"What Degrees of Freedom Are Being Curbed - " - T5E - The Fifth Estate - IIT Madras' Campus News Body

11/26/12
What degrees of freedom are being curbed? | T5E - The Fifth Estate | IIT Madras' Campus News Body
Home
About Us
Subscribe
Events
Contribute
Links
Hindi T5E About Us
ReNEWS
TechSoc Points Tally
Feedback
Search the archive...
Placements
YouPhoria
Interviews
Freshies
Tech
Sports
Litsoc
Videos
Hindi
Home Dean's Column, Featured
What degrees of freedom are being curbed?

11 November 2012 44 Comments
Like
269
Tw eet
Email
StumbleUpon
Following the discussion on entry of visitors into hostel rooms, T5E interviewed the Dean of Students, Prof. L. S. Ganesh, who answered some questions that many students had to ask.
Following is a transcript of the interview:
Tw eet
T5E: Sir, could you elaborate more about the rule?

LSG: The Council of Wardens (CoW), in its recent meeting, unanimously proposed the policy of permitting entry of girl students into specifically earmarked visitors rooms in our boys
hostels, rather than into any of the boys rooms. While the necessary facilities are created, the hostel common room could serve as a visitors room. Some of the student representatives
The SAC Speaker, SGS, HAS, and Sharavati General Secretary who were invited to the meeting voiced their opinions and concerns, and presented supporting points for encouraging
healthy academic and personal interactions among our male and female students for their holistic development as mature individuals. As of now, entry of girls into the rooms of their male
StumbleUpon
friends/classmates is permitted in the night until 09:00 p.m. The proposal to modify the existing policy has to be discussed further within our Institute administration before a final decision
Submit
in this matter is officially stated and implemented.
T5E: Why is this policy being considered now for implementation?
LSG: As Ive stated, the policy is yet to be implemented. However, keeping in mind the possible concerns among some of our students, I wish to add that there are certain well-established
traditions and norms in Indian society that the CoW, and all of us, must uphold in our campus. At the same time, we must carefully balance these traditions with the evolving, modern
socio-cultural realities. We are sincerely trying to find feasible middle ground between these two differing positions of traditions and modernity. Keeping in mind the best interests of our
Institute, students, and their parents, the CoW has proposed this policy. However, we genuinely want to encourage healthy interactions among our girls and boys for academic and
socio-cultural activities, thus the idea of visitors rooms emerged. Of course, please let us note that our entire campus and the numerous facilities are open to use by our students for these
interactions; the proposed visitors rooms is one more option that we are providing as an alternative to the boys rooms.
students.iitm.ac.in/thefifthestate/2012/11/interview-dos/
1/22
11/26/12
T5E: Why were the statistics of the Colloquium poll and discussion not considered? Doesnt it indicate that students views were not given any importance?
LSG: Less than 600 students out of 7000+ have taken that poll. Could we please analyse the academic and socio-cultural composition of the sample? So, statistically speaking, prima facie
Id suspect both, a bias among the respondents and a non-response bias in the results. Moreover, given the stakeholders related to, and the nature and scope of this issue, why should
the poll be conducted only among students? What would the results be, had parents and our faculty also participated in it? As far as students views are concerned, we did invite student
representatives to the meeting. They were asked to suggest compelling reasons in support of girls being permitted access into boys rooms, and they could not come up with any. We are
and will be open to any relevant suggestions/alternatives that any of you can give.
T5E: Many students see this as moral policing and curbing of freedom
LSG: I want the students to answer a few questions:
(a) What degrees of freedom are being curbed now, and how, in terms of our students boys and girls having/gaining access to and use of our Institutes facilities and infrastructure
like hostels, library, labs, eateries, classrooms, stadium, play-fields, OAT, lecture halls, roads, nooks and corners, etc?
(b) When, where and how has the administration ever stopped our students boys and girls from socializing?
(c) Have our boys and girls holding hands or putting their arms around each other while walking on the roads, or even embracing each other, ever been stopped from decent,
acceptable public show of affection?
If indeed, there have been incidents of any curtailment of such degrees of freedom, I would urge you to call me anytime, and I will intervene directly and appropriately. I have clearly
discussed with some officers in our Security Section to instruct all the Institute and contract security personnel to respect individuals personal freedom and space, even when public
show of affection within decent, acceptable limits is noticed. We respect the need for our students to be encouraged to interact with each other, academically and otherwise. We do offer
them more than ample space and facilities to do so. In fact, starting with this academic year, girl students have been given the choice to dine in boys messes too. Moral policing is
certainly a most inappropriate term in this context.
T5E: Students feel they are not being treated as responsible adults. What would you like to say to that?
LSG: The students need to understand themselves a lot first, which is quite a challenge. Unlike Western society, most parents in India do not raise their children to be independent, selfgoverned adults. We continue to raise our children in a protective environment, with only some degrees of freedom. In India, the legal age for adulthood is 18, but, how many parents
(faculty members) will truly accept that their wards (students) are responsible for themselves at that age? When parents leave their children here, they expect the administration to
understand this and accordingly treat their wards. We have had stray incidents of parents blaming the administration for undesirable incidents. Your child is a responsible adult; he/she
should have considered the short-term and long-term consequences before making the mistake would parents accept such a statement from our administration? They would sharply
criticize our administration for letting the possibility of the mistake be realized in the first place. Thats how most Indian parents are, and we have faced this sometimes in the past. My
opinion is that Indian adolescents think that they are responsible adults, while we elders know that they are not. After all, we elders can certainly reflect upon our adolescent days and
recall our experiences and their consequences. Naturally, we are eager to guide our children and youth to avoid the high probability, undesirable effects of their thoughts, words and
actions.
T5E: Is there anything else you want to convey to the students?
LSG: Please have faith in our leadership and administration, and trust us teachers. First and foremost, we act in the best short-term and long-term interests of our Institute. Certainly, we
are your well wishers and will not mislead or misguide you. We must realize that ours is an institution of national importance, although we enjoy autonomy in many areas, we are
answerable to the general public, and to the authorities that represent the general public. The IIT tag gets you, me and everyone in our institute a lot of respect in our society, but it also
subjects us to lot of legitimate expectations from the same society. Our students enjoy enough freedom and facilities, much more than their friends in most other colleges. We want all of
you to use this freedom for personal development in all fields personal health, academics, sports, leadership and socio-cultural activities. Why? Because you young folk must be the
prime movers of Indias competitive strength and capacity in global markets and forums. While I certainly do not wish to divert from the theme of this interview, I wish to underscore the
fact that India is languishing in the bottom decile of competitiveness. Wake up! Work with purpose, with determination and conviction. Work harder and harder, smarter and smarter.
Work for the day, which may even be realized in your lifetimes (certainly not mine, for I have but a few years more to say bye! bye!), when India will be the go to place for everyone for
every moral, ethical, socio-cultural and civilisational reason.
T5E conducted a small video survey (Vox Populi) about this issue. Click here to view it.
Also read Adulthood and Responsibility, an opinion piece written by an alumnus of IIT Madras in context of the same issue.
Rating: 3.9/5 (31 votes cast)
Add a comment...
Post to Facebook
Kaushik Viswanath
Posting as Vinay Yadav (Change)
Comment
Subscribe Indian Institute of Technology Madras
The reason to allow female students into male students' rooms is simple: privacy. In demanding
"compelling reasons" to allow girls into boys' rooms, the administration is essentially asking to know
what goes on behind closed doors. With all due respect, mind your own business. Adults have a
reasonable right to privacy, and asking what they want the privacy for is in itself a violation of that
right.
The Dean asks if boys and girls have ever been stopped from displaying a decent, acceptable public
show of affection. This is problematic on three counts: 1) Yes, they have. 2) Decent and acceptable
by whose standards? 3) Not everyone wants to display their affection publicly.
Let the Dean not mince his words: he is worried about students having sex. In other words, he is not
comfortable with the right that consenting adults have o... S ee M ore
Reply
53 Like Follow Post November 11 at 8:52pm

Antariksh Bothale
Subscribed Business Analyst at A.T. Kearney 2,121 subscribers
Very well put.

