DRAFT

AIAA 20020000
LES SUBGRID-SCALE MODELS OF
TURBULENCE-CHEMICAL KINETICS
INTERACTIONS BASED ON
DISCRETE DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS
J. M. McDonough & Sha Zhang
Department of Mechanical Engineering
University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40506-0108

32nd AIAA Fluid Dynamics

Conference
June 2427, 2002/St. Louis, Missouri
For permission to copy or republish, contact the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
1801 Alexander Bell Drive, Suite 500, Reston, VA 201914344


   
     

  
   

  
   
 

  
 
  
    
  
     

 
 


       
 
"!
$
%
#
$
!
'
#
)
&

(
,
*
+
/
*
.
/
0
1
4
2
6
3
7
5
9
1
;
8
<
:
9
1
,
8
"
+
0
\]H9R[^,>IB`=_IR[>@Cb?"acA,JMBDLCFEGde>I>IH9H9CKCFfgJML OPhiN%akj4>POPl]Q">nA,m/H9R[HZRSOTY,A,CMJiUWH"VXjoHZd'Y,R[prH<>Pq<>IBDs,R[tZHZsvY uiwTs,xZszy
D~k~k{}SDTb|Kk|Tb~kDb`@|T@|`P))oXWI)-DF||nG|DD~k`;~kDS|nD@DkbM@S|MSb||n)b)))`)II@K)@@/FIM]<I@|K)[b|`)|)|T))|T)@|XDD9|Tk)Di|nkXS|Tn)P@||T@Xb ,|T)K|@II)I)|n@|M)F
|T@D)b|TS@)bD|TIoDDbISS DS@|S|D@)@`@|T@~)IDkSISX|b|TS)S){}|b@`|K@k-`4XS|n)@@}IkXbK)<|`Io)@I}@`|
k9D~k~k[SDDD@~k~kS~I|n~k@@K`SS|T$-){})|Xb~kbX|TD|`,P~k|SS|T|nDDSX~)`S|nIS$kT`Ig@|bbX))~|I)b@I|P]|DI|`SDD]||Tb|n|
S |I|K|T|)S)|nZ|TSSvkb4b@b|T~XI`SD|n|T@)M` |n-)X||nk|nF@~bI|kkSI|)S I$X-~|T )|9g MDkW)||nnX/D)4])I|TW)"|TvX)D|TXS)|n"S)SDk`bT||KISb|T|n)F@~i@|D)~b`@|@)bD|
~kS||n)|`P]IFb`X@|oI|K|n`b|T)S|n@D"~)@D@|F~)Dg)b]MKD|n7~i|n|@DX`D|`|nP@SkIi)X`|TS) `@)M )M,Dkz$|
Wk,$
oFnIS- SiPT Z6
"bD '" 

nKkFbS;bXI"SSDbiTPSIzF;bnSDIizDzPInkSFMSDDbnT I MIK@SknbDGIzP<PbIzIb)Sn bbnGDbiMISnnFnDIi4UkZbi&b

<FDbiDbIn9<IKk]niP<IbibozSDDKPbnbDKDSbM)obSK,IbSIkiMMDZ9bb zSn)KnIknibTDIbFinMbbTbFn)KI9SPIST4v i#iD" K

SzII SnIbnIIz
DiX IWkbMD,TbISibiDiFkiDIbZIMiiFDbIkibikMMTSnbbn b
ZnV3DGC IIGVzWG}MknIbbIiIkIY nXTKZ[F.zbSPI]kDz
zkiTMKT,"InnSSDbIbI-Kkb4P)SI]IiD-kDMiniDMbIiIinSM bT`IT9nII^kbZi6b]
)\c-IDKMzbiI)ni WgS)IIko]IK@SSnbDk<S)Ii
iiSI`IbIz"ISSSSiPSn-MIibSiibS`PDi`DI<znI}gbIP iIKbKz` ,,FDDXSbbTMIa \cC _nIb,$nMPWDnInn-Sni;PIZ&
TeSb
KSInISDe)I-bISnKKIWSkISISbTbMk}FbSbTbMnP bnbKISkMTSnb]@bibnD.iP]K^[PIiTIFSDiISnZzIIbibbG c^n,z
bDiS nDZbSi<bSIIi IWIiiIv7ITii
SS)  ScSPD)  )ISP DXSb,4Fbi)I[bbSnMDKd 
Ve8a\
IK)PnIFz]`IIW}DIiiA,I
bDiDMnkDiDzISiDST)nb4KS
)kDoMbobSSSKzMiDSIXS`nbkS 7Mn _niFTb fI}nbzMkiknMbDni<,XniIKKSIbSnbbTFST]D n
  Dk bTM@I SF)ToKDSKnDM4biF)iiDDSbIM ibSb
}@ , } nFbzikIT  zn[iKb IIbSTnbSKbiD,]DKSn<i kTbb,FKiD
k- g,nbn]ISIbbIS)SIKkkiXSiP]I
z`IIbnSMMIIinnFknb`TF)n< P
SXb i$IFnX! %Z&#)
"@b'
cbKIKISIS(nKnFDXbzSD ib nbb  ,i.iP]ZIbiS4)SinMTb)b3SnhPSnI4IShi:jlki mIbIIiSIkbIT-IMMbX
DMSKKiIF)b*I)+4Ib<zTM-,zD<KbkiknnbKDIiDMKiD/.zDKnbneWFzIk iS)Fbnk! ib.i4P]]i)n FT3 GI SIbniIo  DikDniih pG  ,ziXSPoFDk
kDKbIIiiXIIbKnISK8 Fn;  MF: S940 Ii21&34SM15nebnIiMT6 <b7nbnK* Mb@i )i bDIin"PPSS"bbzzDDXbGcni9PFSSPiSnF b 9IKi) 9  iSbK$SbIKKPkDkS
b

;=<*>?A@CBD2D?E>FGD2BHJI+?E>:KLBK&MNB> OQPORO6S
bTkibnKiiDSFnbbkkbniSMDFbi8DS,iTI,ib Inb-bqkTF4PXTzPbTSMIbKTSDTKI SIbK
FIi` ,znDbSkzbeb,SKbbTI4
e8

r
sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

Kz)SnIrDzFSiDbbSnMni Dibi<nPDbiDD<S}9Kbkkz)k<F
bIiK7",MIS<SnIMTMb.zSIMi)7bI zSMSb}SnzMMSbWn4bIiI4IInbIbnISZ07"nIz"IDKSniJbI\@
bk znISbDzbT@47nDi,b$S)nbI<InT44FZkKSnIii77DD* k76z
wD`i-]b 
bFiin iDbSSIn"MScoPSz,FF)IIWKIkPkbSg]ISPn SbDTbSInFZI PIcoiiSIb iSzDbFG ITcvivIDbb}IcinbS n
zDi4SikinbSzTMFISnbzSTnISI kDLSI
e89)
K]k)kn 9bS3kkG inIi IV  MI

9}
8qb
ibiDS: 7 6
CIIobkn$TMbIiK,bbSbnIb-D,[SiDkn}9]i`DIbbWDIivbTh
   ] %  
qV  
bk-Ig,[Tnbn6SczI/]o 9} nIIkb,IPoibInKDiPbDz5Sk Ib}ITWMbbIzP7  SnbD VGzEX nSkIM
bDSDibnbiDFSb=X I SbT*@NSW IMbDIKbXSkSSnKn) kbb Fb-n_S i@
bk)iDK)nD
V!e8h
=jNKk hYk k k-jN b i; e ),SKDSInb}hinnjlk nS bIbI II
bnPbITDnM=nI n)bbnIibDXn] S3 nIbnnnbDFnKDnSTDM I4 Pe =S_IMIM i _h o_ <Fzi]nIiLejlGk SGzE
KFiIISPeIn,n)SKkkinTV bIIibnDDibi)kSk-,g nbn/S ITvbiPF
DWS  nbIFnnKo kkS8Z343 4 nDIo S<1 DDi);IMD W
$Gi$ igDhbi5SjNWk IfJkM b WIMb SkFbb]TP
bo IS<KDIISbPw kLkb nFbki,c S9}$M RP [ D SIM o bIii-I7nDbSnoDbbT4bk
DbIIiS"XbiDXZISnbKSnP4IT } be kS-,g ^nbb nDzFbTkDSg-T_ PPDbIGz
3 Ih TIIicIMKhzi/jlk m I ) I [ cbSnSFMi)DbInIMibII

