Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CORPORATE FINANCE
KHOO YU TING
921227015896
200080
NOVEMBER 2013
TOPIC PAGES
1 Contents 2
2 Task 1 3-12
3 Task 2 13-15
Page 2 of 35
Coursework
6 28-34
TABLE OF CONTENT
2.0 Task 1
One limit to the amount of debt a firm might use comes in the form of bankruptcy costs.3
As the debtequity ratio rises, so does the probability that the firm will be unable to pay
its debtholders what was promised to them. When this happens, ownership of the firm's
In principle, a firm becomes bankrupt when the value of its assets equals the value of its
debt. When this occurs, the value of equity is zero and the shareholders turn over control
of the firm to the debtholders. At this point, the debtholders hold assets whose value is
exactly equal to what is owed on the debt. In a perfect world, there are no costs
associated with this transfer of ownership, and the debtholders do not lose anything.
This idealised view of bankruptcy is not, of course, what happens in the real world.
When the value of a firm's assets equals the value of its debt, the firm is economically
bankrupt in the sense that the equity has no value. However, the formal turning over of
the assets to the debtholders is a legal process, not an economic one. There are legal and
Page 3 of 35
administrative costs to bankruptcy, and it has been remarked that bankruptcies are to
Because of the expenses associated with bankruptcy, debtholders will not get all that
they are owed. Some fraction of the firm's assets will disappear in the legal process of
going bankrupt. These are the legal and administrative expenses associated with the
bankruptcy proceeding. We call these costs direct bankruptcy costs The costs that are
Because it is expensive to go bankrupt, a firm will spend resources to avoid doing so.
When a firm is having significant problems in meeting its debt obligations, we say that it
is experiencing financial distress. Some financially distressed firms ultimately file for
bankruptcy, but most do not because they are able to recover or otherwise survive.
The costs of avoiding a bankruptcy filing incurred by a financially distressed firm are
called indirect bankruptcy costs The costs of avoiding a bankruptcy filing incurred by a
financially distressed firm.. We use the term financial distress costs The direct and
indirect costs associated with going bankrupt or experiencing financial distress. to refer
generically to the direct and indirect costs associated with going bankrupt or avoiding a
bankruptcy filing.
The problems that come up in financial distress are particularly severeand the
financial distress costs are thus largerwhen the shareholders and the debtholders are
different groups. Until the firm is legally bankrupt, the shareholders control it. They, of
course, will take actions in their own economic interest. Since the shareholders can be
Page 4 of 35
wiped out in a legal bankruptcy, they have a very strong incentive to avoid a bankruptcy
filing.
The debt holders, on the other hand, are primarily concerned with protecting the value
of the firm's assets and will try to take control away from the shareholders. They have a
strong incentive to seek bankruptcy to protect their interests and keep shareholders from
further dissipating the assets of the firm. The net effect of all this fighting is that a long,
Meanwhile, as the wheels of justice turn in their ponderous way, the assets of the firm
lose value, because management is busy trying to avoid bankruptcy instead of running the
business. Normal operations are disrupted and sales are lost. Valuable employees leave,
potentially fruitful programs are dropped to preserve cash, and otherwise profitable
These are all indirect bankruptcy costs, or costs of financial distress. Whether or not the
firm ultimately goes bankrupt, the net effect is a loss of value because the firm chose to
use debt in its capital structure. It is this possibility of loss that limits the amount of debt
Page 5 of 35
1.2 Continental airline in the United States once filed for bankruptcy
Continental Airlines filed for protection from its creditors under bankruptcy laws
yesterday, attributing the step to the jump in fuel prices and the cost of interest on its huge
debts.
The airline, the nation's fifth largest, has been flirting with bankruptcy for months. Since
the crisis in the Persian Gulf sent fuel costs sharply higher, Continental's $2.2 billion in
debt -- a legacy of a high-growth strategy in the 1980's under its former chairman, Frank
Eastern Airlines, also acquired by Mr. Lorenzo under that strategy, filed for
reorganization under the bankruptcy laws in March 1989. It is now operating under the
direction of a trustee.
