Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/3275467
CITATIONS READS
4 1,748
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Hamid Shwehdi on 01 February 2014.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 3, JULY 2006 1571
AbstractThe main objective of this research is to develop recording systems for outages over some regions of its power
reliable maps of isokeraunic level (thunderdays/year, TD) for the system since 1989. In Saudi Arabia, no reliable thunderday
country on annual and seasonal bases. New annual thunder day maps have been developed previously, and utilities (SEC) had
maps for Saudi Arabia are presented. The results in this paper are
based on data and records of thunderstorm incidences in Saudi no adequate TD data for designing lightning protection, partic-
Arabia recorded by the Presidency of Metrology and Environ- ularly for transmission and distribution lines. This resulted in
ment. These are compared with data from power system fault serious deficiencies in lightning data for the southwest region
records and with NASA satellite data. These new maps indicate with the highest incidence of thunderstorms. The worldwide
the location, frequency, and intensity of thunderstorms. Such isokeraunic map of 1965 [5] indicates only 5 to 10 thunderstorm
information is useful for engineers concerned with the design and
operation of transmission and distribution lines in the country, days per year in southwestern Saudi Arabia, and this is now
and for the more general design of lightning protection systems. known to be a serious underestimate. So, old Isokeraunic maps
Thunderstorms are most frequent in the southwest mountains in of TD, although providing a general indication of lightning
the country, reaching a maximum TD of 97; the average TD for activity, are not reliable enough for modern lightning protec-
the whole country is 26. tion design needs. It is hoped that lightning damage to power
Index TermsLightning, lightning faults, satellite data, Saudi lines, structures, sensitive installations, livestock, etc., can be
Arabia, thunderday map, thunderdays. considerably reduced when the thunderstorm data obtained
from long-term PME observations are used to develop new
I. OVERVIEW and reliable TD maps for the country presented as annual
and seasonal averages. Capturing the spatial and temporal
it is mountainous with elevations reachingmore than 2000 m the summer. The relative humidity ranges from 35% in summer
a.m.s.l. to 65% in winter.
Thunderday data only provide an indication of regional light- Geographically, Saudi Arabia is divided into four regions.
ning activity based on average quantities derived from histor- Central Region: (Riyadh, Hial, and Qaseem Area) During
ically available ground-level observation [1], [5]. If available, the summer months (June, July, and August), the temperature
a superior measure of lightning activity may be obtained from varies from 25 to 45 C and during the winter, from 10 to 18 C.
lightning ground flash density (GFD) maps, which are created Precipitation varies widely, but generally, the region receives
from information obtained via lightning detection networks, or only 50 mm100 mm rainfall yearly and occurs mostly from
by historical lightning incidence records that include current, October to April.
time, frequency, date, intensity, etc, from online lightning de- Western Region: (western part along the Red Sea, Jeddah,
tection stations [5]. Unfortunately, such GFD data are not avail- Makkah, and Tabuk) During the summer months (June, July, and
able in many countries, including Saudi Arabia, so there is no August ), the temperature varies from 30 to 50 C and during
recourse but to make the best use of the TD data. the winter from 10 to 20 C. Hilly areas of the southwest are
cooler in winter and even in the summer, they remain moderate.
B. Climate and Geography of Saudi Arabia Precipitation is common in this area and average rainfall varies
In both hemispheres, the cells dip eastward, producing from 100 to 500 mm.
stronger winds on the eastern than western arcs. The oceanic Southern Region: (bordering with Yemen) During the
anticyclones are more stable than the continental ones, and summer months (June, July, and August), the temperature
bring more constant and often strong winds to western tropical varies from 20 to 30 C and during the winter from 10 to
desert costs. On land, the trade winds are strongest in the winter 20 C. In hilly areas, the winter nights are cooler. Snowfall is
when high-pressure cells develop over the cool continents, and seldom, but hailstorms and winter frost are common. In this
it is then that they reach closest to the equator. In summer, area, precipitation is also common and average rainfall varies
when the terrestrial high-pressure systems are replaced by low from 100 to 400 mm.
pressure, terrestrial trade winds moderate significantly. In and Eastern Region: (Dhahran, Al-Hassa, Hafr Al-Baten, and
around the Sahara region, the two wind systems are driven part of Aruba-Al-Khali) Temperature varies widely during
by those terrestrial anticyclones [2]. The high pressure of the the winter, with average night temperatures ranging from 5 to
subtropical zone in addition to the local topography affects the 20 C. The summer months are hot and humid; humidity often
climate of the southwest region that receives the highest annual reaches 90%. Precipitation varies from 50 to 100 mm per year,
TD. Both the regional and local circulation have a dominant mostly from November to February.
influence on the climate of this region. According to the world
climate classification as established [6], the southwest region III. LIGHTNING SOURCES IN SAUDI ARABIA
can be divided into three main climate types: 1) the hot desert A. Introduction
climate prevails in the Red Sea Coast, 2) the low latitude semi-
arid climate prevails in the Plateau, and 3) the warm temperate The estimation of the lightning performance of transmission
rainy climate with dry winters prevails in the Scarp Mountains and distribution lines may contain significant uncertainties, such
[6]. as in estimating ground flash density and the number of direct
On the Red Sea Coast, there are two basic types of climate: strikes to line. So rough estimates or generally accepted prac-
cool to warm and stable air originating from the Mediterranean tices are often just as effective as detailed calculations.