M4bSIPSIiz"WSnibPoIS$nMkIz@SFSiD9$S))kFbn-,nPSbS
IiFb`Ii}ISXD<KPInb Kkk
.iiMbiDbGbK,PSb[iknnvoSebTMnS)
)iISbIbzSPD@Dp & .iizk@bzPPSnb]IbzID-i,zIbFko-g/D7SbinSSI,iMF,<IbnF
bkiMI4DbTSivk-nDbi)I& ik.ibPn4So-KW3}nh  I i DbnISPDi]}kiTIb-nbkD bKnKnDIKbIPPS
bbk SIMSPMbSk)iI}KcznPDbibIkzS L %
= $kSnkbT@b
bM4
kMi@z}bMzIbD)g/FIbinSIeMi `M4bbibKMIkvPSDnIMSbTIIIeu4[SDi<knMSnIvKkiSkPbSMn i9lID
<<bPKbiD< a U
o[ SiDIbDV gknbIT

Db/ DZSSobn`KzSI
),b,nz8`IW
/I+ibGcSiIDTbKIiISInbokGciiP
bbiIDi$nu 7TDb$bnIbXKzbPl b$IDz-D/h ibjlTkF  iT`I
k$SnnDMKn,b]XibbnPb
bIkSSDikTzMMbSKIDnSS4)l \ ,iMoSDnbIkiiISD,i bZ&Sn
[
Me8k,
KSKkkn7D
[b<Snb7<I=<$)IibPSgIbWIMbI
b TkiDMn)# 9}Yg)IiIbk $n bVI kk XnFkIkIFibiKni biSbK iIKgFSITicFbbzIP PWSGSb,FiIKbb,TM
biPS`' )b.iiSiMbbDikWkDbbiIni8 W)T
/FS, n[TiWDkbkIbinMWiIIbbKn/P<S)XkiFgIIgib}KbPSnnKISzFinbPF
SiPSbTF,IzISbT@SSiDiInoeInk
.iiMbiDbIinDibnMk4SDbb`DIT
zInSDKbSTIM[ 7iDFS<SIKTI7SIbz7TbMnbKbo`InISIMbIKIeDDSzbb
D9SXbIISDS @bbzITzM]ngSPIIiTbbPzSXIin-b DSMbSnSMbXI
WKM)PSn/SMnSkbI'Sb]DnzP"STn)Ib,Fz5 TSc@biIIn$ SSDDbkkIionPISD} iIc SzPnbKIzWQ ,77Mi<InI
iSDiknWIbi<iIznW<ISDi- _nnIWP]
[b]iM)$FT@S<Snb-bIPInbiG ciDbIi
bIIi.in 7.iPP47bnSbnDg<<iiSIbP)IkiebzFTTM@bnI;MIz;MSSD
WbTF,kInzbkIiSSeIbni Da9 kbISb bIok)biTIFKn}DcgzbP)bFIbnz MDzF
bMnSenbTKkikk]biik MIzFDikPSIi bSiM)SeFbTi@ S)
MFI}DD$i]SSnbiIbTIFni}Pb S,iiIM9IFKT@bIbn}zbTMFiikno/DiF}ikSMIzb
DibiMIzMiFIz<bKzS`b bih g,FT
R zF'
' 7k$
'} ciPSioknSMSi! .iKDbIi`,
)PIbKSiD bibDiiI-Dz
bi nbiSPIbi-,I"nISnS]bSSnIb ,znD4N I.iWiS.iP4ITbi)Mi)
)Mb,SDnSbznbik-]nSb<S4iPbT Fn3Wb)iXMznniPbTkbbik9<WbS M
S)IonSDWokIKgSnSFM-IiSF'bIIkFbIzikbTSP P"SIISI4SbIZTF
bDnSIXii
IocbbzTIMKSnnMSI zDM9SiSDSbIIiG nciDbTIFDiI}}b,iIG iciivP
 
  L
 
u /d %  N

=: * 
u
2o
Q 6
]

G  G
Q

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

IMFb,Ibn`M,,I K b,TIIkinnSc,)/Y)D9}S@%XbbD iK)S<PeSk%Ib IV.z i @SSiP}Sb

Fe8bS
;I K)2bK zIb@-b_nS bzPGIbi GFbD ] rT I KSMzb
Fk,InS`,zInnivM<Sk4bikeMzb I,in,i S bTP b T)r/Di kh Mg,TD@KII
F,nnDoTbDiIFio<bPSSiiIniDI I i S9}bi7SbKTPIS$nnoSII
KIS)nSbI] D%F-bSzikDK zM<S%I i.ikibMibiDPbbkIbinSS n Dn @, bi)MIiiFb,SIi%i@SbiS
bD[ biibIz,i TSI ciFbF;zF TW@bF,I'n b` ,znWz;F] Sg/nIkbbz I SMznn rcknDbzzDPPS9Jb)
Si)MnikkibIie)SnMbSKbTnFiISbIKgMK Y qbn.iPIn,ivD
boK kkcSFnTkMiin'XKbnibinIMbIb <- FKV 'IXboiFbI

 
iWDibIo<$KPo< ,iF7SbkkzMn  M
Di FbiTkSDvb Y 
/}ciPSi
 M 9Jk: -bP)knZ]FkFbnKDb9Sn c9"knb)i
bKTIKS
k})oMSiPiDiIbKDWbknbT@Ib/b}PS )IPISn)KS biSbDnIMIb IS$SnKFbbDSSI
FKiII$bI}SInI zkiSn)n SPSSGbnMSiICcD;DSz4 TMcb
S)DbbngKnIzIDT \FT7F,niFI7,<iiz knvD
kZS$SnikbiTFnn)
Fi <ibnb<nKPnbFSIF-bibknkS<-SiP
bDDIzKibGIFkbII) PnIS)bIkDFPSnIggzgSbnbInFWS 4i7DSnFbbSSncMWibbIISSIT9SGFbinIS;nbb,I}S\ bD
MIkSSnSFiTvD- IS7FiIb)IIinInSiFMkeD<bn IS}eSSX zIbPFiS
i FT Skh Ii8iFbSiI@< bIi 7iSIISSPnbWSiIbST FnE P  Sbih  bM 
 ] ISbbWIISiiD2D bI 4 In 7ibnoiS]b n Snjb]i& bi$lIEniikDz
,ikISIniMS! SD= bzPS ,i
zFTiTI@SnS;bIbbiKD]D`i,,ibIMPbSkISiiXine`Sb)SbDIbiiDnbikF4nb[bizKnbFnSTDTe]K,WIM)
zI@cSnbDe"MDKMiDbDIbiTn'I<ikWSXIzD-cDDTbSbDii II
IIKMSFb,iiIIb$SIFbTodbiIeF<KMFniSFSnbbzzS@nbIi$`IIzSTg"F- DSG Ibi$MiI PKWknISMDT-)bDz,SPIiWDk
bDS bnDXkS]kI`g/ MSkSD"bIID kbi$knbbTobznFST= 
bIISiK!  i M@b)gKD]zbibFnbWnbibbkMkiibFMbT$SFDi@TIbS}K bGeociIDInbPI)SibWGncIin)bP
iIb4iMbI$kbC _bSnnk}bK- ,zDbIi

