Sunteți pe pagina 1din 27

Scaling up

a film-coating process

Thorsten Cech
Manager European Pharma Application Lab,
Pharma Ingredients & Services,
Nutrition & Health Division
G-ENP/ET

The up-scaling problem


Introduction
Source: Brian Helsdon, OYSTAR Manesty, Knowsley, U.K.

Up
Upscaling
scaling

Manesty XL Lab 02

Premier 900

15 kg

Batch size

850 kg

420 m/h

Inlet air quantity

10,000 m/h

60C

Inlet air temperature

60C

Spray guns

42 g/min

Spray rate

???

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 2

The up-scaling problem


Practical example (Kollicoat IR formulation)
Source: Scale-up of an instant release film coating process with Kollicoat IR
K. Kolter; BASF SE; AAPS Annual Meeting; October 21 24, 2001; Denver; Colorado; U.S.A.

AccelaCota

Driacoater

Batch size

[kg]

15

250

Spray rate

[g/min]

14

42

700

[g/min/kg]

2.8

2.8

2.8

[m/h]

83

223

4,400

16.6

14.9

17.6

[C]

71

73

70

Exhaust air temperature [C]

47

50

47

Rel. spray rate


Inlet air quantity

Rel. inlet air quantity[m/h/kg]


Inlet air temperature

These trials show the


linear approach
.
Both relative spray rate and relative inlet air quantity are kept constant in all
scales.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 3

The up-scaling problem


Typical parameters for Glatt coaters in different scale

1,400

7,000

1,200

6,000

1,000

5,000

800

4,000

600

3,000

400

2,000

200

1,000

Process air quantity [m/h]

Spray rate [g/min]

Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Data:
Wolfgang Dejan, Glatt AG, Pratteln, Switzerland

The chart displays the


recommended spray
rate
and
the
commonly
used
process air quantities
in different scales for
horizontal side vented
pan coaters of Glatt.

0
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

Batch size [kg]


Recommended maximum spray rate

Commonly used process air quantity

This chart shows the non-linear reality.


There is no linear slope in spray rate and process air quantity during the up
scaling step.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 4

The up-scaling problem


Typical parameters for Glatt coaters in different scale

6.0

90

5.0

75

4.0

60

3.0

45

2.0

30

1.0

15

0.0

Process air quantity [m/h]

Spray rate [g/min]

Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Data:
Wolfgang Dejan, Glatt AG, Pratteln, Switzerland

The chart displays the


relative spray rate and
the relative process air
quantities in different
scales for horizontal
side
vented
pan
coaters of Glatt.

0
1

10

100

1000

Batch size [kg]


Recommended maximum spray rate

Commonly used process air quantity

The available relative process air volumes are decreasing during up scaling.
For this, the relative spray rate cannot be a constant, for economical
processes. However, low relative spray rates can be used in small scale.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 5

The up-scaling problem


Summary
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany

In typical side vented pan coaters, the available relative process air
volume (m/h/kgcores) is higher in small scale than in large scale.
As a result of this, the relative spray rate (g/min/kgcores) can easily be
used for down scaling of film coating processes. The likelihood for
overwetting is low but the risk for spray drying is increased.
A relative spray rate found and optimised for small scale coaters can
hardly be used in production scale.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 6

The coating process in different scales


General Scale Up Consideration
Source: Elisa Bennie, Active Division, I.M.A. S.p.A., Bologna, Italy
Armin Bohle, Lbb Bohle Maschinen & Verfahren GmbH, Ennigerloh, Germany

Lab scale
Batch size:
Nozzles:

0.5 8.5 kg
1

Pilot scale
Batch size:
Nozzles:

25 50 kg
2 5

Production scale
Batch size:
Nozzles:

>150 kg
3 - 15

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 7

The coating process in different scales


Summary
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany

The Process-Parameter-Chart can be considered as perfect tool to


compare different types of coaters, varying formulations or different types
of process set-ups.
The process time prolongs during scale up procedures.
Main reason for the prolonged process time is the difference in batch to
nozzle ratio during up scaling. The amount of cores per nozzle is
increasing.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 8

