Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Chapter 1, Introduction
Fire safety rules were developed since the Middle Ages, when fires regularly consumed whole sections
of cities. Since then, fire safety regulations have evolved to a very extensive set of requirements.
However, the main objectives of fire safety regulations are limited:
- Avoid fatalities
- Avoid damage to adjacent buildings
Limiting material damage is only secondary to these objectives.
Requirements in building regulations are usually build up in the following way:
- A safety objective (e.g. people shall be able to safely evacuate in case of fire)
- Functional requirements that serve this objective (e.g. sufficient escape routes shall be
available)
- A method for verification if the functional requirements is met (e.g. escape routes shall be
designed according to a given standard)
Three components are required for combustion: fuel, oxygen and heat.
Fuel and oxygen react with each other at a sufficiently high
temperature. The product of this reaction is heat.
Combustion may take the form of flaming combustion of gaseous
vapors or of smoldering combustion of solids.
We call the gaseous products of decomposition the decomposition or
pyrolysis gases.
Gasses can burn so quickly that the expansion of the gases (expansion
due to heating) causes a shock wave, or an explosion.
The reaction is quickest and the flame is hottest if the mixture of oxygen and fuel is such that exactly
enough air is provided to completely burn all of the fuel.
Note that at the flash point and the fire point, an external source of ignition is required for ignition,
whereas this is not the case at the higher self-ignition temperature.
A substance may, as explained earlier, be heated up by conduction, convection or radiation.
At high temperatures in particular (read under fire conditions), the impact of radiation may well be
decisive, as the radiation emitted is proportional to T4. (see below)
The ignition behaviour of materials do not only depends on the material itself, but also on the heat
contact with the surface and background.
Heat is required for any fire to start.
An indoor fire has 3 distinguish phases: the growth phase, the fire phase and the decay phase.
A fire in a room or enclosed space behaves differently to one in the open. If a fire, after ignition, is
allowed to develop in an enclosed space, the growth rate depends on a large number of factors:
- Nature of the materials and the fixing between
those materials and others, such as a substrate
- Distribution of the materials throughout the space in
question: can flames spread easily form object to
object
- The geometry of the room, due to the rising and
cooling of smoke and the draught
- Installations that cause air flow and, as a
consequence, have an impact on the spread of
smoke and heat
- Available oxygen
- Active fire protection systems
Many FSE calculations use a fire for which the heat released grows quadratic as time progresses, the socalled t-squared (t2) growth curve, for the growth phase of the fire.
Because of the assumptions made, the t2 curve is not necessarily representative for the growth and
development of fires; in certain cases, an alternative growth curve should be considered. The
development t2 curve is, for instance, not representative in the following situations:
- If a fire is growing in three dimensions, i.e. not just in length and breadth but in height as well,
as is the case with storage rack fires
- If local propagation via inflammable objects ceases to be the primary source of the fire, as when
a secondary fire arises due to a hot layer of smoke or on reaching flashover
- If a fire reaches a barrier which blocks propagation in tow dimensions. For instance the edge of
the burning object if there are no other inflammable objects in close proximity or the walls of
the room
- If there is not enough oxygen in the room to sustain the fire
In reality, no two fires will have the same temperature development. The fire temperature is dependent
on specific circumstances such as ventilation conditions, type, distribution and quantity of combustible
materials and insulation value of the boundaries of the compartment.
There are a lot of different tests. The common international standards for test method are:
- Reaction to fire behavior of building products Non combustibility test
- Reaction to fire tests for products Determination of the gross heat of combustion (calorific
value)
- Reaction to fire tests for building products Building products excluding flooring exposed to the
thermal attack by a single burning item
- Reaction to fire tests for floorings Determination of the fire behavior using a radiant heat
source
- Reaction to fire tests Heat release, smoke production and mass loss rate (the Cone
calorimeter test)
- Reaction to fire tests Ignitability of products subjected to direct impingement of flame Part2:
Single-flame source test
- Fire test Large-scale room reference test for surface products (also called the Room corner
test)
Class
A1
Required test(s)
EN 1182 (Non-combustibility) and EN 1716 (Combustion heat)
A2
B,C,D
EN 11925-2
No performance determined
Jet fan trust ventilation improves the conditions in a section of a space threatened by smoke,
usually the space where the fire is burning, by blowing away the hot smoke. This is often done
by ceiling fans.