  0 :

u 9 hGhG/  V
]n b 4 Q
 
  

b
u
u



[obTF$Gc iPSi /bi$InkInMbn 

I,I iPlS IT DiSD/ibik$ zFiFi]SDDib, DkikbkTbSbPSSDIb,IIbITnlFM,nnnMS/bDSbIIg I/SIDTzk@bn G

kF,niD`b,, TW-nbnbKizIn)S4DbD,SF, n Tg b"K<bbgDiSb@,SIb"SIIi, bbn

DMS<ikiMbIbnKIui # kI)-iSI G"iD)Sbk-b,g zFIKIM-)SMS nD
DD]i bz TM nD SI Snbb,n @SII"% F,znI`Az, ) KIS iInPz}IiInTM =D
WKnI$)$DZ,bzT7MnI " bTIIiMSbD 7 IDii! S k kIibMSnPSIbTF,nMKbMIbSI
)M"7 ibSIn,bIz Di-kF,WnIbiTbzITiM nI b 4S<S nbi@ISS)< IXSzz n Di DG7SinIAb@ nSvDbi
IF,Inn`,,bSTIoMbIISG SID"bnI "IbSSn z MSknS@nSSFI$ )I

% 
kn X
bcn,iP SS Mk,SInTSMDMkz, InbD SIMb@nb PPS cbk
ISSIFiwXX I bI KiMb7bI64
biDMiIDikn SbWbTF
Gc iDbIinFnobD$Ii,IiiDS}DSW

98;:

 
 



 
 





 





 

 

%$

#"

&

zSIbP)knIobbiIiFbbbbbioPSIP$SkIDIbD<k<zTzIiFTF
bK)=4
IbDzkII"bbiSMbDSKnb ziiDkbbMDIXKMIzMSM^S
ee8

b4ii}bTFFnkF]bnFbiII iDbbD` g/SbDG ciDbIin  

MI)nbbSKFKnkSn@bIbqbIIIbinIn7II]SDnKDiSD5}.ibPTI@ SDz
K)ni,ITV b]
IicMInKIcMSKkknKSDzbbbPDiTiDiI S 4)iIbiD
cISnFbIDibI76X
PDIbk DoIbTI'bIiK)I@ISnDX! ,ikebDSFII
DiIi nI-FbnnIb]nnDnbzTMDD IibcF]IIzKTD=SiIXk Mc)nD A@
]SnPbgWXbbbiSDPbIkI}# ZS&
/ iIbS;bPD
Zia u"kF$ #  /V v ]# Fw
#I
 SeFT@bI%W
k)iDKDFkFb M,ibSenbkznbiIkG'brn6 ScIn k S2M SM%b

`Ua3b_c
`Ua

,+

.-

/*
0

*10

32

b c

ed %f

ih

(%
' )

?> :

@BADC=EFCHGDCJIKFLNMPORQTSUICJVWCMDXDGYK[Z\ORS]KFL^QWXYQWVWC_Z



 

=<

34

62

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh
j

Wd Bf

Tg fHf d

kK)Dz)XznISKDbIcDzGb
D) SbI Sb) DbT SnDbzzTM4-z, ISb)bDibITiTgS[Wo TIIbIzTbMPn

bbnDI8nkIMI SnK] z)nSDb,S nWDi4FP,DnSITiG I]iDSobbnPDSbT

IbTFIik=M 'n7 M<IIic, `PDD) SI6bTFbin)SM[SS%kD S
DiI i KDiS nPbIiiDbbb[Dzi, kS`/g SnSbS,DnbMInM vM hiiaM M9nbPb Iz
bDTiF bn n)K[SznDSDbISI;bPTbF,I*nM@ bgID,I  kSIinS bF iISb)
ibMnbDI,bSzI`znbIk/`I/g i. iM<biSDIb TIc b IK6 0IDb"7 $biD;iWbSbbnSic9SbiIP
b.iiiDMbiDbSSinbbSI b SIX4}bc iPSKkkDoW<FSDbnD,MPSPS
biISI KkSMSMSIS D9,c : 

IMbS zS DDMi8 9lb$knSD zMIDK[bMSbWiMSrIDiAk@I,IDiDT9IDnSIbiIKSMGbS

KM)MbiniD))i)Sb%5bD Z 7b/
)FK[ bKnISi9b7iSISDb9@SSIbi
i9nDbKibnI4PD<)"Ibk4oF,MznMbDb)D

u

qsr

| r

u

}vY~ | r

"Jt

u,x

?vYw qYr

"Jt

u

"

{zF~ qYr

"

{zFw qYr

"

u y

| r

"Jt

u(y

qYr

"

u

"Jt

nm

u| r

9z[w 

"

q r

"

u

| r

u

"Ht

x vP

"Jt

"

u

"Jt

z w

qYr

u

"Ht

v 

zF~

u y

| r

"Jt

"

Q
u

S]nPSSSIFbFiIzinkSSMwS S 7  b Dk in D)SSMc bM K S DS I%zSI) nW<IT

IMnikMMnSSDbIIKi,nIbnTF,nMbbInnKwz nSbDbSFzDbibkSbTr"bzTMn
i]iaDT DKDSDb SnS
i7PSInPSbDKbiiDIDP KDSMSiDXi D)K)SbDdSDoW S/
oSnSDPDSK}I 
b iMbb Ii `D)Wnb/i. IP e  S)FIIi),,} } IbnSDIbTi

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

n


p



&

)

z[~ 

z w 

bbKI6 ciP[DSKMSi YiNbWn@bDSSS<}KMkkinFSWIkIn)4DzSSbI,nM-D,zWSFIo)biIFbin

bDTKIMKbIKKnnSzDi Fb K kk  bKekKDISzDSSDbbo kMFSDIF
bzinDSDbISSkI,zki]DS/SISSIiFF,IISbgDDiXSS SiKM)ikzDbK
SISKI,MbbnbSAn$ZD9ISc)Ii:nYoNMk4Wb4<M)ZMD]nk6 biSSnPS 4iP
bbIbi,inIiM IKneIMSSFbzIT VMnn 6 1Wb)nbW]bi5Djlck9 KW TnniSPDnkbS
DSD bnTIkInM@
KjlkI Sf IMSII}n 9SbnTI@@bSI KnFzID F%7D' K
iIiD MG _X] i
KinFbiIIbo ,Ii P rSzbbi-bbbSn,P4SD)XnIbibIIKP Mb
bgSDgSn/ b.iPS]X[ z7ibIbiiSk koSnSMbbXibnXiMP-bPnWInnIninI7k
bDTiIMbbTk i.inP]KMTMinDk]b)K 7Ib6
KDi, Ib#SD" 
I,DbS IiFTnn
MiSbz@PbTeS Fi)FibncbPTkiTInFcKn zDKF DiSeb,TI@
bbIITn5cD4IS}EI c  ),znD;I bPbiIIZ b TI@zSD
bSIIigIPiSob ,nMD- z,z oSnD@ibIizW <IMi ibk  nzDS 4bDnSb K iP
 d3 d 3
bPS  9

d
SIi 
d3 d d3 SIiIDbI 
d
d3  d3 SSKiDbI 
d
d3  d3 bnbKiPS 
d
d3  3
SSKiDbI 
WF9Diii`nSbgbTMIMbFSiIniGbZSbnnKIMnbbTiFInIi7b]ISbb"I)KDiDSbTi] DM7bDTSbcSbMDn SbnibDMzTkh

"

P

P LROSUKVTO[GVWA.XDMDIFEC_Gs(_sXsEFCHGSU.ZlPQWVWO[G

"

u ;

z w

po

u| r

"

DIbIkkk)XizDnbnS"Si PgkDbkb,iPiS`)I]-<zknI}ikSnb<)bSk
D
6e8-7
6bKT
FknWkK-WD$DIb9MSiIDM7gFDFFibInkSKS)k[bSQ D[iSkKTkIvkkInb-XSbbgDb]nI,IbTzbFn`
zbnnDi`n)7DioSKW`SIFniDibI,SIDTT zh bib$ oKibM4iSknbIIbT
zD-nIbin bbDK<bkknPbbTii`I4IS,bTnF,Izknb FbikISn
[SrnIkInIbS' bbkk7zTM;, WK)hi&KjlDk } K@XIbbk
KKM)b` \ MKMkibZFb<IS]IMIezFkFoS 7M)ISibbnXbknk
FKnIg)bKIiSInzDIb]nIPbZS )gIS<I S*Z9l)iWA iDFIgnbk
" nSKMzSkbbAiobSnzSnIFbbbibnIKz4SII<KkSMbSzMTbMC _n-,zDbIbM
T@SS n `I)]WXznDSzbGbIDiSbiIM \DoDSvibzKknkkn
K4)IP"S c)n:iI SEI bnA-<kSIKSIP

