Sunteți pe pagina 1din 9

Trans Indian Inst Met

DOI 10.1007/s12666-016-0906-8

TECHNICAL PAPER

Corrosion Behaviour of Uncoated and Ceramic Coated 9Cr1Mo


Steel in Molten LiClKClUCl3 Salt
Ch. Jagadeeswara Rao1 T. P. Ismail2 A. Ravi Shankar1 Atul Ramesh Ballal2

C. Mallika1 U. Kamachi Mudali1

Received: 1 January 2016 / Accepted: 13 May 2016


The Indian Institute of Metals - IIM 2016

Abstract 9Cr1Mo steel has been proposed as the con- 1 Introduction


tainer material for the electrorefining process of pyro-
chemical reprocessing of spent metallic fuels from the Non-aqueous pyrochemical process is proposed for the
future sodium cooled fast breeder reactors. The electrore- reprocessing of spent metallic fuels to be discharged from
fining process was carried out using LiClKClUCl3 the future sodium cooled fast breeder reactors in India [1,
molten salt as the electrolyte at 500 C under argon 2]. Among the various processes such as salt purification,
atmosphere. To protect the electrorefining vessel, made of electrorefining, cathode processing, etc., in pyrochemical
9Cr1Mo steel from the attack by the electrolyte, yttria reprocessing, electrorefining and cathode processing are
stabilized zirconia (YSZ) ceramic coating was deposited on the key steps. Molten LiClKCl eutectic salt is used as the
9Cr1Mo steel by thermal spray process. The corrosion electrolyte at 500 C under inert argon atmosphere for the
behavior of 9Cr1Mo steel with and without YSZ coating separation of uranium, plutonium and minor actinides from
was evaluated in LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C the fission products through electrorefining process [2, 3].
under argon atmosphere for various durations (100, 250, To initiate the electrorefining process, 56 wt% UCl3
500 and 1000 h). The results revealed that with increase in containing molten LiClKCl salt is used as the electrolyte.
exposure time, the weight loss of uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel The container material used for electrorefining process
samples increased, while YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel should withstand the highly aggressive molten salt envi-
samples exhibited insignificant weight loss. SEM exami- ronment along with UCl3 at high temperatures and it
nation of exposed uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel samples should not undergo degradation. Since pyrochemical
showed Cr depletion on the surface and formation of reprocessing is a batch process and it involves the handling
chromium based oxides as corrosion products. After the of highly radioactive materials, the vessel used for the
corrosion experiment, SEM/EDS and XRD analyses of electrorefining process should also possess the endurance
both coated and uncoated samples showed the presence of for longer operation. Ferritic steels are proposed for the
FeCr and UO2. fabrication of electrorefining vessel. Previous studies on
the corrosion behavior of 2.25Cr1Mo and 9Cr1Mo steels
Keywords Molten salt corrosion  9Cr1Mo steel  exposed to molten LiClKCl salt at 600 C revealed that
Plasma spray coating  Yttria stabilized zirconia  2.25Cr1Mo steel is more prone to corrosion attack com-
Corrosion behavior pared to 9Cr1Mo steel [4]. Hence, 9Cr1Mo steel is
proposed as container material for the electrorefining pro-
cess because of its relatively better corrosion resistance in
molten chloride environment.
& U. Kamachi Mudali
kamachi@igcar.gov.in
Thermal spray [5] coatings on metallic substrates are
used widely for improving their oxidation and wear resis-
1
Corrosion Science and Technology Group, Indira Gandhi tance. Atmospheric plasma spray (APS) coatings have been
Centre for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam 603102, India developed on various structural materials and their corro-
2
Visvesvaraya National Institute of Technology, Nagpur, India sion resistance has been evaluated for pyrochemical