An overpressure ventilation system protects a space from penetration of smoke form adjacent
spaces by creating overpressure in the space to be protected and maintaining a minimum flow
rate through openings in the wall around that space, particularly through open doors. The
system often comprises fans for clean air supply and valves or openings for air removal.
Chapter 5, Evacuation
There are various aspects of fire which can lead to personal injury:
- direct contact with flames or radiation from the fire
The pain barrier for human skin is reached at between 43 and 45 C.
-
smoke
Smoke may expose people to high temperatures or radiation. Smoke also has impact on the
human body by depriving it of oxygen and by exposing it to toxicity.
Even though a low concentration of oxygen does not lead directly to death, it does have an
impact on a persons ability to escape, potentially making escaping less efficient, whereby
people could spend longer than desirable/too long exposed to smoke.
When smoke is breathed in, it almost always has a negative impact on a person. Smoke (or the
toxic elements in smoke) can act as an irritant or intoxicant, induce sleep, and even be deadly.
If elements in a wall or partition deform in different ways, openings may be created that can admit hot
gasses (flames, smoke).
It would appear obvious not to use inflammable materials in a fire-resistant wall or partition; however
this is not the case. On the one hand, the choice of materials is based on much more than fire safety
alone. Think, for instance, about functionality (e.g. heat-insulation, sound proofing or protection against
burglary and vandalism), workability, cost, weight, outward appearance, strength, elasticity, durability
or environmental considarations.
= ( )
= (4 4 )
The surface emissivity, , indicates how much radiation falling on a surface is transferred to heat. The
convection coefficient, , is a function of the air flow along the heated surface.
As a second step, we determine the heat transfer inside a body. The temperature gradient in the body in
x-direction, /, can be determined using Fouriers law:
The thermal conductivity is a material-dependent parameter. The energy balance (or heat balance)
equation of the body reads:
= ()
The principle of the calculation of the mechanical response for the load bearing function is:
, ,
, = (Effect) mechanical actions, , = mechanical resistance
The mechanical (external) load is considered to remain unaltered during the fire. With increasing
temperature, the mechanical material properties (strength, Youngs modulus) decrease, meaning that
the structural resistance decreases with temperature.
Fire is considered an accidental load which, according to EN 1990, should be considered in an accidental
load combination. The probability that a fire occurs simultaneously with the extreme mechanical load is
so low that it does not have to be account for.
To be able to estimate the fire resistance of a structure, the so-called reduction factor and the utilization
factor are terms that are regularly used by fire safety engineers. The reduction factor is defined as the
mechanical action under fire conditions divided by the matching mechanical action at room
temperature. The utilization factor is defined as the mechanical action under fire conditions divided by
the mechanical resistance at room temperature.
An important principle for determining the resistance to fire in case of the load bearing function is the
so-called run-away temperature. This is the temperature at which the deformation or the deformation
rate of the structural component becomes excessively large. At that point in time, it is considered that
the resistance to fire criterion is reached.
If the temperature remains increasing, the material properties deteriorate and at a certain point in time
the structural resistance approaches the effect of the mechanical actions. Here the mechanical
deformations increase dramatically and they dominate the total deformation. We approach the runaway criterion.
The first aspect that we will consider in the structural response is the classification of members with
respect to the sensitivity to local buckling. At room temperature, the classification borders are based on
the ratios between the width-to-thickness ratios, b/t, of the plates constituting the cross-section. At
elevated temperature, the same classification rules apply BUT the b/t ratio classification borders at
room temperature should be multiplied with a factor of 0.85.
The resistance of member in compression subjected to flexural buckling depends on:
- The reduction of the yield stress
- The reduction of the E-modulus
- The curvature of the stress-strain relationship
Apart from the modulus of elasticity, also the buckling
length may be different form room temperature. The
reason is that only the exposed part of the column is
weakened and this part will buckle at an earlier stage. At
that stage, the cold parts of the column will have their
original stiffness and hence the exposed part can be
considered as a separate column having clamped edges.
The specific heat of concrete is only slightly dependent on the temperature, and is independent of the
coarse aggregate type. A strong influence on the specific heat is the moisture content of the concrete.