Reply Like November 12 at 2:07pm
Sunaek Sivadas Government Engineering College, Thrissur
" even students of the same gender should be limited to meeting in the visiting rooms. Or
is even acknowledging the existence of homosexuality too progressive for the
administration?"
2/22
11/26/12
classic dude....
well said...
Reply
1 Like November 13 at 5:04pm
Shriram Chenji Indian Institute of Technology Madras

So I tried what the Dean suggested. With faith in the administration and trust in my teachers, I visited
the stadium at dusk to interact with a female student. However, before I can even attempt to hold
her hand, six people with heavy duty flashlights accost me. I'm threatened and asked to leave the
stadium because my presence with a girl is 'spoiling the nature on campus' while a bunch of older men
coolly smoke 'beedis' a hundred metres away. Well, as my elders know that I'm not a responsible adult
and they are all dressed in the institute police force's uniform, I assume they are right and embark on
a search for these 'go to' places the Dean is talking about. However, that didn't work too well for me.
Since our Dean has 'clearly discussed with some officers in our Security Section to instruct all the
Institute and contract security personnel to respect individuals personal freedom and space', I don't
know if I ought to refer to them as 'thugs with flashlights'. After all, 'Moral policing is certainly a most
inappropriate term in this context.'
Reply
Subramanya Sadasiva Purdue University

I have a very severe prolblem with bringing indian traditions into the picture and having to uphold
them without questioning the logic or even the existence of any logic behind them.
"I wish to add that there are certain well-established traditions and norms in Indian society that the
CoW, and all of us, must uphold in our campus."
Statements like this make me cringe. Caste based discrimination is a well-established tradition and
norm in Indian society - should we uphold that on our campus? Separate hostels shall we say?
separate tables in the messes! different plates! Discrimination against women is a very well
established tradition and norm in Indian society. Why not just shutter sharav and sarayu and the
whole problem is gone.
Sometimes I wish that India had gone through something like the cultural revolution where all these
oldies would have been made to go through reeducation classes.
Reply

Supradeepa Venkata Purdue University
you are playing the desi politician by picking one specific sentence and ranting on it out of
context. What he actually says which I have no objections with as it stands is - "I wish to
add that there are certain well-established traditions and norms in Indian society that the
CoW, and all of us, must uphold in our campus. At the same time, we must carefully
balance these traditions with the evolving, modern socio-cultural realities. We are
sincerely trying to find feasible middle ground between these two differing positions of
traditions and modernity"
Reply
2 Like November 13 at 7:01pm
Karthik Rao Cavale Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

LSG is weirdly exhibitionist. He seems to be okay with public display of affection (including
the use of "nooks and corners", for god-knows-what). In fact, he likes it so much that
he's encouraging it by shutting off other avenues of displaying affection in a male-female
relationship.
Subramanya Sadasiva Purdue University
Where are the concessions to modernity?
Ashish Kashyap IIT Madras
I just have a simple issue with Dean's remarks -- "They were asked to suggest compelling reasons in
support of girls being permitted access into boys rooms, and they could not come up with any." !!
What is happening to the IIT student community ? Have they lost all ability to mount a simple
argumentative challenge ? .... consider this ---
1. Since the administration is proposing a new change, a significant one -banning entry of girls in
hostels --- the BURDEN of COMPELLING REASON is on the administration. Why change existing policy
? Does this mean that the administration all these years was negligent towards its own students ..
exposing them to decadent Western traditions of "meeting in boys' rooms" ? Being an ex-student, I
am appalled and terribly grieved that my admin. did not care for my personal health an... S ee M ore
Reply

Sunaek Sivadas Government Engineering College, Thrissur
well said... "why fix something when its not broken?" :)
Ravi Shanker 28 years old
:)
Kavya Menon
Subscribe Works at IIT madras
As to the view of "up-holding the Indian traditions", I've always had a doubt. Why is it that always
Valmiki and his Ramayan held with so much of respect. I've never heard people bragging about
Vatsyayan and his Kamasutra... even that is a well-revered and well-written Indian epic. Its more
about what "acceptable" is by a person's comfort level and not what the environment dictates
3/22
Reply
6 Like Follow Post November 15 at 11:31am
Swetha Sridhar Chennai, Tamil Nadu

Haha, If nothing else, makes for some amusement and lots of laughter.
I'll be sure to let my mother know that she's been bringing me up wrong all these years - guess
independence and rational free choice are life values I ought not to have!
Reply
Ravi Krishnan IIT Madras

The typical quoting of the 'norms of Indian Society' is getting really old. It still baffles me as to why
adults imagine that the next generation is waiting to burn down the country and establish anarchy.
We respect the traditions and culture even without it being shoved down our throats. And even if said
flaccid reason is quoted, it is in ethical violation of one's right to decide whats good and bad. The
subjective nature is lost. Any stance lesser than to let the student decide whether she should enter
the hostel is just another attempt at moral policing.
The hostel authorities even find the need to raise their voice and quiz us about our intentions about
taking a female guest to the privacy of hostel room. What activities are you planning to do there,
that cannot be done in the lounge next to the front desk? Well I d... S ee M ore
Reply

Rushabh Menon Indian Institute of Technology Madras
Your argument seems to be extremely valid. The main point obviously would be that its
not their place to decide. I am tired of the 'elders know better' bullshit. They seem to be
randomly putting of ancient Indian texts now. As for the IIT restrictions, they are
actually present in all the major IIT's except Kanpur who have no such restrictions.
Ironically, its Delhi, Bombay and Madras who keep on taking such regressive measures.
And btw I liked your entire argument, seems as if you spent some time thinking about this
:)
Reply Like November 17 at 5:29am
Ravi Krishnan IIT Madras
Yep...should've spent more on endsems :P
Shachit Iyer
Subscribe Summer Intern at HPCL
Yeah , I agree with this as the administration is answerable to parents and the society. So unless the
perceptions of the contemporary society (not just the youth) becomes more liberal and free, which will
with passage of time, such changes are difficult to implement.
Reply Like Follow Post November 11 at 3:17pm
Sushant Veer Chennai, Tamil Nadu
You know what students are afraid of, that these restrictions will keep on piling till (a),(b)
and (c) come true
Jitendra Itankar
Subscribe Asst. Manager at Mahindra & Mahindra Limited
LSG talks sense

Reply Like Follow Post November 11 at 3:17pm
F acebook social plugin
44 Comments
siddu said:
@SubramaniamChandrasekar
its nice to see someone interested to debate about the Indian culture.
which text do you want to debate on? select any one on the following ? How much time do you want ?
Sample question:
Refute the statement your mother is not barren.
Answer this I will consider debating you!
From the Rigveda
001 Aitareya Upanishad
002 Aksha-Malika Upanishad about rosary beads
003 Atma-Bodha Upanishad
004 Bahvricha Upanishad
005 Kaushitaki-Brahmana Upanishad
006 Mudgala Upanishad
11/26/12
007 Nada-Bindu Upanishad