Continental's bankruptcy filing will give the airline a reprieve from paying its debts so
that it can continue its regular flights as it tries to work out a way to pay its bills and
return to financial health. In the filing, Continental said that it had $138 million in cash.
Whereas bankruptcies once gave companies a cash buffer, by allowing them to stop
payment on unsecured debts, today, most debt is secured which is to say, collateralised
(for airlines, with their planes, facilities and landing rights). This leaves debtors reliant on
debtor-in-possession (DIP) lenders for cash. These lenders, typically large investment
banks like JP Morgan, get priority over other creditors and can make all sorts of demands
on the company. And increasingly, DIP lenders have learned to leverage this position to
Page 6 of 35
reshape corporate governance according to their whims: sometimes in preparation to
Since Frank Lorenzo's big union bust of 1983, bankruptcy has been for the airlines a
super trump card in labor negotiations, used to void contracts and impose conditions
unilaterally. It's also a nice way for the company to pass the buck, if cuts are demanded
by lenders as terms of the bankruptcy. American's cash reserves, not to mention its hefty
executive compensation and recent purchase of 460 new planes from Boeing and Airbus
for $38bn, show how much this filing is a matter of careful strategy and not sudden
financial calamity. That makes it harder for the company to plead poverty, either to its
employees or the bankruptcy judge, when demanding yet another round of concessions.
Page 7 of 35
1.3 Steps can stockholders take to reduce the cost of debt
Protective Covenants
Because the stockholders must pay higher interest rates as insurance against their own
selfish strategies, they frequently make agreements with bondholders in hopes of lower
rates These agreements, called protective covenants, are incorporated as part of the loan
document (or indenture) between stockholders and bondholders. The covenants must he
taken seriously because a broken covenant can lead to default. Protective covenants can
A negative covenant limits or prohibits actions that the company may take. I lere are
2. The firm may not pledge any of its assets to other lenders.
4. The firm may not sell or lease its major assets without approval lender.
Page 8 of 35
A positive covenant specifies an action that the company agrees to take or a condition the
Consolidation of Debt
One reason bankruptcy costs are so high is that different creditors (and their lawyers)
contend with each other. This problem can be alleviated by proper arrangement of
bondholders and stockholders. For example, perhaps one, or at most a few, lenders can
shoulder the entire debt. Should financial distress occur, negotiating costs are minimized
under this arrangement. In addition, bondholders can purchase stock as well. In this way,
stockholders and debt holders are not pitted against each other because they are not
separate entities.
This appears to be the approach in Japan, where large banks generally take significant
stock positions in the firms to which they lend money. Debt equity ratios in Japan are far
There are six basic strategies that can help you out of excessive debt:
1. Reduce Costs
Page 9 of 35
make small reductions across the board
To make savings across the board, set a savings target (say, 10%) and reduce each budget
by that amount. Then take small steps to reduce costs, eg: reduce train costs by travelling
purchasing, etc..
2. Increase Income
There are various ways of increasing the amount of money flowing into your business,
such as:
Increase sales
special deals to get additional or advance orders, getting referrals with other
organizations/affiliates
eg: renting out unused office space, assessing your waste or unused products and
seeing if it has any value, selling advertising space on your website (eg: Google
Page 10 of 35
3. Restructure liabilities
Your 'liabilities' are all the amounts of money that you owe to other people. Restructuring
your liabilities doesn't necessarily reduce the overall amount you owe, but it can give you
more cash, more disposable income and/or reduce the amount of debt you need to
Examples of ways that you can restructure your liabilities to reduce your debt include:
o consolidated loans
o shareholder funds
4. Restructure Assets
Page 11 of 35
Your 'assets' are all the things your business owns. This section on restructuring your
Convert necessary assets into liabilities: sell to a finance company and lease them
back
Factor invoices (this can reduce the asset value of the invoice, but raish cash)
obtaining grants
Also, take a look at your asset list and assess whether it can be converted into assets of
greater value. For example, if you own land, can you build more offices or houses on that
land?