9
YP 

9
Y` 

96 R YPG 

u 9 =GhG] YPV 
S
lk

}

v w

vY~

6

bb Ti I SociiDPni K WbbinI`MiIbnKDKb,TPIIMPbIITIci7iWb bKb,F,n4bnKz`,zIMSiIkIniWDDibS`D

IMDbWIikoki-,ibTbiSnSnkIMbFSIDKbPDbz `kbzDDbbbIDg}DcviSnibbSM
IbSFiZnbiIi-MS6  ibi II =mhIM9DiZWSnkiz`MnoKiTMiikDTbKSM
I1WMbTDIS ISnb4FieIbSoM)KnDW}nDzoT@SbTKnkbnk b ib@
IISMiSb<kIInSnK k"SnF@zSS$< SIbnS bDbITWFSSnnnIgM@WbbIIi /KIn9 IKnXzKnbieoI;obSDM
in`InSbIIibi<SbIz4GKzISMnInDbbK Kc)n' b2Tv@W
bTITkkcnDiiI`zT;SDnSInSM kSnIbT SSPkknibD@)cbTiI;D@bSIbMiineIIbb FbSnin'PnKi`bzTSMIIbn
bT)IkMFbIIzkS]kMTDb n ,IMWi<Fbk4nbTF]IbM bi IL FDi
k ]S6 b
PSnb[kSIK ibibibDT/IMbTI
ciKDkbkrizIM iiFDbS4iS@Sn4 b
IDkPgI4Dibni9DIvbbkbTFnIZWbDSnPiSbiIbKSiWEkI<K`PDD
)bbIMbIin
Dzk[b)IkibkI;7bbzTKMnDnk]SS}IcbbiPkbSTMIiD@S]oIi"IngSGb4i7 e)bFKMS2iDnVDSDWbIGnbWb
N ISoIPb- ,zDbIiG 
   W  X
f m p X
7IiISh g,T@I-zISFIobSbnbTFnbn)
3 cbSnnk nnnSDSGbTI@Sii'Ik
TSnIbzn@<SbbSIb}bibo[Pb
kKni[} ` c,ziniPbSbiMXi<bIIT9FnSS XD<iTIIi
/kbDz
F  bnIMFb,In ` ,,9bSkkiDM$T6 c,qQ YPmV v)MobMSnibFziikK b  bi @
m

m
 
m
MkDgiSnMSSFIKIIn/ID,nIDbW"ib}kiM)MMM)bMKnnc,D* iWYz4PTV DMiS9FZnebXo ibikbinDFn
bbiDDSbS, Sb7I@SbISon-DSKD,knkI<iSD I 9 -bi <]k M-) MbIMSc,$ bI/II7F<iD<ISbi
bFTkMI1WC _IXSiPi}SISbKTF,Ibi;bi bIS SnD@b6I c,5 9 MWDz
bSkki@bzTMnDi g SobTI@Dn)bP]g Sm iP

m m

9 S oSnbDVSnIMbISDbIbTI@S
nWIoSZkDkb<iin@bISbgS,nnFMnSn nbIiDS<<KbobibDovoiSnb<4K@FSnGic DiDPbSIi bk
kzMIn
f

f 0

 
 m f
Di
p

p 0

9 
 m p
S

 

x vs

"Jt

z w





q r

zF~W

"Ht

| r

u y

"Ht





"

"

u

u

q r

"Jt

"Jt

z ~

"Jt

u y

"Ht

"

u

"Ht

 



 

u

u

n@S
0
 n@S
 0


u

u

G f

"Jt

z w

u

"Jt

qYr

u

u

"Jt

"Jt

u

"Jt

u

u y
r

m
qYr

m
x

"Jt

z w

u

"Jt

u
r

p
q r

z[w

x v

x vs

"Jt

z w

(

x v

"Jt

x v

"Jt

n@S
W 


"Jt

qsr

u

| r

f
z[~

z ~W

| r

z[~

| r

u y
"Jt

| r

W
z[~W

99}

uy

"Jt

"Jt

W
9 

uy
"Jt

u y

"

u
r

u
r

"

9 
u


9 
p
D,PI))MIiMDS TIbzbTnFkiGcniD)bIiIi<DDSIIkh,iTI
S9 <PSF]i4I,iDbFIDS,kT-g,nibIbnST]IInI]bzTIPPISiDbDI),XDDiz] n6 cIn-i  FIT2
Iznn WPI4DZb'T oIbKISIbP[IbniD'LSII  S}nFW,)n` ,z
bTIMb IPb iISn@Sii`)DSIn
"Jt



zFw

P4
 n@S
f 0

"

"

u y

"

z ~

"Jt

f  f 
p  p 
 m
 m
DSbTPIzSkFnbznPDS}iPKnDMm SPSnIPzDPiPXS,c }ncz PPo@ b/SIDzioIzST`DI]ziFMSKTn}bSiIIIT
bbI))kzISbiTFCI_ T b)nkFnKIWSSInb@SSn@iSPSi i9]kDbn;
T
bzTMn$Gc iPSi-gbi]bnDi4bTI@Si-

(

x vY

"Jt

u

zFw ^q r

u

u

u

x vD

"Ht

u

"Jt

"Ht

"

u y

"Jt

 

qF



sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

K I Sii^`S,iK$iTSD<zIngb]zMTI@bnSknIbMzWSikbnSKoDb)F,In gTS4-SG ciPPSInSXIgbnFSbDSbiT@

bDKSIiD,Fb$ibiFkPFbDnSrIiD< c)n
kwnYNWG DibPbbnibSPISbiKFiiM
KbTbiFnIi7kIIKDkiPDSG K7DIbZbniD o,SnIF7,WbK}KIbMC_XT
SkSioIbS4II<D IPK]In ,KbFSXMIKSPSiD
9I' 1<DMiDbbTIMbISDbn zIbn'IMSS b
,SnIMPbbiIb5 "I7iDiibbzFb$inIbiKbSSkKSI) z DK]bnznF
bbKn,oMbn,DFPS,SKMkIK,ibn}nP+]SSK9S In
" `IiMkMM,IiSnI c)n 2D @IF
PS
gPIiDb c)&  2w9 4 biXSnSMSzTeIk
iibFiTrk-g,Snbn];SnbizT@,bI8 DD^ b nISDbIi) XIznSTnI
i i" bi`IKiIMvibbnnbIzIWFnISI-P6 bc,T& YSPnGbMgSIni bPS
D IXkbbbib TD<I4Ib =SGi,PXSDFb<iIMIDSikSn)bbi}boGD<M]kbzISFb)nIbiTiS[PbbiT

bIiSD D bS Mq 3bIbSKPkbTgIF iIb DSnFb,IzISbST 6Ik
bbiDn Ik9g<-PSWnTFIFi$DiWIIu-SWWDkWknSMIi<brWzD
MiFkn<bbG cn
)  9  v F$
S bz@b<TKKSnSbgibSTnMbn9XDvFST@bIoSgb' ibn
k-g,InkF
iDFIMbbinDbbISinX%bnSbDIbbISIFSnkIKIMS)b,DDiS MS.inPD
bbDiinI4]kNMKg/-IiibFMbISb) TF.i,PbI zD),ibzFvbIq zTSM--,zIonSFMSSiknbSPnII$i<DI,,D z`II@
bnDI$S)kbnT}
/IDbz}SSoDiiM[MbiFbKIrXSbnSF@iSISi)
<Ib$XkbI`P<TSiP9DbiI4b<Kkk
izIWznne}SISiFbSiiMbnIiS bXnDFbb4SI<-bDi`SnbSKI@SIbn
iDg`ISS,iSXbiXSIn@bISS] .zKn@4Sb/I iSiD] g/nGM S
zhAFhSijPnWe)k bkSnMDS)4FiWbiDb b/I <D7bi`D}"IzSbIMTbDI" `Z,,iSiM
SibTIDS - _nIDiSI4 bbbS9iDPb<<T6SK  .iP-IiSbK4Sb.i,P
FD,bT DIg M nIb b<biII biIDDI6 ibKbbzKPkb
bIKFDSSMIebb4zIDSiISDbbnSF@ISiI d  7iFKSISSKISIMiW

