Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
This paper investigates the dynamic behaviour of cable-supported glazing facades subjected to medium-level air blast
loads. Preliminary numerical studies are carried-out in SAP2000 by means of a geometrically refined and simplified
lumped-mass finite-element numerical model, in order to assess the major effects of the design blast load in the main
facade components. As shown, both the glass panels and the cable system are able to properly accommodate the
incoming impulsive loads, typically involving extreme deflections and high tensile stresses. In order to mitigate the
effects of blast pressures on the glazing system, an innovative and particularly efficient active control system is
proposed. The control system implemented in the glazed cable facade is based on a proportional-integral-derivative
(PID) control algorithm, in which the control variable is the tension in the cables.
Notation
A
c
D
d
E
f
h
Kcr
k
l
m
P0
Pcr
Ps0
P s0
p
pt
p
R
T
T0
t
tA
td
u
area (m2)
damping coefficient (N s/m)
released energy (J)
distance (m)
modulus of elasticity (Pa)
frequency (Hz)
height (m)
critical gain
stiffness (N/m)
length (m)
mass (kg)
ambient pressure (Pa)
critical period (s)
maximum overpressure peak (Pa)
maximum underpressure peak (Pa)
blast pressure (Pa)
external force in the glass pane (Pa)
external torque in the glass pane (Pa)
radial distance (m); restoring force (N)
force in a cable (N)
initial force in a cable (N)
time (s)
blast arrival time (s)
decay time from the maximum overpressure peak to
the ambient pressure (s)
displacement (m)
Poisson ratio
density (kg/m3)
damping ratio
1.
Introduction
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
223
2.
Cable
120 m
3.
pt Ps0 1
t
t
exp
td tA
td tA
where tA is the arrival time and Ps0 is the maximum overpressure peak. A medium-high level of protection, requiring
costly security measures and conforming to the GSA Security
Criteria (GSA, 1997), was implemented in the examined
facade (level C of the GSA criteria). The blast wave pressure
instantaneously reaches its maximum value (static overpressure
peak Ps0 = 276 kPa) and decays to an ambient level after time
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
= 374 kPa
Ps0
td tA = 002 s
Ps0
T0
Positive impulse
u1(t)
m1
Negative impulse
P0
Ps0
tA
tA + td
u4(t)
m4
u3(t)
m3
4.
u2(t)
m2
u5(t)
m5
T0
(a)
(b)
Based on the elastic catenary formulation to represent the behaviour of slender cables under self-weight, temperature and
strain loading, the cable elements were able to accurately reproduce the non-linear behaviour of the cable net, as well as to
include tension-stiffening and large-deflection effects inherently. The structural interaction between the cables and the
glass panels were simulated by pinned connections.
Model 2 (Figure 3(b)) is a simplified two-dimensional representation in which the glass panes have been taken into
account in the form of equivalent lumped masses mi.
The first five modal shapes and corresponding frequencies of
the facade, as a result of a modal analysis of model 1, are presented in Figure 4. It can readily be observed that, for higherorder modes, as the curvature of the glass panes increases, the
modal shape associated with the cables diverges from that of
the glass panes. The same results, obtained with model 2, are
depicted in Figure 5.
Comparing the outputs of the two modal analyses, one can
see that, as expected, when the overall stiffness (bending and
membrane) of the glass panes is neglected (model 2), the
natural frequencies of the structure decrease. Nevertheless,
the errors associated with this simplification are limited to the
range 3376% for the considered modes. Further dynamic
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
225
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
226
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
(e)
The effect of a local blast (level C of the GSA criteria), situated at ground zero at a stand-off distance of 7 m from the
facade, was analysed next. The corresponding load profile, p(z),
is illustrated in Figure 6. For model 1, the blast load profile is
considered to be constant within the width of the analysed
facade.
5.
5.1 Introduction
A glazed cable facade subjected to a blast wave is a dynamic
system with highly non-linear characteristics. According to
Figure 8, the force Ti in the tensioned cable, produced by
a horizontal displacement ui, of one considered degree of
freedom, can be expressed by (Timoshenko, 1937)
The corresponding dynamic response, in terms of the horizontal displacement of the facade at mid-height and the tension in
the cable system, is shown in Figure 7.
Ti T0 EA
2:
q
l 2 u2i l 2
l
T0
EA 2
u
2l 2 i
where T0 is the initial tensile force in the wire, ui is a small displacement of the mass mi, in the horizontal direction, l is the
length of a cable segment, A is the cross-section of the cable
and E is its modulus of elasticity. In Equation 2, the unit
elongation of the cable due to a displacement ui is approximated by the first term of its Taylor expansion.
The restoring force acting on the mass mi yields readily, so
T0
3:
EA 2
2ui
2T0
EA
q
u
ui 3 u3i
2l 2 i
l
l
2
2
l ui
Blast wave
T0 + T
T0
u1 (t)
u2 (t)
Ri
z
u3 (t)
u4 (t)
Explosion
u5 (t)
h
d
p (z)
T0
T0 + T
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
227
005
005
u: m
010
u: m
010
005
005
010
010
0
325
325
320
320
315
310
305
305
0
3
t: s
3
t: s
(b)
300
3
t: s
315
310
300
0
330
F: kN
F: kN
330
3
t: s
(a)
(c)
(d)
mi u i cui Ri pi
i 1; N
u1 un u 1 u n 0
Ri
T0
EA
ui1 2ui ui1 3 u3i1 2u3i u3i1
2l
l
m 2 1
Ri
pt =2 p =l
u i
Ri1
pt =2 p =l
6 1 2 u i1
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
The stresses in the glass panes were calculated for the corresponding loading, using an auxiliary FE model of the
glass pane, as shown in Figure 9(c). This model was used to
determine the stresses generated by a generic trapezoidal
loading.
that, for the considered design scenario, the proposed simplification for the dynamic analysis of a glazed cable facade subjected
to a blast loading is adequate.
EA
T0
mi1
T0
u
l i
l
mi
ui
T0
u
l i
EA
mi+1
T0
ki
pi
ui
l/2
p
pt
l/2
m
ui+ 1
ki + 1
(a)
pi + 1
(b)
(c)
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
229
010
010
005
005
u: m
u: m
005
005
010
010
0
3
t: s
(a)
3
t: s
(b)
330
010
320
310
F: kN
u: m
005
0
300
290
005
280
010
0
3
t: s
(c)
270
3
t: s
(d)
330
300
320
F: kN
F: kN
310
300
250
200
290
280
150
270
3
t: s
(e)
3
t: s
(f)
(f) Cable force (controlled, TI = 150 kN). (g) Glass stress (free).
(h) Glass stress (controlled, T0 = 300 kN). (i) Glass stress (controlled,
TI = 150 kN) (continued on next page)
Figures 10(a) and 10(c), it can be seen that the horizontal displacements of the facade remain essentially unaltered by the
control system, since the length variation of the cables associated with the control action is limited to a maximum of 4 mm.
230
Analysing the above results, it can be concluded that the proposed active glazed cable facade is able to successfully
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
80
80
60
60
40
40
20
20
: MPa
: MPa
20
20
40
40
60
80
3
t: s
(g)
60
3
t: s
(h)
60
40
: MPa
20
0
20
40
60
3
t: s
(i)
&
6.
Conclusions
&
&
REFERENCES
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
231
Downloaded by [ UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA] on [14/11/16]. Copyright ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.