Sunteți pe pagina 1din 11

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/rser

Solarwind hybrid renewable energy system: A review


Vikas Khare, Savita Nema, Prashant Baredar
MANIT, Bhopal, India

art ic l e i nf o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The demand for electricity is increasing day by day, which cannot be fullled by non-renewable energy
Received 11 September 2014 sources alone. Renewable energy sources such as solar and wind are omnipresent and environmental
Received in revised form friendly. The renewable emulnergy sources are emerging options to fulll the energy demand, but
2 November 2015
unreliable due to the stochastic nature of their occurrence. Hybrid renewable energy system (HRES)
Accepted 21 December 2015
Available online 9 January 2016
combines two or more renewable energy sources like wind turbine and solar system. The objective of
this paper is to present a comprehensive review of various aspects of HRES. This paper discusses pre-
Keywords: feasibility analysis, optimum sizing, modeling, control aspects and reliability issues. The application of
Solar energy evolutionary technique and game theory in hybrid renewable energy is also presented in this paper.
Wind energy
& 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Hybrid renewable energy system

Contents

1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
2. Pre-feasibility assessment of HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
3. Optimum sizing of HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
4. Modeling of HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
5. Control of HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
6. Evolutionary technique in HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
6.1. Genetic algorithm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
6.2. Particle swarm optimization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
6.3. Fuzzy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
6.4. Neural. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
7. Game theory in HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
8. Reliability in HRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
9. Future scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31

1. Introduction remarkable growth for past two decades in its widespread use of
standalone to utility interactive solarwind systems [3].
Electricity is the important factor for industrialization, urbaniza- Solar and wind energy system works normally in standalone or
tion, nancial growth of any country [1]. There are different types of grid connected mode, but the efciency of these sources is less due
conventional and non-conventional energy sources used to generate to the stochastic nature of solar and wind resources. The hybrid
electricity. Solar and wind energy system is one of the most promi- renewable energy sources with grid integration overcome this
nent sources of energy. The utilization of solar and wind energy drawback of being unpredictable in nature. Hybrid renewable
system has become increasingly popular due to modular and envir- energy system (HRES) is a combination of renewable and con-
onment friendly nature [2]. The eld of solarwind has experienced a ventional energy source, it may also combine two or more
renewable energy sources that work in standalone or grid con-
nected mode. The HRES that combines solar and wind energy key
E-mail addresses: Vikaskhare09@yahoo.co.in (V. Khare), resources, operates in two modes: simultaneous and sequential. In
s_nema@yahoo.com (S. Nema), pbaredar@rediffmail.com (P. Baredar). simultaneous mode, the solar and wind energy system produces

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2015.12.223
1364-0321/& 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
24 V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

energy concurrently while in sequential mode they produce of stand-alone solarwind hybrid energy system for application in
electricity alternatively [4,5]. Newfoundland. Hydrogen is used as an energy transporter for appli-
The signicant characteristics of HRES are to combine two or cation in Newfoundland, Canada. Sizing, performance and various
more renewable power generation technologies to make proper cost indexes were also analyzed. The capital cost, net present cost and
use of their operating characteristics and to obtain efciencies cost of energy for energy consumption of 25 kW h/d with a 4.73 KW
higher than that could be obtained from a single power source. peak power demand is $36738, $47910 and $0.492 respectively.
This paper presents a review of solarwind hybrid renewable Graditi et al. [9] developed scientic and ecological aspects of hybrid
energy system covering issue such as pre-feasibility study, mod- system as well as non conventional energy source. Nayar et al. [10]
eling, controlling, optimization technique, reliability and power discussed a case study of a Photo-voltaic/Wind/Diesel hybrid energy
quality of the system [6]. Fig. 1 presents a basic component of system installed in three remote islands in the republic of Maldives.
solarwind hybrid renewable energy system. Chong et al. [11] presents prefeasibility analysis of a windsolar
HRES with rainwater collection features for urban high rise applica-
tion. Economic analysis includes manufacturing and preservation
2. Pre-feasibility assessment of HRES costs of the system over the given life span. The system is analyzed for
security, visual impact and noise pollution. Sinha et al. [12] presents
Prior to installation and operation, the prefeasibility study of pre-feasibility analysis of solarwind hybrid systems for a complex
hybrid energy system is customarily carried out. The prefeasibility hilly terrain. The study is carried out to assess the potential for a
analysis includes the study of climatic condition of the proposed solarwind hybrid system for Hamirpur town located in Northern
site, availability of renewable energy sources and assessment of its Province of India. The prefeasibility study indicates the quality of
potential load and load demand of application site. The pre- potential for utilizing solar-micro wind hybrid system to supplement
feasibility study assists in nding out the best location to develop a the energy needs in hilly regions. Aydin et al. [13] explore geological
solar wind hybrid renewable energy system. Few signicant con- information system (GIS) based site allocation for solarwind HRES at
tributions of various researchers are discussed here. western turkey. In this paper Fuzzy logic and geographic information
Rahman et al. [7] gave the feasibility study of Photovoltaic (PV)- system tool are used to search best and alternative location of the
Fuel cell hybrid energy system considering difculty in the use of PV target area that benets nancial and ecological criteria. Tao Ma et al.
and provide new avenues for the fuel cell technology. A photovoltaic [14] presented a comprehensive feasibility study and techno-
system uses photovoltaic cells to directly convert sunlight into elec- economic assessment of a remote solarwind hybrid energy system
tricity and the fuel cell converts the chemical energy into electricity with battery energy storage for a isolated island.
through a chemical reaction with oxygen or other oxidizing agent. Climatic condition is the major input to carried out pre-
Khan et al. [8] gave meticulous description about pre-feasibility study feasibility analysis. Figs. 2 and 3 show global map solar energy and

DC/AC
Solar Energy
DC/DC
AC/ AC/ AC/DC Load
AC/AC
DC AC/DC DC
Wind Energy AC/AC
BUS DC/AC BUS
AC/DC
DC/DC

Bidirectional GRID
Storage
Converter

Fig. 1. Basic component of solarwind hybrid renewable energy system.

Fig. 2. Global solar radiation potential [15].


V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333 25

Fig. 3. Global wind energy potential [15].

Optimum Sizing Analysis

Criteria Methodology
Multi- Graphical Computing
Economic Reliability AI Technique Iterative Analytical Probablistic
objective Constraint Tool

Fig. 4. Optimum sizing analysis of solar wind hybrid renewable energy system HRES.

wind energy potential in all over world [15]. Feasibility of solar evaluated optimal sizing of pumped storage plant using single/multi-
wind hybrid renewable energy system mainly depends on solar objective optimization technique for increased generation. Belfkira
radiation and wind energy potential available at the specic et al. [21] gave a method for sizing and optimizing a standalone
location. Designing a hybrid renewable energy system requires wind/Photo-voltaic/diesel hybrid energy system. Paudel et al. [22]
appropriate weather data. presented feasibility study and determined unit size of hybrid
renewable energy system that combines solar, wind and battery
bank for an isolated location of Nepal. Nagabhusana et al. [23] esti-
3. Optimum sizing of HRES mates optimal size of a solarwind HRES employing linear pro-
gramming technique to minimize present worth of capital and
The next step after prefeasibility analysis is to accurately assess operating cost. Kumar et al. [24] used probabilistic reliability analysis
the size of individual component that can economically satisfy the to nd out the most favorable size of solar wind HRES. The stochastic
load demand. Fig. 4 present implicit criteria/methodology gen- belongings in all the parameter in the optimization models are taken
erally employed for optimum sizing of HRES. Chedid et al. presents into consideration for estimating power reliability. Laterra et al. [25]
unit sizing of integrated wind solar power system for either explains procedure to develop the unit sizing of a grid connected
autonomous or grid linked application with the help of a computer solar wind HRES using fuzzy logic based multi-objective optimization
aided design (CAD) tool. The linear programming is used for
idea. Both scientic and cost-effective objective functions are used to
analysis with the objective function set such that the cost of
nd out the best conguration. Further Erdinc et al. [26] explore a
electricity is minimized.
novel perspective component performance squalor issue in optimum
Kellog et al. [17] determined unit sizing of solar wind HRES by
sizing conguration. Author used observe and focus algorithm based
developing simple arithmetical algorithm. Generation and storage
optimization to compute the possible degradation in performance
system are appropriately sized to meet the annual load and reduce
and meticulous conguration of each integrated system component.
the total annual cost to the customer. Nelson et al. [18] carried out
sizing and economic analysis of a hybrid renewable energy system Bayod-Rujula et al. [27] analyzed the inuence of some unit sizing
consisting of a fuel cell (multiple cells combined to form a stack), an structure of grid connected solarwind integrated non-conventional
electrolyzer and hydrogen storage tank that work as energy storage energy system with energy storage and load consumption on their
arrangement. The sizing and economic analysis is done using a multi- crossing point with the electrical network. In this paper sizing con-
paradigm numerical computing environment and fourth generation straint are used as sizing factor which is the ratio of yearly energy
programming language as Matrix laboratory (MATLAB) and break- produced by the non-conventional energy system and yearly energy
even distance analyses is done for each conguration. Lopez et al. demanded by an end user. Erdinc et al. [28] describes unit sizing
[19] presents the inuence of power converter losses assessment in criteria of solar wind integrated renewable energy system by real
the sizing of a HRES. An improved technique for in loss calculation of time routine analysis and scrutinize the effectiveness for entire
static converter is presented with an objective to assess energy losses generated system. Tables 1 and 2 gives hybrid system analysis of
in the system during the unit sizing process. Khatibi et al. [20] study area and summary of sizing methodology of HRES respectively.
26 V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