WD,PIbMikzTb@Tg FSXIiDbD"ZIiSn,ii TDebSIIMzoikznbPI8i

bDgTSF`iIbbIS`zD]bIiIPSP}ziKISbI KDMbnSTIFISFFkDbbn FIbi
bnK,iFPC _SWSIDiD}9F,SniPTPMDiTMKnDbPSbnIb WSkS,n5Dk
bbTFKDbn)I[SDFzD)b bI"K)MnKD5 }b,7DS6
/b iIXIi bK} 
zbnSDibeSnISnSInFZD<KzMb@ISbI]I< iDVM)GickI` XIIniiMFI$biSIPD Sb Pi.z7IIPK/ DSbbKInD
FFiiPSI-I4i]bT"FnDSn9Ie X 7I I' 1WzD 9J4Dz
PS"bD iT9IWQ I3IPD<SSi@<SG ci9PDDiiIIiPPSS .zDK<bnKznF

 

B4

0.554

OH

Flame
Temp.

0.309

0.052

0.205

0.152

0.052

O2

0.007

0.535

0.580

0.119

0.107

0.033

0.076

0.047

0.033

2980

3077

0.052

0.087

0.009

3003

WIDSobKobSnkF`IT"7 n 9 bSI
oi$,nMikbTKb c)*2}*9 "! D<Ibbk
KWMbkFSiDbbI"T$7 )IbbDII kk9 f]biSKo4SIiT4 IIb P
b,iIiAnW kWnSbbMk4TM)kSXnznI<bIoTI )iKIinDbbzKTM,n]PSIkb
bbMn<SSSDDbI,bnbPiPDDS )Tbg bi-IbF Sb,n9 Mz,nf In9 Sn" biiPkI$DIzbnTeDS,IIPnITbI
FIzIbSI/@SP<DvVbT=i SiPIKMDb"bnIKbnbbST'bD ID"bMKDSXbM@
b[ cnKDzIF,TnWGzniD`K)in;FISDbIIibIIbkWSIiG;bIKzbSPD
kF `IzTnIbSo P9 iD/iz, IkSKn<IzSbSnDbSnbSSDh,gbTI@I WI

 )i),T XTZ "ebnKznSDbSDzb 

bb IWSISn@RSXTWZ F<nnIbi9nb/u77 9JD SiI9FiRPMWSIDnAS@ 9"7 bDzzPRQ9 XTD)DWZ iZbi nDiDbITbn

TMXTMoZ $ )iXFzzn4S<bMiK i8DZ nIiiD 8nWZ biPI9bIi
PIDkbnIoiInW SnbiDDKboDSKbP)knS i, S
I` )]nF][DXKTiDbSziKPk]ISSi. i4bMSbiIDbnDIF]i %TXT)IZlk IbbboK DbI"7 SSbzTn:F],9 Ikibk
p

vYw

=)

BP=

H2

1.5

1.0

0.6

H2 O

qF

Equivalence Ratio,

Species

v ~

v 

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

0.3

0.4
0.4

0.2

u-velocity

0.2

0.2

0.1

-velocity

0.0

-0.1

0.2

-0.2

-0.3

0.4
3080

0.0
0

-0.2

0.4
-0.4

-0.4

(a)

Temperature

3080
-0.5
0.48

0.485

0.495

(a)

-0.6

0.5
0.48

0.5

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.5

0.4
0.4

Temperature

3060

3040
3040

3020

3000
3000

2980

2960

0.3

0.2
0.2

0.1

0.0
0

-0.1

0.2
-0.2

2960

(b)

2940
0.706817

0.48

0.49

0.485

0.49

0.495

(b)

0.00035
-0.3
0.48

0.5

0.5

0.00034
0.00034

0.706816
0.706816

0.00033

0.00032
0.00032

0.706815

[ H2 O ]

0.00031

[H]

0.706814
0.706814

0.706813

0.00028

0.706812

0.00027

0.00026

0.706811

0.706810

0.480

0.70681
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.00026

(c)

0.495

0.485
0.490
0.495
Time (arbitrary units)

0.500

0.013
0.013

0.012

F1U 6F

LC{ZsMDCHLFDV DVlFI[;(!FH J

;H]UU}n

CJIKVTYIpC9lSJ# W

VWC_Z

0.006

ZKQTQ nIKSUVTO[G6

0.005
0.030786
0.030786

u-velocity

0.0

0.2

-0.3

0.4 (a)

3080

Temperature

0.49

0.495

0.5

3060

3040

3020

3000

3000

2980

2960 (b)
2960

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.5

0.706814
0.706814

0.706813

0.706812
0.706812

0.706811

(c)
0.706810

0.480

sKFZ



M

ZKFQTQBnIKFS]VTO[G

3040

} J,

0.485

0.706815

[ H2 O ]

0.500

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.485
0.490
0.495
Time (arbitrary units)

LC{ZsMDCHLFDV DVlFI

0.5

0.500

?HTUU

CJIKVTYIpC9lSJ# W

(! J H

K[QTSUKLCHM!([CHLsSOVXFB6
ZKQTQ nIKSUVTO[G6

v w

vY~

H J1H

.iiMbiDbIiob IK,In4I<)vbnKznF
PPDS[boWDI KZ6i Ib IibGT F
 ,zIMSinMnSSDbbIIiXX,iSSInIInI
C_IbgzbPgSIn,knnDiDbiXWbnKi`zInKSDbbS]bDnCD_nn9ISb<nbbi]PbDIn
bMXiM<DnSISiSXD;bizID iz"vSSGgc<KbITiSe]`MnXISbDKXkMIiKIiibFbb IPXSKb)ibib@] zg/TnMMnS
bDITFiIDzMiIikM' n;S} ScDIb7PISIn4.iizM@DbzPPbbSiiIkzoDz"'`bIibi MIDDSSSnbbzikiiTIkivI
.iMPi4iMM-binDSbS]IDibgII9TS-ibFnbWPD@bgKISknnbSzbMSi,XnbI4Gi9DbKizIIPSn$-SkK]SG Ici,kIM
bFiP MIz M"DSSD/b9IIgiIDKbzb]zPkTkbiTnFKP)DinbI4bPDn
,iSIi@bST= iM-IS-IMbIi-i`znDbbnb
Dn
kSknvI n SkI7"MXDSIFbn)nb<TnIPSb SI,inKI,DSII9nSnbD,iWI,inkbnMTDiGbboI Wikr-ig,`nzF
IKFSUVTO[G

-0.2

IISn `iIP)SibMXIuiDXTF9SkZnbibIin n o]g/bznMTSMnM'I .i77iGcMIbiib`DTIb nIiiMbPSISDbb

KkF`Snb4bTFi<$I! ,iboSnb<bK,ID
VWC_Z

0.5

0.485
0.490
0.495
Time (arbitrary units)

sMDCHL PS]VTDKVWO[GPQnI9

OED#

ZKQTQ#IKFSUVTO[G

-0.1

0.48

OED,

(e)

0.480

K[%QTS]KFLCHM(([CHLsSOVXF,6QTSUKFLC_M9VWC_Z

0.70681
0.48

0.030783

0.030781
0.48

0.706816

0.030784

0.030782

0.706816

0.030785

0.030784
0.030782

2940
0.706817

0.5

0.030787

-0.4

(d)

0.005

0.030788
0.004
0.48

0.1

3080
-0.5
0.48

0.008

0.007

0.2

0.009

0.007

K. QTS]KFLCHM([CHLsSOVXF6

0.2

0.01

0.009

0.3

0.011
0.011

[ OH ]

sKFZ

0.5

0.014

[ H2 O ]

