Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
(3D PRINTING)
J00563923
Date: 12/5/2016
1
Table of Contents
2
discharge machining. Since the desired part is produced by the removal of material
there is loss of material, if the material is expensive SM could be highly undesirable.
Moreover, it is cumbersome for complex parts and deep internal features. AM
manufacturing overcome these limitations as it prints the parts by adding layer and layer
and can print complex parts. As AM machines use a single material deposition tool to
build the entire part, which saves time since no part refixturing, zeroing, or tool setup is
necessary [5].
3
Fig: 3D Printer
Set up cost 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0
Cost-low
1 1 0 1 1 1 0
volume
Surface
0 -1 -1 -1 -1 1
finish
Integrated
1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0
Assembly
Complexity 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Customizabil
1 1 0 1 0 1 0 0
ity
Resolution 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 1
Total 6 5 4 4 1 3 2 3
5
Pugh matrix choose Fused Deposition modeling over other Additive Manufacturing technique
with polymer composite.
6
can be ready by specific 3 D printers. After loading the compatible file into the 3D
printer, the structure will be printed based on the slicing of STL file [15].
3 D printing has been mostly use for the designing of the prototype till date but the
advancement in the materials and technology has made it possible to use this
technology to produce functional parts. Subtracting manufacturing has been the
backbone of manufacturing till date but this technology cost too much of waste of
material which in intolerable in case where material cost is too high. Moreover, the time
required for subtracting technology is also very much.
Some the additive manufacturing technique are described below:
1. Fused deposition modeling
Fused deposition modeling (FDM) is an additive manufacturing process used to make
thermoplastic parts through heated extrusion and deposition of materials layer by layer
[8]. FDM continues to be versatile process for rapid manufacturing of extrusion
materials in applications including short-run tooling molds, casting end-use parts, and
more [9]. Extrusion based techniques greatest strength is its versatility of
manufacturing across length scales as shown in fig.4.
Fig.4. extrusion-based AM can operate from the micro to macro scale [10]
Instead of using a mold and high temperature heating, FDM heats the filament a little
above its melting temperature, extrudes to generate thin fiber with diameter around
0.25mm and deposits onto a platform in a 2-dimensional pattern, where it cools below
melting point and solidifies immediately. Another layer will be subsequently deposited
on top. One limitation of FDM is that the printing mechanism involves melting and
extrusion, thus only thermoplastic polymer can be printed [12]. With the continued
improvement of printing head technologies, several companies, including Stratasys and
Arevo labs, have successfully printed high performance polymer with FDM, for
example Polyphenylsulfone(PPSU), Polyehteretherketone(PEEK),
Polyaryletherketone(PAEK) etc. [11-12].
7
Fig.5. Schematic of FDM process [13].
2. Stereolithography
This technique is based on a photoinitiated polymerization printing mechanism [14].
The material that can be printed by SLA should be photocurable. Liquid resin composed
of photocurable monomer/oligomer, photo initiator and other additives, is placed in a
reservoir where a building platform is used to control the motion of resin. Two printing
directions, bottom-up and top-down [15] are applied in different SLA printers, as shown
in fig.6.
Fig.6. Schematic diagram of SLA setup. Left: top-down printing SLA; Right: bottom-
up printing SLA [16].
8
For the top-down approach, the building platform is lifted to the surface of resin bath so
that the resin flows to the bottom and only a thin layer of resin, with a thickness equal to
layer thickness in sliced STL file, is on top of the platform. During printing, laser
light shown with specific wavelength shone from top initiate polymerization. Once a
layer is printed the platform will lower down and roller will place another layer of resin
on top of solidified resin for subsequent curing. On the other hand, the building
platform of the bottom-up printer is moved to a position near the bottom where a
narrow gap will be left between the reservoir and the platform so that a thin layer of
resin can be placed inside the gap. The laser light will be shone from beneath the
reservoir to cure exposed resin. After printing each layer, platform will be lifted to
expose another thin layer of resin. In this case roller requirement is not avoided due to
the gravity effect [12].