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

reprocessing applications [610]. Ceramic coatings devel- emery papers up to 1200 grit. The polished specimens were
oped by plasma spray process on the structural materials grit blasted and 250 micron thick NiCrAlY interlayer
for pyrochemical reprocessing have been found to protect coating and 50 micron thick YSZ top coat were deposited
the substrate materials from molten salt corrosion. Besides by plasma spray process using a METCO 3 MB plasma
being corrosion resistant, the overlay coating on the sub- gun at M/s. Spraymet Surface Technologies Pvt. Ltd.,
strate is also expected to have good adhesion/bonding with Bengaluru. The plasma spray parameters used to deposit
the substrate, no interaction with the environment in which the coatings are given in Table 2. The coating was
it is used, minimum wettability and ability to withstand deposited on all faces of the rectangular specimens up to a
thermal cycles. height of 35 mm.
Periasamy et al. [11] evaluated the durability of ZrN and
HfN in molten LiClKClNaClUCl3 at temperatures 2.2 Molten Salt Corrosion Test
ranging from 525 to 900 C for durations in the range
4485 h under argon atmosphere. They observed that ZrN The electrorefining process in the pyrochemical repro-
and HfN experience weight loss under all experimental cessing of spent nuclear metallic fuels was carried out in
conditions due to the formation of volatile products and/or molten LiClKCl salt at 500 C. As the molten salt was
electrochemical dissolution. Formation of the volatile zir- highly hygroscopic, traces of moisture or oxygen present in
conium and hafnium chlorides may be attributed to the the molten salt would affect the performance of the elec-
reaction of the nitrides with chlorine gas or chloride ion, trorefining process. Therefore, actual pyrochemical repro-
which in turn is generated by the reaction of UCl3 species cessing was carried out in inert atmosphere glove boxes. To
present in the salt with oxygen. The corrosion behavior of simulate the real conditions of the electrorefining process,
yttria stabilized zirconia (YSZ) coating on various struc- the present study was carried out under inert argon atmo-
tural materials such as 2.25Cr1Mo steel, 9Cr1Mo steel, sphere. The LiCl (44.48 wt%)KCl (55.52 wt%) eutectic
Ni-based alloys 600, 625, and 690 has been studied by Ravi mixture was initially purified by passing chlorine gas at
Shankar et al. [4] and they reported that the YSZ-coated 500 C for about 30 min. Molten LiClKCl salt containing
specimens exhibit better corrosion resistance than the UCl3 was prepared by equilibrating uranium metal with
uncoated specimens; however, premature spallation of the cadmium chloride in LiClKCl eutectic salt at 500 C [13].
coating is observed, probably due to either imperfections in Uranium content in the LiClKClUCl3 salt was estimated
the coating or accidental ingress of oxygen and moisture by Davies and Gray method [14]. The LiClKCl molten
during the corrosion test. Recently, we have investigated salt containing 4 wt% UCl3, thus produced was loaded in a
the corrosion behavior of the structural materials, stainless recrystallised alumina crucible along with the 9Cr1Mo
steel 410 (SS 410), alloy 600 and 9Cr1Mo steel in LiCl steel specimens and thermocouple and the loaded crucible
KCl molten salt at 500 and 600 C by thermogravimetry in was sealed in a stainless steel cell inside an argon atmo-
inert (argon) and reactive (argon ? oxygen) atmospheres sphere glove box. The cell assembly containing 9Cr1Mo
and observed the attack by molten salt to be more in 9Cr steel specimens in the molten salt was heated in a furnace
1Mo steel than in SS 410, followed by alloy 600 under both to 600 C and corrosion testing was carried out for 100,
the atmospheres [12]. As the corrosion behavior of these 250, 500 and 1000 h under argon gas atmosphere. The
structural materials in high temperature molten LiClKCl uncoated and coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens were tested
UCl3 salt has not been reliably reported in literature, the in the molten salt separately under identical experimental
present study has been undertaken to evaluate the corrosion conditions. Before and after the immersion test, the spec-
behavior of 9Cr1Mo steel and YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel imens were ultrasonically cleaned using water and acetone
in LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C under argon and allowed to air dry. The initial and final weights of the
atmosphere for their application in electrorefining process. specimens exposed to the molten LiClKClUCl3 salt were
recorded to assess the extent of corrosion.