008 Nirvana Upanishad
009 Saubhagya-Lakshmi Upanishad
010 Tripura Upanishad
From the Shuklapaksha Yajurveda
011 Adhyatma Upanishad
012 Advaya-Taraka Upanishad
013 Bhikshuka Upanishad
014 Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
015 Hamsa Upanishad
016 Isavasya Upanishad
017 Jabala Upanishad
018 Mandala-Brahmana Upanishad
019 Mantrika Upanishad
020 Muktika Upanishad
021 Niralamba Upanishad
022 Paingala Upanishad
023 Paramahamsa Upanishad
024 Satyayaniya Upanishad
025 Subala Upanishad
026 Tara-Sara Upanishad
027 Trisikhi-Brahmana Upanishad
028 Turiyatita-Avadhuta Upanishad
029 Yajnavalkya Upanishad
From the Krishnapaksha Yajurveda
030 Akshi Upanishad
031 Amritabindhu Upanishad
032 Amritanada Upanishad
033 Avadhuta Upanishad
034 Brahma-Vidya Upanishad
035 Brahma Upanishad
036 Dakshinamurti Upanishad
037 Dhyana-Bindu Upanishad
038 Ekakshara Upanishad
039 Garbha Upanishad
040 Kaivalya Upanishad
041 Kalagni-Rudra Upanishad
042 Kali-Santarana Upanishad
043 Katha Upanishad
044 Katharudra Upanishad
045 Kshurika Upanishad
046 Maha-Narayana (or) Yajniki Upanishad
047 Pancha-Brahma Upanishad
048 Pranagnihotra Upanishad
049 Rudra-Hridaya Upanishad
050 Sarasvati-Rahasya Upanishad
051 Sariraka Upanishad
052 Sarva-Sara Upanishad
053 Skanda Upanishad
054 Suka-Rahasya Upanishad
055 Svetasvatara Upanishad
056 Taittiriya Upanishad
057 Tejabindu Upanishad
058 Varaha Upanishad
059 Yoga-Kundalini Upanishad
060 Yoga-Sikha Upanishad
061 Yoga-Tattva Upanishad
From the Samaveda
062 Aruni (Aruneyi) Upanishad
063 Avyakta Upanishad
064 Chandogya Upanishad
5/22
11/26/12
065 Darsana Upanishad

066 Jabali Upanishad
067 Kena Upanishad
068 Kundika Upanishad
069 Maha Upanishad
070 Maitrayani Upanishad
071 Maitreya Upanishad
072 Rudraksha-Jabala Upanishad
073 Sannyasa Upanishad
074 Savitri Upanishad
075 Vajrasuchika Upanishad
076 Vasudeva Upanishad
077 Yoga-Chudamani Upanishad
From the Atharvaveda
078 Annapurna Upanishad
079 Atharvasikha Upanishad
080 Atharvasiras Upanishad
081 Atma Upanishad
082 Bhasma-Jabala Upanishad
083 Bhavana Upanishad
084 Brihad-Jabala Upanishad
085 Dattatreya Upanishad
086 Devi Upanishad
087 Ganapati Upanishad
088 Garuda Upanishad
089 Gopala-Tapaniya Upanishad
090 Hayagriva Upanishad
091 Krishna Upanishad
092 Maha-Vakya Upanishad
093 Mandukya Upanishad
094 Mundaka Upanishad
095 Narada-Parivrajaka Upanishad
096 Nrisimha-Tapaniya Upanishad
097 Para-Brahma Upanishad
098 Paramahamsa-Parivrajaka Upanishad
099 Pasupata Brahmana Upanishad
100 Prasna Upanishad
101 Rama Rahasya Upanishad
102 Rama-Tapaniya Upanishad
103 Sandilya Upanishad
104 Sarabha Upanishad
105 Sita Upanishad
106 Surya Upanishad
107 Tripadvibhuti-Mahanarayana Upanishad
108 Tripura-Tapini Upanishad
Puranas.
1) Vishnu Purana 23,000 verses.
2) Naradiya Purana 25,000 verses.
3) Padma Purana 55,000 verses.
4) Garuda Purana 19,000 verses..
5) Varaha Purana 24,000 verses.
6) Bhagavata Purana 18,000 verses.
7) Brahmanda Purana 12,000 verses.
Brahmavaivarta Purana 18,000 verses.
9) Markandeya Purana 9,000 verses.
10) Bhavisya Purana 14,500 verses.
11) Vamana Purana 10,000 verses.
12) Brahma Purana 10,000 verses.
13) Matsya Purana 14,000 verses.
14) Kurma Purana 17,000 verses.
15) Linga Purana 10,000 verses.
16) Shiva Purana 24,000 verses.
17) Skanda Purana 81,000 verses.
18) Agni Purana 15,400 verses.
6/22
11/26/12
# 23 November 2012 at 7:51 pm
Welcome Rule said:

@ Subramaniyam
First read what my views exactly are.
For ur help, I repeat: Institute gives enough space and opportunity for boys and girls to interact for sports/socio-cultural/academic purposes
I have also done projects with girls as my team-mates, without any need to call them to my room.In Library (a lot of space is there, and even wifi is also
there.for ur info that I feel u are overlooking!)
Also I mentioned that Its not against anyones rights as such.
Its not understandable that anyones rights are being harmed due to this law.
u talk about someones wife/daughter, they and their relatives would be happy with such a rule as they would be able to respect such relationships, and would
like to see everyone with such healthy relationships, and not just any timepass relationships in the name of modernity or maturity
And u also suggest administration to mind on important things (research level, etc), then why r u so worried and so against the implementation of such a
rule.Get urself away with ur important things and mind ur own reserch and Nobel Prize aspirations (whatever).
Anyone can see ur double standards.
And please talk sense
Oliver Tate said:

Is it the excessive addiction to pornography that makes someone think that when a girl visits a boys room, thatll be probably to have sex ?
Sajad said:
Also, Arun.
Bachelor comes from the French word baccalaurat which means berry leaves. A colonial heirloom that we still ape in our continued shameless seeking of
Western acceptance. Again, not every Indian culture-ish. Just thought Id let you know since youre a champion of Indian culture.
Sajad said:
Hey Arun,
Your grandfather never used a computer when he was your age. Thats against Indian culture too. I dont see that stopping you.
If thats the life you want, you go for it man! No ones telling you to have sex with random girls and waste your energy and time that should be dedicated to
studying and getting placed with multiple lakhs per annum. Exactly the same reason, you shouldnt be telling everyone else what to do. Or are you scared that
your power of will is easily bent by the others around you having sex and that youll cave in to these beastly desires? Even so, thats your problem. Dont
expect people to live the way YOU want them to.
Rating: 1.0/5 (1 vote cast)

7/22
11/26/12
Lokesh said:
@subramaniachandrashekhar
what is your problem? His english or girls not coming to your room
Dheeraj Shukla said:

@xyz
Why not talk about why IITians arent exactly turning out to be the best the country has to offer?
just because they dont want to be. they are just happy if a girl is allowed in their rooms officially. What a silly thing? will this yield nobel prizes and Olympic
medals to IITM?
You can excel if you are determined in any situation, provided you dont let dirt into your system which takes the form of idle gossip, useless internet surfing,
pornography. Why always complain about things you dont have control over? Learn to manage your time, resources This is what indian culture is all about.
First of all LEARN how you can become an exemplary person yourself with a view to help and contribute to society positively. If one does not have control
and discipline over his own life, one cant control his own pushings and pullings from with in what can he achieve in his life? May be some nobel prizes and
Olympic medals!!! Good luck.
Arun said:
@subramanya
In india everybody doesnt know good english. Why do you divert from main topic? What is the use of your good english if you only want to promote nonsense
and support rubbish stuff caring nothing for values?
@xyz
I too dont know who you are One thing is clear If you are given charge of, you will make IIT into prostitute house with in no time.
First step: Allow contraceptives in gurunath, next: not enough girls in college, allow others from outside as well no end to the degradation.
I only feel sorry for all of you people. You think you are smart just because you could write and speak well. According to me it is simply perverted intelligence
only.
Surely, we do need enjoyment. But sex is such a thing once you give in you are lost. No matter how interesting the education is, how wonderful the
professors are you can never focus on all that. Whole of your energy just goes in to satisfy the beastly propensity.
Dear friends Yes there are lot more things to be discussed other than sex etc But please understand this is very foundational. That is why the degree
name that we get is BACHELOR of Technology. Dont become a bachelor daddy/mummy. If you lose control over this your life is finished. You will
simply become a hungry beast not satisfied with anything and will go down and degrade yourself to an animal level.
Yes we do have desires as our age is like that. SO what? get your degree, go out and get married. If you have full on affairs now only i will write and give
you you will be frustrated with your life partner. You will stick out your neck out of window and see if you could find some one else where is the end of that
futile frustrated lifes struggle my brother?
Sex is wonderful provided you channelize it properly. Indian culture is so wholesome and wonderful. It never says no to sex but says no to unrestricted sex
(sex before marriage and outside marriage). My grand father and grand mother had 12 children and lived a joyous life till 88yrs of age. There was such trust
and love amongst them Now a days the couple that gets married each one have so many doubts about their partner so much disturbance, so much lack
of peace and lack of trust. Unrestricted sex has caused havoc in families, taken lives of people, broken hearts of people It is simply a disturbance. Those
who give into this trap victimized by modern advertizements and media surely is an unfortunate being causing only disturbace to society in name of his own
Right to privacy.
8/22
11/26/12
Welcome Rule said:

@Definecultureplease
Its the emotion that I am talking about.
Definitely, the situation will be that the world will not mistreat other persons sister/daughter/wife, and will think twice before having any strong inclination
towards that.
And no doubt u r a rascal who wants to bring a girl to his room to have private personal interaction. And the way u have brought this phrase in ur comment,
u need not define it, everyone is able to understand that what kind of culture u want in IIT
And its not hard to conclude that u r a very frustated individual and u have strong lusty desires.
BEWARE OF GOOD PEOPLE.
xyz said:
@Arun whoever you are, I think youre either being really trippy or just insensitive to a lot of issues. Either way, your arguments made me laugh.
Firstly, how sure are we it is students having sex that is the main issue here? In case it is, I think there are a few things we should make clear. As long as it is
consensual between the two participating individuals, no one else should stop them. I do not believe that guarding the Indian value system is an excuse at all in
this case because there is no aggregate Indian value system. The administration is responsible only when someone is molested or someone meets with an
undesired sexual encounter which is against ANY human value system. Contraceptives should be made easily available at places like Gurunath. No one here is
still too young to point and giggle.
Secondly, I believe, and I think a couple of people have mentioned this before me, that the administration should look at more important things than its students
having sex. Why do we not talk about updating courses or changing pedagogy, making classes interesting enough for students to want to come and not have
to? Why not talk about why IITians arent exactly turning out to be the best the country has to offer? Why are IITs getting students who by the end of first year
realize they dont want to become engineers?
SubramaniamChandrasekar said:
Arun/Welcome rule, is giving us enough evidence on how, there is a serious lack of exposure amongst male IITians, to interaction (even academic),with girls
and the understanding that girls (including the persons sister) are human beings and are actually capable of existing on their own, let alone make decisions.
Also, the O level preparatory English course does not seem to have helped him. I seriously worry about his sister and future brother-in-law though. I wonder if
he will start a purification crusade of Lan also very soon.
Arun said:
@DefineCultureplease
Lets not speak big big things like law, this and that. Why dont you have a commonsense to understand what is happening.
It simply pains me if my sister is mistreated the way these IIT intellectuals want to deal with them. Your head can be in clouds but keep your feet on the
ground. Apply common sense man!
personal interaction what do you mean? do it else where. Why? simple. I dont want my hostel to become a prostitution house. get out of the campus and
do all your hellish nonsense somewhere else. Who stops you?
PPl are speaking about right to privacy dont you know that we also have responsibility to let people live with dignity. You dally with one girl and it invariably
9/22
11/26/12
ends up with broken relationship/ heart break and much frustration. Then what? Another girl!!!??? Simple. Dont play with lives of people in name of right for
privacy. Lets not flare up the baser instincts. Simply YOU are going to be frustrated.
Again a Simple thing!!! If somebody else calls your sister to his room and behaves badly. What will you do? I would really want to break his bones. It is not
about indian law, it is not about this and that simple human emotion.
Now one says yeah at our age sexula impulse is natural, we are to be given freedom. Yes. If sexual impulse is natural, then the by product of having sex
also must be natural and you have to accept that as well. Why you fools want to use contraceptives etc? Be natural man. Get a child. Take responsibility to
raise him/her. You want to enjoy but not take responsibility. So i will call you a RASCAL.
to Dean: WOnderful law Please do implement without fail.
Definecultureplease said:
@Welcome Rule
You dont seem to follow a lot of news, right? Honour killing is punishable with death sentence.
Welcome Rule said:

First of all, such a rule is not against anyones rights If a boy wants to interact with a girl for academic, sports or socio-cultural purposes, the institute clearly
gives enough space and opportunity for that.
Private, personal interaction and expression of sexual desires are anti-social, as both boy and girl are from respective families, and so they have duties
towards their families also. If someone interacts sexually with my sister, then I also have RIGHT to murder that person.
If u call my sister to ur room and do nonsense, then I will come to ur room and murder u.MY RIGHT!
xyz said:
Before I start, how much of this discussion really matters? It seems really pointless for a bunch of students to be fighting it out here when no one is really going
to take it into account.
Firstly I dont see any solid reason being given as to why this change of rules is happening in the first place. Instead of tackling that, we are fighting over why
or why not it should happen.
Secondly I do not see how it is the responsibilty of the administration to keep up moral and cultural standards. More importantly WHOSE standards are
they trying to abide by?
Thirdly all that can be gathered from the recent changes that are being made is that the administration does not want responsibility for what the students do. I
understand that. It shouldnt be the administration to have to take the blame for what students do. And if they are so worried about parents blaming them, they
should have them sign a form which says that the administration is not responsible for any students personal and private activities. There has to be some
separation between family values and values imposed by an institution.
Mr. A said:
Seems more of a rant. Poor interviewing skills, I must say. Interviewer let off LSG and let him rant along.
10/22
@Sashank
It is wrong of you to assume that other students are not concerned about stuff. I have frequently engage in conversations with friends, professors and even the
DoS on many of the issues concerning my institute.
Consider an example of University of California, Berkley, it has 91 Olympic Gold Medalists and 71 Nobel Prize winners on its list of alumni/faculty/associates
etc. All we can boast of is a single Padma Sri in our campus. It would be better, if the administration concentrated on asking how to improve itself, how to
make the education more interesting (Think ID 1200 or whatever that God/Science/Leprechaun forsaken course was called). How have our research
resources improved? How have the students encouraged to ask questions or do research? Are we ever going to become World Class in a true sense, and
not be just better than the college in the opposite campus? (Btw, it at least has the distinction of being one of the oldest engineering colleges in the world and
definitely in India).
Honestly, these are not questions with easy answers and the administration has decided , like many of us in question papers decided to opt for the easier
questions in the examination and has decided to answer them. Unfortunately they have failed to realize that their answers for them are poorly formulated.
Now, let it be that The mess timings are not logical (at least in your definition), does not mean other rules should also be the same way. Thankfully owing to
some people with good sense, tea timings have been changed.
Can you elaborate on the legal obligation of the institute on the issue of two people of the opposite sex interacting, in academic or non academic sense, in any
hour of the day? If a man (woman) assaults a woman (man), it the only obligation the institute has is to ensure the woman(man) gets justice.
There is a difference between freedom and licentiousness, which you hardly seem to understand. Ones freedom ends at the other persons nose, which would
not be the case, if we were driving haphazardly as we would be endangering others lives. The same holds true, although more obviously and significantly, for
smoking, and drunk driving (drinking by itself in ones room, is less harmful than reading from a pirated book, if you ask some of the publishing companies)
where the externality suffered by those around us is quite significant. Those rules are based on a)Scientific Evidence b)Sound Logic. and are not arbitary as the
ones imposed on us by the administration (including the attendance rule, which was pointed by a Common IITian)
@IITM Student
But the ban also extends for mothers, sisters and wives in some hostels. Some of the holiest relationships in most religions and cultures, especially in India.
Pathetic situation aint it?
@Sidarth,
Dont generalize about people being reticent. sometimes even the more orthodox people you know, might not have had a problem speaking about such issues
to their parents.
Vineeth said:
@shashank
As many people have pointed out in this thread already, my contention with the arguments and reasoning by the Dean of Students is in the manner in which he
tries to spin a positive light on some decision which he/governing body wants implemented. At least if he was honest in saying that the governing body wants to
ban girls entry to boys rooms Id would have respected that though I dont personally like it. He could have come out and said Look heres the problem.
We are more concerned about the name of the institute. We are more concerned about the Indian culture the way we see it. You students dont have a vote in
the decision making process. So the decision was made and live with it. It is entirely rational. It is not even unimaginable I say. North Korea springs to mind
almost instantly.
If he thinks the students had any say in the matter, then the poll results wouldnt have been overlooked or shrugged away as we are the primary stakeholders in
the matter. I get the need to rationalize the decisions you make. Heck I do them all the time. But when your decisions affect the life of many, you should also be
willing to accept the responsibilities that come with it. So it is ironic to hear talks of students lacking responsibility and of their unwillingness to accept the
consequences of their actions when their own mentor falters in doing so.
To answer your question regarding traffic rules. Some order is better than no order. But more order need to be better than some order. So yes it you are
willing to get run over by a bus, be my guest. But if you want to run somebody over, be prepared to face the consequences.
11/26/12
@shashank
I am glad that you asked the question. In fact Ive mailed many in the administration (including the Dean, Chairman Council of Wardens, and the Director) and
in the Student Representatives on many issues. Ive not shied away from mailing uncomfortable question to them. (In fact, I recently argued for setting up of
smoke-rooms in each hostel so that non-smokers arent affected by smokers unfortunately law of the land wouldnt permit IIT to do that)
There are no legal obligations for the IITM Administration with respect to girls entry into boys rooms (unlike the ban on smoking, consumption of alcohol,
and possession and use of weed which the Admin is legally bound to obey).
The biggest problem that I find with the Institute is the obsession that it has with maintaining its name. As an Institute of National Importance, it need not be
revered all the time! It has to be applauded when required, criticized when necessary, and corrective steps taken. Even the Indian Parliament is not beyond
criticism. Why should institute be afraid of the media?
Private interaction will include anything that they willingly do. It need not just be restricted to sex (as most of this discussion seems to hint at). What if they want
to see a movie together in one of their rooms?
LOLman said:
hhahahahahilarousIITs are going down the drain
shashank said:
@subramanian
@define culture please.
Consider this, since the time you have entered IIT, had there been this rule already implemented.
would you have ever quesitoned it?
If your answer is yes think about have you ever questioned the mess timings, or in the first place entry of boys into grils hostels.
It goes to show this is only a reactive, that too selectively finding the faults of a decision, not trying to understand the legal obligations, or the challenges from
media or other sources that pose a threat to the name of our institute.
@define culture please.
could you please eloborate on the private interaction that you consider equally important??
@vineeth.
dont create such a hypddnt you voice the same concern to the government as well for bothering you with the traffic rules.
Disillusioned_By_IIT said:
Lets all just complete our degrees and get out of this place. Its not as if there are many girl hands here to be held. We can do whatever we want after
graduating. In Teachers we trust !!..lol
12/22
11/26/12
@Chaitanya
Let us logically plot your argument,
IIT is in Chennai,
Most of Chennai is not liberal ,
IIT should also not be liberal.
So,
India is in Asia
Most of Asia is not a democracy,
So India Should not be a democracy
Samma Comedy sir neenga..
# 12 November 2012 at 10:11 am
Siddharth said:
@ definecultureplease
Look at it this way. Suppose you have taken a room on rent basis. The owner of the room, as per the original terms of your contract, asks you to vacate within
the month/ two months. He/she decided something you do at the room is detrimental to his/her business interests and you are asked to vacate within tone
month as per your original contractual obligation. Is he/she not within their rights to do so? Even in this case you have some defense, as since you paid full value
for the room, you have some partial claim to it, especially if you are not doing anything there that deviate from what you are legally permitted to do. So it can
be taken to court, although youll probably lose (because your landlord has, in this matter, absolute control over his property) THere are some exceptions to
this I think if you live in a place for 20 years or something, you assume ownership rights Im a little vague about this
Now in the case that you payed a meager sum for it, the rest of which was subsidized by the landlord himself, then your case becomes weaker. Its the same
thing with the IITM hostel administration. What they are really saying is vacate the hostel, live on your own, and do what you want. How are they not within
their rights to do so?
Also financial dependence means that the parent has some control over what you do. Refuse money from your parents and they have no
control/responsibility. Nobody is losing their fundamental rights because their dignity/freedom is not being compromised. You are perfectly free to refuse
financial assistance on the given terms and conditions and do as you please. Your dignity/self remains inviolate in any tangible, valid terms. Similarly, elders who
are financially dependent are in the same boat. If they dont comply with rules of their dependence upon son/daughter, they too can refuse. I dont see the
problem here.
Polly said:
Chaitanyas comment about the reality in conservative Chennai is not completely relevant to this debate about the normativity of the administrations reasons
behind justifying the implementation of the said rule regarding the entry of girls into boys rooms. The real world and practicality has little to do with debating
the pros and cons of a policy such as this one. Also, Sajads comment on culture is relevant because culture itself cannot be an argument for either approving
or disapproving any rule that deals with individuals and groups of individuals. The justification behind the culture, and the reasons associated with its origins
need to be taken into account.
Siddharths comment about IITM Hostels being subsidized and hence us having to follow rules is infallible, as far as i can see. But it needs to be kept in mind
here that the principle stakeholders in any policy is the student body, and if any decision is made leaving them out of the loop, it would be the top-down
implementation of an experts views, rather than participatory policy making. Similarly, LSGs argument about the poll having to cover all the stakeholders, i.e.
the parents and the faculty can be questioned. The Students here are the primary stakeholders, and they are presumably representative of thiers parents
consent on the issue. If not, the parents must be taken into account, as Siddharth again has rightly pointed out. The debate must start at home. But i do not see
how the faculty is a legitimate body of stakeholders in this issue. The Administration perhaps, but not the faculty.
13/22
11/26/12
Then again, the compelling reason LSG wanted is nothing but a desire for privacy. A freedom to do what we can within the purview of the
law/rules/reasonable limits(what come under reasonable here, cannot be decided unilaterally!!). As Changerous also pointed out, a 600 acre campus and
plenty of space for interaction within the limits is a false facade that crumbles under the slightest provocation.
Sajad said:
Chaitanya, culture and religion are two different things. I agree there is a causal interaction between the two. If India were a religious republic, like Pakistan or
the Middle Eastern state, all your arguments will be valid. But I wasnt aware IITs were established with idea of upholding Hindu culture which is what is being
paraded as Indian culture. Culture evolves. Just like you point out. From hunter-gatherers, there were the dark ages, there was modernity and the change is
constant. People like you & LSG were there when these changes happened over time urging everyone to hold on to their culture. But thankfully, it was
overcome.
@Siddharth
Hostel accommodation is not entirely free. Each student pays 5000 every semester towards Establishment A charges. (This is different from the Establishment
B charges which is equivalent to the hostel budget passed by the hostel council). But linking subsidy and curbing of fundamental rights is problematic. As far as
I know, Right to Privacy is a Fundamental Right (under the expanded definition of Right to Life) as declared by the Supreme Court of India and Im unsure if
an implied contractual obligation (by the means of subsidy) is valid grounds for the termination of such right.
The suggestion that market rate be charged for the hostels is also mired in several problems. Better suggestion would have been to charge operational costs
+ capital investment interest. But since I have not agreed to your earlier suggestion that fundamental rights are overridden by an implied contractual obligation,
I am not going further into the market rate argument.
It is curious that you define adult as financially independent (this argument takes away the age factor from the picture). I am afraid under that definition,
parents in their old age, who are financially dependent on their children will lose their fundamental rights too.
It is also curious that you assert that these debates should start at home. Such movements have been always from without and not from within. Changes
have to brought about from outside,and have succeeded too.
Suhas Raman said:

IITM should consider making a video on these lines. seriously!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eq02OOzo1YE
FlameWarAlert said:
Yet another internet flame war..here we go.
14/22
11/26/12
Changerous said:
So I tried what the Dean suggested. With faith in the administration and trust in my teachers, I visited the stadium at dusk to interact with a female student.
However, before I can even attempt to hold her hand, six people with heavy duty flashlights accost me. Im threatened and asked to leave the stadium because
my presence with a girl is spoiling the nature on campus while a bunch of older men coolly smoke beedis a hundred metres away. Well, as my elders know
that Im not a responsible adult and they are all dressed in the institute police forces uniform, I assume they are right and embark on a search for these go to
places the Dean is talking about. However, that didnt work too well for me. Since our Dean has clearly discussed with some officers in our Security Section
to instruct all the Institute and contract security personnel to respect individuals personal freedom and space, I dont know if I ought to refer to them as thugs
with flashlights. After all, Moral policing is certainly a most inappropriate term in this context.
Siddharth said:
The arguments provided by LSG only partially engage with the actual problem here:
1) Firstly, boarding in IITM hostels is subsidized (actually students pay nothing for lodging per se correct me if Im wrong. Since this is the case, the hostel is
within its right to impose restrictions that do not come in conflict with the fundamental rights of students. It can be argued that the right to sexual liaison is
subsumed within the right to freedom, and such an argument would be valid. At the same time, however, in the process of subsidization, a contract has been
established between the students and the hostel administration, which holds that the student is given board upon his compliance with those rules. Since noncompliance only leads to eviction (from a residence that the student did not pay for in the first place and therefore has no claim to) it cannot be said, from
another point of view, to infringe upon the individuals right to freedom. This is then a grey area. The administration, then, should either (a) charge market rates
for boarding in a number of hostels and admit students with no ridiculous rules such as this or (b)erect new hostels with such a financial scheme.
2) The parents-children argument is actually valid, though not in the form articulated by LSG. When an individual is considered an adult, that implies that he
or she is financially independent. Now in the case of IITM students in particular and Indian higher education in general, parents pay the fees of their wards (as
a rule of thumb) as opposed to Western liberal education, where parental financial responsibility for higher education is significantly lower (read: a lot of
American students pay their way through college through loans in their names). So it is valid, in a sense, for parents to prevent their children (and they are that
in this scenario) from engaging in activities that they believe are detrimental to their financial investment. Im by no means saying that IITM administration should
not treat the students as consenting adults. Im saying that there needs to be consent from parents (who hold financial responsibility over their wards)for a
number of these freedoms. Remember: implied in any democratic notion of adult is an end to parental financial responsibility. A solution here would be to
ask for signed waivers from parents to rules that can be said to infringe upon the wards freedom. Students who are currently bearing the financial responsibility
for their education, it goes without saying, should not be subjected to these rules in the first place after dealing with issue (1) as such.
In philosophy though, those above 18 should be able to have sex with whomever they please in a private space provided such an act is within the law of the
land. What is needed is a socio-cultural debate, which must start at home. I hope everybody who argues for sexual freedom on campus also makes an
attempt to argue for the same at home, with their families, extended families etc (where I have found we can be uncharacteristically reticent)
I agree with our DoS, that most parents would object to such interactions. Say, let us take it as the Golden rule and ponder about many such instances in the
institute, which are a great threat to students, which our parents will feel threatened about.
1) Cyclone Nilam, was such a threat that, districts across two states declared holidays for students, offices closed. Its effects were pretty evident in the
institute. However, we were expected to walk about around shaky and weak trees, will about 3 P.M, when the day was cancelled. Would our parents like
going to classes at the risk of our limbs if not for our life. Agreed the probability is negligible, but so is it for the instance cited by the dean.
2)Clearly, Dengue is a major threat in Tamil Nadu. What measures have we seen, except the occasional spray, and the weak poster in front of Vindhya? Are
are toilets cleaned? Is water stagnation being addressed? Walk around the Physics department and you can see at least 5 breeding sites for the mosquitoes.
Will our parents accept for these alone?
If a person with dengue is more likely to be found, than a pregnant girl,(considering the lack of girls ,good enough boys in campus,the success rate of
contraceptives), and still can be addressed through posters, why cant the latter be?
The Admin, is trying to be more Indian, than the Governments in India themselves. Who else comes up with arbitrary and inconsistent logic and transfers it all
on culture, when they have little clue either about its history or evolution?
15/22
11/26/12
If someone wants to debate to me about Indian Culture, or anything Indian, especially cricket and Hinduism be careful, very careful
Ashish Kashyap said:

I just have a simple issue with Deans remarks They were asked to suggest compelling reasons in support of girls being permitted access into boys rooms,
and they could not come up with any. !! What is happening to the IIT student community ? Have they lost all ability to mount a simple argumentative challenge
? . consider this
1. Since the administration is proposing a new change, a significant one -banning entry of girls in hostels the BURDEN of COMPELLING REASON is on
the administration. Why change existing policy ? Does this mean that the administration all these years was negligent towards its own students .. exposing them
to decadent Western traditions of meeting in boys rooms ? Being an ex-student, I am appalled and terribly grieved that my admin. did not care for my
personal health and my parents worldviews while having such liberal policies in my time. Can I sue them now? What has happened to warrant such a change ?
What will the change accomplish ? Will boys and girls stop spending too much time with each other and suddenly start preparing for quizzes ? I wonder.
2. The ludicrousness of the claim that the admin is interested in promoting exchanges between girls and boys and hence is providing visitors room is
laughable. Apparently, they are so interested that they want new infrastructure for it, while rooms just arent enough for the holistic interaction that they have in
mind! || Also, it is quite funny reading TFE articles and seeing how seriously people are taking these issues. I dont know why I am commenting either.
Nostalgia and boredom, probably.
@IITM Student one shouldnt have personal life inside the institute because it is subsidized education? Ok lets wait till 2013 when the fees of students will
not be subsidized anymore. Then can we have personal life inside IIT? Will girls be allowed inside boys rooms from 2013 onwards?
@Chaitanya what the institute curbs is the right to privacy and personal liberty in spending time with ones girl friend or boy friend and doing whatever they
please as long as it doesnt break any law of the land.
It is imperative that young adults be given freedom to make their own decisions, face the consequences, and learn the hard way. Be it academics, or personal
life including his or her choice of partner. Existing unwritten codes in the society are not a justification to impose any rule of this kind. May I please remind
you that at a time when polygamy was a prevalent practice among Hindus, the GoI brought in the Hindu Code bill banning it. It went for forward looking,
modern idea of family. Polygamy was part of the so-called Indian tradition. When the Parliament passed the 1954 Special Marriage act providing legal
protection to marriage between any two willing adults (from any religion or caste), it went against the existing, and still existing caste and religious
discrimination.
As an Institute of National Importance, what it should do is not to get stuck in a time warp. Unfortunately, the logical, scientific acumen doesnt penetrate the
deep religious ideologies they hold beneath the sophistication of MBA degree or cool, diplomatic words.
Chaitanya said:
Accepted that,(as Adorabell quoted) the administration needs to facilitate forums for opposite-sex interaction (whatever that means as a phrase) to ensure
hoslistic improvement in the personality of all students graduating with the IIT brand.
I would like to ask the people who have commented above, what they mean when they say that the institute, with its policy of not allowing girl students into
boys rooms, is curbing their right to interact? I mean face it IIT Madras is a 600 acre campus (which Im sure gives ample space for students to meet up
and interact).
I am also unable to understand what enhancement the provision of allowing girls into boys room will provide so as to increase the interaction between the two.
Please enlighten me about the same.
Definecultureplease has come out with statistics about the National Sample Survey Organization, but Im sure it does take care that all stakeholders in its
survey are represented within the constraints of logistical ability. Thus LSGs argument about involving all stakeholders cannot to be discarded.
16/22
11/26/12
Sajads remark on culture being harmful to people is unfounded. Culture cannot damage a person. It is just a form of expression of the people. It is how you
embrace it which matters. We all live in a society which is inevitably governed by some unwritten codes of conduct which change with time. If we just want to
throw them all into the dustbin, we might as well live as hunter-gathers!
Finally, being from IIT, one should not throw a blind eye to the prevailing conditions in other institutes (especially in conservative Chennai) where your
comments would be rather preposterous, to mention the least. So, get real! The world outside is rather different from what it is inside IIT!
Common_IITian said:
To all those who are fighting for entry of girls into boys room :
90% of the people dont give a damn and it doesnt affect us in anyway whatsoever
Instead of this stupid issue, please fight for lifting of the 85% attendance rule, take a poll for that and 99% students(except a few maggus probably) will vote
for abolishing the rule.
IITM Student said:

Why girls entry is required to boys room??. If it is required for academics projects or group studies then there are lots of places to do that things like
library,CCD,class rooms.
What i see in campus after 10 pm is not expected in campus of national importance. We are getting lots of things at cheapest cost because of tax payers
money. It shouldnt be misused.
If yo want space for your personnel life then go outside campus.
Be poltically right always said:

1.Why now? question is smartly deviated by Prof.LSG as always. According to his answer certain well-established traditions and norms,India has been
ever since, why was this need not seen before?
2.Regarding the poll,less participation was due to lack of awareness among people,at a minimal level, if you ask general secretaries of the hostels to circulate
among hostel google groups, you would get 60% responses at the least.Non-response can not be taken as a no. If the response is non-response one, then it
should be counted(cant say in the potions given is a non response).
3.Regarding students being not treated as adults by parents,didnt we evolve? We did. Only because certain people were to ready to accept the change and
why dont we become the ambassadors of it using the IIT tag he points out. By saying that parents criticize administration for failures of their wards at many
times and suggesting solutions to avoid it, the administration is effectively playing it safe.Whats the solution to improve Indian adolescents maturity who are
not as mature as they think they are,treat them as immature people and expect them become mature.
4.keeping in best interests of students.. is too cliche.I may be off the topic but I would like cite an example.Recently candle light vigil was conducted as a
protest to false propagation institutes image by the media about suicide. The underlying motto was Let the truth prevail shared by Prof.LSG himself. Why
wasnt a similar thing done when a student from Narmada committed suicide? These things are done only when integrity of the administration is under
question? News which will be forgotten in no matter of time. If it wasnt for the students participated in it, no one would even know there some protest like
that.I ask where the best interests of the students now?.
Playing it safe is not the game.Playing in spirit is the game.
Vineeth said:
My opinion is that Indian adolescents think that they are responsible adults, while we elders know that they are not. After all, we elders can certainly reflect
upon our adolescent days and recall our experiences and their consequences. Naturally, we are eager to guide our children and youth to avoid the high
17/22
11/26/12
probability, undesirable effects of their thoughts, words and actions.

