EVIDENCE CASE ASSIGNMENTS

2016-2017
RULE 128: GENERAL PROVISIONS
Section 1
Miguel vs. Catalino
Section 2
Ong Chia vs. Republic
Section 3
Atienza vs. Board of Medicine
People vs. Yatco
People vs. Valdez
People vs. Ador
Zulueta vs. CA
Salcedo-Ortanez vs. CA
Section 4
Chua Cheng vs. Collector
People vs. Tumimpad
People vs. Sartagoda
People vs. Carpo
RULE 130:
SECTION 1: OBJECT EVIDENCE
Tijing vs. CA
Sison vs People
Phil. Movie Pictures vs Premier
US vs Tan Teng
7081
Villaflor vs Summers
People vs Ruiz
People vs Teehankee
People vs Codilla
DNA evidence:
People vs Vallejo
People vs Yatar
Lucas vs Lucas
Chain of custody rule
People vs. Kamad
Mallilin vs People
People vs Watamama

L-23072

November 29, 1968

127240

March 27, 2000

177407
138388
129296
140538
253 SCRA 699
110662

February 9, 2011
March 19, 2002
September 25, 2000
June 14, 2004

L-9853
109144
97525
132676

December 4, 1914
August 19, 1994
April 7, 1993
April 4, 2001

August 4, 1994

125901
108280
L-5621

March 8, 2001
Nov. 16, 1995
March 25, 1953
Sept. 7, 1912
16444
Sept 8, 1920
L-33609
Dec. 14, 1981
111206
Oct. 6, 1995
100720
June 30, 1993
144656
150224
190710

May 9, 2002
May 19, 2004
June 6, 2011

174198
172953
194945

Jan. 19, 2010

April 30, 2008
July 30, 2012

RULE 130: DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE

SECTIONS 3-4: BEST EVIDENCE RULE
Arceo vs People
142641
Ebreo vs Ebreo
160065
SSS vs Aguas
165546
Villarta vs CA
L-36543
Trans-Pacific vs CA
235 SCRA 494
Ramos vs CA
L-64129
People vs Tandoy
192 SCRA 28
Fiscal vs Reyes
L-35366
Heirs vs Cormoposa
408 SCRA 692
Hernaez vs McGrath
L-4044
Mahilum vs CA
L-17970
People vs Cruz
L-13219
People vs Tan
L-14257
SECTIONS 5-8: SECONDARY EVIDENCE
Jacob vs CA
135216
Citibank vs Teodoro
150905
Rodelas vs Aranza
L-58509

July 17, 2006

February 28, 2006
February 27, 2006
July 27, 1988
Nov. 18, 1991
Aug. 5, 1931
July 9, 1952
June 30, 1966
Aug. 31, 1960
July 31, 1959
Aug 19, 1999
Sept 23, 2003
Dec 7, 1982

Edsa Shangrila vs BF
145842
June 27, 2008
Gabatan vs People
150206
March 13, 2009
SECTION 9: PAROL EVIDENCE RULE
Cruz vs CA
192 SCRA 209
Inciong vs CA
96405
June 26, 1996
Lechugas vs CA
L-39972
Aug 8, 1986
Remalante vs Tibe
158 SCRA 138
Limketkai vs CA
118509
Sept 5, 1996
Bonilla vs Aranza
L-58509
December 7, 1982
BPI vs Fidelity
L-26743
Oct 19, 1927
Mactan vs CA
121506
Oct 20, 1996
Borillo vs CA
55691
May 21, 1992
RULE 132: AUTHENTICATION AND PROOF OF DOCUMENTS
SECTIONS 19-33: PRIVATE AND PUBLIC DOCUMENTS
Pacific Asia vs NLRC
L-76595
June 6, 1988
Zalamea vs CA
104235
Nov 18, 1993
People vs Monleon
L-36282
Dec 10, 1976
People vs Salison
115690
Feb 20, 1996
People vs Lazaro
112090
Oct 26, 1999
IBM vs NLRC
117221
April 13, 1999
Cequena vs Bolante
137944
April 6, 2000
Sanson vs CA
127745
April 22, 2003
People vs Pagpaguitan
116599
Sept 27, 1999
Siguan vs Lim
134685
Nov 19, 1999
Parma vs CA
109370
July 11, 1995
Wildvalley vs CA
119602
Oct 6, 2000
People vs Tomaquin
133188
July 23, 2004
Heirs of Lacsa vs CA
79597
May 20, 1991
ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE:
National Power vs Codilla
MCC Industrial vs Saangyong
Magtolis vs Salud

170491
April 4, 2007
170633
Oct 17, 2007
AM No. CA-05-20-P
Sept 9, 2005

1991 REVISED RULE ON SUMMARY PROCEDURE:

Balayon vs Ocampo
AM No. MTJ-91-619
Jan 29, 1993
Bayubay vs CA
105866
July 6, 1993
RULE 130: TESTIMONIAL EVIDENCE
SECTION 20: QUALIFICATION OF WITNESS
People vs Abellera
L-23533
People vs Dominguez
100199