2 Materials and Methods 2.3 Characterization

2.1 Specimen Preparation During the course of corrosion test, the 9Cr1Mo steel
specimens were removed from the molten salt at various
The chemical composition of 9Cr1Mo steel specimen is durations such as 100, 250, 500 and 1000 h and were
given in Table 1. As-received and YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo examined visually. The surface morphology and elemental
steel specimens of dimensions 50 9 10 9 5 mm were analysis were carried out using scanning electron micro-
used for the corrosion studies in molten LiClKClUCl3 scope coupled with energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM
salt. The 9Cr1Mo steel specimens were polished with SiC EDS, Mini SEM). The tested specimens were mounted in

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Table 1 Chemical composition of 9Cr1Mo steel specimen in wt%


Fe Cr Mo C Si Ni Mn V Nb

Balance 8.97 0.94 0.104 0.41 0.20 0.55 0.20 0.09

Table 2 Plasma spray parameters used for depositing NiCrAlY bond Fig. 1a, c, respectively. The 9Cr1Mo steel specimen
coat and YSZ top coat on 9Cr1Mo steel specimens before corrosion test appeared to be uniform with some
Process parameters (unit) NiCrAlY/YSZ coatings polishing lines and the corresponding EDS profile (Fig. 1b)
showed 9.03 wt% Cr, 1.00 wt% Mo and balance Fe. The
Plasma arc current (A) 450 SEM examination of the molten salt corrosion tested
Arc voltage (V) 60 uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel specimen revealed both porous
Primary gas Ar and corrosion product regions (Fig. 1c). The surface mor-
Secondary gas H2 phology with surface roughening indicated the dissolution
Powder feed rate (g/min) 4045 and etching of 9Cr1Mo steel. The attacked region showed
Spraying distance (mm) 100 porous structure, which might have formed due to the
Ar gas flow rate (l/min) 8090 removal or dissolution of alloying elements into the molten
Type of gun used 3 MB salt from the exposed surface. These dissolved elements
migrated to other regions of the substrate and formed the
corrosion product layer on the exposed surface of the
epoxy and used for cross-section examination and ele- substrate. Dissolution of metal at hot spot and metal
mental mapping by SEMEDS. X-ray diffraction (XRD) deposition at colder regions due to thermal gradient, as
patterns of the tested specimens were recorded using reported in literature [15, 16] upheld the observation in the
monochromatic Cu Ka radiation and the phases (corrosion present study.
products) were identified using the standard JCPDS files. The SEM images of the porous region of uncoated 9Cr
The XRD pattern of the 1000 h exposed sample was 1Mo steel specimens after molten salt exposure for 100,
obtained in glancing incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXRD) 250, 500 and 1000 h durations are shown in Fig. 2ad. It is
mode, while all the other samples were characterized by evident from these images that the extent of attack of the
normal XRD mode. 9Cr1Mo steel specimens increased with increase in the
duration of exposure to molten salt. Grain boundary attack
and grain pull out were visible in the SEM images. With
3 Results and Discussion increase in the exposure time, the attack became more
uniform and the attack was not only restricted to grain
3.1 Weight Loss Measurements boundary but also caused preferential surface dissolution.
The surface morphology of 1000 h exposed sample
The percentage weight loss of the uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel (Fig. 2d) showed a highly porous structure. The molten salt
specimens exposed to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C attack and the leaching of alloy elements were higher for
for 100, 250 and 500 h durations were 0.5, 3.1 and 7.6, 1000 h exposed sample compared to other specimens. The
respectively. Weight loss of the specimens increased with increase in porosity could be due to higher penetration of
immersion time. The percentage weight loss for 100 h dura- molten salt that had resulted in the higher dissolution or
tion was higher compared to the percentage weight loss of leaching of alloying elements.
9Cr1Mo steel specimen (0.31) exposed to LiClKCl molten The SEM images of the corrosion product region of
salt for the same duration [4]. The percentage weight loss of 9Cr1Mo steel specimens exposed to molten salt for dif-
YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens exposed to LiClKCl ferent durations are shown in Fig. 3ad. Significant quan-
UCl3 molten salt for different durations were insignificant. tity of corrosion products were observed as the duration of
exposure increased. Cracks were visible on the corrosion
3.2 Surface Characterization product region at higher magnification. No significant
difference was observed between the corrosion product
3.2.1 Uncoated 9Cr1Mo Steel Specimens regions of exposed samples for various durations. It is
observed from Figs. 2 and 3 that the surface morphology of
The SEM images of the uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel specimen 9Cr1Mo steel specimens exposed to molten salt for dif-
before and after the molten salt corrosion test are shown in ferent durations had similar features except that the