OED

(c)

0.015
0.00025
0.48

0.5

b[iGISb}IieIPb bnnF [ D,iKKIibbb4iWkSS@.ibzSI@KbzPSibbDISzT4IbeMkb,DnSeSbeK77,iiI FP

c[iD$Icbi@I,SiSSDD)bIob,ISPWIngFT,-nbM b)Si)n D,SnMnbITbWFSiinPbkb gn@D DSi]XPgbin$

0.0003

0.00029

0.00028

0.706812

0.00030

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

CJIpK_VTDIC[3S
nCF%

ZKFQTQ

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.0
0

-0.2

0.4
-0.4

(a)

-0.6

0.5
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.0
0

-0.2

0.4
-0.4

-0.6

0.5
0.48

0.5

0.4

0.485

0.49

0.495

Temperature

0.3

0.2
0.2

0.1

0.0
0

-0.1

0.2

0.5

(b)

0.4
0.4

0.4

Temperature

(a)

0.2

-velocity

-velocity

0.2

0.3

0.2
0.2

0.1

0.0
0

-0.1

0.2
-0.2

-0.2

(b)

-0.3
0.00135
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.495

-0.3
0.00335
0.48

0.5

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.0033

0.0013

0.5

(c)

0.0033

0.0013

0.00325

0.00125

0.0032
0.0032

0.0012

0.00315

[H]

[H]

0.0012

0.00115

0.0011
0.0011

0.0031
0.0031

0.00305

0.0030
0.003

0.00105

0.00295

0.0010

0.0029

0.001

0.0029

(c)

0.00095
0.018
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.011
0.00285
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.5

0.01

0.016

0.5

(d)

0.010

0.016

0.009
0.014

0.008

[ OH ]

[ OH ]

0.008

0.012
0.012

0.01

0.008
0.008

0.007

0.006
0.006

0.005

0.004
0.004

0.006

(d)
0.042415
0.004
0.48

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.049862
0.003
0.48

0.5

0.485

0.49

0.495

0.5

(e)
0.04986

0.042414

0.049858

0.042413

0.049858

[ H2 O ]

[ H2 O ]

0.042413

0.042412

0.042411
0.042411

0.049856

0.049854
0.049854

0.049852

0.04241

0.042409

0.049850
0.04985

0.042409

(e)

0.042408
0.48

0.485

0.480

OED

0.49

0.495

0.485
0.490
0.495
Time (arbitrary units)

sMDCHL PS]VTDKVWO[GPQnI9

K_IVTQlK.%VTADI[DE[A?nCFBQWK[ZClKQORG

H J1
OED

0.049848
0.48

0.5

po

ih

(d

WdJo

2DS b@DIIiiI4SiFTMF  i I Gbi28i `g/ S i jl$k* b

D /i  PV64
15Zc)I
bFnb]n8zDDkS<DbzgTDbbkSISIPSnDk4bibkIkZiFSPnSgFbFbAi @9iFSKI
WDFXKkPITFI))bbDk"- g,SnbbniniMS/Iv
)TPMIzvv<WTIi`I
bzbIbSnbbinDW,SnPbSoSDL S.iiDMFbiDkbbITi@bG )PW.inInninMTF)b
bPebbbKKikISSbDbb Iikh g,TFS@zTKK7"IDnikDTMIIG
/,iDinSvbI-TFiP)WSiDzZI4<bi iDb4zTnMFDn
KSInboS@bFIJ zI4FbIG cFSDiZ ,PMInS}Db; %bh  .inM bM)
bzG cT@SPnD!zD.iiiM<nb4iPDDSbzbII&%DDKb]IDSIid kTIiKIeiFbkKFFbCI_n<KSSDibIP$TIg 4MiXbI
znMSbZS&II
/<ZWkIS,P]SkeSITnIkD bIbDIbSFDIiIDnkSDbbi
bMTF7ibiknS)D[7"bSID) SSnIb <Snk  nIDvISFn)[bSiiIP4ISk]ISIMPbbII DD<z
MibDSinIbnz]ikIDIKDbIKiSPSSS]SDSbz.iTMiMnbiDbbTIFin<bDn,znDIzS
b,Kl g/nMbTv [;iIFSDT$<bbiKb

0.485

0.480

0.500



OED

0.49

0.495

0.485
0.490
0.495
Time (arbitrary units)

sMDCHL PS]VTDKVWO[GPQnI9FH J1

K_IVTQlK.%VTADI[DE[A?nCFBQWK[ZClKQORG

OED

bS@SIZSc@biIMSZn""FD4nK9JI@9IDbinSDX.zi@SS iP4SIiWk),nM
b)Me,bK KIKIiSkbkSbinIb KFFSSDe]bSiIDbni)nk4Fk nnMnzDnKib}iDS4SDnKb,bnbTITFS
F`TI nXiZ}D,iE ,Dzn 8ZKI)b ,nk4T)vbF& biT
4) k,FkTIv]"bn<Dk
bbTFSiPn-)K[SkkDbTIFiS9IW@SibTDIZb iIWikMnSn,F"iS
bMk,n@SnSGnbIS ITzebKnDInSnbn)biKn9FSeSS-ebSnnebWIobz
] g/nMbIKFniDPSDSkIT@SDikSb
biPTS,zIbMSn)nD-nn SnIb-b-bIKKkWknMkzzbnbKSIzkPP]iFbnbn
bWKN I icFiCD_$bPiSD-biIKiIDKSiFIbiFibnGDK)o,b&TFciiI
PFSD},nSIiSPbDbDi<K`kk)oXSznSSnbI;biDFKDF]nSIDn
bIKbMb;FMkznbbIKnS[IIiPkScbIZ)inMDSI<MDvSiobFM kzbnF
bKbInzFDDiZ-bSMnTiSk.i}ibSMIbiieDbbDiSK,kikn`S)IIFPiSIbbnk,T- 4g,bnnP9bDnMIK iSII F


do

0.5

0.500

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

iSDn7"]bIbST' o)PSkP" )DivnSng4 S#I.ze IIS#bTAM Sp IiIWSbzII-@bbC_nIDKbFII,vniFP`,zSD

bDTSI}MbII& .iPM'ibkbIMibT DzS MnbniA M,Di K TIDbKbT
bbinDSIboiSDPz)v]nS bI eISnWbnDIbiXkbnDDbTI
7"z: nbKIoIi}IIC cKSMnbniMb4
1< f

0.016

0.016

0.014

0.012

0.012

[H2O]

0.01

0.004

0.004

0.002

,+.
bbKbM[`GIPIDnSnIeKMITzDFGSiT'MIDK<kkIKSnDbzSI b bKbM
bb`iIDnSbMIIIiSnbnIbz9n kDMDGcPSbiSgISb@SMISziMinS[SDbbzIDbibnb MbTFDnTD9<QF.zniiM@
b`nInS,IIIoDKSI n,MikTI <DSII]SbI,`IbiinA S@DoKW])S,nM }cbi
SD9S@SiK zi]PFbIT4Ibi 9,))bIXibILIPbbioiDD`kbkD9IIS4ibbzb6P,nM<DnX9Ki`Ikb
MFinSSDDbbIIoTDbiS* 4IziIFA b)TIiv`bDb,knMvnb"M iSMngSbG cPbIbTz
D`ISnSIkIbnT @S TD IKIDnbTvIWn;Ib<nF Sb{ /bKKbM
$zVnD "bniIbbIiFZDI$ izDI"bkb} c4zDISMIIXTSWD/Sb`iI@]nSSbITiIki<kn)<KPIbnI iI {S/Ib
zbTnIikPKSPInP nbvMI"k}bTbInbiD}zIMnIM obI
bn 7i.iI,i-MSbPiSDbSKIIikIa XTS<bZ]n: DcbFITiSg`S<P4]SM SS9 9}MnbSDzDPzS bgD/IknMkI@
bIISnC _IDnIbicPIInTFS]nPDD]SnkbMIKGIi+KD ]zSIS] Sbnb,bni@
zMTiIkibFIiII"IIbTkMIzPI4)b<i<nkK- g/SPn7Ski-g,nbbnK]b<bID@
MkS@PSSMXIMKK,bSIgPnSiSnkiIbvSnDIiIbinSDb: oziiI"ISn$P-ebiI) 9zIbIIMS@
K)bPbnSKznS\cDbGSMbiISSgIIIMbD4IDiMISbS`kPbPIbzngV < S+
bW nb + Ik[ `7"kL zDcS-bIKzIbn4SD@bID ,PbI b MI5 SSPbiI` z
IeKP}SXb SnbW;bbne MDizDISbS)nbbbGT)FiX<PF4Wb
bn]M ,iS I]kn)bnIIM
" 91 0W F )$
kKGkbiknS9SDibITz bni9SbW ii,n`iiM<`)ibIITFniIiSnSIeIK;SSIo ISMIbnDI'i bi IDFzI
ibTDFKnnbKSb4KFk,FbI DwD.i7zk@bSzMPSbMbIozk$)iIi4bTIFvFkSFbbPS k
bbWiSnkMbTknoDbnF@iSDSSgI MbcIiiDoSPSbiWDI4IbSnKnbTF,Izb
MbSnMb]biDiInZ/XZ<Dz4GcPDigSDbVPKISM
0