The film coating process


Parameters influencing the film coating process
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Quelle: O
HARA
Drawing: Dori Schmetterling, O
Hara, Richmond Hill, Canada

Exhaust air

Inlet air

Temperature
Quantity
Humidity

Temperature
Quantity
Humidity

Drum

Cores

Size
Shape
Hardness
Friability
Roughness
Temperature

Nozzle

Formulation

Design (e.g. ABC)


Number
Angle
Distance
Spray rate
AA-pressure
PA-prressure

Nutrition & Health Division

Type (e.g. solid)


Size
Speed
Filling degree
Surface
Baffles
Temperature

Pharma Ingredients & Services

Polymer(s)
Additives
Solvent
Viscosity
Solid matter cont.
Stickiness
Film properties
T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 9

The film coating process


Visualization of the film coating process
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Drawing: Alexander Rongen, Glatt GmbH, Binzen, Germany

Begin of the
coating process

Core particle

Film building process

Droplets of the film coating dispersion

Finally formed filmed


Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 10

The film coating process


Thermodynamic consideration of the core temperature

Product temperature

Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Time of process cycle

Steady state core bed temperature


Spray pattern, liquid carrier gets
applied
Core is completely dried, when
immersing into the core bed again
Core took up energy and reached
steady state temperature again
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 11

The film coating process


Thermodynamic consideration of the process air temperature

Process air temperature and humidity

Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany

Temperature
Relative humidity

Time of process air in the process

Drop in inlet air temperature due to


convection
Passing spray pattern and transferring energy for evaporating the
liquid carrier
Transfer energy to heat up core
bed to steady state temperature
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 12

Energies inlet air temperature


Equipment schema
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Drawing: Elisa Benni, I.M.A. S.p.A., Active Division, Bologna, Italy

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.

Dispersion tank
Peristaltic pump
Guns adjustment system
Coater
Spray guns
Inlet air unit
Control panel
Dust collector
Outlet air fan
Inlet air unit

Nutrition & Health Division

Inlet air Unit:

Filter
Conditioning
(humidifying and de-humidifying)
Heating

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 13

Energies inlet air temperature


Energies needed for the process air
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Drawing: Elisa Benni, I.M.A. S.p.A., Active Division, Bologna, Italy

=10C

Required energy supply


in

ambient
heat

de-humidification

160

Calculation background

140

Efficiency heater:
100%
Losses of heat:
0%

50C

120
Energy supply [kW]

Dew point:
10C/100% r. h. = 7.6 g/kg

60C
100

70C
80
60
40
20
0
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

Inlet air quantity [m/h]

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 14

Energies inlet air temperature


Energies needed for the process air
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany
Drawing: Elisa Benni, I.M.A. S.p.A., Active Division, Bologna, Italy

& = 3,869 kgh


m

& = 3,793 kgh


m

& = 3,793 kgh


m

T = 35C
3
V& = 3,383 mh

T = 60C
3
V& = 3,600 mh

T = 10C
3
V& = 3,060 mh

Y = 12.7 kgg

Y = 7.6 kgg

Y = 7.6 kgg

V&in

V&out

AA: 2.2bar, 80L/min


PA: 2.2bar, 100L/min

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

Spray rate:
Solid content:
Water:

400 g/min
20%
19.2 kg/h

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 15

Energies inlet air quantity


The drying of the dispersion on the core surface
Source: Comparison of Film Coating Process using fully perforated and partly perforated Coating Pans
Lirong Liu (Pfizer), Timothy J. Smith, Gary L. Sackett (Vector), Ethel Poir (Micro Photonics), Paul Sheskey (Dow)

Conclusions
In this study, the partially
perforated pan required a
lower inlet temperature (at the
same air volume and spray
rate) to maintain the same
exhaust temperature when
compared to fully perforated
pan.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 16

Energies inlet air quantity


The drying of the dispersion on the core surface
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

Drying process

c (T T )
h
Q& = A v ln1 + p,D 2 1
hv
c p,D

The
heat transfer coefficient ()
depends on the air velocity.