Selling off all the business assets (including the business goodwill, eg: the client
3.0 Task 2
In the corporate form of ownership, the shareholders are the owners of the firm. The
shareholders elect the directors of the corporation, who in turn appoint the firm's
management.
This separation of ownership from control in the corporate form of organization is what
Management may act in its own or someone else's best interests, rather than those of the
shareholders.
Page 13 of 35
If such events occur, they may contradict the goal of maximizing the share price of the
The upper-middle and upper class own about 40% of all stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
The middle and lower middle class own another 9%. The bottom 50% of all income
Now for the disturbing part: the top 1% of American income earners own just over 50%
of all corporate stocks, bonds and mutual funds. This degree of ownership effectively
gives 1% of our population unfettered control over the corporations and financial
institutions that are at the centre of our national way of life. The rest of us may have some
interest in their profitability, but a very elite class of persons decide what those
companies do.
The law recognizes a corporation as a wholly separate legal entity. It means the business
is actually viewed as being separate and distinct from the individuals who run the
with 51 per cent of the stock owns a controlling interest in the corporation and can
significantly influence decisions. The shareholders own a corporation. This can range
called "institutional investors," such as mutual funds, retirement plans and insurance
companies. There are a variety of types of shares that can be issued by a corporation, e.g.,
common and preferred, and within these shares there are different classes as well. Shares
can be voting or non-voting, have dividends paid out to them or not. Although the rights
Page 14 of 35
attached to the shares may vary, all of the shares have one thing in common - they
corporation are overseen by the board of directors but there must be an annual meeting of
the shareholders to elect the board, and often to ratify the actions taken by the board on
their behalf. At this meeting the shareholders also have the opportunity to question the
Since such organizations frequently pursue social or political missions, many different
One goal that is often cited is revenue minimization; i.e. providing their goods and
Another approach might be to observe that even a not-for-profit business has equity.
Page 15 of 35
2.3 Corporate ownership varies around the world
We would expect agency problems to be less severe in other countries, primarily due to
the relatively small percentage of individual ownership. Fewer individual owners should
reduce the number of diverse opinions concerning corporate goals. The high percentage
individual owners, based on the institutionsu2019 deeper resources and experiences with
their own management. The increase in institutional ownership of stock in the United
States and the growing activism of these large shareholder groups may lead to a reduction
in agency problems for U.S. corporations and a more efficient market for corporate
control.
4.0 Task 3
Preferred Stock
The proportion of ownership depends on how many shares of stock the corporation has
released into the market. But unlike common shareholders, preferred shareholders
typically don't get involved in running the company. They don't vote on corporate director
Page 16 of 35
Debt
a debt security, under which the issuer owes the holders a debt and, depending on the
terms of the bond, is obliged to pay them interest and/or to repay the principal at a later
date, termed the maturity. Therefore, a bond is a form of loan or IOU: the holder of the
bond is the lender (creditor), the issuer of the bond is the borrower (debtor), and the
coupon is the interest. Bonds provide the borrower with external funds to finance long-
term investments, or, in the case of government bonds, to finance current expenditure.
First, preferred stockholders have a greater claim to a company's assets and earnings.
This is true during the good times when the company has excess cash and decides to
distribute money in the form of dividends to its investors. In these instances when
distributions are made, preferred stockholders must be paid before common stockholders.
However, this claim is most important during times of insolvency when common
stockholders are last in line for the company's assets. This means that when the company
must liquidate and pay all creditors and bondholders, common stockholders will not
receive any money until after the preferred shareholders are paid out.
Page 17 of 35
Second, the dividends of preferred stocks are different from and generally greater than
those of common stock. When you buy a preferred stock, you will have an idea of when
to expect a dividend because they are paid at regular intervals. This is not necessarily the
case for common stock, as the company's board of directors will decide whether or not to
pay out a dividend. Because of this characteristic, preferred stock typically don't fluctuate
security. Adding to this fixed-income personality is the fact that the dividends are
typically guaranteed, meaning that if the company does miss one, it will be required to
To sum up: a good way to think of a preferred stock is as a security with characteristics
3.2 Preferred stock doesnt offer corporate tax shield on the dividends paid
There is no direct tax advantage to the issuing of preferred shares when compared to
other forms of financing such as common shares or debt. The reason for this is that
preferred shares, which are a form of equity, are paid fixed dividends with after-tax
dollars. This is the same case for common shares. If dividends are paid out, it is in after-
tax dollars.
Preferred shares are considered to be like debt in that they pay a fixed rate like a bond (a
debt investment). It is because interest expenses on bonds are tax deductible, while
preferred shares pay with after-tax dollars, that preferred shares are considered a more
Page 18 of 35
expensive means of financing. Issuing preferred shares does have its benefits over bonds
in that a company can stop making payments on preferred shares where they are unable
There are a few reasons why issuing preferred shares are a benefit for companies. One
benefit of issuing preferred shares, is that for financing purposes they do not reflect added
debt on the company's financial books. This actually can save money for the company in
the long run. When the company looks for debt financing in the future, it will receive a
lower rate since it will appear the company's debt load is lower - causing the company to
in turn pay less on future debt. Preferred shares also tend to not have voting rights, so
another benefit becomes that issuing preferred shares does not dilute the voting rights of
Preferred Stock is stock which is preferred over common stock in any number of
Preferred stock may have a liquidation preference, which is a right to be paid first
a certain fixed or formulaic amount of money before the common stock or other
junior series of preferred stock are entitled to receive any portion of the proceeds
Preferred stock may have purchase price anti-dilution protection, which means
that if the company issues additional stock in the future at a price per share lower
than the price per share at which the preferred stock was sold, the preferred stocks
purchase price will in effect be reduced as a result of the subsequent stock sale at the
lower price;
Page 19 of 35
Preferred stock may have special voting rights (including protective provisions,
Preferred stock may be entitled to dividends before any dividends may be paid on
Preferred stock may have redemption rights, meaning the holders will have the
right to have their preferred shares redeemed after a certain period of time.
5.0 Task 4
4.1 The major advantages and disadvantages of the corporate form of organization as
A Sole Proprietorship is a business with one owner who operates the business on his or
her own or employ employees. It is the simplest and the most numerous form of business
organization in the United States, however it is dangerous as the sole proprietor has total
Page 20 of 35
1. Simplest and least expensive form of business to establish and to dissolve.
2. The owner is making all the decisions and controlling the whole operations.
5. It has tax advantage: any income is declared as the owners personal income tax
2. It is difficult to raise capital: it can only use the owners personal saving and
consumer loans.
A Partnership is a business with two or more individuals owns and manages the
business. Partners share the unlimited liabilities of the business and operate the business
together. There are three classification of partnerships: general partnership (partner divide
partnership (in additional at least one general partner, there are one or more limited
partner who have limited liability to the extent of their investment), and limited liability
partnership (all of the partners have limited liability of the business debts; it has no
general partners).
Advantages of a partnership
one investor.
Page 21 of 35
3. Any income is declared as the partners personal income tax returns, therefore
become a partner
Disadvantages of a partnership
1. Partners are jointly responsible for all the obligations of the business.
2. Partners must make decision together therefore disputes or conflicts may occur. It
and is overseen by a board of directors elected by the shareholders. It is distinct from its
owners and can borrow money, enter into contracts, pay taxes and be sued. The
shareholders gain from the profit through dividend or appreciation of the stocks but are
Advantages of a corporation
3. Individual owner liability is limited to the value of stock they are holding in the
corporation.
Disadvantages of a corporation
agencies and are more costly to incorporate than other forms of the organizations.
2. Profit of the business is taxed by the corporate tax rate. Dividends paid to
shareholders are not deductible from corporate income, so this part of income is taxed
Page 22 of 35
twice as the shareholders must declare dividends as their personal income and pay
1. Stability of Earnings. The nature of business has an important bearing on the dividend
policy. Industrial units having stability of earnings may formulate a more consistent
dividend policy than those having an uneven flow of incomes because they can predict
easily their savings and earnings. Usually, enterprises dealing in necessities suffer less
2. Age of corporation. Age of the corporation counts much in deciding the dividend
policy. A newly established company may require much of its earnings for expansion and
plant improvement and may adopt a rigid dividend policy while, on the other hand, an
older company can formulate a clear cut and more consistent policy regarding dividend.
Page 23 of 35
important factor in dividend decisions. A dividend represents a cash outflow, the greater
the funds and the liquidity of the firm the better the ability to pay dividend. The liquidity
of a firm depends very much on the investment and financial decisions of the firm which
in turn determines the rate of expansion and the manner of financing. If cash position is
weak, stock dividend will be distributed and if cash position is good, company can
4. Extent of share Distribution. Nature of ownership also affects the dividend decisions.
A closely held company is likely to get the assent of the shareholders for the suspension
company having a good number of shareholders widely distributed and forming low or
medium income group, would face a great difficulty in securing such assent because they
5. Needs for Additional Capital. Companies retain a part of their profits for
strengthening their financial position. The income may be conserved for meeting the
usually find difficulties in raising finance for their needs of increased working capital for
expansion programmes. They having no other alternative, use their ploughed back profits.
Thus, such Companies distribute dividend at low rates and retain a big part of profits.
6. Trade Cycles. Business cycles also exercise influence upon dividend Policy. Dividend
policy is adjusted according to the business oscillations. During the boom, prudent
Page 24 of 35
management creates food reserves for contingencies which follow the inflationary period.
Higher rates of dividend can be used as a tool for marketing the securities in an otherwise
depressed market. The financial solvency can be proved and maintained by the
companies in dull years if the adequate reserves have been built up.
7. Government Policies. The earnings capacity of the enterprise is widely affected by the
change in fiscal, industrial, labour, control and other government policies. Sometimes
particular industry or in all spheres of business activity as was done in emergency. The
8. Taxation Policy. High taxation reduces the earnings of he companies and consequently
distribution of dividend beyond a certain limit. It also affects the capital formation. N
India, dividends beyond 10 % of paid-up capital are subject to dividend tax at 7.5 %.
9. Legal Requirements. In deciding on the dividend, the directors take the legal
outsiders, the companies Act 1956 prescribes certain guidelines in respect of the
depreciation on its fixed and tangible assets before declaring dividend on shares. It
proposes that Dividend should not be distributed out of capita, in any case. Likewise,
Page 25 of 35
preference shares in priority over ordinary dividend.
10. Past dividend Rates. While formulating the Dividend Policy, the directors must keep
in mind the dividend paid in past years. The current rate should be around the average
past rat. If it has been abnormally increased the shares will be subjected to speculation. In
a new concern, the company should consider the dividend policy of the rival organisation.
11. Ability to Borrow. Well established and large firms have better access to the capital
market than the new Companies and may borrow funds from the external sources if there
arises any need. Such Companies may have a better dividend pay-out ratio. Whereas
smaller firms have to depend on their internal sources and therefore they will have to
built up good reserves by reducing the dividend pay out ratio for meeting any obligation
dividends are concerned. If the directors want to have control on company, they would
not like to add new shareholders and therefore, declare a dividend at low rate. Because by
adding new shareholders they fear dilution of control and diversion of policies and
programmers of the existing management. So they prefer to meet the needs through
retained earing. If the directors do not bother about the control of affairs they will follow
a liberal dividend policy. Thus control is an influencing factor in framing the dividend
policy.
13. Repayments of Loan. A company having loan indebtedness are vowed to a high rate
Page 26 of 35
of retention earnings, unless one other arrangements are made for the redemption of debt
on maturity. It will naturally lower down the rate of dividend. Sometimes, the lenders
(mostly institutional lenders) put restrictions on the dividend distribution still such time
their loan is outstanding. Formal loan contracts generally provide a certain standard of
14. Time for Payment of Dividend. When should the dividend be paid is another
distribute dividend at a time when is least needed by the company because there are peak
times as well as lean periods of expenditure. Wise management should plan the payment
of dividend in such a manner that there is no cash outflow at a time when the undertaking
15. Regularity and stability in Dividend Payment. Dividends should be paid regularly
because each investor is interested in the regular payment of dividend. The management
should, inspite of regular payment of dividend, consider that the rate of dividend should
be all the most constant. For this purpose sometimes companies maintain dividend
equalization Fund.
Page 27 of 35
6.0 Coursework
1. Straight Bonds
debt instrument issued by the company in the form of a certificate. A bond certificate is
evidence that the company (issuer) has borrowed a fixed amount of money from the
lenders (investors) with a promise to repay the principal amount at maturity and make
periodic interest payments on the principal. Unlike loan stocks, bonds are negotiable or
transferable.
When an investor buys a bond, he is lending money to the company and becomes a
creditor of the company. The company issuing the bond is the debtor or the borrower. The
amount owed to the creditor is a liability of the company. Failure of the company to pay
Page 28 of 35
The following are the features of straight bonds:
I. Principal value or par value: Straight bonds are usually denominated in units of RM
100 (if in Malaysia). This stated face value of a bond is called the principal or par value.
The issuing company promises to repay the principal amount by a certain date called the
maturity date. The price is often expressed as a percentage of the par value. For example,
if the price is quoted at 80, this means that a bond with a par value of RM 100 is selling at
RM8O. In this situation, the bond is selling at a discount became the market price is
Bonds can also be sold at a premium with respect to the par value. The issuer of bond
generally pays interest at a rate expressed as a percentage of the par value. For example, a
5 percent bond means that RMS of interest is paid to the holders of the bond, usually in
semiannual installments. These payments are referred to as "coupons" and the 5 percent
agreement that lists the obligations of the issuer to the bondholders, including the
payment schedule and features such as call provisions and sinking funds
3. Call provision: This feature gives the issuer the right to call in the bonds before
maturity. Exercising the call provision becomes attractive to an issuer when the market
interest rates drop below the coupon rate on the outstanding bonds. The issuer can save
money by issuing new bonds at lower rates. When a call is issued, the bondholders must
submit the bonds for redemption and the company (issuer) will have to pay back the
Page 29 of 35
principal and a small premium, the call price, to the bondholders. The call price is always
For example, bond that is callable at 10S is debt that the company can buy back from the
holder at a price of RM 105 per bond, regardless of what themarket value of the bond
might be. Call prices are always specified when the debt is originally issued.
4. Sinking fund: A sinking fund provision specifies payment the issuer must make to
redeem a given percentage of the outstanding issue prior to maturity. A sinking fund is
required for the orderly retirement of the bond issue during the life of the bond. Long-
term debt is usually repaid in regular amounts over the life of the debt. The payment of
The entire debt is extinguished at the end of the amortization. Amortization is typically
arranged by a sinking fund. Each year the company places money in the sinking fund and
5. Collateral: Bonds can have different types of collateral as follows: Secured bonds
These bonds are backed by a legal claim on some specific property of the issuer in the
case of default. In the event of a default, the property can be sold to satisfy the debt for
which the security is given. Holders of such bonds have prior claim on the mortgaged
Unsecured bonds (debentures) These bonds are backed only by the promise of the issuer
to pay interest and principal on a timely basis. As such, they are secured by the general
Page 30 of 35
credit of the issuer. In the event of a default, the debenture holders will obtain something
lenders. Some debts are subordinated. In the event of a default holders of subordinated
debt must give preference to other specified creditors. This means that the subordinated
lenders will be paid off only after the specified creditors have been compensated.
Different Types of Bonds There are many different types of bonds. These are discussed
below.
1. Debentures: A debenture is an unsecured bond. This means that the issuing company
promises to pay principal and interest on the debenture but it pledges no specific assets in
case the company does not fulfill its promise. Therefore, debenture holders depend on the
success of the borrower to make the promised payment. If the issuer does not make an
interest payment, the debenture holders can declare the company bankrupt and claim any
the event of a default, subordinated bondholders have a claim on the assets of the
company only after it has satisfied the claims of all senior secured bonds and debenture
holders.
3. Income bonds: Income bonds stipulate payment schedules, but the interest is due
and payable I only if the issuer earns an income to make the payments by the stipulated
dates. In the event that the company does not earn sufficient income, it does not have to
make the interest payments and it cannot be declared bankrupt. However, the interest
Page 31 of 35
payments must be paid subsequently. Income bonds usually offer higher returns to
compensate investors for the added risk of uncertainty in interest payments of the issuer.
4. Variable interest rate bonds: A variable interest rate bond is a long-term bond with
a coupon rate that varies with changes in the short-term interest rates. The variability of
the interest rate A means that if the short-term interest rate rises, the interest rate paid by
5. Bonds with warrant: In Malaysia, bonds issued with detachable warrants are quite
common. The issuer offers the entire issues of bonds with warrants at face value to a
primary subscriber. The primary subscriber subsequently detaches the warrants and sells
them to shareholders of the issuer in the secondary market. Bonds with warrants have low
coupon rates and are sold at | a discount to yield the rate of return required by investors in
the secondary market. The bonds allow the issuer to first raise money through the sale of
the bonds. Later , when warrants are exercised ,the issuer is able to raise funds again
Page 32 of 35
2.Rules of the Pecking Order
The previous discussion presented the basic ideas behind the pecking-order theory. What
are the practical implications of the theory for financial managers? The theory provides
comparing equity to riskless debt. Managers cannot use special knowledge of their firm
to determine if this type of debt is mispriced because the price of riskless debt is
determined solely by the marketwide interest rate. However, in reality, corporate debt has
the possibility of default. Thus, just as managers tend to issue equity when they think it is
overvalued, managers also tend to issue debt when they think it is overvalued.
When would managers view their debt as overvalued? Probably in the same
Page 33 of 35
situations when they think their equity is overvalued. For example, if the public thinks
that the firm's prospects are rosy but the managers see trouble ahead, these managers
would view their debtas well as their equityas being overvalued. That is, the public
might see the debt as nearly risk-free, whereas the managers see a strong possibility of
default.
Thus, investors are likely to price a debt issue with the same skepticism that they
have when pricing an equity issue. The way managers get out of this box is to finance
projects out of retained earnings. You don't have to worry about investor skepticism if
you can avoid going to investors in the first place. So the first rule of the pecking order is
Rule #2 Issue Safe Securities First Although investors fear mispricing of both debt and
equity, the fear is much greater for equity. Corporate debt still has relatively little risk
return. Thus, the pecking-order theory implies that if outside financing is required, debt
should be issued before equity. Only when the firm's debt capacity is reached should the
Of course, there are many types of debt. For example, because convertible debt is more
risky than straight debt, the pecking-order theory implies that managers should issue
straight debt before issuing convertibles. So, the second rule of pecking-order theory is
Page 34 of 35
Page 35 of 35