Aug 1, 1925
Jan 18, 1993

DISQUALIFICATION OF WITNESSES:
SECTION 21: MENTAL INCAPACITY OR IMMATURITY
People vs Espanola
119308
April 18, 1997
People vs Rodico
107101
Oct 16, 1995
SECTION 22: MARITAL DISQUALIFICATION
US vs Concepcion
L-10396
July 29, 1915
Ordono vs Daquigan
L-39012
Jan 31, 1975
Ortiz vs Araburo
3143
March 21, 1907
SECTION 23: DEAD MANS STATUTE
Guerrero vs St Claires
L-58164
Sept 2, 1983
Razon vs IAC
74306
March 16, 1992
SECTION 24: PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATION:
Marital privileged communication:
US vs Antipolo
L-13109
March 6, 1918
Attorney-client privilege:
People vs Sandiganbayan
115439
July 16, 1997
Regala vs Sandiganbayan
September 20, 1996

Doctor-patient privilege:
Gonzales vs CA
117740
Lim vs CA
214 SCRA 23
State secrets:
Banco Filipino vs Monetary
70054
SECTION 25: PARENTAL AND FILIAL PRIVILEGE
People vs Invencion
131636
BANK DEPOSITS:
Brunner vs Abrogar
107491

Oct 30, 1998

July 8, 1986
March 5, 2003
Feb 21, 1994

SECTIONS 26-33: ADMISSIONS AND CONFESSIONS

Viacrucis vs CA
L-29831
March 29, 1972
People vs Alegre
L-30423
Nov 7, 1979
People vs Godoy
115908
Dec. 29, 1995
People vs Yparraguirre
117702
Feb 10, 1997
People vs Raquel
11905
Dec 2, 1996
People vs Damaso
116084
March 9, 2000
People vs Yatco
L-9181
Nov 28, 1955
People vs Serrano
L-7973
April 27, 1959
People vs Garcia
138470
April 1, 2003
RULE 133, SECTION 3: EXTRAJUDICIAL CONFESSION
People vs Compil
95028
May 15, 1995
People vs Wong
12801
April 12, 1996
People vs Maqueda
112983
March 22, 1995
People vs Encipido
70091
Dec 29, 1986
RULE 130:
SECTION 36: HEARSAY RULE
People vs Gaddi
People vs Franco

74065
118607

Feb 27, 1989

March 4, 1997

EXCEPTIONS TO THE HEARSAY RULE:

SECTION 37: DYING DECLARATION
People vs Laquinon
L-45470
Feb 28, 1985
People vs Salison
115690
Feb 20, 1996
Marturillas vs People
163217
April 18, 2006
SECTION 38: DECLARATION AGAINST INTEREST
Lazaro vs Agustin
152364
April 15, 2010
People vs Majuri
L-38833
March 12, 1980
Fuentes vs CA
111692
Feb 9, 1996
Cavite vs Hong
179540
March 13, 2009
SECTION 39: PEDIGREE
Tison vs CA
121027
July 31, 1997
People vs Alegado
93030
Aug 21, 1991
SECTION 40: FAMILY TRADITION
Ferrer vs Inchausti
L-12993
Oct. 28, 1918
People vs Albalate Jr
174480
Dec 18, 2009
SECTION 41: COMMON REPUTATION
Jison vs CA
124853
Feb 24, 1998
SECTION 42: RES GESTAE
People vs Lungayan
L-64556
June 10, 1988
People vs Putian
L-33049
Nov 29, 1976
SECTION 43: ENTRIES IN THE COURSE OF BUSINESS
Jose vs Michaelmar
169606
Nov 27, 2009
Landbank vs Monets
184971
April 19, 2010
SECTION 44; OFFICIAL RECORDS
Africa vs Caltex
L-12986
March 31, 1966
People vs Leones
L-4877
Sept 30, 1982
SECTION 45: COMMERCIAL LISTS

