21.12.1997
Reg.
-do-
B.E. (Civil)
3t.12.1997
-do-
Kaushal/
AMIE
Res.
31.12.1997
Res.
-do-
Swaroop/
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.t997
-do-
01.12.19s6
25
Ravinder Singtl
31.01.1957
26
27
Madan
Lal
04.08.1958
28
Anand
15.12.1962
29
AMIE
Karam Chand/
B.E. (Civil)
Bhajan
LaU
AMIE
B.E. (Civil)
13.11.1961
AMIE
20.05.1961
35
01.05.1963
Puran Chand (SC)/
16.06.1958
B.E. (Civil)
AMIE
B.E. (Civil)
Bhim Singh/
.do.
31.12.1997
Res.
-do-
31.12.t997
-do-
(SC)
Kartar Singh
40
Paras Ram
-do-
31.t2.r997
-do-
31.t2.t997
-do-
Deleted and shown at Sr. No. 79-A as per the instructions issued by
the D.O.P. vide letter No. PER(AP),C-F(1)-1/9S dated 27.05.1996.
AMIE
24.t0.1956
39
31.12.1997
Res.
Raj Kumar/
31.12.t998
Promotee
Reg.
Rana/
B.E. (Civil)
28.12.1959
31.12.1998
Working
as EE
-do-
Reg.
Chauhan/
AMIE
17.06.1958
31.12.1998
-do-
Reg.
42
43
06.04.1960
Pyush Dogra/
44
Surinder
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.1998
-do-
Res.
09.0s.1967
15.07.1955
31.r2.1997
Ree.
t5.05.t967
4t
-do-
Ree.
30.04.1962
38
31.12.t997
Working
as EE
Res.
va
34
37
-do-
Ree.
Satya PaU
36
31.12,t997
Res.
16.1 1;1958
JJ
as EE
Res.
26.01.1959
31
Working
Reg.
02.03.t959
30
-do-
Res.
Singh/
AMIE
31.12.1999
Res.
-do'
Working
as EE
44-
06.04.1960
45
Kartar Singh
Bhatia/
AMIE
31.12.1998
Res.
-do-
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.t999
-do-
AMIE
.do-
(D/man)
Res.
13.04.1999
Res.
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.t999
-do-
10.04.1965
46
Inder Singh
47
09.12.1959
Ranjeet Singh/
48
11.09.1966
Partap Singh/ 1 0.03. 1 957
Verma/
Ree.
AMIE
-do-
3t.12.2000
B.E. (Civil)
49
Arvind Sood/
50
Pritam Chand
15.03.1967
Res.
Daroch
3r.r2.2Q00
B.E. (Civil)
Res.
31.12.20A0
Res.
Vikas Bakshi/
-do-
t7.03.2001
Direct
24.09.t967
52
-do-
31.12.2000
AMIE
(scv10.10.195s
51
Working
as EE
Ree.
Capt Amit
Dogra/
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.1975 (Ex-Man)
Promotee
Working
as EE
Given
benefit of
Reg.
05
years
approved
military
service
53
54
55
56
AMIE
B.E. (Civil)
58.
59
60
3r.t2.2001
Promotee
-do-
Res.
(scy
AMIE
31.t2200t
-do-
Ree.
B.E. (Civil)
31.12.2001
-do-
AMIE
Res.'
31.t2.2001
-do.
t2.09.t965
57
3t.t2.200t
Res.
Sunder LaU
20.05.19s 1
B.E. (Civil)
Since
retired
Res.
3t.12.2001
-do-
Reg.
01.06.1967
Sanjeev Kumar/
B.E.
(Civil)
ME
24.06.1974
Jagdish Chand/
09.02.19s2
03.0s.2002
Direct
Ree.
AMIE
3r.12.2002
Reg.
Promotee
Since
retired
'
EE
61
Vishal Jaswal/
62
Ms. Hina
BE (Civil)
2r.02.1977
Sabarbal/
ME Structure
B.E. (Civil)
M.Tech
(Env. Enss.)
Vikas Kapur/
14.03.t969
64
Nare'sh
20.t2.197t
Direct.
Ree.
31.12.2002
Promotee
Reg.
.05.08.1967
63
03.0s.2002
Dhiman/
B.E. (Civil)
03.05.2002
Direct.
Res.
03.05.2002
Res.
Direct.
as
65
Ram Chand
66
15.03.1958
Rajesh Chand Kashyap
102.08.1972
67
Katoch/ AMIE
31.12.2002
B.Tech (Civil
03.05.2002
Engg.)PGDM
Reg.