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Fig. 1 SEM image of a plain 9Cr1Mo steel substrate, b EDS elemental analysis of plain 9Cr1Mo steel substrate and c uncoated 9Cr1Mo
steel specimen after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C for 100 h

corrosion attack was more penetrating and prominent all exposed surface had irregular and deep cavities, which
over the surface with increase in the duration of exposure. were visible at severely attacked regions. Some of the
The results of the EDS elemental analysis, given in regions were surrounded by corrosion product which could
Table 3 revealed that the porous and corrosion product be due to the preferential attack of grain boundaries. It
regions of the molten salt tested uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel could be inferred from the EDS analysis that selective
specimens had different chemical composition. The diffusion of Cr was the mechanism for the corrosion of
amount of Cr found in the corrosion product region was uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel in LiClKClUCl3 molten salt.
lower than that in the porous region, which could be
attributed to either the dissolution of Cr or the formation 3.2.2 Coated 9Cr1Mo Steel Specimens
of volatile Cr compounds. Presence of high oxygen con-
tent in the corrosion product region might be due to the The surface morphology of the as-received YSZ coated
formation of oxides of Fe and/or Cr. The oxygen content 9Cr1Mo steel specimens and those exposed to LiClKCl
in the argon cover gas was maintained at less than 2 ppm. UCl3 molten salt at 600 C for different durations of 100,
Formation of oxides of Fe and Cr were possible at low 250, 500, and 1000 h are shown in Fig. 5ae. After expo-
concentrations of oxygen [17]. Hence, the abundant cor- sure to molten salt the surface became more rough and
rosion products formed on the exposed surface of 9Cr some pores were formed. The surface morphology of the
1Mo steel specimens could be of iron oxide and chro- samples changed with increase in duration of molten salt
mium oxide. exposure, as shown in Fig. 5ae. The samples exposed for
Cross section examination of the tested uncoated 9Cr 100 and 250 h exhibited irregular surface than 500 and
1Mo steel specimens at different durations showed similar 1000 h exposed samples, probably because of the removal
features. The cross section image of the sample exposed to of loosely held coating particles from the surface after long
molten salt for 100 h duration is shown in Fig. 4. The exposure.

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Fig. 2 SEM images showing porous regions of uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C for
a 100 h, b 250 h, c 500 h and d 1000 h

The standard Gibbs free energy change, DGr for the are shown in Fig. 6. In the EDS mapping, layers of coating
reactions of ZrO2 and Y2O3 with chlorine have been shown elements were visible in all the tested samples, indicating
in the reactions (1) and (2) [18]. Since the values of DGr for that even after corrosion test, the coating did not peel off
these reactions were positive at 600 C, no possible reaction from the specimen. However, in the case of 1000 h tested
was expected between the YSZ coatings and chlorine. sample, the YSZ coating thickness had reduced signifi-
cantly and became discontinuous (not found in some
ZrO2 2 Cl2 g ! ZrCl4 g O2 g; DGr kJ/mol locations). The bond coat was clearly distinguishable from
185 1 the EDS mapping of Ni and Al elements. As the bond coat
2 Y2 O3 6 Cl2 g ! 4 YCl3 g did not undergo any type of degradation and was intact on
3 O2 g; DGr kJ/mol the substrate, it was confirmed that the base metal had no
730 2 contact with molten salt, thereby preventing the corrosion
of 9Cr1Mo base metal.
The elemental analysis of the YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel
specimens tested in molten salt for 1000 h, by EDS (shown in 3.3 X-Ray Diffraction Analysis
Fig. 5f) confirmed the presence of elements from top coat
(YSZ), bond coat (NiCrAlY) and LiClKClUCl3 molten 3.3.1 Uncoated 9Cr1Mo Steel Samples
salt even after thorough cleaning of the samples for a couple
of times. Fe peaks detected on the tested YSZ coated Figure 7 shows the XRD patterns of uncoated 9Cr1Mo
specimens might be due to the deposition of iron oxide from steel specimens before immersion studies and after 100, 250,
the uncoated region of the specimen. Presence of uranium on 500 and 1000 h exposure in molten salt. The XRD results of
the tested YSZ coated specimens indicated that deposition of the 9Cr1Mo steel specimen before the molten salt exposure
salt had occurred on the surface of the coating. showed the peaks corresponding to FeCr (JCPDS no. 34-
The EDS elemental mapping of the cross sectional SEM 0396). The XRD results obtained for the exposed surfaces of
image of YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimen after uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens were identical and the
exposure to molten LiClKClUCl3 salt for 100 h duration patterns revealed the presence of FeCr (JCPDS no. 34-

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Fig. 3 SEM images showing corrosion product regions of uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at
600 C for a 100 h, b 250 h, c 500 h and d 1000 h

Table 3 Composition of porous and corrosion product regions (in


wt%) obtained from EDS elemental analysis
Region Elements Exposure time (h)
100 250 500 1000

Porous region Fe 77.40 86.00 82.48 41.13


Cr 7.00 7.34 7.03 0.31
O 12.71 6.17 9.46 49.29
Corrosion product region Fe 74.68 76.44 67.34 73.07
Cr 2.35 1.33 1.48 0.69
O 22.56 22.22 29.23 26.24

0396) and UO2 (JCPDS no. 41-1422) on the surface of the


samples. The reason for the formation of UO2 on tested Fig. 4 Cross section SEM image of uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel
samples has been explained as follows: Among the salt specimen after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C
for 100 h duration
mixture components, thermodynamically, UCl3 was the least
stable component and was susceptible to oxidation. Upon
oxidation of UCl3 in the salt mixture, UO2 was produced as dissolved in the salt mixture, (b) ingress of oxygen through
per Eq. (3) [11]. The possible source of oxygen for this the joints in the molten salt test assembly or (c) residual
reaction could be from any one of the following: (a) oxygen oxygen impurity in the argon gas in ppm range.

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Fig. 5 SEM images of a as-received and YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C for
b 100 h, c 250 h, d 500 h and e 1000 h and f EDS elemental analysis of 1000 h exposed YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens

2 UCl3 2 O2 g ! 2 UO2 3 Cl2 g; DGr kJ/mol and cubic phases. The X-ray diffraction patterns of YSZ
501600  C coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimens after exposure to LiCl
KClUCl3 molten salt for 100, 250, 500 and 1000 h are
3
shown in Fig. 8. All the XRD patterns showed the peaks
3.3.2 Coated 9Cr1Mo Steel Specimens corresponding to YSZ and UO2. The cubic and tetragonal
phases of ZrO2 were present and no phase transformation
The XRD pattern of as-sprayed YSZ coating on 9Cr1Mo of zirconia occurred after the exposure to molten LiCl
steel specimen, as shown in Fig. 8 consisted of tetragonal KClUCl3 salt.

