Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
extension.osu.edu
hcs.osu.edu
USINGBRIXASANINDICATOROFVEGETABLEQUALITY:
LINKINGMEASUREDVALUESTOCROPMANAGEMENT
HYG1651
AgricultureandNaturalResources
Date:01/18/2013
MatthewD.KleinhenzandNatalieR.Bumgarner,DepartmentofHorticultureandCropScience,TheOhio
StateUniversity,OhioAgriculturalResearchandDevelopmentCenter
Cropqualityisimportanttofruitandvegetablegrowers,buyers,andhandlers.Brixreadingsindicatesoluble
solidscontent.Sincesolublesolidsrepresentaproduct'spotentialsweetness(anaspectofquality),Brix
readingscaninterestmanythroughoutthevaluechain.Threestepsarerequiredtomakeeffectiveuseof
Brixreadings:(1)obtainaccuraterepresentativevalues(2)becomefamiliarwithotherrepresentativevalues
forsimilarcropsand(3)ifneeded,adjustmanagementpracticesaccordingtohowtheymayaffectBrix
valuesofyourcrops,usingprovenapproaches.
Fourfactsheetshavebeenpreparedtoguidevegetablefarmers,buyers,andhandlersinusingBrixasan
indicatorofcropquality.ThisLinkingfactsheetprovidesreferenceinformationonrepresentativeBrixvalues
andhowtheyareinfluencedbycropmanagement.Equippedwiththisinformation,vegetablesuppliersshould
bebetterpreparedtomakeeffectiveuseofBrixmeasurementintheiroperation.However,theOverviewfact
sheetprovidesimportantbackgroundinformationonBrix,outlinesitsapplicationinhorticulturalcrop
production,anddescribesthebenefitsandlimitationsofmeasuringBrixduringvegetableproductionand
marketing.TwootherfactsheetsprovidespecificinstructionsforthetakingofBrixreadingsinfivevegetable
crops.
BrixValuesinVegetableCrops
Brixvaluesarerelativelystraightforwardtomeasureandarereadilyavailable.However,fewpeopleappearto
befamiliarwithvaluesthatwouldbe"typical"fortheircrop.Referencevaluesareavailableingovernmentand
scientificreportsandotherdocuments.However,ultimately,themostimportantvaluesformostvegetable
growers,buyers,andhandlersmaybethe"bank"ofnumberstheydevelopintheirownoperationovertime
throughconsistent,conscientiousmeasurement.Nevertheless,inthisfactsheet,wepresentthreesetsof
referenceBrixvalues.
Thefirstset(Table1)includesexamplesofsolublesolidsvaluesthatareusedascriteriainofficialUSDAfruit
andvegetablequalitygrades.Incertainfruitingcrops(i.e.,cantaloupe,watermelon)solublesolidslevels
obtainedwithanapprovedrefractometerinfluencetheofficialgradetowhichthecropisassigned.For
example,basedonthechartbelow,Brixvalueslessthan9%and8%incantaloupeandwatermelon,
respectively,meanthatthecropcannotbelabeledashaving"goodinternalquality"byUSDAstandards.
Table1.ExamplesofUSDAcropgradingstandardswhichincorporatesolublesolidsvalues.
"Verygoodinternalquality" 11%
Cantaloupe
"Goodinternalquality" 9%
"Verygoodinternalquality" 10%
Watermelon
"Goodinternalquality" 8%
ThesecondsetofreferenceBrixvalues(Table2)wastakenfrompublishedagriculturalresearch.Thisset
includesvaluesreportedonmultiplecropsgrowninresearchplotsinmanylocations.Keepinmindthatthese
plotsweremanageddifferently:growingsystem,nutrientandirrigationregime,andvarietydifferedfrom
oneexperimenttoanother.Becauseofthisvariation,numbersinTable2donotnecessarilyrepresenttarget
values.Thatsaid,theresearchwasusuallyconductedtostudytheinfluenceofgeneticandproduction
factorsoncropquality.And,theresearchofteninvolvedcommerciallikepracticesandcommonvarieties.
Therefore,itisreasonableforgrowersandotherstoobservesimilarBrixvaluesintheirbusiness.
Table2.Examplesofsolublesolids(Brix)valuesfrompublishedagriculturalresearchreports
acrossavarietyofcropsandlocations.
Greenhousetomatoes
4.35.0 Thyboetal.,2006
Denmark
Table3.Solublesolids(Brix)valuesgatheredduringanonfarmresearchprojectcarriedoutin
Ohioin2011.
Varietyselection,cropmaturity,cropphysiologyormetabolism,andmajorabioticcomponentsofthegrowing
environment(e.g.,moisture,fertility,light,andtemperature)areknowntoinfluenceBrixlevels.Variety
selectionandcropmaturity,metabolism,andwaterstatustendtohavedirectandoftensignificantand
immediateimpactsonvegetableBrixlevels.Incontrast,soilandcropnutrientstatusandenvironmentallight
andtemperaturelevelsappeartohavemoreindirectandsubtleeffectsonvegetableBrixvalues.The
followingisabriefsummaryofsomeofthespecificeffectsofvariousfactorsonvegetableBrixlevels.
InformationgiveninthissectionissupportedbyarticlescitedintheReferencessectionandfarmer
experience.
Weathereffectsonsolublesolidslevelsbeginatplantingandcontinuethroughharvest,inpartbecause
plantingandharvestingdatesdeterminetheenvironmentalconditionsunderwhichcropsgrowandmature.
EnvironmentalconditionsthatmoststronglyinfluencecropqualityandBrixincludesunlight,temperature,
andmoisture.Exposuretovariouscombinationsoftheseconditionsduetoplantingandharvestschedules
caninfluenceelementsofquality(includingBrix)andflavorinfieldandgreenhousegrowncrops.These
conditionsinfluencetheamountofsolublesolids(mostlysugars)thatareinmarketableleaves,stems,fruits,
tubers,roots,etc.,atanyonetime.ThesefactorsinfluenceBrixlevelsaloneandincombination.For
example,temperatureandlightinteracttosettherateofsugarproduction,buttemperaturemayhavea
strongerinfluenceontomatofruitsolublesolidscontentthansunlight.
Weather,plantingandharvestingdates,andsomesoilcharacteristicsoftencannotbealteredsignificantly.
Often,vegetablegrowersmustadheretocertainplantingandharvestingwindows.Also,theycanonly
establishprotectivemicroclimatesaroundcrops(e.g.,usingmulches,films,orloworhightunnels)which
lessenthemoreradicaleffectsthattemperature,moisture,andotherextremeconditionscanhaveoncrop
quality.Likewise,soilamendmentscanincreasesoilorganicmatteroralterothersoilproperties,thereby
creatinggrowingconditionsmoreconducivetocrophealthandquality.Yet,somestepstolimitenvironmental
fluctuationsorenhancesoilqualitymaybeunavailabletosomefarmers.Moreover,theeffectsofthesesteps
oncropqualityintheneartermmaybeindirect.Therefore,vegetablegrowersmayprefertotakeeasysteps
proventohaveimmediateandsignificanteffectsonquality,perhapsespeciallyBrix.Stepsinthiscategory
includepropervarietyselection,waterandfertilitymanagement,andplantingandharvesttiming.
Allthingsbeingequal,varietiesofthesamecroptendtodifferintheirbaselineBrixlevel.Thatis,varieties
haveanaturalinclinationtowardlowerorhigherlevelsofsolublesolidswithintheportionthatismarketed.
Therefore,varietyselectionisoneofthemostimportantanddirectmethodsofshapingBrixandcropquality.
IfBrixisimportanttoyou,considerdiscussingvarietaltendencieswithseedsuppliersandreviewingother
dataonvarieties.Productqualitybeginswithvarietyselection.
Regardlessofvariety,solublesolidslevelstrackcropmaturity.Allvegetablecropsundergochangesintheir
makeupthroughtheirlifetime,regardlessofwhatthefarmerdoes.Sweetcornkernelsturningfrommilkyand
sweettodryandstarchyisoneexampleofthenatural,preprogrammedcropmaturationprocess.So,crop
stageandharvesttiming,inparticular,stronglyinfluencecropqualityandBrixlevels.
Infact,thedegreeofripeningatharvestinfluencesthefullchemicalmakeupofthefruitorimmatureseed
and,therefore,itsflavorandtexture.Solublesolidsandsugarstendtoincreaseduringripening,whileacids
tendtodecrease.Whentomatofruitareharvestedataveryearlystageofripening,thecombinationof
sugars,acids,andvolatilecompoundsrelatedtoflavormaybesuboptimum.Thatsaid,somefruitandseed
continuetomatureafterpicking.And,theymaybemoresusceptibletophysicaldamageduringpostharvest
handlingifpickedtableripe.Regardless,itisclearthatharvesttimingisimportanttoallgrowersandthat
measuringBrixvaluescanhelpdetermineharvestandmarketreadinessinsomecrops.
IrrigationtimingorsoilmoisturelevelsalsoaffectBrixbutinwaysthatmaycomplicatemanagement
decisions.Forexample,reducedwateravailabilityduringfruitdevelopmentcanincreasefruitsolublesolids
contentbutlowertotalfruityield.So,growersmustbalancetheopportunitytoenhancethequalityoftheirfruit
withthepotentialtoreducetheyieldofthemusingthesamepractice.Indryareaswherewateravailability
canbecarefullycontrolled,preciseirrigationhasbeenabletoincreaseBrixandmaintainacceptableyields.
Hightunnelgrowersmaybeabletobalanceyieldandqualitymosteffectivelythroughirrigationandfertility
management.
Indeed,theinfluenceoffertilityprogramsonBrixisbecomingclear.Increasedfertilizerorsalinitylevels(i.e.,
higherelectricalconductivitylevels)inirrigationwaterarereportedtoincreaseBrixlevelsingreenhouse
growntomatoandpepper.Mineralfertilizationcanalsoinfluencevolatilecompoundsandfruitflavor.
Inadditiontoelectricalconductivity,thereisevidencethatnitrogen(N)nutritioncanaffectBrixlevelsbutin
anindirectandcomplexmanner.Nitrogenavailabilitycanimpacttheefficiencyofphotosynthesisthrough
whichsugariscreatedand,therefore,possiblyaltersolublesolidslevels.However,excessNcanalsoslow
maturationandreducesugarandacidcontent.
Effectsonsolublesolidcontentintomatoweremeasuredon Brixlevelsareacommonmetricused
8/24/07inGdll,Hungary.Treatmentswereunirrigated(1), todescribethequalityandsuitabilityof
unirrigatedwithKapplication(2),irrigationupto30daysbefore processingtomatoes(Imagecourtesyof
harvest(3),irrigationupto30daysbeforeharvestwithK HirzelCanningCompanyandFarms,
application(4),standardirrigation(5),andstandardirrigation Toledo,Ohio).
withKapplication(6).Columnsbearingthesameletterarenot
significantlydifferent.Verticalbarsrepresentsignificant
differencesatp=0.05,n=4.
LinkingMeasuredBrixValuestoCropManagementA
Recap
Productionfactorssuchastemperatureandlightlevelsandsoil
moistureandfertilitystatusinfluencecropBrixlevels.These
factorsdifferwithregardtotheamountofcontrolfieldandhigh
tunnelgrowershaveoverthem.Thesefactorsalsodifferwith
regardtotheapparent,directimpacttheyhaveonBrix,based
onscientificevidenceandgrowerexperience.Biologicalfactors
suchasvarietyandcropmaturityaffectsolublesolidslevels
stronglygrowersselectvarietiesbuthavelittlecontrolover
maturityoutsideofharvesttiming.
Controlledenvironmentgreenhouseproductioninvolvesagreateramountofcontroloverfactorsthatinfluence
cropgrowth,yield,andcertainaspectsofqualitythanfieldproduction.Overall,thegreenhouseindustry
continuestopaycloseattentiontotheeffectsofvarietyselectionandcropmanagementonBrix.Also,
adjustmentsinmanagementregimenstooptimizeBrixandothercharacteristicsaregenerallymorefeasible
ingreenhousethanfieldsettings.Farmersworkingwithsoilsinmoredynamicandunpredictableopenfield
andhightunnelsettingshaveanopportunitytogainfromwhatisdiscoveredingreenhouseproductionand
research.Moreimportant,fieldandhightunnelvegetablegrowerscanlearnfromtheirowntestsofthe
relationshipsbetweenmanagementandBrixandotheraspectsofcropquality.Thisfourpartfactsheet
seriesisdesignedtoassisttheminthatprocess.
References
Aldrich,H.T.,K.Salandanan,P.Kendall,M.Bunning,F.Stonaker,O.Kulen,andC.Stushnoff.2010.
Cultivarchoiceprovidesoptionsforlocalproductionoforganicandconventionallyproducedtomatoes
withhigherqualityandantioxidantcontent.J.Sci.FoodAgr.90:25482555.
Anza,M.,P.Riga,andC.Garbisu.2006.Effectsofvarietyandgrowthseasonontheorganolepticand
nutritionalqualityofhydroponicallygrowntomato.JFoodQual.29:1637.
Arias,R.,T.C.Lee,D.Specca,andH.Janes.2000.Qualitycomparisonofhydroponictomatoes
(Lycopersiconesculentum)ripenedonandoffvine.J.FoodSci.65:545548.
Aulenbach,B.B.,andJ.T.Worthington.1974.Sensoryevaluationofmuskmelon:Issolublesolids
contentagoodqualityindex?HortScience9:136137.
Barrett,D.M.,C.Weakley,J.V.Diaz,andM.Watnik.2007.Qualitativeandnutritionaldifferencesin
processingtomatoesgrownundercommercialorganicandconventionalproductionsystems.JFood
Sci.72:C441C451.
Beverly,R.B.,J.G.Latimer,andD.A.Smittle.1993.Preharvestphysiologicalandculturaleffectson
postharvestquality.p.7398.R.L.Shewfelt,andS.E.Prussia(eds).In:Postharvesthandling:A
systemsapproach.AcademicPressSanDiego,CA.
Blaesing,D.,A.Murray,M.Schulz,andM.Stewart.2006.Nutrientmanagementforhighsolublesolids
productioninAustralianprocessingtomatoes.ActaHort.724:7583.
BumgarnerN.,J.C.Scheerens,R.W.Mullen,M.A.Bennett,P.P.Ling,andM.D.Kleinhenz.2012.Root
zonetemperatureandnitrogenaffecttheyieldandsecondarymetaboliteconcentrationoffalland
springgrown,highdensitylettuce.J.Sci.FoodAgr.92:116124.
Chassy,A.W.,L.Bui,E.N.C.Renaud,M.V.Horn,andA.E.Mitchell.2006.Threeyearcomparisonof
thecontentofantioxidantmicroconstituentsandseveralqualitycharacteristicsinorganicand
conventionallymanagedtomatoesandbellpeppers.J.Agr.FoodChem.54:82448252.
Crisosto,C.H.,andJ.P.Mitchell.2002.Preharvestfactorsaffectingfruitandvegetablequality.p.49
54.In:A.A.Kader(ed).Postharvesttechnologyofhorticulturalcrops,3rdEd.Univ.Cal.Agr.Nat.Res.
Pub.3311.
Davis,A.R.,C.L.Webber,P.PerkinsVeazie,andJ.Collins.2006.Impactofcultivarandproduction
practicesonyieldandphytonutrientcontentoforganicallygrownwatermelon.J.Veg.Sci.12:8391.
Fleisher,D.H.,L.S.Logendra,C.Moraru,A.J.Both,J.Cavazzoni,T.Gianfagna,T.C.Lee,andH.W.
Janes.2006.Effectoftemperatureperturbationsontomato(LycopersiconesculentumMill.)quality
andproductionscheduling.J.Hort.Sci.Biotechnol.81:125131.
Gazula,A.,M.D.Kleinhenz,J.G.Streeter,andA.R.Miller.2005.Temperatureandcultivareffectson
AnthocyaninandchlorophyllbconcentrationsinthreerelatedLolloRossolettucecultivars.
HortScience40:17311733.
Gills,L.A.,A.V.A.Resurreccion,W.C.Hurst,A.E.Reynolds,andS.C.Phatak.1999.Sensoryprofiles
ofcarrot(DaucuscarotaL.)cultivarsgrowninGeorgia.HortScience34:625628.
Hale,T.A.,R.L.Hassel,andT.Phillips.2005.Refractometermeasurementsofsolublesolid
concentrationdonotreliablypredictsugarcontentinsweetcorn.HortTechnology15:668672.
Helyes,L.,J.Dimeny,Z.Pek,andA.Lugasi.2006.Effectofthevarietyandgrowingmethodsaswell
ascultivationconditionsonthecompositionoftomato(Lycopersiconlycopersicum(L.)Karsten)fruit.
ActaHort.712:511516.
Hornick,S.B.1992.Factorsaffectingthenutritionalqualityofcrops.Amer.J.Alt.Agr.7:6368.
Johnstone,P.R.,T.K.Hartz,M.LeStrange,J.J.Nunez,andE.M.Miyao.2005.Managingfruitsoluble
solidswithlateseasondeficitirrigationindripirrigatedprocessingtomatoproduction.HortScience
40:18571861.
Kleinhenz,M.D.,andA.Wszelaki.2003.Yieldandrelationshipsamongheadtraitsincabbageas
influencedbyplantingdateandcultivar.I.Freshmarket.HortScience38:13491254.
Krauss,S.,W.H.Schnitzler,J.Grassmann,andM.Woitke.2006.Theinfluenceofdifferentelectrical
conductivityinasimplifiedrecirculatingsoillesssystemoninnerandouterfruitqualitycharacteristics
oftomato.J.Agr.Food.Chem.54:441448.
Lamont,W.J.2005.Plastics:Modifyingthemicroclimatefortheproductionofvegetablecrops.
HortTechnology15:477481.
Lester,G.,andK.C.Shellie.1992.Postharvestsensoryandphysicochemicalattributesofhoneydew
melonfruits.HortScience27:10121014.
Pardo,J.E.,R.Gomez,J.Tardaguila,M.Amo,andR.Varon.1996.Qualityevaluationofwatermelon
varieties(CitrullusvulgarisS.).J.FoodQual.20:547557.
Peet,M.M.,C.D.Harlow,andE.S.Larrea.2004.Fruitqualityandyieldinfivesmallfruitedgreenhouse
tomatocultivarsunderhighfertilizationregime.ActaHort.659:811818.
Pluda,D.,H.D.Rabinowitch,andU.Kafkafi.1993.Pepinodulce(SolanummirucatumAit.)quality
characteristicsrespondtonitrogennutritionandsalinity.J.Amer.Soc.Hort.Sci.118:8691.
Radovich,T.J.K.,M.D.Kleinhenz,J.G.Streeter,R.Miller,andJ.C.Scheerens.2005.Plantingdate
affectstotalglucosinolateconcentrationsinsixcommercialcabbagecultivars.HortScience40:106
110.
Renquist,A.R.,M.J.LaGrange,B.P.Searle,andJ.B.Reid.2005.Towardsacontroltheoryforacidity
ofvegetablecrops.ActaHort.694:463469.
Riga,P.,M.Anza,andC.Garbisu.2008.Tomatoqualityismoredependentontemperaturethanon
photosyntheticallyactiveradiation.J.Sci.FoodAgr.88:158166.
Simon,P.W.1985.Carrotflavor:Effectsofgenotype,growingconditions,storage,andprocessing.p.
315328.In:H.E.Pattee(ed).Evaluationofqualityoffruitsandvegetables.AVIPublishingCompany.
Westport,CT.
Stevens,M.A.1985.Tomatoflavor:Effectsofgenotype,culturalpractices,andmaturityatpicking.p.
367386.In:H.E.Pattee(ed).Evaluationofqualityoffruitsandvegetables.AVIPublishingCompany.
Westport,CT.
Tandon,K.S.,E.A.Baldwin,J.W.Scott,andR.L.Shewfelt.2003.Linkingsensorydescriptorsto
volatileandnonvolatilecomponentsoffreshtomatoflavor.J.FoodSci.68:23662371.
Thybo,A.K.,M.Edelenbos,L.P.Christensen,J.N.Sorensen,andK.ThorupKristensen.2006.Effect
oforganicgrowingsystemsonsensoryqualityandchemicalcompositionoftomatoes.LWT39:835
843.
USDANutrientDatabase.ndb.nal.usda.gov/.
USDAAMSStandards.ams.usda.gov/gradesstandards/vegetables.
Wang,Y.T.,S.W.Huang,R.L.Liu,andJ.Y.Jin.2007.Effectsofnitrogenapplicationonflavor
compoundsofcherrytomatofruits.J.PlantNutr.SoilSci.170:461468.
Wang,Z.H.,S.X.Li,andS.Malhi.2008.Effectsoffertilizationandotheragronomicmeasureson
nutritionalqualityofcrops.J.Sci.FoodAgr.88:723.
Wells,O.S.,andJ.B.Loy.1993.Rowcoversandhightunnelsenhancecropproductioninthe
northeasternUnitedStates.HortTechnology3:9295.
Weston,L.A.,andM.M.Barth.1997.Preharvestfactorsaffectingpostharvestqualityofvegetables.
HortScience32:812816.
Wright,D.H.,andN.D.Harris.1985.Effectofnitrogenandpotassiumfertilizationontomatoflavor.J.
Agr.FoodChem.33:355358.
Wszelaki,A.,andM.D.Kleinhenz.2003.Yieldandrelationshipsamongheadtraitsincabbageas
influencebyplantingdateandcultivar.II.Processing.HortScience38:13551259.
Zerbini,P.E.2008.Roleofmaturityforimprovedflavor.p.180199.In:B.BrucknerandS.G.Wyllie.
(eds).FruitandvegetableflavorRecentadvancesandfutureprospects.WoodheadPublishing
Limited.Cambridge,England.
Factsheetsinthisseries:
UsingBrixasanIndicatorofVegetableQuality:AnOverviewofthePractice,HYG1650
UsingBrixasanIndicatorofVegetableQuality:LinkingMeasuredValuestoCropManagement,HYG
1651
UsingBrixasanIndicatorofVegetableQuality:ASummaryoftheMeasurementMethod,HYG1652
UsingBrixasanIndicatorofVegetableQuality:InstructionsforMeasuringBrixinCucumber,Leafy
Greens,SweetCorn,Tomato,andWatermelon,HYG1653
ThetechnicalcontributionsofStephanieShortandDanaeWolfeinthedevelopmentofthisfactsheetare
appreciated.
Ohioline http://ohioline.osu.edu
OhioStateUniversityExtensionembraceshumandiversityandiscommittedtoensuringthatallresearchandrelatededucationalprograms
areavailabletoclienteleonanondiscriminatorybasiswithoutregardtoage,ancestry,color,disability,genderidentityorexpression,genetic
information,HIV/AIDSstatus,militarystatus,nationalorigin,race,religion,sex,sexualorientation,orveteranstatus.Thisstatementisin
accordancewithUnitedStatesCivilRightsLawsandtheUSDA.
RogerRennekamp,AssociateDeanandDirector,OhioStateUniversityExtension
ForDeafandHardofHearing,contactOhioStateUniversityExtensionusingyourpreferredcommunication(email,relayservices,orvideo
relayservices).Phone18007500750between8a.m.and5p.m.ESTMondaythroughFriday.Informtheoperatortodial6142926181.
Copyright2013,TheOhioStateUniversity