M &MBA
B.E. (Civil)
Anil Kumar/
3r.12.2002
Rajesh
Mongra/ B.Tech.
70
03.05,2002
(Civil)ME
Irrigation &
13.tt.t973
69
Direct.
Promotee
Res.
12.01.1968
68
Promotee
Reg.
Direct
Reg.
Hydraulics
B.Tech
03.0s.2002
(Civil) M.E.
M.Tech
(Civil)
M.E.
-do-
Res.
29.12.2002
Direct
Reg.
(Structure)
7t
BE
18.09.1969
ME
(Civil)
17.09.2002
-do-
Reg.
(Structure)
72
AMIE
tt.09.2002
28.07.1968
73
74
-do-
Res.
"B.E. (Civil)
tt.09.2002
-do-
Reg.
B.Tech.(Civil)
,
M.B.A.
04.03.2005
Reg.
-do-
Direct
(SC)
ward
Exservice-
of
Man
against
General
Ex-Service
man
75
76
AMIE
Sanjeev Kumar/
01.01.1957
Sumit Sood/
3t.t2.2005
Promotee
as EE
Ree.
B.E.(Civil)
28.tt.t970
04.03.2005
Reg.
Working
Direct
General
ward .of
ExServicem
an
77
Rajesh Kumar/
25.08.1968
78
Rakesh
24.02.t974
B.E. (Civil)
Rana/
Degree
in
Building
31.12.20As
Ree.
10.03.200s
Reg.
Promotee
Direct
General
ward of
Ex-
Quantity
Surveying
Servicem
an
79
Hemant
02.tt.1969
Puri/
B.E. (CiniD
31.r2.2005
Res.
Promotee
z--'-
79-
Raj Kumar/(SC)
15.05.1967
Sushil Chand Katoch/
80
B.E.(Civil)
31.12.t997
Promotee
Res.
AMIE
07.03.2005
Reg.
01.04.t970
Direct
General
ward of
ExServicem
an
8l
B.E.(Civil)
82
3t.12.200s
Promotee
(Res.)
06.1 1.1968
Sanjay Kumar/
05.08.1975
B.Tech.
(Civil)
03.03.2005
Reg.
Direct
General
ward of
ExServicerii
an
83
84
Mandeep Kumar/
10.01.1969
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Civil)
31.12.200s
Promotee
Reg.
12.09.1969
3t.12.2005
Promotee
Res.
B.E.(Civil)
85
Rajinder Singh/
86
t4.tt.1970
Ravinder Kumar (SC)/
31.12.2005
Promotee
Reg.
Deleted and shown at Sr. No. 116-A as per the instructions issued
13.01.1973
dated
27.0s.1996.
87
Deleted and shown at Sr. No. 116-B as per the instructions issued
PER(AP)-C-F(1)-1l95, dated
27.05.t996.
88
Deleted and shown at Sr. No. 119-A as per the instructions issued
dated
27.05.1996.
89
issued
dated
27.05.1996.
90
Rakesh
Chand
Thakur/
91
(sT)16.0s.1976
Anil Kumar/
08.i 1.1980
by the
27.05.1996.
B.Tech.
t7.03.2046
(Civil )
Reg.
Direct
M.E.(Env.
Ensineerine)
92
93
t2.06.1954
Ravinder Kumar/
02.02.t978
AMIE
31.12.2006
Promotee
B.Tech
17.03.2006
(Civil)
Reg.
M.E. (Env.
Engineering)
Working
as EE
Res.
"
Direct.
94
95
B.E.(Civil)
Mohd. Arshad/
26.08.1966
Arun Kumar
Sharma/
B.E. (Civil)
08.04.1968
96
Hira Lal
Sharma/
20.l.t9s7
97
98
AMIE
100
101
t02
103
104
105
Promotee
Hoshiar Singh(SC)/
ME
09.1 1.1969
Hiehways)
(Civil
ME (Civil)
Sarwan Kumar/
17.03.2Q06
Res.
Direct.
31.12.2006
Promotee
Res.
(oBC)10.04.1970
99
3t.t2.2006
'Res.
17.03.2006
17.43.2006
Dipct
Reg.
Sanjeev Vohral
AMIE
t7.03.2006
30.12.19i2
M.Tech
(Env Enss.)
Reg.
PyareLaU20.03.1958
Direct.
Res.
AMIE
31.12.2006
Direct.