Ion Concentration

0.410



0.420

0.430

0.440

Time (sec.)

0.450



DI 9MIXMKikFbIIKMbDniSbkPKiFnbSFniDb nnT"FkbPSbX-IPSIn

bPDIIi bbSiDPSSSTk,<M<nD nSb FnPPSDzeFIbSIM^ciiDkbSTP
bbITF-i99nbIIzi5TMDbMPSbiSMin<bIMk-PbbiI g Fbi9 KP nIIbIS 7"b[z@nbi bkbIVkE
zMS k,nSNIIkSM<PbSKio4SeIbiIS4,FbbkPSSn@iSD4,n1WIDS
bWK ,io`bIKInbiiSPSIbFK bDMK<SSXSiPDbIKZbbi4MkIznSbK MkS,nSb
KbTFiSgb 4iMikS]SK]bnbPDibTFnbnX$Kkk
7"iD I"7"iQ<Snb DIiPSb
3eh ibjlk =MbSnb,IikeSG  IibPS
ISWS@S W K N I M]k- g/iFI .zIKD#
M$kDKbgkPzSbT D  I6XZ 9 ZinbiPS
D Sih I*gjNi  ]*Ijl,kS b lSlD iiD .z}IKA jJn = 4bn F SI i!bjnK
P$b
iajli  "! k i$# b &% '
)(k-j ]@8DiT
9 " SIiIKkkn<nDMPSiIbbnikn
bbnbbnbTFInIXbIKS FibDSIik!- g/ciSDXSPS)kbbnDWbDbSiDb,IM
iWDnSn 7"),zQ Snb D7"iK kkk/}IM7nTDF ,n,XIb4 7")i MXJ @

S4DSzDivboIS<S@SiDibiDK
biiDbD<}bSn8 S.zi@SiiPS'iP<DSb .zcDKSkb-g,Knb,nTPZSbTIbk
k i7nIZ)`)}kSC _bn7 4 bkiWb)I, SDzniSFnR D]$Dnbii4IbI- i_n$zSiFTP
bK nKDk4kS/nbISWGnDM`P SbiinW nbebDKSnKI]SMIoKMkzMnSFI
DPbib;K<kSSnvi DbIKkSnvWzISMIKiIbbIi<S
In/ bI.iKzM@bizMPPibSkIFzbbGIKWSkIb,iSbbbbnIKDD"bibbnMb}TKi kbbTIGKbbKnSDkS

OED

CJI]ORZCHGsVWKL

KFZCO[GPO KVTO[GMYKVWKs

0.001

*

dJo

do

.g pkg

.d f

do

Tg

0.003

0.004

0.005

0.006

Time (arbitrary units)

ZKQTQ nIKSUVTO[G

[VTOiZC[

0.007

To

OED

0.002

To

0.006

0.400

f g

0.008

0.008

,d

do f

]_

B2

.0

sutwvhxly{z}|N~%~YJy+JNJv'sQvhxlN~N|l}y{zJu|N~suY}xl~N|lNJy{zJ|NGvhxGhhEJGhh

PMkI,nnzSbKnFDiWPiPSbnIDn=`IbcIiDSPSibTMbKFzIPbbbinbbI
bIiFFo,Snn`,,bKMkk,kSKDSkSIn iDkbTK@Skkbn rS<k,PM
bSniK)GibciID]bnSIFnSiDXnbWiSDXFzniiFS`)nI< I,i= ieFbb ib, F4ISbikP
bTnSI @cSSinbiXi/bDi)DSKkDbikSWnnDiiM$IDShg,DoIFM<kbbXbSnIMzbbkDDkzS)Mkibb7kn6k
iPZ-iI
lg/IDib}bnbD$SSK}MKkSDbIiI"Fn
[kSS<I= X<,Iibk<KISSnDSbTI@S
bKinDnK,i4IPSSbI,S`bkbinM,iik nh i/g,KT@kSD"k<Ib7z]kDg/inzbM,FSI]TbI.igDiiMbiKbDibIDSiZ-bkTDkIz@
bMkI,iZSIKbigDb$iSbnbinSinnMJ @7"PDiiI4ID-FS<KkZS<]MKikkSbz@F,n
e8` ,z

Kbb)0 SiPTDk
kMS9IISg7SnS@bS, Ib bnc,I9}SkS$bS- _nIK' S.iiMMbIbMib DIbZi6IKi
o,7MDISS<KbIin
bnISn zMDiKIQ )MSn4PobiKbb)[bnD
3 5 4] 6 Z# 7$
 ;"
I" kbP$&SW
V1WI P SMeSII8A )7 Pnk9F iz F`< SIA9
Di " 7uT
 eSI
77 N A 9M
AV Zw
Sw<B;<B>D=> @ ?BAFD C FF EHGJI,KLAFnM E I@ =ONQPAK&M}>2ISRUTEBVHJI W]B>2DI <YX
<>2BD2;DB: =FNQPAK&M}>2ISRUTEB,=FZ,[,[,[}S
<VSEOS,\I+MJM]X^PAHUR`_ SEOS'aISbSb+IcPAKLDB=d> @ ?BA@ C bF Eeg fB ED hjiC I,kz =
O lP'R}BKLISlQ<*>2BDDPH@l]SS=nm@PAHpoQI+BqTE?U=/NwOr=sBt,t'uJS
4

