Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Background. We present 2 case reports in the United States and investigations of diphtheria-like illness caused
by toxigenic Corynebacterium ulcerans. A fatal case occurred in a 75-year-old male Washington resident who was
treated with clindamycin but did not receive equine diphtheria antitoxin. A second, nonfatal case occurred in a
66-year-old female Tennessee resident who received erythromycin and diphtheria antitoxin.
Methods. Both case patients and close human and animal contacts were investigated by their respective state
health departments.
Results. C. ulcerans isolated from the patient who died was resistant to erythromycin and clindamycin. For
both isolates, conventional polymerase chain reaction results were positive for A and B subunits of diphtheria
toxin gene tox, and modified Elek tests confirmed toxin production. The source of infection remained undetermined
for both cases. Neither patient was up-to-date with diphtheria toxoid vaccination.
Conclusion. These case reports highlight the importance of early treatment with diphtheria antitoxin, the
selection of effective antimicrobial agents, and prevention through up-to-date vaccination.
Toxigenic Corynebacterium ulcerans was first isolated and goats. Handling of infected dairy animals and con-
from the throat of a patient with respiratory diphtheria sumption of contaminated milk have been associated
like illness in 1926 [1]. Toxigenic strains of C. ulcerans with respiratory diphtherialike disease caused by C.
produce a diphtheria toxin that is similar to that pro- ulcerans [19]. C. ulcerans is also reported to cause cu-
duced by toxigenic strains of Corynebacterium diphth- taneous lesions in humans [20, 21].
eriae [2, 3]. Diphtheria toxin contributes to the for- The epidemiology of human infections caused by C.
mation of a pseudomembrane that characterizes ulcerans is not well known. As shown in table 2, re-
respiratory diphtheria and may cause cardiac and neu- spiratory diphtherialike illnesses caused by toxigenic
rologic sequelae. C. ulcerans also produces a dermo- strains of C. ulcerans are increasingly reported from
necrotic toxin that is similar to that produced by Cor- developed countries [35, 2241]. C. ulcerans ac-
eynbacterium pseudotuberculosis [2]. counted for 21 (58%) of 36 human toxin-producing
C. ulcerans is a commensal in animals and has been isolates of Corynebacterium species in the United King-
isolated from a wide host of domestic and wild animals dom from 1997 through 2002 [42], 3 (33%) of 9 isolates
in Canada from 1999 through 2003 [43], and 1 (33%)
(table 1) [418]. These animals may serve as reservoirs
of 3 isolates in Italy from 1990 through 2001 [44].
for human infection. C. ulcerans causes mastitis in cattle
In the United States, 5 confirmed or probable cases
of respiratory diphtheria caused by C. diphtheriae (in-
Received 19 June 2007; accepted 24 September 2007; electronically published
cluding 1 imported fatal case) were reported during the
20 December 2007. period 19992005. During the same period, the Centers
Reprints or correspondence: Dr. Tejpratap Tiwari, Centers for Disease Control
for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) received
and Prevention, NCIRD/DBD/MVPD Branch, Mailstop C-25, 1600 Clifton Rd. NE,
Atlanta, GA 30333 (tit2@cdc.gov). reports of 2 cases (1 fatal) of diphtheria-like illness
Clinical Infectious Diseases 2008; 46:395401 caused by C. ulcerans; prior to 1999, the last reported
2007 by the Infectious Diseases Society of America. All rights reserved.
1058-4838/2008/4603-0007$15.00
case of diphtheria-like illness caused by C. ulcerans in
DOI: 10.1086/525262 the United States occurred in 1996 [31]. We report the
epidemiologic investigations of these 2 cases of respiratory exudate on the posterior pharynx. His initial WBC count was
diphtherialike illnesses caused by C. ulcerans in Washington 1500 cells/mm3, with 66% polymorphonuclear cells, 5% band
and Tennessee. cells, and 23% lymphocytes. During the first 3 days of hospi-
talization, the patient received intravenous clindamycin. On the
METHODS fourth day after hospital admission, the drug was replaced with
The Washington State Department of Health and the Tennessee metronidazole, ciprofloxacin, and vancomycin, after the local
Department of Health conducted epidemiologic investigations laboratory reported that culture of throat specimens grew 4+
of patients A and B. The investigations included reviewing both diphtheroids that did not show typical C. diphtheriae mor-
patients medical records, identifying close household contacts, phology by methylene blue staining and after diphtheria was
obtaining nasopharyngeal swab specimens from contacts, of- excluded as a likely diagnosis. Although the patient had signs
fering postexposure prophylaxis with penicillin or erythro- of a diphtheria-like illness, diphtheria antitoxin was not re-
mycin, and administering an age-appropriate diphtheria toxoid covered. The patient developed dyspnea and underwent intu-
vaccine to those who were not current with vaccination. Per- bation after an episode of aspiration. His condition rapidly
sonnel from the Minnesota Department of Health interviewed deteriorated, with development of pulmonary edema and evi-
family members and investigated cattle at the Minnesota dairy dence of cardiogenic shock. Despite nasotracheal intubation
farm visited by patient A. Oral and rectal swab specimens were and mechanical ventilation, the patient died on the following
obtained from animal contacts of both patients. day.
The patient had a significant history of Felty syndrome and
RESULTS had been receiving daily 10-mg doses of oral methylpredni-
Patient A (Washington). In 1999, a 75-year-old white non- solone for the preceding 11 years. He had no travel history
Hispanic man presented to an emergency department with a outside of the United States, but he had spent 23 days visiting
3-day history of sore throat with difficulty in swallowing and friends on a farm in Minnesota 10 days prior to the onset of
fever. The result of a rapid streptococcal test of a throat swab his illness. The patient had no history of interacting with anyone
specimen was negative. The patient was prescribed erythro- who had recently traveled abroad or any person with skin ul-
mycin and sent home; the patient reported allergies to ceph- cers. He had reportedly received a booster tetanus and diph-
alosporins and penicillin. He returned to his primary care phy- theria vaccination 112 years prior to this illness.
sician the next day because of persisting sore throat and Postmortem examination demonstrated a thick, gray
worsening difficulty swallowing and breathing, and he was hos- membrane that extended from the throat into the bronchial
pitalized. On examination, the patients oral temperature was tree and into the esophagus. The membrane had sloughed in
38.3C, and he had copious nasopharyngeal secretions. Direct some areas, and there was narrowing of the airways due to
laryngoscopic examination revealed ulceration, with yellowish edema. No significant inflammatory changes were noted in the
Patient characteristic
Country of Source of Dairy
Patient Year residence Sex Age Hospitalized Outcome infection exposure Reference(s)
1 2007 United Kingdom M 50 years No Recovered Unknown No [22]
2 2006 France F 72 years Yes Recovered Dog No [4]
3 2006 United Kingdom F Adult Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [23]
4 2005 France F 47 years Yes Recovered Dog No [5]
5 2004 Germany F 53 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [3]
6 2004 United Kingdom F 58 years No Recovered Unknown No [24]
7 2003 Japan F 52 years Yes Recovered Probably a cat No [25]
that died
8 2003 Italy F 75 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [26]
9 2002 Switzerland F 71 years Yes Recovered Unknown No [27]
10 2002 The Netherlands F 59 years Yes Recovered Unknown No [28]
11 2002 Germany M 77 years Yes Died Unknown No [8, 29]
12 2000 United Kingdom F Adult Yes Died Unknown No [30]
13 2000 United Kingdom F Adult No Recovered Unknown No [30]
14 2000 United Kingdom F Girl No Recovered Unknown No [30]
15 1997 United States F 54 years Yes Recovered Unknown No [31]
16 1995 Denmark M 53 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [32]
17 1994 Germany F 42 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [33]
18 1994 United Kingdom F 9 years No Recovered Unknown No [34]
19 1992 United Kingdom F 44 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [35]
20 1990 Switzerland F 63 years Yes Recovered Unknown Unknown [36]
21 1990 United Kingdom F 73 years No Died Unknown Unknown [37]
22 1987 Denmark M 9 years No Recovered Unknown No [38]
23 1985 United Kingdom M 78 years Yes Died Unknown Unknown [39]
24 1984 United Kingdom F 25 years No Recovered Cows Yes [19]
25 1984 United Kingdom F Child No Recovered Cows Yes [13]
26 1984 United Kingdom M 12 years No (carrier) Cow Yes [13]
27 1979 United Kingdom M 59 years Yes Recovered Unknown No [40]
28 1970 United Kingdom M 60 years Yes Recovered Unknown No [41]
myocardium or in peripheral nerves. Postmortem specimens and trachea but were negative in lung tissue specimens. Real-
from the larynx, trachea, and lungs were obtained for culture time PCR [47] performed on this isolate revealed atypical am-
and conventional PCR testing [45]. plification of subunit A and no amplification of subunit B of
Culture of throat specimens obtained during the laryngo- the tox gene.
scopic examination revealed heavy growth of diphtheroids (4+) Patient B (Tennessee). In 2005, a 66-year-old white, non-
on day 3 of hospitalization. The isolates were forwarded to the Hispanic woman complained of fatigue, sore throat, and dif-
Washington State Department of Health Public Health Labo- ficulty in swallowing. Her symptoms worsened, and on the
ratory (Shoreline, WA), where the agent was identified as C. following afternoon, she presented to the emergency depart-
ulcerans 4 days after the patient died. The agent was resistant ment of a local hospital. She was afebrile (oral temperature,
to clindamycin and erythromycin but susceptible to penicillin, 37.1C) and had sinus tachycardia, with a heart rate of 105
sulfamethoxazole, ciprofloxacin, vancomycin, and cephalospo- beats per min. A throat examination revealed an erythematous
rins. The CDC confirmed these results and demonstrated the palate and edematous pharynx and uvula, with a covering ex-
presence of toxigenic C. ulcerans by the modified Elek test [46] udate that extended into the nasopharynx. CT of the neck
and by positive conventional PCR [45] for subunit A and sub- confirmed marked edema of the uvula and soft palate and
unit B of the diphtheria toxin gene (tox). In addition, the demonstrated near obliteration of the nasopharynx but did not
conventional PCR results were positive for the tox gene in suggest epiglotitis or a retropharyngeal abscess. The result of a
postmortem formalin-fixed tissue specimens from the larynx rapid streptococcal test was negative.
The patient was hospitalized and initially received methyl- erythromycin, clindamycin, ceftriaxone, and ciprofloxacin. Re-
prednisolone, ceftriaxone, and clindamycin and, later, eryth- sults of conventional PCR were positive for both subunit A
romycin and ampicillin/sulbactam. At hospital admission, her and subunit B of the tox gene. However, real-time PCR revealed
WBC count was 12,600 cells/mm3, with 86% granulocytes and atypical amplification of subunit A and no amplification of
7% lymphocytes. During the night, the patient developed re- subunit B. Toxin production in the isolate was demonstrated
spiratory difficulty, with oxygen desaturation to 68%. There by a positive modified Elek test result. A commercial laboratory
was no clinical evidence of neurological abnormality or cardiac reported the serum antibody level to diphtheria toxin to be
abnormality by electrocardiogram. By the following morning, 0.036 IU/mL (protective level, 0.1 IU/mL) in this patient.
the palatine erythema and edema had worsened, her voice be- The patient had not received vaccination against diphtheria
came more muffled, and her breathing became noisy. The pa- during the previous 30 years. She lived in a farmhouse with
tient underwent emergency intubation and taken to the op- her husband and had not traveled during the 2-week period
erating room, where tracheostomy was performed. During before onset of illness. She seldom had direct contact with the
tracheostomy, an extensive, thick, yellowish, fibrinous, slough- animals, although she owned 4 horses and 2 dogs; she did not
ing membrane was noted to cover the lower half of the uvula, own dairy animals. Her close and frequent contacts included
extensively coating the posterior aspect of the soft palate and her children and their families. One daughter had frequent close
the entire nasopharynx and extending into the trachea. The contacts with immigrants from Central America. Members of
membrane measured about 5 3 cm. It was gradually removed her church had recently returned from a 1-week cruise to the
by peeling and suctioning, leaving behind an intact mucosa Caribbean that included island stops.
with mild, punctate bleeding. Direct laryngoscopic examination Contact investigation. As shown in table 3, no specimen
demonstrated a normal hypopharynx, larynx, and epiglottis. from human and animal contacts of either case patient grew
There was marked swelling of the soft palate and pharynx. The C. ulcerans.
attending physician suspected diphtheria and treated the patient
with 60,000 U of diphtheria antitoxin (DAT) obtained on the DISCUSSION
same day from the CDC. Throat swab specimens were obtained
for C. diphtheriae testing. The patient had an uneventful Several published case reports have linked human C. ulcerans
recovery. infections to consuming unpasteurized milk from infected cows
At the Tennessee State Health Department laboratory (Nash- or having close contact with infected dairy animals [13, 18,
ville, TN), cultures of throat specimens grew black colonies on 19]. However, in the majority of reports, patients neither con-
tellurite media that were suggestive of Corynebacterium species. sumed raw milk nor had contact with dairy animals (table 2).
The isolate and membrane specimen were identified as C. ul- In 2 recent reports, human infection followed contact with dogs
cerans at the CDC. The organisms were susceptible to penicillin, with chronic labial ulceration, rhinorrhea, and sneezing [4, 5];