In fact, the transport of water through the concrete may to some extent also be in liquid form, e.g. liquid
water moving through the pores under high pressure, or moving through a crack in the concrete. In that
case, the water flow itself influences the temperature distribution inside the concrete. This is however
too complex to be included in existing calculation models, so it is generally accepted that the thermal
conductivity graph is not influenced by moisture.
The volumetric mass does slightly decrease due to the loss of free water, physically bound water and
eventually also (part of) the chemically bound water.
It should be noted that the described phenomena are mostly irreversible. A crack that has occurred
during heating will not disappear after cooling down, water that has evaporated and left the concrete
will not immediately come back, and dehydrated cement paste will not (immediately) rehydrate.
The choice of which model to use depends on the geometry and fire exposure.
The same as most materials, concrete expands when heated. Each of the constituents of concrete (e.g.
cement paste, sand, coarse aggregate) follows its own thermal expansion.
The thermal expansion is influenced by transitions in the crystal structure of the material
Due to the different thermal expansion coefficients of each of the concrete constituents, internal
stresses develop in heated concrete.
When heated, the cement paste is forced to follow the expansion of the aggregate. This causes tensile
stresses in the cement paste, and leads to a finely distributed network of micro-cracks inside the cement
paste.
The compressive strength of concrete at elevated temperatures is not purely a function of the
temperature. Also, the history of heating and mechanical loading plays a role. A moderate compressive
stress (up to about 30% of fck at room temperature) in the concrete during heating has a positive effect
on the remaining compression strength.
The combination of heating and compressive loading leads to an additional (negative)strain component,
called load induced thermal strain (LITS). This strain component is irreversible, which means that during
cooling down the strain is not recovered.
The exposed surface of the concrete reaches a temperature that is close to the fire (convection +
radiation) temperature. However, deeper into the concrete the temperature is much lower.
This temperature difference lead to Eigen stresses.
It is steel reinforcement that prevents the concrete structure form cracking completely when heated. As
long as the reinforcement is protected from the heat by the concrete cover, the concrete structure will
retain part of its load bearing capacity.
The Eurocode (EN 1992-1-2) contains different calculation methods. In all methods, the effect of thermal
(Eigen) stresses and resulting cracks are neglected. This is a reasonable assumption as long as steel
reinforcement is applied so that thermal cracks do not lead to immediate failure.
Spalling may lead to collapse of the structure if the steel reinforcement is no longer sufficiently
protected by concrete, or if the concrete cross-section is no longer able to resist the compressive loads.
The causes of spalling are a complex interaction of several phenomena. When concrete is heated,
stresses may build up due to two causes:
Thermal expansion of the concrete
Eigen stresses in a heated structure lead to a high level of compression close to the exposed surface, in
the direction parallel to the surface. This compression may be so high that compressive failure occurs in
the most heated part of the concrete.
Pressure inside the pores in the concrete, due to expansion and evaporation of pore water.
The heated water will expand much more than the concrete itself, so to understand the effect of pore
water (moisture) pressures, we may consider the volume of the pores as constant.
At the same time, the strength of the concrete is reduced due to the high temperature.
When a layer of concrete spalls off due to pore pressures and thermal stresses, a new concrete surface
is exposed to fire and the process starts all over again. Therefore, spalling is often progressive, eating
away the concrete layer by layer.
The build-up of water pressure in the pores may also take more time, and reach a deeper level. This is
for example the case if during the fire more and more water is pushed ever deeper into the concrete,
until a level of saturation is reached that leads to an explosion deep in the concrete.
In order to avoid spalling of concrete, a possible solution is the application of an external insulation
layer, also called passive fire protection. By applying an insulation material on the surface of the
concrete, the flow of thermal energy towards the concrete can be strongly reduced, meaning that the
concrete heats up slower.
In the case of concrete protected with a layer of passive fire protection, the concrete surface is in fact
the location of the interface between concrete and fire protection. Therefore, the temperature on this
location is usually referred to as the interface temperature.
A concrete structure that is heated relatively fast may spall sooner than a concrete structure that is
heated slower.
If a passive fire protection is chosen in order to avoid spalling, it is necessary to apply sufficient thickness
to completely avoid spalling.
For the effectiveness of a fire protection system it should be note that not only the type of insulation
material is important but also the way that is applied and the conditions under which it has to function.