Q& A (Tap Tac )

1
c 0

v v lam

2
1 +
Pr 3 1
v

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

= f (v air )
T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 17

Energies inlet air quantity


The drying of the dispersion on the core surface
Source: Technische Strmungslehre
Willi Bohl; 12. Auflage; 2001; VOGEL; Germany

Bernoulli's law derivation diagram

g hinlet

pair ,in
V&air ,in
pair ,out
V&air ,out
+
+
= g houtlet +
+
air ,in Ainlet 2
air ,out Aoutlet 2

V&
v=
A

inlet
Nutrition & Health Division

coating pan
Pharma Ingredients & Services

outlet
T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 18

Energies inlet air quantity


The drying of the dispersion on the core surface
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

pair ,in
V&air ,in
pair ,out
V&air ,out
+
=
+
air ,in Ainlet 2 air ,out Aoutlet 2

This effect described by Bernoulli


for fluid dynamics is the same effect
found by Vector.
The open cross section of the fully
perforated drum is larger compared
to the partly perforated one. Hence,
the drying is more efficient with the
partly perforated drum.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 19

Case Study (1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Materials and equipment
Source: Investigating the influence of inlet air temp. and quantity on the maximum spray rate in a side vented pan coater
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

Side vented pan coater


Perfima Lab and Perfima 200

Formulations

Core ingredients
Ludipress LCE
Kollidon VA 64
Mg-Stearate

Coat ingredients
Kollicoat IR Carmine
Water

Nutrition & Health Division

Quantity [%]
79.5
20.0
3.0

Quantity [%]
25.0
75.0

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 20

Case Study (1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Trial set up for the perforated drum
Source: Comparing the up scaling characteristics of an instant release coating in solid wall and side vented pan coaters
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

All parameters in large scale


were adjusted according to the
suggested up scaling strategy
and are based on the process
settings in small scale the
surface quality was found to be
identical in all scales.
Perfima Lab
40 kg
10.9 kg
2
1
7 rpm
9 rpm
(361 mm/s)
(360 mm/s)

Batch size
Number of nozzles
Drum speed

Inlet air temperature 50, 60, 70C


Inlet air quantity

50, 60, 70C

50, 60, 70C

1,060 m/h

2,120 m/h

530 m/h

Nutrition & Health Division

Perfima 200
140 kg
140 kg
4
4
5 rpm
5 rpm
(349 mm/s)
(349 mm/s)

Pharma Ingredients & Services

30, 50, 60,


70C
2,800 m/h
T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 21

Case Study (1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Maximum spray rate found for different scales
Source: Investigating the influence of inlet air temp. and quantity on the maximum spray rate in a side vented pan coater
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

Maximum spray rate [g/min]

450

Equipment:

400

Perfima Lab
Perfima 200

350
300
250
200

Coating dispersion:

150

Kollicoat IR Carmine
Solid matter content: 25%

100
50
0
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

Inlet air quantity [m/h]


30C

50C

60C

70C

It was found that an that as long as high inlet air volumes are used for the
coating process, the inlet air temperature play a secondary role. Actually, an
increase of inlet air temperature did finally not lead to the possibility to
elevate the spray rate.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 22

Case Study (1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Summary (1)
Source: Investigating the influence of inlet air temp. and quantity on the maximum spray rate in a side vented pan coater
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

Both inlet air quantity and inlet air temperature do influence the maximum
spray rate markedly. However, as temperature is mainly delivering
energy to facilitate the evaporation of the liquid carrier, its effect is
limited. As soon as the energy supply exceeds the energy demand of the
evaporation process, a further increase in temperature does not affect
the spray rate anymore.
Under conditions of an excessive energy supply, the time for evaporating
and exhausting the liquid carrier determines the maximum spray rate.
The time as limiting factor can be influenced by the inlet air volume. An
improvement in drying efficiency can be achieved by an increase in
process air quantity, which is attended by higher air velocity. This
reduces the heat transfer coefficient causing a faster energy transfer.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 23