Sea during the winter period, and warm and moist air due to The best measure of lightning intensity is GFD and this is
monsoons coming in from the Indian Ocean during the summer. measured with a lightning detection network or with flash coun-
From the temperature records in the Red Sea Coast stations, the ters. Unfortunately, many parts of the world do not have such
mean monthly maximum temperature is 38 C and the mean equipment, or sufficient years of data are not available. This is
monthly minimum temperature is 20 C. The highest recorded so in Saudi Arabia, and so there is no recourse but to use thun-
temperature in July is 49 C and the lowest in January is 12 C. derday data to estimate GFD.
The relative humidity varies from 55% in summer to 70% in
winter. B. Thunderstorm Distribution in Saudi Arabia
The climate of the plateau is generally characterized as mild The location of Saudi Arabia is in the orbital overheated re-
with some rain in the winter and spring, and hot and dry in the gion that has low clouds which cause thunderstorms. The clouds
summer and fall. The mean monthly maximum temperature is accumulate over the land usually in the winter and spring sea-
30 C and the mean monthly minimum temperature is 15 C. sons and rarely in the summer season, except in the southern re-
The highest temperature recorded in July is 38 C and the lowest gion where southwestern winds carry the clouds. From the PME
in January is 8 C. The relative humidity ranges from below data, the average annual thunderdays do not exceed 30 in most
20% in summer to 45% in the winter. parts of Saudi Arabia except in the southwestern region. This
The Scarp Mountains, which are characterized by high alti- area experiences up to 97 thunderdays on some mountains, but
tude, tend to have a lower annual range of temperature than the there are only about nine on the coast of the Red Sea in a year.
surrounding low areas. The mean minimum temperature is as In winter, the average number of thunderstorms on the Arabian
low as 0 C in scattered locations, especially in high peaks in Gulf shores is approximately five, but it is only about two on the
the winter. The mean monthly maximum temperature is 25 C in shores of the Red Sea.
SHWEHDI: RELIABLE MAPS OF LIGHTNING THUNDERSTORMS FOR SAUDI ARABIA 1573
TABLE I
COMPARISON OF THE PME TD DATA WITH TD IDENTIFIED FROM
SEC OUTAGE DATA (SEE TEXT) (19942004)
TABLE III
TOTAL ANNUAL AND SEASONAL AVERAGE THUNDERDAYS (TD) USING
ALL OF THE AVAILABLE YEARS OF PME DATA
Fig. 3. AlHasa average seasonal TD/yr for 19 years. (Color version available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.)
Fig. 5. Spring season annual average TD/yr map. (Color version available
Fig. 4. Annual average TD/yr map of Saudi Arabia. (Color version available online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.)
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.)
[7] D. J. Boccippio, K. L. Cummins, H. J. Christian, and S. J. Goodman, M. H. Shwehdi (S74M85SM90) received the
Combined satellite- and surface-based estimation of the Intra-cloud- B.Sc. degree from the University of Tripoli, Tripoli,
Cloud to ground lightning ratio over the continental United States, Mon. Libya, in 1972, the M.Sc. degree in electrical engi-
Weather Rev., vol. 129, pp. 108122, 2001. neering from the University of Southern California,
[8] F. De La Rosa, W. Chisholm, A. Galvn, F. Heidler, and V. Rakov, Los Angeles, in 1975, and the Ph.D. degree in elec-
Lightning Characteristics Relevant for Electrical Engineering: Assess- trical engineering from Mississippi State University,
ment of Sensing, Recording and Mapping Requirements in the Light of Mississippi State, in 1985.
Present Technological Advancements, CIGRE TF.33.01.02, 94, 1995. He was a consultant to A.B. Chance Company and
[9] W. R. Burrows, P. King, P. J. Lewis, B. Kochtubajda, B. Snyder, and Flood Engineering. He has held teaching positions
V. Turcotte, Lightning occurrence patterns over Canada and adjacent with the University of Missouri-Columbia; Univer-
United States from lightning detection network observations, in Atmos- sity of Florida, Gainesville; and Pennsylvania State
phere-Ocean, Aug. 13, 2001. University, University Park. Currently, he is an Associate Professor with the
[10] H. Torres et al., Experiences and first results of Colombian lightning King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals (KFUPM), Dhaharan, Saudi
location network, in Proc. 23rd Int. Conf. Lightning Protection, Firenze, Arabia. His research interests include power system analysis, power quality and
Italy, 1996, pp. 186190. harmonics, and analysis of overvoltages on power systems.
Dr. Shwehdi is listed as a Distinguished Lecturer with the DLP of the
IEEE/Power Engineering Society DLP and was named and awarded the 2001
IEEE/Power Engineering Society outstanding chapter engineer. He was named
and awarded the 1999 IEEE WG for standard award. He is the IEEE/Power
Engineering Society Saudi Arabia chapter chairman since 1999.