So obviously the blame lies with the students. How dare they even try to be independent, self-governed adults when us parents and teachers have made it clear
time and again that you are and will always be treated as second class citizens with no opinions on any matter? Why cant you simply get it inside that thick
head of yours that your polls and mails and protests and demonstrations dont matter to us? It doesnt even matter whether you are 18 or 21 or even 50. If
you are inside the institute, you do what we tell you. No questions asked. And it goes without saying that you are not allowed to feel offended. We simply do
this out of our love for you. We have seen more years than you and obviously know what horrible things can happen if a guy and a girl are allowed to interact
within the confined walls of a hostel room. To put it simply, we make the rules, you follow them.
Adorabell said:
This is such rubbish. Pliss to stop hindering our opposite-sex interactions. You know youre succeeding.
Dear Prof.LSG, even the National Sample Survey Organization conducts only 55,000 household surveys to public nation-wide results. Thats approximately
2.2% of the Indian population. Nearly 10% of students participated in the study. Thats not enough?
While I might agree that Administration will be faulted by some parents (stray incidents as the Dean himself says), why should the entry be banned just to
avoid these stray incidents?
The suppression of adolescent feelings for the opposite sex has, and will continue to be the prime reason for atrocities against the vulnerable. Boys and girls are
separated at birth (mostly). The division starts in school (separate rows in classroom, separate stair cases, sometimes even separate classrooms). If it continues
even in college, then it is disappointing.
LSG is true when he says that there is no bar on public, social interaction between boys and girls in our institute. But private, personal interaction is equally
important. Also, by banning entry of girls into boys hostels, what the Administration has effectively done is to avoid blame in time of crisis (whatever done
outside the Institute is not within its purview, right?) So the real intention is not to guide students, but to avoid blame.
Sajad said:
Also, the reasoning mentioned in this article are strikingly to similar to Bal Thackerys ideas of tradition and Maharashtra as a moral high ground based on
religious traditions. Its sad that a national institute in a secular country has to be administered with tradition in mind. No surprises then to why IITs are far
behind other universities in the world. We are happy with being one of the best in India. Because we need to champion are culture, even if it is detrimental for
our students.
Sajad said:
Just because parents think of their children as incapable of living without constant supervision & guidance, it doesnt mean they actually are incapable of living
without constant supervision & guidance. If parents and the administration continue to chaperon the students, this generation and the generations to come will
graduate, take up jobs and have no clue what to do with their lives at that point instead of being prepared for it after college. But then again, when has anyone
ever thought of anything about the students except eat well, sleep early, study hard, leave everything else for later.
18/22
11/26/12
hash said:
Even though I felt girls must be allowed but ,after reading this article the answers of LSG were gawd level __/\__ and to the point..
Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.
Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.
Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website (optional)
CAPTCHA Code *
You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q
cite=""> <strike> <strong>
This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.
Submit Comment
About the Author

T5E
The Fifth Estate, IIT Madras
Weekly Poll
If minimum attendance is relaxed, will you still attend classes regularly?
Yes
No
Depends on the course
Can't say
Vote
19/22
11/26/12
Subscribe to T5E via Email

Get T5E news/articles directly in your inbox.
Enter your e-mail: *

Submit
Follow us
Follow @t5e_iitm
The Fifth Estate on
Follow
+398
The Fifth Estate on Facebook

Like
2,460
2,460 people like The Fifth Estate.
A nkitha
S ibaprasad
A rchit
Kaushik
V iv ekanandan Jitendra
A tul
V ineet
A nzar
Kunal
F acebook social plugin
Printed Issues
IIT-M Annual Magazine 2011-12
August 2011 T5E Issue
February 2011 T5E Issue
January 2011 T5E Issue
August 2009 TFE Issue
The Buzz
IIT-M to strengthen international ties soon
IIT-M computer system gets fastest tag
Student commits suicide
IITM signs MoU with Automation Industry Association
IIT-M convocation: "Be optimistic about our country" -Fali S. Nariman
Daily Popular
Campus Placements 2011-2012
Applying Abroad for MS/PhD: FAQs
What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Adulthood and Responsibility
20/22
11/26/12
Standard Deviation
Popular Posts
Standard Deviation
Open Discussion With Director, Dean Students
Freshie Guide: How To Speak Insti
Recent Comments
siddu on What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Welcome Rule on What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Oliver Tate on What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Sajad on What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Sajad on What degrees of freedom are being curbed?
Events
Nov 26
All Day - End Sem E Slot
Nov 27
All Day - End Sem F slot
Nov 29
All Day - End Sem G Slot
Follow IITM on google +

IIT Madras on
Follow
Sister Media Bodies

IIT Bombay: Insight
IIT Kgp: The Scholars' Avenue
Independent Publications
ReNEWS: An initiative by the Research Affairs Secretary, IIT Madras
Quotable Quotes
"He called me 'senior correspondent' - AHAHAHAHA! ...Just realised, it sounds way more cool than 'manager' :("
- A T5E Manager
"We must be banned. It is the only way."
- Vision of former Executive Editor for T5E
"We will arrange for a merry band to cheer you on with pom-poms if you can finish this by Saturday."
- Previous Editor to Current Editors
"How do you change the quotes?"
- Executive Editor to Editor
Meta
Register
Log in
Entries RSS
Comments RSS
WordPress.org
21/22
11/26/12
TFE Archives
August 09
April 09
April 08
Nov 07
Jan 07
Apr-03
Nov-02
Pages
About Us
Subscribe
Events
Contribute
Feedback
Links
Hindi T5E About Us
ReNEWS
TechSoc Points Tally
Powered by WordPress | Log in | RSS | Arthemia theme by Michael Hutagalung | Header designed by Pramod 'PDF' Kasi
22/22

"What Degrees of Freedom Are Being Curbed - " - T5E - The Fifth Estate - IIT Madras' Campus News Body

Încărcat de

Informații document

Descriere originală:

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

"What Degrees of Freedom Are Being Curbed - " - T5E - The Fifth Estate - IIT Madras' Campus News Body

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

11/26/12

What degrees of freedom are being curbed?

T5E: Sir, could you elaborate more about the rule?

Rating: 3.9/5 (31 votes cast)

Posting as Vinay Yadav (Change)

Subscribe Indian Institute of Technology Madras

53 Like Follow Post November 11 at 8:52pm

Subscribed Business Analyst at A.T. Kearney 2,121 subscribers

Very well put.

1 Like November 13 at 5:04pm

Shriram Chenji Indian Institute of Technology Madras

29 Like Follow Post November 11 at 10:01pm

Subramanya Sadasiva Purdue University

11 Like Follow Post November 13 at 4:25pm

2 Like November 13 at 7:01pm

Karthik Rao Cavale Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

11 Like Follow Post November 11 at 7:25pm

Subscribe Works at IIT madras

6 Like Follow Post November 15 at 11:31am

Swetha Sridhar Chennai, Tamil Nadu

5 Like Follow Post November 11 at 9:27pm

Ravi Krishnan IIT Madras

2 Like Follow Post November 16 at 6:48pm

Subscribe Summer Intern at HPCL

Subscribe Asst. Manager at Mahindra & Mahindra Limited

LSG talks sense

007 Nada-Bindu Upanishad

065 Darsana Upanishad

# 23 November 2012 at 7:51 pm

Welcome Rule said:

# 23 November 2012 at 5:24 pm

Oliver Tate said:

# 22 November 2012 at 4:26 pm

# 22 November 2012 at 4:19 pm

# 22 November 2012 at 4:14 pm

# 21 November 2012 at 8:43 pm

Dheeraj Shukla said:

# 21 November 2012 at 2:11 pm

# 21 November 2012 at 1:50 pm

Welcome Rule said:

# 15 November 2012 at 11:24 pm

# 15 November 2012 at 9:56 pm

# 15 November 2012 at 9:52 pm

# 15 November 2012 at 1:41 pm

# 15 November 2012 at 12:27 pm

Welcome Rule said:

# 14 November 2012 at 11:41 pm

# 13 November 2012 at 5:37 pm

Rating: 3.3/5 (7 votes cast)

# 13 November 2012 at 3:36 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 11:39 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 10:14 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 9:25 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 8:38 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 8:35 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 6:01 pm

# 12 November 2012 at 10:11 am

# 12 November 2012 at 9:05 am

# 12 November 2012 at 6:55 am

# 12 November 2012 at 6:52 am

# 11 November 2012 at 11:55 pm

Suhas Raman said: