Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Brooke Habit
Abstract
This paper explores the positive and negative effects of hydraulic fracturing and their subsequent
effect on the health of the environment and U.S. citizens. A brief history and description of the
process, in addition to an explanation as to where it occurs, will offer insight into fracking. In
addition, through the analysis of case law, enacted and proposed legislation, and public opinion,
the paper will examine the need for strict, federal regulation of fracking and disclosure of the
The "more we experiment with underground drilling, the more we discover..." (Dobb,
2013). Hydraulic fracturing is a process developed to obtain natural gas from underground shale
formations. As it grows in use, controversy mounts and an increasing number of inimical effects
are connected to the fracking process. The lack of strict federal regulation and consideration of
ingredients in the chemical mixture used during hydraulic fracturing as proprietary information
are detrimental to the environment and people because it leaves U.S. citizens unknowingly
exposed to dangerous carcinogens and unable to effectively recover from the effects of fracking.
Hydraulic fracturing is a process designed to recover natural gas from shale rock. It
involves drilling into the Earth's shale rock and injecting a mixture of water, sand, and chemicals
to release gas previously thought to be unreachable (Jain, 2015). This drilling process is
conducted both vertically and horizontally to reach the permeable rock layer (BBC, 2015).
Alternative Names
Halliburton Corporation developed fracking in the 1940s; however, it did not become a
widely used technique of extracting natural gas until more recently ("Fracking," 2015). Since the
early 2000s, the use of fracking by energy recovery businesses has increased and the growing
desire for U.S. energy independence has expanded efforts to locate and use previously
unreachable natural gas. The U.S. Department of Energy projects shale gas production in the
WHAT THE FRACK? 4
United States will rise to 12.3 trillion cubic feet by 2030, and fracking could eventually account
Process
The exact process involves using a large drill pipe, encased in cement and steel, and
passing it through water aquifers. Once past water aquifers, the pipe is uncased and travels
downwards 4,000 to 8,500 feet to reach the shale rock. As the pipe reaches the shale, it changes
direction from vertical to horizontal and drilling occurs laterally 3,000 to 5,000 feet. Cement is
then pumped to the end of the drill pipe and a perforated gun is placed into the casing. A small
electrical charge is sent by wire to detonate a charge, blasting small holes through the casing and
cement into the shale. The fracturing occurs when the electrical charge is emitted through the
pipe. A chemical mixture is then pumped into the fractures, freeing natural gas. The natural gas
then collects in traps and folds in the porous, permeable rock layers (Burford, 2012).
Chemical Mixture
The chemical mixture pumped into the fractures created during the fracking process has
raised numerous concerns by several government officials, environmentalists, and citizens. From
the 2,500 fracturing additives, more than 650 are known or possible carcinogens, which means
they are a substance capable of causing cancer (Jain, 2015). In addition, the mixture is known to
contain volatile organic compounds, or VOCs. The entirety of the chemicals additives are
unknown due to a 2005 legislation that exempts industry from disclosing the names of chemicals
used in the hydraulic fracturing mixture. Energy companies have claimed the ingredients of
Loophole" and it also prevents the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from effectively
Fracking occurs largely in an area referred to as the Marcellus Shale, which is located in
western mountains and valleys. This includes areas in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia
("Fracking is Safe," 2016). In addition, Texas, New York, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Colorado, and
Wyoming have fracturing wells (Clary, 2015). Southwest Virginia and the Taylorsville Basin, an
area in Virginias coastal plain beneath the Northern Neck and Middle Peninsula, are also areas
Negative Effects
Environment
research confirms the connection between several detrimental environmental issues and fracking.
