Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
com
Abstract
The product formed on weathering steel exposed to salt lake atmosphere for 12 months was investigated by X-ray diraction (XRD),
infrared transmission spectroscopy (IRS), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), electron probe micro analyzer (EPMA) and electrochemical techniques. The rust was mainly composed of b-FeOOH, Fe8(O,OH)16Cl1.3 and a little c-FeOOH. Amorphous d-FeOOH
was only on skyward surface. The rust layer suppressed anodic reaction and facilitated the cathodic reaction. The very small value of
rust resistance Rr in this work indicated that the rust had poor protective ability. Cl element was rich in the whole rust layer and played
an important role in accelerating the corrosion of weathering steel in salt lake atmosphere.
2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: A. Weathering steel; C. Atmospheric corrosion; C. Salt lake
1. Introduction
Weathering steel is often used in the atmospheric
environment without paint or other protective coatings.
Atmospheric corrosion is an important cause of destruction of weathering steel constructions and has received
much interest in recent years [1,2]. When the same steel
is exposed to dierent environments, the characteristics
of corrosion products vary due to dierent environmental factors [3]. Therefore, it is signicant to study the
rust on weathering steel in a given atmospheric
environment.
Studies on atmospheric corrosion of weathering steels
have been carried out in many countries [111]. Wang
et al. investigated the corrosion of weathering steel
exposed to industrial atmosphere for 6 years in Taiwan
and concluded that the phase transformation of c-FeOOH into a-FeOOH contributed to the resistance of the
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +86 24 2389 3544; fax: +86 24 2389 4149.
E-mail address: qxli@imr.ac.cn (Q.X. Li).
0010-938X/$ - see front matter 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.corsci.2007.06.020
366
Table 1
Environmental conditions of the exposure location
Average temperature
(C year1)
Average rainfall
(mm year1)
Average evaporation
(mm year1)
Saline particles
(mg m2 day1)
Natural deposition
(g cm2 month1)
Soluble
17.5
a
b
38.3
3067.0
19.16
23.19
Insoluble
20.98b
The data were reported by Communication of National Network for Environment Corrosion Survey of Materials, China.
Average of natural deposition values in a year were provided by Wuhan Institute for Materials Protection, Wuhan, China.
2. Experimental methods
2.3. Analysis of the rust layer
2.1. Atmospheric rusting
Corten A weathering steel was selected and its composition (wt.%) is C 0.09, S 0.005, P 0.081, Mn 0.35, Si 0.3, Cr
0.48, Ni 0.27, Cu 0.28, Al 0.037 and Fe balance. The four
parallel samples (three for weight loss measurement and
one for rust layer analysis) were cut into the sizes of
100 mm 50 mm 5 mm and degreased with acetone. In
order to completely evaporate the water on the surface,
these samples were cleaned with ethanol and then kept in
a desiccator for at least 24 h. After the treatments, the samples were weighed using analytic balance (the precision is
0.0001 g). Samples for electrochemical analysis were
mounted in epoxy resin at room temperature and the
exposed area was 1 cm2. The electrode samples were
ground on SiC paper successively to 1000 grit and then
cleaned with ethanol.
The exposure site was located on the roof of an oce
building about 40 m far away from the salt lake. The environmental parameters of the exposure locations are listed
in Table 1. The weathering steel samples were exposed to
south at an angle of 45 to horizontal under open conditions. After 12 months, the samples were taken back for
analysis.
2.2. Analysis of the rust powder
The rusts formed on the steel surfaces were characterized by means of infrared transmission spectroscopy
1
The value was measured by Inspection and Testing Center for Agroproduct Safety and Environment Quality, Institute of Applied Ecology,
CAS.
367
exhibited dierence: they were 52 lm and 65 lm, respectively. Therefore, it can be concluded that after 12 months
of exposure, the corrosion on eld-ward surface was more
severe than that on skyward surface.
SEM observation of the rusted steel surface (Fig. 2) further conrmed the above conclusion. Compared with that
on the skyward rust layer, the surface on the eld-ward rust
layer was rougher and contained more cavities.
EDX analysis was carried out on more than ve dierent positions of the rust layer and the average contents of
elements contained in the rust layer were obtained (Table
2). The foreign elements O, Mg, Al, Si, Cl, K, and Ca were
detected in both eld-ward and skyward rust layers. And
their contents in the rust of skyward surface were lower
than that of eld-ward surface. Generally, skyward surface
favored deposition of pollutant particles. However, comparing with eld-ward surface, the skyward surface was
subjected to more radiation by sun and more removal by
rain and wind. This resulted in the lower content of contaminations retained in the skyward rust.
Based on the above results, more severe corrosion of
eld-ward surface can be explained as the following factors. First factor is that the rust layer on eld-ward surface
is rougher and more porous than that on skyward surface.
Such phenomenon was also found in Refs. [12,13]. More
porous structure of eld-ward rust layers lead to less barrier against the ingress of precipitation and chlorides pollutants and higher corrosion rate. Second factor is the larger
amounts of polluted particles retained in the eld-ward
rust. The pollutants diused through the rust to the
metal/rust interface (conrmed by EPMA in Fig. 3) and
accelerated steel corrosion during wetting. Third is the formation of amorphous d-FeOOH only in the skyward rust
(see Fig. 5). Amorphous d-FeOOH is helpful to inhibit
the corrosion of weathering steel [14].