Case Study (1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Summary (2)
Source: Investigating the influence of inlet air temp. and quantity on the maximum spray rate in a side vented pan coater
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

The Perfima 200 allows using high process air volumes. This enables the
conduction of coating processes at unusually low inlet air as well as
product temperatures. Especially, if temperature sensitive cores have to
be coated, this characteristic might be an interesting option to be
considered in process optimisation.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 24

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Producing the same quality in different scale
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Conditions to produce film coated tablets in different scale with


identical quality and comparable stability:
Energy exposure / core bed temperature
Temperature sensitive drugs
Humidity exposure / spray rate
Water/humidity sensitive drugs
Homogeneity of layer (e.g. thickness)
Functional coating formulations
Obtaining the same dissolution profile
Obtaining the same protective properties

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 25

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Energies passing the 1st system boundary
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Exhaust air
Temperature, quantity, humidity

nd

Convection

sys

.
Q5
.
Q6

tem
bo
un
da
ry

.
Q1
.
Q2
.
Q3
.
Q4
Wt

Inlet air
Temperature, quantity, humidity
Dispersion
Temperature, quantity
Compressed air
Atomisation air, pattern air

Light
Electric power
Work
rotation of drum

1st system boundary

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 26

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Energies passing the 2nd system boundary
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Exhaust air
Temperature, quantity, humidity

nd

Convection

.
Q5
.
Q6

sys
tem
bo
un

.
Q7

da
ry

Evaporation of liquid carrier


Spray rate

1st system boundary

.
Q1
.
Q2
.
Q3
.
Q4
Wt
.
Q8

Inlet air
Temperature, quantity, humidity
Dispersion
Temperature, quantity
Compressed air
Atomisation air, pattern air

Light
Electric power
Work
Rotation of drum
Cores
Temperature, speed

Variable
Constant
Disregarded
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 27

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Aim for the applied spray rate

Low spray rate


High spray rate Mean spray rate

Range of usable spray rates

Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes


Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

Very low spray rates may cause spray drying effects, even if
this is not a problem, with most products a very high
abrasion (friability) and long process times will be found.
Mean spray rates lead to best results with regard to surface
quality. For optimising the process time the highest spray
rate which results in perfectly coated surfaces has to be
evaluated.
AIM

Nutrition & Health Division

High spray rates bear the risk of overwetting. The likelihood


of rough surfaces is high.
Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 28

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Droplet size
Source: Experiments on the atomization of liquids in an airstream
S. Nukiyama, Y. Tanasawa; Transaction of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers; 1939

In any up scaling considerations it is important to keep the nozzle settings


constant. This is for instance droplet speed. Yet droplet size is also of huge
importance and has to be regarded.
DDs
s

Mean
Meandroplet
dropletsize
size
Surface
tension
Surface tensiondispersion
dispersion
Density
dispersion
Density dispersion

[m]
[m]
[N[N/m/ ] ]
m
[kg
[kg/m
/ ]]
m

m
air,liq Ratio
Ratioofofexit
exitspeed
speedair
air: :liquid
liquid [ [m/s/]s]
air,liq

Dyn.
[mPas]
Dyn.viscosity
viscositydispersion
dispersion
[mPas]
JJ
Ratio
of
exit
quantity
air
:
liquid
[-]
Ratio of exit quantity air : liquid [-]

1.5
585 103

1000

0.225
0.45

Ds =


+ 1683 ( )

J
air ,liquid
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 29

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Circumferential speed
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

u = dn
u =u
s

d
d

d n = d n
s

n =n

u
us

Circumferential speed
C. speed small scale

[cm/s]
[cm/s]

ul

C. speed large scale

[cm/s]

d
n

Diameter drum
Pan speed

[cm]
[1/s]

It is aim to keep a constant circumferential velocity.


Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 30

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Calculating tablet velocity
Source: Prediction of tablet velocity in pan coaters for scale-up
Ronny Mller, Peter Kleinebudde; Powder Technology 173 (2007) 51-58

Velocity of particles in a
tumbling blender

or simplified

g
= k r npan
d
2
3

Velocity of particles in a
tumbling blender considering
the filling degree
1
6

g
= k r npan 1.8
d
2
3

Nutrition & Health Division

2 (2r n )
2u

1
6

k
r

Particle velocity
Constant
Pan radius

[cm/s]
[-]
[cm]

npan
g

Pan speed
Gravity (981)

[1/s]
[cm/s]

Particle size

[cm]

Filling degree

[-]

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 31

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Process air volume
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

& production
m
&
Vproduction =
V&pilot
& pilot
m

According to the spray rate, the


inlet air quantity has to be adapted.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 32

Deducing an up scaling strategy


Making sure that all products are the same
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Keeping the surface time constant


The limiting factor in film coating is the amount of dispersion applied
on a single core when it is passing the spray pattern once.

Keeping the drying / evaporation of the liquid carrier constant


Relative spray rate not calculated on batch size, calculated on
number of assembled nozzles
Keep the same type of nozzle
Keep the same tablet speed by adjusting the circumferential
speed accordingly
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 33

Case Study (2) Kollicoat Protect


Schema for the up scaling trial
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

Number of
nozzles

If the maximum spray rate per


nozzle is determined, the up scaling
calculation will be quite simple.

Spray rate

[kg]

[g/min]

Inlet air
quantity
[m
[m/h]

50

200

2000

100

200

2000

100

300

3000

200

300

3000

200

400

4000

140

9800

120

8400

total process time


[minutes]

To account for the increasing water


impact (increasing overall spray
rate), the inlet air volume has to be
adapted as well.

Batch size

100

7000

80

5600

60

4200

40

2800

20

1400

0
25

75

125

175

inlet air quantity [m/h]

Theoretical scale up calculations

0
225

batch size [kg]


total process time
[minutes]

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

inlet air quantity


[m/h]
T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 34

Case Study (2) Kollicoat Protect


Perfima 200, Kollicoat Protect
Source: Scaling up a Film Coating Process by Keeping the Ratio of Spray Rate and Inlet Air Quantity Constant
Cech, Wildschek; BASF SE; Funaro, Mondelli, Cembali; IMA; ExcipientFest, June 18./19., 2008, Cork, Ireland

Formulations

Drum design

Coat ingredients

Quantity [%]

Kollicoat Protect
Kaolin
Titanium dioxide
Iron oxide (brown)

25.0
67.0
3.0
5.0
Maximum drum load

Side vented pan coater


Perfima 200

Minimum drum load


Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 35

Case Study (2) Kollicoat Protect


Schema for the up scaling trial

Trial

Number of
nozzles

Process time [minutes]

Up scaling calculations / results

100

8000

80

6400

60

4800

40

3200

20

1600

0
25

Batch size
[kg]

35

75

75

136

136

Spray rate
[g/min]

200

200

300

300

400

Inlet air
quantity
[m/h]

1,750

1,750

2,625

2,625

3,500

Process
time
[minutes]

31

66

44

79

60

Nutrition & Health Division

50

75

100

Batch size [kg]


Total process time
[minutes]

125

Inlet air quantity [m/h]

Source: Scaling up a Film Coating Process by Keeping the Ratio of Spray Rate and Inlet Air Quantity Constant
Cech, Wildschek; BASF SE; Funaro, Mondelli, Cembali; IMA; ExcipientFest, June 18./19., 2008, Cork, Ireland

0
150

Inlet air quantity


[m/h]

For achieving an economical and


fast production scale film coat
process very short process times
have to be realised in small scale.