PNOC vs CA
107518
Oct 8, 1998
SECTION 47: PRIOR TESTIMONY
Manliclic vs Calaunan
150157
Jan 25, 2007
SECTIONS 48-50: OPINION RULE
People vs Adoviso
116196
June 23, 1999
People vs Abriol
123137
Oct 17, 2001
People vs Baid
129667
July 31, 2000
Tabao vs People
187246
July 20, 2011
RULE 130, SECTIONS 34, 35, 51: CHARACTER EVIDENCE
RULE 132, SECTION 14
People vs Santos
100225
May 11, 1993
People vs Nardo
133888
March 1, 2001
People vs Lee
382 SCRA 596
People vs Edualino
119072
April 11, 1997
People vs Deopita
130601
Dec 4, 2000
RULE 132: EXAMINATION OF WITNESSES
SECTIONS 1-2: EXAMINATION IN OPEN COURT
P vs Estenzo
L-41166
August 25, 1976
Galman vs Pamaran
71208
Aug. 30, 1985
SECTION 6: CROSS EXAMINATION
Dela Paz vs CA
71537
Sept. 17, 1987
Fulgado vs CA
L-61570
Feb. 12, 1990
SECTION 9: RECALLING WITNESS
P vs del Castillo
L-16941
Oct. 29, 1968
P vs Rivera
98376
Aug. 16, 1991
P vs dela Cruz
78582
June 10, 1987
Carredo vs P
77542
March 19, 1990
P vs Rodriguez
90255
Jan. 23, 1991
SECTION 10: LEADING QUESTION
P vs Cana
139229
April 22, 2002
Limaco vs Shonan
158245
June 30, 2005
P vs Chaves
131377
Feb. 11, 2003
Gomez vs Gomez-Samson
156284
Feb. 6, 2007
SECTIONS 11-12: IMPEACHMENT BY BIAS
US vs Abel
469 US 45
US vs Harvey
547 F.2d 419
De Leon vs P
66020
June 22, 1991
P vs Aranda
100985
Sept. 17, 1993
Gaw vs Chua
160855
April 16, 2008
P vs Malimit
109775
Nov. 14, 1996
P vs Montejo
133475
March 26, 2001
P vs Peralta
128116
Jan. 24, 2001
SECTION 13: IMPEACHMENT BY PRIOR INCONSISTENT STATEMENT
Villalon vs IAC
L-73751
Sept. 24, 1986
P vs Resabal
26708
Sept. 29, 1927
P vs Sambaho
182789
Aug. 3, 2010
P vs Antonio
128900
July 14, 2000
SECTION 15: EXCLUSION OF WITNESSES
P vs Palacio
L-13933
May 25, 1960
P vs Sandal
32394
Sept. 5, 1930
SUMMARY PROCEDURE:
Balayon vs Ocampo
Bayubay vs CA

AM MTJ-91-619
105866

Jan. 29, 1993

July 6, 1993

CHILD WITNESS RULE:

P vs Santos
P vs Rama

172322
136304

Sept. 8, 2006
Jan. 25, 2001

P vs Baring
P vs Caete
RULE 131
SECTION 1: BURDEN OF PROOF
Parel vs Prudencio
P vs Pajenado
P vs Verzola
P vs Garcia
Jison vs CA
P vs Mediado
SECTION 3: PRESUMPTIONS
P vs Padiernos
Titan Construction vs David
P vs de Jesus
Burgos vs Pres. Arroyo
Marques vs Far East
Santos vs National
Ampatuan vs P
P vs delos Reyes
Filipinas vs delos Santos
RULE 129: JUDICIAL NOTICE
JUDICIAL NOTICE
Occidental vs CA
Baguio vs vda. De Jalagat
Yao Kee vs Sy-Gonzales
EXCEPTIONS TO JUDICIAL NOTICE
Tabuena vs CA
Fule vs CA
P vs Godoy
JUDICIAL ADMISSION
Torres vs CA

137933
142930

Jan. 28, 2002

March 28, 2003

146556
L-27680
L-35022
173480
124853
169871

April 19, 2006

Feb. 27, 1970
Dec. 21, 1977
Feb. 25, 2009
Feb. 24, 1998
Feb. 2, 2011

L-37284
615 SCRA 362
93852
183711
171379
171129
183676
174774
152033

Feb. 27, 1976

Jan. 24, 1992
July 5, 2011
Jan. 10, 2011
April 6, 2011
June 22, 2011
Aug. 31, 2011
March 16, 2011

220 SCRA 167

42 SCRA 337
167 SCRA 736
196 SCRA 656
162 SCRA 446
115908

Dec. 6, 1995

L-37420

July 31, 1984

RULE 132:
SECTIONS 34-40: OFFER AND OBJECTION
Interpacific vs Aviles
86062
Delos Reyes vs IAC
74768
Vda de Onate vs CA
116149
Sabanpan vs Comorposa
152807
Catacutan vs P
175991
Pasag vs Parocha
155483
SECTION 35:
P vs Ancheta
143935
P vs Siscar
L-55649
P vs Cadocio
L-106197

June 6, 1990
Aug. 11, 1989
Nov. 23, 1995
Aug. 12, 2003
Aug. 31, 2011
April 27, 2007
June 4, 2004
Dec. 3, 1985
Dec. 17, 1993

RULE 133: SECTIONS 1-7: WEIGHT AND SUFFICIENCY OF EVIDENCE

Pealber vs Ramos
178645
Jan. 30, 2009
P vs Pabol
187084
Oct. 12, 2009
P vs Rubio
179748
Oct. 2, 2009
Formantes vs Duncan
170661
Dec. 4, 2009
P vs Chingh
178323
March 16, 2011
P vs Quintal
184170
Feb. 2, 2011
Republic vs De
175021
June 15, 2011
Capiral vs Robles
173628
Nov. 16, 2011
Tolentino vs Loyola
153809
July 27, 2011
P vs Ocden
173198
June 1, 2011
Republic vs Sandiganbayan
152154
July 15, 2003