Table 1
Hybrid system analysis of study area.

Author (s) Hybrid system component Evaluation area Load details Sizing approach Result of sizing

Kalantar et al. [29] Wind turbine (WT), Photo-voltaic Tehran, Iran 225 kW Peak Genetic Algorithm (GA) 195 kW WT, 85 KW PV 230 kW
(PV), and Battery 25 kW Base Microturbine
2.14 kA h battery
Yang et al. [30] WT, PV, microturbine and battery Dala Jia Island, 1.5 kW Constant GA 6 kW WT, 12.8 kW PV,
China 6 kA h battery
Bounbum roong et al. WT, PV, diesel and battery Chik Island, 26 kW peak Particle swarm optimization 15 kW WT,
[31] Thailand 5 kW base (PSO) 24 kW PV,
50 kW diesel,
151 kW h battery

Table 2
Summary of sizing methodologies of solar wind HRES.

Author/year Analysis Sizing constraint Output/conclusion

Yang et al. [30] Probabilistic Loss of Power Supply Probability A battery bank with an energy storage space capability of 3 days was appropriate for
(LPSP) ensuring the desired LPSP of 1% can be achieved with a battery bank of 5 days storage
space capacity.
Celik et al. [32] Techno-economic Cost/kW h, level of autonomy Author suggests that a third energy source should be integrated into the system instead
of escalating the hardware size.
Kamels et al. [33] Economic Net Present Value (NPV) Optimization result shows that integrated systems are less costly than diesel generation
from a NPV perspective.
Koutroulis et al. [34] Techno-economic Total cost and load energy The simulation results verify that integrated systems are obtained in terms of desired
requirement system reliability and the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE).
Yang et al. [35] Techno-economic LPSP and LCOE The most favorable congurations of the integrated system are obtained in terms of
desired system reliability and the LCOE.
Gupta et al. [36] Economical LPSP and Life Cycle Cost Result explores the cost V/S prot of growing or decreasing the size/number of each
generating component prior to realization of the design. Net present cost and cost of
energy of a given system is $86462 and $0.41 respectively.
Diaf et al. [37] Economical LPSP and LCOE The result indicates that the HRES is the best option for all the sites considered in the
study.
Yang et al. [38] Techno-economic LPSP This model can be used to compute the system productivity pattern which can attain the
desired LPSP with a least annualized cost of system.
Tina et al. [39] Probabilistic Energy index of reliability The outcome noties the design of a preprocessing phase for one input of an algorithm
that probabilistically optimizes the plan of HRES
Khatod et al. [40] Economic Production cost Result shows that the developed technique needs less computational time than Monte
Carlo simulation method.
Kaabeche et al. [41] Economical Deciency of Power Supply Prob- The most favorable arrangement of the integrated system is determined in terms of
ability, Life Cycle Cost desired system reliability requirement.

4. Modeling of HRES power system. Hybrid system is studied from the view point of small
signal, frequency, voltage and transient stability. Haque et al. [48]
There are different types of renewable energy sources such as solar, investigated the most viable conguration of a hybrid energy system
wind, hydro, biomass, fuel cell, tidal etc. Modeling is the rst step to for a typical electric-heated home in St. John's, Newfoundland. It is
design a system according to the different parameter and constraint. found that multi-port direct current (DCDC) converter is appropriate
Marchetti, et al. [42] gave statistical modeling of solar wind HRES for the desired hybrid energy system. Gupta et al. [49] developed
based on annual cost, battery autonomy function, sizing criteria and modeling of hybrid energy system for off grid electrication of a group
ecological statistical factor. Step by step optimization practice is used to of villages and suggested cost minimization through proper compo-
nd out the betting result of the solar wind HRES model. Consoli nent sizing and load matching. The model is developed with the
et al. [43] developed solar wind hybrid system model based on long objective of minimizing cost function based on demand and potential
term simulation. This system integrates diesel generating sets with the constraint and is optimized using Linear Programming LINDO s/w 6.10
renewable energy source. Bonanno et al. [44] present logistical model versions. Based on the hydrogen fuel cell Alam et al. [50] developed
of HRES to evaluate fuel and energy saving and reported the problem model of wind-photovoltaic-fuel cell. To maintain uniform supply of
related to the exploitation of combined renewable and conventional hydrogen for fuel cell, an electrolyzer and a reformer is used. Badejani
energy sources. A special feature of logistical model is that a supple- et al. [51] developed modeling of standalone hybrid Photovoltaic-wind
mentary ctitious source is introduced in order to obtain the power system. A discrete cost function is dened and optimized to determine
balance at the bus-bar during the simulation stage. Ghali et al. [45] optimal design option with minimum number of Photovoltaic and
used loss of power supply probability (LPSP) to develop integrated wind units to sustain yearly demand load. System imitation and
renewable energy system model. Based on load distribution, the energy balance computation over a period of 3 years are used to
probability density function of the storage is obtained and conse- reimburse for design error caused by the discrete nature of the opti-
quently the battery size is calculated to give the relevant level of the mization approach. Gupta and Saini [52] developed an optimal hybrid
system reliability using the LPSP technique. Zahedi et al. [46] devel- energy system for remote rural area of Jaunpur block Uttaranchal state
oped statistical model of one or more PV arrays to be combined with of India. HRES model consisting of wind, solar, biomass and small-
diesel and/or wind for making a more reliable electricity supply. A micro hybrid is optimized to maintain uninterrupted supply. Gupta
near ideal size of system's component is estimated using Matrix and Saini [53] have explored modeling of solar wind HRES using
Laboratory program to predict system's performance. Potamianakis LINDO s/w 6.10 versions for off grid electrication of a group of vil-
et al. [47] demonstrated modeling and simulation of the small hybrid lages. The model is developed with the goal of cost function
V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333 27

minimization based on demand and potential constraint. Belfkira and 5. Control of HRES
Nichita [21] modeled and optimized sizing of HRES and used a
deterministic algorithm to diminish the life cycle cost of the system Control technique plays a very important role in enhancing
while guarantee the accessibility of the energy. The statistical model- system efciency and desired output of a plant. The availability of
ing of the principle elements of the hybrid Wind-Photovoltaic system power from a hybrid system can be economically maximized by
is exposed showing the key sizing variable. Ruiz and Cirstea [54] choosing proper control technique in the system design process.
modeled integrated renewable energy system (PV-wind) and used an Jonathan et al. [62] presented a control technology for HRES that
optimized holistic digital control system design followed by rapid track and make control decisions based on the denite battery state
prototyping of the controller into a single eld programmable gate of charge offering signicant advantages over other methods.
array (FPGA) where as Karagiannis et al. [55] modeled and analyzed a Ottoson et al. [63] used a data logger and gave exhaustive analysis
solar wind hybrid energy system using fuzzy cognitive maps and of the energy production and performance of a remote hybrid
learning algorithm. Olulope et al. [56] presented modeling and power plant having solar, wind and diesel plant. Nogaret et al. [64]
simulation of hybrid power system and investigated the dynamic developed a new expert system based control system tool for HRES
impact of hybrid wind/Photovoltaic/small hydro-power on transient and used an advanced control system for the optimal operation and
stability with the help of DIgSILENT power factor software which is supervision of Photovoltaic and wind based medium size power
carried out using single machine innite system concept. Bansal et al. system. CAD (Computer aided design) tool is used by Chedid et al.
[57] modelled and optimized integrated renewable energy system for [13] for optimal design and control of a hybrid wind solar power
a rural site considering total price as an objective function. Hybrid systems considering all ecological factor. Linear programming
Optimization Model for Electric Renewable (HOMER) software is used techniques are used to reduce the production cost while meeting
to model the above conguration. Table 3 gives summary of modeling the load requirement. Pitrone and Pitrone [65] used an expert
method of HRES. system, fuzzy logic theory, neural network and programmable

Table 3
Summary of modeling method of solar wind HRES.

Author/year/ref. Objective Technique/software Conclusion/special nding

Marchetti [42] Mathematical model of HRES Analytical method Gave a mathematical approach to the environment statistical factor.
Consoli [43] Long term simulation model of HRES Matlab simulink 1. The system integrates different kind of generator and by traditional
electric energy plant.
2.Estimated the long term performances of hybrid system for electric
energy production
3. Model result shows a fuel consumption reduction of 64% in case of full
DC conguration and about 72% in AC conguration
Rahman and Optimal design of a hybrid windsolar Linear programming 1. Reduce the average production cost of electricity while meeting the
Chedid power system load constraint
2.Environmental factors are considered both for the design and opera-
tion phases
Ghali [45] Model of HRES based on LPSP. Loss of power supply 1. The probability density function of the storage is obtained and battery
probability size is calculated the system reliability.
2. Changing the number of PV modules is not much effective in dropping
the storage capacity required
Kellog [17] Generation unit sizing and cost analysis Numerical algorithm 1. Optimum generation capability and storage required is determined for
for PV/ wind system a stand-alone, wind, PV, and hybrid wind PV system for an experimental
site in Montana with a typical residential load
2. The hybrid combination of wind and solar generation makes the
system more reliable
Zahedi [46] Numerical model of HRES Analytical method Developed a numerical model for optimum sizing of the components in
PV-hybrid power systems and presented an optimum way to predict the
performance of the system.
Ai and Yang [58] Computer-aided design of PV/wind hybrid Loss of power supply 1. Developed complete sets of mathematical formulation for optimum
system probability sizing of PV/wind hybrid system.
2. Performance of PV-wind system in view of loss of power supply
probability is studied considering practical load data.
Vani [59] Modeling of HRES HOMER Hybrid power system contains solar, wind and diesel power generation
with battery storage for Jamnya Van village dist. Barwani in Madhya
Pradesh, India. Optimized a problem to minimize total net present cost,
operating and running cost of the hybrid system.
Gupta [52] Modeling of HRES for off grid electrica- LINDO Software 6.10 version Based on demand and potential constraints cost function is minimized.
tion of cluster of villages
Alam [50] Modeling of HRES Fuzzy logic 1. Performance of HRES studied under different environmental
condition.
2. Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT) of the PV system and blade
angle pitch control of wind turbine included.
Gupta [53] Steady state modeling for grid electrica- Mixed integer linear mathe- 1. Cost constant for each of the proposed resource is introduced with the
tion of cluster of villages matical programming objective that source having lesser unit cost shares more to optimize the
objective function.
2. A case study of rural remote area is presented.
Dursun [60] Hydrogen production capacity of a stan- Matlab/Simscape software 1. Dynamic model based on PEM electrolyzer hydrogen productions are
dalone renewable hybrid power system is developed with Matlab/Simscape and simple application developed for
used Istanbul's 2010 meteorological condition.
Mezzai [61] Identication and modeling of HRES. Matlab/Simulink/Labvie w The identication and the control of the hybrid system are presented.
software Lab- view software has been used and has a real-time acquisition of
renewable energy parameters.
28 V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

logical controller for on line supervision and control of distributed step perturbation tracking maximum power point algorithm. The
hybrid renewable energy power plant. A real time analysis of the control strategies of the PV array, wind power generation and
control structure and management functions of a solar wind hybrid battery is simulated using Matlab/Simulink. Preethishri et al. [77]
micro-grid system is reported by Gaztanaga et al. [66] which works developed embedded emulator of the PV array and wind driven
perfectly in both operation and transition mode. Based on the induction generator by using digital signal regulator. Prabhakar
power transfer utility concept Jinhong and Seulki [67] developed et al. [78] proposed a control system for accomplishing consistent
several power control module in service modes such as normal harmonization of windsolar energy adaptation system in remote
operation, power dispatching and power averaging according and locations. The control technique is formulated to utilize the avail-
effectively controls the inverter. The control module has environ- able energy source in an efcacious manner to render power at
mental and utility friendly operation policy such that power injec- nearly constant voltage and frequency to the isolated load. Croci
tion into network is less uctuating. Based on supervisory con- et al. [79] developed obedience based control method which han-
troller, Abdulwahid and Manwell [68] developed a dynamic central dles the energy exchange directly for PV-Wind HRES. Budh et al.
communication system for hybrid power system. Capacitor voltage [80] explained smoothing control for battery energy storage system
equilibrium control scheme is used to control hybrid cascaded H (BESS) based HRES. Professionally simulation tool for computer
bridge inverter with single direct current (DC) source to get rid of aided design (PSCAD) is used to develop the smoothing control
higher order harmonics for an integrated energy system by Hui system for effective regulation of power output level. Table 4 gives
et al. [69]. Web based actual time monitoring with supervisory summary of controlling method of HRES.
control and data attainment system for a Wind-PV battery renew-
able energy system is developed by Wang et al. [70] which consists
of two wind induction generator, ACDC converter, a PV unit and a 6. Evolutionary technique in HRES
battery. Vechu et al. [71] developed digital control over analog
control with a 3 phase four leg inverter for HRES. This system Evolutionary computation is a subeld of articial intelligence
compensates unbalance voltage conditions and the addition of a that involves combinatorial optimization difculty. The use of
fourth leg provides an extra degree of freedom, making it possible Darwinian principles for automated problem solving originates in
to handle the natural current caused by the unbalance load. Zhang the 1950s.
et al. [72] used PSO based statistical dynamic control system to
manage Wind-PV hybrid system operation. Hernandez et al. [73] 6.1. Genetic algorithm
developed a hierarchical control of hybrid power system consisting
of a wind turbine, PV panels, a battery for a DC bus arrangement. Genetic algorithm is a randomized hunt and optimization system
Mbaup et al. [74] gave a new concept control design using a guided by the morality of the natural genetic system. GA is an
Petri-net regulator which calculates the operating mode of the adaptive heuristic search algorithms based on the evolutionary ideas
multisource renewable energy system to optimize the energy of natural selection and genetics. Daming et al. [83] explained an
transfer and the load irregularity for HRES. Arulampalam et al. [75] elitist strategy of optimal sizing of standalone hybrid PV-wind power
developed micro-grid control of PV-wind-diesel hybrid system with systems using genetic algorithm with loss of power supply prob-
island and grid linked function. Huang et al. [76] gave the MPPT ability as a constraint and minimizes the total capital of the entire
control scheme to track the global power of the windsolar hybrid system. Zhao et al. [84] used a genetic algorithm with PSO to observe
generating system according to the basic standard of the variable the best probable capacity model of a solar wind hybrid renewable

Table 4
Summary of controlling method of solar wind HRES.

Author/Yr/ Objective Method/S.W Conclusion/special nding


reference

Lynch [62] Maximizing hybrid availability 1.battery voltage Amp. Hour accumulation offers signicant compensation over voltage based
through system control 2.Avg. battery voltage methods of system control for HRES
3. Amp. hour accumulation
Akurlund [63] A data logger By data logger Analysis of the energy production and performance of HRES is studied in
and remote control of HRES. detail
Vander Linde [81] Microprocessor Microprocessor Life span of battery is increased by controlling state of charge of the battery
Based control of HRES. based, 'C' Programming,
Motorola 6800
Chedid Unit sizing and control of HRES Linear programming ,RAPSODY 1. This analysis allows the user to study the interaction among economic,
Software operation and environmental factor.
2. It offers a useful tool for the design and analysis of HRES.
Jinhong [67] Power control of a HRES By prototype system design 1. The system has several operation modes which are normal operation,
power dispatching and power average to coordinate control of the battery
energy storage system (BESS).
2. The BESS operate as an energy buffer to exibly shift the generation from
the renewable energy sources without frequent shifts between battery
charging and discharging.
Boquan [72] Dynamic control of HRES Particle swarm optimization A mathematical model is developed and a new PSO algorithm based on
(PSO) uniform design and inertia mutation is used to solve the mathematical model
which is further is used to control the operation of wind-PV HRES.
Mboup [74] Petri-nets control design of Petri-nets controller A supervisory control strategy optimize the energy transfer according to the
HRES source power variation and the load characteristics
Preethishri [77] Digital signal controlling of PV- Matlab/embedded emulator This HRES can tolerate the rapid changes in natural conditions and sup-
Wind HRES presses the effect of uctuation on the voltage within the acceptable range.
Gota [82] Design and control of smart Genetic Algorithm (GA) and direct An efcient tool for the selection of the component of the energy system is
HRES design control developed with two major selection criteria (Price and number) using
modied GA.
V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333 29

energy system with rapid global convergence. Gupta et al. [85] used an island. The result obtained proves its feasibility and efciency.
GA to design and supply varying load located in the area of Jaipur Dehgan et al. [88] develop most favorable sizing of a hydrogen based
(India). Result shows that the system can deliver energy in a stan- wind/PV plant allowing for reliability indices by applying a particle
dalone installation with an acceptable price. Ben et al. [86] developed swarm optimization. Wang et al. [89] modied PSO algorithm to
optimum sizing of hybrid PV/Wind battery system using Fuzzy develop multicultural design of the integrated power generation
adaptive GA which decides the optimal number of PV panels, WT and system. Sensitivity study is also carried out to examine the impacts of
storage units, Further GA is used to conclude optimal power different system parameter on the overall design performance. Sizing
arrangement of an off-grid hybrid renewable energy system. Tutkun of solarwind renewable energy system is done by Sanchez et al. [90]
et al. [87] develop authentic power scheduling of an off grid HRES and evolutionary computation technique called PSO is used with the
used for heating and lighting in an archetypal residential house. In cost of system as an objective function. PSO algorithm is used by
this paper binary coded GA is used instead of assorted integer linear Ardakani et al. [91] for optimal sizing of system's component. As a
programming to minimize the operational unit cost of HRES. result the optimum number of pv modules, wind turbine and battery
along with inverter capacity is obtained. Bansal et al. [92] develop
6.2. Particle swarm optimization optimization of hybrid PV/Wind/ batteries energy system using
multi-objective particle swarm optimization (MOPSO). An objective
Particle swarm optimization (PSO) is a population based sto- function for cost of the hybrid system is formed which includes initial
chastic optimization practice enthused by social behavior of bird costs, yearly operating costs and maintenance costs. . Due to the
ocking or sh schooling, where bird ocking or sh schooling is the intricacy of hybrid renewable energy system with nonlinear integral
collective motion of a large number of self propelled entities. Zhao planning, MOPSO is used to solve the problem. The improved PSO
et al. [84] gave an improving the PSO algorithm for optimal capacity can avoid the option of a local minimum trap. Bashir et al. [93]
arrangement of an independent wind/PV hybrid power supply sys- explain size optimization of new hybrid standalone renewable
tem. The way out for Hybrid power system capacity optimal con- energy system by PSO. To assess system dependability level, the
guration is a typical non-linear integrated integer optimization equivalent loss factor (ELF) has been used as an index. Keyrouz et al.
problem. An algorithm is projected and tested on system located at [94] developed a unied MPPT for controlling a hybrid windsolar

Table 5
Summary of evolutionary technique in solar wind HRES.

Author/year Objective Technique Conclusion/special nding

Wang [70] Improvement of power factor (P.F.) and Programmable logical controller This paper presents a novel control scheme using a PLC with a new
voltage for RES (PLC)'s new Fuzzy module fuzzy module to enhance the P.F. and voltage of a hybrid Wind/PV
system.
Alam [50] Modeling and analysis of a Wind/PV/ Fuzzy and HOMER Based on simulation result it has been found that RES would be a
Fuel cell feasible solution for distributed generation of electric power for
standalone application at remote location.
Chakraborthy [98] Optimal economic operation of smart Fuzzy logic The method is tested on a hypothetical power system with 10
grid thermal units, 4300 equivalent solar and wind farm.
Berrazouane [104] Energy management and supervision Fuzzy logic The method addresses and resolves power quality issue resulting
from real power imbalance uctuations due to non-conventional
energy.
Chakraborthy [100] Intelligent economic operation of smart Fuzzy logic Wind generator and PV generation as renewable power generation
grid source are modeled.
Shahirinia [105] Optimal sizing of hybrid power system Genetic Algorithm(GA) A GA approach is employed to obtain the best cost value of hybrid
power system construction.
Xu et al. [106] Capital cost GA The issues regarding loss of power supply probability and reliability
criteria are discussed.
Yang et al. [35] Annualized cost GA Probability of loss of power supply is explained.
Arabali [107] Optimization approach for energy GA A new strategy to meet the controllable HVAC with a solarwind
management HRES is proposed.
Merei [108] Sensitivity analysis of an off grid hybrid GA Sensitivity analysis is done for different battery prices, interest rate
system with battery technology. and cost of carbon emission.
Jifang [102] Control strategy for multi-energy com- Neural Simulation shows that this strategy can be used to keep make the
mon dc bus hybrid power supply voltage stable and continuous.
Ricalde [109] Design of a smart grid management Neural A management system based on multi-agents is designed to measure
system with renewable energy and control the loads inside the building using neural network.
generation
Ghareeb [110] Renewable energy sources for con- Neural The performance of solarwind hybrid power system with high
tinuous supply in microgrid application penetration of renewable energy sources was investigated under
dominant weather condition.
Zhao [84] The optimal capacity conguration of a Particle swarm optimization The algorithm is tested for a standalone RES, the result analysis
supply system (PSO) shows its feasibility and effectiveness.
Kaviani et al. [111] Annualized cost PSO The equivalent loss factor and impact of component outages on the
reliability performance analysis is discussed.
Hakimi et al. [112] Net Present Value PSO Extra energy was delivered to the electrolyzer and decit power is
fullled by fuel cell.
Ardakani [91] Design of an optimum HRES PSO Hybrid generation system under different design scenarios are
designed based on PSO approach.
Khare [113] Optimization of HRES PSO, CPSO, HOMER The study is based on simulation and optimization of the renewable
energy system of a police control room in Central India. The pattern
of load consumption is studied and optimized by PSO, CPSO algo-
rithm and HOMER software. Net present cost, operating cost and cost
of energy for 1.5KW system is $34,811, $950/yr. and 0.444/kW h
respectively.
30 V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

Study of Duopoly- Formal Theory of games- Theory of games-John Economic Behaviour-John Finite games on
Antoine Cournot [1838] Emile Borel [1921] Neumann [1928] Neumann [1944] equilibrium -Nash [1950]

Fig. 5. Overview of game theory.

and fuel cell system. A tracking algorithm based Bayesian informa- analysis more complex plans and strategies. Fig. 5 presents over-
tion combined with swarm intelligence is used as an optimization, view of GAME theory.
searching algorithm by Amer et al. [95] for minimizing the loss of Sharp et al. [114] developed several types of solar energy incen-
energy with a satisfactory choice of the production taking in delib- tives for industrial energy consumer. The incentives are formulated
eration the losses between production and demand sides to reduce using Stackelberg game theory with the government as a leader
the cost. Sanchez et al. [96] congure isolated solar wind energy offering incentives to the end user. Ogino et al. [115] presented non-
system in the southeast region of Mexico and scientic-nancial cooperative game approach in an electric generating system which is
analysis is done very effectively using PSO technique which searches related to public participation and resource supply. The main draw-
the best possible sizing for the energy system, minimizing the total back of this system is that it does not give any control mechanism of
cost of the system. An outcome shows that PSO performance is faster the entire system. This problem is compensated when Lygeros and
and is capable of providing an optimization pattern that saves around Godbole [116] designed multi-agent hybrid system using game the-
10% of the total cost of the integrated system. Borhanazad et al. [97] ory. A methodology for designing a hybrid controller for the large
developed optimization of micro-grid system using MOPSO and scale multi-agent system is presented. The paper reports problem
found the best conguration of the hybrid system using power based on the optimal and timely investment on grids and is solved
management algorithm. using the concepts of the Nash-Bayesian equilibrium. Wu and Rad
[117] developed demand side management solution for wind power
6.3. Fuzzy integration in micro grid using dynamic potential game theory.
Interaction among users to efciently utilize the available renewable
Chakraboty et al. [98] presents an optimal economic operation of and conventional energy sources is analyzed and coordinated to
smart grid by fuzzy advanced quantum evolutionary method. Adhikari minimize the total energy cost to the system. Street and Lima [118]
et al. [99] explained analysis, design and control of a standalone gave, sharing quotas of a non-conventional energy hedge pool with
integrated non-conventional energy conversion system based on the the help of a cooperative game theory approach. The objective of this
work was twofold: rst objective was to propose a risk-adverse
fuzzy logic control method by sensing the DC voltage and current
renewable energy hedge pool to jointly sell a single complementary
output of solar and the rectied output voltage of permanent magnet
renewable generation portfolio and secondly it analyzes different
brushless direct current (PMBLDC) generator driven by a wind turbine.
schemes of sharing the nancial gains, namely quotas between the
Chakarborty et al. [100] developed intelligence economic operation of
members of such a pool from a cooperative game theory point of
smart grid using fuzzy advanced quantum evolutionary method.
view. Saad and Han [119] has given a coalitional game theory of
cooperative micro-grid distribution networks of solar panels, wind
6.4. Neural turbines etc. Baeyens and Bitar [120] explained the wind energy
aggregation with the help of a coalitional game approach. The paper
Neural network is an interconnected group of articial neurons studied the extent to which a group of N wind power producers can
that uses a mathematical model or computational model for infor- exploit the statistical benets of aggregation and amount risk is
mation processing based on a connectionist approach to computation. formulated by coalitional game approach. Mei and Wang [121]
Fidalgo et al. [101] applied articial neural network (ANN) based developed the game approaches for integrated power systems
approach for applying preventive control strategies for a large hybrid planning. Game theory is introduced in this paper to model the
renewable energy system. ANNs are an essential part which is better planning of a grid connected integrated power system comprising of
than customary statistical methods in the dynamic security pattern wind turbines, PV panels and storage batteries. Both non-cooperative
class and also evaluates the degree of security. Jifang et al. [102] pro- and cooperative game theory models are built by taking wind tur-
posed a neural network control strategy for multi-energy common DC bines, PV Panels and storage batteries as players and their life cycle
bus hybrid power supply by analyzing the distinctiveness of solar income as payoffs. Wu and Rad [122] develops wind power inte-
energy, wind energy. LevenbergMarquaret algorithm linked to neural gration via aggregator end user coordination by a Game theoretic
network is used and momentum factor is introduced in the training. approach. The game theory algorithm is implemented in an aggre-
Duang et al. [103] develop a hybrid model for an hourly forecast of PV- gator in order to organize the action of demand side resources via
wind renewable energy system and used computational intelligence of pricing in order to tackle the intermittency and uctuations in wind
PSO for computing different denitions of the forecast error. Table 5 power generation. Wei and Liu [123] presented game theory based
gives summary of evolutionary technique used in HRES. scheduling of modern power systems with large scale wind power
integration. A mixed integer Stackelberg game model is proposed to
address the generation arrangement problem under uncertainties.
7. Game theory in HRES Zhu and Zhang [124] developed a framework for control of dis-
tributed renewable based energy resources in smart grids. Author
In 1838 games appeared in economics literature and at that used a game theory structure for modeling the tactical behavior of
time cournot and others developed a model which is based on buses that are connected to renewable energy system and study the
oligopoly pricing and production, but the model has the drawback equilibrium distributed power generation at each buses. Dai and Qiao
of restricted player to strategies that only involved quantity or [125] proposed a Game based stochastic programming to generate
price decision. After the cournot in 1944 John Von Neumann and optimal bidding strategies to maximize the total prots of wind and
Oskar Morgenstern explained the basic theory of games which can conventional power producers in both the energy market and a
V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333 31

Reliability Analysis
Loss of power supply probablity
Levelized cost of energy
Expected Energy not supplieed
Level of autonomy

Fig. 6. Reliability analysis indices.

bilateral reserve market, where the reserve price is settled between system installed on the Davutpasa campus of the Yildiz technical
wind and conventional power producers by using game theory. Vikas university. Reliability indexes are calculated for the system.
et al. [126] developed game theory based cournot's model for solar
wind HRES and provides strategic decision to nd out best response
from solar and wind energy system. Vikas et al. [127] discuss appli- 9. Future scope
cation of game theory in PV-wind hybrid system. A game approach is
employed to analyze solar wind hybrid system. Various methods The utilization of solarwind hybrid renewable energy system
such as GAME theory logic, Nash equilibrium, cooperative and non is increasing day by day and has shown tremendous growth in last
cooperative GAME theory are studied and compared. few decades for electricity production all over the world. With the
development of new technologies in the eld of solar wind hybrid
renewable energy system, a new problem arises, which become
8. Reliability in HRES much more fascinating to be solved. These problems will be
compensated by some future research in the respective eld.
Reliability is dened as the probability of a device or system The following lists give idea of future research this eld:
performing its purpose adequately for the intended operating
period of time. It is also dened as the ability of electrical power  Some problem are reported to nd out the exact location and
system to supply the system load having reliable continuity and climate condition, site to site data is needed, which is difcult to
quality of supply. Fig. 6 presents reliability analysis indices. obtain for remote location. Hence it is necessary to develop an
Billionton and Karki [128] addressed reliability analysis of small exact optimization technique and geographical software to nd
isolated renewable energy system by deterministic and probabilistic out the potential of solar radiation and wind velocity.
technique. Zhao et al. [84] deals with the comprehensive objective  There are different types of sizing methods being used such as
functions which not only include the investment cost, but also the iterative method, articial intelligence method, but these
reliability and optimal operation of the system. The objective func- methods do not represent accurate dynamic performance of
tion consists of the investment of wind turbine, PV and cost of loss of solar and wind energy system. Hence it is necessary to develop
power energy in the system which can be calculated by reliability. a unit sizing method which avoid complexity in designing of the
Ardakani and Riahy [91] developed a design of an optimum HRES system and explain perfectly frequency response of the system
considering reliability indices subjected to nancial and scientic in dynamic performance criteria.
constraints. The technical constraints related to system reliability are  It is necessary to develop centralized and multilevel controlling
articulated by the equivalent loss factor. The reliability index is cal- technique which avoid the potential complexity of commu-
culated from component stoppage that includes WT, PV array, bat- nication system and large computation burden which is sub-
tery and inverter failure. Zhao and Wang [129] presented impacts of jected to single point failure.
renewable energy penetration on nodal price and nodal reliability in  Game theory is a recent topic in the eld of solar wind hybrid
deregulated power system. In this paper the reliability of wind and renewable energy system. It is necessary to use cournot,
solar power is investigated in a pool co-market operation. The stackelberg, Bertrand duopoly concept to nd out the exact
method captures the chronological performance of enumeration system cost and salvage value of integrated system in view of
reliability analysis. Kishore and Farnandez [130] presents a reliability increased day by day installation of HRES.
assessment of PV-wind hybrid system using Monte-Carlo simulation.
The paper discusses the various components of HES involving PV and
wind energy conversion system (WECS) and their modeling for References
reliability studies. Several methods for reliability evaluation have
been reported in this paper. Blaabjerg and Ma [131] presented [1] Khare V, Nema S, Baredar P. Status of solarwind renewable energy in India.
improvements of system reliability with the help of power electro- Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2013;27:110.
[2] Elhadidy MA, Shaahid SM. Parametric study of hybrid (wind solar diesel)
nics. Pradhan and Karki [132] develop a probabilistic reliability eva- power generating systems. Renew Energy 2000;21:12939.
luation of off grid small hybrid solar wind power system for the rural [3] Nema S, Nema RK, Agnihotri G. Matlab/Simulink based study of photovoltaic
electrication in Nepal. The paper is focused on the study and ana- cells/modules/array and their experimental verication. Int J Energy Environ
2010;1:487500.
lysis of hybrid system reliability based on various reliability indices
[4] Elhadidy MA, Shaahid SM. Promoting applications of hybrid power systems
like loss of load expectation (LOLE), Expected energy not served in hot regions. Renew Energy 2004;29:51728.
(EENS), Energy index of reliability (EIR), Expected customer inter- [5] Notton G, Muselli M, Louche A. Autonomous hybrid photovoltaic power plant
using a back-up generator: a case study in a Mediterranean Island. Renew
ruption cost (ECOST) which are evaluated through probabilistic
Energy 1996;7:37191.
approach using analytical method. Wang et al. [133] demonstrates [6] Karaki SH, Chedid RB, Ramadan R. Probabilistic performance assessment of
adequacy assessment of generating system incorporating wind, PV autonomous solarwind energy conversion systems. IEEE Trans Energy
and power storage. The reliability evaluation models of wind power Convers 1999;14:76672.
[7] Rahman S, Tam KS. A feasibility study of photovoltaic, fuel cell hybrid energy
and solar power are used in sequential Monte-Carlo simulation. system. IEEE Trans Energy Convers 1988;3:505.
Nagarajan et al. [134] represents reliability and cost analysis of solar [8] Khan MJ, Iqbal MT. Pre-feasibility study of standalone hybrid energy system
wind hybrid renewable energy system. Moreover the optimization of for application in Newfoundland. Renew Energy 2005;30:83554.
[9] Graditi G, Favuzzas S, Sanseverino ER. Technical, environmental and eco-
the system is based on no. of variables like solar radiation, wind nomical aspects of hybrid system including renewable and fuel cells. In:
speed etc. Kekezoglu et al. [135] gave a reliability analysis of a hybrid Proceedings of SPEED-IEEE; 2006. p. 53136.
32 V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333

[10] Nayar C, Tang M, Suponthana W. A case study of a PV/Wind/diesel hybrid [43] Consoli A, Musumecis S, Raciti A. Hybrid system long simulation. IEEE; 1995.
energy system for remote island in the republic of Maldives. In: Proceedings p. 26670.
of AUPEC-IEEE; 2007. p. 17. [44] Bonnano F, Consoli A, Lombardo S, Raciti A. A logistical model for perfor-
[11] Chong WT, Naghavi MS, Poh SC. Techno-economic analysis of a windsolar mance evaluations of hybrid generation system. IEEE; 1997. p. 17783.
hybrid renewable energy system with rainwater collection feature for urban [45] Ghali FMA, Syam FA. Simulation and analysis of hybrid system using prob-
high rise application. Appl Energy 2011;88:406777. abilistic techniques. IEEE; 1997. p. 83135.
[12] Sinha S, Chandel SS. Prefeasibility analysis of solar wind hybrid system [46] Zahedi A, Wren S. Development of a numerical model for evaluating the
potential in a complex hilly terrain. Int J Eng Technol Adv Eng performance of renewable generation system. In: Proceedings of IEEE TEN-
2013;3:27782. CON; 2002. p. 195053.
[13] Aydin NY, Kentel E, Duzgun HS. GIS based site selection methodology for HRES: [47] Potamianakis EG, Vournas CD. Modeling and simulation of small hybrid
a case study from western turkey. Energy Convers Manag 2013;70:90106. power system. IEEE; 2003, 2. p. 17.
[14] Ma T, Yang H, Lin Lu. A feasibility study of a standalone hybrid solarwind- [48] Haque RU, Iqbal MT, Quaicoe JE. Sizing dynamic modeling and power elec-
battery system for a remote island. Appl Energy 2014;121:14958. tronics of a hybrid energy system. In: Proceedings of CCECE IEEE; 2006. p.
[15] www.geni.org/global energy/library/renewable-energy-resources/solarbig. 113538.
shtml. [49] Gupta A, Saini RP, Sharma MP. Modeling of hybrid energy system for off grid
[16] Chedid R, Rahman S. Unit sizing and control of hybrid wind solar power electrication of cluster of villages. In: Proceedings of PEDES; 2006. p. 15.
system. IEEE Trans Energy Convers 1997;12:7985. [50] Alam MA, Gao DW. Modeling and analysis of a wind/pv/fuel cell hybrid
[17] Kellog WD, Nehrir MH, Venkataramanan G, Gerez V. Generation unit sizing system in HOMER. In: Proceedings of ICIEA-IEEE; 2007. p. 159499.
and cost analysis for standalone wind, pv and hybrid wind pv system. IEEE [51] Badejani MM, Masoum MAS, Kalanta M. Optimal design and modeling of
Trans Energy Convers 1998;13:705. standalone hybrid PV-Wind system. In: Proceedings of AUPEC-IEEE;
[18] Nelson DB, Nehrir MH, Wang C. Unit sizing and cost analysis of standalone hybrid 2007. p. 16.
Wind/PV/Fuel power generation system. Renew Energy 2006;31:164156. [52] Gupta A, Saini RP, Sharma MP. Design of an optimal hybrid energy system
[19] Lopez M, Morales D, Vannier JC, Sadarnac CD. Inuence of power converter model for remote rural area power generation. In: Proceedings of ICEE-IEEE;
losses evaluation in the sizing of a HRES. In: Proceedings of ICCEP-IEEE; 2007. 2007. p. 16.
p. 24954. [53] Gupta A, Saini RP, Sharma MP. Computerized modeling of hybrid energy
[20] Khatibi M, Jazaeri M. An analysis for increasing the penetration of renewable system- part II: combined dispatch strategies and solution algorithm. In:
energies by optimal sizing of pumped storage power plants. In: Proceedings Proceedings of ICECE; 2008. p. 1318.
of EPEC-IEEE; 2008. p. 15. [54] Ruiz AP, Cristea M, Koczara W, Teodorescu E. A novel integrated renewable
[21] Belfkira R, Nichita C, Reghan P, Barakat G. Modeling and optimal sizing of energy system modeling approach allowing fast FPGA controller prototyp-
hybrid renewable energy system. IEEE; 2008. p. 183439. ing. In: Proceedings of OPTIM-IEEE; 2008. p. 395400.
[22] Paudel S, Shrestha JN, Neto FJ, Ferreira JAF. Optimization of hybrid PV/Wind [55] Karagiannis IE. Modeling and analysis of a hybrid energy system using fuzzy
power system for remote telecom station. In: Proceedings of ICPS-IEEE; 2011. cognitive maps. In: Proceedings of MED-IEEE; 2013. p. 25764.
p. 16. [56] Olulope PK, Folly KA, Venayagamoorthy GK. Modeling and simulation of
[23] Nagabhusana AC, Rohini J, Raju AB. Economic analysis and comparison of hybrid distributed generation and its impact on transient stability of power
proposed HRES for standalone applications at various places in Karnataka system. In: Proceedings of ICIT-IEEE; 2013. p. 175762.
state. In: Proceedings of IEEE PES; 2011. p. 38085. [57] Bansal M, Khatod DK, Saini RP. Modeling and optimization of integrated
[24] Kumar A, Zaman M, Goel N. Probabilistic reliability assessment in the opti- renewable energy system for a rural site. In: Proceedings of ICROIT-IEEE;
mization of hybrid power generating units. In: Proceedings of EPEC-IEEE; 2014. p. 258.
2012. p. 759. [58] Ai B, Yang H, Shen H, Liao X. Computer-aided design of PV-wind hybrid
[25] Laterra G, Salvina G, Tina GM. Optimal sizing procedure for hybrid solar wind system. Renew Energy 2003;28:1491512.
power system by fuzzy logic. In: Proceedings of MELECON-IEEE; 2006. p. [59] Vani N, Khare V. Rural electrication system based on hybrid energy system
86568. model optimization using HOMER. Can J Basic Appl Sci 2013;1:1925.
[26] Erdinc O, Uzunoglu M. A new perspective in optimum sizing of hybrid [60] Dursun E, Acarkan B, Killic O. Modeling of hydrogen with a standalone
renewable energy system: consideration of component performance renewable hybrid power system. Int J Hydrog Energy 2012;37:3098107.
degradation issue. Int J Hydrog Energy 2012;37:1047988. [61] Mezzai N, Rekioua D, Rekioua T, Mohammedi A, Idjdarane K, Bacha S.
[27] Bayod-Rjula ngel A, Haro-Larrod Marta E, Martnez-Gracia Amaya. Sizing Modeling of hybrid photovoltaic/wind/fuel cells power system. Int J Hydrog
criteria of hybrid photovoltaicwind systems with battery storage and self- Energy 2014;39:1515868.
consumption considering interaction with the grid. Solar Energy [62] Lynch JA. Maximizing hybrid availability through system control. In: Pro-
2013;98:58291. ceedings of INTLEC; 1986. p. 15556.
[28] Erdinc O, Elma O, Uzunoglu M, Selamogullari US. Real time performance [63] Akerlund J, Ottosson J. A data logger and remote control for hybrid power
analysis of an optimally sized hybrid renewable energy conversion unit. system. In: Proceedings of INTLEC; 1987. p. 44349.
Energy Build 2014;75:41929. [64] Nogaret E, Stavrakakis G, Bonin JC. A new expert system based control tool
[29] Kalantar M, SMG Mousavi. Dynamic behavior of a stand-alone hybrid power for power system with large integration of PV and Wind power plant. IEEE
generation system of wind turbine, microturbine, solar array and battery Photovolt Energy Convers 1994;1:10525.
storage. Appl Energy 2010;87:305164. [65] Pitrone A, Pitrone N. On line management and control of distributed
[30] Yang H, Zhou W, Lu L, Fang Z. Optimal sizing method for stand-alone hybrid renewable energy power plant. In: Proceedings of Power Tech Conference;
solarwind system with LPSP technology by using genetic algorithm. Solar 1999. p. 415.
Energy 2003;82:35467. [66] Gaztanaga H, Etxeberria O, Bacha S, Roye D. Real time analysis of the control
[31] Boonbumroong U, Pratinthong N, Thepa S, Jivacate C, Pridasawas W. PSO structure and management functions of a hybrid microgrid system. In:
for ac- coupling standalone hybrid power system. Solar Energy Proceedings of IECON; 2006. p. 513742.
2011;85:5609. [67] Jinhong J, Seulki Kim, Changhee C, Jonbo A, Jangmok K. Power control of a
[32] Celik AK. Techno-economic analysis of autonomous PVwind hybrid systems grid connected hybrid generation system with PV/Wind/Battery source. In:
using different sizing methods. Energy Convers Manag 2003;44:195168. Proceedings of ICPE-IEEE; 2007. p. 50610.
[33] Kamel S, Dahl C. The economics of hybrid power systems for sustainable [68] Abdulwahid U, Manwell JF, Mcgown JG. Development of a dynamic control
desert agriculture in Egypt. Energy 2005;30:127181. communication system for hybrid power system. IET Renew Power Gener
[34] Koutroulis E, Kolokotsa D, Potirakis A, Kalaitzakis K. Methodology for optimal 2007:7080.
sizing of stand-alone photovoltaic/wind-generator systems using genetic [69] Hui Li, Kaiyu W, Da Z, Wei R. Improved performance and control of hybrid
algorithms. Solar Energy 2006;80:107288. cascaded H bridge inverter for utility interactive renewable energy applica-
[35] Yang H, Lu L, Zhou W. A novel optimization sizing model for hybrid solar tions. In: Proceedings of PESC; 2007. p. 246571. ISSN 0275-9306.
wind power generation system. Solar Energy 2007;81:7684. [70] Wang Li, Kuo Hua Liu. Implementation of a web based real time monitoring
[36] Gupta SC, Kumar Y, Agnihotri G. Optimal sizing of solarwind hybrid sys- and control system for a hybrid wind-pv-battery renewable energy system.
tem. In: Proceedings of IET-ICTES; 2007. p. 28287. In: Proceedings of ISAP; 2007. p. 916.
[37] Diaf S, Notton G, Belhamel M, Haddadi M, Louche A. Design and techno- [71] Vechiu I, Curea O, Comblong H, Ceballos S, Villate JL. Digital control of a
economical optimization for hybrid PV/wind system under various meteor- 3 phase four leg inverter under unbalance voltage conditions. In: Proceed-
ological conditions. Appl Energy 2008;85:96887. ings of EPE-IEEE; 2007. p. 110.
[38] Yang H, Zhou W, Lou C. Optimal design and techno-economic analysis of a [72] Boquan Z, Yimin Y, Lu G. Dynamic control of wind /PV hybrid power system
hybrid solarwind power generating system. Appl Energy 2009;86:1639. based on an advanced particle swarm optimization. In: Proceedings of ICIT-
[39] Tina GM, Gagliano S. Probabilistic modeling of hybrid solar/wind power IEEE; 2008. p. 16.
system. Renew Energy 2011;36:171927. [73] Torres Hernandez M.E, Velez Reyes M. Hierarchical control of hybrid power
[40] Khatod DK, Pant V, Sharma J. Analytical approach for well-being assessment system. In: Proceedings of CIEP-IEEE; 2008. p. 16976.
of small autonomous power systems with solar and wind energy sources. [74] Mboup AB, Guerin F, Ndiaye PA, Lefebvre D. Petri nets control design for
IEEE Trans Energy Convers 2010;25:53545. hybrid electrical energy systems. In: Proceedings of ACC-IEEE; 2009. p.
[41] Kaabeche A, Belharnel M, Ibtiouen R. Sizing optimization of grid independent 501217.
hybrid PV/Wind power generation system. Energy 2011;36:121422. [75] Arulam Palam A, Mithulanan Than N, Bansal RC, Saha TK. Microgrid control
[42] Marchetti GP, Piccolo M. Mathematical models for the construction of a of PV-Wind-Diesel hybrid system with islanded and grid connected opera-
renewable energy hybrid plant. IEEE; 1990. p. 50209. tions. In: Proceedings of ICSET-IEEE; 2010. p. 15.
V. Khare et al. / Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 58 (2016) 2333 33

[76] Huang Y, Xu Y, Zhou XC. Study on wind solar hybrid generating system [104] Berrazouane S, Mohammedi K. Hybrid system energy management and
control strategy. In: Proceedings of ICMT-IEEE; 2011. p. 7736. supervision based on fuzzy logic approach for electricity production in
[77] Preethishri TPV, Kumar KS, Sivakumar P. Embedded emulator of photovoltaic remote areas. In: Proceedings of ICREVT-IEEE; 2012. p. 3249.
array and wind driven induction generator by using digital signal controller. [105] Shahirinia AH, Tafreshi SMM, Gastej AH, Moghaddomjoo AR. Optimal sizing
In: Proceedings of IICPE-IEEE; 2011. p. 17. of hybrid power system using genetic algorithm. In: Proceedings of FPS-IEEE;
[78] Ram Prabhakar J, Ragavan K. Classical controller for coordination of wind 2005. p. 15.
solar hydro energy conversion system in isolated region. In: Proceedings of [106] Xu. D, Kang L, Liuchen C, Binggang C. Optimal sizing of standalone hybrid
ICPS-IEEE; 2011. p. 16. Wind/PV power system using genetic algorithm. In: Proceedings of CCECE-
[79] Croci L, Martinez A, Coirault P, Champenois G, Gaubert JP. Passivity based IEEE; 2005. p. 172225.
control of photovoltaic wind hybrid system with Euler lagrange modeling. [107] Arabali A, Ghofrani M, Etezadi AM, Fadali MS. Genetic algorithm based
In: Proceedings of IECON IEEE; 2012. p. 112631. optimization approach for energy management. IEEE Trans 2013;28:16270.
[80] Budh DD, Virulkar VB. Smoothing control for battery energy storage system [108] Ghada M, Leuthold M, Dirk Uwe S. Optimization of an Off-grid hybrid PV-
based hybrid renewable energy system. In: Proceedings of SCEECS-IEEE; Wind-Diesel system with different battery technologies sensitivity analysis.
2014. p. 14. In: Proceedings of IEEE-INTELEC; 2013. p. 16.
[81] Vander Linde H, Clark I. Microprocessor control of hybrid energy system. [109] Ricalde JL, Ordonez E, Gamez M, Sanchez EN. Design of a smart grid man-
IEEE; 1992. p. 21720. agement system with renewable energy generation. In: Proceedings of
[82] Gota D, Domuta C, Miclea L. Design and control of smart hybrid renewable CIASG-IEEE; 2011. p. 15.
[110] Ghareeb AT, Mohammed OA. Wavelet adaptive ANN forecaster for renewable
energy system using modied genetic algorithm and direct design control.
energy sources for continuous supply in microgrid applications. In: Pro-
In: Proceedings of APPEEC-IEEE; 2012. p. 14.
ceedings of PES-IEEE; 2013. p. 16.
[83] Daming Xu, Langyun K, Liuchen C Binggang C. Optimal sizing of standalone
[111] Kaviani AK, Riahy GH, Kouhsari SHM. Optimal design of a reliable hydrogen
hybrid wind/PV power system using genetic algorithms. In: Proceedings of
based stand-alone wind/PV generating system, considering component
CCECE-IEEE; 2005. p. 172225.
outages. Renew Energy 2009;34:238090.
[84] Zhao YS, Zhan J, Zhang Y, Wang DP, Zou BG. The optimal capacity con-
[112] Hakimi SM, Moghaddas-Tafreshi SM. Optimal sizing of a stand-alone hybrid
guration of an independent wind/PV hybrid power supply system
power system via particle swarm optimization for Kahnouj area in south-east
based on improved PSO algorithm. In: Proceedings of APSCOM-IEEE; of Iran. Renew Energy 2009;34:185562.
2009. p. 17. [113] khare Vikas, Nema Savita, Baredar Prashant. Optimization of the hybrid
[85] Gupta RA, Kumar R, Bansal AK. Economic analysis and design of standalone renewable energy system by HOMER, PSO and CPSO for the study area. Int J
wind/PV hybrid energy system using genetic algorithm. In: Proceedings of Sustain Energy 2015;34:118.
ICCCA; 2012. p. 16. [114] Sharp JK. Consumer incentives for solar energy. IEEE; 1981. p. 84951.
[86] Ben Jemaa, Hamzaoui A, Essoonbouli N, Hnaien F, Yalawi F, Optimum sizing [115] Ogino K. Non-cooperative game approach for public participation and
of hybrid PV/Wind/battery system using fuzzy adaptive genetic algo- resource supply in electric generating system development. In: Proceedings
rithm. In: Proceedings of ICSC; 2013. p. 81014. of ICSMC-IEEE; 1990. p. 1514.
[87] Tutkum N, San ES. Optimal power scheduling of an off-grid renewable hybrid [116] Lygeros J, Godbole DN, Sastry S. Multiagent hybrid system design using game
system used for heating and lighting in a typical residential house. In: Pro- theory and optimal control. In: Proceedings of CDC-IEEE; 1996,2. p. 11905.
ceedings of EEEIC; 2013. p. 3525. [117] Wu C, Hamed MR, Huang J. Wind power integration via aggregator-
[88] Dehgan S, Saboori H, Parizad A, Kiani B. Optimal sizing of a hydrogen based consumer coordination: a game theoretic approach. In: Proceedings of
wind/PV plant considering reliability indoces. In: Proceedings of EPECS; IEEE-ISGT; 2012. p. 16.
2009. p. 19. [118] Street A, Lima DA, Freire L. Sharing quotas of a renewable energy hedge pool:
[89] Lingfeng W, Singh C. Multicriteria design of hybrid power generation system a cooperative game theory approach. IEEE; 2011. p. 16.
based on modied particle swarm optimization algorithm. IEEE Trans [119] Saad W, Zhu Han. Coalitional game theory for cooperative microgrid dis-
2009;24:16372. tribution network. In: Proceedings of ICC-IEEE; 2011. p. 15.
[90] Sanchez V, Ramirez J.M, Arriaga G. Optimal sizing of a hybrid renewable [120] Bayens E, Bitar EY, Khargonekar PP, Poolla K. Coalitional aggregation of wind
system. In: Proceedings of ICIT-IEEE; 2010. p. 84954. power. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2011:111.
[91] Ardakani FJ, Riahy G, Abedi M. Design of an optimum hybrid renewable [121] Mei S, Wang Y, Liu F, Zhang X, Sun Z. Game approaches for hybrid power
energy system considering reliability indices. In: Proceedings of ICEE; 2010. system planning. IEEE Trans Sustainable Energy 2012;3:112.
p. 8427. [122] Chenye Wu, Hamed MR, Huang J, Wang AY. Demand side management for
[92] Bansal AK, Gupta RA, Kumar R. Optimization of hybrid pv/wind energy wind power integration in microgrid using dynamic potential game theory.
system using meta particle swarm optimization. In: Proceedings of IICPE; In: Proceedings of IEEE-SGCN; 2011. p. 11991204.
2010. p. 17. [123] Wei W, Liu F, Mei S. Game theoretic scheduling of modern power systems
[93] Bashir M, Sadeh J. Size optimization of new hybrid standalone renewable with large scale wind power integration. IEEE;2012. p. 16.
energy system considering a reliability index. In: Proceedings of EEEIC; 2012. [124] Zhu Q, Zhang J, Sauer P, Dominguez-Garcia A, Baar T. A game-theoretic
p. 98994. framework for control of distributed renewable-based energy resources in
[94] Keyrouz F, Hamad M, Georges S. A novel unied maximum power point smart grids. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference (ACC); 2012. p.
tracker for controlling a hybrid wind solar and fuel cell system. In: Pro- 36238.
ceedings of EVER-IEEE; 2013. p. 16. [125] Dai T, Qiao W. Trading wind power in a competitive electricity market using
[95] Amer M, Namaane A, Msirdi NK. Optimization of HRES using PSO for cost stochastic programming and game theory. IEEE Trans Sustain Energy
reduction. Energy Procedia 2013;42:31827. 2013;4:16.
[96] Sanchez VM, Chavez Ramirez AU. Techno-economical optimization based [126] Khare V, Nema S, Baredar P. Game theory based cournots model of solar
wind hybrid renewable energy system. In: Proceedings of ICRESE-IEEE; 2013.
on swarm intelligence algorithm for a standalone Wind-PV hydrogen
p. 711.
power system at South-east region of Maxico. Int J Hydrog Energy
[127] Khare V, Nema S, Baredar P. Application of game theory in solar wind hybrid
2014;39:1664655.
energy system. Int J Electr Electr Eng Res 2012;2:2532.
[97] Borhanazad H, Mekhelif S, Ganapathy VG. Optimization of micro grid system
[128] Billinton R, Karki R. Maintaining supply reliability of small isolated power
using MOPSO. Renew Energy 2014;71:295306.
systems using renewable energy. In: Proceedings of generation, transmission
[98] Chakaborty S, Ito T, Senjyu T. Optimal economic operation of smart grid by
and distribution IEEE. 148; 2001. p. 5304.
fuzzy advanced quantum evolutionary method. In: Proceedings of IEEE-PES;
[129] Zhao Q, Wang P, Goel L, Ding Y. Impacts of renewable energy penetration on
2012. p. 18. nodal price and nodal reliability in deregulated power system. In: Proceed-
[99] Adhikari N, Singh B, Vyas AL, Chandra A, Kamal Al Hadad. Analysis, design ings of IEEE-PES; 2011. p. 16.
and control of a standalone hybrid renewable energy conversion system. In: [130] Kishore LN, Fernandez E. Reliability well being assessment of pv wind hybrid
Proceedings of PEDG; 2013. p. 18. system using Monte Carlo simulation. In: Proceedings of ICETECT; 2011. p. 638.
[100] Chakarborty S, Ito T, Senjyu T, Saber AY. Intelligent economic operation of [131] Blaabjerg F, Ma K, Zhau D. Power electronics and reliability in renewable
smart grid facilitating fuzzy advanced quantum evolutionary method. IEEE energy system. In: Proceedings of IEEE ISIE; 2012. p. 19-30.
Trans 2013:90516. [132] Pradhan N, Karki NR. Probablistic reliability evaluation of off-grid small
[101] Fidalgo JN, Lopez JA, Mirenda V. Neural network applied to preventive con- hybrid solar pv wind power system for the rural electrication in Nepal.
trol measures for the dynamic security of isolated power systems with In: Proceedings of NAPS-IEEE; 2012. p. 16.
renewable. IEEE Trans Power Syst 1996(11):18116. [133] Haying W, Xiaomin B. Adequacy assessment of generating system incorpor-
[102] Jifang L, Tianhao T, Jiuhang H. A neural network control strategy for multi ating wind, pv, and energy storage. In: Proceedings of ISGA Asia; 2012. p. 16.
energy common dc bus hybrid power supply. In: Proceedings of SPEEDAM- [134] 1Nagarajan T, Vijiyasamundiswary S, Sasilkumar P. Reliability and cost analysis
IEEE; 2010. p. 182731. of hybrid renewable energy system. In: Proceedings of ICCPEIC; 2013. p. 848.
[103] Duong M.Q, Ogliari E, Grimaccia F, Leva S, Mussetta M. Hybrid model for [135] Kekezoglu B, Arikan O, Erduman A, Isen E, Durusu A, Bozkurt A. Reliability
hourly forecast of photovoltaic and wind power. In: Proceedings of FUZZ- analysis of hybrid energy system: case study of Davutpasa campus. In: Pro-
IEEE; 2013. p. 16. ceedings of EUROCON; 2013. p. 11414.