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 36

Case Study (3/1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Materials and equipment perforated drum
Source: Comparing the up scaling characteristics of an instant release coating in solid wall and side vented pan coaters
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A

Side vented pan coater


Perfima Lab and Perfima 200

Formulations

Core ingredients
Ludipress LCE
Kollidon VA 64
Mg-Stearate

Coat ingredients
Kollicoat IR Carmine
Water

Quantity [%]
79.5
20.0
3.0

Quantity [%]
25.0
75.0

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 37

Case Study (3/1) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Trial set up for the perforated drum
Source: Comparing the up scaling characteristics of an instant release coating in solid wall and side vented pan coaters
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

All parameters in large scale


were adjusted according to the
suggested up scaling strategy
and are based on the process
settings in small scale the
surface quality was found to be
identical in all scales.
Perfima Lab

Perfima 200

40 kg

140 kg

7 rpm (361mm/s)

5 rpm (349 mm/s)

50C

50C

Inlet air quantity

1,060 m/h

2,120 m/h

Maximum spray rate

150 g/min

300 g/min

Batch size
Number of nozzles
Drum speed
Inlet air temperature

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 38

Case Study (3/2) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Materials and equipment solid wall drum
Source: Comparing the up scaling characteristics of an instant release coating in solid wall and side vented pan coaters
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A

Solid wall coater


GS HP 25 and GS 300

Formulations

Core ingredients
Caffeine, gran. 0.2-0.5
Ludipress LCE
Kollidon CL-F
Kollidon VA 64 Fine
Mg-Stearate
Coat ingredients
Kollicoat IR Carmine
Water

Quantity [%]
15.5
74.0
5.0
5.0
0.5
Quantity [%]
25.0
75.0

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 39

Case Study (3/2) Kollicoat IR Carmine


Trial set up for the solid wall drum
Source: Comparing the up scaling characteristics of an instant release coating in solid wall and side vented pan coaters
Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Rottmann, Mistry, Wildschek, et al., 37th CRS World Meeting, July 2010, Portland, U.S.A.

All parameters in large scale


were adjusted according to the
suggested up scaling strategy
and are based on the process
settings in small scale the
surface quality was found to be
identical in all scales.
GS HP 25

GS 300

22 kg

202 kg

8 rpm (335 mm/s)

4 rpm (329 mm/s)

60C

60C

Inlet air quantity

350 m/h

1,400 m/h

Maximum spray rate

48 g/min

192 g/min

Batch size
Number of nozzles
Drum speed
Inlet air temperature

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 40

Case Study (4) Kollicoat SR 30 D


Materials and equipment
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

Formulations
Core ingredients

Quantity [%]

Caffein, gran. 0.2-0.5


Ludipress LCE
Kollidon CL-F
Kollidon VA64 fine
Mg-stearate

Side vented pan coater


Perfima Lab

15.5
74.0
5.0
5.0
0.5

Coat ingredients

Quantity [%]

Kollicoat SR30 D
Triacetin
Kollicoat IR
Kollidon 30
Titanium dioxide
Iron oxide red
Talc
Water

43.5
0.7
3.3
0.5
0.5
0.5
3.5
47.5

Nutrition & Health Division

Drum
Small
Medium
Large

Diameter
[mm]

Volume
[L]

Drum speed
[s-1]

765
865
985

15
30
60

9
8
7

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 41

Case Study (4) Kollicoat SR 30 D


Coating and analytical results
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

1.0

Round shaped cores


S
M
L
21.8

43.7

600

600

1,200

39

39

78

0.6

Small pan
Medium pan
Large pan

0.4
0.2
0.0
0

Football shaped cores


S
M
L
Batch size
[kg]
Inlet air volume
[m/h]
Number of
nozzles
Spray rate
[mL/min]

Drug release [-]

10.9

10.1

40.3

530

1,060

31

62

12

16

20

24

Dissolution time [h]


1.0
0.8
Drug release [-]

Batch size
[kg]
Inlet air volume
[m/h]
Number of
nozzles
Spray rate
[mL/min]

0.8

0.6
Small pan
Large pan

0.4
0.2
0.0
0

12

16

20

24

Dissolution time [h]

Dissolution test: 0.08M HCl (pH 1.1, 2h), phosphate buffer (pH 6.8, 22h)
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 42

Case Study (4) Kollicoat SR 30 D


Considering the standard deviation of the dissolution profiles
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

Round shaped cores


S
M
L
Batch size
[kg]
Inlet air volume
[m/h]
Number of
nozzles
Spray rate
[mL/min]

10.9

21.8

43.7

600

600

1,200

39

39

77

The necessarily to apply the coating


material with the maximum possible
spray rate led to very short process
times in small scale (72 min., 11kg).
These caused a high standard
deviation for the small pan.