Air emissions. The chemicals in the mixture used for fracking are extremely potent. One
employee, Susan Connell, wears a H2S detector and gas mask when she pumps the fracking fluid
to avoid the smell. Once, the fracking fluid odor was so hazardous the detector sounded and
Connell was forced to immediately evacuate the area, although the limited exposure still left her
experiencing health problems of weeklong stomach pains and vomiting (Dobb, 2013). Methane
leaks also occur frequently (Jain, 2015). Methane is a more potent greenhouse gas than carbon
dioxide, and 3-8% of methane extracted from each fracking well is emitted into the atmosphere
contamination (Efstathiou, 2013). When the chemical mixture used for fracking is incorrectly
managed and chemicals breach the casing system, they can enter into the groundwater during
vertical or horizontal drilling (Clary, 2015). In addition, the release of natural gas can infiltrate
WHAT THE FRACK? 6
groundwater. A 2011 research study conducted by Duke University confirmed this, discovering
dangerous levels of methane in water supplies located within one kilometer of natural gas wells
in which hydraulic fracturing has occurred. Homeowners near fracking wells have also
discovered the water in their faucets to be flammable, a product of natural gas migration into the
water supply as a result of leaking fracking mixture ("Gasland the Movie," n.d.). Also, well
water has become brown and undrinkable. This is not the first occurrence of groundwater
contamination due to fracking. In Dimock, Pennsylvania 2009, Cabot Oil and Gas had to agree to
provide clean water to more than a dozen families after fracking fluid contaminated groundwater
("Fracking," 2015). In addition, a 2011 blowout during fracking in a well near Killdeer, North
Dakota pierced the aquifer the entirety of the town relied on (Dobb, 2013). However, not all
companies are held accountable for groundwater contamination. Often times, citizens cannot
prove groundwater contamination resulted from fracking because the exact concentration of
chemicals used for fracking is unknown due to its classification as proprietary information. In the
rural areas where hydraulic fracturing occurs, there is little industry, so it is unreasonable to
In December 2010, New York Governor David Paterson signed an executive order halting
hydraulic fracturing until new regulations are enacted to protect water sources and provide better
oversight. New York City receives nearly half of its water from the Delaware River Basin, which
was named the country's most endangered river in 2010 because of the threat of natural gas
contamination from fracking (Hoye, 2010). The concern of hydraulic fracturing's impact on the
of wastewater. This wastewater has been found to be radioactive because of naturally occurring
WHAT THE FRACK? 7
uranium, radium, radon, and thorium being dislodged during fracking (Jain, 2015). This presents
yet another risk because disposal of wastewater involves either injecting it back underground or
trucking it away to be treated. In 2011, the New York Times reported that treatment plants in
Pennsylvania, overwhelmed by fracking wastewater that could not be fully treated, discharged
water containing radioactive waste into the Monongahela and Susquehanna rivers, which
Uses large quantities of water. Fracking also uses a significant amount of water. Per
application, two to nine million gallons of water are used ("Fracking," 2015). As the number of
hydraulic fracturing wells increases, more water is used. In 2000, there were 23,000 wells; in
2010, there were 300,000. Considering the extensive growth of fracking, the amount of water
Seismicity. Ohio's state Department of Natural Resources verified in March 2012 that
fracking fluids disposed into a deep injection well were responsible for a series of earthquakes.
This area has only one fault line, meaning the likelihood of an earthquake occurring in the area,
responsibility in their occurrence (Jain, 2015; "Fracking," 2015). Ohio is not the only state
experiencing increased seismicity. Arkansas and Texas have experienced a surge of earthquakes,
and four Oklahoma high-volume wastewater wells are linked to earthquake activity as far as 35
km away from the site. Specific to Oklahoma, in 2014, the state experienced more magnitude 3.0
The U.S. Geological Survey, governed by the U.S. Department of Interior, also confirms
that fracking causes an increase in permeability of the shale, which can cause earthquakes.
Additionally, they affirm hydraulic fracturing wastewater injected into deep wells can cause
WHAT THE FRACK? 8
earthquakes that are large enough to be felt and cause damage ("USGS FAQs: Earthquakes
Induced by Fluid Injection - Does the Production of Natural Gas from Shale Cause Earthquakes?
If So, How Are the Earthquakes Related to These Operations?," 2016). The increased seismicity
resulting from fracking is caused because drilling holes into the subsurface geology disturbs
tectonic plates.
Health
The impact of fracking on the environment also affects people's health. Birth defects,
cancer, and disorders involving the nervous system are linked to fracking ("Gasland the Movie,"
n.d.). Concerns are so significant that former Democratic Presidential Candidate, Bernie
Sanders, called for an outright ban of hydraulic fracturing in his campaign platform ("Hillary,
Bernie, Hydraulic Fracturing and the Future of US Oil and Gas Production," 2015). In addition,
US Energy Secretary Steven Chu asked the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board Natural Gas
performance of natural gas hydraulic fracturing," due to the innumerable concerns arising
Positive Effects
Currently, 84% of U.S. energy consumption is supported by oil, gas, and coal and
fracking contributes significantly to this (Jain, 2015). The Marcellus Shale in Pennsylvania,
Ohio, and West Virginia is believed to contain enough gas to supply the United States for the
next six years (Efstathiou, 2013). The amount of natural gas gained from hydraulic fracturing
increases United States energy independence. This leads to reduced reliance on unstable
countries for oil and gas, subsequently improving national security (Jain, 2015).
WHAT THE FRACK? 9
Economy
Fracking has also been reported to reduce the trade deficit because it has increased the
U.S.'s role as an exporter of energy sources (Jain, 2015). However, further study by the Institute
for Sustainable Development and International Relations has concluded fracking only has a
short-term effect of a .4% increase in GDP. Due to natural gas being a nonrenewable resource, it
is highly unlikely fracking will make a substantial contribution to GDP growth in the future
(Jain, 2015).
Job Creation
In the areas where hydraulic fracking occurs, numerous jobs are created. People are hired
to work the natural gas wells and perform the extraction, transport, and cleaning of the area. In
one central area of fracking, unemployment is less than one percent. However, these jobs are
temporary and often times are a large boom market, accompanied by a subsequent crash (Dobb,
2013). In addition, landowners often enter into gas leases with energy companies, giving them
the right to extract natural gas from under the property. These contracts are frequently under
explained. Homeowners experience adverse effects from the fracking on their property, and
many have found the water supply to their homes contaminated. One family in Dimock,
Pennsylvania, discovered the water from their faucet is highly flammable, and investigation by
the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) revealed the cause to be from
gas drilling. They also found 18 drinking-water wells in the area to be affected by the operations
of Cabot Oil & Gas, a fracking company ("Gasland the Movie," n.d.).
One class action lawsuit questions the contracts between homeowners and energy
companies. In Tioga County, New York, numerous landowners leased drilling rights to Energy
Companies. A habendum clause was within the lease, establishing a five-year "primary term" and
WHAT THE FRACK? 10
secondary term. In addition, a force majeure clause was included that argues a secondary term
may begin if there are ever any delays or interruptions of natural gas extraction. In 2008, New
York Governor David Paterson "ordered formal public environmental review to address the
impact of combined use of high-volume hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling," pausing the
energy companies' ability to drill. Inflection Energy agued this warranted enacting the force
majeure clause secondary term. The landowners did not want drilling to continue and countered
that the lease had simply expired and the force majeure clause was not applicable. This case
began in the District Court, ruling in favor of the landowners. Inflection Energy appealed to the
New York Court of Appeals had their motion denied, and appealed again to the United States
According to the United States Court of Appeals, this case was of significance because it:
turns on significant and novel issues of New York law concerning the
interpretation of oil and gas leases, a legal field that is both relatively
Ultimately, the United States Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment of the District Court
Some sources have concluded fracking to have dramatically lowered greenhouse gas
emissions in the United States because natural gas is the cleanest burning fossil fuels ("Fracking
is Safe," 2015; Burford, 2012). Although, a 2011 study led by Robert Howard of Cornell
University concluded the carbon footprint of shale gas will be greater than those of oil, coal, and
The chemical mixture used during the fracking process, often referred to as the fracking
fluid, is considered proprietary information. Corporations are not required to release any
ingredients contained in the mixture. This has sparked controversy due to the effects associated
In this case, the appellant has sued the Pennsylvania Attorney General and the Secretary
13 of 2012 is unconstitutional. The District Court dismissed his case and the US Court of
occurs and various wastewater ponds of fracking fluids are easy to find. He asserts that direct or
indirect contact with fracking fluid is detrimental to health and proper treatment for exposure
requires knowing the environmental toxins contained in the fracking fluid. This information is
currently considered proprietary information. So, under Article 13, in medical emergencies,
medical professionals must verbally agree to keep the information confidential and use the
information only for the specific medical emergency. In non-emergency situations, fracking
signed and a written statement of need is submitted. Rodriguez asserts that the public must be
made aware of the toxins contained in fracking fluid to protect themselves, and that the "Medical
Gag Rules" threaten his ability to properly diagnose and treat his patients. Rodriguez's case was
dismissed because he did not allege any specific situation where he needed this information to
WHAT THE FRACK? 12
treat his patients (Dr. Alfonso Rodriguez M.D. v. Secretary Of Pennsylvania Department Of
case in Colorado of an ER nurse treating a worker who was splashed in the face by hydraulic
fracturing fluid and a week later was suffering from multiple organ failure and in critical
condition after being exposed to same fracturing fluid that was on the worker she treated. The
nurse's doctors could not help her because they did not know what chemicals were in the fluid
Registry
A web-based registry, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, was initiated in 2014 for
the voluntary reporting of chemicals used in fracking mixtures. It was created to encourage
companies to release the controversial ingredients used in fracking that are considered
proprietary information and have previously gone unshared with the public. The Ground Water
Protection Council and the IOGCC partnered to create this registry ("Hydraulic Fracturing in
Virginia," 2015).
Hydraulic Fracturing is currently governed solely by state law. States submit regulatory
plans to the federal government specific to the individual state and are processed and approved.
The Interstate Oil and Gas Compact Commission (IOGCC) represent "the state gas and oil
agencies" and argue that laws are already in place to protect citizens from the harmful effects of
fracking (Burford, 2012). Specifically, the IOGCC maintains that any regulation of hydraulic
fracturing under the Underground Injection Control portion of the Safe Drinking Water Act
State Regulators
The regulators who inspect fracking wells supervise management and ensure state plans
are followed and maintained. However, due to the exponential growth of fracking, a large
number of wells are left unchecked for years, and prioritization of inspection can prevent various
wells from being effectively regulated (Burford, 2012). In Texas, there are 273,660 fracking
wells and only 106 regulators to supervise their management and safety. Then, in West Virginia,
there are 52,222 active wells and only 17 inspectors, meaning regulators would have to inspect 9
wells per day without taking off weekends or vacations to inspect each one. The limited number
of regulators provided by the state government creates the possibility of increased risk from
Federal Law
argue the federal government is best to regulate because it would provide uniformity to the
industry and "eliminate any lobbying that forces states to compromise public health" (Burford,
2012). To avoid the process of having an entirely new piece of legislation passed, many
environmentalists argue fracking should be governed under pre-existing federal law. This would
include the Safe Drinking Water Act, which sets "requirements for proper well siting,
("Natural Gas Extraction: Hydraulic Fracturing," 2016). Currently, the Energy Policy Act of
2005, referred to as the Halliburton Loophole, excludes fracking from the SDWA. In addition,
the Clean Water Act sets national standards for wastewater discharge; fracking is excluded from
this regulation too. To add on, the Clean Air Act monitors and regulates greenhouse gas
WHAT THE FRACK? 14
emissions, but it does not include fracking ("Natural Gas Extraction: Hydraulic Fracturing,"
2016).
FRAC Act. This bill was introduced to the House of Representatives on March 17, 2015.
It was proposed to amend the Energy Policy Act of 2005 to include hydraulic fracturing under
the Safe Water Drinking Act ("FRAC Act," 2015). The bill is sponsored by democratic Senator,
Robert Casey of Pennsylvania, an area where the fracking industry is present. Neither the House
Fracturing Regulations are Effective in State Hands Act. As there is a large group of
people lobbying for federal, more stringent regulations on fracking, there are those who believe it
should remain governed by state law. The Fracturing Regulations are Effective in State Hands
Act was introduced March 18, 2015 "to clarify that a State has the sole authority to regulate
hydraulic fracturing on Federal land within the boundaries of the State" ("Fracturing Regulations
Are Effective in State Hands Act," 2015). Neither the House nor the Senate has voted on this bill.
A hydraulic fracturing conference was scheduled for March 7-10, 2016, at Hilton
Technology Conferences sponsored by ASME. The conference was created "to offer innovative
solutions for the construction, delivery and production of unconventional wells" for fracking. It
would also offer insight and discussion on the developments in regulation and technology for
hydraulic fracturing. Unfortunately, the conference was canceled due to market conditions
Public Opinion
WHAT THE FRACK? 15
Americans who are aware and informed of hydraulic fracturing favor stricter regulation.
A national poll by Bloomberg News in 2012 found that more than three times as many people
said more regulations are needed as opposed to fewer for fracking ("Americans Favor Stricter
Regulations for Fracking," 2015). Mark Boling, executive Vice President for Houston-based
We have been so focused as an industry on figuring out how to crack the code and
get these huge volumes of gas trapped in shale formations. We haven't focused on
In addition, reputable surveyor Gallup reported in 2015 that opposition to fracking in the U.S.
was 40%. In 2016, opposition raised 15% to 51% opposition to fracking in the U.S (Gallup,
2016). Gallup has concluded with only a 4% margin of error that "opposition to hydraulic
fracturing...has increased significantly in the past year...even though the procedure has helped
Conclusion
Hydraulic Fracturing jeopardizes the safety of the environment and of United States
citizens because it is not well regulated, and the dangerous chemicals used in the process are
considered proprietary information and go undisclosed to the public. People need to be better
informed of the risks associated with fracking and the federal government needs to govern it,
rather than the state. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 is hindering the ability of the federal
government to effectively do this ("Natural Gas Extraction: Hydraulic Fracturing," 2016). The
negative effects of fracking outweigh its potentially positive effects and present a clear danger to
the public. As additional risks associated with fracking are discovered, it is crucial the public is
WHAT THE FRACK? 16
cognizant of the exact chemicals used in the fracking process so medical professionals have
References
WHAT THE FRACK? 17
Beardslee v. Inflection Energy LLC (United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit August 19,
2015).
Burford, E. (2012). The need for federal regulation of hydraulic fracturing. Retrieved December
6, 2016, from
http://search.proquest.com/docview/1266035798/32CA100431B5429EPQ/20?
accountid=3785
Clary, R. (2015). The human impact on earthquakes: natural fracturing versus fracking.
accountid=3785
Dobb, E. (2013, March). Bakken shale oil: The new oil landscape. Retrieved November 14,
Efstathiou, J., Jr. (2013). Americans favor stricter regulations for fracking. Retrieved November
http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/ovic/ViewpointsDetailsPage/ViewpointsDetailsWindow?
disableHighlighting=false&displayGroupName=Viewpoints&currPage=&scanId=&quer
y=&source=&prodId=OVIC&search_within_results=&p=OVIC
%3AGIC&mode=view&catId=&u=vbcps&limiter=&display-
query=&displayGroups=&contentModules=&action=e&sortBy=&documentId=GALE
WHAT THE FRACK? 18
%7CEJ3010861209&windowstate=normal&activityType=&failOverType=&commentary
= doi:GALE|EJ3010861209
Egan, M. (2016, March 24). Oil Milestone: fracking now fuels half of U.S. oil output. Retrieved
boom/
Environmental law and hydraulic fracturing [E-mail interview]. (2016, December 1).
EPA Hydraulic Fracturing Study Improvement Act. (2013, July 29). Retrieved October 16, 2016,
from https://www.countable.us/bills/hr2850-113-epa-hydraulic-fracturing-study-
improvement-act
Fox, J. (Writer). (2015, September 15). Gasland [Television broadcast]. In Gasland. HBO.
FRAC Act. (2015, March 17). Retrieved October 16, 2016, from
https://www.countable.us/bills/s785-114
http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/ovic/ReferenceDetailsPage/ReferenceDetailsWindow?
disableHighlighting=true&displayGroupName=Reference&currPage=&scanId=&query=
&source=&search_within_results=&p=OVIC%3AGIC&mode=view&catId=GALE
%7CEUKWKX900918839&u=vbcps&limiter=&display-
query=&displayGroups=&contentModules=&action=e&sortBy=&documentId=GALE
%7CPC3010999096&windowstate=normal&activityType=&failOverType=&commentar
y= doi:GALE|PC3010999096
http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/ovic/ViewpointsDetailsPage/ViewpointsDetailsWindow?
disableHighlighting=false&displayGroupName=Viewpoints&currPage=&scanId=&quer
WHAT THE FRACK? 19
y=&source=&prodId=OVIC&search_within_results=&p=OVIC
%3AGIC&mode=view&catId=&u=vbcps&limiter=&display-
query=&displayGroups=&contentModules=&action=e&sortBy=&documentId=GALE
%7CEJ3010930208&windowstate=normal&activityType=&failOverType=&commentary
= doi:GALE|EJ3010930208
Fracturing Regulations are Effective in State Hands Act. (2015, March 18). Retrieved October
effective-in-state-hands-act
Fracturing Responsibility and Awareness of Chemicals Act of 2015. (2015, March 18). Retrieved
responsibility-and-awareness-of-chemicals-act-of-2015
Gallup. (2016, March 30). Opposition to fracking mounts in the U.S. Retrieved December 12,
http://www.gaslandthemovie.com/whats-fracking
http://fracfocus.org/water-protection/groundwater-aquifers
Hillary, Bernie, hydraulic fracturing and the future of US oil and gas production. (2015, March
http://www.forbes.com/sites/thebakersinstitute/2016/03/25/hillary-bernie-hydraulic-
fracturing-and-the-future-of-us-oil-and-gas-production/#66def63b41d9
How hydraulic fracturing works. (2016). Retrieved November 18, 2016, from
http://www.energyfromshale.org/articles/how-hydraulic-fracturing-works
WHAT THE FRACK? 20
Hoye, S. (2010, December 13). New York governor pauses 'fracking.' Retrieved November 30,
https://www.asme.org/events/hydraulic-fracturing-conference/our-sponsors-exhibitors
https://www.dmme.virginia.gov/dgo/HydraulicFracturing.shtml
http://energy.gov/fe/hydraulic-fracturing-technology
Introduction to hydraulic fracturing. (2015, February 25). Retrieved November 18, 2016, from
https://www2.usgs.gov/hydraulic_fracturing/
Natural gas extraction: hydraulic fracturing. (2016, August 16). Retrieved December 8, 2016,
from https://www.epa.gov/hydraulicfracturing
Offshore Fracking Transparency and Review Act of 2015. (2015, April 21). Retrieved October
transparency-and-review-act-of-2015
Safe Hydration is an American Right in Energy Development Act of 2015 (H.R. 1515). (2015,
https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/hr1515
Schumacher, J., & Morrissey, J. (2013). The legal landscape of "fracking": The oil And gas
industry's game-changing technique is its biggest hurdle. Retrieved November 18, 2016.
USGS FAQs: Earthquakes induced by fluid injection - Does the production of natural gas from
shales cause earthquakes? If so, how are the earthquakes related to these operations?
WHAT THE FRACK? 21
https://www2.usgs.gov/faq/categories/9833/3428
Virginia regulatory Town Hall view action. (2013, February 12). Retrieved November 18, 2016,
from http://townhall.virginia.gov/L/viewaction.cfm?actionid=4117
What is fracking and why is it controversial? (2015, December 16). Retrieved October 16, 2016,
from http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-14432401