To determine the distributions of elements in the rust on
the steel, the EPMA analysis was performed. The results
are shown in Fig. 3. A large amount of Cl and a little S
were detected in the rust and Cl had diused to the interface between the rust and substrate. Therefore, it can be
postulated that Cl played an important role in the corrosion of weathering steel in the salt lake atmosphere. Si, Al,
Fig. 2. Scanning electron micrograph of the rust layer on weathering steel exposed to the salt lake atmosphere: (a) the skyward surface and (b) the eldward surface.
368
Table 2
Average contents (wt.%) of elements containing in corrosion product
Element
O
Mg
Al
Si
Cl
K
Ca
Fe
Content
Skyward surface
Field-ward surface
4.51
1.15
0.87
2.13
1.58
0.76
0.81
88.50
5.74
2.07
3.47
8.34
3.60
1.72
0.97
75.60
Fig. 4 shows the X-ray diraction patterns of the powdered rust formed on the weathering steels. The rust layers
on both surfaces were mainly composed of akaganeite (bFeOOH; JCPDS card # 34-1266), complex compound
Fe8(O,OH)16Cl1.3 (JCPDS card # 42-1315), and a little lepidocrocite (c-FeOOH; JCPDS card # 44-1415). In addition, the quartz was also found in the rust layers.
IR spectra were used to analyze the composition of the
powered rust (shown in Fig. 5). The main absorb peaks
were characterized according to the reported spectra of
iron oxides [8,18,19]. The main compositions of the rust
on both surfaces were b-FeOOH and c-FeOOH. Amorphous d-FeOOH was found only in the skyward rust.
Fe8(O,OH)16Cl1.3 was not examined because no IR data
Fig. 3. The distribution of O, Cl, S, Si, Ca, Mg, Fe, Cr, Ni and Cu in the rust formed on skyward surface of 12 months old weathering steel. Back scatter
electron image (BSEI) of the analyzed portion is shown in (a).
for Fe8(O,OH)16Cl1.3 can be obtained in the public literatures. Compared with that of the eld-ward rust, the peaks
of the skyward rust were broader and weaker, indicating
that the skyward rust was poorly crystallized. The absorption band at the vicinity of 1630 cm1 demonstrated that
all corrosion products contained a considerable amount
of bound water [8,19].
The results of XRD and IR indicated that a large
amount of b-FeOOH was present in the rust, which is associated with the high concentration of Cl in the Qinghai
salt lake atmosphere. This is due to the facts that the formation of b-FeOOH needs halogen ions such as Cl and
F, which stabilize the tunnel structure of b-FeOOH crystals [6,9,14]. b-FeOOH is considered to be the most detrimental to corrosion resistance of steel among the ferric
oxyhydroxides [2].
Generally, a-FeOOH is present in the rust of weathering
steel. However, in this work, no a-FeOOH was detected in
the XRD and IR spectra of rusts. This may be associated
with the chlorides-rich atmosphere of salt lake region. It
is well established that the content of b-FeOOH in rust
increased with increasing the concentration of Cl in the
environment [6,9,14]. Therefore, most Fe involved in the
corrosion reaction may be transformed into b-FeOOH,
resulting in the little amount of a-FeOOH in rusts. In addition, the transformation from c-FeOOH to a-FeOOH
requires several years [7,8]. In present work, the exposure
time is one year, which is not sucient for the formation
of a-FeOOH.
To determine the protective characteristics of the rust
layers, electrochemical measurements were performed on
bare and rusted electrodes. Polarization results are shown
in Fig. 6. Compared with that of naked steel, the corrosion
potential of the rusted sample became more positive. And
its anodic currents decreased. In addition, with the increase
of potential, the current density of the rusted sample
increased and then decreased at about 0.034 V. When
the potential further increased to the range of 0.40
0.75 V. the current density almost kept stable indicating
369
370
nrust
Y rust jx
1
Rr
1
1
Y dl jxndl 1=Rt Z w
where Yrust and nrust, Ydl and ndl are constants representing
the elements Qrust and Qdl, respectively, Zw is the Warburg
resistance. Zw is represented as follows [22]:
Z w Aw jx
0:5
Z Rs
1
Y dl jx
ndl
1=Rt
Table 3
Fitting data of impedance parameters in equivalent circuits
Samples
Rs (X cm2)
ndl
Rt (X cm2)
Rr (X cm2)
nrust
Aw (X cm2 s1/2)
Naked
Rusted
23.34
38.59
0.90
1.17
0.81
0.51
891.4
23.34
6.57
9.106
0.53
0.018
Fe-2e
H2O+O2+4e
Fe2+
4OH-
Oxidation withoutelimination of Cl
deliquescence (Mg,Na,K)Cln
Cl
-FeOOH
Fe8(O,OH)16Cl1.3
GRI(Fe(OH,Cl)2.55)
Air oxidation
Rapid oxidation
and dehydration
-FeOOH.
-FeOOH
amorphous
Fig. 11. Model of initial rusting process for weathering steel in salt lake atmosphere.
371