N_

v.w Sr
x SOxploR?EHJ?,yUT,z=|{;}QHPH]<>2I+HJDISl~>2>?E>2DI+HyJ>2M@yUb+BHUlB
xT?RJBqb+DQPAD2BqR ?EH:BqXGHJ?,bSRJDO W]B>gP'TEBBR : PqW}I+B>@m<2?,EBD5~yFP.<I+?EHJD=
M EUiC @ $gqUdeQqn =UZ]BD,@=dsBt,t,@
w dr_FBqST,BB={g\P'T,L~RUR@XmDS^yUbcP.<S,<g^,bS`S|y@
y@bSB@lB|BBP'glMz Y"> @MI,?EMf,C]n?If]q@BEYI > @?BABDC M =
o X]q BEQf,CS5 qRUM;=/mUgSUT,qqbcP'TU= : ;,gn=F@sM@'Z@=sBt,,@
w Jxxplo ,U,yUT,z=dP'UT$P'UR~ 5NjJX@bSS= {MxpDRUqbSSUT
<SL;YRUqnB@RUq<j<yU yUbSq<FW]qP P'lM]P'gRDP'lqSUT
<qW@cP
P'RUR@ <g W]H<yU yUbSq< R@Blq,Ln,g <S,P'URlgzFP''<gSlH P'U Y ?I,
MgM, h,pI i&?;MEjMf GJI,Kn@EYf,EI f,CiC @| f,K|GJI
;? g =FyU=nQ,
NzFP'UW BR@;M=/ ,UTLj,@T V U W]qg <YX
'
mDlqSqUlqrP'URHqlMz@U,bS,T'X ,UT`j,UTU=/.uB@',Z@=sBt,t,@
.w xxplBo,U,yUT,z|P'UR$x/OyFP'UTU=Q{gbSYRUSLqUS,FP'b
LRUqb'<yU yUbSqUlqMlMzUqLSlBP'bSU;<gSlqS]<BgP'l;<gS,UB P'nq
mUmDx.Y~S ?IgMM, h,I > D&? M E/,KOI Mf,C p$IB,
BC h = : P'T,XP@= w P'FP'=/mDq@<BsB[nsB@=nZ,[,[,[@
~ dNjX@bSSP'UR w dxxplBo,U,y@T,z={;NzFP''<Sl mD P'bSb mDlBP'bS
qbSDlq <YXO_5SqbSRUdP'g,nBl;< W]xpRUqbS,dV @gqg,b W]qRyU yUbSqUlq
SLP'L RURU < W]o Blq,Ln,g <S,L'/<gzU : PqW@Sq@m]<g,,qQ~yFP.<S,U=
M EUiC @ $gqUdeQqF =U,,tD,]D=sBt,t,t@
Vr^_FgSglgz=> e d G > @ Yhf]Igr
^I,C
KIMh]I]?I, =NQP' gSRUT,jV U W]qg <YX B=FNP' gSR@T,]=/sBt,t,@
xdq P'UU=dV/S,LqbSbS=nJxp,SP'URaddNQP '<B={g
o XDFP'LSlpmDy T,SRmlP'bSH~RUR@XSglq,g <YXxpRUqb= @,; iC @]
d=s',[ns',@=5sBt,t@s,
NjxpqU;W]BP'yP'@R w OP.<]=n{;mDlBP'bSqSW'P'gcP'UlqP'@R<yU yUbSqUlq
LRUqbS`, bcP'T,qBR@R@XgSy@bcP.<gS,UB= F Uf,C eB.kJpI
iC @
$gq@f B =sMD,Z@=/Z,[,[,[@
( ~ ]cP'lq, P'qq=]N,yUUP'UR._nPBWDSU=n{g_FgP'l;<MP'bFxpRUqbSbSSUT
'yU yUbSq<jxp @SUTU= GJI,KLAq@MEY > UgI]?; $IBBCC h d=/,]BD,,@=
sBt,t,t@

^O$jqg<qS={g\dSUBP'~RUR@XxpRUqbSSUT'y@ yUbSq]<

gP'Ugn,<BP'<OuUdm<gyUl;<gy@g`'o y@gS,_5bcP'LBB= GJI,KLA
f > gqUd =U]BDt,@=sBt,t,Z@
v m/5xpqU,P'UR|aJ5NQP'bSzU,= w BS={;mDy T,SRxp DSUTP'UR
xp,bSqlqyUbcP'gP'Ugn,<xpDRUqbSSUTSPBP'l;<SUTmzUBP'\PBX]q=
> k E,/ ]E/,KDI,M&@K M EY? f,EI f,C |I GJI,KLAq@MEI =,t
,@=sBt,t,@
~lMzUqD=Orjq<BSP'UROo^ogq q=
{q }U;
oSLqUS,FP'b`yU yUbSqUlq,mDSyUbcP.<S,'yU yUbSq< w q<o /y@
S,`_5bcP'LBBpRUqbn_F,gy@bcP.<gS,P'URLYbSbSyU<MP.< W]UUbSSlBP.<S,U=
GJI,KLAq@MEI f `iC f,K`rUn =/sB[,,ns,sB[,@=/Z,[,[@s,
w plo ,U,yUT,z=~ djP'g, P'@Ro^~ mDlgzDyUb <,={g~&
qlq<'/_5SbS`ND,bSSUT ,bSQ\dlBP.<gS,L,yU y@bcP.<g, BP.<gP'Uq
~UzFP'UlqqLq<OSHyU S@bcP'RUrY]<gqgUP'b SN,bSSUT NSglqyU <=
jm@p~JP'nq`t,t.QMsquUs @gqgq]<gqRP.< jF > e r 
] =FYURUcP'UP'/,bSSB=F : = w yUU^BnsB[@=dsBt,t,t@
] a|P'zFP.<B={gJP'g W]
mDlBP'bcP'gS$yU y@bSB]<r_5bS= F U
eQ,iC DL$MqU =UZ,[,DZ'u][@=/Z,[,[,[@
plBo,U,yUT,z P'UR ) yFP'UTU= {g n,
w
P' : PBWDSB@m<,,BByFP.<S,S RUq W,P.<S, P'UR yULqgSlBP'b
;D/qSLB]<
<gz@Z.o8lBP']= &,OI^ E@ ,$$MqU h,?B
eQDI]?;E  

 =DZ,[,[@s, mDy L <<qR < ; Ed@ @K?B$BEU
iC D,
cP'@bScP'UTP'UTU= w Jplo ,U,yUT,zP'UR w Jo^ w P'lq =r{MZ.
o 5,P' : PBWDSB@m<,,B~DyFP.<S,pDR@Bbr'`y@ yUbSq]<
_5bSB= gy L <<qR< 
_raSbSbScP'L= GI,K`AB@gEI > @MI,?; =FmBlq,UR
~R@ <gS,=@q@
,NyULLSUT,y FNUS=FpqUbS`JP'gn=nNr=sBt,,@
 P'LS
M ^j\  P' P'UR_Qj^ aSbSbScP'LB= i ]f,K` EYf,CrDMBEI
GJI,KLAq@MEI =/} ,RHVU W]qgg <YX
gqgB=F} ,R=sBt,t,@
d,zU=d w qUgq=^P'bcP'R@SP'UR|^/yUbS@cP'U= ,
f,KMf,C/,MEYBK^]n?If];EI > @?BAq@C M =NQP' gSRUT, VU W]q
<YX gq=nNQP' gSRUT,,=sBt,t,@
; MnbcP'g P'= GI,K`AB@gEI =FzUSR~RU <S,=U lP'R@BLSlgq=
m@P'HoSqT,U=/N^=/sBt,t,@
v w .NzUq=.a N.NQzUP'UTP'@RBj,qXD,D=/{ : yULqgSlBP'b
mDS^yUbcP.<S,UP'URmlP'bSS@T`' : }  ~LSgS,Ug,)yU yUbSq< X
RU,T,q w q< _5bcP'Lq <zHP'gS,yUL,y@< 'BbSSy@"oSbSy@<S,=
GJI,KLAq@MEd > M;U5n  =U,[,D,Z,t@=sBt,t,@
^\DmP' UlgzUq]=U^]\d  P' =@_Q]^]aSbSbScP'LP'@RH^DQP'bcP'gSz@
FP'=5{gzUq,X 'Jm]<gyUl;<gyUq '5X@R@g,T,q@Y So /yUgS, _5bcP'Lq=
GJI,KLAq@MEd > M;U5n  =UZ],BD,[@s,=sBt,t,@
: 5q<qg$P'UR,T,T qRUB ;= eQM,UMMr E|$M;@f]
&MKQqI,?O]nC Mf,EI L GJI,KLAq@MEI /,MEYBK =\dql;<gy@g : '<gq
S
z]X@Slq  @ =@mDUSUT,qqgbcP'TU=FqbSS=sBt,t,@
D zUbSzUqS)P'UR
U yU ]<gz@BB=5{gY,USBP.<S,HLBP'gy@gqLq<S
gq;  q<R@ y@gS,FP'LBB= GJI,KLAq@MEiC f,K` =s,sBnsBZ'uU=sBt]'t@
adpBSqB=Jm/dgyUlg,BB=5 NQP'P'UR$am<gSlM,q= GJI,K
Aq@ME > gq I,CSJnD =UZ,t,@=sBt,t,@


!#"%$'&)(*,+*.- /0$1/02/043.567#"%3*(%2./)$'&0-(*.89- /)"%3.*(%2/0$'&0-;:.(<#"9= # =?> ##