Drug release [-]

1.0
0.8
Small pan
Medium pan
Large pan

0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0

12

16

20

24

Dissolution time [h]


Dissolution test: 0.08M HCl (pH 1.1, 2h), phosphate buffer (pH 6.8, 22h)
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 43

Case Study (4) Kollicoat SR 30 D


Considering the standard deviation of the dissolution profiles
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

Football shaped cores


S
M
L
Batch size
[kg]
Inlet air volume
[m/h]
Number of
nozzles
Spray rate
[mL/min]

10.1

40.3

530

1,060

31

62

Due to the tablet shape, lower spray


rates had to be applied for these
cores, leading to a longer process
time (80min., 10kg), hereby causing
a lower standard deviation in the
small pan.

Drug release [-]

1.0
0.8
Small pan
Medium pan
Large pan

0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0

12

16

20

24

Dissolution time [h]


Dissolution test: 0.08M HCl (pH 1.1, 2h), phosphate buffer (pH 6.8, 22h)
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 44

Case Study (4) Kollicoat SR 30 D


Considering the standard deviation of the dissolution profiles
Source: Els Mehuys, Jean Paul Remon, Lab of Pharmaceutical Technology, Ghent University, Gent, Belgium

Round shaped cores


S
L

Coating
Batch size
[kg]
Inlet air volume
[m/h]
Number of
nozzles
Spray rate
[mL/min]

10.9

43.7

600

1,200

1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4

39

0.2
0.0
0

12

16

20

24

20

24

D is s o lutio n tim e [h]

77
1.0

Dissolution
Colour (chart)
Samples

S
red
78

0.8

L
blue
80

0.6
0.4
0.2

The coating uniformity represented


by the variations in drug release in
drug release was found to be
improving with larger batch sizes.
Nutrition & Health Division

0.0
0

12

16

D is s o lutio n tim e [h]

Dissolution test: 0.08M HCl (pH 1.1, 2h), phosphate buffer (pH 6.8, 22h)
VanKel VK7010 dissolution apparatus equipped with
VK8000 auto-sampler and VK750D heater

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 45

How to proceed in an up scaling process?


Use of the up scaling strategy
Source: Thorsten Cech, European Pharma Application Lab, BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany

Feasibility
0.1

Lab

Pilot

15

Production
75

125

500 [kg]

Model 970/S35
Model 970/S75
Model 930/S45

The up scaling strategy applies on processes conducted in lab, pilot and


production scale. Feasibility studies can hardly be basis for up scaling
calculation, problems: dimensional ratios, nozzle, etc.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 46

How to proceed in an up scaling process?


Development and up scaling start in production
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained-release coating using side vented pan coating technology
Agnese, Cech, Cembali, Funaro, Mondelli, Wildschek; 7th PBP World Meeting; March 8 - 11, 2010; Valletta, Malta

Production scale

Evaluate:

Max. inlet air temp.


Max. inlet air quantity
Number of nozzles
Type of nozzles

Nutrition & Health Division

Production scale

Lab and pilot scale

Development on:
Formulation (coating, core)
Polymer
Solid matter content

Process parameters
Inlet air temp. and quantity
Spray rate per nozzle
Drum speed

Production, keeping:

Temperatures
Rel. inlet air quantity
Spray rate per nozzle
Circumferential speed
Number of nozzles
Type of nozzles

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 47

How to proceed in an up scaling process?