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

Fig. 6 EDS elemental mapping of YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel specimen after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 600 C for 100 h
duration

4 Conclusions corrosion product region enriched with Cr. The mechanism


of corrosion in the uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel material was
Corrosion behavior of YSZ coated and uncoated 9Cr1Mo the selective diffusion of Cr from the exposed surface.
steel samples was investigated in molten LiClKClUCl3 Surface morphology of the molten salt tested YSZ coated
salt at 600 C for 100, 250, 500 and 1000 h. With increase samples showed more smooth surface compared to the as-
in exposure time, the percentage weight loss in uncoated coated sample. The XRD patterns of tested uncoated
9Cr1Mo steel specimen increased and YSZ coated 9Cr samples revealed the presence of base metal FeCr and
1Mo steel specimen showed insignificant weight loss. UO2, while the tested YSZ coated samples revealed the
Surface morphological examination revealed that the tested presence of zirconia and UO2. Based on the weight loss and
uncoated samples exhibited porous region with low Cr and surface characterization results, it was concluded that YSZ

123
Trans Indian Inst Met

coating had provided adequate protection to 9Cr1Mo steel


specimens against corrosion in LiClKClUCl3 molten
salt.

Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge Dr. B. Prabhakara


Reddy, Scientific Officer H and Shri. P. Venkatesh, Scientific
Officer F, Chemistry Group, IGCAR for providing the molten salt.

References

1. Raj B, Energy Procedia 7 (2011) 186.


2. Nagarajan K, Reddy B P, Ghosh S, Ravisankar G, Mohandas K S,
Kamachi Mudali U, Kutty K V G, Kasiviswanathan K V, Anand
Babu C, Kalyanasundaram P, Vasudeva Rao P R and Raj B,
Energy Procedia 7 (2011) 431.
3. Laidler J J, Battles J E, Miller W E, Ackerman J P and Carls E L,
Prog Nucl Energy 31 (1997) 131.
4. Ravi Shankar A, Thyagarajan K and Kamachi Mudali U, Cor-
rosion 69 (2013) 655.
5. Herman H, Sampath S and McCune R, Trends MRS Bull 25
(2000) 17.
6. Ravi Shankar A, Mathiya S, Thyagarajan K and Kamachi Mudali
U, Metall Mater Trans A 41A (2010) 1815.
7. Ravi Shankar A, Kamachi Mudali U, Sole R, Khatak H S and Raj
Fig. 7 X-ray diffraction patterns of uncoated 9Cr1Mo steel spec- B, J Nucl Mater 372 (2008) 226.
imens before and after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at 8. Sure J, Ravi Shankar A, Ramya S, and Kamachi Mudali U,
600 C for 100, 250, 500 and 1000 h duration Ceram Int 38 (2012) 2803.
9. Sure J, Jagadeeswara Rao Ch, Venkatesh P, Prabhakara Reddy B,
Mallika C and Kamachi Mudali U, Ceram Int 40 (2014) 6509.
10. Jagadeeswara Rao Ch, Ravi Shankar A, Mallika C and Kamachi
Mudali U, Ceram Int 41 (2015) 3128.
11. Periasamy P, Hurley M F, Marx B M, Simpson M F and Butt D P,
J Nucl Mater 405 (2010) 266.
12. Jagadeeswara Rao Ch, Ravi Shankar A, Ajikumar P K, Kam-
ruddin M, Mallika C and Kamachi Mudali U, Corrosion 71
(2015) 502.
13. Nakayoshi A, Kitawaki S, Fukushima M, Murakami T and Kurata
M, J Nucl Mater 441 (2013) 468.
14. Davies W and Gray W, Talanta 11 (1964) 1203.
15. Kane R D, in ASM Handbook, Volume 13A: Corrosion: Funda-
mentals, Testing, and Protection, (eds) Cramer S D, Covino Jr B
S, ASM International, Materials Park (2003), p 216.
16. Molten salt corrosion, in High Temperature Corrosion and
Materials Applications, (ed) Y Lai George, ASM International,
Materials Park (2007), p 409.
17. Birks N, Meier G H and Pettit F S, Introduction to the High
Temperature Oxidation of Metals, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge (2006).
18. Knacke O, Kubaschewski O, Hesselmann K, Thermochemical
Properties of Inorganic Substances, 2nd Ed, Springer, New York
(1991).

Fig. 8 X-ray diffraction patterns of YSZ coated 9Cr1Mo steel


specimens before and after exposure to LiClKClUCl3 molten salt at
600 C for 100, 250, 500 and 1000 h duration

123

S-ar putea să vă placă și