9
Fig. Selective laser sintering (SLS)
5. Polyjet
10
Polyjet is a photopolymerization printing technique; the resin is supplied via injection
from a printing head to form a 2-dimensional pattern. UV light is shone right after to
cure and solidify the injected resin. This technique can be used to print different resin
materials in one part together. Although resolution of Polyjet is very high, its
mechanical strength is weaker than SLA or SLS [20, 21].
Fig. Polyjet
6. Laminated object manufacturing
It is a combination of subtractive and additive manufacturing. Subtractive component of
the process form a 2-dimensional pattern from the bulk material sheet. Additive
component involves the adhesion of one layer of bulk material sheet to another to form
a 3-dimensional structure [22].
11
Fig. Laminated object manufacturing
7. Paste extrusion printing
Paste extrusion printing, also called direct-writing 3D printing, is a newly developed
technique [24, 25]. The process is like FDM except instead of filament it uses printable
ink, which is highly viscous and shear thinning fluid composed of single or multiple
components. The ink needs to have lower viscosity while being extruded to flow
smoothly and solid like after extrusion to maintain its shape as well as to support the
subsequent layers [26].
Fig.7. Schematic of paste extrusion printer setup a) full setup, b) deposition from
printing nozzle, c) the printed paste [27].
12
Challenges with 3D printing
Print speed: most of the 3D printers function in the Cartesian plane where the
movements gets restricted to vertical and horizontal direction. The time
necessary for printing objects is increased and chances of errors increases.
Material mixing: It is quite difficult to find a printer that can mix different
materials to print a single object.
Finished product: failure rate is high with 3D printers. So most popular uses
for 3D printing are limited to prototyping. The required safety standard does
not comply with normal standards in the more advanced countries.
Energy inefficiency: 3D printers consume 50 to 100 times more energy as
compared to energy consumed during the conventional moulding of plastic.
Health risk: the printer emits particles like the kind given off by cigarettes
which can cause serious health related issues.
3D printing security: Hackers can get into the system and destroy the system
or can make system to work differently.
4.0 Context Diagram
Automotive
Maintenance
and diagnostic
Medical Device
Prototyping
Electricity 3D Printing
Entertainment
Commercial
product
prototyping
13
Education
Consumer
products Digital Dentistry
prototyping
14
Commercial products prototyping: Commercial manufacturers with 3D
printing capabilities have the power to say yes to more opportunities, when
clients make tough demands. Designers and engineers can skip expensive,
time intensive machining and gain the agility to make changes any time.
Consumer product prototyping: Consumer have grown incredibly discerning
and they have keener eye for aesthetics, a greater expectation for
customization and less patience for products that arent just right. 3D printers
in customer product prototyping improve customization, turn great ideas into
successful products, maintain confidentiality and avoid IP theft by keeping
sensitive designs in-house until youre ready to unveil the product.
Dental: 3D printing in dental and orthodontic labs can speed production while
improving quality and precision. By combing oral scanning, CAD/CAM
design and 3D printing, dental labs can accurately and rapidly produce
crowns, bridges, stone models and a range of orthodontic appliances. With
the aid of 3D printer dental labs eliminate the bottleneck of manual modeling
and let the business grow.
Education: Presence of 3D printer quickly turn idea to prototypes and keeps
student engaged. And it gives them time to explore more ideas, analyze
problems in-depth, and develop the persistence they will need to excel in
todays fastest growing and most rewarding fields. They are powerful to
convey the meaning and importance of research with realistic models that
illustrate the findings in vivid detail. 3D printing in research field save time
by making lab more efficient and responsive. 3D printed custom fixtures and
lab instruments improve accuracy, repeatability and safety.
Entertainment: Effects studios, filmmakers and game designers use 3D
printing technology in some of their most demanding projects. Hollywood
special effects studio Legacy Effects uses 3D printing to make blockbuster
movies like farm family.
Medical: 3D printing empowers doctors, researchers and medical device
manufacturers to work faster, test more thoroughly and personalize care like
never. They have been extensively use in the medical field to medical training
models, personalized patient care, medical device innovation, preclinical
device testing, medical manufacturing, sales aids and demos, orthotics,
Prosthetics and Bionics, etc.
Maintenance and diagnostic: Maintenance and diagnostic is equally
important to keep the system useful and upgrade. Timely maintenance and
diagnostic will improve the system efficiency and monitor the possible
problems before it arrives.
Electricity: Electricity is the backbone of the 3D printing system s it runs
only with electrical supply.
15
5.0 System Requirements:
The system shall print the simple and complex models.
3D printers shall support wide range of materials for printing.
The system shall produce noise below 100dB.
3D printers shall have at least 6 degrees of freedom.
3D printers shall have effective air cooling for extruders and bed.
The system shall support. STL, OBJ, VRML,.X3G, PLY, FBX file type for printing.
The system shall have resolution below 200-micron.
3D printers shall have automatic printing bed levelling.
The printed parts shall be easily taken out of the system without sticking in the
printing bed.
The system shall feature safety features to indicate faults in the system.
The cost to produce part by the system shall be less than 0.06/cm3.
The system shall have travel speed 30mm/s-300mm/s when not printing.
The system shall support windows/Mac/Linux.
The system shall be able to print using SD card, computers, laptops.
The system shall use open source software.
The system shall consume average 110 watts in 30 mins.
The system shall have Wi-fi and Ethernet connectivity.
The system shall have built in camera to monitor the process.
The system shall effectively exhaust the fumes generated during printing
The system shall have set up cost of $1000 for normal small size printing.
The system shall have clear instructions for the user to use the system.
The printed part by the system shall have mechanical properties as produce by the
others method.
The system shall have material mixing capabilities to print the object.
The system shall have low failure rate.
The system shall not produce any health risk to the users.
The system shall have strong printing security.
The system lifecycle should not affect the natural environment.
The system shall be timely monitored for the maintenance
The system used in Aerospace and Defense industry shall be able to reduce fuel cost
and increase payload by printing less weight object.
The system shall offer maximum flexibility to the design engineers for rapid changes
and modification in printing object.
16
6.0 Functional definition:
The use of most feature rich software CORE helped to present requirement, functional,
and component diagram of 3D printer clearly. The images from the software are
presented below.
18
Fig: Clear monitoring of process
19
Fig: hierarchy of print simple to complex model
20
Fig: EFFBD diagram for accepting SD card.
21
Fig: IDEF0 diagram
22
Fig: component diagram
23
Fig: House of Quality
24
7.0 Conclusion:
After going through the fundamentals of system engineering course, I realized system
engineering typically follows top-down processing approach which means big picture first.
System engineering is driven by the users/stakeholder requirements, these requirements are
translated to concepts and to system requirements which follows analysis-synthesis-
evaluation to have tangible, visible physical system. So as a system engineer it is our first
duty to know our stakeholders requirements. To get the fertile information out of
stakeholder, system engineer must ask why five times and system engineer should be
active listener and able to paraphrase their requirements in their words. By the time
system-level architecture and high level design is complete 85 % of the total costs will be
used, this is the area where system engineers come into the picture. So, system engineers
are the backbone in design of large complex system. Investing in system engineering
during the big project has a huge pay off in the system design.
The best part of practicum which I enjoyed most is the use of highly feature software
CORE. As a system engineer in the future this software could really help a lot to design a
system. Through the requirements diagrams hierarchy, it is easy to communicate between
the customers and engineers and it saves time to know the system. The diagram clearly
communicates. The software provides the special feature to draw Enhanced function flow
block diagram which relates the relationship between functions and interactions thats
present in the system between various functions. Another part is to draw the house of
quality, which is voice of customer analysis tool and key component of the Quality
Functional Deployment technique. It begins with the voice of customer, in system
engineering which is a big picture. It helped me to know what the customer wants into
products or services that meet the customer wants in terms of engineering design values
by creating a relationship matrix. It could be very helpful in trading the system
requirements as well. Pugh matrix is also a fun part of the practicum. The Pugh Matrix is
easy to use and relies upon of pairwise comparisons between design candidates against
several criteria or requirements. Whenever, I will be stuck with confusion amongst number
of alternatives, the first idea will be use Pugh matrix.
At the end of semester, after going through the course and practicum, I felt like I learnt
some new things and get to know the basics of fundamental of system engineering. The
things I learned are the basics for my future work and I think it will be used time and again.
Introducing the concept of software Core for the System engineer is vital which I enjoyed
the most. The House of Quality and Pugh matrix concept were equally helpful to design
the system. As a system thinker, we should think our system from birth to death. I felt like
the world needs system engineer for the optimization of system.
25
References:
[1] Sood AK, Ohdar RK, Mahapatra SS.parametric appraisal of mechanical property of fused
deposition modeling processed parts. Mater Des 2010;31:287:-95
[2] Zhong W, Li F Zhang Z, Song L, Li Z. Short fiber reinforced composites for fused deposition
modeling. Mater Sci Eng A 2001; 301:152-30
[3] Fu SY , Lauke B, Mader E, Yue CY, Hu X. tensile properties of short-glass-fiber and short-
carbon-fiber-reinforced polypropylene composites. Composites Part A 2000; 31:1117-25.
[7] C.Iancu, D.Ianccu,A.Stancioiu, From CAD model to 3D print via STL file
format,fiabilitate Durab.1 (2010) 73
[13] Fuda ning, Weilong Cong, Jinging Qiu, Junhua Wei, Shiren Wang. Additive manufacturing
of carbon fiber reinforced thermoplastic composites using fused deposition modeling.
Composites Part B 80(2015) 369-378
[14] S.S.Crump, Fast, precise, safe prototype with FDM, ASME, PED 50(1991) 53-60.
26
[15] R.Noorani, Rapid Prototyping- principles and Applications, John Wiley &Sons, Inc., New
Jersey, 2006.
[17] C.Deckard, J.J Beaman, process and control issues in selective laser sintering, ASME, PED
33(1998) 191-197.
[18] E.Sachs, M.Cima, J.Cornie, Three dimensional printing: rapid tooling and prototypes
directly from CAD model, CIRP Ann, Manuf.Technol.39 (1990)201-204.
[20] J.J.Beaman, J.W.Barlow, D.L Bourell, .H. Crawford, H.L.Marcus, K.P.McAlea, Solid
Freeform fabrication: A new Direction in Manufacturing, Springer, New York, 1996.
[21] L.E. Murr, S.M. Gaytan, D.A. Ramirez, E. Martinez, Hernandez, K.N.Amaato, P.W. Shindo,
F.R. medina, R.B. wicker, Metal fabrication by additive manufacturing using laser and electron
beam melting technologies, J. Mater. Sci. Technol.28 (2012)1-14.
[22] R.P. Mudge, N.R. Wald Laser engineered net shaping advances additive manufacturing and
repair, Weild. J.N.Y.86 (2007)44-48.
[24] J.T.Muth, D.M.Vogt, R.L.Truby, Y.Menuc, D.B.Kolesky, R.J.Wood, J.A, Lewis, Embedded
3D printing of strain sensors within highly stretchable elastomers, Adv.Mater, 26(2014)6307-
6312
[25] H.P.Le, Progress and trends in ink-jet print technology. J.Imaging Sci. Technol.42 (1998)49-
62.
[26] K.S. Lee, R.H. Kim, D.Y. Yang, S.h.Park, Advances in 3 D nano/micro fabrication using
two-photon initiated polymerization, Prog.Polym.Sci.33(2008)631-681.
[27] http://www.stratasys.com/
27