Summary (1)
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

It can be concluded that the up scaling theory suggested for instant


release film coating polymers can be transferred to functional coatings as
well.
As the approach requires very short process times in small scale, the
resulting release profile shows high standard deviation.
The determination of the maximum spray rate in small scale is necessary
to calculate the spray rate and process air volume in large scale, while
maintaining the same moisture exposure throughout the entire scale up
process.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 48

How to proceed in an up scaling process?


Summary (2)
Source: Investigating the up scaling properties of a sustained release coating using side vented pan coating technology
T. Agnese, T. Cech, F. Wildschek, C. Funaro, G. Mondelli, F. Cembali, PBP World Meeting, March 2010, Valetta, Malta

It is suggested to perform both trials in small scale during development:


1. Using optimal process time with low spray rate to apply a
homogenous coat.
Development of the release profile.
2. Using maximum spray rate to do the up scaling calculations and to
expose the same amount of moisture as in production.
Important for moisture sensitive drugs or formulations.
The energy exposure can easily be kept constant by leaving the cores in
the drum for the required period of time.
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 49

Summary
Theoretical consideration
Source: Scaling up in Film Coating Processes
Thorsten Cech, Florian Wildschek; BASF SE; ExcipientFest Europe, June 17./18., 2008, Cork, Ireland

If a certain amount of inlet air is reached, a further increase of process air


quantity does not improve the drying characteristics significantly. The
improvement of the coating process which can be observed, results from
a higher air velocity leading to a higher heat transfer coefficient.
As parameter to calculate a scale-up process, the amount of film coating
dispersion applied on a single core, when it is passing the spray pattern,
can be used.
To simulate the characteristics of a production scale film coating process,
the shortest possible process times has to be used in pilot scale.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 50

Summary
Study 1 keeping the ratio of spray rate and air quantity
Source: Scaling up a Film Coating Process by Keeping the Ratio of Spray Rate and Inlet Air Quantity Constant
Cech, Wildschek; BASF SE; Funaro, Mondelli, Cembali; IMA; ExcipientFest, June 18./19., 2008, Cork, Ireland

Independent from scale, the ratio of spray rate to inlet air volume is
responsible for the surface quality. Using this parameter scale-up
calculation can be done easily.
Process times in small scale have to be as short as possible to be
comparable with large scale.
The Perfima 200 is a variable coater system enabling a broad range of
batch sizes.
Kollicoat Protect can be used with a very low polymer content of just 25%
in pilot and production scale. This enables formulations offering highest
protective properties against ambient moisture.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 51

Summary
Study 2 keeping the ratio of spray rate and air quantity
Source: Investigating the Dependency of the Maximum Spray Rate on the Amount of Inlet Air
Cech, Wildschek; BASF SE; Funaro, Mondelli, Cembali; IMA; ExcipientFest, June 18./19., 2008, Cork, Ireland

The drying efficiency depends strongly on the inlet air quantity. The
higher the inlet air quantity the higher the applicable spray rate.
With very high spray rates process times can be realised which might too
short to assure a uniform coating depending on the mixing efficiency of
the coater.

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 52

ExAct magazine
Column on trouble shooting

#21: Film coating Scuffing


#22: Film coating Spots
#23: Tabletting Loss on drying
#24: Film coating Sedimentation
#25: Film coating Plasticizers
to be continued

http://www.pharma-ingredients.basf.com/exact.aspx
Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 53

Contact

Thorsten Cech
Manager
European Pharma Application Lab
BASF SE
G-ENP/ET Nutrition & Health
Pharma Ingredients & Services
Europe, Africa, West Asia
Phone:
Mobile:
Fax:

+ 49 (0) 621 / 60 99 290


+ 49 (0) 173 / 347 99 58
+ 49 (0) 621 / 60 66 99 290

Mail:
Internet:

thorsten.cech@basf.com
www.pharma-ingredients.basf.com
http://www.excipients-academy.basf.eu/Home.aspx

Nutrition & Health Division

Pharma Ingredients & Services

T. Cech - G-ENP/ET - page 54

S-ar putea să vă placă și