Another commonly applied measure to reduce or prevent spalling of concrete during fire is by adding
special types of polypropylene (PP) fibres to the concrete mix. From many fire tests it has become clear
that PP fibres can have the effect of reduction of spalling, even though the exact theory behind the
effectiveness is not fully clear. The most likely theory is that PP fibres reduce the pressure inside the
pores, because the fibres melt due to the heat and then a permeable network is formed that allows for
the water to escape from the concrete.
The effectiveness of PP fibres against spalling is strongly dependent on other factors, such as the
geometry, concrete mix, mechanical loading and fire curve. PP fibres mainly influence the flow of water
through the concrete. However they have no significant influence on the temperature distribution inside
the concrete and the resulting stresses due to thermal expansion. Therefore, PP-fibres do not prevent
internal cracking on structural scale or micro-scale, chemical deterioration and spalling if primarily
caused by thermal stresses.
The effectiveness of fibres against spalling varies from case to case, and can only be proven by fire tests
representative for the specific situation.
Apart from adding PP fibres to the concrete mix, there are other improvements that can be made in
order to make a concrete mix less sensitive to spalling. These improvements all have to do with thermal
expansion and permeability for pore water. The most important parameters are briefly described:
Type of coarse aggregate
Maximum diameter of the coarse aggregate
Fine fillers such as silica fume and fly ash strongly reduce the permeability of the concrete, and
increase the spalling behaviour significantly
Water cement ratio
The only method to determine spalling behaviour of a specific concrete structure under exposure to a
given temperature time curve is by performing fire tests.
In some cases, creating the test specimens for a representative test in a fire laboratory is not feasible.
This is for example the case with existing structures, where the exact mix of the concrete cannot be
reproduced anymore, or in case of very large concrete elements or large travel distance to a fire lab. In
that case, a mobile furnace can be applied. A mobile furnace applies the fire temperatures directly to
the surface of the actual structure.
Fire damage to concrete can be prevented by applying an external fire protection system. For example a
fire protective board, a spray mortar or a reactive coating. Each system has the aim of reducing the
amount of heat that flows into the concrete, and as such to limit the temperatures that occur in the
concrete during the fire.
Types of systems:
Sprinkler system
A sprinkler system suppresses or extinguishes the fire by spraying relatively large droplets of water,
sometimes mixed with foam, usually form sprinkler heads in the ceiling or in racks.
Water mist system
A water mist system suppresses or extinguishes the fire by spraying relatively small droplets of water,
usually from sprinkler heads in the ceiling.
Water cannons
A system with water cannons (controlled or otherwise) suppresses or extinguishes the fire by spraying
relatively concentrated jets of relatively large water droplets, sometimes mixed with foam. The
extinguishes monitors/water cannons are mounted on a wall or on the ceiling, or on consoles, and are
controlled manually (by remote control) or automatically.
Foam extinguishing system
A foam fire extinguishing system suppresses or extinguishes the fire by spreading a layer of foam that
covers the space, and thus the fire as well, in whole or in part. This is often done through foam
generators or nozzles/sprinkler heads fitted to the ceiling.
Gas extinguishing system
A gas fire extinguishing system s suppresses or extinguishes the fire by filling the whole space with a gas
that suppresses combustion. The gas is blown into the space from a bottle-cell battery and a pipe
network. Certain gases dilute oxygen while others work on the combustion reaction.
Powder and aerosol extinguishing systems
A powder fire extinguishing system suppresses or extinguishes the fire. The powder for sort of system is
spread through nozzles/generators using an inert gas.
An aerosol fire extinguishing system suppresses or extinguishes the fire by filling the whole space with a
very fine powder that is sucked into the fire. Aerosols are produced by heating a solid or liquid in
separate units that are spread over the space.
Obstacles to the free rise of the plume of smoke or the free horizontal spread of smoke in the smoke
buffer must be included in the model if that means that more cold air is mixed in.
In a finite element model, a construction is divided into small elements. The model can calculate
temperatures as well as stresses and strains in solid materials by solving fundamental equations.
In a thermal finite element model, the internal temperature distribution inside the
construction as a function of time is calculated. As the model calculates the temperature distribution
inside the construction, the boundary conditions at the edges must be defined. These boundary
conditions can be heat transfer through radiation and convection, and may vary in time.
A thermal finite element model can be coupled with a CFD model. The CFD model then calculates the
convection and radiation conditions resulting from the fire, as function of time and space. And these
conditions are then imposed on the boundaries of the finite element model.