Promotee
Reg.
Satish
Kumar
B.Tech
17.03.2006
Sharma/07.12.1975
(Civil)
Reg.
Sanjay Kaushal/
B.Tech
17.03.2006
24.04.t980
(Civil)
AMIE
Res.
Narota Ram
alias
Neeraj Kumar (SC)/
10.04.1960
31.12.2006
Direct.
Direct.
Promotee
Reg.
AMIE-
t7.03.2006
Direct
Res.
B.Tech
17.03.2006.
(Civil)
ME
Reg.
Direct
(Structure)
106
r07
Mrs. Lalita
Kumari
$cY26.12.t9i82
Ajeet Kumar (ST)/
20.08.1981
108
Sandeep
109
(oBO/10.07.1971
Ashwani Kumar (SC)/
110
l1t
Chaudhary
15.07.1971
Ashish Rana (SC)/
01.04.1982
Mrs. Kanchan Sharma/
M.Tech.
ME (Pursins)
B.Tech (Civil
Ensineerins)
B.E. (Civil)
113
17.03.2006
1-
Direct.
Res.
17.03.2006
Direct.
ME
(Hishwav)
ME
(Hishwav)
AMIE
17.03.2006
Direct
Ree.
17.03.2006
Direct
Res.
17.03.2006
Direct.
Reg.
Physically
Handicapp
ed
Raj
AMIE
Promotee
3t.12.2008
Working
as EE
-do-
Ree.
Sharma/
B.E. (Civil)
29.06.1969
Ravinder
3r.t2.2008
Res.
B.E.(Civil)
Sudhir Gupta/
t6.03.1967
tt4 Lekh
115
Direct.
Ree.
21.06.t970
tt2
17.03.2006
Reg.
13.12.2008
.do.
Ree.
Kumar
Sharma/ 30.05.1957
AMIE
31.12.2008
Res.
10
Promotee
Working
as EE
116
Jeevan
Prakash/
B.E.(Civil)
03.02.1966
1t7
17.10.1966
Ramesh Chand/
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Civil)
AMIE
Anup Kumar/
B.E.(Civil)
119
22.t0.1970
Mrs. Staya Devii
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Civil)
09.08.1968
,do.
31.12.2008
.do.
31.12.2008
Working
as EE
.do.
3r.12.2008
.do.
31.12.2005
.do.
Res-
Rajinder
121
Sharma/ 09.03.1960
Rahul Abrol/
Kumar
AMIE
3t.t2.2008
.do.
Reg.
B.E.(Civil)
03.10.1970
tzt- VipinKumar
31.12.200s
(Res.)
Res.
120
.do.
Reg.
06.09.1969
19-
31.12.2005
Ree.
118
.do.
Ree.
09.01.1957
31.12.2008
Res.
3t.12.2008
.do.
Reg,
(SC)/
122
17.01.1974
Om Prakash (SC)/
123
27.tt.1966
Dev Raj 123.01.1974
B.E.(Civil)
31.12.200s
.do.
Req.
AMIE
31.12.2008
.do.
Ree.
B.E.(Civil)
3t.t2.2008
.do.
Res.
124
B.E.(Civil)
21.04.1970
124-
Rakesh
Thakur/
3t.t2.2008 .
.do.
Reg.
Chand
B.E.(Civil)
31.12.2005
.do.
Reg.
(sT)16.05.1976
t2s
t26
23.12.t961
Pardeep Kumar/
rt.04.1967
t27
AMIE
129
B.E.(Civi1)
3t.12.2008
Promotee
Res.
AMIE
3t.12.2008
Promotee
Parveen Kumar/
18.07,1966
B.E.(Civil)
Bodhbardhar/
B.E.(Civil)
31.r2.2008
Promotee
AMIE
Res.
3 I . 12.2008
Promotee
196s
Sanjeev
K*u{
Jagbir Singhl
t32
02.08.1967
Sanjay Kumar/
i33
25.03.1970
Basant Singh/
30.09.1968
Promotee
Reg.
Kapoor/
i5.01.1963.
131
31.t2.2008
Working
as EE
Res.
3 I .03.
130
Promotee
Ree.
25.11.1956
128
31.t2.2008
B.E.(Civil)
AMIE
3t.t2.2008
Promotee
B.E.(Civil)
Res.
31.12.2008
Promotee
Reg.
il
Working
as EE
Reg.
B.E;(Civil)
31.t2.2008
Surinder Kumar/
27.t0.1960
31.12.2008